Couldn't find specific clips for SHINee so I just included their random reacting and correcting moments. *SONG TIME STAMPS* 0:10 No.1 (BoA) 0:29 More Days With You (SJ) 0:40 Beginning (SNSD) 0:56 Her Back (Na Yoon Kwon) 1:59 Sunday Morning (Maroon 5) 5:59 Into the New World (SNSD) 6:17 Love In the Ice Kor. ver (TVXQ) 6:47 Ice Cream Cake (RV) 7:43 Home (SJ KRY) 9:08 (Outro) *Angel* (Super Junior) . This song was also remade by BTOB entitled *"For you"* for *Cinderella and Four Knights* drama ( just incase you find it familiar) 😊
SM artists have such high standards when it comes to singing and it shows in their top tier vocals. Not saying that other artists don’t but SM artists take it to a higher level.
I also remember that award show closing when someone was off key and rv was srsly judging them and also sings louder than anyone else to save the performance 😂😂😂
i think the staff behind the stage turned rv's mics up! i remember you could hear them and seventeen super clearly, i rewatch the stage every so often :)
@@anistardi Not every member has to be at the level of the main vocalist to meaningfully contribute though. I think the main point of this video is how well trained their ears are. So many groups from other companies don’t do any harmonies, or very minimal/simple ones if they do, because only their set vocal positions can hold a tune. With SM groups, most members have some singing ability and most seem to have a good understanding of music itself, which enables them to have a lot more depth in their songs through harmonies and through most or all members being able to sing the chorus.
@@anistardieveryone there were at least trained to sing as a group. Even if they have limited skill, they know how to harmonise with each other. And to know when they're off tune or not.
@@anistardithat’s even worse for other non SM idols cuz if it’s that easy then why most of them don’t even know how to sing correctly in pitch and without straining 😂 SM idols are actual musicians most of them play instruments, know how to harmonize and are well trained overall in musicality which is something other companies don’t do.
@@anistardi at least they have some basic singing skills. they may not be as good as the mains but they still experienced all the vocal training. even the rappers and dancers sometimes can sing better than some groups' vocalists outside sm
@@anistardiYour opinion is invalid when you claimed Dimash has the best vocal technique. The majority of vocal pedagogues have already stated that Dimash is not good technically. Yes, his range is impressive, but that's all. Most of his high notes are heady mix and completely strained. Even if you search the video comparison between him and David Phelps, you can recognize the wide difference between the two singers.
@@kpoppiest i looked at the full aespa fancam and yujin wasn't even holding her mic at the time. i can't tell from the voice who it is, tho. so many people singing at once.
Lol the days where fanny got called out several times by everyone because of her horrendous singing and this isnt the only clip where taeyeon removed her earpiece when she sang. Hahah
He is maybe one of the best singers out there in the world, according to many. He just knows what he wants to sing and how to do it in the best possible way. He is there to show all fans that said idols are not singers that improvement, discipline and constant trainig bears fruits.
@@belaytriks I remember watching all of those "strained vs supported" videos and all people were able to found on Kyuhyun is one millisecond of Masquerade performance, I believe lol and even that didn't sound strained to my ear. Even if there are more, Kyuhyun is skilled, gifted and, on top of that, he knows his limits well enough not to push it and risking both embarrassing himself and damaging his vocal. He faced the possibility (even if in retrospective as he was unconscious at the time) of losing his voice and never singing again. He won't do anything to ruin it.
Alot of kpop idols can sing but very few sing with support. Most SM vocalists have very good vocal support that have been developed since training days while the dancers & rappers are taught breathing techniques to support their vocals. And perhaps the best testament to SM's focus on vocals is the continued vocal lessons even after debut. A good vocal support & singing technique is what allow you to deliver a great song and to sing for years with minimal wear & tear on your vocal chords. Another aspect I appreciate about SM's vocal program is the emphasis on harmonization. Each & every group from them can harmonize well. You don't just sing but you sing WITH your group. And don't even get me started on the vocal layering. Top notch 👌. No one does vocal layering as well as SM I swear. Alot of singers can sing but very few know how to sing correctly. Most of those few are SM vocalists.
yesung was doing his real best and when he said "hey we're LIVE", i could see in his face he's about to throw his slippers in the air like he did in Super TV to hyukjae lmfao 🤣
That's why I love SM Artists! They are very talented and know what they are doing. Eventhough the company is not that good atleast the training is good
and this is why sm stans (fans who stans a lot of sm idols) has a lot to say when they hear non sm vocals because weve been so used to hearing them sing, harmonize and criticize each other. the standard was set above high.
