it's SO funny dude. like this guy tried so hard to get some realism for his minecraft horror video and just ended up getting his posts removed for being stupid
46:50 ngl it made me realize something about the herobrine creepypasta, people usually depict herobrine as this super powerful evil entity who wants to kill you, but in the original herobrine creepypasta herobrine never really does anything malicious, he really is only there in the world.. existing... a ghost running aimlessly in a empty world doing things with seemingly no rhyme or reason.
I befriended him, and now he helps me build and mine and whatnot. Really cool dude, it sucks that he gets such a bad wrap for no reason. Really just a gigachad minecraft buddy.
@@RoseWitchMaple jokes aside, that would be a really cool mod. Have Herobrine run around your world doing his thing, you can befriend him and then you can tell him to tag along on your spelunking, much like an Elder Scrolls/Fallout companion.
The little hints that David is used to playing modern versions of minecraft, like right clicking to equip armor or dragging items really add to this. He hasnt been playing beta for the past 10 years, refusing to play newer versions, he _chose_ to go back to beta. Maybe he wanted the simplicity of the old versions, maybe he was just nostalgic. This is reaching a bit, but I think something happened to David, something that made him turn to this old, nostalgic, _comforting_ version of minecraft. But then things start getting weirder and weirder, and he becomes more and more paranoid. You could read it as a metaphor, the anxieties of life seeping in to places we used to find comfort in, until it hits a breaking point. Deleting the world at the end felt really sad, something he put time and effort in to, something peaceful in his life, gone forever.
The reddit post is the most realistic thing. I once asked for a datapack or something to increase netherite spawn just to have an easier time and i get people hardcore arguing 'just cheat it in if you dont wanna play the game' with mass downvotes or whatever. Some suggesting it in the 'its singleplayer it doesnt matter lol' way when i just wanted the server with my friends to be more casual.
Dang, man. People really just kick others for no reason. I don't think there's a "Right" way to play minecraft, and a datapack is literally just a tiny mod to make things easier.
Never, ever use Reddit unless it’s for technical troubleshooting and there’s already a thread for it. Only thing it’s good for. Personal experience there
The biggest thing for me that added to the realism: he didn't scream or anything when he was jumpscared or came across something unexplainable. Just a sharp nose inhale. That's exactly how the vast majority of people playing alone would respond.
Exactly! When I play any game and get startled or scared by something, I don’t go: “AHH!!!” Instead I jump or flinch a little and do a sharp inhale. Well, except for those times when I get *really* scared lol
@@troneysauce that video was genuinely one of the best and most-indepth research I've ever seen, on any topic. that forum poster was the true hero for having all those files, but you did an incredible job
i only caught this because someone mentioned it in the comments,but i absolutely love that the sign changes to say goodbye in the final shot, makes me think the entity that did this (possibly mc itself like you said) is almost a bit smug, cause theres no way that our protag could have seen that, it just seems a lil unessacary, but also theres the more wholesome interpretation of this going along with what you said as this being beta mc saying goodbye to david, and being happy that it can finally rest
the next video will be: "A strange youtube video i did not build" Jokes aside, excellent video, as always. I'll only be able to finish it tomorrow actually, but it's still amazing to see the quality you put into your videos.
I like how his paranoia is seen with how much armor he equips as it goes on. Going from a calm completely chill player to completely and utterly on edge.
The reason this video is great is because its a scary story IN Minecraft and is not using a Minecraft to tell a story. It works because it uses what makes Minecraft unnerving and the fears we might've had while playing, especially during the old versions.
What stood out to me watching the video was that the village used a lot of mossy cobblestone. In earlier versions, that stuff was super rare to come by, because you'd only find it on the floor of dungeons. So someone just building a whole village with mossy cobblestone isn't something that's actually going to happen, and you only have that block in naturally generated structures.
you hit the nail on the head on why i like this video so much. its not just that the playing/acting is so human, but also because everything about it is so relatable to a beta player. getting startled by skeleton arrows and calm4, getting lost in the labyrinthian cave generation, or going out in the world desperately trying to find clay, its all stuff anyone who has played old minecraft has experienced before. its so clearly full of love towards the golden age community as well, like the dialko video or the ONE helpful person in the reddit threads being called "themastercarver" lmao. it all just makes the experience feel so raw and real.
I was pondering weather to watch this since ive already seen "The last beta player", but then I realised its your channel so I stayed. And out of topic, YOUR PICTURES AND ART IS AMAZING HOLY SHIT???? THATS SO COOL
I had no idea it was unconfirmed whether or not calm4 would play in minecraft? I swear I heard it in game myself once. As is the general consensus, it scared the shit out of me
i believe it was almost definitely in the game at some point, but the way that sound resources were downloaded rather than stored in version files, plus the lack of credible videos of it playing means its technically not 100% proven.
