I've been a GoPro user since 09 or earlier. The 360 cams, when punched in at 1080p remind me of the quality of the hero 2 or 3... Also, it appears that the 360 cam would need to be much closer to the subject to get the same shot, and I already find that somewhat of a challenge with the modern GoPro. With that being said, I'm not interested in 360 camera tech until they achieve 8k or higher, I'd like to see the punched in image be 2.7k at least. That's my thoughts on the 2 cameras, I do not yet have a hero 11 but I've got two 8's a 9 and a 10 not to mention all the older gopros I still have that are obsolete. Thank you David for all the work you do!!! 🤟😎
Really great video as always! Personally, I lean more towards the GoPro right now. The 360 footage looks really cool, but I just don't like that the resolution of the end product is so low. The thing I find very interesting about the current Black Friday deals over at GoPro though, is that they've increased the prise of the Hero 11 this week, so 15% off isn't a big sale compared to the price last week (at least here in Sweden, 15% off is just making a few dollars difference (converted from SEK). I don't know how it is in the other countries, but at least the Swedish GoPro site isn't running a very good deal). I was very disappointed seeing that, because the sale was much better during the Halloween deals, which I find a bit strange because I thought Black Friday usually offers better deals than Halloween. Hopefully they'll have better prices on Friday, but I'm not sure since they're already offering a pretty good price with the subscription.
I am leaning toward the GoPro as of right now. I have a hero 4 and (just like all the other comments say) the quality of the 360 cams aren’t good enough. I also NEED the Insta360 to be more durable to scratches. I do mountain biking and snowboarding, so if I fall the camera could be heavily damaged or even broken. I’d love to try a 360 camera nonetheless
For filming activities with your kids it seems to me the X3 will be much easier to work with. And resolution vs actually usable footage is something a lot of people don’t get until they have gone through a few cameras. A shot where dad doesn’t have to make everyone wait for the camera setup is a lot easier on everybody and results in better footage IMO.
When will gopro fix the hero 9 10 and 11. Still freezing and glitchy. The 9 is unusable 10 still glitchy. The 11 freezes and over heats even after the updates. Such a shame
@@retroonhisbikes They would have to reduce the sensor back down to 12mp to do that. I can record all day long on the Hero 8 because it has a 12mp sensor. Same with the DJI Action 3. It's 12mp sensor keeps it from overheating. The bigger the sensor the more processing power needed. Also, video cameras don't need higher mp sensors. Only photo cameras. Good example is the Sony A7siii. Its only a 12mp sensor and its internals are used in their cinema line of cameras. Who pays $14,000 for a 12mp sensor cinema camera? Someone who wants to film good videos. @GoPro
I am sold on the X3. With the 360 footage I don't need to worry where I mount the camera or where I am pointing at, I can decide the angle in post which is my favourite feature. Also the invisible stick effect is insane, never get tired of it lol. My uncle just bought the gopro 11 a couple of weeks ago and he sent it back, it was freezing every now and then
I have Insta360 x3 and GoPro 10 and my opinion is: Having both cameras is a game changer. They complement each other pretty well with the video/photo quality of GoPro and the versatility of X3. But, if you have none of these, the first one I recommend is the GoPro. Even that you have a lot of freedom with the X3, the GoPro has a greater quality of video, so it’s the best camera for most of situations. The X3 you will use in specific situations that the GoPro isn’t so versatile, most of “selfies” shots the X3 is easier to use and will deliver a stunning angle of the shot, but the opaque and low resolution will keep you doing just some short clips as B-rolls.
Can you edit the film from Gopro and Insta360 in the same software? So you can use scenes from both cameras in the same film? What software to use then?
@@theofficecyclist tried to import the GoPro files into the Insta360 app and is not possible. The software for the 360 is mainly to reframe your shots and adjust the field of view. Later, you need to process in a video editor normally (sony vegas, after effects, filmora… the one that you prefer).
1920 x 1080 is the default export settings. In the Video Export Settings box you can change this to 3840 x 2160 (4K). Also you can increase the bitrate and use ProRes 422 encoding format for increased video quality. You can then save this as the default.
I just ordered this camera on amazon, imo there is not a debate about which one is the best. Insta just can do what gopro can do and then also other things...
I've had the GOPRO hero 9 for a couple of years and love it. I use it mostly for overlanding video and the stabilization is great. Just picked up the Insta 360 X3 and it does amazing stuff also. But you're right, they are two very different cameras with different usages. Just driving down dirt roads I think the Gopro is a clear winner because I set the lens to linear and get rid of a lot of dashboard from my truck. The 360 X3 shows a lot of dashboard that gets boring after a few seconds. But having the ability to video 360 degrees and editing it later means I won't miss thing as much, if at all. Both will be used with all my travels and RUclips videos and really looking forward to Maui this spring and snorkeling with the Insta 360 X3, I think it will be awesome in that environment.
I'm a solo traveler who shoots for my personal social media. The 360 makes more sense for my use like you said. I don't need the super high quality that the GoPro has, and having the invisible selfie stick with multiple angles make it seem like I have a camera crew and a drone when I'm shooting by myself. Great review!
I’ve got to go with the 360, since you can sometimes only have a one-shot to capture whatever you’re doing. A studio selfie setup would be a different story, where maybe a GoPro would be better. But life experiences, not knowing what’s going to happen wherever you are, and if something is happening out of frame etc, it’s best to just capture EVERYTHING, and figure out what works best in your post. Yes you have the inconvenience of having to post-process. But most people already do that before uploading to their social media of choice. And with the bugs from GoPro with freezing and overheating and lack of firmware updates etc, I think DJI or Insta360 are better choices.
