Game Reviews are TRASH

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
  • Coney learns about the worst IGN game reviews according to this video, and gives his talk on review critiques in the video game industry and why they keep getting away with it.
    Watch the original video here:
    • The Top 10 Most Dislik...
    ➤ WATCH ME LIVE: / coney
    ➤ Follow me on Twitter: / coney
    ➤ Subscribe to my RUclips: / coneyzz
    ➤ Watch my VODs: / @coneyvods
    Edited by FriendAlias: / friendalias
    #coney #games #react

Комментарии • 331

  • @tominator4468
    @tominator4468 Год назад +647

    Crying with laughter at this. Your reaction to me saying 'blathering' was brilliant! Cheers for watching, Coney mate. Glad you guys got a chuckle out of it. Had no idea more than 300 people were ever going to see this video lol. Really helpful seeing my video through the eyes of someone else, so thanks.

  • @chrisray7728
    @chrisray7728 Год назад +366

    I don’t know how to explain it, but you’re right, there is absolutely a difference between a 9/10 with no cons and a 10/10 game.

    • @kyx5631
      @kyx5631 Год назад +86

      I would honestly argue that there are even 10/10 games that have cons.

    • @emanonomoi
      @emanonomoi Год назад +29

      The difference is 10/10 implies it has no specific demographic and *everyone* can enjoy it. 9/10 with no cons acknowledges that it’s main “flaw” is that it isn’t universally appealing. It’s not listed as a flaw because it really isn’t, it’s just purposeful design. Hades fits here because not everyone like rougelikes.
      And yeah 10/10 with flaws is also a thing, but more complicated.

    • @silvergalaxia8538
      @silvergalaxia8538 Год назад +66

      @@emanonomoi I heavily disagree with the opinion that 10/10 media has to have mass appeal. If anything, I find that games that hone into a specific audience can achieve a more personal feel and leave a greater impact.
      Everyone is into different things, and by your logic the only games that would qualify for 10/10 is stuff like Tetris or Mario Kart, since those are the only games that truly have "universal appeal".
      Games like celeste or resident evil 4 would be disqualified because not everyone likes platformers or horror games.

    • @danielalorbi
      @danielalorbi Год назад +6

      @@emanonomoi Really depends on how scores are meant to be interpreted.
      a) As a measure of how much the reviewer liked the game
      b) As a measure of how much the reviewer thinks the audience will like the game
      c) As a measure of some pre-defined qualities of the game
      d) As a measure of comparison against other games inside (and sometimes outside) a genre
      In all of those types of reviews con-less 9/10 and 10/10 mean different things.
      a) Liked it a lot, but not quite enough
      b) Thinks people will like it, but not enough
      c) Great but not Excellent (or just a consequence of the algebra not working out)
      d) Great but doesn't feel better than other 9/10's or close enough to other 10/10s

    • @chrisray7728
      @chrisray7728 Год назад +2

      @@kyx5631 Oh there's absolutely 10/10 with flaws, even 10/10 with a hell of a lot of flaws (Looking at you, breath of the wild), but I didn't wanna open that basket of worms in this youtube comment.

  • @theaa47
    @theaa47 Год назад +271

    I only trust one man with my game reviews and that is OnlyOneHere on metacritic.

  • @smollmoth6376
    @smollmoth6376 Год назад +619

    I really feel coney when he says there are no winners in this video. The British dude is letting out his colonial gamer rage lmao

    • @notimeforcreativenamesjust3034
      @notimeforcreativenamesjust3034 Год назад +13

      Yeah and Coney saying Death stranding bad is just plain wrong

    • @SnowyJop
      @SnowyJop Год назад +37

      The Death Stranding reviewer was a winner for sure. That is the most 6/10 game ever made

    • @OwNAvenged
      @OwNAvenged Год назад +18

      @@notimeforcreativenamesjust3034 He literally followed it up with "Ah, but people are doing the whole "It's actually just misunderstood" bit."
      And that's exactly what you're doing lmao

    • @notimeforcreativenamesjust3034
      @notimeforcreativenamesjust3034 Год назад +8

      @@OwNAvenged I liked it when it first came out, theres no change of opinions here

    • @wlt3585
      @wlt3585 Год назад +8

      @@notimeforcreativenamesjust3034 For the amount of people who absolutely couldn't care to get into the game, a 6/10 is like a perfect score. When giving a score for the masses, you can't just say it's a 7 or 8/10 'if you're into this specific type of thing' and act like there aren't countless people who are not at all interested in it, even amongst fans of the creator

  • @Alylion
    @Alylion Год назад +136

    “I hate politics in games that’s why I love bioshock” might be one of the funniest comments I’ve ever heard, it’s so good

  • @Geirks280
    @Geirks280 Год назад +201

    I love how I've already seen 2 comments about OnlyOneHere. It's hilarious how he's become such a well known character in Coney's fanbase

    • @zacharywoloszynski4258
      @zacharywoloszynski4258 Год назад +48

      I remember when I was reading Splatoon 3 reviews, and there was 1 insanely negative review. I clicked on the persons profile, and was pleasantly surprised to see it was OnlyOneHere.

