REACHER (1x05) "No Apologies" | First Time Watching | Reaction

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024

Комментарии • 72

  • @swordmonkey6635
    @swordmonkey6635 11 месяцев назад +86

    In the military, you get over modesty and concern about nudity pretty quickly. It's not sexual if you don't make it sexual. Neagley and Reacher served together in a unit so they got over that a long time ago.

    • @jeremylarson6267
      @jeremylarson6267 11 месяцев назад +5

      not in today's military

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад

      @@jeremylarson6267
      Yes. In today's military. You know who screams and cries about gays in the military, trans people, lesbians... people NOT in the military.
      Because let me tell you from someone that sat in a foxhole in Iraq with another person being told "kill whatever comes over that hill"... you don't CARE if that person is a man or woman, gay or straight, dresses in mens clothes or womens clothes... ALL you care about is that they are competent, have your back, and won't freak out when you need them the most. That's it. Once that is established, the rest just happens; the cohesiveness, trust, bonding, and not worrying if you have to strip down to skivvies in front of each other.

    • @roadrash6565
      @roadrash6565 11 месяцев назад +8

      @@jeremylarson6267 Nothing today is like it was when the timeline of this story is based. Nothing...

    • @frmthefuture
      @frmthefuture 11 месяцев назад +10

      the book also goes into detail as to WHY they [reacher and neagley] are the way they are- especially neagley...

    • @chuckwilson4186
      @chuckwilson4186 11 месяцев назад +1

      Well said .. and true

  • @D0CI87PC
    @D0CI87PC 11 месяцев назад +41

    I think the nudity served a specific purpose. Their comfort with each other is probably related to their service together. You get over modesty pretty quickly in the kind of environment they both worked. Neagley does not like being touched. I think a fair assumption based on how she says it, her interpersonal reactions, and her reaction in the strip club is that she has experienced sexual trauma. So, the fact that she would get naked along with Reacher is a comment on her level of trust in Reacher.

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +19

      I really didn’t get that out of the strip club scene which I’m now feeling stupid for, but I can totally see that now. Thank you!

    • @D0CI87PC
      @D0CI87PC 11 месяцев назад +4

      @@cinemawithsteph missing something isn't stupid. Hell, my interpretation could be wrong.

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад +3

      @@D0CI87PC
      I haven't read all of the books, much less would remember every detail even if I had. But Neagly does in fact have a very hard time with being touched and it is alluded to that it was some sort of negative experience in her life. This was indeed shown in the episode with the strip club and her statement to the man about women not wanting to be touched. So your interpretation isn't wrong, just that the reason for it is left ambiguous in the episode, maybe even in the books, but again, that I don't know, only that in season 2, we MIGHT get more on that given the book it is based upon.

  • @mrwomby5007
    @mrwomby5007 11 месяцев назад +11

    Neagley is named after a real person who won a competition to have Lee Child write a character with their name in the books.

  • @Bikebrh
    @Bikebrh 11 месяцев назад +27

    They were never anything in the past. Due to some past trauma, Neagley HAAATES being touched. You saw it in a part of the show that you didn't include on this video when she assaults the guy in the strip bar for unwanted touching of one of the strippers. I'm pretty sure she's celibate, and may even be a virgin, at least as far as willing sex goes. It's never specified in the books exactly why she is that way, Reacher has never asked, he doesn't think it's his business.

    • @zurnie
      @zurnie 11 месяцев назад +6

      Neagley's issue, from the books, was alluded to an incident involving a commanding officer who went unpunished. While the incident content is not mentioned we can guess what it was. Neagley and Reacher are basically brothers in arms, or more like brother and sister in arms.

    • @r.e.tucker3223
      @r.e.tucker3223 10 месяцев назад

      This.

  • @aaronbarlow4376
    @aaronbarlow4376 8 месяцев назад +1

    Neagley is my favourite character after Reacher. She's also really hot :) Fun fact: Maria Sten was actually Miss Denmark.

  • @TomTomson81
    @TomTomson81 11 месяцев назад +13

    In case you haven't noticed, Reacher's military girlfriend doesn't touch anyone. That's why she doesn't shake Reacher's hand in farewell. So she has a psychological problem in that regard. Therefore, it is highly doubtful that they ever had anything intimate.
    Undressing in front of each other clearly shows that there is no sexual interest. They see each other as absolutely equal, and they do so in the very foundations. Simply put, in Reacher's world, she's a guy. In addition, this is an absolute habit due to the military missions they had together. There is no time for shame. These are simply comrades who can rely on each other 100 percent, even naked. Absolutely professional handling with the greatest possible trust.

