I saw it yesterday in a movie theater in Pisa! I love it! It deserves an Oscar as best picture in foreign language! The screenwriting is more powerful than Roma by Cuaron! The latter is an overrated film!
Speaking on both sides, cause I have slav but also mexican roots, I think Cold War was a piece of art, all the music was beautifu, the folk songs from Poland, Montenegro,Russia,etc., all the shoots of places like Warsaw, Croatia, Serbia; it deserved to win more awards but being objective, the topic of Cold War was love, which is a lil bit more common than the subject of Roma, which speaks of racism,classism,lack of chances for humble people and genocide; which, I think, it's a very strong message. I think Cold war should have win for Best foreign movie and Roma should have win for Best movie of the year.
They were both great. As a European I'm partial to Cold War as I understand the context quite well, but Roma was excellent too. They were similar as despite the themes, both were shot beautifully in black and white and the dialogue is very sparse. Cold War is perhaps more subtle and it needs multiple viewings to get to the emotional layers that Palikowski has so brilliantly laid there. And OMG Joanna Kulig! What a star!
People cannot imagine how hard the times of Satlinism were in Poland. Speaking of music! Jazz became forbidden music and had to go underground. Yes jazz musicians were a kind of underground fighters in Poland. Resistance through music! Speaking of the underground! At that time there were still armed groups of partisans troops in Poland. Even up to the early 50s, some units fought. All of that came to my mind when I saw this movie.
@@stephenhryncewicz8160 The movie "Ashes and Diamonds" is communist propaganda to defame the Polish anti-communist resistance. Because the Polish underground army (Home Army), which previously fought against the Germans, then also fought against the Soviets, who also occupied Poland after the Germans. The director of this propaganda movie Andrzej Wajda was a communist hadnlanger who also made other propaganda movies in which the Polish army and the Polish anti-communist resistance was defamed. For example, in one of his Peopaganda movies, he spreads the absurd legend of Polish cavalry attacking German tanks. Working with the Soviet henchmen in Poland has really paid off for Wajda. He lived a very privileged life like all communitarian henchmen while the Polish population suffered from communitarian oppression.
Как много девушек хороших, Как много ласковых имён, Но лишь одна из них тревожит, Унося покой и сон, Когда влюблён. Сердце, тебе не хочется покоя, Сердце, как хорошо на свете жить. Сердце, как хорошо, что ты такое! Спасибо, сердце, что ты умеешь так любить!
Bellísimo film, Joanna Kulig tiene una belleza que hipnotiza,el diseño de arte y la fotografía realmente espectacular,sin duda queda en mi lista de películas favoritas.
The song Zula sings solo after the duet is “Kak mnogo devushek khoroshikh" (Such a lot of nice girls), from the 1934 Soviet musical film Jolly Fellows. The song was later covered by Pyotr Leshchenko as “Serdtse.” Music by Isaak Dunayevsky, lyrics by Vasily Lebedev-Kumach. Info courtesy of Wikipedia!
Best scene of a decent movie. Unfortunately, the majority of people won't get the whole context. Let me explain))) The leading actress looks like a double of famous modern Russian singer-songwriter Glukoza (Natasha Ionova). The song about heart was sung in a movie "Jolly Fellows" with Loubov Orlova as a leading lady (and performer). The movie was directed by Sergei Eisenstein's assistant and rumored lover for 10 years named Grigory Aleksandrov who met his future wife Orlova during the audition for "Jolly Fellows". She was a noblewoman who was playing Soviet Cinderellas (with education and hard work as her "Prince Charming") and hiding her ancestry during Stalin's reign because otherwise she wouldn't have survived. Aleksandrov and Eisenstein have spent 3 years at Hollywood making connections with Charlie Chaplin, Marlene Dietrich, and other movie stars at the point. Although Eisenstein has only promoted himself as a genius it was his team (incl. Aleksandrov) that created his most famous movie about 1917 Revolution. So, in this segment the woman who interrupts the girl before the chorus it's just a song in Russian (=no fit). For a man it's a sign that a girl has a great ear for good music. Because "Jolly Fellows" (1934), "Circus" (1936), "Volga-Volga" (1940) and "Springtime" (1947) were a female empowerment and humanist movies that are still relevant today at some degree in their message: a modern woman can both make a successful career and find love. It might be funny for the Poles they've switched the narrative to traditional national Polish Catholic culture and then the democratic Anglo-Saxon trend has brought to them the same ideas of globalism and women rights but in a better package (from a nation that benefited the most from racism and genocide... no offense, I'm just green eyes with jealousy). And finally, Poland is nominated for Oscars with a forced "Romeo and Juliette" out-of-place ending that just makes the whole story look like a trashy "killed by writing" comedy made to please the West, first and foremost. Not to tell the story. Amazing attempt by the Poles but they could have done so much better by pretending to be a religious Catholics who has more fantasy at solving problems with Soviets. But they still "played the wictims" script wise and that's why Oscar has to wait. A lost opportunity. No offense, just IMHO.
