Anyone who commented on the last critique video demanding more frequent episodes is in luck! Here's the next instalment of the series! Thanks so much to everyone submitting. Hopefully this episode can help as much as the previous ones have seemed to! Enjoy, Frank.
I actually like how he points out the issues so directly. In fact I would like him to dig the knife in a little further cause information is more valuable to my art progress than my emotions.
It really is remarkable that someone as accomplished as Frank would take the time like this to help others. Very humble and very inspiring. Good man. I'm not an aspiring car designer but I would like to help others in my own field if possible.
"Always do something that drives the engineers nuts." As an engineer I can confirm that's how a true designer operates. There's nothing like that 0.1mm design offset that takes a week to integrate into the engineered part only to be changed again next week. :)
Sketchmonkey's designs are actually quite bad imo, he slaps on modern designs but doesnt integrate it into the overall theme, and the designs aren't really fresh
ok 3 mins in Frank’s dropping science and giving the normal guy a lesson in car design worth more than money itself .... I’ve got a frank designed cosworth and this is internet gold
I've been drawing cars and eventually sketching since 4 years old, however I stopped around 10 years old. I'm 14 right now and this video is making me feel like trying it out again.
this is so relatable. i started at 7 drawing cars, ships, planes, etc and stopped at around 11 because i had to focuss on different things. i also lost like most of my art skills that i used to have. kinda sad actually :( but sometimes when i do have freetime ill give drawing a shot.
Man this channel! I wish i had this back 4 years ago when i was sketching cars nearly everyday just for fun. I felt so isolated when designing, it felt like I was the only person that drew cars and to see these professional critiques is so helpful. One day I'll get back into the swing of designing cars once i finish my engineering degree, but for now I'll just enjoy the amazing videos!
Frank, your critiques are so... diplomatic, insightful, and helpful... I guess it comes with understanding that drawing is a language, and it's a language people can learn. I wouldn't t feel so scared to send you a drawing for critique because I know you wouldn't destroy me 😅
The young artist is a tiiiny plant... The mighty artist can step on the little greenleaf, crushing it, and it will never grow again. The key is to nurture the plant... let it grow... pruning, aggressively, IF NEEDED... but being gentle. To let it grow mighty large and strong, blossoming in a towering tree of perspective and illustration!
As someone who has ridden bikes most of his life and only started driving recently I can't help but agree with you about A pillars. Imagine my surprise when I first went around a corner and my view was blocked by a big metal post, this was a new and unpleasant experience for me.
I never thought tis would happen! that's for the Critique! i designed it about 5/6 years ago and on google sketch up with no plans but freestyle, was the first car i done and thank you for you honest opinion! all the best! (lee Webb)
Why would you submit a 5/6yr old design for a critique? Like wouldn't you want a recent design that is more representative of your current level so the feedback is more relevant to you?
@@euly tbh I just free styled it and never really thought much of it, I saw this channel and thought might aswell send it in, also it was just a hobby at the time, I’ll do a newer version and re submit it
I'll be honest, I clicked on this video expecting some random old person that nobody had ever heard of yelling at the newer generation, but what I found was someone who seems to have a lot of experience, and genuinely wants to help the people he's critiquing the designs of. Nice.
Love these videos. I've loved cars for majority of my life but I have never looked at car design in the same way you do. Its extremely interesting to see how deep the language of car design goes.
Very refreshing to see such an honest review. Not sugarcoated just to win the masses like everyone else out there! And i do think that your comments are really valid and will help those designers to become better. Well done!
First time I’m watching one of your videos and gotta say: love the critique! You’re not sugar coating anything and your experience is tangible. Critique/review videos tend to be sugarcoated and all good feedback. It’s nice to hear actual legit feedback. Keep up the goodwork!
Thank you for the great content Frank, really learning more every video you put out! I'd love to see another episode of your dream garage series. Or maybe more videos of new experimental designs you have done yourself
I really enjoy these videos. Frank - it is really good of you to offer your expertise like this - helps those who submit designs - fascinating for us who watch. Thank you!!🚗
After listening to the first two minutes, I can actually understand this guy. I've taken two architectural classes in college. I had trouble interpreting what they were saying to me. Very well way of explaining things to students.
