A bit too merciless. These men are not real criminals. They are having to struggle under difficult conditions in a foreign country and behave honourably towards each other. Imprisonment and strokes of the cane are excessive
I agree with this comment. The least the police force could’ve done was to give him what he wanted by deporting him. Imprisoning him was counterproductive. Cane strokes were definitely unnecessary. Perhaps the outcome could’ve been different if the overstayer surrendered, but I digress. Edit: Grammar
Perhaps there should also be better protection for migrant workers, like for example, make it illegal for employers to keep the passports of migrant workers and allow them to quit if they wish to. Employers should only request passport purely for ID purposes and nothing else
Excessive and disproportional punishment is what singapore does best. but commit sexual offense committed by people studying in college? a slap on the wrist cuz you have BRIGHT FUTURE!!! and it had to take public pressure for the bright future defence to be not taken into consideration. migrant workers fucking up immigration law? I CANE YOUR ASSS!!!!!! Singapore is essentially a caste system country
Maruf shouldn’t snitch on his friends. Since his phone was lost in the sea & his fate was sealed, he could have said he met those friends at a coffee shop. What they did wasn’t heinous. I pity their work conditions and predicament. What Joanne Peh shared was true about the point that scammers prey on our fear. So always think twice before reacting.
Madam Soot Beng husband now works for the Singapore Police. Finally he learns his lesson not to cheat with his wife. But...... What about Vicky, his daughter?
@@Jason-uo6yc you do know that its their choice to work? we dont kidnap them and force them to work for us, if they applied and agreed to our terms and conditions, then why would it count as human decency? its just that the bosses cant let them quit, which is indeed our peoples problem, but most of the construction companies allow their workers to take breaks and fly them to their country free of charge.
Maruf Al Mamum was convicted of overstaying and illegal departure from an unauthorized place, he was sentenced to 12 weeks imprisonment and 4 strokes of cane Miah Shorif and Jowel was convicted of abetting an illegal departure from an unauthorized place, they were both each sentenced to 4 weeks imprisonment. (Available on a chinese mode)
Well, he was definitely in a restricted area. A very sensitive place. I see the need for the harsh punishment to stop others from trying the same thing or worst...
Go embassy. And with embassy help. Surrender to the police station for illegal overstayers. Then sure will be light one. Maybe even no jail just get warning. Can fly home.
You help a desperate friend for free in a victimless crime then they snitch on you and you end up in prison. Lol. The worst thing is you convince another friend to help and he ends up in prison with you. Maruf is a punk.
when they interviewed joanne peh and showed her instagram post, why did they have to censor the name of the internet service provider company that she mentioned? i assume her post is public & anyone can find it just by scrolling through her instagram feed anyway.
1. no child porn 2. no sex with minors 3. no illegal drugs and 4. no illegal firearms in any nation or 5. violence against women or children!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Crimewatch Singapore now why not have showing face true criminal and description type act like crimewatch old.. Now just fast forward host talk . Melayu:kenapa Crimewatch sekarang dah tak tunjuk wajah pesalah sebenar dan selitkan jenis hukuman.. Kalau crimewatch dulu ada last sekali ada thn 2019 je sekarang cepat sangat hos cakap..
So d company that consfiscate his passport, they got into trouble? In d 1st place if he ran away, shoulnt b company alerted d police n return his passport to Ica, so they can put an alert for him? 3 y his on d run
The real SIO Nicholas Koh from ICA obviously far from looking that handsome. He could well be a baldy today. No wonder Mediacorp has to engage part-time actors to portray those parts 🤣
One of the worst Crimewatch episodes ever....should instead just film how the mata catch the rich towkays who impound foreign worker passport and don't pay their salary
A bit too merciless. These men are not real criminals. They are having to struggle under difficult conditions in a foreign country and behave honourably towards each other. Imprisonment and strokes of the cane are excessive
I agree with this comment. The least the police force could’ve done was to give him what he wanted by deporting him. Imprisoning him was counterproductive. Cane strokes were definitely unnecessary.
Perhaps the outcome could’ve been different if the overstayer surrendered, but I digress.
Edit: Grammar
Perhaps there should also be better protection for migrant workers, like for example, make it illegal for employers to keep the passports of migrant workers and allow them to quit if they wish to. Employers should only request passport purely for ID purposes and nothing else
Excessive and disproportional punishment is what singapore does best.
but commit sexual offense committed by people studying in college? a slap on the wrist cuz you have BRIGHT FUTURE!!! and it had to take public pressure for the bright future defence to be not taken into consideration.
migrant workers fucking up immigration law? I CANE YOUR ASSS!!!!!!
