Kong76 You can tell it takes a toll on Arthur, due to the fact that he was dying TB, and knew he was going to die, and this naive and poor kid sacrificed himself for a dying man.
It was foolish, but honorable. He really shouldn’t have, because both Arthur and Eagle Flies knew about the sickness. Either way, he did and it showed a symbol of how the Natives were not savages, but loving people that will literally give their life to help a dying person.
Arthur: “oh, we’re all gonna die Agent” Milton: “some of us sooner than others” Chilling part is Arthur is the one to get TB yet Milton died before Arthur did.The way fate gives us hints is insane
ClickTypeClick Ross wasn’t the one who said “some of us sooner then others”.... But we can still say Rockstar decided to hint fate with him as well as Ross says to young Jack “enjoy your fishing kid”.... years later Jack sees Ross once again, this time around, Ross is fishing by the lake as Jack shoots him down for Redemption for his Parents/fallen family(Gang)
ASYLUM-ONE man I died when my horse died ugh I kept the same horse he was American standard bread I think and had a red mane and tail and was tan with a white spot on his nose 😕
No he wasn't loyal. The gang was already fallen apart when they got Herr Strauss. Yet he still didn't tell anything to anyone which is better than loyalty. He could have just said everthing he knows and be done with it but he cared about those people.
I hated strauss throughout the whole game for preying on vulnerable people but my god I gained a lot of respect for him after finding out what happened to him in the end
Jade Allcott you make it sound like he forced those people to take the money. If you borrow something from someone you better be able to at least give it back.
MysteryGuy Y that was never confirmed John only suspected that, that was what happened we don’t actually know if dutch could or couldn’t have helped John it in the bank
Even if it is the low honor version that’s still super emotional it kinda makes it seem like he knows he’s a bad person so he doesn’t want people to waste time missing him
@@averythebirateking8347 I got the high honor ending in my game and i agree with you on this, he’s a bad man and he knows it, doesn’t want too many people grieving a dying, bad man
I didn’t like Kieran for Chapter 1-3 he was just really annoying to me but then I started to liek him more when he started actually talking to the gang and acting normal until.. well... everyone knows what happened to him
@@Joel_Lifts No one talks to him was because he was an O'Driscall in their eyes in Chapter 1-3, same as how everyone looked down on Sadie till she defended them at the end of 3 and again in the bayou when the Pinkertons came in force at the end of Chapter 5.
@@Joel_Lifts Well, Arthur, Sadie (at some point) and Mary-Beth talked to him alot in the end till the point of his death. Mary-Beth was even said to have liked him or at least he had fallen in love with Mary-Beth as she was the only one who fed him when he was tied up at Horseshoe Overlook and consulted him and even consoled him. They subsequently talked to him after he held his guns on the Pinkertons with the gang when they held up the gang at Horseshoe Overlook.
I honestly think #1 should be when Dutch shoots Micah and says nothing. Dutch was finally able to accept the mistakes he made during the game and act on it by killing Micah. Even though it took him 8 goddamn years after he knew Micah betrayed him, he punished him for it, accepted his mistakes, and saved John in the process.
YaBoy Shadow right? Like I do have some respect for Dutch cause of his decision to shoot Micah and fully believe it was because he realized Arthur was right and he wanted to Avenge his son but that doesn’t change the fact he is still utterly insane and goes on to kill many innocent people in the first game.
“One, two, three...” “Uh, Milliken is it?” “Uh, yes sir” “Can you count for me? I got talkin’ to do” “Uh yes sir of course sir...from one or four?” “Real funny, we must be at 11 by now.” Funnier than it should be lmao
i think arthur's sacrifice to save john should've been the #1 moment, he was loyal to what he thought mattered most and it brought his whole character arc to a great bittersweet end.
I dont think player choices should be counted, otherwise it would dominate the majority of videos such as these. It means more when Arthur or anybody else would make their own honorable choices without player influence
@@oceancactusrequiem6232 I've never understood why she had to kill Cleet. I know he was with Micah, but he tried to save a little girl and he quit from Micah's gang. It was so heartless and psychotic to kill him. Everytime she's doing a mission with you, she just think about killing and killing, even in that mission when you just have to go to the mail station and the grocery store, she wants to kill someone.
