Honestly I just watched American Graffiti, and it was fascinating as a teen movie in comparison to how modern teen movies are constructed. It was so much more chaotic, and really full of people being cruel and foolish in a way that seemed so real.
this! i hate how the series' public perception has denigrated so heavily, as a result of the other films. to all the boys *deserved* its success, and it *deserves* to receive the same respect as the other goats in its genre, but it's treated as being indistinguishable from the likes of "the kissing booth" and "tall girl" all because of its sequels and status as a netflix film. i think one of the biggest issues is that the visual aesthetics of the first film is extremely-similar to its sequels; susan johnson's directorial skills are leaps-and-bounds above fimognari's (made especially-evident by the cinematography), however, to an untrained eye, theyre very visually-similar which makes it hard for the audience to really notice the dip in quality between films... definitely only worsened by how the books' narratives worsen over time, too. i really need all of its detractors to rewatch the first film, without the plot points of the second in mind (especially how they destroyed peter's character). it knows exactly what it wants to be - a charming, laid-back romcom between two normal teenagers - and it excels at it in an extraordinary fashion. most romcom's rely on excess amounts of drama to keep the viewers enticed (hence the genre's propensity for toxicity), but to all the boys manages to escape this through how down-to-earth its characters, dialogue and overall narrative is. even the more-dramatic elements (the fake romance, lara jean's letters leaking, lara jean's crush on josh etc) dissolve very quickly to focus on peter and lara jean's development. i was really expecting the drama surrounding the letters to be a big feature upon my first viewing of the film, and was pleasantly-surprised by how its handled; instead of being some grand-drama that encompasses the entire film, it's just a small facet that sets that plot in motion. i really loved how lara jean takes a humiliation like that in stride and just deals with the cards she's been dealt. the film's writing is shockingly-mature in how it has its characters handle the situation they landed themselves in - especially so, given that the narratives *immaturity* is one of its charms. it's really sad to see how the public's respect for it has dwindled over time
Omg my roommate and I just watched all 3 and we kept noticing how ugly the last 2 are…like they were trying to do something but not quite getting there. I had no idea that they switched directors, that explains it!!
It's crazy how often it happens and how noticable it becomes. 50 Shades (think of the movies what you will) also switched out the female director for a male one for the last two movies and the difference was super noticable
I think the reason To All The Boys is so loved is honestly because it scratches that heartwarming itch we have and feels unapologetically cute and girly
Comparing "To All the Boys" with "The Kissing Booth" is akin to comparing a bestselling, critically lauded book series with a story which originated from Wattpad... Oh, wait.
@@artatmidnight wait so which one is better? did they mean that the book was written by a 15yo girl and the wattpad was by someone older? sorry english is not my 1st language
I also really enjoy the dialogue in this movie!! It’s not perfect but so many teen movies try so hard to “talk like a teen” that it ends up being cringey and loses its authenticity. In To All the Boys, they treat all the characters like real people and most of the cringeyness doesn’t come from trying too hard, it comes from the genuine awkward nature of real life situations, which is why no one is really bothered by it like they would be in other dramas. The character writing is raw and real and it just makes the vibes and execution of this movie so fun! I love watching this movie, definitely a comfort film
yes you're so right! I also like how they included social media/texting. like you said, it doesn't feel forced or trying too hard to be "trendy" or "with the kids." it all feels natural which makes it actually enjoyable to watch 🩷🩷
I loved how likable and relatable the characters were, especially how close the three sisters were. Sure, they picked fights and could get snarky, but that's what siblings do. Also, it was understandable why Lara Jean, despite being intelligent, kind and attractive, wasn't very popular, since her shyness was holding her back.
The 1st To all the boys movie is one of those i can watch over and over again, it makes me feel giddy inside. The colors, the theme of Lara Jean breaking out of her shell... feels like a classic
As someone who read the book I think the only significant change is Peter’s motivation, in the books he gets in the deal bc he realizes his relationship with gen is toxic and if he dates someone else he is not going to go back to her, it’s very simple but it changes a lot
@@artatmidnight I don’t think it takes away from the first movie, it makes Peter a little less likable and his actions a little less understandable, but it works out, in the second tho, it changes the felling of the whole story
it doesnt really have a lot to do with your comment but its rare to find people who are actually fans of the books instead of just the movies , so i gotta say; to all the boys is my favorite book series and theres a whole lot of changes from the books to the movies, ESPECIALLY the second one. in the second book, theres so much romance between john and LJ bt in the movies they have 00000% chemistry, and even though im a PK+LJ shipper (obvii), i feel like it takes away most of the magic from the book. the second book is my favourite out of the three, but the second movie is my least favorite (pls someone tell me im not the only one)
@@falatudosofia yes, the second one is also my fav!! I like of how even tho there was a lot of romance between lara jean and john ambrose it still felt like peter was the right choice for her and how their relationship was actually growing, the movie didn’t capture any of that it feels weird
Also, they wanted to rewrite Lara Jean as a WHITE girl & Jenny Han had to fight like hell to make sure they casted an ASIAN actress for Lara! Jenny earns my permanent respect for that.
@@danaco9942 It's not respectful to the book though. They ended up casting a Southeast asian actress to play a half korean half yt character. Ask any east asian person and they'll tell you how they felt about this respresentation.
@@danaco9942 What kind of asian are you? I'm east asian and the rest of us east asians do not consider this fair representation of us, let alone half east asians at all. The 2 sisters were half east asian and half yt but literally the main character was off both in terms of her half ancestry and east asian ancestry.
i'm glad you pointed out the presence of teal in almost every scene. i didn't notice it until you pointed it out, but yeah, every time i think of that movie, my mind always thinks of teal. very consistent branding
I never noticed about the teal, but whenever I think about this film, the first thing that pops up is the beautiful warm comforting colour pallete. Makes it feel so nostalgic
i will die on the hill that to all the boys (1st movie only) is SUCH a good movie. i remember being SO disappointed with the second one, and the third one was okay but nothing stood out to me like the first movie. i am obsessed, it is so cute, the chemistry between lana and noah is so good. i will die
You can tell this movie had a lot of actual effort put into it, you know? I say this as someone who wasn’t the biggest fan of it, but it wasn’t a blatant cash grab like the Kissing Booth. It tried to authentically explore the trials and tribulations of adolescent romance, grief and drama, even if in my opinion it didn’t succeed in all these areas. It was genuine, and I enjoyed it for what it was.
