Legal Spat Over Who Invented Butter Chicken Reaches Delhi HC | Vantage with Palki Sharma
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 21 янв 2024
- Legal Spat Over Who Invented Butter Chicken Reaches Delhi HC | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Moti Mahal, the restaurant credited with inventing butter chicken, has sued rival restaurant Daryaganj for claiming it was their ancestor who created the dish. The legal spat has now reached the Delhi High Court. The court will now decide who can claim the culinary invention. Palki Sharma tells you more.
---
Butter Chicken | Legal Battle | Moti Mahal | Daryaganj | Delhi High Court | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#butterchicken #legalbattle #motimahal #daryaganj #delhihighcourt #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
Finally some real issues being taken to the court
YES!
😂😂
😄
The Tamil Sangam literature Purananuru mentions that the Sri Lankan king Villiyatan(வில்லியாதன்) was wealthy enough to serve ghee-fried pork and rice.
Purananuru Hymn 379, lines 8-10
குறுந்தாள் ஏற்றைக் கொழுங்கண் நல்விளர்
நறுநெய் உருக்கி நாட்சோறு ஈயா
வல்லன் எந்தை பசிதீர்த் தல்எனக்
Frying meat in butter and ghee is a cultural food custom of Tamils.
@@perambu3441Absolutely. Meat fried in Ghee with Rice is part of Indian cuisine.
Thanks for this source you mentioned - " Tamil Sangam literature Purananuru mentions that the Sri Lankan king Villiyatan(வில்லியாதன்) was wealthy enough to serve ghee-fried pork and rice. - Purananuru Hymn 379, lines 8-10 "
1980s: we will have flying cars in future
Le 2024: who invented butter chicken 😂
How Dare You 🤓? Anything “ Buttering” related has to Belong to Singapore 🇸🇬… 1st They Buttered the British Colonisers & Japanese Occupiers … Then Malaysia & for longest time Superpowers 😂😂😂
The case will run for 50 years keeping both restaurants in limelight. Profits for both
That’s called smart biz. They deserve all the profits.
The Tamil Sangam literature Purananuru mentions that the Sri Lankan king Villiyatan(வில்லியாதன்) was wealthy enough to serve ghee-fried pork and rice.
Purananuru Hymn 379, lines 8-10
குறுந்தாள் ஏற்றைக் கொழுங்கண் நல்விளர்
நறுநெய் உருக்கி நாட்சோறு ஈயா
வல்லன் எந்தை பசிதீர்த் தல்எனக்
Frying meat in butter and ghee is a cultural food custom of Tamils.
If something is mentioned in tamil doesn't mean it originated from tamil nadu
It is just a note
@@rayudurayudu9348 Present-day Sri Lanka was formerly a Tamil region.
@@rayudurayudu9348 - Does the truth really matter here if both can profit? 😁.
Wah ! Very important issue to solve in Modern India 😅
Very indeed
When will India take Britain to International court of Justice for saying Chicken tikka masala is the national dish of Britain🤣
well, 1 will see cultural appropriation (includes exchange) with music, languages, food, architecture, etc across nations worldwide - fusions of various cultures including various types of yoga too. so, going to court for all these including ones Indians appropriated too with regards to architectural styles, interior designs of homes? not worth it going to court for as people worldwide love them and that includes butter chicken too.
Cultural Appropriation (includes exchange) - Drawing Room came from UK while Skyscrapers, Ferris Wheel and many more originated from Chicago and Yet the World has drawing rooms, skyscrapers, ferris wheels etc which are there in India too (Go to court for all of them too? Not worth it as people worldwide enjoy them).
Or we can look at it with different perspective. Imagine with the diversity of the UK our indian dish still captured their hearts. They may have left India and their spices but Indian spices didn’t leave them 😂
allowed
@@rmot2911lol go and read history uk didn’t invent Ferris wheel
I don't think people understand whoever wins the case will get a significant and inherent advantage. The winner can claim royalties, ads, credit, etc. They may also be able to dictate who can/cannot make it.
However, the court may rule that it has been over X years, and therefore, the butter chicken can be made by anyone with no royalties paid. But the number of ads, promotions, and fee they can charge, franchisees they can open boasting about their invention (that others are copying) will make them super rich and famous overnight.
