Sheikh Uthmaan and Dr Zakir Naik are both among the list of my Heroes of Islam in the modern age. I pray that they work together on some scale. It isn’t about either of their pride but it’s about the benefit and evolution of the Ummah of Islam! Fear Allah, Both of you!
Masturbation with pornographic materials is forbidden in Islam, but masturbation without pornography is known to God because there is no authentic hadith or verse that speaks about that "directly", but if masturbation were good, the Messenger would not have said that you should fast.
That is right. It is not said to be a good act especially when conducted directly with the palm of self hand. The point is what happens when ones wife is observing her period of menses'? Scholars agreed that she could use her hands, thighs but not her rectum, to relieve her husband of his tension. That is why the Quran and Hadiths were silent about it. The Prophet's (SAW) advised on fasting to keep unmarried men's eyes away from women and going for fornication, contact between two opposite genitals. Fornication and Masturbation, which one is openly called haram?
Well please answer me, you Will masturbate and no woman and Haram thoughts will be in your head, you will not imagine any woman, you'll not imagine a woman you know ? you'll be just moving your hand with good intentions to relieve yourself ?
His art of Critical Analysis and presenting things without any prejudice makes him an outstanding scholar. May Allah protect him. May Allah bless him & strengthen him.
Actually brother, the difference of opinion regarding various issues have been there between Sahabas, taba'in, thobe taba'in, and it will continue till the day of Judgement. And Dr zakir naik rightly said, it is our tak'wa which will make us not to do this even if it is makrooh(discouraged).
Dr. Zakir said in his first video that some scholars consider masturbation to be haram and others halal. Mr. Uthman said that masturbation is haram but permissible only in limited, harsh conditions or circumstances. What is the real difference between the two above? I do not see it. In Christianity, all "scholars" agree with the Bible that Masturbation is haram. Better to follow the Bible than Islam and the Quran which appear to be confused about what is absolutely haram and people will go to hell because of it.
@@robertokello5201 Which verse in Bible says masturbation is forbidden? Were both Jesus and Paul impotent since both were singles and never married especially if they never masturbated in Bible?
This is not about Dr.Naik or sheikh Usman opinion ..this is about serious matters of Deen..Deen is for everyone. How will anyone decide what is wrong and what is right if the teachers themselves are not agreen with eachother.
It's actually quite simple. Harma means not to do it maqroo better not to do it. So don't do it. Otherwise we sin all the keep it between you and Allah. May Allah forgive us all.
A khilaf, or a difference in opinion is common among scholars. When in doubt, go to the qur'an and sunnah. If you can't, feel free to follow one of the scholar that you trusted. I'll suggest following someone from medina, as medina and makkah, is the place of insyallah pure islam
Honestly, one of my friends inspired by Dr. Zakir Nayek lecture that Masturbation is Makrooh not Haram so I can do it and will not be accountable for that. He is doing that and propagate with Dr. Nayek's lecture. I think many people could be inspired by Dr. Nayek's lecture which really dangerous... May Allah SWT save from sinful act.
' ...That Masturbation is Makrooh and not Haram so I can do it and will not be accountable for that.' Your friend is trying to make you stupid and heres why... "The intelligent one is he who has subdued his LOWER SELF and who has worked for what comes after death and the STUPID ONE is he who has put his lower self in pursuance of its desire and who have vain hopes about Allah". (Tirmidhi, Ibn Maja).
The very fact that in all the arguments there is no mention of sayings of the prophet saw or the book of Allah even once declaring masturbation by name of the act being haram. I don't know why didnt Allah make it clear in his book just like day and night. It is clear to me that this is a debatable topic, to which there is no clear answer from Quran or ahadeeth rather opinions of scholars. The ayat of surah mominoon can easily be taken for a man desiring any other woman not his wife or his slave, or a woman desiring a man not her husband, or even a man desiring a man ie people of lut, but to unfortunately deduce this ayat mentions masturbation is haram is a pure biased opinion. Some times common sense is not very common. This was an untouched topic by Allah and his prophet saw, yet we find many later scholars making it a subject of haram and halal. Allah knows best. Opinions are opinions but all major sins are clear as day and night and fully detailed in Qur'an and ahadith by names of the deeds. The cognitive bias is very clear from certain named scholars who have said such and such narration is weak therefore my opinion is masturbation is haram. Even if narration is weak does not mean your cognitive bias leads to declaring an act haram where there is no clear declaration of haram for that act in Qur'an or hadith. And that is why there are some scholars with differing opinions when it comes to masturbations, while zero scholar differs on the matter of shirk, zina, alcohol etc. I am not endorsing the act of masturbation, however logically I can not accept that it is clear from Quran and hadith that it is haram. I'm sorry no matter how ever you argue this it is unclear and may be Allah left it on purpose like this as otherwise majority of Muslim men and women will be having trouble. If this deed can prevent zina and other issues that arise from desire then surely it's a lesser evil for unmarried teenagers who have high hormonal desires. Addiction to masturbation is a bad thing and no one will say it's halal. But when you are young unmarried man in today's day and age, where no one gives their daughter in marriage unless a man earns, makes is very difficult for a young man to control his desires. He/ she will either indulge in zina, pornography, or even alcohol, drugs out of that carnal desire, and on top you tell them it is haram for you to do masturbation, you will open doors of major sins for these young men/ women. Unfortunately our scholars can be sometimes very tunneled visioned, completely disconnected with the harmful effects of not releasing desire in one way or the other. It is not Allah and his prophet who make the Deen difficult, it is pride of certain contemporary scholars who feel they can make halal and haram as they see fit, through their own concoctions and cognitive bias. This breeds a culture of relentless authority and kills debate and differing opinions in ummah once you label something haram.some of them even lead to hatred or disdain as you have made a video trying to prove that my elders feel this is haram, so I have to make a video proving Dr zakir Naik is wrong and he is quoting unauthentic narrations( mind not from prophet saw, but opinions of sahabah). In my humble opinion brother you are also quoting opinions of this sheikh that sheikh but ( no direct reference from the book of Allah or the act of prophet saw explicitly mentioning masturbation being haram, rather using cognitive bias in deriving meanings from Book of Allah). In summary if something is haram Allah and his rasool will not leave it to interpretation but will make it clear, as deen was complete at the time of prophet SAW. Surely Allah's book and his prophet saw would have mentioned it very clearly if this act was haram.
Understanding the meaning of the Quran and Hadiths is made easier by having a knowledge of Science. The Bible, the Quran and Science by Dr. Maurice Bucaille proved this point.
This subject has confused the younger generation. Don't know who to believe.Sex without marriage is Haram , this is for sure and there is punishment for it.
Even if you believe that it is Makruh, you cannot say that it is Makruh in Islam. Because if you consider the disagreement, you cannot say your opinion is Islam.
DR Bilal Philips said also it's makrooh the reason he gave was that the is no direct verse prohibiting it. but maybe we need to understand the word makrooh because normally Muslims of today when we are told that something is makrooh then we make it 100% halal..... better to stay away from it to be on the safer side and may Allah forgive us
The truth its better for Dr. Zakir naik and sheik uthman meet in live video or one on one to reconcile this issue because alot of muslims ummah are very confused about this Fatwa
ulama are divided on this matter. in this debate, Prophet (SAW) didn't say clearly that masturbation is Haram. so there's not a clear answer for this matter, ulama are speculating according to their understanding that whether it is haram or makrooh. in both cases it should be avoided.
Clearly , scientifically proved by Dr. Zakir Naik. He said it is discouraged , not as allowable. To say it is Harm, we must have a strong evidence. I agree with Dr. Zakir Naik
@@mzmi1422 I have watched this video. Again I am telling brother , Dr. Zakir didn't say it is halal. Then what did he say ? He said it is a discouraged thing and perfectly not allowable thing. And additionally Dr. Zakir clearly said major scholars are said it is Haram only. But the same time minority numbers of scholars said it is a discouraged thing, not categorized as Haram. To mention as haram there should be evidence as undoubtedly sources. Among the scholors it is unitedly said " a discouraged thing ". To mention as Haram. Need a strong evidence. Not views.
@@shahilxd1288 Highly respectedfully he advised to Dr. zakir Naik. I think actually he didn't listen the full video. Dr. Zakir Naik didn't say it is halal. What Dr. Zakir Naik really said ? He said few scholars said it is not haraam and many scholars said it is haraam. Anyway all the scholars unitedly agreed it is a discouraged thing. Dr. Zakir Naik perfectly replied it. Scientifically With clean evidence. He didn't say it is Halal. He said it is a discouraged thing. Definitely it is a discouraged tHing , there is no doubt.
Question:- I have a question which I am shy to ask but another sister who has come to Islam recently wants an answer to and I do not have an answer (with evidence from the Quran and Sunnah). I hope you can help and I hope Allah will forgive me if it is inappropriate but as Muslims we should never be shy in seeking knowledge. Her question was "Is it permissible in Islam to masturbate?" May Allah increase us all in knowledge! Summary of answer:- Masturbation (for both men and women) is haram (forbidden) in Islam based on evidence from the Quran and the Sunnah. See the detailed answer for 13 tips on how to give up masturbation. Detailed Answer:- Praise be to Allah. Is masturbation haram in Islam? Masturbation (for both men and women) is haraam (forbidden) in Islam based on the following evidence: Prohibition of masturbation in the Quran Al-Imam Shafi'i stated that masturbation is forbidden based on the following verses from the Quran (interpretation of the meaning): {And those who guard their chastity (i.e. private parts, from illegal sexual acts). Except from their wives or (the captives and slaves) that their right hands possess, - for them, they are free from blame. But whoever seeks beyond that, then those are the transgressors.} (Al-Muminun 23:5-7) Here the verses are clear in forbidding all illegal sexual acts (including masturbation) except for the wives or what their right hand possesses. {And whoever seeks beyond that is the transgressor.} Some scholars used as evidence the ayah (in meaning), {And let those who find not the financial means for marriage keep themselves chaste, until Allah enriches them of His bounty.} (Al-Nur 24:33) This verse also clearly orders whoever does not have the financial means to marry to keep himself chaste and be patient in facing temptations (including masturbation) until Allah enriches them of His bounty. Prohibition of masturbation in the Sunnah 'Abdullaah ibn Mas’ud said, "We were with the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) while we were young and had no wealth whatsoever. Allah's Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said, 'O young people! Whoever among you can marry, should marry, because it helps him lower his gaze and guard his modesty (i.e. his private parts from committing illegal sexual intercourse etc.), and whoever is not able to marry, should fast, as fasting diminishes his sexual power.'" (Al-Bukhari 5066) The hadeeth orders men who are not able to marry to fast despite the hardship encountered in doing so, and not to masturbate despite the ease with which it can be done. There is additional evidence that can be cited to support this ruling on masturbation, but due to the limited space we will not go through them here. Tips on how to give up masturbation As for curing/treating the habit of masturbation, we recommend the following suggestions: 1. The motive to seek a cure for this problem should be solely following Allah's orders and fearing His punishment. 2. A permanent and quick cure from this problem lies in marriage as soon as the person is able, as shown in the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) hadeeth. 3. Keeping oneself busy with what is good for this world and the Hereafter is essential in breaking this habit before it becomes second nature after which it is very difficult to rid oneself of it. 4. Lowering the gaze (from looking at forbidden things such as pictures, movies etc.) will help suppress the desire before it leads one to commit the haram (forbidden). Allah orders men and women to lower their gaze as shown in the following two verses and in the Prophet's hadith. {Tell the believing men to lower their gaze (from looking at forbidden things) and protect their private parts (from illegal sexual acts, etc.). That is purer for them. Verily, Allah is all-aware of what they do. And tell the believing women to lower their gaze (from looking at forbidden things) and protect their private parts (from illegal sexual acts, etc.) ..... } (24: 30-31) Allah's Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said: "Do not follow a casual (unintentional) look (at forbidden things) with another look." (Al-Tirmidhi, 2777) This is a general instruction by the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) to abstain from all that may sexually excite a person because it might lead him/her to commit the haram (forbidden). 5. Using one's available leisure time in worshipping Allah and increasing religious knowledge. 6. Being cautious not to develop any of the medical symptoms that may result from masturbation such as weak eyesight, weak nervous system, and/or back pain. More importantly, feelings of guilt and anxiety that can be complicated by missing obligatory prayers because of the need to shower (ghusl) after every incidence of masturbation, especially in the winter, and the invalidating of the fast. 7. Avoiding the illusion that some youth have that masturbation is permissible because it prevents them from committing illegal sexual acts such as fornication or even homosexuality, while they may not be at the gates of that immorality to begin with. 8. Strengthening one's willpower and not surrendering to the shaytan, and avoiding spending time alone as recommended by the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) when he said "Do not spend the night alone" Ahmad, 6919. 9. Following the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) aforementioned hadeeth and fasting when possible, because fasting will temper one's sexual desire and keep it under control. However, one should not overreact and swear by Allah not to return to the act because if one does not honor one's promise, one would be facing the consequences of not living up to one's oath to Allah. Also, note that medication to diminish one's sexual desire is strictly prohibited because it might permanently affect one's sexual ability. 10. Trying to follow the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) recommendation concerning the etiquette of getting ready for bed, such as reading the well-known supplications, sleeping on the right side, and avoiding sleeping on the belly (the Prophet-peace and blessings be upon him- forbade sleeping on the belly). 11. Striving hard to be patient and chaste, because persistence will eventually, Allah willing, lead to attaining those qualities as second nature, as the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) explains in the following hadith: "Whoever seeks chastity Allah will make him chaste, and whoever seeks help from none but Allah, He will help him, and whoever is patient He will make it easy for him, and no one has ever been given anything better than patience." Al-Bukhari:1469. 12. If one falls into this sin, they must hasten to repent, asking forgiveness from Allah, doing good deeds, and not losing hope and feeling despair; these are all prerequisites to curing this problem. Note that losing hope is one of the major sins punishable by Allah. 13. Finally, Allah is the Most Merciful and He always responds to whoever calls on Him. So, asking for Allah's forgiveness and help will be accepted, by His will. And Allah knows best source:- islamqa.info/en/329
السلام وعليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته I don’t know what dr Zakir Naik wants to prove about Masturbation but to my knowledge sheikh Uthman corrected dr Zakir Naik because dr Zakir Naik have quoted some of the weak narration
Well said...nd i considered masturbation is forbidden.. because prophet Mohammed 💓 never said that u can do masturbation..The alternative he has given is marriage or fasting..There is no place of masturbation
Yes... but u all should ask why the muftis kept quiet about the government let the womens dressing revealing their body and many prostitution places running their activities. ...all the fatwas is given based on the situation and although it's still haram but what about the persons in charge of looking after the laws of islam that have been broken by the people which leeds to people doing masturbation or more worse fornication .... and many laws have been broken ...the haram have became halal done by muftis that is to comfort the government. ...how about that? ?....come to reality brothers and start changing the situations from the top don't just talk between the lower stages and became a hero without feeling the pain of dakwah by correcting the leaders and governments in Islamic countries. ....
I’ve been watching Dr zakir for years now and he’s number 1 in my book, but this is the first time that i disagree with him, for me it’s HARAM and even if it’s not it SHOULD BE
I dont understand the conclusion to be drawn from the ayat of surah mominoon. When I see the videos of other scholars it seems they are right and when I watch the video of Dr Zakir Naik it seems he is right Anyone who is confused like me I have a suggestion that it would be better if you do not to do it because we don't know what is right.
