Separatist Fleet at Ryloth vs. Rebel Alliance Fleet at Kamino | Star Wars: Fleet Battles
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024
- We have an epic battle today, as the Separatist (CIS) Fleet from the Battle of Ryloth, from the Clone Wars TV Show, takes on the Fleet fielded by the Rebel Alliance at the Battle of Kamino, from Star Wars: The Force Unleashed 2. CIS vs Rebels. It's a Star Wars Legends Space Battle! Separatist vs Alliance. Mon Calamari Cruiser vs Droid Control Ship. Who Will Win? Find out on today's episode of Star Wars: Fleet Battles!
***
Links:
Join the (superfun!) Discord: / discord
Follow me on Twitter: / eckhartsladder
Support the Channel: / eckhartsladder
***
The Ryloth Campaign was a serious moment in the first season of the Clone Wars, starting with Ashoka's disastrous attempted attack against the Ryloth Blockade, and ending with the Republic's defeat against the Confederacy of Independent Systems in the space above the planet.
The Battle of Kamino was a serious battle between the Rebel Alliance and the Empire during the Galactic Civil War, as shown in Star Wars: The Force Unleashed 2. 
Кино
If you guys haven't already, make sure you join the (superfun!) Discord, we're nearing 1,000 members: discord.gg/3jbNnaK
If you'd like, also follow me on Twitter: twitter.com/eckhartsladder
and
Support the Channel: www.patreon.com/eckhartsladder
EckhartsLadder hello
EckhartsLadder oh
The 501st (clone wars era) vs Death Troopers
Hey there wanted to point out a small mistake the separatist fleet only had 6 munificent cruisers 2 were there in the beginning and they called in the other 4 later
Mozart wuz blacck I think the rebels modified Gr-75 transports with light weapons. It would not be able to fight very well though, and it's probably used more because they didn't have ships in the places needed most, so they used whatever they had available
The CIS fleet at christosis(the one admiral trench was leading) vs the rebel fleet at endor
Justin Riv with trench vs ackbar
Space Battleship Yamato(2199 version) vs Eclipse-Class Super Star Destroyer or other various combinations.
Justin Riv That would be a good fight but I would have to go w/Trench on that one.
Justin Riv I think you meant christophis
Justin Riv The CIS would win, due to Trench’s following missles would destroy Starfighters easily. 30 Ships vs 75 Ships, might be a good battle but the CIS would win easily, by more firepower and Starfighters.
Uhm.. battle over Coruscant..? How many fighters did we see get launched by Grevious..? I think this is a limitation in the shows rendering, rather than in the CIS. In the original Star Wars clone wars animated series, we saw HUNDREDS, of droids pouring out of one ship.
That was seriously over exaggerated also you see like 10000. LAATs from only like 20 aclimators
Omar Baba 20•80 is 1,600 lasts. Acclimatized carry 80 Laat gunships and there were 20 so it is very reasonable for the movie to have that many, a Lukrehulk could carry over 500 star fighters in jsut one side of its hangar.
The important part about the Lucrehulk and especially about the Droids is that after the battle of Naboo(not sure how long after) the Lucrehulk stopped being an actual control-ship and became more of a command ship and carrier. That was because they made the Droids more indepent from a Controller, which meant they would no longer deactivate if you shoot down the Lucrehulk but made them also less strategically effective. Which means, instead of a few ship-controlled starfighters, you had trillion of droids with simpler AI, which could fight independently. That is probably, why there were so many Vultures and Tridroids in the Airspace
At least, that is what i have found after Research
You can't blame Ashoka at the Battle of Ryloth (the part you mentioned) she was a kid, 14/15/16, over time she grew to what she has become by season 5's end.
Finally someone agrees with me
ANAKIN STILL A DUMBASS HE IS
You can easily blame her
During The Battle of Königsberg young German Boys managed to weaken a portion of the Soviet front line and thanks do that a Panzer Division managed to make a hole in it and Re-Establish a supply line.
Did i know? -
On of the greatest indian king name who spread Buddhism and Hinduism to other countries was Ashoka
We indians called hin ashoka the great❤
Wow. I'm I CIS supporter through and through but you're REALLY giving the Munificents a favorable light. I mean ineffective armor, VERY exposed bridge, not too sure about the turbolaser placement (see Lucrehulk for more info). Honestly I despise these things.
