If you don’t mind never having an orgasm again, constant infections, bowel and bladder issues, being chained to constant upkeep and hormones…. sure, it’s a great surgery for everybody 18 and up.
The brain doesnt "finish" developing until around the age of 27ish. And I can tell you, as a 44yo I still feel like I change all the time. I grow, and learn, and change views and get new ones...I dont even have tattoos because 5yrs down the road, I may not want it. Its too serious of a decision to be made by children. period.
I definitely believe people should wait to get surgery until they are at least 18 years old. Many times children and teens rush into things without doing enough research or even understanding what will happen after they do get the surgery. Also children and teens are heavily influenced by what they think is popular at the time and this means more then likely making bad decisions. So it's best to wait and do all ur research before hand and understanding all the risk involved
My opinion is children shouldn’t be on HRT, blockers or be given surgery. I think 18 is still too young. I also agree with you, I didn’t feel like an adult until 24/25 and I’m 27 now. 18 is technically an adult but it’s still so young. 18 you are barely out of high school. I’m so glad to see that someone who identifies as “non-binary” holds these opinions. I think you are brilliant for waiting to get a double mastectomy. I think you are brave for taking this stance, the Trans community can be absolutely ruthless. Much love ❤ Also want to make it clear that I don’t care what grown adults do with their bodies.
For me I came out a couple of months ago. I’m gender-fluid and I’m 35 years old. But I have kinda always knew that I was different from a young age however I don’t think that I wouldn’t have been able to make a proper decision about it until I was older. And for years I kinda just did wanted to do as far as presentation goes. So I wouldn’t be changing anything in that regard which is nice. And now I trying to get top surgery for my gender dysphoria. Until then I have started to bind. Which has helped a lot.
lol technically yes. I know you're just being a jackass, but yes, a handful of medical professionals believe that the desire for healthy limb amputation is symptomatic of a mental disorder that can be treated only by amputation, there is currently no consensus on what causes a person to desire such a disabling intervention.
@@JustTheLetterK with that being said, I am no jackass. I am half cat and half leprechaun ,the fact that you miss gingering me is very offensive . I must cry about it on tictok now
I knew at a young age that I wanted to do hormones but I waited till I was 21 make sure that I wanted to do it I don't think people under 18 should transition I rember being in high-school the younger kids where identifying as bikes and unicorns
I don't like to say "kids don't know what they want." But I will say that as they grow, what they want can certainly change and that's the critical part. When I was a kid I was absolutely sure I didn't want a family or kids of my own. Fast-forward 7 or 8 years and now I do want a family. There's been plenty of things about me that haven't changed since that time. But there's also been plenty of things that have. I used to not care about having a good TV or having a good pair of headphones. Now I do. I gained a stronger appreciation for good sound and video. What you want can change and there's almost no telling what will change. Luckily for me, not wanting kids when I was younger didn't damage my ability to have them now that I do want them. But for some things, that's not the case. Some choices you can't come back from. Some histories cannot be unwritten.
People who think kids really know what they feel when they change their opinions and minds so quickly after, as a kid I loved and still love feminine clothing/things I wear makeup now, I thought I was a girl when I was younger which was around the 2006-007 where myspace still was alive I was born in 2000 but that wasn't in my head after let kids be kids let them try new things, toys and stuff to want to play with, don't change their body because they say "oh I feel like a girl" I know not all change and still do feel the same way but I agree with you kids should be kids, I don't know what it's like to have dysphoria or things like it I wish I could understand but yea
Well they don't have surgery until 16-18, depending on the state, and hormones don't get be given until 16-18+, they least kids are getting, are hormone blockers. And that just blocks puberty from happening until they know what they wanna do and if the kid stops the blockers then their normal puberty will start. Kids who say they don't feel like the gender needs at least therapy and hormone blockers I believe
i respectfully disagree with your opinion (as a nonbinary 28 year old who's been unable to have surgery or hormones due to medical complications) but i appreciate that you brought this to my attention!
@@KtheScreamerOfficial the fact of the matter is i live in florida too, so this is deeply personal to me i didn't realize i was nonbinary until around the start of 2022, so i can't speak for people who realized as kids, but i can speak for the feeling of being held back from transitioning, because of other medical factors. the problem is surgery and hormones would be too risky. i'm well aware that may be causing me to be biased, and i mostly commented to help with the youtube algorithm, but i would like people to understand where my sentiment is coming from as well.
I agree with you K. No disrespect to any other opinions but i feel like the age 18 you make wiser decisions and have more of a sense that you actually want to fallow through with how you feel/or identify as. I am 26 years old and still learning about the LBGT+ community. But this information is helping understand so much
Minors can't get surgery and rarely get hormones but therapy and puberty blockers can be life saving. Blockers are completely reversible and can help a child feel more comfortable in their skin.
If you don’t mind never having an orgasm again, constant infections, bowel and bladder issues, being chained to constant upkeep and hormones…. sure, it’s a great surgery for everybody 18 and up.
The brain doesnt "finish" developing until around the age of 27ish. And I can tell you, as a 44yo I still feel like I change all the time. I grow, and learn, and change views and get new ones...I dont even have tattoos because 5yrs down the road, I may not want it. Its too serious of a decision to be made by children. period.
I agree with that. Minors shouldn’t transition until they are 18. At the very least.
1000%
I definitely believe people should wait to get surgery until they are at least 18 years old. Many times children and teens rush into things without doing enough research or even understanding what will happen after they do get the surgery. Also children and teens are heavily influenced by what they think is popular at the time and this means more then likely making bad decisions.
