Go to ground.news/artchad to break out of echo chambers, understand different perspectives and find common ground with Ground News. Save 40% on their unlimited access Vantage plan with my link.
You say that Canada was the gold standard for harmonious and successful immigration. Then you document how first generation immigrants are corrupt as heck and profiting off of fraudulent immigration, fraudulent education, fraudulent home building and fraudulent home renting. You also document the violence and crime and unrest that these same first generation immigrants have generated via their greedy drive to profit off of subsequent immigrant waves. Sounds to me like Canada was never a gold standard and if it was, it was perhaps 30-40 years ago when every single immigrant wanted to shed their third world way of life and adopt Canadian culture. But that hasn't been happening for 20+ years now and the fruits of our immigration system have been disastrous BY DESIGN, not disastrous by happenstance.
It was not accidental. Read book Cold Terror: How Canada Nurtures and Exports Terrorism Around the World & 2 while most people in Punjab don't support Khalistan but there is still a sizable population of people who are whipping up sentiments in the Punjab for Khalistani cause and are using international links for doing so while Indian govt. has been handing international govt.'s dossiers for years for extradition / cooperation. I understand your desire to see this from national politics perspective but not providing correct info. will not help anyone.
Good report. Thank you for showing the truth. I do disagree with one portion @21:26, because I believe this was done intentionally. Allow me to explain why. Most of the ethno-religious trouble you see that stem from some Sikhs who sympathize with the Khalistan movement. Sikhs in India live mainly in Punjab. Punjab is like the bread-basket of India. Punjabis are very hard working. The Green Revolution that turned India from a grain importing country into a grain exporting country began in Punjab. The Canadian government has a lot of land, and it was the policy of the Canadian government to grant easy visas to people predominantly from Punjab. There is also an angle where Canada might have sought to favour importing those from India who harbour anti-India sentiments and have propensity for violence. This is done to allow Canada to have leverage over India. What happened accidentally is that the serpents Canada reared in its own backyard in the hope they will bite the neighbour is causing havoc in its own backyard. There is a joke in India that it is easier for an extremist to immigrate to Canada than a doctor or an engineer. This is only the only case. Canada has, along with a Khalistan problem, a Banderastan problem. Banderastan is roughly Lvovskaya Oblast in Western Ukraine that was formerly part of the Hapsburg Monarchy and the Austria-Hungarian Empire. These people are the strongest supporters of the war against Russia which began in 2014 with the Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovich being violently removed and replaced by a western puppet called Petro Poroshenko, who then invaded the Russian speaking Donetsk and Lugansk. Canada, specifically Alberta, is home to this demographic. I am waiting to see when the *Khalistan* problem is paired by a *Banderastan* problem. Good luck Canada.
Politicians *and bureaucrats,* both national (federal) and those at local levels, universities, real-estate corps, etc, have all been in cahoots with human traffickers in this scam. I really feel bad for Canadians. I'm afraid that even after you elect the Conservatives into power, things will not get better for a long time. (The leaders in power would be different, but the bureaucrats are still going to be the same.)
what about the mass Ukranian thing? or any othr Complete mismanagement by the guvs on all lvls in Canada..........what We need to do is keep our focus on the ones We overpay n undertax to manage these things properly
@@skinnytimmy1 the favouritism shown to the country of our dippy deputy should hav made it evidnt of just how self-serving canadian politicians hav been allowed to b Love n Blessings Family!!!
It's WEF bub. THEE ELITES doing all this! Get informed. EVERYTHING you see happening WORLD WIDE is literally planned...and ON their website. GLOBAL DEI included.
Australia has a similar issue, there are multiple fake unis in Melbourne that only exist to funnel Indian students into low level truck drivers and restaurant workers, it's pretty miserable
the state of immigration is definitely a macro issue going on in most first-world countries. My guess is it's a combination of countries hurting from covid and trying to deal with declining birth rates through mass immigration.
As an actual Indian, I am not surprised. ‘Indo-Canadian Tours and Travels’ is the most common travel agency/ground transport agency name I’ve seen in my 33 years.
Guilbeault soldout this country’s ethics for Chinese heat pump, solar, ac etc technology because he choked while taking the green pill. Climate change is real. So is the Cobra Effect 💀💀💀💀💀
As well as, respect that country where you come I don't hate Canada and Canadians but Canadian government should understand what they are promoting, when these Khalistanis insult our flag, I get very angry🤬😡
Accidentally, huh? I was tutoring a newcomer engineer in English whose wife had had servants in India and now worked in a factory while he upgraded his skills, who'd been told the streets were paved with gold here. His kids were in grade 6 or 7 and informed me that Canada was intentionally creating an underclass. This was over a decade ago.
Canada also didn't fall in recession for the last 3 fiscal years because of immigrants. The Trudeau administration is not capable to handle the overall situation to a positive way.
Dude don't you understand?!?! We need immigrants to work those jobs because Americans won't work those jobs... Because those jobs won't hire Americans, because the employers pay their laborers far below the legal minimum wage, because their workers are illegal immigrants, because the employer decided to hire illegal immigrants because they could get away with paying them less. This is why the only solution is OBVIOUSLY to be more lenient on illegal immigration.
Correction: "I fired my janitor and gardener yesterday because they weren't okay with being paid under minimum wage. We need to import immigrants, our current residents are too light-skinned to enslave." -Nancy Pelosi and Kelly Osborne
We don't need agriculture workers. I did agricultural work through junior high school and high school. When my kids turned 13 and were available for agricultural work, they were turned away. Our family was told NO ONE that wasn't Mexican or South America were hired. Blatantly discriminated against.
@@slowboywhiteboardv4 The truth is that countries in the West (and even Israel) just use automation where the USA would use cheap labor. It is a sign of how strong US oligarchy is.
Don't attribute something to malice when it can be attributed to incompetence. If you think the government wanted to do this, it means you're assuming they can get things done. No, they are not, they are simply incompetent, being unable to do anything. That's why we're in the shxt show, because they didn't do all the things that they should.
@@xShadowChrisx I was referring to the government, the body/entity in the best position to stop this from happening or continuing. The people directly benefiting from of course know what's up.
@@cobytang They're not stupid, not the people on top at least. They're just willfully selling their people out. Usually because they don't consider us "their people"
Canadians don’t get a chance to have a family anymore because they can’t afford the cost of having children , putting food on the table and a roof over their head at the same time.
You have wrong numbers. It is not one million in 3 years but over one million in last one year alone. Last year only intl student numbers are over 682,000 plus over 450,000 immigrants plus refugees plus temporary workers, plus spouses, parents and siblings of intl students on long term visas plus visitors who did not return. So numbers are over 9 million in 9 years of JT liberals.
As an Indo-Canadian I have to say this is a well made video presenting facts without any bias or prejudice. Something I’ll mention is that many of the newcomers knew what they were getting into or didn’t bother to do their research. Some of them were aware of the immigration loopholes. Once their gamble failed, they pretend to be victims and protest.
Most aren't pretending to be victims, they're openly protesting having genuinely FAILED their "college" courses or simply demanding not to be blamed and to address the "broken system" implying that it's completely fine to exploit immigration loopholes as long as they exist. It's hilarious seeing them with their "don't blame us, fix your system" signs all over Canada expecting people to take them seriously 😂😂 Sad thing is, theirs always a group of liberal women that do.
Yup as another indo-Canadian it really sucks having our culture belittled and undermined due to the governments immigration policy choices… Just hoping for the day things balance out and we’re are respected as equal 🥲
@@walnuthead the only garbage we had to pick up from white neighbourhoods was roadkill. I’ve literally picked up mattresses that smell like curry. I’m not even trying to be funny, I don’t want to have this hatred in me, but when you literally have to keep going to the same road because the local Khalistani congregation doesn’t feel like paying to use the landfill (I’m not even joking, the school in that area doesn’t even have a Canadian flag, it literally only has a Khalistan flag and I don’t think there’s a single non-Indian student) it really fucking weighs down on you if you have any ounce of respect or love for the country you live in.
50% from India 45% from Pakistan 5% from the Philippines and china. Shits out of hand. It's designed to drive down wages. I had an hour and a half long interview with service Ontario. Told them I would be their manager for $20 an hour, undercutting myself trying to land the job. (I made more managing a vape shop in 2019) I never received a phone call back. But I go in there last week and there's an Indian man with an accent thicker than oatmeal, who doesn't know what theyre doing working as manager... I'm sure he only wanted minimum wage so he could remain in the country. Even at $20, I was already undercutting myself, and was only going to be able to afford living expenses, since I'd be able to walk to work... This country is beyond embarrassing at this point
Dude I had the same issue in Alberta, I applied for an electrical job at a local greenhouse cause it was ten minutes driving distance from my house. Get this, I'm a certified electrician with 17 years experience and the average rate for a journeyman electrician is 38$ an hour but usually you take a pay cut to work at a production plant so I figured 32$ per hour which is very reasonable but they were only wanting to pay 25$ per hour!! That's a 12$ an hour pay cut. The reason they do that is cause they are so used to pay low wages cause of all the immigrants that work there. So frustrating. I don't know how you guys do it out there in Ontario, like it's bad here but it has to be worse there.
@@fashyDad most jobs available in Ont without putting out a cpl lrge r all part time. the canadian guv allows this, but sum dum just blame the Ppl who r only trying to improve the quality of life for thm n their families. what needs to be done is to keep the blame wher it belongs n tht is with the Too highly paid mismanagers of Our money n the direction Our Great country goes in.
The immigration issue has always been about money. Many industries such as real estate and tertiary education would implode if it wasn't for selling to immigrants.
@@anarchostatist191 This is exactly the big lie that the 'immigration consultants' tell young immigrants. 'All Canadians have fair paying jobs, and everyone is prosperous. Why not come get one of these lucrative jobs and join the many!' haha
The Indians in Canada are very different demographic than the ones that came to the UK or even America. Canada is importing factional rivalries from the homeland
@@kc4276 Indians always seem to move in regional cliques. When I lived in France the Indians were all Pondicheri. While in San Jose they are all from Bangalore or Chennai (sundar pechal is from Chennai)
After the way you’ve explained it, it doesn’t sound like any of this was on accident at all. In fact, it seems completely intentional despite the Canadian govt’s best efforts to curb it. Also Punjabi rap and gangs were not on the bingo card but neither was any of this so here I am.
Not an accident at all. You should watch the liberal immigration minister. He spouted something along the lines of, and I quote, "international students in Canada is a lucrative business". I absolutely despise this government. They really think Canadians have the mind of a 4 year old and couldn't think for themselves.
@@charlesxchaves that’s completely fucked and I understand your frustration. America causes so much destruction in other countries that we’ve caused our own immigration problems and people want to hate people escaping terror we’ve directly caused for wanting to live a normal life. It makes me sick to my core.
First he makes fun of conservatives now he criticises immigration, I can’t believe someone would ever have a nuanced view on politics and not just follow whatever a particular ideology states
I mean, he does start this video by saying conservative concerns around immigration that are cultural/ethnic/etc are ignorant, instead the only real problem with immigration is the technocratic implementation. I don't think Art Chad has any issues with Surry or Brampton, just the speed/implementation.
Canada invited the khalistani in the 80's! The Punjabi diaspora was growing steadily through the 90's early 2019! Then Trudeau was asked to import more people by the corporations and land owners and make it look legal. So the Punjabis took the bait.
Except the cumulative population of Punjabis in Canada as part of Indian diaspora is around 25-30 per cent. A large sectionnof Gujaratis, and multiple other areas of South Indianare abound. How would you explain anything about that
@@nananou1687 In 2021, 2.66% of Canadians were of Sikh heritage. If non Sikh Punjabis are added to this total, then over 3.5% of Canadians are Punjabis.
Don't forget his father Pierre Trudeau's appeasing of them, and the video creator left out the worst event of them all- the bombing of Air India 182. The Khalistanis had committed the worst terrorist attack on an aircraft in America before 9/11.
@@nananou1687 A very small percentage of non Punjabis who visit Canada stay in Canada long term. Non Punjabi Indian Canadians are the richest and highest academically performing group in Canada.
