Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Everything Wrong With Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 сен 2024
- Just in time for The Last Jedi, and only a year after you began requesting it... we finally have the sins of Rogue One. And there are plenty. Maybe more sins than midichlorians in this movie.
Thursday: Sins of a 90's adventure.
Remember, no movie is without sin! Which movie's sins should we expose next?!
•CinemaSins website: www.cinemasins... •
•Channels•
--TVSins: / @tvsins
--MVS: / @musicvideosins
•Members get MORE! ALL videos early, bonus videos and podcasts, merch discounts and MORE on Patreon!• / cinemasins
•Merch!• teespring.com/...
•Podcasts•
-SinCast A weekly chat with Jeremy, Chris and Barrett about their love and hatred for movies and entertainment. cinemasins.lib...
--Behind the Sins: CinemaSins writers Aaron, Jonathan and Deneé, give a behind the scenes look at what it takes to release the previous week's videos across the CinemaSins brand. redcircle.com/...
•Writers Social•
Jeremy: / cinemasins
Chris: / sincastcinemasins
Barrett: / musicvideosins
Aaron: / aarondicer
Jonathan: / samloomis13
Deneé / deneesays
•Discord: Request on Facebook or Reddit!
•Reddit: / cinemasins
•Jeremy's Book: cinemasins.com...
The worst part of rouge one is that i have to wait till 1977 for the sequel
*Rogue
Whores wear rouge, nice girls pinch...
Dern Vader nice Simpsons reference
The worst of rogue one is that empire and rebels are totally same agresors.And that's a lie compared to other tv shows and movies.
Lol
So my friend and I watched this movie a year ago and then after the movie ended, she asked me a question:
"The last scene with Darth Vader was so cool. But, where was he for the whole beach battle?"
"He hates sand. It coarse, rough, irritating and it gets him everywhere."
margareth michelina *tipping my hat to your wit
I mean, this is Vader (you know robot suit), there is no telling just how bad that would be for his system. Finally, his hatred is justified.
It was sandy down there, and he does hate sand.
Plus, it's the low ground. He doesn't do very well while he's on low ground.
Jim B. You never know when Obi Wan will use it against him.
Vader scene was worth of the price of admission alone.
Requix dude Vader was the best part of this movie everything else sucked
Vader is the best part in any movie
Let me explain?
I think this is the best Disney star-wars movie and the Vader seen was was by far the best part
I just gave you your 1000th like
Darth Vader’s movements were almost perfect. Wasn’t too fast, but it definitely made him feel almost like an impenetrable wall of inevitable death closing in on the rebels. He literally walks almost casually up to them.
His helmet looked like it was bought at toys r us, though.
Forget “almost”. They were perfect. He slowly and calmly strolls forward while disposing of Rebel scum, and does so in spectacular fashion. He was exactly like that in the OT.
Actually, Vader is slow NOT because of confidence, though he does have plenty to spare. He's slow because of the suit and all the life-support equipment required to keep him going. Palpatine designed it specifically to keep Vader from making any kind of real recovery from Mustafar and unable to make a move against him
@@kalligthegrey7010 That's legends. In the new canon, Vader is more than capable of moving faster and, more than that, has made adjustments to his suit before. So this is in part, his confidence and lack of faith in the rebels.
@@RobotronSage tbf, his helmet is made of what's basically plastic
Lmfao at the end "I would trust her with my life"
*Cut to death star blowing up Alderaan*
Ghost of Obi-Wan: How that work out for you Bail?
Ghost of Bail Organa: I don't know how was your 'retirement'?
Ghost of Grand Moff Tarkin: Better than my future career and legacy that's for certain.
"Alderaan chunks *everywhere!* "
I don't like Alderaan chunks. They're coarse and rough and irritating and they get everywhere.
hahahahahaha
Jeremy, on Jyn's "Deadpool costume": She is wearing the uniform of an Imperial Ground Crewman. The things on her back aren't swords. They're like the sticks those guys on the airport runways use to guide airliners.
They'll Sin Jyn's "Deadpool costume" but not the fact that discount Han Solo's walking around an imperial installation, where EVERYONE is clean shaven, with a mustache and a 3 day growth?
I just realized... They specifically made Red 5 die in this film, because Luke takes the spot of Red 5 in A New Hope. Huh... The more you know.
damn should've taken sins off for the continuity
Qrazy Quarian they also wiped out Blue Squadron - originally Luke was going to be part if Blue Squad but they took it out and made it red because it messed with the blue screens (as in, pre-green screen) they used to backgrounds
Cool, didn't see that either.
I actually enjoyed this film a lot more than the other new ones
my favorite 'new' one.
To be fair the new ones are trash
@@ToxicSkull0 why so negative? Just fucking enjoy it than having nothing at all
@@redphones3295 Episode 9 shouldn't have been made. It was a disgrace.
@@buibuddha at least we saw Palpatine in the movie screen once more
Am I the only one whos just happy Tarkin is in the movie and doesnt care about the CGI? Sure its not perfect but it keeps the movies continuity
ZAchary TErsigni I think it’s great that we can continue this characters story and the actors legacy by having the character in.
The CGI work is fantastic, not perfect, but the animation is so cool
I agree my boi
ZAchary TErsigni Not alone. I have been out spoken on bad CGI in place of real actors. Tarkin in Rogue One was INCREDIBLE! I absolutely loved his scenes. I was all smiles with the outcome of the CGI mixed with one of Cushing’s relatives. Peter Cushing is such an iconic actor with such a unique physical look, to completely recast the role could’ve been bad...very bad.
Plus one.
12:26 Now first of all thats not a bounty hunter droid thats an imperial ground crew outfit, basically the equivalent of an air traffic controller. Wich means those aren't katanas...they are "Illuminated Traffic Wands" or over-glorified glow sticks if you will.
Ben Sam I was thinking the same
Ben Sam just an FYI....ATCs do not use light up wands. ATC are the ones in the tower directing the planes where to go in the sky...the light up wand ground crews are usually airline employees.
Ben Sam lol he called marshaling wands-handheld illuminated bacons katanas cinema sins needs to do more homework
Oh look a fake channel, let's take it back outside behind the shed and shoot it.
Okay sure its not for fighting, but then why does a guy whose job is to direct ships landing get inside the ship for inspection?
Princess Leia was never on a diplomatic mission to Alderaan. That's just what she told Vader when she was captured. The video recording she made with R2 in A New Hope made it very clear that her mission was to find Obi Wan Kenobi.
