2020 Girls' Generation Vocal Ranking (SNSD)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 июл 2020
- #SNSD
Taeyeon, Tiffany, Yoona, Yuri, Seohyun, Sooyoung, Sunny, Jessica & Hyoyeon most recent vocalist ranking based off their most recent live performances. No lip sync allowed.
Finally someone who sees the amazing vocalist Sooyoung is.
Agreed
Sooyoung for me is an all rounder. She is an amazing dancer, too considering she has longer limbs due to her tall body.
@@forsythiazephyrinecho1783 Yeah. She actually dances gracefully even with those awkward dangly limbs of hers. And she has quite nice voice too.
yes!
She has improved so much.
So sad to see Jessica like this.. she lost a lot of her confidence as a singer after being a soloist and even admitted to be scared to sing without backtrack :( She should know that she is an amazing main vocalist and should not be afraid
She is still the second best singer in OT9 SNSD, she just needs her confidence back 😔 she was heavily criticized for her vocals after being kicked out and now this fear is also present in her vocal ability and how it influences her technique :( everybody can be good in something but if they have no to little confidence it will not be as good..
but i think jessica has found back her confidence in singing based on her recent cover of 'let it go' and 'birthday'. oh gosh i miss her singing so much right now
🥺
@@hazelgrace6454 let it go is in studio they can edited it to be better we need live she really lost her confidence when singing live
Kpop World yes as much as I love her let it go and birthday was a studio version and can be edited, we need a live version and without backtrack, she was praised for her vocals in the comment section and maybe this will encourage her again to have confidence in her vocals and maybe we will see her sing without backtrack
Not surprised about Tiffany, she got a vocal trainer when she came to America so her really vocal talents are being taken care of while SM would really push the girls too hard. Even Taeyeon has sounded raw from too much abuse. I love Seohyuns falsetto so much too, her high note in Don't Say No is gold!
I'm happy that she got a vocal trainers she was criticism before
Don't Say no is such a good song, Her "Hello" duet with Eric Nam is still my go to jam
I thought I was the only one that noticed Taeyeon's voice got thinner and more nasal than usual. 🤔
Tiffany likes American pop more
Tiffany, I always knew snsd songs weren't her genre because her english covers, and now her solo songs much more complements her voice and she's much more comfortable.
Jess also had a different genre now that she's a soloist which is more relaxing and tamed songs. I miss J's singing back when she was in gg because her vocal range were really explored then.
I hope SM would give Taeyeon more relaxing songs as to relax her voice though I'm more or less used to her powerful singing but @30 her voice is showing too much strain which is obvious in live singing.
i feel like during snsd, tiffany can't really showcase her full ability, when she goes solo she finally can sing the way she wants and we love to see our queen!
People needs to realized that being a good vocalist isn't all about who can hit the most high note. It's all about technique, breath control and how stable you are in singing despite changing keys and dancing. Sunny can actually hit high notes(& whistle notes) but does that mean she's at the same level with Taeyeon in terms of vocal?
I agree with this ranking. So many members improved their singing capabilities, most notable is Sooyoung and Tiffany.
I wish I could like this multiple times. There's a lot more that goes into singing than just hitting a high note a few times in the studio.
Be stable or not actually don't determine if you are a good vocalist or not. If you are gonna judge the breath control and breath management always is better check vocals without dances.
i think Seohyun has vocal skill better than Tiffany and Jessica, Sunny better than Soo. they have stable and large support.
Jessica is part of vocal line, her best is vibratos. She is vocally more stable and distinctive than sooyoung. She has great potential and ability. She should be 4th. Sunny (5th) has wide range but lack of stability and distinction.
Sooyoung sing fine, but she must not ranked as 4th. She couldn't make any long vibratos and her stability and distinction is smaller than vocal line.
Stability : Seohyun > Taeyeon > Tiffany > Jessica > Sunny > Sooyoung = Yuri > Hyoyeon > Yoona
Distinction of voice : Tiff = Jes = Hyo = Tae > Sun = Seo > Yoon = Yuri = soo
Range : Sun = Tae = Seo > Tiff = Jes > Soo = Yuri > Yoon = Hyo
Breath control : Tae = Tiff = Jes > Seo = Sun > soo = yuri = yoona = hyo
I saw Tiffany live in LA last year and people are really sleeping on her talent. Her voice is so rich and full. Most kpop voices are thin and high pitched to sound aegyo, but Tiffany is like a sexy woman. Her City of Stars cover here is magical.
