Correct! I'm not old enough to know but from what I understand after independence, Chinese people were discriminated. I hear that it's getting worse as each yr passes. My family migrated to Australia in the 80s. My parents already said back then they had to bring us elsewhere, too racist there. They are worried about us. 😢😢 that's probably the best decision they made in their whole life to help us kids. I'm always thankful my parents made that decision. Our life is 10 times better now.
Many Malaysians who have not lived in overseas before always think the other countries are fairer and better, but the truth is not so. Discriminations, culture and living problems always happen in so called developed countries, these Malaysians might not know and they always think these foreign countries have greener and fairer pastures, which are not true. For me, after living in and travelling to those developed countries for years, I think Malaysia is still the best country for me to live. Proud and happy to be a Malaysian Chinese.
Not true to every msians living in the foreign countries I have been living in the 4 continents - Canada, uk, Usa, Africa for years differently I personally love Canada the most in my foreign countries years This is mainly depend on indvidually social activitiest with the west locals There is no racist encounter in canada where I lived in Victoria BC This is typically where u live in good high ends area or Poor incomer earners area in the foreign countries where racist happened frequently I encountred with local Msia Malays confront me wildly fiercely whilst walking my dog in the good Chinese Garden neighbourhood park With No Malays living here,100% msians chinese lives here in this good garden housing There is a big crowds kampong malay bikers coming to confronted me that I cant walk my dog in the park, I am in no talking to them,i quickly took my dog into my car to drive away, this is a typical racist violent to chinese,Now u know WHY MSIANS CHINESE POPULATION IS DECREASINGLY EACH YEAR TO ONLY 20% LIVING HERE, EVERY MSIAN CHINESE TRYING TO MOVE TO A BETTER EQUAL HUMANS RIGHTS COUNTRIES FOR HIS/HER FUTURE GENERATIONS LIVING IN A NO QUOTA RATIO RATED COUNTRY TO MAJORITY N MINORITY IN ALL THINGS BUT ANNUAL TAXES PAYING IS 100% TO EVERY RACE MSIA CHINESE TAX PAYERS DO NOT GAINING ANY BENEFITS TO UNI EDUCATIONS CAREERS HIGH POSTS ETC
Here's the dilemma: ethnic Malaysian-born Chinese (as well as Indians) feel the unfair practices of the Bumiputera policy that actively protects the interests of Malays at the expense of other ethnics. Foreign Chinese like to visit Malaysia as tourists or as MM2H visa holders think very differently, because right from the start, they DO NOT CONSIDER political participation or ethnic-based affirmative action to be THEIR CONCERN. In other words, those overseas Chinese visa holders in Malaysia see things from vastly different angles, they do not consider that discriminatory politics to be a relevant factor in their daily lives.
@刘麗麗 I guess they feel their peaceful life has been disturbed by the Chinese people from China. It's really understandable. Unfortunately the country needs more money from tourism including mm2h.
Yes, but it's only happening when you apply for higher education in Malaysia, other else is just politics. I'm Indian, and I've got many Indian friends who try to work in Chinese companies and got rejected even though we got enough qualification for the jobs, and also we Indians always being discriminated by Chinese business owners. You're lucky that at least you have many Chinese business owners in Malaysia all over the country so It's easy to get a job and you're still complaining
It's not a national policy, it's part of Malaysia constitution made and written by British colonials and Malay rulers who fought and die for their country.
@@PrakathRakeshhyou know the policy/ constitution was there because it's racist in the first place 😂😂. Still racist so they never changed it. If one day, before I died, they make Malaysian born Chinese equal, that will be the day they become non racist ❤
Many forgotten New Economy Policy (quota system) is not what we agreed during Merdeka. It is a policy by government. And after many years, the new generation forgot and thinks it's their fundamental rights. When you entitled for something too long, you assume it's yours. So when we try to end the policy which long overdue, they become very sensitive
@@whwong7141 exactly. Article 153 of the federal constitution was meant to rectify the Malay poverty at the time of independence which is a sunset clause meant to expire after two decades and it does not have any reference to "malay privillange" or "malay rights" but special position of the Malays. And later the introduction of "quota system" in 1971 which was not in the original Article 153 and there no mention also "bumiputera" in the original constitution, and conveniently includes pribumi borneo in the narrative to suit their racial agenda. Over time the Malay majority see this as their birth right while the suppresed minority especially some chinese in the comment view this as a gift and should be grateful. Wtf? They already have the mindset of second class citizen the same as the actual pendatang in the video.
ah tiong 就是 ah tiong, live here only 1 month think u know everything already, ppl ancestors here bleed and cry for 4 5 generations just to become 2nd class citizen u think very fair very tolerant
I beg to differ. A foreigner retiring on FIRE here may view things differently compared to a person born and raised here. Foreigners would not take the political situation as seriously as the locals. If anything goes south, a foreigner may just dump everything and leave, but it’s not as easy for the locals. That’s the truth. A foreigner not treated equally may just justify it by saying it’s because they are a foreigner. For a citizen born here, inequality means being treated as a second-class citizen compared to others. All the Chinese cultural customs, education, and language preservation you see here are not without the sweat and blood of the locals. We fought for it, and even today, politicians still threaten to shut down Chinese schools. Every local who becomes successful can chalk it up to their multiple folds of hard work. If given a choice, no one would want to uproot to leave. Do you think Michelle Yeoh would be what she is today if she had not ventured out of the country? Do you think you would be as successful today if you had lived here all your life, without education and work experience in America and Hong Kong, and not earning SGD and GBP?
Robert kwok move to hong kong because of .........and also because of malaysia was uk colonies , thailand and indonesia not colonies they no anyone can help if racism massacre. i was work in factory they also give priotity for race
Frankly, your videos had make me had second thoughts on Malaysia, it makes me to rethink all the good things we have on Malaysia and i started to appreciate Malaysia more. I had always loved the US, the American dream, but the disparity between Malaysia and US is closing up due to recent changes. Thanks!
im agreed with her opinion about the unfair policies. im living in australia, everytime i went back to malaysia and catched up with friends. they kept complaining how unfair the government, but then most of them are doing quite well, good business , high management level. driving good car, big house, comfortable spending, oversea holiday regularly. sometimes i questioned myself - shouldnt i leave the country?
This is very typical of some Malaysian Chinese esp those little pinky . They never realized that as a developing country, a lot of thing in Malaysia are evolving and we are part of the solution if we want changes. They are just harping on the bad sides and never appreciate the good things they are enjoying. While at the same time, I do have some friends migrated to Australia. They are now at best "average" and most of them experienced significant downgrade in lifestyle and career. I have no intention of questioning other people's choice but I just hope Malaysians sometime could be more confidence about themselves and their country.
@@omgsam2263 did they end up getting a uni degree? If they did, then they are from rich families. They fixed the unfair policies with money. I have friends who are capable of getting university degrees but did not because parents did not save up money for them. To them local u was the only option. And those who end up in local uni, were given majors that were of no interest to them. After graduating, they end up taking up jobs like grab drivers.
@@btlim4316 I'm sure you told the truth. But at the same time I too have Chinese friends from poor families. They took up PTPTN loan and got into private universities and now they have very successful careers and life. In life they are choices and efforts to be made, university is just one small chapter of your life. To simply blame it on the majors you got is being irresponsible to yourself.
@@hhc9013 ah yes. i forgot about private universities。 Those exploded in the 1990s. in the 1980s, there were no private universities. It was either local or overseas. So that is why many ended up not pursuing university if they were not offerred a spot at local u. And those PPTN loans, were only established in 1997.
我非常非常欣賞你說的這一句「我喜歡用結果來分析一件事情」 . This was how I explained to a well intention caucasian friend, who is very well-traveled and familiar with Africa, but obviously lived in Canada, UK, Africa and Norway for too long😀. His point of view was that Malaysia practices apartheid, which went largely undetected by the world. As a Malaysian Chinese, who has lived in US, Norway and like you, enjoy living in Malaysia, this was how I explained to him: About the “apartheid” in Malaysia. The reality is a bit more subtle. During the English colonization, the British has located Chinese in major towns area. While the Malay in the estates or so called kampung. The first separation or apartheid if u will was designed by the British, where Malay was deemed inferior in social status. Malay by nature are laid-back with its relatively peaceful history and easy living. The Chinese coming from a long turbulent history were wired to work hard, self- invention, so they have performed financially and academically far more superior compared to other races, notably the Malay. These two key backdrops, created a vast gap between Chinese and Malay where the minority Chinese possess majority of the wealth, possibly about 90% in the 50s thru the 70s. Hence came the First Malaysia Plan, 1966-1970, was created. Its objectives include: welfare for all, increase in the level of income, increase in the well-being of inhabitants of the rural areas, generation of employment opportunities, new economic activities, to progress with health and social welfare and electric power development. The quota system was introduced to ease the path for Malay to the economic area and university seats. This was well intended to narrow the gap. In fact, I recall my eldest brother who has always been the analytical one, said this was justified, we need to help them. All my life in Malaysia, I have never felt inferior to Malay, in fact the opposite. This is an important point that outsiders do not comprehend. Both in terms of social status and private job market, Chinese has always been privileged and the preferred recruits. In foreign invested companies and Chinese companies, you can clearly see Chinese hold important positions while Malay are at the bottom ranks. So what is apartheid? By social status, you can hardly called Chinese being inferior in Malaysia. By political policies, that’s a different story. Today this policy is outdated and needs to be abolished urgently, but that is very difficult to do when 70% of your voters enjoy those privileges, and religion further complicates things. However, similar policies are also introduced in the west. In US, there are the subsidies and universities quota to the African American. In Norway, there is the board quota for women. In South Africa, the white now feels they were the ones discriminated as quota system is introduced to place blacks on board of corporates. The Malaysia Economic Plan intention is similar to the Western ones. I don’t think it merits the branding of “apartheid”, the main difference here is Chinese has always been relatively privileged albeit hard earned.
To be clear, I almost fell out of the wheels not having the opportunity to study abroad. I must admit feeling unjust when I see many of my Malay classmates in Form Five at a convent school in KL with lesser grades had it easy with government scholarships to go abroad, “elevator ascend” . So, I definitely agree that all races must be treated equally, so does A Nomad Life. Neither she nor I are justifying the differential treatment, we all agree that it is fundamentally wrong. That said, the struggle to fend for yourself often build character, in my case I went on to complete a bachelor and master degree with partly self finance and partly scholarship from my uni in US. Today I built a successful career in high tech and well recognized by my peers, and rewarded handsomely. So the point was just to offer another perspective without any disregard for the apparent systematic injustice.
Thank you! You totally understand what I'm trying to say. I'm not trying to "justify" the government policy. Lots of countries have similar policy to "help" underperformed races, it just in most countries, the underperformed race is often the minority, but in Malaysia, it's the opposite.
