Nazism, Ideologies
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 апр 2024
- Dive into the depths of history as we explore the pervasive influence of Nazism in today's world. Join us in part one of our extensive journey to understand this debunked ideology.
INTRO TEXT/AD PLUG
→ Subscribe for new videos at least twice a week!
ruclips.net/user/biographics...
Love content? Check out Simon's other RUclips Channels:
MegaProjects: / @megaprojects9649
SideProjects: / @sideprojects
Casual Criminalist: / @thecasualcriminalist
Today I Found Out: / todayifoundout
Highlight History: / @highlighthistory
XPLRD: / @xplrd
Brain Blaze: / @brainblaze6526
Places: / @places302
Astrographics: / @astrographics-ve4yq
Simon's Social Media:
Twitter: / simonwhistler
Instagram: / simonwhistler
Credit to Simon and his team for putting on a video they knew damn well was going to be demonetized but we all wanted to see
I'll do you one better, all you said + also deciding to make it a 1h 40m video.
Quote: 'but we all wanted to see'
Between you and me there is no we. Speak for yourself!
I’ll be the other half of that “we”
He does a lot of in video ads
This is not the Taco Tuesday companion piece I was expecting.
"We'd say they were treated like animals, but that would be untrue. Animals actually had rights in Nazi Germany" what a chilling delivery. It hits like a truck.
Are you a middleaged woman?
@@saulspanco854 No? Why?
@@saulspanco854what a weird question to ask a stranger 💀
@@saulspanco854are you under 25?
@@Jackiee_Chann better question is whether he is under 12
I think Simon and the Warographics team deserve huge credit for being to tackle this topic head on in such an open way. Historical study should never be afraid of facing difficult subjects in the name of education. At the time of writing this comment, the video was still monetised, I hope it stays that way because I honestly believe we are on a path to repeat this very history and the more resources we have to remind ourselves of what we're trying to avoid, the better.
Lmao😂 tackle? Are we forgetting who runs the media and censorship? 😂😂😂 I doubt he's hitting any roadblocks in publishing what he wants brother😂😂😂 just spit balling
@@BeenGoldenBro, just saying nazi or Hitler is grounds for demonization. To the point that smaller channels have to come up with creative ways of talking about nazis. My favorite being, Bad Muststach Man, and his 30's German army. Making an entire video is basically saying take all my money for this video.
@@BeenGolden Yes, I absolutely mean that. As the other comment mentions; just mentioning that party or it's leader is likely to get a video automatically demonetised by the Algorithm, and everyone who has worked on this video does want to get paid... So do we juts ignore the past and the lessons it teaches or us, or pull our thumbs out of our asses and look at in depth, knowing it will not be comfortable or pleasant.
Plus I firmly believe we're in a period of history where we could quite easily repeat the events of nearly 100 years ago; the world is becoming more polarised, tribal, isolationist and nationalistic, which are the exact circumstances that led us to WWII, so yes it is extremely important we educate ourselves on what came before so we don't do the same dumb sh*t all over again.
And to do that, we have to be willing to look at how the Nazi's came to power, the words and phrasing they used to indoctrinate the population. If you look at what a look of leaders, politicians and activist/pressure groups are doing and saying, there are a shocking number of similarities.
For some reason I read the thumbnail as "Nazim" thinking this was gonna be about Skyrims greatest character
"Everything in the Cloud district, nothing outside the Cloud district, nothing against the Could district!"- Nazim.
Can't spell Nazim without Nazi
Lmao 🤣. The best character is the...?? They're all pretty useless. Conjuring 2 dremora lords is a bit of a power play.
I'm sure the video would have been shorter, and on a different channel. Probably.
His name is Nazeem though 😢
Heavy topic, definitely deserving of a lengthy video. I'm looking forward to it, Simon and team!
A lengthily video in Simon's case!
Love the recommendations for literature at the end, would instantly make that a standard procedure for all your more educational weighted videos.
