The first with Jimmy Brooks was so funny because when I took that horse,that NPC screamed “That’s my horse” and Arthur replied “Just borrowing it”.Before I delieveried the horse back I crashed into some rocks and the horse almost died.When that feller got it back he was so happy “you were just borrowing it friend.Thanks for bringing this old girl back to me”.But his old girl was almost dead.
Arthur is the best shooter/gunslinger in the game imo , and prolly strongest , look at how he beaten up that buffed bastard in valentine , look how he outdrawed the OGs of gunslinger , and in the showdown with micah , Arthur draws faster even at his worse condition (TB) .
@@professormetal4411 When playing as john in rdr 1 There was a red gauge and a blue gauge .in red dead revolver there were Red and yellow crosses. Arthur dosent have these while john,jack and red do .
@@Lupo32 yes I'm aware of that, I'm saying RDR2 is more realistic and better for it. You're either faster, or dead. There isn't any of this countdown or aiming time bs. Of course quick draw duels aren't realistic at all, the only fight we can historically verify that happened like a duel is Hickok and Tut's duel sometime in the... 1860s... iirc, and we can't confirm whether or not it was actually quick draw. Pretty much any other "duel" was fought where one opponent had a ridiculous advantage over the other, or you were just shot in the back. And going back to Hickoks duel it's likely that it wasn't a quick draw duel considering fast draw holsters (revolver with the trigger exposed) weren't even a thing until the early 20th century. Now I'm not at all complaining about the game, in fact as mentioned before I love this system, makes more sense. Life or death fights are a cheatin mans game.
Why? The guy deserved to die IMO, he would be just too dangerous to keep alive, also, he was looking for it, and did everything on his own, talked, escaped and fell to his death.
Omar personally I think the best is being scumbag slightly conflicted Arthur and once he realizes he’s dying he starts being better gradually on a quest for redemption and then ending with high honor. I think it’s beautiful
@@jacobleukus6930 Yeah its more sentimental the good honor story but in real would be bad honor if you think it, in every mission you killed like 50 people jaja
Àngel Wehr sometimes I’d think of that after a mission like “fuck man I know I’m honorable but I mean I did just slaughter a towns worth of people they couldn’t all be bad lol”
Revolver Ocelot there’s no repercussions now terms of the story with John so after I bought all the high honour stuff I just got max bounties in all the states
@@chris2217 Not every outlaw is a complete asshole. Charles is an outlaw but you don't see him going around bullying people. Hosea is an outlaw but you don't see him bullying people. I'm not saying outlaws are good people but not every outlaw is the embodiment of Micha either.
@@chris2217 I'm a pussy for not beating the shit out of and killing every innocent person I see? I killed people who deserved to die in the game. I let the guy that was trying to snitch in Valentine die too. Also Arthur isn't NEARLY as cold blooded as Micha. Micha killed innocent people, he constantly bullied everyone in the camp including Jack. Do you think it's realistic for Arthur to bully Jack? When Arthur had a kid himself at one point. Micha contributed nothing to the gang other than souring the gang's reputation even more. Sure Arthur can be cold blooded, but he is not even on the same level as Micha. The way I played Arthur was how I would be if I was an outlaw on the run. Kill any snitches and any person that deserves to die. You don't need to be an edgy middle schooler and say "oh I kill everyone because I'm hardcore." Don't judge people on how they play and I won't judge you. In my opinion, I just don't see Arthur as a psychopath.
I noticed in my first playthrough, I was looking at the documents I gathered in the game and I had the prospectus of Thomas Downes for the charity. I already felt bad for the guy, and knowing even though he was poor he was helping people broke my heart.
I never had that massive drop when I killed Jimmy Brooks in my bad play through. I think it was because I questioned him first as supposed to just killing him outright
Arthur was a bad person and didn't show compassion for people in chapter 1 to 4 When he knows that he is dying, finally tries to become a better person and starts his redemption
Red_Eye 99 Exactly, it’s called red dead *redemption* for a reason, he was a complete fuckin scumbag THEN turned into a better man. People wanna act lke he was always good.
