Cold War - The Power of the Leitmotif

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 янв 2025
  • In this video I explore the powerful new film by Pawel Pawlikowski.
    Subscribe for more videos.
    Support on Patreon: / filmpersona
    Twitter: / filmpersona
    Facebook: / filmpersona
    Instagram: @filmpersona

Комментарии •

  • @intifadayuri
    @intifadayuri 5 лет назад +152

    Cold war is such an unique movie, it reflects the true tragedy of love in a way no other movie has ever done before.
    Definitively one of my favorite movies ever.

  • @nataliadoe7126
    @nataliadoe7126 4 года назад +111

    This film really captivated me. I’m Polish and more often than not modern Polish films seem shallow and do not leave an impression on me. This is one of the most visceral, beautiful films I’ve ever seen and the songs are that much better because they are sang in my mother tongue and I can fully understand all the nuances.

    • @zepter00
      @zepter00 3 года назад

      Natalia.... watch „ Najlepszy” Eng title braking the limits or something like that „ Boże ciało” Corpus Christi... „Kler” - Clergy .. and „ Twarz” - mug. You will like or even love it.

  • @cyronascimento6462
    @cyronascimento6462 2 года назад +15

    I am brazilian and I saw it again yesterday. The same power from some years ago when I saw at cinema. So beautiful, What a masterpiece.

  • @Bulacanos
    @Bulacanos 5 лет назад +96

    That scene where Wiktor has Zula sing a melody after she asks him if he's into her is a very lovely musical reference

    • @tekkynew2
      @tekkynew2 4 года назад +2

      I loves you Porgy.

  • @pedjabrepedja
    @pedjabrepedja Год назад +1

    I can't shake this movie off of me. Every now and then I think about it, and rewatch some parts. But this is the first time i stumbled upon this video essay and I am amazed. Thank you, dear man. I can't make my friends watch some important movies, and I need you to make these kind of videos so I can send them away to them lol

  • @thecinephilefish9465
    @thecinephilefish9465 4 года назад +25

    The subtitles for like half the movie on Amazon Prime were missing. While watching this essay I realised how much of a dialogue / lyrics I missed. The film STILL left a massive impact on me. Some brilliant visual filmmaking. What a beautiful movie.

    • @DeadpoolAli
      @DeadpoolAli 3 года назад +1

      THIS!!!!!!!
      I was wondering if i was paying attention to the movie... Both you and me were.
      the amazon subtitles failed us!!!!

  • @MAFion
    @MAFion Год назад +5

    The bold move of the film is to structure the film sort of like a series of postcards sent from different places at different times. We recognize the same handwriting in each one. This style is like a memory play and allows the audience to fill in the blanks, and lends a lyrical quality to what is a musical of sorts.

  • @jarrodanderson2124
    @jarrodanderson2124 4 года назад +34

    this movie is an absolute masterpiece

  • @adamprokulewicz5534
    @adamprokulewicz5534 6 лет назад +52

    What a beautiful essay! Great job, man.

  • @Orson2u
    @Orson2u Год назад

    Thank you. It is a shame that this fine expository has not found a larger audience. It deserves this.

  • @alanflaco2081
    @alanflaco2081 2 месяца назад

    Absolutely brilliant work on the video essay., You expertly encapsulate this power of the leitmotif and the power of music transcending genre and meaning

  • @rch456789
    @rch456789 5 лет назад +9

    Fantastic analysis of the film! I was blown away after having watched it just now but I love it even more after this video. Thank you

  • @mobilis951
    @mobilis951 3 года назад +1

    rarely do I find such well made movie reviews as this. It is very clear and to the point, just what I was looking for. Good job!

  • @rg3388
    @rg3388 5 лет назад +29

    As an example of a nonmusical leitmotif, George Crow cites this film’s use of various mirrors.

    • @gerunkwon2598
      @gerunkwon2598 5 лет назад +4

      Interesting. Who is George Crow? Could you link me his paper?