I scare very easily but I was able to sit through this whole video :) I appreciate that you didnt put scary music or sounds or anything in the background (yes thats how easy i scare 😅), it makes it so much nicer for me, I loved the strange house i did not build videos too! Ive watched them like 4 times each lol Loved the video 💙💙💙
The use of Calm4 in the cave was brilliant. It's such a weird, off-putting track on its own, but in this situation? It's an escape sequence track, and it's perfect for it. It's more energetic than the normal backing tracks, and in this situation, more frantic. 10/10
Great video! And great movie as well, it's so refreshing to see a creepy minecraft ARG not immediately destroy all suspension of disbelief by introducing some "admin dimension" or shadow entities or whatever. It really keeps riding the line of "oh well this could be some weird data corruption" (strange torch I did not break, strange calm4 i did not play). Andhaving a live cam of the player as well keeps it grounded nicely. Sometimes in some ARGs it feels like the creators forget that minecraft is a game and act like they are embodying their player character directly and minecraft is real life. Here the acting makes it feel super believable as just some guy trying to play old mc and being spooked but also intrigued by the weird stuff he sees I hope you make more videos of the kind because the way you present info is rly neat (Shoutout to the section at 30:50) and it seems u have a good eye for non-slop mc horror 🙏
I hate the "Minecraft is real life and you realize you're in a simulation" trope there's always some players named like VORT101 and VORT102 and then VORT403 and so on with pitch black skins just stalking you and then all of a sudden you cross an acacia door and you're in the VORTEX admin dimension or whatever (btw if anyone wanna do this go ahead lmao) it's so overdone, seeing something like the one on the video is very refreshing
This is EXACTLY my thought. Having the IRL cam and showing him going on Reddit really sold it for me. With other ARGs that are about shadow entities and weird admin dimensions with souls getting trapped in the game and such it really destroys my suspension of disbelief cause I think "Wait... so this kid just goes to school, has dinner with his family, then logs onto minecraft to stop these world-ending entities... and then just turns off the computer and goes to bed???" Like you said, it's more believable here since it's just "weird corruption, anyone know why this happened?"
The Last Beta Player made me feel like so nostalgic. I remember playing like that, and everyone had stories of weird things happening to their worlds. You are awesome. I hope you go back and find old, ancient, or defunct Minecraft ARGs or mystery videos such as Strange House and just pour some analytics into them. The beating your head against the wall investigation was so nice and relaxing, along with your somewhat random chatting with your friend. I kinda wish they had been in this video as well, but I have no clue how that would have worked.
Can we talk on how he never had any wood with him? It's such a trauma for me that I have at least a half stack of logs in my inventory, this guy is not ok. Love your vids, please continue, I'm really happy for ytb algorithm recommending you.
You are probably my favorite minecraft guy, you just sound so genuinely interested in what you talk about and I love it, already waiting for the next vid
I found you the DAY you posted your first video with like 500 views. and holy shit dude your ability to tell a story is crazy and so captivating. I literally watch your videos 4-5 times just to get the entire thing.
Okay, that dark cave chase was awesome. Very tense, the low light and everything. Good stuff. And nice narration too, I like the tone and cadence. 👍 Agreed on the down to earth writing of this show, it feels more real than some of the crazy super sized conspiracies with cabals of shadow people and what not.
I’m glad I have your analysis of this. I completely missed all the footsteps and stuff, and was quite confused what had him so scared when he ran away from his base, and I even missed LITERALLY EVERYTHING except the ice breaking in David’s cobblestone hut on the ice.
Reminds me of AndrewGaming's arg, where Andrew himself doesn't want to face the change of the game, reminising about his time playing Halo with his friend Chris, even the colour pallet of the arg is this kind of bloomy and saturated shader that makes it look like OG Minecraft. His ARG is nowhere near the authentic feel of this one, it's actually a polar opposite as it has different characters, acting, structures that you cannot argue in any way shape or form are genarated naturally by the game, spooky stuff going on, and ghosts of the past reaching out to him, but it's still immensely well-made and enjoyable. Then there was this one that later on turns out the guy who is covering the ARG is part of it himself as a last-minute twist. All in all, you are absolutely right, when an arg is made with passion and love for both the horror genre and the game it takes place in it's a thoroughly enjoyable experience.
Not only is the video so good, but the way you analyze the video made me captivated to watch it all the way through even after eating my dinner. I literally forgot to clean my dishes while watching this video for more than 30 minutes. This analysis video is so simple (in how it's edited) yet i really liked the way you narrate it. It's not like one of those ARG analysis videos where i can literally predict each words the narrator would say because not only does minecraft ARGs been so cliche, but also the videos analyzing them too.
Woah! I watched your first video for the first time just yesterday, and watched your second video this afternoon, and I was sitting here thinking "I wonder if this guy went on to make more videos", and AN HOUR LATER, you upload another video. Excellent channel and content, please keep making more.
I recommend a minecraft arg parody series by Oneshef. It's very good and funny. Its called something like "minecraft arg but the protagonist is tired" There are multiple videos in the universe, and i recommend all of them. They are all so good, and he needs more recognition
there’s no point in looking in to them if it is just compiled funny clips and no lore, I agree they are very funny but the videos just speak for themselves
i think the series's status as a parody enhances the bits of horror in there, too; the parts with hungry and souler wouldn't be nearly as scary (and would honestly be. not scary at all lmao) if the majority of the series wasn't satire. also hiiii another collinlock16 fan!!!!
this was my first time learning about and watching the last beta player, and oh my gosh its definitely one of my favourite mc horror videos now. it doesn't have any crazy unrealistic aspects or scares to it, makes it seem like it could be real when you know it isn't. i have been looking forward to your next video ever since i stumbled upon the first strange house video and got even more excited seeing you tease it on instagram and you never disappoint holy shit!!! the way you edit is so nice and easy to look at, LOVED the little irl scenes, and you're very well spoken too. you did a really good job, troney!!!!!!!
Your videos are seriously so great to listen to (and watch obv..) while writing, please keep on posting more bro... I need more to listen to while world building the hell out of my fanfic...
I love this video, it's nice seeing how you've refined your style in just a few videos. I really loved the last beta player as well, thanks for showing me such a cool minecraft horror video!
i love how when you see one of his reddit posts, there's the comment "you know the game's been updated a few times in the last decade right?" paired with him opening a high-energy youtube short and disliking it, it really reinforces the idea of him being alone in this endeavor; everyone else has moved on to the more modern thing, he is the last beta player.