What Star Wars ships don't have very exposed bridges?
germanvisitor2 I love how the Resurgent class ships have less exposed command towers...to correct a weakness of Imperial class destroyers
Ive started despizing you too general
@@Julius_Caesar69420 why did you eat your piano
Oh and Justin i think that if The munificents would be good Set The Lucrehulk would survive too or Deal really good damage against The liberty and home one ships
There was only 6 Munificent-class frigates at the Battle Of Ryloth, not 10. The fleet started off with only two and then an additional 4 jumped in.
I think if the CIS was able to realize the rebels were going for the droid control ship, they could just position their other ships around it as a PD wall, then flood the field with droid fighters.
This was over from the beginning. Unless you take away 4 of the frigates, they just have too much tonnage and weapons compared to the Rebel fleet. The Republic only beat this blockade because the final Venator had extreme plot armor on its underside and didn't succumb to 8 frigates opening up on it.
Top 5 Illegal Weapons in the Star Wars universe?
The Senate will never approve!
+Grant Kohles Fuck the Senate Sidious did lol.
I AM THE SENATE
I would love to see that video.Let me add I think one of them would be the disruptors used against the Lassat
Dude disruptors would probably top the list
"I hate Ahsoka during this arc"
I accuse you of treason against the republic
I also hate Ashoka in this arc tho.
@@shauryapallav5674 Yea same
Emperor Palpatine vs The Diadact
Didact
@@anythinggoes4986 3 years
@@miguelsalazar1059 got to correct him 3 years late
And I agree, Ahsoka was unbearable during that ark. If it wasn't for how good she got latter I would have called her one of the worst characters in star wars
TheT7770ify yeah I hated her at first but after like season three I loved her
TheT7770ify yeah she became one of the best characters later
TheT7770ify I hated cause they too the time to give most of blue squadron names, they killed all but two of them. It makes the deaths more impactful when they have names
I love Ashoka I don't think she was bad at all during any season what I have seen.
The Immortal Super Being eh she was a little bit of a shite at first
I thought the Lucrehulks at this point in the Clone Wars had become Battleships, far more heavily armed and shielded from their Droid Control Ship versions, the type that was used before the Clone Wars. I heard the Republic needed 2-3 Venators + Starfighters in order to effectively take down a Lucrehulk Battleship.
I dunno, just a thought anyways.
Great video! ODST vs arc troopers
Delta squad vs noble team would be awesome!
*EDITED FOR MY QUESTION*
What is your order from least favorite to favorite of the halo games?
As well, what is your order from least favorite to favorite of the star wars movies?
Arc troopers weapons are too strong for ODST
Noble Team absolutely curb stomps Delta squad, hell Jorge could probably destroy them by himself
I personally always was very interested how Delta Squad would fare against a Starfleet Hazard Team.
BACON DAVID I think ODST could hold there own against arc troopers,but I agree and don't think Delta could beat noble. Surprisingly people do and I think it would still be an awesome match up
Arc Troopers for the win. There weapons armour and fighting skills and training are way better they won't stomp but I think they would come out on top.
The Immortal Super Being i think it would pretty close!
And also the Lucrehulks are known in the lore for having excellent shield strength, with the Republic needing five or six Venators to take down the shields on a Lucrehulk according to one source.
You did miss one thing, you stated that the republic had 3 Venators when they defeated the blockade, but one, the redeemer, fell in the initial assault, the resolute commanding officer was wounded in action, and the defender was critically damaged to the point that it was sacrificed in the main battle, without any notable separatist casualties. The one remaining venator successfully took out all of the munificent class frigates
The Cybermen vs The Borg.
Best idea ever
Thank you. My original idea was The Cybermen vs The CIS, but I realised that was a bit one-sided
if the Borg can adapt to the Cybermen's Lasers, its game over.
But you have to remember the Cybermen can just as easily adapt to the Borgs weapons (Source: Nightmare in Silver).
The CYBERMEN are too numerous to count they have not only defeated much stronger opponents but have traveled throw dimensions not only that but there adaption and there armour is way better I mean look how fast they got when they upgraded so ya Im
on THE CYBERMENS side.
