Dostoyevsky's works are complex, deep, and multi-dimensional and it is usually impossible to draw a general conclusion from his stories. However, you tried to present your interpretation and pointed out some good points. By the way, in my opinion raskolnikov & prince myshkin weren't a loser.
@@fazzy_fuzzy The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov | Goodreads The Master and Margarita is a novel, by Russian writer, Mikhail Bulgakov, written in the Soviet Union between 1928 and 1940 during Stalin's regime.
For me, Dostoyevsky's appeal lies mainly in his male characters, who in real life would be annoying or nuisance😊. I want to revisit them for the first time in a very long time. And, congratulations on the success of your channel. It must have been a challenge to attract a large audience in the literary field.
Some people seem to fail to understand that it is merely one aspect of Dostoevsky's writing which he beautifully depicted and described, Fiction Beast is not trying to limit the works and their meaning to only men's loneliness, he's just analyzing one of many many themes of Dostoevsky' books, congratulation for this deep understanding of the greatest author of all time, Fiction Beast, I always envy you for that! your videos and style of narration are unique, keep 'em coming!
I have missed you, Fiction Beast . I have been reading so many various books of late various kinds. Sometimes, my library has to get them from other libraries, or I buy those out of print from used books of those I don't have in my own library. It is àlways wonderful to hear your voice with your excellent insights about authors. 🙏❤️🌎🌍🌏🌿🕊🎵🎶🎵✨️💫✨️💫
Can you do a video on Indian subcontinent literature? , I read books called " Mella achal " , " godan " , " kafan " etc that were extremely great , the literature and philosophy of there countries are being ignored by the world because they are 3rd worlds. I really recommend you checking their literature our they have one of the most dense , philosophical and socio-psy literature I have read till now , especially Punjabi, gujurati, Bengali, bihari, Farsi, urdu literatures . At least check them if you are too busy for reading all of them
I got kind of confused on #5, was the main characters motive for killing the old pawn broker motivated by greed and to get rich quick? Don’t remember that part
@@RadioDrama007 yes, but that motivation was just his rationalisation to commit the crime. Raskolnikov actually wanted power and riches. He had to convince himself that he was a superior man, and give himself a noble motive to be able to justify his desire for power.
@@MrReedling hmm, perhaps. I’m by no means a scholar on the work. To anyone that hasn’t, I’d definitely read the book, it’s a lot more interesting than “greedy man envies rich old lady, greedy man kills rich old lady.”
I am sorry , but don't you think interpreting Dostoevsky's and Tolstoy's works through the mundane ( in a Darwinian, Nietzschean ,Freudian JordanPetersonean fashion ) parameters as to limiting all thoughts to merely" mating struggle " , is utterly wrong , and definitely misunderstanding those two great thinkers !?
@Itsuser_1234 No, I respect Darwin ( however he has borrowed his evolution theory from Jean Baptist Lamarck ) , nevertheless I am also critical of his theories on " natural Selection " , but I cannot deny that I certainly despise J Peterson .
What exactly is mundane ( in what way) could you elaborate more on that? Also, who said he is limiting only to "mating struggle" ( even though it is an really important aspect of our lives that has been shaping us through evolution for the last millions of years, since mammals evolved ), the damn topic of the video is about men in Dostoevsky's work and what they share in common, he didn't mention anywhere that his work is only about this, but you would be a fool to deny that "mating struggle" is embedded in our unconscious and affects us in ways we can't even imagine. It's stupid to make conclusions about someone based just on one comment, but based on yours specifically related to disliking the presented idea in the video because you dislike Jordan Peterson ( and again, it's very popular to dislike Peterson now, very morally outstanding if you do it actually) talks a lot about your character and about your moralistic stances. Anyway great video, thank you,!
Tolstoy was better in life’s picture, dostoevsky is just state of life that every intellectual individual has to go through, if we want better day to come, must listen to tolstoy. If an individual has any spiritual consciousness, there is no comparing.