I hope you do more horror stuff, I love the mix of calm and spooky that you're able to give :3!! I'm too scared to watch horror stuff, but I still love it, so it's nice to have a more distant, calmer way to watch it
I really enjoy your enthusiasm about this stuff especially how genuine it is. Hard to find channels doing stuff like this that aren't super fake and pandering.
I have no idea if this was intentional or not, but my favorite subtle "scare" of this movie is the pumpkin that was staring right at David the first time he stumbled across the beta village. Little details like that absolutely sell it for me, even if, again, it wasn't intentional. Love it.
What I like about ur channel is that from the very first video on this channel 3 months ago, you have ensured that it was good quality, and ur sequel to ur first one does not disappoint either. Even this video demonstrates your skills and efforts as a RUclipsr. I'm sure many of us happily say we are glad you have gotten the recognition you deserve for your deep dives. Have fun with whatever you decide to do next :)
This ARG and the "Lilypad Versions" ARG are what I consider peak Minecraft horror. It has everything, the suspension of disbelief, the realistic odds, and it's not afraid to make use of the outside world and the broader internet in order to make the story more believable and have more layers. No shadow entities and no secret dimensions made by a shady organization necessary. Just the mysteries of Minecraft. I also agree with your take. It's a love letter to classic Minecraft, but also it's a story about nostalgia and letting go of the past. One big thing I do when looking back at older Minecraft versions is appreciate them as they are. Too many people slip into the old-school elitism of Minecraft, and others also forget about it and seem to discard the things that came before. I see old Minecraft as a good way to experience nostalgia, a good challenge to play Minecraft without all of the small quality-of-life updates, and also a way to appreciate how far the game has come. As the old adage says "dont cry because it's over, smile because it happened"
genuinely i love your content. i look forward to the shit you put out, your deep dives are just straight investigation and information and your passion for these niche things are lovely to behold. I'm pretty sure i left a comment on your first or second one, and it makes me happy to know you got to read not just mine but everyone's. keep up the good work and focus on your passion first. RUclips NEEDS more creators like you.
I can understand seeking out old versions, I look back fondly on my days playing legacy console edition. Im an adult now, and that scares me, I wish I could feel like that again. But I cant, life moves in with or without me. I realize what is happening now is going to be someones else's childhood to look back on, we're not nostalgic for just the game, but for how we were then, young, untroubled by the world. Modern Minecraft is beautiful, I find comfort in it, it may not be what I once new, but it's still Minecraft, It never left, it grew up with me. by learning to let go, I found a new perspective, and feel great about each new addition, I remember booting up my 360 and getting on after an updste and exploring what was new, Now, I Boot up the same game, just on a different platform, and find joy in what is new, and what I grew up with is still there, just with a fresh coat of paint.
this video is literally my biggest nightmare, a bunch of small things paired with major paranoia. love the videos btw man, said it before but i’ve been here since hour 2 of your first video, keep it up💕
WAITER, WAITER MORE PLEASE !! I absolutely love your content and take on things so far I didn't even realize until the end of the video you were a new content creator Imagine my surprise upon clicking on your channel and only seeing 3 videos, goddamn
I like the idea that entity isn't evil, it just want to say "stop being stuck in the past, it did already happen and what matters is the present, it's time to move on".
HONEY COME HERE !! NEW TRONE(Y)SAUCE VIDEO CAME OUT !!! Nonetheless thank you so much for your videos, they are so calm and I love how you do them generally. I watch them every night to fall asleep. Youre currently my comfort zone, thank you.
I just wanna say i love the videos you’ve put out so far. The deadskin video really gave my 8 year old self from back then the closure it needed after watching the “STRANGE buildings i didnt build”
Damm another great video. I just like the vibe your videos give of. They feel genuine i would say. No unecessary things and consistent. Keep up the good work and stay the way you are!
haven’t started the meat of the video yet but i’m so glad i listened to your recommendation of watching the movie first, that really was a phenomenal take on the genre!! usually i’m content to just watch the analysis only but your review was so glowing i had to see what the fuss was about and you weren’t kidding, that was a treat to watch blind! can’t wait to see what other mysteries and args you cover in the future, your thorough analyses are engaging and really hook me in!
Hooooly, The videos and commentary are such high quality, and also rlly alot of things are mentioned that I didn't notice while watching the vid on Mongster's channel. Congratz man u deserve it :)
You’ve only made 3 videos so far but your one of the best Minecraft RUclipsr and I do have to admit something…..I fell asleep around 5 mins of the video because the video was so peaceful in a way (great video)
this reminds me of an old seed on MCPE that would put you underground in a perfect spherical room with grass. youd have to punch through stone for like an hour to escape into this odd world. this seed was known as the 'herobrine' seed that we played as kids. IDK if anybody else remembers that or not but I believe the seed was just "Ss" if anybody else remembers this as being a thing let me know, my sister told me about it when i was little and we played on it together but idk who told her and she isnt the type of person to use youtube or browse online so idk if anybody else even knows about it. Probably just some odd generation glitch but ive never experienced anything like it since
For someone who's a bit new you're doing a great job! :D Your videos have been really enjoyable so far gonna be cool to see what more you do man, good luck
Just finished watching, this was great! So happy to see a new video from you! RUclips has been recommending me a lot of minecraft after I accidentally got hyperfixated on Parkour Civilization and decided to play again (do keep in mind I hadn't played minecraft since beta so it's kinda funny imo), and your first video was one of them. I ended up binging both and subbing since they were just delightful, and it's great to see a new one!!! Anyway, sorry for rambling! Wishing you the best, can't wait to see what you do next! 🥳💖
Between The Last Beta Player and things like Whitepine, seems like greatly made minecraft movies have been appearing around youtube recently. And I'm definitely not complaining.
