Thoughts on this trade idea and leave any REALISTIC trades you think they should make in the comments for a future episode! Thank you as always for participating
Why are we talking trades. We need these kids play better defense. Love Winn just wish more concentration on the cardinals way, Defense. Bob Gibson was a winner because, Defense. Our over all moral for a great defense has diminished. Cardinal Way will restore this team . We don't need changes we need belief that we can be FUN teem to see. I LOVE my Cards just play the game.
I think it’s a conversation starter, this trade offer. I feel like that we need to explore the trade option though. I agree with someone else in here who stated that we need to ask about Pham at the very least. I like Crochet more. Let’s go for him.
no, fire Mo, and Marmol will make the HOF as a Manager! Oli has already won league champion in the Minors, won our Division in MLB the first year he Managed in MLB, and is now challenging for another Division title. He's a pretty astute Manager, doing a good job. The players like and respect him (unlike their feelings toward Mo). Mo is all that's holding Oli back.
Yea I'm DC fan ..he had the best spring of all our guts only that unfortunate collision was a big set back..that ac joint still healing..I see him working that shoulder still..keep him Unless it's a number 1 or 2 pitcher which we need
When Edman is back he should go to 2nd and stay there. Much less chance for Edman to hurt himself again. And what a middle infield that would be. A top duo in the Nat'l league. Leave Siani in CF and Gorman to DH and use when Tommy needs a day off. Gorman did well defensively at 2nd but the bat is dreadful. He need to focus on contact and let the power come naturally.
Put Tommy Pham in the Fedde deal. Also add a reliever. Does Brebbia work? All vets for the stretch run. Or build a deal for Luis Robert that throws in Fedde
Bowden needs to have someone report him and be declared insane! He is going around making CRAZY trade suggestions on a whole boatload of MLB teams this week, selling out their futures. He must have issues with self-esteem, needs to see his weird pronouncements in print and on video to feed his ego. 😂
This lineup gets tricky once guys like Edman and Noot, and especially Contreras, come back. The only question is, do they all or who's able to make it back by the trade deadline. If Edman stays in Center, I think it's the end of the line for Carlson despite the amazing throw, which admittedly, Edman could never have made. But the reality is, we need someone to hit higher than .175. Once Noot comes back, I'm assuming Burleson goes to pure DH and Donovan to 2nd. It's going to get sticky between Donovan and Gorman. You want Gorman's power, but he strikes out way to often. His strikeout percentage is higher than his on-base lol. Last thought, why is JW not on this team? Are we saying, regardless of power numbers, we don't think he can hit over .175 and maybe 2 hr in 40 games? Why do we continue to give opportunity after opportunity to guys like Paul Dejong and Carlson but leave Victor Scott and JW in AAA???
maybe because they were hitting below 150 with 1 homer between the both of them speaking of dejong he is hitting better than arenado and goldy..Im sure glad your not a Gm the cardinals would be 20 games with you running the show
SIGN TREVOR BAUER!!!!!! Is there one decent legitimate reason the Cardinals shouldn't sign him? He's proven his innocence one of the women who accused him of wrongdoing is being charged for it, what else does he need to do?!?!? Leage minimum guys. Thats all he costs. No prospects to give up. And he definitely is better than Lynn.
Hey JD- I think Masyn Winn is most likely the biggest hitter - but also Alec Burleson has done a lot for the teams wins. On the trade situation I have to agree with you - your way smarter than I am. I'm still excited about the throw by Dylan Carlson at home plate - it was awesome - the guy came through when we needed it the most.
Man, the comment about being back over .500 didn’t age well at all. I feel like this team is a below .500 team, hard to imagine them consistently winning to stay over .500.
You've got to go ahead and walk the Marlin hitter when it's a count of 2-0. On Wednesday 3-3 tie in bottom of ninth. Then set up new for next hitter. Definite coaching error! Ya can't lose 2 of 3 to the marlins
No to Erik Fedde. He somehow found lightning in the bottle but he has been extremely bad over the past. Fedde is no better than Pallante. Fedde has a career 5.03 ERA. No signs that the recent success will continue. It's like trading away Gallen again.
Matz and Gio should be traded or cut. Gorman is trade bait he strikes out to much and will not likely be in the league more than a few more years. Carlson should be trade bait too.