Yes! The effort is totally there. I've always loved the set and costume design! You can absolutely tell how intentional it is and it creates a vibe for the whole universe of the movie that is very chic, yet relatable.
I read the full trilogy growing up! It was such a good adaptation, and as an Asian American I loved seeing the Yakult in the movie and all the Asian references. The only thing that was not really accurate to the book (that I remember, i read this a long time ago) was in the movie Kitty sent out the letters cause she thought that Lara Jean was lonely. In the book, Kitty talked about wanting to get a dog and Lara Jean told Josh that Kitty wanted to name the dog after him and Kitty wanted revenge.
YESS SAME!! The only thing is I’m half Asian and I’m sad that Lara Jean, a popular wasian character, was played by a full Asian actress. She did an amazing job but this was our chance to have wasian representation and we didn’t get it😭😭
@@-chenlanying5818In the books, Kitty had a crush on Josh and wanted to name the dog after him because of that. And Lara Jean was just teasing her abt it by telling Josh, which made Kitty feel embarrassed and in turn want to take revenge on her sister; And thus, sending out the letters.
As someone who's read the books many times, I think both versions are really good. I prefer the books because of how much detail you get (and there's more drama), but this movie is so cozy, well made and does capture the essence of lara jean and her coming of age story. The parts of the book that they changed and took out for the movie did simplify the story in some places but it made the story work in the movie framework.
THANK YOU!!! THIS!!!! Everyone hating on the book series cause it's messy aha like, what else are you reading a teen romcom for??? But I also love the books so much because all the characters grow so much, and I love remembering all the little details too. It's truly such a great book series!
I don’t understand why something being for children or teens has the pass of being bad, we all deserve good quality, good animated movies and romcoms 😭 this movie and the third are two of my recent go to along with do revenge, recently Lisa Frankenstein and Enola Holmes
Lisa Frankenstein is so good!! It totally gives odd Edward sccusorhands early 2000s Tim burton style movie, and I love the visuals soo much. Cult classic for sure.
it's crazy as someone who's read the books thrice and watched the first movie so many times i nearly have it memorized frame for frame, i've never dissected the visual language that so clearly elevates this film above other romcoms of the past decade. this was so fun to watch for me!! (also you're so real for not watching the third because the second movie made you mad but that's a whole other convo lmaoooo) i would watch hours of your analysis 😭💕 thank you for your hard work, i'll probably rewatch this a few times tbh. and to answer your question: yes! i'd say the first film particularly is a great adaption. more than just following the book to the T, i think the film perfectly captures the warmth that made the book such a comfort read for me.
I will never shut up about how good To All The Boys I've Loved Before is-no matter how many times I rewatch it I'm always entertained with the storyline and characters. 👏👏🎉🎉
the main reason this movie worked so well is simply because laura jean actually feels like a real teen girl and her world feels genuinely lived in. like so many can see at least a little bit of themselves in her, and even if you can't anyone can pinpoint at least 1 girl they knew growing up that was very similar to her
I think to all the boys I have loved before is such a classic 😭 it’s like 10 things I hate about you (the cultural significance not the plot) but from the late 2010s, when you rewatch it, it’s literally a time capsule
my mom loves rom coms, but she could never find the perfect movie that she could rewatch. My mom resonated with Laura jean and loved that they respected the character enough to not make her passed around once she was considered pretty.
I don’t think it’s a mistake that the two most popular teen rom coms are both Jenny Han book series. The summer I turned pretty has so many similar qualities and attention to detail
Do Revenge is another great teen movie for the visuals alone. The overall plot kind of borders redundant and camp, but the costume and set design? gorgeous.
this movie is unironically one of my favorite movies of all time and as a film major I've been clowned by others for saying how GOOD this movie is so thank you for making a video proving my point😌
Jenny Han writes really relatable, realistic and well rounded characters. She also writes her stories in a very immersive way, where you get to know why the characters do what they do and you get attached to them. To all the boys i loved before was such a good adaptation and such a moment in pop culture.
I just love when things in movies and tv shows are intentional and you are always so great at picking it out! This video is so well done and the research in your video essays are incredible👏🏾👏🏾
The cinematography is amazing. The soundtrack, the clothes, the characters and the relationships are soothing. The lighting makes the aesthetic so warm.
Ahh é incrivel ver que outras pessoas tem o mesmo sentimento que eu em relação ao filme. Eu tinha 15 anos quando lançou , eu assisti com umas colegas e comemos pizza barata.Tbm ouvia com frequencia as musicas, ainda hoje procuro a soundtrack as vezes.Essa trilogia sempre vai estar em uma parte do meu coração
ok the thoughts are genius. tbh, and author knows way more about what she wrote and why instead of the interpretations of someone else or a reader, so their input in movies like these are very very important, and , urgent.
honestly i think the movie captured the emotions that you get when you read the book so well. nothings too similar or too different, honestly a perfect adaptation.
It didn’t take itself too seriously like most cringy teen media and that was honestly what made it so good. The characters are so silly and they’re kids and they know it. She’s not ashamed to be a girly, preppy teen girl, and that shows. She’s okay with who she is and doesn’t feel the need to bring down other women and the absence of the unfortunate “NLOG” teen trope adds so much to this story.
I’m so happy you talked about this film! It was honestly so cute and I was really surprised by how much I enjoyed it. Many teen films nowadays or even romantic films are just aggravating. I loved how the main character wasn’t dressed frumpy, didn’t have to go through a whole transformation scene to be “beautiful” or “liked”.