SM provides not only vocal training but also the fundamentals of music that’s why you can notice how their artists are very knowledgeable when it comes to singing.
They know how to sing and understands music. Apart from SM, groups like Mamamoo and Seventeen (remember that Seventeen wasn't originally from hybe, so the credits to their training won't go to that company) are among a few that understand what they're doing.
I still laugh at Yesung, Ryeowook and Kyuhyun's video even after watching it for so many times... ofcourse I know nothing about music but their reactions are too funny🤣
Hearing Jaehyun, Taeil, and Doyoung sing Sunday Morning made me miss their NCT U songs. Their reaction to Doyoung's voice crack the second time was hilarious - he's so cute! SOLOIST DOYOUNG COMING SOON!!! So deserved - I just know I'm going to love whatever he releases. Jaehyun solo in the talks and hopefully Taeil solo plans have started. Also hoping for a dojaejung comeback. Missing Taeil :( wishing him a quick recovery!
ah yes that iconic kyutv live 7:41 where KRY were going over and over with song Home and my boy Yesung was struggling 😭 he was close to murdering his bros pls lmfao 🤣
Kyuhyun teaching Donghae how to use vibrato is the funniest part here . Dude want everyone will be as good as him haha. And you know how skilled he was when he was also correcting someone like Ryeowook.
It’s so much funnier when they judge each other 😂😂😂 they’re so experts in recognizing tones! This is why SM artists are always the best in vocals and those who disagree are just jealous.
why there are existence of company stans? THIS... we are not stanning the company but every idol that they produced is high quality. not like certain company, having company stans just because of popularity.
Literally. I do not respect SM's treatment as well but oh do they know how to choose trainees, form the best groups and make the best songs. Most idols from SM are great at what they do and it's rare to find that level of quality and care in other kpop companies.
i hope sm’s vocal coaches are being paid VERY well because even the “worst” sm singers are at the very least above average. idols who used to have very little lines can have a high note line after years of training. taemin recently hit jonghyun’s high note in lucifer live and that made me soooo proud and also amazed because he went from having barely any lines to a successful soloist and a great vocalist
I mean, Taemin was covering that note for a decade and a half by now, ever since Jonghyun had to skip the Lucifer performance for the first time. And he was getting better and better with it and was covering it well for literal years.
3:15 Oh I remember this clip. Taeyeon and Tiffany solo stans were at war. Tae was getting hate for being a bad friend, and this was back when people were still blaming her for "kicking out Jessica". Tiffany was getting bashed for her vocals even though she had nodules. Bottom line is that in this clip the feedback was just way too loud and Tiffany, who was already a darn great singer, should be considered a beast in today's standards.
Man this is funny/adorable and everything but can i just say...man, SM has got a powerhouse of voices like nobody damn businesses. No other label even comes CLOSE.
Oooh I love this. Makes me respect them all the more coz they are very sensitive to these things and always expect/exact nothing less than 100% of themselves and each other
I dunno whether is LSM or BOA created SM water and I bet it tastes good 😂😂 LSM and BOA set the vocal standards so high till no other companies can fight with them 😅😅
@@irisnatasha06 nahh babe, its all started with lee soo man him self then acompanied with yoo youngjin bringing up idol training system just for overal k-pop with BoA
I love how EXO just straight away says EXO-Ls were out of tune and that they needed to work on their singing 😂. I love our boys so much 😂❤ Plus thank you for including an F(x) clip, I miss them sooo much 😭
As a singers that's why i choose to be SMstan since 2009 ❤❤ When you always sing, your ear Will learn to listen off tone and not 😅 and Yups SM Idol Family is the Best for Singing No debat ✌🏻
Couldn't find specific clips for SHINee so I just included their random reacting and correcting moments.