THIS IS SO VALID 👌🏻
Lucky you! I am just too busy traveling in my work to be able to plan for a live concert. I would have loved to see her live.
I very much agree with you, when she turns it on she is stunning.
I agree, I went to her concert here in Chicago and she sounds fantastic and she was amazing she didn’t take a break at her concert. She dances throughout the whole concerts which is about 1-2 hours long.
The reason why she is not that recognized a singer in Korea. Korean are more into thin and squeaky voices.
Sooyoung’s vocals are so underrated and undermined but she’s freaking stable as hell, re-watching her lives and she hits every single note rock solid with no problem!! I’m so proud of everyone though! No matter what list they’re on, they’re always number one for me!
Yeah sooyoung got A LOT better at singing over the years but people refuse to acknowledge
Sooyoung isn't that stable tbh she sometimes cracks her voice bec it's a bit thin
Nonetheless she has a soothing voice i like her lines
Idk actually if she's improved or because she has longer lines now than before. But I definitely love her voice even before as she's my bias.
i think some here haven't watched Sooyoung when she was singing TEARS (which is a very, VERY high song that requires a powerful voice)
Taeyeon was one of the golden voice SM have. So they would give her comebacks as long as she rested good. Over the years, she developed and mastered her low and high range.
Agree, her lower register deffinetly developed so much since her debut
Her low notes in Angel was so good I got goosebumps.
@@lemonringo566 SAME SIS
@@lemonringo566 ikr in teaser video angel
Sooyoung is so underrated!! Her vocal tone is SO stunning
I totally agree!
And people sleeping on Tiffany's talent & her strong voice.....
But sometimes she's offpitch but i like her voice
Jyko Yee she’s human too. Her voice gets tired, especially she got her vocal nodules removed. It gets very painful at times
Jyko Yee Tiffany, like many other idols, was forced to use her voice in a range that wasn’t comfortable to her in SM. Tiffany developed vocal nodes very early on and she suffered greatly because of the pressure from SM. Comparing her vocals from then to what they are now, she sounds way better and more comfortable!
@@jykoyee1534 . every singer miss's a note now and then. She used to struggle at really high notes a bit, but I think she has been taking some voice training as in her newer works I'm not seeing that any longer.
I think Tiffany's treble is sometimes out of control, or sunny is more stable. Sunny is the one who is buried
So obsessed with sooyoung, after never being put in a vocal position and focusing on acting/dance she still makes an effort to improve vocally and perform live. A goddess
Me too. My UB CSY ♡
She’s my visual too. She is so beautiful.
Sooyoung Legit Surprised me, I wish OHGG had gotten some live performances for lil' touh *sobs* Happy for Tiffany finally proving the haters wrong and Seobaby is such a grown lady! Her voice is so pretty and she plays the piano and guitar while singing0.0
Taeyeon sounds so good despite everything she went through this year T.T She is a real professional, I hope she gets to be with Tiffany again and TTS do a special live one day.
agree!!!
I'm so proud of Sooyoung & Yoona. I can hear SO much improvement. Yoona sings live a lot for being just a visual and Sooyoung has been practicing so much I can really hear a difference. She's so much more stable and her voice is so beautiful ^^
I always believed that Sooyoung is lead vocalist material. She gets better in each live. She got less lines back then because she’s not that popular, and she’s amongst the most not popular member until now. She’s so underrated. Glad she left SM to pursue her solo career.
So What I never said she is in vocal line, but I said she has lead vocal material. SNSD should consist of 3 main vocal, 3 lead vocal, 3 sub vocal which sounds fairer. In other girl groups Sooyoung is easily a lead vocal. Her technique is the best among the dance line, even far better than Yuri who tends to go off tune & crack her voice although she has thick husky voice.
@So What sooyoung was literally supposed to be a lead vocalist till sunny joined so its quite ironic
@@iyainorangsakitjiwa1803 3 main vocals is way too much
@@TheCottonCandy707 but it happen.. started in RDR era, snsd has 3 main vocal, 2 lead vocal, 4 subvocal.. Seohyun took turns with Tiffany as the main vocalist joining Taeyeon and Jessica. And snsd has 4 main vocalist in "dancing queen" and "mr.mr"
The reasons why she have less lines is because the vocal line is just really good in singing. Look at Yoona, most of the popular but barely sing in their songs too.
Everybody talk about Tiffany and she took a huge leap yes, but don't sleep on Sooyoung who also improved too much!
