Thanks to shaykh hamza yusuf and shaykh abdullah hakim murad, among other great shaykhs, in the UK and around the world, for your explanation as they make so much sense...
Allah knows best how many countless people are helped by this event over the centuries. How many people are awakened by this event non Muslims and Muslims.
How pathetic is it that on a video talking about the Prophet's birth pbuh, people come here arguing against each other. If you think it's bidah and we're going to burn for loving him on Mawlid, then leave us alone. Allah will decide.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x I suggest you acquaint yourself on the fiqh behind types of Bidah. There are "good" and "bad" bidahs as elaborated by the likes of Imam Shafi. Taraweeh is a bidah. Making the quran into an organized written manuscript is bidaah. Using an electronic microphone for azaan is bidaah.
@@AntiKaratekid Exaaaactly, they just don't love Allah man. If they loved Allah, they would celebrate his servent and messenger, Mohammed (habib Allah).
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x i agree that you shouldn’t leave a muslim alone with sin, however in this instance there is ikhtilaf among the ulama about the mawlid.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5xok so if I make dhikr 500 times or 5000 then according to your understanding of the Hadith I’ve performed a bid3 that will be considered dolala
What Sh. Hamza Yusuf is saying about Dr. Tim Winters being rarified is so true. One only needs to read his book the Eleventh Contentions. It is so beautifully written and covers so many topics from marriage to Palestine, all built on a sense of taqwa and sincerity. From the book: 43. Use words in your preaching only if absolutely necessary. 44. Academic Islamic Studies is as foolish as it is because we are as foolish as we are.
Ou ou ou, your mawlid is blessed? Says who? I dont think so, because if it was blessed the first 3 generations would do it more than you. And if someone is a wahhabi for you when hes working against bidaah than ALHAMDULILLAH that we are Wahhabis according to you...than we are on the right path
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x So what the first 3 generations didn't do it? That doesn't make it wrong or haram, use your logic and common sense. This is an act of love, if you love your wife, you would celebrate her birth. If you love your prophet, you would celebrate his birth......simple.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x ahlul bidah this ahlul bidah that. There’s bid3a even amongst those of the wahabiya brother and there’s bid3a amongst the sufiya. As long as one does not have the intellect of a retarded donkey they should be fine and able to veer away from it bi idhn Allah.
You are right we should remember Allah's greatest blessing to the World everyday, not just one day but the reality is, most of us don't. So at least this day is a good way of reminding those who don't remember the Prophet(pbuh) at all or very little. There is no harm in it but goodness for those who know not the Messenger(pbuh) as the Sahaba knew him(pbuh). Which I believe is most of us nowadays, it seems as we are moving away from the Prophet (pbuh) because so much misinformation about the Blessed Messenger (pbuh) of Allah. Our youth are fed lies about the Final Messenger(pbuh) so perhaps this can be a way of calling them back. Don’t worry about Milad worry about the real issues, fornication, haraam, fraud, drugs, illicit relationships outside of marriage and extremism.
For those people who confess to be muslims, remember one thing. If you fail to understand the true status of our noble Prophet (saw) then there is no way in this universe u'll ever become a 'muqarybeen' i.e. close to Allah. And if ur happy being a mere believer, then there is no way u'll ever get 2 taste the spiritual ecstacy of being close to Allah.The door way 2 Allah can only b entered if u give our beautiful prophet (saw) the respect which Allah accorded him that of 'Insaan-al-Kamil'.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x the technology used to wake up for ibadah. How about creating the 3, 4 FRIDAY PRAYERS I SAME MOSQUE. EID PRAYERS WERE DONE ON GROUNDS NOW THEY ARE DONE I MOSQUES. NEW INNOVATION THE HAJJ WILL BE DONE IN A BUILDING INSTEAD OF TENTS. O TOP OF ONE ANOTHER. THERE IS A SERO S WHICH HUNAN KIND HAS MADE FOR EASE BUT THE ONLY BIDDAH THAT COMES TO PEOPLE'S MIND IS ASSOCIATED WITH LOVE AND RESPECT.
those who say oh birthdays, prophet never did birthdays, right but he did hint towards his birth being a specially day by his own tongue and it is narrated : Abu Qatada al-Ansari narrates in Sahih Muslim, Kitab as-siyam, that the Prophet was asked about the fast of Monday, and he answered: "That is the day that I was born and that is the day I received the prophecy." its but obvious the prophet of Allah wasnt gonna cut a cake, but was only gonna do shukar, that being his style :) salam
@SayfAlMujahid99 i will upload a video soon insha'Allah on extreme sufism, although tassawuf is fundemental in islam we should be careful as their are many ott sufi's out ther and this deen is a deen of balance.
@SayfAlMujahid99 Yeh i read the deobandi position on this and i was very much inclined towards it and i agree with it mostly. But also i think there is nothing wrong with getting together on such a day to discuss or praise the messenger of Allah (saw) as long as people dont go over the top.