I am a Malaysian that is currently working in the UK, since I am young my parents have told me to study hard and they will do their upmost best to send me overseas to study. I didn't understand why until I am a little older and started to see that there are certainly some unspoken cracks in the society. In the city, everyone lives in harmony but I am not entirely sure what people actually thinks in the outskirt (not KL, Penang and other major city) where majority of the population lies. I have been a city boy all my life but recently I started venturing out of the city during the holidays when I am back in the UK and noticed that they are still a lot of underdeveloped/poor villages out there and they are mostly the indigenous people. I am definitely more than happy that the government is supporting these people who needs more help but I am against those politicians that use us as scape goat during elections because we worked hard and amassed our wealth. The people in the city don't pay much attention to what those politician says but what about those people living outside? I really don't know what they think and if they keep creating a divide, I am just worried that the divide will just keep getting bigger and it will escalate to something worse in the future (30 - 40 years). As you rightly point out, the Chinese are better educated in the country and with that the wealth gap will only grow larger.... You are in a good position cause you can always go back to your home country if anything happens but that's not the same for the local.
Some of the most racist Malaysians I've met come from big cities, especially those in the less well-off areas. Ask the Chinese in Jalan Ipoh/Brickields what they think of Indians. Or the Chinese in Cheras what they think of Malays.
@@UMingLeeThey will think all the Malaysian Chinese will become like Kwok family or Hock Tan, Broadcom CEO… if Malaysian government abolishes quota system. 🤔
Yea, but in reality, there is still quota for each race. A 1600 SAT score Asian boy with bunch of extracurricular experience, still got rejected by many IVY leagues.
@@A-Nomad-Life Legally speaking, affirmative action is outlawed in the US. For example, the MIT class admitted last year was 40% Asian, while this year it was 47%. However, I do agree that there might be still be some biases in the admissions process.
@@A-Nomad-LifeUS has thousands of colleges. One need not go to the IVY league to be successful. It's that stupid Asian mentality that thinks IVY league school is the best. It's harder to get into UC school in California depending on the course.
I'm proud & happy to be Malaysian Chinese. Every where u go there is pros & cons. I took ACCA professional course, now I'm 50's & doing well. Dont always be negative & look at the positive.
I am proud to be a Malaysian as I am a chinese born here. I have been staying in fee country before even i have been staying in China for almost 5 years but I feel it is better to be in Malaysia as i have compare those country. Malaysia People here are very friendly of any races as food all kind of food we have and even more we just wear summer cloth whole year (That is so awesome) If you say studying if you have some $$$ maybe can goto private or Home school or goto local university here as their degrees is the same as oversea one as you took those test. Few of my friend now they really suffer due expense issue they are planning to come back to Malaysia even some of my friend from Shanghai (Malaysia born but his wife is China born). Most thing here are now cheap if another 10 time years i think real estates will jump up and can not effort to purchase it anymore.
👍👍👍Totally agreed , Chinese students- mostly can get government loans ( applicable in private universities too) for studies if they want to … always have ways & plenty of quality private universities ( some chose to study in private uni for quaranteed chosen courses , u don’t wish to go into any unwanted streams 🥴) … no one w’d be out of study or work if care to find ways in M’sia 🧐🤔
Being Malaysian Chinese, true that this discriminatory gov policy is an irritant to a point many parents want to send their children abroad and hope they get a PR and never come back. But things have changed of late. The western world is no longer so rosy. The drug problem, gun rights, racial discrimination, homelessness, daylight looting, pick pocketing, a society that is over prescribed with medication, no, it's not a place I'd send my kids to. Malaysian Chinese have done very well. The "oppression" makes us work harder and be more competitive. Most of us own our own homes, doing quite well indeed. In fact the Chinese survive and thrive anywhere, without handouts. A life full of handouts makes you lazy and weak. In Malaysia, you are free to practice your own culture, your own religion (unless it's a cult). Food is great and cheap. As a fallout of covid, nowadays there are remote job opportunities these days. A remote job from a foreign MNC that pays foreign currency, but living back in Malaysia, that's the best possible option.
What you have said and analyzed are perfectly reasonable and valid. I’m 4th gen Malaysian Chinese and my daughter is 5th gen now. We are currently residing in Melbourne but will return one day.
This is why when local Chinese say that Malaysia is racist, they haven't live in Thailand and Indonesia yet. The Tionghua a.k.a Indonesian Chinese cannot even use their indigenous name and learn Mandarin back then. Most of them have assimilated to Indonesian culture just like Thailand. At least in Malaysia, Chinese can preserve their culture, heritage and language.
@@ViolentCabbage-ym7ko because it was incorporated in federal law when diplomatic negotiating with the British to gain independence with different ethnic. what the heck with NEP, suppressing basic and equal education right of other ethnicity groups in malaysia? shouldn't it expire long ago before it became a special privilege of the majority.
Good analysis. Kudos to you. Being a Malaysian of ethnic Chinese, I never consider myself a second class citizen. I am as Malaysian as any other race. We're born here, grew up here, received basic education here, work and dutifully pay tax here.Don't really feel being discriminated against. So, what I'm trying to say is, abandon the idea of considering or calling oneself second class unless you reckon yourself so. Fellow Chinese Malaysians, walk with your heads up, you're not second class, you're just a normal citizen like anyone else.
@@howkwanglim352 never felt discriminated? You must be born after 1980 and from a middle class family that can afford to pay private uni tuition. Those born before 1980 only had 2 choice after spm. Local which means form 6, or overseas which means money.
@@btlim4316 born 1956. Was offered a place to study locally but preferred to go to Southampton cos relatives were there. Anyway, thank you for your comment. I only voiced how I feel. Everyone is free to express his view point. 谢谢你。
I would say for most people, it's perfectly fine. You don't get lots of riots or public disturbances. There is no gun crime. Probably from a rule of law pov, the biggest problem is corruption, big fish like 1MDB, and small fish like bribes for traffic offences. But these are not everyday occurrences. For an ordinary person living a quiet life I've honestly never had any public security issues.
The naysayers are usually from certain countries. Just come and stay a couple of months and experience it yourself. There are also other factors like weather , food , transports etc you would like to take into consideration before making your decision.
请你胡乱发表意见之前， 问一下马来西亚华人， 先辈如何砸锅卖铁， 奋斗来保留华人文化。又如何被边沿化。 不要站着说话不腰疼。
她讲得很像是政府的功劳
@limeelin6189 说得好，不是我们没有礼貌的去反驳博主。而是她把马来西亚华人先辈所付出的努力，说成是我们华人是一群得到了政府很多恩惠而又不懂得感恩的白眼狼。
你的意思是，在其它国家的华人，就没有任何奋斗？会不会或许他们也曾留血留汗，最后也保留不到中华文化？我们都不知道真正的情况，只是我觉得客观上，以结果回推，是一个不错的思维。她只是客观的在说出她的看法
他本意也不是这个意思，是你自己太敏感了吧？@@tzlab1561
马来西亚华人中，也有不少站着说话不腰疼的人。我作为一个土生土长的中国人，深知中国社会存在的问题。有的时候我在脸书或者油管上批评中国的问题，结果招来不少马来西亚华人的攻击辱骂。他们说我是什么牧羊犬，什么难听的话都说得出来。这些马来西亚华人，对中国一知半解，根本没在中国生活过。中国政府在国内的恶政，也只能伤害中国老百姓，这些马来西亚华人只是隔岸观火而已。他们却给中国政府的很多恶政背书，助纣为虐。这种站着说话不腰疼的做法，真的很让人厌恶。
拿着一大笔钱，只是过来旅居在吉隆坡，然后谈论这个话题，其实就是相当于盲人摸象
盲人摸象至少還摸的到象，在牆國內，是連象都碰不得的
准确
角色不同，有不同感观，这也是自然的...
版主只是发表自己的关点，不能满足所有人.. 👌🏻
你也可以说马来西亚华人当局者迷旁观者清
就是搞點流量説事。如今博客個個身懷絕技，啥都懂。😄
你说的现象，便是华人在这片土地上发奋图强的原因，没有那个靠爹靠娘靠政府的命，就只能靠自己。
文化的保留也是这种宿命的反弹。
看看“林连玉”的故事，你会明白华人有过的挣扎。
她用結果來分析一件事情，这种思维简直荒诞至极。日本人会告诉中国人，中国在二战属于战胜国而日本属于战败国，你们都赢了我们都输了，我们也si了好多人已经够惨了，你们还想怎样，以前的事都把它全忘了就一笔勾销今后别再提了，中国人会说行吗。日本兵甲砍了100中国人，日本兵乙砍了99中国人，以此可以看得出日本兵乙还是有良心的，这种逻辑合理吗。
建议博主先了解马来西亚的历史，从三大民族一起奋斗独立，接下来独立后这几十年华人的生活是怎样…请了解后再发表😊
Correct! I'm not old enough to know but from what I understand after independence, Chinese people were discriminated. I hear that it's getting worse as each yr passes. My family migrated to Australia in the 80s. My parents already said back then they had to bring us elsewhere, too racist there. They are worried about us. 😢😢 that's probably the best decision they made in their whole life to help us kids. I'm always thankful my parents made that decision. Our life is 10 times better now.
@@steph4922澳洲那麼好，為甚麼沒有給你完整的華教體系？
@@kenchua5958澳洲就是没有那么排华而以。因为我小时候就来了澳洲、大学也是英语的、所以自然英语对我来说比较容易。 澳洲也有排华的人、可是不是政府排华。感觉还是比较好的。
在马来西亚，华文统考是不受承认的，至使华人纷纷移居海外，在新加坡，有1O名华人中就有3人是马来西亚华人.
@@steph4922 给脸上纹上 我是澳洲人，我比你们白人更反华，我是好狗
上大学有固打制, 买屋子有土著价格, 买股票也有土著制. 国外来的华人, 不需要念政府学校,不需要买普通价钱的屋子.. 你们看不到我们的苦
为何华人会过得好?因为我们比一般人都努力很多很多
什么叫结果? 这是我们自己努力得来的结果..
越说越乱说,看不下去了
自以为是
虽然我是马来西亚华人，但是不熟的人我还是比较相信马来人，不知道为什么😂
还有一样，我的朋友开公司有固打制，聘请马来人，马来人告诉他宁愿少一点钱，在office 有冷气就接受这份工作，出去做sale 就不要了因为大马天气熱，把他气得呱呱叫。
@@刘麗麗看下泰国和新加坡就知道了某一些特别种族真的tak boleh pakai
@@thesiulailai4896 说得好！
你在这里生活不久。你是不理解这里华族的困境，当你长期被欺负，不公平对待，你就理解了
你在中国生活不久，你是不明白这里生活比中国轻松多了。
因为他们的钱财富和收入都不来自于马来西亚，如果有小孩也大都读国际学校，社交，生活都是包裹在外国人的泡泡里面，即使生活久了也未必能理解本地华人面临的困境。说到底，无论是中国移民，还是海外华人，都是讲华语的外国人。
我同意，但是马来西亚华族不管移民同时间去到哪，还是是一样被欺负。
华族唯一的办法就是团结，例如加入公会，争取公平对待。
@@kennyng8335我在上海生活20年很快乐 是你自己的问题
Many Malaysians who have not lived in overseas before always think the other countries are fairer and better, but the truth is not so. Discriminations, culture and living problems always happen in so called developed countries, these Malaysians might not know and they always think these foreign countries have greener and fairer pastures, which are not true.