Tiffany is Sooyoung's vocal coach.
I was present on that Tiffany’s concert in Manila. And I tell you, I did get goosebumps when I heard all her belting. She really had a strong voice and greatly improved in singing. Also, on Taeyeon’s concert too, her voice is a real music to my ears! It made me cry that night coz I’m so proud of them both! 🥰👏❤️
I'm proud of seohyun. I still remember that time when she's struggling with her breath control while performing. Now, she improved and doing good
I'm seeing a lot of people in this comment session whose opinion is still based on what their vocals used to be 6 years ago. Guys, people change, voice is muscle, it changes, it gets worse if you don't practice enough, also gets much much better with the appropriate practice and coaching, get your heads out of 2014, don't be fulled by autotune, this video is very much not biased, you guys are just nostalgic.
This deserves more likes
6 years?????? Are you a new SNSD fan? Do you even know Jessica?? Go and watch her solo albums. How can you say that she has not used her vocal since 6 years like you are making fun of yourself. She is not active only in 2020 otherwise you can search on Google about her solo albums and songs after departure from snsd. People really never follow updates and talk shit about idols and drag their images down. It's funny how people are making it seem like Jessica has not sung since 6 years when her solo album was one of the best selling albums in 2016 in china and other countries. That year only EXO and BTS and JESSICA had made to the list in China. Even in 2019 she had her song out (Call me before you sleep with Giriboy) Only 2020 is inactive including all the other snsd members too. It's ridiculous how people hate her without even knowing anything about her as an artist.
I have been listening to their newer releases. Tiffany's new songs are very good. I like her Lips on my Lips and Teach you quite a lot. Her beauty on Lips on lips is so breathtaking. She has improved her range greatly. She doesn't struggle at all with high notes any longer. She has had some voice coaching, no doubt. Even her dancing is smoother. It is not just nostalgia. She may now be the best singer in SNSD (I think so) but if so not by much. Taeyeon's voice and music are excellent. Although she hasn't changed her style all that much. It makes me wish Taeyeon, Tiffany, and Seohyun would restart TTS.
@@independentminds1177i am very much NOT a new fan, I've been a die-hard SONE since 2009, i listen to Jessica's albums, yes, thanks for the wall of text, you're still biased. Releasing some songs is not the same as focusing on singing and literally no one is dragging idols down here, chill the fuck down, i didn't even mention Jessica on my commentary.
@@Larucos Biased?? Just the facts haters can't digest. Just to make Tiffany's voice seem better it's not necessary to compare her voice with Jessica by putting her in 6th place and bring her position down. You can always appreciate your bloody bias's vocal without having to drag main vocalists. Taeyeon is also a main vocalist and makes a lot of mistakes sometimes on stage her voice sometimes goes off track that's okay it happens sometimes but people often ignore it but judge Jessica very harshly as she is an easy target and not in the group. Apart from this the video shows only non challenging performance videos of both Taeyeon and Jessica. Anyone can say that. I just wish haters will just STOP being FUCKING vocal coaches and judges when it comes to Jessica's voice. Dude she is a main vocalist over the years till now she is singing and excellent at it. Doesn't matter how much people try to drag her down her position will remain as a main vocalist in snsd and Tiffany as a lead vocalist. So CHILL THE FUCK DOWN.
SM really fukd up not putting Tiff and Seo as main vocals, TaeTiSeo was really something special. Before Mamamoo, these ladies paved the vocal stage.
I thought too after Jessica was not a part of SNSD anymore that now Seohyun or Tiffany will take her Main Vocalist position but sadly it did not happen :(
I like Tiffany's voice very much. Her singing sounds strong and infectious. Especially after returning to the United States, the vocal position has changed, and her new album lips on lips is really good to hear.
Seohyun improved so much really since debut, it's just unfortunate she's not active in the music industry or even musicals since 2018. So the growth probably stopped for a bit but she's still really a great vocalist overall and harmonizer. Can't wait to see her again performing!
Finally!! Some recognized Tiffany's voice! She's improved leaps and bounds lately and definitely deserves her No. 2 spot.
I feel bad. Jessica got so scared after leaving SM but her voice is what brought me into SNSD way back in their Oh days. But Taeyeon and Tiffany? Unmatched. Theyre amazing.
The clips op used are misleading
ruclips.net/video/4507gBzciAQ/видео.html
Scared? She is still making covers and her own music. Last year she did a collaboration with GIRIBOY.
