Weapon Comparison | EA Battlefront (2015) vs EA Battlefront 2 (2017) Graphics and Sounds

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 авг 2024
  • A comparison between the Weapons, Blasters, Pickups/Powerups and Star Cards common to both EA Star Wars Battlefront (2015) and EA Star Wars Battlefront 2 (2017) in terms of graphics, sounds, animations, effects and functionality.
    Weapon Timestamps:
    0:02 DLT-19
    0:22 DH-17
    0:39 RT-97C
    1:08 A280C
    1:18 E-11
    1:36 CA-87/Repulsor Cannon
    1:48 DLT-19X
    2:00 EE-4/Infiltration
    2:16 TL-50 Heavy Repeater/TL-50
    2:53 A180
    3:07 Thermal Detonator
    3:24 Ion Torpedo
    3:50 Pulse Cannon
    4:08 Impact Grenade
    4:21 Ion Grenade/Smart Ion Grenade
    4:42 Barrage
    5:00 Sonic Imploder
    5:22 Thermal Imploder
    5:39 Smart Rocket
    5:57 Disruptor Rifle/Ion Disruptor
    6:15 Infantry Turret/Blaster Turret
    7:02 Vehicle Turret/Ion Turret
    7:38 Melee
    7:58 Orbital Strike
    Note this comparison only shows infantry weapons. Jyn Erso's Sonic Imploder is an exception to this as it can also be obtained as an infantry. Including an aim down sights comparison wasn't viable as it would make the video too long and the games do not have proper aim down sight modes. Some weapons simply zoom in while others have an on-screen overlay which is disabled when the HUD is disabled. Blaster Rifles have the same HUD design as other Blaster Rifles other and the same is true for Targeting Rifles aside from some slight blue/green tint differences.
    Not applicable due to EA skirmish limitations: Homing Shot, Flash Grenade, Bowcaster, Stinger Pistol, Disruption, Laser Trip Mine, Shock Grenade and Scatter Gun/Vanguard.
    ►Join Our Community Discord: / discord
    ►Subscribe: / wintoroperator
    ►Support the channel: / wintoroperator
    ►Follow Me
    -Twitter / wintoroperator
    -Instagram / wintoroperator
    -Facebook / wintoroperator
    Thank you for watching. If you enjoyed the video consider leaving a like and subscribe for more content.
    -WintorOperator
  • ИгрыИгры

Комментарии • 1 тыс.

  • @WintorOperator
    @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +497

    0:02 DLT-19
    0:22 DH-17
    0:39 RT-97C
    1:08 A280C
    1:18 E-11
    1:36 CA-87/Repulsor Cannon
    1:48 DLT-19X
    2:00 EE-4/Infiltration
    2:16 TL-50 Heavy Repeater/TL-50
    2:53 A180
    3:07 Thermal Detonator
    3:24 Ion Torpedo
    3:50 Pulse Cannon
    4:08 Impact Grenade
    4:21 Ion Grenade/Smart Ion Grenade
    4:42 Barrage
    5:00 Sonic Imploder
    5:22 Thermal Imploder
    5:39 Smart Rocket
    5:57 Disruptor Rifle/Ion Disruptor
    6:15 Infantry Turret/Blaster Turret
    7:02 Vehicle Turret/Ion Turret
    7:38 Melee
    7:58 Orbital Strike

  • @jarbean2723
    @jarbean2723 6 лет назад +839

    The thermal imploder, and the at-at falling looked wayyy better and more satisfying in the first

    • @reyncoat
      @reyncoat 6 лет назад +9

      A part of the issue with the thermal imploder clip (BF2) is that it was thrown in a small depression. I think that blocked out some of the explosion's animation

    • @MolochMinion
      @MolochMinion 6 лет назад +2

      Jared De Los Santos in battlefront 2 that is what I imagine an implosion will look like. it looks more real and you can see small particles being pulled in from a distance before turning blue then erupting, almost reminds me of a super nova only thing that ruins it is the dramatic mushroom cloud. The first game just looked like some type of bright explosion with a weird bubble affect now I see it with a side by side comparison.

    • @mcbone2178
      @mcbone2178 6 лет назад +4

      Also greedos thermal imploder in BF1 had an amazing sound and was satisfying to watch and listen.

    • @Viper-yv8tw
      @Viper-yv8tw 6 лет назад

      Agree

    • @CD-R828
      @CD-R828 4 года назад

      Do you guys have played a game before do you know what graphics are!

  • @arty-AN5690
    @arty-AN5690 6 лет назад +701

    Battlefront 1 looks more saturated and vibrant, and it sounds more like Star Wars than BF2.

    • @TokenChineseGuy
      @TokenChineseGuy 5 лет назад +56

      Agree, Battlefront 1 looks like it was shot on beautiful 35mm film, while Battlefront 2 looks like it was shot on a digital camera rig.

    • @WetPickle998
      @WetPickle998 5 лет назад +18

      Yeah they made the first one a cinematic masterpiece everything is perfect but that’s why there’s no objects that move with explosions

    • @jelleposthuma8786
      @jelleposthuma8786 4 года назад +15

      @@WetPickle998 there are though, the trees in the forest break and fall through explosions.

    • @bruh-fw7op
      @bruh-fw7op 3 года назад +9

      BF2 id say is much more saturated and beautiful now due to the complete VFX overhaul.

    • @fdangleshadang-a-lang7149
      @fdangleshadang-a-lang7149 3 года назад +9

      100000% agree. Battlefront 2015 was superior in several aspects. Visually and audibly, but also in terms of gameplay. The weapons felt better and targets weren’t bullet sponges like in BF2. Normally in Star Wars, it only takes one laser to take someone out. In BF2, I’d unload 100 shots on someone and they manage to escape

  • @enrageddong1869
    @enrageddong1869 6 лет назад +298

    When it's compared to its sequel, am I the only one who starts to genuinely like and appreciate Star Wars battlefront 1?

    • @lokochon2000
      @lokochon2000 6 лет назад +5

      A wild meme has literally ruined his entire life! i also do, so far i am not much enjoyed BF2 it feels weird.