It is tricky. This case will be just another 'who invented it first' - and such cases are common across the globe. This case got the hype because almost any non-veg would know about this dish globally.
So - tell me, why are people making a mockery of it? If I invented something, and someone else took the credit, I will go to court, too!
well, 1 will see cultural appropriation (includes exchange) - music, languages, food, architecture, etc across nations worldwide - fusions of various cultures including various types of yoga too. going to court for all these including ones Indians appropriated too including architectural styles, interior designs of homes? no royalty will happen as it will just be case of who came out with the butter chicken 1st where it came out on Indian subcontinent anyway
Cultural Appropriation (includes exchange) - Drawing Room came from UK while Skyscrapers, Ferris Wheel and many more originated from Chicago and Yet the World has drawing rooms, skyscrapers, ferris wheels etc which are there in India too (Go to court for all of them too? Not worth it as people worldwide enjoy them even though Ancient Indian homes of rich didn't have Drawing Room but had Other Rooms especially for Storage and More).
Idiotic analogy...who invented pop music do you know that!! No one can claim royalty on butter chicken. You invented I don't care, if I open a restaurant I will also make butter chicken
@@Sn28septSounds good. Your education comes across really well. Do you have any idea about how inventions work? How are they registered? If there is ever a dispute how they get resolved and what the consequences are?
If person A invented something, and A finds you copying it without their written authorisation then you will be liable to pay A royalties, or almost anything A wants from your earnings (or damages).
Just simply how inventions and rights work.
Problem with most Indians is they have degrees but continue to be unemployable because you fail to understand simple logic.
If any tom dick and harry (like you) started legally copying others inventions, then there wouldn't be any person inventing because they get no benefit from putting the hard work.
Just because in India you can do it and get away from it due to hardly any legal enforcements/consequences doesn't mean it is right.
Also - I am not claiming who invented butter chicken The comment was about how inventions and claims/rights work.
I learned the skill of preparing butter chicken from my mother. According to my grandmother, this recipe, albeit with minor alterations, has been a part of our family heritage since the 1930s. Personally, I find my version of butter chicken superior to that of Moti Mahal's. Several years ago, while I was studying in New York, my friends, who hailed from Europe, the United States, and South America, were particularly fond of it, drawn to its distinctive aroma. It is noteworthy that many such recipes, including the one I utilize, predate those used in restaurants.
You should file a case in Delhi High Court!
Should I laugh 😂 or cry 😢
There was no butter Chicken existed before Partition of India, it started only after Partition and in Old Delhi 😎
someone seems to be blowing their own trumpet..
Bhai recipe share karde
Dang!! This is my favorite Indian dish 😅 need to know who invented it for real! 😂😂
My grand mom actually 😂
Kundan Lal actually, now it's upon which Kundan Lal you want to give credit to. 😂
There are crores of pending cases in Indian courts.
But clearly this is a globally important issue & calls for a full bench, top priority day to day hearings!
The outcome will shape the future of the world.
There is no chance for daryaganj because all the original founders worked in the venture named moti mahal from which Mr. Kundan lal jaggi retired from in 1992 , but yet moti mahal continued and then daryaganj was established in 2018 after 26 years , so the claim of daryaganj is baseless because the so called founder of Daryaganj only was a part of the moti mahal orignal butter chicken . It is as simple as pakistan’s claim for kashmir is the same claim of daryaganj .
The fact remains that I never had Butter Chicken till I heard about it abroad 😄
I never had it myself, and I don't care. Indian cuisine is extremely diverse. Just because some foods get popular overseas doesn't make them better than others.
@@someonejustsomeone1469 Because the British, just like other colonisers, have only tried making themselves look superior to us. So they don't care about India's diverse cuisine. Btw I love butter chicken. But I won't know why foreigners only talk about a few Indian food. There are millions of dishes across India. Anyways let's not be concerned with their ignorance about our culture. Who are they?
@@someonejustsomeone1469 it's good. Do try it
I have it in India since childhood. Mumbai, I'm 29 now
yeah because we got better dishes than that here.
So many Indians are waiting for justice from court but they are busy in these petty issues.
It's my favorite Indian dish. My husband attempted it late last year before Christmas and I loved it!