I know what u mean. I felt like that too. But finally Dr Naik convinced me more because there i no single direct and explicit prove that its haram. And brw even Dr shabir ally said that in an interview, its very interesting.
The very fact that in all the arguments there is no mention of sayings of the prophet saw or the book of Allah even once declaring masturbation by name of the act being haram. I don't know why didnt Allah make it clear in his book just like day and night. It is clear to me that this is a debatable topic, to which there is no clear answer from Quran or ahadeeth rather opinions of scholars. The ayat of surah mominoon can easily be taken for a man desiring any other woman not his wife or his slave, or a woman desiring a man not her husband, or even a man desiring a man ie people of lut, but to unfortunately deduce this ayat mentions masturbation is haram is a pure biased opinion. Some times common sense is not very common. This was an untouched topic by Allah and his prophet saw, yet we find many later scholars making it a subject of haram and halal. Allah knows best. Opinions are opinions but all major sins are clear as day and night and fully detailed in Qur'an and ahadith by names of the deeds. The cognitive bias is very clear from certain named scholars who have said such and such narration is weak therefore my opinion is masturbation is haram. Even if narration is weak does not mean your cognitive bias leads to declaring an act haram where there is no clear declaration of haram for that act in Qur'an or hadith. And that is why there are some scholars with differing opinions when it comes to masturbations, while zero scholar differs on the matter of shirk, zina, alcohol etc. I am not endorsing the act of masturbation, however logically I can not accept that it is clear from Quran and hadith that it is haram. I'm sorry no matter how ever you argue this it is unclear and may be Allah left it on purpose like this as otherwise majority of Muslim men and women will be having trouble. If this deed can prevent zina and other issues that arise from desire then surely it's a lesser evil for unmarried teenagers who have high hormonal desires. Addiction to masturbation is a bad thing and no one will say it's halal. But when you are young unmarried man in today's day and age, where no one gives their daughter in marriage unless a man earns, makes is very difficult for a young man to control his desires. He/ she will either indulge in zina, pornography, or even alcohol, drugs out of that carnal desire, and on top you tell them it is haram for you to do masturbation, you will open doors of major sins for these young men/ women. Unfortunately our scholars can be sometimes very tunneled visioned, completely disconnected with the harmful effects of not releasing desire in one way or the other. It is not Allah and his prophet who make the Deen difficult, it is pride of certain contemporary scholars who feel they can make halal and haram as they see fit, through their own concoctions and cognitive bias. This breeds a culture of relentless authority and kills debate and differing opinions in ummah once you label something haram.some of them even lead to hatred or disdain as you have made a video trying to prove that my elders feel this is haram, so I have to make a video proving Dr zakir Naik is wrong and he is quoting unauthentic narrations( mind not from prophet saw, but opinions of sahabah). In my humble opinion brother you are also quoting opinions of this sheikh that sheikh but ( no direct reference from the book of Allah or the act of prophet saw explicitly mentioning masturbation being haram, rather using cognitive bias in deriving meanings from Book of Allah). In summary if something is haram Allah and his rasool will not leave it to interpretation but will make it clear, as deen was complete at the time of prophet SAW. Surely Allah's book and his prophet saw would have mentioned it very clearly if this act was haram.
@@kamransaleem3027 It is as clear as day and night in Surah Muminoon verses 5 to 7 Let me quote it: 23:5 وَٱلَّذِينَ هُمْ لِفُرُوجِهِمْ حَـٰفِظُونَ ٥ And they who guard their private parts 23:6 إِلَّا عَلَىٰٓ أَزْوَٰجِهِمْ أَوْ مَا مَلَكَتْ أَيْمَـٰنُهُمْ فَإِنَّهُمْ غَيْرُ مَلُومِينَ ٦ Except from their wives or those their right hands possess, for indeed, they will not be blamed - 23:7 فَمَنِ ٱبْتَغَىٰ وَرَآءَ ذَٰلِكَ فَأُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ هُمُ ٱلْعَادُونَ ٧ But whoever seeks beyond that, then those are the transgressors - So in these verses its as clear as day and night that anything besides what is meant in Verse 6 is prohibited. Look at verse 7, whoever seeks beyond that are the transgressors meaning whoever acts on this desire boyond what is commanded in these verses are going against Allah
I request dr zakir to revisit the video of sheikh uthman....and dr should refrain from touching the fiqh issues as he is not expert in that....by the way love dr zakir for the work he has done but no one is infallable and he should accept where he commits a mistake
I believe Zakir Naik is more suited to discuss about or do debate about comparative religion not giving out Masalas that can have a negative effects on Ummah. Saying Masterbation is not Haram but Makruh will allow the deviants to use his view to make Masterbation Halal!!!
there is definetly a lot to unpack especially since there is many people coming back to these videos. Its 2 years old but I found this in my recomended. I am honestly confused on which is right. But when he is saying its not halal if your masterbating but your married then this is incorrect but for example my sistuation I cant be with my wife due to citizenship. What do I do fast what if this is not enough. I am fasting but I have extrem urge. Do I just get married again. There is no temporary marriage in islam. And my current fincial capabilites is one wife not 2 wives. But do I belive there is the majority of muslims who are not masturbating honestly no I dont belive this especially the ones in western countries.
Bismillah as I know we must not stay away from our spouses more than 3 months. If we can't we must hold patience/ keep fasting and so on..... and go for 2nd or 3rd or more marriages if possible. Or wait for your spouse.
The position of Dr Zakir for it is makrooh it is makrooh in the origin and that’s correct with evidences Because there are a reasonable big numbers of scholars who say it is makrooh and some say halal Also the Hanbali school the jumhor says it is haram in “ conditions “ not in origin and the origin is makrooh and this is the problem that some people who are same us from Hanbali school they do not understand the real correct view of imam Ahmad bin Hanbl and it is actually a lock of understanding the view more that the collect of evidences and under that comment I will give a response to the most quotes that they say it is weak and I will show the truth of their quick judgement of saying they are weak when most of them there is a discussion on them it is not all of them weak And I will show big number of who said it is makrooh and some who said it is halal and I will show quotes of the correct view of jumhor and famous people of Hanbali school that clearly showing that they are saying it is haram in conditions not on origin and it is makrooh in origin and it will show who some misunderstandings imam Ahmad bin Hanbl :
قال الإمام الشوكاني رحمة الله عليه: (ومن جملة ما تمسكوا به قياس الاستمناء بالكف على العزلة ويجاب بأن الأصل مختلف في تحريمه ، لاختلاف أدلته ، فلا يصح القياس بمحل النـزاع على ما هو متنازع فيه وايضاً يجاب بالمعارضة بمثل الاستمتاع من الزوجة والأمة بغير الفرج فإن كان ما فرض مانعا من الاستمناء فهو مانع من الاستمتاع) الرسائل الفقهية - للإمام الشوكاني ص ١٦٦ بلوغ المنى في حكم الاستمناء وحكى ابن القيم عن الامام ابن عقيل أنه قال (وأصحابنا - أي : الحنابلة وشيخنا - ابن تيمية - لم يذكروا سوى الكراهة ولم يطلقوا التحريم) المصدر كتاب بدائع الفوائد لابن القيم (3/96 - 98) قال ابن عقيل أيضاً : ( وإن لم يكن له زوجة ولا أمة ولم يجد ما يتزوج به كُره ولم يحرم ، والفقير إذا خشي العنت فإنه جائزٌ له ، نص على ذلك أحمد) المصدر كتاب بدائع الفوائد لابن القيم (4 / 82) وقال ابن الهمام في شرح فتح القدير(2/230) : ( فإن غلبته الشهوة وأراد تسكينها به فالرجاء أن لا يعاقب) قال الإمام ابن العربي رحمه الله: " وأحمد بن حنبل على ورعه يجوَّزُه ويحتج بأنه إخراج فضْلةٍ من البدن ، فجاز عند الحاجة ، أصلُه الفَصْد والحجامة ".اهـ [أحكام القرآن 3/251] وايضاً ذكره القرطبي انظر الى [ تفسير القرطبي (الجامع لأحكام القرآن) 1-11 ج6 - الجزء الثاني عشر - سورة المؤمنون الآية (٥) - ٧١ .. ١٠٦ ] قال الإمام ابن حزم رحمه الله: "فيكره هذا ، ولا إثم فيه ، وكذلك الاستمناء للرجال سواء سواء ، لأن مس الرجل ذكره بشماله مباح.. بإجماع الأمة كلها ، فإذ هو مباح فليس هنالك زيادة على المباح ، إلا التعمد لنزول المني ، فليس ذلك حراماً أصلاً ، لقول الله تعالى: (وقد فَصلَ لكم ما حرمَ عليكم) وليس هذا مما فصل لنا تحريمه فهو حلال ، لقوله تعالى: (خَلق لكم ما في الأرضِ جميعاً) إلا أننا نكرهه ، لأنه ليس من مكارم الأخلاق ، ولا من الفضائل".اهـ [المحلى 13/221] وقد نقل الإمام ابن حزم رحمه الله آثاراً في ذلك: "عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما: "وما هو إلا أن يعرك أحدكم زبه حتى ينزل الماء". وعن ابن عمر رضي الله عنهما: "إنما هو عصب تدلكه". وعن العلاء بن زياد عن أبيه: أنهم كانوا يفعلونه في المغازي "يعني الاستمناء" ، يعبث الرجل بذكره يدلكه حتى ينزل.. قال قتادة: وقال الحسن في الرجل يستمني يعبث بذكره ينزل ، قال: "كانوا يفعلون في المغازي". وعن جابر بن زيد أبي الشعثاء قال: "هو ماؤك فأهرقه -يعني الاستمناء-". وعن مجاهد قال: "كان من مضى يأمرون شبابهم بالاستمناء يستعفون بذلك". وعن الحسن: أنه كان لا يرى بأساً بالاستمناء. وعن عمرو بن دينار: ما أرى بالاستمناء بأساً..". [انظر المحلى 13/221-222]. قال الإمام ابن حزم رحمه الله بعد أن ساق هذه الآثار وغيرها: " الأسانيد عن ابن عباس وابن عمر -في كلا القولين- مغموزة. لكن الكراهة صحيحة عن عطاء ، والإباحة المطلقة صحيحة عن الحسن ، وعن عمرو بن دينار ، وعن زياد أبي العلاء ، وعن مجاهد. ورواه من رواه من هؤلاء عمن أدركوا -وهؤلاء- كبار التابعين الذين لا يكادون يروون إلا عن الصحابة رضي الله عنهم ".اهـ [المحلى 13/222]. 13593 أخبرنا عبد الرزاق قال : أخبرنا ابن جريج قال [ ص: 392 ] أخبرني إبراهيم بن أبي بكر ، عن مجاهد قال : " كان من مضى يأمرون شبانهم بالاستمناء ، والمرأة كذلك تدخل شيئا " . قلنا لعبد الرزاق : ما تدخل شيئا ؟ قال : " يريد السق يقول : تستغني به عن الزنا " . [ المصدر: انظر " المصنف " لعبد الرزاق (7/391) ] 13586 عبد الرزاق قال : أخبرنا ابن جريج ، عن عطاء ، أنه كره الاستمناء . قلت : أفيه(حديث)؟ قال : " ما سمعته " . [ المصدر: انظر " المصنف " لعبد الرزاق (7|390) باب الاستمناء ] ورد عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما قال : " قال رجل : إني أعبث بذكري حتى أنزل ؟ قال : إن نكاح الأمة خير منه ، وهو خير من الزنا" . رواه عبد الرزاق في " المصنف " (7/ 390) أخبرنا أبو زكريا بن أبي إسحاق المزكي أنبأ أبو عبد الله بن يعقوب ثنا محمد بن عبد الوهاب أنبأ جعفر بن عون أنبأ الأجلح عن أبي الزبير عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما: أن غلاماً أتاه فجعل القوم يقومون والغلام جالس ، فقال له بعض القوم: قم يا غلام ، فقال ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما: دعوه شيءٌ ما أجلَسَه ، فلما خلا قال: يا ابن عباس إني غُلامٌ شابٌّ أجِدُ غلمةً شديدة فأدلك ذكري حتى أنزل ، فقال ابن عباس: (خيرٌ من الزنا ، ونكاح الأمة خيرٌ منه). أثر صحيح ، أخرجه البيهقي في ((ألسنن الكبرى)) (ج٧ ص٣٢٣) او (7|199) يقول المجد رحمه الله في “المحرر” (2/154): “ويُباح لمن يخشى العَنَت أن يستمني بيده, فإن لم يَخشَهُ حرُم. وعنه: يُكره تنزيهاً” ا.هـ. وقال في “الإنصاف” (26/466): “وعنهُ: يُكره. نقل ابن مَنْصور: (لا يُعجبني بلا ضرورة)” ا.هـ. المراد. أبو حيان رحمه الله ، قالَ في: “البحر المحيط” (6/397): “وكان أحمد بن حنبل يُجيز الاستمناء ، لأنه فضلة من البدن ، فجاز إخراجها عن الحاجة ، كالفصد والحِجامة” ا.هـ. ابن العربي رحمه الله كما قال في: “أحكام القرآن” (3/131): “وأحمد بن حنبل على ورعه يُجوّز الاستمناء ، ويَحْتَج بإنه إخراجُ فَضْلةٍ من البدن ، فجازَ عند الحاجة ، أصلُه الفَصْد والحجامة” ا.هـ. المراد. وتَبِعه القرطبي رحمه الله في “الجامع” (12/105). وقال ابن عابدين عليه رحمة الله : ( إن أراد - اي فعله للعادة السرية - تسكين الشهوات المفرطة الشاغلة للقلب ، وكان عزباً لا زوجة لـه ولا أمة ، أو كان لـه زوجة إلا أنه لا يقدر على الوصول إليها بعذر ، قال أبو الليث : أرجو أن لا وبال عليه) انظر كتاب السراج لابن عابدين وقد قال الإمام الصنعاني رحمة الله : ( وهذه الآثار تدور في فلك تلك الأقوال التي تدل على عدم حرمة الاستمناء ) انتهى من كتاب سبل السلام (1/385) للامام الصنعانى ويقول الشيخ سيد سابق في كتابه “فقه السنة” (المجلد الثاني، الطبعة الثامنة، 1407هـ - 1987م، دار الكتاب العربي، بيروت.. صفحة 388 - 390) ((استمناء الرجل بيده مما يتنافى مع ما ينبغي أن يكون عليه الإنسان من الأدب وحسن الخلق، وقد اختلف الفقهاء في حكمه: فمنهم من رأى أنه حرام مطلقًا، ومنهم من رأى أنه حرام في بعض الحالات وواجب في بعضها الآخر، ومنهم من ذهب إلى القول بكراهته)). انتهى قال الامام الشوكاني رحمة الله عليه : ((ليس في كتاب الله ولا سنة رسول الله دليل صحيح ولا ضعيف يقتضي تحريم الاستمناء )) المصدر كتاب بلوغ المنى فى حكم الاستمناء للامام الشوكانى وقال الامام الشوكاني رحمه الله (( الاحاديث التي استدل بها المحرمون ضعيفة أو موضوعة ولا يصح منها شيء )) وقال ابن العربي المالكي عن بعض العلماء قولهم : " لو قام الدليل على جوازها ، لكان ذو المروءة يعرض عنها لدناءتها " انتهى من " أحكام القرآن " (3/315) .
