Mac Mini vs Mac Studio: Shocking results!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии • 76

  • @matthewdaley7535
    @matthewdaley7535 27 дней назад +4

    The 10gbit upgrade is great value. I have no idea why anyone would think it pushes the cost to the point where you should order a much more expensive laptop with a max chip that doesn’t even come with an Ethernet port.

  • @nick066hu
    @nick066hu 27 дней назад +7

    7:10 Ethernet port. I don't get, it if you need a 10 GBit Ethernet so much that it is a 'deal breaker' for you, why just don't click on that upgrade. costs only $100. This is the cheapest upgrade of all available, and the only one that does not have Apple Tax on it. ..roughly what a typical computer factory would charge for such a thing.

  • @Kevin6t8
    @Kevin6t8 26 дней назад

    I upgraded from Base M1 Mac Mini to the unbinned 14/20 M4 Pro Mac Mini. What a huge difference in performance!
    I left all of the other boxes for Ram, SSD, and Ethernet unchecked. For extra storage, I have a Crucial 4TB TB4 external SSD that gets swapped between my Mac Mini and M4 iPad Pro.

  • @JakobMooney
    @JakobMooney 27 дней назад +3

    The unboxing transition was solid! 🔥

  • @fluxcapacitor
    @fluxcapacitor 27 дней назад +3

    07:03 You can as an option configure the Mac mini M4 Pro with 10 Gigabit ethernet. And if you double the RAM (going from 24 to 48GB) to make it more like a "mini Mac Studio", then… it is just $100 less than the current Mac Studio M2 Max, which is slower, as you've shown - BUT… for power users, since the price difference is so thin, I'd just wait for the Mac Studio M4 Max. Otherwise, the "base" Mac mini M4 Pro (no options) is a great deal.

    • @damient9040
      @damient9040 25 дней назад

      The ram speed itself is what he’s referring too. * fyi Doubling up the m4 ram, 10g nic makes it actually a few hundred more than the m2 studio. But the m4 mini pro sounds phenomenal nonetheless

    • @fluxcapacitor
      @fluxcapacitor 25 дней назад

      • Mac mini M4 Pro 48GB with 10 Gigabit ethernet = $1,899
      • Mac Studio M2 Max = $1,999

    • @EricBBarker
      @EricBBarker 22 дня назад

      Agreed. The quick screenshot he shows of the Mac Store is actually of a MacBook Pro (notice the bit about Display options). Macbooks are great, but they're not appropriate for an office setting with an external display, so he shouldn't really even be referencing that. Seriously, if 10Gb is such a big deal, spend the extra $100 on the computer you need, don't jump over to a completely different line with an internal display you will never use and less connectability. When compared to the Mac Studio, the Mini is just better, as he's seeing all around. So again, just get the 10Gb on the Mini. I don't understand why this is so complicated.

    • @damient9040
      @damient9040 22 дня назад

      @@fluxcapacitor my bad . You can get the studio in refurb store for $1700 so that price was logged in m head. You’re correct , as that’s apples-apples comparison

  • @darylfortney8081
    @darylfortney8081 27 дней назад +2

    right now I am considering getting a used m1 or m2 studio on eBay instead of the new mini so good to see first hand comparisons. I guess the biggest advantage of the m4 is 3 years longer software support

  • @dutnakke
    @dutnakke 27 дней назад +3

    which monitor do you recommend cheaper than the Studio Display?

  • @brucekennedy5274
    @brucekennedy5274 27 дней назад +1

    Ethernet aside, you didn’t say if it could replace your M1Max. Maybe I missed it. I have a base M1Max studio 2TB, for design (PS, illustrator, InDesign) and video FCP & AE. I was considering swapping it for the M4pro mini with some extra ram and maybe the 1Tb upgrade for comfort. Am I crazy?

  • @vtrandal
    @vtrandal 6 дней назад

    In this video, it’s good to see that you’re comparing this with this for this is the reason we have this video

  • @burprobrox9134
    @burprobrox9134 27 дней назад +1

    No one mentions the memory speeds and it’s incredibly important

  • @im_tankster
    @im_tankster 27 дней назад +2

    Dude, you mentioned throttling, showed us or made us hear loud fans kicking in, and went on to conclude: "other than throttling". By how much does thermal throttling affect performance on a day-to-day use?. I'm not trying to be an a-hole, but genuinely curious!!