    • @shatterpointgames
      @shatterpointgames 4 года назад +13

      BF1 didn't have half the content that bf2 has. That's the issue with bf1 the game was basically empty

    • @CT7056
      @CT7056 3 года назад +12

      Battlefront 2015 is a masterpiece

    • @spartacussmith7070
      @spartacussmith7070 3 года назад +1

      @@CT7056 take away the jetpacks and it's literally perfect

    • @CT7056
      @CT7056 3 года назад +1

      @@spartacussmith7070 You know, it's not the game's fault. It's better to have more star cards, it's players that use ones more and ones less.

  • @sevs42
    @sevs42 6 лет назад +1296

    The blaster bolts on the first Battlefront are waaay better.

    • @sevs42
      @sevs42 6 лет назад +37

      Great video by the way.

    • @Sean-kc4ob
      @Sean-kc4ob 6 лет назад +86

      They’re very saturated. The new one looks more movie like

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +15

      Thanks :)

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +46

      They are thicker and as a result easier to see.

    • @sevs42
      @sevs42 6 лет назад +11

      Winimatic I actually find the blaster bolts harder to see.

  • @Aurik-Kal-Durin
    @Aurik-Kal-Durin 6 лет назад +396

    I know it's been said a million times, but the blaster bolts in Battlefront II look WAY too small. The exception is on starfighters; the blaster bolts for starfighters look perfect, exactly like the films (and what they should be using for the infantry blasters).

    • @CamoflaugeDinosaue
      @CamoflaugeDinosaue 6 лет назад +6

      Yes, because they couldn't copy/paste assets from battlefield into Starfighter Assault, they had to actually use Star Wars as a reference.

    • @danialadzha84
      @danialadzha84 6 лет назад +1

      Except the nt-243. When i use it literally 3 sniper aiming at me lol

    • @danialadzha84
      @danialadzha84 6 лет назад +1

      *nt-242

    • @vedantleva2508
      @vedantleva2508 6 лет назад

      Aurik Kal-Durin agreed.

    • @AF-tv6uf
      @AF-tv6uf 6 лет назад +3

      Agreed! I feel like a few of the sounds are a bit off as well, especially with the E-11. Should be a bit...I don't know...deeper. In the films it was kind of a throaty "choom, choom". I think they modified the sounds to make them what they thought would be more "satisfying" to FPS players used to the sounds/shapes of guns/ammo from our world. What do you think?

  • @pyryvirtanen6081
    @pyryvirtanen6081 6 лет назад +1040

    The blaster fire looks better in the first game.

    • @Plant104
      @Plant104 6 лет назад +99

      Dah Magpie I honestly think the first one looks better in general...

    • @NatsumiTakanawa
      @NatsumiTakanawa 6 лет назад +39

      Dah Magpie i agree. The lazer trace is too subtle. Looks more like bullets.

    • @richardms9888
      @richardms9888 6 лет назад +20

      Check DLT 19X in BF II, its literally a fucking bullet. No blaster fire, just a regular sniper rifle

    • @thatperformer3879
      @thatperformer3879 6 лет назад

      Miss Tokyo Fun I think that was the intention

    • @dr.muller3243
      @dr.muller3243 6 лет назад +2

      EXACTLY!!!!!

  • @robinnitsche758
    @robinnitsche758 6 лет назад +352

    Is it just me, or didn't anyone else notice that the explosions in Battlefront 2 look like crap?

    • @robinnitsche758
      @robinnitsche758 6 лет назад +5

      The laser thing is kinda like in the first good two Battlefront games.
      In the first one they looked incredibly nice and light! But were very slow. In Battlefront 2 (2005) they are kinda like in the new one. Barely visible but fast as hell. Great thing: you are able to get some mods too change that problem. But not with the new Ones :(

    • @bmgmist273
      @bmgmist273 6 лет назад +1

      frank 36631 not me because i just enjoy the game as is 😊

    • @viktorceder4985
      @viktorceder4985 6 лет назад +10

      The first game looks like fucking fireworks and unrealistic as hell.

    • @mathismoro7957
      @mathismoro7957 4 года назад +1

      Robin Nitsche the fact is that the environment is not destroyed after the explsion in BF2 and it’s a way better in BF1

    • @CD-R828
      @CD-R828 4 года назад

      Mathis Moro nope

  • @MrDox90
    @MrDox90 6 лет назад +176

    Not a single comment on how they screwed up the thermal imploder animation in BF2? In the first there is a clear implosion happening, in 2 its a regular explosion just bigger than a detonator. Also all the explosion effects are way clearer, and overall nicer in bf1. Just look at that at-at explosion. It's a step back not forward.

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +1

      Agreed.

    • @christianantillon3305
      @christianantillon3305 6 лет назад

      Yeah cause if it isn't broken don't fix it dice!

    • @NedranMusic
      @NedranMusic 6 лет назад +2

      I actually think that it's because in Battlefront 2, they privileged contents and gameplay instead of graphics. All the graphics of Battlefront 1 are better, the textures, the explosions etc... But the maps feel more alive in Battlefront 2, with more particles like leaf, birds and so on. It's like Battlefront 1 was the demo of their new graphic engine and Battlefront 2 is a more serious game which was not created only to show the engine's capabilities.
      So overall I can't blame Battlefront 2 to have some lower graphics than Battlefront 1 because there is just so more content in that new one, it would have been all laggy with incredible graphics.

    • @Kalsiem
      @Kalsiem 6 лет назад +4

      Maybe we didnt watch the same video. There is literally an implosion. It just looks different than bf1. Like??? It literally implodes. Whiney bitches only see what they wanna see.

    • @MrDox90
      @MrDox90 6 лет назад

      It's split frames to see the implosion and the explosion and smoke lasts lot longer, so when gaming it's way more difficult to see. While in the first game i spotted imploders across half the map, easily. Also they left almost no smoke. Thus making it less appealing.

  • @BlackHammerLaz
    @BlackHammerLaz 6 лет назад +261

    Battlefront 2 need to work on them blaster bolts

    • @vincentpalermo3452
      @vincentpalermo3452 6 лет назад +1

      The blaster bolts look like they did in the original trilogy.

    • @vincentpalermo3452
      @vincentpalermo3452 6 лет назад

      Josh Lacey EA's just a shit company, has been since Mass Effect 3.