Sadie is a badass but Charles doesn't get enough credit for being a legend. He's against chaos, helps and defends the natives, fights clean, hunts clean, will ride with you no matter what and risks his life to make sure you escape Saint Denis. What a guy.
Da snake 19 Yeah, everyone knows that, he said that Jack met first when he was fishing and last when he was fishing, which he wasn't he was duck hunting.
Luke-Tyler Harington he did, at some point in the epilogue when you entered john house (roam) he will be in the living room with abigail. Then jack said “Arthur really saved us eh”
MidnightYT i don't know if he was actually loyal. Strauss last seen the gang at the last hide out up until ARTHUR kicked him out and the Pinkerton found the camp before getting to Strauss. Strauss probably died not knowing where the gang really were when they disbanded.
@@unclebuns5286 Thats the thing though, what if there were lingering agents. If Jack got caught in crossfire. There was no way to know. Very tough decision
@@bhagmachine9739 - he was hunting duck. Play the first game, then get back to me before you make an ass out of yourself. And tell me... How do you fish with a damn rifle?
Burt Macklin it wouldn’t have changed anything everything else those agents knew was documented and if they were killed someone else would have just taken there place
Lol the most disloyal dishonrable and cowardly act in the game at NR1! Yet next one of the most honrable and bravest Acts in the game. Its just sad to think that the person you regarded as family through the whole game betrayed you and a random guy who you met towards the end saved you!
@@kxuki1549 No need to be rude man. His comment makes it sound like he think it's Dutch's (i quote) "the most dishonorable and cowardly act in the game at NR1!"
@@thevideocommenter3061 I basically ment that both the most dishonerable and hoberable acts can both be found in Nr1 clip. Eagle Flys having the most honerable and Dutch the most dishonerable buy you would never see it coming at the beginning of the game.
There was no saving Arthur. All dutch could do was kill Micah right there but probably didn't cause Dutch's realization for his mistakes and lack of ability to think straight. The heat with the Pinkertons didn't help also
Charles is the best, no matter when during the story, he is the most respectful towards everything, he tries to do jobs without killing anyone, he helped out the Reservation as much as possible, hell he rarely used a gun. Charles would mostly use a Bow unless he absolutely needs to use a gun.
10:56 I like how Charle’s dialogue about Strauss got cut off too soon in this playthrough. He tries to talk about how he died nobly without squawking a word to the Pinkertons, despite getting kicked out from the gang by Arthur. But John interrupts and ends the conversation with a dismissive “okay,” as if talking about and being reminded of Strauss and his “beady little eyes” is not something of his interest at all 😂
been playing videogames for 15yrs, never played a mission in a game as satisfying as American Venom. There will never be another character like Arthur Morgan in videogames
I feel like after chapter 5 Arthur kinda had his own gang comprised of Sadie Charles John and his family because Arthur knew Dutch was going crazy and Arthur no longer felt like he knew Dutch no more
I think Dutch shooting Micah is number one,and I'll explain :3 Dutch Thought Arthur only stayed to kill the rest of them,betraying the camp,he didn't know who to believe Micah or Arthur,in the end,jhon says that Arthur SAVED HIM And You Know What Dutch always says? "Always look out for the gang" he finally realizes the terrible choice he did,and that Arthur was trying to save the only father figure he ever had and Dutch betrayed him,that's why after jhon says It Dutch doesn't say a word,he's heartbroken. 💔 Dutch already Let Arthur die for nothing,he wouldn't let Micah destroy the one thing Arthur gave his life for,plus we never see where goes on after that,maybe he went to say sorry one last time? (I got the help jhon get to his family ending)
I feel bad for dutch. When you rob the trolley station and the trolley crashes dutch suffered head trauma. Which would most likely caused him to go insane and since he got no treatment it only got worse. Somehow through all that he managed to come to his senses and kill micah. Thats my view on it.
Agreed the the reply above. Ross was Milton's assistant. Now that Milton dies, Ross takes the leadership and gets a new assistant who is seen in the Credits Cutscenes and RDR1.
All of charles' moments should be posted. This man is just an extremly loyal member of the gang, a loyal friend to Arthur and John and loyal to the native as well Amazing character
I respected Strauss in a way..I mean I respect that even though Arthur kicked him out, Strauss still stayed loyal to the gang and didn’t say a word even though he was tortured.