Which makes a New Hope hilarious, as every rebel on that Cruiser was openly lying to Vader's face, while timeframe wise he was mowing them down just a moment ago. No wonder the guy got force choked.
A diplomatic mission to Alderaan was pretty much her only hope of slipping the Imps and getting home. "No your Vaderness, we totally have a legit reason for being out here, and you can't prove shit any way!"
If she was going to see Obi wan then why did she have a recorded message?
David Stinnett she didn't? You see her record it right before r2 and c3po leave.
*when she tells you that she's on a diplomatic mission to Alderon, but you just slaughtered about 10 rebels who you saw with the plans get on the ship*
I was sad you didnt mention the "are you kidding me? I'm already blind!" joke
that was at least worth taking off 3 sins, and the Vader hallway scene was worth taking off 20 sins
12:27
Wait, you thought those were....swords? THEY ARE SIGNAL STICKS. She basicaly disguised herself as the imperial equivalent of an air traffik controller!
LordDarthHarry Have to correct you here, as an Air traffic controller that is not what we do. She is the equivalent of ground personnel.
Did she even use them?
Why would she use them? It's not that her mission was to direct ships' landing.
I came here to say the same thing. Why would a bounty hunter go onboard for an inspection?
12:27 Those are not blades, there lights sticks to help space ships land. It's because she took the uniform of a landing technician.
darkadrien14 I was looking for this comment!
Yeah, that was pretty fucking obvious lmao. Wonder how fed up Jeremy gets looking for sins that he just puts fake ones in there because why not.
darkadrien14 it's pretty fucking obvious
SirBrickalot OfLego dude, like 50 people have mentioned it lol
4:07 Let's be honest that storm trooper was just looking for a reason to shoot that other storm trooper. Probably slept with his wife or something.
Lmao....now that is funny!!
Especially considering 3 of his shots go directly into his crotch plate
The KotOR sidestory is strong with this one.
lol!
Wasn't he the stormtrooper that brought his daughter on a bring your kids to work day ?? ..robot Chicken
You mistook those light-landing-stick-thingies for swords and it’s been years and I’m still mad. That’s a sin.
Thought they were batons lmao
this! they're wands for flagging aircraft when they land lol
I see this 1 year later and i am also mad 😅
Those aren't the swords you're looking for...
The "strongest stars have hearts of kyber" line makes perfect sense if your paying attention. The Death STAR, the STRONGEST weapon in the galaxy at the time, has a Kyber core to power the planet destroying laser.
Emerald Sceptile3 He also doesn't seem to know what Kyber Crystals are, at least not well
I study astronomy and luckily for you, I just studied supergiant stars this week, which are like around billions of times larger than the Sun, which in turn are millions of times larger than the Death Star. and the Sun's total energy emitted in one second can supply the Earth's human population with enough power for a couple million years. So no, that sentence made no sentence whatsoever, not even in chemical terms (supergiants contain hydrogen in their "hearts"). Oh, and you're*
Jester the fact you actually typed that is kinda sad lol
oh okay, the astronomer is here guys, we can all rest assured that the space religious telepathic samurai ninjas are wrong in thinking that their world has stars with kyber crystals, that's just dumb of us, what were we thinking
Jester I don't know if you've realized this but the Death Star isn't a real star
That Bail Organa clip at the very end of the video though.
"I would trust her with my life"...
Alderaan explodes with him on it.
Hilarious.
Tomo Atomos Fuck off.
Viktor Reznov what was it
A Star Wars Battlefront II gameplay, with a 5:186 like ratio, filled in the comments section with complaints for Tomo Atomos to stop linking his videos in other comments.
Hopefully this saves you guys a click.
That part made me lose it.
Positively brutal!
3:18 "The strongest stars have hearts of Kyber" If you think about it it is paid off kinda because the Death star is powered by Kyber and its pretty powerful.
Comrade Stalin!
And it actually explains the power of Starkiller base, which literally DESTROYS stars to feed itself in energy (hence the star's cores)
When Stalin is right for once.
Stalin exactly
Joey M Stalin is always right, you disagree you go to gulag.
"the strongest stars have hearts of kyber" isn't this a reference to the death star, which is powered by kyber and insanely powerful
No, he's a Schwarzenegger fanboy.
and also has star in the name, and is a similar size of a moon, which are things that float around other things that float around big stars, or something along those lines.
No he literally means the element Kyber, I think, correct me if I’m wrong
Kyber crystals also power light sabers
In the force awakens that deadstar planet uses the power of a star to shoot a laser. Thus using kyber like the other deathstars.
That Vader scene at the end was better then anything that happened in 7 or 8
8 was a disgrace to Star Wars
Skar
Hey, at least they gave some new appreciation for the prequel trilogy amirite?
Anonymous Person I know, I never thought I’d say these words: the prequels are better than the sequels
Nope. The prequel trilogy - excepting Episode 3 - have some of the worst filmmaking in popular movies in the last 30 years.
The fight in Snoke's throne room was amazing.
I think we can all agree that the Vader hallway scene is the best thing ever.
I used this for the lightspeed kamikaze, and I'll use it for Vader's killing spree.
IT. WAS. *FUCKING BADASS.*
No I heard that someone said it was "the worst sequence in Star Wars history".
But the movie still sucks
@@Bobman-ml5qf and that person is wrong.
@@tuseroni6085 yes they are
The “swords” in Jyn’s disguise weren’t swords, but actually the light thingys that the guys who help land ships use.
took it off
@ur mom I would pay money to see THAT happen.
@@isaned -beat me to it by three months.
@Rafael Enriquez Well...it's been months but Felicity and her Husband are expecting their first child (and she looks about ready to pop too) so I'm guessing Jyn likes 'the real thing'.
Damn my dumbass thought they were bolt cutters
I am stunned you sinned Rogue One for using archival and deleted footage of Rebel pilots from the original trilogy. This was a beautiful connection to the original film and made me feel Rogue One was truly connected to the immediate events of A New Hope. How was this a sin?
...Dude, this happened right before a new hope. How in the world could 'future' footage have been played on tapes from the past?
Percy Leung what in the hell are you blowing steam about?
@@TheSharkIsWorking_23 The original trilogy consists of a new hope, empire strikes back and return of the jedi. Rogue One happened right before a new hope. And now footage from a new hope, empire strikes back and return of the jedi can suddenly appear in the movie that happened before all of them?