    • @darkpotat
      @darkpotat 6 лет назад +1

      download cinematic firefights mod.
      www.nexusmods.com/starwarsbattlefront22017/mods/257/?tab=1&navtag=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nexusmods.com%2Fstarwarsbattlefront22017%2Fajax%2Fmoddescription%2F%3Fid%3D257%26preview%3D1

  • @SlavaUkraini85
    @SlavaUkraini85 6 лет назад +54

    why do i have the impression that Battlefront 1 looked better? more vibrant

    • @brukernavn142
      @brukernavn142 3 года назад +10

      Because battlefront 1 used photogrammetry while this was not the case with battlefront 2 nor bf 1 and bf 5

    • @Eva01-jy2qu7pu9r
      @Eva01-jy2qu7pu9r 2 года назад +6

      @@brukernavn142 BF1 actually did I believe. BFV didn't.

    • @erikmueller2651
      @erikmueller2651 2 года назад +2

      @@Eva01-jy2qu7pu9r that's why this game feels incredible ugly and unrealistic

    • @Eva01-jy2qu7pu9r
      @Eva01-jy2qu7pu9r 2 года назад +3

      @@erikmueller2651 For real. I mean seriously that game looked like a soap commercial

    • @erikmueller2651
      @erikmueller2651 2 года назад

      @@Eva01-jy2qu7pu9r yes lmao. Only Narvik looks and feels authentic, nice and realistic.

  • @roboballz9042
    @roboballz9042 6 лет назад +385

    Is it just me or are the guns just better across the board on battlefront 2015? Easier to use imo

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +72

      Yes, less recoil, less spread and lower time to kill.

    • @keendog1293
      @keendog1293 6 лет назад +55

      To be honest I think that BF2 is better in this respect because I feel like gunplay requires more skill with more recoil and more spread, so it makes you want to ADS. But that’s just me

    • @shmexygamer
      @shmexygamer 6 лет назад +7

      And how having no recoil no spread better? Shooters is about shooting ppl and if you dumb down the core element of it like BF2015 did whats the point to even play a shooter?

    • @elishajohnson4788
      @elishajohnson4788 6 лет назад +4

      Nicolas Sigorides That just sounds ridiculous. No recoil or spread takes away from the skill or realism and immersiveness of the game and player. Even games as toony as Fortnite have recoil and spread.

    • @shmexygamer
      @shmexygamer 6 лет назад +3

      Elisha Johnson well say it to ppl who want BF2 to be like BF1 where you had no spread or recoil. I am all up for game to require more skill than just have pretty fcking graphics

  • @cptTK421
    @cptTK421 6 лет назад +150

    My one gripe with the sound design is the E-11's firing sound.
    It should be the one from the OG Battlefronts, which were themselves based on sound used in ANH.
    To me, the original sound communicated power, and made me feel like a badass whenever I used it. Heck, it's part of why I favored the Empire in the second game.
    The A280 is also different, but I don't care as much about that one.

    • @ryleynations6251
      @ryleynations6251 6 лет назад +5

      cptTK421 actually the sound in the battlefront games are accurate, and the OG battlefront is incorrect

    • @shadow-squid4872
      @shadow-squid4872 6 лет назад

      Ryley 18 Basically everything that fires a blaster bolt or even a lightsaber changes the sound throughout the films. I prefer the Rebels blaster sound from the OG Battlefront game. And the Republics DC-15 sound from the OG Battlefront as well

    • @tristanskywalker1998
      @tristanskywalker1998 6 лет назад +2

      Shadowy-Squid 682 Oh god. The Republic blaster rifle sound in the original Battlefront was the most horrid thing to ever assault my eardrums. The DC-15 and DC-15A both actually sound like the movies in the new game. And with regards to the E-11, I also prefer the sound from the original games, as they were based on the original trilogy sounds, but the new E-11 sound gets a pass because it's based on the sound the E-11 makes in Rogue One and is pretty spot-on.

    • @rundc6979
      @rundc6979 4 года назад

      @@tristanskywalker1998 I like the DC-15S Blaster Sound in the Republic Commando game than the ones in the OG battlefronts.

  • @richardched6085
    @richardched6085 6 лет назад +128

    I like the original DH-17 and A280 better in terms of sound effects and rate of fire. I guess I'm just used to the original formula.

    • @22mambo27
      @22mambo27 6 лет назад +3

      Richard Ched in BF2 you actually have 2 A280's. The STG44 looking one, and one that looks like an M4. He showed the m4 looking one.

    • @richardched6085
      @richardched6085 6 лет назад +5

      So we now have 3 versions
      A280-CFE (Cassian's ICWS)
      A280 (STG44 ESB or A295)
      A280 (M4 ROTJ or A280)
      This is exciting thanks for the Info :)

  • @Edgarthepoe
    @Edgarthepoe 6 лет назад +394

    There's something wrong if the E-11 is accurate

    • @brianhlange1
      @brianhlange1 6 лет назад +42

      Henry thecat I agree. Why on the world did they screw that up? It was perfect in the first one. Why mess with it? It just does not sound right anymore. The E-11 is the most iconic laser sound in history. They had it right. Then fucked it up. Why????

    • @geekw.4758
      @geekw.4758 6 лет назад +3

      Brian Lange it sounds exactly the same

    • @brianhlange1
      @brianhlange1 6 лет назад +9

      Geek W. Ummm listen again. It is not the same. The pitch is higher. I didnt say it is completely different, but it is certainly not the same.

    • @Edgarthepoe
      @Edgarthepoe 6 лет назад +13

      The change in pitch is extremely subtle but I would say that it sounds more accurate to the movies in battlefront 2

    • @brian_the_person
      @brian_the_person 6 лет назад

      Henry thecat It is different. Sounds more like the DC-15A put into an E-11.

  • @ilikeheavymuzic135
    @ilikeheavymuzic135 6 лет назад +83

    the funny thing is, if you were to show me these 2 games side by side and ask me which one i wanted to play, without knowing which one was which, id pick battlefront 1 every time. something about it just looks.... better. the visuals, gun animations, everything. im just glad battlefront 2 has more content, star fighter assault is awesome.

    • @PsychoticSorcerer666
      @PsychoticSorcerer666 5 лет назад +1

      All they need to do is give the BF2 blasters the BF1 glow and they're good to go.

  • @Red_Vega
    @Red_Vega 6 лет назад +262

    Some how I’ve enjoyed battlefront 2015 more than battlefront II. Is that just me?

