Another reminder, I will be making a Director's Commentary on this video (most likely on the second channel) going over some questions in the comments. Be sure to leave them if you have any!
Just a dumb question here, but what was stopping you from grinding the Maderame blue will seed in Mementos before the Kamishido palace boss? The barrier if I'm not mistaken does absorb ANY attack. I'm just curious, but if it's in part 2 or such my apologies. Thx for reading if you do I enjoyed the video
If you didn't do this already, couldn't you have legally used Phys or Gun skills after maximized Baton Passes in some fights, since this would make them cost no HP?
I still can’t believe them thinking Female Orpheus was balanced. Like I get that Izanagi No Okami is overpowered too but it’s available at level 91 (assuming you don’t buy from the compendium). Orpheus is available with Neo Cadenza innately at level 11/13. Heat Riser isn’t even available for other Personas until level 75 (excluding Magatsu Izanag which is at level 50/54) and that doesn’t even heal for 30 SP and only targets one ally. Meanwhile Neo Cadenza is only 24 SP, heals, and affects everyone. After I saw how busted this was, I fused Orpheus (and Kaguya) away and forbid myself from using the other DLC Personas (though I’ll probably fuse Athena later on as it’s my favorite of the DLC Personas)
@@Reversemotion20 I actually know the outcome to this. The holy grail is still unlocked. Another fun fact if you don’t explore mementos at all in the game you’ll be forced to travel through the entirety of mementos in one go.
@@JackBenci I have a question for a challenge runner of the series, so you think it’s at all possible to beat Devil survivor Overclocked under the following circumstances: I’ve beaten the game multiple times, cracked every skill, and know all the possible auction demons, BUT the compendium and skills that aren’t obtainable at the start aren’t allowed, meaning until a demon has it I might as well be playing from the normal start and not new game plus
Holy damn man! I thought the Doing Nothing run was insane, but this is really insane, I'm surprise it's even possible this far into the game! Lucky for you, DLC and the various mechanics can break the game to raise your odds of doing so much damage and evading. Now try doing it WITHOUT DLC or Insta-Kill! :D
And so we begin the journey of misery and despair of a No Hit Run, let's see if it didn't end up to be as painful as DarkViperAU's GTA V one, good luck Jack.
I just watched the no attacking run and thought "huh i wonder if anyone has beaten this game without taking damage" and its the same guy! This guy is the supreme masochist.
Hey Jack, I know this is months and months later, after the video released, but I just wanna say with all sincerity, that I really appreciated how you addressed the pronunciation debacle in the Intro section. You spoke humbly, were able to poke fun at yourself, showed off WAY more examples than I expected of the precise mispronunciations under discussion from the last video - thus ADDING PROBABLY A LOT MORE TIME to your editing load - showed off the correct pronunciations according to Google, and gave a really good reason for being a bit scatterbrained. I can't IMAGINE the stress I'd have trying to go thru uni AND play Persona 5 Royal, let alone do a challenge run AND RECORD IT, AND EDIT IT, for RUclips consumption. TLDR - your amicable, easy-going approach is really appreciated. I see too many Angry Gamerz(tm) these days, and it's really a relief to see someone be able to acknowledge criticisms while staying positive and not flying off the handle.
I'm super-grateful to see the list of songs used in the description, I wish more RUclipsrs did this!! I haven't watched the video yet, but I am pretty sure it's gonna hurt...
Joker: "And then we destroyed this ancient monster god inside the twisted desire world of the local yakuza boss, obviously without even getting a single scratch on us. Anyway, that's when I started dating your sister..." Sae: (Silently contemplates committing Persona 3)
In the Super VIP form, you could attack Kaneshiro instead of the pig. Yes, you can do it. It saves item bait. If you damage Kaneshiro enough, he falls off and you take no damage. Of course you need a sufficiently powerful persona, but I am pretty sure you can get that easily.
@@sul_9999 item wasnt expensive enough. thats what led me to just hitting him directly accidentally. my understanding is, if you can hit a cup, u can hit a fly
I scoff at someone complaining about the length of the no attacking vid. I once watched a Persona 5 (not Royal) analysis video that was 5hrs 30 minutes long. Thank you for doing these challenge vids, they've got me excited about finally playing Royal once it comes to PC (i've only played some of the PS3 original).