I got the GoPro 11 cause image quality is the most important factor for me and i already got the Max for the rare occasion i need 360 footage. But having said that, the X3 is pretty cool. For someone who doesn't own an action camera and wants something that's good all round, the X3 is probably the best choice at the moment.
I have some extra Max batteries I am trying to sell. Seems to be no one in Canada has a GoPro Max…or any action camera. Anyways, let me know if you are interested.
@@teamsaunz Hey, thanks but i have more than enough batteries and i barely use my GoPro Max anymore. I also live in Europe, only the shipping will probably cost more than the batteries themselves 😅Hope you find someone in Canada, someone has to need some batteries there 🤔
@@ArchangelAmin Hey, well i love it! In the meantime i have traveled a lot and used it in many different scenarios and never had an issue. I think it's an awesome little camera and the GoPro Labs firmware unlocks many advanced options. I shoot more with my GoPro than my Sony A7C 😅
I have not read any comments, but I hope someone else who is subbed here would mention that the x3 would be absolutely perfect for VR....I can right off the bat think of a real estate agent. They could record a property they are selling, and prospective buyers could view the whole house from anywhere in the world, like they were pretty much there. My daughter just turned 4....I would have loved to have shot the party with one of those. I'm even using an older Rift and this would blow me away and the people I would make watch them. Nice review. Thank you.
It's my first 360 camera and its already replaced my GoPros. Any perceived shortcomings is easily outweighed by the versatility and ease of use. My absolute favourite camera.YMMV
I bought a GoPro 10 just before the GoPro 11 came out, i have never had a problem with it freezing or anything else up to now, i did crash my MTB and the GoPro took the full impact but apart from a slight scrape to the edge of the lense it is fine and still no problems with it, the price puts me off the 360 X3 so i am thinking of getting a GoPro 11 but i might wait and see what the next GoPro is like first, price does play a big part in my decisions and i think it does for a lot of people.
DM - totally agree with both if you can, I have a 7 black and a one x2. I don't fully trust the insta for water proof action but otherwise it gets more use right now. Just wish, 2 years or so into it that insta would already put out next gen 360 with higher reso when you frame down. whichever brand accomplishes that in their next release will crush the market
Just received my X3. I used to have Gopro 9 but decided not to upgrade to 11. Looking for something new and fun so decided to buy X3 simply because the invisible selfie stick...
Your summary was bang on the money, both cameras serve different purposes and as such you pick the right tool for the job. Get and use both! There's something nice and simple about having a fixed view though, probably not having to go through hours of footage from all those different angles, plus an easier editing workflow.
Great video on these two. I personally have found myself reaching for my X3 more and more recently, but when I go on my trip to the Okefenokee Swamp next week, I'll be taking both (as well as my Canon R). I definitely agree that they are similar tools that can be used in conjunction/tandem. Also, always a fan of your added commentary/sound effects.
Great to know your opinion but, my man, talk about downloading the content from the camera, app gimmicks, accessory compatibility, performance in different settings, first time buyer’s heads ups… there’s so many categories that are missing from this comparison.
Good points I was thinking the same. I like the GoPro unlimited upload subscription and the auto-upload feature that saves every clip to the Cloud in original resolution. Even lets you save non-GoPro videos I think. It also pretty easy to edit videos from the app.
Two separate tools for different things. But if you can take only just 1 in an unfortunate way, I’d say the 360 X3. But in my case it would be the DJI Action 3 for filming others and the Insta360 X3 for self filming. After an entire day of watching camera videos of GoPro, Insta360 X3 and DJI Action 3 camera reviews, that’s how I narrow it down and for use. Can have both, just use them differently.
The part you left out is the video editing. The X3 requires some video editing experience to really make it work. GOPro is far easier on the video editing. I shoot with the X3 as it is a complete film studio in your pocket. I think image quality is the compromise with the X3 as the GoPro has better image quality
I have BOTH. I like Go Pro for point and shoot content but Insta360 is great for when I do live demos where a point and shot camera can’t capture every angle or all the action happening. If you’re rough on your action camera DO NOT get the Insta360 because you will have to ship the camera back, it takes around two weeks to get it back, and the repair cost is SINFUL 💀
That Insta360 tripod can also be used for bullet time, which isn't used often, but can be kind of a cool secondary shot. I have the X2 and the Hero 8, use them both, but I've prefered the X2 as I don't have to think too much about where I'm pointing. Lens covers for the 360 are a must and I don't think detract that much, and with mtn biking it's required.
Solid points Troy! How often do you need to swap out your lens protectors? I find that a little rock bump and I usually get a pretty noticeable scratch on the cover
@@DavidManningvlog I've been lucky so far an no rock strikes, But I also use the rubber lens cover a lot. I think our PNW trails aren't quite as dry as they are where you are.
I use both the 11 and the 3X.... the 11 is great underwater with proper video lights.. the 3X is not a deep dive camera as it will never ever work with proper video lights underwater... works fine at shallow diving with the housing... so you can actually mix the footage and using both you can show a dive vacation so much better than if you had to just choose one camera..
Couple additional points in the gopros favor. Audio is much better on the gopro. Also if you are changing light say in and out of the woods the gopro does much better. Snowboarding shots in the insta look great, not a fan of them on bikes. They dont seem to stabilize as well and the iso balance on the gopro is much better. While id love to have both, as a solo option i gotta stick with gopro
Great video! I have a Hero 7 and I am looking at a new camera for motovloging, but also looking at different angles for the videos. Have some friends that got the Hero 11 and are complaining that they overheat all the time and they lost their videos. So, I'll probably move on with the insta and keep my Hero 7 attached to the helmet. Thanks for the video!
I'm looking forward to getting the 360 as a poor man's drone. More to the point, drones are hard to travel to foreign countries with (some get really paranoid about them!). But sticking a 360 action camera on a BAS (big a$$ stick) up high out the window or roof rack is a good substitute.