والرد على بعض من ضعف بعض او قليل جدا من الاثار رغم ان تضعيفها لا يؤثر على باقي الادله واحده منها فيها نظر ربما الكلام صحيح : أخرج البيهقي في سننه الكبرى (7\199): أخبرنا أبو زكريا بن أبي إسحاق المزكي أنبأ أبو عبد الله بن يعقوب ثنا محمد بن عبد الوهاب (ثقة) أنبأ جعفر بن عون (جيد) أنبأ الأجلح (شيعي ضعيف) عن أبي الزبير (منقطعاً) عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهم: أن غلاماً أتاه، فجعل القوم يقومون والغلام جالس. فقال له بعض القوم: «قم يا غلام». فقال ابن عباس رضي الله عنهم: «دعوه. شيءٌ ما أجلَسَه». فلما خلا، قال: «يا ابن عباس. إني غُلامٌ شابٌّ أجِدُ غلمةً شديدة. فأدلك ذكري حتى أنزل؟». فقال ابن عباس: «خيرٌ من الزنا، ونكاح الأمة خيرٌ منه» الأجلح ليّن الحديث ، أما الحكم على رواية أبي الزبير عن ابن عباس بالانقطاع فمحل بحث؛ فقد روى مسلم في صحيحه لأبي الزبير عن ابن عباس نعم؛ قد روى ابن أبي حاتم في المراسيل بسند صحيح عن ابن عيينة: يقولون: أبو الزبير المكي لم يسمع من ابن عباس 13588 عن الثوري ومعمر عن الأعمش عن أبي رزين (مسعود بن مالك ، ثقة) عن أبي يحيى (مستور) عن ابن عباس أن رجلاً قال له:«إني أَعْبَثُ بِذَكَرِي حتى أُنْزِلَ». قال: «إن نِكاح الأمَةِ خيرٌ منهُ، وهو خيرٌ من الزنا». رجاله كلهم ثقات إلا أبو يحيى ، واسمه: مِصْدع، وهو الأعرج المعرقب ، قال عمار الدهني: كان مصدع أبو يحيى عالما بابن عباس. ووثقه العجلي ، وروى له مسلم في الصحيح ، وتكلم فيه الجوزجاني وغيره لتشيعه. أما ابن حبان فجرحه بما لم يسبقه إليه إمام. والظاهر أن السند جيّد ، والله أعلم. 13593 أخبرنا ابن جريج قال أخبرني إبراهيم بن أبي بكر (الأخنسي ، مستور) عن مجاهد قال: «كان من مضى يأمرون شُبّانهم بالاستمناء. والمرأة كذلك تدخل شيئاً». قلنا لعبد الرزاق: «ما تدخل شيئاً؟». قال (عبد الرزاق): «يريد السق. يقول (أي مجاهد): "تستغني به عن الزنا"». رجاله ثقات إلا إبراهيم وهو مستور ، وقال الذهبي: محله الصدق. 13591 عن الثوري عن عبّاد عن منصور عن جابر بن زيد أبي الشعثاء (البصري ت103) قال: «هو مَاؤُك فَأَهْرِقْهُ». أخشى أن يكون (عبّاد عن منصور) غير مستقيم، وتكون الباء تحرفت إلى العين، ويكون الصواب: عن (عبّاد بن منصور)، وهو من شيوخ الثوري، ويروي عن الحسن البصري وغيره من طبقة أبي الشعثاء والله أعلم وعباد بن منصور ضعيف مدلس ، فالسند لايصح 13594 أخبرنا ابن جريج (مدلّس) قال: قال عمرو بن دينار (ت126): «ما أرى بالاستِمناءِ بأساً». لم يصرح ابن جريج بسماعه من عمرو
@@Imdadmzbh The evidences are too much and I don’t have their translated resources but however I think it is better for anyone reading them to ask someone who understands Arabic to translate them Also I will try to translate them to English and send them here but I can not promise to make them in correct English because English is my second language and I’m from Arabia
Even the sahabah wasn’t perfect but they were perfect all together because they could correct one another in issues one didn’t understand.. Imagine if the students of Islamic knowledge all got along..
He essentially answered all the things that were pointed out in Sk uthman’s video in a very concise manner with the direct references and explanations... Not only did he stand by his views on the matter, he solidified it with better explanation of the references... Allah knows best!
Go check Sheikh uthmans answer its not true that he mentioned the direct references of sheikh uthman go see the second video of Sheikh Uthman. Dr Zakir put words in Sheikh uthmans mouth and didn't mention the right references. Do not let your desires blind you from the truth deep down we know it is despicable. Allah knows best.
The very fact that in all the arguments there is no mention of sayings of the prophet saw or the book of Allah even once declaring masturbation by name of the act being haram. I don't know why didnt Allah make it clear in his book just like day and night. It is clear to me that this is a debatable topic, to which there is no clear answer from Quran or ahadeeth rather opinions of scholars. The ayat of surah mominoon can easily be taken for a man desiring any other woman not his wife or his slave, or a woman desiring a man not her husband, or even a man desiring a man ie people of lut, but to unfortunately deduce this ayat mentions masturbation is haram is a pure biased opinion. Some times common sense is not very common. This was an untouched topic by Allah and his prophet saw, yet we find many later scholars making it a subject of haram and halal. Allah knows best. Opinions are opinions but all major sins are clear as day and night and fully detailed in Qur'an and ahadith by names of the deeds. The cognitive bias is very clear from certain named scholars who have said such and such narration is weak therefore my opinion is masturbation is haram. Even if narration is weak does not mean your cognitive bias leads to declaring an act haram where there is no clear declaration of haram for that act in Qur'an or hadith. And that is why there are some scholars with differing opinions when it comes to masturbations, while zero scholar differs on the matter of shirk, zina, alcohol etc. I am not endorsing the act of masturbation, however logically I can not accept that it is clear from Quran and hadith that it is haram. I'm sorry no matter how ever you argue this it is unclear and may be Allah left it on purpose like this as otherwise majority of Muslim men and women will be having trouble. If this deed can prevent zina and other issues that arise from desire then surely it's a lesser evil for unmarried teenagers who have high hormonal desires. Addiction to masturbation is a bad thing and no one will say it's halal. But when you are young unmarried man in today's day and age, where no one gives their daughter in marriage unless a man earns, makes is very difficult for a young man to control his desires. He/ she will either indulge in zina, pornography, or even alcohol, drugs out of that carnal desire, and on top you tell them it is haram for you to do masturbation, you will open doors of major sins for these young men/ women. Unfortunately our scholars can be sometimes very tunneled visioned, completely disconnected with the harmful effects of not releasing desire in one way or the other. It is not Allah and his prophet who make the Deen difficult, it is pride of certain contemporary scholars who feel they can make halal and haram as they see fit, through their own concoctions and cognitive bias. This breeds a culture of relentless authority and kills debate and differing opinions in ummah once you label something haram.some of them even lead to hatred or disdain as you have made a video trying to prove that my elders feel this is haram, so I have to make a video proving Dr zakir Naik is wrong and he is quoting unauthentic narrations( mind not from prophet saw, but opinions of sahabah). In my humble opinion brother you are also quoting opinions of this sheikh that sheikh but ( no direct reference from the book of Allah or the act of prophet saw explicitly mentioning masturbation being haram, rather using cognitive bias in deriving meanings from Book of Allah). In summary if something is haram Allah and his rasool will not leave it to interpretation but will make it clear, as deen was complete at the time of prophet SAW. Surely Allah's book and his prophet saw would have mentioned it very clearly if this act was haram.
@Kenneth George brother peace on you. Can you point out direct prohibition of the act of masturbation by Quran or hadeeth. Rest are all opinions from scholars based on their own understandings which is why I reiterate we see difference of opinion. Agreed more scholars are of the view that masturbation is haram and they quote surah muminoon as their justification from Quran, this is just their own opinion and not a clear answer from Quran. As far as narration of Ayesha RA, the man asked him regarding mutah marriage, when she quoted surah muminoon, a clear non biased answer from this hadith will be that mutah marriage is not allowed. Again this was a topic not discussed particularly in Qur'an or hadith in clear words. Brother years of seeking knowledge does not mean you are always right in your assumptions. This is clearly a topic of cognitive bias and assumptions. I understand from your talk that you rever and follow opinions of your sheikhs and as such are a muqallad. I'm asking you to share with me direct words of quran and hadith and all you do is tell me that we follow years of studies of scholars?. And agree blindly to what our mind agrees to ie cognitive bias. All you need to do is show me a verse from Quran or hadith which directly prohibits the act of masturbation brother and I will agree 100 percent with you. Again smoking I don't know whether it's khimr brother as it does not make you lose your senses like alcohol or drugs. But yes smoking is harmful to a human health as in it can cause oropharyngeal cancers, lung cancers, COPD and harms your body and is an addictive substance. Anything which harms human body is prohibited in Islam ok be it khimr or non khimr. Again use common sense, for which Allah made you Ashraf ul makhlukat and just tell me a verse of quran where Allah says oh believers masturbation is haram. Or a hadith in which the prophet saw says masturbation is haram. If you have this evidence I will accept it. As far as music goes please tell sheikh usman to remove the introductory music from his RUclips videos. As far as your mention of mutazallite, this is completely off topic, if you have doubts in sifat of Allah may he guide you, I do not doubt Allah's siffat.
@@kamransaleem3027 So Uthman is going against the principles of Islam by playing music on his RUclips videos? Islam really grabs every aspect of the human life, doesn't it?
@@gospeltruth6368 I don't know who you are but, but sheikh usman is a fellow countryman, mufti of Islam. I do understand where he is coming from, and there is no harm in following his opinion which is a majority opinion, infact If one can follow his and many other scholars view then there is nothing wrong for they understood it with best of their capacity.
Please explain to me, if you are a rich 60 years old Emirati and is okay to relieve yourself with 4 different wives a week is some how justifiable, but the 18 years old single boy who doesn’t have the money in Bangladesh, you think he cannot do anything with his body? It’s hard to control the needs of chemical reaction in your body!
Misturbation is not haraam God is no shy to talk directly the issue which are personl People those who are claimming its not halal based upon fatwas and base less sources Its a fact even all the Mulla come together the cnnot show us where Allah and Muhammad have talked directly about that Dont make stupid vedio agaist Zakir You are nothing compared to his knowledge. Mr Utman or Mir Engineer or Mr Tariq Masood show us prove instead of talking foolishness In Quran it is clearly written that sex outside marital affairs is haraam not misturbation so stay away from the things that you know nothing
brother Muhammad He is a da'ee there are many things he has done them correctly excluding matters on comparative religion I do not think its a good Idea when someone makes a mistake or understands something different from you. you shut him down completely consider the good he has done and ignore the bad...... The good part of this issue is that He is relating to some Scholars he is not only saying from his fatwas
My friend, Dr zakir is saying as narrated by scholars. He further mentioned the ayah surah nisa chap4 , verse 59 where it is mentioned if opinions of scholar differs go back to Allah and rasool . he further mentioned he has a right to choose which he agree with and you may not agree with. That's ur problem . not his
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 but he's wrong akhi dont let your desires blind you Dr Zakir is very knowledgeable but on this fiqh issue he is simply wrong the evidences said it all. Go check the 2nd video of Sheikh Uthman Ibn Farooq every evidence is presented.
@@hmzzrg5045 He's giving you references 😂 what's wrong in that ? Ibn Hazam is wrong ? Tabihin is wrong ? And who's Uthman ? How on earth would you even compare a layman with Zakir Naik ? 😂
Young scholars want the fame and credibility by trying to show they are better then the Kings of Deen and in this case one of the most famous after Sheik Ahmed Deedat is Dr Nakir Naik...... Just like the young lions in the desert trying to dethrone the old lion king....
Dr Zakir Naik ....Is the most famous renowned scholar in the world... He has done excellent work in spreading islam.... Allah has given him ..so much talent he can convince anyone to accept islam... I will request to young scholar instead of fighting and correcting Dr Zakir Naik sir ...they should more focus on dawah...
Allah give shiek uthman great reward Imam shafi shiek Albani shiek uthameen Scholars like assim al Hakeem dr Muhammed salah usama at thaibi Wajid akari and all the true scholars that are in the sunnah that comdem this evil act satanic act I pray to Allah we as Muslims must not support this act we must condem all condem this act its poison to the ummah targetting the youths especially
Satanic? Really? Isn't that too much? Its something that doesn't have a lot of evidence behind it. It's not even mentioned by name once in either the quran or a sahih hadith though people draw conclusions from ayahs in surah muminoon but its not mentioned directly. Probably 95% of people do it and ur calling it satanic?
We follow Quran and Sunnah, not imam this and imam that, if you have a verse from Quran or an authentic hadith saying that masturbation is haram bring it, otherwise shut up
This is not the correct attitude and can even be a means to shirk because you're elevating someone to higher than their status. He is human like anyone else and isn't exempt from mistakes. Only the prophet ﷺ we take everything from without debating or doubting him but anyone else can make mistakes
Anyone can be wrong, there is a reason why he quotes everything, it's because it's not him that has the credibility, it is the source he is using that gives him credibility, it's the holy quran. Of course Zakir Naik is a one in a billion man knowing every scripture from quotes a living dictionary. He has turned more people into muslims than anyone.
It depends on whether there's a consensus. Ibn Othaymeen said it is haram, and other reliable sources hold this position, but if there's consensus on it being haram, then it is haram.
My friend, Dr zakir is saying as narrated by scholars. He further mentioned the ayah surah nisa chap4 , verse 59 where it is mentioned if opinions of scholar differs go back to Allah and rasool . he further mentioned he has a right to choose which he agree with and you may not agree with. That's ur problem . not his
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 Zakir Naik, may Allah rectify him, is too proud to admit that he takes an opinion which is extremely minoritatian, he lets his pride to drive his responses to Uthman Farooq. And by the way Zakir Naik is a deviant in Aqīdah, so just because he memorised books of ahadith and several scriptures by even knowing the exact verse numbers, I don't have to be excited. His field is comparative religion, he's not a faqih, he's not a scholar, and his teacher was a deviant as well because he denied some attributes of Allah and he celebrated the Mawlid. This is the reality, may Allah rectify him and enable him to curb his pride about his own knowledge.
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 @Muhammad Shariq Khan And by the way I don't know whether there's consensus about masturbation, but if there's any, then he must retract his own ruling about the issue, simple. Being a talent in medicine does not enable to become a doctor/physician, likewise is for certain sciences in Islam. If a 10 year old for example happened to memorise several mutoon of Aqīdah, the Qurān and all the books of Sahih hadith, would he be allowed to address the questions and give fatawah? Obviously not, because firstly he has not delved into the specific sciences, secondly he has not the maturity to teach people, so being a talent clearly is not enough in roles of high responsibilty roles. There were mashaykh whose sons were well taught in Islam as well (since they learned from their fathers), but they didn't allow their sons to teach certain sciences despite they were very knowledgeable, because in order to address certain topics to the masses you have to be white bearded, wise, and not hasty or emotional.