Harrower Class Dreadnought VS Venator Class Star Destroyer
Venator, no contest
2000 years is a crazy long time. Even if the venator is inefficiently designed, it is insanely newer
Alackofcaring 96 but Palpatine praised the Harrower so... The Venator Sucks.
Rito Yūki is Ultimate Harem Protagonist
The venator is inefficient, but millenia of tech advancement are at work here. Palpatine also praised the Rindilli dreadnought.
Alackofcaring 96 Its just a crappy new ship vs an amazing old one.
Even if the Venator has thousands of years of advancements on its side, is it enough to defeat an older amazing ship?
Droid Tri-Fighter vs Tie Interceptor
250 venator star destroyers vs. The second Death Star
Ninja 84 nice one
No its not. The rebel fleet's measly starfighter contigent killed the death star, and the fleet could hold its own. 250 Venators could conquer any system, ever. Thats over 2000 starfighters, along with the preexisting firepower of a Venator
Ninja 84 rip death star
I still wonder why the death star didn't deploy its full tie fighter garrison.
Does the Death Star get a planet that gives it a shield? If not then... welp.. gg
Also, the second Death Star has a 3-8 minute laser recharge time. Which, if saying that it takes 3 minutes, it would take 12.5 hours to destroy the fleet. Not too bad. But that isn’t considering time for the laser to aim
To be fair, the fact that Alliance starfighters almost all have their own hyperdrive means they could bring a lot more than just what can be ferried on larger capital ships. Although considering the point-defenses you mentioned, I'm not sure how much difference even doubling their numbers would actually make.
You're videos are the best on RUclips by far the Star Wars videos are so interesting! Most videos from different channels are boring but you're videos are amazing!
In star wars fire power, the ISD is often used as a standard unit of measurement.
5 dreadnoughts (stupidest name for a class until the mega became a thing) can out fight one ISD. 2 Venators can also outfight an ISD. We also know that one venator can overpower 7 Munificents according to wookiepedia. So 14 munificent class can outshoot an ISD.
so then, lets just round and assume a dreadnought has the firepower of 3 munificent class. They also have much better armor.
The two prong assault ship is a dreadnought with better shields, worse armor, and more guns.
Lets assume its a 25% increase in firepower. 4 munificents are now outgunned.
The nebulon b class still carried 12 turbolasers on a much newer heavily shielded KDY hull. If its kuat, you know its good. Lets say its one to one. These 4 medium cruisers outgun the majority of the blockades firepower, and have much better armor and/or shields.
Dp20s carry dominant shield passing concussion missile weaponry, as well as 14 anti fighter turbolasers. Sorry, was that your shield generator, bridge, and hangar bays? I couldnt see them through the shrapnel of your fighters getting mulched by cr90 fire. The freighters are inconsequential at best, and are likely just there to assist in the anti fighter barage. Both moncal cruisers are heavily shielded and armored, to the point where home one could tank the executor while its support fleet knocked out her shields. They also get ion cannons and turbolasers that could also feasibly take down the executor's shields.
Star fighters are held back until the moment they are needed, swooping down over the Munificents in dive bomber fashion. Why? Because the Munificent's gun batteries can only aim down and to the side. These fighters will have to avoid the Lucrehulk's guns, but they aren't going to have to worry about enemy fighters due to the corvettes killing every droid in sight and the gunships disabling the prominent hangars of the lucrehulks first.
Rebellion wins with minor casualties to the less skilled pilots and perhaps a gunship or corvette if the fishmen don't do their jobs right. Also, thats a lancer frigate, not a dreadnought. Empire at war made me a tactical genius
lmao a year late but this is much more probable if the rebels were really thinking they could just jump in close enough for the DP20s to be in range with missiles and fire off as many as possible at the bridges of the munificents while the frigates laid down support fire as the two MC80s used their ion cannons to disable the lucrehulk's shields then fire on the command tower
Also the Lucrehulk over Ryloth was a battleship varient
If it is possible, I will like to see the match up between the Rebels fleet on Scarif (Rogue One movie) vs Empire Grand Admral Thrawn fleet on Atollon (Star War Rebels Season 3). I personally think this will be a great and balance battle between two faction.
Damn nice video Eck!! Keep up the awesome work man!!!!!
