I think it doesn’t matter if the live-action revealed some things earlier compared to the anime/manga. The live-action does a nice job of tying the story together. Some things revealed to new watchers wouldn’t even know until later if it’s explained. Also, the story has been going on for so long that I won’t be surprised if Oda just wrote things on the fly/sudden idea that’s why it took 1000+ to know about it. So I like that the live-action is not doing the same and makes the story more connected. I read a lot of historical fantasy comics, it is common for historical/fantasy settings to also have futuristic/modern things like electricity. I mean anything goes right in a fantasy setting.
Always fun to watch your videos - When Usopp got scared next to that taxidermy animal it looks like it belongs on the Island of Rare Animals in particular this makes me think of Cocox the hybrid of a Fox & rooster - During Kunia’s funeral notice that she just like another person’s had 3 sake cups - I noticed this if you look at Buchi’s face you can see that around his left eye is lighter this is maybe because of his mask / helmet, but this maybe a mistake with me
I really wish they'd kept the line of Zoro's "I'll become so famous that my name will reach the heavens so that Kuina will know I didn't break our promise"
I am glad I wasn't the only one who thought it was odd how Luffy, who seemingly just regain his conscious from the poison soup, knew right away who were the culprits. I wish they also kept the way Luffy restrain Kuro from the manga. But I guess that's extra budget for CGI and fight choreo plannings.
I have been watching your breakdowns and genuinely enjoying each one of them. The efforts you put on every video are not just detailed but also fun to watch. I admire your hardwork and dedication and would love to see more of your OP breakdowns. That being said..here's my sub sub fruit!
Outside of the breakdown, I really enjoyed this episode. I know the Syrup village episodes get some flack for cutting an arc that didn't have a lot to begin with but I really enjoyed the changes they made and what they did with Usopp.
Don't read this comment if you haven't watched episodes 5&6 I think they had Luffy drink the poison because they cut the Krige fight, where luffy gets his first dose of poison
I finished this last night! It was aight! 7-8/10 The deemphasizing of the folks living in these places bums me out a bit, and they dropped the canonball with Usopp but otherwise well done
Oda uses real-world language in the titles of his manga color spreads. For instance, in chapter 147, he used Spanish, and in chapter 226, he used French. However, I think it's worth noting that the inclusion of the word "Vivere" in "Vivere Ridere Amare" may be a reference to Vivre Cards in the One Piece world.
Yes definitely, though my point was more so that these languages do not exist in the world of One Piece for the characters. And it could, though it all stems from the Latin root for the word meaning "to live", so not sure if it's that's really a reference more than just romance languages being romance languages
I think they could have included Jango and the rest of the crew and still sort of have much of the same things happen. They could have had Jango posing as a ground-keeper or something, and he be kind of creepy at first (sort of like Filch in Harry potter), but then start showing how weird and silly he really is, yet he could have hypnotized Luffy to fall asleep instead, and then Usopp could have tried to get Kya to leave, taking her out the window and they try escaping, but are confronted by Jango who chases them into the garden, slicing up the bushes flowers with his disc (referencing him chasing Kya and the Usopp Pirates as they tried to get Kya to safety and Jango was slicing up the trees), but then Usopp manages to shoot Jango in the head with a slingshot pellet, but as they run away, he calls the rest of the crew who are surrounding the property, so when Usopp and Kya try going out one gate, they are scared by a few of the pirates, and then Jango could yell to them that the whole place is surrounded by the crew (or he could have said so while he chased them in the garden to say that running is futile), so Usopp and Kya are forced to escape back into the mansion and then get trapped inside. The only problem is that with the crew surrounding the property, Coby and the Marines wouldn't have been able to get in, but maybe they could have had Jango come up to Kuro to tell him the crew said Marines were coming, and asking if they should stop them, but Kuro says no, let them come to the door, he will handle them (then Usopp runs off after seeing the Marines won't arrest Kuro, and he goes to get Kya out, leading to the garden chase).
At about the 27:30 mark in this episode, when Usopp, Kaya, and Nami are trying to turn the wheel (to open the shutters, I imagine?) it looks like Usopp is pulling down from one side while Nami is pulling down from the other. Perhaps that's why it wouldn't turn?
I think they removed jango as the joke in the fandom he could of just hypnotised Kia instead of the 3 year plan so took him out to removed the plot hole 🤷♀️
Well, in this version, they needed to wait until the night after Kaya's 18th birthday anyway, so the plothole would've still been fixed even if Jango was there.
Usopp gets freaked out by spiderwebs. I found this weird because large spiders are pretty much the only thing Usopp isn't afraid of. In the Jaya arc, he's seen playing with tarantulas like they were puppies, which freaked out everybody else. Spoiler alert!: Usopp gets a kiss from Kaya, something that never happened in the text, but longtime fans are still happy for the guy.