As someone who has read the books, the first one is pretty much the same except for the ending, and then the second and third lose a lot of the plot and certain characters from the books
I liked the movie so I wanted to read the book. But, oh boy, did I hate them. I love how much more complex and layered the characters are in the movie and how likable as well. I love they didn’t make Josh have feelings for her, but rather be a good friend and support her even though he was the one going through a breakup
Netflix and other movie companies should be taking notes because it is great to have the author be involved and be able to show and explain what the readers liked about the book in the first place.
I already liked To All the Boys, even though I don't really like teen movies anymore, but this really helped to explain why this one feels so different. The use of color and style is especially impressive. ^^
I watched this movie for the first time the night before my first day of freshman year. I ended up staying up a little too late but all my nervousness about school was gone. It's just such a lovely happy movie.
You can really feel the difference when a teen-movie is written and directed by women, and when it is directed by men. Probably one of the only modern teen movies that gives you real butterflies
The first movie will always hold a special place for me. Truly love it one of the best original Netflix teen romances that doesn’t make me cringe. The visuals aesthetics and Lana and Noah’s chemistry is so good. I still wonder how much better the other two movies would’ve been if they stuck with the same director
The first movie absolutely captured and built on the magic of the book, I read it as a teenager and it was my favorite book series. I was so excited for the second book as I liked it more than the first, and they cut so many plot points that made it so endearing and charming and it was a bit disappointing but still.
One of my favourite things about the colour palette used in this movie, now that it’s been pointed out, is that when it shows the flashback of Laura Jean and Josh being friends she’s drinking the lemon version of Arizona iced tea which comes in a yellow teal and pink can. Even her drink choice is colour coordinated.
Having read and loved the books, I LOVED the first movie and they really captured the cozy sweet vibe of the book. The ONLY change that bugged me was actually Gen's motive behind hating LJ...in the book, LJ and Peter were the last ones left at the middle school party and they kissed, which wasn't part of a game or anything. LJ knew Gen had a crush on Peter. Gen walked in on them and felt betrayed. That line of thought feels far less silly than the movie's motivation, which has her upset about a kiss during Spin the Bottle. It made Gen a bit more relatable and less just hardcore irrational mean girl. That's just my thoughts, though!
15:33 the second book had me not only mad at Peter but also rooting for John-Ambrose especially after the 50s dance and when he took her home and kissed her 😢
The camerawork on this movie really elevated it. The framing where she is off center outside the diner is so perfect and really shows how artistic they wanted it to be
Im a 30 year old woman with a 38 year old boyfriend and weve watched to all the boys trilogy at least three times in total. Its SUCH a heartwarming film for when you're sick or depressed. Its awkward but in a realistic and not too exaggerated way. Youre constantly thinking "that couldve been me in my teens!" And the cast is really good. The colours and the style of everyone is pretty af but not too unrealistic like euphoria e.g.
this is one of my favorite comfort films and I love this analysis, especially the colors and what they represent. I'll have to watch it again and look out for these details!
your points about the intentionality of the visuals, sets, and fashion remind me of bottoms (2023) -- another teen movie, though completely different tonally, that is so so good
I cannot tell you how ecstatic I was to hear you say you have a love hate relationship with Peter AND WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT THE SECOND MOVIE, GIRL I WAS IN THE SAME POSITION!!! I didn't watch the third one for a YEAR and some change after it came out, but trust me it's worth it, HE GETS BETTER! the third one is my favorite. I've read the books and for me I don't completely understand the hype. How Peter is in the second movie he's like in ....basically all the books. Their relationship comes off toxic to me, especially when John comes into play, he just shows a lot of red flags. The MOVIES ABSOLUTELY PULLED THROUGH! (not counting the second one, I don't even acknowledge the second movie all due respect to EVERYONE, it's just not for me.) Genuinely, for the first time the movies are better than the books. (TO ME!) To call these movies (except the second one) "comfort movies" is an absolute understatement and you nailed every detail as to why they work. I literally remember thinking to myself "oh no here comes the love triangle" during the movie/bench scene and then she said she would never do that to Margot and I went "oh!" Beautiful.
The Perks of Being a Wallflower and To All the Boys I've Loved Before are teen movies that I love to watch over and over again. Lara Jean and Charlie are both such lovable and relatable protagonists.
I love how since i've been watching your video's, i've been notecing these little details in the movies I watch too. It makes it so much more interasting and you actually start to see the art in movies!
Woah thank you for pointing out the doors! I've rewatched these movies dozens of times and never fully noticed that! I think the third movie is worth watching, but only because I love LJ and her ability to not be a perfect protagonist, instead being one that grows. Plus it also let's us meet Dae, kitty's love interest for her spinoff show. Who knows, maybe one day Jenny Han will give us a Margo spinoff too. Sorry random ramble over😅 great video, I really enjoyed your attention to details
I never watched this cuz its got a lot of anxiety and embarrassment in it which would probably trigger my own. Grateful to see it through this lens to maybe prepare me enough to watch it (or read it!) myself one day
To be honest when I first watched this movie I wasn't a big fan, but this video helped me develop a new appreciation for it. I'm gonna go rewatch and reread the books now lol.
Now I'm not a girl but i think I'm used to this visuals because in most asian series, if you're the MAIN CHARACTER, you'll always be stylish. Poor or rich. And if you're in a quirky style, you're just the best friend who's the comedic relief.