In the battle of Ryloth, Asoka Tano comes up with the infamous Marg Sabel maneuver, popularized by Grand Admiral Thrawn. Essentially, you point your ships hangers away from the enemy ships, wait for them to maneuver in close, launch fighter and bombers to attack and destroy the enemy ships from close up.
Like I said yesterday, you make amazing quality videos and seriously deserve way more subs. Judging by your growth you'll be at 100k in no time! Good luck :)
Says "Dreadnought-class heavy cruiser", Points to a carrack.
Star Wars versus idea: Halo UNSC Pillar of Autumn (not a regular halcyon) versus a MC80a Cruiser. (13th try)
Also, an idea for galactic versus: UNSC vs the Red Legion from Destiny 2, with the Almighty super weapon included.
B1 battle droid vs Halo Grunt
That would be an interesting fight.
The battle droid would win, b1’s are quite effective when not facing plot armour.
A match up I have been interested in would be the fleet defending earth during halo 2, and the rebel fleet during the battle of the second death star. The halo fleet will have all their ships but no orbital Mac stations and will not have Lord hood as a leader(we will assume it is before they are Built.) and the rebels will keep all their ships but will they will not have major leaders.
Jacob McDaniel I believe he had already done this
Jacob McDaniel i think he alrady did this 😉
Василий Данилов he has done one during halo 4, but halo 2 fleet had a different ships
Brutes vs Krogan,Turians vs Elites, Quarians vs Skirmishers, Elcor vs Hunters or Grunts vs Volus. Mass effect vs Halo species battles have so many good match ups. [Third time requesting]
Congrats on over 50k subs. Keep up the good work, and I hope the subs keep going up.
For the Q&A, what are your favorite sources for your personal research?
I would love to see what kind of ideas for merch you have. Rebel pup-pilot pins perhaps?
This is absolutely brilliant and genius, I have been subscribed since 2000 subscribers and I am just so impressed with how far your content has come, you have found a fantastic niche and I am so happy your channel exists. Keep it up!
I think the worst thing in that particular episode was how Ahsoka saved the day in the end. Deploy a Venator with it's belly up front? Yeah, of course that makes it indestructible. It was probably meant to represent outside the box thinking, because it was one of the rare instances of 3D-manuevering in space, which you don't see very often in Star Wars. But that is what gives the usual Star Wars ship engagements a nice feeling of sea battles plus WW2 dog fighting.
I think it was meant to be a reference to a Thrawn tactic where he rolled an ISD in a similar way.
You seem to have forgotten that after the control ship is taken out most of the droid star fighters would stop working. Freeing up rebel fighters to attack the larger ships
Question: have you ever thought about designing your own star destroyer?
They never really got into it, but Turian navy vs Systems Alliance navy.
Hey Eckhart, I recommend becoming acquainted with Isaac Asimov's Foundation universe, it'd be a cool opponent for Star Wars. Also, you should start including Ancient Humanity from the Halo Universe. I think they are really powerful and interesting, but are often forgotten about. The Engineers from the Alien universe would be a good match for them
First order vs the Death watch in season five in star wars the clone wars.
Solar One death watch would be destroyed, the first order is much bigger
someone person. I'm not saying the entire first order maybe just 2 or 3 star destroy.
Today will be remembered, as the LAST DAY! OF THE DEATH WATCH,!
The pic of the dreadnought on the rebellion side is a picture of a lancer corvette
I'm pretty sure there were only six Munificents at the battle of Ryloth; two at the beginning, and four more joining later on.
Wraith (Stargate) vs Galactic Empire (Star Wars)
BC-304 Daedalus-Class Battlecruiser (Stargate, Post-Unending, No ZPM & With ZPM) vs Imperial Escort Fleet (Star Wars)
BC-304 USS Daedalus (Stargate, Pre-Unending, No ZPM) vs SSV Normandy SR-2 (Mass Effect)
Can the Reaper Invasion from Mass Effect 3 take the UNSC controlled Earth from Halo 2, 3, & ODST?
I suspect the Wraith have it against the Galactic Empire do to their ability to make good their losses; but there are to many unknown variables here.
I have no idea how Daedalus-Class would fare against an Imperial Escort Fleet, though I suspect she would lose.