    • @taylortots5549
      @taylortots5549 Год назад +10

      I almost wonder if OnlyOneHere is satire but I'm just gonna keep telling myself it's not

    • @rixrobin
      @rixrobin Год назад +15

      @@taylortots5549 I am convinced it’s real because they also have a “parody” account called “onlyonemissing” where he gives games he gave 0s and sarcastically reviews them as 10s. It could be a copycat but the way the reviews read are so similar.

  • @Moneymancer
    @Moneymancer Год назад +84

    The thing about too much water is that it's right. Everywhere that has water in the late game has the exact same encounters, as well as high encounter rates. It's frustrating and unrewarding

    • @patrickburton1401
      @patrickburton1401 Год назад

      Repels exist for a reason

    • @Kay-im6ht
      @Kay-im6ht Год назад +35

      ​@@patrickburton1401 I think repels being required to get through (not enjoy, get through) 1/3 of the map can def be notee as a flaw

    • @Moneymancer
      @Moneymancer Год назад +11

      @@patrickburton1401It doesn't change the fect that for a good chunk of the game you have no new encounters

    • @AwesomeMooseSmile
      @AwesomeMooseSmile Год назад +3

      The main thing that I've heard is that they gave the original games a 9 out of 10 despite it having a worst problem with the water section of the game. This is the big issue with IGN, they get different people to review different games, and as such they're inconsistent inconsistent and unreliable. That's really the actual issue with IGN and not "they review the game that I like badly and it makes my gamer blood rage" like most people's issues with them.

    • @HaxeRain
      @HaxeRain Год назад +2

      The thing is, while thats true until some extent, ORAS introduced the flying on the top of latios which allows you to straight up ignore most of the water sections and instead give you new things to do, by the time you get to that, you are done with the water unless you are doing the regis initial puzzle on the rapids, and at the point you can do that, you also get the upgrade to national dex encounters and the dexnav upgrade, in the originals? yeah no, screw you gamer, eat up all the water routes every time, still, repels help a lot and they are less obnoxious to use later games

  • @studi0651
    @studi0651 Год назад +180

    I don’t think I’ve ever seen a more accurate depiction of Gamers than this video. It seriously needs to be studied by future generations.

    • @Diamond_Aura
      @Diamond_Aura Год назад +4

      You get a gamer influencer commentating the opinions of a gaming top 10 reviewer’s opinions of a game journalist. Discourse of all kinds in 20 minutes

  • @vitalbeat2778
    @vitalbeat2778 Год назад +36

    The twitch comment “gamers (as a slur)” at 0:46 had me dying 😂

  • @d4nkey
    @d4nkey Год назад +86

    It's crazy how they ordered the tier list on the number of dislikes instead of a ratio.

    • @bibbyboxx2219
      @bibbyboxx2219 Год назад +27

      Gamers don’t do math

    • @relaxation_and_tax_evasion
      @relaxation_and_tax_evasion Год назад +6

      Thank you!!! Spot on

    • @senritsujumpsuit6021
      @senritsujumpsuit6021 Год назад

      @@bibbyboxx2219 Have you seen Mobile game players they do a lot math same with MMO players

    • @FlamingZelda3
      @FlamingZelda3 Год назад +12

      Sheer number draws you to what got a lot of negative attention. Ratio will bring you to some review with 25 likes and 100 dislikes. Doesn't really have the same oomph or lean well into the type of video he was trying to make.

  • @Rockalanche
    @Rockalanche Год назад +88

    There are so many people who don't understand the "Too much water" meme. It's funny out of context, but the actual review was just about there being too many water pokemon compared to all the other types.

    • @TinkLink1111
      @TinkLink1111 Год назад +12

      I think the overwhelming amount of water types in those games kinda goes hand-in-hand w there being too many water routes, it’s kinda the same review. But if you’re right and it’s just about the Pokémon themselves i think that makes the review much much worse funnily enough, just don’t use them, buy repels.

  • @gameboycolor47
    @gameboycolor47 Год назад +34

    this guy feels like he fell out of a time gate from 20010-ish youtube

  • @luigiongaming3959
    @luigiongaming3959 Год назад +67

    Idk why IGN got shit on for the "too much water" ruby/sapphire thing. Even though those were my favorite pokemon games as a kid I remember even at 10 years old hating how many water sections there were where I was just stuck in random encounter hell.

    • @TheDukeofCheese12
      @TheDukeofCheese12 Год назад +8

      9 year old me who didn't understand how Repels worked hated those water routes and the multitude of Tentacools and Wingulls that lived within.

    • @saskay7046
      @saskay7046 Год назад +6

      I understand where she's coming from with the too much water statement, but at the same time, it fits the theme of the game too well for me to complain about it. Also repels are a thing, and eventually you get to fly around to whatever location you want.

    • @Ryleeman54number2
      @Ryleeman54number2 Год назад

      Yea but how do you take out the water in a remake. They actually made it much more bearable then in the original

    • @daniell5740
      @daniell5740 Год назад

      It’s called repels

    • @perkypears
      @perkypears Год назад +9

      the water is just uninteresting to look at. it's just a big flat open area without any identifiable terrain like the land has. it's just like 1/3 of the area of the map is just completely blank

  • @kay_sou
    @kay_sou Год назад +14

    On the "9/10 with no flaws" thing, I can agree with that. For me, a 10/10 piece of media (game, show, etc.) has to leave a lasting impression on me. There's a personal, subjective level to it. As an example, I played Axiom Verge and Hollow Knight at around the same time. Both are great Metroidvanias that accomplish exactly what they wanted to do, but only Hollow Knight left a major impression on me. I have no complaints about Axiom Verge, it's just that there's some intangible quality missing from it, or missing from me, that prevents it from having the same impact.

