Tom is NOT derailed (DCAS analysis #1)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 окт 2024
  • you probably heard this term a lot, didn't you? Part 1 of 4 (allegedly).
    episode 12 rant if you're curious: / uhyfranhe7
    #disventurecamp
    #disventurecampallstars

Комментарии • 62

  • @gardengraffitii
    @gardengraffitii 3 месяца назад +28

    Love the video! I really appreciate the Tom defense especially because I often see people being more understanding of Jake's behavior (getting James eliminated, being petty and jealous about Tom's friendship with Aiden, and Ally's friendship with Ashley) because they can view his actions as things that stem from his past experiences and trauma and yet when it comes to Tom, they don't?
    People seem to forget that Jake was not the only one hurt by the way things ended between them in DC1. Tom's actions (avoiding Jake, lying about a boyfriend) are things that ALSO stem from his trauma and past experiences.
    Also I'm not trying to paint Jake as the bad guy, this is all coming from someone who likes both characters a lot

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +7

      you put this perfectly. Tom and Jake have the same issue with deferent methods of approaching it.

  • @emanuelgarcia928
    @emanuelgarcia928 3 месяца назад +21

    Oh my god, thank you for talking about this, people need to realize that Tom was not derailed at all, yes, sadly he wasn't the main focus of the season like Jakester here, but it doesn't really mean anything aside from that, Tomster was always not that socially intelligent, he was just better at hiding it back in s1 because guess what he was a spy, though obviously not full one effective at being one, also by the way, just a side note, he also still loves Jake though it should have been clear by now, what he did to him for the two years and in the game was not out of malice, but rather fear of things going down the same way as it did in s1, but all thanks to Mariam sage of wisdom, he's now gonna try again regardless of what outcome, and he even now made a promise to fix everything up, and I hope for the best for them both here later on even though I know they will probably become a thing again!

  • @pizza8567
    @pizza8567 3 месяца назад +17

    Thank god this was finally addressed to people because Tom’s personality barely changed from what it was before. In fact he might’ve been better in all stars but I personally found him more enjoyable in Season 1.

  • @jeanrios3345
    @jeanrios3345 3 месяца назад +11

    Very good insight. I think the same as you regarding Tom. Only to add up to the "Nerf" part of the discussion. Jared showed on twitter, a video of the Jailbreak challenge on survivor, where one of the contestants, and experienced Girl Scout (The one Lil is based off) made the knots for the stick and it still broke. That goes to show that the tiebreaker could have gone either way independent of how capable Tom was at making Traps and stuff.

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +2

      nice info. thank you.

  • @ImYukiGamer
    @ImYukiGamer 3 месяца назад +7

    I liked that you talked about this topic. The truth is I didn't know if Tom was really being mean to Jake because Tom just doesn't want to get his heart broken again and he doesn't technically know how to react to this type of situation. I liked your video.

  • @supersonicheroes
    @supersonicheroes 3 месяца назад +4

    Thank you. Finally, someone showing Tom some respect.

  • @aaronscc.
    @aaronscc. 3 месяца назад +10

    PPL ACTUALLY CALLED THIS DERAILMENT..?? that's literally tom's multiple arcs

  • @starryboi1834
    @starryboi1834 3 месяца назад +4

    Love the analysis. Some people don’t realize Tom’s behavior makes sense. He’s always been socially awkward and dense. Of course, he’d delay the interaction with Jake as most as he could. He experienced something he had never before. He was overwhelmed and clearly didn’t know how to handle it.
    Off topic, also love the music choice.

  • @JT_999
    @JT_999 3 месяца назад +4

    I love this video, shows good proof theres no derailment and its a topic that needed to be talked about. Great job!

  • @Da_BaconKing
    @Da_BaconKing 2 месяца назад +1

    2:36 lmao he could’ve took it for himself, that shows how innocent he is

  • @gdmrhotshot3731
    @gdmrhotshot3731 3 месяца назад +5

    I always loved Tom, especially after he took the mask off since I got to see him be better and so

  • @TheCuphead02
    @TheCuphead02 3 месяца назад +3

    FINALLY SOMEONE UNDERSTANDS!!!!! THANKS! THANKS SO MUCH

  • @awoooga5857
    @awoooga5857 3 месяца назад +4

    Omg thank you. It's annoying af when I see people call all star tom derailment. It's like they watched with their eyes closed.