I recently beat this game and it was amazing, can't wait to try challenge runs like this in the future. Also i can't wait to see your future runs for this game, keep up the good work! And Finally, GG on beating this challenge :)
I highly commend you for taking on this challenge. I thought your no attack run was ridiculous, but this is like hard in the absolute next level. I would definitely be interested to know if this challenge is possible without the use of DLC personas.
@@JackBenciFinished this challenge without no dlc, and hated first, second, and 6th palace. It was pretty good though. Izanagi really just makes the whole game a joke
just started doing this same challenge thinking nobody else had done it cause i couldn't find any videos, then got sent this as i couldn't think of how to deal with kamoshida, must say you're really entertaining!!
the first fight, and subsequently your first reset can be avoided. Joker is scripted to hit a crit if you melee on your first turn, then just use your 1 more to kill it with Brave Blade
I feel like you could probably mathematically model success probability by looking at damage over party and dodge efficiency over party (size and composition etc) for every major encounter but I’m not smart enough to do so
holy fuck i keep forgetting how low level orpheus f is 17:53 to add to the rediculous nature of neo cadenza tho. yes it is possible to spam thermoplaye, but that requires max hanged man. a party member also gets a 90sp thermoplaye... in the 3rd semester... and yet orpheus f is like "nah have it right now + heals for 24 sp. 24 sp is a special number casually cause 24 /2 (spellmaster) + invig 2 + wearing / having invig 3 = 0 cost
11:02 You mention a "scouting run", what exactly would that be? And furthermore, what must it be like to begin a run like this (or your No Attacking* run) without knowing if it's even possible?
a scouting run is basically another save file without the need to restart every time he's hit. that way he could plan a route based on what he finds while scouting instead of going in completely blind
I love Persona 5 Royal and the various challenge runs that people have made and I’ve gotta say that a no damage run is probably the one category I could manage under condition that it was a NG+ run because of my top tier team I customized. No Damage from fresh start? Not in my lifetime.
Damn I read that you will beat p5 royal without talking like in dialogue and was so confuse when you were talking about not taking damage, i guess it makes more sense and not impossible. Very good video and wow, you did great for how far you went
Kamoshida: "Damn you!!" Jack: "That's my line!" Question: can Ippon-Datara be put to sleep in the Yusuke awakening fight? I feel like it is possible, but not 100% sure. Because if it is possible, that could have been useful if you know when he is going to take a turn, he will heal a bit, but the technical damage would make up for it. EDIT: For Kaneshiro, it may have been risky to have a second party member, but the added evasion from Yusuke's trait may have saved you a bit of sanity and you may not have had to swap to Orpheus as much to buff evasion seeing as Yusuke has that skill.
14:00 i actually pulled the dlc personas by accident and now half of my personas are kinda busted, i do use them moderately, but the small space for new ones is pretty bothering
Hello and welcome to what’s hopefully my final attempt at completing persona 5 royal without taking any damage. I have a max HP of 1 so damage from any source will immediately kill me. I want this to also be a no hit run, so joker’s dlc personas are disabled. I have completed every single fight without taking damage, but I yet have to to do it all in one go
honestly your mispronunciations werent *that* bad, ive seen a lot of persona/SMT videos with way more obnoxious and upsetting mispronunciations where they felt like they weren’t even trying
Love these challenges and ideas, good lords does it look like one hell of a task Just wondering what the sound effect for the reset number counter is, even better if you have a file of it
The counter effect is just a common notification bell I've grabbed from a youtube channel SFX database. ruclips.net/video/r4B4WGzJDjQ/видео.html&ab_channel=SoundEffectDatabase
If you still have the VODs for this can you edit together all the loads where you don't take damage back to back so it looks like you just played the whole game without taking damage and without reloading at all. Even if it can't be edited together convincingly it would still be cool to see
I know this is like, 2 years late, but in the Kamoshida fight wouldn't it be easier to go into the fight with Joker only, if possible? I don't know if you can control your party at that point, but if you can then the boss would require less resets - keeping Shiki Ouji on would keep you from taking any damage until the spikes, upon which you'd just need to get lucky and then take out Shiho.
I implore you for taking advantage of changing the difficulty as you saw fit since this challenge is incredibly difficult as is. I’m surprised that the increased critical/technical damage applies to the opponents as well. I don’t think I’ve seen another challenge run do the same thing besides lowering it if it gets too difficult.