Olá amigo sou brasileiro trabalho com a pequena agricultura, criação de galinhas, vacas e plantação de hortaliças, sou o Idiota, minha namorada assim que passou a ganhar muito dinheiro com dois empregos disse que: “está tudo sobrecarregado pra mim, não estou feliz com a gente não, esfriei no meio do caminho.” Mas fato curioso, estou por vezes me encontrando numa felicidade ensandecida, sou um legítimo solitário, cuido da minha avó acamada com meus pais e Jesus só Deus sabe como foi bom ler crime e castigo hahahaha, enfim obrigado pelo vídeo, estou cursando direito e quero escrever artigos
To correct you on the dagestanis being best in the combat sports remark, they've got zayvudin magimedov and that terrorist Kadyrov that finance their sports escapades, i mean if any country had the same anount of funding as they do without a doubt they'd be in the same spot
In terms of funding for sports and related endavours, no group of people in the world receive as much funding as the Americans do. Dagestanis are undoubtedly dominant in MMA and you're just down playing that.
@@Bravo6goindark Bruh stop the copium, USA has the most olympic medals and it isn't even close. That's what funding looks like. Why would you even lie?
Every failure in Dostoyevsky is a triumph in its own way. "Some falls are means the happier to rise," as Shakespeare said.
You’re a born storyteller ❤
You're such a fine story teller! Keep it up, we enjoy.
Thanks for your wonderful videos ...and i really love your voice❤
He's a psychologist, there is no way he could be blind to such clear reality.
great insightful video as always.
Dostoyevsky's works are complex, deep, and multi-dimensional and it is usually impossible to draw a general conclusion from his stories. However, you tried to present your interpretation and pointed out some good points. By the way, in my opinion raskolnikov & prince myshkin weren't a loser.
@@fazzy_fuzzy The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov | Goodreads The Master and Margarita is a novel, by Russian writer, Mikhail Bulgakov, written in the Soviet Union between 1928 and 1940 during Stalin's regime.
They were
Great video. Nice voice. Thank you very much.
Great content! Thank you
This was an amazing video !! , thank you sir .
Amazing video 😭💯
For me, Dostoyevsky's appeal lies mainly in his male characters, who in real life would be annoying or nuisance😊. I want to revisit them for the first time in a very long time.
And, congratulations on the success of your channel. It must have been a challenge to attract a large audience in the literary field.
Great explanation of Dostoyevsky.
There is a Mosfilm release of the 1959 movie, "White Nights" with English subtitles on RUclips.
I think Doestoyevsky drew not only on his own life, but experiences of the men he knew in his decade in Siberia
Thank you! My favorite author.
Thank you very much This is so enlightening. I bow to your literary knowledge ❤
Some people seem to fail to understand that it is merely one aspect of Dostoevsky's writing which he beautifully depicted and described, Fiction Beast is not trying to limit the works and their meaning to only men's loneliness, he's just analyzing one of many many themes of Dostoevsky' books, congratulation for this deep understanding of the greatest author of all time, Fiction Beast, I always envy you for that! your videos and style of narration are unique, keep 'em coming!
Really appreciate the comment.
Fantastic
I have missed you, Fiction Beast . I have been reading so many various books of late various kinds. Sometimes, my library has to get them from other libraries, or I buy those out of print from used books of those I don't have in my own library.
It is àlways wonderful to hear your voice with your excellent insights about authors.
🙏❤️🌎🌍🌏🌿🕊🎵🎶🎵✨️💫✨️💫
Thank you! You’re making the most of your library. Well done!
Can you do a video on Indian subcontinent literature? , I read books called " Mella achal " , " godan " , " kafan " etc that were extremely great , the literature and philosophy of there countries are being ignored by the world because they are 3rd worlds. I really recommend you checking their literature our they have one of the most dense , philosophical and socio-psy literature I have read till now , especially Punjabi, gujurati, Bengali, bihari, Farsi, urdu literatures . At least check them if you are too busy for reading all of them
I just love dostoevsky
And love the way u talk about him, thanks a lot❤
I got kind of confused on #5, was the main characters motive for killing the old pawn broker motivated by greed and to get rich quick? Don’t remember that part
@@RadioDrama007 yes, but that motivation was just his rationalisation to commit the crime. Raskolnikov actually wanted power and riches. He had to convince himself that he was a superior man, and give himself a noble motive to be able to justify his desire for power.