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад +1

      That’s a great question, and it’s my fault because i did actually talk about whether or not it’ll be an issue for day to day usage but then decided to cut that part out cuz i thought that might bore people.
      But basically I've been using this Mac mini for the past 3 weeks or so and l've used it to edit this video, 2 shorts, made the thumbnail for this video, a little bit of after effects, and also browsing, watching videos and stuff like that, and I never heard the fan.
      So assuming the fan only gets loud when the system is starting to get too hot/throttle, then for everything I’ve done on it so far it didn’t throttle since I didn’t hear the fan.
      The cinebench test was an extreme scenario (100% cpu usage). So as long as your normal workflow isn’t pushing this Mac to its limits you should be fine.
      Hope this helps :)

    • @EricBBarker
      @EricBBarker 22 дня назад

      @@imSpixel A lot of people are going to be pushing any computer they have to their limits, so that's really important. Cinebench is by Maxon who make Cinema4D, the most widely-used 3D graphics program in the world, which pushes CPU and GPU to it's limits on every render. I use it, my whole team uses it. It's a big deal to me, and a big deal to many many people. If you have a chance, I'd explore that a bit more deeply and share your findings. Thanks!

  • @Realist-m9c
    @Realist-m9c 27 дней назад +1

    The Ryzen 1950x Threadripper is quite fast but is a 2017 chip that can not be upgraded to run Windows 11. I have one. You are correct a PC can not be built for less than a Macmini and be competitively fast. Also the AMD chips do not decode H264 10 bit 4.2.2, only Apple and Intel have those decoders.

  • @TheAndrewL27
    @TheAndrewL27 27 дней назад +1

    Hey. So from your video I understand that the Mac Studio is better for video editing in 4k . More ram, no fans noise. Interesting to see in realtime editing the difference. And what is your opinion about Mac mini m4 base model for editing 4k video. Thanks

    • @redesignedlife777
      @redesignedlife777 27 дней назад

      4k editing will be ok. Im on m1 Mac mini and it runs thru no problem. You just want to make sure your external drive is on tb4.

    • @TheAndrewL27
      @TheAndrewL27 27 дней назад

      @ I have a m1 mini and it works fine with 4k 4.2.0 but for 4.2.2 wiht color grading I think to buy a mini m4 base model. I work just in premiere pro and for me it’s very important to understand if make sense to upgrade to m4 or to M1 Max

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад

      This Mac mini is pretty good for 4K video editing as well, 90% of this video was filmed on a Sony A7iv (10bit 422 H.264) and it handled everything fairly well. In terms of realtime editing, previewing the timeline and stuff, it’s great but not perfect, lags a little initially when there are over 3 or 4 layers with color grading, but that’s more or less the same as my Mac Studio. And I edited in full resolution in premiere not 1/2 or 1/4.
      In terms of the fan, I've been using this Mac mini for the past 3 weeks or so and l've used it to edit this video, 2 shorts, made the thumbnail for this video, and also used a little bit of after effects, and I never heard the fan.
      So its really not an issue as long as your not pushing it to its limits.
      And about the base model I can’t say much since I haven’t used it myself

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад

      @@TheAndrewL27you can always just buy it, test it for your workflow, and if it doesn’t seem to work out you can return it.
      Not sure which country you live in but if you’re in Northern America this can be something you try, in some other countries I know it’s not as easy to do this.

    • @TheAndrewL27
      @TheAndrewL27 27 дней назад

      @@imSpixel thanks dude. I will try the base m4 model to see if its good for my weddings edit.

  • @evertigo
    @evertigo 25 дней назад +1

    How many time it will be relevant? Let’s wait for video “Mini M4 Pro vs Studio M4 Max shocking results”. I really don’t understand this hype around obviously faster Mini over 1st gen Studio.

  • @fluxcapacitor
    @fluxcapacitor 27 дней назад +1

    Wait for the upcoming Mac Studio M4 Max then, you're going to be "shocked" again but in the other direction! And what about the Mac Studio M4 Ultra, which will apparently be the first Mac to outperform a GTX 4090 in GPU compute?

  • @Halo9K
    @Halo9K 27 дней назад +1

    Hi, I also bought the M4 Pro. Great review. Thanks for skipping the unboxing. So far very pleased with it though I don’t do video editing, yet. Great to know what it can do.

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад +2

      Haha, I guess skipping the unboxing was the right decision then 😂
      I’m glad you like yours so far!

    • @Halo9K
      @Halo9K 27 дней назад +1

      There have been so many doing the unboxing, it was refreshing to have someone skip that part. 😊 Great review!