  • @scottb.3905
    @scottb.3905 Год назад +60

    Man i remember feeling like I was crazy defending "Too much water" back in the day, it's a perfectly reasonable criticism of Hoenn as a region and that whole thing was peak gamers taking something out of context (ie just reading the blurb instead of the review) and running it into the dirt

    • @turkeyman631
      @turkeyman631 Год назад +2

      Lol it’s a water region tho I mean

    • @z.t.9491
      @z.t.9491 Год назад

      Not really cause it’s literally a tropical region though

    • @scottb.3905
      @scottb.3905 Год назад +15

      @@z.t.9491 It being themed tropically doesn't fix the problems that that design decision creates
      For like half the game, every wild Pokémon is water and every trainer used water Pokémon. It gets repetitive and tedious quickly and forces you to use certain pokemon or be at a disadvantage instead of properly diversifying your team (which is hard unless you like water pokemon). Not to mention travelling on wide open spaces of blue tiles isn't very interesting compared to the variation in designs you get in the rest of the game, AND of course every water tile can spawn a random encounter so you're just absolutely spamming repels the whole time. This wouldn't be too bad occasionally but the second half of the game is a constant barrage of water routes and running from wingulls.
      Hoenn was my generation growing up, and I love it dearly, but there being too much water is completely true. The real issue is that if they wanted that much water they needed to give it significantly more variety to make it interesting.

    • @poliorice3600
      @poliorice3600 Год назад

      The problem comes in that their original ruby and sapphire review that was not at all counted as a negative and the originals got a better score because of it

    • @joplin4434
      @joplin4434 Год назад +6

      @@poliorice3600 Expectations change in 15 years lmao

  • @Ethan-nl2wg
    @Ethan-nl2wg Год назад +65

    I don’t like IGN, but one thing I think is weird with people criticizing it, is that they think that everyone at IGN is a monolith or something, and they bring up multiple different bad reviews even tho they were reviewed by different people. We have to look at the reviewers individually, it’s like how people talk about rotten tomatoes as well, as if there’s like a council of people who collectively decide on a score

    • @saskay7046
      @saskay7046 Год назад +12

      Thats true, holding the reviewer accountable when it really isn't their fault isn't something that people should be doing. My only issue with the people who review the games is that some of them are obviously not interested in the games they review or they start comparing it to completely different games and use said comparison as the benchmark. For example, they did this with SMT and Persona 5.

    • @Ryleeman54number2
      @Ryleeman54number2 Год назад +5

      I dont really agree with this. Its a review meant to represent ign thats why its posted on their channel. They def need to have more then one person reviewing a game

    • @LegendsForever206
      @LegendsForever206 Год назад +3

      It doesn’t matter they still gave bad reviews

    • @grayfox6518
      @grayfox6518 Год назад

      IGN is a media company, a collective of people working toward the success and promotion of IGN. There's no standards they consistently practice, which has many believe that scores are propagated by paid promotion and bribery. They don't hire the right person for the job because it doesn't matter, they're getting paid for good reviews and not paid for games that receive low scores. If game reviews are motivated by paid promotion or identity politics, then the scores are predetermined and therefore deception.

    • @jmurray1110
      @jmurray1110 11 месяцев назад +2

      I mean putting unsuitable reviewers on projects is a flaw with IGN
      They don’t have a good enough understanding of there reviewers to assign them to appropriate projects and likely don’t have enough specialists for more niche genres tgat don’t appeal to the mainstream audience so you get shit like doom 2016 being reviewed like a battlefield game despite the game being designed like an old school PC boomer shooter with a focus on arcade style fun rather than more modern games preference for endjess multiplayer skinner boxes or console focused cover shooters

  • @bladefox5082
    @bladefox5082 Год назад +15

    He missed how the Unleashed reviewer was intentionally shit at the game 😭😭😭

  • @chrisray7728
    @chrisray7728 Год назад +15

    Playing Death Stranding feels like watching one of those weird art pieces directed and staring massively know Hollywood superstars where you know it’s “good” but you’d never actually watch it given the choice.

  • @Kidusrox
    @Kidusrox Год назад +76

    Crazy that some people in chat couldn't understand between a great game held back by flaws and a good game with no issues being both being 9/10. It's like every game has some kind of checklist of requirements to meet to be 10/10

    • @garrettpullen9740
      @garrettpullen9740 Год назад +6

      Yeah fr it’s not hard to comprehend. Games/movies/songs don’t reach a 10/10 because there are zero flaws. They reach that mark because you absolutely love them. Not having glaring flaws does not equate to loving a game to that extent. People with that viewpoint take out any subjectivity in a review and only look at the game on paper

    • @Ed95366
      @Ed95366 2 месяца назад +2

      ​@@garrettpullen9740 that is the issue that a lot of people don't seem to understand. You can't say a game is 9/10 with no flaws and don't give a reason as to why it's not a 10/10. You are either covering yourself so nobody can say you are wrong, you are too scared to voice your opinion, or you are unable to make a good review. Hell, you could say the game is dull, not enough ambition, too cut and dry, ANYTHING too justify being it a 9/10, but it's just people are unable to convey what they feel in words.