18:09 i may be stupid but what is the song at 18:08? nevermind i went song by song in the description till i found it: its Bang Bang Bang Bang Have a nice dream
Another reminder, I will be making a Director's Commentary on this video (most likely on the second channel) going over some questions in the comments. Be sure to leave them if you have any!
I don't have any but that song for describing the math brought back memories
Don't worry my interest is hold me hostage watching this while playing p5r merciless
Just a dumb question here, but what was stopping you from grinding the Maderame blue will seed in Mementos before the Kamishido palace boss? The barrier if I'm not mistaken does absorb ANY attack. I'm just curious, but if it's in part 2 or such my apologies. Thx for reading if you do I enjoyed the video
Did this ever end up happening???
If you didn't do this already, couldn't you have legally used Phys or Gun skills after maximized Baton Passes in some fights, since this would make them cost no HP?
Tell me you hate yourself without telling me you hate yourself. Good luck, bud
evil me be like: i love myself
_Eh, I could take myself or leave myself._
I am he. He hates me
“This friend of mine is my clone. This clone hates me.”
I wish I was never born
So you created an ideal world where no one experiences any pain... 🤔
So this is basically the Baal Avatar Scenario in Noctourne. Even if you agree with them, ya feel the need to prove yourself better for the task.
You are definitely a man of focus, commitment, and sheer fucking will.
That's all without my dog dying!
@@JackBenci so is your dog dead or is he still alive?
Guys I don't like where this is heading.
@@Not_Alanius his horny ass cat sure is
I still can’t believe them thinking Female Orpheus was balanced. Like I get that Izanagi No Okami is overpowered too but it’s available at level 91 (assuming you don’t buy from the compendium). Orpheus is available with Neo Cadenza innately at level 11/13. Heat Riser isn’t even available for other Personas until level 75 (excluding Magatsu Izanag which is at level 50/54) and that doesn’t even heal for 30 SP and only targets one ally. Meanwhile Neo Cadenza is only 24 SP, heals, and affects everyone. After I saw how busted this was, I fused Orpheus (and Kaguya) away and forbid myself from using the other DLC Personas (though I’ll probably fuse Athena later on as it’s my favorite of the DLC Personas)
This challenge run and others are so cool, it almost inspires me to make one of my own : D it’s so impressive
Go for it! Lots of fun to challenge yourself
this is not really a challenge run but i want to see what happens if you dont do any of the mementos requests do you still unlock the holy grail part
@@Reversemotion20 I actually know the outcome to this. The holy grail is still unlocked. Another fun fact if you don’t explore mementos at all in the game you’ll be forced to travel through the entirety of mementos in one go.
@@Kaijo- thanks that is really cool to know
@@JackBenci I have a question for a challenge runner of the series, so you think it’s at all possible to beat Devil survivor Overclocked under the following circumstances: I’ve beaten the game multiple times, cracked every skill, and know all the possible auction demons, BUT the compendium and skills that aren’t obtainable at the start aren’t allowed, meaning until a demon has it I might as well be playing from the normal start and not new game plus
Fun Fact: The clip used at 7:02 is a speech given by the last president of my country. He also couldn't count.
9:56 “this fight sees us taking on two Jack-O Lanterns” why you gotta do Pyro Jack dirty like that
loved hearing the Danganronpa ost being used
I love the music choices. It really brought the video together
I often spend way to much time on the music!
I KNOW! Especially the DR music! It was surprisingly well fitting
Holy damn man! I thought the Doing Nothing run was insane, but this is really insane, I'm surprise it's even possible this far into the game! Lucky for you, DLC and the various mechanics can break the game to raise your odds of doing so much damage and evading.
Now try doing it WITHOUT DLC or Insta-Kill! :D
Surely that’s impossible right
What was the Doing Nothing run?
@@tdogwatcher8395 just watch this guys channel
@@tdogwatcher8395 it’s on nitsuagamers channel, it’s worth a watch
When the legend meets the legend
And so we begin the journey of misery and despair of a No Hit Run, let's see if it didn't end up to be as painful as DarkViperAU's GTA V one, good luck Jack.