@@nananou1687 non punjabi, indian immigrants are actually much more like their kin in US, they are well skilled while most punabi immigrants barely speak english and come to canda in droves due to misguidance through the punabi diaspora and punjabi music.
This is exactly what happens when people become ideologically devoted to one word concepts and get them confused for morality of good and bad. When your ideology doesn’t allow the possibility of immigration ever being bad for anyone involved everyone is bound to get hurt eventually. Too much of a good thing is always possible.
Mass Immigration is an explicitly bad thing, in this context and most others, calling it "too much of a good thing" just shows the wrong frame of mind in dealing with this issue. Being OK with outside groups, even of your own race or culture, coming in to compete with your native population is incredibly unwise, and shows a divorce from very real biological, cultural, and historical bonds. But the simplest way to understand it, is that every single other political concern is meaningless if you are being displaced or replaced in your polity, electorate, province, etc. Which is exactly what's going on in Canada to actual Canadians through mass immigration. There's exceptions to the rule, small amounts of immigration from your "family peoples" is one thing, particularly to get "the best", but the exceptions prove the rule and beyond that, you're playing with fire.
I hate how people just act like this came out of the blue and people weren’t saying it would turn out like this for years. “Diversity is our strength” they said.
@@datchicrayin short, because now it’s affecting them. When it’s happening places you don’t live it’s easy to ignore. Not so easy when it’s in your backyard.
Diversity is, and has always been a strength, but now the emerging far right is brainwashing uneducated idiots into hating everyone who isn't a straight white male.
I don’t think its a good idea for the original population to become a minority a few decades. Assimilation, even the exchanging of genetic material is something that takes hundreds of years, maybe a millennial. Oike when the vikings mixed with the natives in Britian and created the English, it didnt happen overnight. Took hundreds of years and it also lead to unrest for a long time. Now with all the dangerous technology we have in modern times, the west having unrest probably isn’t a good idea.😆
This is terrible. Those students you interviewed who haven't been in the country long sound utterly lost, stressed out, defeated, and also somewhag still in disbelief that after all they were told, this is what's happening them. 😔
I don’t feel bad for them, I’m sure there’s a punjab proverb somewhere equivalent to “if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is”. And look, it’s their own kind doing it to them. Why do we think we’re the same? I’m only 23 and I’m still old enough to remember when I didn’t even have to lock the doors to my house. Half of my class is Indian, they never do the projects, they never participate in class, there’s no way that this is anyone’s “best”.
they are not the best and brightest of indians and every indian knows this, i'm surprised it took canadian gov so long to figure out., the reason is canadian immigration has no filters so it attracts those indian who can't compete in india and also can't immigrate to countries like US since they aren't skilled/talented enough. Also most of the immigrating students are jatt punjabis not exactly know for being skilled or meritorious in india, in fact quite the contrary they are infamous for being rowdy and violent here. They are painting themselves as victims now, but it's not as black and white, there is a reason guns and violence is such a common theme of punabi music and in those songs canada is depicted as the wonderland.
I'm from Brazil and our country did something VERY similar a century ago: After slavery was abolished, the Brazilian government started looking for a cheap labour force from other countries. So we basically started a propaganda campaign targeted at southern Europeans and at the Japanese people, saying all of those "great" things our country had and how much opportunities we had. However, when those immigrants finally arrived, they realized that none of those opportunities were true and that they were actually being used as cheap manual labour. The worst part is that they were in so much debt that most of them couldn't go back home so they got stuck here working at low paying jobs in terrible conditions. Looks like the Canadian government is doing the exact same thing to Indians.
you know what as an indian who lives in india and is never gonna immigrate i can confirm that all majority indians in toronto are from only one state of india punjab
Not only punjab, punjabis are immigrating from all over india. Back in the days, sikhs/punjabis were backbone of military services. Now, everyone just runs to canada because its a faster access to wealth.
@@FictionHubZAPunjab has rich farmers and low employment opportunities, also the Punjabis especially the Sikhs served a lot in the BIA so a lot of them migrated when they had the chance in 1940s to 60s so they have well established communities in the commonwealth nations and to sprinkle on top the lax immigration policies of Canada lead to a a lot of Punjabis going there and in the last 10 years going to Canada or kaneda as become a part of panjabi culture
Shit feels weird when you are from India and live in India yourself and it's the first time I've seen someone actually look into the issues instead of calling us uncivilized and spewing alt right points
he is right about all of this and the indians here are victims. but lets be honest they are also uncivilized. i have seen homeless chinese people with more class
Bro I’m sorry but what do you want us to do? If CANADA is saying that about you, you guys fucked up. I’m sorry but it’s true. I go on the bus with you guys (Indians and Africans and arabs) and I see old people standing, and you guys act like you’re completely in your own space. Your people came here and made no attempt to integrate, what do you want us to think about you?
Exactly. And I mean, I am with alt right to some extent here as well. A good chunk of Indians are real sellouts and lack basic civic sense. And it makes sense, India is the multicultural liberal dream. But, we don't care about each other because we can't really relate with each other. So, all we have is individualism and caste systems. It's the byproduct of a multicultural state.
Brampton born Ontario raised I've escaped to the maritimes and now im leaving the country. Its not Brampton hasn't been since the 2000's its Bramaladesh now.
I remember in the early 2000's, white people were leaving Brampton in droves, as there were too many Indians around for their liking! Hohoho I guess it is now COMPLTELY Indian! In Calgary, the North East quadrant is nicknamed "Brown Town". I went there once to buy something from someone on Facebook Marketplace, and sure enough, it felt like I went to India!
Very very dangerous drivers in Brampton with fake driving experience from back home to get cheap insurance plus they bribe to get license here without proper test many cars are on the roads without insurance. No policing as police numbers are about same while half a million unregistered intl students, refugees and illegals etc has moved to brampton.
this is class struggle, not class warfare. class _warfare_ is not an euphemism. In the past, employers have had their own militias that they used to fight against workers protesting for better rights, that's where the term class warfare comes from.
I wish people in general were smart enough to see issues like this through the lense of class struggle instead of thinking it got like this cause liberals just love brown people or some moronic shit like that. (Like I'm sorry but the people running society are not as simple minded as the average trump voter lol 😂)
@@ThePigsmasher We.... are? The socialists and communists are two of the major groups advocating for open borders. Conservatives have been saying for over a fucking decade that immigration is just a ploy to import cheap slave labor for corporations and votes for democrats, but commie red-tards keep voting blue no matter what and then erroneously acting as though they're better than liberals.
the only person online who talked about actual issues with open mind, instead of trying to be funny edgy racist and blame everything on Indian immigrants. Good job!!
Many European Canadians do not want to be made an ethnic minority in their own country. That is a perfectly reasonable quarrel to have so yes, a lot of blame goes on the Indian immigrants, not matter how much they try to integrate or assimilate.
Yes it is STILL the students' fault that they were bamboozled. It doesn't matter what they were told- they have the internet in India, they should have enough agency to research this topic before essentially bankrupting their family to move to an entirely different continent. The English requirement in particular exemplifies this. People know if they don't speak a language- those students came to Canada knowing perfectly well that they would not be able to function adequately here and their contributions would be limited, and they came anyways. This alone should disqualify those particular students from sympathy due to arriving here in bad faith. All of the students that should not be here due to be unqualified, or by getting in through illegal means should be deported- however the Gov't should seize the assets of the colleges that have participated in the dipoloma mill scams and have gotten filty rich on the tuition fees. Those fees should mostly be returned to the students when they are sent home. Administration that knowingly participated in the scheme should be prosecuted.
As an Indo-Canadian I agree, I’ve also been saying this, that these people knew exactly what they were doing. When that falls apart they pretend to be victims and protest. They are not victims, they use immigration loopholes to get what they want.
Search engine algorithms have done a lot of damage to the Internet in all fairness. Google is going to give you the information a person of your background wants to see.
@@whitewall2253 I agree that search algorithms work against all of us- however it's still the responsibility of the student to research the topic. Typing in the results that you specifically don't want to see will also bring up results, you just need to try harder, and youtube on it's own has a lot of videos going back at least a couple years talking about these phoney college scams (from mainstream sources too). It's more likely they just engaged in confirmation bias, and didn't look for counter arguments.
No, it's not working very well even now. Being part Native and settler descent, my culture has been tread on, spit upon, and destroyed. Mass immigration has played a role in this, as our governments have made laws against us, against free speech, and have even criminally charged peaceful protesters. 😢
Im a 30 year old Indian who chose to stay in India 10 years ago because I had a good life here. Many if my friends left my city becuase they were furstrated of staying with their parents. They were not financially well to do here so they chose to leave the country. Their situatioon is much worse than it was here.
The Indian culture is bit of an issue. New Indian immigrants are taken advantage of scamed or enslaved often often by older Indians. That's not even talking about the racial discrimination experienced because of Indians in the work place. All people should be treated well not like tools to discard after abuse.
Truly...an incredible breakdown and analysis of the Indo-Canadian situation. As yet another Indo-Canadian who stumbled upon this video. You've gained a new subscriber my bro! Thank you for this, and for all that you do!!
We need more Indo-Canadians warning these people about the cost of living in Canada, and how it is not quite as advertised. I think the first thing I would tell them is that they need to have a good paying job lined up, BEFORE even thinking of immigrating ($100K/yr is middle class in Canada). These immigration consultants work at arms length of the oligarch corporations that want low-wage labor for their factories. They promise a great lifestyle, but in truth, are given salaries so low, that things would in fact be worse for immigrant after relocating. This whole program is a lie, to strand immigrants once they are bankrupt, into having to work for one of the Canadian oligarch corporations.
I think the thing that's misrepresented here is the housing crisis. I'm not denying that immigration can cause increased house/rent prices, but the reality is that plenty of places like Saskatoon, Moncton, Red Deer and Quebec city have 1-5% population increases from immigration with 20-30% increases in rents in the last year alone. Combine interest rate hikes, construction backlogs from the pandemic, and increased corporate buyers like REITs outbidding regular people (1 in 5 rental units nationwide is now owned by corporate buyers, up from 1 in 10 a decade ago) and you have the much bigger culprit for housing costs skyrocketing. Banks and landlords are taking advantage of the situation to the detriment of both immigrants and the rest of us and driving housing cost hikes
Lol funny you mention Moncton I speak enough French to live there but only make enough to live in Saint John. However I don't want cancer so I've said fackit and I'm looking at the states. Ps Fack the Irvings they've destroyed this province's environment and the peoples lives and health but "they give jobs".
@@seanandernacht800 because older Canadians get pushed out of cities and start looking at smaller places to move, hence the rent goes up, it’s still linked to immigration, and I’m tired of people trying to find a “oooo corporate greed” angle, like no, there’s too many people coming here, it’s simple as that. Where was the corporate greed 30 years ago? Why does corporate greed magically correlate with other problems that people want to ignore?
That's a misrepresentation, pretty much every city has grown by 8-10% over the last 8 years. Saskatoon is actually outpacing the GTA and even Calgary when it comes to growth over that period. As people have said largely due to internal migration. The bottom line is in 2023 we built 219,942 homes, we let in 433,842 immigrants, about 0.5 homes per immigrant (the US, for example builds 0.89 homes per immigrant), which we have maintained for decades, while over this same period we have seen some of the greatest year over year increases in the cost of housing, in the developed world. When you have lots of demand, prices are going to go up and the accommodations people can afford will get worse. I wish we could blame the banks for this one, but the solution to affordable housing is either to let less people in, thus lowering demand and allowing supply a chance to catch up, or to improve Canada's ability to build more homes (reducing red tape, investing in skilled trades, subsidizing new developments...etc.), thus allowing supply to outpace demand. "Corporate greed' is like this magical panacea that explains all of our problems, but the reality of the matter is that corporations follow the money and thus its a symptom not the root cause. Companies wouldn't be investing nearly as heavy in rental properties if supply and demand were normal, because it would be less profitable to do so. It also works against itself, because there's always a different group of corporations that stands to gain immensely from flooding the housing market. Thus, corporate greed cancels itself out.