@@MrReedling hmm, perhaps. I’m by no means a scholar on the work. To anyone that hasn’t, I’d definitely read the book, it’s a lot more interesting than “greedy man envies rich old lady, greedy man kills rich old lady.”
I am sorry , but don't you think interpreting Dostoevsky's and Tolstoy's works through the mundane ( in a Darwinian, Nietzschean ,Freudian JordanPetersonean fashion ) parameters as to limiting all thoughts to merely" mating struggle " , is utterly wrong , and definitely misunderstanding those two great thinkers !?
Are you a Christian?
@Itsuser_1234 No, I respect Darwin ( however he has borrowed his evolution theory from Jean Baptist Lamarck ) , nevertheless I am also critical of his theories on " natural Selection " , but I cannot deny that I certainly despise J Peterson .
What exactly is mundane ( in what way) could you elaborate more on that? Also, who said he is limiting only to "mating struggle" ( even though it is an really important aspect of our lives that has been shaping us through evolution for the last millions of years, since mammals evolved ), the damn topic of the video is about men in Dostoevsky's work and what they share in common, he didn't mention anywhere that his work is only about this, but you would be a fool to deny that "mating struggle" is embedded in our unconscious and affects us in ways we can't even imagine. It's stupid to make conclusions about someone based just on one comment, but based on yours specifically related to disliking the presented idea in the video because you dislike Jordan Peterson ( and again, it's very popular to dislike Peterson now, very morally outstanding if you do it actually) talks a lot about your character and about your moralistic stances. Anyway great video, thank you,!
please make a video on sylvia plath
More blue pills please...😢
Tolstoy was better in life’s picture, dostoevsky is just state of life that every intellectual individual has to go through, if we want better day to come, must listen to tolstoy. If an individual has any spiritual consciousness, there is no comparing.
Olá amigo sou brasileiro trabalho com a pequena agricultura, criação de galinhas, vacas e plantação de hortaliças, sou o Idiota, minha namorada assim que passou a ganhar muito dinheiro com dois empregos disse que: “está tudo sobrecarregado pra mim, não estou feliz com a gente não, esfriei no meio do caminho.” Mas fato curioso, estou por vezes me encontrando numa felicidade ensandecida, sou um legítimo solitário, cuido da minha avó acamada com meus pais e Jesus só Deus sabe como foi bom ler crime e castigo hahahaha, enfim obrigado pelo vídeo, estou cursando direito e quero escrever artigos
Digo que sou dentre os miseráveis o menos miserável, sou razoavelmente bonito e alto, mas idiota
To correct you on the dagestanis being best in the combat sports remark, they've got zayvudin magimedov and that terrorist Kadyrov that finance their sports escapades, i mean if any country had the same anount of funding as they do without a doubt they'd be in the same spot
In terms of funding for sports and related endavours, no group of people in the world receive as much funding as the Americans do. Dagestanis are undoubtedly dominant in MMA and you're just down playing that.
У них это в культуре, в менталитете, они любят борьбу с детства. Финансирование конечно играет роль, но поверьте, не главную.
@@Hashashin_420 what funding Olympians are barely able to provide for their families
@@Карина-г1ф3р They have a warrior history I'll give them that but still they were always conquered either by Persians or by Russians
@@Bravo6goindark Bruh stop the copium, USA has the most olympic medals and it isn't even close. That's what funding looks like. Why would you even lie?
More black pill rather than red if you ask me
Why Not Crush Red Pill and Blue pill together add Our Favourite Color In it and see what will be Why not be Artists ?
Yey 🎉
👌👌👌
❤❤❤❤❤❤champ❤❤❤❤
Тебе тоже здравствуй
❤
I think this is a superficial understanding of the books.
Why on earth you spoil the plots??? Can't you just give a general idea of what's going on? Is it really necessary to tell everything?
Hey shut up 🤣
Dostoyevsky is the original incel?