You must be new too Jeremy and how cinema sins works
@@joebuck4957 Me or Travis Starr?
"Guys...i'm having a hard time figuring out which character is blind in this scene." fuckin golden 13:00
@Coldheart I mean there is a theory that that's why storm troopers have such bad aim in the originals too
@@snekkoheckko4466 eh I like the idea that it’s their helmets that cause their bad aim but that’s good as well.
I have to admit, in theatres, I got chills when Vader showed up in that corridor.
I have to admit I got chills when I realized how idiotically the scene is shot.
He rips the gun out of the rebels hands but doesn't think to stop the guy holding the fucking plans he wants.
the rebels don't stop to help the guy holding the plans that the entire mission was for in the first place and instead run the other direction.
vaders blade coriography was so baddddd.
I can’t see that scene now without hearing “what up, noobs?”
The Z-Family I was smiling the entire time and felt nothing but happiness at the sight of Vader cutting down rebels.
Forgotten Syrup he did though? Why do you think the door was jammed, Vader was using the force to hold it closed while he dealt with the troops.
Plus..it's a movie. Being a cynical douche that nitpicks everything, of course you won't enjoy it.
If you just let yourself enjoy a movie and be stoked on a cool scene you wouldn't be so bitter.
Badass scene, I agree. However, my friend pointed out one crucial flaw: why didn't Vadar use the force to retrieve the plans? He knew what it was and where it was. Imagine how much more edgy it would've been if he crushed it in his hands. But, there were more copies made! It could've been a race to find all the plans, and considering how powerful Vadar is, he could've destroyed multiple ships trying to take off, but one gets away, Leia's. Lots of speculation I know, but still :P
"The strongest stars have hearts of kyber" so obviously referring to the death star it's shocking you didn't get that. Sorry for being that guy.
So Starkiller Base, with its heart (core) of kyber crystals is one of the strongest stars.
or maybe because Jyn's nickname is Stardust and she has a kyber crystal close to her heart?
OH MY GOD you're right!! Hahahaha.
I literally thought of this when that line was said.
@@killuazoldyck9929 no, that used a star for its power. There's a pretty big hint in the name.
Actually, Carrie Fisher was so impressed by the CGI that she actually thought it was deleted footage from a New Hope
not to be rude but soo??
Micke Persson meaning it’s good enough to fool the person it’s literally based off of.
@@DapperMudkip to be fair she was probably high
I dont think people realise that a new hope was made in 1985 or something and that this kind of technology was unheard of.
There literally wasnt hd in 1985 you idiots
@@scoutbite4334 1977, with somebody who has the name Darth Vader you should know this
That Vader scene deserves to knock half those sins off
Davidoff Productions - but his awesomeness here means he's turned into a moron in the scenes in Star Wars.
Not really, all it means is that the fight between Obi wan and Vader wasn't a straight rest of skill, it was something more
Until you realize that if Vader could do that in Rogue One, why wasn't he doing in a New Hope? It would have saved the lives of dozens of storm troopers.
10tonhamster this. This a thousand times
Star Wars Rebels did it better.
Those deadpool style swords on her back are landing lights used to guide aircraft to land.
Yep
Yup
People never really understand the briliance of how amazing the death star and its structure was. Yes there was an exhaust pipe that destroys the death star with ease.
For a PLANET-SIZED super structure, only having ONE exaust pipe is pretty Damn incredible to say the least.
Edit: thank you for the likes, never thought I would get any form of support. Have a great day all!
I blame the contractor...
Trepp size of a small moon as episode four says, but still pretty big
Also its not really a plot Hole. Just imagine how much exhaust shit and technical shit the death star is. its so fucking big and so heavily armed noone of the empire would possibly think some rebels fly through a dig and make a 1 in a million shot, the chances were like 0,000001%
also it's never stated that the exhaust port was 1. even actually stated to be there by galen erso. or 2.part of galen's plan. the flaw galen built is ONLY the fact that an explosion to the reactor would cause the destruction of the system. the exhaust port could have very easily been someone else's legitimate mistake. also the fact that the entire tube was free of obstructions (turbines, grates and the like) is extremely convenient for luke and the rebels however seeing as that was the ONLY exhaust port for the entire station and it was ONLY 1m wide makes it a bit more understandable as to why it was built the way it was. as far as the reactor flaw, most starwars reactors can take a pretty decent beating before they explode as is evedent in the force awakens with starkiller base. also, even when they do explode its not usually an event that will vaporize the entire ship/station, as is shown in the phantom menace with the trade federation control ship. I have no doubts that if the empire had completed construction of the second death star it would not have had the reactor flaw and would have been effectively impossible fore the rebel alliance to combat let alone destroy.
the port was something like 2 metres wide as well. that's tiny like less than a 10th a percent of the width of the actual structure. the structure is also loaded with turbo lasers. literally anyone but, Luke or Vader would have died before getting close enough to fire a shot in the first place, let alone one that hit properly.
Cgi tarken honestly wasn’t that bad I didn’t even notice it was cgi until I realized he was dead in real life
I see my clone and I meet
She died not long *AFTER* Rogue One appeared in cinemas. I know this because I was at the cinema watching Rogue One when the news came out.
@@S-Fan20062 years late, but he meant Tarkin and not Leia
Vader made a dad joke without knowing that he had a son
Andy Miller Ever heard of auto correct
Mr. Loser So he made a dad joke without knowing he has a son...Leia doesn't count?
Vader: "Be careful not to choke on your aspirations...director."
Luke: *Rolls eyes*
TurboFerret87 I guess he did it to make up for the child inside the wife he killed.
Honest, that shit had me wanting to walk out there and then - but I'm tight, I'd paid so I stayed. Way to butcher a character, Rogue One.
Should've taken a sin off for when Donnie Yen says "Are you kidding me? I'm blind" when they put a bag over his head
Edit: omg thank you for the likes!
Nah, should have added a sin for the "Blank would be excellent at cinema sins" sin.
ohhkay bye yeah that was hilarious 😆
Tomo Atomos Stop advertising your videos
What's funny is that in my D&D game I played a blind monk, and then a month later I heard about Donnie Yen in this movie. Needless to say, my character used that line after I saw Rogue One.
ohhkay bye that line was lame as fuck, if you laughed at that you probably think the fast and furious series is good
1:20 "Congratulations you are being rescued". Love this scene.
And he comes complete with forced chiropractics too!
no what they should've called the film: suicide squad a unnecessary story
Matt Gales so edgy
What about the scene: "Are you kidding me, I'm blind!" - It deserves at least 5 sins off...