Yeah, I’d love this feature added as well.
Wow, "Germany's Coca-Cola plants were more than happy to use slave labor". Certainly brings a new meaning to "Have a Coke, have a smile".
Not just Germany's.
@@tombrown407Russias? I guess it’d be Pepsi in this case
Any company would be more than happy to use slave labor seeing that slavery has always been motivated by economic factors.
Colombia.
@@ASlickNamedPimpback why russia? And many US companies use slave labour in the form of prison labour, many of which don’t get paid more than 3 dollars a day.
Truly, his hatred for modern art didn't have anything to do with him being rejected from our school, right?? Right???
The world may never know.
I mean, plenty of people who pass art school also hate modern art 😅
Not essentially, he is quite right about modern "art." His rejection is a tragedy because he would have been one of the best probable "counter-culture" figures against that degenerate art.
@@EarthForces dude you are using the same rhetoric as the Nazis about modern art. Art is subjective just because you don't like something doesn't mean that it is not art, or degenerate art.
And how is traditionalist would be counterculture. Yes the status quo of art world is the counterculture.
@DubhghlasMacDubhghlas if bifurcation is something you cannot grasp upon, thats your problem. As for me, there are things I can agree and disagree on someones worldview. Not everything labeled as "progressive" is correct and that also applies to the word "traditional." As for art, one can say it is a matter of "taste" and people can consider modern "art" as a degenerate and tasteless form of expression while not advocating for everything the nasties stood for.
This was eye opening. I knew it was bad, rabid ferret in your pants kinda bad. But thiswas genuinely intriguing and good lord... thank you simon and your writers, for this bit of information
Monarchism next please 👸👸
Would love a vid on it too
Oh then Communism!
@@drhapi5308 That would take far too long. Communist ideologies can be more different from each other that Fascism is from a Sweden style social democracy.
@@something1600 and all monarchies are the same? the HRE had the same social and political Dynamics as the Ming Dynasty and the Tudors?
Posadism
Considering the state of things in the world at the moment, and that many of the lessons learned have been forgotten, this is possibly the most important video you and the team have made to date. Thank you for making it.
Indeed
Free Palestine
It's a sad day when the oppressed become the oppressor
no its not, its completely bias as usual, the claim hitler was far right is partially true, but its also true he was very socialist in his economic approach.
third position,perhaps.
robert owen founded socialism not marx before some clown gets above themselves,
There are only 10,000 videos on RUclips alone about Germany during the N@zl era. people are lazy. All we need are a bunch of new experts on the subject since they watched a Simon video.. One can acquire historical knowledge that would surpass that of a damned history major if they utilized 1/1,000,000 of the information available here on YT. I can have very few conversations these days about historical matters, partly due to the youth U 30 not even knowing who G.Washington is. It's kind of sad that our kids aren't learning much. They are being Indoctrinated though, which will make them good little n@zl's when the dems get back in office. They didn't have enough time to implement in just 4 years the braindead one has had in office. It's coming though. And to all those who say BS, the only party & people who desire authoritarian control are on the left. Your rhetoric surrounding the orange person is a joke. The MSM, who knows that anyone that watches them gets all their opinions from them & are braindead, spreads the misinformation & watch the sheep eat it up. They love to tell people orange is bad, while they shill for & do the bidding for the elitist left!
Anyone who hasn't read Shirer's work on the Third Reich is missing out. Not only is the book itself (while massive) incredible, but the background on how it was written, and Shirer's experience (both directly and through access to primary source material) with the rise of Nazism is a fascinating tale in its own right.
While a good read, there's some serious source bias in the work where he relies too much on unverified personal accounts from those motivated to lie
I accidentally clicked on the notification… I am not disappointed
The PFP is surprisingly fitting
You're not disappointed, but your parents are
“Let us hope the RUclips censors are incapacitated”
Facts
As long as you don't tell the truth about this subject, the video will stay up. The amount of things from my playlists that have been deleted off yt is amazing. 10 year old videos are even targeted.