If u are saying that women had more rights and power during soviet i completely agree with u but i dont know what u talkin about ! For example racism and genocide. Which genocide and racism ? And those anglo saxon stupid laws and system that now runs the poland is as traditional and patriarchal as catholic laws and system they are both same and fascist. I think poland have roman law now not anglo saxon or common law but as i said there are no difference they both are traditional.
Thanks for the first part of your comment i didnt know about those movies but the other half its hard to read really i can see what "history" they teach you in russia really... Russians as Poles and other countries of soviet bloc were the victims of this incredibly fucked up system, or maybe your family belonged to the communist party that explains a lot
Love this movie. Great music, cinematography, and editing.
Really surprised it took me so long to see it
What I wouldn’t give for a track of her singing the second song! Glorious.
Do you know the title of the original song?
@@antoniomema9166it’s a Russian song called “Kak Mnogo Devushek Khoroshikh”
@@antoniomema9166 “Serce” The closest version I found on youtube is sung by Irena Santor
@@antoniomema9166 “Serce” The closest version I’ve found is sung by Peter Leschenko :)
@@antoniomema9166 the original song is from a Croatian 1970 movie "Tko pjeva, zlo ne misli" its called "Ja ljubim"
I wish there was a full soundtrack to this film ( not just the single) including the folk songs from this film.
I don’t blame Wiktor for falling in love with her. I couldn’t take my eyes off her especially when she was talking about the song
I saw it yesterday in a movie theater in Pisa! I love it! It deserves an Oscar as best picture in foreign language! The screenwriting is more powerful than Roma by Cuaron! The latter is an overrated film!
Purtroppo vince la Roma,per motivi politici....
Exactly 👍
I loved Cold War, but Roma is even better in my opinion :)
Speaking on both sides, cause I have slav but also mexican roots, I think Cold War was a piece of art, all the music was beautifu, the folk songs from Poland, Montenegro,Russia,etc., all the shoots of places like Warsaw, Croatia, Serbia; it deserved to win more awards but being objective, the topic of Cold War was love, which is a lil bit more common than the subject of Roma, which speaks of racism,classism,lack of chances for humble people and genocide; which, I think, it's a very strong message. I think Cold war should have win for Best foreign movie and Roma should have win for Best movie of the year.
They were both great. As a European I'm partial to Cold War as I understand the context quite well, but Roma was excellent too. They were similar as despite the themes, both were shot beautifully in black and white and the dialogue is very sparse. Cold War is perhaps more subtle and it needs multiple viewings to get to the emotional layers that Palikowski has so brilliantly laid there. And OMG Joanna Kulig! What a star!
Masterpiece of a film.
Спасибо сердце что ты умеешь так любить 💔
People cannot imagine how hard the times of Satlinism were in Poland. Speaking of music! Jazz became forbidden music and had to go underground. Yes jazz musicians were a kind of underground fighters in Poland. Resistance through music! Speaking of the underground! At that time there were still armed groups of partisans troops in Poland. Even up to the early 50s, some units fought. All of that came to my mind when I saw this movie.
Yes. Wajda’s Ashes and Diamonds is a great film about those times.
@@stephenhryncewicz8160 The movie "Ashes and Diamonds" is communist propaganda to defame the Polish anti-communist resistance. Because the Polish underground army (Home Army), which previously fought against the Germans, then also fought against the Soviets, who also occupied Poland after the Germans. The director of this propaganda movie Andrzej Wajda was a communist hadnlanger who also made other propaganda movies in which the Polish army and the Polish anti-communist resistance was defamed. For example, in one of his Peopaganda movies, he spreads the absurd legend of Polish cavalry attacking German tanks. Working with the Soviet henchmen in Poland has really paid off for Wajda. He lived a very privileged life like all communitarian henchmen while the Polish population suffered from communitarian oppression.