    • @sammy094sbiggestfan2
      @sammy094sbiggestfan2 6 лет назад +40

      You're not alone...
      I want to enjoy the new one... I really do, but I can't and I don't know why. I have over 700 hours on the first one and now I miss it.
      Maybe it was the smaller modes like old HvV and cargo.

    • @ouuu6096
      @ouuu6096 6 лет назад +8

      Red Vega Agreed I went out a bought Battlefront 2015 again and it’s hella fun I’m level 50 in BF2 and it’s just not as fun for some reason

    • @sammy094sbiggestfan2
      @sammy094sbiggestfan2 6 лет назад +19

      It's unfortunate really... I loved the first one and when I saw the second was even better I immediately pre-ordered.
      I think it's the fact the old maps actually seemed to have more care put into them, or the fact the objectives seemed better then compared to now. That's my take atleast.

    • @nathonfleming6631
      @nathonfleming6631 6 лет назад +8

      with all due respect i have to say the gameplay is a lot more fun in the new game (especially classes) and the maps are more complex and fresh. Its just that battlefront as a whole is getting a little old to you i think.

    • @sammy094sbiggestfan2
      @sammy094sbiggestfan2 6 лет назад +7

      Yeah that's fine, it's your opinion and I respect that. I want to share your opinion but I struggle to enjoy the new game.
      Why am I cursed?

  • @Looppehh
    @Looppehh 6 лет назад +53

    Should have put similar lighting in both

  • @robthetallnut6825
    @robthetallnut6825 6 лет назад +55

    does anyone else notice that the first battlefront had more destructible maps.

    • @killhimnotme9129
      @killhimnotme9129 6 лет назад

      CT 4654 whot

    • @richardched6085
      @richardched6085 6 лет назад +3

      CT 4654 yeah... BF1 looked alot better in multiple aspects. Glad I didn't get BF2 lol

    • @TheMason7125
      @TheMason7125 6 лет назад +3

      Richard Ched lol better in what aspects? the maps are insanely detailed in bf2. can't comment on the detail when you havent played.

    • @richardched6085
      @richardched6085 6 лет назад +1

      I've played the Demo and some of the actual game at a friends house. I'm getting the full game for myself in a week. But from what I have seen. BF2 Weapons are better in some ways (Such as Recoil and Kick) But worse in others (Generic Sounds added to iconic sounds, Rate of Fire Nerfed on some weapons) You know the phrase "Can't fix what ain't broke"

    • @robthetallnut6825
      @robthetallnut6825 6 лет назад

      yes the guns ARE better but don't really look better

  • @Scottcels
    @Scottcels 6 лет назад +153

    Say what you want about BF1, but it had wayyy better guns. Everything felt usable and it looked like actual star wars shit

    • @andrewcarpinella1217
      @andrewcarpinella1217 6 лет назад +5

      Scott The Philosopher graphics were WAY better. No one points that out

    • @excelsior8712
      @excelsior8712 6 лет назад +2

      SKULLRAIDER Not really. Look at the graphics comparison from Cinematic Captures.

    • @Andre-pc7hg
      @Andre-pc7hg 6 лет назад +1

      And guns are getting nerf down even more

    • @JoeKingYT
      @JoeKingYT 6 лет назад +2

      Then again no-one saw it, everyone used the OP DL-44 and EE-12.

  • @Jeerin_
    @Jeerin_ 6 лет назад +18

    Battlefront 2015 is looking pretty good right now

    • @Jeerin_
      @Jeerin_ 6 лет назад

      domesticgull51 stfu

    • @smarrkidd5538
      @smarrkidd5538 6 лет назад

      TheGamingGeek you stfu you slimy momma's boy

    • @Jeerin_
      @Jeerin_ 6 лет назад +1

      domesticgull51 all I said is that the older battlefront is looking good right about now wtf is wrong with that?!

    • @smarrkidd5538
      @smarrkidd5538 6 лет назад

      TheGamingGeek dude fuck BF 2015 it's shit that's takes no skill

    • @Jeerin_
      @Jeerin_ 6 лет назад +1

      domesticgull51 yes it does

  • @daeshawnkenway7932
    @daeshawnkenway7932 6 лет назад +254

    In my opinion, battlefront 2 contains more immerse, beautiful maps than its predecessor, but the first contains superior gameplay,and explosions.
    EDIT:I miss when the smart rocket was a Noob tube.

    • @jelleposthuma8786
      @jelleposthuma8786 6 лет назад +3

      daeshawn kenway same

    • @daeshawnkenway7932
      @daeshawnkenway7932 6 лет назад +14

      Not including the hero gameplay, the heros in battlefront 2 are perfect, and the lightsaber duels are amazing

    • @NintendoMaster709
      @NintendoMaster709 6 лет назад +10

      What Battlefront 2 gameplay is much better

    • @Pwng
      @Pwng 6 лет назад +2

      daeshawn kenway cant really call it a duel if its hold L2 to win and if your hero cant youre fucked unless youre maul

    • @daeshawnkenway7932
      @daeshawnkenway7932 6 лет назад +3

      mr-ruiler I'm inclined to disagree, I use luke skywalker and am capable of taking on 4 Heros at once. I'm exempting boba he's a bitch.

  • @clover4522
    @clover4522 5 лет назад +5

    One thing I like to point out, BF2 incorrectly mixed up the name for the A280 variants. The StG-44 style blaster is the A280C, the M16 styled one of the standard A280.

  • @SLim-ih7lq
    @SLim-ih7lq 6 лет назад +129

    Everything just got nerfed?

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +7

      yea

    • @Keiseru
      @Keiseru 6 лет назад +1

      I think they're fine if you spend the countless hours to unlock anti-recoil mods. Did you do the video with mods?

    • @TK-556
      @TK-556 6 лет назад +3

      Dallin N No. How about you actually try playing the game. You unlock attachments via kills with the weapons. First unlock is at 50 kills and is usually a stock to reduce recoil. Then some other stuff at 100 and 200 I believe

    • @danialadzha84
      @danialadzha84 6 лет назад

      +Lecl its 150 and 250

    • @Andre-pc7hg
      @Andre-pc7hg 6 лет назад

      More nerfs are coming

  • @vadernation1233
    @vadernation1233 4 года назад +3

    One thing I like about the orbital strike in BFII compared to BFI is the fact that you can hear canon firing before the actual strike so it feels more like it’s actually summoning in fire from an orbiting ship compared to them just appearing

  • @lokochon2000
    @lokochon2000 6 лет назад +12

    on of the things that really take the immersion out in BF2 is the respawn time, it makes the gameplay less chaotic making it a less enjoyable experience.