@@papermind4010 I'm not saying that housing built isn't being outpaced by migration/immigration recently, but immigration also isn't the only factor in this equation. 30 years ago REITs and major investment firms like BlackRock weren't buying up apartment blocks, multiplex houses, and single family homes at the pace they are now, as I said, 1 in 5 rental units now. There's plenty of data to back up this acceleration, look up the work of Martine August, she's researched this extensively. 30 years ago we were also building the same amount of public housing each year that Trudeau's "once in a generation" housing fund was building over 10 years, and some Conservative premiers rejected that funding. Mulroney and Chretien gutted those old housing programs and set the pieces in motion for where we are today, historical context matters
@@lilpwnige think about what you're saying. The supply and demand nature of a commodified housing market IS the root of the problem. When you or I have to bid against a company with tons of raw capital and building assets to leverage against, who do you think has the ability to drive up prices more? 1 in 5 rental units are owned by corporations, and those are increasingly becoming single family homes, proportionally. If 20% of all rental units were to be expropriated by the government and brought back into the market and only regular people could buy them, how does that affect your supply/demand calculation? Yes, migration/immigration is a factor, the brain drain of city people moving to small towns during COVID also drove up prices, hell, I was a part of that. But until we treat housing like a human right and stop letting people own multiple houses (let alone multiple apartment blocks) until everyone has one, then capitalists keep us poors (born here or not) fighting amongst ourselves rather than fighting them
Accidental? Really? I was part of an exploited workforce in the Middle East for nearly a decade, and let me tell you-there’s nothing accidental about it. No matter how many times people try to frame it as an 'accidental slave state,' the truth is far darker. The leaders, lobbyists, and bureaucratic machinery knew exactly what they were building. My heart goes out to the younger generation, Canadians, and immigrants who now face the financial burdens this system created. You have a tough road ahead, and it’s only getting harder.
I live just outside Brampton in a majority Indian neighbourhood, and spend most of my time in Brampton so I'm used to feeling like an outsider lol. But just wanna point out that the number of Indians isn't actually more than the other immigrant groups combined. If you just look at the top 10 source countries for immigrants it is, but including the rest of the countries Indians are about 1/3 of the immigrants, the other top ten (Philippines, China, Pakistan, Iran, Nigeria, France, etc.) are another 1/3, and the remaining countries are another 1/3. Also not the majority are coming from Punjab. I'd guess its also around 1/3 of Indians coming from Punjab and are Sikhs, so they are definitely overrepresented, but Indians from all parts of India are coming in large numbers. I've met Indian international students who've come in the past year from all over India--Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Kerala, Telangana, Jammu, etc. Disproportionately the Punjabi Sikhs will go to Brampton and Surrey because that is where they're dominant, but Indians of other groups settle all across the country whether in other parts of Ontario, Quebec, Maritimes, Prairies, etc. This isn't just a Brampton issue. As someone who has spent my whole life living next to Brampton I'd actually say that the effects are felt less here than they are elsewhere in the country because there was already a large Indian community here before the Post-Covid migration wave.
will 21 million Indians move to Canada from Mumbai? The population of Mumbai, India in 2024 is estimated to be over 21.6 million people, a 1.77% increase from the previous year. The UN estimates that the population will grow to over 24 million by 2030. Mumbai is the capital of the state of Maharashtra and India's financial capital. It's also the most populated city in India, and the Mumbai Metropolitan Region is the sixth most populated metropolitan area in the world.
Not exactly it's because of the demographic disaster your those countries are suffering. Let me make simple for you. Indians are young , Highly educated, skilled, efficient and Trustworthy. So naturally MNC's and different organisations outsourcing Indians from decades for running their businesses. While natives of those countries specially youths are not Educated and skilled enough so that's why their countries organizations outsourced Indians. In USA Indian Americans are the highest earning ethanic groups and largest Tax payers to the Government of United States. Only 1% Indian American population of total countries population pays 6% of Taxes . They are the richest race over there and also same for UK. In Canada they are having share with Chinese immigrants besides as highest earning ethanic groups than major native Canadians. Yes Indians are talented so they get admired everywhere. Out of 1.4 Billion less than 1% immigrated to such nations in recent years. Majority is not leaving. And we don't need others to tell about India's greatness. India is world's fastest Growing Nation and its in 5th position right now. It's has one of the most powerful Military in the world. In terms of critical Technology innovation. India is ahead of UK and Canada specially in AI, Fintech, Space , Medical and Bio Technology, Defence and Etc.
Great journalism cbc could never ctv could never. Very educational im currently near ottawa and it is just under 1 million to get a house outside of even ottawa. I can't get a home off 6 figures and to learn that our government essentially never cracked down on these scam universities is wild and it sounds intentional. I never blamed all these students because they were sold a dream but the fact we got so bad that people are comming from a 3rd world country and finding out that it is worse than their native country is kind of disgusting.
My girlfriend is in Vancouver at the moment when i went to visit her i was shocked at how many indians were there. The job market doesnt exist, these people apply for hundreds if not thousands of jobs and theres no opportunity for them. Its hard in the US but im glad her and I will at least have some opportunity.
@@toppedtop5787corporatism. The money seeking universities and service-sector companies can’t just invite a bunch of people to immigrate to a country without the involvement of the government.
He isn't. He is still dismisses the struggles of whites due to immigration as "reactionary". I guess wanting a land for your people something every race has is a no go. being pro white is deemed as low class and is shamed.
@@constantinethecataphract5949 "land for your people" bruh you already have many lands for your people. Its shunned bevause its delusional. Or is it that you want a land only for your people
It's so crazy that we put those immigrants in sometimes even literal slums and exspect something good. I live in Germany and it's similar here. I used to help two punjabi kids with their homework in my home village. They were so friendly, honest, dedicated and proud of being german with punjabi roots. It really breaks my heart comparing this story to the situation of not only punjabis in canada but all immigrants that arrive in cities that are even hostile environments for the people that always used to live there
@@mikeyrose4183 That's kinda the point of a comparison. You take two different things and see what they have or have not in common. What Germany and Canada have in common is that both countries are too stupid to handle immigration correctly. Ofc. there are less student visa scams in Germany as this is mostly a north american thing but over all the result stays the same. Migrant families have to live in bad conditions because the government is incompetent. Btw. I'm really proud of you, that might be the first swear word that I've ever heard from a Canadian (if you're Canadian). Don't be too tough, though. You might start a world war like... nvm.
guys welcome to what italy and europe are experiencing since a decade. the migrants coming to Italy are allured by the prospective of a country with high standards of living, and while we certainly have no war, the country's economics is crumbling and everyone is running away, so both locals and immigrants remain with no job, criminality rises and sentiment of hate and division with it.
except most areas that have the worst living standards often require a revolt to dismantle the autocratic ruling class which just causes more refugees *looks at Libya*
I'm from Aus and I see a lot of racist anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim rhetoric. A common thing being thrown around is "look at what they did to Canada, the exact same thing is happening here". I never knew where it came from or what they were talking about until now. Thanks for the video, now I have an idea on where to look at things based on this type of issues.
And does being an a-hole help with reducing immigration? Instead of blaming the poor immigrants who left their failing countries, they should blame their politicians who allow this to happen
I’d say it’s closer to a million. There are so many undocumented people there, and throughout the gta. You’ve got 15 undocumented Indian “students” living in illegal basement apartments. We don’t even know how many people are actually here
Hey man, Amazing video. I usually do not comment on videos but I wanted to say some words. I am a first gen south Indian Canadian (not from the Punjab state mentioned in this video) and I think that this is a very neutral way of expressing your love for Canada. I really like how you did not bash on the students and blamed the root cause, which are the "middle men" the greed colleges and the "loose" immigration system. I also like how you were optimistic at the end and did not really show support to any political parties. Very respectable content. It makes me so sad to know that the Indian international student - Permanent Resident Loophole has gotten this bad. I first started to notice the uptick in international students around 2018-2019. I just want to add that I am not trying to generalise all international students, there are many who study and go back home, but I am aiming for the ones that come here for the reason to become a permanent resident and eventually bring their family here. What frustrates me so much is that back when I started to notice the uptick in 2018 and mentioned it to friends and forums, they all called me "racist" "ungrateful" or "your parents were immigrants". People only started changing their mind after how many issues have risen since then. Cancel culture has scared many of us to talk about such topics. I grew up in Canada so I might be a little biased here, but the issue is that Canadian "culture" is slowly fading. The Indians are hanging out with other Indians. They are not trying to learn Canadian culture. Without "culture", conflicts will arise just like the one you mentioned in the video. I just felt like I needed to let it out here in the comment section as I am sure that this video is viewed by many other first gen Canadian - Indians who feel the same way that you do. We love our country and we do not want it to get ruined. To the Indian international students who read this, I am not angry at you, I am angry at the people who brainwashed you to come here and struggle. I am angry at the money hungry people that profited off of your misery. You deserve better. Glad the government is making changes, although it may be late. I do hope the new government continues to tackle this issue quite seriously. We can not fix the international student immigration system in a day, but we can make huge steps towards it!
17:04 In Eastern Europe we have a saying: "If you're dumb enough to get scammed, you deserve to be scammed." You go to a child with such a deal, they child will raise its eyebrows.
As an Indian I really appreciate this video. Really well researched and well made without any racism. Also lokied the fact that you talked about things like Moosewala that most westerners don’t know about. This situation is ruining the image of Indians at the global stage which is really disheartening to see.
@@mikeyrose4183 You're not even Canadian as you mentioned in another comment. How exactly are your opinions relevant here? That was not a rhetorical question, I'd really like to understand where you're coming at it from.
I live in South Florida with tons of Haitians all around me. It is a known fact that they eat all sorts of creatures. We have even had people killing horses and alligators for food and ritual sacrifice. Not to mention pigeons, and rats, of course.
@@JohnPrepuceHaitians will literally eat people. And people are calling it a conspiracy when they hear stories of people seeing them cooking peoples pets or wild animals
Everything goes back to policy. Don’t blame the ones given a false hope and dreams of a better life - blame the politicians who clearly have a hidden agenda. As a first generation Canadian, I’m shocked how bad this has gotten. Also I’m just halfway through the video, but a lot of universities were legit going BROKE and relied on international students to stay afloat..
Oh and don’t forget about the “work agencies” offering work for cash, where employers get a tax break and internationals can finesse work above the restrictions, JOBS TAKEN AWAY from Canadians who are struggling to find any work.
But because they're Indians, Indians are good people, they have real religions, some of them are even Christians, unlike the "sandpeople", with their "islam", which is a fake prophet cult.
Man racial discrimination goes hard with you. I think you maybe a racist ambassador your kind of people need. You maybe a victim but it doesn't give you justification to be racist. U racist pos.@@josiek7589
Its a normal 5 day work week here, or at least it was a decade ago. Almost everyone I know in my city in Canada is working 2 jobs, and those who aren't are looking for a second one. Without a good paying professional job, 40 hours isn't enough for rent here. I don't know what that guy was talking about.
Really awesome video. I really appreciate the effort you put into properly explaining and justifying everyone's opinions. People don't behave in certain ways or believe things for no reason (at least not on a large scale like is shown in this video) and its refreshing to see a piece of media actually interested in understanding the root of a problem from all ends. I started watching you originally for your art analysis, but I feel like your channel is taking an important progression.
As an anti-immigrantism and As an Indian, let me give you a clear perspective. the state of punjab is sikh dominated. since the start of sikhism as a religion 555 years, hindus and sikhs have lived in great peace n harmony except for one riot of 1984. now many sikhs who ran away from india after 1984 still believe that there is sikh genocide happening in india. which is completely and utter nonsense. ask indian sikhs. but victimisation is profitable. so they continue that fear mongering and exort young sikhs to leave india to come to canada.
I'm in India and I'm terrified to look at the situation of those poor students, they are cheated, they are scammed, they are used and now being thrown out of their dream country 😢
I've watch my town turn into a city (one right next to the gta) and watched crime sky rocket and nothing is done i see the same type of people walking in everyday to stores and walking out buzzing with a bag full of merch from drugs stores and in the summer something like 40 cars a day get stolen here I grew up never having to lock my bike and being able to leave my doors all unlocked the gta used to have little to none shooting now its families getting attack for their car keys
Great coverage. Housing is huge issue, my parents bought a house in one of Toronto's suburbs for $365,000 in 2009, it is now $1.1M and that blows my mind. how could i ever live close to home now. i spend 3hrs a day commuting cause i cant afford rent 💀💀
That is underperforming the SP500 by a million. If your parents had bought SP500 ETF the money would be 2.1 M excluding Dividends. Even better if they put the money in a Tech ETF they would be sitting on 6.1 M excluding dividends.