Daedalus would stomp Normandy SR2
Reapers would almost certainly take earth, though UNSC would have an easier time of it than the alliance did.
Yeah I'd suspect that the Wraith could eventually overrun the Empire. Two or three Hives with their escorts could probably overrun a system with the sheer number of Darts that each carries.
A Daedalus-class might get overwhelmed eventually by an Imperial Escort Fleet, though with Asgard Plasma Beams & an upgraded Asgard shield they will inflict serious damage to the Imperials.
Yeah, the Daedalus would stomp all over the SR-2. Just thought I'd want to see the ship built to replace the Prometheus fight the ship built to replace the SR-1. Battle of the replacements, though the Odyssey might fit here as well....
I don't know about this one thought. With at least 300 ODPs surrounding Earth, along with hundreds of ships & pretty much every Spartan-II besides Gray Team on or around Earth, the Reapers would have a very tough time taking a UNSC controlled Earth. I feel that MACs from cruisers & Super MACs would easily punch through Reaper kinetic shields while MACs from destroyers & frigates would take 2-3 shots.
Here's why I think the reapers would win. We know that the light macs used by destroyers and frigates are 183 meters long and accelerate a 600 ton slug to 30km/ps which would give us a 270 TJ kinetic yield. I have read the cruisers have a 366 meter long mac firing the same slugs. This would make sense given how much else they carry. It is reasonable, therefore to assume that they accelerate the projectile to twice the velocity. 600 tons at 60 km/ps gives us a 1,080 TJ kinetic yield. We're not going to bother calculating the super mac's kinetic yield. I agree they would easily one shot a reaper. I will say that their projectile's velocity is 12,000 km/ps; which will become relevant later.
To get an idea of how well these would fare going toe to toe with a reaper we'll look at the ships that actually did. The Kilimanjaro class dreadnaught's main gun accelerates a 20kg slug to 4500km/ps (if you ask, I'll tell you how I come by those numbers) that gives us a 202.5 TJ kinetic yield. The Everest can fire one shot every six seconds, it is reasonable to assume the Kilimanjaro can do at least that much. The ME codex says that two dreadnaughts are inferior to a reaper capital, three have even odds against one and four usually win, it also says that no ship has ever survived a direct hit from a reapers main gun. The reapers seem to take some time between shots. For the sake of argument we'll say 30 seconds. In the 30 seconds it takes the reaper to fire it's first shot the three Kilimanjaros have fired 15; then the first one dies. One of three things happens next. A.) the two remaining dreadnaughts overwhelm the reapers shields, do critical damage to it and ultimately defeat it. B.) they bring down its shields and it still fires the next shot and the second dreadnaught dies, or C.) they fail to bring down its shields and the second dreadnaught dies. In all three cases, the two dreads fire ten shots between them. In the later two cases the last dread has no more than five shots left before it wins or dies. In this scenario the reaper might take as many as thirty hits totaling 6075 TJs. for this reason I do not believe a UNSC cruiser could take down a reaper in one shot. The ME codex says the reapers have four times the effective range of their citadel council counterparts which means their main guns have a max velocity of 16,000-18,000 km/ps and as their bursts last a second or more, there is almost certainly several tons of material; possibly hundreds of tons. This means they can out range the mac platforms and can almost certainly one shot a marathon class. And so I think they would win.
You forget that the droid fleet would be in disarray after the droid control ship went down.
MrCoolguy425 Thing is these are all equally skilled and capable people controlling the ships not droids
UNSC Autumn Class Cruiser vs Imperial 2 Class Star Destroyer (10th attempt)
Space Battleship Yamato(2199 version) vs Eclipse-Class Super Star Destroyer or other various combinations.
The autumn class cruiser will destroy the star destroyer. Think the star destroyer that had it's bridge destroyed by and asteroid and replace it with a Mac gun. Tie fighters are ripped apart from both ai controlled point defense guns and fighter craft from the autumn cruiser(5 longsword). If we go the boarding craft way then think of numbers over strategy, star wars weapons are like covanent weapons that fire at slower rates. The empire would have to flood the autumn cruiser with troops to make any gains and that goes the same for the other way due to the empires amount of troops in an isd(10,000 soldiers per ship). So in the end autumn wins.