@@mememachine5811 100% agreed. some retard wants to argue that arthur always had morals and all this other bullshit but in reality he didnt give a fuck about people outside the gang until his sickness struck
its so anticlimactic for you to play as this nice dude at the beginning of the game, only for arthur to fuck around with the downes family during that cutscene where he finally takes their debt money. he clearly doesnt give a shit about being a good man before he gets sick of tb
I disagree. If your redemption arc is inspired by one thing, it's weak. The arc started at the very ebginning, where Arthur heard about the girl on the train who Dutch killed for no apparent reason. He may be bad, but it's implied he's better now than he has been before. And he doesn't enjoy doing the things he does, if you read the diary entries he keeps. It's all about the gang. But slowly he begins to change. Seeing Micah's insanity makes him second guess himself. In Chapter 4 he has that whole beginning of goodness sidequest thing with the Nun and Brother Dworkins. He's against Dutch the whole way through Guarma. Even an evil Arthur realizes something is wrong om Guarma when he says "maybe we've all gone rotten" after Dutch kills that old lady. Getting TB wasn't what made Arthur good. It was the straw that broke the camel's back. He'd had all these thoughts of goodness before, but until this point the gang always came first. But now they don't. Now he realizes that his life has been nothing but a tool in Dutch's war against civilisation. That his death will be meaningless. To say Arthur turns good immediately after being evil for 20 years is horseshit
Yeah personally I don't like the Strauss missions because with the exception of the last 2 Arthur kinda has to be a dick leading his death, which doesn't make sense because by the time my Arthur started doing the Strauss missions he had a pretty consistent characterization of rushing to help people in need, donating to charity, being nice to everyone he passes on the street, and sparing people far worse than the tuberculosis guy. And it's not like my Arthur was an infallible paragon, he robbed quite a few rich people and shot more than a few armed guards just doing their jobs, but tormenting a some desperate sick man with TB who tries to get money for charity seems wildly out of character.
That ride back to the camp from the downes place...felt so depressing on my first playthrough especially me not knowing what would transpire in the end game 😔
I have a theory for the huge honor drop I think it dropped so much was because he never had any conversation about the situation and if you think about it Arthur never even questioned about killing this man since right as he was on the cliff he instantly stomped on his hands now if Arthur had the conversation you could say that he was questioning whether he should kill him or let him live
This reputation system is just here to choose which ending you get. Just play like you want. I believe this show something in humans, the ones that want to fit the perfect ideal and the roamers that just play with what they have in their hands
Dared I’ve completed this game before many of times, I’ve killed Jimmy brooks each time but I’ve always had dialogue before killing him which wasn’t such a big honor drop compared to just stomping on his hands right away without dialogue which demonstrated in this video had a ginormous drop in honor
TB aint got no cure in 1899 , its somewhere around 1930s or 1942 if iam not mistaken , TB is like aids but its affect ur lung not ur antibody back then .(cmiiw)
@Parker Hetzel They created medicine and food that can instantly heal bullet wounds, stimulants that effectively give horses more endurance, and potents that allow you to slow down time, but can't make a cure for a disease?
@Heroin Bob Arthur gets over 1000 bullets in his body and a shot gun in his stomache but he dies only because of TB. R* made a very bad choice to let Arthur die.
Overall honor system is amazing in my opinion just lacking more moral choices, i would like the next rdr will have that system + some of the plot choices like we had on gta iv but on rdr it will depends on and shape ur honor play style ..