I didn't know so many Indian food classics are so recent: Butter Chicken, Chicken Tikka Masala, Dal Makhani. Surely there must be great dishes that are old.
Chicken Tikka Masala has Controversy like many worldwide. Here are the Indian Authors and Food Historians where these are Few of their Books Too - 1) "Whose Samosa Is It Anyway?: The Story of Where 'Indian' Food Really Came From" by Sonal Ved, 2) "Masala Lab" by Ashok Krish, 3)"The Indian Pantry : The Very Best of Rude Food" by Vir Sanghvi, etc. Chili came to India via Portuguese. Pulao, Jalebi, Samosa, Idli, etc not from India. Same goes with many fruits and vegetables Indians enjoy as they come from Outside India.
All those books have RUclips videos on them. 1 of those RUclips videos "Vir Sanghvi Unravels Popular Indian Food Myths", Vir Sanghvi clearly states "Chilli" came to India via Portuguese. Pulao, Jalebi, Samosa, Idli, etc not from India. Same goes with many fruits and vegetables Indians enjoy as they come from Outside India. Can check out these books and videos as a start to get the knowledge about Indian food and origins
"Indian Food: A Historical Companion" is another book by K.T. Acharya, yet another Indian Author and Food Historian who states what you want including from Prehistoric Times of Indian Food where he's also 1 who has stated Idli doesn't come from India and comes from Indonesia
@@rmot2911 Thanks for your replies, though I was hoping for just a few examples of good Indian dishes that were more old, more traditional.
@@pjacobsen1000the curry itself is around 4500 years old, khichdi is another 1
Actually o.o it was invented by my great grandma
But we cannot publish it, o.o as my grandma used the neighbours' chicken without permission & ever since then, they been keepin an eye on us o.o
Yeah I also know about that actually my grandma was school friend of this guy's grandma and she saw her while stealing the chicken 🐔 infact my grandma was the one who suggested the idea of stealing in the first place🤷♂️
😂😂😂 Surprising to see people fighting over a recipe of leftovers... at least that's what current restaurants do! Sad but true!
As you've rightly pointed out, it's an recipe mAde out of leftover tandoori chicken.... slather butter over anything and it becomes blood delicious 😂
I remember once I attended meeting called by Principal District Judge now High Court Judge there he said no case is big or small case is case. It looks absurd and rightfully so however credit of being first to invent something might have sentimental value for warring families while it might not help them commercially since it widely available.
Seriously Man we have so much of back logs of cases and our judiciary is wasting time on this case. Dhabe wala outside of my home claims that he invented Butter chicken.
Get rid of butter and add ghee instead...😂😂😂
ghee is clarified butter
same same but difalant
🎉❤Oh Wow! ❤🎉 Our beautiful Ms. Palki in elegantly stunning Indian fashion-nobody can surpass her in such fashion on online world news. Thank you for always staying amazing and stunningly beautiful. ❤A real India Barbie! 🎉 You are really our Ms.Universe on online media. God bless ❤ ❤❤Firstpost, 🎉❤Vantage❤ Ms. Palki and her whole family, the great Indian nation, and the beautiful people of India. God bless to all!❤🎉🎉🎉🎉🙏🙏🙏.
Palki has a baritone ?😂
Incredible that such a small matter as experimenting with foods can reach such immaturity.
it isnt really immaturity its about the money and fame that comes with it lol
Butter chicken? Biriyani was invented in north India part mughal grandkids who just came 1400y fighting for biryani 😂 sure your Arab Mughal even saw one grain of rice in desert?
Some Dumasss in my cmnt
Not just the rice but also the SPICES.
Biryani is persian
@@tazboy1934 do you even know King Nala? He was indian he invented biryani
Mughals original ancestors came from Persia; And nobody beats them in cooking.
@@myglobalytthe root of several Mughal dishes are in Persia, of course the spice mix came from India, cuisines are complex and change hands several times in history, its nearly impossible to credit one person no matter how ingenious chef (s)he maybe.
As a 🇱🇰🇱🇰 I've been thinking that Butter Chicken was a centuries old Indian dish. 😂😂
It's now Century Old
@@heiAMB Lol. 😂
What I meant was 3 or 4 centuries at least.
When more serious matters are pending, it is sad that the courts have been burdened with this too.