The master was BRUTAL on last CGI design! I thought it was great, if perhapds a bit too pancake. But fantastic concept! To be torn down by Master, like that, is just brutal and soul crushing. Which is the wellspring of all great timeless design. That bounceback from teardown. I would not have been so harsh, but then I am not The Master.
That whole tangent he went on about car designers having to design cars like they are from the future, is exactly why I hate most car concept art. I actually like seeing designs that look like they can be produced today. Not stupid looking hot wheels.
He's not talking about the super futuristic cars, he means more like, cars that won't age quickly. For example, for the 2012 model year we had the sonata, and Chevy sonic. Those cars look very much their age. Then the same year we have something like the Pagani huayra, a car that very much looks like it could come out now. I know it doesn't seem fair for me to compare a typical car against a multi million dollar car. But, it does show the importance of designing a car for the future. Even the mclaren f1, (aside from the old looking taillights), still has very beautiful sleek modern lines
I may not go into this industry but the things I've learned from you critiquing others is inspiring. With the things I've learned from you I will probably use while making my comic.
Hi Stephenson, I'm Alan and I am turning 18 this year. I'll finally be getting my driver's license and be able to buy my first car. Could you please make another video recommending more bargain cars with beautiful designs?
You can look up individual designers, for example Giorgetto Giugiaro, wikipedia has a list of cars designed by them. Also i'm 27 and i can't afford a car and i hate you.
Would love to see an episode of what you would consider as near perfection in design. Possibly from the designs being sent to you. Great work nonetheless, I really enjoy seeing designs which I think are great as a layman being critiqued.
From someone who works in the technology industry, believe me when i say sometimes it can get very difficult to innovate and flip the industry upside-down with something big and completely new
I recommend Scott Robertson's "How to draw" book. Is a must-read for all students of design. Maybe for some, the book goes a bit too heavy on the technical aspects of perspective, but all of his techniques (like mirroring curves in perspective, drawing arcs, etc.) are one hundred percent fundamental to know. I don't even draw cars (yet), but that book is a must read even when you feel you're above that "absolute beginner" level, because the techniques he teaches are fundamental to drawing.
Could you critique designs by Tata Motors and Mahindra? They both acquired brands known for their beautiful styling( Tata acquired Jaguar Land Rover, and Mahindra acquired Pininfarina), and yet don't seem to be able to make their cars compelling on the basis of their designs to their markets in India.
That second drawing reminds me of the Z3 hatchback I think they called it the clown shoe shape. Of course not trying to insult you but that critique while obvious to some it still essential I just hope they don't feel bad about it
My age. My intellectual age is about ninety-four, my emotional age is about fourteen, my work experience age is about sixty-two, and I am about eleven in dog years. Love your channel, it is a channel for persons of all ages.
It would be awesome to see an series or couple episodes of student work from universities or colleges and give everyone I guess an example of what is successful and how it can be even better, as a student it would be awesome to get your input in my work
Nice video! Especially enjoyed Lee Webb's design, I'm always learning alot when watching your videos! Could you please critique the Ferrari SF90 design? That would be so cool!
I’m new here and ignorant about a lot of what is going on. But I would say that clear pillars on a car is an attractive thing in rocket league, as it helps distinguish car positions which helps with car control and connection with the ball. Also, when people purchase cars in rocket league it’s different from real life, as such, maybe there isn’t such an emphasis on having a futuristic design. Perhaps the brief for designing a rocket league care would veer more towards something that stands out/is playable (obvious shapes)/is attention grabbing (which doesn’t necessarily mean futuristic for rocket league).
Basically designe awesome looking cars with features that could be used because these cars will not be used outside of a show for maybe one time only. Its the features itself that makes the money, not necessarily the car.
Interesting, I had seen this video when I saw your favourite BMW designs recently. You said the same here I said there, that thick A-Pillars are a design killer and need to he made thin. Not just for design but to he able to see out again!
4:25 basically very honest and true advice that you probably won't hear in College. But it will get you further In any design field. The reality is that you come across many set in their ways people that want to do it the "good old way" without any innovation aka. RISK.