@@jacrispy3275 Defending yourself or antagonizing people then defending yourself? Just a hint man:when a gangmember like lemoyn raiders shoot you first then shoot him but when a normal men with gun shoots you just go and knock him out and no bounty and loosing honor or let the lawmen kill him
I don't think so,because you can see him in a couple of weeks later in the mission "A Quiet Time" where Arthur and Lenny get drunk,you can see Tommy at a table and when you try to talk with him,he will speak retarded
@@1globaljosh591 Oh yeah I remember now,when you visit the gun store owner in Valentine a few days later after A quiet time,he will tell you that he died last night
Did anyone notice how Mr.Downes intentionally coughed straight into Arthur´s face? He didn´t want him leaving unscathed. What I don´t get is why Arthur, seeing that he´s sick, didn´t come wearing a bandana (as well as to hide his identity). Although the game doesn´t let you equip it because if not there would be no story.
I like to play as "in between" good and bad. I don't massacre people (except after I'm done with one of those Gambler challenges and save my game) and I help those in need (up to a point) but won't hesitate to kill a witness after a robbery if they don't stop like I tell them to (or they're too far away to lasso them.) After TB, I go full honor. After all, the game is called Redemption for a reason, and the story goes along great with it.
You all too soft. My eyes opened only after I started to understand the point of "evil". And this "goodness" isnt a right thing. The only thing is real bad is stupidity. But Arthur is not so smart, just angry. And his stupidity cost him his life. John got the same fate. Outlaw cannot live as general population. But no, he got in this woman's trap thing, as the most of us. And it ends badly.
That honor dropped harder than Dutch in rdr1
Silber Sterne lol
Bruh
@@prod_revo What, too soon?
@@incredibletyphoon4558 nono
@@prod_revo Then what
When you commit a crime
Honor: Goes back all they way to red
When you greet 50,000,000 people
Honor: Nah I think I'll stay
I remember I was greeting people in saint Denis and got wanted for disturbing the peace
I'll let him bully me.
Get a loan with strauss and don't repay him
Being bullied by chapter 1-4 Arthur seems like a terrifying experience but you do you.
_kinky._
0:48 am I the only one who said “Long live the king”?
You are evil man
@@wok3n203 stfu, you dead meme
0:48
"LONG LIVE THE KING!!!" 0:45
The first with Jimmy Brooks was so funny because when I took that horse,that NPC screamed “That’s my horse” and Arthur replied “Just borrowing it”.Before I delieveried the horse back I crashed into some rocks and the horse almost died.When that feller got it back he was so happy “you were just borrowing it friend.Thanks for bringing this old girl back to me”.But his old girl was almost dead.
The Thomas downes mission made me feel bad I didn’t wanna do it but I had to
I hated hurting the poor polish guy I felt SO bad for him
Is it me or is it that john actually
Has a showdown draw while Arthur
Just draws early ?
Yeah because in rdr1 it was a full on minigame
Arthur is the best shooter/gunslinger in the game imo , and prolly strongest , look at how he beaten up that buffed bastard in valentine , look how he outdrawed the OGs of gunslinger , and in the showdown with micah , Arthur draws faster even at his worse condition (TB) .
There's no such thing as drawing early, you're either the cheater, or dead.
@@professormetal4411
When playing as john in rdr 1
There was a red gauge and a blue gauge .in red dead revolver there were
Red and yellow crosses.
Arthur dosent have these while john,jack and red do .
@@Lupo32 yes I'm aware of that, I'm saying RDR2 is more realistic and better for it. You're either faster, or dead. There isn't any of this countdown or aiming time bs.
Of course quick draw duels aren't realistic at all, the only fight we can historically verify that happened like a duel is Hickok and Tut's duel sometime in the... 1860s... iirc, and we can't confirm whether or not it was actually quick draw. Pretty much any other "duel" was fought where one opponent had a ridiculous advantage over the other, or you were just shot in the back. And going back to Hickoks duel it's likely that it wasn't a quick draw duel considering fast draw holsters (revolver with the trigger exposed) weren't even a thing until the early 20th century.
Now I'm not at all complaining about the game, in fact as mentioned before I love this system, makes more sense. Life or death fights are a cheatin mans game.