I just realized that the first time agent Ross meet jack was fishing and the last time they ever saw each other was when agent Ross was fishing and jack killed him
Loyalty meaning: Charles Smith
Shoar
True tbh
Apa no uncle
And lenny
And Sadie
"Look at this necklace I made for momma!"
"SHOORE"
Shoahh
@@MNSTRShams shoreeeeeee
I vaguely remember this
@@paulaleo1287 hey Jack
Suahh boah
Charles: "I heard they picked up Strauss... The agents, made a real mess of him, he died in custody, he never said a wo-"
John: "K"
Sprite Cranberry Nils is an aquired taste.. , “OK”
🤣
Sprite Cranberry no one cares about strauss
I didn’t really notice what an honourable act Strauss did either. Dang.
@@tanim.3578 Kept his mouth shut. He wasn't all bad.
Eagle flies giving his life for Arthur is so underrated, I'm glad that was no. 1
Me too
Chapter 6 is full of honorable acts with Arthur
Arthur definetly didn't want the kid to sacrifice himself for his life, he was dying anyways and arthur knew that
Kong76 You can tell it takes a toll on Arthur, due to the fact that he was dying TB, and knew he was going to die, and this naive and poor kid sacrificed himself for a dying man.
It was foolish, but honorable. He really shouldn’t have, because both Arthur and Eagle Flies knew about the sickness. Either way, he did and it showed a symbol of how the Natives were not savages, but loving people that will literally give their life to help a dying person.
Arthur: “oh, we’re all gonna die Agent”
Milton: “some of us sooner than others”
Chilling part is Arthur is the one to get TB yet Milton died before Arthur did.The way fate gives us hints is insane
Although Ross didn't die until the epilogue of the first game
ClickTypeClick Ross wasn’t the one who said “some of us sooner then others”....
But we can still say Rockstar decided to hint fate with him as well as Ross says to young Jack “enjoy your fishing kid”....
years later Jack sees Ross once again, this time around, Ross is fishing by the lake as Jack shoots him down for Redemption for his Parents/fallen family(Gang)
@@john-tobeymaguirecena yeah. I was just saying that Ross probably agreed with that statement
Jael H. Velez Ross was shooting ducks by the water. How does know one know that?! You obviously didn’t play the first game
Jael H. Velez although the TB end is canon, my Arthur was shot in the face
Jack first met agent Ross as a child , fishing , that’s iconic
then he last met him when Ross was fishing
parallels
Iconic, or ironic?
You mean ironic, right?
@@ye7170 duck hunting actually. Pay attention to the dialogue when you talk to his wife.
No he was fishing
I was emotionally ready for arthur to die. I was not at any time of day, emotionally ready for my horse to die.
ASYLUM-ONE agreed, when my horse died my heart just sank as i payed my final respects to my good horse friend
ASYLUM-ONE man I died when my horse died ugh I kept the same horse he was American standard bread I think and had a red mane and tail and was tan with a white spot on his nose 😕
The thank you he gave to the horse as it was dying messed me up.
I had to pause and cry
Yeah I emotionally prepared for Arthur but then when my horse died, I couldn’t handle Arthur’s death
Sadie and Charles man that’s all you need. I love it when he asks Charles will you ride with me and he replies yes. No questions just straight yes
That's how I roll. 😊
@@NoshirDalal holy shit you're real
@@Supernaturalsoup Haha so they tell me.
Mrs. Adler, Charles , Arthur and Jonh is perhaps the most honorable group in the history of videogames
@@rvss_0 Dont forget good Old Horsea... Everyone forgets him but he was always there. With his Heart and Mind :(
Leopald Strauss was a loyal person he had a chance to stay alive just to snake the gang and he didn’t
Loyal to the wrong way of life.
No he wasn't loyal. The gang was already fallen apart when they got Herr Strauss. Yet he still didn't tell anything to anyone which is better than loyalty. He could have just said everthing he knows and be done with it but he cared about those people.
I hated strauss throughout the whole game for preying on vulnerable people but my god I gained a lot of respect for him after finding out what happened to him in the end
I like but dislike Strauss in the same time I was so surprised when Charles told me
Jade Allcott you make it sound like he forced those people to take the money. If you borrow something from someone you better be able to at least give it back.