  • @shanmango
    @shanmango 9 дней назад

    5:57 Mac Studio has replaceable SSD's and third party options are already available

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  9 дней назад

      Yep, I also recently found out. But wasn’t really widely known when I made this video. But they aren’t exactly cheap, definitely cheaper than apple prices tho

  • @fourthtunz
    @fourthtunz 27 дней назад +1

    Thank you for doing this video! I have the same M1 Max studio the only difference is is I have the 2 GB internal drive. If I remember correctly, the 2 Gig Dr. is faster than the 512. I think the M1 max studio is still a good option. I’m gonna hang onto it till I see what Apple does next year.

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад +2

      I think you mean 2TB internal drive, but I’m pretty sure this is an issue with the M2 series not the M1 where the base model M2s have a slower ssd, even slower than the base model M1s.
      But I agree, the M1 Max is still great. I also won’t be upgrading, sticking to my Studio for now.

    • @fourthtunz
      @fourthtunz 26 дней назад

      @ ha ha yep i’m meant 2 TB Drive🤪

  • @itsgmani
    @itsgmani 11 дней назад

    Ya I dunno man I really wanted the mini for the m4 pro but the Mac Studio M2 Max is just sounding better for the ports and the heat control. I don’t know how good that Mac mini would last if you’re using it for video and music in the long run. I really wanna wait for a studio m4 but I don’t think I can lmfao 🤦‍♂️

  • @mikeef747
    @mikeef747 24 дня назад

    Very informative and helpful as I was planning to trade my Mac Studio M1 for the Mac Mini today, the last day of their Black Friday promotion, but other than physical desk space it seems like there is absolutely no single advantage to make the switch. In fact, it seems like the only thing I would accomplish is spending more money for less features and I'd rather wait for the new Studio if I want to do that.

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  24 дня назад +1

      Yep, I’m not switching. Sticking with my Studio for now!

  • @longlostcoder6322
    @longlostcoder6322 27 дней назад

    What screen are you using?

  •  24 дня назад

    I need to now about the base model. But thanks.

  • @DanielDaveta
    @DanielDaveta 27 дней назад +1

    Is 24GB enough or should I get the 48GB model?

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад +3

      Depends on your workflow, but generally speaking more ram is always better :)

    • @Realist-m9c
      @Realist-m9c 27 дней назад

      always buy more RAM as it can’t be upgraded later.

    • @kjltube
      @kjltube 27 дней назад +4

      @@Realist-m9cI could also say save your (ram upgrade), money and buy an M6 mini pro later 😊

  • @aahh5281
    @aahh5281 27 дней назад

    Hello, could you please advise me the best way to connect a MAC MINI M4 PRO to an AZUS PRO ART DISPLAY PA279CRV screen. Thank you

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад

      Easiest way is to just use the hdmi port on the Mac mini, otherwise a better option imo is to just get a USB-C hub / dock like the one showed in the video.
      This is just generally advice for any monitor :)

  • @o2p2a
    @o2p2a 20 дней назад

    Hello, I am from Saudi in our country mac mini m4 with 512gb and 24 of ram cost 1250$, base model m1 max mac studio cost 950$ what is better

  • @theanhnguyen711
    @theanhnguyen711 26 дней назад

    could you please help me test : how long the m1 max and the mini m4 pro enhance denoise 1 raw sony picture ? Thank you so much

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  25 дней назад

      I can try, but how do I test that?

    • @theanhnguyen711
      @theanhnguyen711 25 дней назад

      @@imSpixel you go to the Detail panel (in develop lightroom), then see in the denoíse, click it, then it will appear a window with have estimated time (my mac mini m1 is 1mins)
      the image must be raw compressed or uncompress, not S or M raw
      thank you so much

  • @Realist-m9c
    @Realist-m9c 27 дней назад +7

    Buying an M4 Max is not really an option to the M4 Mini as it’s a laptop. Unless you actually want a laptop.

    • @redesignedlife777
      @redesignedlife777 27 дней назад +2

      A lot of people use their laptop as their desktop. They just keep it closed and hook up 1-2 monitors.

    • @chidorirasenganz
      @chidorirasenganz 27 дней назад

      @@redesignedlife777yes but it’s much more expensive. M4 Max 14in starts a 3k

    • @fourthtunz
      @fourthtunz 27 дней назад +2

      I think the M1 max studio, which I have is still a good option for a lot of people

    • @burprobrox9134
      @burprobrox9134 27 дней назад +1

      Huh? The mini is a laptop? The thermals are totally different

    • @Realist-m9c
      @Realist-m9c 26 дней назад

      @@burprobrox9134 Sorry bad grammar on my part. The M4 max is a laptop compared to the mini.