0:49 the honour drop
Jesus I’ve never seen honor drop that much
The Downes one is the hardest because it’s what kills Morgan in the future
Friend: So...is Arthur a good man?
Me:Depends the way you play bro.
Me: punches thomas downes once
Thomas: dies
Jesus christ what was with the huge drop of honor with the first one
The Thomas downes guy gave Arthur tuberculosis 😔
This vid would take YEARS to how many kills arthur did
The honor dropped so much in the first one
JTGameZ
It's supposed to be a deciding point in the game
Why? The guy deserved to die IMO, he would be just too dangerous to keep alive, also, he was looking for it, and did everything on his own, talked, escaped and fell to his death.
Oliver Genz yeah I think that if it was any other of the gang members that went after him they would have killed him to.
I think the cool thing about it, is that it make the player decide. There is not right or wrong choice, it's just how you want to be.
@@olivergenz8877 except if you keep him alive the gang stays alive for a while
0:47 how a high honored player feels when they commits their first sin
@Albin Karlsson early game honor determines early game dialogue and cutscenes
Relatable
I’m doing evil play through and it’s harder
Bro legit
True
It hurts to see Arthur being a bad person I’m replaying the game as Asshole Arthur and it is hard
Omar personally I think the best is being scumbag slightly conflicted Arthur and once he realizes he’s dying he starts being better gradually on a quest for redemption and then ending with high honor. I think it’s beautiful
@@jacobleukus6930 the bad honor is cool too, more real
Àngel Wehr that’s the beauty of multiple play throughs
@@jacobleukus6930 Yeah its more sentimental the good honor story but in real would be bad honor if you think it, in every mission you killed like 50 people jaja
Àngel Wehr sometimes I’d think of that after a mission like “fuck man I know I’m honorable but I mean I did just slaughter a towns worth of people they couldn’t all be bad lol”
When I'm Arthur I am a total good boy but when I'm John I just release a total hellstorm of bad honor and boy it feels good
Same
ASIANBOY 95 literally 😭🤣
I tried going straight as John by selling what I got from hunting and fishing but that didn't last long.
Revolver Ocelot there’s no repercussions now terms of the story with John so after I bought all the high honour stuff I just got max bounties in all the states
I am a total bad guy as Arthur.. and after beat the chapter 6, im became a total good guy as John
2:17 this is where Arthur gets marked for death
CuttingEdgeGaming you know what is funny ?People have actually survived with TB without the vaccine
Nick Alex Cage 19 century fool
@Jim Pickens The game has been out for 2 years already
@@f.b.i3209 There are people who just got it on pc and is playing for first time. Not everyone plays on console.
@@JabPlayz-Gaming Rdr2 has been on pc for 4 months.
17:35 Redditors when they see someone playing literally any other game instead of Minecraft.
Vutch Dan Der Linde underrated comment
Or istagramers when they see someone playing other game instead of fortnite
@@munskachana4789 also ture
@@munskachana4789 found the redditor
@@latinospammer8441 found the instagrammer
11:19 he tried to Max Payne him
Exactly lol.
I love how Arthur killed his ass
He never did that with me
😂😂
holy crap he actually tried to
that huge honor drop jezz
Mr Donkeypants2 Dude its a glitch... it was never that High honor before so..
Madz yes i know that
Mr Donkeypants2 dropped like he did
No, it was only a glitch. That happened to me too
6:29 the only time that i thought inside me:Good job Micah
Γιαννης Γαλαν3ς I know
Επιτέλους ένα Έλληνας που παίζει Rdr2
@@mariakaliontzi6396 I said that shit out loud and my furniture started floating
That and when Micah and I were blasting through Strawberry like badasses. Other than those small moments, hate the man.
@@ScoutTrooperTK LMAOOOO🤣🤣🤣
Angry Chihuahuas 🅱️e like: 17:35
JAJAJAJAJA
Bruh true
I still have Jimmy Brook's pen
I just give it to the camp.