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +11

      Thank you! Someone else explained that as well, and I had no idea. It’s not a world I’m familiar with but I know now :)

  • @MrShadowfax42
    @MrShadowfax42 11 месяцев назад +4

    The "For being too violent" line and the death stare Reacher gives KJ in the restaurant is one of my favourite moments of this season. Enjoy your reactions - keep it up! The subs will come rolling in.

  • @CodyFarris-j9t
    @CodyFarris-j9t 11 месяцев назад +4

    Can't wait for 2 season love your videos always look forward to the reacher reactions

  • @Ernwaldo
    @Ernwaldo 11 месяцев назад +5

    Great reaction to this episode. Have certainly missed you providing this. Thank you.
    The context of the nudity in this episode has been thoroughly covered, and I realize certain people have a particular problem with it. That being said, it’s always struck me as weird that something that “trivial” would bother a person (especially when they weren’t actually nude), when the show is replete with violence, assault, homicide & murder. Not that I personally have a problem with those in entertainment, either.
    Anyhow, thank you for all the work you put into bring us your reactions. Eagerly anticipating the next.

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад +1

      Yep! About a month before the second season starts. I just finished the book it is based on so I can see what they kept, changed, added, etc.
      Am looking forward to the rest of her reactions to season 1.

    • @Ernwaldo
      @Ernwaldo 11 месяцев назад

      @@mgass1354 Right? Killing Floor is a good book & interesting to see the changes from page to screen, as always. Neagley wasn’t even introduced!
      I’m also excited for more.

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад

      @@Ernwaldo
      While I'm not positive about it, my guess is that Neagly was introduced in season 1 so that there would be at least one character to bring some continuity of characters throughout the series. Especially since season 2 would have introduced her as a character anyway. So her character is a good bridge from season 1 to season 2.

  • @Bikebrh
    @Bikebrh 11 месяцев назад +10

    One other thing, the undressing and redressing in front of each other didn't strike me as odd at all. They are both ex-military and spent years in barracks undressing in front of people all the time. Neither one of them took their underclothes off, if they did, they might have turned their backs to each other. Women use sports bras as outerwear all the time now, it's not that shocking.

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +5

      Thanks for explaining! I know nothing about that world so it’s new to me.

  • @chrisszostek6700
    @chrisszostek6700 11 месяцев назад +4

    Can wait reacher season 2

  • @vintage0256
    @vintage0256 11 месяцев назад +1

    Glad to see you back with Reacher. I just saw the trailer for season two and it looks awesome!

  • @morgananderson9647
    @morgananderson9647 11 месяцев назад +1

    Thanks for the great review Steph! It's nice returning to this series again.
    I think the people responding to the nudity issue below have it nailed. Also as us "people" get older, especially when we interact & see others we know are "not items of interest" (although highly respected) professionalism takes over and everything moves to strictly business mode.
    Keep up the good work! The Channel will keep growing.
    All the best,
    M-

  • @grafffuller3265
    @grafffuller3265 11 месяцев назад +7

    Great reaction, as normal.
    In the military, nudity between soldiers is definitely less weird than in civilian society. They were in the Special Investigators 110th in the Army together. When they were on ops, they'd have to strip down and get dry clothes on...so you have to get over that, quickly.
    This is a defining episode. You are correct, Roscoe is a great character. Reacher b*tch SLAPPED him. That was even worse than if he had actually punched him. KJ is such a jerk.
    Remember, Neagley doesn't like people touching her. She's an "odd" bird, but she's also an incredible mind. The two of them are sympatico, when it comes to investigating...so they are not "involved", they are work partners. They each KNOW each other incredibly closely, but not intimately (in the biblical sense of to know someone).
    Marie and I love your reactions.

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +4

      Thank you both so much for watching!

    • @grafffuller3265
      @grafffuller3265 11 месяцев назад +1

      @cinemawithsteph - we love what you're doing. Thank you for allowing us to share this with us. Much appreciated.

  • @reevecole223
    @reevecole223 11 месяцев назад

    Yeah in the military you get over the whole nudity thing pretty quickly. It was super cute that talking about it made you blush though. ☺🤭 Totally enjoying watching you react throughout this season though. Thank you for sharing with us.

  • @daverowe03
    @daverowe03 10 месяцев назад

    Reacher and Neagley being naked around each other would be no big deal. They served together, and he was her superior officer.

  • @grafffuller3265
    @grafffuller3265 11 месяцев назад +2

    I don't know if you saw it, but the S2 trailer for Reacher is out. Marie and I were hoping that you were going to do a reaction to it. If not, that's okay too, because we are pretty sure you will be reacting to S2 of the show, which drops on AmazonPrime on December 15th...so not too long to wait. Really hope you do a reaction to these episodes, too. Okay, that said...now we are going to watch this reaction. Thank you.