3:24 I just realized Arthur was just about to shoot them in the back but he didn’t because that would have traumatize Jack.
+1 Honorable point
He should've done it instead of being a coward. Who cares if it's in front of Jack it'll solve all their problems
@@tastycookiechip It will add more problems, even if they were dead, then new agents will track them down, with a bigger price on their heads.
@@meowmeow3778 They won't have a lead. Whereas Milton and Ross did
@@tastycookiechip i think this would be suspicious for other agents if Milton and Ross would be gone without any clue
Rip Van Winkle you kinda remind me of jim milton
Sadie 1907: “I’m fine, it ain’t nothing”
Sadie 1899: “I ain’t afraid of dying”
She really ain't afraid.
She got nothing to lose, that's why
She said she wasnt afraid of death in 1907 on her mission on Rhodes
dutch enters the cabin after so much time without energies*
abigail: DutCh tHEy HavE jOhn!!
Yeah she was like that to everyone who came back
But Dutch could have help John in the Saint Dennis Bank but he didn't
@@mysteryguyy5675 yeah but since john cant swim he would have died when the boat sunk so technically dutch saved john
@@dj_sugarboy9437 your lowkey spitting facts
MysteryGuy Y that was never confirmed John only suspected that, that was what happened we don’t actually know if dutch could or couldn’t have helped John it in the bank
When Tilly tried saying, “I’ll miss y-“
And Arthur cut her off to say, “no don’t” that hit on another level. That’s when I started to get emotional.
That was bad honor, Just watch the good honor, and you'll die emotionally
He says "Me too, sweetheart," in the good honour version.
I hate the low honour version, the high honour is miles better
Even if it is the low honor version that’s still super emotional it kinda makes it seem like he knows he’s a bad person so he doesn’t want people to waste time missing him
@@averythebirateking8347 I got the high honor ending in my game and i agree with you on this, he’s a bad man and he knows it, doesn’t want too many people grieving a dying, bad man
Damn Kieran was a good character, real shame what happened to him :(
I know, he didn't deserve it.
I didn’t like Kieran for Chapter 1-3 he was just really annoying to me but then I started to liek him more when he started actually talking to the gang and acting normal until.. well... everyone knows what happened to him
@@Joel_Lifts No one talks to him was because he was an O'Driscall in their eyes in Chapter 1-3, same as how everyone looked down on Sadie till she defended them at the end of 3 and again in the bayou when the Pinkertons came in force at the end of Chapter 5.
Jun Kitami yeah Ik that’s mainly why I disliked him was because they didn’t talk to him meaning he wouldn’t talk back to them
@@Joel_Lifts Well, Arthur, Sadie (at some point) and Mary-Beth talked to him alot in the end till the point of his death. Mary-Beth was even said to have liked him or at least he had fallen in love with Mary-Beth as she was the only one who fed him when he was tied up at Horseshoe Overlook and consulted him and even consoled him. They subsequently talked to him after he held his guns on the Pinkertons with the gang when they held up the gang at Horseshoe Overlook.
I honestly think #1 should be when Dutch shoots Micah and says nothing. Dutch was finally able to accept the mistakes he made during the game and act on it by killing Micah. Even though it took him 8 goddamn years after he knew Micah betrayed him, he punished him for it, accepted his mistakes, and saved John in the process.
@@triangle4549 Nahh Dutch shot you first! John Finished the Unfinished!
He did it so he would not get shot cause he a cowered
Have y’all forgot red dead 1 Dutch
YaBoy Shadow right? Like I do have some respect for Dutch cause of his decision to shoot Micah and fully believe it was because he realized Arthur was right and he wanted to Avenge his son but that doesn’t change the fact he is still utterly insane and goes on to kill many innocent people in the first game.
Dutch was going to kill him dosent matter john was there or not he was for micah just to kill him dutch says the same as you I suspposed .
Definition of loyalty: Charles Smith
Red Dead Redemption Tips and Tricks Stealed comment
Stealed comment
Why do you kepp forgetting qbout sadie adler too
Alex Torres.
Yes it’s almost as if I was repeating the comment above mine as a joke. You spineless horse.