  • @liamcox9043
    @liamcox9043 Год назад +78

    This is a really interesting issue because game journalism does often seem to come from a place that is out of touch, but gamers are largely unable to voice their dissatisfaction with reviews in a specific or productive way. I think a rotten tomatoes-like approach where games have a critical score and an audience score might help with these kinds of issues.

    • @EbonMaster
      @EbonMaster Год назад +25

      I think a part of that is that voicing dissatisfaction in a reasonable, productive way feels like its typically ignored. Big, loud and explosive gets people heard on the internet.
      Also Metacritic has an audience score and its just as useless as the RT audience score for the most part lol

    • @joplin4434
      @joplin4434 Год назад +10

      >a rotten tomatoes-like approach where games have a critical score and an audience score
      That's just metacritic. Gamers still cry about it.

    • @Watburnt
      @Watburnt Год назад +1

      Metacritic exists but people still throw a fit there's no pleasing people they will hate you for not liking there game

  • @MemerTheMemer
    @MemerTheMemer Год назад +35

    I thought this was gonna be an Onlyonehere metacritic video.

    • @melk4417
      @melk4417 Год назад +6

      Onlyonehere is the only critic I believe in

  • @Three_ZE
    @Three_ZE Год назад +22

    So happy this became a video, watching it live was hilarious

  • @darkknightgamer123
    @darkknightgamer123 Год назад +19

    "What did she mean by this?" < "WOT ON URTH IS SHE BLATHERING ABOUT"

  • @cbass2238
    @cbass2238 Год назад +13

    A 9/10 game is like a very well-written school essay that follows the instructions to a tee. “Minimum of 5 pages”? It’s exactly 5 pages long. “Must have at least 3 sources”? It has exactly 3 sources. There’s nothing wrong with it, but it could’ve been so much more.

  • @saigesmart4167
    @saigesmart4167 Год назад +13

    The problem with pokemon sword and shield wasnt that it didnt have all the pokemon, its that they explained they wouldn't put them all in because it was going to take too much time/resources with making the new ones and updating old ones. So you'd expect the pokemon actually in the game to be like looking good right? NOPE, THEY REUSED 3D MODELS AND LIED ABOUT IT. So basically their explanation didn't make any sense, they were already porting stuff in, no reason to not do it for everyone or say its for the "meta" instead of outright lying. I would have been fine with saying they wanted to encourage a healthy competitive meta, which they did a good job with. But yeah, when people got the game and investigated the models and discovered the nodes (i think thats the term for the 3D points) were all the same as older 3D gens, I at least, was livid

  • @epicsause21
    @epicsause21 Год назад +4

    I remember in around 2008 my 4th grade teacher was explaining how language is constantly changing and he said that "gamer" is now a word.

  • @mettatonex7221
    @mettatonex7221 Год назад +33

    Look, I do think that SMT is inferior to Persona, but I also think it's ridiculous for anybody to criticize SMTV for not being enough like Persona 5. First off, expecting anything to be as good as Persona 5 besides maybe another Persona game is setting yourself up for disappointment, but more importantly, the two franchises split off in the first place because they were going for different vibes and focuses.

    • @bureahuwaito
      @bureahuwaito Год назад +14

      Your last point is exactly why people hate the comparison between the two. In my experience, SMT is way more focused on the difficulty in battles and strategy in using demons while Persona is more story and character focused. Disliking SMT for having a lacking story is fine, but giving Persona a pass on it's difficulty is a double standard

    • @GIRru11
      @GIRru11 Год назад +3

      That's the disappointing and annoying thing about anyone talking about Persona. It's gotten to the point where every RPG is being compared to Persona 5 which makes it impossible for any RPG game to stand out. Especially if it has any kind of school setting, they automatically expect it to have a dating Sim like Persona

    • @saskay7046
      @saskay7046 Год назад

      Exactly, they are two very different franchises. SMT is way more focused on the battles and the strategy you use while Persona has the benefit of having an overarching story and activities and ways to level up rather than just the battles. The fact that a bunch of people and that IGN reporter compared the two is just obnoxiously ignorant.

    • @DigiNiverg
      @DigiNiverg Год назад +3

      There's other persona games and other main line smy games that are better than 5

    • @Junya01
      @Junya01 Год назад

      Tried getting into p5 a few years after playing P4G and it being my fave single player game of all time. After 50 hours I couldn’t get into it - the UI is nice but really hurt and strained my eyes half an hour into a play sesh, the writing was not up to par with P4G and the characters were just real cringe. The dungeon design and music were pretty banger tho, maybe I’ll give P5R a try one of these days

  • @DumbIdeaPresentedStupidly
    @DumbIdeaPresentedStupidly Год назад +26

    I get annoyed when people talk about reviews like there is just some mathematical equation that just says how good a game is. People also care wayy too much on how good a game is
    Also there are multiple people at ign, it is dumb to say "THEY GAVE THIS A HIGHER SCORE THAN THAT" when there are two reviews by two different people

    • @TheDukeofCheese12
      @TheDukeofCheese12 Год назад

      I feel the same way about a site like Pitchfork for album reviews
      It's just one guy reviewing it. It's not like it's imperative to the rest of the site or anything.

