I love how you people that criticize they way this girl sings this song think your all critics. To the contrary you are all far from it. This song is extremely difficult to perform simply because of the comparisons involved.... I would challenge any one of you to try to sing this song the way she does. GOOD LUCK to all of you ...... you will fail miserably!!!!
>she doesnt know the chemistry of this song> A nice pointing out . Celine Dion is not my favo. ,but when she sings it, her chemistry synchronises with mine.
@kitaeee very insightful diagnosis. Far better than Simon's remark. I don't care for a tiny piece of range as long as overall tone qualities are there. Melissa's voice is bigger and more pleasant to my ear than Celine's. She should have done better job interpreting the song though.
I personally liked her and I LOVED this song, I think she just received like no slack, for some reason Simon like hated her so far as to criticize even her absolute best performance. ok we get it, Lakisha, melinda and Jordan were better but damn cut the girl some slack she was really good.
I saw a couple clips. This girl seems like she wold rather do Distillers covers than do soul stuff or 70`s emo. The talent is there to do whatever she wants without tv help. JMO.
@@AJ-qp1it what the hell?????? this is one my favorite songs of all time...How the hell did I not know this song 13 years ago??!?!?!?? Excuse me for a second, I need to travel back in time to have a word with '07 me
JT Rebel oh my God I had no idea the comment I replied to was from 13 years ago! That is hilarious 😂 American idol back then really was pop culture in its golden age.
@@AJ-qp1it Yea, crazy I was in 8th grade when Kelly Clarkson won..then I stopped following around when Jordan Sparks won (what a coincidence, it was '07 when she won)..but I'm still bugging out why I wouldn't know my favorite Bryan Adams song, even at 18..
2:00...absolutely terrible, that was shouting, not on key at all, the rest was ok but she was def wrong when she said she hit every note, Simon was right
she can most definately sing BUT she doesnt know the chemistry of this song... she tries too hard and though she has a good voice and can sing well, destroys this song. the pinacle of this song is supposed to be the chorus but she tried too hard in the verses and made it confusing.
I LOVE Gina.... I still get chills every time I hear her... the bomb! She shouldn't have left so early in the season.
That was wonderful. I love Gina. She is my favorite idol contestent of all time.
Gina's very powerful and talented.
One of the best version of this amazing song...congratulations!
freaking LOVED gina!!
Always Loved Gina's voice. She was my favorite in the Top 12. My favorite version of this is LaToya London's, on American Idol Pre- Top 12.
I loved that last "anymore"
i love herrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
WOW WOW WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOW
Damn Gina!
ok she was NOT off key, she hit every note on there...thanks
wow!
I love how you people that criticize they way this girl sings this song think your all critics. To the contrary you are all far from it. This song is extremely difficult to perform simply because of the comparisons involved.... I would challenge any one of you to try to sing this song the way she does. GOOD LUCK to all of you ...... you will fail miserably!!!!
>she doesnt know the chemistry of this song> A nice pointing out . Celine Dion is not my favo. ,but when she sings it, her chemistry synchronises with mine.
I actually think Pia Toscano could take this song to a whole other level.
wow shes good
I feel like she's screaming instea dof singing...Celine's kicking her ass ;p
She sings really well, but the high end note is not so amazing than I heard with Latoya...anyway,
do we have to compare 2 artists ?
Good performance! :)
1:32 - "Obama's elf, dont wanna be Obama's elf anymore ..." ^^
Genial!!!
damn. she can sing.
@kitaeee very insightful diagnosis. Far better than Simon's remark. I don't care for a tiny piece of range as long as overall tone qualities are there. Melissa's voice is bigger and more pleasant to my ear than Celine's. She should have done better job interpreting the song though.
exelent!
I do...
I personally liked her and I LOVED this song, I think she just received like no slack, for some reason Simon like hated her so far as to criticize even her absolute best performance. ok we get it, Lakisha, melinda and Jordan were better but damn cut the girl some slack she was really good.
I saw a couple clips. This girl seems like she wold rather do Distillers covers than do soul stuff or 70`s emo. The talent is there to do whatever she wants without tv help. JMO.
THis song came out in 1997 right?
It's different when the song dropped keys. The beginning song a bit like if Pink was singing a slower song.
@neocshs This girl was copying Celine Dion's rendition. the original does NOT have any big notes in it at all.
@bennyd140790
celine did only a cover
The original is by Eric Carmen................ this song was NOT made for Celine Dion
A tittle bit out of tone at 2:04 but still very good...
girls dont have a falsetto, they have a head voice. also, head voice and belting are two different things.
no one ever could be put in comparison with celine dion cause this wouldnt be in her interest celine is the incomparable
nobody beats celine at this song, not even the original by eric carmen
They advertise her as "rocker chick" - I don't see it.
umm, why do u say that? did you have a bad experience with her?
wow i don't remember posting that...but yea i guess it wasn't that bad..
This song is made for Jamie O'neal imo
at :30, wat song is that
Have you ever really loved a woman.
That’s the song not a question lol.
@@AJ-qp1it what the hell?????? this is one my favorite songs of all time...How the hell did I not know this song 13 years ago??!?!?!?? Excuse me for a second, I need to travel back in time to have a word with '07 me
JT Rebel oh my God I had no idea the comment I replied to was from 13 years ago! That is hilarious 😂 American idol back then really was pop culture in its golden age.
@@AJ-qp1it Yea, crazy I was in 8th grade when Kelly Clarkson won..then I stopped following around when Jordan Sparks won (what a coincidence, it was '07 when she won)..but I'm still bugging out why I wouldn't know my favorite Bryan Adams song, even at 18..
That song is made for Eric Carmen.... so i think that is better when he sings...
she got put off the show because she listened to the judges way to much. sum times their advice can hurt you
You spelled "better" wrong.
she's not quite getting the right ressonnance... Kinda sloppy, but still pretty good... She's kinda shouting..
I Don't agree with you Simon she hit the big notes she's a Rocker girl
Karaoke
why the fuck didn't this girl win?
WOW! WTF?? happpened to her?
she's overconfident and kinda cocky
not bad, i don't get it. why was she voted off any way.
Lower Key~ Less Power.....
I dont like the deep voice...she can hit the highs...a bit....but her voice just isnt right.
2:00...absolutely terrible, that was shouting, not on key at all, the rest was ok but she was def wrong when she said she hit every note, Simon was right
she cant keep long notes, just another kelly clarkson
she can most definately sing BUT
she doesnt know the chemistry of this song...
she tries too hard and though she has a good voice and can sing well, destroys this song.
the pinacle of this song is supposed to be the chorus but she tried too hard in the verses and made it confusing.
Adom is better no offence
leona lewis is better ...
i like her, but she's always off-key. sadly.
didn't like this one
leona sings better :)
Vaya caballazo. Canta como una burra. Horrible. de lo peor que he escuchado nunca. :(
I don't like, sorry
shite
The original is by Eric Carmen................ this song was NOT made for Celine Dion