    • @faultyblue9934
      @faultyblue9934 6 лет назад +4

      yaquirami 4212 sometimes it’s the reason why you lose objectives, because nobody is spawning in to stop the enemy team

    • @lokochon2000
      @lokochon2000 6 лет назад

      Faulty Blue yes, sometimes 10 seconds of respawn is too much and now you cant respawn with a buddy near yo the Battlefield, you always respawn far away from the objective.

    • @TheKingOfPunk
      @TheKingOfPunk Год назад

      That's nothing compared to cross era heroes, blasters, and snowtroopers on every planet. Makes the game feel like a nihilistic joke. The first game was a lot more immersive, despite having only one era.

    • @BuzzingMeat
      @BuzzingMeat 10 месяцев назад

      ⁠​⁠@@TheKingOfPunkyes, because everyone using jetpacks, cross era guns, and death trooper in the first one is immersive

    • @TheKingOfPunk
      @TheKingOfPunk 10 месяцев назад

      @@BuzzingMeat There was no cross era blasters in the first game. You could be a rebel carrying an E-11 but that’s still era accurate. Death Troopers would only spawn when and If Krennic was on the map. How is that worse than making them reinforcements? I’ll admit that you’re right about Jump Packs, that’s something I never liked about the first game and made no sense. But that’s not nearly as bad as Rey fighting Grievous on Hoth, cross era blasters, and extremely out of place skins. Both games suck anyway so why bother arguing about failed reboots? You can trash them as much as you want. I don’t care.

  • @Militaryman64
    @Militaryman64 6 лет назад

    Great comparisons thanks for putting this together.

  • @kaetce
    @kaetce 6 лет назад +116

    Lol so they ruined The a280C BADLY

    • @ant2539
      @ant2539 6 лет назад

      michael cooper what do your mean

    • @ant2539
      @ant2539 6 лет назад

      michael cooper which cooling card

    • @ant2539
      @ant2539 6 лет назад

      michael cooper okay thankss

    • @kash45
      @kash45 4 года назад

      And the dh-17

    • @MrSchplingle79
      @MrSchplingle79 3 года назад

      Seriously, it was a solid gun in Battlefront 1, but you couldn't pay me to use it in 2

  • @prickly10000
    @prickly10000 6 лет назад +35

    Battlefront (2015) DLT- 19X: *Bang! Overheats* .... Well OK Its a sniper rifle.
    Battlefront 2 (2017) DLT- 19X: F!@#$ THAT SH!#!!! *BANG! BANG! BANG! BANG! BANG!*

    • @azrael2435
      @azrael2435 6 лет назад +1

      It was really weak in the old game.

    • @NedranMusic
      @NedranMusic 6 лет назад +2

      Sniper rifles were shitty and frustrating in the first game. You couldn't oneshot someone without shooting him in the head (I'm okay with that) but with the immediate overheats, you could'nt shoot anymore and the ennemy just had to hide and wait to recover his health. Now you can finally kill with a sniper rifle and it's not that easy, it's just more balanced. It shoots faster but do less damage, you need three hits in the body to kill or one in the head. I prefer that instead of "Whoops, finally touched him but in the body, well let him run I can't shoot anymore !"

    • @cooper_s
      @cooper_s 6 лет назад

      Nedran
      You could just use the T-21B in the first game, which functions similarly to the default snipers in the second one, killing in three hits and whatnot.

  • @firstnameandlastnameples9570
    @firstnameandlastnameples9570 6 лет назад +4

    Awesome :D Thanks for doing this.

  • @xShoshin
    @xShoshin 6 лет назад

    Impressive video for a channel this small, I subscribed keep up the good work!

  •  6 лет назад +8

    Am I the only one who find BF 2015 was more beatiful than BF 2017? look at light or texture on Tatooine :/

  • @WIC47
    @WIC47 6 лет назад +220

    I don't like what they did to the sounds, they don't really sound like they did in the movies anymore

    • @rocklobster5612
      @rocklobster5612 6 лет назад +36

      C. Hocolate you’re toxic internet trash with nothing of value in your comments

    • @truegamers5010
      @truegamers5010 6 лет назад +2

      Set course for the Hosnian system, bitch.

    • @ReviveHF
      @ReviveHF 6 лет назад +8

      Some of the Battlefront 2 sound effects are actually recycled from Battlefield 3/4.

    • @bruhtholemew
      @bruhtholemew 6 лет назад +2

      Grand Moff Tarkin That's awful

    • @makoro9161
      @makoro9161 6 лет назад +2

      C. Hocolate im fucking dead

  • @barackobama0101
    @barackobama0101 6 лет назад +67

    I love all Guns from the frist game. A280 was so good, now IT looks like shit

    • @Dame.1k
      @Dame.1k 6 лет назад

      Dumbass ,that’s how it supposed to look though

    • @geekw.4758
      @geekw.4758 6 лет назад +5

      thats because they're using an A280C which is based off the M16, rather than the A280 which is based off the STG44

    • @barackobama0101
      @barackobama0101 6 лет назад

      NFINITY XTRA fuckface That's why I wrote that it looked like crap because it was a completely different version from the very beginning

    • @renatabanks3751
      @renatabanks3751 6 лет назад

      The a280c was based off the sturnqgewere? Wow...

    • @Andre-pc7hg
      @Andre-pc7hg 6 лет назад +2

      Now more nerfs are coming. This game is going to be so unpopular because of these nerds that suck

  • @RenagadesSW3
    @RenagadesSW3 Год назад +2

    The affects look way better in the first game! And there's something about the movement in the first one that look way better

  • @theelectricscar
    @theelectricscar 4 года назад +15

    I feel like I enjoyed the gunplay and graphics in Battlefront 2015 much more than battlefront 2, but In Battlefront 2 the characters in third person look much cooler and are aesthetically pleasing. Keep in mind this is my own opinion, and battlefront 2 does have a few improvements, like starfighter gameplay, but overall the special effects in battlefront 2015 were much smoother, clearer and satisfying.