I just watched the no attacking run and thought "huh i wonder if anyone has beaten this game without taking damage" and its the same guy! This guy is the supreme masochist.
Hey Jack, I know this is months and months later, after the video released, but I just wanna say with all sincerity, that I really appreciated how you addressed the pronunciation debacle in the Intro section. You spoke humbly, were able to poke fun at yourself, showed off WAY more examples than I expected of the precise mispronunciations under discussion from the last video - thus ADDING PROBABLY A LOT MORE TIME to your editing load - showed off the correct pronunciations according to Google, and gave a really good reason for being a bit scatterbrained. I can't IMAGINE the stress I'd have trying to go thru uni AND play Persona 5 Royal, let alone do a challenge run AND RECORD IT, AND EDIT IT, for RUclips consumption.
TLDR - your amicable, easy-going approach is really appreciated. I see too many Angry Gamerz(tm) these days, and it's really a relief to see someone be able to acknowledge criticisms while staying positive and not flying off the handle.
You're insane and I respect you so much
51 minute Persona 5 video?! Extremely stupid challenge?! Doom Eternal intro and the Soul Eater OST?! I think I found the perfect channel. Subbed!
the bastion music jumpscare put me back in nostalgia land hahah, i loved watching this! : D
I'm super-grateful to see the list of songs used in the description, I wish more RUclipsrs did this!! I haven't watched the video yet, but I am pretty sure it's gonna hurt...
my first question is: "why is it 52 minutes?"
my second question is: "PART 1?"
oh god.
Joker: "And then we destroyed this ancient monster god inside the twisted desire world of the local yakuza boss, obviously without even getting a single scratch on us. Anyway, that's when I started dating your sister..."
Sae: (Silently contemplates committing Persona 3)
In any other context that phrase would be unintelligible
for how small your channel is, your editing is amazing
In the Super VIP form, you could attack Kaneshiro instead of the pig. Yes, you can do it. It saves item bait. If you damage Kaneshiro enough, he falls off and you take no damage. Of course you need a sufficiently powerful persona, but I am pretty sure you can get that easily.
I have played this game 5 times over now. I had no idea this was an option. End me. Thank you for bringing this to my attention!
I gace mofo a bead and he didnt do smack
@@sul_9999 item wasnt expensive enough. thats what led me to just hitting him directly accidentally. my understanding is, if you can hit a cup, u can hit a fly
The true, biggest mystery of P5R?
How the heck did Joker fit all of those outfits and accessories in that single box…..?
I scoff at someone complaining about the length of the no attacking vid. I once watched a Persona 5 (not Royal) analysis video that was 5hrs 30 minutes long. Thank you for doing these challenge vids, they've got me excited about finally playing Royal once it comes to PC (i've only played some of the PS3 original).
20:54 how does your ps5 homescreen look like that???? Not the background that's from the game I think but the icons to the side? It looks so cool
It’s a part of the persona 5 royal theme that comes with the dlc
The funny thing is I was wondering a few hours ago if Persona 5 Royal could be beaten without getting hurt and here the video is.
I'm here to serve the people!
@@JackBenci yes yes I know I can't wait for parts 2 and 3 I know they will be epic!
You don’t truly beat the game until you beat the demifiend and nahobino challenges
I recently beat this game and it was amazing, can't wait to try challenge runs like this in the future. Also i can't wait to see your future runs for this game, keep up the good work!
And Finally, GG on beating this challenge :)
I highly commend you for taking on this challenge. I thought your no attack run was ridiculous, but this is like hard in the absolute next level. I would definitely be interested to know if this challenge is possible without the use of DLC personas.
It most certainly would be. Unfortunately I don't have years of free time to spend on it - maybe someone else will take up that challenge?
@@JackBenci I see. Still kudos to you. XD
@@JackBenciFinished this challenge without no dlc, and hated first, second, and 6th palace. It was pretty good though. Izanagi really just makes the whole game a joke
Fantastic work dude! You've got some hardcore dedication to do this!
love the commentary lol, good on you for still going after the no attack run
you madlad you deserve my sub for this
Absolutely phenomenal intro. Top notch.
The soul eater music took me by surprise but it was so hype
...I'm torn between encouraging you and being concerned for your sanity after something like this
Ah yes, the psychological damage run.
just started doing this same challenge thinking nobody else had done it cause i couldn't find any videos, then got sent this as i couldn't think of how to deal with kamoshida, must say you're really entertaining!!