I look at it this way: If somebody is doing things that need an action cam, they should (already) have a GoPro in their kit. Most people then, should get the 360 camera before upgrading their GoPro. Can i ask: what's that tripod pole you use for both of your cameras? (LOL heh heh)
Tnx David for the video. IMO, for 90% of users, the insta 360 wins. I've had enough of filming others and had too many trips without a pic or a video of myself.
Some of my favorite shots are from the Insta360 because there’s no pole and it looks like someone is filming you. But I do like go pro for more vlog style. Sooo we need both!
I have both. But the 360 is the best for me. I record kayak fishing. The 360 can get the shot that takes at least 3 Gopro's. Now, if I'm talking or showing what I see on my fishfinder, I use a Gopro. The 360 is behind me, and Gopro is facing me.
Coming from the Hero 8, and all of the headaches surrounding the software issues with go pro. I just ordered the X3; I’d much rather get every shot in 1080p, than completely miss it in 4K lol 😂
I just bought the insta360 X3 & WOW, what a cool piece of tech!!! 💯👍 Even a novice like me can look like a real videographer, because no matter what way you face the camera you can edit it & guys the perspective in the app. Yeah, you're not lying, the Ulanxi PT-20 was hard to find, I ordered the wrong 1 off insta360, so had to get the right 1 from B&H Photo, because they had free shipping, unlike insta360. I bought the sticky lens as well, but questionable about using them, how are they still holding up, any issues visible? Didn't look too bad in your video, but could see glares & the dreaded red dot
Hey! What do you recommend for a water park/family vacation? That’s mainly what I want it for for family moments/vacations. I’m struggling here to decide
Wouldn’t a better comparison have been between the GoPro Max and the Insta360? After all, both are a 360 degree action camera. I’ve got the Max, and the footage is great. Had it mounted on the rear of my motorbike, and the footage is great. No shaking, even on the back of a large V-Twin bike that shakes and vibrates a lot
Help please, I got the X3 camera and I see that in normal 360 video outdoors, the image is too white and unclear, while in other modes (photo, 1 lens video) the image is normal and clear. Why is this happening? How do you fix this please?
Yep. I thought I would never say it.. "I mean being a gopro fanboy and all" 1080P is fine... I can see everything Sorry.. But gopro just lost a fanboy #justsaying
Both good tools, but the issue with the INSTA is the faffing around with the pre processing, GoPro 11 is is the way to go if you can only afford the one.
I allways watch till the end, you know it.😄 I have been scared the whole video through, watching your handtalking, not smashing accidently the one x 3. But it is how you said, both action cams have their specific use for what you need. I think I'd be more interested in the one x3.
compared x3,hero11and action 3 ,just went to 11 just for mostly the image quality and dynamic range and in addition to pretty good stabilization ,,360 looks cool but will wait for it a little more time .too many brands to cary ,I think the next version of max will get it right with the 360 .will wait for until they get hero 4k60 in go pro max .
5.7K is the entire 360 sphere that you record, but then when you reframe and cut a 16:9 video out of that sphere, it becomes 1080. And they usually run specials where you can get the stick included👍
Great video and agree that they're similar in many ways, and picking one over the other tends to come down to scenario. I think the extra workflow to reframe 360 videos is worth mentioning. The Insta360's AI tracking does make it way, WAY easier than working with a GoPro Max's 360 footage, but it's still an extra step you have to go through.
I've had nothing but trouble from my 11. Overheating multiple times. Lock ups and having to pull battery. I also own the x3 and its nice it really good lighting..
I have both and me personally, I 100% recommend the X3. I honestly can't stand the GoPro, too finicky, too many bugs and constantly missing footage because of freezing up and overheating. The freezing and overheating have been a problem from day one with GoPro and they have done very little if anything to fix it. It's even worse if you have your GoPro in the media mod and now you have to pull it apart freezes to pull the battery wasting time and missing footage. There is also no comparison to battery life on the Insta360 X3, X3 wins hands down, go's the entire day without having to swap out or recharge a battery. Now if I'm comparing the X3 to the Max, again, can't beat the X3 in battery life, size, function and stitching, hell the Fusion was a better 360 than the MAX, at least the Fusion you could shoot in low light, the MAX is done at sunset. GoPro's customer service is horrendous and that is being generous at best. Vid quality may be a touch better on the GoPro but thats only if it doesn't bug out before you shoot, X3 works every time. Just a note: Insta is working on replaceable lenses, next generation maybe? I replace camera's almost every 12 months or so, so not really an issue if I scratch one. My X3 spends a lot of time sticking out in front of my Jeep on the trail and going though brush, not a scratch yet and Ive cleaned a lot of mud off of it.
I went through this in the spring when i wanted my first action camera to supplement my sports photography. I went with the Hero 9 b/c I did not understand the role of a 360 camera at the time. At the time, I was comparing GoPros with the One RS and I liked the quality of the GoPro better. Now I wish I had a 360 of some sort, so I am looking for a used one (I can't justify the cost of a new one as I do not think I'll ever make any money with it) and have learned a ton from your videos this year. Also, I really like those tripods and stick. Are they one unit or is that the selfie stick you linked in your accessories video on top of something else?
what camera do you suggest for just the usual family type and holiday videos with the only action type shot being the race for the buffet at the hotel😂 we just want an easy to use camera that really shows off holiday scenery etc... (only cameras available in the Uk please) Your videos are great by the way...
I’ve heard GoPro 11 battery gets hot faster and it shuts off quicker. So I’ll stick with my GoPro 9 but I just bought a insta360. X3 and I love the quality more on the insta360. Insta360 films in a higher quality than the GoPro 11. I saw videos saying GoPro 11 films in like 5.1k or something like that while insta360 x3 films in 5.7k (even though it’s not much difference ).