I did read the books when I was a teenager and I do think that the movies really captured the spirit of the books and I think all of the changes makes sense and I’m okay with that however they cut some of my favorite passages and so that’ll always make me a little bitter, but I love these movies like I love this movie the first one whenever I just need something on it’s great
you always put so much thought and effort into your commentaries and it's amazing just how well-versed you are. thank you for bringing quality back to youtube
This is such a wonderful video! Thank you for taking the time to put it all together. I particularly loved everything you pointed out about colours as I hadn’t consciously noticed this! Thoroughly enjoyed watching this on my lunch break 🙌🙌🙌❤️
Love this movie!! Love that instead of defeating the Mean girl she reconciles with her (while still standing up for herself), love that they made actors look like teenagers, love the dreamy shy but not a pushover heroine! Great movie! And a great video, thank you!!
the feeling that i had watching the first movie i wish i could have had for the last 2 movies. it was so good. the cinematography, colour grading & overall aesthetic of the movie was amazing and its what caught my eye while watching. lara jean was so relatable as a character and peter kavinsky had all the girls in a chokehold. when they switched directors, the change in quality was sooo obvious - the only scenes that stood out to me was the last scene in the 2nd movie and the nyc scenes in the 3rd. nothing is beating the first one
This movie meant so much to me when it came out, I was in late middle school and LOVING IT. Obsessed with this movie, unlike I was with any other “teen” movie. Still love this movie ✨✨💖
loved this video!! this movie is my absolute favorite. while i knew i liked the movie because of its cozy atmosphere, beautiful visuals, cute storyline, and the chemistry between the leads, i never knew how much thought when into this movie! all the color symbols and strategic outfit choices make me appreciate the movie even more 😍
As someone who loves the books, the movie gets Lara Jean and Peter right, but everything else is so off. They cut out a lot of characters and scenes that contribute to who Lara Jean is as a person and a lot of her growth. I put off reading the last book for awhile and ended up reading it during a stressful time of Law School applications for me. Her turmoil of applying to college and trying to decide where she wants her life to go and who she wants to set herself up to be was so realistic for me. The movies focused primarily on her love life so it isn't as prominent or impactful as it is in the books
HEY!. I absolutely love your video essays and they are super descriptive and fun to watch and listen. the way you describe every single thing is just mindblowing and the efforts you put are astonishing. i actually had a little thought more like a suggestion. i have not seen much video essays on 13 Reasons Why and i think you should try on that its an interesting topic and i would love for you to dive into it. its just a small suggestion i hope this comment catches your eye. At last, i wish you all the best and love your vids. KEEP UP!! PERIODT.
The first movie is such a great adaptation, I don’t think Ill ever get over it 😭 I read all three books along with the rest of Jenny Han’s trilogies and this one is definitely my favorite 🥹
probably a modern romcom that comes close to to all the boys i loved before is prom pact in disney+!! we have the quirky yet headstrong character, she has her own style, and not to mention the 80s nostalgia.
You have absolutely blown my mind with how the colours in this movie have symbolism. I always loved the visuals of this film but the thought behind it makes it even better.
I need to give the third one another try then according to these comments😭 I just hated the second one even though I tried SO HARD for Jeremy… I did end up watching XO Kitty however! and it’s such a fun dumpster fire that it makes me somewhat excited for season 2.
any suggestions for other good modern teen movies??
Easy A, The Edge of Seventeen, Ladybird, Booksmart and The Half of It all spring to mind.
I really have no clue 🥲
I love the half of it, my comfort film!
dinner in america but more like early 20's type movie tbh but still sooooo good
Honestly I just watched American Graffiti, and it was fascinating as a teen movie in comparison to how modern teen movies are constructed. It was so much more chaotic, and really full of people being cruel and foolish in a way that seemed so real.
The change from female director for the first film to male for the second affected the quality of the films so so so much.
this! i hate how the series' public perception has denigrated so heavily, as a result of the other films. to all the boys *deserved* its success, and it *deserves* to receive the same respect as the other goats in its genre, but it's treated as being indistinguishable from the likes of "the kissing booth" and "tall girl" all because of its sequels and status as a netflix film.
i think one of the biggest issues is that the visual aesthetics of the first film is extremely-similar to its sequels; susan johnson's directorial skills are leaps-and-bounds above fimognari's (made especially-evident by the cinematography), however, to an untrained eye, theyre very visually-similar which makes it hard for the audience to really notice the dip in quality between films... definitely only worsened by how the books' narratives worsen over time, too.
i really need all of its detractors to rewatch the first film, without the plot points of the second in mind (especially how they destroyed peter's character). it knows exactly what it wants to be - a charming, laid-back romcom between two normal teenagers - and it excels at it in an extraordinary fashion. most romcom's rely on excess amounts of drama to keep the viewers enticed (hence the genre's propensity for toxicity), but to all the boys manages to escape this through how down-to-earth its characters, dialogue and overall narrative is. even the more-dramatic elements (the fake romance, lara jean's letters leaking, lara jean's crush on josh etc) dissolve very quickly to focus on peter and lara jean's development.
i was really expecting the drama surrounding the letters to be a big feature upon my first viewing of the film, and was pleasantly-surprised by how its handled; instead of being some grand-drama that encompasses the entire film, it's just a small facet that sets that plot in motion. i really loved how lara jean takes a humiliation like that in stride and just deals with the cards she's been dealt. the film's writing is shockingly-mature in how it has its characters handle the situation they landed themselves in - especially so, given that the narratives *immaturity* is one of its charms. it's really sad to see how the public's respect for it has dwindled over time
Omg my roommate and I just watched all 3 and we kept noticing how ugly the last 2 are…like they were trying to do something but not quite getting there. I had no idea that they switched directors, that explains it!!
It's crazy how often it happens and how noticable it becomes. 50 Shades (think of the movies what you will) also switched out the female director for a male one for the last two movies and the difference was super noticable
I have been saying this and no one around me sees or gets it
The male director also completely changed the story from the books
I think the reason To All The Boys is so loved is honestly because it scratches that heartwarming itch we have and feels unapologetically cute and girly
exactlyyy!! especially when so many films punish characters fro embracing their girliness, this is such a refreshing take
that + the soundtrack just works
while also taking the fun of girliness and teen romance seriously!! it's such a good, refreshing balances
Comparing "To All the Boys" with "The Kissing Booth" is akin to comparing a bestselling, critically lauded book series with a story which originated from Wattpad... Oh, wait.
wait I actually didn't know that story originated from wattpad lol help 😭
@@artatmidnight Yep, and it was written by a fifteen year old girl, believe it or not.