Whats the world coming too ??? Whats this sudden Obsession with Bashing your Bishop !!! We got a major Pandemic in the world and bigger things to worry about...Focus on your Salat, get closer to Allah and read Quran daily before Malik Al MAwt comes knocking on your Door and he could come while you are half way through Bashing your Bishop ....Can you imagine !!! Holding onto your Banana and the Angel of death takes your Soul....Oh My days !!! This is Serious !!!
@@gamingexe723 hasn't always worked for me. I've felt sexual urges while fasting before. Also, most people struggle fasting 2 days a week (mondays and thursdays) so they most certainly aren't going to fast everyday
Subhanallah people are sick and very selective may Allah guide us all. Why are people acting like he is telling everyone to go and masturbate? Stop being the haram police and understand how he came to his conclusion and the fatwa he shared. Why are people disregarding the scholars he mentioned? He is also a medical doctor who has a broader understanding of the human anatomy. I am not here to defend who does what and I personally think masturbation is a disgusting act, but let's not make that which is makrooh- haram. If there is not a clear verse in the Quran or a hadith we should not attack or judge anyone, especially someone like Dr. Zakir Naik. Additionally, people looking to commit such an act should also not be misconstruing what he said to justify their actions. Ramadan Kareem and may Allah forgive me if I misspoke.
the issue is with people like you, who have no knowledge and judge by their desires, zakir naik literally lied in the video, he quoted wrong btw, thats not true, masturbation is not makruh, it is considered haram by the scholars he mentioned himself, he doest know, he is not a scholar, he should not be taken seriously in fiqh issues
Zabranjeno je i ne opravdavaj ! To delo gasi nafaku , pa se osoba koja to radi nikad neoženi ili ne uda. Allah mrzi one koji to rade! Jer logički razmisli, sve što kvari post nije dozvoljeno , sem ako nije brak upitanju pa je obaveza. Nakon toga covek mora da uzme gusul. Da bi namaz mogao da obavi. Sve sto je van braka uzivanje nije dozvoljeno!
Zakir Naik should not interfere in Halal haram things, it's not his field. He himself claim that he is not a scholar. So please stop giving fatwas on such sensitive issues. Because you're an influencer and you might be misleading youth in this days of fitna. P.S. Shaikh Uthman on this matter talked very clearly and proved your point is WRONG. You are a dayee, please keep calling people to deen.
everything is good but we the simple people who dont have much knowledge about those things maybe we are good practicing muslim we really confused which side we really go. Some says haram the give there reference. Some says halal or makruh they also give there reference. I dont know where i will go😞😞
And this is problematic situations that we face, that’s why I only say to read Quran and believe in the first sets of scholars only it’s clear cut Haram. And not finding what this scholars n those scholars say’s .. Sheikh always say if the scholars differ then go back to the Quran and sunnah than why they confuse us like that by saying these kind of tasfir
Dr Zakir naik You are such living Legend the way you express your opinion and the way you give anwers to the Disblivers is truely Brilient but this time you make a mistake
It is just like food. If some one likes he or she may do it. If the others do not like it they can avoid it. It is very personal. Your any act that is not harmful to others is not haram or makroo.
Must Read abt sheikh Uthman view. I am not a scholar since I am just a common person.But the way sheikh uthman shared his naseeha wasnt good. 1) he should have tried to reach dr zakir naik and his associates. 2) he directly talks about his personal remarks. Like you, your people, Your ego. in entire video. 3) He may have though by posting video he may take away Dr zakir naik follower. Which is too bad. Look Humans arent perfect that dosent mean we discredit someone in front of audience even though he might have done error in picking up daeef hadith by mistake. As a Common person I cant be like 99/1. I can be only like 50/50 becauseof knowledge Dr zakir naik has. And Dr.making mistakes will be negligible. IMPORTANTLY- Dr. Zakir naik never said its Halal. He gave it as final option after following everything prophet muhamed said. Thats my view. Once again even if dr zakir naik is Wrong . Shk uthman way of approach is really bad.
He did try to reach zakir Naik but there was no response from zakir Naik so he posted a video.. he said if zakir Naik can see the video and contact him he will remove the video immediately.. he praised zakir Naik for his work that he's done but he doesn't agree with zakir Naik on this topic of masturbation and it is important that they both discuss this to they guide people to the truth that's why he tried to get hold of zakir Naik personally but couldn't get hold of him
@@rumaysahkhan7552 yrs he wasnt wrong he was confused because of his lack of knowledge How can he prove it as Haraam without the Words of God God is no shy to discuss personal matter like anal sex and sex during mastural cycle And if one has right to touch his private parts then Usman ruling is non sense God never forbaid man himsrlf to take plesure from himself rather toching other properties
@@rumaysahkhan7552 According to him the tabeen he loves are right and the tabeen that are less in no are wrong Majority is not the authrity Christatins are more then muslims do we have to follow them because they are in majority
My friend, Dr zakir is saying as narrated by scholars. He further mentioned the ayah surah nisa chap4 , verse 59 where it is mentioned if opinions of scholar differs go back to Allah and rasool . he further mentioned he has a right to choose which he agree with and you may not agree with. That's ur problem . not his
@@robertokello5201 my friend Holy Quran is very clear cut. As I quoted the verse of surah nisa chap 4 verse 59 that "obey Allah and obey messenger and those who has knowledge (scholars) and if they differ in opinion go back to Allah and Messenger" So on the topic of masturbation different scholars have different opinions so Zakir naik is saying with whom group of scholars he agrees with. That's totally fine . now these people who are nor scholars neither student of knowledge want to imposing their point of view.so that's what I was explaining to him its ur problem not his. We can't force anybody to agree with what u agree.
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 Have failed to respond to my previous comment? Also, the God of Israel, creator of all things, created man in His image and put in him a conscience to know the difference between right and wrong. From one's conscience, one is able to know that masturbation is haram, why would he need a Allah, "the messenger" or the "Scholars" to tell him this? To say one should go to Allah, the messenger, or "scholars" to be instructed on something as basic as masturbation being halal or haram, means that people do not have within themselves the knowledge of something like this being haram. It treats grown people like little children who have no knowledge of what is good or evil. How can you be proud to be part of a religion which treats people like little children with no knowledge of right and wrong? ---SLAM IS A SCAM
@@robertokello5201 who's Uthman ? Bring me a verse of Quran or an authentic hadith saying that masturbation is haram, otherwise i don't follow imam this and imam that
Man I believe if there are two sins, then it is not right to compare their level and say, at least this one is better than the other. It is like you are supporting that sin. Note: These are only my views.
He is not scholar, the westernised Asian slaves of Social Services don't know Arabic and give fatwa without knowledge. To stop Ihtilam stop eating meat except in Eid or family celebration and you can eat fish once a week instead unless you work hard lifting or weight lifting un gyms 4 days a week that pushes you to bed straight away
Just imagine 19 years old man trying to hold it, planing to get marry after this coming ramadan. He never mastarubate or watched haram/ disgusting video. Someday he heard one of his favorite shikhs saying mastrubation is not haram. He started mastrurbating. He couldn't do it, so he decided to get "help" from haram/ disgusting video which he never watched before. After few weeks, he became addicted to mastrubation and haram/ disgusting video. He postponed his wedding. He started not praying salatul Fajr because he sleep the night time after he mastribate, and it's hard for him to wake up 5 am, take shower due to last night's mastrubation, then pray. Thanks to Dr Zakir!
Too bad that in Islam one has to listen to the "scholars" to know whether something like masturbation is haram or halal. Better to listen to one's conscience than the so called "Scholars." It appears one's conscience is more clear on what is haram and halal that Islamic "Scholars" who are totally confused (some saying it is haram, others halal, and others again, Makrooh. In Christianity, what is haram and halal is black and white, clear as day. Masturbation is haram, period. To avoid Masturbation, and fornication in general, one ought to Marry. Period. This much more clear than the confusion in Islam on the matter.
@@robertokello5201 I gave a reply to you about the surah 5:5 contradiction you made and I still did not get a reply? You say that everything is black and white in the bible, can you explain that part that jesus even after his death paid for all of our sins? I wonder where the black is now? The black has been paid for by jesus right? This is according to your bible of contradictions, that has been changed throughout ages by your churches. Do you know that the demise of palestine and yemen is prophesied by our prophet. Look what's happening in the world now, palestine is taken off the map and a famine is happening in Yemen with almost 30 million deaths in the last 10 years. This is all prophesied 1400 years ago, robert stop beating around the bush and come inside it. The truth is infront of you, you know that you want to say yes, but it's hard to take that step. When you let go of bias and prejudice, I am sure you will find a place in islam.
@@khurramjaved7301 In part, Surah 5:5 says, "..and chaste women from among those who were given the Scripture before you..." "Those given the Scriptures before you" means the Jews and the Christians. But Surah 5:51says, "O you who have believed, do not take the Jews and the Christians as allies (friends in other translations). They are [in fact] allies of one another. And whoever is an ally to them among you - then indeed, he is [one] of them." So can you tell me why the Quran says Muslims should marry Jews and Christians and then say, that Muslims should not take them for Allies or friends? How can one marry some he cannot be friends or allies with? Does this contradiction make any sense to you? Surah 4:82 says, "If it had been from [any] other than Allah , they would have found within it much contradiction." The contradiction of Surah 5:5 by Surah 5:51, means that the Quran is not from God. And there are many more contradictions like this in the Quran. The Quran is a self-defeating mess! Indeed, it is a book of "revelations" given to an illiterate man. It appears that in the morning Muhammad had something written, changed his mind in the evening and had something contradicting the morning "revelation" written. Read your Quran in a detailed a serious manner and you are learned in logic, you will too many of this contradictions. Talk to me when you have done that.
@@robertokello5201 Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala said: "This day [all] good foods have been made lawful, and the food of those who were given the Scripture is lawful for you and your food is lawful for them. And [lawful in marriage are] chaste women from among the believers and chaste women from among those who were given the Scripture before you, when you have given them their due compensation, desiring chastity, not unlawful sexual intercourse or taking [secret] lovers. And whoever denies the faith - his work has become worthless, and he, in the Hereafter, will be among the losers." (QS. Al-Maaida 5: Verse 5) Can you read the full verse properly mister illiterate. It says at the end "whoever denies the faith, his work has become worthless and he will hereafter be among the losers" meaning that whoever you are trying to marry has to accept islam and if he/she does not, than he/she will be among the losers. You send 75% of the verse and ignoring the other 25% shows that there was no contradiction. The other point you mentioned, it's talking about out prophets, who were given the scriptures such as Jesus, moses, and david. It is not talking about christians or jewish. Please use a little ounce of your symbolic illiterate brain. Can you find anymore contradictions? Cause you did not find any yet sir?
Sheikh Uthmaan and Dr Zakir Naik are both among the list of my Heroes of Islam in the modern age. I pray that they work together on some scale. It isn’t about either of their pride but it’s about the benefit and evolution of the Ummah of Islam! Fear Allah, Both of you!
It was more than a year ago.
@@GDL88 so?
They ended at that. I agree with sheikh uthman.
@@GDL88 so do I however my message is a reminder of togetherness and remembrance of Allah. Non is greater than Allah.
Oh come on brother please don't put anyone in this generation beside Zakir Naik, he's a genius
Masturbation with pornographic materials is forbidden in Islam, but masturbation without pornography is known to God because there is no authentic hadith or verse that speaks about that "directly", but if masturbation were good, the Messenger would not have said that you should fast.
That is right. It is not said to be a good act especially when conducted directly with the palm of self hand. The point is what happens when ones wife is observing her period of menses'? Scholars agreed that she could use her hands, thighs but not her rectum, to relieve her husband of his tension. That is why the Quran and Hadiths were silent about it. The Prophet's (SAW) advised on fasting to keep unmarried men's eyes away from women and going for fornication, contact between two opposite genitals. Fornication and Masturbation, which one is openly called haram?
Well please answer me, you Will masturbate and no woman and Haram thoughts will be in your head, you will not imagine any woman, you'll not imagine a woman you know ? you'll be just moving your hand with good intentions to relieve yourself ?
His art of Critical Analysis and presenting things without any prejudice makes him an outstanding scholar. May Allah protect him. May Allah bless him & strengthen him.
Plzzzzzzz I request Dr Jaakir Naik to meet Sheikh Uthman in a live Video.. 😘 After that, our All doubts will come to an End.. 😘
this is a good suggestion bro siting at the table with mahabba thats the way of muslim leaders
Actually brother, the difference of opinion regarding various issues have been there between Sahabas, taba'in, thobe taba'in, and it will continue till the day of Judgement. And Dr zakir naik rightly said, it is our tak'wa which will make us not to do this even if it is makrooh(discouraged).
Did any of the Salaf ever masturbate OR none among the Salaf mastubated?
Dr. Zakir said in his first video that some scholars consider masturbation to be haram and others halal.
Mr. Uthman said that masturbation is haram but permissible only in limited, harsh conditions or circumstances.
What is the real difference between the two above? I do not see it.
In Christianity, all "scholars" agree with the Bible that Masturbation is haram. Better to follow the Bible than Islam and the Quran which appear to be confused about what is absolutely haram and people will go to hell because of it.
@@robertokello5201 Which verse in Bible says masturbation is forbidden?
Were both Jesus and Paul impotent since both were singles and never married especially if they never masturbated in Bible?
Dr zakir naik it would be so easy for him to become a scholar mashallah very intelligent man
*ma'sha' ALLAH
Name of ALLAH should be written in capital letters
@@ahlehaqatmanhajesalaf5894 thank you brother for taking time out to reply and pointing this out but the meaning is understood
@@ahlehaqatmanhajesalaf5894What's the problem when it's read correctly?Also
Actions are judged by intentions
Sahih Bukhari 1
This is not about Dr.Naik or sheikh Usman opinion ..this is about serious matters of Deen..Deen is for everyone.
How will anyone decide what is wrong and what is right if the teachers themselves are not agreen with eachother.
Sir this is fiqhi masla not aqeeda plz note
It's actually quite simple. Harma means not to do it maqroo better not to do it. So don't do it. Otherwise we sin all the keep it between you and Allah. May Allah forgive us all.
A khilaf, or a difference in opinion is common among scholars. When in doubt, go to the qur'an and sunnah. If you can't, feel free to follow one of the scholar that you trusted. I'll suggest following someone from medina, as medina and makkah, is the place of insyallah pure islam
Honestly, one of my friends inspired by Dr. Zakir Nayek lecture that Masturbation is Makrooh not Haram so I can do it and will not be accountable for that. He is doing that and propagate with Dr. Nayek's lecture. I think many people could be inspired by Dr. Nayek's lecture which really dangerous... May Allah SWT save from sinful act.
' ...That Masturbation is Makrooh and not Haram so I can do it and will not be accountable for that.'
Your friend is trying to make you stupid and heres why...
"The intelligent one is he who has subdued his LOWER SELF and who has worked for what comes after death and the STUPID ONE is he who has put his lower self in pursuance of its desire and who have vain hopes about Allah". (Tirmidhi, Ibn Maja).
Masturbation with your wife can't be haraam,, but involved with pornography or zina (other than spouce) must not be permissible.
The very fact that in all the arguments there is no mention of sayings of the prophet saw or the book of Allah even once declaring masturbation by name of the act being haram. I don't know why didnt Allah make it clear in his book just like day and night. It is clear to me that this is a debatable topic, to which there is no clear answer from Quran or ahadeeth rather opinions of scholars.