  • @gamma68
    @gamma68 2 месяца назад +2

    Seeking information about the folk song at 1:42, please.

  • @a.m.z1710
    @a.m.z1710 5 лет назад +11

    Thank you for that essay. From Poland 🇵🇱

    • @FilmPersona
      @FilmPersona  5 лет назад +3

      Thank you for such kind words. Really means a lot coming from a fellow slav. :)

  • @epicurus1117
    @epicurus1117 6 лет назад +14

    Great analysis man ! Please make more of this!!

    • @FilmPersona
      @FilmPersona  6 лет назад +2

      Thanks a lot. I plan on making more. Make sure to subscribe to get the notification.

    • @zepter00
      @zepter00 3 года назад

      @@FilmPersona You are great. Real profesional. Maybe you could make review of „ Boże Ciało - „ Corpus Christi”..almost got Oscar. If is great movie in mu opinion. I wonder what you think about it.

  • @ariessunvirgomoonrising833
    @ariessunvirgomoonrising833 5 лет назад +6

    Brilliant analysis of a most amazing achievement!

  • @davido1953
    @davido1953 2 года назад +1

    A movie that stays with you. Quite remarkable.

  • @1996MURADa
    @1996MURADa 3 года назад +1

    There are so many subtle details I missed that you highlighted beautifully! Amazing job friend! 💜

    • @1996MURADa
      @1996MURADa 3 года назад

      Also form 11:30-11:40 does anybody kind of hear the La La Land tune?

    • @samanthakarl8916
      @samanthakarl8916 2 года назад +1

      @@1996MURADa Now that you say it, yes absolutely

  • @julieannsarabia
    @julieannsarabia 2 месяца назад

    Brilliant cinema. My mentor would have loved it. A suggestion for a future video essay: The Assassin by Director Hou Hsiao-Hsien

  • @Jimmy1982Playlists
    @Jimmy1982Playlists 3 года назад +1

    You got a new subscriber for this one! Lover of _Ida_ & _Cold War..._

  • @josiahingegneri7209
    @josiahingegneri7209 2 года назад

    Cold War is one of my favorite films. I loved this breakdown.

  • @bensophagus
    @bensophagus 6 лет назад +9

    Saw your post on Reddit. Nice work!

  • @juentare1485
    @juentare1485 5 лет назад +8

    Beautiful film

  • @scent007
    @scent007 4 года назад +1

    Really appreciate your video for such a wonderful film

  • @ajayraval7479
    @ajayraval7479 4 года назад +2

    Master piece...
    Love this movie

  • @Muumimamman
    @Muumimamman Год назад

    Портрет Шостаковича в фильме - респект! У Павликовского отличный вкус

  • @lilliehayes7750
    @lilliehayes7750 3 года назад +1

    I loved your video! New suscribe!

  • @hectorpena8511
    @hectorpena8511 5 лет назад

    Awesome analysis man , I have subscribed for more!

  • @flaauros
    @flaauros 5 лет назад +2

    make more videos like this, you're pretty good!
    love from México

  • @pilipalanda6990
    @pilipalanda6990 2 года назад +1

    Please, can anyone tel me who is playing in the film the aria of Golberg Variations? Wonderful film!

  • @yoloswag228
    @yoloswag228 4 года назад +2

    Great analysis! Does anyone know the name of the piano piece on the background of the video? Thx

    • @davidcronan4072
      @davidcronan4072 4 года назад +2

      Bach Goldberg Variations. Also used in the film "The English Patient".

  • @mirtozafiropoulou
    @mirtozafiropoulou 4 года назад

    Excellent movie. Excellent in every aspect.

  • @Muumimamman
    @Muumimamman Год назад

    Потрясающе красивая актриса

  • @brandnewyorker
    @brandnewyorker 4 года назад +1

    Masterpiece 💕

  • @ikasten07
    @ikasten07 2 года назад

    Hey mate, thanks for make this emotive video. Do you know if the song of the young girl's scene was recorded or I just can find It on the film? Thnaks in advance.