Scary stories for night time story telling. I was walks into tim Hortons to get job application to get job there. Littles did I know, Baljeet was standing right behind me. I had no chance
As an Indian, I would never recommend to go to US, Canada just for living there, their popular unis are one of the best in world. Go there for improving ur career
The immigration selection system needs an overhaul. I have worked in both the US and Canadian immigration fields as legal counsel. It seems to me that Indian immigrants are quite favored by our government and they are given more quotas, less scrutiny. I have nothing against immigration, but to massively import people from one or two particular countries is not productive for the host country and for the immigrants.
Bro a note about cars. Even among the various ethnicities of India, Punjabis and Jats are especially known to live lavishly (many times out of their means) and are known for their superflous, show off culture. That is why you will see them with luxury cars, it is their culture to show off. And most immigrants to Canada can from the Punjab-Haryana region, where these two communities originate from.
Yeah, naw bro, I appreciate your nuanced and honest take, but don't make the mistake of thinking this was any sort of accident. Our leaders are and have been aware of this problem for a long time and have continued to let it rot.
How was immigrants eating cats proven false? From what people who live there say, it's happening. Also from personal experience I know that in many cultures eating dogs and cats is quite acceptable and so if they are hungry and a cat comes into their yard, what's wrong with free food.
@@cocomonglover Yes, eating cats is practiced by some Haitians and is seen as traditional since eating feral cats was done by Haitian guerrillas who fought the French during the Haitian Revolution.
@@cocomonglover Not by choice. Like many post-colonial states, it's extremely poor. They invented cookies made from literal dirt just to have something in their bellies.
I mean, just because some individuals have done it, it doesn't mean you blame the rest who aren't even remotely involved. You could try and potentially raise awareness, or increase cultural integration programs to integrate them into your culture, why just literally blame, negatively stereotype an entire ethnic group of people, just because of the actions of some.
Why didn't you talk about the real reason Canada wants high immigration: To keep the ponzi pension scheme going a little longer. Nearly every major economist acknowledges that Westerm pensions will be going bust in the 2030s and 40s. So, these immigrants will never be seeing these pensions.
Until Stephen Harper destroyed our Pension Plan by underfunding it its endowment was actually guaranteed to last till 2070! So part of the responsibility of this f****** problem goes to Stephen Harper by the way
I notice that a lot of Canadian commentators cannot accept the possibility that government could be intentionally malicious rather than accidentally negligent
@@Kimster182, Agreed. Many Canadians actually believe that their country is based upon rule of law, when in reality, in India, we joke that it is easier for a criminal to get into Canada than for a hard working doctor or engineer.
@@pmaitrasm Well, it might be intentional to bring in low skilled people and criminals. The sole authority of issuing visas is in the hands of the Canadian government. I am pretty sure, they knew the people that they were importing.
It's bad for the immigrants. Housing and food costs are way cheaper in India. And the weather is better there and family is there. And India's economy is one of the fastest growing in the world.
yup if someone is skilled enough there is actually ample opportunity in india to live a good life, there is mostly 2 groups of indians who are immigrating the most, 1st are those really high IQ and skilled indians whose talent can't be utilized properly in india and american companies offer then really good money, this first group mostly immigrates to US and UK. Then there is the second group who basically don't have much skill and are unwilling to work hard in india and compete here, these are the people who are running to the diploma mills in Canada hoping for the easy and grand life there. Most of the middle skilled indians actually stay in india and are contributing to the growth of the country.
I was prepared to see a video with contempt and stereotypes (which, I know, stems from the truth btw) but I ended up liking and subscribing to a channel of a guy who understands the world far better than most people. I am not uncomfortable with somebody showing me a mirror, but what this man has done quite well, is precisely what is missing a lot these days - rationality. Long Live Canada! From India ❤
![FORTNITE CLASSICS IS BACK! Fortnite Item Shop [November 15th, 2024] (Fortnite Chapter 5)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RbQURbeFwqs/mqdefault.jpg)
Go to ground.news/artchad to break out of echo chambers, understand different perspectives and find common ground with Ground News. Save 40% on their unlimited access Vantage plan with my link.
grats on the bag, but i'll consume fake news from my free echo chambers instead.
You say that Canada was the gold standard for harmonious and successful immigration. Then you document how first generation immigrants are corrupt as heck and profiting off of fraudulent immigration, fraudulent education, fraudulent home building and fraudulent home renting. You also document the violence and crime and unrest that these same first generation immigrants have generated via their greedy drive to profit off of subsequent immigrant waves. Sounds to me like Canada was never a gold standard and if it was, it was perhaps 30-40 years ago when every single immigrant wanted to shed their third world way of life and adopt Canadian culture. But that hasn't been happening for 20+ years now and the fruits of our immigration system have been disastrous BY DESIGN, not disastrous by happenstance.
It was not accidental. Read book Cold Terror: How Canada Nurtures and Exports Terrorism Around the World & 2 while most people in Punjab don't support Khalistan but there is still a sizable population of people who are whipping up sentiments in the Punjab for Khalistani cause and are using international links for doing so while Indian govt. has been handing international govt.'s dossiers for years for extradition / cooperation. I understand your desire to see this from national politics perspective but not providing correct info. will not help anyone.
Damn this vid was spicy
Good report. Thank you for showing the truth. I do disagree with one portion @21:26, because I believe this was done intentionally. Allow me to explain why.
Most of the ethno-religious trouble you see that stem from some Sikhs who sympathize with the Khalistan movement. Sikhs in India live mainly in Punjab. Punjab is like the bread-basket of India. Punjabis are very hard working. The Green Revolution that turned India from a grain importing country into a grain exporting country began in Punjab. The Canadian government has a lot of land, and it was the policy of the Canadian government to grant easy visas to people predominantly from Punjab.
There is also an angle where Canada might have sought to favour importing those from India who harbour anti-India sentiments and have propensity for violence. This is done to allow Canada to have leverage over India. What happened accidentally is that the serpents Canada reared in its own backyard in the hope they will bite the neighbour is causing havoc in its own backyard. There is a joke in India that it is easier for an extremist to immigrate to Canada than a doctor or an engineer.
This is only the only case. Canada has, along with a Khalistan problem, a Banderastan problem. Banderastan is roughly Lvovskaya Oblast in Western Ukraine that was formerly part of the Hapsburg Monarchy and the Austria-Hungarian Empire. These people are the strongest supporters of the war against Russia which began in 2014 with the Ukrainian president Viktor Yanukovich being violently removed and replaced by a western puppet called Petro Poroshenko, who then invaded the Russian speaking Donetsk and Lugansk. Canada, specifically Alberta, is home to this demographic.
I am waiting to see when the *Khalistan* problem is paired by a *Banderastan* problem. Good luck Canada.
yeah you dont create a slave state accidentally
yeah a very dumb point made by him
Fair, the Scammers who brought the Indians and put them in this situation knew what they were doing.
Oof. Went over your head ,huh?
All part of the plan.
Came here to say this. He lost me at this part.
He Is incorrect.
This was designed and is functioning as planned. This was not an accident or mistake.
I squarely blame Canadian politicians. They knew what they were doing when they allowed so many students from Punjab.
Politicians *and bureaucrats,* both national (federal) and those at local levels, universities, real-estate corps, etc, have all been in cahoots with human traffickers in this scam.
I really feel bad for Canadians. I'm afraid that even after you elect the Conservatives into power, things will not get better for a long time. (The leaders in power would be different, but the bureaucrats are still going to be the same.)
what about the mass Ukranian thing? or any othr Complete mismanagement by the guvs on all lvls in Canada..........what We need to do is keep our focus on the ones We overpay n undertax to manage these things properly
@Vocal-Vegan they literally have a program called jobs for Ukraine smh. How about jobs for Canadians wtf
@@skinnytimmy1 the favouritism shown to the country of our dippy deputy should hav made it evidnt of just how self-serving canadian politicians hav been allowed to b
Love n Blessings Family!!!
It's WEF bub. THEE ELITES doing all this! Get informed. EVERYTHING you see happening WORLD WIDE is literally planned...and ON their website. GLOBAL DEI included.
Australia has a similar issue, there are multiple fake unis in Melbourne that only exist to funnel Indian students into low level truck drivers and restaurant workers, it's pretty miserable
The UK too.
I bet its nowhere near the absurd level as it is here in Canada
the state of immigration is definitely a macro issue going on in most first-world countries. My guess is it's a combination of countries hurting from covid and trying to deal with declining birth rates through mass immigration.
@@lonalxaia In the UK, since 2000.
@@pontificate2090it’s not that crazy, yet. Everything is set to be the exact copy of what’s happening in Canada, just a reversed timezone this time.
Immigration exists so that leaders don't have to worry about paying their populace enough to afford families.
More slave labor for billionaire's who care about nothing but extracting money from the populace. Absolute leaches.
That's it. And identity politics exist to keep us busy fighting each other.
It's ALL about paying people less.
@@ulfhednar9304 yes bu also to keep the welfare system going, the young (including immigrants) pay for the old people pensions
Canadian boomers, like your neighbors down South, gave up on family decades ago.
I visited Punjab last year, and I saw more Canadian flags than Indian flags.
As an actual Indian, I am not surprised.
‘Indo-Canadian Tours and Travels’ is the most common travel agency/ground transport agency name I’ve seen in my 33 years.
what nonsense ? im punjabi lmao ive barely seen other flags
@@justicethedoggo3648 you are not punjabi then because I am one
@@Jewishpatriot1 your agenda won't work among real people
Honestly you didn't see auto walas parading the Canadian flags?@@justicethedoggo3648
Say their names: Trudeau, Fraser, Guilbeault, Freeland!
They broke everything in Canada! 🇨🇦
Don’t forget Singh who’s basically just a puppet of the Libs, pining for that pension money
Guilbeault soldout this country’s ethics for Chinese heat pump, solar, ac etc technology because he choked while taking the green pill.
Climate change is real. So is the Cobra Effect 💀💀💀💀💀
@@PhoenixRiseinFlame Trudeau, Freeland, and Singh are all on WEF's payroll.
"We have penetrated ze cabinets" - Klaus Schaub
Blame one person?
Or people like you who are dum.
UN->IOM->HIAS, Catholic Charities and NGO's->MegaCorporations->MSM disinfo machine->politicians
As a Indian ,I approve this Message , Please respect the country where u go...
As well as, respect that country where you come
I don't hate Canada and Canadians but Canadian government should understand what they are promoting, when these Khalistanis insult our flag, I get very angry🤬😡
Only thing proves you're not a bot is "An Indian"
I completely understand the concerns of Canadian common people. Isn't it what we Indians fell the same with Bangladeshi and Myanmar ingredients.
@@shawan4545Mexico border kin log paas kaar rahe daliy 😂😂😂 jara vedios dekh 😂😂😂
How about staying in your homeland instead?
Accidentally, huh? I was tutoring a newcomer engineer in English whose wife had had servants in India and now worked in a factory while he upgraded his skills, who'd been told the streets were paved with gold here. His kids were in grade 6 or 7 and informed me that Canada was intentionally creating an underclass. This was over a decade ago.
Yes it is very much by design. The elites want to suppress wages
yeah
@@teob3777 the engineer is the slave now in canada working in factory🤣👳♂️
@@teob3777 Engineer now tim hortons worker👳♂️
@@StinkyIndianStudentmake sure my coffee is no warmer than 75 degrees celcius
Journalism Chad
Nuance chad
Centricide Chad
Not so art now eh, bruv?
I hope he gets more techno-capital.
More like MAGA Chad. (MCGA)
1 million in 3 years? They brought in a million in 9 months.