    • @Shot5hells
      @Shot5hells Год назад

      Battlefront 2015 is so much more polished and they really perfectly nailed the atmosphere. Battlefront II feels like playing battlefield 1 but less satisfying. I think the issue the first game had was that it didn’t include a lot of content and had quite a narrow focus, whereas with the second game it feels like there was too much stuff for them to handle making to the same standard within whatever time limits they had and with at the time peaking poohole EA micromanagement. I still think bf2 is great, and it definitely feels more intense and immersive with the battles to me, but if it was more finely tuned and crafted like the first game I’d be playing it a lot more than I do. At the moment I’m designing a Star Wars character for my concept design degree so I’ve been into it again, I actually got here trying to find out why the ‘default’ DC15a in bf2 is smaller than the unlockable one lol.

  • @fudgeitweball
    @fudgeitweball 6 лет назад +16

    You forgot the scatter gun/vanguard. I was waiting for that one in the whole video.

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +4

      I wasn't able to compare those due to technical issues.

    • @HastelloyC276
      @HastelloyC276 6 лет назад

      Tf2?

    • @alexbibby9641
      @alexbibby9641 3 года назад

      t 21 should be here, used by republic troopers and imperials/rebels

  • @Dkoolpharaoh
    @Dkoolpharaoh 6 лет назад +5

    I got both battlefronts but I think the first one is still more fun and gives off great memories plus I feel like I have to stay in third person for bf2

  • @william_brobrine8975
    @william_brobrine8975 4 года назад +5

    The gun play felt better in the first game imo every gun felt unique and I feel like I could actually hit my shots in battlefront 2 I feel like I'm missing more than actually hitting something

  • @marissaawesome2422
    @marissaawesome2422 6 лет назад +197

    Hate weapons in this new game..Seems it takes alot more shots to kill someone for sure..

    • @joaquincollet4291
      @joaquincollet4291 6 лет назад +2

      Marissa A i agree

    • @jared8019
      @jared8019 6 лет назад +2

      Marissa A it emphasizes headshots bruv

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад +25

      You're right the time to kill is a lot higher in this game.

    • @ArtistXXX
      @ArtistXXX 6 лет назад +1

      Marissa A I gess they make them like that so is fair when you fight as or against a Jedi.

    • @shmexygamer
      @shmexygamer 6 лет назад +7

      TheDevilsMessenger4 what? Ever tried doing headshots?

  • @koolbeans3572
    @koolbeans3572 6 лет назад +21

    Why would EA change the DH-17 :( that was my second favorite gun

  • @maxsainz2279
    @maxsainz2279 6 лет назад +51

    So they upped the recoil... Nice...

  • @christopherkeller6367
    @christopherkeller6367 3 года назад

    The orbital strike sound in the second one is a cool addition

  • @ltnagle2492
    @ltnagle2492 6 лет назад +2

    7:58 looks beautiful with the battle above.

  • @linerdad4991
    @linerdad4991 6 лет назад +42

    I find battlefront is better than battlefront2

  • @caseybarrett8352
    @caseybarrett8352 6 лет назад +5

    why does 2017 version look exactly the same if not worse

  • @cadror26
    @cadror26 6 лет назад

    That "OW" at 3:30 really sells it.

  • @squooshy2999
    @squooshy2999 3 года назад

    bro that orbital strike looked so good in the first one
    in the second one it was litterally just
    LASERS FROM SKY

  • @rev927
    @rev927 6 лет назад +49

    Why all this blasters looks downgraded

    • @gabe3531
      @gabe3531 6 лет назад +5

      Capture_ifaviation doungraded? Lol check YOUR grammar

    • @Assterix
      @Assterix 6 лет назад

      pay2win, you can upgrade everything with your credit card ;)

    • @overthrower5453
      @overthrower5453 6 лет назад

      Because the game requires more skill this time around, instead of picking up any weapon and destroying with it regardless of skill.

  • @JimmyWebs
    @JimmyWebs 6 лет назад +18

    last clip - what's the desert maps with walkers and orbital strike? O_o

  • @magma728
    @magma728 6 лет назад

    Strange that no one else has mentioned it but in the first battlefront they seemed to have put much more time into the visuals which is probably why there was such a lack of content in it as well, at least we have more than a handful of maps now

  • @Malteasers
    @Malteasers 6 лет назад

    If you go all the way back you'll notice that the TL-50 sounds like that minigun the rodians use in The Force Unleashed

  • @akramouru3443
    @akramouru3443 6 лет назад +15

    Damn even Bf1 looks better than Bf2. WTF!?

    • @YB--iy8nh
      @YB--iy8nh 4 года назад

      Na this guy just intentionally got the ugliest footage he could

  • @angiesbabies1
    @angiesbabies1 6 лет назад +6

    Personally i like the first ones more don’t judge

  • @OBSDCC7
    @OBSDCC7 5 лет назад

    Looking back, I still prefer the new blaster bolt sizes but the old ones look a lot more vibrant and I like that more. I’d love a mix of both

  • @kiggeh
    @kiggeh 6 лет назад

    Cool video! :)

  • @tjp_real
    @tjp_real 6 лет назад +54

    The weapons in Battlefront 2 looks and sound like regular guns. This realy sucks. Takes away from the star wars feeling.

    • @ruinedflipper7387
      @ruinedflipper7387 6 лет назад +3

      TJP Real They all look the same what the hell are you talking about?

    • @tjp_real
      @tjp_real 6 лет назад +5

      Ok my bad, I meant the bullets.

    • @a.hauptmann8798
      @a.hauptmann8798 6 лет назад +2

      TJP Real Wow, bullets in Star Wars. What a fucking noob.

    • @panzerrjcb
      @panzerrjcb 6 лет назад

      actually all star wars weapons are all based on real life guns like the german ww2 mg-34 and british sterling smg for the E-11 imperial standard blaster. You can clearly see the magazine port in some guns and some even have the receiver handler.

    • @tjp_real
      @tjp_real 6 лет назад

      The Imperial Navy tell that DICE,they made the gunshots look like bullets.