The ayat of surah mominoon can easily be taken for a man desiring any other woman not his wife or his slave, or a woman desiring a man not her husband, or even a man desiring a man ie people of lut, but to unfortunately deduce this ayat mentions masturbation is haram is a pure biased opinion. Some times common sense is not very common. This was an untouched topic by Allah and his prophet saw, yet we find many later scholars making it a subject of haram and halal. Allah knows best. Opinions are opinions but all major sins are clear as day and night and fully detailed in Qur'an and ahadith by names of the deeds.
The cognitive bias is very clear from certain named scholars who have said such and such narration is weak therefore my opinion is masturbation is haram. Even if narration is weak does not mean your cognitive bias leads to declaring an act haram where there is no clear declaration of haram for that act in Qur'an or hadith. And that is why there are some scholars with differing opinions when it comes to masturbations, while zero scholar differs on the matter of shirk, zina, alcohol etc.
I am not endorsing the act of masturbation, however logically I can not accept that it is clear from Quran and hadith that it is haram. I'm sorry no matter how ever you argue this it is unclear and may be Allah left it on purpose like this as otherwise majority of Muslim men and women will be having trouble.
If this deed can prevent zina and other issues that arise from desire then surely it's a lesser evil for unmarried teenagers who have high hormonal desires.
Addiction to masturbation is a bad thing and no one will say it's halal. But when you are young unmarried man in today's day and age, where no one gives their daughter in marriage unless a man earns, makes is very difficult for a young man to control his desires. He/ she will either indulge in zina, pornography, or even alcohol, drugs out of that carnal desire, and on top you tell them it is haram for you to do masturbation, you will open doors of major sins for these young men/ women.
Unfortunately our scholars can be sometimes very tunneled visioned, completely disconnected with the harmful effects of not releasing desire in one way or the other.
It is not Allah and his prophet who make the Deen difficult, it is pride of certain contemporary scholars who feel they can make halal and haram as they see fit, through their own concoctions and cognitive bias. This breeds a culture of relentless authority and kills debate and differing opinions in ummah once you label something haram.some of them even lead to hatred or disdain as you have made a video trying to prove that my elders feel this is haram, so I have to make a video proving Dr zakir Naik is wrong and he is quoting unauthentic narrations( mind not from prophet saw, but opinions of sahabah).
In my humble opinion brother you are also quoting opinions of this sheikh that sheikh but ( no direct reference from the book of Allah or the act of prophet saw explicitly mentioning masturbation being haram, rather using cognitive bias in deriving meanings from Book of Allah).
In summary if something is haram Allah and his rasool will not leave it to interpretation but will make it clear, as deen was complete at the time of prophet SAW. Surely Allah's book and his prophet saw would have mentioned it very clearly if this act was haram.
yes true🥰🥰
Wrong, watch Skeikj Uthman Ibn Farooq’s answer. He proves with evidence that masturbation is haram: m.ruclips.net/video/BQQR-GkqECo/видео.html
Your English is good
14:50 DR ZAKIR NAIK replying to ENGR MUHAMMAD ALI MIRZA
Correctly replied to him as he is bound to be replied 😂👌
Dr.Zakir Naik made really good points.
ruclips.net/video/6ZhZr9TW0tY/видео.html❤️❤️❤️
Understanding the meaning of the Quran and Hadiths is made easier by having a knowledge of Science. The Bible, the Quran and Science by Dr. Maurice Bucaille proved this point.
This subject has confused the younger generation. Don't know who to believe.Sex without marriage is Haram , this is for sure and there is punishment for it.
Even if you believe that it is Makruh, you cannot say that it is Makruh in Islam.
Because if you consider the disagreement, you cannot say your opinion is Islam.
DR Bilal Philips said also it's makrooh the reason he gave was that the is no direct verse prohibiting it. but maybe we need to understand the word makrooh because normally Muslims of today when we are told that something is makrooh then we make it 100% halal..... better to stay away from it to be on the safer side and may Allah forgive us
By Shaykh YQ
ruclips.net/video/nr9AI-OAYhg/видео.html
@@mdreazhosen5 but they say makrooh If you do it as halal you reach a point of getting sins registered to your account
@@mdreazhosen5 they are not ofcoz
Please watch this, he was corrected.
ruclips.net/video/BQQR-GkqECo/видео.html
@@mdreazhosen5
Please watch this and make your conclusions. ruclips.net/video/BQQR-GkqECo/видео.html
The truth its better for Dr. Zakir naik and sheik uthman meet in live video or one on one to reconcile this issue because alot of muslims ummah are very confused about this Fatwa
Zakir Naik wouldn't debate with any tom dick and Harry, who's Uthman ? 😂
ulama are divided on this matter. in this debate, Prophet (SAW) didn't say clearly that masturbation is Haram. so there's not a clear answer for this matter, ulama are speculating according to their understanding that whether it is haram or makrooh. in both cases it should be avoided.
Dr zakir naik gave very good reference.
ruclips.net/video/6ZhZr9TW0tY/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/W7il22xeqng/видео.html
Trur
Yes, weak narrations
Yeah weak narrations
Clearly , scientifically proved by Dr. Zakir Naik.
He said it is discouraged , not as allowable.
To say it is Harm, we must have a strong evidence. I agree with Dr. Zakir Naik
@@mzmi1422 I have watched this video. Again I am telling brother , Dr. Zakir didn't say it is halal. Then what did he say ? He said it is a discouraged thing and perfectly not allowable thing.
And additionally Dr. Zakir clearly said major scholars are said it is Haram only. But the same time minority numbers of scholars said it is a discouraged thing, not categorized as Haram. To mention as haram there should be evidence as undoubtedly sources.
Among the scholors it is unitedly said
" a discouraged thing ". To mention as Haram. Need a strong evidence. Not views.
@@rajajanaki8615 there's not strong evidence from Quran and books of Ahadith..
It is wrong
ruclips.net/video/_nxoqjZg9Yk/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/BQQR-GkqECo/видео.html
@@shahilxd1288 Highly respectedfully he advised to Dr. zakir Naik.
I think actually he didn't listen the full video.
Dr. Zakir Naik didn't say it is halal.
What Dr. Zakir Naik really said ?
He said few scholars said it is not haraam and many scholars said it is haraam.
Anyway all the scholars unitedly agreed it is a discouraged thing.
Dr. Zakir Naik perfectly replied it. Scientifically With clean evidence.
He didn't say it is Halal. He said it is a discouraged thing. Definitely it is a discouraged tHing , there is no doubt.
.......😢 Never thought that this is how it will End.
Question:-
I have a question which I am shy to ask but another sister who has come to Islam recently wants an answer to and I do not have an answer (with evidence from the Quran and Sunnah). I hope you can help and I hope Allah will forgive me if it is inappropriate but as Muslims we should never be shy in seeking knowledge. Her question was "Is it permissible in Islam to masturbate?"
May Allah increase us all in knowledge!
Summary of answer:-
Masturbation (for both men and women) is haram (forbidden) in Islam based on evidence from the Quran and the Sunnah. See the detailed answer for 13 tips on how to give up masturbation.
Detailed Answer:-
Praise be to Allah.
Is masturbation haram in Islam?
Masturbation (for both men and women) is haraam (forbidden) in Islam based on the following evidence:
Prohibition of masturbation in the Quran
Al-Imam Shafi'i stated that masturbation is forbidden based on the following verses from the Quran (interpretation of the meaning):
{And those who guard their chastity (i.e. private parts, from illegal sexual acts). Except from their wives or (the captives and slaves) that their right hands possess, - for them, they are free from blame. But whoever seeks beyond that, then those are the transgressors.} (Al-Muminun 23:5-7)
Here the verses are clear in forbidding all illegal sexual acts (including masturbation) except for the wives or what their right hand possesses. {And whoever seeks beyond that is the transgressor.}
Some scholars used as evidence the ayah (in meaning),
{And let those who find not the financial means for marriage keep themselves chaste, until Allah enriches them of His bounty.} (Al-Nur 24:33)
This verse also clearly orders whoever does not have the financial means to marry to keep himself chaste and be patient in facing temptations (including masturbation) until Allah enriches them of His bounty.
Prohibition of masturbation in the Sunnah
'Abdullaah ibn Mas’ud said, "We were with the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) while we were young and had no wealth whatsoever. Allah's Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said, 'O young people! Whoever among you can marry, should marry, because it helps him lower his gaze and guard his modesty (i.e. his private parts from committing illegal sexual intercourse etc.), and whoever is not able to marry, should fast, as fasting diminishes his sexual power.'" (Al-Bukhari 5066)
The hadeeth orders men who are not able to marry to fast despite the hardship encountered in doing so, and not to masturbate despite the ease with which it can be done.
There is additional evidence that can be cited to support this ruling on masturbation, but due to the limited space we will not go through them here.
Tips on how to give up masturbation
As for curing/treating the habit of masturbation, we recommend the following suggestions:
1. The motive to seek a cure for this problem should be solely following Allah's orders and fearing His punishment.
2. A permanent and quick cure from this problem lies in marriage as soon as the person is able, as shown in the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) hadeeth.
3. Keeping oneself busy with what is good for this world and the Hereafter is essential in breaking this habit before it becomes second nature after which it is very difficult to rid oneself of it.
4. Lowering the gaze (from looking at forbidden things such as pictures, movies etc.) will help suppress the desire before it leads one to commit the haram (forbidden). Allah orders men and women to lower their gaze as shown in the following two verses and in the Prophet's hadith.
{Tell the believing men to lower their gaze (from looking at forbidden things) and protect their private parts (from illegal sexual acts, etc.). That is purer for them. Verily, Allah is all-aware of what they do. And tell the believing women to lower their gaze (from looking at forbidden things) and protect their private parts (from illegal sexual acts, etc.) ..... } (24: 30-31)
Allah's Messenger (peace and blessings be upon him) said: "Do not follow a casual (unintentional) look (at forbidden things) with another look." (Al-Tirmidhi, 2777) This is a general instruction by the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) to abstain from all that may sexually excite a person because it might lead him/her to commit the haram (forbidden).
5. Using one's available leisure time in worshipping Allah and increasing religious knowledge.
6. Being cautious not to develop any of the medical symptoms that may result from masturbation such as weak eyesight, weak nervous system, and/or back pain. More importantly, feelings of guilt and anxiety that can be complicated by missing obligatory prayers because of the need to shower (ghusl) after every incidence of masturbation, especially in the winter, and the invalidating of the fast.
7. Avoiding the illusion that some youth have that masturbation is permissible because it prevents them from committing illegal sexual acts such as fornication or even homosexuality, while they may not be at the gates of that immorality to begin with.
8. Strengthening one's willpower and not surrendering to the shaytan, and avoiding spending time alone as recommended by the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) when he said "Do not spend the night alone" Ahmad, 6919.
9. Following the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) aforementioned hadeeth and fasting when possible, because fasting will temper one's sexual desire and keep it under control. However, one should not overreact and swear by Allah not to return to the act because if one does not honor one's promise, one would be facing the consequences of not living up to one's oath to Allah. Also, note that medication to diminish one's sexual desire is strictly prohibited because it might permanently affect one's sexual ability.
10. Trying to follow the Prophet's (peace and blessings be upon him) recommendation concerning the etiquette of getting ready for bed, such as reading the well-known supplications, sleeping on the right side, and avoiding sleeping on the belly (the Prophet-peace and blessings be upon him- forbade sleeping on the belly).
11. Striving hard to be patient and chaste, because persistence will eventually, Allah willing, lead to attaining those qualities as second nature, as the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him) explains in the following hadith:
"Whoever seeks chastity Allah will make him chaste, and whoever seeks help from none but Allah, He will help him, and whoever is patient He will make it easy for him, and no one has ever been given anything better than patience." Al-Bukhari:1469.
12. If one falls into this sin, they must hasten to repent, asking forgiveness from Allah, doing good deeds, and not losing hope and feeling despair; these are all prerequisites to curing this problem. Note that losing hope is one of the major sins punishable by Allah.
13. Finally, Allah is the Most Merciful and He always responds to whoever calls on Him. So, asking for Allah's forgiveness and help will be accepted, by His will.
And Allah knows best
source:-
islamqa.info/en/329
السلام وعليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته I don’t know what dr Zakir Naik wants to prove about Masturbation but to my knowledge sheikh Uthman corrected dr Zakir Naik because dr Zakir Naik have quoted some of the weak narration
Well said...nd i considered masturbation is forbidden.. because prophet Mohammed 💓 never said that u can do masturbation..The alternative he has given is marriage or fasting..There is no place of masturbation
Yes... but u all should ask why the muftis kept quiet about the government let the womens dressing revealing their body and many prostitution places running their activities. ...all the fatwas is given based on the situation and although it's still haram but what about the persons in charge of looking after the laws of islam that have been broken by the people which leeds to people doing masturbation or more worse fornication .... and many laws have been broken ...the haram have became halal done by muftis that is to comfort the government. ...how about that? ?....come to reality brothers and start changing the situations from the top don't just talk between the lower stages and became a hero without feeling the pain of dakwah by correcting the leaders and governments in Islamic countries. ....
Dr Zalir Naik is proving with Greater Quran
Fatwas and shatiya are weak
Shik was also wrong at some point and quoted incomplete narration listen him carefully
Jazakallah hu khair Doctor ❤
I’ve been watching Dr zakir for years now and he’s number 1 in my book, but this is the first time that i disagree with him, for me it’s HARAM and even if it’s not it SHOULD BE
Same here
You must be a sinless soul😂
Even if it's not it should be ? What does that mean ? Who r u to decide?
I dont understand the conclusion to be drawn from the ayat of surah mominoon.
When I see the videos of other scholars it seems they are right and when I watch the video of Dr Zakir Naik it seems he is right
Anyone who is confused like me
I have a suggestion that it would be better if you do not to do it because we don't know what is right.
I know what u mean. I felt like that too. But finally Dr Naik convinced me more because there i no single direct and explicit prove that its haram. And brw even Dr shabir ally said that in an interview, its very interesting.
@@lionking4052 yes I agree with you too
The very fact that in all the arguments there is no mention of sayings of the prophet saw or the book of Allah even once declaring masturbation by name of the act being haram. I don't know why didnt Allah make it clear in his book just like day and night. It is clear to me that this is a debatable topic, to which there is no clear answer from Quran or ahadeeth rather opinions of scholars.
The ayat of surah mominoon can easily be taken for a man desiring any other woman not his wife or his slave, or a woman desiring a man not her husband, or even a man desiring a man ie people of lut, but to unfortunately deduce this ayat mentions masturbation is haram is a pure biased opinion. Some times common sense is not very common. This was an untouched topic by Allah and his prophet saw, yet we find many later scholars making it a subject of haram and halal. Allah knows best. Opinions are opinions but all major sins are clear as day and night and fully detailed in Qur'an and ahadith by names of the deeds.
The cognitive bias is very clear from certain named scholars who have said such and such narration is weak therefore my opinion is masturbation is haram. Even if narration is weak does not mean your cognitive bias leads to declaring an act haram where there is no clear declaration of haram for that act in Qur'an or hadith. And that is why there are some scholars with differing opinions when it comes to masturbations, while zero scholar differs on the matter of shirk, zina, alcohol etc.
I am not endorsing the act of masturbation, however logically I can not accept that it is clear from Quran and hadith that it is haram. I'm sorry no matter how ever you argue this it is unclear and may be Allah left it on purpose like this as otherwise majority of Muslim men and women will be having trouble.