Me too
I don't give a s*** how adorable BB-8 is. He will never replace R2-D2 in my heart. You get a sin, cinemasins. ;-)
BB-9E came close for me, but I still love R2's attitude.
@ANTHONY THOMAS It seriously disgusted me when CinemaSins said "BB-8 replaced R2 in our hearts". I'll give you K-2SO over C-3PO, but BB-8 is no more than a marketing product. I can't believe Jeremy thinks we like BB more than R2. He also thought the Duel on Mustafar was a let-down, and that it was boring. He has the worst Star Wars opinions.
ANTHONY THOMAS I really don’t like Jeremy sucking off the sequels. He gives TFA way too much praise, just like Rotten Tomatoes and all the sequel fans. BBitch-8 will never ever be better than R2-fucking D2. And The Force Awakens will never be as good as even Revenge of the Sith.
ANTHONY THOMAS In my opinion TLJ was better. I hated TFA because it was literally just a gender swap. Also, they made me not like Han Solo, who was by far my favourite character in the OT.
ANTHONY THOMAS I recognise that TLJ is in no way good, and is actually bad, but TFA gets way too much praise. TFA hasn’t been hated enough. TFA was A New Hope but worse, and is in no way a good film. It was literally just a gender swap, but the main character was a Wahmen. She’s a Mary Sue more than she is in TLJ. I somewhat respect TLJ for actually trying to do something new.
"It's almost like the guy voicing him is 40 years older now. Weird."
I don't know if you're supporting what he said or you're against it
B0RD3R M4N
I thought it was funny.
But it's stupid, Darth Vader's voice actor James Earl Jones is fucking 86 six years old, so saying that he is 40 years older is bullshit.
B0RD3R M4N
He's forty years older than he was forty years ago during the filming of A New Hope.
I don't see the problem here.
But the problem is that he critizices it for a ridiculous thing
Ffs, a moon-sized station with an exhaust hole that's only a few meters wide? That's not a flaw, that's an engineering masterpiece.
It was a secondary port. The Primary one had a particle shield but the secondary one they fired at was only ray shielded and thus, could not stop a torpedo. This is straight from A New Hope.
Also, Galen didn't make that flaw. He made the reactor susceptible to be blown up. The rebels had to figure out how to hit the reactor, which is why they needed the plans. Galen himself probably doesn't have access to the fill plans.
rezaka116 my question is at what point does an exhaust port suck and not blow like normal exhaust? I mean I know the force and all but still, it's a kinda bullshit shot
An engineering masterpiece is to have no major flaw like that at all. You think with all the advance technology you couldnt fix that hole that could literally blow up the entire ship?
what part of "exhaust" port do you not understand? can you imagine how much heat is generated by the battle station alone, even without subsequent use of it's superlaser?
energy output for refueling stations, considering it docks tens of thousands of TIE fighters. environmental and life support functions within the vessel. central heating. need i say more?
I actually thought Tarkin's and Leia's CGI looked amazing.
i agree with the tarkin, but leia's was pretty bad. there's a deep fake out there that is spot on.
Leia in Rogue One looks paler than than the ghost ot Carrie Fisher
@@ryanbarker5217 Yeah, her face appears a bit wider than usual.
Austin Wood leia looked good until she talked
I'm sure at some time in the future they could return to the footage and re-edit it so it looks near perfect. Until then, I'm happy with what they have done..
As for the “double swords” on the “bounty hunter/droid costume”, those are like those handheld guidance light thingies airport workers use because she’s in an imperial ground crew uniform
cinmesains running out of things to sin so he makes stuff up
@@nulanusa4104 your suspension of disbelief is broken by…Felicity Jones being able to fit into a probably male ground crew uniform? (Also, it’s Star Wars. Even if for some reason we’re claiming Jyn Erso (not Urso) would be unable to fit in a standard ground crewed uniform, you can’t believe that the advanced tech of Star Wars may include outfits that can be adjusted for different standard bodies?
@@BeskarDevil GFY
@@nulanusa4104 what a constructive comment. I’ll give you points as GFY is a less common acronym than KYS.
Imagine if the Vader scene was him slicing through the main characters as Jyn finally hands the plans throgh the door in the place of that final rebel, just in time for Vader to kill her too.
Yeah, I thought of it too, it could have made the Vader scene even more impactful instead of the rather cliche scene on the beach they ended up using.
A female cannot be harmed by a lightsaber because... Disney logic?
I think they were planning on doing that, but decided it would be too dark.
Jff007 Why did they not add this
They were going to do this but Disney decided it was too dark and wanted to give the rebels more “uplifting” deaths....personally I would’ve loved seeing Vader kill them off but his scene was still badass
"I'm having a hard time trying to figure out who is actually blind in this movie"
😂
CinemaSins
¡Be gone spam!
Not good with star wars world anymore but the force flows in everyone but the sith and Jedi are the only one's harness and use it right so the blind ninja makes no sense
the fork Man
1. There are more Force-users than just Jedi and Sith, they're just the two main factions of Force-users.
2. There's a race of aliens who have no eyes and can "see" through the Force.
3. Blind people have done some pretty amazing things in real-life.
4. Chirrut had (literal) blind faith in the Force and trusted it to guide him. It's his faith in the Force that kept him alive so long. So, while not able to truly manipulate the Force to his will, his faith in it has indeed rewarded him.
I said the force flows in everyone and that my star wars knowledge was iffy but why the hell was he able to sense everyone and anything but he had to feel is way to the lever
@fork man; The Force flows in all LIVING things. The lever isn't a living thing.
You acting like the exhaust vent was easy to find, when it’s a 2 meter wide hole on a sphere 120 kilometers in diameter, among thousands of such holes. I doubt anyone would notice it unless they were looking for it.
The sins regarding this are a bunch of BS. Jeremy claims it was super obvious and glaring and should have been fixed, but then says to actually exploit this small flaw that it was a one in a million shot. Why would the Empire be concerned about a flaw (even if they were aware of it) that practically couldn't be used?
@@brandonb.5304 Conversely, why would a designer trying to sabotage the Death Star put in a flaw that practically couldn't be exploited? The bridge crew on the Death Star figured out the flaw when it was attacked and thought it was enough of a threat to consider Tarkin evacuating (can't remember the exact line).
@@jrd33 Imperial Officer: We've analyzed their attack, sir, and there IS a danger. Should I have your ship standing by?
