Galaxy S24 Ultra vs S23 Ultra Camera Comparison!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 янв 2024
- In this video, I compare the cameras on the Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra and the Galaxy S24 Ultra, two of the most powerful smartphones on the market. I test both phones in various lighting conditions, from bright daylight to dark night, and see how they perform in video mode. I also show you some of the features and settings that each phone offers, such as optical zoom, 8K resolution, HDR, and more.
The Galaxy S23 Ultra has a quad-camera setup on the back, with a 200MP wide-angle camera, a 12MP ultra-wide camera, and two 10MP telephoto cameras with 3x and 10x optical zoom. It also has a 12MP selfie camera on the front. The Galaxy S24 Ultra has a similar setup, but with a 50MP telephoto camera with 5x optical zoom instead of the 10MP one. Both phones can record videos in up to 8K resolution at 30fps, or 4K resolution at 60fps. The Galaxy S24 Ultra can also record 4K at 120fps in Pro Video Mode and Slow Motion Mode. They also support HDR10+ and OIS for enhanced dynamic range and stabilization.
Which phone has the better camera for video recording? Watch the video to find out, and don’t forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more tech reviews and comparisons. Thanks for watching!
Grab the Galaxy S24 Ultra here: howl.me/clmIjSb7vJu
►►► OTHER VIDEOS TO CHECK OUT! ◀︎◀︎◀︎
⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺
10 New Galaxy S23 Ultra Camera Features You NEED To Know (One UI 6) • 10 New Galaxy S23 Ultr...
Galaxy S23 Ultra Camera Tips: Must Have Camera Accessories and Apps • Galaxy S23 Ultra Camer...
⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺⎺
Check Out My KIT Page Here: kit.co/JonathanJCasey
Get My Music HERE: bit.ly/2z6T2E2
Get Your Colorware Skin HERE: bit.ly/2z1mLhN
********************Stay Connected***********************
Twitter: / jonathancaseyyt
Facebook: / ot4tech
Instagram: / jonathanjcasey
Pintrest: / ot4tech
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/ot4tech
#galaxys24ultra #samsunggalaxy #galaxys23ultra 
Наука
Let me know what you think about the camera comparison and is there anything specific you want me to cover in the photo mode test?
Grab the Galaxy S24 Ultra here: howl.me/clmIjSb7vJu
Awesome camera comparisons video, Jon!
wow great video. So glad you actually tested the cameras like this and pinpointed the issues.
When doing the photo mode test, can you review the specific settings that are enabled in the settings and camera settings?
S23 Ultra is still a beast!
Strongly Agree❤❤
Phone is phone , phone is not about camera
Please make up your own opinion. S23U isn't that great. Was on the edge of buying iphone 15 Pro but I think the S24U is pretty great and more towards iphone 15 if you look at the color science, contrast, noise control.
Keeping mine. I'll be going to Google pixel 9 pro in October that phone looks nice
More like it's bad and now we barely get any improvement...
I love my s23 ultra ❤❤🎉🎉
I also love your s23 ultra 😂oh I meant mine haha
Love the call out for what the issue really is. People have been noticing in reviews but not always explaining. I hope they do come out with an optimization update. Thanks for the content!
🙏
Absolutely no need to update your phone every year, gonna rock my S22 Ultra one more year!
Any Ultra series should be used till the Company pushes the Android update
keeping my S23U i prefer the 10X optical zoom i dont think the S24U is worth the upgrade.i will wait to see what the S25U brings,hopefully samsung brings back the 10X periscope zoom.
Hopefully a sony camera
I thought the same until I bought it. Now I love 5x zoom because it has become my go-to for portraits.
I love how you point out all the issues with no bias. I'll keep my S23U for a year and wait for a bigger hardware improvement (hopefully next year), I'd really love an under-display front-facing cam, I barely use selfies and I'd love to have that beautiful front screen with no punch-hole. 😄I believe ZTE has the most advanced under-display cameras that are impossible to see by eye while they maintain a decent selfie cam quality. It'd be really cool if Samsung could do something similar.
I have an S23 Ultra and honestly if I ever need to take a selfie I use the vastly superior main camera... I don't need a selfie camera and would gladly not have it on my S23ULTRA screen as well!
the quality of ZTE under display cameras are awful. it's impressive tech but can't really compare them to modern normal selfie lenses.
I think they'll just feature on gaming phones where selfie shooters don't matter as much till the tech improves.
Finally a really well put and thorough review comparison from someone who understands photography and videography. Nicely done man keep up the good work!