Weapons- autumn
Fighters- draw (numbers vs quality and heavy point defense)
Troops- empire(10,000 vs couple hundred for defense)
The reason the autumn wins is that you don't have a use for 10,000 troops if your ship is blown up, The heavy point defense against unshielded tie fighter craft, and the fact that while star wars does have particular shields that protect from solid weapons the are less advanced do to plasma weapons being favored for thousands of years. Also one last thing the affective weapon range of the isd is severely outclassed by the autumn, meaning the autumn can fire before the isd can.
@@eternalhowl8895 Ye, the autumn class has forerunner class tech and shields so it will probably win
thanks for finally doing a vs episode
9:52 "clone wars good guy magic" *cough cough* plot armour *cough cough*
I agree with you. That droid control ship would unleash large volleys of droids at the rebels and most likely overwhelm them more then tie fighters would
I think you've over estimated the Munificent, they are heavily armed, but they're glass cannons, their shields and armor are weaker then other ships of their size, and with the slow tracking on their heavy guns, the DP-20s and CR-90s would actually have an advantage over them
I dunno, Venators seemed to give a pounding to Munificent class cruisers in RotS, and one Venator delivered a crippling volley to the Invisible Hand. That even of a conflict makes me think more sophisticated ships would handle impressive numbers.
Do one on the kamino defence fleet in thw clone wars and the separatist defence fleet on umbarra. Love this kind of vid!
The Dominon vs the Empire
The battlestar Pegasus vs a Venator class star destroyer
Anubis' invasion fleet vs the imperial fleet at endor
I think you underestimate the Assault Frigate Mark One badly if you believe it can't match a Munificent.
stargate Milkyway Replicators Vs the star wars Galaxy
UNSC vs the Combine from the Half Life series, would be pretty cool.
Dreadnought class heavy cruiser. What a name for a spacecraft.
Kandosii Dreadnought vs Centurion Battlecruiser
Pillar of Autumn VS Xenomorph attack!
Hi! This was a very interesting Video (as usual :-) ) For your futur vs videos, I think it could be very interesting to see a Imperial II star destroyer VS a star trek Dominion battleship! Those really seem like an even match to me, I'd love to see your take on this! Best regards!
the entirety of the 22nd century Federation fleet vs Two Executor-class Super Star Destroyers.
Daleks vs The Galactic Empire
Minton---I think the Daleks would win.
daleks win definitely I like daleks vs forunners so join with be to convince him
You do know stormtroopers were trained for 2 years and a imperator 2 star destroyer averaged about 200 megatons of power per turbo laser shot
You do know that in one episode of Doctor Who a Dalek fleet completely destroyed a planet in a matter of seconds just by shooting at it.
Tiger Tank yes, of course I know that. This is not about it being fair, but being cool to watch
Face reveal?
Btw what is your favorite faction overall?
delta class t3c shuttle he said he will do one at 100k
delta class t3c shuttle he's shown his face before
ARC Trooper 147 the fuck where??
he obviously a starwar fan
when did he show his face I don't remember
For Q and A
Where did the name EckhartsLadder come from
T-800 Terminator vs IG88.
MartianProductions depends if you mean terminator 1 t 800 or terminator 2 t 800 (or t 850)
Separatist and republic vs covenant and UNSC before reach
We really gonna ignore the massively scaled up Nebulon B that Starkiller was on with the super gun that one shots Star Destroyers huh
A halo fleet vs. A homeworld kith (from the original game) fleet
Ori Mothership vs. Eclipse
I've got some good star ship versus ideas!
*1.* 100 CR-90 Blockade Runners VS 1 Alligiance Star Destroyer
*2.* Tyrant Heavy Missile Cruiser VS World Devistator
*3.* Aclemator Class Assult Ship VS Nebulon B Frigate
*4.* Droid Control Ship VS Scarif Shield Gate
*5.* Tie Phantom VS Tie Defender
*6.* Imperial Class 3 Star Destroyer VS First Order Recergence Star Destroyer
*7.* T-800 Terminator VS IG-88
*8.* World Devistator VS Late Clone War Lukerhulk Droid Control Ship
*9.* 1,000 Tie Defenders VS The Sun Crusher
10.Darth Vader vs. Sandman
*chris pearson* Yep
Could you do a fleet battle video on the Imperial fleet from the samr battle of kamino
Glad to see the separatists win one of these matchups
"The Alliance would have 1 dreadnaught-class heavy cruiser"
*squint*
That... That's a Lancer.