Yeah you got me I had screenshot the poles and started Googling them for my GoPro11 did some leg work and said Self just watch video again verify you likey and yeah … yeah good one watch to end of video!!! Thanks man great video great info gonna do both yeah me!!!!
Great video. Could you additionally comment on tone options/quality and post production? May be you could comment on different use cases e.g. Moto Vlogging?
Hahahaa! It's for sure the best selfie pole out there right now! I thought the DJI one was going to be better, but then the base screw ripped out with very little effort
Good day to you! I am a senior rider on HONDA motorcycle from Japan. I am enjoying camping ,touring and upload video. Your comparison video is so nice! Awesome! Full supported ! Have a nice day my friend!
I currently have a gopro 4 an been using it for pov fishing videos, but looking between upgrading between these two camera's, is there one you would recommend one over the other for somthing like how i want to shoot?
In the stabilization section where you gave it to the X3, I'm surprised you didn't mention the GoPro 11's horizon lock which does the same thing when you rotate the camera to any angle! Cool review though!
Same-ish thing! I love the GoPro’s 360 horizon lock, but it crops in quite a bit to achieve that ability. The Insta360 achieves 360 lock in three dimensions and can be super wide👍
Technically it’s 1080 in every direction. So it doesn’t look great no matter wichi way you zoom :) but when it you in the shot 6 feet away you won’t really notice. Only distant things are clearly blurred.
I am from India and i love your videos and i am ur subscriber , this comparison was great but it could have been better if you had mention about heating issue which is common in most of the action camers.
I like how Insta360 X3 is UVC support out of the box with no need install software. I dislike GoPro in this case, needs software. I’d prefer media mod an USB hdmi capture.
I just bought the Insta360 x3 last month after watching your videos. I don’t think i should watch your Go Pro 11 videos, i might get it too lmao. Keep it up! Tnx for the help David Manning!
I own a go pro 10 black. I like the camera but the battery life sucks. It takes longer to charge the battery than it runs.. what is the battery life on the insta 3?
Nice that you showed the actual resolution of insta 360 x3. Resolution is one thing, but what I like about the gopro are the colors. On the oled tv they look like the original (I have a gopro). I keep thinking about insta 360. I wish these colors were similar.
Great review pal.. I am not a pro. can you please suggest me if x3 in single lens 4k mode video will be normal like go pro or it will give a round shape view of the background like the 360 mode? Then I'll go for the twin edition, where both 4k and 360 different lenses are available. I heard about the heating issues with gopro 11. I need to shoot myself during vlog and video regarding daily life which does not require 360 all the time.
Okay, I wanna hear your thoughts on this video and these two cameras! Towards the end of the video, I explain how I decide which camera to reach for👍
I've been a GoPro user since 09 or earlier. The 360 cams, when punched in at 1080p remind me of the quality of the hero 2 or 3... Also, it appears that the 360 cam would need to be much closer to the subject to get the same shot, and I already find that somewhat of a challenge with the modern GoPro. With that being said, I'm not interested in 360 camera tech until they achieve 8k or higher, I'd like to see the punched in image be 2.7k at least. That's my thoughts on the 2 cameras, I do not yet have a hero 11 but I've got two 8's a 9 and a 10 not to mention all the older gopros I still have that are obsolete. Thank you David for all the work you do!!! 🤟😎
Really great video as always! Personally, I lean more towards the GoPro right now. The 360 footage looks really cool, but I just don't like that the resolution of the end product is so low.
The thing I find very interesting about the current Black Friday deals over at GoPro though, is that they've increased the prise of the Hero 11 this week, so 15% off isn't a big sale compared to the price last week (at least here in Sweden, 15% off is just making a few dollars difference (converted from SEK). I don't know how it is in the other countries, but at least the Swedish GoPro site isn't running a very good deal).
I was very disappointed seeing that, because the sale was much better during the Halloween deals, which I find a bit strange because I thought Black Friday usually offers better deals than Halloween.
Hopefully they'll have better prices on Friday, but I'm not sure since they're already offering a pretty good price with the subscription.
I am leaning toward the GoPro as of right now. I have a hero 4 and (just like all the other comments say) the quality of the 360 cams aren’t good enough. I also NEED the Insta360 to be more durable to scratches. I do mountain biking and snowboarding, so if I fall the camera could be heavily damaged or even broken. I’d love to try a 360 camera nonetheless
@@theodalin5355 blackfriday is overrated 👌
For filming activities with your kids it seems to me the X3 will be much easier to work with. And resolution vs actually usable footage is something a lot of people don’t get until they have gone through a few cameras. A shot where dad doesn’t have to make everyone wait for the camera setup is a lot easier on everybody and results in better footage IMO.
Pumped to see you continue to put HERO11 Black through the paces, David! High quality durability is the name of our game 💪
When will gopro fix the hero 9 10 and 11. Still freezing and glitchy. The 9 is unusable 10 still glitchy. The 11 freezes and over heats even after the updates. Such a shame
@@retroonhisbikes They would have to reduce the sensor back down to 12mp to do that. I can record all day long on the Hero 8 because it has a 12mp sensor. Same with the DJI Action 3. It's 12mp sensor keeps it from overheating. The bigger the sensor the more processing power needed. Also, video cameras don't need higher mp sensors. Only photo cameras. Good example is the Sony A7siii. Its only a 12mp sensor and its internals are used in their cinema line of cameras. Who pays $14,000 for a 12mp sensor cinema camera? Someone who wants to film good videos. @GoPro
@@retroonhisbikes You can sue them in the court. You might get a solution with 💰
Pleaseee!! we need a special gimbal for go pro, to achieve 10/10 🙌🏼
@@CrisandLucianoVlog I have a gimbal but my over heating issue has been on a tripod stab off etc
I am sold on the X3. With the 360 footage I don't need to worry where I mount the camera or where I am pointing at, I can decide the angle in post which is my favourite feature. Also the invisible stick effect is insane, never get tired of it lol. My uncle just bought the gopro 11 a couple of weeks ago and he sent it back, it was freezing every now and then
Yeah but are you ok with blurry background? Especially out in nature with distant rocks and trees where it noticeable that they are not resolved?