EXCELLENT video. Finally a RUclipsr not trying to fool the audience in order to get sales comissions! I am holding until they update and your follow up video because right now, the S23 Ultra is better in terms of overcall camera performance. BTW, try testing with and without Scene Optimizer as without it, I get better detail with the S23 Ultra.
Great Vid! Exactly how i wann see a camera comparison in which you point at the things you noticed. Maybe adding a little extreme low light there for better showing the differences, no need to be a good photo, but the difference in extreme shots is easier to see.
I absolutely love my S23 Ultra! Not a lot of differences. I think I will stay with the S23. Great video ❤
Awesome job as always, Jon! Kodus to your effort.
This is a videa that will be very helpful to all that plans to update to the newer model or keep the older model.
Much appreciated!
WOW, a solid comparison. What most reviewers do, after they get the phone for free to review it is, that they take bunch of photos and videos and pick the ones, that will suit best to what they want to achieve in their review. S24 ultra is a slightly better phone, but will need updates, just like the S23 got up to this point, to get even better. It will happen 100%. But S23 ultra will get updates as well, to bring it closer to S24 ultra. If you own an S23, it is probably smartest to wait out one round, till the S25. I hope they do something more radical next year, not just slight improvements in terms of design, performance and features.
Looking forward to your dedicated camera, photo/photography review video of S24Ultra, like you made for the previous models in your channel
Great comparison. How long it usually takes Samsung to release camera SW update?
Thank you for the video! That was insanely useful. I use the camera in pro mode with my own settings most of the time so hopefully these issues wont be as bad or get better with updates. I just couldnt stand the curved screen of the s23 ultra for how much i use the spen.
This is honestly a great comprehensive comparison between the two phones. No random fluff was used and details pointed out are useful for any samsung devs to understand and tweak the cam software. Great work!
Really informative comparison,,great 🎉
I heard on other videos that the 24Ultra shoots and record in HDR automatically out of the box. Will it help to switch it off to help with the exposure problem. Other people's videos also show that it is too bright. Mostly my problem too that I have.
Will you be making another video after the official release and update comes out?
Nice video bro 👍. Hey Johnathan, do you recommend upgrading to the S24 ultra if I have the S22 Ultra?
Hi Jonathan, I was eagerly awaiting your review on the Samsung S24 Ultra because I like the way you dive deep into the phone features you review. I have pre-ordered the Samsung S24 Ultra 01 TB version.
That was a great comparison. Are you going to review the cameras of Oneplus 12?
I like watching your videos, they are objective and realistic.
many try to justify their switch from s23u and look for problems that are real, or others just promote the product, by the way when you test it it become hot?I saw that some users complained about the heating
Excellent video with great analysis. Very well explained.
Whats the best video recording settings for the s23u? Do you use the high bitrate option?with HDR10+ on?
Solid comparison! you clearly put a lot of effort into this
Nice job, can't wait for updates.
Hi
How about the less saturated app icons and display overall...?
12MP on S24 ultra tends to be overprocessed on the images, however, if you switch to the 200MP or 50MP, things changes and result in a more natural/darker image.
5:41 what a beautiful oak table. Are all these photos from the Winchester mystery house? That's on my bucket list to visit. Anywho, what about taking photos in RAW mode? I haven't heard anybody taking about that yet, that's still a thing, right?
Yep, all the interior photos were from the Winchester House. It’s definitely something you should check out.
RAW is still a thing but it’s hard to compare it since the benefit of RAW is for post processing and color correction and filters are subjective.
A few months have passed. Any updates to the camera?
Very detail, very helpful.. now im confuse still 23 ultra or 24 ultra 😅
You must be doing a test for S23Ultra VS S24Ultra in specific in space zoom x100 please.
Maybe s24u will be the same quality as s23u in the end in some months.
Or s23 ultra will be updated with the same worse exposure and overshapened software to make them equaly bad.
@sentisenti3229 It already has. S24 will get it and the brainwashed will call it amazing.
All phones get a slight camera enhancements every year by a little bit nothing huge just like you can compare the iphone 15 pro max to the 14 pro max and get better videos and pictures sometimes on the 14 pro max. Also the s24 line up will be getting an update so it will correct any small issues they said.
I have the S24 Ultra and agree with all your assessments here..
Greenish tint low light..
Also on camera does that..
I mainly shoot indoor with studio lights and this phone seems to kinda fall apart when doing that
I got the S23 Ultra a year ago and had camera issues like shutter lag and low shutter speed when taking photos of children, and also oversaturisation for like food but also of my skin during a video call. They later fixed these issues. It´s kinda strange that you get the newest most expensive camera and having problems like this. It´s like it´s better to wait half a year or so after release getting the phone, at least if you´re a camera person.