If this deed can prevent zina and other issues that arise from desire then surely it's a lesser evil for unmarried teenagers who have high hormonal desires.
Addiction to masturbation is a bad thing and no one will say it's halal. But when you are young unmarried man in today's day and age, where no one gives their daughter in marriage unless a man earns, makes is very difficult for a young man to control his desires. He/ she will either indulge in zina, pornography, or even alcohol, drugs out of that carnal desire, and on top you tell them it is haram for you to do masturbation, you will open doors of major sins for these young men/ women.
Unfortunately our scholars can be sometimes very tunneled visioned, completely disconnected with the harmful effects of not releasing desire in one way or the other.
It is not Allah and his prophet who make the Deen difficult, it is pride of certain contemporary scholars who feel they can make halal and haram as they see fit, through their own concoctions and cognitive bias. This breeds a culture of relentless authority and kills debate and differing opinions in ummah once you label something haram.some of them even lead to hatred or disdain as you have made a video trying to prove that my elders feel this is haram, so I have to make a video proving Dr zakir Naik is wrong and he is quoting unauthentic narrations( mind not from prophet saw, but opinions of sahabah).
In my humble opinion brother you are also quoting opinions of this sheikh that sheikh but ( no direct reference from the book of Allah or the act of prophet saw explicitly mentioning masturbation being haram, rather using cognitive bias in deriving meanings from Book of Allah).
In summary if something is haram Allah and his rasool will not leave it to interpretation but will make it clear, as deen was complete at the time of prophet SAW. Surely Allah's book and his prophet saw would have mentioned it very clearly if this act was haram.
@@kamransaleem3027 It is as clear as day and night in Surah Muminoon verses 5 to 7
Let me quote it:
23:5
وَٱلَّذِينَ هُمْ لِفُرُوجِهِمْ حَـٰفِظُونَ ٥
And they who guard their private parts
23:6
إِلَّا عَلَىٰٓ أَزْوَٰجِهِمْ أَوْ مَا مَلَكَتْ أَيْمَـٰنُهُمْ فَإِنَّهُمْ غَيْرُ مَلُومِينَ ٦
Except from their wives or those their right hands possess, for indeed, they will not be blamed -
23:7
فَمَنِ ٱبْتَغَىٰ وَرَآءَ ذَٰلِكَ فَأُو۟لَـٰٓئِكَ هُمُ ٱلْعَادُونَ ٧
But whoever seeks beyond that, then those are the transgressors -
So in these verses its as clear as day and night that anything besides what is meant in Verse 6 is prohibited. Look at verse 7, whoever seeks beyond that are the transgressors meaning whoever acts on this desire boyond what is commanded in these verses are going against Allah
Dr zakir Naik should go to present the view of majority of scholars rather than to down the hardwork of fuqahaa.
I request dr zakir to revisit the video of sheikh uthman....and dr should refrain from touching the fiqh issues as he is not expert in that....by the way love dr zakir for the work he has done but no one is infallable and he should accept where he commits a mistake
I believe Zakir Naik is more suited to discuss about or do debate about comparative religion not giving out Masalas that can have a negative effects on Ummah. Saying Masterbation is not Haram but Makruh will allow the deviants to use his view to make Masterbation Halal!!!
there is definetly a lot to unpack especially since there is many people coming back to these videos. Its 2 years old but I found this in my recomended. I am honestly confused on which is right. But when he is saying its not halal if your masterbating but your married then this is incorrect but for example my sistuation I cant be with my wife due to citizenship. What do I do fast what if this is not enough. I am fasting but I have extrem urge. Do I just get married again. There is no temporary marriage in islam. And my current fincial capabilites is one wife not 2 wives. But do I belive there is the majority of muslims who are not masturbating honestly no I dont belive this especially the ones in western countries.
Bismillah as I know we must not stay away from our spouses more than 3 months. If we can't we must hold patience/ keep fasting and so on..... and go for 2nd or 3rd or more marriages if possible. Or wait for your spouse.
The position of Dr Zakir for it is makrooh it is makrooh in the origin and that’s correct with evidences Because there are a reasonable big numbers of scholars who say it is makrooh and some say halal
Also the Hanbali school the jumhor says it is haram in “ conditions “ not in origin and the origin is makrooh and this is the problem that some people who are same us from Hanbali school they do not understand the real correct view of imam Ahmad bin Hanbl and it is actually a lock of understanding the view more that the collect of evidences and under that comment I will give a response to the most quotes that they say it is weak and I will show the truth of their quick judgement of saying they are weak when most of them there is a discussion on them it is not all of them weak
And I will show big number of who said it is makrooh and some who said it is halal and I will show quotes of the correct view of jumhor and famous people of Hanbali school that clearly showing that they are saying it is haram in conditions not on origin and it is makrooh in origin and it will show who some misunderstandings imam Ahmad bin Hanbl :
قال الإمام الشوكاني رحمة الله عليه:
(ومن جملة ما تمسكوا به قياس الاستمناء بالكف على العزلة ويجاب بأن الأصل مختلف في تحريمه ، لاختلاف أدلته ، فلا يصح القياس بمحل النـزاع على ما هو متنازع فيه وايضاً يجاب بالمعارضة بمثل الاستمتاع من الزوجة والأمة بغير الفرج فإن كان ما فرض مانعا من الاستمناء فهو مانع من الاستمتاع)
الرسائل الفقهية - للإمام الشوكاني ص ١٦٦
بلوغ المنى في حكم الاستمناء
وحكى ابن القيم عن الامام ابن عقيل أنه قال
(وأصحابنا - أي : الحنابلة وشيخنا - ابن تيمية - لم يذكروا سوى الكراهة ولم يطلقوا التحريم)
المصدر كتاب بدائع الفوائد لابن القيم (3/96 - 98)
قال ابن عقيل أيضاً : ( وإن لم يكن له زوجة ولا أمة ولم يجد ما يتزوج به كُره ولم يحرم ، والفقير إذا خشي العنت فإنه جائزٌ له ، نص على ذلك أحمد)
المصدر كتاب بدائع الفوائد لابن القيم (4 / 82)
وقال ابن الهمام في شرح فتح القدير(2/230) :
( فإن غلبته الشهوة وأراد تسكينها به فالرجاء أن لا يعاقب)
قال الإمام ابن العربي رحمه الله:
" وأحمد بن حنبل على ورعه يجوَّزُه ويحتج بأنه إخراج فضْلةٍ من البدن ، فجاز عند الحاجة ، أصلُه الفَصْد والحجامة ".اهـ
[أحكام القرآن 3/251]
وايضاً ذكره القرطبي انظر الى [ تفسير القرطبي (الجامع لأحكام القرآن) 1-11 ج6 - الجزء الثاني عشر - سورة المؤمنون الآية (٥) - ٧١ .. ١٠٦ ]
قال الإمام ابن حزم رحمه الله:
"فيكره هذا ، ولا إثم فيه ، وكذلك الاستمناء للرجال
سواء سواء ، لأن مس الرجل ذكره بشماله مباح..
بإجماع الأمة كلها ، فإذ هو مباح فليس هنالك زيادة على المباح ، إلا التعمد لنزول المني ، فليس ذلك حراماً أصلاً ، لقول الله تعالى: (وقد فَصلَ لكم ما حرمَ عليكم) وليس هذا مما فصل لنا تحريمه فهو حلال ، لقوله تعالى: (خَلق لكم ما في الأرضِ جميعاً) إلا أننا نكرهه ، لأنه ليس من مكارم الأخلاق ، ولا من الفضائل".اهـ
[المحلى 13/221]
وقد نقل الإمام ابن حزم رحمه الله آثاراً في ذلك:
"عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما:
"وما هو إلا أن يعرك أحدكم زبه حتى ينزل الماء".
وعن ابن عمر رضي الله عنهما:
"إنما هو عصب تدلكه".
وعن العلاء بن زياد عن أبيه:
أنهم كانوا يفعلونه في المغازي "يعني الاستمناء" ، يعبث الرجل بذكره يدلكه حتى ينزل..
قال قتادة: وقال الحسن في الرجل يستمني يعبث بذكره ينزل ، قال: "كانوا يفعلون في المغازي".
وعن جابر بن زيد أبي الشعثاء قال:
"هو ماؤك فأهرقه -يعني الاستمناء-".
وعن مجاهد قال:
"كان من مضى يأمرون شبابهم بالاستمناء يستعفون بذلك".
وعن الحسن: أنه كان لا يرى بأساً بالاستمناء.
وعن عمرو بن دينار: ما أرى بالاستمناء بأساً..".
[انظر المحلى 13/221-222].
قال الإمام ابن حزم رحمه الله بعد أن ساق هذه الآثار وغيرها:
" الأسانيد عن ابن عباس وابن عمر -في كلا القولين- مغموزة. لكن الكراهة صحيحة عن عطاء ، والإباحة المطلقة صحيحة عن الحسن ، وعن عمرو بن دينار ، وعن زياد أبي العلاء ، وعن مجاهد. ورواه من رواه من هؤلاء عمن أدركوا -وهؤلاء- كبار التابعين الذين لا يكادون يروون إلا عن الصحابة رضي الله عنهم ".اهـ
[المحلى 13/222].
13593 أخبرنا عبد الرزاق قال : أخبرنا ابن جريج قال [ ص: 392 ] أخبرني إبراهيم بن أبي بكر ، عن مجاهد قال : " كان من مضى يأمرون شبانهم بالاستمناء ، والمرأة كذلك تدخل شيئا " . قلنا لعبد الرزاق : ما تدخل شيئا ؟ قال : " يريد السق يقول : تستغني به عن الزنا " .
[ المصدر: انظر " المصنف " لعبد الرزاق (7/391) ]
13586 عبد الرزاق قال : أخبرنا ابن جريج ، عن عطاء ، أنه كره الاستمناء . قلت : أفيه(حديث)؟ قال : " ما سمعته " .
[ المصدر: انظر " المصنف " لعبد الرزاق (7|390) باب الاستمناء ]
ورد عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما قال : " قال رجل : إني أعبث بذكري حتى أنزل ؟ قال : إن نكاح الأمة خير منه ، وهو خير من الزنا" .
رواه عبد الرزاق في " المصنف " (7/ 390)
أخبرنا أبو زكريا بن أبي إسحاق المزكي أنبأ أبو عبد الله بن يعقوب ثنا محمد بن عبد الوهاب أنبأ جعفر بن عون أنبأ الأجلح عن أبي الزبير عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما: أن غلاماً أتاه فجعل القوم يقومون والغلام جالس ، فقال له بعض القوم: قم يا غلام ، فقال ابن عباس رضي الله عنهما: دعوه شيءٌ ما أجلَسَه ، فلما خلا قال: يا ابن عباس إني غُلامٌ شابٌّ أجِدُ غلمةً شديدة فأدلك ذكري حتى أنزل ، فقال ابن عباس: (خيرٌ من الزنا ، ونكاح الأمة خيرٌ منه).
أثر صحيح ، أخرجه البيهقي في ((ألسنن الكبرى)) (ج٧ ص٣٢٣) او (7|199)
يقول المجد رحمه الله في “المحرر” (2/154): “ويُباح لمن يخشى العَنَت أن يستمني بيده, فإن لم يَخشَهُ حرُم. وعنه: يُكره تنزيهاً” ا.هـ.
وقال في “الإنصاف” (26/466): “وعنهُ: يُكره. نقل ابن مَنْصور: (لا يُعجبني بلا ضرورة)” ا.هـ. المراد.
أبو حيان رحمه الله ، قالَ في: “البحر المحيط” (6/397): “وكان أحمد بن حنبل يُجيز الاستمناء ، لأنه فضلة من البدن ، فجاز إخراجها عن الحاجة ، كالفصد والحِجامة” ا.هـ.
ابن العربي رحمه الله كما قال في: “أحكام القرآن” (3/131):
“وأحمد بن حنبل على ورعه يُجوّز الاستمناء ، ويَحْتَج بإنه إخراجُ فَضْلةٍ من البدن ، فجازَ عند الحاجة ، أصلُه الفَصْد والحجامة” ا.هـ. المراد. وتَبِعه القرطبي رحمه الله في “الجامع” (12/105).
وقال ابن عابدين عليه رحمة الله :
( إن أراد - اي فعله للعادة السرية - تسكين الشهوات المفرطة الشاغلة للقلب ، وكان عزباً لا زوجة لـه ولا أمة ، أو كان لـه زوجة إلا أنه لا يقدر على الوصول إليها بعذر ، قال أبو الليث : أرجو أن لا وبال عليه)
انظر كتاب السراج لابن عابدين
وقد قال الإمام الصنعاني رحمة الله :
( وهذه الآثار تدور في فلك تلك الأقوال التي تدل على عدم حرمة الاستمناء )
انتهى من كتاب سبل السلام (1/385) للامام الصنعانى
ويقول الشيخ سيد سابق في كتابه “فقه السنة” (المجلد الثاني، الطبعة الثامنة، 1407هـ - 1987م، دار الكتاب العربي، بيروت.. صفحة 388 - 390)
((استمناء الرجل بيده مما يتنافى مع ما ينبغي أن يكون عليه الإنسان من الأدب وحسن الخلق، وقد اختلف الفقهاء في حكمه: فمنهم من رأى أنه حرام مطلقًا، ومنهم من رأى أنه حرام في بعض الحالات وواجب في بعضها الآخر، ومنهم من ذهب إلى القول بكراهته)). انتهى
قال الامام الشوكاني رحمة الله عليه :
((ليس في كتاب الله ولا سنة رسول الله دليل صحيح ولا ضعيف يقتضي تحريم الاستمناء ))
المصدر كتاب بلوغ المنى فى حكم الاستمناء للامام الشوكانى
وقال الامام الشوكاني رحمه الله
(( الاحاديث التي استدل بها المحرمون ضعيفة أو موضوعة ولا يصح منها شيء ))
وقال ابن العربي المالكي عن بعض العلماء قولهم : " لو قام الدليل على جوازها ، لكان ذو المروءة يعرض عنها لدناءتها " انتهى من " أحكام القرآن " (3/315) .
والرد على بعض من ضعف بعض او قليل جدا من الاثار رغم ان تضعيفها لا يؤثر على باقي الادله واحده منها فيها نظر ربما الكلام صحيح :
أخرج البيهقي في سننه الكبرى (7\199): أخبرنا أبو زكريا بن أبي إسحاق المزكي أنبأ أبو عبد الله بن يعقوب ثنا محمد بن عبد الوهاب (ثقة) أنبأ جعفر بن عون (جيد) أنبأ الأجلح (شيعي ضعيف) عن أبي الزبير (منقطعاً) عن ابن عباس رضي الله عنهم: أن غلاماً أتاه، فجعل القوم يقومون والغلام جالس. فقال له بعض القوم: «قم يا غلام». فقال ابن عباس رضي الله عنهم: «دعوه. شيءٌ ما أجلَسَه». فلما خلا، قال: «يا ابن عباس. إني غُلامٌ شابٌّ أجِدُ غلمةً شديدة. فأدلك ذكري حتى أنزل؟». فقال ابن عباس: «خيرٌ من الزنا، ونكاح الأمة خيرٌ منه»
الأجلح ليّن الحديث ، أما الحكم على رواية أبي الزبير عن ابن عباس بالانقطاع فمحل بحث؛ فقد روى مسلم في صحيحه لأبي الزبير عن ابن عباس
نعم؛ قد روى ابن أبي حاتم في المراسيل بسند صحيح عن ابن عيينة: يقولون: أبو الزبير المكي لم يسمع من ابن عباس
13588 عن الثوري ومعمر عن الأعمش عن أبي رزين (مسعود بن مالك ، ثقة) عن أبي يحيى (مستور) عن ابن عباس أن رجلاً قال له:«إني أَعْبَثُ بِذَكَرِي حتى أُنْزِلَ». قال: «إن نِكاح الأمَةِ خيرٌ منهُ، وهو خيرٌ من الزنا».