Marination.1 kg chicken
500 gms curds
1/2 lemon juice
1 1/2 tbl spoon ginger garlic paste
1 tps honey
1/2 tps tandoori chicken masala
1/2 any chicken masala or add another 1/2 tps tandoori chicken masala
1/2 tps Haldi
1 tbs viniger
Salt and spicy red chili powder to taste
200 gms kajoo soak...and then fine paste with little water
Method
Heat oil
1 tps kashmiri red chilli powder..let oil turn red...
Add the chicken pcs only and cook for 5 minutes. Then add the marination ka left over masala. Cook for 10 minutes.
Add tomato puree and blanched tomato blended juice
Cook for another 10 minutes...add kajoo paste..slit green chilies and malai...Cook till oil separates. Keep turning in between so the kajoo does not get stuck at bottom..
😂
The Tamil Sangam literature Purananuru mentions that the Sri Lankan king Villiyatan(வில்லியாதன்) was wealthy enough to serve ghee-fried pork and rice.
Purananuru Hymn 379, lines 8-10
குறுந்தாள் ஏற்றைக் கொழுங்கண் நல்விளர்
நறுநெய் உருக்கி நாட்சோறு ஈயா
வல்லன் எந்தை பசிதீர்த் தல்எனக்
Frying meat in butter and ghee is a cultural food custom of Tamils.
Imagine Kolkata vs Kerala for Fish. 😂
Then what about Bangladesh, Maldives and Sri Lanka where it's citizens love eating fish cought from the sea that boarder the respective countries. 😊
Kolkata Vs Orissa for Rashogolla
Goa is gonna fight dirty..
@@ruwanfonseka ita internal issue why we care about other countries kerela and kolkata are Indian state lol
I invented Butter Chicken… it was in 3rd year college, my bois were hungry , I had 2 days old bits of Tandoori chicken in one plate, I added cream, Amul butter and tomato ketchup…cooked in the electric kettle…and Voila Butter Chicken.
Shall I also sue these Moti Mahal and Darya Ganj ?? Ngl I hate these courts ke chakkar tho
I think this is good for Butter Chicken. It makes wanna go eat it again but it’s not as good as those in the UK.
Written statements from both the persons claiming can be analysed by professional graphologist and report can be submitted to the court...
Y u r showing it in black n white ?? 🙄😏
I am hoping that as evidence they are both gonna make butter chicken for the judges .😂😂😂😂
I remember a similar scene in Jolly LLB 2..
That movie was ahead of its time
😂🤣😂🤣 can't wait for the court ruling. . what happens before they come up with a decision
Interesting!!
I was talking to my dear uncle Mahat macoat and he said he actually invented it in the slums of Bombay but unfortunately we can’t get him to testify as he slipped over in a spilt butter chicken and no is in a korma 😢hopefully he wakes up soon and can lay claim to this wonderfull dish 🤓
I'm always reminded of curry whenever someone mentions India. I would love to feast on some buttered chicken but unfortunately i can't, for health reasons. Sucks to be on a diet. You miss out on the yummy stuff 😟😢😂
There are gazillion veg and non veg curries . You can try any one of them
@@VARMOT123 yup, i will certainly do that after my FORCED diet 😂. I would order chicken masala first 😁. This is making me drool just thinking about it 😂
u can replace with almond and nuts if u wanna Dairy free/Kal free@@Techguy-zt3mz
There are wars going around, people are battling hunger and here people are having a legal issue over who invented butter chicken..
Finally some worth it issues are being taken up in the courts
My favorite Indian dish 😋 😍
If my bharla masale wanga is stolen i m going to supreme court.
Power to this guy who filed the case.
Forget about these guys, I invented it.
Tanduri Tikka Masala is the most popular food in the UK.
A jugaad on left over tandoori chicken is something that our honorables courts will drcide
Butter chicken wow...who ever created we are loving it
Battle worth fighting for 😃
as a filipino who loves buttered chicken, i didnt know its from india lmao
most types of chicken are from india or turkey anything related to masala is indian and anything related to keema kebab and shwarma is prolly turkish
Badi duvidha thi, bete ki sunte ya baap ki.. fir humne socha hatao yaar butter chicken pe concentrate karo 😂😂
If I were to visit these restaurant is there a vegetarian substitute for butter chicken?? ( same gravy minus non veg possible)
Yes, paneermakhni
Obviously Indian 💪🕉️🤞🇮🇳
Nonsense butter chicken belongs to us (indian) we will fight for it 🙂💪
UK says Butter chicken is their's . Lol invite them for the session as well 😂
Why on earth you want to know who the hell invented it, just eat it and relish it
Chickens also should allowe to speak in Delhi HC.