I have Insta360 x3 and GoPro 10 and my opinion is:
Having both cameras is a game changer. They complement each other pretty well with the video/photo quality of GoPro and the versatility of X3. But, if you have none of these, the first one I recommend is the GoPro. Even that you have a lot of freedom with the X3, the GoPro has a greater quality of video, so it’s the best camera for most of situations. The X3 you will use in specific situations that the GoPro isn’t so versatile, most of “selfies” shots the X3 is easier to use and will deliver a stunning angle of the shot, but the opaque and low resolution will keep you doing just some short clips as B-rolls.
Can you edit the film from Gopro and Insta360 in the same software? So you can use scenes from both cameras in the same film? What software to use then?
@@theofficecyclist tried to import the GoPro files into the Insta360 app and is not possible. The software for the 360 is mainly to reframe your shots and adjust the field of view.
Later, you need to process in a video editor normally (sony vegas, after effects, filmora… the one that you prefer).
1920 x 1080 is the default export settings. In the Video Export Settings box you can change this to 3840 x 2160 (4K). Also you can increase the bitrate and use ProRes 422 encoding format for increased video quality. You can then save this as the default.
Is this for the Insta ?
@@Blackirish__ Yes, from the export dialog box in the Studio software.
I just ordered this camera on amazon, imo there is not a debate about which one is the best. Insta just can do what gopro can do and then also other things...
I've had the GOPRO hero 9 for a couple of years and love it. I use it mostly for overlanding video and the stabilization is great. Just picked up the Insta 360 X3 and it does amazing stuff also. But you're right, they are two very different cameras with different usages. Just driving down dirt roads I think the Gopro is a clear winner because I set the lens to linear and get rid of a lot of dashboard from my truck. The 360 X3 shows a lot of dashboard that gets boring after a few seconds. But having the ability to video 360 degrees and editing it later means I won't miss thing as much, if at all. Both will be used with all my travels and RUclips videos and really looking forward to Maui this spring and snorkeling with the Insta 360 X3, I think it will be awesome in that environment.
I'm a solo traveler who shoots for my personal social media. The 360 makes more sense for my use like you said. I don't need the super high quality that the GoPro has, and having the invisible selfie stick with multiple angles make it seem like I have a camera crew and a drone when I'm shooting by myself. Great review!
I’ve got to go with the 360, since you can sometimes only have a one-shot to capture whatever you’re doing. A studio selfie setup would be a different story, where maybe a GoPro would be better. But life experiences, not knowing what’s going to happen wherever you are, and if something is happening out of frame etc, it’s best to just capture EVERYTHING, and figure out what works best in your post. Yes you have the inconvenience of having to post-process. But most people already do that before uploading to their social media of choice.
And with the bugs from GoPro with freezing and overheating and lack of firmware updates etc, I think DJI or Insta360 are better choices.
I got the GoPro 11 cause image quality is the most important factor for me and i already got the Max for the rare occasion i need 360 footage. But having said that, the X3 is pretty cool. For someone who doesn't own an action camera and wants something that's good all round, the X3 is probably the best choice at the moment.
I have some extra Max batteries I am trying to sell. Seems to be no one in Canada has a GoPro Max…or any action camera. Anyways, let me know if you are interested.
@@teamsaunz Hey, thanks but i have more than enough batteries and i barely use my GoPro Max anymore. I also live in Europe, only the shipping will probably cost more than the batteries themselves 😅Hope you find someone in Canada, someone has to need some batteries there 🤔
Hi, what's your opinion about the GoPro 11 now? does it suffer from freezing issues?
@@ArchangelAmin Hey, well i love it! In the meantime i have traveled a lot and used it in many different scenarios and never had an issue. I think it's an awesome little camera and the GoPro Labs firmware unlocks many advanced options. I shoot more with my GoPro than my Sony A7C 😅
@@vlightphotography thanks!
I have not read any comments, but I hope someone else who is subbed here would mention that the x3 would be absolutely perfect for VR....I can right off the bat think of a real estate agent. They could record a property they are selling, and prospective buyers could view the whole house from anywhere in the world, like they were pretty much there. My daughter just turned 4....I would have loved to have shot the party with one of those. I'm even using an older Rift and this would blow me away and the people I would make watch them. Nice review. Thank you.
It's my first 360 camera and its already replaced my GoPros. Any perceived shortcomings is easily outweighed by the versatility and ease of use. My absolute favourite camera.YMMV
I bought a GoPro 10 just before the GoPro 11 came out, i have never had a problem with it freezing or anything else up to now, i did crash my MTB and the GoPro took the full impact but apart from a slight scrape to the edge of the lense it is fine and still no problems with it, the price puts me off the 360 X3 so i am thinking of getting a GoPro 11 but i might wait and see what the next GoPro is like first, price does play a big part in my decisions and i think it does for a lot of people.
DM - totally agree with both if you can, I have a 7 black and a one x2. I don't fully trust the insta for water proof action but otherwise it gets more use right now. Just wish, 2 years or so into it that insta would already put out next gen 360 with higher reso when you frame down. whichever brand accomplishes that in their next release will crush the market
Just received my X3. I used to have Gopro 9 but decided not to upgrade to 11. Looking for something new and fun so decided to buy X3 simply because the invisible selfie stick...