Does s24 has the 10 minute limit if you record 8k?
After years of enjoying the reliability and performance of my Note 10+, I made the leap to the Samsung S24 Ultra, anticipating an upgrade in camera quality. Despite my satisfaction with the Note 10+ overall, I sought a change due to its tendency to produce oversaturated colors, particularly noticeable in main camera shots.
With the impressive camera capabilities of my work phone, the S22, in mind, I was excited to experience the advancements promised by the S24 Ultra. However, my excitement quickly turned to disappointment upon discovering a noticeable drop in image quality, especially in scenes with high dynamic range.
Comparing images captured by the S22 and the S24 Ultra, I observed that the latter tends to crush details in shadows excessively, rendering them as complete black areas. This results in a loss of overall image quality and makes it challenging to discern details within these darker regions. Additionally, the images from the S24 Ultra appear grainier compared to the crisp output of my S22, detracting from their clarity and sharpness.
Furthermore, I've noticed that the final images from the S24 Ultra undergo excessive processing, with unnecessary additional exposure added, further diminishing their appeal.
I don't know if these issues are only faced by me, but other than those image processing issues, the phone is sublime.
While I remain hopeful that these issues can be addressed through future software updates, it's essential for Samsung to hear feedback from users like myself to prioritize improvements. I'm curious to learn if others have encountered similar challenges with their S24 Ultra and if there are any potential solutions or workarounds available to enhance camera performance.
As a longtime fan of Samsung products, I had high expectations for the S24 Ultra's camera quality, but unfortunately, it has not met my hopes straight out of the box.
No regrets on swapping my 23 ultra in for it, all the issues will get fixed by updates, all new phones need updates when they first come out.
Yup. There will be a ton of updates for the S24 Ultra.
no they dont,vivo x100 pro is working like clock just out of box.samsung is just lazy and crap
Also take note that the note 24 ultra is currently running on a pre-released OS. Surely the update will release once the phone is released to the public
It released to the public on 24th Jan (when I got mine). Samsung has been great in the past at getting lots of updates out. I have no doubt that the S24U will be the same.
@@dpleech1 i see, did you notice any difference with the update?
All these promises of software updates to improve the camera performance of the S24 Ultra are part of the sales drive by Samsung. They are just being business savvy in promising this. In reality however software updates generally only have a minimal effect, or they seem to 'avoid' key issues. Anything they avoid tends to become a long term issue. For example, my Exynos S21 Ultra had very poor noise control in low light video at launch. Samsung promised an update to fix this so sales kept happening and revenue kept on coming in. Three years my later my 21U still has AWFUL noise control in low light video. Software update promises mean little sadly.
Brilliant test.
Thanks for the honest review!!
Any time! 😁
Stay with S23 Ultra due to optical zoom because Samsung said that they ditched the optical zoom for S24 Ultra and only has digital optical zoom which is less quality image when taking a picture.
Absolutely 💯 should wait for at least 02 months for the updates and then compare with S23 Ultra. Meanwhile, thank you for the video 😊 at least for the coming 06 months, I'm stuck with S23 Ultra, then switch on 😉
It's the same hardware, if anything s23 ultra will be updated to look equally over exposed and over sharpened too to match s24 ultea.
I think you have the HDR10 on the S24, the same thing happened to me and when I turned it off I realized that the colors were better and the over-exposure theme was removed.
HDR10 was turned off on both. You would know immediately if it was on when viewing back the footage on a different device since it will appear very flat unless converted.
Finally, someone who says it clearly! We keep seeing overexposed pictures from the S24 Ultra and we hear at the same time that it's the best phone. 🤷
Let's hope that this update will come before the end of the trade-in offers 😅. If it doesn't, too bad for Samsung! No gambling with Samsung updates
Can anyone confirm when you take a picture in HDR that it says ultra HDR when you swipe up on the picture and see the data in the gallery :) thanks
dziękuję potrzebowałem tego
Sad thing is, if they cant be arsed to fix oversharpening on s23u, then what makes think they will fix s24u issues?
The thing is the S23Ultra is already updated to the max. S24Ultra is still growing.
Exactly, let us wait for samsung to fix over-exposure to the s24 ultra, it would definitely be slightly better than the s23 ultra
6:40 This is the clearest difference that I saw. Just looking at the lines on the ground in this shot, the S24 Ultra is denoising them completely off. S23 is still much better and hopefully a software update will help the S24.
Let's wait for the update
I’ll definitely follow up once it hits.