Wow great news to be shared on news media and to be argued in courts. Rest all issues in the country are sorted bas yehi baki hain. 😂
Palki you don't invent food, you create new food
China enter the chat & Claim that they are the Real inventor of butter Chicken and Favorite food of the 1st Emperor of China🤣🤣🤣
Me watching this while eating butter chicken😀
Interesting clip
: but why chuk chuk tharain of pothori khukhrain isnt called by a name of isles but of ashoka worldwide
Both parties need to be penalized for wasting court's time.
At first, find out who invented butter and discovered chicken first, it can help to resolve the case 😂😂😂
Who won? Society. 🗿
I really want to know who invented it!
First they should ask, who invented butter?
Justice for butter chicken
Why fight? Eat, it's tasty and has many versions.
Never knew butter chicken have to defend his self today .
Butter chicken Khao ,khilao aur enjoy kharo , I am sure the person who invented wanted others to enjoy it , rather than wanted rights over its recipe , or name
I can settle this argument butter chicken was invented by myself now go and eat butter chicken peacefully
Manipur ❌
Butter chicken ✅
in the US its tikka masala(the most popular one) and seaaaag paneeerrrr (thats how you say it) ...both dishes in the US are screwed up by south indian cooks who dont even know what these should be looking like
🙀I can’t handle the stress I have a bad tikka sort this mess out
Nice for lawyers and courts who will earn money 💰
Waiting for the fight over fried chicken and who owns the right to fried rice brand
Both the restaurants cook such an underwhelming Butter Chicken honestly. I have had both and I was seriously unimpressed by both.
WTF a case for butter chicken.
Judges have time for this?
Stupid Judicial system
There are communal judges , civil judges and criminal judges. Now they also have online court judges.
😂 The chicken who was used in the first Butter chicken can only tell the truth because it was the main ingredient in the invention. Unfortunately the witness in no more. So the case is dismissed.
Whoever may invented it I love to eat 😋🤤
Great public stunt by grandson 😂,
There was no butter chicken existed before Partition of India, it was invented in Delhi after partition.
I tried moti mahal butter chicken its the best butter chicken in the world
Butter Chicken was invented by a very hungry man who had limited resources 😂
Its like fight between the Parents who made their baby...was it mum or was it dad.
Judge be like : Let me first taste then decide 😅
So family is fighting over the rights.
,40 million pending case yet butter chicken is more important
The Battle of Butter Chicken in independent India.
Get this sorted out before I die, don’t take 50 years, the Nation wants to know?
It was actually invented in Tamil nadu
The whole world knows it.. I've lived in old Delhi I know it and ur story says it too.. Moti Mahal invented it. Daryaganj is his kins new upscale watery who went to shark tank is trying to get fame...
Who is watching the gas station 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why are you on leave? Dont you have another one of you closed eyes to replace, you...just make him stand in your place, noone will know the difference. LOL
It was invented in Scotland by Bengali immigrant
Either of them are below average. There are 1000s of eateries which make better butter chicken.
I want a movie on this
Johar take notes ?
One day the family of the chicken seller, who had sold chicken to both the Jaggi brothers, would come and say that this recipe was invented by our ancestors and it would not have been possible if he had not given them the chicken...

Judges be like "Abhi maza aayega na bhidu"
This is hilarious 😂
Again a unsplved case....all judge lawyers gonna earn high profit only....whi cares who had invented its just taste...which can be in Kolkata nicest restaurant as well
Around 40 years ago, As for my learning Kunden Lal Gujral of Moti Mehel Delhi Dariajung was the one who invented Butter Chicken and them Daal makhani. well Daal makhani originated from Jammu Dogra’s but not as daal makhani but Black Daal ( Urad whole ) use to be cocked in Curd (yoghurt) W/O onion, Tomato and garlic, instead they used Anis!
You should be a key witness in this law suit.