"Hey there's this song that embodied the visceral fear that you get when you enter a room and a boss health bar appears, what should we call it?" "Uhh, Calm4?"
I remember I’d be like “I used to be so scared when playing minecraft when it first came out” and people would be making fun of me. mongster’s video really captured that old minecraft creepy atmosphere
I did watch it before watching this. That last part made me anxious 😂 the way he blocked himself in. The ice breaking and the splash after was so dramatic and descriptive even in pitch blackness, it gave me chills.
Funnily, I stopped the video right before being told to do so and made sure watch the actual video first. It was a nice experience, although as a player I was annoyed by the tower not being finished and the lots of iron ores that were not picked up. I even picked up on a few of the small details. Like you said it was beautifully, meticulously crafted. It really felt just like a let's play. Your analysis and overall presentation was also really nice. I love your conclusion of the world trying to help David to move on. The thought of horror originating from a benevolent source that wants to aid in your betterment sounds very wholesome and intriguing. It both elevates and ruins the last beta player for me. As I love the thought of appreciating aspects of the old and choosing to experience them. Not of a way of being stuck in the past, but being able to appreciate the simpler experience and having to utilise more creativity with the given limitations. However, the details you gave do paint a clear picture of David and how my feelings do not quite fit with the material. Hope you find even more success, mate. You were quite entertaining to watch. Similarly to the last beta player, it did not feel like 50 minutes passed.
![Lethal Company Music Video 🎵 "Follow The Orders" [VERSION A]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QeooZB4Z7RA/mqdefault.jpg)
She last on my beta til I player
i just beta'd everywhere
I played everywhere.
Legend
she mong on my 83 till i ster
real and true
The most realistic Part about this is that r/Minecraft moderators removed his legitimate questions
i mean it wasnt a legitimate question, calm 4 doesn't play and he knew that, he just needed the shot of the Reddit post for his video
@@dumb0999it wasn't, unlike ones that are removed all the time
it's SO funny dude. like this guy tried so hard to get some realism for his minecraft horror video and just ended up getting his posts removed for being stupid
@@CybenX_yt that is realism
Thats what r*dditors are like
46:50 ngl it made me realize something about the herobrine creepypasta, people usually depict herobrine as this super powerful evil entity who wants to kill you,
but in the original herobrine creepypasta herobrine never really does anything malicious, he really is only there in the world.. existing... a ghost running aimlessly in a empty world doing things with seemingly no rhyme or reason.
I befriended him, and now he helps me build and mine and whatnot. Really cool dude, it sucks that he gets such a bad wrap for no reason.
Really just a gigachad minecraft buddy.
@@RoseWitchMaple jokes aside, that would be a really cool mod. Have Herobrine run around your world doing his thing, you can befriend him and then you can tell him to tag along on your spelunking, much like an Elder Scrolls/Fallout companion.
@@BastetFurryBros gonna put the hero in herobrine
Reminds me of the different versions of Bigfoot. Some he's malicious, some he's just chilling
The little hints that David is used to playing modern versions of minecraft, like right clicking to equip armor or dragging items really add to this. He hasnt been playing beta for the past 10 years, refusing to play newer versions, he _chose_ to go back to beta. Maybe he wanted the simplicity of the old versions, maybe he was just nostalgic. This is reaching a bit, but I think something happened to David, something that made him turn to this old, nostalgic, _comforting_ version of minecraft. But then things start getting weirder and weirder, and he becomes more and more paranoid. You could read it as a metaphor, the anxieties of life seeping in to places we used to find comfort in, until it hits a breaking point. Deleting the world at the end felt really sad, something he put time and effort in to, something peaceful in his life, gone forever.
i like this way of thinking
Maybe he got tired of the mob vote or something
The reddit post is the most realistic thing. I once asked for a datapack or something to increase netherite spawn just to have an easier time and i get people hardcore arguing 'just cheat it in if you dont wanna play the game' with mass downvotes or whatever. Some suggesting it in the 'its singleplayer it doesnt matter lol' way when i just wanted the server with my friends to be more casual.
Dang, man. People really just kick others for no reason. I don't think there's a "Right" way to play minecraft, and a datapack is literally just a tiny mod to make things easier.
Ah yes because stripmining for netherite is such a riveting and exciting experience!
Never, ever use Reddit unless it’s for technical troubleshooting and there’s already a thread for it. Only thing it’s good for. Personal experience there
@@cloud1973 IF YOU WANT TO BYPASS THE GAME ANYWAYS JUST USE CHEATS TO GET ENTIRE STACKS LOL?
Redditors are subhuman and pathetic, what's new?
The biggest thing for me that added to the realism: he didn't scream or anything when he was jumpscared or came across something unexplainable. Just a sharp nose inhale. That's exactly how the vast majority of people playing alone would respond.
Exactly! When I play any game and get startled or scared by something, I don’t go: “AHH!!!” Instead I jump or flinch a little and do a sharp inhale. Well, except for those times when I get *really* scared lol
Occasionally let a "jeez..." but most of the time I wouldn't talk on my own.
@@anitakim_ honestly when i get jumpscared i just say a very very unamused "Ahh" or "Oh" (i cannot scream in my house so 😭)
also the need to quit the game as quick as possible. Release the tension
"weird village that i did not build"
i won't escape that video anytime soon, huh?