*SONG TIME STAMPS*
0:10 No.1 (BoA)
0:29 More Days With You (SJ)
0:40 Beginning (SNSD)
0:56 Her Back (Na Yoon Kwon)
1:59 Sunday Morning (Maroon 5)
5:59 Into the New World (SNSD)
6:17 Love In the Ice Kor. ver (TVXQ)
6:47 Ice Cream Cake (RV)
7:43 Home (SJ KRY)
9:08 (Outro) *Angel* (Super Junior) . This song was also remade by BTOB entitled *"For you"* for *Cinderella and Four Knights* drama ( just incase you find it familiar) 😊
There are quite a few moments like these for SHINee too! I could list them here if you at some point make a part 2 ^^
@@littlebluebird4736 Hi, what clips do you suggest? Thank you so much for the help. I appreciate it a lot. ❤
thx
Their ears are trained so well, they can detect who messes up right away.
LOLLL love the k-drama like ending 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yesung was so tired at that point lol
SM artists know how to harmonize and do adlibs and they are great at that.
kyuhyun is another level u know, even when doing military service he corrected his instructor while singing their national anthem😂
Wait, what? I didn't know about this!
Valid tho. His technique is enough to put him among the best south korea
Lmao
HAHAHA
HAHAHAHHAAH
SM artists have such high standards when it comes to singing and it shows in their top tier vocals. Not saying that other artists don’t but SM artists take it to a higher level.
I also remember that award show closing when someone was off key and rv was srsly judging them and also sings louder than anyone else to save the performance 😂😂😂
do you remember when this was? I wanna watch it lol
@@dianabanana7394 i think it was kbs song festival 2021 all of you performance
@@meklitalem5256 thanks! I'll look it up
Yes and there’s also when they were at jonghyun’s radio show. Wendy was covering joys line but sang it wrong and Irene gave her the side eye 🤣
i think the staff behind the stage turned rv's mics up! i remember you could hear them and seventeen super clearly, i rewatch the stage every so often :)
its the water, Sm’s water
Not Yuri judged by SNSD's main dancer for her vocal😂
Hahahaha right so funny 😂
Not just a dancer but the girl who only sing 1 sec 🤣 You have to watch SNSD do re mi game so it will be more accurate 🤣
When even the main dancer judged you, you clearly messed it up. 😅😂😂😂
and Tiffany (vocal line) just laughing 😭😭
Sunny was lauging too... Poor Yuri, she was just having fun there.
The side eyes always send me 😂😂😂 they're so good in harmonising that's why they judge everyone who stood out like a sore thumb 😂
joy side eyes will always iconic
Her side eye kills me 😂😂😂
It's amazing all SM groups from Super Junior to aespa and even Riize who are just debut recently all experiencing this lol
@@anistardi Not every member has to be at the level of the main vocalist to meaningfully contribute though. I think the main point of this video is how well trained their ears are. So many groups from other companies don’t do any harmonies, or very minimal/simple ones if they do, because only their set vocal positions can hold a tune. With SM groups, most members have some singing ability and most seem to have a good understanding of music itself, which enables them to have a lot more depth in their songs through harmonies and through most or all members being able to sing the chorus.
@@anistardieveryone there were at least trained to sing as a group. Even if they have limited skill, they know how to harmonise with each other. And to know when they're off tune or not.
@@anistardithat’s even worse for other non SM idols cuz if it’s that easy then why most of them don’t even know how to sing correctly in pitch and without straining 😂 SM idols are actual musicians most of them play instruments, know how to harmonize and are well trained overall in musicality which is something other companies don’t do.
@@anistardi at least they have some basic singing skills. they may not be as good as the mains but they still experienced all the vocal training. even the rappers and dancers sometimes can sing better than some groups' vocalists outside sm
@@anistardiYour opinion is invalid when you claimed Dimash has the best vocal technique. The majority of vocal pedagogues have already stated that Dimash is not good technically. Yes, his range is impressive, but that's all. Most of his high notes are heady mix and completely strained.
Even if you search the video comparison between him and David Phelps, you can recognize the wide difference between the two singers.
Taeyeon removing her earpiece is always iconic hahaha
and Joy and Kyuhyun judging
🤣
I always laugh at Karina side-eyeing the person that sang off tune😂😂😂😂
I wonder who was the one singing badly 😅
@@starry.princesss1115 I've seen somewhere that it was Yujin from Kep1er but I'm not sure
@@kpoppiest i looked at the full aespa fancam and yujin wasn't even holding her mic at the time. i can't tell from the voice who it is, tho. so many people singing at once.