@@artatmidnight wait so which one is better? did they mean that the book was written by a 15yo girl and the wattpad was by someone older? sorry english is not my 1st language
@@littleMahika The Kissing Booth was the Wattpad story written by a 15 year old
Lol that explains alot
I also really enjoy the dialogue in this movie!! It’s not perfect but so many teen movies try so hard to “talk like a teen” that it ends up being cringey and loses its authenticity. In To All the Boys, they treat all the characters like real people and most of the cringeyness doesn’t come from trying too hard, it comes from the genuine awkward nature of real life situations, which is why no one is really bothered by it like they would be in other dramas. The character writing is raw and real and it just makes the vibes and execution of this movie so fun! I love watching this movie, definitely a comfort film
yes you're so right! I also like how they included social media/texting. like you said, it doesn't feel forced or trying too hard to be "trendy" or "with the kids." it all feels natural which makes it actually enjoyable to watch 🩷🩷
I loved how likable and relatable the characters were, especially how close the three sisters were. Sure, they picked fights and could get snarky, but that's what siblings do. Also, it was understandable why Lara Jean, despite being intelligent, kind and attractive, wasn't very popular, since her shyness was holding her back.
yeah i honestly saw myself in her
The 1st To all the boys movie is one of those i can watch over and over again, it makes me feel giddy inside. The colors, the theme of Lara Jean breaking out of her shell... feels like a classic
YESS FOR REALLLLLL
As someone who read the book I think the only significant change is Peter’s motivation, in the books he gets in the deal bc he realizes his relationship with gen is toxic and if he dates someone else he is not going to go back to her, it’s very simple but it changes a lot
oh interesting! do you think that was a good change to make or does it take away from the original story?
@@artatmidnight I don’t think it takes away from the first movie, it makes Peter a little less likable and his actions a little less understandable, but it works out, in the second tho, it changes the felling of the whole story
Wait. Really? It’s been a while since I read the first book.
it doesnt really have a lot to do with your comment but its rare to find people who are actually fans of the books instead of just the movies , so i gotta say; to all the boys is my favorite book series and theres a whole lot of changes from the books to the movies, ESPECIALLY the second one. in the second book, theres so much romance between john and LJ bt in the movies they have 00000% chemistry, and even though im a PK+LJ shipper (obvii), i feel like it takes away most of the magic from the book. the second book is my favourite out of the three, but the second movie is my least favorite (pls someone tell me im not the only one)
@@falatudosofia yes, the second one is also my fav!! I like of how even tho there was a lot of romance between lara jean and john ambrose it still felt like peter was the right choice for her and how their relationship was actually growing, the movie didn’t capture any of that it feels weird
Also, they wanted to rewrite Lara Jean as a WHITE girl & Jenny Han had to fight like hell to make sure they casted an ASIAN actress for Lara! Jenny earns my permanent respect for that.
I never knew this what the hellll
@@stargirlliv unfortunately it’s true. Thankfully the company that eventually funded and filmed the movie was more respectful to book accuracy!
@@danaco9942 It's not respectful to the book though. They ended up casting a Southeast asian actress to play a half korean half yt character. Ask any east asian person and they'll tell you how they felt about this respresentation.
@@cassiem.4580 and respectfully idc. I’m Asian and see zero problems with it. Fuck groupthink
@@danaco9942 What kind of asian are you? I'm east asian and the rest of us east asians do not consider this fair representation of us, let alone half east asians at all. The 2 sisters were half east asian and half yt but literally the main character was off both in terms of her half ancestry and east asian ancestry.
i'm glad you pointed out the presence of teal in almost every scene. i didn't notice it until you pointed it out, but yeah, every time i think of that movie, my mind always thinks of teal. very consistent branding
I never noticed about the teal, but whenever I think about this film, the first thing that pops up is the beautiful warm comforting colour pallete. Makes it feel so nostalgic
This colour palette has my heart cause of how nostalgic 2019 is
I'm unsure of the ages of the actors, but one thing that elevates this film is that they actually look like teenagers.
They aren't lol
okay let’s not lie
@@kamila9870 Google exists babes they were all in their twenties or older during the filming the only teen teen would have been her younger sister
maybe for lara jean, but the love interests not as true 😭
i will die on the hill that to all the boys (1st movie only) is SUCH a good movie. i remember being SO disappointed with the second one, and the third one was okay but nothing stood out to me like the first movie. i am obsessed, it is so cute, the chemistry between lana and noah is so good. i will die
I agree but it’s mainly bc they changed the director from the first movie sadly. You can tell in the quality for sure
YESSSSS
@@hayley623 it is sooo sad :( i didnt know until recently and no wonder
SAME i would die 4 this movie
You can tell this movie had a lot of actual effort put into it, you know? I say this as someone who wasn’t the biggest fan of it, but it wasn’t a blatant cash grab like the Kissing Booth. It tried to authentically explore the trials and tribulations of adolescent romance, grief and drama, even if in my opinion it didn’t succeed in all these areas. It was genuine, and I enjoyed it for what it was.
Yes! The effort is totally there. I've always loved the set and costume design! You can absolutely tell how intentional it is and it creates a vibe for the whole universe of the movie that is very chic, yet relatable.
I read the full trilogy growing up! It was such a good adaptation, and as an Asian American I loved seeing the Yakult in the movie and all the Asian references. The only thing that was not really accurate to the book (that I remember, i read this a long time ago) was in the movie Kitty sent out the letters cause she thought that Lara Jean was lonely. In the book, Kitty talked about wanting to get a dog and Lara Jean told Josh that Kitty wanted to name the dog after him and Kitty wanted revenge.