I myself have gone to deobandi mosque since childhood as its near my house...but recently i came to know of certain of its founders believes...its not as if the muslim who go there to pray adopt those corrupted believes...no one (normal muslims) actually knows about it...the problem is with certain elders among deobandi ulema who defend certain of the founders believes ....but now i am a bit shock and confused....but i am free from such belief....i will soon learn aqeedah at tahawiya
door of misguidance. They said: "By Allah oh Abdur Rahman we intended only to do good". He (AbdurRahman) said: " And how many are those who intend to do good but do not achieve that goal!.." Peace to all sincere seekers who puts the intellect before that of "humanistic, so called feelings". Oh muslims hold on to the guidance of the one who said: "There is nothing that brings you closer to Jannah exept that I have told you about it & there is nothing that brings you to Jahannam exept that i
@safi456 Bro, no one ever suggested to make this the only day. We do it everyday, with extra effort on sacred days such as Ramadan etc. Just because we try harder some days does not devalue the others. That being said ask yourself: On mawlid when people are out thanking Allah in masjids and gatherings for the Messenger (saw) and you're in your house, which of the two groups is Allah's favor really with?
Assalamu alaykum w rahmatullahi w baraktuh, For all the brothers are celebrating the prophet's (SAW) please watch the following video by Salim bin Sa'd Al-Taweel who talks about the ways we should worship Allah like he wants to be worshipped. May Allah guide us all. Please make dua that may Allah guide me.
@DopePatriot i am not a wahabi, but what you must understand my honoured friend is that we acknowledge that they are there and we will just have to tolerate them, as sufism and islam teachers love and tolerance
Unfortunately most of you don't seem to know the passing date of our Beloved Master (s.a.w.s.); he passed away on Rabialawwal 12, just like he was born and finalized his hijrah exactly on the same date. SO: a vast majority of the sahaba (radiyallahu anhum) were not old enough to remember, and therefore, celebrate his birth! Maybe Abu Kuhafa, but there were only a handful of them. So, the sahaba didn't have anything to celebrate; R.awwal 12 was the worst day for them! Let's not miss this point.
@ali12147: Mawlid is a very common practice in our part of the world: Senegambia and very spiritually fulfilling. It is only recently I heard people critizing it and considering it shirk on the claim that the Prophet (SAW) had never done it and as such an "innovation".
@peaceANDislam You see the issue is that if i start bringing evidences (which their are many) to support such actions then i could but i wont because we aint scholars. U bring up the classical issue of innovation which is very real buthas to be understood properly. Use intellect, not emotion. The point is that stop flooding the page with comments that cause confusion and dont watch such people or videos if you disagree with them. Otherwise i'll just delete your comments.
Its more important to follow the Prophets sunnah, then to celebrate his birth. Not to disregard the fact it is fardh to send salawat onto Muhammad saw. I think its extremely important to remember Rasoolullah every day of my life whether its on his birthday or not! But to set a specific day aside and to celebrate his birth when our Prophet never prescribed us to do so and neither did the sahabah ever do such a thing, i feel like its going too far. Please correct me if I am wrong. jazakhallah.
@peaceANDislam Nobody justifies going to bars or any of the other practices that u seem to be attributing to certain scholars. Also if u feel praising the messenger of Allah saw is an evil act then May Allah ta'ala guide you.
@MrGrandDragon Well thats your personal opinion, but it isnt a matter of trying to hard. If an english person embraces islam they still have aspects of their culture and heritage embedded in them. So if they want to utilize these in a halal way then good for them. Im sure chinese or african muslims have their own nasheeds which i may dislike but thats what bring them closer to their Lord so be it.
@ saminashaikhsyed shirk is to attribute or remove something to the worship of Allah, a birthday doesnt fall in that category and if we are questioning Abdul Hakim Murad and Sh Hamza Yusuf, well then we know someone who is a bigger scholar then them or we are convinced with, what comes from our passion :(
Loving the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, implies keeping his sunnah alive, adhering firmly to it, and avoiding words and deeds that go against it. Undoubtedly everything that goes against his sunnah is a reprehensible innovation (bid'ah) and a manifest act of disobedience. That includes celebrating his birthday and other kinds of bid'ah. A good intention does not mean that it is permissible to introduce innovations into the religion. Islam is based on two things, purity of intention and following [the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him]. Allah says (interpretation of the meaning), "Yes, but whoever submits his face (himself) to Allah and he is a Muhsin (a doer of good) then his reward is with his Lord (Allah), on such shall be no fear, nor shall they grieve." [Al-Qur'an 2:112] Submitting one's face to Allah means being sincere towards Allah, and doing good means following the Messenger and implementing the sunnah.
Lets not mistake this to be a bid'ah because its not being treated as a day of specific worship like eid ul fitr or eid ul adha. Its just a day that we try to recognise to be significant and be thankful that the prophet was born and that we're from his Ummah. To be honest, just to have a reminder about his description on this day of the year is not an innovation, rather its just a tool that we could use. An innovation would be like having a khutba and an extra 2 rakaa during the day like we would in the prescribed days of eid. This is not the case. (sorry this was just a logical conjecture to think about, this is really the issue of the fuqaha. May allah forgive me if im wrong).