For me, after living in and travelling to those developed countries for years, I think Malaysia is still the best country for me to live. Proud and happy to be a Malaysian Chinese.
You are absolutely right bro
Totally agree with you
.
@@yougohgoh1 Totally agree.
Not true to every msians living in the foreign countries
I have been living in the 4 continents -
Canada, uk, Usa, Africa for years differently
I personally love Canada the most in my foreign countries years
This is mainly depend on indvidually social activitiest with the west locals
There is no racist encounter in canada where I lived in Victoria BC
This is typically where u live in good high ends area or Poor incomer earners area in the foreign countries where racist happened frequently
I encountred with local Msia Malays confront me wildly fiercely whilst walking my dog in the good Chinese Garden neighbourhood park
With No Malays living here,100% msians chinese lives here in this good garden housing
There is a big crowds kampong malay bikers coming to confronted me that I cant walk my dog in the park, I am in no talking to them,i quickly took my dog into my car to drive away, this is a typical racist violent to chinese,Now u know
WHY MSIANS CHINESE POPULATION IS DECREASINGLY EACH YEAR TO ONLY 20% LIVING HERE,
EVERY MSIAN CHINESE TRYING TO MOVE TO A BETTER EQUAL HUMANS RIGHTS COUNTRIES FOR HIS/HER FUTURE GENERATIONS LIVING IN A NO QUOTA RATIO RATED COUNTRY TO MAJORITY N MINORITY IN ALL THINGS BUT ANNUAL TAXES PAYING IS 100% TO EVERY RACE MSIA CHINESE TAX PAYERS DO NOT GAINING ANY BENEFITS TO UNI EDUCATIONS
CAREERS HIGH POSTS ETC
海外华人想来马来西亚但不介意大马本身对华人的政策是因为知道他们只是移居, 马来西亚不是他们的国籍国, 所以对大马歧视华人的政策没有那么敏感, 更多关心的是国际学校, 居住条件, 和吃吃喝喝. 这和马来西亚国籍的华人是两种完全不同的感受. 但是, 如果我移居到马来西亚常住, 我是会捐钱个华校支持他们的.
华小其实是大马教育部旗下的政府学校，教师薪资，学校营运都是政府出的，偶尔的捐款是学校自身的硬件提升
马来西亚1300+所华小都是政府资助的，有时我也不知道为何华人天天说到华小有多惨烈似的! 事实就是华小是教育部底下的政府学校根本就是资金不愁的免费教育! 有些马来小的设备甚至比华小还烂!大部分人也就久久捐个10-20块提升设备，这么点付出说到自己有多悲壮简直无语。
@@威-r5q 我说的是独立中学（Sekolah Menengah Persendirian），也称马来西亚独立中学，是在马来西亚《1961年教育法令》的实施下，坚持母语教学，拒绝改制为国民型中学而被迫自行筹措经费办学的学校。因没有得到政府一分一毫的资助，因此，称之为“独立中学”。[1]
截止2018年2月，马来西亚共有60所独立中学。[1]
独立中学的办学经费来自于马来西亚华人、华社及民间，且独立中学的学生要自行付学费。独立中学的运作由董教总负责，即马来西亚华校董事联合会总会（董总，UCSCAM）和马来西亚华校教师会总会（教总）。
@@timhe9170 独中有政府拨款只是很少，2024年拨款是1890万马币，我和姐姐都是独中生，我觉得国际学校挤压了独中的生存空间，毕竟相比捐款独中更需要的是学生，唯有学源稳定学校才能生存下去
@@timhe9170 政府每年都有拨款独中，虽然独中拨款很少，但是不能说完全没有，2024年的政府拨款是1890万马币，我本身就是独中生，如果真的想为独中和华教出份力把自己孩子送去独中比捐款更有意义，毕竟我个人认为真正挤压独中学源的不是政府国中而是国际学校
我知道博主喜欢住马来西亚，但是最好不要一直把种族这些讲烂了的话题不断炒了又炒，就是对大马华人最好的帮助了
主要是无解,讲了白讲.
正面和乐观是好的，知足感恩也是好的，只是见解流于表面，似乎淡化和默许了政府对不同族群的国民有不同待遇的事实。
这些离开本地的华人，被动的和主动的都有，留下来的想离开而没有资源的也有。
这些经历磨难和顽强生命力的华文教育，天时地利之下反而成为今天你们眼中美丽的风景。
我想这些风景，绝不是宽容就能形成的。还是，应该反过来说，是国民在“宽容”那些不公的对待？
Here's the dilemma: ethnic Malaysian-born Chinese (as well as Indians) feel the unfair practices of the Bumiputera policy that actively protects the interests of Malays at the expense of other ethnics.
Foreign Chinese like to visit Malaysia as tourists or as MM2H visa holders think very differently, because right from the start, they DO NOT CONSIDER political participation or ethnic-based affirmative action to be THEIR CONCERN. In other words, those overseas Chinese visa holders in Malaysia see things from vastly different angles, they do not consider that discriminatory politics to be a relevant factor in their daily lives.
True, the mm2h visa holders would only focus on the relatively low cost of living in Malaysia.
Sometimes I see some malay RUclipsrs leaving comments calling us Chinese "balik China"
@刘麗麗 I guess they feel their peaceful life has been disturbed by the Chinese people from China. It's really understandable. Unfortunately the country needs more money from tourism including mm2h.
@@刘麗麗不用管，但黄明志也有做过这种歌就算我们吵不起那些马来人流言但我喜欢他的歌，silently critics malay ppl 😂😂
Yes, but it's only happening when you apply for higher education in Malaysia, other else is just politics. I'm Indian, and I've got many Indian friends who try to work in Chinese companies and got rejected even though we got enough qualification for the jobs, and also we Indians always being discriminated by Chinese business owners. You're lucky that at least you have many Chinese business owners in Malaysia all over the country so It's easy to get a job and you're still complaining
马来西亚是由全部种族争取独立。所以不因该分土著与非土著的待遇。因该所有种族都享有公平的待遇。不是政府对我们不错，是很多事情是我们用血与泪换回来的。请多去了解马来西亚华人的历史才来发言吧！
英殖民政府同意和支持的，因为他们也不想华人控制这个国家，因为他们认为华人会倾向中国，对他们不利。你应该了解当年的国际政治局势。
如果你说行，耀仔就不用含着泪啦当初
完全赞同你说的，博主不久前就因为签证时间差问题就数落大马政府歧视中国人，现在却在慷他人之慨，事不关己高高挂起。大马华人一路来的血汗和心酸她一点都没兴趣知道也不在乎，竟然还轻描淡写的认为“大马华人身在福中不知福”。
阶梯式所得税率几乎全球都在采用！公平吗？大马华人的误区就是被华文报纸民粹主义洗脑仇恨马来政府！土著群体的教育生活方式远远不如华人你要求他们和你一起公平竞争？你为何不回去中国和中国人竞争？多民族社会如果族群贫富差异太大，必定会造成种族仇视进而产生种族斗争！大马华人太没有见过世面！去旅游几天你根本不可能了解当地的问题！我是土生土长的大马华人华校毕业被父亲逼去新加坡念中学丧失了我在大马上大学的机会被迫到西方国家留学！我家境清寒我玩命的打工同时有5份兼职工作及暑假一天工作16个小时！我旅居海外40年但我没有一天想过放弃大马公民！我现在退休回到大马！我认同及理解政府对土著的倾斜政策！我没有怨恨政府！我视马来友族为我的兄弟同胞！他们比我们懒散，书念的少，或者不如我聪明，但是你对你的兄弟姐妹们都要求父母绝对公平吗？我完全能够接受对弱势的兄弟姐妹给予更多的照顾和包容，让一大家子其乐融融的不好吗？大马华人别再接受民粹主义的洗脑挑拨离间！好好的享受大马幸福生活吧！
这可要追溯回历史。当大马独立时，华人代表当初同意马来人特权地位而换取的公民权和华教地位。马来人不可能放弃特权所以华人也不该轻易放弃牺牲地位和得来不易的公民权和华教。
你不知道马来西亚政府歧视华人吗？除非你住在那里足够长的时间，否则你不会感受到歧视。为你的孩子着想。当你刚到一个国家时，一切看起来都很新鲜有趣。但时间一长，你就会后悔，那就晚了。到时候你就已经跟不上自己国家的发展了，回到自己的国家就跟不上步伐了。你将被困在马来西亚，你必须接受你的错误决定。所以别太天真了。当连当地人都成群结队地离开时，就出现了严重的问题，因为除非别无选择，否则没有人愿意离开自己的国家。这是一件很严重的事情，值得你深思。为你的孩子着想。俗话说，招聘时总是听起来甜甜的。加入公司后你就会看到现实。那么就太晚了。
她都财富自由躺平了，你还是想想怎么把新加坡公积金一次性取出来享受人生才是真的。
我是土生土长的华人…. 是的，政府对非土著有些不公平….不过华人的生活一般都是过的很好…. 可以说是比起一般的香港人生活好太多了…..
我有个同学去美国读了个硕士….我们现在都七十多岁了……她连房子都买不起….还是租房子住…. 还有一个朋友的儿子… 现在是一家公司的CEO…. 也是成了美国公民…. 可是现在的公司在马來西亚… 为了家人住在美国 …每个月飞来大马工作两个星期…. 每次來回飞來飞去….你觉的是享受吗……
我还是呆在马來西亚好….. 有房有车有钱花… 亲戚朋友都在身边；管它政府多给土著…我也过的很好…..
@@booteechee6560 在大马生活和养老还是很好的。但是对那些有抱负有能力，需要比较大的发展空间的年轻的华人来说，环境还是不太好，受教育和进入政府部门工作的权利都被限制
@@chengfan5421 本地华人都不想进入政府部门工作的……觉得没有前途（因为升职都是遍向马來人）薪金比私人企业还要低…. 总得來说华人都生活的很好….