He also said Brampton is a city of 400,000 people. It’s approaching a million now
Liberals DONT understand the difference between cultures…..they think 100 million indians is going to keep Canada …..Canada 🤦♂️🤣🤡
Cry 😂😂
Canada also didn't fall in recession for the last 3 fiscal years because of immigrants. The Trudeau administration is not capable to handle the overall situation to a positive way.
Britain moment. 😂
"We need them to pick our crops."
-Nancy Pelosi
"Who else is gonna scrub your toilets?"
-Kelly Osborne
Dude don't you understand?!?! We need immigrants to work those jobs because Americans won't work those jobs...
Because those jobs won't hire Americans, because the employers pay their laborers far below the legal minimum wage, because their workers are illegal immigrants, because the employer decided to hire illegal immigrants because they could get away with paying them less.
This is why the only solution is OBVIOUSLY to be more lenient on illegal immigration.
Correction:
"I fired my janitor and gardener yesterday because they weren't okay with being paid under minimum wage. We need to import immigrants, our current residents are too light-skinned to enslave."
-Nancy Pelosi and Kelly Osborne
Come in sista dont make this racial.
Look at your skin color: AFRICA.
Saludos 🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽
We don't need agriculture workers. I did agricultural work through junior high school and high school. When my kids turned 13 and were available for agricultural work, they were turned away. Our family was told NO ONE that wasn't Mexican or South America were hired. Blatantly discriminated against.
@@slowboywhiteboardv4 The truth is that countries in the West (and even Israel) just use automation where the USA would use cheap labor. It is a sign of how strong US oligarchy is.
"accidentally"
they let it go on for years btw
Don't attribute something to malice when it can be attributed to incompetence. If you think the government wanted to do this, it means you're assuming they can get things done. No, they are not, they are simply incompetent, being unable to do anything. That's why we're in the shxt show, because they didn't do all the things that they should.
@@cobytang you think the people paying for this don't know what they're doing lol.
They're laughing
@@xShadowChrisx I was referring to the government, the body/entity in the best position to stop this from happening or continuing. The people directly benefiting from of course know what's up.
@@cobytang They're not stupid, not the people on top at least. They're just willfully selling their people out. Usually because they don't consider us "their people"
@@cobytang I cannot assume incompetence when it's clear they are doing things according to UN's Global Compact for Migration and Agenda 2030.
government does not do anything by accident
government does it for a reason........
Its the government and YOU people.
when it comes to government never attribute anything to accident or incompetency, but to malice first, then incompetency. its never accident.
Canadians don’t get a chance to have a family anymore because they can’t afford the cost of having children , putting food on the table and a roof over their head at the same time.
Fr, have u seen how trudue keeps talking about siks as canadian and being strict about it.
You have wrong numbers. It is not one million in 3 years but over one million in last one year alone. Last year only intl student numbers are over 682,000 plus over 450,000 immigrants plus refugees plus temporary workers, plus spouses, parents and siblings of intl students on long term visas plus visitors who did not return. So numbers are over 9 million in 9 years of JT liberals.
You are right
As an Indo-Canadian I have to say this is a well made video presenting facts without any bias or prejudice. Something I’ll mention is that many of the newcomers knew what they were getting into or didn’t bother to do their research. Some of them were aware of the immigration loopholes. Once their gamble failed, they pretend to be victims and protest.
Exactly.
Facts
Most aren't pretending to be victims, they're openly protesting having genuinely FAILED their "college" courses or simply demanding not to be blamed and to address the "broken system" implying that it's completely fine to exploit immigration loopholes as long as they exist. It's hilarious seeing them with their "don't blame us, fix your system" signs all over Canada expecting people to take them seriously 😂😂 Sad thing is, theirs always a group of liberal women that do.
Yup as another indo-Canadian it really sucks having our culture belittled and undermined due to the governments immigration policy choices…
Just hoping for the day things balance out and we’re are respected as equal 🥲
Its actually still bias but its called factually bias, you cannot escape from biases whether its true or not.
I spent the last two summers cleaning up illegal garbage dumping. Guess which neighbourhoods we spent our most time around?
white
@@walnuthead the only garbage we had to pick up from white neighbourhoods was roadkill. I’ve literally picked up mattresses that smell like curry. I’m not even trying to be funny, I don’t want to have this hatred in me, but when you literally have to keep going to the same road because the local Khalistani congregation doesn’t feel like paying to use the landfill (I’m not even joking, the school in that area doesn’t even have a Canadian flag, it literally only has a Khalistan flag and I don’t think there’s a single non-Indian student) it really fucking weighs down on you if you have any ounce of respect or love for the country you live in.
@@walnuthead cope
@@papermind4010 okay
And all that despite the presence of garbage trucks passing through those neighborhoods?
50% from India 45% from Pakistan 5% from the Philippines and china. Shits out of hand. It's designed to drive down wages. I had an hour and a half long interview with service Ontario. Told them I would be their manager for $20 an hour, undercutting myself trying to land the job. (I made more managing a vape shop in 2019) I never received a phone call back. But I go in there last week and there's an Indian man with an accent thicker than oatmeal, who doesn't know what theyre doing working as manager... I'm sure he only wanted minimum wage so he could remain in the country. Even at $20, I was already undercutting myself, and was only going to be able to afford living expenses, since I'd be able to walk to work... This country is beyond embarrassing at this point
Dude I had the same issue in Alberta, I applied for an electrical job at a local greenhouse cause it was ten minutes driving distance from my house. Get this, I'm a certified electrician with 17 years experience and the average rate for a journeyman electrician is 38$ an hour but usually you take a pay cut to work at a production plant so I figured 32$ per hour which is very reasonable but they were only wanting to pay 25$ per hour!! That's a 12$ an hour pay cut. The reason they do that is cause they are so used to pay low wages cause of all the immigrants that work there. So frustrating. I don't know how you guys do it out there in Ontario, like it's bad here but it has to be worse there.
@@fashyDad most jobs available in Ont without putting out a cpl lrge r all part time.
the canadian guv allows this, but sum dum just blame the Ppl who r only trying to improve the quality of life for thm n their families.
what needs to be done is to keep the blame wher it belongs n tht is with the Too highly paid mismanagers of Our money n the direction Our Great country goes in.
@@Vocal-Vegan bro learn some English. I barely understood what you said.
are india and pakistan seeing this as a competition, cause i wouldent be suprised
Wrong... For last 15/20 years the immigration flood has been exclusive from India. Stop trying to cover up the Indian flooding Canada.
The immigration issue has always been about money. Many industries such as real estate and tertiary education would implode if it wasn't for selling to immigrants.
Wouldnt be a problem if they hooked them up with good jobs and create lots of housing.
@HalasterBlackCloak-u2w well should the govt give good jobs to candians or foreigners
@@HalasterBlackCloak-u2w Except that most Canadians don't even have good jobs or housing yet.
it's also to counter declining birth rates.
@@anarchostatist191 This is exactly the big lie that the 'immigration consultants' tell young immigrants. 'All Canadians have fair paying jobs, and everyone is prosperous. Why not come get one of these lucrative jobs and join the many!' haha
The Indians in Canada are very different demographic than the ones that came to the UK or even America.
Canada is importing factional rivalries from the homeland
It’s the same in Australia, mate - lots of Khalistanis, Palestinians, Islamic State and Pakistanis …pretty nasty scene
@@dumdumbrown4225 You forgot Haryanvis?
This.
Canada does not (by and large) get the kind of Indian immigrants that the US does.
Every single Indian knows this too.
@@kc4276 Indians always seem to move in regional cliques. When I lived in France the Indians were all Pondicheri. While in San Jose they are all from Bangalore or Chennai (sundar pechal is from Chennai)
@@httm241pondi was a french colony, nd chennai nd banglore guys are really good in STEM..this might be the reason
If you plan to go to India (don't) you could just go to Canada.
If you plan on going to Pakistan you could just go to Birmingham and Leicester in England.
New China or New India
Canadians are also horrible soulless people tho
Bro your not here too… worst opinions ever
>My toddler came out as punjabi though
Chinese historian also covered this and it's unfortunate how he turned homeless because of this
Yeah he seems like a really solid guy, I hope things work out for him soon
God Bless that dude
Who? What happened?
?
@@liltupac1536rent in Canada is completely unaffordable.
After the way you’ve explained it, it doesn’t sound like any of this was on accident at all. In fact, it seems completely intentional despite the Canadian govt’s best efforts to curb it. Also Punjabi rap and gangs were not on the bingo card but neither was any of this so here I am.
Not an accident at all. You should watch the liberal immigration minister. He spouted something along the lines of, and I quote, "international students in Canada is a lucrative business".
I absolutely despise this government. They really think Canadians have the mind of a 4 year old and couldn't think for themselves.
@@charlesxchaves that’s completely fucked and I understand your frustration. America causes so much destruction in other countries that we’ve caused our own immigration problems and people want to hate people escaping terror we’ve directly caused for wanting to live a normal life. It makes me sick to my core.
@@ZeroN1neZeroYou’re an imbecile. American foreign policy is not the cause of mass immigration.
@charlesxchaves It was the same under the conservatives. The international student and the whole immigration is a billion $ industry.
Punjabi rap is kinda fire tho ngl
First he makes fun of conservatives now he criticises immigration, I can’t believe someone would ever have a nuanced view on politics and not just follow whatever a particular ideology states
A saint fr
It's a shame it's very rare
I don't think in that video he was making fun of conservatives (the video was very unfunny)
I think it was more like self-critique
NOOO MUST THINK WHAT BOOK SAYS
I mean, he does start this video by saying conservative concerns around immigration that are cultural/ethnic/etc are ignorant, instead the only real problem with immigration is the technocratic implementation. I don't think Art Chad has any issues with Surry or Brampton, just the speed/implementation.
Canada invited the khalistani in the 80's! The Punjabi diaspora was growing steadily through the 90's early 2019!
Then Trudeau was asked to import more people by the corporations and land owners and make it look legal.
So the Punjabis took the bait.
Except the cumulative population of Punjabis in Canada as part of Indian diaspora is around 25-30 per cent. A large sectionnof Gujaratis, and multiple other areas of South Indianare abound. How would you explain anything about that
@@nananou1687 In 2021, 2.66% of Canadians were of Sikh heritage. If non Sikh Punjabis are added to this total, then over 3.5% of Canadians are Punjabis.
Don't forget his father Pierre Trudeau's appeasing of them, and the video creator left out the worst event of them all- the bombing of Air India 182. The Khalistanis had committed the worst terrorist attack on an aircraft in America before 9/11.
@@nananou1687 A very small percentage of non Punjabis who visit Canada stay in Canada long term.
Non Punjabi Indian Canadians are the richest and highest academically performing group in Canada.
@@nananou1687 non punjabi, indian immigrants are actually much more like their kin in US, they are well skilled while most punabi immigrants barely speak english and come to canda in droves due to misguidance through the punabi diaspora and punjabi music.
"Accidentally" respectfully I dont think thats the case.
It’s actually surreal, I live in Ireland with a Sikh roommate who basically said what you said
@@oscardighton8580 tell him to leave ireland
@@StinkyIndianStudent What's yo justification?
@@StinkyIndianStudent he was literally born here
@@oscardighton8580 Doesn't change a thing. He still doesn't belong there and will never be Irish. Tell him to go back to the punjab.
Okay, tell him to repatriate the homeland of his kinsmen. Is that poetic enough for you?
Bruh you know shit's fucked when the left starts complaining about immigration.
lol
This is exactly what happens when people become ideologically devoted to one word concepts and get them confused for morality of good and bad. When your ideology doesn’t allow the possibility of immigration ever being bad for anyone involved everyone is bound to get hurt eventually. Too much of a good thing is always possible.
Sugar never once caused diabetes. You can never become addicted to it.
Nuanced takes bad, pick a failed ideology and stick to it.
Liberalism failed because of extreme concepts of “everything good otherwise you’re a bad person”
Mass Immigration is an explicitly bad thing, in this context and most others, calling it "too much of a good thing" just shows the wrong frame of mind in dealing with this issue. Being OK with outside groups, even of your own race or culture, coming in to compete with your native population is incredibly unwise, and shows a divorce from very real biological, cultural, and historical bonds. But the simplest way to understand it, is that every single other political concern is meaningless if you are being displaced or replaced in your polity, electorate, province, etc. Which is exactly what's going on in Canada to actual Canadians through mass immigration.