What is this gem that I was not informed about RUclips. Terrible system getting in the way of great content
That Lagiacrus certainly fits the feeling of *DEATH* .
Yusuke boosting evasion probably carried his awakening fight
the first fight, and subsequently your first reset can be avoided. Joker is scripted to hit a crit if you melee on your first turn, then just use your 1 more to kill it with Brave Blade
p5 challenge runs are the best!
I feel like you could probably mathematically model success probability by looking at damage over party and dodge efficiency over party (size and composition etc) for every major encounter but I’m not smart enough to do so
I was considering this! However the evasion calculations are very hidden in this game and so I wouldn't be able to make a reliable model :(
Absolutely love your channel man, keep it up please!
Correction, the make it rain attack is physical not almighty, equipping rangda makes the second phase of kaneshiro’s palace unlosable
holy fuck i keep forgetting how low level orpheus f is
17:53 to add to the rediculous nature of neo cadenza tho.
yes it is possible to spam thermoplaye, but that requires max hanged man.
a party member also gets a 90sp thermoplaye... in the 3rd semester...
and yet orpheus f is like "nah have it right now + heals for 24 sp. 24 sp is a special number casually cause 24 /2 (spellmaster) + invig 2 + wearing / having invig 3 = 0 cost
just commenting such that more people may find this video as it is solid entertainment
31:25 if my math teacher, teached like this man I would really Enjoy math class
11:02
You mention a "scouting run", what exactly would that be? And furthermore, what must it be like to begin a run like this (or your No Attacking* run) without knowing if it's even possible?
You appear to have repeated the same thing at 25:44 and 27:07, I don't know if this is worth pointing out or if anyone else already has
a scouting run is basically another save file without the need to restart every time he's hit. that way he could plan a route based on what he finds while scouting instead of going in completely blind
I love Persona 5 Royal and the various challenge runs that people have made and I’ve gotta say that a no damage run is probably the one category I could manage under condition that it was a NG+ run because of my top tier team I customized. No Damage from fresh start? Not in my lifetime.
"Bascially" lmao 3:50
Bascially shut it.
Bahaha oh lordie my spelling there
Finding this video was so satisfying.
Then I saw SWOT analysis. Thought youtube was a safe place 😩
In other word this is a sadist challenge but I'm looking forward to how it turns out.
Damn I read that you will beat p5 royal without talking like in dialogue and was so confuse when you were talking about not taking damage, i guess it makes more sense and not impossible. Very good video and wow, you did great for how far you went
I completely forgot that you could increase the technical rank from billiards. I stop going to Kichijoji as soon as I get Haru's baton pass to rank 3
This man just did 10x better then I did on madarame with this challenge I couldn’t be more dissapointed in myself.
Soul eater music while grinding oh helll yea this is gonna be very good run :0. Lord this was hilarious
Oh wow, I never made the connection between interrogating Mishima and then learning about shadow interrogations.
Absolute mad lad. No idea how people put themselves through this stuff.
Just found your channel due to youtube recommendation, and gotta say, I just sub to you. I like your stuff.
The soul eater music made me sub. Great choice.
Kamoshida: "Damn you!!"
Jack: "That's my line!"
Question: can Ippon-Datara be put to sleep in the Yusuke awakening fight? I feel like it is possible, but not 100% sure. Because if it is possible, that could have been useful if you know when he is going to take a turn, he will heal a bit, but the technical damage would make up for it.
EDIT: For Kaneshiro, it may have been risky to have a second party member, but the added evasion from Yusuke's trait may have saved you a bit of sanity and you may not have had to swap to Orpheus as much to buff evasion seeing as Yusuke has that skill.
6:15 I split it into 10-15 minutes episodes.
Part 1 length 51:53
It's about timestamps. You can go to any palace timestamp from the description.
That shiki ouji pronunciation of yours sounded like shinji, and I couldn't tell if you did it on purpose or not in the pacifist challenge video
you see that, shiki?
Get in the fucking robot, Shiki!
the intro scared me i thought i was watching a doom eternal play through at first
I enjoy this video.