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +7

      I’m so sorry, but I already watched the trailer after I finished recording season 1! But I will definitely be doing season 2 👍🏻

    • @grafffuller3265
      @grafffuller3265 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@cinemawithsteph - No worries. One, just wanted to make sure it didn't slip through without you seeing it. Two, Marie and I are SO excited that you are going to react to S2. We truly love your reactions. You are so honest and pure, and to see this series through your eyes is refreshing. My wife is a HUGE horror fan, and I've read all the Reacher books (some even twice), so...we are not pure in any sense...when it comes to movies (we've watch nearly 4,000 movies) and stories (and we both read between 300-400 books a year).
      Your perspective is unique to us...and you are near the top of who we want to see watch S2 of Reacher. Yay!

  • @scottedwards8895
    @scottedwards8895 11 месяцев назад +1

    People who are confident in what they have do care and people in the military who have seen so much probably can stand naked and not flinch

  • @tomhoffman4330
    @tomhoffman4330 11 месяцев назад

    👋Good Afternoon, Steph!💝 Sorry I'm a little late, overslept...but (and if I may say so) I do Love waking up to that Sweet Smile of Your's!😁 Thanks for today's Reaction, this was a Fun Episode indeed...I think Reacher is rubbing-off on Roscoe and Finlay, but in good ways! (LOL) Can't wait to see what happens next, I've so-far avoided reading-ahead or watching any other's Reactions because I'd rather wait to watch-first with You! 😉👌

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +3

      Thanks Tom! I’m currently editing the next ones so hopefully there won’t be too much of a delay in getting them posted :)

    • @tomhoffman4330
      @tomhoffman4330 11 месяцев назад

      @@cinemawithsteph Oh My Dear-Friend, do Take Your Time! There's no need to rush...

  • @lava3218
    @lava3218 10 месяцев назад

    "Is this normal, the being naked infront of other people and not thinking it's weird." Yes and no. You have to do some uncomfortable things for survival. For example, I try not to be one on one with a woman around my age to avoid temptation or false accusations; so I definitely wouldn't be naked around one I wasn't married too. That being said, if I was in an emergency situation with a lady my age, I couldn't just leave her to fend for herself, her odds of survival with me around are greater, and she would be a companion that could keep my moral up. If we begin to go hypothermic, they way to fight that is you have to start a fire, and strip naked, stay near the fire for warmth and let your clothes dry. Now, we could try to make a system where we take turns facing the fire, so all we see is the other person's buttocks and nothing more, but that's about the most you could do if you didn't want to just face away and freeze one side of you. Worse would be if she was hypothermic and I was not, but we had like a wool blanket. The best way to warm someone up is with skin to skin contact. And as much as we would both hate it, even a fire may not be fast enough if you can't start one. So our options would be limited to nude cuddling under the blanket or she would die. Same the other way around. As much as I would hate it, I don't think I could live with myself to let someone die over awkwardness and uncomfortablity. But I would really hope I could atleast put something between us down there, because I think we could both agree, gross.

  • @ReaLifeHDchannel
    @ReaLifeHDchannel 2 месяца назад

    1:21 Peak Reacher

  • @lidlett9883
    @lidlett9883 10 месяцев назад

    "Is it normal to be naked in front of othet people and not feel weird?"
    After any time in the military you have showered 60 plus people as well as used toilets next to other toilets without stalls for privacy for the entire time of basic training.
    After that depending upon your job you may end up using shower with more people. After a while you just get the mindset of this is what i have to do right now.

  • @jsharp3165
    @jsharp3165 9 месяцев назад +1

    What kills me about this show is the body count the bad guys leave everywhere they go. It would be pretty obvious to even casual observers that Margrave has a ridiculous mortality rate.

  • @johnmcilroy2293
    @johnmcilroy2293 11 месяцев назад +3

    Have you seen Reacher season 2 trailer it's out 😊

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +2

      I have! I finished watching the first season then watched it right after

  • @chriswilliams9684
    @chriswilliams9684 11 месяцев назад

    Not even halfway through video and I've tried to wipe away what turned out to be your doorstop off of my phone screen 3 or 4 times. 😅😅

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +3

      😂 this gave me a good laugh, thank you for that

    • @chriswilliams9684
      @chriswilliams9684 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@cinemawithsteph you're welcome lol

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад

      @@cinemawithsteph
      This is off-topic a bit, but reading about doorstop in the comment reminded me of something I've seen/heard in other youtuber videos that I think you, and every youtuber, needs to know and be aware of; noise. So, some watch the videos with headphones on (I do) and that means we hear everything. Usually a background noise is no big deal. But what I've seen... a LOT... are youtubers that have a mic on their desk, and they kick the desk, hit the desk, etc, which then POPS on the mic. They do it without realizing it, nor, how it sounds on the audio. So, it's constant. You're listening to them and POP and they talk and POP and you try POP and you are now focused on POP... and then you really start deciding if watching this youtuber is worth having to hear that POP in the audio. One youtuber I used to watch and sub to did it constantly through a 15 min video... every video.
      So yeah... just a heads up from a person that reallllly wants to see your reactions to Reacher, in all the series put out.

