SHE'S LEAVING HOME BEATLES REACTION | Their saddest song?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 май 2021
  • Get todays AMAZON biggest discount deals
    amzn.to/3yn2fI3
    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    She's leaving home The Beatles reaction music video.Possibly the saddest song by The Beatles.
    A beaitifully told story of a young girl who ran away from home,throwing her parents into panic.
    Lennon and McCartney in a beautiful duet where one plays the role of the father,while the other plays the role of the mother.
    Every parent dreads this happening and sadly,many parents out there can empathise with this song.
    Enjoy the reaction.
    #beatlesMusic
    #shesLeavingHome
    #musicReaction
    To become a Patreon and support the channel plus the perks you get, such as Guaranteed video reactions of your choice.....Here's the Link
    • PATREON News! Request ...
    Or simply go to the SUBSCRIBE button and Click on The blue JOIN Button below
    🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽

Комментарии • 469

  • @nicholaspowell7949
    @nicholaspowell7949 3 года назад +211

    This just confirms why John and Paul are the greatest songwriters ever, the album is a classic as well.

  • @timl.b.2095
    @timl.b.2095 3 года назад +38

    This still makes me weep, and I'm a 68-year-old man. I think when I heard it in the 60's, many of my peers resonated with the girl. Now, I bet we all resonate with the parents (and grandparents).

  • @laurateall8847
    @laurateall8847 3 года назад +14

    My perspective on this song is more connected to the girl's choice--and why she's leaving. John sings "love is the one thing that money can't buy..." so life w/ mum and dad has been difficult--lacking in an emotional connection. Think about what the parents are saying---"Never a thought for ourselves, we gave her everything money could buy." Sort of lacking in an awareness of who they've been in the relationship w/ her. "She's leaving home after living alone for so many years..." Of course it's devastating for the parents, but the light is shining on her, I think, and she needs to go. Perhaps she wasn't heard or considered in all the plans and rules they lived by. Thanks for this one. Always makes me sad to hear it, but it's a keeper.

  • @xoxxobob61
    @xoxxobob61 3 года назад +15

    NO Guitar, NO Bass, NO Drums so could you imagine what the Record Company was thinking when they first heard this? It speaks volumes about their Songwriting.

  • @kimtaylor90

    It is impossible to say which BEATLES song is the best nothing nothing transcends them, brilliance off the scale.

  • @edh7071
    @edh7071 3 года назад +67

    I love the dichotomy between being happy for the girl being brave enough to break away from a stifling parental relationship and the grief of the parents who didn't realize how much they were smothering their daughter.

  • @1960rlv
    @1960rlv 3 года назад +44

    One of my favorites from the Beatles. Not a wasted word or note. Tells the complete story in such a vivid minimalist manner it’s a masterpiece IMO.

  • @jasontaverner391
    @jasontaverner391 3 года назад +2

    Your reaction is a common one among listeners, which is somewhat puzzling. If you really listen to the lyrics, the parents' reaction to her leaving suddenly is one of defending their own legacy, rather than concern for her well-being. The "nightmare" here is that communication in this family was so desperately terrible, that their daughter came to make such a desperate decision. The only other Beatle song that I can think of that carries this same John/Paul vocal interplay is "A Day in the Life" on the same album.

  • @ericanderson8886
    @ericanderson8886 3 года назад +89

    Eleanor Rigby was pretty sad. Both are hauntingly beautiful and sad.

  • @personalcheeses8073
    @personalcheeses8073 3 года назад +65

    The Beatles really are the gift that keeps on giving

  • @kirpalite
    @kirpalite 3 года назад +79

    This was written at a time when teenagers were questioning everything, especially their own existence. I consider this song THE DEFINITIVE work on the subject.

  • @nigelgibson2242

    When Lennon comes in at 55 seconds........oh my word! I tear up every single time.

  • @kikeolvera2614
    @kikeolvera2614 2 года назад +4

    The Beatles is the best band ever.

  • @Philtration
    @Philtration 3 года назад +42

    I was teaching my daughter to ride a bike one moment, to drive a car the next and then taking her to the airport to move 2,000 miles away.

  • @andrewclayton4181
    @andrewclayton4181 3 года назад +80

    The fact that the song manages to convey both viewpoints of the story shows the maturity of attitude they had. They were still in their twenties when they wrote it. George Martin arranged the strings, which feature on a lot of their work from this time.

  • @danacasey8543
    @danacasey8543 3 года назад +28

    Harri, I loved the song as a kid wanting to get away from controlling parents. Now, as a mother (and grandmother), it breaks my heart that all she wanted was love and understanding, and had to leave to get it. So sad that in an age of people wanting global love, it is the ones close to you that need it most.

  • @debbiechang5781
    @debbiechang5781 3 года назад +43

    Even after all this time, I still get a little choked up when I hear this. These guys were so far ahead of their actual ages when they wrote these songs. Another great one. And yes! Very sad (but insightful)! Love your reaction.

  • @almostfm
    @almostfm 3 года назад +20

    Something I've always thought, and it's based on the way John and Paul's vocals are treated-John's vocal is covered in reverb and other effects, while Paul's voice is quite "clean"-without effects.

  • @TimStCroix
    @TimStCroix 3 года назад +31

    The first thoughts her parents have are selfish, not worry for her safety. Then we have the line "She's leaving home after living alone for so many years."

  • @rickobwald1276
    @rickobwald1276 3 года назад +22

    It was 1967 and mass quantities of kids were leaving home for Haight Ashbury or wherever. The song was very topical then. The difference between then and now was to the parents, the world had gone upside down, and to the kids, it was right side up. So yes, it’s heartbreaking & beautiful but very listenable.