  • @riccia888
    @riccia888 27 дней назад

    What monitor can you recommend for mac mini that has nos scaling issues?

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад

      I think you’re talking about the little message in setting “using a scaled resolution may affect performance” when using 1440p. I personally don’t think it’s an issue, I’m sure there’s some extra processing required to show that rez but it’s negligible. So pretty much any normal 4k monitor should be fine. But obviously 5k would be better.
      I’m personally using the Dell U2723QE for now

  • @almarketing2849
    @almarketing2849 27 дней назад

    Great Review. Can you do Gaming performance against a mini PC of the same price?

  • @recipekitchen5984
    @recipekitchen5984 28 дней назад

    Love your videos bro

  • @dmzbdg
    @dmzbdg 27 дней назад

    THANK YOU for the update 411 , my G

  • @kjltube
    @kjltube 27 дней назад

    I see you have a Caldigit hub.
    Regarding the M4 Mini and cooling I think maybe elevating it off the ground might improve cooling. I'd like to put mine in small stilts.

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад +2

      I filmed almost the entire video way before the Anker hub arrived, that’s why you see the CalDigit :)
      I agree that maybe raising the Mac mini off the ground may improve cooling but I think as consumers we shouldn’t have to think about all this, the product should ideally be designed in a way that you use it as is and it works perfectly.
      However, to be fair I could only hear the fan during the cinebench test which is quite intensive, cpu usage goes to 100%, otherwise I never heard them. It was an extreme scenario

    • @Mangolite
      @Mangolite 27 дней назад

      @@imSpixel I’m contemplating purchasing a M4 Pro Mac mini. While I don’t consider Cinebench tests as relevant to my needs, as they cater to tech enthusiasts, I’m more interested in real-world applications, such as photo editing, design, and occasional video editing. If the machine can perform these tasks without throttling or running the fan excessively, I’ll be satisfied with its performance.

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад +1

      I’ve been using this Mac mini for the past 3 weeks or so and I’ve used it to edit this video, 2 shorts, made the thumbnail for this video, and also used a little bit of after effects, and I never heard the fan.
      So if you’re concerned about that i don’t think you should be. The cinebench test was an extreme scenario and i ran that test just to see how this Mac mini compares to the Studio.

    • @kjltube
      @kjltube 27 дней назад

      @@imSpixelI’ve had my m4 mini pro for about two weeks and it’s usually cool and quiet, but I’ve noticed it gets quite warm playing Company of Heroes 2 on high resolution settings. Istat shows about 75c for the cpu. Nothing crazy but I notice the desk surface is warm behind the mini in this situation and feel if it was elevated slightly it would dissipate better. Maybe I’ll try sitting it on a couple of pencils from left to right to see what difference 8mm of height makes.

  • @SheldonWilton
    @SheldonWilton 26 дней назад

    are you really comparing a mac mini 4 pro vs a mac studio M1??
    How is that even a logical comparison?

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  26 дней назад +1

      Because M1 Max Mac Studio is what I’ve been using for over a year, and normally you wouldn’t upgrade to only one generation higher, but by the M4 series the incremental improvements have added up to make a significant difference.

  • @TheMetalMag
    @TheMetalMag 27 дней назад

    the M1 was the first computer not making any noise with fans since intel. Now the more it gets and the more the M computers are doings lots of noise like intel. That's sad. I fI could buy a second hand Mac Studio M1 I would buy one!

    • @chidorirasenganz
      @chidorirasenganz 27 дней назад

      They don’t make noise under nothing situations and they aren’t as loud as intel macs

  • @yaolet
    @yaolet 27 дней назад

    the power consumption of that usb hub is a lot more than mac mini itself.

    • @imSpixel
      @imSpixel  27 дней назад

      I’m not sure when the Anker USB dock would use all 180 watts (probably when you have many things connected) but would rather have all the extra ports or less power consumption, I know i would choose more port over power consumption. But even then both the Mac mini and the dock combined would probably use less power than a typical windows PC. I’m sure you’d agree with me :)

  • @kamaboko1
    @kamaboko1 27 дней назад

    Great video. Very informative. The Apple tax for memory is so &Y$@*#*@# steep, I wonder if 48GB would be enough. I was looking at the M4 pro with 1TB SSD and 48GB of memory.