@Willy_Tepes please let me know what "truth" you refer to that the censors are trying to delete ?
@@Willy_Tepes good.
@@Willy_Tepeslololol seething since ‘45
This was very difficult to watch and I imagine even more difficult to write and read. Kudos to you guys. A very important exposition to the confusion surrounding the ideology and gives us the power to spot its early roots if they develop again.
The whole Maga alpha male schtick of trad life and the great replacement theory is the dressed up Lebensborn movement. The Maga movement and the Christian nationalists have project 2025, they're already planning all of this if they get back into power with a 2nd tRump term, they have the extreme court in their pocket already.
When the victim turns to committing genocide. The roots already developed again ironically it’s the Netanyahu zionist regime committing atrocities, blatant genocide and war crimes killing over 13.000 innocent children as of today, and a lot of other civilians who have nothing to do with “Hamas”. And don’t mind me i am not a arab im a full Dutch 🇳🇱 citizen. Open your eyes people war is everywhere, evil lurks around every cornerstone of the earth. Don’t let the propaganda fool you.
Please do communism next
Which type of communism: Stalinism, Leninism, Trotskyism, Titoism, Marxism, Anarchist communism?
@@something1600orthodox historical materialism
@@markostevanovic4119 what about Rosseauism?
We probably should be more specific. This video isn’t about fash-ism in general, after all, but a specific version.
Preferably Marxism in it's base form and maybe diving into the other ones to touch on how they affected the evolution of the ideology. Or they could eventually do a deep dive into each one but that's alot XD
Holy cow! Thanks for making a video you know will get demonitized. This is going to be an interesting one!
There was an easier way to sum up the intro question of if it's left/right: It's authoritarian, a quality than can be wielded regardless of alignment on the left/right spectrum and poses a danger all it's own. It's also possible for a party to claim it's one thing while being another, for example who takes seriously North Korea's claims that it's a democracy?
Well summed up: Nazism was left wing FOR INSIDER ARYANS. For the rest, it was wildly right wing
_"for example who takes seriously North Korea's claims that it's a democracy?"_
Well they certainly are more democratic than other socialist countries, like Cuba. At least in North Korea, people are allowed to vote and they hold elections in the first place. Neither are a thing in Cuba.
@@_Historia_Magistra_Vitae um.. ya double check that claim about NK. I mean Cuba, no idea, bhuuut..
@@myflippinggoodness8821 this guy is a blatant troll Cuba is a LOT more democratic than North Korea
@@myflippinggoodness8821truth
Acording to the defenition given, Soviet Russia was also far right, which only points to show how the dichotomy of left and right is just a tool for simplifying the complicated truth in a way that allows the speaker to deceive the listeners.
The best distinction for left vs right is anti-capitalism vs capitalism, in the same that it used to mean capitalism vs feudalism.
So is America too if they want a certain individual back in action. NO I'm not saying baby criminals but if you don't touch the roots you don't touch anything
@@edwardbateman3094
The problem is that most people don't know what capitalism is.
Anti-capitalism became a pretty good business model, reformation instead of revolution.
Soviets were right wing military pov, it’s military hypothetically at minimum influence a quarter of their economy. I view Soviet as left simply because at the end no matter state owned everything and that’s Communist.
Amen to this. The whole dichotomy is designed to subjugate people and is so squidgy to the point of being useless.
Can you do 3 additional videos in a series format? Communism (Soviet Union), an exploration of fascist beliefs in other countries, and an exploration of socialist beliefs in other countries? You're one of the few channels that I can trust to be impartial (or at least I trust that you work hard to be as impartial as you can be).
Fyi the ideology of the Soviet Union was called Marxism-Leninism
I'm sorry did you really just say you trust this channel to not be partial? Are you joking? This video itself has tons of issues. You should watch these as entertainment not viable scholarly research. Please stop using Wikipedia and find first hand sources if you're genuinely looking for information. These videos are for entertainment not information. Half of them have real factual problems with them including his videos on Pearl harbor and pretty much any of the world war II he even got one ship wrong and said it was sank and it wasn't.