Guys it’s a stealed comment.
“One, two, three...”
“Uh, Milliken is it?”
“Uh, yes sir”
“Can you count for me? I got talkin’ to do”
“Uh yes sir of course sir...from one or four?”
“Real funny, we must be at 11 by now.”
Funnier than it should be lmao
I shot him dead right after
he was shot like hosea
He was so nice tho
It went from 0 to 100 real fast for me xD
I was laughing and the second after I felt horrible when the guy started crying
Who are they?
No one to worry about!
12 years later Jack kills Ross
15 years*
Jack's epilogue takes place in 1914.
fuzzy apple pie I just realised that jack kills agent Ross the year that WW1 started that kinda feels weird now that I realise that
1# should have been Arthur and John's last moments together
MilanS agree
MilanS nah that is 2 cuz eagle flies sacrifice for arthur was more iconic cuz if he didn’t did that, Arthur would’ve died right there
Clone Trooper 501st Legion yea agreed
Yeah eagle flies sacrifice is very important
@@Devdanz I agree, it really shows how Dutch only cared about exploiting Natives by the time RDR1 happens. Brilliant way to fill in the gaps 💯
They are loyal and brave because they had *FAITH* in Dutch
thats the point XD
@@JoseMora-wc5zz it's a joke
Dutch didn't have faith in them it seems
@@geraltofrivia160 Dutch was too arrogant for that
Man I hated when Kieran died, he saved Arthur’s life and was always nice to the gang members but was treated poorly...
i think arthur's sacrifice to save john should've been the #1 moment, he was loyal to what he thought mattered most and it brought his whole character arc to a great bittersweet end.
give me food pls he wasn’t sacrificing anything, he was practically dead already, he just bought John extra time
Thank God I got the good ending where he is looking at the sunset realizing that he had won
Patrick Gracias which is called sacrificing
@@patrickgracias5782 he saved John. He was the reason John lived. He died because of his mistakes
I dont think player choices should be counted, otherwise it would dominate the majority of videos such as these. It means more when Arthur or anybody else would make their own honorable choices without player influence
Sadie and charles: exist
EVERYONE LIKED THAT
Sadie was really annoying tho, and her missions during the epilogue were really boring.
@@evangelicae_rationis K
@@evangelicae_rationis ok
@@evangelicae_rationis It's really concerning how everyone seems to just turn a blind eye to Sadie. She's a shit person
@@oceancactusrequiem6232 I've never understood why she had to kill Cleet. I know he was with Micah, but he tried to save a little girl and he quit from Micah's gang. It was so heartless and psychotic to kill him. Everytime she's doing a mission with you, she just think about killing and killing, even in that mission when you just have to go to the mail station and the grocery store, she wants to kill someone.
TF you got Arthur wearing?
flexing mexican My thoughts exactly
Default outfit?
Elias IA the hat
A Trilby Hat
This whole video on loyalty and your question is about fashion?
Nice. 😂👌
Sadie is a badass but Charles doesn't get enough credit for being a legend. He's against chaos, helps and defends the natives, fights clean, hunts clean, will ride with you no matter what and risks his life to make sure you escape Saint Denis. What a guy.
“We got one!
*A WHITE ONE!”*
I am white, but somehow, I was insulted when those soldiers said that.
@@meowmeow3778 how
@@meowmeow3778 Oh...
Leo Limited Edition racism 💯
@@paigegrew5680 lol yeah
When ross said "enjoy your fishing kid" its forshadowing when jack kills ross while he is fishing
Preston Garvey Duck Hunting, not fishing.
I hate that this fucking mistskes keep going
Preston Garvey CAN I FUCKING TAKE THE CASTLE?! DON’T DARE YOU GIVE ME ANOTHER SETTLEMENT MISSION!
Congratulations #9394949606 to point this out
Da snake 19 Yeah, everyone knows that, he said that Jack met first when he was fishing and last when he was fishing, which he wasn't he was duck hunting.
1:08 he got up so fast
LOL he’d have to be he’s a outlaw
@@eldawg124 No duh
Hacaii's Notorius outlaw 6597 shut up
@@eldawg124 ok
What an irrelevant comment.