I sold it
Same.
Same
Mary-Beth requests it at some point I think 💭
17:30
*MY MAN WENT FROM 0 TO SMEAGOL/GOLUM FROM LORD OF THE RING REAL QUICK*
You got 69 likes
Scaring someone without hurting them is something I never knew that Arthur had that.
7:11 M.U.N.E.H
I want a 10 hour version of this
Just like EA
I was a good Arthur
You were a good boah
@Lynx _76 a outlaw is not supposed to be a littel fairy boy. He has to make the hard decisons like killing the gut at the begining
My honor was low at the end of the game but I still got the good honor ending
Twuffs same i spared everyone and always was helpful and friendly
Being good is boring
1:15 go crazy
17:35 go stupid
7:11 go Muneh
It’s so strange to see Arthur be so cruel and violent. I can never play with bad honor.
bruh the point of the game is to be an outlaw i go fucking bonkers with everyone
@@chris2217 Not every outlaw is a complete asshole. Charles is an outlaw but you don't see him going around bullying people. Hosea is an outlaw but you don't see him bullying people. I'm not saying outlaws are good people but not every outlaw is the embodiment of Micha either.
@@SmokeyGames420 arthur may not be as arrogant as micah but he is for damn sure just as cold blooded.
@@chris2217 I'm a pussy for not beating the shit out of and killing every innocent person I see? I killed people who deserved to die in the game. I let the guy that was trying to snitch in Valentine die too. Also Arthur isn't NEARLY as cold blooded as Micha. Micha killed innocent people, he constantly bullied everyone in the camp including Jack. Do you think it's realistic for Arthur to bully Jack? When Arthur had a kid himself at one point. Micha contributed nothing to the gang other than souring the gang's reputation even more. Sure Arthur can be cold blooded, but he is not even on the same level as Micha. The way I played Arthur was how I would be if I was an outlaw on the run. Kill any snitches and any person that deserves to die. You don't need to be an edgy middle schooler and say "oh I kill everyone because I'm hardcore." Don't judge people on how they play and I won't judge you. In my opinion, I just don't see Arthur as a psychopath.
Buttcheek Titties hope u know the good honor ending is most likely canon 😌
Replaying the game and noticing that the guy with tuberculosis even collects alms for the poor in valentine...
Oh shit
He’s also the one that stops Arthur from beating up the big guy Tommy? In Valentine. Who throws you out the window
I noticed in my first playthrough, I was looking at the documents I gathered in the game and I had the prospectus of Thomas Downes for the charity. I already felt bad for the guy, and knowing even though he was poor he was helping people broke my heart.
I mean, you don‘t have to kill Jimmy Brooks, Jean Marc or Anthony Foreman. That‘s the players choice, not Arthur‘s.
Anothony Foreman must be dead because he was threat ro gang
@@jasonvolkanov3123 No, you can let him leave and run off
@@jacobwilliams6980 I killed him anyway
@@jasonvolkanov3123 I had 3 playthroughs, midway through 4, I killed him once, let him live twice
Jason Volkanov I killed him too, but you don‘t have to kill him.
OK that is so unfair how you kill Jimmy Brooks and you gain like a lot of bad honor but when u help him u got a Tiny Tinsy little bit of good honor
AJ Stephens glitches
It’s not that much
He was already bad before
It happens when you replay a mission
My Business Partner HERRRRR Strauss
I never had that massive drop when I killed Jimmy Brooks in my bad play through. I think it was because I questioned him first as supposed to just killing him outright
It’s a glitch. He didn’t have that much honor in the first place
Arthur was a bad person and didn't show compassion for people in chapter 1 to 4
When he knows that he is dying, finally tries to become a better person and starts his redemption
Red_Eye 99 Exactly, it’s called red dead *redemption* for a reason, he was a complete fuckin scumbag THEN turned into a better man.