Call Me Before You Sleep.
For me, it was all of them that made me a fan. My first exposer to GG was the Lion Heart music video. They were all so incredible and incredibly beautiful and stylish.. I fell in love with them all.
@@elley13 There was no fear involved. There was resentment that she was not taking her job seriously. That her fashion company took up too much time. She wasn't practicing with the group, she was constantly lipsyncing her part during live performances. She also had a major clash with a group member who would no longer even talk to her. It was causing too much stress with the group. So they voted her out. This is how I perceive what happened. Only the members know for sure though. I was sad to see her depart.
@@keithhoward4069 what I mean is SM block her after she was kicked out. I think she want to sing in broadcast show but she can't.
The moment you say sunny had weak head voice this is the moment i realised that this is not reliable
People seriously need to wake up and see what an amazing singer Tiffany is cuz she is AMAZING💖🥵🔥
Tiffany is not just a singer. She is a performer. She knows how to hype the crowd. She talks to them. She do addlibs and she's really good with audience. Her concerts are more enjoyable than taeyeon's tbh (tae is also good too). But there is something with tffany that will make you ask for more. You will never get bored with tiffany's concert tour.
Plus, she has emerged as a talented songwriter.
Yoi
@@Miunbxp as I said taeyeon is good as well because of her voice but when it comes to stage presence and overall performance, definitely tiffany. Taeyeon is more on the reserve side while Tiffany has this diva attitude when performing. And im talking about the recent concerts they had.
I saw clips of Magnetic Moon tour where she just talked about the most uplifting, and positive things I've ever heard. Kinda corny not gonna lie, but that's just because I'm a sour person. And i feel like, because her 1st language is english people could resonate with her words more because you don't need to translate what she's saying.
No wonder people love her, she just an overall great person
Well Tifanny has strong charismatic stage presence and exceptional showmanship so that really explains.
I agree, hyoyeon may be last but it's not bad, she loves her dance music and is getting to shine in her talents :)
And when did Tiffany get so gud? Hot damn her voice is making me speechless 10:30
*Also guys stop saying Hyo's "Good Girl" Stages are live, they all auto tune and it's so painfully obvious...*
I think it had to do with the fact she is now more involve in her music, therefore is doing more music that suits her voice... Hence the improvement.. B4 i realise she strain a lot, if not she kinda "overshoot" like too pitchy?? That is my opinion as a listener...
@@addlykajateklai1790 and still she deser that place now 😅 hater gonna keep hate her because her voice but Tiffany already show us how power her voice
Snsd has just great vocals that even the last place isn't bad
They stated out a good fact for hyoyeon- shes technically not a singer. She's a rapper/ dancer/ DJ so we shouldn't expect her to sing well
She shouldn’t be last.
that sooyoung live performance was unbelievably good, no backtrack yet she hit perfectly almost every single note!
Earlier days Ranking
1. Taeyeon
2. Jessica
3. Seohyun
4. Tiffany
5. Sunny
6. Sooyoung
7. Yuri
8. Hyoyeon
9. Yoona
6. Yuri
7. Sooyoung*
Back in the days.
@@MOMO-xx1yy in my opinion Sooyoung's always been a stronger vocal
@@xanyeeast back in the days!
yuri have one beautiful voicr for me
In my opinion, sooyoung's voice better than yuri, not biased tbh
GET IS SOOYOUNG Vocal qweens
Tiffany vocals really did improve more and more and her vocal teachniques this days are more comfortable to her now, and considering that she had history of vocal nodule, shes still belting, thankfully with the proper treatment she eventually recovered- What i mean is, that is PURE TALENT right there.
Seohyun I love her voice sweet and clear.
I love SNSD&TTS
Taeyeon is the Queen of Everything vocal, so I trust her the most. There was a reason she always chose Tiffany as her Duet partner, the one she went out karaoke all night long to sing ballads was Tiffany. Taeyeon saw her love and talent for music, and later Seohyun too. TaeTiSeo was born of these 3 pillars of vocals.
Seohyun high falsetto and harmonizing, Taeyeons strong middle & belting and Tiffanys low voice and velvety texture made perfection ^^
@@mic-shellcrackson3800 Lol that is not true. It's hilarious what lies you delulu fans come up with. Tiffany and Taeyeon went to SM and ASKED to have the Sub unit after their Lady Marmalade collab became a huge hit and later added Seohyun of their own choice.