I wonder if Jack remembered this all those years later
He did,jack mentioned it in the epilogue
Luke-Tyler Harington he did, at some point in the epilogue when you entered john house (roam) he will be in the living room with abigail. Then jack said “Arthur really saved us eh”
Not all of it but most of it
Jack remembered the fishing trip.
He didn't remember Angelo Bronte
Leopold Strauss is one of the most loyal character , [Spoil] he said nothing to the pinkerton, even when he got beat to death
MidnightYT woah he gets beat to death, I never heard about that part
MidnightYT i don't know if he was actually loyal. Strauss last seen the gang at the last hide out up until ARTHUR kicked him out and the Pinkerton found the camp before getting to Strauss. Strauss probably died not knowing where the gang really were when they disbanded.
Strauss is the reason why Arthur got tb he's an asshole in my opinion
@@FBI-mg5qb It wasn't, he just wanted to help the gang even if it was loansharking, do you expect him to know that the guy who loaned from him has TB?
@@meowmeow3778 well yes because why wouldn't you know if your customer has tb when you give him alot of money
3:25 Arthur was supposed to kill milton and ross but because he was responsible for Jack he didnt do it
Rodrigo Duterte I wish he could’ve told jack to hide behind a rock and ignore the gunshots just like John did in the epilogue
But he still got traumatized at the age of 12 just think about him at 4 although he hated gunslinging till 16
@@unclebuns5286 Thats the thing though, what if there were lingering agents. If Jack got caught in crossfire. There was no way to know. Very tough decision
@@shrimpshramp you’ve got a point there
you can just hear the pain in his voice saying dutch at 9:52
I like how the dude arthur takes hostage when trying to break john out is also in the start of rdr online
Trends Best same with that Milton guys at the horse fence
When everyone forgets that Ross was DUCK HUNTING when Jack came to kill him.
Fishing.....
@@bhagmachine9739 - he was hunting duck. Play the first game, then get back to me before you make an ass out of yourself. And tell me... How do you fish with a damn rifle?
Mathew C. Accurately
@@GrassPokeKing - true... But you know what I was getting at.
Seriously that pisses me off everytime someone says that.
Shot during gameplay: 👌😃👍
Shot during cutscene: *FRICCCIN*
*D*
*E*
*D*
Dude so true
Except for lenny
Dutch: "What Do you want agent moron"
Agent Milton: DeStRoYeD
Damn I loved Eagle Flies, such a fearless young fool
He did have his father's sense of nobility. Eagle Flies was young and extremely pissed off at the treatment of his people.
Not enough love for Arthur's horse passing and just that little "thank you". Neverending story vibes.
3:25 you can see Arthur is about to reach for how gun but he realizes Jack was there so he didn’t.
I did t notice that! Arthur would've killed them..
He should’ve. Pieces of shit. We could’ve preserved Hosea and Lenny.
Burt Macklin it wouldn’t have changed anything everything else those agents knew was documented and if they were killed someone else would have just taken there place
Haven’t watched video but eagle flies sacrificing himself, Arthur sacrificing himself and Dutch killing Micah should all be on here
Loyalty:meaning charles sadie lenny arthur ❤️
Gfh Jff don’t forget eagle flies
Hosea
Arthur was more loyal toward Hosea than Dutch(When Hosea has a plan no question he accept) and (when dutch has a plan x to doubt)
Uncle?
Lol the most disloyal dishonrable and cowardly act in the game at NR1! Yet next one of the most honrable and bravest Acts in the game. Its just sad to think that the person you regarded as family through the whole game betrayed you and a random guy who you met towards the end saved you!
The number one spot goes to Eagle Flies dude. Not Dutch calm down.
TheVideo Commenter that's what he said idiot
@@kxuki1549 No need to be rude man. His comment makes it sound like he think it's Dutch's (i quote) "the most dishonorable and cowardly act in the game at NR1!"
@@thevideocommenter3061 I basically ment that both the most dishonerable and hoberable acts can both be found in Nr1 clip. Eagle Flys having the most honerable and Dutch the most dishonerable buy you would never see it coming at the beginning of the game.
@@Ziolek.2000 yup I get that now but the other guy's rudeness wasn't necessearry.
Milton: Five thousand for your head alone
Arthur: Wow, can I turn myself in
❤️😂😂
I got some jellybeans you want some jellybeans ?