  • @zaibabraar
    @zaibabraar 3 месяца назад +5

    If tom doesn't want to get his heart broken, then he need to get back in all-stars.

  • @Heathers.necklace
    @Heathers.necklace 3 месяца назад +3

    i never found tom "derailed" because thats his personally in my opinion
    anyways great video, keep up the good work!

  • @luizeduardoR2D2
    @luizeduardoR2D2 3 месяца назад +7

    I think he was very poorly written in episodes 5, 6 and 7. He seemed like 3 different people.
    • In episode 5 he was horrible for ignoring Jake saying he wanted to move on.
    • In 6 he was worried about the challenge scene because it could complicate things with Jake (more consistent with Tom's character)
    • And in 7 he got upset with Jake because he should have known the kiss was for the challenge.
    I really felt angry at the writers for their poor work on one of our favorite characters. 😡

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +4

      I think he's morally wrong, but not badly written.
      I understand his concern for Jake by episode 6 but everyone could tell the kiss was fake anyway (except Jake apparently lol)

    • @-Theo-
      @-Theo- 3 месяца назад +4

      The writers for this show have no idea what they’re doing 🙄

    • @luizeduardoR2D2
      @luizeduardoR2D2 3 месяца назад +2

      @@-Theo- I think because there are so many episodes they try to stretch the plot anyway.

    • @epicnessgames4561
      @epicnessgames4561 3 месяца назад +1

      @@-Theo-also writing a show takes a lot of work. And there are only 5 writers, so ofc they’re gonna accidentally flop somewhere

    • @-Theo-
      @-Theo- 3 месяца назад +2

      @@epicnessgames4561 I know they have the capacity to do well because season 1 was pretty good. However they repeatedly flop time and time again in all stars, it’s not a one time thing. I think their biggest problem is they are very biased towards a few characters (like Jake and Aiden) and they mold everything around them, while doing actually likable characters like Tom and Ashley dirty just to make things better for their annoying faves
      The elimination order has been atrocious. The final 9 are so bad that I’m no longer interested in watching (Tom should’ve made the finale. There’s no reason why Yul and Aiden should still be here)

  • @toxic__boy987
    @toxic__boy987 3 месяца назад +4

    Cool vid.
    However, I do need to point out that Tom's reasoning for "why" he's been so avoidant of Jake HAS to be deeper than what he stated to Aiden in episode 9.....or else I'll be extremely disappointed/done with his character. Cos, the actions that Tom has done to Jake to avoid him, is WORSE than what Jake did to him in S1 atp.

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +3

      narratively it makes no sense for him to not have a deeper reason to avoid Jake especially if it will get revealed so late in the show so I wouldn't worry about that.

    • @toxic__boy987
      @toxic__boy987 3 месяца назад +2

      @@MP_Guz I hope you're right.

  • @cowboylikedinos
    @cowboylikedinos 3 месяца назад +5

    3:22 "This isn't some teen romance." Exactly why they acting like teenagers at their big age 💀

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +5

      lots of adults behave like this though.

    • @epicnessgames4561
      @epicnessgames4561 3 месяца назад +2

      @@MP_GuzJake is I think 23 or 24 in this season. He’s in his PRIME age of his brain development. I’m glad he’s trying to change himself, but dang is he having trouble.

  • @-Theo-
    @-Theo- 3 месяца назад +5

    Now that he’s gone I don’t care about the show anymore. He was the only reason I even watched it, so when he got eliminated, it didn’t even take me a second to unsubscribe and drop the show

    • @ultimxtemiracxler
      @ultimxtemiracxler 3 месяца назад +3

      Ummm okay?

    • @Keem643
      @Keem643 3 месяца назад +6

      I hear you man I mean I’m still gonna watch the show cause I have a few favorites I’m rooting for but Tom was one of the main people I wanted to see win all stars or at least make it to the finale especially since he got done dirty in season 1

    • @epicnessgames4561
      @epicnessgames4561 3 месяца назад +1

      Watch it for Gabby! Tom would def support that!