Impartial but autocorrect is crap
communism isn’t fascist though…
@@theescoob8684Yeah, just it's gay lover.
Thanks for your dedication Simon and the team. You knew a video on this topic was going to get demonitised straight away, but put up an amazing educational piece anyway. Bravo.
"First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me"
…? They were socialists. Why would they come for those? 😂
Okay, explain how censoring Nazis is good.
@@Willy_Tepes Who cares what a Nazi has to say? You chose to identify with an inhuman ideology.
@@Willy_Tepes Who cares what a Nazi has to say?
@@Willy_Tepes Explain why Nazis should be allowed human rights when they deny them to others.
Oh wow, the Russian trolls are here in force now
If they actually watched the video, the Russians would find the content to be familiar.
And they would deny objective historical fact when you tell them their precious USSR made a pact with the Nazi's to invade Poland lmao, so the Ruzzians really do have more in common with Nazis than they'd like to admit
@@vivecald-vehk6978 Russian ideology worst than nazi because it's pure practical authoritarian ideology, what been alive among thousand years from Moskau captured by mongolian horde
@@vivecald-vehk6978the pact between USSR and the Nazis was based on political and military conveniences, not ideological agreements. You’ll note that Germany invaded the Soviet Union, killing millions of Russian soldiers, and exterminated many Slavs.
As a Jew, I thank you. As a woman, I thank you. As a citizen of the United States, I especially thank you as truth is challenging to share and saying ‘poorly received,’ is an understatement.
☝🏻🤓
I'm seriously joking jus had to say it 🤦🏼♂️ sorry 😅
as a German man, I can but agree with you.
Jew expect me to believe that ( its a joke and to fact i feel the need to say do you and Jew sound the same is beyond me") but hey i love Jew 2
You sound incapable of impartiality.
This is insanely well done, with extremely good messaging at the end on how to look at and possibly acquire primary resources safely. Well done team!
lmao
According to a video about the Beerhall Putch by historian Mark Felton, the idea behind the name change from German Workers Party, DAP, to National Socialist German Workers Party, NSDAP, was to reach out to those in Germany who were on the "moderate left," but as another historian, John D. Ruddy, points out: "don't let the name fool you, just because it has "Socialist" in its name, it doesn't make "National Socialist" left wing."
There were elements within the Nazi party that were left wing. What many people mistakenly believe is that Hitler founded the Nazi party. He didn't, he took it over. Those same people also seem to forget about a very import historical event that happened on June 30, 1934 called the Night of Long Knives. That is when ALL of those left and moderate leaning political leaders in the NSDAP were KILLED and all that was left was far right.
It doesn't stop the MAGAs from claiming that Nazis are leftist, though.
Ruddy is enrirely wrong. The defining characteristic of left and right wing is how the ideology views the need for government (literally Control Mind in latin) control. Since the late 1800s the left has been emphatic for maximal government control . This is PERFECTLY in line with how Nazis viewed government. Thus they are left wing
Mark Felton has some issues with the truth. There been several reddit threads on things he gotten wrong.
Ask Historians pretty much says his written stuff is good, his RUclips stuff is bad.
There were also those known at the time as the "roast beef" members of the party - former "reds" in "brown" clothing that had crossed from the communists to the NSDAP, attracted by the revolutionary aspects of the party against the traditional reactionaries, not put off by the clear hierarchical bent that sought to replace the old elites of the monarchy with new ones ("meritocraticically" to arise from those the party approved of).
an hour and 40 minutes, simon and team you just made my life better
The nazis also brawled in the streets with left wing groups. Anyone who thinks nazism is left wing is severely ignorant.
the nazis allied with the communist party in the fight against the social democratic party. I think this line of reasoning leads nowhere
@@mariaanissimowa4626 no they didn't.