  • @Al3x10_
    @Al3x10_ 6 лет назад +16

    1rst have better graphics the 2nd is more realistic and you can play as a clone 👍

  • @SashaMasonVR
    @SashaMasonVR 5 лет назад

    Gotta love how the default assault blaster is pretty much a 1:1 copy of the E-11 from the first game

  • @adamxo9999
    @adamxo9999 3 года назад +1

    5:23 I love the thermal imploder sounds

  • @phairecouchpotato3912
    @phairecouchpotato3912 6 лет назад +18

    As of December 23rd, 2017, Battlefront 2 (EA) is still in beta

    • @thy_tomali1856
      @thy_tomali1856 6 лет назад +3

      Phaire Couchpotato You realize the game was released more than 3 weeks ago, right? Beta ended a long time ago

    • @tallestred8245
      @tallestred8245 6 лет назад

      vickie o'malley i think he's making fun of the people that tried to defend the game

    • @phairecouchpotato3912
      @phairecouchpotato3912 6 лет назад +2

      Vivkie, the game is not finished yet, it still has many months left to go.
      Negative, I'm not making fun of people, I'm just making a statement.
      Please understand that I want this game to succeed however, at the moment I cannot recommend to anyone to buy the game because it feels unfinished

    • @tallestred8245
      @tallestred8245 6 лет назад

      Phaire Couchpotato honestly, i want the game to succeed too but, EA has always made their games feel unfinished and then release the rest as dlc.(i know all dlc is free)

    • @WintorOperator
      @WintorOperator  6 лет назад

      They'll finish the game in 12 months. Look at the bright side, the updates are free. :)

  • @XxBlackCellxX
    @XxBlackCellxX 6 лет назад +5

    I'm pretty positive they took shooting from battlefield one and changed the way it looked so save money. I liked the shooting mechanics in the first one a ton more

  • @Assassin-eh3du
    @Assassin-eh3du 6 лет назад

    It's beginning to look like a lot of loot creates everywhere you go-Christmas in Star Wars battlefront 2

  • @MrSHURIKENCHO
    @MrSHURIKENCHO 5 лет назад

    Hot damn - the orbital strike in 1 looks fucking cinematic AF!

  • @andresgonzalezcorona7876
    @andresgonzalezcorona7876 6 лет назад +12

    Apparently Battlefront 1 is better than 2 in all the graphics

    • @canarioobediente92
      @canarioobediente92 6 лет назад

      exactly

    • @SolentSam
      @SolentSam 6 лет назад

      i don't fucking get it, i never played bf1 but i think the layout of the things look shit bf2 is so much better, from the graphics to the gameplay...

    • @IP_Films01
      @IP_Films01 6 лет назад +1

      Lol no. BF1 is so disorganized and it promotes camping to get tokens while BF2 requires u to actually play to get vehicles and heroes

    • @SolentSam
      @SolentSam 6 лет назад +1

      IP Films totally agree...

    • @harryliston2631
      @harryliston2631 6 лет назад +1

      Finally someone agrees with me

  • @sgtpaloogoo2811
    @sgtpaloogoo2811 6 лет назад +18

    Looks like most of the guns do basically the same thing

    • @tevcon317
      @tevcon317 6 лет назад +5

      Sgt Palooggoo they all shoot lasers

  • @kekegenkamaru
    @kekegenkamaru 5 лет назад

    B1 looks like they took their time to detail it.

  • @mox195
    @mox195 6 лет назад +1

    Melee in the new one looks great

  • @jcdenton1454
    @jcdenton1454 6 лет назад +307

    lol you missed every shot cant even aim

  • @MikMoen
    @MikMoen 6 лет назад +5

    The new overheat sound is annoying and unnecessary. That skybox in the old Jakku map looks fantastic. It almost feels like the new game was a downgrade..

  • @cameronh2457
    @cameronh2457 6 лет назад

    The bf 2 orbital strike looks dope

  • @zcplayer1
    @zcplayer1 6 лет назад

    Why some weapons still have charging handle and magazine releaser even bullet feeding port when they all use energy or laser gun?

  • @akramouru3443
    @akramouru3443 6 лет назад +54

    There just making BF2 more casual than BF1. It takes more melees to take down an enemy, and the fighters are way more slower..... It's disgusting

    • @banita9448
      @banita9448 6 лет назад +14

      Fighters are slower? Didn't see that. Flying is way more fun in Battlefront 2 and not so boring

    • @DDDiego
      @DDDiego 6 лет назад +8

      I think the fighters are better in Battlefront 2017 mainly because now you have to have good aim to take fighters down instead of just holding a button to lock on an enemy

    • @markuscraig7945
      @markuscraig7945 6 лет назад

      Akram Ouru casual wtf nigga im still going for them bitch ass star cards to max and I play a lot casual wont get to my level unless they pay for it which sucks

    • @viktorceder4985
      @viktorceder4985 6 лет назад +3

      So you think more effort means more casual? Fuck outta here

    • @eshurkaev8028
      @eshurkaev8028 6 лет назад

      Dreadlord Sinister You tell 'em

  • @Ahziu
    @Ahziu 4 года назад +4

    Is it me or is battlefront 1 waaayyyy better

  • @ReedyJRsup
    @ReedyJRsup 6 лет назад +1

    I love how the battle of Jakku is far more detailed in the first game XD

  • @KoljaBeckmann_music
    @KoljaBeckmann_music 6 лет назад

    Bro, what machine are you running these on. Looks better than on my 1060.

  • @DollaKamalaSwalla
    @DollaKamalaSwalla 6 лет назад +56

    2015: Pay to get the other half of this weapon in 6 months
    2017: Pay to MAYBE get the weapon that will allow you to beat everyone regardless of skill

    • @jhayrcampoy
      @jhayrcampoy 6 лет назад +4

      Randy Stalcup but it's progressive with getting weapon kills unless you're talking about the star card weapons, then yes

    • @lugit36
      @lugit36 6 лет назад +3

      Weapons come in crates?

    • @manuel_k791
      @manuel_k791 6 лет назад +15

      2005: Play and have fun

    • @JN-ug5ky
      @JN-ug5ky 6 лет назад +2

      Lugit36 i you are lucky, yes. I got the final heavy gun, the TL-50 heavy repeater in one of the hero creates.

    • @lugit36
      @lugit36 6 лет назад +1

      Jan Philip LUCKY I WANT THAT GUN SO BAD

  • @CamoflaugeDinosaue
    @CamoflaugeDinosaue 6 лет назад +7

    Gosh Battlefront 1 looked so much better.
    Explosions seemed to have gotten twice as big and violent, yet they don't do any more (seemingly less) damage. It makes it so unsatisfying. Blaster bolts look like shit/don't exist.
    Mood lighting in BF1 was done artistically and with care, lighting in BF2 is washed out and lazy with glaring contrast and exposure issues that make everything impossible to see.