您太消极了。 看得出来您人生一定很坎坷。 加油。
华人在马来西亚就相当于中国面对美国的打压，马来人感受到华人给他们的压力，所以一些制度都是对华人不友善。华人能过得好就是付出比他们多很多的努力，逆流而上的精神。
外来华人还不知道事情的严重性。等他们发现已经太迟了。
我们因为没有靠山，所以只能靠自己打拼才能活出春天的。
我经常故意和马来人去聊关于不同种族间的问题，令我感到奇怪的是，马来人总是觉得和当地华人的关系不错。并没有我想象中的那么紧张。但是我去华人餐厅吃饭闲聊时，却总是可以听到华人抱怨不公。也许不管什么问题，对于老百姓而言都没有太大关联，主要还是高层的原因。就像中国和美国。我有很多美国网友，和我关系不错，平时也是随便掏心窝子，但是高层之间却是竞争不断。
中国面对美国打压？我想是现世报呗！先反省自己又如何欺压周遭的国家呗！
说打压是有点夸张了
马来西亚很好，这是真的。
但是不妨碍我们追求我们的权利。
凭什么我们因为优秀而退让？能者多劳吗？那付出相对的尊重了吗？我们的优秀是有付出的，不是天上掉下来的。
而且播主举的例子是因为当时的美国无论是黑人还是华人，他们都是移民过去，落地生根的。
马来西亚除了真正的土著，马来人是从印尼来的，华人从中国，印度人从印度，合力申办独立。
不能相提并论。
就像中国的高考，部分人因为特殊理由而特别加分，但是你们是扶持少部分的人，我们这边是扶持70%的人，这个公平吗？
我没有否认华人先辈们的付出，只是想说不要那么悲观，这片土地还是比较包容的。至少在我这居住的一个多月来看，我感受到的是三大种族的和谐相处 互相尊重，种族间的冲突远少于我在美国和英国感受到的。
说到美国，那美国的原住民印第安人，被屠杀了很多，文化和语言都很少保存下来。
关于少部分还是多部分，我视频里说了，我的理解是永远会扶持相对弱势的群体（经济状况，受教育程度，等等）。当然，也要靠华人多多参与政治，多生育，一点一点改变现状。
马来人印尼来的，马来人在马来西亚落地生根时印尼还没独立只是荷兰殖民地😅，独立前华人还拿着中国护照
人家有人数优势，投票都能投死你，你不想妥协的结果就是回教党上台
这个世界肯定没有公平的，努力是必须，但不一定得到😅
@@tonychew4604 真是当然的含着金汤匙出生的跟一无所有的孩子起点就不一样了
请理解马来西亚历史和政治后再做这样的主题比较好
马来西亚是少数没有签ICERD 的国家，国家政策有没有种族偏差是不是一目了然？
It's not a national policy, it's part of Malaysia constitution made and written by British colonials and Malay rulers who fought and die for their country.
@@PrakathRakeshhyou know the policy/ constitution was there because it's racist in the first place 😂😂. Still racist so they never changed it. If one day, before I died, they make Malaysian born Chinese equal, that will be the day they become non racist ❤
因為他們是外國籍 馬來西亞什麼福利或政策都不會關他們事
传承不是政府的功劳 是华人自己的努力和牺牲
正解，她喜欢用結果來分析一件事情，这种思维简直荒诞至极。日本人会告诉中国人，中国在二战属于战胜国而日本属于战败国，你们都赢了我们都输了，我们也si了好多人已经够惨了，你们还想怎样，以前的事都把它忘了一笔勾销，中国人会说行吗。日本兵甲砍了100中国人，日本兵乙砍了99中国人，以此可以看得出日本兵乙还是有良心的，这种逻辑合理吗。
外来华人还不知道事情的严重性。等他们发现已经太迟了。
@@thenobleman4557 没有政府的包容，你孩子有免费华小读？很多华人也就捐了5块10块就天天说到自己有多委屈多悲壮！！可笑
@@威-r5q po 多点lp 政府不会感激你
@@thenobleman4557 你读华小有缴学费？事实就是如此
我是赞成你的说法 凡事不要只看坏的一面 从结果来看反让我们更珍惜自己语言和文化 我是马来西亚华人
@@pohwahphang7866 让你珍惜自己拥有的 不是让你合理化国家制度的不公平 逻辑能力不好的人 很容易就混淆了关系
T6t6t6
世上哪有绝对的合理公平 小小的问题就要放大吗 是无知你懂吗
@@leehyunsong7001 我上回就说过，博主这么受大马人欢迎不是没有道理的，大马领导人和官员们办不成的事却让一名中国博主妹子给办成了，她成功的让大马人觉得大马是颗闪耀的明珠是块瑰宝。
@@北上广深渝不这么说她们怎能享受到现在现场的美好，平常没錢莫到的摩登高级廣場来消费，溜达溜达？
读到一则博主回复网友54TY0（不认同）的留言，博主其中一句写到 ‘说到美国，那美国的原住民印第安人，被屠杀了很多，文化和语言都很少保存下来’。以此为依据，言外之意就是在说大马华人应该庆幸，心满意足不应该有过分的奢求，博主应该是这个意思吧。
请不要曲解我的意思，我只是以此来说明那位网友说的，美国也没有绝对公平，甚至做的更差，而且种族间的hate crime比马来西亚多的多。至少我在这里居住的这段时间看到马来西亚各族还是很和谐相处的。世界上没有完美的制度。
@@A-Nomad-Life 美国当然会比大马乱得多因为更民主自由，人种更多更复杂。大马相对和谐得多正因为大马华人都非常节制，难听的说就是有点忍气吞声。
所以你是觉得大学录取不应该有任何quota，马大医学系70%华人就70%咯；股票ipo不应该有bumi quota，股票全是华人占有就占有咯；你觉得房子不应该有bumi discount,马来人买不起可以跟华人租咯；政府公立大学应该承认统考文凭，就算统考的科学是中文教学，就算统考的评分系统不受政府管控，公立大学也应该接受。是你想要的太多，你有没有想过如果你想要的都实现了会发生什么事？
@@fluritho3486 全球第二穷国家的领导告诉国人，我们并不穷还有比我们穷的。你不用讲这么多，大马华人在自己的国家被不公平对待是铁一般的事实不容狡辩，只能遗憾的说这是大马华人世世代代不可改变的宿命。
@@HuaZan-hw4zo 说得我好想哭，乌乌😭😭😭。太难了我们，乌乌😭😭
种族固打制，马来西亚宣布独立的时候没有的，就一些马来政治人物阴谋策划区域的513种族冲突事件，然后被逼改宪法，推行所谓的新经济种族扶贫政策20年期限，再延长10年，然后不了了之，大部分马来人把这政策认为自己的该有特权，其他种族都是外来者不能质疑；马来人人数不够借着土著的名义壮大自己份额，还鼓吹土著进入回教穆斯林，扶贫是可以，可是收益的多数不是贫困群体，反而是许多政治人物白毛和tun daim，而且都不会出现在富豪榜，继续营造马来人很穷的现象。马来西亚华人现在的成就不是政府的包容，而是老一辈华人以血汗争取甚至被剥削公民权的结果。
憲法是没有改
@@lewkengsong1023 同个意思，新经济政策没有直接纳入联邦法律，但其原则和目标是通过各种政策、法律和政府倡议来实施的。
马来人的贫富差距比华人还大，然后孟加拉人，巴基斯坦人等轻易成为马来人，他们自己的蛋糕被分走，未来他们自己会有所不满。当然我们也要注意政客会不会把问题转为华人抢走他们的蛋糕。
Many forgotten New Economy Policy (quota system) is not what we agreed during Merdeka. It is a policy by government. And after many years, the new generation forgot and thinks it's their fundamental rights. When you entitled for something too long, you assume it's yours. So when we try to end the policy which long overdue, they become very sensitive
@@whwong7141 exactly. Article 153 of the federal constitution was meant to rectify the Malay poverty at the time of independence which is a sunset clause meant to expire after two decades and it does not have any reference to "malay privillange" or "malay rights" but special position of the Malays. And later the introduction of "quota system" in 1971 which was not in the original Article 153 and there no mention also "bumiputera" in the original constitution, and conveniently includes pribumi borneo in the narrative to suit their racial agenda. Over time the Malay majority see this as their birth right while the suppresed minority especially some chinese in the comment view this as a gift and should be grateful. Wtf? They already have the mindset of second class citizen the same as the actual pendatang in the video.
比上不足比下有餘..
我馬來西亞人
在海外住了36年 .
只有離開了才懂得珍惜 .
馬來西亞是很好的👍
大半辈子都已在国外生活了。
@@JH-kv8mt
是的26離開今年62 .
也不是為了政治或種族.
當初只想出去看看 .
@@bobfong3086當賺了桶金回來，有退路就覺生活沒壓力，有閒情心情平和
@@bobfong3086 我们可以更好就因为不公平和政治
@@cindylee9070 因為不好，所以我們得到更好
ah tiong 就是 ah tiong, live here only 1 month think u know everything already, ppl ancestors here bleed and cry for 4 5 generations just to become 2nd class citizen u think very fair very tolerant
馬來西亞政府並不公平。但若公平，大馬華人及印度人將在各領域佔有一面倒優勢。那麼政治可能更動蕩。
Well put
就是不公平才会导致一面倒的优势，有人送饭到口边，荡平摆烂就有饭吃，谁还要努力？这就为何每次看到新闻那些政府有扶助的公司竟然会倒闭
@@84yyds81现实是先进文明影响不了落后文明，那社会就不会发展。
@@84yyds81remind me of malakat mall 倒闭😂😂
内容实在太实用了,很受启发!分享这么高品质的知识就是最惹人喜欢的地方。继续关注您的作品
I beg to differ.
A foreigner retiring on FIRE here may view things differently compared to a person born and raised here. Foreigners would not take the political situation as seriously as the locals. If anything goes south, a foreigner may just dump everything and leave, but it’s not as easy for the locals. That’s the truth.
A foreigner not treated equally may just justify it by saying it’s because they are a foreigner. For a citizen born here, inequality means being treated as a second-class citizen compared to others.
All the Chinese cultural customs, education, and language preservation you see here are not without the sweat and blood of the locals. We fought for it, and even today, politicians still threaten to shut down Chinese schools. Every local who becomes successful can chalk it up to their multiple folds of hard work. If given a choice, no one would want to uproot to leave.
Do you think Michelle Yeoh would be what she is today if she had not ventured out of the country? Do you think you would be as successful today if you had lived here all your life, without education and work experience in America and Hong Kong, and not earning SGD and GBP?