There's exceptions to the rule, small amounts of immigration from your "family peoples" is one thing, particularly to get "the best", but the exceptions prove the rule and beyond that, you're playing with fire.
@@RingworldTyrant Trust me I’m well aware of this I’m just framing the discussion in a way to have wider appeal
I hate how people just act like this came out of the blue and people weren’t saying it would turn out like this for years. “Diversity is our strength” they said.
Yeah this was crazy and out of hand when I moved to Toronto in 2016. Idk why everyone’s just talking about it now.
@@datchicrayin short, because now it’s affecting them. When it’s happening places you don’t live it’s easy to ignore. Not so easy when it’s in your backyard.
They lied to replace you with a swarthy underclass who will never care about the nation that hosts them they have to go
Diversity is, and has always been a strength, but now the emerging far right is brainwashing uneducated idiots into hating everyone who isn't a straight white male.
I don’t think its a good idea for the original population to become a minority a few decades. Assimilation, even the exchanging of genetic material is something that takes hundreds of years, maybe a millennial. Oike when the vikings mixed with the natives in Britian and created the English, it didnt happen overnight. Took hundreds of years and it also lead to unrest for a long time. Now with all the dangerous technology we have in modern times, the west having unrest probably isn’t a good idea.😆
This is terrible. Those students you interviewed who haven't been in the country long sound utterly lost, stressed out, defeated, and also somewhag still in disbelief that after all they were told, this is what's happening them. 😔
I read an anthropology book 8 years ago and I was convinced the illegal immigrant thing was a way to moralize creating an effective slave class.
I don’t feel bad for them, I’m sure there’s a punjab proverb somewhere equivalent to “if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is”. And look, it’s their own kind doing it to them. Why do we think we’re the same? I’m only 23 and I’m still old enough to remember when I didn’t even have to lock the doors to my house. Half of my class is Indian, they never do the projects, they never participate in class, there’s no way that this is anyone’s “best”.
ONCE MORE WITH FEELING: ITS THEIR OWN KIND DOING IT TO THEM.
@@derekharvey6352 It’s both. Plenty of greedy opportunists in Canada (non-Indian descent) too getting rich off of this.
@@derekharvey6352who let them come there? not indians perhaps
they are not the best and brightest of indians and every indian knows this, i'm surprised it took canadian gov so long to figure out., the reason is canadian immigration has no filters so it attracts those indian who can't compete in india and also can't immigrate to countries like US since they aren't skilled/talented enough.
Also most of the immigrating students are jatt punjabis not exactly know for being skilled or meritorious in india, in fact quite the contrary they are infamous for being rowdy and violent here.
They are painting themselves as victims now, but it's not as black and white, there is a reason guns and violence is such a common theme of punabi music and in those songs canada is depicted as the wonderland.
I'm from Brazil and our country did something VERY similar a century ago: After slavery was abolished, the Brazilian government started looking for a cheap labour force from other countries. So we basically started a propaganda campaign targeted at southern Europeans and at the Japanese people, saying all of those "great" things our country had and how much opportunities we had. However, when those immigrants finally arrived, they realized that none of those opportunities were true and that they were actually being used as cheap manual labour. The worst part is that they were in so much debt that most of them couldn't go back home so they got stuck here working at low paying jobs in terrible conditions.
Looks like the Canadian government is doing the exact same thing to Indians.
you know what as an indian who lives in india and is never gonna immigrate i can confirm that all majority indians in toronto are from only one state of india punjab
"You know saar I am Indian saar I am one of the good ones saar pls accept me white saar"
-you
Not only punjab, punjabis are immigrating from all over india. Back in the days, sikhs/punjabis were backbone of military services. Now, everyone just runs to canada because its a faster access to wealth.
Why punjabs specifically?
@@FictionHubZAPunjab has rich farmers and low employment opportunities, also the Punjabis especially the Sikhs served a lot in the BIA so a lot of them migrated when they had the chance in 1940s to 60s so they have well established communities in the commonwealth nations and to sprinkle on top the lax immigration policies of Canada lead to a a lot of Punjabis going there and in the last 10 years going to Canada or kaneda as become a part of panjabi culture
@@FictionHubZA research the khalistan movement
Shit feels weird when you are from India and live in India yourself and it's the first time I've seen someone actually look into the issues instead of calling us uncivilized and spewing alt right points
As a Moroccan I can relate
he is right about all of this and the indians here are victims. but lets be honest they are also uncivilized. i have seen homeless chinese people with more class
Bro I’m sorry but what do you want us to do? If CANADA is saying that about you, you guys fucked up. I’m sorry but it’s true. I go on the bus with you guys (Indians and Africans and arabs) and I see old people standing, and you guys act like you’re completely in your own space. Your people came here and made no attempt to integrate, what do you want us to think about you?
Exactly. And I mean, I am with alt right to some extent here as well.
A good chunk of Indians are real sellouts and lack basic civic sense. And it makes sense, India is the multicultural liberal dream. But, we don't care about each other because we can't really relate with each other. So, all we have is individualism and caste systems. It's the byproduct of a multicultural state.
I dunno. Frankly although right is not far right enough
Brampton born Ontario raised I've escaped to the maritimes and now im leaving the country. Its not Brampton hasn't been since the 2000's its Bramaladesh now.
I remember in the early 2000's, white people were leaving Brampton in droves, as there were too many Indians around for their liking! Hohoho
I guess it is now COMPLTELY Indian! In Calgary, the North East quadrant is nicknamed "Brown Town". I went there once to buy something from someone on Facebook Marketplace, and sure enough, it felt like I went to India!
Brampton born too, but small town raised.
@@ryeguy7941 same I would say it was the equivalent of letterkenney.
@shaetteb1272 Unfortunately, the small towns are no longer small towns now.
Very very dangerous drivers in Brampton with fake driving experience from back home to get cheap insurance plus they bribe to get license here without proper test many cars are on the roads without insurance. No policing as police numbers are about same while half a million unregistered intl students, refugees and illegals etc has moved to brampton.
What Marx called a reserve army of labour my friend, class warfare.
this is class struggle, not class warfare. class _warfare_ is not an euphemism. In the past, employers have had their own militias that they used to fight against workers protesting for better rights, that's where the term class warfare comes from.
I wish people in general were smart enough to see issues like this through the lense of class struggle instead of thinking it got like this cause liberals just love brown people or some moronic shit like that. (Like I'm sorry but the people running society are not as simple minded as the average trump voter lol 😂)
EndUSURY,FiatCentralBanks,Corporatocracy,LandlordingSlumlords,50%ofgovernmentCulled
@@ThePigsmasher We.... are? The socialists and communists are two of the major groups advocating for open borders. Conservatives have been saying for over a fucking decade that immigration is just a ploy to import cheap slave labor for corporations and votes for democrats, but commie red-tards keep voting blue no matter what and then erroneously acting as though they're better than liberals.
The Marx or the Capitalist????????
the only person online who talked about actual issues with open mind, instead of trying to be funny edgy racist and blame everything on Indian immigrants. Good job!!
Dude exactly!! I never expected Artchad to be the guy who does proper journalism on this topic!!
Your right it's the Canadian government, and Indian immigrants fault.
Many European Canadians do not want to be made an ethnic minority in their own country. That is a perfectly reasonable quarrel to have so yes, a lot of blame goes on the Indian immigrants, not matter how much they try to integrate or assimilate.
@@ciceroromano5974and Corproratism who don't want to pay fair wages.
If you are so offended, why do you all go to Canada? Lmao the self entitlement😂
Yes it is STILL the students' fault that they were bamboozled. It doesn't matter what they were told- they have the internet in India, they should have enough agency to research this topic before essentially bankrupting their family to move to an entirely different continent.
The English requirement in particular exemplifies this. People know if they don't speak a language- those students came to Canada knowing perfectly well that they would not be able to function adequately here and their contributions would be limited, and they came anyways. This alone should disqualify those particular students from sympathy due to arriving here in bad faith.
All of the students that should not be here due to be unqualified, or by getting in through illegal means should be deported- however the Gov't should seize the assets of the colleges that have participated in the dipoloma mill scams and have gotten filty rich on the tuition fees. Those fees should mostly be returned to the students when they are sent home.
Administration that knowingly participated in the scheme should be prosecuted.
have u seen old generation indian parents in rural area they are nuts and everyone is turned into an emotional idiot
what a delusional comment lol, u christian bud?
As an Indo-Canadian I agree, I’ve also been saying this, that these people knew exactly what they were doing. When that falls apart they pretend to be victims and protest. They are not victims, they use immigration loopholes to get what they want.
Search engine algorithms have done a lot of damage to the Internet in all fairness. Google is going to give you the information a person of your background wants to see.
@@whitewall2253 I agree that search algorithms work against all of us- however it's still the responsibility of the student to research the topic. Typing in the results that you specifically don't want to see will also bring up results, you just need to try harder, and youtube on it's own has a lot of videos going back at least a couple years talking about these phoney college scams (from mainstream sources too).
It's more likely they just engaged in confirmation bias, and didn't look for counter arguments.
No, it's not working very well even now. Being part Native and settler descent, my culture has been tread on, spit upon, and destroyed. Mass immigration has played a role in this, as our governments have made laws against us, against free speech, and have even criminally charged peaceful protesters. 😢
You have no idea how many Americans feel for you.
That's a cycle, You did to somebody, now you're feeling it 💪✅
@@nashtrashcool Exactly the same logic pædoph1les use to justify the cycle of abuse. Guess what's coming.
Im a 30 year old Indian who chose to stay in India 10 years ago because I had a good life here. Many if my friends left my city becuase they were furstrated of staying with their parents. They were not financially well to do here so they chose to leave the country. Their situatioon is much worse than it was here.
The Indian culture is bit of an issue. New Indian immigrants are taken advantage of scamed or enslaved often often by older Indians. That's not even talking about the racial discrimination experienced because of Indians in the work place. All people should be treated well not like tools to discard after abuse.
So Canada is Dollar Store Singapore?
Singapore is Chinese
"Dubai with snow"
@@JohnnyChau-w7q Canada is only good cause some hks live there and make good yt videos
It's Punjab with snow
Canada, Australia, the UK & NZ - all dollar store Sjngapores
Truly...an incredible breakdown and analysis of the Indo-Canadian situation. As yet another Indo-Canadian who stumbled upon this video. You've gained a new subscriber my bro! Thank you for this, and for all that you do!!
We need more Indo-Canadians warning these people about the cost of living in Canada, and how it is not quite as advertised. I think the first thing I would tell them is that they need to have a good paying job lined up, BEFORE even thinking of immigrating ($100K/yr is middle class in Canada). These immigration consultants work at arms length of the oligarch corporations that want low-wage labor for their factories. They promise a great lifestyle, but in truth, are given salaries so low, that things would in fact be worse for immigrant after relocating. This whole program is a lie, to strand immigrants once they are bankrupt, into having to work for one of the Canadian oligarch corporations.
I think the thing that's misrepresented here is the housing crisis. I'm not denying that immigration can cause increased house/rent prices, but the reality is that plenty of places like Saskatoon, Moncton, Red Deer and Quebec city have 1-5% population increases from immigration with 20-30% increases in rents in the last year alone. Combine interest rate hikes, construction backlogs from the pandemic, and increased corporate buyers like REITs outbidding regular people (1 in 5 rental units nationwide is now owned by corporate buyers, up from 1 in 10 a decade ago) and you have the much bigger culprit for housing costs skyrocketing. Banks and landlords are taking advantage of the situation to the detriment of both immigrants and the rest of us and driving housing cost hikes
Lol funny you mention Moncton I speak enough French to live there but only make enough to live in Saint John. However I don't want cancer so I've said fackit and I'm looking at the states.
Ps Fack the Irvings they've destroyed this province's environment and the peoples lives and health but "they give jobs".