Hi Frank! Thanks for your great videos. I started to design cars because of your videos got me to do it. Now I'm looking thru car designs and futuristic car models. Atm I'm making a Poor-Men's-Bugatti style car. I will send it when it's finished. Thx for your good content.
This is so funny this video was recommended to me. For years i wanted to go to art center college of design for transportation design. While working on my portfolio to apply I kind of lost interest. Now Im finishing my degree in Electrical Engineering instead, maybe I would have stuck with transportation design had there been motivational videos like this back then.
Anyone who commented on the last critique video demanding more frequent episodes is in luck! Here's the next instalment of the series! Thanks so much to everyone submitting. Hopefully this episode can help as much as the previous ones have seemed to!
Enjoy,
Frank.
On Wednesday I sent you mine👌😀
@@juana9795 where can you send it?
@@6000neothere's an email on the description of the video: supercar designer Frank Stephenson will critique your design
I sent him a couple of results twice, but he replied that there are too many designs sent by subscribers
@@JohnnyBlaster I’m checking them all Johnny. 👍
Would be cool to see you do a video on Rocket League car designs now that you've mentioned it.
Yes, and not just the standard cars, but the imports and rocket pass ones too
I bet its coming
I would love to see his insight on Cyclone.
it looks pretty good ingame.
@@cadeira2261 The whole Hot Wheels pack was really interesting. I hope if he does this he talks about the Scarab too.
Agreed. Like, he just casually mentions rocket league but it’s nowhere on his channel. Now I desperately want to see it.
The out of focus grenade is a perfect threat
Ahh, I'm not the only one who thought that.
Oh they were supposed to crop that out its just to make sure he makes the video
You see, the grenade is simple...
I actually like how he points out the issues so directly. In fact I would like him to dig the knife in a little further cause information is more valuable to my art progress than my emotions.
i haven't seen anyone so straightforward as him. He is so good at critiquing.
Although I'm pretty emotional, to me, information is key so I like his way of speaking but I understand that some people don't.
Dude, do not listen to this guy! He is a fraud, and knows absolutely nothing about design...
It really is remarkable that someone as accomplished as Frank would take the time like this to help others. Very humble and very inspiring. Good man. I'm not an aspiring car designer but I would like to help others in my own field if possible.
I agree, it's great to see him in a place where he's done everything and now he just wants to chill, work on what he wants and help others
"Always do something that drives the engineers nuts." As an engineer I can confirm that's how a true designer operates. There's nothing like that 0.1mm design offset that takes a week to integrate into the engineered part only to be changed again next week. :)
"Rule number 1. Do not design current vehicles. Design futuristic vehicles."
Thesketchmonkey: *sweats intensely*
Lol true but he does try to make current cars more futuristic
@@quincypurcell5222 he really doesn't
Sketchmonkey's designs are actually quite bad imo, he slaps on modern designs but doesnt integrate it into the overall theme, and the designs aren't really fresh
@@rnvsinha exactly
"Nah."
*proceeds to make 1700s minivan*
ok 3 mins in Frank’s dropping science and giving the normal guy a lesson in car design worth more than money itself ....
I’ve got a frank designed cosworth and this is internet gold
Frank when you hit 500k can we get a video of you riding the longboard in the background?
I wish you could double upvote
To the top
Would love to see your critique of Rocket League car designs.
lol the second one
I've been drawing cars and eventually sketching since 4 years old, however I stopped around 10 years old. I'm 14 right now and this video is making me feel like trying it out again.
Go for it!
this is so relatable. i started at 7 drawing cars, ships, planes, etc and stopped at around 11 because i had to focuss on different things. i also lost like most of my art skills that i used to have. kinda sad actually :( but sometimes when i do have freetime ill give drawing a shot.
@@shadowlord0162 Me too. I lost my art skills when I tried to draw a few days ago. I'll try to retain it back so I can make good sketches again.
@@bruhmoment6443 Thanks I needed the support man
Hello fellow 14 year old
Frank, you are the coolest guy in the entire world.
Man this channel! I wish i had this back 4 years ago when i was sketching cars nearly everyday just for fun. I felt so isolated when designing, it felt like I was the only person that drew cars and to see these professional critiques is so helpful. One day I'll get back into the swing of designing cars once i finish my engineering degree, but for now I'll just enjoy the amazing videos!