The Cardinals had a 3 run lead in the late part of that game and ended up allowing the tie but it went into extras and fernandez was mvp of that game completely saved us there. The Cardinals are that team that if fhey do something good they do something bad and sometimes it's the other way around. I think the starting OF should be Edman, Michael Sani, Nootbar or Burly. I would completely trade Carlson because you have Jordan Walker that could return and you need maybe someone else in Carlson spot. Carlson actually gunned that runner down so that was amazing but I'm thinking long term Carlson should be traded.
Walker will be traded, he will not be coming back for more than a cup of coffee after the Minor league season ends. He has been awful in AAA, the general consensus is saying.
Jim Bowden? You mean the Jim Bowden that picked us last in our division to start the season? You mean the man who crowed to no end in April when he insisted the Cards will not hit and the Cubs are much better? Jim Bowden, the perennial Cards hater? Mr. West Coast slang and smooze now has advice for us? Screw that guy!!!!!!!!!!!!
I remember when I hit 10k subs here on RUclips a few months ago. It may not seem like a lot to many, but It's a big deal. In my opinion it crazy that JD here on locked in & Brenden Schaeffer channel here on RUclips doesn't have at minimum 100k subs by now. You guys in my opinion do amazing commentary about the St. Louis Cardinals. You'll be a 10k in no time and it's well deserved sir.
Hey JD; I agree with your take to not trade our farm pitchers for a relatively unknown. The Redsox may be sellers and RH Starter Nick Pivetta could be available, albeit I have no idea what the Sox would require in a return. Also, the Rays Zach Eflin might be had. The question would be if the Cards could take on his 40M contract that runs through 2025. Taking on that contract should cost less in prospects though. Would the Cards be willing to give a big haul in Chicago Whitesox Garrett Crochet? To get someone to go with Gray as a solid 1 two punch you have to pay or give up prospects. It all depends on what the other team wants and if the FO is willing to puke or not.
Good answer! We do better for longer with organic growth!! Think about the unseen yet potential that currently exists and get a couple of those motors going to be at a perfect sync for the playoffs….TLR days, I recalll him saying around this time during a tough opening that let’s see where we are at All Star break, I’ll be happy at 500….then we will be in a competitive position!! They went into the playoffs and I believe that was the same year into the series…Great answer- let’s a I m for all cylinders firing middle of to end of September…👍🏻
Bowden is always trying to destroy our team. I would like them to go after Lorenz from Florida. I would give up one of those with a Sageese for someone.
How about NO on that trade. No disrespect to Fedee but you should get a bit more for that. Hjerpe has that Hader type delivery and I think he will be great.
Guys they barely and I do mean barely beat one of the worst teams in baseball yesterday. I have no hope for them until first they get rid of a manager who never even played big league ball. A lot of the games they have won has been because of errors made by the other team, not them playing good baseball.
@@muthergoose4084 Gah! Yes, I put the Y in the wrong name. I recently watched an old draft recap of that class (2020?) and the guy called Winn a pitcher. 😁
@dennissmith5042 yeah you just compliment his few bad outings..already 33 ip at that rate he will pitch over 100 ip for the year or 3quarters of the games total and really should be around 75 for a reliever or just under half of 162 game season. Respectable 2.41 era for leading in innings pitched. Hopefully he will have the day off again but it sounds like he may pitch today if needed. It's just a result of very high leverage situations and number of bt and were only at 72 games in. Don't just look at 3 days off it is your overall ip..bt ..games pithed...sore loser🤣 maybe you want to trade him.. it's similar to all those people comments when we were losing. Remember we are just good enough to beat the sub 500 teams at this point. If our hitting comes around we might catch the brewers.
Edman is trade bait as far as I'm concerned. He got hurt in Oct '23 for goodness sake. Wtf. Seems he's most happy being a dad. So glad they hung on to Donovan.
Thoughts on this trade idea and leave any REALISTIC trades you think they should make in the comments for a future episode! Thank you as always for participating
JD I think they should go after Luis Roberts or a veteran OF with not many injury issues because we need that with Edman, Nootbar out.
Bowden is a tool . That would be WAY to much to give up for Fedde.
