Nvidia RTX 3070ti and RTX A4000 Ampere GPU - Are they the same? discussion, comparison, information
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 июл 2024
- In this video you will learn a bit about workstation vs gaming cards, the price difference and comparisons of the Nvidia workstation line up vs the gaming Geforce line up. What to expect out of the GPU vs the Price
00:00 Intro
00:33 vRam Comparison
01:00 Specification discussion RTX 3070 Ti
01:22 Specification discussion RTX a4000
01:48 My take on the two GPU's
Please like and subscribe, that's the best way for you to support my channel and to motivate me to create new interesting content! Thank you all very much for your support, comments and positive influence via my channel!
The Quadro a4000 is going to be power limited vs any gaming card... rated at 140w vs the 3070ti 300w is going to be your biggest limiting factor. the a4000 may have the core of a 3070ti but expect it to perform closer to a 3060ti with the power limitations. if you don't need the 16gb of Vmem then a gaming card will be a better fit if you can find them at around the same price
Thanks for the video, do you think that there is a noticable difference between the GDDR6 Ram in the Quadros and the GDDR6X Ram in the 3080 and 3090 ? Is there a reason they use a slower memory on the Quadros/non Geforce ?
ecc memory i believe is the reason there. multi bit ecc registered ram. im like 90% sure
yes, ecc vs not ecc. ecc is essentially server grade technology and wardware. any ram intesive a software will use modo ram, any thing that enables gpu a celeration will use vram. usually, vram speedist a bottlenck i n software. servers rsm just runs slower
What about video editing; such as DaVinci Resolve 17? Editing seems to be more like CAD; thus a workstation card should be better.
But is this assumption correct?
I switched my Quadro P4000 for a RTX3080 and it is 200-400% faster in SolidWorks and more than enough for my 17000+ part assembly to rotate at 20-60fps compared with 5-20fps
you shoukd watch my video about workatation gpus vs gaming gpus.
Bullshit. Solidworks chokes on 300 part assemblies. It's nit made for that kind of data. That's where catia comes in. Don't fool yourself. 17000 parts my ass
@@baitish1 It will do 20k parts/bodies. You have to know what you are doing but you can do that for sure see it all the time, jpl disney northrop boweing work with large files all the time. It is dependent on the topology, i could just as easily have a 300 part file thats tough to handle or a 3000 part file and so on... Id say topology, then file size then the number of parts (configs get heavy fast too). You might be thinking of like 2005 solidworks
@@baitish1 no gridge on catia tho, i like all cad tools. hard to hate on making stuff
A p4000 is like 7 years old too, you were due for an upgrade, and new gpu woukd work wonders for ya
I'm working with A-Cad, 3D max and lumion Should I buy RTX A4000, what's your opinion?
Hi can you please help me out on what card should I opt for rendering purposes. I mostly use blender and other than that unreal engine and Houdini. I have previously owned rtx 3080 which didn't really worked out for me as it have crashed twice and card became faulty so now planning to ask my vendor to change this into rtx a4000. Should I just rtxa4000 or should I stick with rtx 3080. I am cg generalist so basically use all sorts of software.
well blender will use every bit of gpu power you will throw at it so long as you know how to adjust the settings. ecc ram will theoretically reduce crashing, workstation cards are technically server quality, and therefor are designed to handle loads differently then say gaming cards. with that said you get less for your money, an a4000 is closer to throughput of a 3070, id say if you want comparible power to your 3080 you need an a5000 if money isnt an issue. With gaming cards i would disable the thirdparty overclock and just dial it back to nvidia oem specs, that could also help you. with blender specificallu, i was able to use 12gb of vram on the tutorial files something to thank about. file size usually dictates vram usage.
rtx a4000 support gsync?
Not sure if this would be an upgrade for my P5000 but since i also game on my rig not sure the A4000 would be of much use, both cards have 16 gig ram but, only doing minor video edits and some very newbie 3D stuff in Lightwave / zBrush could likely get away with 1 gig ram on the video card :)
ya know im a firm believer of "if it ain't broke dont fix it"... At some plint in time youll hit a gpu roadblock, and when you do thats whwn you should upgrade. my last computer was 7years old and i just now upgraded. squeeze the juive out of your 5000, every lasy drop
does it matter much if I just use A4000 for video editing on Premiere Pro, and Sony Vegas etc? More stable for editing software, and less chance to crash?
yes, thats the idea, better hardware at more reliable power and driver settings
@@AdamWayneHughes
Whenever i run sony vegas with nvidia gaming gpu(s), it crashes often, no matter which series I get. Strangely, it doesnt happen to Premiere Pro.
Do you think it's nvidia's gpu problem when sony vegas crash? Or gaming gpu problem regardless of nvidia or amd?
@@MatthewInstrumentalMusic more than likely hardware compatibility or Driver issue. check your mobo qvl list an make sure u r running approved ram. try a diff driver as well
run program as administrator
Hi, which one is better for solidworks? Thanks.
4000 for sure
Perfect, what about RTX a3000 12gb? Is enough for gaming, 4k editing or sth like that?!
3000 is great power for a laptop, but now that's the 4500 is out maybe shoot for that if you have a desktop
How does the A4000 compare to a Mobile 3070 performance-wise for Blender, SolidWorks?
i never tested the mobile, but you need to make sure the power ootio s are set to performance and disable the integrated graphics in the bios
which is best card for me for 3d Architectural Rendering in Lumion, Twinmotion etc (Price Aprox in INDIA - A4000 16GB(1600-1700USD) or 3080 10GB(1750-1800USD)... As 3080 have more cuda core but A4000 is more power aficient and having 6GB more VRam
I would run the 3080 and if you don't like the stability it's easy to sell, then get the a4000. I can run gpu intensive programs without a crash for months if not a year. You want the same sort of thing I'd imagine
I have such a question: can you compare RTX 4000 vs RTX A2000 and RTX A4000 or maybe RTX 3080, i will use it in Solidworks with large assembly. In our country RTX 4000 and A2000 is the same price, A4000 and RTX 3080 is twice price than A2000. I have 11700 CPU, 32GB ram and old P1000 card. Thanks, regards!