Yes, when all we had was the official trailer, lots of people were thinking the well scene was some kind of allegory depiction of Mihawk's line "you're like a frog croaking at the bottom of a well." Turns out it was something else, however, Zoro having to struggle out of an actual well while he ruminates on his most defining piece of history only makes the line more poignant when Mihawk says it in the following episode.
@@Torazuki Except in the original manga Mihawk says basically the same thing, the frog in the well is very famous in east Asian folklore. The dialogue in the LA is just lifting the line almost verbatim from the manga (which is referencing the famous folklore) because Zoro has been a big fish in a small pond up until this point in the story. Zoro's "well scene" in the LA was only something added in after the fact by the showrunners, doesn't match the theme from his Mihawk fight about him not realizing how vast the world of swordsmanship is in One Piece.
@@adambysice2362 Yes, the well scene did not exist in either the manga or the anime. It was added in the LA as a way of interpreting things into live action. I think the LA writers tried to pull from the source as much as they could. I doubt it's a coincidence that they put the well scene in before Mihawk delivered his line. Diligent writing usually works by weaving themes in throughout a story and it looks to me like they took an opportunity to add an extra weave, since they had to change so much about the pacing and setting of syrup village anyway. I could certainly be wrong about their writing intentions. We'd have to ask them directly to be certain. But I appreciated the connection in my own interpretation regardless. ✌
I would give this guy the best hummer of his life
I think it doesn’t matter if the live-action revealed some things earlier compared to the anime/manga. The live-action does a nice job of tying the story together. Some things revealed to new watchers wouldn’t even know until later if it’s explained. Also, the story has been going on for so long that I won’t be surprised if Oda just wrote things on the fly/sudden idea that’s why it took 1000+ to know about it. So I like that the live-action is not doing the same and makes the story more connected.
I read a lot of historical fantasy comics, it is common for historical/fantasy settings to also have futuristic/modern things like electricity. I mean anything goes right in a fantasy setting.
Always fun to watch your videos
- When Usopp got scared next to that taxidermy animal it looks like it belongs on the Island of Rare Animals in particular this makes me think of Cocox the hybrid of a Fox & rooster
- During Kunia’s funeral notice that she just like another person’s had 3 sake cups
- I noticed this if you look at Buchi’s face you can see that around his left eye is lighter this is maybe because of his mask / helmet, but this maybe a mistake with me
I mentioned the We Are bit, but the rest are neat!
@@onepieceexplainedSorry I must have not paying attention at that part
I noticed buchi's skin tone too! Its like a really subtle, very large birth mark. Hard to miss after watching so many times lol.
I really wish they'd kept the line of Zoro's "I'll become so famous that my name will reach the heavens so that Kuina will know I didn't break our promise"
I love these videos and excited for all the details for Episode 5 with Baratie 😁👍
your attention to detail is incredible
I am glad I wasn't the only one who thought it was odd how Luffy, who seemingly just regain his conscious from the poison soup, knew right away who were the culprits. I wish they also kept the way Luffy restrain Kuro from the manga. But I guess that's extra budget for CGI and fight choreo plannings.
I have been watching your breakdowns and genuinely enjoying each one of them. The efforts you put on every video are not just detailed but also fun to watch. I admire your hardwork and dedication and would love to see more of your OP breakdowns. That being said..here's my sub sub fruit!
I love these videos, looking forward to the rest of the series :-)
You got this one out in record time my man! Keep it up!
I’m excited to hear from you on the final episodes.
You should have *at least* 100x the amount subs you have. You rock, man!
Excelent video!
Love this series, keep going!❤
Outside of the breakdown, I really enjoyed this episode. I know the Syrup village episodes get some flack for cutting an arc that didn't have a lot to begin with but I really enjoyed the changes they made and what they did with Usopp.
Never misses
7:30 I like to think he was in this episode, but he hypnotized everyone into forgetting him so he could escape, including the audience.
Don't read this comment if you haven't watched episodes 5&6
I think they had Luffy drink the poison because they cut the Krige fight, where luffy gets his first dose of poison
Did you guys ever notice that the whole marine bases and everything is english based but Garp's ship does have Japanese written on it
Yeah, and I love it 😂❤
I like to think luffy knew his crew and kaya were in danger due to the shitty soup knocking him out
I finished this last night! It was aight! 7-8/10
The deemphasizing of the folks living in these places bums me out a bit, and they dropped the canonball with Usopp but otherwise well done
Oda uses real-world language in the titles of his manga color spreads. For instance, in chapter 147, he used Spanish, and in chapter 226, he used French. However, I think it's worth noting that the inclusion of the word "Vivere" in "Vivere Ridere Amare" may be a reference to Vivre Cards in the One Piece world.
I appreciate your videos and would love to see more of them!