Yep, I agree. Don't do this deal
@@tonynelson2259Luis Robert is worse than Tyler O’Neill at staying on the field. Hard pass on him based on what he’s going to cost.
@@brianbartelsmeyer6032 well him or a younger prospect. Dylan Carlson can be replaced out there.
From Minnesota, longtime Cardinals fan. Really like the show, thank you.
Masyn Winn is a big reason why the Cards are in 2nd and moving up!
they should have kept dejong and put him at third hell he has twice the dingers of arenado
There is tons of information in this video, thanks jd
Two young arms for an older one that’s had one good year, No!
My initial trade reaction is the same, and I like the way Locked On promo competes for market viewership.
Why are we talking trades. We need these kids play better defense. Love Winn just wish more concentration on the cardinals way, Defense. Bob Gibson was a winner because, Defense. Our over all moral for a great defense has diminished. Cardinal Way will restore this team . We don't need changes we need belief that we can be FUN teem to see. I LOVE my Cards just play the game.
That's way too much to give up for a guy who has had two good months.
I think it’s a conversation starter, this trade offer. I feel like that we need to explore the trade option though. I agree with someone else in here who stated that we need to ask about Pham at the very least. I like Crochet more. Let’s go for him.
Yes I like that. McGreevy , ROM, and Graceffo for Fedde and Pham.
Yeah sure trade the players and prospects.@@ameliarobbins3180
lol when you
Said Dylan Carlson throw u said next year after break lol
Trade the manager for a cup of sugar.
no, fire Mo, and Marmol will make the HOF as a Manager!
Oli has already won league champion in the Minors, won our Division in MLB the first year he Managed in MLB, and is now challenging for another Division title.
He's a pretty astute Manager, doing a good job. The players like and respect him (unlike their feelings toward Mo). Mo is all that's holding Oli back.
@@rayrussell6258 He hasn't made a move yet that's impressed anyone other than the opposing teams hitters and pitchers. I agree that Mo has to go too.
Anderson will be playing better cause he wants to go to the Dodgers.
Dylans bats coming around its only a short time till he starts putting it over the wall
Yea I'm DC fan ..he had the best spring of all our guts only that unfortunate collision was a big set back..that ac joint still healing..I see him working that shoulder still..keep him Unless it's a number 1 or 2 pitcher which we need
When Edman is back he should go to 2nd and stay there. Much less chance for Edman to hurt himself again. And what a middle infield that would be. A top duo in the Nat'l league. Leave Siani in CF and Gorman to DH and use when Tommy needs a day off. Gorman did well defensively at 2nd but the bat is dreadful. He need to focus on contact and let the power come naturally.
Put Tommy Pham in the Fedde deal. Also add a reliever. Does Brebbia work? All vets for the stretch run.
Or build a deal for Luis Robert that throws in Fedde
They gave Lance Lynn 7 in the second game and the Marlins lit him up. I hope he doesn't complain about run support!
That's a big fat no for Hjerpe and Graceffo. I'd trade him McGreevy, Carlson, and Rhom.
Carlson ,rhom are horrible.
Especially Dylan
Overated .
Dude can't hit a lick
Buck 80.😂😂
Feels good to be over .500 again. Great video JD, keep it up
Bowden needs to have someone report him and be declared insane!
He is going around making CRAZY trade suggestions on a whole boatload of MLB teams this week, selling out their futures. He must have issues with self-esteem, needs to see his weird pronouncements in print and on video to feed his ego. 😂
The Athletic is based on clicks & comments, that's what Bowden does, nothing more nothing less.
@@brianhoffies4846 right .... being intelligent doesn't factor into his makeup anymore
This lineup gets tricky once guys like Edman and Noot, and especially Contreras, come back. The only question is, do they all or who's able to make it back by the trade deadline. If Edman stays in Center, I think it's the end of the line for Carlson despite the amazing throw, which admittedly, Edman could never have made. But the reality is, we need someone to hit higher than .175. Once Noot comes back, I'm assuming Burleson goes to pure DH and Donovan to 2nd. It's going to get sticky between Donovan and Gorman. You want Gorman's power, but he strikes out way to often. His strikeout percentage is higher than his on-base lol. Last thought, why is JW not on this team? Are we saying, regardless of power numbers, we don't think he can hit over .175 and maybe 2 hr in 40 games? Why do we continue to give opportunity after opportunity to guys like Paul Dejong and Carlson but leave Victor Scott and JW in AAA???
maybe because they were hitting below 150 with 1 homer between the both of them speaking of dejong he is hitting better than arenado and goldy..Im sure glad your not a Gm the cardinals would be 20 games with you running the show
Looking forward to seeing the Cardinals in Toronto September 13 14 15
Cardinals need run production!!!! Can’t win if you don’t score.