@@tiannacowan6999 oh my bad. As I've said I wasn't sure that was Yujin, just seen someone else say that. Thank you for clarifying tho!
@@kpoppiest no worries, you're fine. i'm nosy and want to find out who it is lol, but it is hard to do with the footage i could find.
The hate Taeyeon got when she remove the earpiece while Tiffany singing. Those times were like nightmares oh god!
wait, was the Taeny shipper also fighting during that time? 🤔
its actually iconic, i think that because she can hear the high note right into her ear
it was too loud even for the bestie 😂
Lol the days where fanny got called out several times by everyone because of her horrendous singing and this isnt the only clip where taeyeon removed her earpiece when she sang. Hahah
My girl Tiffany is super loud even when speaking let alone singing 🤣
The worse SM singer can be the lead in the other companies.
Or even the main vocal.. 🎉
I agree, I've seen a lot of group main vocalists were an ex-SM trainee like jungwon from enhypen
@@drckhuang9644chaeyeon from kep1er too
Si, también está el vocalista principal de SS501
absolutely howling at the suju clips, no wonder elf are always joking about "kyuality control"
He is maybe one of the best singers out there in the world, according to many. He just knows what he wants to sing and how to do it in the best possible way.
He is there to show all fans that said idols are not singers that improvement, discipline and constant trainig bears fruits.
@@belaytriks I remember watching all of those "strained vs supported" videos and all people were able to found on Kyuhyun is one millisecond of Masquerade performance, I believe lol and even that didn't sound strained to my ear.
Even if there are more, Kyuhyun is skilled, gifted and, on top of that, he knows his limits well enough not to push it and risking both embarrassing himself and damaging his vocal. He faced the possibility (even if in retrospective as he was unconscious at the time) of losing his voice and never singing again. He won't do anything to ruin it.
Remember, the main dancer in SM can be a lead vocal in another company
not all of them
@@BP-tm6ye Who doesn't?
@@lisasimpson1403 the only one that i think of is hyo from snsd
@@BP-tm6ye liar
@@lisasimpson1403 ?
Alot of kpop idols can sing but very few sing with support. Most SM vocalists have very good vocal support that have been developed since training days while the dancers & rappers are taught breathing techniques to support their vocals. And perhaps the best testament to SM's focus on vocals is the continued vocal lessons even after debut.
A good vocal support & singing technique is what allow you to deliver a great song and to sing for years with minimal wear & tear on your vocal chords.
Another aspect I appreciate about SM's vocal program is the emphasis on harmonization. Each & every group from them can harmonize well. You don't just sing but you sing WITH your group. And don't even get me started on the vocal layering. Top notch 👌. No one does vocal layering as well as SM I swear.
Alot of singers can sing but very few know how to sing correctly. Most of those few are SM vocalists.
Imagine how seriously it was taken the vocal trainning for them, like that right there is not only talent, but KNOWLEDGE
The bombastic side eyes 😂
SUJU KRY though HAHAHHAHAHAHA wook and kyu were arguing for so long when they can't harmonize well 😂😂 and there's yeye who's singing his heart out 😂
yesung was doing his real best and when he said "hey we're LIVE", i could see in his face he's about to throw his slippers in the air like he did in Super TV to hyukjae lmfao 🤣
THIS WAS SO FUNNY TO ME HAHAHAHAHA IM LAUGHING SO HARD
Lmao the side eyes are so funny. Taeil was ready to throw hands on national television lmaooooo
That's why I love SM Artists! They are very talented and know what they are doing. Eventhough the company is not that good atleast the training is good
"hoksi neo" is now engraved in my brain 😂
The way RW panicked and the way KH looked at him lol. 😂
😂😂
Just a normal day in SM
That Joy side eye always made me crack 😆
That is why you need to drink SM Water taste like water
Joy's iconic bombastic side eyes on Ice Cream Cake
Just to show the level. That was SNSD dance line correcting one of its members in singing, vocal line was just laughed there.
and this is why sm stans (fans who stans a lot of sm idols) has a lot to say when they hear non sm vocals because weve been so used to hearing them sing, harmonize and criticize each other. the standard was set above high.