Whether the other girls were free or not, change's nothing. Jessica, Sunny or anyone else was never apart of the plan. TTS was made of the members who wanted to *sing* for real because it was their passion. Not play with other side projects.
@@mic-shellcrackson3800 Brainless ment. TTS is the best sub uni of Kpop forever.
Any female group can't beat their levels till today because SM trained Tiffany and Seohyun as main vocalists from training days. So TTS are very good at vocal skills like Super Junior's KRY (main vocals sub unit). And you said as other members were busy, haha!
Leader Taeyeon and Tiffany, the most talented member, (being MC, Designer, CFs, she attended many fashion shows, variety shows, etc.).
Sooyoung shined more since Jessica left, hope no one takes that out of context >< she's just gotten more chances to sing since then Still love Jessica and thought she was the 2nd best vocal after Taeyeon with ot9
Yes. She's got longer lines after that although I didn't want it even though SY is my bias cuz huhu it cost us Jessica.
@@ainnemiguel7389 I agree. I love them both but Soo only really got the chance to show her vocal range when Jessica left. I guess it’s for the better, I miss Jessica though 🥺
Yeah, i could feel it. Tiffany is always very passionate when it comes to singing
I know Yoona is lacking but I love her voice, it's so cute and fluffy
Don't sleeping on Tiffany's voice🥺💔
gosh tiffany eonnie sounds so strong here. unlike when she's on SM
ent.🤦
finally someone gave Tiffany comments she deserves on her vocal
And Tiffany's vocals also improved. Her stint in the US really helped her a lot.
Tiffany has improved so much since 2015. She got a lot of problems with her voice that year
I agree, I think 2015 was her roughest year. I think after she got her solo in IJWD she started taking more control over the music and was able to push songs that fit her voice and style.
@Champ ! That wasn't live though. The ranking on this video is based on live vocal performances. Even the videos of her performing the song at her Golden Night concerts are all back tracks.
Honestly I can see why either Tiffany and Seohyun would be 2nd, I think they both deserve it.
When Tiffany nails her line it's magical, shes as good as Taeyeon in that moment especially the belting, but she can be inconsistent so you brace yourself like "will she make it?" XD
While Seohyun has a much higher chance of hitting her notes, maybe a bit less impressive than fany, but she's stable and clear and also has a lovely texture to her voice. I think Seohyun has a bit more control of her voice where Tiffany can get carried away in the song.
I think this is why I love them so much, SeoFany balance each other out, all of SNSD balance each other where others lack a bit behind
Omg u are my voice
I always saw many bash Tiffany for her vocals and mistakes but they seem to forget that she suffer(s)ed from vocal nodes and that makes it difficult to sing in various ranges. SM pushed her vocals ALOT and I think that’s a huge reason as to why all that occured. She’s doing much better now with TA, its good to see her sing in the range best suited for her
For real I always see people saying she can't do high notes live so she can't sing but like her lower register is amazing???
I think Sunny’s was not accurate, she has a high tessitura so her lower register is quite weak. She has decent mixed and also the best head voice in SNSD. And the video say the opposite 🤷🏼♂️
I was thinking the same, I remember vocal analyst saying sunny have one of the best head voices in snsd.
Agree not only the best head voice but she has the widest range in snsd
Agree. I think her and sooyoung should switch. She has the best mix and head voice.
I totally agree!
Truuu
The thing is Sunny & Yuri were the voices that were sooo strong in the beginning but we either lost/weaken little by little or werent used as much and correctly as time passed by 💔 💔💔
THANK YOU FOR DOING TIFFANY JUSTICE.
But anyways, I wanna say that SNSD are such queens like come on, we have 8(9) girls who are perfectly capable of releasing their own solos. Because they're talented enough to do so and because they're unique enough. I won't ever forget the way these girls performed ITNW right when they debuted, they're still the standard until today. Hyoyeon may be the bottom of the list but look at her go in Good Girl! You would rarely find the sub vocalist of a girl group being like Hyo on stage. The girl was singing with so much confidence and sass. That's Girls' Generation for you.
At the same time, I do miss Jessica's strong singing. Nothing wrong with her shifting her focus, I just miss the powerful vocalist Jessica.
I think if Jessica had more confidence and does more training, she could be higher. I’m very glad people are seeing Tiffany improving tremendously as she has a new vocal coach and SM not straining her voice anymore!