    • @LegendsForever206
      @LegendsForever206 Год назад

      What so people aren’t supposed to care if the game is good or bad is that it?

    • @LegendsForever206
      @LegendsForever206 Год назад

      It doesn’t matter who did the review it is still a shit review.

    • @DumbIdeaPresentedStupidly
      @DumbIdeaPresentedStupidly Год назад +2

      @@LegendsForever206 Good or bad can not easily be reduced to number tho

  • @wienerschnitzel1739
    @wienerschnitzel1739 Год назад +4

    I’ll stand by the fact that ORAS did in fact have “too much water”
    I don’t know why they phrased it like that, but there are too many water routes and too many water Pokémon in the game

  • @jayceallen6530
    @jayceallen6530 Год назад +7

    I will never not be salty over the ign sonic unleashed review

  • @Vastspartan
    @Vastspartan Год назад +2

    Coney, woman who play softball do not engorge to man levels of thickness. That butch woman was hitting the juice

  • @the_godbodor7026
    @the_godbodor7026 Год назад +4

    Alright, IGN giving Alien Isolation a 5.0 really hurts me. That game is absolutely amazing and a 5.0 is way too low

  • @mropti6350
    @mropti6350 2 месяца назад +1

    2:00 One year later, Coney would indeed find out that Sonic fans do in fact go crazy

  • @guywithaguitar8521
    @guywithaguitar8521 Год назад +7

    Coney laughing at britishisms for 22 minutes. i love it man

  • @CaptainFalcon333
    @CaptainFalcon333 Год назад +3

    10:16 That doesn't make Pokémon change. Kids will still buy it, and they likely won't notice why people hate some games or "features" included in them.
    The competitive mad scientists will *always* buy the game. Likely even both versions to guarantee access to every Pokémon and ability to trade with themselves before end-game.

    • @joplin4434
      @joplin4434 Год назад +1

      >The competitive mad scientists will always buy the game. Likely even both versions to guarantee access to every Pokémon and ability to trade with themselves before end-game.
      This is just wrong lol competitive pokemon is divided between people who don't really bother with the games and play on simulators and the ones who play official nintendo tournaments in which case they do build teams in game but no one really cares about having mons or abilities for the single player mode lol
      The "competitive" side of single player is in nuzlockes or mods that increase the difficulty of the game, as without self imposed challenges the games are very easy (kids need to be able to beat it)

  • @LostApotheosis
    @LostApotheosis 3 месяца назад

    I unironically adore death stranding. There's something so soothing and melancholy about it's meandering pace, muted colors, soundtrack, and bright yellow traversal aids placed by others that make your trek a little easier. The problem is that I wouldn't really call it a game in a classical sense. If I was trying to sell it to someone, I would sell it as an experience. That being said, it's one I find myself returning to often when I feel worn down and need a moment of decisive quiet.

  • @Xearrik
    @Xearrik Год назад +3

    Gamer isn't a weird word. Video games are an extremely new hobby by humanity's standards and hobbies have enthusiast names, so people invented one for gaming naturally. That's how language works.
    For example, book lovers/collectors are called bibliophiles.

  • @goldencyclone4984
    @goldencyclone4984 Год назад +4

    On the SMT 5 review... Even if we assume that the intro about being Persona's edgy little sibling is a joke, that was probably the dumbest joke to make in this context. Persona being wildly more popular than its parent series is a *huge* sore spot for SMT fans and choosing to lead off with that was poking the hornets' nest on purpose.

    • @kyx5631
      @kyx5631 Год назад +2

      To be honest, I don't know how and why you would care about popularity for a single player game. Just take the game and enjoy it? Who cares that another series is more popular (even if it is related)?

    • @joplin4434
      @joplin4434 Год назад

      @@kyx5631 lack of an identity means latching on to their purchising habits to compensate. See also console wars, dub vs sub, ship wars and many many more pointless things people argue about
      The companies promote this as it increases consumer-brand identification leading to increased sales and free marketing.

    • @goldencyclone4984
      @goldencyclone4984 Год назад +1

      @@kyx5631 I mean... More popularity means a bigger likelihood of the game/franchise getting more games. SMT is a mechanically more intense and in depth series than its spinoff and there are people who prefer that, so they want SMT to have more exposure and thus more incentive for Sega and Atlus to put out more entries.

  • @BubbaBrons
    @BubbaBrons Год назад +2

    I mean, to be fair, the water was lowkey mad annoying in Hoenn lol

    • @Loner098
      @Loner098 8 месяцев назад

      And what about Alola?

  • @TomWeez
    @TomWeez Год назад +4

    This guy sounds like the most British British guy in Britain

  • @blauserum
    @blauserum Год назад +7

    My favorite part of the video was when Coney said "It's gaming time" and gamed all over everyone

  • @godzilladude
    @godzilladude Год назад +2

    That originally video feels so nostalgic lnao

  • @nyami2381
    @nyami2381 Год назад +1

    I remember when IGN complained that Super Mario 3D world's rerelease was worse than the original, even though it was a port that added stuff. Main thing that I remember being so dumb was when they complained about CHARACTER DIVERSITY which is hilarious just because of how stupid it is.