_"The nazis also brawled in the streets with left wing groups."_
With Marxists mainly, but then again, so did the Bolshevik regime before and after the October Revolution.
_"Anyone who thinks nazism is left wing is severely ignorant."_
Wrong. It's a historical fact, that National Socialism was a totalitarian far-left, socialist 3rd position ideology based on ethnonationalism.
To be fair, left wingers tend to infight a lot.
"History can say what it want but rarely does it remember anything correctly"-Lawkeeper Equity Mlp Ace Attorney EOJ
Love these long videos!
As usual, an amazingly informative video! I also really appreciate the literature references and recommendations at the end.
When i started watching, there were 4k views. When i finished, there were 18k.
Good. Its video worth watching
I render my verdict as...
Fuck Nazi ideologies.
Well you wouldn't like where the us is going
fuck socialism is what your saying. got it.
@@FortuneProduction I honestly can't say I have liked it for a long time, but I never swore an oath to any person when I had enlisted, only to protect my country and its freedoms granted by her constitution.
Damn good episode! I know that was a shit ton of work but I LOVED IT!
Thanks Simon & con for doing this. Ive done some reading on my own to get a better grasp of this subject & this video helps in organizing my thoughts & further reading
Well done as a whole, explicative and pedagogical, also with the discretion advice at the end. Thank you
So much truth said by Simon he and team should get an award for honest documentary making.
Agreed. This channel has just been taken up a notch. RUclips at its finest.
With as much content as you release, I truly believe you spend more time talking than sleeping. And I appreciate it 😂
Great topic, Thanks for the video!
Simon, I love your and your team's work. You are an invaluable set of channels. Thank you.
Thank you for doing this video. I’ve wanted a solid deep dive into this for a while
Excellent video Simon & team.
Very well done content, thank you for making this given the topic.
Such a long video on such an interesting topic with zero monetisation thank you and congratulations 🎉❤️
Now people say “nAzI” to anyone they disagree with. Anyone they want to paint as a bad person. Even if said person has shown repeatedly that they are against said ideals.
Heck yeah. That intro should come with every intro to this topic.
Obvious, but actually needs to he said
Great video team! Really impressive on multiple levels
Wow that was an excellent episode well written worded presented an informative gr8 job
I am only 30 seconds in but I had to pause to laugh at the “zenith of evil” thing being done in the style of the pornhub logo 😂
The "Nazis weren't right wing" thing is such a shocking example of the failings of our education systems, and a scary example of how quickly history can become warped to suit a political narrative.
Edit: Thank you to all the commenters helping to prove my point.
Yet the right displays similar traits. Hmm makes you wonder.
leftards behave more like nazis than the imaginary nazis they fight
Its shocking that you think the whole political system can be divided into left and right.
All the Neo-N's are the ones who identify with the right.
@@Jameson1776 Are you insane?! Even NOT being from the states, EVERYTHING your president has done over the past 3.5 years has followed in the footsteps of the Nazi's. What democrat propaganda pushing news have you been watching?
Wow, that was an excellent video. Really puts a lot into perspective. I'm surprised this video doesn't seem to be doing as well as the others on this channel, I wish more people would watch it (as I'm sure a lot of people could really be more informed).
The book recommendations are a feature I'd love to see in other videos. Super conducive to further research.
Posting before the video has been up long enough to have watched it all
Id like to see a colaboration between Simeon and Dr. Mark Felton
Nah
This is such a multi-spectral look at the topic, that I have not seen it in years! Keep up the good work Warographics!
This program has great material and subject matter that’s professionally put together and displayed and shown.