@@troneysauce "weird response i did not write"
@@troneysauce man, that video was a banger, obviously not
@@troneysauce that video was genuinely one of the best and most-indepth research I've ever seen, on any topic. that forum poster was the true hero for having all those files, but you did an incredible job
@@troneysauceweird heart i did not add
i only caught this because someone mentioned it in the comments,but i absolutely love that the sign changes to say goodbye in the final shot, makes me think the entity that did this (possibly mc itself like you said) is almost a bit smug, cause theres no way that our protag could have seen that, it just seems a lil unessacary, but also theres the more wholesome interpretation of this going along with what you said as this being beta mc saying goodbye to david, and being happy that it can finally rest
stick to what makes you interested an i'll stay along for the ride :) congratz man
glad to hear that, thank you :)
the next video will be: "A strange youtube video i did not build"
Jokes aside, excellent video, as always. I'll only be able to finish it tomorrow actually, but it's still amazing to see the quality you put into your videos.
thanks azu
I think you just prophesied his latest video lmao
I like how his paranoia is seen with how much armor he equips as it goes on. Going from a calm completely chill player to completely and utterly on edge.
The reason this video is great is because its a scary story IN Minecraft and is not using a Minecraft to tell a story. It works because it uses what makes Minecraft unnerving and the fears we might've had while playing, especially during the old versions.
What stood out to me watching the video was that the village used a lot of mossy cobblestone. In earlier versions, that stuff was super rare to come by, because you'd only find it on the floor of dungeons. So someone just building a whole village with mossy cobblestone isn't something that's actually going to happen, and you only have that block in naturally generated structures.
you hit the nail on the head on why i like this video so much. its not just that the playing/acting is so human, but also because everything about it is so relatable to a beta player. getting startled by skeleton arrows and calm4, getting lost in the labyrinthian cave generation, or going out in the world desperately trying to find clay, its all stuff anyone who has played old minecraft has experienced before. its so clearly full of love towards the golden age community as well, like the dialko video or the ONE helpful person in the reddit threads being called "themastercarver" lmao. it all just makes the experience feel so raw and real.
I was pondering weather to watch this since ive already seen "The last beta player", but then I realised its your channel so I stayed. And out of topic, YOUR PICTURES AND ART IS AMAZING HOLY SHIT???? THATS SO COOL
thank you :DDDDD
At 9:04 I could just FEEL the immediate "NOPE-" the way he IMMEDIATELY backed away and turned to stare at the rest of the cave-
i can absolutely see you evolve into one of those long breakdown RUclipsrs of more than just Minecraft stuff and im so here for it
17:10 haunted by sick tunes
Agreed
is it copyrighted? cause i really wanna use it in a yt video
She sick on my tunes till i haunted
@@glumbus-qe7zk That music is the Minecraft Boss Battle made by Notch, so, very probable.
@@GuardianWorld thanks for the info, sucks that its most likely copyrighted tho :(
I had no idea it was unconfirmed whether or not calm4 would play in minecraft? I swear I heard it in game myself once. As is the general consensus, it scared the shit out of me
The reason I added it myself was because that’s what happened to me. I was so shocked to hear it, it really caught me off guard
i believe it was almost definitely in the game at some point, but the way that sound resources were downloaded rather than stored in version files, plus the lack of credible videos of it playing means its technically not 100% proven.
I scare very easily but I was able to sit through this whole video :) I appreciate that you didnt put scary music or sounds or anything in the background (yes thats how easy i scare 😅), it makes it so much nicer for me, I loved the strange house i did not build videos too! Ive watched them like 4 times each lol
Loved the video 💙💙💙
thank you so much
same
Same
The use of Calm4 in the cave was brilliant. It's such a weird, off-putting track on its own, but in this situation? It's an escape sequence track, and it's perfect for it. It's more energetic than the normal backing tracks, and in this situation, more frantic. 10/10
Great video! And great movie as well, it's so refreshing to see a creepy minecraft ARG not immediately destroy all suspension of disbelief by introducing some "admin dimension" or shadow entities or whatever. It really keeps riding the line of "oh well this could be some weird data corruption" (strange torch I did not break, strange calm4 i did not play). Andhaving a live cam of the player as well keeps it grounded nicely. Sometimes in some ARGs it feels like the creators forget that minecraft is a game and act like they are embodying their player character directly and minecraft is real life. Here the acting makes it feel super believable as just some guy trying to play old mc and being spooked but also intrigued by the weird stuff he sees
I hope you make more videos of the kind because the way you present info is rly neat (Shoutout to the section at 30:50) and it seems u have a good eye for non-slop mc horror
🙏
I hate the "Minecraft is real life and you realize you're in a simulation" trope there's always some players named like VORT101 and VORT102 and then VORT403 and so on with pitch black skins just stalking you and then all of a sudden you cross an acacia door and you're in the VORTEX admin dimension or whatever (btw if anyone wanna do this go ahead lmao)
it's so overdone, seeing something like the one on the video is very refreshing
Hi calamity guy
the part you mentioned in the comment is genuinely so well done, very clever
This is EXACTLY my thought. Having the IRL cam and showing him going on Reddit really sold it for me. With other ARGs that are about shadow entities and weird admin dimensions with souls getting trapped in the game and such it really destroys my suspension of disbelief cause I think "Wait... so this kid just goes to school, has dinner with his family, then logs onto minecraft to stop these world-ending entities... and then just turns off the computer and goes to bed???" Like you said, it's more believable here since it's just "weird corruption, anyone know why this happened?"