YESS SAME!! The only thing is I’m half Asian and I’m sad that Lara Jean, a popular wasian character, was played by a full Asian actress. She did an amazing job but this was our chance to have wasian representation and we didn’t get it😭😭
ha ha I remember this in the book!!!
@@ladydiamond6611 why did LJ told Josh that Kitty wanted to named to dog after him ? And why did Kitty got mad about that ?
@@-chenlanying5818In the books, Kitty had a crush on Josh and wanted to name the dog after him because of that. And Lara Jean was just teasing her abt it by telling Josh, which made Kitty feel embarrassed and in turn want to take revenge on her sister; And thus, sending out the letters.
I kinda understand Kitty. I don't justify her actions but LJ was out of line.
As someone who's read the books many times, I think both versions are really good. I prefer the books because of how much detail you get (and there's more drama), but this movie is so cozy, well made and does capture the essence of lara jean and her coming of age story. The parts of the book that they changed and took out for the movie did simplify the story in some places but it made the story work in the movie framework.
THANK YOU!!! THIS!!!! Everyone hating on the book series cause it's messy aha like, what else are you reading a teen romcom for??? But I also love the books so much because all the characters grow so much, and I love remembering all the little details too. It's truly such a great book series!
I don’t understand why something being for children or teens has the pass of being bad, we all deserve good quality, good animated movies and romcoms 😭 this movie and the third are two of my recent go to along with do revenge, recently Lisa Frankenstein and Enola Holmes
Enola Holmes is so goooood
Lisa Frankenstein is so good!! It totally gives odd Edward sccusorhands early 2000s Tim burton style movie, and I love the visuals soo much. Cult classic for sure.
@@tarathoughts13 I really hope it becomes an icon cause I don’t remember the last time a movie had me so focused on the TV
it's crazy as someone who's read the books thrice and watched the first movie so many times i nearly have it memorized frame for frame, i've never dissected the visual language that so clearly elevates this film above other romcoms of the past decade. this was so fun to watch for me!! (also you're so real for not watching the third because the second movie made you mad but that's a whole other convo lmaoooo)
i would watch hours of your analysis 😭💕 thank you for your hard work, i'll probably rewatch this a few times tbh.
and to answer your question: yes! i'd say the first film particularly is a great adaption. more than just following the book to the T, i think the film perfectly captures the warmth that made the book such a comfort read for me.
thank you!! 🤗 I'm so glad this is such a good adaptation! it's the best feeling when a beloved book is actually done justice, but so rare to find 💛💛
wow i never even noticed the red at the scary scenes, but i did subconsciously pick up on it. her red jacket at the love confession stands out majorly
I will never shut up about how good To All The Boys I've Loved Before is-no matter how many times I rewatch it I'm always entertained with the storyline and characters. 👏👏🎉🎉
the main reason this movie worked so well is simply because laura jean actually feels like a real teen girl and her world feels genuinely lived in. like so many can see at least a little bit of themselves in her, and even if you can't anyone can pinpoint at least 1 girl they knew growing up that was very similar to her
The thumbnail is the realest thing I've read today😭🙌
oohhh so I'm actually testing 3 different versions. which one did you see??
A gem amongst Trash😭😂😂🙌
@@artatmidnight I clicked on CARE. didn't really get it, the other one sounds better
@@artatmidnight i got Trash vs Taste 😂
OMG i know i wasn’t tripping that it changed
I think to all the boys I have loved before is such a classic 😭 it’s like 10 things I hate about you (the cultural significance not the plot) but from the late 2010s, when you rewatch it, it’s literally a time capsule
my mom loves rom coms, but she could never find the perfect movie that she could rewatch. My mom resonated with Laura jean and loved that they respected the character enough to not make her passed around once she was considered pretty.
I don’t think it’s a mistake that the two most popular teen rom coms are both Jenny Han book series. The summer I turned pretty has so many similar qualities and attention to detail
Do Revenge is another great teen movie for the visuals alone. The overall plot kind of borders redundant and camp, but the costume and set design? gorgeous.
this movie is unironically one of my favorite movies of all time and as a film major I've been clowned by others for saying how GOOD this movie is so thank you for making a video proving my point😌
Jenny Han writes really relatable, realistic and well rounded characters. She also writes her stories in a very immersive way, where you get to know why the characters do what they do and you get attached to them. To all the boys i loved before was such a good adaptation and such a moment in pop culture.
Man, I would just love video essays on all the "To All the Boys" movies. These movies are cheesy masterpieces that I can watch again and again!!!
I just love when things in movies and tv shows are intentional and you are always so great at picking it out! This video is so well done and the research in your video essays are incredible👏🏾👏🏾
thank you so much!! 🫶🤗
this is my favorite movie of all time. i listen to songs from the soundtrack almost everyday!! this movie is such a comfort for me.
The cinematography is amazing. The soundtrack, the clothes, the characters and the relationships are soothing. The lighting makes the aesthetic so warm.
Ahh é incrivel ver que outras pessoas tem o mesmo sentimento que eu em relação ao filme. Eu tinha 15 anos quando lançou , eu assisti com umas colegas e comemos pizza barata.Tbm ouvia com frequencia as musicas, ainda hoje procuro a soundtrack as vezes.Essa trilogia sempre vai estar em uma parte do meu coração
As a 19 teen year old this movie makes me want to date again😭💘
ok the thoughts are genius. tbh, and author knows way more about what she wrote and why instead of the interpretations of someone else or a reader, so their input in movies like these are very very important, and , urgent.
As a quiet introverted girl who loves dressing up, i liked allll Lara's outfits and i related to her personality more. Shy but not a push over
honestly i think the movie captured the emotions that you get when you read the book so well. nothings too similar or too different, honestly a perfect adaptation.
This is one of my comfort movies ill never get tired of it
It didn’t take itself too seriously like most cringy teen media and that was honestly what made it so good. The characters are so silly and they’re kids and they know it. She’s not ashamed to be a girly, preppy teen girl, and that shows. She’s okay with who she is and doesn’t feel the need to bring down other women and the absence of the unfortunate “NLOG” teen trope adds so much to this story.