Tarkin: Evacuate?! In our moment of triumph?! I think you over estimate their chances.
Always curious about that line since Tarkin never actually _saw_ what the danger was. Can't remember if that tid-bit was sinned or not in the _Star Wars: A New Hope_ CinemaSins.
John Davis that does acknowledge that (a) it was small enough to go unnoticed until the moment of attack and (b) it did pose a threat. Yes, it’s a plot hole that the chances were small, but any other method would’ve been detected.
You can tell he ain’t a fan 😹 it was made for fans this movie, not jus anyone who hasn’t watched Star Wars
Rogue One is the best Star Wars movie outside the original trilogy. It’s the only newer Star Wars film to not damage the original trilogy
Yes it is. And tbh even tho I love the originals i had a lot more fun with roque one than with episode 4 so my Ranking of the best 5 star wars movies is kinda unpopular as number one for me is Episode 6 Not 5. Then 5, then Roque One, then 4 then III
I agree!!!
Dittos!
And K2SO was something else!
Revenge of the Sith > Rouge One imo. But it’s still really good
Woahhhh, hold on 1 single second. "The strongest stars have hearts of Kyber". Kyber crystals fuel the Death Star. Blind guy knows the future, or writes poetry about it
I think he was talking about her, as her father calls her startdust and she has a Kyber crystal necklace. He is at the same time complimenting her. For whatever reason, that vague statement is not unlike what Chirrut says the entire movie. It is vaguely connected and true, so I think the force is somehow leading him to say those.
because originally jyns mother was going to be a jedi, but they chaged it when they did all the changes to the ending)
Caytonseb OMG it makes sense now! I always knew it was powered by Kyber crystals but never made the correlation
And honestly, the movie is better of for it.
Surpise Jedis are such a tired old plot.
It even buggd me in the Thrawn trilogy.
That C'baoth. Where the fuc kdid the old fuck come from.
Stoy would have gone smoother by going deeper into the conflict betwen mara, luke, old palps ghost and maras conflicting emotions.
old C'baoth just seemed like third a wheel.
The Death star is powered by a hypermatter reactor. The kyber crystals are part of the super-laser systen.
You missed the biggest sin of them all! How the fuck did R2-D2 and C3P0 get aboard Princess Leia’s ship? It had already left by the time the rest of the rebels were leaving.
Another fine plot hole.
Maybe they were in the ship that had the plans
They took a different ship to meet up with leia's ship after Scarif
Thats a good question
Just because they didn't show it doesn't mean it didn't happen.
Aren't the "Deadpool-like weapons" on Jyn's back just landing batons?
Tempos yes
Venazone The landing batons themselves aren't the focus, it's the people using them. The people on the ground watch for mistakes the pilot made that he might not be able to see, and wave the batons to correct him. The batons are brightly colored or lit up so that the pilot can see them clearly.
yes
A blind person who can fight as if they still have eyesight because of some radar sense was always a unique and interesting concept to me. It’s kinda why I like characters like daredevil and toph. Even mortal kombat has a character like that.
"Ive got a bad feeling about.."
"K"
"Quiet"
Oh, fuck you, movie
David Schultz it’s not a official star wars movie. i think it should stay in Star Wars
So when they don’t say it it’s a sin, and if they would have said it would have been a sin?
Look at that, this channel’s integrity is nonexistent.
if they didn't say it, it couldn't be sinned. it was sinned because they teased us by starting to say it but stopping. therefore, the sin was for teasing us.
I don't get the whole "It's not a starwars movie, though!" I don't care, it's pretty dog shit regardless.
It pissed me the heck off when The Last Jedi was the first movie to not have anyone say it at ALL.
"Normally, I'd shoot this ship down but they promoted Gary over me" this has me dying dude
You should be removing sins for the amazing tarkin CGI. I had absolutely no idea he wasnt real until the internet told me like a week after i saw the movie.
emwZEEK I have no idea why he thinks the CGI is bad in this movie
Nope, none of my friends noticed either. It looks damn good. Leia was off though.
Leia was a little off but her and tarkin still had good CGI, im not really sure why he said it was a "bad CGI decision"
Leia's mouth was a little sketchy, but I actually thought they just found the two actors that looked closest to the originals and they got the parts. Had no idea they were so heavily CGI'd until I found out later on the internet.
How did you not see that? I noticed it immediately and it took me out of the movie. His mouth movements were dreadful and he looked very plasticky and weird - definitely uncanny valley. I’ve seen better CGI in Game console trailers.
The last 45 minutes of Rogue One are the best 45 minutes in all of Star Wars.
The Clone Wars and The Mandalorian would like to speak with you, lol.
Anakin saying the reasons he hates sand > Episodes 7-9
@@SomeRandomGuy789 Hahahahaha
3 major gripes with this movie.
1. Galen erso was the best character with an awesome actor but was barely in it
2. Not enough Vader
3. Not enough tudyk
The Macca I agree with everything except for number 2. More Vader would just seem really forced.
honestly more galen would have gotten boring unless they actually went in depth but they wouldnt cuz to much time
Well, if you want more Galen, I think that prequel book to Rogue One will help.
4. Not enough cowbell
Not enough T.Rex/Godzilla
omfg im sick of explaining this, Galen didn't build the exhaust port, he built a faulty reactor. The exhaust port needed to be there but had the reactor been built properly Lukes shot wouldn't have done anything but because of the reactor being faulty it caused a chain reaction exploding the death star.
Darth Revan who cares 😂
So, the most explosive part of any spaceship/starbase...wasn't explosive? How the fuck do they supply power to their vehicles? "If you shoot a highly explosive reactor with a burning plasma weapon, it won't blow up!" except literally every reactor we ever see get shot or hit with a lightsaber in all of Star Wars blows the fuck up! The Death Star's reactor was supposed to be different? Dude! You shouldn't say shit like this. I know Galen Erso also said it in the movie, and he sounded like an idiot, too!
+mr4thelulz1 do you know what a chain reaction is
its that one shot would do it. you don't build a nuclear reactor in a ship so if it gets alittle damaged it explodes or has a melt down do you
Jeremy Does, 5:01
“Guys I’m having a hard time figuring out which character is blind in this scene.
Hahahahaha I’m dead😂💀
That was funny but I thought it was because he was using the force.
ANIMANIACS!!!!!!!!!!!!
"I can't see a thing in this helmet".
Canaan B it's because the storm troopers can throw rocks and miss the ground
CALJ154 CellSpex fan?