Do you game also?
@@AdamWayneHughes a little bit i think, the 4/5 of time im work in solidworks
@@MIFrus ok here's the thing, imo and experience, solidwork will use about 85% of an a4000 which makes its a great pairing. If you can get the a4000 with 16gb ram instead of 8gb, it's the best all around bang for the buck.youll be happy in solidworks and gaming. Also the a4500 is coming out real soon, samples are being shipped out right now.maybe wait a month and see if you can snag one of those or pick up an a4000 at a discount
@@MIFrus another thought, the radeon pro w6800 is a workhorse, depends on your budget really
@@AdamWayneHughes and once more question, rtx a4000 is better than rtx 3080 if use it only in solidworks?
Hello. Thinking of purchasing the Nvidia RTX A4000. I use Adobe premiere pro, Davinci resolve, Photoshop and After Effects. However I want decent performance on 1440p gaming as well. I have a Ryzen 7 3700x + 32 GB ddr4 3200 mhz. Will this card suffice?
its going to be close but it should pull that kinda weight. how many monitors?
@@AdamWayneHughes Just 1
@@ajaykiller1992 i think the a4000 woukd be a good fit. if you were running 2x 8k monitors then that would justify a5000
Whatever is cheaper! I never used 8+ GB of ram for any Adobe product. I'm a video editor myself. I sometimes have people working for me so at the studio there are 3 PC's. 12700K, 3060 TI, 3 or 4 monitors. 128 GB RAM. If you don't use Cinema 4D, 3DSM, or any other 3D program with big projects you don't need it. The only software that started bothering me, why I'm now looking into buying A4000 or 3080 is Sony Catalyst Prepare (or browse), to stabilize FX6 footage! Unfortunately, it made me sell a nice MSI 3060 TI Gaming X Trio, that I bought for stock price @ € 500. But yeah, if you can buy a 3060 TI for half the price, and don't use Catalyst software I'd do that!
@@tomghzel A happy update : I could finally get an RTX 3060ti for my work and thankfully at a good price. I'm happy about my upgrade now ☺️
in Germany price same.... 1250E
Test in Games!!!! pleasee...
Hello, Any news about the availability, It becomes depressing. No listing, No news.. Nothing. PNY said weeks ago, Late May or early June. Then said within 10-12 weeks. I live currently in Egypt. I can't buy a Founder Edition commercial gaming cards. I want RTX A4000 or even A5000. Old gen wouldn't be a smart decision. I have a complete build for 5 weeks now waiting for a GPU card. Would appreciate any uplifting news :(
It's a storm out there for Gpus, you need to check microcenter and nvidia website everyday. I'll look for ya too. There are some units out there, but I'm still waiting for nvidia to get back on loaning me one just for RUclips videos. Let's see how this all plays out. I'll be in touch if I hear anything
@@AdamWayneHughes Thank you very much. I will check them both. Yes please. Thank you for the awesome videos. Please keep them coming.
I have my tracking numbers for both A4000 & A5000 cards should come in today ....I hope
there here !!
@@willbaker3004 congratulations, do mind sharing where did you order? And which version? The boxed or the bulk “OEM” version? Than you.
I had somewhat heavy scenes in Redshift and never filled 8 gigs. Arnold will suck the same thing and crash after.
I am a student of animation and VFX college , it's worth to buy rtx 4000 or rtx a 4000 or rtx 3070
Well what sort of gpu acceleration is integrated into your programs and rednerers you use? Do you have problems with crashes? Tell me more so I can help you out
I have been using Quadros and GeForce in VFX for about 15 years. Even the standard RTX 3070 (non-Ti) will be slightly faster than the RTX A4000 for VFX, GPU rendering or gaming. The A4000 will be a much better card for Solidworks / CAE or data science - but not much else. Its drivers are optimized for FP64 performance, where it outperforms even a 3090. But this means nothing for VFX - for content creation / 3D or gaming, the lower clock speeds of Quadros weakens them.
That being said if you can get an A4000 for a good price, I would still recommend it for VFX because 8GB VRAM is very limiting for 3D scenes, 16GB is a decent :) The 3090 is the best VFX card but its prices are insane lol.
@@AdamWayneHughes sir I have only the minimum pc requirements.
Processor: core i3
Hard drive : 1 Tb HDD
Graphics card : no
Ram : 4 gb
With this specs I was started to learn rigging. Now I was go to the intermediate level in rigging . In this intermediate level I want to weight paint . But my pc sticks and maya crashes so many times . I wanted to be a specialist in rigging. I wanted to join the college next year . So I wanted a better pc with better specs to learn 3d and achieve my goal. please help me. Please recommend best specs pc . I was living in india. Thankyou
@@hindustangraphics439 I would say snag a graphics card and that should drastically improved your performance. Most software is gpu accelerated so it would make a significant difference in your performance on Maya amongst other programs. While you are at it thow some more ram in there if you can. For a gpu I would recommend a rtx 3070 if you can afford it, if not see about an older 1080
@@AdamWayneHughes thank you very much sir.
3:21 I cannot get back from a video that didn't say anything. :(
Funny that in my country RTX 3060 cost more than Quadro RTX a4000 (50000 UAH) vs (38000 UAH extinct already)
Bummer