To chose just one point, your explanation of “Aryan” isn’t really accurate. Aryans, as they were previously known academically, who would today be referred to as Indo Europeans, are the peoples of the world who speak Indo European languages, such as English, German, Swedish, and all Germanic languages; Latin and all derived Romance languages such as French; also Russian and the other Slavic languages, plus Greek, Hittite, the Celtic languages such as Irish Gaelic, Indian languages (hence the ‘Indo’ in Indo European) such as Sanskrit, Iranian languages (still known as Indo Aryan), etc., etc. The grouping known as Indo Europeans (or Aryans) also includes their descendants, who have clear genetic links with each other. I could go on and on, but suffice it to say that this video is much more editorial than objective, which doesn’t surprise me.
The reason that the "Is nazism right-wing" question is hard is because of the large differences between American and European conservatism, which share the same label but are two entirely distinct ideologies.
American conservatism is individualist in nature, and prefers social structures such as the church over government control. European Conservatism is grounded in traditional governmental institutions and tradition. Nazism falls squarely in the latter category.
Long story short: Nazism is a EUROPEAN right wing ideology.
Yeah if you need a better explanation look at the colleges. Liberal democratic run places protesting Anti-israel. Which contrary to what simon said in min 2. Nazism.
Your wrong about the church part. Not every right wingers is a church goer. Sure they may lean towards religious beliefs but most believe there should be a separation between religion and government. What you mean is the John Locke philosophy.
The idea that individuality and religion go together is a little silly
@@calebbean1384 how so?
There is no difference in the definition. It is just the "right" in the US is so far right they are getting in the brown territory (for the Hearts of iron players out there) that they get big sad when told they are FAR RIGHT and there is nothing "left" about the Democrats.
I wish this episode had been cut in half into a two-part video. It's just to hard to find an hour and 40 minutes to watch a video... But, time allowed and once again an excellent work by the Simonizer🎉
F**K*NG WOW this is by far the best video you and your team has ever made and i think is the best i have ever seen on RUclips. To take such a polarizing topic and portray it in what seams to be an unbiased way is just awesome.
I never thought I’d agree with Mr H!Tyler but his comments about modern art requiring intimate knowledge to understand is kinda a fair point
…
Many people think everything "modern" is "progress."
Literally some have a confirmation bias akin to a hive mind. It is like, if you are against the trash modern "art" thus you are a nasty or some horrible person.
@@Brockliy ???
Thank you Simon and team for covering important but uncomfortable topics such as this
This was very well done. Alot of good information.
Here before this gets flagged, shadow banner, edited by the powers that be
For all its impact I think a lot of people don’t realize how “brief” the nazi regime lasted. As a results a lot of its ideology was not yet set in stone and was highly emotional “of the moment” madness and anger. Sort of like the Bolsheviks in Russia, difference being the reds won and had time to come up with a polished ideology and foundation.
The NSDAP is always about the bombastic and glorious. I think they didn't have much more ideas. They are like a party of apocalyptic conspiracy theorists who believe an international jewish cabal will bring about the end of days.
There is an ideological/leadership split between Stalin and Trotsky at the time. Trotsky is still a violent revolutionary, but he believes in the world revolution. Like setting up one revolution after another in Berlin, Paris etc.
any chance you guys can add an appendix or a link to sources for further reading?
I am surprised this showed up in my feed. Glad though, just settling in to watch.
Nazi iconography?? I want that video from you
Thanks!
Camera filter is perfect now! Thanks for changing it
Thank you so much for covering a topic that badly needed to be covered.
Leaving a comment because this video deserves more attention.
Im sure this will be a fair and balanced comment section.
Great video, shame about the lack of views. I imagine the length has put some off.
Just started to watch. I know this sounds weird but I'm excited to see the more resanbel parts. (See if there is any). Thanks for the video
Love the pronunciation, SImon really is an Aussprachengenie, wa.
A timely subject today Apr 30.
Googled it, couldnt find anything. What is special about april 30?
@@DataC0llect0r
April 30 is Patriots day in which USA president George Sears (aka "Solidus Snake") wanted freedom for the country against the Patriots (aka "La Li Lu Le Lo") a secret organization seeking to control the world via information and press control.