你还没有遇到倒楣的事 ， 可能那时你的观点又不一样 ， 以前华人容易找吃因他们受教育不高又没有这么精现在就不一样 ， 现在不代表未来都容易找吃因为他们有特权 ， 大多数公务员都是马来人 ， 他们掌握权利很多政府部门执法部门不公正执法腐败你没有看到， 就好像最近的儿童院事件就是一个列子 ，这对一个国家是非常不健康的现象
哦在外國就沒有倒楣的事？
其实，不只是马来西亚华人，马来西亚人出国留学不仅是为了质量，也是为了经验。但我知道很多人也回国了。如果国内经济和环境好，会有更多的人回国。我认为大约有40%-50%的人会回国，但如果情况好的话，回国的人可能会更多
30多万的中国留学生在美国，90%以上都回国了。主要是目前的留学生不能吃苦。
回来退休好
@@stephenclark8715 現在也只有讀名校的才有機會留下來，辛苦工作不適合高學歷
@@stephenclark8715但我听说很多国际新闻有些大学生读完了回来中国没有好的工作有些还走老鼠路进去美国被抓😮
@@yunytotoro7184 这情况非常少，有，是那种家里突然断供后，国内失去经济支柱，也没了人脉背景，不得已再出来。网上也就见到过两个。概率就是0.1%，这种不具备讨论意义，没有普遍性。
参照身边的亲戚朋友，那些混得好的基本没打算回国，顶多是老了回老家养老，不过生活圈子都在海外，想回去也不容易。 另一点是马来西亚城市发展严重不平衡，除了雪隆槟城新山外，其他地方华人人口都在萎缩，发展停滞， 小镇周末市中心都是外劳出没，所以见过国外花花世界的人有几个会想回去呢
国外哪有什么花花世界？我走遍近4-50最发达国家也在海外呆了40多年！我坚定不移的放弃新加坡公民身份或美加澳欧国籍！我的财富也足够让我移民任何发达国家！但我没见到什么花花世界！周末商店关门5:30商店关门，毫无夜生活怎么成了花花世界呢？
我们许多印度和华人在受苦. 你只看到表面. 华人大部分成功虽然被压, 并不代表种族隔离无存在. 是否我们没有被阻止成功是一件善事, 美国平权行动最近已被禁止, 情况完全不同. 我们受到非常严厉的对待. 最近政府由于政治改变一点可以持续多长时间? 你们侨民当然随时欢迎因为他们想要你钱, 当然当你不受影响的时候 住宿很愉快, 然而旦你受到影响时候 . . . .
Don't include us Indians in your “sufferings”, we Indians also got discriminated by Chinese business owners
@@PrakathRakeshh Don't tell people what to say. Stop lying and get lost.
@@gglin7146 Wow, a Chinese telling me what's not true/true and telling me to shut up, LOL. Thank you for proving my point!
你有多惨啊？
以旁觀者來說出我的看法，首先必須說愛國愛這片地方和愛政府愛黨還是有差別的。影片主的觀點並不能說沒有道理，但終歸不是當事人無法深切體會大馬當地華人過往的一段難忘痛苦的經歷。拿泰國印尼和美國來比較也不妥，這些國家的情況當然比馬來西亞更糟糕，但這不代表大馬沒事華人公平對待。大馬華人的訴求應該是三大民族都應該獲得同等的國家待遇，因為他們大家都是外來戶並不是原住民，依我看來其實也沒錯也不過分。
当然公平最好。但弱势掌权都会庇佑自己族人，但如果华人生活水平教育等都垫底时，生活需要援助时，可能才会得到怜悯，获得平等待遇的一天，毕竟已经威胁不了他们的地位和资源。一旦开放平等就不可能收回。他们绝不会轻易让步的。谁知道打破平衡后他们族人下场会怎么样，到时华人生孩子有补贴了，可能将来首相也可能让位给别族。这后果那个官敢为华人争取，只能靠华人官做出成绩慢慢上位罢了。但最后也做不了首相呀。要不然就是国家暴富，像新加坡那样，蛋糕管够不用抢。这个可能性感觉比较容易实现🤣
哇 又发新视频了 这期讲得太好了 确实 马来西亚是个围城 我在海外遇到好多马来西亚华人 但我们不是马来西亚的都很向往那边生活 这个Bangsar mall真不错 越来越期待去马来西亚了
其实，不只是马来西亚华人，马来西亚人出国留学不仅是为了质量，也是为了经验。但我知道很多人也回国了。如果国内经济和环境好，会有更多的人回国。我认为大约有40%-50%的人会回国，但如果情况好的话，回国的人可能会更多
多聊聊投资和其它吧，马来西亚翻来覆去也就这点好，所有博主翻来覆去像念经一样😂
他们这些FIRE的都得靠话题来吸引流量啊
你是才进入一个国家，新人感觉光环还没退去。很多现实的问题根本没接触到。另外拿少部分华人富人来得出结论没有太多意义，大多数是普通人。普通人更在乎公平，公正。当然咯，进入一个非移民国家，或者一个移民国家，这些都是很正常的现象
非常认同
@@hoongsk7660
哪个国家更适合华人啊？除了马来西亚
这样的国家适合有钱的人去生活和养老，马来西亚是伊斯兰教国家，最好不要入籍。
@@OrlandoGolf北朝鮮或俄羅斯，它們都得中國的好朋友❤❤
Robert kwok move to hong kong because of .........and also because of malaysia was uk colonies , thailand and indonesia not colonies they no anyone can help if racism massacre. i was work in factory they also give priotity for race
非常公平的评论，深入浅出，讲得好全面，比马来西亚人还马来西亚，谢谢你您！
@@seateeling5836 对不起！ 她的观点完全不正确。 马来西亚的先辈付出很大的努力， 一身奉献， 甚至被污蔑入狱，甚至被流放， 都坚持维护华人的根、文化，才会有今天的保留完好。 华人在马来西亚， 教育被剥削， 大学学位也是固打制。 一切都必须先给马来人优先的。
有素质， 有责任的制做， 是要放心思， 访问， 分析， 讲真相。
我们华人文化保留下来，得来不易。都是有血有肉换来的！
zh.m.wikipedia.org/zh-my/林连玉
zh.m.wikipedia.org/zh-my/林连玉
被允许和靠争取，应该先去了解更深入一点再讲。
好是因为华人勤劳致富，但是政策的歧视特别在经济上，比如你华人如果把生意做大了，政府就来做你股东，不给的话就让你license不能renew…..和国内共同富裕一样，你刚来马来还没过蜜月期呢，再住几个月就知道了
共產共同富裕是明面講好的條件，大馬的和西方的就是完全雙重標準，講一套做一套！😅
住久了你就会知道了，华人的不易，
对！
其實馬來人也不容易
@@liongvenessa3833 你去共产国家住看看你会知道他们更不易！朝鲜人民都懒吗？中国8亿农民比你勤奋百倍但是比你穷百倍你知道吗？马云在中国的永久产权土地比你我还要少你懂不懂？
印度人更少也同样不容易. 只有做官的政治人物容易.
要知道海外移居来到马来西亚都是有经济条件允许的。他们不都是有着超过百万马币流动相等的资产在户头吗。如果没有相对的条件怎么会移居？本土的华人或其他友族人才都是在没有好的收入情况才逼不得已选择出走。
1998年我中学从独立中文中学转校去国立马来中学，马来同学叫我回中国。我是第三代出生的华人还被人这样叫吗。好几年前我净资产过千万马币了，我都不愿意回去马来西亚长住或者退休。每个人的生活经历不一样，要是我不是土生土长的马来西亚人或者会考虑带一千万马币回去长住。当然楼主带英镑去吃喝玩乐，没有碰到过什么糟心事。一切入那个国家的圈子不一样，感受不到本地华人的委屈。
我個人在馬來西亞生活沒覺得委屈。
這只是個人經歷
我和你一样，在马来西亚36年，突然被M摩托打，报警被欺负，上庭被欺负做了6个小时的牢，那些议员帮助都是假的，辞这里的大公司工作去了新加坡。刀没割到肉都不懂痛，驾豪车，住大屋又怎样，只要随便一个M的人打你伤你强你都没问题。身边都有类似经历都选择带过，我没有是因为有带一点西方的抵抗，加油↖(^ω^)↗
其实也有很多在其他国家的华人被歧视，如果遇到歧视就要把一千万搬走，恐怕要被银行抽很多钱😂
@@MayMay-May你没经历过不代表其他人没有。读读我们首富郭鹤年为什么离开大马和他怎样被逼迫。离开了大马他还是为大马贡献，但是还是很多马来人骂他。
我们在吉隆坡快3年了 二家 上国际学校 你的视频看了很多 你说的基本都很认同 感觉你对世界/大马的认知还蛮准确的 虽然你刚来 希望二家能开放办理你们就不用每年办签证了
你说的优点是居住在马来西亚的本地人没办法发觉的，也是很多移居的其他分享视频没有说到的。很棒
這種情況 在疫情之前 的確身邊有很多親友都有離開大馬的想法尤其是在換政府之前， 可是 這種情況在疫情之後 再加上換了政府之後 就明顯有許多人開始覺悟 開始覺得原來自己身在的這個國家是這麼好的。
大馬人太好命了 身在福中不知福😂
多了解一下林连玉及其伙伴们为了争取华文教育权付出了什么！
@@jeffersonhou9845 种族主义民粹主义的大马义和团份子！你查查一下全球大马是唯一，独一无二允许用他国语言教学的国家！连新加坡都消灭了华小！中国也绝不可能允许蒙古小学，西藏，新疆小学或者粤语小学更别论英语小学！
将心比心！别成天种族主义民粹主义的仇恨怨恨马来政府！
马来人是全球最温和，最友善，最宽容的民族，我也被逼留学海外及在海外工作创业30多年！但我义无反顾的让海外出生的子女加入大马国籍并回到大马退休！
窮人家孩子出生的我，能有免费的书读，已经很感恩了。
各有各的说词，各有各的想法，凡事中庸便好。
世界没有完全的公平或完全的不公平，要争什么都可以争。
以身作则，当个好公民。
只感恩国家，能让我有机会在五十五岁的高齢进入大学修完博士学位。
人生没遗憾。
你没遗憾，很多人有遗憾喔
@@user-dyu6jgfdk3hfl
在有生之年，尽自己所能去達成。
尽力而为便好，
成敗無所谓。
我从小到大就是读所谓的马来西亚政府教育，也毕业于政府的国立大学，我不觉得被歧视也不觉得被不公平对待。各族同学和老师相处起来也没问题👍🏻 我并非读所谓的华文独中和华人私立大学，可是我还是能够说流利的华语。我就是在就是在马来西亚政府学校学习华文华语，免费教育，不见得有任何问题，也可以申请进入国立大学，没有被排挤，大学班上华族接近一半。
说的好，其实也有少数的本地的华人受到政府的帮助。我也是读本地国立大学的，当年就有华人同学从偏远地区来的。成绩一般，但也能顺利毕业。
读独立中学，就不要和国民或国民型的学生争本地国立大学学位了。去私立大学或出国读书吧？ 外国大学都承认你的马币😅。
@@jflee9918 完全同意，現在整個大馬華人圈都被所謂獨中與華文教育騎劫，其實還有很多華人是讀國立學校，然後自學中文，例如我亦從小讀國立學校沒有甚麼華文教育但我懂中文而且我對中國文化認識不比那些所謂受中文教育的差，而且大馬華人光普很濶的但整個網絡現在就被一群大中華主義人士騎劫恍惚大馬華人就是讀華文學校熱愛中華文化對中國有歸屬感，hell no大馬華人還有很多不同光譜的
贊成，之前看到的都看到獨中出來的埋怨進不到國立。😅
其實可以像你說的，順順國立畢業，國立文憑出國也是承認的。
老兄,你只是幸运进到本地大学.当然你讲政府没有不公.你没讲有多少的华人子弟有很好的成绩申请不到！！！！而且是非常好成绩,给到的是第三或第四选择.
你没讲出真相.