"This is more like confusion" - Frank Stephenson 9:46
more like concussion
Maybe not using an eraser is part of the artist's culture
@@danielwandawn3070 more like internal combustion
Yhea but after looking at it for a while it looks like an attempt of airflow,
Frank, your critiques are so... diplomatic, insightful, and helpful... I guess it comes with understanding that drawing is a language, and it's a language people can learn. I wouldn't t feel so scared to send you a drawing for critique because I know you wouldn't destroy me 😅
The young artist is a tiiiny plant...
The mighty artist can step on the little greenleaf, crushing it, and it will never grow again.
The key is to nurture the plant... let it grow... pruning, aggressively, IF NEEDED... but being gentle. To let it grow mighty large and strong, blossoming in a towering tree of perspective and illustration!
As someone who has ridden bikes most of his life and only started driving recently I can't help but agree with you about A pillars. Imagine my surprise when I first went around a corner and my view was blocked by a big metal post, this was a new and unpleasant experience for me.
These videos are always a good reminder of the beauty of the knowledge exchange era we are living in... nice.
I never thought tis would happen! that's for the Critique! i designed it about 5/6 years ago and on google sketch up with no plans but freestyle, was the first car i done and thank you for you honest opinion! all the best! (lee Webb)
Why would you submit a 5/6yr old design for a critique? Like wouldn't you want a recent design that is more representative of your current level so the feedback is more relevant to you?
@@euly tbh I just free styled it and never really thought much of it, I saw this channel and thought might aswell send it in, also it was just a hobby at the time, I’ll do a newer version and re submit it
I think it would be great to see Frank analyse some of Khyzil Saleem's renders!
Would love to see hatchbacks! And more sketches from people with a different artistic background (architect, painter, sculptor..)
Who needs to sketch when you can just make a poligon and you have a cybertruck
Keep up the great work, Frank! Always look forward to your videos!
I'll be honest, I clicked on this video expecting some random old person that nobody had ever heard of yelling at the newer generation, but what I found was someone who seems to have a lot of experience, and genuinely wants to help the people he's critiquing the designs of.
Nice.
Thanks. I just look old for 37.
Sad my submission didn’t make it in, but I’ll keep sending it in hope of inclusion
Welcome to the club.
Love these videos. I've loved cars for majority of my life but I have never looked at car design in the same way you do. Its extremely interesting to see how deep the language of car design goes.
Constructive criticism is so important.. and to get it from a legend, what a blessing.
Very refreshing to see such an honest review. Not sugarcoated just to win the masses like everyone else out there! And i do think that your comments are really valid and will help those designers to become better. Well done!
He's such an experienced person and a top professional in his field. We're blessed to get such great tips from him free of cost.
Lee Webb did a very nice job. Actually, I like the thick A-pillar because it integrates into and enhances the beautiful arched roofside.
I love Frank Stephenson and i think he should play Beast in the next X-Men
he kinda looks like a mob boss lol
Lol. True.
@@drincc Mob Boss? Hahahahahaha!
@@richardike2342 I mean, no? 😬
@@drincc Frank was a Car design Boss, that's about what he looks like to me.
The Spitfire, the Concorde...please
All the best to everyone
You mustn't forget the Hawker Hurricane too :D
First time I’m watching one of your videos and gotta say: love the critique! You’re not sugar coating anything and your experience is tangible.
Critique/review videos tend to be sugarcoated and all good feedback.
It’s nice to hear actual legit feedback.
Keep up the goodwork!
I don't know how I got here but watching an expert constructively roasting submissions is strangely cool
Thank you for the great content Frank, really learning more every video you put out!
I'd love to see another episode of your dream garage series. Or maybe more videos of new experimental designs you have done yourself
The last submission looks like a Bentley-Beetle hybrid.
I had the same thought, looks like a hypercar made by their collective effort.
I really enjoy these videos. Frank - it is really good of you to offer your expertise like this - helps those who submit designs - fascinating for us who watch. Thank you!!🚗
We want a video where you would be showing what scale models you have in your studio.....pls
After listening to the first two minutes, I can actually understand this guy. I've taken two architectural classes in college. I had trouble interpreting what they were saying to me. Very well way of explaining things to students.