I wouldn't call it ARG
The Last Beta Player made me feel like so nostalgic. I remember playing like that, and everyone had stories of weird things happening to their worlds.
You are awesome. I hope you go back and find old, ancient, or defunct Minecraft ARGs or mystery videos such as Strange House and just pour some analytics into them. The beating your head against the wall investigation was so nice and relaxing, along with your somewhat random chatting with your friend. I kinda wish they had been in this video as well, but I have no clue how that would have worked.
I fall in love with your chanel dude please never stop uploading videos
13:37 bro still got 5 sticks and there was coal in that cave. He could've just mine some and get 20 more torches.
he passes by like 5 iron ores too
@@WithManyVoices absolutely unwatchable
Not only that he runs amok when his sword breaks and has a diamond axe with a few good whacks left in his inventory.
@@creakycracker he doesnt even utilize the saddam tactic or just build up
@@creakycracker Axes don't do much damage pre 1.9
Can we talk on how he never had any wood with him? It's such a trauma for me that I have at least a half stack of logs in my inventory, this guy is not ok.
Love your vids, please continue, I'm really happy for ytb algorithm recommending you.
Didn't get the coal when they were out of torches either, even though they had sticks in their inventory.
You are probably my favorite minecraft guy, you just sound so genuinely interested in what you talk about and I love it, already waiting for the next vid
thank you!!
I found you the DAY you posted your first video with like 500 views. and holy shit dude your ability to tell a story is crazy and so captivating. I literally watch your videos 4-5 times just to get the entire thing.
Okay, that dark cave chase was awesome. Very tense, the low light and everything. Good stuff.
And nice narration too, I like the tone and cadence. 👍
Agreed on the down to earth writing of this show, it feels more real than some of the crazy super sized conspiracies with cabals of shadow people and what not.
I’m glad I have your analysis of this.
I completely missed all the footsteps and stuff, and was quite confused what had him so scared when he ran away from his base, and I even missed LITERALLY EVERYTHING except the ice breaking in David’s cobblestone hut on the ice.
Reminds me of AndrewGaming's arg, where Andrew himself doesn't want to face the change of the game, reminising about his time playing Halo with his friend Chris, even the colour pallet of the arg is this kind of bloomy and saturated shader that makes it look like OG Minecraft. His ARG is nowhere near the authentic feel of this one, it's actually a polar opposite as it has different characters, acting, structures that you cannot argue in any way shape or form are genarated naturally by the game, spooky stuff going on, and ghosts of the past reaching out to him, but it's still immensely well-made and enjoyable. Then there was this one that later on turns out the guy who is covering the ARG is part of it himself as a last-minute twist. All in all, you are absolutely right, when an arg is made with passion and love for both the horror genre and the game it takes place in it's a thoroughly enjoyable experience.
31:43 upper screen 😵💫
WHY NO ONE IS TALKING ABOUT THIS MOMENT GOOOSH
holy moly this scared me
it's not there in the actual video
WOAH NO WAY
I checked, can affirm @troneysauce is playing with us
Really glad you’re continuing this kind of thing (calling it an explanation video or something doesn’t feel like it does it justice).
👀
The cobblestone hut scene gets me every time. The tension is so thick, it's amazing
the least calm song ever being called “calm 4” is mind boggling tbh
Not only is the video so good, but the way you analyze the video made me captivated to watch it all the way through even after eating my dinner. I literally forgot to clean my dishes while watching this video for more than 30 minutes. This analysis video is so simple (in how it's edited) yet i really liked the way you narrate it. It's not like one of those ARG analysis videos where i can literally predict each words the narrator would say because not only does minecraft ARGs been so cliche, but also the videos analyzing them too.
YAY I’ve been hoping you’d upload again! Very excited for this!
Edit: this was awesome!! Well done!
thank you!
BRO I WAS LITERALLY WONDERING IF YOU WERE GOING TO UPLOAD A NEW VIDEO AT SOME POINT AND THE NOTIFICATION POPPED UP WTF
Love the clips you made throughout the video. Had to subscribe after that little sign that said subscribe halfway through the video. Keep it up!!
the entity did me a favor with that sign
Woah! I watched your first video for the first time just yesterday, and watched your second video this afternoon, and I was sitting here thinking "I wonder if this guy went on to make more videos", and AN HOUR LATER, you upload another video. Excellent channel and content, please keep making more.
thank you, there's gonna be more :D
AHHHH! I'm so glad I watched the original video before continuing this one, it's so good. Thanks for the recommendation!
I recommend a minecraft arg parody series by Oneshef. It's very good and funny. Its called something like "minecraft arg but the protagonist is tired" There are multiple videos in the universe, and i recommend all of them. They are all so good, and he needs more recognition
I'm catching up with some of the newer videos and it's actually so fucking hype
there’s no point in looking in to them if it is just compiled funny clips and no lore, I agree they are very funny but the videos just speak for themselves
I like the ones where there's no commentary. It makes it even funnier when I'm able to imagine the protag's emotions.
@@stephaniegiacco7524 but there is lore. It's all a connection story
i think the series's status as a parody enhances the bits of horror in there, too; the parts with hungry and souler wouldn't be nearly as scary (and would honestly be. not scary at all lmao) if the majority of the series wasn't satire. also hiiii another collinlock16 fan!!!!