@@DataC0llect0rAustrian painter unalives himself
@@MJ2Aaccording to the very trust worthy soviets.
@@MJ2A Austrian painter painted his wall
Excellent video! And a video that most definitely needed to be made, especially before the American election! Everyone should watch this.
Major props to Simon and his team for uploading this video, especially since they had to know that it would be demonetized because of RUclips's daft rules and algorithm!
Love the longer videos
I do agree that Nazism, as a distinct political movement, died in a bunker on April 30, 1945. Well, sort of, you had diehards that stuck around who were too cowardly to take their leaders route, but they aren't around now. What you do have is politically similar ideologies from folks who took a lot of inspiration from the Nazis. Of course, there are those folks that do the typical internet thing of calling someone a Nazi who doesn't agree with them. This, unfortunately, means that there are those who are actually acting like Nazis who try to use Godwin Rule to win the argument. They have also tried to extend Godwin's Rule to being labeled FASCIST and that is a political ideology that has NOT died out.
For clarification, Nazism is a form of fascism, but not all fascists are Nazis.
Thank you, I had such a hard time trying to explain that to my brother who is insistent that Facism and Nazism are the exact same. I do not advocate for either, but nuance is important.
Usually fascist movements are defined by the interests and the identity of the certain nation it’s being used in for its gain and circumstance
Ex:
Classical fascism = Italian fascism
National Socialism = German fascism
Falangism = Spanish fascism
Monarcho-fascism = British/Bulgarian/Hungarian fascism
Legionism/Clerical fascism = Romanian/Austrian fascism
Nazism is being reborn in america. Its just being rebranded as republicanism
_"For clarification, Nazism is a form of fascism, but not all fascists are Nazis."_
Wrong. Nazism is National Socialism. Fascism was Fascism. They had nothing to do with each other, and were fundamentally two different ideologies. However both National Socialism and Fascism were forms of 3rd position movement.
@@_Historia_Magistra_Vitae it is so adorable you are telling someone with a degree in history who has studied this more than YOU that they are wrong. Umberto Eco disagrees with you and I'll take his credentials over someone pretending to be a historian on the internet.
Calling someone a Nazi so easily these days just for disagreeing with you, massively undermines the memory of those who suffered under that evil regime.
It's almost like calling someone a Nazi just because you disagree with them kinda makes you a Nazi
Agreed, though many who insisted upon vehement disagreement with Nazi ideals during Hitler's rise to influence/power saw no problem whatsoever where the inherent nastiness of the ideology was concerned, so long as it didn't directly impact them/theirs.
Tolerating evil aimed at others, so long as one views oneself as safe from the impact of said is every bit as bad as engaging in said evil directly.
Life is varied and complicated in quite a few ways, but some things, how one views Nazism, for instance, are absolutely black and white.
As stated in the vid, they were taking ideas from all over (plus having plenty of internecine disagreements) so if you squint it's easy to cite ways other movements match them (as long as you ignore all the ways they don't).
Just check Orwell's list of all that had been daubed Fascist in the 40's - it's been basically everyone from when it was current onwards.
@@surfnbird6480with that youre doing ecxactly the same thing the original comment was correctly complaining about
Take it as a compliment
6:36 The only question I have is I’m pretty sure I’ve heard of Nazi women concentration camp guards, was this just when numbers were running thin or did they make exceptions?
They existed for supervising women prizoners.
ruclips.net/video/K2Km6-teyHQ/видео.html
Im pretty sure they were just auxilleries since they were women
I dont have time to watch this now, but I didnt want to leave without a comment. Well done team for jumping into this topic
Good job fact boy.
When I clicked on this video looking at the title i didnt expect the ad thats the most shocking thing
Excellently researched and presented, thank you
Bravo- this team is incredible!
Simon now making how to videos now?
Dear RUclips, slapping a warning on the holocaust actually does more harm to the seriousness of the topic than allowing it to stand on its own. That’s right, your credibility after COVID-19 far worse than suspect.