Very generous of Mr. Stephenson. Fun and educational as well.
Honestly the kindest critique I've ever heard
This guy: "Rule number 1:.."
Rocket league players: "There is another"
😭😭😭
The master was BRUTAL on last CGI design! I thought it was great, if perhapds a bit too pancake. But fantastic concept! To be torn down by Master, like that, is just brutal and soul crushing. Which is the wellspring of all great timeless design. That bounceback from teardown. I would not have been so harsh, but then I am not The Master.
Don't change it! Your A-pillar is totally fine.
Best,
Structural Engineer
Have you been sent to the future from the past Zujia???
@@FrankStephensondesign Haha!
Man it’s crazy that I just found about your Chanel just now. Keep up the good work you are the man!
That whole tangent he went on about car designers having to design cars like they are from the future, is exactly why I hate most car concept art. I actually like seeing designs that look like they can be produced today. Not stupid looking hot wheels.
He's not talking about the super futuristic cars, he means more like, cars that won't age quickly.
For example, for the 2012 model year we had the sonata, and Chevy sonic. Those cars look very much their age.
Then the same year we have something like the Pagani huayra, a car that very much looks like it could come out now.
I know it doesn't seem fair for me to compare a typical car against a multi million dollar car. But, it does show the importance of designing a car for the future.
Even the mclaren f1, (aside from the old looking taillights), still has very beautiful sleek modern lines
I am 49 and i learned something new today. Thanks Frank :)
I may not go into this industry but the things I've learned from you critiquing others is inspiring. With the things I've learned from you I will probably use while making my comic.
I love this lava lamp in the background. Its quite fancy ngl xD
Hi Stephenson, I'm Alan and I am turning 18 this year. I'll finally be getting my driver's license and be able to buy my first car. Could you please make another video recommending more bargain cars with beautiful designs?
You can look up individual designers, for example Giorgetto Giugiaro, wikipedia has a list of cars designed by them. Also i'm 27 and i can't afford a car and i hate you.
@@hrsmp buy a second hand car
"Don't forget the licence plate, you need that..."
BMW 4series designers " Shit..."
Isuzu made a concept car back in the 80's called the 4200R. I would like you two cents on that design which I think was very interesting for that era.
Would love to see an episode of what you would consider as near perfection in design. Possibly from the designs being sent to you. Great work nonetheless, I really enjoy seeing designs which I think are great as a layman being critiqued.
From someone who works in the technology industry, believe me when i say sometimes it can get very difficult to innovate and flip the industry upside-down with something big and completely new
I recommend Scott Robertson's "How to draw" book. Is a must-read for all students of design.
Maybe for some, the book goes a bit too heavy on the technical aspects of perspective, but all of his techniques (like mirroring curves in perspective, drawing arcs, etc.) are one hundred percent fundamental to know.
I don't even draw cars (yet), but that book is a must read even when you feel you're above that "absolute beginner" level, because the techniques he teaches are fundamental to drawing.
Could you critique designs by Tata Motors and Mahindra? They both acquired brands known for their beautiful styling( Tata acquired Jaguar Land Rover, and Mahindra acquired Pininfarina), and yet don't seem to be able to make their cars compelling on the basis of their designs to their markets in India.
17:10 somehow with just that little filling in with his pen he made that car look like a boat.
Funny how I've never been a car guy, but always a sketcher, and now suddenly I get suggested this and I simply can't get enough.
That second drawing reminds me of the Z3 hatchback I think they called it the clown shoe shape. Of course not trying to insult you but that critique while obvious to some it still essential I just hope they don't feel bad about it
Would be cool to hear you about front and rear lights design in general. Greetings from Argentina.
The rocket lava lamp is super cool. You got some cool pieces in your office
My age. My intellectual age is about ninety-four, my emotional age is about fourteen, my work experience age is about sixty-two, and I am about eleven in dog years. Love your channel, it is a channel for persons of all ages.