Just me who actually thinks the CGI of Tarkin and Leia is really good?
I think so. People bitch for the sake of bitching.
Leia was decent. Tarkin wasnt
lEIA, YES. Tarkin did make me cringe in places. But I accepted it
Caleb Lim couldn’t agree more.
In the next 6-8 or so years they would need actors anymore. No one will be able to tell the difference between real and CGI.
3:13 kyber crystals have been known about for a long time
chirre SW only in the EU and video games. Movies never mentioned it until this
chirre SW Even without counting the EU/Legends, lightsaber-powering crystals make sense and are nowhere near as out of left field as midichlorians. I am actually fine with them though.
Zom 2018 it was shown in clone wars show too. So it's been in cannon for awhile
Zom 2018 And the clone wars TV show which is canon. They had multiple episodes discussing them and even 1 about padwans getting them.
But they made the EU uncommon....so he just told us things out of a better Storry.
I find the lack of sins taken off for Vader.... disturbing.
Especially for the scene with him going ham on the Rebel troops.
John W. Jones -
Should've removed 50 sins just for how awesome that scene was, fifteen sins removed when he ignites his lightsaber, and then another 30 sins removed for him standing on the door of the ship, watching Leia's ship blast away.
WolverinesFan 1990
Yet that last one you mentioned is absolute crap. I know it's fantasy and Star Wars and all that, but HE WAS IN SPACE! He should have gotten sucked out of the opening as soon as the corellion corvette detached.
Hik Molokov; I imagine that since Vader has cybernetic legs, he can magnatize to the ships hull. Just a thought.
Tyler Fernandes Grevious could canonically do this
So maybe
"I haven't felt this much suspense since Titanic"
Jeremy looks so much in love with this movie XD
I support u.
By that I mean u with dat not thing male.
MalevolentFiber not impossible
MAGGOT VOMIT not really, I mean most people didn't really get why there was a flaw in the death star any ways. If you want us less star wars movies go see the last Jedi.
Actors during filming: "Where are the lifeboats on this sinking ship?"
Sin for calling it a “tape”? That’s what it was referred to in ANH. The Stolen Data Tapes
Do not forget that it is common to continue to use an old name for something that has been changed into something new. Computer is actually a person who counts math.
YOU COULD'VE REMOVED A SIN FOR THEM BLINDFOLDING DONNIE YEN AND HIM CALLING THEM OUT FOR IT T^T
Yes!
Bunny! STOP TYPING IN CAPS! IT FEELS LIKE YOU ARE YELLING AT ME.
i agree +Bunny. My favourite bit:)
BB8 has not stolen R2's spot he never will
Fearsome Lord r2 is boring
In the eyes of merchandising he has
I don't think they'll do that.
K2S0 might have replaced threepio but R2 will forever be the best droid in the star wars universe. screw bb8, he looks like a soccer ball someone glued a battlebot to.
Fearsome Lord He already has
It's worth watching this movie just for that last Vader scene.
true
It's worth buying the movie just so you can skip the movie and go straight to the last Vader scene
Julie Weinand ... Or not spend money and watch it on RUclips whenever you want?
No its not, I'd say just look up the K2SO scenes and the Vader scene on youtube and you're set.
The rest of this movie is either boring or nonsensical.
No way,
More like watch the vader scene on youtube and save the money for popcorn.
Fun fact, the main reason Vader didn't move like that in the earlier movies is because the lightsaber props broke for like no reason. They got a bit more durable by Return of the Jedi, but it was still pretty bad.
I honestly couldn't even tell it was CGI until after the movie ended. That's when I remembered that those actors had died. The CGI gets a ton of hate, but it's really good. They use CGI in a lot of movies to fix up people's faces and it goes completely unnoticed. But once it's used on a beloved actor's character people will flip their shit over it.
A Rigel I noticed it immediately.
It is clearly noticeable
A Rigel Same. I knew Cushing was dead and figured they just hired someone with a similar look. I only realized it was CGI when my co-worker asked what I thought of it. Even rewatching it now, knowing that fact, I don't notice anything really off.
If you can't tell its CGI , you may need some glasses my guy.
If you compare the two, sure, but I forgot what he looked like, so I didn't really notice. Leia, on the other hand, I knew right away. I get it, but Tarkin wasn't fresh in my mind.
They didn’t say hope enough. +10 sins
Daddy Donald
Go find a trash monster with the last name komaeda
Oh my goodness, 36 likes in 36 minutes
Didn't I see you under an idubbbz video...
No Jabba the Hutt... 100000000 sins
Jabba was an underrated Jedi...
Daddy Donald IM SEEING YOU EVERYWHERES DOPPLEGANER
I have a feeling he said “the strongest stars have hearts of kyber” to refer to the Death Star having a massive kyber crystal powering its weapon. It’s a Sort of not needed foreshadowing.
Electric Two Lights More like a reference.
I think it is a multiple meaning phrase.
It might indicate that he is aware that the crystals are being used for the Death Star, but it also has the notion of force-sensitive people(people who act upon the force, even without knowing it) have a role to play yet.
He still strongly believe in the Jedi code and believe that the force will continue to guide people to "do the right thing"(Basically, "A strong heart is guided by the force").
I'm fairly certain it is just a throw away inspiration line referring to Jin (I don't know the spelling). With her kyber neckless close to her heart and her nickname "star dust".
*Hunter Davis* Yes, Jyn is the "strongest star" with the "heart of kyber" in that sentence.
Again I am in awe how you are able to nonchalantly going over one of THE BEST lines in the whole fricking SW Universe. "Are you kidding me? I'M BLIND!"
12:25 m8, shes in a landing pad crew uniform, those are landing flags you know that?
The fact that they have s specific uniform, and specific armor set with back slots for landing control signals is, in short, fucking stupid. I've marshaled aircraft, I didn't have to go change to do it.
TwoHeavens well yeah i know, bonus points for making the uniform dark black instead of the properly reflective colours, its just character design tho tbh
"I've marshalled aircraft." But have you marshalled spacecraft?
cannonball117 oh shitt
cannonball117 Also it's a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. Who said they have to do anything the way we do it?
“I would trust her with my life”
*ALDERAAN EXPLODES*
To be fair it wasn't her fault
No, but that was pretty hilarious. :D
Probably one of the best endings to a Cinemasins video
3:52 this droid dies in one shot, but K2SO survives a thousand! They are the same design by the same people!