@@seanandernacht800 because older Canadians get pushed out of cities and start looking at smaller places to move, hence the rent goes up, it’s still linked to immigration, and I’m tired of people trying to find a “oooo corporate greed” angle, like no, there’s too many people coming here, it’s simple as that. Where was the corporate greed 30 years ago? Why does corporate greed magically correlate with other problems that people want to ignore?
That's a misrepresentation, pretty much every city has grown by 8-10% over the last 8 years. Saskatoon is actually outpacing the GTA and even Calgary when it comes to growth over that period. As people have said largely due to internal migration. The bottom line is in 2023 we built 219,942 homes, we let in 433,842 immigrants, about 0.5 homes per immigrant (the US, for example builds 0.89 homes per immigrant), which we have maintained for decades, while over this same period we have seen some of the greatest year over year increases in the cost of housing, in the developed world.
When you have lots of demand, prices are going to go up and the accommodations people can afford will get worse. I wish we could blame the banks for this one, but the solution to affordable housing is either to let less people in, thus lowering demand and allowing supply a chance to catch up, or to improve Canada's ability to build more homes (reducing red tape, investing in skilled trades, subsidizing new developments...etc.), thus allowing supply to outpace demand.
"Corporate greed' is like this magical panacea that explains all of our problems, but the reality of the matter is that corporations follow the money and thus its a symptom not the root cause. Companies wouldn't be investing nearly as heavy in rental properties if supply and demand were normal, because it would be less profitable to do so. It also works against itself, because there's always a different group of corporations that stands to gain immensely from flooding the housing market. Thus, corporate greed cancels itself out.
@@papermind4010 I'm not saying that housing built isn't being outpaced by migration/immigration recently, but immigration also isn't the only factor in this equation. 30 years ago REITs and major investment firms like BlackRock weren't buying up apartment blocks, multiplex houses, and single family homes at the pace they are now, as I said, 1 in 5 rental units now. There's plenty of data to back up this acceleration, look up the work of Martine August, she's researched this extensively. 30 years ago we were also building the same amount of public housing each year that Trudeau's "once in a generation" housing fund was building over 10 years, and some Conservative premiers rejected that funding. Mulroney and Chretien gutted those old housing programs and set the pieces in motion for where we are today, historical context matters
@@lilpwnige think about what you're saying. The supply and demand nature of a commodified housing market IS the root of the problem. When you or I have to bid against a company with tons of raw capital and building assets to leverage against, who do you think has the ability to drive up prices more? 1 in 5 rental units are owned by corporations, and those are increasingly becoming single family homes, proportionally. If 20% of all rental units were to be expropriated by the government and brought back into the market and only regular people could buy them, how does that affect your supply/demand calculation? Yes, migration/immigration is a factor, the brain drain of city people moving to small towns during COVID also drove up prices, hell, I was a part of that. But until we treat housing like a human right and stop letting people own multiple houses (let alone multiple apartment blocks) until everyone has one, then capitalists keep us poors (born here or not) fighting amongst ourselves rather than fighting them
Canada is such a beautiful country😞 its a shame the crisis is going on
Accidental? Really? I was part of an exploited workforce in the Middle East for nearly a decade, and let me tell you-there’s nothing accidental about it. No matter how many times people try to frame it as an 'accidental slave state,' the truth is far darker. The leaders, lobbyists, and bureaucratic machinery knew exactly what they were building. My heart goes out to the younger generation, Canadians, and immigrants who now face the financial burdens this system created. You have a tough road ahead, and it’s only getting harder.
I live just outside Brampton in a majority Indian neighbourhood, and spend most of my time in Brampton so I'm used to feeling like an outsider lol.
But just wanna point out that the number of Indians isn't actually more than the other immigrant groups combined. If you just look at the top 10 source countries for immigrants it is, but including the rest of the countries Indians are about 1/3 of the immigrants, the other top ten (Philippines, China, Pakistan, Iran, Nigeria, France, etc.) are another 1/3, and the remaining countries are another 1/3. Also not the majority are coming from Punjab. I'd guess its also around 1/3 of Indians coming from Punjab and are Sikhs, so they are definitely overrepresented, but Indians from all parts of India are coming in large numbers. I've met Indian international students who've come in the past year from all over India--Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat, Maharashtra, Kerala, Telangana, Jammu, etc. Disproportionately the Punjabi Sikhs will go to Brampton and Surrey because that is where they're dominant, but Indians of other groups settle all across the country whether in other parts of Ontario, Quebec, Maritimes, Prairies, etc. This isn't just a Brampton issue. As someone who has spent my whole life living next to Brampton I'd actually say that the effects are felt less here than they are elsewhere in the country because there was already a large Indian community here before the Post-Covid migration wave.
But it’s amplified in Brampton, also in GTA, and even in other parts of Southwestern Ontario.
France? 😮
7:43
>SAR Real Estate
can't make this shit up
kek
DO NOT REDEEM SAAR ....!!!!!
@@wolfgangoppenheimer2905 saar please saar
😂🤣🤣
@@wolfgangoppenheimer2905redeemed your mom
Indians love India so much they all immigrated to Canada, UK, and the US to talk about how great India is
will 21 million Indians move to Canada from Mumbai?
The population of Mumbai, India in 2024 is estimated to be over 21.6 million people, a 1.77% increase from the previous year. The UN estimates that the population will grow to over 24 million by 2030.
Mumbai is the capital of the state of Maharashtra and India's financial capital. It's also the most populated city in India, and the Mumbai Metropolitan Region is the sixth most populated metropolitan area in the world.
Not exactly it's because of the demographic disaster your those countries are suffering. Let me make simple for you. Indians are young , Highly educated, skilled, efficient and Trustworthy. So naturally MNC's and different organisations outsourcing Indians from decades for running their businesses. While natives of those countries specially youths are not Educated and skilled enough so that's why their countries organizations outsourced Indians. In USA Indian Americans are the highest earning ethanic groups and largest Tax payers to the Government of United States. Only 1% Indian American population of total countries population pays 6% of Taxes . They are the richest race over there and also same for UK. In Canada they are having share with Chinese immigrants besides as highest earning ethanic groups than major native Canadians. Yes Indians are talented so they get admired everywhere. Out of 1.4 Billion less than 1% immigrated to such nations in recent years. Majority is not leaving. And we don't need others to tell about India's greatness. India is world's fastest Growing Nation and its in 5th position right now. It's has one of the most powerful Military in the world. In terms of critical Technology innovation. India is ahead of UK and Canada specially in AI, Fintech, Space , Medical and Bio Technology, Defence and Etc.
@@Marty_RUclipsr your english is not englishing
@@sunumonidas9966 English
Cry about it lol.
Great journalism cbc could never ctv could never. Very educational im currently near ottawa and it is just under 1 million to get a house outside of even ottawa. I can't get a home off 6 figures and to learn that our government essentially never cracked down on these scam universities is wild and it sounds intentional. I never blamed all these students because they were sold a dream but the fact we got so bad that people are comming from a 3rd world country and finding out that it is worse than their native country is kind of disgusting.
My girlfriend is in Vancouver at the moment when i went to visit her i was shocked at how many indians were there. The job market doesnt exist, these people apply for hundreds if not thousands of jobs and theres no opportunity for them. Its hard in the US but im glad her and I will at least have some opportunity.
You don't shock how many whites are there when it's not europe white supremacist?
"blame the middle men" no blame the statecapitalist complex. More demand = more jobs, but the canadian state artificially props up grocery monopolies
“Accidentally” lol you really are young. Very smart but definitely naive.
Its just captilism not any scary cabal
@@toppedtop5787corporatism. The money seeking universities and service-sector companies can’t just invite a bunch of people to immigrate to a country without the involvement of the government.
@toppedtop5787 LaSalle as described by Marx maybe
He isn't. He is still dismisses the struggles of whites due to immigration as "reactionary".
I guess wanting a land for your people something every race has is a no go. being pro white is deemed as low class and is shamed.
@@constantinethecataphract5949 "land for your people" bruh you already have many lands for your people. Its shunned bevause its delusional. Or is it that you want a land only for your people
It's so crazy that we put those immigrants in sometimes even literal slums and exspect something good. I live in Germany and it's similar here. I used to help two punjabi kids with their homework in my home village. They were so friendly, honest, dedicated and proud of being german with punjabi roots. It really breaks my heart comparing this story to the situation of not only punjabis in canada but all immigrants that arrive in cities that are even hostile environments for the people that always used to live there
Canada and Germany is different.
Dont get involved in the politics overe here, dumazz.
@@mikeyrose4183 That's kinda the point of a comparison. You take two different things and see what they have or have not in common. What Germany and Canada have in common is that both countries are too stupid to handle immigration correctly. Ofc. there are less student visa scams in Germany as this is mostly a north american thing but over all the result stays the same. Migrant families have to live in bad conditions because the government is incompetent. Btw. I'm really proud of you, that might be the first swear word that I've ever heard from a Canadian (if you're Canadian). Don't be too tough, though. You might start a world war like... nvm.
@@mikeyrose4183 You should rather tell the ccp to stay out of your politics
@@flx2463 I am not Canadian.
As a indian second generation immigrant i can confirm lmfao shits actually insane
guys welcome to what italy and europe are experiencing since a decade. the migrants coming to Italy are allured by the prospective of a country with high standards of living, and while we certainly have no war, the country's economics is crumbling and everyone is running away, so both locals and immigrants remain with no job, criminality rises and sentiment of hate and division with it.
It's like all the leaders of western nations got together and came up with a plan to destroy their countries.
Wow it's almost as if racism and a dedication to fixing your own country rather than running somewhere better really is a better option. Who knew.
If you truly believe that then you must also believe that europeans should never have left Europe.
except most areas that have the worst living standards often require a revolt to dismantle the autocratic ruling class which just causes more refugees *looks at Libya*
Easier said when you don't come from abject poverty
It's better, but way down the line. Most people don't have that much patience or dedication.
@@jamesroa1904 they really shouldn’t have, but they built great countries pretty much everywhere they congregated.
I'm from Aus and I see a lot of racist anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim rhetoric. A common thing being thrown around is "look at what they did to Canada, the exact same thing is happening here". I never knew where it came from or what they were talking about until now. Thanks for the video, now I have an idea on where to look at things based on this type of issues.
And does being an a-hole help with reducing immigration? Instead of blaming the poor immigrants who left their failing countries, they should blame their politicians who allow this to happen
What Muslims did to Canada? Australians aren't very bright are they?
The Islam shit is next level of the immigration shit. You'll see later.
Brampton actually has closer to 700,000 people.
I’d say it’s closer to a million. There are so many undocumented people there, and throughout the gta. You’ve got 15 undocumented Indian “students” living in illegal basement apartments. We don’t even know how many people are actually here
Hey man, Amazing video. I usually do not comment on videos but I wanted to say some words. I am a first gen south Indian Canadian (not from the Punjab state mentioned in this video) and I think that this is a very neutral way of expressing your love for Canada. I really like how you did not bash on the students and blamed the root cause, which are the "middle men" the greed colleges and the "loose" immigration system. I also like how you were optimistic at the end and did not really show support to any political parties. Very respectable content.
It makes me so sad to know that the Indian international student - Permanent Resident Loophole has gotten this bad. I first started to notice the uptick in international students around 2018-2019. I just want to add that I am not trying to generalise all international students, there are many who study and go back home, but I am aiming for the ones that come here for the reason to become a permanent resident and eventually bring their family here.
What frustrates me so much is that back when I started to notice the uptick in 2018 and mentioned it to friends and forums, they all called me "racist" "ungrateful" or "your parents were immigrants". People only started changing their mind after how many issues have risen since then. Cancel culture has scared many of us to talk about such topics.
I grew up in Canada so I might be a little biased here, but the issue is that Canadian "culture" is slowly fading. The Indians are hanging out with other Indians. They are not trying to learn Canadian culture. Without "culture", conflicts will arise just like the one you mentioned in the video.
I just felt like I needed to let it out here in the comment section as I am sure that this video is viewed by many other first gen Canadian - Indians who feel the same way that you do. We love our country and we do not want it to get ruined.
To the Indian international students who read this, I am not angry at you, I am angry at the people who brainwashed you to come here and struggle. I am angry at the money hungry people that profited off of your misery. You deserve better.