People wanna act lke he was always good.
@@mememachine5811 100% agreed. some retard wants to argue that arthur always had morals and all this other bullshit but in reality he didnt give a fuck about people outside the gang until his sickness struck
its so anticlimactic for you to play as this nice dude at the beginning of the game, only for arthur to fuck around with the downes family during that cutscene where he finally takes their debt money. he clearly doesnt give a shit about being a good man before he gets sick of tb
@@bluetapz9852 exactlyyy bro
I disagree. If your redemption arc is inspired by one thing, it's weak.
The arc started at the very ebginning, where Arthur heard about the girl on the train who Dutch killed for no apparent reason.
He may be bad, but it's implied he's better now than he has been before. And he doesn't enjoy doing the things he does, if you read the diary entries he keeps. It's all about the gang.
But slowly he begins to change. Seeing Micah's insanity makes him second guess himself.
In Chapter 4 he has that whole beginning of goodness sidequest thing with the Nun and Brother Dworkins.
He's against Dutch the whole way through Guarma.
Even an evil Arthur realizes something is wrong om Guarma when he says "maybe we've all gone rotten" after Dutch kills that old lady.
Getting TB wasn't what made Arthur good. It was the straw that broke the camel's back. He'd had all these thoughts of goodness before, but until this point the gang always came first.
But now they don't. Now he realizes that his life has been nothing but a tool in Dutch's war against civilisation. That his death will be meaningless.
To say Arthur turns good immediately after being evil for 20 years is horseshit
2:18 and that's where it all started to go down.
That one cough 😔
17:35 here's the reason the Valentine sheriff is my favorite sheriff.
he’s cheating on his wife though
@@beanprotein okay and...
@@KingFrog13. he killed an innocent women too...
He murdered his mistress . I kill that sheriff whenever I am causing mayhem in Valentine 😆
He murderd the woman he was with choked her to death and cheated on his wife
I hate low honor Arthur in my opinion Its an insult
Thank you everybody for likes
you got high honor greeting ppl
@@anthonypadilla1747 no I got high honor with helping people donating greeting and help camp
@@Psychic_Analyst in the words of aurther himself ahem "it's ok boyyy''
I disagree, i think it's meant to be the other way around. Arthur is supposed to be, and is a bad man, that's the whole point of his redemption arc.
Yeah personally I don't like the Strauss missions because with the exception of the last 2 Arthur kinda has to be a dick leading his death, which doesn't make sense because by the time my Arthur started doing the Strauss missions he had a pretty consistent characterization of rushing to help people in need, donating to charity, being nice to everyone he passes on the street, and sparing people far worse than the tuberculosis guy. And it's not like my Arthur was an infallible paragon, he robbed quite a few rich people and shot more than a few armed guards just doing their jobs, but tormenting a some desperate sick man with TB who tries to get money for charity seems wildly out of character.
*OUTTA THE DAMN WAY*
Ok boah
My business partner HAIR STRAUSS
The hair of Mr. Strauss is like Shrek's one
How do you not have when Arthur slaps the shit out of the broom boy during Mary Linton's second mission in Saint Denis?
Talk shit get hit
1:15 = Me trying to record videos with my phone
0:46 his honor dropped super low wow
That ride back to the camp from the downes place...felt so depressing on my first playthrough especially me not knowing what would transpire in the end game 😔
I felt so bad for mr Downes, he was so nice... I really didn’t want to hurt him😢
He killed Arthur in the end
18:35
Revolver: let me go in!
Holster: noo
Revolver: LET ME GO IN!
Holster: NO!