    • @-Theo-
      @-Theo- 3 месяца назад +3

      @@epicnessgames4561 No. I liked Gabby in season one but in all stars she’s been really annoying. She also voted for Tom, which made her drop even more in my estimations. Plus even if I did like her it wouldn’t be enough to get me to watch the show if Tom’s not there

    • @ultimxtemiracxler
      @ultimxtemiracxler 3 месяца назад +2

      @@-Theo- She voted Tom but he also voted her without hesitation? And apparently they are still friends in the end bcz it's literally just a game. Also she wasn't going to vote him out initially anyways, it's just the villains alliance. If you hate every single interaction Tom has with other people that had a slight negative impact on him, maybe you're right that you shouldn't continue watching it then.

  • @c1r3ka
    @c1r3ka 3 месяца назад +2

    1:56 oh!

  • @cagibritneyspearsfan4ever32
    @cagibritneyspearsfan4ever32 3 месяца назад +3

    I have no idea why people keep comparing DC to that terrible total drama show. DC is so much superior. It actually has good writing, comedy and characters unlike total drama which has no good writing in it at all and almost all of the characters are awful. It's no surprise people keep using the word derailment for that show but for DC it makes no sense. DC is almost flawless

  • @superiggykoopa3997
    @superiggykoopa3997 3 месяца назад +2

    I agree Tom was not derailed it only sucks of the plot like he was stuck in

  • @DawnFanForever2013
    @DawnFanForever2013 3 месяца назад +1

    Top tier music choice ❤

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +1

      your body SOTY

    • @DawnFanForever2013
      @DawnFanForever2013 3 месяца назад +1

      @@MP_Guz I used to listen to it so many times back in the day, I even used it in some of my videos I believe, it's just so iconic 💋

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +1

      @@DawnFanForever2013 i still do I'm obsessed

  • @lovelyloveloveribrianne2217
    @lovelyloveloveribrianne2217 3 месяца назад +4

    Can the TD/DC fandom stop with their obsession of using the word derailment everytime a character does something they don't like. It's getting really annoying.

  • @maciejpatura
    @maciejpatura 2 месяца назад

    I just hate, that they got rid of all Badass Tom moments in S1 and cranked up his stupidity to 11 in AS

  • @YourNumber1BoyToy
    @YourNumber1BoyToy 3 месяца назад

    I wanted to see them kiss so bad WHY DID THEY DO THIS TO US AUGBHHH

  • @zyxwv1838
    @zyxwv1838 3 месяца назад +2

    W video

  • @MarryMeTom
    @MarryMeTom 3 месяца назад +1

    Tom is not derailed but he can derail me 🤭

  • @starlightofmars3867
    @starlightofmars3867 3 месяца назад +4

    finally someone gets it lol he always was a himbo

  • @frisk8632
    @frisk8632 3 месяца назад +3

    Pretty good video regarding Tom
    Honestly Derailment gets thrown around so much without looking at the actual meaning

  • @CodySimp
    @CodySimp 3 месяца назад

    They definitely derailed his intelligence tho they made him look like a himbo

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +5

      He always was.
      I season 2 he cut off Ellie's arm as an attempt to help her, that's dumb af lol.

    • @awoooga5857
      @awoooga5857 3 месяца назад +4

      No, he was always an idiot. It's just that in season one, he was more serious because of his job. In all stars, he's more laid back, so it comes off as more goofy.

    • @CodySimp
      @CodySimp 3 месяца назад

      ​@@MP_GuzThat wasn't dumb that was what you would think to do in a apocalypse like that and a heat of the moment decision does not effect his overall intelligence. They go out of their way to make several comments on how dumb he is now that did NOT Happen in s1 that's just a fact

    • @MP_Guz
      @MP_Guz  3 месяца назад +3

      ​​@@CodySimp that was extremely dumb especially for him who has developed survival instincts, unless you want to kill someone for exsanguination you don't chop someone's arm off. he fell for a 6 year old's tricks, he cauaually revealed Ellie where the totem was, his lies are kindergarten level of stupid and he was casted as an undercover spy and showed up dressed as a spy.

    • @CodySimp
      @CodySimp 3 месяца назад

      ​@@MP_Guzeveryone fell for fiores tricks, it's not fair to compare his intelligence to an episode where logic is literally out the window. They go out of their way to make him an idiot in all stars which they didn't do in s1 EVERY character can make mistakes without insulting their intelligent like they do in all stars he literally thinks there's a post office in the woods if you think that compares to falling for a trick idk what to say 💀

  • @thecoyotemaya
    @thecoyotemaya 3 месяца назад +2

    W video