This is like free schooling im soaking all this up! Thanks Frank!
that first one looks kinda like a potiac judging the grille
Thought about giving your thoughts on Hotwheels cars? Considering a portion is designed by actual Vehicle Designers
It would be awesome to see an series or couple episodes of student work from universities or colleges and give everyone I guess an example of what is successful and how it can be even better, as a student it would be awesome to get your input in my work
Thanks for the masterclass
Oh i did not expect drawing advice before clicking this, very cool
Nice video! Especially enjoyed Lee Webb's design, I'm always learning alot when watching your videos!
Could you please critique the Ferrari SF90 design? That would be so cool!
Somehow I can smell the ink of that black ballpoint pen from here.
great tips! learning perspective the right way is key
I’m new here and ignorant about a lot of what is going on. But I would say that clear pillars on a car is an attractive thing in rocket league, as it helps distinguish car positions which helps with car control and connection with the ball. Also, when people purchase cars in rocket league it’s different from real life, as such, maybe there isn’t such an emphasis on having a futuristic design. Perhaps the brief for designing a rocket league care would veer more towards something that stands out/is playable (obvious shapes)/is attention grabbing (which doesn’t necessarily mean futuristic for rocket league).
Nice to see something new every now and then
Basically designe awesome looking cars with features that could be used because these cars will not be used outside of a show for maybe one time only. Its the features itself that makes the money, not necessarily the car.
Interesting, I had seen this video when I saw your favourite BMW designs recently. You said the same here I said there, that thick A-Pillars are a design killer and need to he made thin. Not just for design but to he able to see out again!
Easily one of my favourite youtube channels :)
First thing I thought was how much this guy looks like jack black, might just be me but anyways amazing video
I seriously like that second one I recon with a little bit of improvement it could be a really nice hatchback
I love how harsh you critique because its not in an agressive way is to try to improve.
As a swedish guy absolutely in love with volvos new style it would be fun to se what you have to say about for example XC40 or XC90
No Doubt about Volvo, but i'd love to see SAAB make a comeback into Mainstream car industries
Man, I wish I had a teacher like this when I was in school.
This is fantastic feedback. With this sort of feedback, the learning curve for a designer would be dramatically increased. Very interesting videos
What do you think of the Lucid Air? It's a new EV with a lot of the design elements you mention in your videos. Maybe give it a look?
4:25 basically very honest and true advice that you probably won't hear in College. But it will get you further In any design field. The reality is that you come across many set in their ways people that want to do it the "good old way" without any innovation aka. RISK.
Once a friend that works as an engineer told me that, and i quote, "The designers work is to make the engineers sweat". Awesome video as always Frank!
Awesome to share your expertise.
I’m only here because I saw the rocket league logo in the thumbnail lol
Wheels being taller than the car itself, poking out the top with no cover. he said “its the future”
Another CYD video dropped! Always anticipating these
Last one is great! Something like VW or PORSCHE near future. Render is perfect! Only problem maybe proportion, but I not quit sure.
Sir Stephenson is a great teacher
WHY IS THERE A GRENADE IN FRONT OFF THE CAMERA !!
The necessary accessory of a pro designer... a pen, a cigar and a reliable grenade.
I thought you will critique people's Rocket League car designs after seeing the Rocket League logo at the thumbnail. Pretty cool video anyways.
Maybe the white blob on the last model was meant to accentuate the shape of the side mirror
Hi Frank!
Thanks for your great videos.
I started to design cars because of your videos got me to do it. Now I'm looking thru car designs and futuristic car models. Atm I'm making a Poor-Men's-Bugatti style car.
I will send it when it's finished.
Thx for your good content.
True inspiration you are sir
I clicked for rocket league. But I subscribed because this is actually really interesting.
This is so funny this video was recommended to me. For years i wanted to go to art center college of design for transportation design. While working on my portfolio to apply I kind of lost interest. Now Im finishing my degree in Electrical Engineering instead, maybe I would have stuck with transportation design had there been motivational videos like this back then.
I have no artistic ability. Just a lot of creativity. I enjoy your videos for the artistic insights.
Last one was a bentley bugatti ferrari Lamborghini combo
Pretty sure that second drawing was channeling the Ferrari FF/ shooting brake style.