Singapore is essentially a caste system country
wandering for 3 years is a long time though, could have settle something if less than
@@avriia9173 Sentencing is a matter for the judiciary the police are obliged to prevent illegal border crossings
Maruf shouldn’t snitch on his friends. Since his phone was lost in the sea & his fate was sealed, he could have said he met those friends at a coffee shop. What they did wasn’t heinous. I pity their work conditions and predicament.
What Joanne Peh shared was true about the point that scammers prey on our fear. So always think twice before reacting.
Madam Soot Beng husband now works for the Singapore Police. Finally he learns his lesson not to cheat with his wife. But...... What about Vicky, his daughter?
Lmao
LOL
Someone body once told me
"My business failed and I joined the Singapore Police Force" sounds like an interesting storyline
Loll
i feel so bad for them and idk why 💀
Because the Singaporean government is commiting a moral crime against their abused migrant workers
Human decency
@@Jason-uo6yc you do know that its their choice to work? we dont kidnap them and force them to work for us, if they applied and agreed to our terms and conditions, then why would it count as human decency? its just that the bosses cant let them quit, which is indeed our peoples problem, but most of the construction companies allow their workers to take breaks and fly them to their country free of charge.
Maruf Al Mamum was convicted of overstaying and illegal departure from an unauthorized place, he was sentenced to 12 weeks imprisonment and 4 strokes of cane
Miah Shorif and Jowel was convicted of abetting an illegal departure from an unauthorized place, they were both each sentenced to 4 weeks imprisonment. (Available on a chinese mode)
I saw this on TV I saw the imprisonment charges
@@cleejryosores6679 that's weird, i couldn't see it on the youtube
@@jiashuanchiah yeah not mention episode 2-5 in RUclips i rarely see the imprisonment charges as if they are lazy
@@cleejryosores6679 yeah, only the episode one just have the imprisonment charges. I only used for the imprisonment charges speech.
@@jiashuanchiah no kidding idk why Mewatch can just put that anymore in the English why can they just make it fair??
Pretty educational. For WP holder should seek help from MOM instead of take law into own hand
Caning just for overstaying?? Seriously, what an asinine sentence!
Never try swimming across Straits of Johor, even if you are skillful in swimming! Entering or exiting Singapore without a valid passport is illegal!
Not to mention the crocodiles in the area...
3:00 Nicholas Koh appears in both Crimewatch and Jian Hao Tan's videos. Wow!
jianhao tan cringe
That's why the guy look so familiar
and the guy who also played mr faiz has been in some of jianhaos vids
@@cleejryosores6679 he grew a beard and is his actor
I know right
Lol😂internet provider call “hey what the hell internet do slow! Disconnect come on! “ lol😂
Cool that Keith is working with the police instead of cheating on madam Soot Beng
Treat every message you receive as a scam message. With this mindset, you are unlikely to get scammed. just my 2 cents!!
before this program I had never seen anything from Singapore. I thought it was a really cool format and getting to know a little about this country
Is the guy named Das? His voice sounds different
ikr he look like the tiktoker
i'm guessing he changed his accent to suit this character
Well, he was definitely in a restricted area. A very sensitive place. I see the need for the harsh punishment to stop others from trying the same thing or worst...
“What is he doing at the restricted location” wait uh let me read his mind
what happen to the company which hires the worker?
Go embassy. And with embassy help. Surrender to the police station for illegal overstayers. Then sure will be light one. Maybe even no jail just get warning. Can fly home.
how about those that get hold up at airport immigration for not showing return ticket and hotel booking? can't find anything on the net.
Always waiting for new episode
I'm here because of Das
From Jian Hao videos to crimewatch😮
17:28 Loki busted…
Crimewatch 2019 Ep6
few years ago, my mum got an sms saying her internet line has won 1st prize or something
It is probably a scam
Hi you have won the first prize for internet! Contact me on icq
@@victoriaregina8344 your a scam
is the construction company not sanction for withholding his passport? i mean that's illegal right, taking another person's passport?
Maruf is a good swimmer.
Why not depart via like the scammer couple using container ?
INSANE!!!
The fact that he said a turban would cover his face is so funny
So called stupidity kind of punishments
great crimewatch episode
they were talking so loud in a public place.😁😁😁
So why didn’t ICA go after the employer? Racial profiling? Favouritesm?
You help a desperate friend for free in a victimless crime then they snitch on you and you end up in prison. Lol. The worst thing is you convince another friend to help and he ends up in prison with you. Maruf is a punk.
Lucky never kena attack by crocodile at waterfront...
Lucky never got possessed by a chaos demon...
Y are the company not liable when they were holding the passport in the first place…they are not allowed to
because singapore is pro business country!