@@NyctoPhobia197 can I pay in jellybeans?
I rarely see people talk about how dutch just left arthur to die when that happened I lost all respect for dutch and not even the ending helped
There was no saving Arthur. All dutch could do was kill Micah right there but probably didn't cause Dutch's realization for his mistakes and lack of ability to think straight. The heat with the Pinkertons didn't help also
『DJ Thanos』 He means at the oil factory. He saw Arthur in trouble and walked out the door
@@Alessandro-vl8bu oh that, then I didn't understand right, Dutch left people to die once too many times
@@Alessandro-vl8bu yeah bro that broke my faith to dutch after watching that cutscene.
I didn’t know agent Milton had hair
WATCHU TRYING TO SAY BOAH?!?!
Arthur Morgan is it really you boah
You’re a good man Arthur
Ross:enjoy your fishing while you still can
Jack:kills ross while he was fishing
Me:killed by irony
He was duck hunting not fishing
@@buckybuu5367 what?
Geralt of Rivia Ross was hunting for ducks not fishing but none the less they first met by a river and the last time they would meet was by a river
The irony.
Geralt of Rivia Fishing with a shotgun 🤦
Charles is the best, no matter when during the story, he is the most respectful towards everything, he tries to do jobs without killing anyone, he helped out the Reservation as much as possible, hell he rarely used a gun. Charles would mostly use a Bow unless he absolutely needs to use a gun.
1:50
Arthur: i got some jellybeans
you like jelly beans
The fact that strauss died, not ratting out the vander linde gang even though arthur made him leave was pure loyalty.
I love how Strauss got kicked out of the gang by Arthur and still never said anything to the Pinkertons
9:10
MICAH WAS ABOUT TO SHOOT TILLY ON PURPOSE, AND POSSIBLY JACK TOO
That's just how he stops his horse, he holds it up so high he chokes it, the gun is an npc glitch
@@theresarayner5726, ok. Thx
10:56 I like how Charle’s dialogue about Strauss got cut off too soon in this playthrough. He tries to talk about how he died nobly without squawking a word to the Pinkertons, despite getting kicked out from the gang by Arthur. But John interrupts and ends the conversation with a dismissive “okay,” as if talking about and being reminded of Strauss and his “beady little eyes” is not something of his interest at all 😂
4:57 when Arthur says "I said don't thank me" is one of my favorite moments. Glad that made it on here.
Definition of loyalty, bravery and honour: Sadie Adler, John Marston and Charles Smith
Charles Smith was my personal favorite. Every chance you have to do a mission with him was cool
Charles Smith is the definition of Loyalty
I like how Arthur was gonna shoot Milton and Ross, but then remembers that jack was there
"You enjoy being a rich mans toy do yah"!!!- Arthur Morgan
been playing videogames for 15yrs, never played a mission in a game as satisfying as American Venom. There will never be another character like Arthur Morgan in videogames
9:09 that scene is just sad you can hear arthue voice of pain
arthur was so pissed he attempted to reach his gun, love the detail.
I feel like after chapter 5 Arthur kinda had his own gang comprised of Sadie Charles John and his family because Arthur knew Dutch was going crazy and Arthur no longer felt like he knew Dutch no more
4:02 I know that was really cool, but I can't help but imagine how amazing it would have been if Charles went to Guarma too
I think Dutch shooting Micah is number one,and I'll explain :3
Dutch Thought Arthur only stayed to kill the rest of them,betraying the camp,he didn't know who to believe Micah or Arthur,in the end,jhon says that Arthur SAVED HIM And You Know What Dutch always says? "Always look out for the gang" he finally realizes the terrible choice he did,and that Arthur was trying to save the only father figure he ever had and Dutch betrayed him,that's why after jhon says It Dutch doesn't say a word,he's heartbroken. 💔 Dutch already Let Arthur die for nothing,he wouldn't let Micah destroy the one thing Arthur gave his life for,plus we never see where goes on after that,maybe he went to say sorry one last time? (I got the help jhon get to his family ending)
I feel bad for dutch. When you rob the trolley station and the trolley crashes dutch suffered head trauma. Which would most likely caused him to go insane and since he got no treatment it only got worse. Somehow through all that he managed to come to his senses and kill micah. Thats my view on it.