Ikr.only few of idols outside sm can give me that wow factor ..
I can hear the error in most of these but the KRY ones are so funny cuz there's barely any error and they're still unsatisfied 😂
it's still not up tp kyuality control standard 😂 poor yesung had to suffer
SM provides not only vocal training but also the fundamentals of music that’s why you can notice how their artists are very knowledgeable when it comes to singing.
Exo telling there own fandom it was a little off key 😂😂😂😂
You give us money but we will tell you the truth even if it hurts 😅
Singing along during exocons is a graded performance. Exo panelists will throw their honest reviews during ments
😂😂😂
They know how to sing and understands music. Apart from SM, groups like Mamamoo and Seventeen (remember that Seventeen wasn't originally from hybe, so the credits to their training won't go to that company) are among a few that understand what they're doing.
SM's strength is vocal. These days there are many good faces but there are very few good voices. SM should never give up on vocal.
The way joy giving side eyes🤣🤣
8:14 Kyuhyun was so done with Ryeowook that day 🤣 and Ryeowook's satisfied nod was so cute
I cant Kyuhyun lecturing his big brothers look at that unapproval sharp gaze 😭
ok now i would take a vocal lessons just to go to any sm artist concert, i don't want to take the blame anymore 😂
thankfukly, im not an idol, if an SM idol judges me like that, I'd probably cry and quit 🤣
Just imagine Kyuhyun, Taeyeon, Taeil in 5th gen group. They might throw hands 😅
exo won't throw hands, but they definitely will tell you to go hire a vocal coach constantly if they don't do it for you
Kyu doesn't let anyone slide, lol!
if an sm artist judged you for your singing, then change careers.
This video make me respect and love SM idols. They are not idols but top tier vocalists. Thanks for the wonderful compilations 😊😊
I still laugh at Yesung, Ryeowook and Kyuhyun's video even after watching it for so many times... ofcourse I know nothing about music but their reactions are too funny🤣
Hearing Jaehyun, Taeil, and Doyoung sing Sunday Morning made me miss their NCT U songs. Their reaction to Doyoung's voice crack the second time was hilarious - he's so cute!
SOLOIST DOYOUNG COMING SOON!!! So deserved - I just know I'm going to love whatever he releases. Jaehyun solo in the talks and hopefully Taeil solo plans have started. Also hoping for a dojaejung comeback. Missing Taeil :( wishing him a quick recovery!
You know you've made it when kyuhyun doesnt judge you 😭😭
ah yes that iconic kyutv live 7:41 where KRY were going over and over with song Home and my boy Yesung was struggling 😭 he was close to murdering his bros pls lmfao 🤣
this just further proves how sm has the most vocally talented artists in the industry.
Kyuhyun teaching Donghae how to use vibrato is the funniest part here . Dude want everyone will be as good as him haha.
And you know how skilled he was when he was also correcting someone like Ryeowook.
Ryeowook laughing got me lol
Key 4:07 and Joy 6:46 got me dying 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👏👏👏👏
edit 7:44 also this trio!! that head tilt and drama ending LOL..poor Yesung 😂
It’s so much funnier when they judge each other 😂😂😂 they’re so experts in recognizing tones!
This is why SM artists are always the best in vocals and those who disagree are just jealous.
why there are existence of company stans? THIS...
we are not stanning the company but every idol that they produced is high quality. not like certain company, having company stans just because of popularity.
Literally. I do not respect SM's treatment as well but oh do they know how to choose trainees, form the best groups and make the best songs. Most idols from SM are great at what they do and it's rare to find that level of quality and care in other kpop companies.
i hope sm’s vocal coaches are being paid VERY well because even the “worst” sm singers are at the very least above average. idols who used to have very little lines can have a high note line after years of training. taemin recently hit jonghyun’s high note in lucifer live and that made me soooo proud and also amazed because he went from having barely any lines to a successful soloist and a great vocalist
I mean, Taemin was covering that note for a decade and a half by now, ever since Jonghyun had to skip the Lucifer performance for the first time. And he was getting better and better with it and was covering it well for literal years.