I really enjoyed this video, not only showing me a cool movie thingy , but also making me find a cool RUclipsr!
this was my first time learning about and watching the last beta player, and oh my gosh its definitely one of my favourite mc horror videos now. it doesn't have any crazy unrealistic aspects or scares to it, makes it seem like it could be real when you know it isn't. i have been looking forward to your next video ever since i stumbled upon the first strange house video and got even more excited seeing you tease it on instagram and you never disappoint holy shit!!! the way you edit is so nice and easy to look at, LOVED the little irl scenes, and you're very well spoken too. you did a really good job, troney!!!!!!!
THANK YOU BROOK
Your videos are seriously so great to listen to (and watch obv..) while writing, please keep on posting more bro... I need more to listen to while world building the hell out of my fanfic...
This is literally the best new long-form breakdown channel of this RUclips era
im flattered, thank you
I love this video, it's nice seeing how you've refined your style in just a few videos. I really loved the last beta player as well, thanks for showing me such a cool minecraft horror video!
I was sitting in the bus when I saw that you uploaded a new video. Couldn't wait to get home to watch it!
I love your videos!
sleep token mentioned (also thank you)
i love how when you see one of his reddit posts, there's the comment "you know the game's been updated a few times in the last decade right?"
paired with him opening a high-energy youtube short and disliking it, it really reinforces the idea of him being alone in this endeavor; everyone else has moved on to the more modern thing, he is the last beta player.
I hope you do more horror stuff, I love the mix of calm and spooky that you're able to give :3!! I'm too scared to watch horror stuff, but I still love it, so it's nice to have a more distant, calmer way to watch it
I will be doing a whole lot more horror stuff thank you
I really enjoy your enthusiasm about this stuff especially how genuine it is. Hard to find channels doing stuff like this that aren't super fake and pandering.
I have no idea if this was intentional or not, but my favorite subtle "scare" of this movie is the pumpkin that was staring right at David the first time he stumbled across the beta village. Little details like that absolutely sell it for me, even if, again, it wasn't intentional. Love it.
Calm 4 is honestly the most terrifying bone chilling bed wetting song ever made
Sonic Drowning theme:
it certainly makes my bed wet 🥵🥵🥵
Breath of the Wild guardian theme
What I like about ur channel is that from the very first video on this channel 3 months ago, you have ensured that it was good quality, and ur sequel to ur first one does not disappoint either. Even this video demonstrates your skills and efforts as a RUclipsr.
I'm sure many of us happily say we are glad you have gotten the recognition you deserve for your deep dives. Have fun with whatever you decide to do next :)
thank you so much
No way I was thinking about if you were gonna upload again oh my I have so much to much at the moment before I can get to this
no problem, the vids not going anywhere, come back when you can 😎
How many red squares?
28 red squares
@@shivers.ID_ you didn't wanna leave him a chance, huh?
Nine red squares
@@Kristijan_Did you feel anger? Hate?
She red on my square till i 28
This ARG and the "Lilypad Versions" ARG are what I consider peak Minecraft horror. It has everything, the suspension of disbelief, the realistic odds, and it's not afraid to make use of the outside world and the broader internet in order to make the story more believable and have more layers. No shadow entities and no secret dimensions made by a shady organization necessary. Just the mysteries of Minecraft.
I also agree with your take. It's a love letter to classic Minecraft, but also it's a story about nostalgia and letting go of the past. One big thing I do when looking back at older Minecraft versions is appreciate them as they are. Too many people slip into the old-school elitism of Minecraft, and others also forget about it and seem to discard the things that came before. I see old Minecraft as a good way to experience nostalgia, a good challenge to play Minecraft without all of the small quality-of-life updates, and also a way to appreciate how far the game has come. As the old adage says "dont cry because it's over, smile because it happened"
genuinely i love your content. i look forward to the shit you put out, your deep dives are just straight investigation and information and your passion for these niche things are lovely to behold. I'm pretty sure i left a comment on your first or second one, and it makes me happy to know you got to read not just mine but everyone's. keep up the good work and focus on your passion first. RUclips NEEDS more creators like you.
I can understand seeking out old versions, I look back fondly on my days playing legacy console edition. Im an adult now, and that scares me, I wish I could feel like that again. But I cant, life moves in with or without me. I realize what is happening now is going to be someones else's childhood to look back on, we're not nostalgic for just the game, but for how we were then, young, untroubled by the world. Modern Minecraft is beautiful, I find comfort in it, it may not be what I once new, but it's still Minecraft, It never left, it grew up with me. by learning to let go, I found a new perspective, and feel great about each new addition, I remember booting up my 360 and getting on after an updste and exploring what was new, Now, I Boot up the same game, just on a different platform, and find joy in what is new, and what I grew up with is still there, just with a fresh coat of paint.
Real
This is a perfect recreation of that fear you always used to have playing Minecraft alone after watching herobrian videos
this video is literally my biggest nightmare, a bunch of small things paired with major paranoia.
love the videos btw man, said it before but i’ve been here since hour 2 of your first video, keep it up💕
gotta respect the og's
WAITER, WAITER MORE PLEASE !!
I absolutely love your content and take on things so far
I didn't even realize until the end of the video you were a new content creator
Imagine my surprise upon clicking on your channel and only seeing 3 videos, goddamn
I like the idea that entity isn't evil, it just want to say "stop being stuck in the past, it did already happen and what matters is the present, it's time to move on".
HONEY COME HERE !! NEW TRONE(Y)SAUCE VIDEO CAME OUT !!!