去看看全国大学本地华人錄取%才来讲公不公平吧！
很多中学毕业志顾有能力笵圉下出国深造是第一选择，本地学府是为了方便和減少成本考量 原因。如果去政治化就难免会产生很多误解了
说结论：我, 马来西亚华人80后，孩子现在9岁读华小，目前在马来西亚工作与生活。我绝对认同你说的“结果论”与在视频里分析的所有观点，非常客观、理性。👍
你很勇敢，因为在马来西亚说到3R (Race, Religion, Royal) 相关的课题, 国人就会很敏感，所以言论如果偏激了请见谅。
每个人的认知、体验、经历都不一样才会有那么多不一样的观点与看法，这也是它美丽的结果，也是博主想看到的言论自由、百花齐放的现象。
我相信每件事都有它正反两面的，比如政府的不公平政策，它可能就让人才流失，国家无法更好的发展；但另外一面留下来的人就不会那么卷，在国内生活就不用那么压力。
多的就不说了，我以身为马来西亚华人为荣，感恩与知足目前拥有的一切。谢谢华人先贤的斗争与牺牲换来的母语教育、中华文化、民族特性等等。
希望博主继续勇敢的做自己，多多分享你的观点，我可不希望它受到特定舆论压力而变质变形噢！你也知道原来的你才是我们一开始喜欢与关注的对象。加油，爱你！❤️
你是一个有智慧博主，你的分析与见解很客观 ，很到位 。
外国人来马来西亚生活，因为本地物价低。本地人抢着到海外打工，因为本地薪水低。物价低和薪水低是一样的事，也就是成本低，然后你们是来生活的，我们是去赚钱的，这件事上面，我们的立场是不同的，是对立的
一针见血。只要是有钱的，到了物价低又生活便利的国家和地区，都会感到生活舒适，就像当初西方人到亚洲能请得起佣人并且随便就能找到高薪工作过人上人生活一样。这跟美国人去墨西哥没什么两样，大批退休老人去墨西哥生活，大批墨西哥非法移民涌进美国。
那些马来西亚华人如果说马来西亚不好的，大部分是没有出去看看外面的世界的。
@@yewkeesim4874 那看你要拿什么国家比较咯，如果拿落后的肯定大马是比较好的
简而言之拿自己在别处高收入时的储蓄去马来西亚生活消费与在马来西亚本地讨生活是两回事
@@84yyds81 我在美中台新生活超過20年，結論是馬來西亞最好生活，請問上訴幾個國家落後嗎？
只要到國外住了幾年, 才會知道馬來西亞美麗！
上述國家沒有回教堂每天早午晚念經，only you can take me 取西經@@tanchengs5502
3R课题（ royal, religion and race), 你今天touch 其中一个。另外两个千万千万不要碰。你一开主题，不到24小时马上被赶出马来西亚。
他即没有侮辱马来人!侮辱华人!侮辱印度人! 这里讲的是给予马来人优待的不公平政策，像这样对于优先政策的批评网络多了去，即便公开场合印度裔matrix学生都当面咨询首相安华关于入学不平等的课题，安华包庇马来族打断女学生的咨询反被骂烂
马来西亚华人的经济地位相对较高，语言文化保留较好较完整很多都是前一两代打下的基础，1970年之前的政府政策比较公平，后来才逐渐地趋向保护多数的一群。
应该是从老奸马开始施行对非马来人(由其是华人)不公平的政策。
因为在马来西亚有这些不大公平的政策而导致大马华人要更加努力
Totally
那就努力吧，別怨天尤人了，塞翁失馬焉知非福
不是进本地大学难，是有点钱有点能力的人不想卷进本地大学需要的STPM（A level 同等）。其实90年代后私立大学和外国大学分校如春笋一般成立，要skip STPM有很多选择了。更多的是华人不稀罕进本地公立大学。 但是马来西亚华人有如祥林嫂一样逢人就爱控诉不平等待遇。
确实是大部分中产华人家庭的心态
@@ccw2472 是这样的。我们上一代因为父母经济能力有限都去卷STPM进公立大学。但新一代有中产的父母，有选择。我侄儿就是不想读STPM，直接去私立大学读预科进的大学。侄女成绩比较好，本来已经拿到全额奖学金去私立大学读预科，幸运的被matriks录取就退学去了Matriks然后马大。
Frankly, your videos had make me had second thoughts on Malaysia, it makes me to rethink all the good things we have on Malaysia and i started to appreciate Malaysia more. I had always loved the US, the American dream, but the disparity between Malaysia and US is closing up due to recent changes. Thanks!
认同你的分析， 不敢说100分， 也有95 分了， 说的太好了。。
Fully agree
博主真的是一个人才，即使一面逛街一面录影也能过说的头头是道，有条有理，佩服佩服😂
你们很多外国来马来西亚人就是会不了解马来西亚华人的地位在那里。所以你来久了就会了解更多。但最近是有改善一点。
我有两个侄女 大侄女考得10A在马来亚大学 念化学工程。
小侄女11A 申请国油奖学金去美国威斯康辛大學念it 已经念了两年。
(是侄女选择去美国念书 而不是马来亚大学不收)
只要学生成绩够好 不怕担心念不到大学。邻国最爱大马人才 文化相同容易融入当地社会。台湾时常来大马招学生人才。前几个月新闻报导香港政府也要招收大马人才。
台湾的薪水能过日子？😂😂😂
@@1965Singaporean当然
大馬公立大學錄取非土族是比較嚴格的。你兩位侄女的成績太優秀了另當別論啦。我兩個妹妹成績沒她們倆位好沒有機會修第一選擇科系但還是很感恩國家，不需要背景也可以申請低利率的PTPTN..
@@1965Singaporean为什么不能？我家老三就是在台湾
@@mingleechia 哈哈哈
博主分析的挺好的，我觉得基本上击中要点，感谢分享
我是一位马来西亚去美国留学目前工作 并打算熬多几年就回去大马了。 马来西亚这种族quota 的确很不公平而且每次听到心理都难受愤怒 但其实美国也没用媒体口中描述的多好啊。歧视方面也很严重只是美国没把歧视表露出来。好多华人在美国顾着拼命工作赚钱没深入了解社会，就以为是很自由。我就举个列子：政客为了防止内幕交易而立法所有从业金融业务都受限制的购买股票听起来很合理对不对，可是政客他们却没受到这条限制。好多政客透过政治背景内幕交易从中套利例如佩洛西就是其中一名。还有 哈佛案件，NY Stuy HS quotas,政治等等等等。。。
美国保护的是掌权者和资本家的自由，而不是普通老百姓的自由，他们想限制你时还是会限制你的
Well said. The American dream is no longer valid. Racism is prevalent in the West, targeting Chinese.
美国枪击案真的让人怕怕!
来久了你就不会喜欢这里了。除了便宜，外国样样比这里好。
雖然你說你是以結果論來看這件事，但這個結果你覺得是好的，有保留的，但對當地人可能不一定。馬來西亞對其他種族歧視，不提供公平的教育，造成華人只能另外建不被認同的學校，但美國提供較公平的機制，有教無類。你以兩邊皆有人數控管，就當成兩邊都有作控管，但實際上兩邊管控的動機是完全不同的。
現在政府學校都有華語，不要講到一無是處了，有錢讀獨中，沒錢政府學校也有華語。
im agreed with her opinion about the unfair policies. im living in australia, everytime i went back to malaysia and catched up with friends. they kept complaining how unfair the government, but then most of them are doing quite well, good business , high management level. driving good car, big house, comfortable spending, oversea holiday regularly. sometimes i questioned myself - shouldnt i leave the country?
This is very typical of some Malaysian Chinese esp those little pinky . They never realized that as a developing country, a lot of thing in Malaysia are evolving and we are part of the solution if we want changes. They are just harping on the bad sides and never appreciate the good things they are enjoying. While at the same time, I do have some friends migrated to Australia. They are now at best "average" and most of them experienced significant downgrade in lifestyle and career. I have no intention of questioning other people's choice but I just hope Malaysians sometime could be more confidence about themselves and their country.
@@omgsam2263 did they end up getting a uni degree? If they did, then they are from rich families. They fixed the unfair policies with money. I have friends who are capable of getting university degrees but did not because parents did not save up money for them. To them local u was the only option. And those who end up in local uni, were given majors that were of no interest to them. After graduating, they end up taking up jobs like grab drivers.
@@btlim4316 I'm sure you told the truth. But at the same time I too have Chinese friends from poor families. They took up PTPTN loan and got into private universities and now they have very successful careers and life. In life they are choices and efforts to be made, university is just one small chapter of your life. To simply blame it on the majors you got is being irresponsible to yourself.
@@hhc9013 ah yes. i forgot about private universities。 Those exploded in the 1990s. in the 1980s, there were no private universities. It was either local or overseas. So that is why many ended up not pursuing university if they were not offerred a spot at local u. And those PPTN loans, were only established in 1997.
本地华人上大学的门路其实很多。比如几乎是全华人的拉曼大学，学费也不贵。念独中的还有不少去台湾升造，念大学，念医学，学费也不贵。没什么钱的好学生，如果不嫌弃，去Sunway念护士还几乎免学费,还有生活费呢。我们的上一代，一直向我们打毒针，说什么歧视啦，不公啦，其实我出去很多国家，也有不少亲戚朋友在外国，他们的机会反而没有比我们好。
华人低一级，二等公民是事实，这些政策就是不公平，华人过得好是 因为勤奋和智力，办中文学校的人还被剥夺了公民身份，只能说歧视没那么严重，比印尼等国家好
對， 馬來西亞華人看東西的眼界的確比較淺。
留意到年輕的華人都說馬來人很種族主義，但我發覺華人的種族主義偏見也不逞多讓。
@@tacticsrecluse 中国居民也是比马来西亚和非洲黑人低一级，没投票权的二等韭菜是事实，中国人进清北比大马华人难!
成绩普通没钱还可以申ptptn贷学金
你举出的华人深造的门路是政策不公而间接制造出来的。基本上华人家长在子女深造上花费众多。
刚拔完牙齿，2个牙角，1个大牙，才马币$3
政府医院，排1个钟就搞定了 🇲🇾人还好的！👍❤️
马来西亚就是什么都有，但什么都不是最好，结果综合起来却又是最好的一个地方😂
因为有低收入外劳服务本国人
比上不足，比下有余🎉🎉🎉
以结果來衡量公平公正原则，这种颠倒事非，本未倒置的歪论，不敢苟同。你不了解被逼离乡背井 ，父母辛辛苦苦挣钱供子女上学，毕业后各居一方的痛苦和无奈。我相信多数大马国外成功人士，背后都有一段辛酸经历和故事.....