Holster: okay
I always felt bad for hurting Wrobel he sounds so innocent and scared
screw him i killed him
I didn’t hurt Thomas Downes I just slapped him when he tries to hit us with a rake and talked to him until the timer was up
Same but sum how he got bruises on his face im like "god i love game logic"
17:35 when u eat 7 gum at once
How it feels to chew 5 gum
stimulate your senses
14:23 ouch did anybody hear that
I have a theory for the huge honor drop I think it dropped so much was because he never had any conversation about the situation and if you think about it Arthur never even questioned about killing this man since right as he was on the cliff he instantly stomped on his hands now if Arthur had the conversation you could say that he was questioning whether he should kill him or let him live
This reputation system is just here to choose which ending you get. Just play like you want. I believe this show something in humans, the ones that want to fit the perfect ideal and the roamers that just play with what they have in their hands
Dared I’ve completed this game before many of times, I’ve killed Jimmy brooks each time but I’ve always had dialogue before killing him which wasn’t such a big honor drop compared to just stomping on his hands right away without dialogue which demonstrated in this video had a ginormous drop in honor
If Arthur Knew He would get TB because of 2:23 , could he have gone to the doctor sooner to get rid of it before it starts
Thatgamer pro97 what you think some doctor can go back in the future and cure him
TB aint got no cure in 1899 , its somewhere around 1930s or 1942 if iam not mistaken , TB is like aids but its affect ur lung not ur antibody back then .(cmiiw)
@Parker Hetzel They created medicine and food that can instantly heal bullet wounds, stimulants that effectively give horses more endurance, and potents that allow you to slow down time, but can't make a cure for a disease?
Bruh there was no cure for TB back in 1899, what are you even saying?
@Heroin Bob Arthur gets over 1000 bullets in his body and a shot gun in his stomache but he dies only because of TB. R* made a very bad choice to let Arthur die.
2:17 tuberculosis
I remember on that ride back to camp thinking "Arthur just contracted something..."
Overall honor system is amazing in my opinion just lacking more moral choices, i would like the next rdr will have that system + some of the plot choices like we had on gta iv but on rdr it will depends on and shape ur honor play style ..
Yes, losing honor for defending myself is just *peachy.*
@@jacrispy3275 Defending yourself or antagonizing people then defending yourself?
Just a hint man:when a gangmember like lemoyn raiders shoot you first then shoot him but when a normal men with gun shoots you just go and knock him out and no bounty and loosing honor or let the lawmen kill him
HOWDY FELLERS.
Howdy partner
Howdy.
Howdy to you as well sir
I read this in my head as Arthur lol
2:18 at this time Arthur contracts tuberculosis
this guy is Brazilian nobody fucking asked
Lynx _76 That wasn’t blood. It was Downes coughing into his face.
Lynx _76 you are so stupid look it up
@Lynx _76 You can get TB just from an infected person breathing on you.
Lynx _76 you just put a timestamp of him coughing on him and now you say no
0:47 When you're max honor and you accidentally run over someone on your horse
I killed the man from blackwater by accidnet i was like opps i meant to question him but i clicked B instad of X
2:18...
''Cowboys never die, they just ride off into the sunset''.❤️
You missed Tommy from the bar fight in Valentine, I believe he died a couple days later from brain damage.
I don't think so,because you can see him in a couple of weeks later in the mission "A Quiet Time" where Arthur and Lenny get drunk,you can see Tommy at a table and when you try to talk with him,he will speak retarded
Rob TZ after you meet someone who said he’s passed, I can’t remember exactly who.
@@1globaljosh591 Oh yeah I remember now,when you visit the gun store owner in Valentine a few days later after A quiet time,he will tell you that he died last night
@@1globaljosh591 Damn, I never even discovered that, I thought he would still be alive but just have aphasia.
Nobody:
Arthur's Honor at 0:47 : *Parkour!*
11:27 what mission is this?
0:40 "Teamwork begins with 2 people trusting each other."
0:47 "But you... you're no person."
Poor Mr Wróbel
MasterMisu i got so mad when he hit them all you can just be mean to them or not do them :/
@@skylar_nightzu8853 And....
Im from Poland
18:10 "No"
"YEEEEEEEEESSSS!!!"