  • @rebe6461
    @rebe6461 5 лет назад

    Great review of the greatest movie x

  • @rdavidmarks5326
    @rdavidmarks5326 4 года назад

    Thanks so much.

  • @asapfilms2519
    @asapfilms2519 2 года назад

    Cinema is all about giving the audience a treat…leave your home and come to the cinema hall…because I promise you…it’s going to be wonderful two hours of your day….

  • @marek.lukasz
    @marek.lukasz Год назад

    I watched this film and the only thing i can say is that people's soul disposition to find beauty in toxins and pathlogy is horrifying. Even though it's wrapped in a very attractive superficiality.

  • @kevinmuendo9889
    @kevinmuendo9889 5 лет назад

    what song started at 0:50 ???

    • @FilmPersona
      @FilmPersona  5 лет назад +2

      It is from Bach's Goldberg Variations. Pawel uses it in the closing credits of the film.

  • @Schmidteren
    @Schmidteren 3 года назад +2

    The movie is too dark for me. But to it's credit, it realy captures life. My life. I have darkness in my life as well. I prefer to go to other worlds, escape from my own darkness. Saing that, my fav movie of all time is Eternal Sunshine of The Spotless Mind. Also a rather dark movie, but I feel like this movie lacks hope. Hope is what is keeping me alive.

    • @anamaria-db7pq
      @anamaria-db7pq Год назад

      Interesting and I know what you mean. I have this darkness around me too and I totally resonate with the hopelesness. I wonder even if it is a slavic thing, this melancholy and tragedy without hope… I can imagine that for many people it’s too heavy

  • @cabhi1804
    @cabhi1804 2 года назад

    @5:31 what 'circumstances' exactly?
    I just saw the movie and I'm both fascinated & frustrated...especially with Zula...why does she leave him so many times? that too in such extreme ways...didn't make sense at all...is there some subtext I'm missing? is it that she loves her homeland too much or is it because wiktor lied about her to the producer or something else? the video essay did not help in any way!

  • @domclegg1225
    @domclegg1225 2 года назад +1

    great video but i think you need a better mic dude

  • @ladouleurpasselabeauterest3384
    @ladouleurpasselabeauterest3384 3 года назад +1

    🍂✨🍂

  • @rajsingharora26
    @rajsingharora26 4 года назад

    just saw it...... so you here....like me.

  • @SilverScarletSpider
    @SilverScarletSpider Месяц назад +1

    poland is not yet lost. taiwan, ukraine, hong kong.

  • @GV_777YT
    @GV_777YT 2 года назад +1

    bro trash that mic yesterday please.

  • @markkavanagh7377
    @markkavanagh7377 3 года назад +1

    Sadly I didn't 'get' this movie as good as the music and visuals were.
    I didn't like either of the leads and I didn't get their choices; either of them returning to Poland for a start.
    The age gap was bothering too.
    Anyhow, hope you enjoyed it.

  • @warsztatyscenariuszowe5342
    @warsztatyscenariuszowe5342 Год назад

    ble ble ble :(((((

  • @ernestocasillas731
    @ernestocasillas731 4 года назад

    Nunca había visto tanta glosa disfrazada de ensayo. Igual muy padre la película.

  • @WithASideOfFries
    @WithASideOfFries 4 года назад +1

    I appreciate your analysis, but gosh, really didn't like this movie myself. I'm just sick of the doomed love story trope.

  • @XxbiohazardxX223
    @XxbiohazardxX223 4 года назад +6

    i think this movie is kinda overrated to the point that i dont really get most of the praise it gets, it was really rushed and it had no pacing at all, just a lot of time skips and underdeveloped characters that seek conflict for no reason XD cinematically its really pretty, but nothing else

    • @markkavanagh7377
      @markkavanagh7377 3 года назад

      Nail on head, its a movie in the way Ed Sheeran is a musician!!! Has popular appeal but others just cant connect with it.