رجاله كلهم ثقات إلا أبو يحيى ، واسمه: مِصْدع، وهو الأعرج المعرقب ، قال عمار الدهني: كان مصدع أبو يحيى عالما بابن عباس.
ووثقه العجلي ، وروى له مسلم في الصحيح ، وتكلم فيه الجوزجاني وغيره لتشيعه.
أما ابن حبان فجرحه بما لم يسبقه إليه إمام.
والظاهر أن السند جيّد ، والله أعلم.
13593 أخبرنا ابن جريج قال أخبرني إبراهيم بن أبي بكر (الأخنسي ، مستور) عن مجاهد قال: «كان من مضى يأمرون شُبّانهم بالاستمناء. والمرأة كذلك تدخل شيئاً». قلنا لعبد الرزاق: «ما تدخل شيئاً؟». قال (عبد الرزاق): «يريد السق. يقول (أي مجاهد): "تستغني به عن الزنا"».
رجاله ثقات إلا إبراهيم وهو مستور ، وقال الذهبي: محله الصدق.
13591 عن الثوري عن عبّاد عن منصور عن جابر بن زيد أبي الشعثاء (البصري ت103) قال: «هو مَاؤُك فَأَهْرِقْهُ».
أخشى أن يكون (عبّاد عن منصور) غير مستقيم، وتكون الباء تحرفت إلى العين، ويكون الصواب: عن (عبّاد بن منصور)، وهو من شيوخ الثوري، ويروي عن الحسن البصري وغيره من طبقة أبي الشعثاء
والله أعلم
وعباد بن منصور ضعيف مدلس ، فالسند لايصح
13594 أخبرنا ابن جريج (مدلّس) قال: قال عمرو بن دينار (ت126): «ما أرى بالاستِمناءِ بأساً».
لم يصرح ابن جريج بسماعه من عمرو
@@essa200911 Please, can you translate it in English?
@@Imdadmzbh
The evidences are too much and I don’t have their translated resources but however I think it is better for anyone reading them to ask someone who understands Arabic to translate them
Also I will try to translate them to English and send them here but I can not promise to make them in correct English because English is my second language and I’m from Arabia
ruclips.net/video/6ZhZr9TW0tY/видео.html
He first replied to engineer Ali Mirza.
Second person was sheikh uthman
Thank me later
Thanks 😁
They both are intellectual
Yes, I know.
Even the sahabah wasn’t perfect but they were perfect all together because they could correct one another in issues one didn’t understand.. Imagine if the students of Islamic knowledge all got along..
Jazakallah sheikh
He essentially answered all the things that were pointed out in Sk uthman’s video in a very concise manner with the direct references and explanations... Not only did he stand by his views on the matter, he solidified it with better explanation of the references...
Allah knows best!
Go check Sheikh uthmans answer its not true that he mentioned the direct references of sheikh uthman go see the second video of Sheikh Uthman. Dr Zakir put words in Sheikh uthmans mouth and didn't mention the right references. Do not let your desires blind you from the truth deep down we know it is despicable. Allah knows best.
The very fact that in all the arguments there is no mention of sayings of the prophet saw or the book of Allah even once declaring masturbation by name of the act being haram. I don't know why didnt Allah make it clear in his book just like day and night. It is clear to me that this is a debatable topic, to which there is no clear answer from Quran or ahadeeth rather opinions of scholars.
The ayat of surah mominoon can easily be taken for a man desiring any other woman not his wife or his slave, or a woman desiring a man not her husband, or even a man desiring a man ie people of lut, but to unfortunately deduce this ayat mentions masturbation is haram is a pure biased opinion. Some times common sense is not very common. This was an untouched topic by Allah and his prophet saw, yet we find many later scholars making it a subject of haram and halal. Allah knows best. Opinions are opinions but all major sins are clear as day and night and fully detailed in Qur'an and ahadith by names of the deeds.
The cognitive bias is very clear from certain named scholars who have said such and such narration is weak therefore my opinion is masturbation is haram. Even if narration is weak does not mean your cognitive bias leads to declaring an act haram where there is no clear declaration of haram for that act in Qur'an or hadith. And that is why there are some scholars with differing opinions when it comes to masturbations, while zero scholar differs on the matter of shirk, zina, alcohol etc.
I am not endorsing the act of masturbation, however logically I can not accept that it is clear from Quran and hadith that it is haram. I'm sorry no matter how ever you argue this it is unclear and may be Allah left it on purpose like this as otherwise majority of Muslim men and women will be having trouble.
If this deed can prevent zina and other issues that arise from desire then surely it's a lesser evil for unmarried teenagers who have high hormonal desires.
Addiction to masturbation is a bad thing and no one will say it's halal. But when you are young unmarried man in today's day and age, where no one gives their daughter in marriage unless a man earns, makes is very difficult for a young man to control his desires. He/ she will either indulge in zina, pornography, or even alcohol, drugs out of that carnal desire, and on top you tell them it is haram for you to do masturbation, you will open doors of major sins for these young men/ women.
Unfortunately our scholars can be sometimes very tunneled visioned, completely disconnected with the harmful effects of not releasing desire in one way or the other.
It is not Allah and his prophet who make the Deen difficult, it is pride of certain contemporary scholars who feel they can make halal and haram as they see fit, through their own concoctions and cognitive bias. This breeds a culture of relentless authority and kills debate and differing opinions in ummah once you label something haram.some of them even lead to hatred or disdain as you have made a video trying to prove that my elders feel this is haram, so I have to make a video proving Dr zakir Naik is wrong and he is quoting unauthentic narrations( mind not from prophet saw, but opinions of sahabah).
In my humble opinion brother you are also quoting opinions of this sheikh that sheikh but ( no direct reference from the book of Allah or the act of prophet saw explicitly mentioning masturbation being haram, rather using cognitive bias in deriving meanings from Book of Allah).
In summary if something is haram Allah and his rasool will not leave it to interpretation but will make it clear, as deen was complete at the time of prophet SAW. Surely Allah's book and his prophet saw would have mentioned it very clearly if this act was haram.
@Kenneth George brother peace on you. Can you point out direct prohibition of the act of masturbation by Quran or hadeeth. Rest are all opinions from scholars based on their own understandings which is why I reiterate we see difference of opinion. Agreed more scholars are of the view that masturbation is haram and they quote surah muminoon as their justification from Quran, this is just their own opinion and not a clear answer from Quran.
As far as narration of Ayesha RA, the man asked him regarding mutah marriage, when she quoted surah muminoon, a clear non biased answer from this hadith will be that mutah marriage is not allowed. Again this was a topic not discussed particularly in Qur'an or hadith in clear words.
Brother years of seeking knowledge does not mean you are always right in your assumptions. This is clearly a topic of cognitive bias and assumptions.
I understand from your talk that you rever and follow opinions of your sheikhs and as such are a muqallad.
I'm asking you to share with me direct words of quran and hadith and all you do is tell me that we follow years of studies of scholars?.
And agree blindly to what our mind agrees to ie cognitive bias.
All you need to do is show me a verse from Quran or hadith which directly prohibits the act of masturbation brother and I will agree 100 percent with you.
Again smoking I don't know whether it's khimr brother as it does not make you lose your senses like alcohol or drugs.
But yes smoking is harmful to a human health as in it can cause oropharyngeal cancers, lung cancers, COPD and harms your body and is an addictive substance. Anything which harms human body is prohibited in Islam ok be it khimr or non khimr.
Again use common sense, for which Allah made you Ashraf ul makhlukat and just tell me a verse of quran where Allah says oh believers masturbation is haram. Or a hadith in which the prophet saw says masturbation is haram. If you have this evidence I will accept it.
As far as music goes please tell sheikh usman to remove the introductory music from his RUclips videos.
As far as your mention of mutazallite, this is completely off topic, if you have doubts in sifat of Allah may he guide you, I do not doubt Allah's siffat.
@@kamransaleem3027 So Uthman is going against the principles of Islam by playing music on his RUclips videos? Islam really grabs every aspect of the human life, doesn't it?
@@gospeltruth6368 I don't know who you are but, but sheikh usman is a fellow countryman, mufti of Islam. I do understand where he is coming from, and there is no harm in following his opinion which is a majority opinion, infact If one can follow his and many other scholars view then there is nothing wrong for they understood it with best of their capacity.
Please explain to me, if you are a rich 60 years old Emirati and is okay to relieve yourself with 4 different wives a week is some how justifiable, but the 18 years old single boy who doesn’t have the money in Bangladesh, you think he cannot do anything with his body? It’s hard to control the needs of chemical reaction in your body!
A student should not give fatwas
Misturbation is not haraam God is no shy to talk directly the issue which are personl
People those who are claimming its not halal based upon fatwas and base less sources
Its a fact even all the Mulla come together the cnnot show us where Allah and Muhammad have talked directly about that
Dont make stupid vedio agaist Zakir
You are nothing compared to his knowledge.
Mr Utman or Mir Engineer or Mr Tariq Masood show us prove instead of talking foolishness
In Quran it is clearly written that sex outside marital affairs is haraam not misturbation so stay away from the things that you know nothing
Without any evidence a normal person can easily say that it is Haram . Because any harmful thing in Islam is haram
Who says masturbation is harmful ?
What's harmful is speaking without knowledge
Why doesn't he just concentrate on comparative religion and leave figh question to be answered by figh experts.
brother Muhammad He is a da'ee there are many things he has done them correctly excluding matters on comparative religion I do not think its a good Idea when someone makes a mistake or understands something different from you. you shut him down completely consider the good he has done and ignore the bad...... The good part of this issue is that He is relating to some Scholars he is not only saying from his fatwas
My friend, Dr zakir is saying as narrated by scholars. He further mentioned the ayah surah nisa chap4 , verse 59 where it is mentioned if opinions of scholar differs go back to Allah and rasool . he further mentioned he has a right to choose which he agree with and you may not agree with. That's ur problem . not his
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 but he's wrong akhi dont let your desires blind you Dr Zakir is very knowledgeable but on this fiqh issue he is simply wrong the evidences said it all. Go check the 2nd video of Sheikh Uthman Ibn Farooq every evidence is presented.
Then why Muslims are asking about such type questions...if you don't like dr.naik to give answer such..no problem....
@@hmzzrg5045 He's giving you references 😂 what's wrong in that ? Ibn Hazam is wrong ? Tabihin is wrong ? And who's Uthman ? How on earth would you even compare a layman with Zakir Naik ? 😂
I don't agree in this topic with Naik
Well explained.. the best answers.. ❤
I think u r a great scholar
Young scholars want the fame and credibility by trying to show they are better then the Kings of Deen and in this case one of the most famous after Sheik Ahmed Deedat is Dr Nakir Naik...... Just like the young lions in the desert trying to dethrone the old lion king....
Dr Zakir Naik ....Is the most famous renowned scholar in the world...
He has done excellent work in spreading islam....
Allah has given him ..so much talent he can convince anyone to accept islam...
I will request to young scholar instead of fighting and correcting Dr Zakir Naik sir ...they should more focus on dawah...
Allah give shiek uthman great reward
Imam shafi shiek Albani shiek uthameen
Scholars like assim al Hakeem dr Muhammed salah usama at thaibi
Wajid akari and all the true scholars that are in the sunnah that comdem this evil act satanic act
I pray to Allah we as Muslims must not support this act we must condem all condem this act its poison to the ummah targetting the youths especially
Satanic? Really? Isn't that too much?
Its something that doesn't have a lot of evidence behind it. It's not even mentioned by name once in either the quran or a sahih hadith though people draw conclusions from ayahs in surah muminoon but its not mentioned directly.
Probably 95% of people do it and ur calling it satanic?
Dont call it satanic. Its a disputed topic. As said here some scholars condemn it and some didn't. So its up to you. Try to avoid it.
@@k1003944 ur right
Dont confuse it with Haraam God never feel shy to discuss personal matters of humanity
We follow Quran and Sunnah, not imam this and imam that, if you have a verse from Quran or an authentic hadith saying that masturbation is haram bring it, otherwise shut up
Dr.zakir naik can't be wrong 👍👍
why not? is he infallible?
This is not the correct attitude and can even be a means to shirk because you're elevating someone to higher than their status. He is human like anyone else and isn't exempt from mistakes. Only the prophet ﷺ we take everything from without debating or doubting him but anyone else can make mistakes
Anyone can be wrong, there is a reason why he quotes everything, it's because it's not him that has the credibility, it is the source he is using that gives him credibility, it's the holy quran. Of course Zakir Naik is a one in a billion man knowing every scripture from quotes a living dictionary. He has turned more people into muslims than anyone.
ruclips.net/video/PFnsTC7wfPw/видео.html
😂😂😂 Love you zakir sir
perfect & best reply for some peoples @14:47
Thank you for your great explaination sir
surely I will ask dhua for you
He's talking about ENGR MUHAMMAD ALI MIRZA
It depends on whether there's a consensus. Ibn Othaymeen said it is haram, and other reliable sources hold this position, but if there's consensus on it being haram, then it is haram.
By consensus u mean majority? But majority isn't authority.
@@UrDaddy4Real No, by consensus I mean entirety. Majority is not consensus.
My friend, Dr zakir is saying as narrated by scholars. He further mentioned the ayah surah nisa chap4 , verse 59 where it is mentioned if opinions of scholar differs go back to Allah and rasool . he further mentioned he has a right to choose which he agree with and you may not agree with. That's ur problem . not his
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 Zakir Naik, may Allah rectify him, is too proud to admit that he takes an opinion which is extremely minoritatian, he lets his pride to drive his responses to Uthman Farooq.
And by the way Zakir Naik is a deviant in Aqīdah, so just because he memorised books of ahadith and several scriptures by even knowing the exact verse numbers, I don't have to be excited.
His field is comparative religion, he's not a faqih, he's not a scholar, and his teacher was a deviant as well because he denied some attributes of Allah and he celebrated the Mawlid. This is the reality, may Allah rectify him and enable him to curb his pride about his own knowledge.
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 @Muhammad Shariq Khan And by the way I don't know whether there's consensus about masturbation, but if there's any, then he must retract his own ruling about the issue, simple.
Being a talent in medicine does not enable to become a doctor/physician, likewise is for certain sciences in Islam.
If a 10 year old for example happened to memorise several mutoon of Aqīdah, the Qurān and all the books of Sahih hadith, would he be allowed to address the questions and give fatawah? Obviously not, because firstly he has not delved into the specific sciences, secondly he has not the maturity to teach people, so being a talent clearly is not enough in roles of high responsibilty roles.