    • @lokochon2000
      @lokochon2000 6 лет назад +1

      Kevin B yes, BF1 maps were beautifull to see, but bf2 looks Terrible specially kashyyyk thats the worse map ever, i cant see shit while playing it.

    • @CamoflaugeDinosaue
      @CamoflaugeDinosaue 6 лет назад +1

      Yep. Their obsession with overusing fog/particle effects/lens flares/spastic camera exposure turned it into visual chaos.

  • @orifolatakryshtmor3631
    @orifolatakryshtmor3631 5 лет назад

    Some one more notes that EA BFs blasters sounds more like new Halos sound than classic SW blaster sounds?

  • @tardarsauce1842
    @tardarsauce1842 3 года назад

    I like how many weapons from the Star Wars Universe are heavily inspired from WWII era weapons

  • @canarioobediente92
    @canarioobediente92 6 лет назад +5

    why did star wars bf1 has better graphics than bf2?

  • @Radio_SSB
    @Radio_SSB 6 лет назад +49

    Good meme

  • @Mr.E22
    @Mr.E22 6 лет назад

    Bf2 should’ve included all original guns from bf1 in the initial launch just for the sake of making the game so much bigger. Really liked using the t-21 heavy blaster and t-12 blaster pistol. And the Bo rifle was sick as fuck with that melee electrocution

  • @themoderndaygamer637
    @themoderndaygamer637 6 лет назад

    Also why can’t I choose my gun in this new game ? Like I want to be able to choose the shotgun with a heavy and just have fun but it won’t let me

  • @speedertank2171
    @speedertank2171 6 лет назад +8

    The classic battlefronts did it better.

  • @Andrew22
    @Andrew22 6 лет назад +9

    I’m high and this is really fucking cool

  • @patientzero6075
    @patientzero6075 5 лет назад

    I like the look of everything in both Battlefronts i only wish that we could have had larger maps and more control over the vehicles like in Battlefront 2 2005

  • @aljgaming3368
    @aljgaming3368 6 лет назад +2

    The explosions in battlefront 1 looks better than 2. At least I think it does

  • @cameronguy3964
    @cameronguy3964 6 лет назад +4

    Why did they nerf the DH17

    • @Andre-pc7hg
      @Andre-pc7hg 6 лет назад

      Now CR2, Blurg, Super Charged Sentry, Wookie Warrior is getting nerf

  • @phairecouchpotato3912
    @phairecouchpotato3912 6 лет назад +5

    There should be Faction weapons in Battlefront 2
    I hate cross era weapons
    Seeing battle-droids with First order weapons is Immersion breaking!!!!!!

    • @vincentpalermo3452
      @vincentpalermo3452 6 лет назад +2

      Phaire Couchpotato It's meant to be fun, not canonical.

    • @TheyWantMeGone69
      @TheyWantMeGone69 6 лет назад

      Vincent Palermo canonical can be fun. Clones vs Droids for example is canon but it's fun.

  • @despeckt
    @despeckt 3 месяца назад +1

    the sound of the DLT-19 got nerf on battlefront 2 lol

  • @lecart6796
    @lecart6796 6 лет назад

    You guys need to try the flash pistol and the ca87 in BF2 they are amazing

  • @spygearman
    @spygearman 6 лет назад +265

    Battlefront: "pulls RT" "Shoots"
    Battlefront 2: "pulls RT" "5000000000000000 XP required to unlock the free 'Shoot' DLC".

  • @RaidriarTheRadicalKing
    @RaidriarTheRadicalKing 6 лет назад +5

    What bout the real battlefronts

    • @ordersquamata930
      @ordersquamata930 6 лет назад

      PISS True.

    • @scottkrafft6830
      @scottkrafft6830 6 лет назад +1

      To be honest though I like the new Battlefront 2 more than the old ones. (Wait! Hear me out!) The old ones just look like complete shit now. It's at that point where it's not old enough to be retro but it's way to old to be modern. Second it seemed too linear; capture points. That was it. I like having something else to do rather than just do the same thing in a different spot. Thirdly, it obviously doesn't have the Resistance or First Order as the prequel trilogy wasn't even fully out yet. I'm not gonna count that as too much against it hence that's why it's third, but come on! That's 1/3 of Star Wars completely missing! Don't get me wrong, I loved the originals, but I like the new ones a lot more. They have more content, they're more fun, and they look MUCH better.

    • @RaidriarTheRadicalKing
      @RaidriarTheRadicalKing 6 лет назад +3

      The only thing better bout the new ones are the graffics

  • @mattthedestroyer2804
    @mattthedestroyer2804 6 лет назад +1

    Best graphics and sounds in a gam Ive seen yet

  • @-Seeker-
    @-Seeker- 6 лет назад

    Why was the A280C changed from the STG-44 to the AR-15?

  • @MuffinManProductions3D
    @MuffinManProductions3D 6 лет назад +6

    I dont think you're playing battlefront 2 on ultra, so you can't really do a comparison...

    • @adam_4079
      @adam_4079 6 лет назад +1

      Yeah because bf2 does not look that terrible

    • @XxBlackCellxX
      @XxBlackCellxX 6 лет назад +3

      It's less about the way it looks but the overall mechanic. Swbf1 was more like shooting blasters while swbf2 is more like shooting guns that look like blasters

    • @MuffinManProductions3D
      @MuffinManProductions3D 6 лет назад +2

      I was talking more about the explosions and effects

  • @PooSkidd
    @PooSkidd 6 лет назад +13

    Pls everyone go back to battlefront 1

  • @ALilCancer
    @ALilCancer 29 дней назад

    Wait a sec. How did you get to call down an orbital strike onto an ATAT in BF2?

  • @kjartankariivarsson9927
    @kjartankariivarsson9927 6 лет назад +1

    Is Chewbacca the only person that can have a thermal imploder in battlefront 2? I really want to be able to use it as a trooper.

    • @piotrjasinski2130
      @piotrjasinski2130 2 года назад

      only wookiee warrior can use thermal imploder in Battlefront 2