Thank you for this, Simon.
The timing of this video is amazing for me as a Dutchie. This weekend is a special one for us, on saturday may 4th we remember the people who died in the war and hear their stories. On sunday, May 5th, we celebrate our freedom. Next year it will be 80 years since our country was liberared from the Nazis.
It is so important to know how people like Hitler can come to power so we can stop another person from rising to power. And to remember how bad the quality of life was for most people in that time.
Thank you for your hard work Simon and team! ❤
After the fall of the USSR the 90's was a time with a lot of hope for a new world order where the huge wars were led behind, then came the balkans, koxovo, somalia, Kuwait, but we never suspected fascism would be back so soon. It's sad how we are descending the same path the world did in the 1930's
I think it's different though. Most of the fascist supporters today are in denial about their leaders being fascist. I don't think they would support an actual fascist regime.
Plus Western countries have really strong democratic institutions. Look at Trump's attempted coup in America. That would have succeded in a middling democracy but in America it just fizzled out
Russia got anarcho-capitalism. I think the failiure of the time was to keep telling russians that this lawless corruption and banditry is what democracy is supposed to be like. But it was a bit more free, at least the different oligarchs were balancing eachother.
South African here. Dad's a former member of the AWB. It's crazy thinking this madness have developed so close to home
Thank you for this informative video.
THANK YOU ! Can you do more on ideologies /ideological capture even ?
Wow, this covered material I've never ever heard.
Nice that it did get monitsed too.
Hmm, why am I not surprised that a lot of the things they said about women could be found today in any manosphere podcast or tradwife Instagram Reel. Thankfully, not as many people are buying this propaganda today as they did back then.
Go travel to India, Asia or the Middle East. You'll find those values multiplied by 100. It's not just manospere men on the internet.
@@cg5471 and those are the countries people move away from
@@kayakat1869 yes & I'm not trying to defend them. What I am pointing out is the idea of misogyny being deeply rooted in a lot of cultures & that the nazis didn't invent it. The west is the exception to the rule & that's a great thing which I'm sure we agree on. What I don't agree with is the idea that people who speak about trad values as being akin to fascists. You don't have to like them but it seems you are making that leap.
Thank you so much for this!
Honestly, not focused listening, but come on with the lectures! Just because we can't pay for the entire education or have the time for it don't mean we are not interested or could not understand.
Beside looking forward to the next parts and in depth vids, I hope more on Asia and for instance the Dutch Indies comes as well.
And I am now also curious what the difference between an 'actual' lecture and these videos would be. If you can help close that gap, or show more of specifically what the gap entails that would be really interesting. Is it different terms? Different sources? Different goals?
Keep it up fact boy and basement dwellers!! 💜
But also, all of you keep in mind your own mental health! You put a lot of time into some heavy shit! Take care of yourselfs and the people around you!
Videos get demonetization for MUCH less controversial content than this video so hats off to Simon and his team for pulling this one off
15:50 "Third position" is what the Nazis said about themselves, but a lot of what Nazis (and the fashos more generally) say is advertising designed to co-opt the causes of the left for the goals of the right. Example: "Job insecurity and wage exploitation? Had you considered immigrants are to blame?"
If you want to understand what they *really* believe, you need to give more weight to what they do than what they say. They expressed disdain for (non-Nazi) conservatives and monarchists, but who got sent up the chimney? The disabled, the mentally ill, the communists, the Jews, and the Gypsies. To get lined up against the wall as a German conservative, you had to be connected to the bomb plot.
In short, it's obvious to anyone paying attention to what the Nazis did as much as what they said, the Nazis were of the right.
_"In short, it's obvious to anyone paying attention to what the Nazis did as much as what they said, the Nazis were of the right."_
Wrong. They had nothing to do with right wing of any kind whatsoever. It was a totalitarian far-left, socialist 3rd position ideology based on ethnonationalism.