Your summary was bang on the money, both cameras serve different purposes and as such you pick the right tool for the job. Get and use both! There's something nice and simple about having a fixed view though, probably not having to go through hours of footage from all those different angles, plus an easier editing workflow.
Great video on these two. I personally have found myself reaching for my X3 more and more recently, but when I go on my trip to the Okefenokee Swamp next week, I'll be taking both (as well as my Canon R). I definitely agree that they are similar tools that can be used in conjunction/tandem.
Also, always a fan of your added commentary/sound effects.
Thank Man. Good info And great delivery too. I'm buying the Insta 360 x3 to fill in some gaps in my vlogging..
Great to know your opinion but, my man, talk about downloading the content from the camera, app gimmicks, accessory compatibility, performance in different settings, first time buyer’s heads ups… there’s so many categories that are missing from this comparison.
Good points I was thinking the same. I like the GoPro unlimited upload subscription and the auto-upload feature that saves every clip to the Cloud in original resolution. Even lets you save non-GoPro videos I think. It also pretty easy to edit videos from the app.
I have both. They aren't the same. They are 2 different types of camera's for different uses.
Two separate tools for different things. But if you can take only just 1 in an unfortunate way, I’d say the 360 X3. But in my case it would be the DJI Action 3 for filming others and the Insta360 X3 for self filming. After an entire day of watching camera videos of GoPro, Insta360 X3 and DJI Action 3 camera reviews, that’s how I narrow it down and for use. Can have both, just use them differently.
I have both now too! Just picked up the X3 for the exact reason of filming myself! Gopro for the vlog styles. Thanks for a great video David!
The part you left out is the video editing. The X3 requires some video editing experience to really make it work. GOPro is far easier on the video editing.
I shoot with the X3 as it is a complete film studio in your pocket. I think image quality is the compromise with the X3 as the GoPro has better image quality
Thanks for the Black Friday links! I bought a GoPro Hero 11 Black and saved some money :)
Would you consider a video comparing the GoPro Max to the Insta360 X3?
I have BOTH. I like Go Pro for point and shoot content but Insta360 is great for when I do live demos where a point and shot camera can’t capture every angle or all the action happening. If you’re rough on your action camera DO NOT get the Insta360 because you will have to ship the camera back, it takes around two weeks to get it back, and the repair cost is SINFUL 💀
That Insta360 tripod can also be used for bullet time, which isn't used often, but can be kind of a cool secondary shot. I have the X2 and the Hero 8, use them both, but I've prefered the X2 as I don't have to think too much about where I'm pointing.
Lens covers for the 360 are a must and I don't think detract that much, and with mtn biking it's required.
Solid points Troy! How often do you need to swap out your lens protectors? I find that a little rock bump and I usually get a pretty noticeable scratch on the cover
@@DavidManningvlog I've been lucky so far an no rock strikes, But I also use the rubber lens cover a lot. I think our PNW trails aren't quite as dry as they are where you are.
I use both the 11 and the 3X.... the 11 is great underwater with proper video lights.. the 3X is not a deep dive camera as it will never ever work with proper video lights underwater... works fine at shallow diving with the housing... so you can actually mix the footage and using both you can show a dive vacation so much better than if you had to just choose one camera..
Couple additional points in the gopros favor. Audio is much better on the gopro. Also if you are changing light say in and out of the woods the gopro does much better. Snowboarding shots in the insta look great, not a fan of them on bikes. They dont seem to stabilize as well and the iso balance on the gopro is much better.
While id love to have both, as a solo option i gotta stick with gopro
Great video! I have a Hero 7 and I am looking at a new camera for motovloging, but also looking at different angles for the videos. Have some friends that got the Hero 11 and are complaining that they overheat all the time and they lost their videos. So, I'll probably move on with the insta and keep my Hero 7 attached to the helmet. Thanks for the video!
I'm looking forward to getting the 360 as a poor man's drone. More to the point, drones are hard to travel to foreign countries with (some get really paranoid about them!). But sticking a 360 action camera on a BAS (big a$$ stick) up high out the window or roof rack is a good substitute.
Same!
I look at it this way:
If somebody is doing things that need an action cam, they should (already) have a GoPro in their kit. Most people then, should get the 360 camera before upgrading their GoPro.
Can i ask: what's that tripod pole you use for both of your cameras? (LOL heh heh)
Insta360 - if you wanted to showcase your surroundings
Gopro - if you wanted to showcase what you feel while doing your sport/xtreme sport
GoPro is yesterday's action camera. I have 2 Gopros but I just received my new X3 today. It is way more fun than a GP.
06:32 The cast shadow ruins the 21st-century technology of Insta 360 x3 🤠
Hahaha! I don't know about ruined, but it for sure gives away the effect🤣
Tnx David for the video. IMO, for 90% of users, the insta 360 wins.
I've had enough of filming others and had too many trips without a pic or a video of myself.
I must fit in that 10% 😅
The X3 is for sure the best "Film Yourself" camera I've ever used!
Some of my favorite shots are from the Insta360 because there’s no pole and it looks like someone is filming you. But I do like go pro for more vlog style. Sooo we need both!
I agree. They take very different shots and I found them useful in different situations.
I have both. But the 360 is the best for me. I record kayak fishing. The 360 can get the shot that takes at least 3 Gopro's. Now, if I'm talking or showing what I see on my fishfinder, I use a Gopro. The 360 is behind me, and Gopro is facing me.
Trick. Export X3 in reframed 1080 then run that clip through Topaz for 4k. Amazing results.
Coming from the Hero 8, and all of the headaches surrounding the software issues with go pro. I just ordered the X3; I’d much rather get every shot in 1080p, than completely miss it in 4K lol 😂
Hi David can you make a video or tutorials video how to edit video from insta360 x3 ? Thank you.
Very informative review thanks!