As soon as he turned good he was heavily reinforced with plot armor.
Maybe different blaster
Maybe wrong upgrade
The stormtrooper's bad aim explains everything.
They just aren't able to hit his weak spots!
The power of plot saves characters until they stop being important
"Nobody important dies in this scene"
Saw dies
And also every main character ends up dying in the end
thats a bit of a shocker to me ngl
No one in this movie is an important character
@@johnbush5347 Jyn had to deliver the plans (a big part of a new hope) and Krennic helped design and build the death star, YeAh No oNe iS iMpOrTaNt. Dude, srlsy? Watch the movie before you make judgements
@EL AUTENTICO did you not read what I said
The point stands, no one important dies
I don’t know how K2-SO knew where they were. Maybe he just followed the fucking explosions.
Ben Lieberthal Yes. He even said it “There’s an awful lot of explosions for two people blending in.” It’s a pretty safe bet that he followed the chaos and it lead straight to them.
kyber crystals have kinda been a thing in Star Wars for years now. it doesn't take away too much mystery, they're rare crystals found on planets influenced by the force. Jedi use em to make sabers. thats it.
I first recall seeing them like 10 years ago when i played the KOTOR games, in which you literally venture into the caves on Dantooine that they grow in
Thank you
ya and each color is significant with a aspect of the force. green for agility, blue for defense, purple for bad assery (force use), red for combat and force attacks.
which is why sith lords mainly use red, why yoda has a green sabar and the skywalker sword is blue.
The crystals have been a thing for time now, I don't think they dismiss the mystery per se but what they do with the crystals kind of take it away. I mean living crystals in tune with the Force and the user?
Azura Moonstar before a few months ago the red crystal was created artificially which made them red and more powerful, but it also gave them a tendency to malfunction. Only very recently did Disney make it that a Sith would have to make a Jedi’s crystal “bleed” and only then could the Sith properly take control of the crystal. Personally I liked it the way it was before.
Lightsaber crystals have been a thing since long before Disney took over. All they did was add a fancy name and change the rules slightly for red and white crystals
This is easily the best Star Wars movie just for the simple fact that this is the only one that ever felt like a WAR movie as well....and that Vader cameo is the best thing they've put out in years 😂
I agree completely. I think Cinemasins just likes to criticize the "logic" of a fictional movie, when it's a MOVIE.
This is hilarious, but you weren’t paying attention in several places.
1) There are thousands of exhaust ports on the Death Star, and one that is deceptively connected to the main reactor. It’s literally a needle in a haystack.
2) The rebel fighters on Eadu literally set off an alarm. It happens right before they fly in, yet you’re sinning it for not setting off an alarm. Try watching the movie next time.
3) Galen didn’t have access to the plans, and if he tried to get them it would have raised suspicion.
4) Jyn doesn’t have swords, those are the landing batons, you literally see the person she stole the uniform using them when they land on Scarif. Again, try watching the movie.
5) Leia was being escorted to Tatooine by Admital Radus on his ship, then he decided to fight and they went here to get the plans first. Then Leia made a daring escape on board the Tantive IV, though I’ll give you a pass there because that was in the Rogue One book and not explained in the movie.
Anyways, this was hilarious and I love your videos.
1) Actually there were thousands of exhaust ports in the second Death Star, not the first. The first had just the one (or perhaps a few others) of the same size as it allowed more exhaust to escape from the reactor. The ones on the second were smaller than 2m to fix the design flaw. And I really don't understand why he even sins the design flaw as it's not that big of a flaw at all. Half of the Rebel fighter defense were killed in their passes on the exhaust port and it was pretty tight and heavily defended. The weakness that Galen explains in the film isn't so much on the exhaust port but rather on the reactor itself that would cause a chain reaction.
2) True that.
3) No argument here either.
4) True true.
5) In ANH, Leia even said that she was on her way to Tatooine to pick up Obi-Wan and bring him to Alderaan. She just gets handed the plans as a safety measure that doesn't really last. So, really, he doesn't need to read the book to figure this out he can just remember the other films. But I'm sure he would sin it anyways because that would be homework.
Don't forget Kyber Crystals being around since 1978 and this video treating them like a brand new ex-machina.
TBH it's a bit much for CS to say that the flaw should have been noticed by anyone who took a cursory glance at the plans and fixed and also note that it took a one-in-a-million shot that was only possible through the use of the force by the chosen one and therefore not remotely obvious to anyone else. Like, I get the point is nitpicking for laughs but those two adjacent statements completely contradict each other.
Michael Ayers I mean, they only missed 5 things. That doesn't really mean several
Several is anything three or more, so five things would be several.
BTW, the things on her back are the lights used to guide ships into parking spaces not awesome swords
Exactly! They even show them being used to guide the shuttle in to land, by the very same guy Jyn steals them from. Gah. Sometimes their lack of basic attention is annoying.
He makes mistakes on purpose, these aren't real reviews, it's a parody of a review and he's playing the part of an asshole. When they write the script for these videos they have a formula with a set % of intentional mistakes, every time
If you aren't catching several mistakes per video, the jokes on you
Exactly, it's all about being a fun channel. Heck, his voice tone and choice of words reveals it's a joke lol.
"We're not reviewers. We're assholes."
Vincent Beers true but it's obvious when he is just hating on a film he doesn't like.
"Alas poor Red 5 I knew you not"
A bit too funny tbh
A Porkins died first in The Last Jedi too!
The things on her back weren't swords, they were lights for landing ships which we've seen in many Star Wars movies/ shows. Sooooo 105 sins?
What always amuses me in science fiction (or space opera ...) is how an entire planet is used for one thing:
The prison planet, the archive planet, the factory planet, the farming planet ...
Scale it down to our globe and you have to build the prison city, the archive city, the factory city and the farming city.
My tiny home town of 100.000 people has libraries and archives, a jail, Adidas headquarters and lots of farming.
Do I make sense?
That is kinda funny, but I think they do that because it's easier for the audience to keep track of, and often times they are newly-developed/colonized planets.
So using Earth as an example, I guess they're using the colonization of the New World as a template, as certain parts of the Americas were better for farming or lumber or fur, so that was the primary use of those areas until many years later they developed into multi-faceted cities and states.
I never really thought about that but you have a valid pointm thinking about it is down to more straight forward storytelling, they only have a few hours to tell everything they can.
When you have a sufficiently large multi-planet society, then planets become the new cities. And we do have farming towns, mining towns, financial centers, etc. The only reason Earth is this diverse is because it's the only planet we've got, and we need to use it for everything.