Joanna is gonna shine in Hollywood soon coz she is already a big name in her native Poland
What a beautiful women
Me emociona!! Excelente película!! Bellísima voz!!
Как много девушек хороших,
Как много ласковых имён,
Но лишь одна из них тревожит,
Унося покой и сон,
Когда влюблён.
Сердце, тебе не хочется покоя,
Сердце, как хорошо на свете жить.
Сердце, как хорошо, что ты такое!
Спасибо, сердце, что ты умеешь так любить!
Это классика советского киноматографа
Bellísimo film, Joanna Kulig tiene una belleza que hipnotiza,el diseño de arte y la fotografía realmente espectacular,sin duda queda en mi lista de películas favoritas.
Mutlaka izlenmeli şarkılarıyla bile cok guzel
Bardzo ładnie śpiewa po rosyjsku
So beautiful!
Ja ljubim !
❤️
Politicians eventually use artists to spout their agenda whether the artist wants to or not, very sad situation.
What is the name of the last song?
The song Zula sings solo after the duet is “Kak mnogo devushek khoroshikh" (Such a lot of nice girls), from the 1934 Soviet musical film Jolly Fellows. The song was later covered by Pyotr Leshchenko as “Serdtse.” Music by Isaak Dunayevsky, lyrics by Vasily Lebedev-Kumach. Info courtesy of Wikipedia!
Thank you all!!
what's the name of the duet in the beginning?
Austin Dykstra „Ja za wodą, ty za wodą”
Ada Kiełpińska what about the one Zula sang?
Song name of the duet piece anyone? Help please
Ja za wodą
jo za wodom
Best scene of a decent movie. Unfortunately, the majority of people won't get the whole context. Let me explain))) The leading actress looks like a double of famous modern Russian singer-songwriter Glukoza (Natasha Ionova). The song about heart was sung in a movie "Jolly Fellows" with Loubov Orlova as a leading lady (and performer). The movie was directed by Sergei Eisenstein's assistant and rumored lover for 10 years named Grigory Aleksandrov who met his future wife Orlova during the audition for "Jolly Fellows". She was a noblewoman who was playing Soviet Cinderellas (with education and hard work as her "Prince Charming") and hiding her ancestry during Stalin's reign because otherwise she wouldn't have survived. Aleksandrov and Eisenstein have spent 3 years at Hollywood making connections with Charlie Chaplin, Marlene Dietrich, and other movie stars at the point. Although Eisenstein has only promoted himself as a genius it was his team (incl. Aleksandrov) that created his most famous movie about 1917 Revolution. So, in this segment the woman who interrupts the girl before the chorus it's just a song in Russian (=no fit). For a man it's a sign that a girl has a great ear for good music. Because "Jolly Fellows" (1934), "Circus" (1936), "Volga-Volga" (1940) and "Springtime" (1947) were a female empowerment and humanist movies that are still relevant today at some degree in their message: a modern woman can both make a successful career and find love. It might be funny for the Poles they've switched the narrative to traditional national Polish Catholic culture and then the democratic Anglo-Saxon trend has brought to them the same ideas of globalism and women rights but in a better package (from a nation that benefited the most from racism and genocide... no offense, I'm just green eyes with jealousy). And finally, Poland is nominated for Oscars with a forced "Romeo and Juliette" out-of-place ending that just makes the whole story look like a trashy "killed by writing" comedy made to please the West, first and foremost. Not to tell the story. Amazing attempt by the Poles but they could have done so much better by pretending to be a religious Catholics who has more fantasy at solving problems with Soviets. But they still "played the wictims" script wise and that's why Oscar has to wait. A lost opportunity. No offense, just IMHO.
you didn't understand much from the movie
If u are saying that women had more rights and power during soviet i completely agree with u but i dont know what u talkin about ! For example racism and genocide. Which genocide and racism ? And those anglo saxon stupid laws and system that now runs the poland is as traditional and patriarchal as catholic laws and system they are both same and fascist. I think poland have roman law now not anglo saxon or common law but as i said there are no difference they both are traditional.
What the hell did I just read? Are you offended by historical accuracy in Polish - Soviet relations depiction in the movie or something?
Thanks for the first part of your comment i didnt know about those movies but the other half its hard to read really i can see what "history" they teach you in russia really... Russians as Poles and other countries of soviet bloc were the victims of this incredibly fucked up system, or maybe your family belonged to the communist party that explains a lot