说得好！
全世界只有马来西亚是唯一的国家，把固打制和保护政策用在多数民族身上的，别的国家都是看到少数族群很弱势，所以会出台一些保护政策来让少数民族也有一样的机会，而我们则是相反，华人作为少数群体却是缴税最高的群体，被冷落就算了，打不能还手，骂还不能还口（政治话语权不足），无论我们再优秀，得到的福利都是二等公民，就连那些回教难民的福利还比我们好，不是我们不爱这个国家，是这个国家没爱过我们 😢
你说的最贴切和精准，马来西亚华人所面对的困境和被压迫是刚来一个月的博主所无法了解的。华人表面上看起来生活还可以，因那是几代人刻苦耐劳拼搏的成果，何况也有很多低下层的生活难苦三餐不继。其实现今的马来人经过政府几十年的“特别照顾”，富人和中等阶级已比比皆是！
@@hoongsk7660博主忽略了，认为虽然公立大学虽然很难进，但是可以自费进私立大学，这个只是事实的一半，真相是公立大学的费用几乎比私立大学便宜10倍，要不是没钱，谁想要去经历公立大学的那些不公平的入学制度 😢
@@quanlim8755
那国难民比我们好？难民们也能拿到政府派钱援助金吗？也有一块医疗吗？
@@TerryThang5600拿着难民证是不能在马来西亚工作赚钱的，政府每个月都会给他们津贴，罗兴亚人，巴勒斯坦人都有拿着难民证，去查证吧😊
@@quanlim8755
网上没有你说的 政府每个月津贴难民？
无奈本地的薪水太低，最容易方便的就是去邻国新加坡打工，3倍的工资太香了。曾经有过报道，大马总共有180多万人在外地工作，其中的110多万选择新加坡，又其中的三四十万是早出晚归跨境工作，没办法大家都是为了养家糊口。
好像大马一个姓倪的部长保证，要让新加坡人来马来西亚当外劳？
Singaporeans are thinking of retiring in Malaysia. Singapore, the rich, gets richer. Damn expensive city state, no welfare for poor retirees.
@@choonhockong8215 大马也是半斤八两，最主要的是这么多年来物价涨薪水都没涨，对外地人来说在大马的生活费非常负担得起，但是对本地人只会告诉你贵贵贵。穷点的新加坡人还可以来环境好的大马退休养老，穷大马人呢却是没地方可去。
@@p.b.p.9095本地华人真的好难。。不过自求多福吧 希望越来越好
@@p.b.p.9095 穷大马人可以去新加坡或欧美当苦力变成中产！还可以在大马的小县城过的不错的生活！
穷新加坡人死路一条！他根本不可能申请第二家园住在大马！
我非常非常欣賞你說的這一句「我喜歡用結果來分析一件事情」 .
This was how I explained to a well intention caucasian friend, who is very well-traveled and familiar with Africa, but obviously lived in Canada, UK, Africa and Norway for too long😀. His point of view was that Malaysia practices apartheid, which went largely undetected by the world. As a Malaysian Chinese, who has lived in US, Norway and like you, enjoy living in Malaysia, this was how I explained to him:
About the “apartheid” in Malaysia.
The reality is a bit more subtle.
During the English colonization, the British has located Chinese in major towns area. While the Malay in the estates or so called kampung. The first separation or apartheid if u will was designed by the British, where Malay was deemed inferior in social status.
Malay by nature are laid-back with its relatively peaceful history and easy living. The Chinese coming from a long turbulent history were wired to work hard, self- invention, so they have performed financially and academically far more superior compared to other races, notably the Malay.
These two key backdrops, created a vast gap between Chinese and Malay where the minority Chinese possess majority of the wealth, possibly about 90% in the 50s thru the 70s.
Hence came the First Malaysia Plan, 1966-1970, was created.
Its objectives include: welfare for all, increase in the level of income, increase in the well-being of inhabitants of the rural areas, generation of employment opportunities, new economic activities, to progress with health and social welfare and electric power development.
The quota system was introduced to ease the path for Malay to the economic area and university seats. This was well intended to narrow the gap. In fact, I recall my eldest brother who has always been the analytical one, said this was justified, we need to help them.
All my life in Malaysia, I have never felt inferior to Malay, in fact the opposite. This is an important point that outsiders do not comprehend. Both in terms of social status and private job market, Chinese has always been privileged and the preferred recruits. In foreign invested companies and Chinese companies, you can clearly see Chinese hold important positions while Malay are at the bottom ranks.
So what is apartheid? By social status, you can hardly called Chinese being inferior in Malaysia. By political policies, that’s a different story. Today this policy is outdated and needs to be abolished urgently, but that is very difficult to do when 70% of your voters enjoy those privileges, and religion further complicates things.
However, similar policies are also introduced in the west. In US, there are the subsidies and universities quota to the African American. In Norway, there is the board quota for women. In South Africa, the white now feels they were the ones discriminated as quota system is introduced to place blacks on board of corporates.
The Malaysia Economic Plan intention is similar to the Western ones. I don’t think it merits the branding of “apartheid”, the main difference here is Chinese has always been relatively privileged albeit hard earned.
To be clear, I almost fell out of the wheels not having the opportunity to study abroad. I must admit feeling unjust when I see many of my Malay classmates in Form Five at a convent school in KL with lesser grades had it easy with government scholarships to go abroad, “elevator ascend” . So, I definitely agree that all races must be treated equally, so does A Nomad Life. Neither she nor I are justifying the differential treatment, we all agree that it is fundamentally wrong. That said, the struggle to fend for yourself often build character, in my case I went on to complete a bachelor and master degree with partly self finance and partly scholarship from my uni in US. Today I built a successful career in high tech and well recognized by my peers, and rewarded handsomely.
So the point was just to offer another perspective without any disregard for the apparent systematic injustice.
Thank you! You totally understand what I'm trying to say. I'm not trying to "justify" the government policy. Lots of countries have similar policy to "help" underperformed races, it just in most countries, the underperformed race is often the minority, but in Malaysia, it's the opposite.
@@A-Nomad-Life 说出自己的观点并没问题。我知道很多博主为了流量，都倾向于讨好观众，都说一些多数观众喜欢听的东西。你一定要守住自己的风格！
我也可以理解一般华人的不满，这等于是少数族群在养着多数族群，过后政府还把资源给了多数族群，难免会让华人心理不平衡，只能说政府在制定政策上不够精明，政府清楚知道讨好马来人才能保持自己的政治利益。政府也许没办法完全公平对待各族群，既然全部的政策都是有利于土著，那就制定一两个政策专门回馈非土著对国家的贡献吧，这样政府能照顾到土著之余又能平衡到非土著的心理。
I am a Malaysian that is currently working in the UK, since I am young my parents have told me to study hard and they will do their upmost best to send me overseas to study. I didn't understand why until I am a little older and started to see that there are certainly some unspoken cracks in the society. In the city, everyone lives in harmony but I am not entirely sure what people actually thinks in the outskirt (not KL, Penang and other major city) where majority of the population lies. I have been a city boy all my life but recently I started venturing out of the city during the holidays when I am back in the UK and noticed that they are still a lot of underdeveloped/poor villages out there and they are mostly the indigenous people.
I am definitely more than happy that the government is supporting these people who needs more help but I am against those politicians that use us as scape goat during elections because we worked hard and amassed our wealth. The people in the city don't pay much attention to what those politician says but what about those people living outside? I really don't know what they think and if they keep creating a divide, I am just worried that the divide will just keep getting bigger and it will escalate to something worse in the future (30 - 40 years). As you rightly point out, the Chinese are better educated in the country and with that the wealth gap will only grow larger.... You are in a good position cause you can always go back to your home country if anything happens but that's not the same for the local.
Some of the most racist Malaysians I've met come from big cities, especially those in the less well-off areas. Ask the Chinese in Jalan Ipoh/Brickields what they think of Indians. Or the Chinese in Cheras what they think of Malays.
@@UMingLeeThey will think all the Malaysian Chinese will become like Kwok family or Hock Tan, Broadcom CEO… if Malaysian government abolishes quota system. 🤔
My boy islamic is a trend, no body can stop it. How far can it go, no body know......
欣赏博主的分析与见解，客观，到位👍
小弟本身分享下自身的浅见哈 ：
我妹与妹夫就是个例子。
2个人从婚前到新国打工到现在已婚在直到拿到新加坡PR. 目前他们也没打算回国，因为打算拿新加坡国籍，以及购买新国房屋。
我也是支持他们这样做.
坦白说，身为马国的华人是有隐忧的. 博主看到马国的华人一般生活的还行，这其实只是表面。反之，因为政治因素等因素（举例很多房屋工程都是政府只给马来人，餐厅都是越来越伊斯兰化等）马来人在我国已经越来越富裕甚至超越华人（拜我国的拐杖政策所赐）
总结是，因为我国的政策越来越趋向伊斯兰化，以及利好偏袒于马来人，所以这是导致我国华社子弟向外移民的主因。
（p/s:现任安华视乎比较开明，让我们拭目以待吧）
有了国籍，CPF就不是你的了
新国的人也一样，外面的人想进去，里面的人却想跑出来， 很多东西有时候别只是看表面😅
博主，我先把我国槽点说在前头哈。
这里补充的一下国家趋向伊斯兰化可能发生状况:-
-戏院看戏男女必须分割2例进入观看
-一般便利店完全禁止卖酒
-disco, ktv karaoke等不能在该州营业.
以上是举例，很多时候，我国的国会议员/政府在议会是提出的政策/提议，看到我们非穆斯林眼里其实是无语/摇头的。
华社普遍上认为，全球好像都在进步，但马国却似乎开倒车，越来越固步自封，保守及趋向于伊斯兰化。反观，东盟国家诸如印尼越南等发展速度(年均gdp已超越我国）
所以我们普遍对该宗教反感。
*人才输出国* 这词也会常在新国听到，该国反而会在照顾华人比例（吸纳华人移民以保持华人人口占7成以上就是个例子）
@@WaterMaitreya对的
你不用支持 , 最好你也移民去吧❗新加坡或其他国家都好去吧❗大马很危險不適🈴你居住最好也換国籍 , 🈶空才来大马遊玩 , 我们也欢迎 , 不过錢也要多花点 OK 👌 Bye 👋
The US Supreme Court overturns race-based college admissions last year. So the US has stopped affirmative action while Malaysia hasn't.
Yea, but in reality, there is still quota for each race. A 1600 SAT score Asian boy with bunch of extracurricular experience, still got rejected by many IVY leagues.
@@A-Nomad-Life Legally speaking, affirmative action is outlawed in the US. For example, the MIT class admitted last year was 40% Asian, while this year it was 47%.
However, I do agree that there might be still be some biases in the admissions process.
@@A-Nomad-LifeUS has thousands of colleges. One need not go to the IVY league to be successful. It's that stupid Asian mentality that thinks IVY league school is the best. It's harder to get into UC school in California depending on the course.