I’m so happy you talked about this film! It was honestly so cute and I was really surprised by how much I enjoyed it. Many teen films nowadays or even romantic films are just aggravating. I loved how the main character wasn’t dressed frumpy, didn’t have to go through a whole transformation scene to be “beautiful” or “liked”.
As someone who has read the books, the first one is pretty much the same except for the ending, and then the second and third lose a lot of the plot and certain characters from the books
Not the queen doing a video of my all-time favorite movie!!
I liked the movie so I wanted to read the book. But, oh boy, did I hate them. I love how much more complex and layered the characters are in the movie and how likable as well. I love they didn’t make Josh have feelings for her, but rather be a good friend and support her even though he was the one going through a breakup
i cant believe you hated them......they were so good..... TT
Netflix and other movie companies should be taking notes because it is great to have the author be involved and be able to show and explain what the readers liked about the book in the first place.
I already liked To All the Boys, even though I don't really like teen movies anymore, but this really helped to explain why this one feels so different. The use of color and style is especially impressive. ^^
PLEASE make an Uglies video bestie
i think i need to 😭 i have so many thoughts
I watched this movie for the first time the night before my first day of freshman year. I ended up staying up a little too late but all my nervousness about school was gone. It's just such a lovely happy movie.
I really didn't expect to like this movie this much as i was already in my 20s but it's just so good!
also the soundtrack for to all the boys is the BESTTT and i'm still obsessed with it
You mentioned the teal, but I was also looking at the color grading, and it looks exactly like polaroids!!
You can really feel the difference when a teen-movie is written and directed by women, and when it is directed by men. Probably one of the only modern teen movies that gives you real butterflies
Tatlib is justt so realistic, lara jean and peter are so cuteee
"Nothing good or bad can happen if you just think about it" is actually is very good advice
The first movie will always hold a special place for me. Truly love it one of the best original Netflix teen romances that doesn’t make me cringe. The visuals aesthetics and Lana and Noah’s chemistry is so good. I still wonder how much better the other two movies would’ve been if they stuck with the same director
The first movie absolutely captured and built on the magic of the book, I read it as a teenager and it was my favorite book series. I was so excited for the second book as I liked it more than the first, and they cut so many plot points that made it so endearing and charming and it was a bit disappointing but still.
One of my favourite things about the colour palette used in this movie, now that it’s been pointed out, is that when it shows the flashback of Laura Jean and Josh being friends she’s drinking the lemon version of Arizona iced tea which comes in a yellow teal and pink can. Even her drink choice is colour coordinated.
I LOVE LOVE LOVED John Corbett as the girl’s dad!!! He SCREAMS girl dad in the best way!
Having read and loved the books, I LOVED the first movie and they really captured the cozy sweet vibe of the book. The ONLY change that bugged me was actually Gen's motive behind hating LJ...in the book, LJ and Peter were the last ones left at the middle school party and they kissed, which wasn't part of a game or anything. LJ knew Gen had a crush on Peter. Gen walked in on them and felt betrayed. That line of thought feels far less silly than the movie's motivation, which has her upset about a kiss during Spin the Bottle. It made Gen a bit more relatable and less just hardcore irrational mean girl. That's just my thoughts, though!
15:33 the second book had me not only mad at Peter but also rooting for John-Ambrose especially after the 50s dance and when he took her home and kissed her 😢
The camerawork on this movie really elevated it. The framing where she is off center outside the diner is so perfect and really shows how artistic they wanted it to be
Im a 30 year old woman with a 38 year old boyfriend and weve watched to all the boys trilogy at least three times in total. Its SUCH a heartwarming film for when you're sick or depressed. Its awkward but in a realistic and not too exaggerated way. Youre constantly thinking "that couldve been me in my teens!" And the cast is really good. The colours and the style of everyone is pretty af but not too unrealistic like euphoria e.g.
this is one of my favorite comfort films and I love this analysis, especially the colors and what they represent. I'll have to watch it again and look out for these details!
Such a great breakdown! I typically don't enjoy newer teen movies and I couldn't put my finger on exactly why I love this series. You nailed it 👏🏾
your points about the intentionality of the visuals, sets, and fashion remind me of bottoms (2023) -- another teen movie, though completely different tonally, that is so so good
It is a great adaptation,it even improved things by changing and upgrading the scenarios
oh please do watch the third one, it was kind of frustrating but it was sweet.
I cannot tell you how ecstatic I was to hear you say you have a love hate relationship with Peter AND WHAT YOU SAID ABOUT THE SECOND MOVIE, GIRL I WAS IN THE SAME POSITION!!! I didn't watch the third one for a YEAR and some change after it came out, but trust me it's worth it, HE GETS BETTER! the third one is my favorite.
I've read the books and for me I don't completely understand the hype. How Peter is in the second movie he's like in ....basically all the books. Their relationship comes off toxic to me, especially when John comes into play, he just shows a lot of red flags. The MOVIES ABSOLUTELY PULLED THROUGH! (not counting the second one, I don't even acknowledge the second movie all due respect to EVERYONE, it's just not for me.) Genuinely, for the first time the movies are better than the books. (TO ME!)
To call these movies (except the second one) "comfort movies" is an absolute understatement and you nailed every detail as to why they work. I literally remember thinking to myself "oh no here comes the love triangle" during the movie/bench scene and then she said she would never do that to Margot and I went "oh!" Beautiful.
The Perks of Being a Wallflower and To All the Boys I've Loved Before are teen movies that I love to watch over and over again. Lara Jean and Charlie are both such lovable and relatable protagonists.
Omg!!! That was amazing!! The points, loopholes, editing, it was all there!! Never stop making content!!! Love ur videos 💜
I love how since i've been watching your video's, i've been notecing these little details in the movies I watch too. It makes it so much more interasting and you actually start to see the art in movies!