Sooyoung and sunny have such underrated voice, there voice are so sweet
Tiffany's voice is beautiful, it's so pretty✨
Taeyeon is a national treasure
i don’t say this lightly but taeyeon literally never disappoints, her albums are absolutely incredible and she both sounds so good and portrays such raw emotions in their lives
Sooyoung improved so much it makes me happy someone recognizes her talent :)
Thank you for including the first performance of Tiffany cuz I considered that a birthday present 😭😭
Taeyeons nasality is more an stylistic choice ,it gives her a twang sound.
Sunny has the best head voice in Girls’ Generation. Like, everyone knows this as a fact. So I’m surprised that you said she has a weak head voice. Her lower register is her weakest, she has the highest voice in SNSD.
And despite her weaker lower register, she has a wider range than Sooyoung, Seohyun & Tiffany (I’m not sure about Taeyeon), last time I checked professional analytics. Octave wise.
I know right? I would understand if they said it was an unexplored register, but weakest? I don’t think so..
Sorry but she actually has a weak head voice, it tends to be shaky especially when she reaches higher notes
Sorry but she actually has a weak head voice, it tends to be shaky especially when she reaches higher notes
@@lalainequebrado4000 What makes it weak ? Her head voice is the most consistently well produced up to G5, meanwhile her low notes start to become inaudible around Bb3
@@elijahjohnson5146 well she reaches the notes but it tends to be shaky and not supported, try listening to her "actually live" performances. There are times that she hits them perfectly but she tends to be unstable sometimes compared to the other vocalists of snsd
not Sunny having weak Head voice when she actually has the best head voice in GG after Tae
Finally someone recognizes Tiffanys talent! Second only to Taeyeon. She is the heart and soul of SNSD songs next to Taeyeon thanks to her incredible harmonizing and background vocals. All My Love Is For You - she carries that song with seohyun!
I don't know why people hate Tiffany? GOLDEN TALENT, VOCALS, VISUAL, STAGE PRESENCE, AMAZING PERFORMER, as well as an AMAZING PERSON EVER, kind and positivity overflows around her and of course her smile that light up everything. true enough, that people hate a person whos close to be perfect, Tiffany definitely GOT ALL OF EM, that's why they're so pressed.
she's so sweet 🥺
Finally, someone speak up and acknowledge Fany's improved vocals🖤
Same goes for Sooyoung's vocal whom alot of people are forgetting about.
Tiffany’s improvement is inspiring... her work ethic is crazy
Technique wise based on supported range
1-Taeyeon
Sp:F#3/G3~D5~F5/F#5(G#5)
Tier:Proficient
2-Seohyun
Sp:G3/G#3~C5~Eb5/E5
Tier:A-AA
3-Jessica
Sp:G3/G#3~B4/C5
Tiers:A-AA
4-Tiffany
Sp:G3/G#3~Bb4/B4
Tier:Average
5-Sunny
Sp:Bb3~Bb4/B4~F#5/G5
Tier:Average
6-Yuri
Sp:A3~A4
Tier:Weak to average
7-sooyoung
Sp:Bb3~G#4
Tier:Weak
8-Hyoyeon
Sp:N/A
Tier:Underdeveloped
9-Yoona
Sp:N/A
Tier:Underdeveloped
Correction should say put shallow near Yuri and Sooyoung as it is shallow
Sooyoung really improved a lot
The main factor that makes you cant compare 2020 snsd with 2012 snsd is the fact, now all of them find their own separate direction in music. Each of them discover their own style and colour, some still pretty much active in singing, some lessen the singing activity. For example, Jessica suits the most with snsd songs, hence she is the main vocal back then, compare to other members who dont match much like Sooyoung. But now, Sooyoung able to discover music that fits her the most, hence boost her position. Also, this does not mean Jessica become worse, it just that she also kinda stop being that active in singing hence nothing much to judge anw.
Another example is Tiffany. Back then, ppl thought her voice is too strong for snsd, but now, she discovers music that fits her strong vocal. She also kinda become one of the members who still strongly active in music, hence added points to her.
I love Tiffany so much...
So sad about my sista Jessica she lost all of her confidence and just gave up singing/bettering herself after getting kicked out of SM and SNSD. Shes still number 2 in my heart
Are you trying to justify the fact that she is 6?
I don't think J lost her confidence, J just lack the passion to continue singing because she found a new passion which is fashion. Unlike Tiff and Tae who really wanted to become singers, J likes to sing as a hobby which can be clearly seen in their present careers. Though most of the time it's a matter of preference, technically J hadn't been practicing her vocals so its lost its high quality.