在文化语言的保留和国家对某些种族的待遇，我认为你不应该拿印尼，泰国或其他欧美地区的华人来相提并论，你应该先去了解一下马来西亚独立建国的过程和历史，先去了解一下马来西亚华人对这个国家独立建国的贡献。 先了解一下当时英国人对马来亚独立的条件、 英国人在马来亚的国家宪法写了什么？ 明白后，你就会知道为什么马来西亚的华人现在会觉得自己是二等公民。 而且，比起其他种族，马来西亚的华人生活过得比较富裕或好一些不是因为政府给了华人什么好的待遇而是全靠华人自己努力，刻苦耐劳得来的，相信其他东南亚地区或欧美地区的华人也一样，都是靠自己努力争取来的。
在保存中华文化的辛苦过程，对所有的马来西亚华人前辈们及现辈们，他们所付出的努力与奋斗，献上深深的敬意与佩服。不能只看结果，得看过程，前因后果。还有中国的日益兴盛强大，对马来西亚的中华文化保留也有一定的隐性帮助。曾经马哈迪前首相，公布要禁止舞狮，甚至还批评华人不该使用筷子。但是后来他不再提，因为发现对中国经济的依赖越来越不能忽视，他才停止。不过暗着来的欺压华人教育与经商等方方面面，是没停止过的。
Good perspective ❤.
Welcome to Malaysia.
OMG You are so real
Well said . Let's the result show the facts . Very practical perspective views . Cheers !
I'm proud & happy to be Malaysian Chinese. Every where u go there is pros & cons. I took ACCA professional course, now I'm 50's & doing well. Dont always be negative & look at the positive.
absolutely correct
I am proud to be a Malaysian as I am a chinese born here. I have been staying in fee country before even i have been staying in China for almost 5 years but I feel it is better to be in Malaysia as i have compare those country. Malaysia People here are very friendly of any races as food all kind of food we have and even more we just wear summer cloth whole year (That is so awesome) If you say studying if you have some $$$ maybe can goto private or Home school or goto local university here as their degrees is the same as oversea one as you took those test. Few of my friend now they really suffer due expense issue they are planning to come back to Malaysia even some of my friend from Shanghai (Malaysia born but his wife is China born). Most thing here are now cheap if another 10 time years i think real estates will jump up and can not effort to purchase it anymore.
其实所谓quota 的影响已被稀释了很多，马来西亚的私立大学和外国大学分校（11间）越来越多，也没任何限制。而贫穷的华人家庭也可以申请政府学生贷款，所以也没外面想象的很大问题。另外，华裔不热衷公务员纯粹是薪水低和比较喜欢无上限的冲薪水，无关什么固打。很多政府部门包括警察，军队，海关等都特地有活动招聘华人，但很多时候是华人本身冷淡。还有虽然大马和中国人均生产是接近，但华人平均收入在马来西亚是远超中国平均值的。马来西亚最有钱的50人，除了3个马来人，3个印裔，1个华澳混血外都是华人。占比87% 。 华人在大马人口比例才23%。请问世界上有那个非华裔主流国家，能有这么多华人姓名在富豪榜里？
👍
👍👍👍Totally agreed , Chinese students- mostly can get government loans ( applicable in private universities too) for studies if they want to … always have ways & plenty of quality private universities ( some chose to study in private uni for quaranteed chosen courses , u don’t wish to go into any unwanted streams 🥴) … no one w’d be out of study or work if care to find ways in M’sia 🧐🤔
對，這是另一個大家忽略的事實
我只能說人各有志、每個人的生活品質需求不樣。40年前、米商，糖商和銀行都是華人的產業、被打壓的歷史非一個grab司機一言兩語可以道盡。我們的祖先可以為生活離鄉背井、做為後代為理想再移居也沒有什麼不可。
你说得对！没必要浪费生命去改变一个地方状况，哪里凉快哪里去！尽快享受生活 😂😂😂
@@1965Singaporean 因為、post主還沒機會去體驗。大馬在以前就已經是“四小龍”、陪者一班不肯上進的到現在默默無名。2000年以前是發展中國家，現在還是發展中國家；而中國已成了先進國。現在、國內最流行的是搞boycott⋯
@@cheeheanleong2000任何大馬人認為大馬不好可以選擇心目中的理想國生活。大馬有很多不足但對我和弟妹來説還是好地方的所以我們大專/公立大學畢業後都留在本國工作和生活。
@@MayMay-May 大馬需要你、請繼續努力
@@cheeheanleong2000 我弟妹要提早退休也沒問題因為靠租金都夠生活了😊。
海外华人的涌入, 友族发出很难听的声潮和反应
本地華人也發出難聽的聲音呀
Balik china
澳洲的外交部長也是馬來西亞華人。
Being Malaysian Chinese, true that this discriminatory gov policy is an irritant to a point many parents want to send their children abroad and hope they get a PR and never come back. But things have changed of late. The western world is no longer so rosy. The drug problem, gun rights, racial discrimination, homelessness, daylight looting, pick pocketing, a society that is over prescribed with medication, no, it's not a place I'd send my kids to. Malaysian Chinese have done very well. The "oppression" makes us work harder and be more competitive. Most of us own our own homes, doing quite well indeed. In fact the Chinese survive and thrive anywhere, without handouts. A life full of handouts makes you lazy and weak. In Malaysia, you are free to practice your own culture, your own religion (unless it's a cult). Food is great and cheap. As a fallout of covid, nowadays there are remote job opportunities these days. A remote job from a foreign MNC that pays foreign currency, but living back in Malaysia, that's the best possible option.
Salary is not high in Malaysia but cost of living is not as expensive like many European countries. .
What you have said and analyzed are perfectly reasonable and valid. I’m 4th gen Malaysian Chinese and my daughter is 5th gen now. We are currently residing in Melbourne but will return one day.
I’m one of them… I left Malaysia in 1996 for fun and I’m in nyc but will be retiring back to kl in 2028… no heart feelings and no regrets
Stay safe and stay healthy, all the best endeavour to you and your family
This is why when local Chinese say that Malaysia is racist, they haven't live in Thailand and Indonesia yet. The Tionghua a.k.a Indonesian Chinese cannot even use their indigenous name and learn Mandarin back then. Most of them have assimilated to Indonesian culture just like Thailand. At least in Malaysia, Chinese can preserve their culture, heritage and language.
Yes, I fully agree.
@@ViolentCabbage-ym7ko because it was incorporated in federal law when diplomatic negotiating with the British to gain independence with different ethnic. what the heck with NEP, suppressing basic and equal education right of other ethnicity groups in malaysia? shouldn't it expire long ago before it became a special privilege of the majority.
分析的不錯. 土生馬來族一出生就必須得归納為穆斯林別旡其他選擇！ 可以享受四个老婆政府部門工作高等教育全資助商業準証津貼平價融資種種数不盡的優待！ 而華人則被邊緣化教育程度再高再好也不給予機會去參於国家發展工程事項！ 让华人自生自滅！除非你有錢去收買貪官就別想謀生！ 公平嗎？ 太多太多令大馬华人厌倦的例子！ 移民外国也得有本錢, 本領. 所以华人被迫加強自身的語言教育能力！有本事的馬來人利用他們法定專利和政权左偷右挖也成了億万富豪！ 這樣的作為你們認為好嗎？😅
this is because the chinese/indian population was made up around 45% at that time compare to indonesia and thailand, so they have a larger voice
Justice n fairness. Not measured by who's having it worse
离开大马的是打工一族，涌入的是富人来过退休生活。
Good analysis. Kudos to you. Being a Malaysian of ethnic Chinese, I never consider myself a second class citizen. I am as Malaysian as any other race. We're born here, grew up here, received basic education here, work and dutifully pay tax here.Don't really feel being discriminated against. So, what I'm trying to say is, abandon the idea of considering or calling oneself second class unless you reckon yourself so. Fellow Chinese Malaysians, walk with your heads up, you're not second class, you're just a normal citizen like anyone else.
couldn't agree more on your point
Agree...
@@howkwanglim352 never felt discriminated? You must be born after 1980 and from a middle class family that can afford to pay private uni tuition. Those born before 1980 only had 2 choice after spm. Local which means form 6, or overseas which means money.
@@btlim4316 born 1956. Was offered a place to study locally but preferred to go to Southampton cos relatives were there. Anyway, thank you for your comment. I only voiced how I feel. Everyone is free to express his view point. 谢谢你。
这商场Bangsar Shopping Centre 是小型老牌富人区商场。卖的东西都是偏高端和高价的，所以不是那种人潮拥挤的地方。但是商铺还是100%常驻，可见顾客群的消费力。
二家有消息吗，有人说可以递交了，但是期待你聊聊
所以你的 "结果论" 只看到表面，大马华人的今天，其实是很不容易的存生。你慢慢看，会看到真实的一面的。不过说实话，众多中国人，你是相当有水准的一个。Selamat datang ke M'sia!
移民也不见得容易！华人，安啦！你问题不是政治问题，是经济与个人素质是否达到全球化自力更生的条件喔！以及时机问题，中国与马来西亚某个时期，都更好或更坏！
我不否認，不過她說的很客觀，是另一個角度的思考
大马华人不容易但这也是我们能得到最好的结果了，你还想怎样？马大医学系给你70%华人好不好？如果真发生，第二年回教党就上台了。habis
这对很多本地老一辈的马来西亚华人是非常敏感话题，很欣赏你提出来讨论的勇气，蛮担心你被他们骂，因为他们在这一个话题是非常情绪化的。我非常认同你说的，其实纵观全球以及相对其他国家，马来政府真的不算歧视华人，马来政府已经对华人非常非常宽容了。
认同😊
@@leeseokcheng1460 谢谢，我也是”斗胆“来分享一下我的想法，抛砖引玉~ 大家有不同意见都可以心平气和的讨论，求同存异嘛~
宏观来说，公平的政策不代表公正的政策。
最好的办法是分配一部分给有需要的人，我认为这是公平的。你需要一个平衡的方法。
例如，30%的大学名额分配给有需要的人，70%的名额可以根据能力而定。
应该是大马的华人比较兇，不会轻意就被同化，他们也无可奈何。
感谢介绍, 我目前居住在美国, 也在考虑移居大马, 由于我们是考虑退休, 所以对工作机会和收入其实不太在意. 但是还是比较在意大马是否是一个真正意义的法治社会. 并不是担心他的治安, 而是政府和老百姓是否有法治的观念. 这其实是安全感的很重要的来源. 能否介绍一下大马的法治状况
Then MY is not the ideal place. People go there is because cheap cheap cheap. If money not an issue, Singapore is the best!
I would say for most people, it's perfectly fine. You don't get lots of riots or public disturbances. There is no gun crime. Probably from a rule of law pov, the biggest problem is corruption, big fish like 1MDB, and small fish like bribes for traffic offences. But these are not everyday occurrences. For an ordinary person living a quiet life I've honestly never had any public security issues.
@@nicolelee7205 I disagree! Why most capable Malaysian Chinese left MY. Because MYis not a place for Chinese races. 危邦不入 乱邦不居！ conman are all over MY.
考慮法治社會的話，亞洲就是新加坡，臺灣，日本跟南韓，比較享有健全的醫療和保障生活品質
The naysayers are usually from certain countries. Just come and stay a couple of months and experience it yourself. There are also other factors like weather , food , transports etc you would like to take into consideration before making your decision.