From bangladesh as a bangladeshi some ppl cannot afford a passport
11:15 why need police to help? ICA cannot make arrest?
Did they lim kopi the company who withheld the guy's passport?
when they interviewed joanne peh and showed her instagram post, why did they have to censor the name of the internet service provider company that she mentioned? i assume her post is public & anyone can find it just by scrolling through her instagram feed anyway.
"we need to make sure he is safe"?🤣🤣🤣🤣
OMG! James Ng works for Singapore police, If Madam Soot Beng see this,she will be shocked to see her ex works for the Singapore police forces
1. no child porn 2. no sex with minors 3. no illegal drugs and 4. no illegal firearms in any nation or 5. violence against women or children!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
To Das who can speak four language: do you ihow English? 😅🤣
He can say all of them at least one by one and nearly appeared all of the MediaCorp besides Crimewatch
SG the best city in Asia..
"we need to make sure he is safe" ... SPF stop lying...
Of course. He drown or dead. Even it worse.
Finally !!!!!!!!!!!
The guy who played the illegal immigrant is Das DD isn’t it?
Aktar Khan should star
1:04 Das DD
Live in Singapore is very very though.
Woah naveen Sundram at the first top left 10:36
17:25 Crimewatch 2019 footage
Same IO Jeff voice back on 2019 Ep 10
Mesti Klu masuk border Malaysia lalu paip tu Mesti immigration dorg dah sound woi ko buape.
Does anyone realised Nicolas Koh is jianhao tan Vicky’s father
I realise that he is on jianhao tan ❤
ok wait why does maruf look familar....
11:46 why is he holding the card like that?😂
james from jail hao tan
wowww madam soot beng's ex husband is a cop too? crazy
How Come among bangladeshi they speak in English
it is re-enactment,role by model
I love joanne peh's voice 🥰
6:15 isn’t that the guy from Jianhao tan
"found him on the causeway"
Where was he going? 🤣
Maybe to japan!
Crimewatch Singapore now why not have showing face true criminal and description type act like crimewatch old.. Now just fast forward host talk
.
Melayu:kenapa Crimewatch sekarang dah tak tunjuk wajah pesalah sebenar dan selitkan jenis hukuman.. Kalau crimewatch dulu ada last sekali ada thn 2019 je sekarang cepat sangat hos cakap..
Malaysia near Singapore. It s border. It is Chinese PLA soldier in Singapore on 1964-1965. He is monster.
So d company that consfiscate his passport, they got into trouble? In d 1st place if he ran away, shoulnt b company alerted d police n return his passport to Ica, so they can put an alert for him? 3 y his on d run
Dude didn’t even hesitate to snitch.
Nah what is this James From Titan acedemy and Robin?????
The real SIO Nicholas Koh from ICA obviously far from looking that handsome. He could well be a baldy today. No wonder Mediacorp has to engage part-time actors to portray those parts 🤣
After their jail term, they were offered permanent citizenship??? 🤣
Just sent them home immediately, dont need to waste money to keep them ! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Normally will be go back directly with warning
3:12 THAT GUY IS FROM JIAN HAO TAN
14:01 His drink diluted until jialat, can stir abit at least so to look nicer
So the company steals his passport, and gets no punishment? I thought Singapore was a lawful society
is caning really neccesary…
legalize public urination and class c drugs in every antion.
at 7:20 there was jianhao tan actor there
My man jogging in jeans
Mdm Soot Beng husband is called Nicholas Koh?
One of the worst Crimewatch episodes ever....should instead just film how the mata catch the rich towkays who impound foreign worker passport and don't pay their salary
Sorry to ask but Is it true that chewing gum is illegal in Singapore
Selling Chewing gum? Illegal
If u buy from Malaysia, bring to SG? Legal
Is this Footage Actual ? Or acted ? Not sure
All footage are fake or uk acted but some are based on real incidents at real footage are provided it will say so
I see Das I click
JIAN HAO ACTOR AKA VICKY DAD
I thought Diego Costa sia.
Luckily they're minors.
some people arew form jian hao tan
madam sootbengs exhusband lol
What's up Das
legalize public urination and class c drugs in every nation!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
no IPS ppl will call or sms u.
Wow loki look alike…
omg is that mdm soot beng husband from jian hao tan
11:40 is so cheesy. i laughed so hard. and the sound effect is like terminator 2 music
Hmm.. honne road..ica building shifted? Lol
Lol .. that why don’t anyhow trust friends .. kena sabo Liao lo
Star awards rising star awards winner Das 🎉
Being racist with the bangala accent lol
they sound more like indians rather than bangladeshi
Because they are originally Indian
Das!!!!!?
Is that madam soot bang ex husband or her husband