Pride of core Vs. Super Star Destroyer
I could see one way in which the Rebels could win. I'm gonna go out on a limb and assume that the Rebel ships are for the most part faster than the Confederate Munificents. The strategy would be to launch the fighters and have them close in on the Lucrehulk ship as fast as they can, exploiting their lack of point defense or starfighter support that could compare technologically to the Rebel starfighters. At the same time, use the lighter Rebel ships (the non-Mon Calamari Cruisers) to kite the Munificents in an attempt to hold their attention by getting within range, firing a salvo, pulling out of range, rinse and repeat. Then with the two Mon Calamari ships, move in targeting a single Munificent and focus fire on that ship, then moving onto the next closest one, so on and so forth until the entire fleet is eliminated. For the starfighters, once the Lucrehulk is eliminated, their focus would be to eliminate all remaining enemy fighters, and then to dock as they'd have no more use. As the Munificents start to fall, the ships freed up by this can move to help the ships that are the worst off while the Mon Calamari Cruisers continue to pick off the Munificents one by one. Whether this works or not or if the admiral in charge would even think of this plan, and it would certainly be a difficult fight regardless, but I think that this is a plan that could work.
*As soon as video starts
Oh...THAT fleet. Sweet!
Returned to this old video, and almost did a double take when I didn’t hear Resonance at the end.
if one or two of the heavy frigates were to provide point defense coverage for the lucrehulk class battleship and the lucrehulk's fighters were focused on intercepting rebel fighters, i believe that the battleship would easily survive this battle. the standard configuration of the combat converted lucrehulk class allowed it to carry 1500 droid starfighters. while usually only around half of them were launched at any given time, (this was to allow continuous fighter support while recovered fighters refueled their notoriously inefficient sublight engines,) this would still be more than sufficient to completely overwhelm the rebel's powerful but few fighter craft. it would take dozens of y-wing fighter-bombers working together, if not hundreds to deal with the exceptionally powerful shields of the separatist battleship. the heavy guns of the rebel capital ships would be occupied trying to deal with the remaining eight heavy frigates on offense, and even that would be a losing battle for the rebels due to the significant firepower wielded by the munificent class heavy frigate.
it should be mentioned that the munifcent, while technically classified as a frigate (the same as many of the smaller rebel ships,) it was very large and powerful for a ship of it's class, and is actually on par with many cruisers on terms of firepower and shield strength, and was actually larger and more powerful than the dreadnaught class cruisers occasionally utilized by the rebels.
I have an idea or two for a Fleet Vs...
1) Location - Alderaan planetary orbital fragments
Empire - 1x Victory, 2x Vindicators, 1x Raider corvette
Rebellion - 3x Marauder corvettes, 1x Dreadnaught
Set up -
The Raider is ordered into the planetary fragments to scout for a Rebel task group while the 2 Vindicators wait to be called in. The Victory II is stationed farther out to protect from any heavy units the Rebels might call in to assist them.
2) Location - Red Nebula
Galactic Empire - 4x Imperial SD, 8x Vindicators, 16x Nebulon-B
Terran Empire (ST) - 2x Phalanx dreadnaughts, 4x Mirandas, 2x Excelsiors, 6x Constitutions
Rebel Alliance - 1x Lucerhulk, 2x Venerator, 4x Recusant, 2x Acclamator II, 6x Gladiators, 3x Munificents, 10x Gaurdians
Terran Rebels (ST) - 1x Federation dreadnaught, 2x Constellations, 1x Vor'cha, 2x K't'ingas, 3x D'kyr, 5x Kumari
Set up -
After discovering one another some 15 years prior, the Terran Empire agreed to an alliance with the Galactic Empire and both Emperors were pleased. Not long after this historic agreement, rebellious factions in both governments began open revolution and they too became allies against the empires. Both alliances came to a head in the Battle of the Red Nebula.
Holy shit! You did a video the rebel Fleet at Kamino. Awesome!
I always kind of wanted to see the rebel Fleet at kamino versus The Rebel Fleet at scarif
You should totally throw the star wars guys against supreme commander and supreme commander 2, it would be amazing. Keep up the good content man!