  • @NovaSolarsis835
    @NovaSolarsis835 Год назад +5

    Its not on the list but Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Explorers of Sky might have the one of worst like to dislike ratios. 700 likes and 10k dislikes. Obviously they didn't beat the first dungeon lol

    • @sladevalen2120
      @sladevalen2120 Год назад

      To be fair I'm one of those people. I think I was in the second dungeon and I got crit one shot by a starly about 3 steps into the dungeon and never looked back

    • @blackbluem1210
      @blackbluem1210 Год назад +8

      @@sladevalen2120 skill issue

    • @Jaydakin
      @Jaydakin Год назад

      They criticized it for not having new content when they didn’t play long enough to see the new content

  • @cagethelonewolf
    @cagethelonewolf 2 месяца назад +1

    he is spitting tho, they get people who don't enjoy the game series or completely biased to other games, you wouldn't get a fps fantic to
    play death standing and expect a decent review

    • @SharkSandwich-115
      @SharkSandwich-115 2 месяца назад

      Well there’s your problem, you are expecting Triple A suck offs to comprehend that there’s no such thing as a game for everyone and that’s a good thing.

    • @cagethelonewolf
      @cagethelonewolf 2 месяца назад

      @@SharkSandwich-115 you're a idiot, you don't get the Minecraft player to review forziza they don't know what makes a good racing game they play fucking Minecraft

  • @lionzcrown1702
    @lionzcrown1702 Год назад +7

    I mean that last sentence they said regarding fragility is amazingly true for last of us 2. You can hate the direction the writing too, but it was still amazingly written in that direction.

    • @turkeyman631
      @turkeyman631 Год назад +2

      I mean if you hate the direction of the writing you’re not going to see it as amazingly written. Can’t really blame them for not being able to kill the person that was beloved to Last of Us fans lol.

    • @lionzcrown1702
      @lionzcrown1702 Год назад +1

      @@turkeyman631 hard disagree. I acknowledge that halo 1-3 are amazing games though I personally don’t like them. Anyone who takes their head out of the own personal preference can give credit where it’s do. I think the game is fantastically written. It just isn’t the story people wanted written, which I get. Part of me agrees. But I have to appreciate that it’s that feeling that makes it an achievement. That’s the essence of the game. It ain’t fair, your preference isn’t the reality of the world. Game was split in half. Divisive in its essence, even the games theme it it’s divisiveness in characters reflected even the players, and that’s intentionally. If that makes sense, the reaction was desired by design and they succeeded. That being said I will always wish I could have a spin off where I can watch their relationship build, Joel and Ellie, like I thought I was getting but I def truly appreciated the darkness of what we got

    • @saskay7046
      @saskay7046 Год назад +1

      Hard disagree, they could've taken the writing in so many different directions, but they chose one of the worst ways to handle the story imo. For reference, from how they handled the beginning of the game to Joel's death to playing with Abby, it all felt..... unenjoyable. The way that Joel dies does subvert expectations yeah, but not in a meaningful way. When Joel dies, it comes out of nowhere and takes you by surprise, and after, you're just sitting there grieving and trying to hold it together until you suddenly switch characters and are playing as the same person who killed Joel. That interaction alone is one of the main reasons why people hated Abby and said this game was bad. You don't have time to reconcile with his death, the death is only present for the shock factor, and once you get to play as Abby, your hate and anger are still present, and trying to enjoy the game afterward just becomes tedious and disingenuous.

    • @Loner098
      @Loner098 8 месяцев назад

      Don't feel bad. The Last of Us: Part 2 wasn't as bold of a sequel as Chrono Cross anyway.

  • @bogusWasHere
    @bogusWasHere Год назад +3

    no way coney read my message in a youtube video im literally crying

  • @jekfrumstotferm9830
    @jekfrumstotferm9830 Месяц назад

    The weakness of a game’s cons is not the same as the strength of its pros. If they were, then hot dog buns would be a universal 10/10 food.

  • @Bonecrusher1022
    @Bonecrusher1022 Год назад +5

    I know Sonic posting but on the topic of remakes/re-releases hear me out. I remember when Sonic Adventure came out on 360/PS3, IGN gave it like a 3/10. I won't deny it's aged poorly but a 3???

  • @rodzz3833
    @rodzz3833 Год назад +3

    I've never been this close to being on IGN's side

  • @XanderW7381
    @XanderW7381 Год назад +2

    Idk if any of those reviews are as bad as the xenoblade definitive edition one where they got the names of main characters wrong

  • @tyrelllowery2074
    @tyrelllowery2074 Год назад

    Gotta love it when Coney puts out a vid on my birthday. Thanks for the present bro!

  • @Phentem2
    @Phentem2 Год назад +8

    OnlyOneHere should be the only reviewer that we should trust

  • @abdi212
    @abdi212 Год назад +5

    Hello conogla bologna, thanks for the hard working content you put our every day. Uhh I don't have a good comment I just wanted to say conogna bologna

  • @esrohm6460
    @esrohm6460 Год назад +25

    this video lost all credibility when something with a better ratio was rated as more disliked. with that logic basically every high traffic music video on the platform is more hatted than these games because when thousand times the people watch the video. you just need 1 million likes+dislikes to make something extremely liked like 95% approval to 50k dislikes to get number 3 on the most hated ign review list

    • @kyx5631
      @kyx5631 Год назад +2

      Semantics and content.
      It's also way easier to research - just sort by dislikes. Otherwise you would have to check even the super-low-traffic videos, which takes longer, and need to put in some disclaimers where you draw the line. This here is straightforward, crystal clear counting.
      That said, I would have appreciated a more nuanced approach.