Though comparing them isn't really applicable since they now have different genre and style of singing. I think they can only be compared when they were back in gg because they have the same premises.
Kicked by SNSD? XD
How to be kicked when you want to leave a group to focus on your dreams?
@@fiorellamucha2008 it's amazing how Jessica specifically said what happened to her but you, who had zero involvement in the situation, will make up your own story and say it like it's true with your whole chest
Fiorella Mucha She mentioned twice in both of her statements that she felt betrayed and that the members had her influence you delusional, try to twist her statements like the way you want to see and accept that they kicked her out :)
1 tay
2 Jessica
3 seohyun
4 tiffany
5 sunny
6 sooyoung/ yuri
7 hyo
8 yoona
I’m so proud of Sooyoung. Whether this ranking is accurate or not (let’s face it, ranking can always be biased) Soo really improved a lot. I guess the most important thing is that she improved regardless of the ranking. So sad that she’s underrated. Hope more people would recognize her talent
sooyoung has improved a lot, gosh i love her so much!
Tiffany's falsetto is heaven
Queen Taeyeon, always on the top from the first time until now
Tiffany deserves this spot... She's so underrated... She will shines more more and moreeee.... Tiffany is The Unofficial Main Vocalist of SNSD❤❤ her vocal❤
Guys, please calm down.. this is just her opinion, please respect that. I love SNSD too but everyone have their own judgements and rankings
Sooyoung is an ace. She has strong visuals, an EXCELLENT dancer and also has a very stable voice. She’s even hit some high notes on few snsd songs
Rap?
@@musicformylife6550 that too
@@SraSobreNatural okeay
@Hae_Moon94 paradise!
Finally sooyoung gets recognized!!!! And thank God for whatever coach Tiffany got in the US. They're making her voice the best it can be, and it's incredible she sounds so much healthier
Check out Hyoyeon in good Girl She really improved her voice a lot and everything is live ♥️🥺
Exactly! She should definitely not be 9.. and that is not from a biased stand point, she just plain should not be 9th.
True. Hyo must be on 7
I'm not hating but S.M has its magic with vocals during live shows (most obviously in award shows) their backtracks are actually pre-recorded live vocals.
@Pinkii Lights I can agree with your opinion about Yuri but Yoona has more clear voice and good with falsetto. Hyoyeon's Range is limited. Yes, she did a high note before but that doesn't mean that it's powerful
@@coy_shi8883 can yoona sing fast and upbeat songs? Not really... Can hyo sing and rap and dance? Yes.. Hyo can sing upbeat songs powerfully... Pls update abit...
TTS proved once again. Before they don't appreciate Tiffany and Seohyun singing capabilities. If have passion and get your goals nothing is impossible. Change my mind.
Sunny❤️❤️❤️❤️
I’m happy for Sooyoung... to yuri, yoona, hyoyeon and TTS specially to Tiffany for working hard she made it💜💜💜
Wow, Sooyoung really improved a lot!
I like this ranking but for me personally ^^
1. Taeyeon
2. Tiffany & Seohyun
3. Jessica
4. Sooyoung & Sunny
5. Hyoyeon
6. Yoona
7. Yuri
jessica in 6? you're being biased. among the nine girls, jessica is the most stable along with taeyeon and this "she lost her confidence bla bla bla" sucks. you say that because she doesn’t release music with a lot of high notes, as if high notes were the most important thing. jessica has the best vibrato, lower register and falsetto in the group, and since you apparently give so much importance to a high note, watch her cover of let it go, birthday and dangerous woman on her youtube channel, maybe seeing this you can change your mind.
Check her/him new video about this video
ruclips.net/video/DQ9Ha6m1_ZE/видео.html
gab who Let it go and Dangerous Woman were all auto tuned and prerecorded, she didn’t sing them live. The uploaded posted a follow up video on the comments from this evaluation.
Salty golden star spotted lmfao. Learn to accept that her skills have deteriorated because she's focusing on other more important things in life. I wonder how old are you to still be this salty
I think u r one of that biased. For sure, I prefer Taeyeon and Sunny as my bias. But i noticed tiffany get the perfect vocal after she debuted in US🤧 i've discussed about this with my friends before, we realy noticed it
Ed Jay Manzon she’s lost confidence in her singing. it’s most likely psychological but since leaving gg i don’t believe she’s had much vocal training to maintain her voice as she isn’t performing much still. if this was back when jessica was still in the group she could be competing with tae for number 1 but it’s 2020 when she hasn’t been using her voice as much, left the music industry, then returned. although i don’t think she should be 6. she would be #4 for me
Taeyeons voice is so rich and colorful. I really miss SNSD together
Taeyeon : sing, sing and sing
Backtrack, autotone,.... : Are we a joke?
oh, I didn't expect Sunny would be higher than Jessica, but I absolutely love when Sunny sings.