So it's best to wait and do all ur research before hand and understanding all the risk involved
My opinion is children shouldn’t be on HRT, blockers or be given surgery. I think 18 is still too young. I also agree with you, I didn’t feel like an adult until 24/25 and I’m 27 now.
18 is technically an adult but it’s still so young. 18 you are barely out of high school.
I’m so glad to see that someone who identifies as “non-binary” holds these opinions. I think you are brilliant for waiting to get a double mastectomy.
I think you are brave for taking this stance, the Trans community can be absolutely ruthless.
Much love ❤
Also want to make it clear that I don’t care what grown adults do with their bodies.
For me I came out a couple of months ago. I’m gender-fluid and I’m 35 years old. But I have kinda always knew that I was different from a young age however I don’t think that I wouldn’t have been able to make a proper decision about it until I was older. And for years I kinda just did wanted to do as far as presentation goes. So I wouldn’t be changing anything in that regard which is nice. And now I trying to get top surgery for my gender dysphoria. Until then I have started to bind. Which has helped a lot.
You think the doctor will cut off my right arm? Because I feel like a one arm person
lol technically yes. I know you're just being a jackass, but yes, a handful of medical professionals believe that the desire for healthy limb amputation is symptomatic of a mental disorder that can be treated only by amputation, there is currently no consensus on what causes a person to desire such a disabling intervention.
@@JustTheLetterK You can pretty much “treat” any desire by giving the person what they want.
@@JustTheLetterK with that being said, I am no jackass. I am half cat and half leprechaun ,the fact that you miss gingering me is very offensive . I must cry about it on tictok now
I knew at a young age that I wanted to do hormones but I waited till I was 21 make sure that I wanted to do it I don't think people under 18 should transition I rember being in high-school the younger kids where identifying as bikes and unicorns
I don't like to say "kids don't know what they want." But I will say that as they grow, what they want can certainly change and that's the critical part.
When I was a kid I was absolutely sure I didn't want a family or kids of my own. Fast-forward 7 or 8 years and now I do want a family. There's been plenty of things about me that haven't changed since that time. But there's also been plenty of things that have. I used to not care about having a good TV or having a good pair of headphones. Now I do. I gained a stronger appreciation for good sound and video. What you want can change and there's almost no telling what will change.
Luckily for me, not wanting kids when I was younger didn't damage my ability to have them now that I do want them. But for some things, that's not the case. Some choices you can't come back from. Some histories cannot be unwritten.
Exactly. A child’s mine doesn’t have the ability to critically weigh their choices like an adult.
People who think kids really know what they feel when they change their opinions and minds so quickly after, as a kid I loved and still love feminine clothing/things I wear makeup now, I thought I was a girl when I was younger which was around the 2006-007 where myspace still was alive I was born in 2000 but that wasn't in my head after let kids be kids let them try new things, toys and stuff to want to play with, don't change their body because they say "oh I feel like a girl" I know not all change and still do feel the same way but I agree with you kids should be kids, I don't know what it's like to have dysphoria or things like it I wish I could understand but yea
Well they don't have surgery until 16-18, depending on the state, and hormones don't get be given until 16-18+, they least kids are getting, are hormone blockers. And that just blocks puberty from happening until they know what they wanna do and if the kid stops the blockers then their normal puberty will start. Kids who say they don't feel like the gender needs at least therapy and hormone blockers I believe
Well done Florida
Honestly ... GOOD this trans crap is going too far.
Florida didn’t get this done in time to save poor Jazz Jennings from her munchausen’s mama. 😢
The clinics will stop offering it to minors soon anyway. Too many lawsuits now from destransitioners. They cannot consent legally
yess i really agree, and the human brain isn´t fully developed before the age of 21
i respectfully disagree with your opinion (as a nonbinary 28 year old who's been unable to have surgery or hormones due to medical complications) but i appreciate that you brought this to my attention!
Totally fine to disagree! I knew people would
@@KtheScreamerOfficial the fact of the matter is i live in florida too, so this is deeply personal to me
i didn't realize i was nonbinary until around the start of 2022, so i can't speak for people who realized as kids, but i can speak for the feeling of being held back from transitioning, because of other medical factors. the problem is surgery and hormones would be too risky.
i'm well aware that may be causing me to be biased, and i mostly commented to help with the youtube algorithm, but i would like people to understand where my sentiment is coming from as well.
Oh absolutely! I value your perspective so much! It's good to hear from all sorts of people. Thank you so much for taking the time to comment.
Could I ask why you disagree with this stance?
Seems entirely sensible........
Good news for kids.
I agree with you K. No disrespect to any other opinions but i feel like the age 18 you make wiser decisions and have more of a sense that you actually want to fallow through with how you feel/or identify as. I am 26 years old and still learning about the LBGT+ community. But this information is helping understand so much
We all were uncomfortable with our bodies as teens. Stop butchering kids
Hopefully all the other states will follow suit! It’s absolutely ridiculous to let these children transition!
Great news.
21
𝙥𝙧𝙤𝙢𝙤𝙨𝙢 🙌
Minors can't get surgery and rarely get hormones but therapy and puberty blockers can be life saving. Blockers are completely reversible and can help a child feel more comfortable in their skin.
They may be reversible, but you’ll need to be on some form of hormones forever, so they aren’t actually reversible.
@@JustTheLetterK I'm talking about puberty blockers not hormones
@@JustTheLetterK that's only if they have bottom surgery
They are not completely reversible at all. Delaying puberty includes emotional development, bone density etc.....absolutely not ok.
The FDA actually had to release a warning because puberty blockers being used off-label have caused brain swelling and other serious complications.
good