Prison, factory and farming planets make some sense. Prisons don’t need to be perfectly habitable, so putting them on planets that are out of the way, and not very nice to live on make sense. Factories are often close together, and would be best kept away from agricultural centers, so the entire planet having manufacturing as a primary source of their economy would make sense. Farming planets need good soil and water, but not much else, so the planet might not have any heavy metals, but still be able to grow crops. As for Archives, it’s likely that certain planets don’t have a ton of influence, but they have collected a lot of information, so the only reason people go there is to access the archives.
This is Star Wars I’m more referencing here, where planets which are influential are diverse, but less important ones barely make enough to get by. Doctor Who has a planet that is entirely covered by a library and that really doesn’t make sense. Star Trek, well every species has a hat, so why wouldn’t the planets have one?
I await the Adidas planet with some interest :)
Vader puns are just dad jokes.
katanamaru1 jeez... what did your dad do to you?
MakeAVideoOnNuka-WorldYouMilkbag I think they were referencing the fact that "Vader" means dad in German
And that he is a dad at this point. Even if he doesn't know it yet; he knows it to be true.
katanamaru1 Vader has always done that. "Apology accepted, Captain Needa...".
katanamaru1 This reminds me of the HISHE of rogue one.
I wondered about the things on Jyn's back (sin 87), but I was shown that they are just the signal-sticks for waving at the landing pad, carried by the guy she got the disguise from.
You mean she's not a discount Deadpool? 😭
stormtrooper casually walking in outer space, below the deck on 10:02 WTF :D haha
Hard to see but he's there
WOW... WTF Indeed! And they didnt even show if He had a space suit or something!
I kinda love that I didn't notice the Grand Moff Tarkin CGI at all. Only when it was pointed out to me after the first viewing, did I notice it :)
madeoson Makes TWO of us.
Yes it was well done people complain about anything.
Niether of my parents noticed it, but it was jarring af to me
I imagine it would be jarring to some people :)
lol when i saw it in cinema i noticed something wrong with it immediately, especially when they cut between tarkin and krennic.
I have been waiting for this cinnemasins.
Here’s a suggestion, watch cinemawins
+Reiss Hozak what is EGA?
Kyber Crystals have been in star wars lore for the longest time, nothing new
They are well accepted by the fandom, and are vaguely defined as “magic crystals that power lightsabers”.
starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Kyber_crystal
The biggest surprise is that you are not the real Cinema Sins
No, Lightsaber crystals have been in the lore for the longest time.
Kyber as its now used in Disney canon is quite different. Furthermore dumb stuff like Kyber needing to be "bled" red is regarded with nearly as much disdain as mediclorians.
Owl Circus yeah, I think it was the implication that the crystal is what gave him his force powers is what's lame
"I wonder of they will succeed, "I havnt felt this much suspense since titanic" i laugh every time
"This movie changes planets faster than a Guardians of the Galaxy film"
Finally someone who said it.
Coraline Parmentier - Pianist for Peace That was hilarious ...
I don't get why everyone hate's on the cgi tarkin so much. Yes it's cgi, but it is some damn impressive cgi too, and i don't think it's there long enough to ruin anything
It's very distracting.
psinjo yeah, I was stunned, when I saw him for the first time in cinema!
psinjo I agree it's very impressive how they were able to do it and it also made him appear more evil
I'll defend the decision as Peter Cushing is badass enough that I doubt you could find a suitable lookalike.
I had no idea what Tarkin was saying the whole movie because I was distracted and focusing on his face looking less real than Ackbar's cousins in the final battle.
“I would trust her with my life.”
Alderan blows up with him on it.
Comedic GENIUS!
Kyber Crystals are from the extended universe and was actually a staple to a lot of the lore
That is what I was thinking. They never ruined Star wars mystery when revealing that. It was a well known thing well before this movie came out. Hell, if you didn't read any of the extended universe stuff (Like how I didn't), you can learn about this from The Knights of the Old Republic games. They don't specifically call them kyber crystals but they are still pointed out.
Kotor IS extended universe. However, Kyber crystals have been canon for a long time. They are in the Clone Wars animated series.
@@kirschnermate They were also in a "technology of Star Wars" book back in the 90s. I've known crystals power lightsabers for years. This was not a midichlorian comparison by any means
Those things on Jyn’s back weren’t swords. They were signal batons used for directing aircraft when they’re landing. There was even a scene of someone using them
The Kaiber crystals are a really big part of Star Wars and have been things since the beginning
i'm genuinely asking, since a new hope? i don't remember it, i've heard of them from Rebels, and some other "spinoffs" but not from the original trilogy
Clone Wars. In other words the "prequel" era.
In the WAY original Star Wars, while writing A New Hope, the Kybur Crystals were going to be the source of the Force. This was eventually dropped, and in the expanded universe, the crystals were used to create lightsabers.
undead890 yeah, but the crystal contains an aspect of the force because the chrystal speaks to the jedi almost like the wand chooses it's wizard in Harry Potter.
Pretty early. Some form of the crystal was introduced in the novel Splinter of the Minds Eye, which was originally created as an outline for a New Hope sequel had they not gotten the budget they wanted for Empire. New Hope was a smash hit and they got all the money they needed, but still published that story as a book.
The concept was more recently explored and better explained in Clone Wars, but the idea of a crystal being in the sabers has been there for a while, if only vaguely.
12:35 The're not swords, they're signaling sticks for incoming space-ships.
Jellex i said this too, tbh a marshalling uniform being jet black is retarded, does the empire even have a safety board?
Probably not, actually. The way they kill and die themselves left and right.
Yeah, two Star Destroyers almost crashed into each other while chasing Han in Empire. They even had full control of the ships.
9:36 I literally said, “Rogue Credits” in my head when I saw this scene.
The "swords" on Jyn's back are actually those air traffic batons
The “bounty hunter” costume on Jyn is actually a landing operator suit and the swords are light sticks for the landing crafts
A movie made for the sole purpose of justifying a plothole. What a time to be alive.
A porthole plothole, even.
Extremely entertaining ? are you serious...
It's a good thing not a bad thing
and it created its own plothole, where were the Bothans!?
It also creates a bigger plot hole: why would Leia think she could bluff Vader five minutes after he's seen her ship take delivery of the plans?
Here's a problem: the film shows R2 and 3PO still on Yavin when the ship they're on in A New Hope has already left.