😂
This video is supposed to be 3 hours long, you forgot about the people we antagonize
This has got to be a long list
All these people aren’t in the story mode? What side mission are these and can John do them as well❓🤔
Nayops 19 some of them John can do but none of the loan sharking missions.
I can't have a bad honor Arthur, he's better with good honor
Every single fucking time i see Thomas cough on Arthur I legit wanna break my monitor like Dellor broke that one keyboard...
I was a good boah at every possibility 😁 finished Arthur's story at near-perfect honor
Uhhh, this guy forgot the 1827271827 random strangers I shot graveyard dead XD
Arthur:i am unarmed
Also arthur:has a gun on his back
5:00 "Because otherwise, I'll be in New Haven"
Amazing and Intimidating...
On anthony foremen i stole his polka dot horse and named it dotta.
Did anyone notice how Mr.Downes intentionally coughed straight into Arthur´s face? He didn´t want him leaving unscathed. What I don´t get is why Arthur, seeing that he´s sick, didn´t come wearing a bandana (as well as to hide his identity). Although the game doesn´t let you equip it because if not there would be no story.
is when Arthur is infected with tuberculosis 2:18
Isnt that just a theory, he never SAID it was thomas
@@sbrw4316 - how the Hell else did he get it?
Mathew C. Guarma?
@@sbrw4316 Here's a quote from Arthur himself. "Got TB. I got it, for beating a man. For a few bucks."
It's from a conversation with Sister Calderón
U forgot the countless o’Driscolls Pinkertons and lymone raiders
The honor 0:49 my god.....
I like to play as "in between" good and bad. I don't massacre people (except after I'm done with one of those Gambler challenges and save my game) and I help those in need (up to a point) but won't hesitate to kill a witness after a robbery if they don't stop like I tell them to (or they're too far away to lasso them.)
After TB, I go full honor. After all, the game is called Redemption for a reason, and the story goes along great with it.
I like how you’re entire honor drops but if you save him then nothing happens
Rdr2 actually makes you feel bad for what you do to people, not like cyberpunk.
And GTA
Felt so bad going for the debt money from the guy with tb 😭
You all too soft. My eyes opened only after I started to understand the point of "evil". And this "goodness" isnt a right thing. The only thing is real bad is stupidity. But Arthur is not so smart, just angry. And his stupidity cost him his life. John got the same fate. Outlaw cannot live as general population. But no, he got in this woman's trap thing, as the most of us. And it ends badly.
So much for that pen the fella you killed have.
2:17
*Tuberculosis has entered the chat*
Arthur in the first scene: I just want to talk with him *Loads shotgun
I saved Jimmy Brooks and he gave me his pen infact I saved all of the ones I had the choice to do
My conscience hits me when I realize what I've been doing to these NPC's. I suddenly get pity on them when I watch this xD
6:56 Oooooh so that's why Germans hated polish in ww2
Reserve
I played the game the way it has to be, i started with bad honor, then when arthur got tb i started doing good things
I did the same except I shot up Van Horn 4 times before the final mission and I got the low honor ending
Poor Thomas Downes 🥺🥺
You feel sorry for the man that killed Arthur?
Morgan treeman well it was actually Strauss’ fault who made Arthur go beat up a man for money who got TB and gets infected with TB
I felt sad for him!
I hated that part! Poor old man :-(
Hugo Trejo I blame Strauss for doing his sh*tty money lending job
Mr. Mayhem yea it was Strauss but boy does Thomas make me angry, he’s the reason Arthur’s dead
You forgot when Arthur kills Cornel Henry Favours after Eagle Flies rescuers Arthur.
Why would you kill Jimmy Brooks?
Why not?
A Snitch, he did everything by himself, too risky too keep alive. Plus, you don't even shoot him, he just falls to his death like an idiot!
@@olivergenz8877 not if you save him
Misclick in my case
@Lynx _76 yes he does idiot
Read the title