What advice would you give a beginner whose buying their first Action Camera to go with the Insta360 or GP?
I just bought the insta360 X3 & WOW, what a cool piece of tech!!! 💯👍
Even a novice like me can look like a real videographer, because no matter what way you face the camera you can edit it & guys the perspective in the app.
Yeah, you're not lying, the Ulanxi PT-20 was hard to find, I ordered the wrong 1 off insta360, so had to get the right 1 from B&H Photo, because they had free shipping, unlike insta360.
I bought the sticky lens as well, but questionable about using them, how are they still holding up, any issues visible?
Didn't look too bad in your video, but could see glares & the dreaded red dot
Hey! What do you recommend for a water park/family vacation? That’s mainly what I want it for for family moments/vacations. I’m struggling here to decide
Wouldn’t a better comparison have been between the GoPro Max and the Insta360? After all, both are a 360 degree action camera. I’ve got the Max, and the footage is great. Had it mounted on the rear of my motorbike, and the footage is great. No shaking, even on the back of a large V-Twin bike that shakes and vibrates a lot
Mhh on the motorcycle Insta360 X3 rules supreme though
Help please, I got the X3 camera and I see that in normal 360 video outdoors, the image is too white and unclear, while in other modes (photo, 1 lens video) the image is normal and clear. Why is this happening? How do you fix this please?
Hands down for action, travel and overall versatility, the Insta360 paired with the invisible selfie stick is the winner!
The Insta360 X3 has lens protectors available, so the durability issue is a moot point.
have you tried any, i need one thats good but all the reviews ive seen say they suck
don't be silly. I'm shopping for a camera and seriously considering the X3, but calling durability a "moot point" is just silly
Yep.
I thought I would never say it..
"I mean being a gopro fanboy and all"
1080P is fine...
I can see everything
Sorry..
But gopro just lost a fanboy
#justsaying
I just like the audio/video quality on the GoPros better.
Both good tools, but the issue with the INSTA is the faffing around with the pre processing, GoPro 11 is is the way to go if you can only afford the one.
I like the accessories available for GoPro. I love the snap mounts as well.
I allways watch till the end, you know it.😄 I have been scared the whole video through, watching your handtalking, not smashing accidently the one x 3. But it is how you said, both action cams have their specific use for what you need. I think I'd be more interested in the one x3.
compared x3,hero11and action 3 ,just went to 11 just for mostly the image quality and dynamic range and in addition to pretty good stabilization ,,360 looks cool but will wait for it a little more time .too many brands to cary ,I think the next version of max will get it right with the 360 .will wait for until they get hero 4k60 in go pro max .
Does the insta360 lenses covers make a difference in not stacking the camera. I’m trying to decide what to buy
You should have mentioned that the X3 has lens guards too. Just like the Hero. Those guards protects the lens very well.
Look at what other people say about them. They create flare. Not like go pro.
@@Catpanl that's exactly right, I removed the lens guards of my X3 because of this, and the footage is way better without them.
X3 Can do single lens mode at 4K. Essentially you have both cameras in one.
If you traveling somewhere and you want to record the experience which one would be better ?
Which one would be better to mount to my helmet when wakeboarding.? Great video, big fan of the channel.
I would vote GoPro for that👍
@@DavidManningvlog Aye thank you.!!
Im confused, is the insta 360 1080 like you mention in the video - But on the web-specs it says 5,7k 30 fps?
Also, is the stick included or extra $$ ?
5.7K is the entire 360 sphere that you record, but then when you reframe and cut a 16:9 video out of that sphere, it becomes 1080. And they usually run specials where you can get the stick included👍
Great video and agree that they're similar in many ways, and picking one over the other tends to come down to scenario. I think the extra workflow to reframe 360 videos is worth mentioning. The Insta360's AI tracking does make it way, WAY easier than working with a GoPro Max's 360 footage, but it's still an extra step you have to go through.
which one will you recommend for a guy who will be filming while riding motorcycle? Thank you
I've had nothing but trouble from my 11. Overheating multiple times. Lock ups and having to pull battery. I also own the x3 and its nice it really good lighting..
It's so odd how some people have issues while others do not 🤔
Well my friend and I didn’t experience those issues as well.
The most details video i watched on youtube just missing battery life part its fine we all know we need extras for both 😂
Thank you so much for your review!! Comparison, it's so informative!! Both good so far, I loved X3 so much I will order it with the kit tools as well
I have both and me personally, I 100% recommend the X3. I honestly can't stand the GoPro, too finicky, too many bugs and constantly missing footage because of freezing up and overheating. The freezing and overheating have been a problem from day one with GoPro and they have done very little if anything to fix it. It's even worse if you have your GoPro in the media mod and now you have to pull it apart freezes to pull the battery wasting time and missing footage. There is also no comparison to battery life on the Insta360 X3, X3 wins hands down, go's the entire day without having to swap out or recharge a battery. Now if I'm comparing the X3 to the Max, again, can't beat the X3 in battery life, size, function and stitching, hell the Fusion was a better 360 than the MAX, at least the Fusion you could shoot in low light, the MAX is done at sunset. GoPro's customer service is horrendous and that is being generous at best. Vid quality may be a touch better on the GoPro but thats only if it doesn't bug out before you shoot, X3 works every time. Just a note: Insta is working on replaceable lenses, next generation maybe? I replace camera's almost every 12 months or so, so not really an issue if I scratch one. My X3 spends a lot of time sticking out in front of my Jeep on the trail and going though brush, not a scratch yet and Ive cleaned a lot of mud off of it.
I went through this in the spring when i wanted my first action camera to supplement my sports photography. I went with the Hero 9 b/c I did not understand the role of a 360 camera at the time. At the time, I was comparing GoPros with the One RS and I liked the quality of the GoPro better. Now I wish I had a 360 of some sort, so I am looking for a used one (I can't justify the cost of a new one as I do not think I'll ever make any money with it) and have learned a ton from your videos this year.