Sm's standards
Taeyeon taking out her in-ear @ 3:23 was because tiffany’s voice is loud. She mentioned it on radio.
Karina's side eye, Hyo's roasting and Taeyeon never fails me 😭
The BoMBaStIc SiDe EyE CrImiNaL OfFeNsIvE SiDe eYe always gets me 🤣🤣🤣
yup i stan most of them for a reason. TALENT
sm should lend their vocal trainers to hybe😂
HYBE should steal SM vocal trainee and not just their art and creative team
@@whatever_voyez5123 they wouldn't know what to do with them
Taeyeon reactions to Tiffany's failed highnotes will always be iconic HAHAHAHAHAH
joy's side eye so scary huhu wi'd cry if she looks at me like that XD
7:32 whats more funny was the caption wrote (main dancer 1) (main dancer 2) 😂
Not them judging eyes 😅 'iconic'
I swear SM should makes their own water branding, wkwk
That's why I am SM bias. My bias, the person who brought me to Kpop left me but I cannot stop listening to his songs, his voice.
3:15 Oh I remember this clip. Taeyeon and Tiffany solo stans were at war. Tae was getting hate for being a bad friend, and this was back when people were still blaming her for "kicking out Jessica". Tiffany was getting bashed for her vocals even though she had nodules. Bottom line is that in this clip the feedback was just way too loud and Tiffany, who was already a darn great singer, should be considered a beast in today's standards.
No wonder, SM is known for having best kpop vocalists .. ❤
so proud to be SM stam, stan great artists❤
The editing of this is so funny. Especially the side eye at the end 😂
SM’s vocals are no joke 🙌🏻
0:40 even their non-vocalists know when something's off. i knew i chose the right ones when i saw these talented visuals the first time
Man this is funny/adorable and everything but can i just say...man, SM has got a powerhouse of voices like nobody damn businesses. No other label even comes CLOSE.
the last KRY clip got me crying pleaseee and their parallels with the dojaeil clip 😭
Oooh I love this. Makes me respect them all the more coz they are very sensitive to these things and always expect/exact nothing less than 100% of themselves and each other
When sub vocalists judge lead/main vocalists
Joy & Kyuhyun can never spare those who make mistakes 😅
This is why all SM arists will FOREVER be superior.
the doom sound you put over every side eye is keeeeling me LOOL
SHINee just here messing their lines :))
I dunno whether is LSM or BOA created SM water and I bet it tastes good 😂😂
LSM and BOA set the vocal standards so high till no other companies can fight with them 😅😅
Its actually yoo young jin. He taught them vocal. All their singing style resembles him
@@irisnatasha06 nahh babe, its all started with lee soo man him self then acompanied with yoo youngjin bringing up idol training system just for overal k-pop with BoA
The Bada erasure.
I love SM artists voices so much💗
SM Artists Vocal is the best in KPOP Industry 👏👏
Hate them all you want, their vocal skills is untouchable
ahh poor Yesung 😂😂😂
I love how EXO just straight away says EXO-Ls were out of tune and that they needed to work on their singing 😂. I love our boys so much 😂❤
Plus thank you for including an F(x) clip, I miss them sooo much 😭
finally!!!! thank u soo much for this long video
As a singers that's why i choose to be SMstan since 2009 ❤❤
When you always sing, your ear Will learn to listen off tone and not 😅 and Yups SM Idol Family is the Best for Singing No debat ✌🏻
Pls make more of these they are hilarious😂😂
This shows how well trained the SM artists are when it comes to singing. Their skills of noticing who’s off is spot on 😂
SM Artists: You dare be off-key in my presence?
Hyo yelling at Yuri was funny but Sunny and Sica joining in was wild 💀💀💀 I miss them 😩❤️
Imagine debuting in SM with this kind of quality and said can't sing 😂😂😂
JOY REACTION IS SO FUNNY HAAHAHAHAHAHAJAHAHA
it's always the side eye hahahah you know they mean business when it happens
Kyuality control 😂
Kyuhyun is sooooooo funny judging his hyung 🤣
OMG, SuJu K.R.Y one got me laughing out loud 😂😂😂
jungwoo always makes me laugh
omg didn't expect f(x) to be here 😭 since people seems to underestimate f(x) and forget that they're training and debut under SM
That's why we stand SM artist❤