SIGN TREVOR BAUER!!!!!!
Is there one decent legitimate reason the Cardinals shouldn't sign him? He's proven his innocence one of the women who accused him of wrongdoing is being charged for it, what else does he need to do?!?!?
Leage minimum guys. Thats all he costs. No prospects to give up. And he definitely is better than Lynn.
Hey JD- I think Masyn Winn is most likely the biggest hitter - but also Alec Burleson has done a lot for the teams wins. On the trade situation I have to agree with you - your way smarter than I am. I'm still excited about the throw by Dylan Carlson at home plate - it was awesome - the guy came through when we needed it the most.
Ok, I'm glad I was wrong about Nolan Gorman striking out all the time..
What's George Kirby doing now and day wish he was a St Louis Cardinal! The Cardinals need stellar bullpen help like seriously.
Man, the comment about being back over .500 didn’t age well at all. I feel like this team is a below .500 team, hard to imagine them consistently winning to stay over .500.
You've got to go ahead and walk the Marlin hitter when it's a count of 2-0.
On Wednesday 3-3 tie in bottom of ninth. Then set up new for next hitter. Definite coaching error! Ya can't lose 2 of 3 to the marlins
No to Erik Fedde. He somehow found lightning in the bottle but he has been extremely bad over the past. Fedde is no better than Pallante. Fedde has a career 5.03 ERA. No signs that the recent success will continue. It's like trading away Gallen again.
Hard pass on those deals. We need a deal that moves big league position players for a quality SP
Again Oli takes series losses to White Sox Marlins and imo Rockies count as they are terrible why is this guy still coaching
Matz and Gio should be traded or cut. Gorman is trade bait he strikes out to much and will not likely be in the league more than a few more years. Carlson should be trade bait too.
Who gives a F they just lost to the marlins in a series
We. Need. Bats.
Really appreciate all your work! Thank you.
I miss edmuns and wilson and Jordan is picking it up in 3a
I agree JD I would not trade 2 good young pitchers for Feede
Plus we can add to those 2 with the draft this year
The Cardinals had a 3 run lead in the late part of that game and ended up allowing the tie but it went into extras and fernandez was mvp of that game completely saved us there. The Cardinals are that team that if fhey do something good they do something bad and sometimes it's the other way around. I think the starting OF should be Edman, Michael Sani, Nootbar or Burly. I would completely trade Carlson because you have Jordan Walker that could return and you need maybe someone else in Carlson spot. Carlson actually gunned that runner down so that was amazing but I'm thinking long term Carlson should be traded.
Walker will be traded, he will not be coming back for more than a cup of coffee after the Minor league season ends.
He has been awful in AAA, the general consensus is saying.
Jim Bowden? You mean the Jim Bowden that picked us last in our division to start the season? You mean the man who crowed to no end in April when he insisted the Cards will not hit and the Cubs are much better? Jim Bowden, the perennial Cards hater? Mr. West Coast slang and smooze now has advice for us? Screw that guy!!!!!!!!!!!!
Haha he sounds like a lot of the cardinals fans earlier this season 😅
That's to much for a questionable starter. And people forget how valuable Goldie is on defence.
Great show and a great game last night JD!!!
I remember when I hit 10k subs here on RUclips a few months ago. It may not seem like a lot to many, but It's a big deal. In my opinion it crazy that JD here on locked in & Brenden Schaeffer channel here on RUclips doesn't have at minimum 100k subs by now. You guys in my opinion do amazing commentary about the St. Louis Cardinals. You'll be a 10k in no time and it's well deserved sir.
Dont trade the house for a rental. The cardinals have had to many rentals.