I feel like this doesn't explain the way Dutch is in the first game
Blitz_ Lightning_ your right since the first game happened before the 2nd one right?
@@Holloesoulz that’s nonsense.
“Ms. Adler..... You ride with me” with the music in the background ramping up was so powerful
I can’t believe it took 15 years to finally kill Agent Ross but it took Milton a couple Weeks
That’s cuz Ross didn’t do much until RDR1 that’s when he actually did stuff so it was more like a few years not 15
Agreed the the reply above.
Ross was Milton's assistant.
Now that Milton dies, Ross takes the leadership and gets a new assistant who is seen in the Credits Cutscenes and RDR1.
Edgar Ross to Jack Marston: Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can.
*15 years later*
Jack: No u
All of charles' moments should be posted.
This man is just an extremly loyal member of the gang, a loyal friend to Arthur and John and loyal to the native as well
Amazing character
Charles would be my favorite character of all time but then hosea came and now he’s my second favorite
Jack sure enjoyed his fishing. Fishing out Edgar Ross's corpse in the river decades later
6:28 I like how Kieran first acts scared then explains his argument like a kid which wants to prove it did nothing wrong 😂
Chapter 2 was the best
Charles and Sadie were so good to Arthur
Tbh.
When Micah said "Abigail without John is just bait" I kinda agreed lmao
Well then you are lost
"You count, I've got some talking to do"
"From 1 or 4"...
"Very funny, we must be on at least 11 by now".
Best diagolue EVER.
The least honorable thing here is you not wearing Arthur’s hat in the second clip,
THANK YOU. totally fing ridiculous.
Uncle owning up to having lumbago was the bravest act
Says most honorable: in the mission Red Dead Redemption, where you save Abigail has low honor. wow
zuz he ment saving Abigail was honorable
3:24
Jack:shuts his mouth
Arthur:shoots both of em
Game:ends happily
Most honorable moments ranked
“Show Arthur threatening a young cops life and letting him count the seconds”
But he let him go.
Yeah he let him go
He only did that so he could help John escape which is honourable especially when he let the guy go when he didn’t have to
" He let him go "
Not for me! Shot the bastard as he was hollering away!
Dutch and Company return from Guarma and the first thing Abigail says is that they got John? Wow.
Thank you Mr. Morgan
I SAID DONT THANK ME.
Chapter 6 makes me cry the whole damn chapter. Only at the end does Arthur finally understand. Best game ever.
"Enjoy ur fishing kid" wow weird how he gets shot fishing years after
Duck hunting
" Quack quack "
the last few 5 or so missions were so depressing
3:20 dIdnt notice till now but is very much Karma to the end of the first game.
I respected Strauss in a way..I mean I respect that even though Arthur kicked him out, Strauss still stayed loyal to the gang and didn’t say a word even though he was tortured.
Molly was actually pretty Brave to sacrifice herself by saying she was the rat....
@@Harry-tm9pn to make Dutch feel bad by making him feel betrayed as a revenge on Dutch
She was drunk.
@@eddie2913 if you asked Karen she would disagree. She thinks drunk is when you litteraly fall in coma
Every time I see the scene where Ross makes that comment to jack, so have to go back and watch Ross’ death scene in RDR1
Small channel good content👌🏼👌🏼
Charles:Never said a-
John:okay
I’m happy Arthur didn’t shoot Milliken
Why would he
Ring-A-Ding-Ding Benny When he ran in the gate I shot him and lost some honour
@@conmanreloaded4249 lol that's prob because you used him and as SpongeBob says, "That's not nice."
The Chosen Moose I immediately let myself be killed so he checkpoint would reload and he’d still be alive
Dude. I saw sadie shoot him in the back, he fell down but survived
When my Tennessee Walker died I cried so much I used him ever since the first mission
What about Javier and Arthur rescuing John?
Arthur: Just take the money, don't thank me
Archie- Thank you Mr Morgan
Did Micah disliked?
Truffle-mushroom squad apparently Micah, Colm and Gavin disliked...
I just realized that the first time agent Ross meet jack was fishing and the last time they ever saw each other was when agent Ross was fishing and jack killed him
Hunting.
1:07 most loyal
Arthur's sarcasm waa one of the best things in this game 😂