Glad the government is making changes, although it may be late. I do hope the new government continues to tackle this issue quite seriously. We can not fix the international student immigration system in a day, but we can make huge steps towards it!
Dont care you need to leave no one likes you guys
17:04 In Eastern Europe we have a saying: "If you're dumb enough to get scammed, you deserve to be scammed." You go to a child with such a deal, they child will raise its eyebrows.
yup
Eastern Europe is the last region of common sense
@@OneTrueKing23bro I swear no common sense here either
@@SusanooMainindians🤮
@@OneTrueKing23 india is the toilet of the world ..number 2 ..Nigeria
As an Indian I really appreciate this video. Really well researched and well made without any racism. Also lokied the fact that you talked about things like Moosewala that most westerners don’t know about. This situation is ruining the image of Indians at the global stage which is really disheartening to see.
How is it ruining india image
Karma buddy.
You people are the same .
@@mikeyrose4183 You're not even Canadian as you mentioned in another comment. How exactly are your opinions relevant here? That was not a rhetorical question, I'd really like to understand where you're coming at it from.
@@anakein I am not Canadian? Lol
You are from INDIA.
You have a say so, here?
@@mikeyrose4183 You yourself said you're not a Canadian in another comment of yours. Didn't you?
The "eating pets" story is fake? Oh, so the videos I saw of cats on a BBQ and residents complaining about them eating cats are all fake, huh?
I live in South Florida with tons of Haitians all around me. It is a known fact that they eat all sorts of creatures. We have even had people killing horses and alligators for food and ritual sacrifice. Not to mention pigeons, and rats, of course.
Because he's an idiot.
@@JohnPrepuceHaitians will literally eat people. And people are calling it a conspiracy when they hear stories of people seeing them cooking peoples pets or wild animals
Who are the ones doing that ?
@@srikrishna2561 Haitians. They're on video doing such things. Tim Pool also covered this topic, and I highly recommend his coverage.
This is the most balanced perspective I have ever seen - kudos.
You bought luxury car on loan that you cant afford you deserve whats happened, thats beyond stupid. 19yo? So an adult not a 8 year old child.
Everything goes back to policy. Don’t blame the ones given a false hope and dreams of a better life - blame the politicians who clearly have a hidden agenda. As a first generation Canadian, I’m shocked how bad this has gotten.
Also I’m just halfway through the video, but a lot of universities were legit going BROKE and relied on international students to stay afloat..
Oh and don’t forget about the “work agencies” offering work for cash, where employers get a tax break and internationals can finesse work above the restrictions, JOBS TAKEN AWAY from Canadians who are struggling to find any work.
POLICY AND POLICING will fix a LOT of
Dont blame the gov.
It people like you who actually decides who comes in or not.
@@mikeyrose4183 how is that?
@@MrBololicious Mass Brainwashing.
So refreshing to see someone bring up immigration that actually sees them as humans without infantilising them
infantilizing or demonizing because i see both
But because they're Indians, Indians are good people, they have real religions, some of them are even Christians, unlike the "sandpeople", with their "islam", which is a fake prophet cult.
Man racial discrimination goes hard with you. I think you maybe a racist ambassador your kind of people need. You maybe a victim but it doesn't give you justification to be racist. U racist pos.@@josiek7589
40 hours a week, that's the normal 5 day a week job in Colombia.
Its a normal 5 day work week here, or at least it was a decade ago. Almost everyone I know in my city in Canada is working 2 jobs, and those who aren't are looking for a second one. Without a good paying professional job, 40 hours isn't enough for rent here. I don't know what that guy was talking about.
@@emmetwwyw6772 What is your city and is it only rent people are struggling with
Damn, this is the journalism we need more of. Great work!
first of all, a very educational video and a point to be corrected is that Narendra Modi is not the President of India, he is the Prime Minister
So what you’re saying is, we got we got Indian Tupac, and Indians fleeing a bad life in Canada across the US-Canada Border? All before TES 6?
Lmao TES 6 isn't for a while. GTA 6 has the time to be released way before 😅
@@Poodleinacan True, but all this is going on before either.
Really awesome video. I really appreciate the effort you put into properly explaining and justifying everyone's opinions. People don't behave in certain ways or believe things for no reason (at least not on a large scale like is shown in this video) and its refreshing to see a piece of media actually interested in understanding the root of a problem from all ends. I started watching you originally for your art analysis, but I feel like your channel is taking an important progression.
As an anti-immigrantism and As an Indian, let me give you a clear perspective. the state of punjab is sikh dominated. since the start of sikhism as a religion 555 years, hindus and sikhs have lived in great peace n harmony except for one riot of 1984. now many sikhs who ran away from india after 1984 still believe that there is sikh genocide happening in india. which is completely and utter nonsense. ask indian sikhs. but victimisation is profitable. so they continue that fear mongering and exort young sikhs to leave india to come to canada.
I'm in India and I'm terrified to look at the situation of those poor students, they are cheated, they are scammed, they are used and now being thrown out of their dream country 😢
I've watch my town turn into a city (one right next to the gta) and watched crime sky rocket and nothing is done i see the same type of people walking in everyday to stores and walking out buzzing with a bag full of merch from drugs stores and in the summer something like 40 cars a day get stolen here I grew up never having to lock my bike and being able to leave my doors all unlocked the gta used to have little to none shooting now its families getting attack for their car keys
Great coverage. Housing is huge issue, my parents bought a house in one of Toronto's suburbs for $365,000 in 2009, it is now $1.1M and that blows my mind. how could i ever live close to home now. i spend 3hrs a day commuting cause i cant afford rent 💀💀
Azn...
Myself & all the ppl I went to Highschool with in Ontario either live with our parents or FAR away from Ontario bc of this
That is underperforming the SP500 by a million. If your parents had bought SP500 ETF the money would be 2.1 M excluding Dividends. Even better if they put the money in a Tech ETF they would be sitting on 6.1 M excluding dividends.
Scary stories for night time story telling. I was walks into tim Hortons to get job application to get job there. Littles did I know, Baljeet was standing right behind me. I had no chance
were u ready to work as hard as “Baljeet” for pay below the minimum wage? no? Yeah thats where it all went wrong buddy
@@yybrbolt7833Baljeet had no shoes before he came to canada living in a mudhut covered in flies..he will anything for money👳♂️🤑
🤣😂🤣😂🤣
@@RingworldTyrantThe gov ernment is subs idizing their wages. That's part of the reason there are few entry level jobs for Canad ians.
Looking at your English, I am wondering what-jeet you are. 😉
As an Indian, I would never recommend to go to US, Canada just for living there, their popular unis are one of the best in world. Go there for improving ur career
bruh .lets be honest ppl go to universities for better jobs ...if the universities dont give jobs there no one gonna go to them.
I really appreciate your unique and informed opinions, keep it up bro
you're a good human being simply saying the truth instead of blaming the other. Good Job Brother. Love from India❤
This only has ~8,000 Views?
That's criminal.
Keep this kind of thing up man. Excellent fuckin' work.
The immigration selection system needs an overhaul. I have worked in both the US and Canadian immigration fields as legal counsel. It seems to me that Indian immigrants are quite favored by our government and they are given more quotas, less scrutiny. I have nothing against immigration, but to massively import people from one or two particular countries is not productive for the host country and for the immigrants.
Bro a note about cars. Even among the various ethnicities of India, Punjabis and Jats are especially known to live lavishly (many times out of their means) and are known for their superflous, show off culture. That is why you will see them with luxury cars, it is their culture to show off. And most immigrants to Canada can from the Punjab-Haryana region, where these two communities originate from.
Yeah, naw bro, I appreciate your nuanced and honest take, but don't make the mistake of thinking this was any sort of accident. Our leaders are and have been aware of this problem for a long time and have continued to let it rot.
How was immigrants eating cats proven false? From what people who live there say, it's happening. Also from personal experience I know that in many cultures eating dogs and cats is quite acceptable and so if they are hungry and a cat comes into their yard, what's wrong with free food.
I don’t think eating pets is a part of Haitian cuisine I think
@@cocomonglover
Yes, eating cats is practiced by some Haitians and is seen as traditional since eating feral cats was done by Haitian guerrillas who fought the French during the Haitian Revolution.
@@cocomonglover Not by choice. Like many post-colonial states, it's extremely poor. They invented cookies made from literal dirt just to have something in their bellies.
@@pumpjackmcgee4267Same times yes because of the prentice of voo/doo
I mean, just because some individuals have done it, it doesn't mean you blame the rest who aren't even remotely involved. You could try and potentially raise awareness, or increase cultural integration programs to integrate them into your culture, why just literally blame, negatively stereotype an entire ethnic group of people, just because of the actions of some.
Bruh I got lost in the forest and ended up in the Canadian border and they deported me
Why didn't you talk about the real reason Canada wants high immigration: To keep the ponzi pension scheme going a little longer.
Nearly every major economist acknowledges that Westerm pensions will be going bust in the 2030s and 40s.
So, these immigrants will never be seeing these pensions.
If it goes bust in the 40s that wouldn't even get through all of the boomers. 🙃Which wouldn't surprise me at all.
Until Stephen Harper destroyed our Pension Plan by underfunding it its endowment was actually guaranteed to last till 2070! So part of the responsibility of this f****** problem goes to Stephen Harper by the way
Finally you're talking about your own country. Break the Canada Curse, understand you're not american
Fr
Canada isn't a real country
The Canada curse is that you ARE AMERICAN. North American. Duh
We're British.
@@fuct9569 Mostly Native, French and British Christian until the PM's father decided to irreparably change the demographics.
Just because someone else’s country goes to shit doesn’t mean they can come to our country to turn ours to shit too
Some person’s jealousy made other countries like shit!
@@ArtIsDrawingNo country wants indians ..we want quality immigrants ..preferably european or asian
Same goes for Britishers and other colonial powers
@fat1990 our country is actually growing so much so that canadian pension fund invests in Indian markets
@@Nopee395their countries never went to shit tho, they uplifted the others out of the shit😂😂😂
The title was so raw and outragous that I dropped everything I was doing to click. Great job.
Least clickbaity, rage baity title on RUclips
I thought this was gonna be a VERY different video when I clicked on it, thanks for defying my expectations
I went to Toronto last weekend and was shocked at how many Indians there were over there
It wasn’t accidental, my guy.
I notice that a lot of Canadian commentators cannot accept the possibility that government could be intentionally malicious rather than accidentally negligent
@@Kimster182, Agreed. Many Canadians actually believe that their country is based upon rule of law, when in reality, in India, we joke that it is easier for a criminal to get into Canada than for a hard working doctor or engineer.
@@pmaitrasm it is easier for an Indian criminal to be a politician, more likely than for him to be a Canadian refugee
@@pmaitrasm Well, it might be intentional to bring in low skilled people and criminals. The sole authority of issuing visas is in the hands of the Canadian government. I am pretty sure, they knew the people that they were importing.
Been waiting for new Art Chad for the longest
It's bad for the immigrants. Housing and food costs are way cheaper in India. And the weather is better there and family is there.
And India's economy is one of the fastest growing in the world.
yup if someone is skilled enough there is actually ample opportunity in india to live a good life, there is mostly 2 groups of indians who are immigrating the most, 1st are those really high IQ and skilled indians whose talent can't be utilized properly in india and american companies offer then really good money, this first group mostly immigrates to US and UK.
Then there is the second group who basically don't have much skill and are unwilling to work hard in india and compete here, these are the people who are running to the diploma mills in Canada hoping for the easy and grand life there.
Most of the middle skilled indians actually stay in india and are contributing to the growth of the country.
I was prepared to see a video with contempt and stereotypes (which, I know, stems from the truth btw) but I ended up liking and subscribing to a channel of a guy who understands the world far better than most people. I am not uncomfortable with somebody showing me a mirror, but what this man has done quite well, is precisely what is missing a lot these days - rationality.
Long Live Canada!
From India ❤
Embrace the Third Position 🗿
distributism?
🤚🔥
@@iagomartinezdealegriamader52haha no
Why would I do that? I'm not a lonely gay retard
Yes...yes we need to embrace it
This is coming from someone who had numerous great grand relatives and ancestors die in concentration camps in ww2