Going to replace my Note 10 with one of these phones which one should i buy?
S23 ultra cuz it will save you money plus it has best ever "Curved" display
Я считаю что s23ultra в большенстве лучше снимает насыщеней и контрастней. S24ultra лучше только ночью и то в тёмных местах шумов меньше. А 23ultra хорошь!!!!
Samsung using clever Apply tactics of downgrading a feature (10x zoom) so they could upgrade it again to 10x zoom on S25 Ultra. Of course Samsung wouldn't admit it's a downgrade and saying they upgraded on other features of the camera.
The camera comparison between Galaxy S24 Ultra and S23 Ultra is truly an exciting journey through technological advancement! 📸✨
We have so much normalized companies shipping half baked products and selling them.
We shouldn't be a slave or be in a desperation to own their products. Hold them accountable, call them out!
the sharpness cuts through my eyes
Just got the S24 Ultra and compared photos to S23 Ultra . I am noticing details and texture loss to The S24 Ultra advantage. The Pixel 6 pro takes much more detailed photos. I am debating if I should take the phone back!
I mostly record concert videos and the s23Ultra is literally the best with it's x10 zoom. Nothing compares
what about colors saturation VIVIVD colors that we buy this are gone and allso what about color saturation dead pixsels green lines that are noticable from some angle ect. ppl alredy return s24 ultra to get theie s23 ultra why is that ?
I'm holding for the S25.
I got the S23 Ultra and i will never understand why people switch there phones every year, the differences are so minimum! To me it's a waste of money to upgrade every year it's better to upgrade after 3-4 years, only than you will have a better phone!
Bottom line There is no significant difference nor reason to spend more money for virtually the same phone
Phone is a phone. Phone is not about camera😊
Jonathan you'll wake up another day and be thinking the opposite - Just kidding. They both look good to me.
Final someone who can see problems with this camera on s24u,only legit youtube video!This guys just addressed all problems of s24u cameras,doing what samsung should do.Right now cameras on s24u is just crap.we will see with update will they fix all what this guys mentioned.If they do then i will keep s24u if not it is instant return.Giving them 10 more days to address this problems.this all should be fixed BEFORE they give phones to people.If they keep like that this vivio brand will eat samsung for breakfast
The minimal hardware of the s23 ultra does not warrant an upgrade from the s23 ultra. The s23 ultra checks all the boxes one needs . Are the upgrades worth it to you ? Me, I'll just continue to use my s23ultra happily knowing i saved senseless spending knowing i have a great phone still .
Can't really say anything negative about either one of them they both are great cameras
For sure, but the S24 Ultra definitely needs to be optimized a bit better
Nothing a little update can't fix
Wait for s25 ultra
The Nokia 3310 is still the best phone available. It comes with a unique green screen. You can also play snake in true black and green.
s24 ultra needs an update urgently
Differences year over year are now minor. Even a "big leap" from s21u to s23u is small in everyday use. I would have regretted but i cascade phones down in my family
I hope samsung comes out with an update for the 24 ultra because right now I'm regretting trading in my s23 because the s23 camera is way better. My s24's camera is too contrasty, my pics and videos are too dark and it wasn't like that on my s23. Im waiting for that update anxiously!!! Sometimes i think i have a defective unit because ive seen videos on RUclips and they don't look like mine. Mine is way darker, photo and videos and i end up using my iphone 15 pro max because of that. Samsung please fix it......
I bought the S23U when it was released and in the beginning the camera was pretty bad and it was improved 6 to 8 months later, expect the same for this one. The real problem of S23U is oversharpening, excessive microcontrast and reds that has nothing to do with what I see with my eye, horrible reds; today for videos I use my Gopro instead of my S23U because of Samsung´s horrible oversharpening and microcontrast.
Yeah, I'm glad I skipped this update and stayed with my S23U.
7:53 the baby is better in s23u more cute more lovely but lady makes more red so i think s23u is adapt to only baby
23 ultra is the way to go!!! Typing on one now. Absolutely 0 point in shedding out 1300 bucks or trading in a better phone for a worse phone(camera department) in hopes they fix those issues. 0 point. Same main sensor and, don't take low light video with zoom on the 23 ultra cause the sensor is so small. Problem fixed. That's like running with zoom and testing the stabilization. Who does that?! Lol
i have the s23u it isnt good really it stutters alot doing regular tasks and video is stuttery
Technology has reached its peak.😢
I'm a Samsung fan, but I think that today, we have to admit that Samsung is really purposely staying in excessive oversaturation and unnecessary overexposure (especially in the background) in photo-video 🤦🏽♂️
Just by lowering the exposure by 1-2 notches, the quality you get is so so much better.