14:00 i actually pulled the dlc personas by accident and now half of my personas are kinda busted, i do use them moderately, but the small space for new ones is pretty bothering
6:12 says the man in the 50 minute vid lol (not nitpicking just funny imo)
Haha! The chapters themselves of the palaces are 10-15 mins long.
(Maybe I should have made that more clear... Oh well!)
Hello and welcome to what’s hopefully my final attempt at completing persona 5 royal without taking any damage. I have a max HP of 1 so damage from any source will immediately kill me. I want this to also be a no hit run, so joker’s dlc personas are disabled. I have completed every single fight without taking damage, but I yet have to to do it all in one go
THERE AREN'T ARSENES IN MISSIONS
RUclips name: Jack Benci
Real name: Molotov Man
Super underrated
I was NOT expecting death the kids theme but im NOT complaining
honestly your mispronunciations werent *that* bad, ive seen a lot of persona/SMT videos with way more obnoxious and upsetting mispronunciations where they felt like they weren’t even trying
How did you have your ps4 persona 5 royal theme ?
I just watched your no attacking run and my gods i feel so bad for ya man
25:27 is it Fox Traps or is my mind just ruined by the internet?
(Before I watch the video) Ring of Glutttony is broken op lol
“This video is so LOOOONG” bro have you PLAYED persona 5???? This is a reasonable amount of time
All we need now is a Super Shotgun introduced into the persona series that can pull enemies around 🤣
Love these challenges and ideas, good lords does it look like one hell of a task
Just wondering what the sound effect for the reset number counter is, even better if you have a file of it
The counter effect is just a common notification bell I've grabbed from a youtube channel SFX database.
ruclips.net/video/r4B4WGzJDjQ/видео.html&ab_channel=SoundEffectDatabase
Mind you, can't remember what video exactly I got it from! Something like above!
Finishing this run would take longer than making a video game better than Persona 5 Royal with no experience
yes, its called izanagi no okami
i want to see your past suffering vods unfortunately twitch deleted them
The squad is angry cus they didn't get their fill of violence last time
maybe with the ad revenue from this vid you can get a therapist after the mental strain gained from this
If you still have the VODs for this can you edit together all the loads where you don't take damage back to back so it looks like you just played the whole game without taking damage and without reloading at all. Even if it can't be edited together convincingly it would still be cool to see
Basically torturing yourself to death.
What are the odds i just finished darkviperau gta v ohko run and i stumbled upon this, this will be good
I know this is like, 2 years late, but in the Kamoshida fight wouldn't it be easier to go into the fight with Joker only, if possible? I don't know if you can control your party at that point, but if you can then the boss would require less resets - keeping Shiki Ouji on would keep you from taking any damage until the spikes, upon which you'd just need to get lucky and then take out Shiho.
you can't remove people from the party until you get the fifth party member
You can't change party until Yusuke joins
I'm just here for the soul eater lotus juice jams
I implore you for taking advantage of changing the difficulty as you saw fit since this challenge is incredibly difficult as is. I’m surprised that the increased critical/technical damage applies to the opponents as well. I don’t think I’ve seen another challenge run do the same thing besides lowering it if it gets too difficult.
31:42 It should be 0.25*0.5*0.5*0.3
You replaced the 0.5 with an 0.3, literally unwatchable
Good eye you have there! Apologies for ruining your experience. Please take a complementary comment as compensation.
didn't expect the DOOM Eternal intro
18:09 i may be stupid but what is the song at 18:08?
nevermind i went song by song in the description till i found it: its Bang Bang Bang Bang Have a nice dream
i would like to point out that the first ever battle in the game, that crit always happens
I genuinely spent hours of my free time trying to figure out what 25:27 means.
Please help
I can only read that as f**cks tr*ps, which would probably get him kicked off of RUclips, so maybe not.
The only thing I can think of would be "Fox Traps"
But Jack doesn't strike me as that kind of person
Ok but did you reset for the classroom chalk events?
Now I kinda want to do this with Persona 4 golden...
That sounds like it'll be even worse than this.
Even I'm not that insane!!
You counted 26 twice. Before the ann fight.
Agh! Haha I'll have to keep in mind that for the next part
I dont get why he didn't use yuisca how ever you spell his name, he has a good dodge and good damage
Yusuke?
@@averagechannelname9969 yeah
Where did you get that persona 5 royal theme? I have the others but not that one