I think her singing is really underrated. Especially because she's "just" SooMan's niece
(many people used to say that a lot back then, and I really didn't like it)
Tiffany voice is really strong and she can got a high note easy. i love his vocal so muchhh
We know taeyeon is the best😍😍😍🔥
Tiffany sounds amazing 🥰
i don't know about jessica at n.6... but one thing i'll say is thanks for crediting sooyoung for actually being a good vocalist. with kpop's habit of having fixed and never changing positions, she never got the chance to get more lines even though she really improved a lot from debut 'till now. i hope she'll release more solo stuff when she has some free time from her actress schedules, i really miss her voice.
This show how hardworking tiffany and sooyoung not hating others
Yes👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
i always see sooyoung (and yoona) have big passion in singing more than people give them credit..
Most videos I've seen aren't recent and used pre-recorded/ lip sync stages from like 2013 XD
These are their most recent "Live" performances I could find to date, no lipsync, No backtrack (if even possible for that member), no auto tune or pitch correcting mics. I really wish Sunny would find a passion for singing again, I realized how much I missed her voice seeing her last live was in 2017 T.T
Honestly so many kpop fans can't even tell when something is pre-recorded anymore the shows try so hard to fool us. SNSD is one of the rare groups that can go without any ^^ I never see 3rd gen even dare acoustic unless it's on Sketchbook where they autotune anyways
absolutely agree! especially I loved Sunny in You Think song! it was so dope!
wow, time flies so fast
Sunny‘s last live was in 2018 though
Sunny's head voice is her strongest register?? It's her low notes that sound weird
I also think Sunny's weakness is her lows(i mean she's the worst even at A3),her head voice is her best register from far,she has supported C6 a few times before and even make it to use whistle register (but i haven't find that vid yet)
y'all are sleeping to sooyoung's voice!!!!!
Fact
I agree with this ranking so much. I feel like many times people are either biased or stuck in the past with their vocal rankings. Some members improved a lot over the years and other declined like lets be honest here.
My list:
1 Taeyeon
2 Tiffany
3 Seohyun/Jessica
4 Sunny/Sooyoung
5 Hyoyeon/Yuri/Yoona
But bottomline, all members can sing well ❤️
I agree with this
I always believe that my bias wrecker, choi sooyoung is the lead vocal material. She is very good vocally but sm prefer her to be in line dance instead of vocal line. Look at her performance during fan meeting, its all live singing duhh. I hope she will be releasing more song and promote it on music show. Well she deserve to be in #4 in this list.
True....I even watched one of her live performance during a fanmeet and she started first without any instrumentals or backtracks which only entered in the middle of the performance and still slayed the stage and made the fans sing along with her.
I always say that ..sooyoung is a hidden voice in snsd
YES!!!
I knew Tiffany was my bias because of something I love her voice, Sooyoung her voice is amazing I love it and of course Taeyeon Girl🔥🔥 These are my favorite voices from GIRLS GENERATION ❤️❤️ Agree with this video ❤
Sooyoung has a very sweet voice, I believe she didn´t get as much attention because most strong songs may not suit her voice, but you can totally feel the feelings she put into every piece and how stable she is. Her passagio is very weak, and trust me, a weak passagio mixed with dances, it makes it really hard to actually pull off a good performance, maybe that is why. I am not saying she has a weak voice, I really like it, I love all of SNSD´s members so please do not attack me
I've been seeing Sooyoung sing live more often recently. But wow, dare I say, she has a similar tone or singing voice with Tiffany? Or idk if I'm hearing it right? But she deserves that 4th rank.
she definitely has a similar tone to Tiffany’s nasal one. I used to not be able to differentiate their voices with the older music. but as Tiffany’s voice matured and Sm started letting her sing with her natural deeper tone, that’s when the differences became more evident
True... especially in their sailing song, when I didn't watch the video with their line distribution I really thought that Tiffany got so many lines that she almost ate up the whole song but it was actually hers and Sooyoung's. And I didn't identified my bias (Sooyoung) voice😭