But if you have to do it every time you take a photo-video, it becomes annoying, and it's unacceptable, incomprehensible that Samsung's engineers don't realize it, to think that they are constantly working with very smoky sunglasses 🕶️ 🤔
Samsung should genuinely think about adding a realistic color profile to its photo app for photography, or allowing users to have something like the ''Photographic Style'' of iPhones, to allow us Galaxy users who can't stand oversaturation and excessive overexposure to adjust that.
Ps: don't tell me about the Pro mode (I've known and used it for years), I ask to have this in automatic mode, not everyone is (certainly not) a professional photographer, but would like to have the possibility to make some quick adjustments to their liking.
A software update would resolve 90% of the criticisms made about the S24 ultra.
when the s23 ultra was launched it had the same complaints
Have to keep in mind the S24U is running on what is essentially beta software, whereas the S23U has had a whole year of updates under its belt.
Phone started shipping, still no update. It’s not beta software lol.
@OT4Tech When the vivid mode doesn't even work among other broken things, it's definitely beta software. I've been to the Samsung forums these past few days, there's A LOT of issues with the S24 Ultra. The phone came in really HOT with a lot of little bugs, and this is coming from someone that owns a S24 Ultra. Don't get me wrong, it's a great phone that is fairly polished on the surface, but it has a lot of little cracks when you dig deeper that need to be patched. Don't you remember the S23 Ultra getting camera updates to fix it's issues and improve quality? Same thing will happen with the S24 Ultra.
Right, but that doesn't mean it's beta software. That's an issue with Samsung rushing unfinished products out. We were told that the software was final. Beta software is not something companies ship to paying customers it's something that you choose to opt in for but can always fall back on the stable version.
@OT4Tech Beta software vs rushed unpolished software is just a semantics distinction, they're functionally the same experience for the end user. One UI 6.1 is definitely sub optimal with missing and broken features. Maybe I'm being a bit hyperbolic to call it beta software, but it definitely feels like it is.
I just removed S24U from my cart!! Will keep my S23U for one more year!!
No significant improvement in Camera which i would prefer a main reason to upgrade..
Ugh im starting to think i shouldn't have upgraded from S23U to S24U
Get a proper gcam port with configs and it will be multiple times better than either these.
Compare to s23ultra, don't think s24 ultra does anything to justify the price hike in the USA. Once AI features rolled out to s23ultra, we are technically looking at same phone. And I think color options are pretty ugly this year too
4:37 Daniel Sin,
7:45 S23 Ultra 👍 👍 👍
agree 100 percent with you , today i almost bought 24U , but i will wait update ... dont now now , iphone 15pro max or s24 u ...
I highly recommend basic English lessons for 120$
if you like natural colors use s23....if you like bright and clear colors use s24....
S24 is S23Ai
And some of the ai features are coming to S23 in a future update making even less reason to upgrade but it's rarely ever worth upgrading yearly now
Shit shit shit! I preordered s24 ultra just for the sake of having better video :(
Good job with the comparison though 👏
0:56 The S24 Ultra has less digital sharpness and captures shadow detail better. It's literally a more "professional" looking image. In fact, that's a MAJOR plus for me. Any videographer that uses "real" cameras would agree that almost the FIRST thing you do when getting a new camera is turn the sharpness all the way down. They would also agree that most of the time it's best to shoot in a LOG format. Why? Because it captures more highlight/shadow detail. The S24 Ultra's image is much better in my opinion but I'm someone that's been practicing videography since 2012. The average person doesn't understand the benefits and just wants something "punchy" straight out of the camera. The funny part is those exact same people will just apply a TikTok filter to the video anyway 🤦♂
As for the other issues, mine was literally just delivered today. Give it some time to get ironed out lol
Your confusing log with decreased saturation and contrast due to over exposure. You’re literally losing information in most of the shots due to the highlights being clipped. Also, I said at the end of the video and in the very beginning that an update is coming and I’ll redo any comparisons. But, it’s my job to relay this information since Samsung is watching our videos so they know how and what to fix.
Yes, and you did your job very well. If they don't fix this...
If the highlights are the subject of your picture and they are overexposed, your subject is gone... I can't believe that they missed that.
Mr sins 😢😢😢
Very nice competition between the 2 phones
Twisting the narrative to soften how bad the s24. It's pure trash considering how much it costs.
How am I twisting a narrative?
You are trying too hard to make the s24 as the better phone.
I have to disagree. My experience is different with S23U and S24U