There were mashaykh whose sons were well taught in Islam as well (since they learned from their fathers), but they didn't allow their sons to teach certain sciences despite they were very knowledgeable, because in order to address certain topics to the masses you have to be white bearded, wise, and not hasty or emotional.
I don’t agree with zakir naik, masturbation should be considered haram
he doesn't do anything. his team does the work. wheres humility
Whats the world coming too ??? Whats this sudden Obsession with Bashing your Bishop !!! We got a major Pandemic in the world and bigger things to worry about...Focus on your Salat, get closer to Allah and read Quran daily before Malik Al MAwt comes knocking on your Door and he could come while you are half way through Bashing your Bishop ....Can you imagine !!! Holding onto your Banana and the Angel of death takes your Soul....Oh My days !!! This is Serious !!!
Major pandemic doesn't stop sexual urges mate
@@k1003944 but fasting does
@@gamingexe723 hasn't always worked for me. I've felt sexual urges while fasting before. Also, most people struggle fasting 2 days a week (mondays and thursdays) so they most certainly aren't going to fast everyday
@@k1003944 do you have means of getting married
@@gamingexe723 no. Guess there is no solution for me at the moment lol. I dont even have a job
I agree
Subhanallah people are sick and very selective may Allah guide us all. Why are people acting like he is telling everyone to go and masturbate? Stop being the haram police and understand how he came to his conclusion and the fatwa he shared. Why are people disregarding the scholars he mentioned? He is also a medical doctor who has a broader understanding of the human anatomy. I am not here to defend who does what and I personally think masturbation is a disgusting act, but let's not make that which is makrooh- haram. If there is not a clear verse in the Quran or a hadith we should not attack or judge anyone, especially someone like Dr. Zakir Naik. Additionally, people looking to commit such an act should also not be misconstruing what he said to justify their actions. Ramadan Kareem and may Allah forgive me if I misspoke.
the issue is with people like you, who have no knowledge and judge by their desires, zakir naik literally lied in the video, he quoted wrong btw, thats not true, masturbation is not makruh, it is considered haram by the scholars he mentioned himself, he doest know, he is not a scholar, he should not be taken seriously in fiqh issues
Masturbation is natural - Q - Is masturbation a sex act? I believe it is not because sex involves two or more than two parties.
Zabranjeno je i ne opravdavaj ! To delo gasi nafaku , pa se osoba koja to radi nikad neoženi ili ne uda. Allah mrzi one koji to rade! Jer logički razmisli, sve što kvari post nije dozvoljeno , sem ako nije brak upitanju pa je obaveza. Nakon toga covek mora da uzme gusul. Da bi namaz mogao da obavi. Sve sto je van braka uzivanje nije dozvoljeno!
Zakir Naik should not interfere in Halal haram things, it's not his field. He himself claim that he is not a scholar. So please stop giving fatwas on such sensitive issues. Because you're an influencer and you might be misleading youth in this days of fitna.
P.S. Shaikh Uthman on this matter talked very clearly and proved your point is WRONG. You are a dayee, please keep calling people to deen.
You are totally right sir
everything is good but we the simple people who dont have much knowledge about those things maybe we are good practicing muslim we really confused which side we really go. Some says haram the give there reference. Some says halal or makruh they also give there reference. I dont know where i will go😞😞
And this is problematic situations that we face, that’s why I only say to read Quran and believe in the first sets of scholars only it’s clear cut Haram. And not finding what this scholars n those scholars say’s .. Sheikh always say if the scholars differ then go back to the Quran and sunnah than why they confuse us like that by saying these kind of tasfir
Prophet Mohammed said leave that thing which is doubtful...So my brother plzz don't do masturbation
ruclips.net/video/6ZhZr9TW0tY/видео.html❤️❤️❤️
ruclips.net/video/W7il22xeqng/видео.html
@@mohdafnan8278 but in Quran it is not stated about doing it with hand
Dr. What has touching private parts has to do with masturbation? Just because someone touches his private parts doesnt mean that he is masturbating.
Oh come on you really don't believe you know more than Zakir Naik
I am die heart fan of dr zakir but am not agree with this view
Sheikh uthman debate with great scholar dr zakir naik
i love both dr zakir naik and engineer muhamad ali mirza
Naav na chi ne ye wanan
Who is Engineer Mirza🥱
Dr.zakir is talking about Sheikh Uthman fool
Maybe he's talking about eng. Ali Mirza 🤔
100% 1 is engineer Ali and one is sheikhuthman
Sir please Dawah is more important. Leave this topics to scholars.we love you
Some time this topic also very important.
And how do you know he is not a scholar ?
volume is too low! almost impossible to hear clearly even after maximizing the volume!!!
Dr Zakir naik You are such living Legend the way you express your opinion and the way you give anwers to the Disblivers is truely Brilient but this time you make a mistake
What mistake?
I agree with you
It is just like food. If some one likes he or she may do it. If the others do not like it they can avoid it. It is very personal. Your any act that is not harmful to others is not haram or makroo.
Nice video
Jazakallah khair
Great reply and saving our iman by giving best reply
Mufti Tariq Masood,, have you anything to reply to this ??
All the contemporary and salaf scholar are of the view to be haram
Allah give you to jaziya khair sir
Must Read abt sheikh Uthman view.
I am not a scholar since I am just a common person.But the way sheikh uthman shared his naseeha wasnt good.
1) he should have tried to reach dr zakir naik and his associates.
2) he directly talks about his personal remarks. Like you, your people, Your ego. in entire video.
3) He may have though by posting video he may take away Dr zakir naik follower. Which is too bad.
Look Humans arent perfect that dosent mean we discredit someone in front of audience even though he might have done error in picking up daeef hadith by mistake.
As a Common person I cant be like 99/1. I can be only like 50/50 becauseof knowledge Dr zakir naik has. And Dr.making mistakes will be negligible.
IMPORTANTLY-
Dr. Zakir naik never said its Halal. He gave it as final option after following everything prophet muhamed said.
Thats my view. Once again even if dr zakir naik is Wrong . Shk uthman way of approach is really bad.
He did try to reach zakir Naik but there was no response from zakir Naik so he posted a video.. he said if zakir Naik can see the video and contact him he will remove the video immediately.. he praised zakir Naik for his work that he's done but he doesn't agree with zakir Naik on this topic of masturbation and it is important that they both discuss this to they guide people to the truth that's why he tried to get hold of zakir Naik personally but couldn't get hold of him
@@rumaysahkhan7552 at the end Usman was wrong + stupid
@@abdullahparacha0 he wasn't wrong
@@rumaysahkhan7552 yrs he wasnt wrong he was confused because of his lack of knowledge
How can he prove it as Haraam without the Words of God
God is no shy to discuss personal matter like anal sex and sex during mastural cycle
And if one has right to touch his private parts then Usman ruling is non sense
God never forbaid man himsrlf to take plesure from himself rather toching other properties
@@rumaysahkhan7552 According to him the tabeen he loves are right and the tabeen that are less in no are wrong
Majority is not the authrity
Christatins are more then muslims do we have to follow them because they are in majority
Please don't try to justify, its haram, its is Haram.
My friend, Dr zakir is saying as narrated by scholars. He further mentioned the ayah surah nisa chap4 , verse 59 where it is mentioned if opinions of scholar differs go back to Allah and rasool . he further mentioned he has a right to choose which he agree with and you may not agree with. That's ur problem . not his
What do you say to Sheik Uthman who said it is Makrooh, permissible under difficult circumstances?
@@robertokello5201 my friend Holy Quran is very clear cut. As I quoted the verse of surah nisa chap 4 verse 59 that "obey Allah and obey messenger and those who has knowledge (scholars) and if they differ in opinion go back to Allah and Messenger"
So on the topic of masturbation different scholars have different opinions so Zakir naik is saying with whom group of scholars he agrees with. That's totally fine . now these people who are nor scholars neither student of knowledge want to imposing their point of view.so that's what I was explaining to him its ur problem not his. We can't force anybody to agree with what u agree.
@@muhammadshariqkhan5405 Have failed to respond to my previous comment?
Also, the God of Israel, creator of all things, created man in His image and put in him a conscience to know the difference between right and wrong. From one's conscience, one is able to know that masturbation is haram, why would he need a Allah, "the messenger" or the "Scholars" to tell him this?
To say one should go to Allah, the messenger, or "scholars" to be instructed on something as basic as masturbation being halal or haram, means that people do not have within themselves the knowledge of something like this being haram. It treats grown people like little children who have no knowledge of what is good or evil.
How can you be proud to be part of a religion which treats people like little children with no knowledge of right and wrong?
---SLAM IS A SCAM
@@robertokello5201 who's Uthman ? Bring me a verse of Quran or an authentic hadith saying that masturbation is haram, otherwise i don't follow imam this and imam that
Why such a long video 😥
Man I believe if there are two sins, then it is not right to compare their level and say, at least this one is better than the other. It is like you are supporting that sin.
Note: These are only my views.
Every reference that you gave is hasan or zaeef to its core
Jabir ibn zaid is not a tabi i
But Jafar ibn Zaid
All that you quote is weak.
Sheikh uthman is wrong
Listen also sheikh uthman ❤ about Masturbation #zakir Naik
Dr zakir naik ❤
Where is the origin source?
Assalamualaikum brother
Brother have you watched the complete video ??
ask me about gusul
He is not scholar, the westernised Asian slaves of Social Services don't know Arabic and give fatwa without knowledge. To stop Ihtilam stop eating meat except in Eid or family celebration and you can eat fish once a week instead unless you work hard lifting or weight lifting un gyms 4 days a week that pushes you to bed straight away
Don't disrespect anyone. If you don't agree
Mufti uthman tried to enlighten you
akhi where's the source video link?
What do you mean?
@@Imdadmzbh this original video link do you have it? was it posted on dr zakir naik channel or? i couldn't find it there
@@whyayyyerrlaffinfhorr2152 it was Live session, and I screen recorded.
This video has not been uploaded yet in Dr zakir naik channel.
@@Imdadmzbh ok thanks, this is very helpful anyway
Very good answer
Sir aapko jo laga wo apne kaha
Allowing Haram.
Shame
youre an idiot. did you even watch the video?
Who said it's haram ? Allah or his Rasool ?
Bro lets see the hair on your palms......😅
👍
Best
plzz debate with uthman farooq...
No
Who's that ? 😂 He isn't in a place to debate with Zakir Naik plz
@@Safeeullahelhanhe actually is
bad low audio.
ruclips.net/video/6ZhZr9TW0tY/видео.html❤️❤️
Tolong terjemahkan dalam bahasa Indonesia
I agree with Dr Zakir Naik
How us your yankathon going?
42:32
☝️🤲💪
Very good Dr naik
ruclips.net/video/_nxoqjZg9Yk/видео.html
Zakir why run away from india? Alhaduilliahlah go debate christian prince
Are u stufid.
He is a big scholar of Islam and he is saying the right things
And he is saying both side views
He did just Hijrat which is sunnah in Islam ,bring your Christian scholar he is ready😂😂😂😂
manipulative. should stick to debate.
Not all of us can get married.
@@specialagentorange4329 not all of us will go to jannah
@@delightedadnan this is black and white thinking
This is what happens when u try to learn deen from dr’s , professors and engineers instead of muftis.
And who said a doctor can't be a scholar or a mufti ?
Aawaaz badha na re bhaiii 😡
Just imagine 19 years old man trying to hold it, planing to get marry after this coming ramadan. He never mastarubate or watched haram/ disgusting video. Someday he heard one of his favorite shikhs saying mastrubation is not haram. He started mastrurbating. He couldn't do it, so he decided to get "help" from haram/ disgusting video which he never watched before. After few weeks, he became addicted to mastrubation and haram/ disgusting video. He postponed his wedding. He started not praying salatul Fajr because he sleep the night time after he mastribate, and it's hard for him to wake up 5 am, take shower due to last night's mastrubation, then pray. Thanks to Dr Zakir!
Too bad that in Islam one has to listen to the "scholars" to know whether something like masturbation is haram or halal. Better to listen to one's conscience than the so called "Scholars." It appears one's conscience is more clear on what is haram and halal that Islamic "Scholars" who are totally confused (some saying it is haram, others halal, and others again, Makrooh.
In Christianity, what is haram and halal is black and white, clear as day. Masturbation is haram, period. To avoid Masturbation, and fornication in general, one ought to Marry. Period. This much more clear than the confusion in Islam on the matter.
@@robertokello5201 the confusion isn't with Islam, but with these so-called scholars who answer questions that are out of their depth and field.
@@robertokello5201 I gave a reply to you about the surah 5:5 contradiction you made and I still did not get a reply? You say that everything is black and white in the bible, can you explain that part that jesus even after his death paid for all of our sins? I wonder where the black is now? The black has been paid for by jesus right? This is according to your bible of contradictions, that has been changed throughout ages by your churches. Do you know that the demise of palestine and yemen is prophesied by our prophet. Look what's happening in the world now, palestine is taken off the map and a famine is happening in Yemen with almost 30 million deaths in the last 10 years. This is all prophesied 1400 years ago, robert stop beating around the bush and come inside it. The truth is infront of you, you know that you want to say yes, but it's hard to take that step. When you let go of bias and prejudice, I am sure you will find a place in islam.
@@khurramjaved7301 In part, Surah 5:5 says, "..and chaste women from among those who were given the Scripture before you..." "Those given the Scriptures before you" means the Jews and the Christians.
But Surah 5:51says, "O you who have believed, do not take the Jews and the Christians as allies (friends in other translations). They are [in fact] allies of one another. And whoever is an ally to them among you - then indeed, he is [one] of them."
So can you tell me why the Quran says Muslims should marry Jews and Christians and then say, that Muslims should not take them for Allies or friends? How can one marry some he cannot be friends or allies with? Does this contradiction make any sense to you?
Surah 4:82 says, "If it had been from [any] other than Allah , they would have found within it much contradiction."
The contradiction of Surah 5:5 by Surah 5:51, means that the Quran is not from God. And there are many more contradictions like this in the Quran. The Quran is a self-defeating mess! Indeed, it is a book of "revelations" given to an illiterate man. It appears that in the morning Muhammad had something written, changed his mind in the evening and had something contradicting the morning "revelation" written.
Read your Quran in a detailed a serious manner and you are learned in logic, you will too many of this contradictions. Talk to me when you have done that.
@@robertokello5201 Allah Subhanahu Wa Ta'ala said:
"This day [all] good foods have been made lawful, and the food of those who were given the Scripture is lawful for you and your food is lawful for them. And [lawful in marriage are] chaste women from among the believers and chaste women from among those who were given the Scripture before you, when you have given them their due compensation, desiring chastity, not unlawful sexual intercourse or taking [secret] lovers. And whoever denies the faith - his work has become worthless, and he, in the Hereafter, will be among the losers."
(QS. Al-Maaida 5: Verse 5)
Can you read the full verse properly mister illiterate. It says at the end "whoever denies the faith, his work has become worthless and he will hereafter be among the losers" meaning that whoever you are trying to marry has to accept islam and if he/she does not, than he/she will be among the losers. You send 75% of the verse and ignoring the other 25% shows that there was no contradiction. The other point you mentioned, it's talking about out prophets, who were given the scriptures such as Jesus, moses, and david. It is not talking about christians or jewish. Please use a little ounce of your symbolic illiterate brain. Can you find anymore contradictions? Cause you did not find any yet sir?