    • @esrohm6460
      @esrohm6460 Год назад +2

      @@kyx5631 i mean i don't expect the perfect 100% answer but don't put the video with a 50% dislike ratio in the same rank as the one with an 80% especially if it's number 2. it just stares at you and says i have no idea why i'm here

    • @saskay7046
      @saskay7046 Год назад

      That's just arguing semantics at that point, also it's easier.

    • @daniell5740
      @daniell5740 Год назад

      “Lost credibility” you gonna cry

    • @LegendsForever206
      @LegendsForever206 Год назад

      Why you whining?

  • @yggdrasilsaltar
    @yggdrasilsaltar Год назад +3

    what do you think an OnlyOneHere review of coney’s channel be like

  • @DPXSolo
    @DPXSolo Год назад

    Holy shit, I actually just watched this list today! What insane timing!

  • @Dayashii
    @Dayashii Год назад +1

    You know looking back at bo3 it really does feel like a good 8.7/10 just for the zombies alone. Aswell as having workshop

    • @freedfg6694
      @freedfg6694 Год назад

      It's also just an awesome game. Yeah the campaign is bad. But we've accepted that out of call of duty. It just got massive hate because the internet had/has a huge hate boner for movement mechanics for some reason. The "Boots on the ground" movement might have been the biggest chop block of the games industry since "People don't enjoy single player experiences"

    • @Dayashii
      @Dayashii Год назад

      @@freedfg6694 the campaign’s narrative was interesting but did not continue after bo2

  • @b-sha2744
    @b-sha2744 16 дней назад

    I still say, for as much as Sword and Shield get disliked into the Earth's core. I had fun with it and every once in awhile I like to boot it up and try another challenge idea with it. I especially like the dlc and what it added to the game. Being able to gain a free, overleveled pokemon by just going through the roguelike dungeon will never not be a great thing that makes any solo type run I tried easy to do without having to make rulings like "Oh I'll use this pokemon as an honorary x type till I get said pokemon type later on"

  • @gechoman44iwantahippo
    @gechoman44iwantahippo Год назад +1

    Personally, I have no problem with giving something a 9/10 with no issues. Personally, I never rate anything a 10/10 unless it is one of my favorite games/movies/shows, or if it is just such a good product that it blows every other option out of the water.

  • @duhve
    @duhve Год назад +1

    The too much water review is a meme but in my opinion, the most infamous pokemon IGN review is Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky.
    The reviewer gave it a lower score (4.8 iirc) than darkness or time and only played up to apple woods (like 1/8 of the game)
    Explorers of sky, one of the best pokemon games of all time, is a 4.8/10 according to IGN.

  • @nintenx1235
    @nintenx1235 Год назад +1

    SMTV was honestly the weakest in terms of story. Over explained (10+ minute text dumps) and rushed character arcs. SMTIV is still the best game in the franchise followed by devil survivor and P5R.
    I've warmed up to it as it's gameplay was really good but it's story was just a really bad nothing-burger.
    I prefer demons being tools you have to eventually fuse or they'll get weak and drag you down, but having a team of any demon at lv99 to kill Lucifer was really fun.

  • @baddealdude807
    @baddealdude807 Год назад +7

    this guy seems to not understand that IGN has many different reviewers that don't share the same opinions

  • @byrontheusurper6505
    @byrontheusurper6505 Год назад +1

    Ok the bike thing is kinda cute in context

  • @aizunaizu6755
    @aizunaizu6755 Год назад +1

    my least favorite is the IGN LEGO Batman review

  • @anametoignore2286
    @anametoignore2286 3 дня назад

    I love how he keeps bringing up game reviews from likely different reviewers and in completely different genres "IGN gave alien isolation blah but goat simulator an 8"
    Yeah apparently

  • @byrontheusurper6505
    @byrontheusurper6505 Год назад +1

    Yeah death stranding is weird but might be cool to dive into

  • @v1rtuosoviolinist
    @v1rtuosoviolinist Год назад

    oh my god what's the song at the start i love it

  • @SharkSandwich-115
    @SharkSandwich-115 2 месяца назад

    14:19 Wow its almost like the best horror games are the ones with slow build up before reaching their climax after the introduction ends. Yeah sorry man, but power fantasy doesn’t work with genres of video games that are trying to prioritize “HORROR”! Here’s my advice, take a break from TikTok so that your attention span can regenerate.

  • @danielvan12
    @danielvan12 10 месяцев назад

    For me personally a 9/10 and a 10/10 are basically the same in terms of quality and/or enjoyment; it’s just that a 10/10 is saved for games that I have like a strong emotional connection to or one that I always think about.