1: mandator 2 class star dreadnought vs the malevolence 2: 3 Acclamator class assault ship's vs 1 venator class star destroyer 3: mc80 liberty vs imperial 2 star destroyer 4: saber tank vs AT ST 5: mandator 2 class star dreadnought vs 3 imperial 2 star destroyers 6: alderann security force trooper vs naboo security force trooper 7: UNSC vs the republic 8: munificent class frigate vs Assault frigate mark 2 or mark 1 idk 9: UNSC vs the rebel Alliance 10: the capal from destiny vs the covenant 11: the empire vs the combine
Q and A do you know of any new animated Star Wars series in the making?
Bellator class star destoryer vs mediator class star cruiser
I WILL NEVER GIVE UP!!
Starwars C.I.S. Vs the Starcraft Protoss
racspartan1 which time protoss? Because pre-sc1 protoss stomps
brak danych Typically i say both prime for prime. I'd really like to see Warhammer Eldar vs the Protoss
racspartan1 prime protoss had hundreds of planets all over the galaxy three 75 km arks and thousands mothership so CIS stand no chance, maybe galactic empire as well
But eldars and their 2k km craftworlds, it could be hard very hard
brak danych Yea not to familiar with the Protoss (still learning Starcraft Universe) but I'm very familiar with Warhammer 40k Universe
Anything with the Protoss in it will be good regardless of whether they win or not.
Klingon empire vs madalorians
At 2:38 the ship you talk about is not a attack cruiser, but actually looks like a Nebulon-B2 assault frigate, a improved version of the Nebulon B escort frigate with better armament, shields and armor.
After the battle of Naboo there were no Droidcontrollships. After Naboo every B1 was able to work without a controlship. I thin he just did this so the Rebbels got a small change to win...😂
I don't think the CSI frigates are as impressive as you think. Sure they have the heavy forward guns. But they fire slow. They have very weak armour. From what I've read about rebel assault frigates, they had high firepower. I think the Star fighters would wreck the CIS frigates. While the smaller rebel cap ships would take shots from range whilst letting the moncals strong shields take the brunt of the fire power.
Old Republic Hammerhead vs Republic Dreadnought class Cruiser
Covenant Elite/Brute Honor Guard vs Emperor's Royal Guard or the CIS Magna Guard
Tie Hunter vs X-wing
Finally some love for the munificent 😂
do the unsc infinity+master chief against coveneant supercarrier ground battle with vehicales and space battle that would be amazing!!!!!
Favorite Rebel, Imperil, Separatist , and Republic star ships.
The lucrehulk had a few ,,forms"
Droid control ship
Transport
Battleship
And i think it was a battleship
Weapons of the battleship:
42 quad turbolasers
48 turbolasers
472 attack laser cannons
656 point defense cannons
And in the core are a few nore weapons
Wait, how many Munificents? I thought they had 2 initially, plus the 4 reserves?
2:40 the ship in the lower right blew up like it was paper
Starkiller Base+ the supremacy + 20 resurgent class star destroyers vs Death Star and its fleet + executor (both superweapons are fully charged)
ScopeN0Ob SUPPORT I WANT TO SEE THIS
Dearh star wins. Because he could shot diwn starkiller base before it can shot. Twith the next dhot the supremacy will find its end. And then...
Brot kann schimmeln Edited it a little
ScopeN0Ob but i think the death star would shot first(because he has the ,,smaller" weapon). So in my oppinion the starkiller base would destroy 9 out of 10 times. But if it can shot the death star down before gets destroyed i think the first order wins
Brot kann schimmeln i like your profile pic, it makes me hungry
I have a glorious idea. A what-if. What if Mother Talzin succeeded in absorbing Queen Julia's force energy? She said it would make her more powerful than any Jedi or Sith. What would have happened?
Here is a new idea for a space battle: Admiral Trench's fleet at Christophsis vs Snoke's fleet in the last jedi. (Hux vs Trench)
I’m pretty sure on the Wii version of Force Unleashed has the ship that Starkiller on being one of the two pronged ships, would they be different depending on which version of the game
CIS fleet used to invade Kamino in the Clone wars 2008 vs Imperial Defense fleet at Scarif in Rouge one