  • @mgass1354
    @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад +1

    So, they weren't naked, just down to underwear.
    Edit: This statement I made is wrong. There is point in the scene where Reacher ditches his briefs and Neagly her sport bra. It went by fast enough I missed it. So, I apologize to Steph.
    No, there was nothing between them; he was her commanding officer and fraternization between workers, much less officer to enlisted, was highly discouraged in the military. But, in the military, when you are around people especially when deployed, you get over modesty quickly, even between sexes. When I was in Iraq, I was deployed on the top of a hill with me, my boss, a humvee, cot, and mosquito net. We "showered" from water bottles, ie, one poured the water while the other cleaned off.
    Edit: In light of this new knowledge, I'll amend this previous paragraph a little to add to it. Neagly has some prior trauma that keeps her from touching others. This we know from the books and the scene in the bar. We also get a hint of it in this scene because when Reacher ditches the briefs, you get the brief camera shot on Neagly's face. It's not a look of, "oh my, look at this big hunky guy", like we got from Roscoe. It's almost, disgust. Not towards Reacher for doing it, but at the sight of a man's naked body. As for Reacher, he's not in the least modest; he's the hunky guy, after all. Why should he be? THEN you can add into that the previous paragraph about being buddies, former military, working together, having that bonding and trusting the other with your life.

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад +3

      Some other comments let me know about this! I really didn’t know. I could’ve sworn he took his underwear off at the very least but either way, I understand what you’re saying :) thanks!

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад +1

      @@cinemawithsteph
      It's fine. There are things we know from our lives, experiences, and things we don't. Hope that I and others can answer your questions with a bit of clarity.
      "I could’ve sworn he took his underwear off at the very least"
      If he did, I missed it. When the camera pulls back, he is in his briefs and Neagly in her sport bra.

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад

      @@cinemawithsteph
      Also, if I can ask a question... I know many MANY people hate spoilers. So do I. But if we've read the book and it gave more insight to something not in that episode, is that ok to bring out in the comments? Not spoiling future episodes, just like a difference between the book and a scene in the episode you reacted to.

    • @mgass1354
      @mgass1354 11 месяцев назад

      @@cinemawithsteph
      I went back to check that scene from the full episode just in case I was wrong. I was wrong. My original comment is amended appropriately.

    • @cinemawithsteph
      @cinemawithsteph  11 месяцев назад

      @@mgass1354 I'm totally open to differences between episodes and the book, just not spoilers :) Also, sorry for the late response. The app doesn't tell me when I've received a response to something, only the initial comment made.

  • @daviddaking5969
    @daviddaking5969 11 месяцев назад

    His name is giermoe lol

  • @ingobordewick6480
    @ingobordewick6480 10 месяцев назад

    "The nudity thing is so weird...." Well, you have to be an american then. They weren't even fully naked. They served in war together, probaply have seen each other in many different situations. They trust each other. What is weird about nudity? We here go naked into the sauna with strangers and we have nudity beaches. To me finding nudity weird is weird. And YT policies are weird. You can show any kind of violence but you have to blur out the boobs. That to me is crazy and weird. Greets from Germany.

  • @aranerem5569
    @aranerem5569 11 месяцев назад

    Hi there

  • @purgiaali
    @purgiaali 10 месяцев назад

    For more of the nudity thing you need to see Starship troopers.

  • @chrismcfetridge620
    @chrismcfetridge620 11 месяцев назад

    The Trailer season 2 dropped a few days ago, you should check it out! [Only a few episodes of season 1 left already]

  • @hinesmaster99
    @hinesmaster99 11 месяцев назад +2

    Where you been cuteness?

  • @Befree898
    @Befree898 11 месяцев назад

    Hello my favorite Reacher reactor, the very smart and assertive Steph. Sorry l am 3 days later to this reaction.
    As they told you already Neagley hate being touched by anyone. They don't explain why. She goes continue appearing in some of the other books of the series. She can hold her ground and fight anyone just like Reacher. She was his assistant on the military. He always respect her and she appreciated it, they became best friends, nothing else.
    She is the only one from season 1 coming into season 2 with Reacher. She by herself is also an interesting character.
    You could make a reaction video to the trailer of Reacher season 2.

  • @martinlatour9311
    @martinlatour9311 11 месяцев назад +1

    Hey gorgeous