  • @phypesmash6154
    @phypesmash6154 Год назад +2

    >Watching/reading game reviews
    Lol

  • @sharlockshacolmes9381
    @sharlockshacolmes9381 Год назад

    "Last of us? ... Aaaaaah" is probably my favourite line in any video on this website

  • @john4786
    @john4786 Год назад

    It’s kinda like music with the no cons by 10/10 thing. I liked every song in that new babytron album but there’s no way it’s perfect

  • @Gohka
    @Gohka Год назад +2

    As a Brit I'm not sure how I feel with Coney's chat literally going on and on about his accent from the moment the video started right through to the end lol.

    • @1mrcow143
      @1mrcow143 Год назад

      As an American I kinda like the British accent and especially Australian accents.

  • @yupjuliansje
    @yupjuliansje Год назад

    I fking love how unapologetic the guy reviewing the reviews are, I can't take it seriously and it just makes me laugh and sometimes that's just what I need.

  • @Kugabare
    @Kugabare Год назад +3

    Wooo! 🎉 New Coney upload ♥️

  • @clintwaki6936
    @clintwaki6936 Год назад +1

    All I know is that SMT fans are always seething about something and super elitist for like no reason.

    • @athorem
      @athorem Год назад

      100% correct

  • @ackyducc5040
    @ackyducc5040 Год назад

    Not only are there 9/10s with no flaws, I would also argue that there are 10/10s with flaws.
    Skyrim is my favorite game ever and is easily a 10/10 in my book, but I could go on and on about everything wrong with it.
    It absolutely has flaws, but I still had an amazing time with it. How much you enjoy something should not be boiled down to pros vs cons, it should just be how much you enjoy it. If any flaw keeps a game from being a 10/10, then there would be 9/10 games i like more than 10/10 games.

  • @IONProd
    @IONProd Год назад

    8:27 if it's late game just buy repels or use fly...

  • @angryii5411
    @angryii5411 Год назад +3

    Death Stranding go crazy

    • @Chilled_
      @Chilled_ Год назад +2

      Literal worst take of the vid, DS so _coomfy_ how can you hate it?

    • @angryii5411
      @angryii5411 Год назад +2

      @@Chilled_ catch me building zipline highways in the rockies whippin it like Ride w/ Norman Reedus

  • @erainmartinez8175
    @erainmartinez8175 Год назад +1

    I like it 18:00

  • @angelor9211
    @angelor9211 Год назад +7

    The weirdest guys are always the ones that go in-depth about these small details nobody cares about

  • @byrontheusurper6505
    @byrontheusurper6505 Год назад +1

    There's a spyro remake?

  • @freedfg6694
    @freedfg6694 Год назад

    Man. The absolute shitshow that was the piggybacked hate on CoD BlOps 3. One of the legitimately best call of duty in YEARS. But gamers hate innovation and couldn't stand that they didn't get their EA Sports edition Modern Warfare 20. Well are they happy now?

  • @SilharaTheChosen
    @SilharaTheChosen Год назад +2

    I will never stop laughing at Americans making fun of other people's accents. Never. The irony is too good.

  • @FlorianHeart
    @FlorianHeart Год назад

    I need to watch the vod cause we're missing a game

  • @SkribbleNL
    @SkribbleNL Год назад

    Loved the ssx remake but I was cracked at SSX might be the most cracked I've ever been in a game. Although I do get the haters the funkyness was gone but it was pretty intouch with the more current snowboard vibe of big mountain.

  • @daseancedoesgeek2667
    @daseancedoesgeek2667 Год назад +2

    Ol machinma RUclips era ass video 😂

  • @nathanielhertsel4453
    @nathanielhertsel4453 Год назад +1

    Yoooo, Coney!
    I love WatchConey

  • @byrontheusurper6505
    @byrontheusurper6505 Год назад +3

    Shin megami tensei 5 looks good as hell

  • @treedude4246
    @treedude4246 Год назад

    15:28 I mean I respect death stranding just for how balls to the wall WEIRD it is but you can do weird and still be fun (look at yoko taro) so i dont think its good but I do think its interesting

  • @madnessarcade7447
    @madnessarcade7447 Год назад

    Not every Pokémon is in the game because they wanted the Pokémon habitats to be accurate to similar animals that would live there irl

  • @BrianDeBrain_
    @BrianDeBrain_ Год назад

    Banjo and Kazooie Nuts & Bolts is actually a very good game, but it shouldn't have used the Banjo & Kazooie title.

  • @Omeg1
    @Omeg1 Год назад +1

    This video really is a great reacting video great minds think alike

  • @Goose_was_taken
    @Goose_was_taken Год назад

    Choo Choo Charles would probably be high up there

  • @byrontheusurper6505
    @byrontheusurper6505 Год назад +1

    I still need a spectrobes remake, those games FUCK! Disney sucks for keeping that banger franchise under lock and key!

  • @AshArtzMusic
    @AshArtzMusic Год назад

    Gotta love new coney video and lunch

  • @byrontheusurper6505
    @byrontheusurper6505 Год назад +1

    Oh my god I love ORAS so much. But yeah hoenn is a lot of water

  • @micahbarrus8406
    @micahbarrus8406 Год назад

    Xenoblade fans have had bad reviews going back to saga, but I believe IGN has a pretty bad one of the original Xenoblade where several important characters' names are wrong (like dunban became Duncan), major spoilers are shown, and the person talking is grating to listen to.

  • @ashlynx1
    @ashlynx1 Год назад

    As a postman myself, I really enjoyed Death Stranding