When you get to 10k subs maybe you wont have to do so many ads lol
That’s on Locked On’s network decisions…not JD
Not likely haha
Use an adblocker and you don't get any.
Just FYI that was light hearted lol. I love the content and I can fast forward through the speaking ads lol
@@cococoolio7561 I figured as much. You wouldn’t know about all the ads if you weren’t a regular listener and fan. 👍
No thanks , iwatched jim in Wash. I want Nester Cortes. Yanks want contollable relief pitchers
Hey JD; I agree with your take to not trade our farm pitchers for a relatively unknown. The Redsox may be sellers and RH Starter Nick Pivetta could be available, albeit I have no idea what the Sox would require in a return. Also, the Rays Zach Eflin might be had. The question would be if the Cards could take on his 40M contract that runs through 2025. Taking on that contract should cost less in prospects though. Would the Cards be willing to give a big haul in Chicago Whitesox Garrett Crochet? To get someone to go with Gray as a solid 1 two punch you have to pay or give up prospects. It all depends on what the other team wants and if the FO is willing to puke or not.
Don't forget pages threw out a base stealer
Good answer! We do better for longer with organic growth!! Think about the unseen yet potential that currently exists and get a couple of those motors going to be at a perfect sync for the playoffs….TLR days, I recalll him saying around this time during a tough opening that let’s see where we are at All Star break, I’ll be happy at 500….then we will be in a competitive position!! They went into the playoffs and I believe that was the same year into the series…Great answer- let’s a I m for all cylinders firing middle of to end of September…👍🏻
Bowden is always trying to destroy our team. I would like them to go after Lorenz from Florida. I would give up one of those with a Sageese for someone.
Apples to oranges... Kurt Warner was bagging groceries before 99
How about NO on that trade. No disrespect to Fedee but you should get a bit more for that. Hjerpe has that Hader type delivery and I think he will be great.
What's wrong with JoJo his last 7 games ERA over 7
Overuse. See Giovanny Gallegos.
I commented 2wks ago..be careful over use..the starters weren't able to go 7 or more.. he will be ok with rest..
Guys they barely and I do mean barely beat one of the worst teams in baseball yesterday. I have no hope for them until first they get rid of a manager who never even played big league ball. A lot of the games they have won has been because of errors made by the other team, not them playing good baseball.
I don't mind that trade...
I think we need a strong left hander
Remember when Wynn was drafted and expected to be a pitcher? (There were some that placed his as a pitcher. Wild how things work out.)
You mean Masyn Winn # 0?
@@muthergoose4084 Gah! Yes, I put the Y in the wrong name. I recently watched an old draft recap of that class (2020?) and the guy called Winn a pitcher. 😁
A waist of a great pitching exhibition by sonny ,, shame on Romero for that pitiful pitching ,, but they never gave up
No it's not Romeros fault
@@scott2726 yea he gave up the runs had 3 days rest to
@dennissmith5042 yeah you just compliment his few bad outings..already 33 ip at that rate he will pitch over 100 ip for the year or 3quarters of the games total and really should be around 75 for a reliever or just under half of 162 game season. Respectable 2.41 era for leading in innings pitched. Hopefully he will have the day off again but it sounds like he may pitch today if needed. It's just a result of very high leverage situations and number of bt and were only at 72 games in. Don't just look at 3 days off it is your overall ip..bt ..games pithed...sore loser🤣 maybe you want to trade him.. it's similar to all those people comments when we were losing. Remember we are just good enough to beat the sub 500 teams at this point. If our hitting comes around we might catch the brewers.
I want a number 2 or 3 starter.
The National League is a joke. You have three good teams and a whole bunch of mediocre teams.
Its the level of talent in right now.
Whats people think of oli's 200th win
Edman is trade bait as far as I'm concerned. He got hurt in Oct '23 for goodness sake. Wtf. Seems he's most happy being a dad. So glad they hung on to Donovan.
Blow blow Romero and Helsley suck. If the cards made the playoffs, these two would blow it.
Sounds like a cubs fan from those 3 games up there
I think Luis Roberts would contribute to the OF tremendously especially with all the injuries out there. Pick up Roberts.
Robert is no better than Ciani. Lol
@@cadi197 Robert is better than Carlson