Also, I really like those tripods and stick. Are they one unit or is that the selfie stick you linked in your accessories video on top of something else?
what camera do you suggest for just the usual family type and holiday videos with the only action type shot being the race for the buffet at the hotel😂 we just want an easy to use camera that really shows off holiday scenery etc... (only cameras available in the Uk please) Your videos are great by the way...
What about GoPro Max David? I know it’s pretty bad editing in the GoPro app, but I would like to know about your thoughts about GoPro 360 camera.
I just had a tree “skiyah”🌲 my lens the other day man! Good thing I had a screen cover!
I am not a tech expert but how about using go pro with a insta 360 stick?😢
Hey David! Love your videos. What selfie sticks are you using in this video? They look Carbon and Beefy.. Thanks!
at my location anyway gopro hero 11 and 10 black are both on sale at walmart for $399 and the 9 is for $299
I own GoPro 10. It’s pretty good. Still learning how to make good footages.
I’ve heard GoPro 11 battery gets hot faster and it shuts off quicker. So I’ll stick with my GoPro 9 but I just bought a insta360. X3 and I love the quality more on the insta360. Insta360 films in a higher quality than the GoPro 11. I saw videos saying GoPro 11 films in like 5.1k or something like that while insta360 x3 films in 5.7k (even though it’s not much difference ).
Yeah you got me I had screenshot the poles and started Googling them for my GoPro11 did some leg work and said Self just watch video again verify you likey and yeah … yeah good one watch to end of video!!! Thanks man great video great info gonna do both yeah me!!!!
Great video. Could you additionally comment on tone options/quality and post production? May be you could comment on different use cases e.g. Moto Vlogging?
Ya I really like the idea of a x3....I want that 360. One day lol I will not ask what that selfie pole is by the way LOL 😉
Hahahaa! It's for sure the best selfie pole out there right now! I thought the DJI one was going to be better, but then the base screw ripped out with very little effort
Good day to you!
I am a senior rider on HONDA motorcycle from Japan.
I am enjoying camping ,touring and upload video.
Your comparison video is so nice!
Awesome!
Full supported !
Have a nice day my friend!
Super helpful video, I've got my hero 9 and will probably wait until 360 cameras up the recording quality. Appreciate ya!
I currently have a gopro 4 an been using it for pov fishing videos, but looking between upgrading between these two camera's, is there one you would recommend one over the other for somthing like how i want to shoot?
In the stabilization section where you gave it to the X3, I'm surprised you didn't mention the GoPro 11's horizon lock which does the same thing when you rotate the camera to any angle! Cool review though!
Same-ish thing! I love the GoPro’s 360 horizon lock, but it crops in quite a bit to achieve that ability. The Insta360 achieves 360 lock in three dimensions and can be super wide👍
@@DavidManningvlog ahh, I see what you mean, thanks for the reply! Both fantastic bits of kit by the look of it!
Cool informative video. This will really help us which one to choose.Thank you.
In my GoPro videos, you do not see the selfie stick. I have no issue with that. And I am recording myself.
Very good video, I finally got which one is the downside of the Insta, the 1080 resolution if you don't want the 360 view....
Technically it’s 1080 in every direction. So it doesn’t look great no matter wichi way you zoom :) but when it you in the shot 6 feet away you won’t really notice. Only distant things are clearly blurred.
I have both but I always find insta x3 very fish eye distortion in most shots go,pro,simple but better footage.
I am from India and i love your videos and i am ur subscriber , this comparison was great but it could have been better if you had mention about heating issue which is common in most of the action camers.
I like how Insta360 X3 is UVC support out of the box with no need install software.
I dislike GoPro in this case, needs software. I’d prefer media mod an USB hdmi capture.
hey david! what’s the selfie stick/tripod used in the video for the gopro?
I always use the Insta360 invisible selfie stick for all of my action cameras👍
Should have compared the insta with the Gopro Max. Would have been a better comparison.
I just bought the Insta360 x3 last month after watching your videos. I don’t think i should watch your Go Pro 11 videos, i might get it too lmao. Keep it up! Tnx for the help David Manning!
your video helped me made the decision. thanks a lot.
Which one did you go for?!
@@DavidManningvlog X360!
Div what’s the selfie stick that you are using in this video if you don’t mind pls.thanks ❤
I watched the end of the video so I don't need to ask what pole you use. Did you ever try with the 360 to upscale the footage to 4k and than edit it?
If you haven’t can you review GoPro 360 camera?
Thanks for guide. Please advice how is the sound recording quality on each of these cameras? Can we attach 3d microphones?
I own a go pro 10 black. I like the camera but the battery life sucks. It takes longer to charge the battery than it runs.. what is the battery life on the insta 3?
Thank you that was helpful... how about audio quality ? Also can you edit the insta 360 in final cut pro or must you use their editing software?
Nice that you showed the actual resolution of insta 360 x3. Resolution is one thing, but what I like about the gopro are the colors. On the oled tv they look like the original (I have a gopro). I keep thinking about insta 360. I wish these colors were similar.
Just do some color correction or get a LUT for that. Colors shouldn't be the thing that makes you decide for one or another.
Great review pal.. I am not a pro.
can you please suggest me if x3 in single lens 4k mode video will be normal like go pro or it will give a round shape view of the background like the 360 mode? Then I'll go for the twin edition, where both 4k and 360 different lenses are available.
I heard about the heating issues with gopro 11.
I need to shoot myself during vlog and video regarding daily life which does not require 360 all the time.
I wish the X3 had a 1 inch sensor, if it did there would be no discussion. It's still better than the Hero 11 tho.