Yes definitely, though my point was more so that these languages do not exist in the world of One Piece for the characters. And it could, though it all stems from the Latin root for the word meaning "to live", so not sure if it's that's really a reference more than just romance languages being romance languages
I think they could have included Jango and the rest of the crew and still sort of have much of the same things happen. They could have had Jango posing as a ground-keeper or something, and he be kind of creepy at first (sort of like Filch in Harry potter), but then start showing how weird and silly he really is, yet he could have hypnotized Luffy to fall asleep instead, and then Usopp could have tried to get Kya to leave, taking her out the window and they try escaping, but are confronted by Jango who chases them into the garden, slicing up the bushes flowers with his disc (referencing him chasing Kya and the Usopp Pirates as they tried to get Kya to safety and Jango was slicing up the trees), but then Usopp manages to shoot Jango in the head with a slingshot pellet, but as they run away, he calls the rest of the crew who are surrounding the property, so when Usopp and Kya try going out one gate, they are scared by a few of the pirates, and then Jango could yell to them that the whole place is surrounded by the crew (or he could have said so while he chased them in the garden to say that running is futile), so Usopp and Kya are forced to escape back into the mansion and then get trapped inside. The only problem is that with the crew surrounding the property, Coby and the Marines wouldn't have been able to get in, but maybe they could have had Jango come up to Kuro to tell him the crew said Marines were coming, and asking if they should stop them, but Kuro says no, let them come to the door, he will handle them (then Usopp runs off after seeing the Marines won't arrest Kuro, and he goes to get Kya out, leading to the garden chase).
I just now realised the 4 on the clock is written wrong…
At about the 27:30 mark in this episode, when Usopp, Kaya, and Nami are trying to turn the wheel (to open the shutters, I imagine?) it looks like Usopp is pulling down from one side while Nami is pulling down from the other. Perhaps that's why it wouldn't turn?
I’m bummed the meowban siblings didn’t fight with their original cat claws. I would’ve loved to have seen them use them against zoro in their fight
Proud to be the 3rd! 🥹
Its a stretch but they maybe make Kuro having the Jango storyline in the show.
You da bomb
I think they removed jango as the joke in the fandom he could of just hypnotised Kia instead of the 3 year plan so took him out to removed the plot hole 🤷♀️
Well, in this version, they needed to wait until the night after Kaya's 18th birthday anyway, so the plothole would've still been fixed even if Jango was there.
Usopp gets freaked out by spiderwebs. I found this weird because large spiders are pretty much the only thing Usopp isn't afraid of. In the Jaya arc, he's seen playing with tarantulas like they were puppies, which freaked out everybody else.
Spoiler alert!:
Usopp gets a kiss from Kaya, something that never happened in the text, but longtime fans are still happy for the guy.
🐐
Nami Kaya and Usopp team up are the first instance of the weak trio with it being Kaya instead of Chopper
i always though kuina ended herself and the stairs thing was just to mask it
when Zoro climbed up the well there was a panda easter egg on the right of the screen i remember
Yup, it talked about the shrub in the previous video.
I hope Oda paid these actors well
FYI Frog in a well is a Chinese folklore story about a frog in a well not knowing how big the world is, not what you described
I'm sure there is an origin to Mihawk's line, but what I described was that this was Mihawk's line to Zoro during their encounter at the Baratie...
Yes, when all we had was the official trailer, lots of people were thinking the well scene was some kind of allegory depiction of Mihawk's line "you're like a frog croaking at the bottom of a well."
Turns out it was something else, however, Zoro having to struggle out of an actual well while he ruminates on his most defining piece of history only makes the line more poignant when Mihawk says it in the following episode.
@@Torazuki Except in the original manga Mihawk says basically the same thing, the frog in the well is very famous in east Asian folklore. The dialogue in the LA is just lifting the line almost verbatim from the manga (which is referencing the famous folklore) because Zoro has been a big fish in a small pond up until this point in the story. Zoro's "well scene" in the LA was only something added in after the fact by the showrunners, doesn't match the theme from his Mihawk fight about him not realizing how vast the world of swordsmanship is in One Piece.
@@adambysice2362 Yes, the well scene did not exist in either the manga or the anime. It was added in the LA as a way of interpreting things into live action.
I think the LA writers tried to pull from the source as much as they could. I doubt it's a coincidence that they put the well scene in before Mihawk delivered his line. Diligent writing usually works by weaving themes in throughout a story and it looks to me like they took an opportunity to add an extra weave, since they had to change so much about the pacing and setting of syrup village anyway.
I could certainly be wrong about their writing intentions. We'd have to ask them directly to be certain. But I appreciated the connection in my own interpretation regardless. ✌
In live action
You didn't see kanjo
kassam!!!!!
First 🥳
First🙏
real life anime is cringe af