Woah thank you for pointing out the doors! I've rewatched these movies dozens of times and never fully noticed that! I think the third movie is worth watching, but only because I love LJ and her ability to not be a perfect protagonist, instead being one that grows. Plus it also let's us meet Dae, kitty's love interest for her spinoff show. Who knows, maybe one day Jenny Han will give us a Margo spinoff too. Sorry random ramble over😅 great video, I really enjoyed your attention to details
Videos like this help me appreciate movies like this more.
I am really blind to hints and things shown through visuals colours and themes.
literally just rewatched this movie earlier this week! love ur videos, this is just what i needed
aahh im earlyy!! i could literally sit through ur videos foreverrr theyre so entertainingg lol
omg thank u 😭💛💛
@@artatmidnight eee Ofcc!
I never watched this cuz its got a lot of anxiety and embarrassment in it which would probably trigger my own. Grateful to see it through this lens to maybe prepare me enough to watch it (or read it!) myself one day
I watched it and loved it but I don’t get you what do you mean by anxiety and embarrassment?😅
To be honest when I first watched this movie I wasn't a big fan, but this video helped me develop a new appreciation for it. I'm gonna go rewatch and reread the books now lol.
one of my fav movies!! thank you for this!
this video is top tier, I will be rewatching it. I adore this and just had to tell you how fantastical and lovely it is.
20:52 i was just telling my bf about how much i love your channel 😭💖💕
14:40 finally, someone who is also still mad abt that scrunchie.
Now I'm not a girl but i think I'm used to this visuals because in most asian series, if you're the MAIN CHARACTER, you'll always be stylish. Poor or rich. And if you're in a quirky style, you're just the best friend who's the comedic relief.
I did read the books when I was a teenager and I do think that the movies really captured the spirit of the books and I think all of the changes makes sense and I’m okay with that however they cut some of my favorite passages and so that’ll always make me a little bitter, but I love these movies like I love this movie the first one whenever I just need something on it’s great
to all the boys was literally PERFECTION
I’m so glad someone’s talking about this movie. I kept looking for commentaries about it. And there’s barley any
you always put so much thought and effort into your commentaries and it's amazing just how well-versed you are. thank you for bringing quality back to youtube
This is such a wonderful video! Thank you for taking the time to put it all together. I particularly loved everything you pointed out about colours as I hadn’t consciously noticed this! Thoroughly enjoyed watching this on my lunch break 🙌🙌🙌❤️
Your analysis is very complete. This video is amazing
Love this movie!! Love that instead of defeating the Mean girl she reconciles with her (while still standing up for herself), love that they made actors look like teenagers, love the dreamy shy but not a pushover heroine! Great movie! And a great video, thank you!!
I needed to hear the part about chronic daydreaming, so thank you for that
the feeling that i had watching the first movie i wish i could have had for the last 2 movies. it was so good. the cinematography, colour grading & overall aesthetic of the movie was amazing and its what caught my eye while watching. lara jean was so relatable as a character and peter kavinsky had all the girls in a chokehold. when they switched directors, the change in quality was sooo obvious - the only scenes that stood out to me was the last scene in the 2nd movie and the nyc scenes in the 3rd. nothing is beating the first one
This movie meant so much to me when it came out, I was in late middle school and LOVING IT. Obsessed with this movie, unlike I was with any other “teen” movie. Still love this movie ✨✨💖
I love when you can tell when an author has poured their heart and soul into such a passionate project like to all the boys, it’s beautiful
I LOVE THE WAY YOU TALK ABOUT COLOUR
loved this video!! this movie is my absolute favorite. while i knew i liked the movie because of its cozy atmosphere, beautiful visuals, cute storyline, and the chemistry between the leads, i never knew how much thought when into this movie! all the color symbols and strategic outfit choices make me appreciate the movie even more 😍
11:03 SHE'S LEFT HANDED, THAT'S A DETAIL CAUSE LEFTIES ARE CREATIVE AAAAHH I LOVE THIS
As someone who loves the books, the movie gets Lara Jean and Peter right, but everything else is so off. They cut out a lot of characters and scenes that contribute to who Lara Jean is as a person and a lot of her growth. I put off reading the last book for awhile and ended up reading it during a stressful time of Law School applications for me. Her turmoil of applying to college and trying to decide where she wants her life to go and who she wants to set herself up to be was so realistic for me. The movies focused primarily on her love life so it isn't as prominent or impactful as it is in the books
HEY!. I absolutely love your video essays and they are super descriptive and fun to watch and listen. the way you describe every single thing is just mindblowing and the efforts you put are astonishing. i actually had a little thought more like a suggestion. i have not seen much video essays on 13 Reasons Why and i think you should try on that its an interesting topic and i would love for you to dive into it. its just a small suggestion i hope this comment catches your eye. At last, i wish you all the best and love your vids. KEEP UP!! PERIODT.
i just rewatched all these movies lately to feel something 🥹 love this franchise
The first movie is such a great adaptation, I don’t think Ill ever get over it 😭 I read all three books along with the rest of Jenny Han’s trilogies and this one is definitely my favorite 🥹
probably a modern romcom that comes close to to all the boys i loved before is prom pact in disney+!! we have the quirky yet headstrong character, she has her own style, and not to mention the 80s nostalgia.
Omg when I watched this movie I was thinking the same thing about the color palette!!!! ❤ I love your videos sm you are so right
You have absolutely blown my mind with how the colours in this movie have symbolism. I always loved the visuals of this film but the thought behind it makes it even better.
YOU NEED TOO WATCH THE THIRD ONE!!! I don’t consider the second one apart of the trilogy atp but believe me, the third one is worth the watch!!
The third movie really redeemed the trilogy! I actually enjoyed it since the second one was mad corny
I need to give the third one another try then according to these comments😭 I just hated the second one even though I tried SO HARD for Jeremy… I did end up watching XO Kitty however! and it’s such a fun dumpster fire that it makes me somewhat excited for season 2.