Nonetheless thank you so much for your videos, they are so calm and I love how you do them generally. I watch them every night to fall asleep. Youre currently my comfort zone, thank you.
that means a lot, thank you very much
I'm glad to see you got so many views and comments. I'm happy your previous videos ended up on my recommended (probably cause of Dialko funny enough)
Man I'm really happy you're still making new vids, I like alot your style of narrating things ❤
I just wanna say i love the videos you’ve put out so far. The deadskin video really gave my 8 year old self from back then the closure it needed after watching the “STRANGE buildings i didnt build”
I love the mountain of plushies, also as someone who obsesses over stuff like this you're not alone I love you
Damm another great video.
I just like the vibe your videos give of. They feel genuine i would say. No unecessary things and consistent.
Keep up the good work and stay the way you are!
I'm here for whatever you make :D
thank you
haven’t started the meat of the video yet but i’m so glad i listened to your recommendation of watching the movie first, that really was a phenomenal take on the genre!! usually i’m content to just watch the analysis only but your review was so glowing i had to see what the fuss was about and you weren’t kidding, that was a treat to watch blind!
can’t wait to see what other mysteries and args you cover in the future, your thorough analyses are engaging and really hook me in!
DUDE, I LITERALLY JUST FINISHED YOUR LAST VIDEO, YOU REALLY ARE CURSED
Blessed*
Sameee
are you stupid this isnt the same person you dumb fuck
i live in your walls
@@troneysauce sameee
Hooooly, The videos and commentary are such high quality, and also rlly alot of things are mentioned that I didn't notice while watching the vid on Mongster's channel. Congratz man u deserve it :)
"who's this trone(y)sauce on my subscriptions feed" followed by "OOOH rtihg"
"the guy in your house named Jason" hes a few states away right now, but close
I’m so glad that you’re continuing to make content
THANK YOU TRONEY!! Such a banger again
great video man, hope you keep doing this type of videos
I will, thanks :)
Please keep uploading you really struck gold with the first video, and you struck gold with this one, I love your style
You’ve only made 3 videos so far but your one of the best Minecraft RUclipsr and I do have to admit something…..I fell asleep around 5 mins of the video because the video was so peaceful in a way (great video)
Also sorry for my bad grammar/english
that was one thing i noticed too, all the acting felt genuine and i feel like it helps the horror a LOT
I'm so excited for more videos, you a truly a treat to watch! keep up the great work, the editing was so fun. my fav was pov of u lol
this reminds me of an old seed on MCPE that would put you underground in a perfect spherical room with grass.
youd have to punch through stone for like an hour to escape into this odd world.
this seed was known as the 'herobrine' seed that we played as kids. IDK if anybody else remembers that or not but I believe the seed was just "Ss"
if anybody else remembers this as being a thing let me know, my sister told me about it when i was little and we played on it together but idk who told her and she isnt the type of person to use youtube or browse online so idk if anybody else even knows about it.
Probably just some odd generation glitch but ive never experienced anything like it since
For someone who's a bit new you're doing a great job! :D Your videos have been really enjoyable so far gonna be cool to see what more you do man, good luck
Just finished watching, this was great! So happy to see a new video from you! RUclips has been recommending me a lot of minecraft after I accidentally got hyperfixated on Parkour Civilization and decided to play again (do keep in mind I hadn't played minecraft since beta so it's kinda funny imo), and your first video was one of them. I ended up binging both and subbing since they were just delightful, and it's great to see a new one!!!
Anyway, sorry for rambling! Wishing you the best, can't wait to see what you do next! 🥳💖
How dare youtube hide this from me for 1 min
I am amazed by your video. The quality and atmosphere of it is what I like. Thank you, I'm going to follow
God, you did such a great job covering this film. I think you did The Last Beta Player justice. :]
Between The Last Beta Player and things like Whitepine, seems like greatly made minecraft movies have been appearing around youtube recently. And I'm definitely not complaining.
11:35 still in what? 🐒⚔️🍊🔫🦵🦌🌸🤖💀🐟
THE ONE PIECE IS REAAAALLLLL
I really like the idea of the RNG being used against him as if it has its own autonomy
just finished the mongster video o7 i’m back again haha
procrastinating art coursework 😭😭
"Hey there's this song that embodied the visceral fear that you get when you enter a room and a boss health bar appears, what should we call it?"
"Uhh, Calm4?"
Trone finally passed his recaptcha test for his youtube channel login, bravo
i love your content and the passion you have, it’s really amazing to watch
I remember I’d be like “I used to be so scared when playing minecraft when it first came out” and people would be making fun of me. mongster’s video really captured that old minecraft creepy atmosphere
less go new video🔥🔥
I showed my dad the 2 strange house I did not build videos, he doesn't even play minecraft, and he was genuinely invested
you got something here, man
I did watch it before watching this. That last part made me anxious 😂 the way he blocked himself in. The ice breaking and the splash after was so dramatic and descriptive even in pitch blackness, it gave me chills.
Funnily, I stopped the video right before being told to do so and made sure watch the actual video first. It was a nice experience, although as a player I was annoyed by the tower not being finished and the lots of iron ores that were not picked up. I even picked up on a few of the small details. Like you said it was beautifully, meticulously crafted. It really felt just like a let's play. Your analysis and overall presentation was also really nice. I love your conclusion of the world trying to help David to move on. The thought of horror originating from a benevolent source that wants to aid in your betterment sounds very wholesome and intriguing. It both elevates and ruins the last beta player for me. As I love the thought of appreciating aspects of the old and choosing to experience them. Not of a way of being stuck in the past, but being able to appreciate the simpler experience and having to utilise more creativity with the given limitations. However, the details you gave do paint a clear picture of David and how my feelings do not quite fit with the material.
Hope you find even more success, mate. You were quite entertaining to watch. Similarly to the last beta player, it did not feel like 50 minutes passed.