Completey disagreeing with that celeberating mawlid is bidah...thats wrong bcz he peace be upon him told us that he did fast on MONDAY bcz he was born on that day. SubhanAllah. Alhumdulillah
to show our love for the Prophet we dont celebrate his birthday, we follow his teachings and emulate his character. when my children obey my command or follow what i have taught them, for me that is the best form of love and shukr, not when they celebrate my birthday. our sahaba never celebrated rasulullah's birthday, yet they would have laid down their lives without hesitation for him. and if we wish to celebrate his greatness, why on a fixed day? why not any day of the year? why ritualise it?
Following inclinations is something to be weary about. There's mention of not distinguishing between any of the messengers alayhum salam. This brothers intentions are probably good but he is speaking about something that's not mentioned in Al Quran and there for it's not accepted as certainty.
@SayfAlMujahid99 so is taraweeh prayers in ramadan brother...that doesnt mean u dont pray them. mawlid is proven quran and ahadith. please listen to both of these videos again.
@peaceANDislam Do you get bored on a monthly basis which makes you come and watch this video that you despise and then you write a comment expressing how much you despise it, lol. What is wrong with you man.
Someone who follows in righteousness as he didn't do Mawlid as the verse states. 9:100 And the foremost to embrace Islam of the Muhajirun (those who migrated from Makkah to Al-Madinah) and the Ansar (the citizens of Al-Madinah who helped and gave aid to the Muhajirun ) and also those who followed them exactly (in Faith). Allah is ... Spelling eras are all you can talk about and verses aren't gud enough, you in deep trouble in Allah's religion. Surah 2 says have no doubt the Quran is guidance!
Remember ever soul is accountable for their action. And remember there is no such thing as good innovation in religion. Allah has completed this religion if you do an act of deed which was not prescribe and act on while thinking you will be reward will only throw one in hell.
5:3 This day, those who disbelieved have given up all hope of your religion; so fear them not, but fear Me. This day, I have perfected your religion for you, completed My Favour upon you, and have chosen for you Islam as your religion. But as for him who is forced by severe hunger, with no inclination to sin (such can eat these above mentioned meats), then surely, Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful. Islam is perfect stop imitating kufar's pagan ignorance in celebrating b-days!!!!
@kamelz86 And surley these people seems to be very nice people. But for a persons actions to count on yawmil qiyaamah the have to be according to THE Sunnah and not the christian one. Why don't we all gather on every new years eve to sing a song of praise for the sahaabah and the messenger? Becuse it's not legislated in islam so it becomes bid'ah since it's a form of worship, (even though you maight #feel# it's nice it's still bid'ah and every bid'ah.....
Wat things done in mawlid are against sunnah?we recite durood,recite poem,recite quran and seerah and express joy and happiness cooking food...all are according to shariah ....yes i agree there are people who free mix thats another issue
The term "sufism" didn't exist until the advent of Wahabism & the babies it gave birth to. It should be known that 'sufism' is a derogatory term used for the followers of Ahelul-Sunna-Wa-Jamah. If u examine the contemporary belief system of Ahlel Sunna & cross-referenced it witht the life style of the Sahaba (AJ) then they'd b classed as 'Sufis' too. Neo-salafis et al have made it their life time mission to deliberately misunderstand the true charachter of our magnificent master Muhammad (saw).
Lol wat logic is this....the saudi forcefully took the two holy cities ...yes ofc by Allah will...but it does not mean that they are on truth....by your logic u can say the pagan of pre islamic were on truth thats why Allah gave the haram to them lol...
Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him had never celebrated his birthday even after the revelation neither his companions. Despite the good intentions behind the idea of Mawlid but it's still considered among the majority of scholars a bedaa.
U are just repeating the same sentence that the wahabi said....be careful whom u follow...stick with traditional ahlus sunnah wal jamaah and ahlul bayt and traditional scholars...
if you like mawlid keep Islam out of it Islam is following Quran and Sunnah, not bid'ah 6:89 They are those whom We gave the Book, Al-Hukm (understanding of the religious laws), and Prophethood. But if these disbelieve therein (the Book, Al-Hukm and Prophethood), then, indeed We have entrusted it to a people (such as the Companions of Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) who are not disbelievers therein. Sahabas Radiyallahu ANhu were trusted with teh revelation of religion and didnt do mawlid!
My position is to quote Quran which isn't gud enough for you because you don't feel like it and do bid'ah, that is not a fatwa that is a fact, denying ayats and facts is what makes a fatwa even though thats not what i am doing, however you follow innovation like the x-tians and jews who celebrate b-days. Leave Islam out of it, as Islam is the Qu'ran, the speech of Allah, and Sunnah which has nothing to do with your mawlid fitnah bidah ignorance of x-ians.
Sad to see these evil practices beeing justified in this manner, very sad :(. But at the same time on yawmul Qiyaamah I will only have my self to worry about. Oh muslim brothers and sister stick to the practices of islam and you will be saved. We dont go do bars and chill with naked women and drunks listening to trance in order to make dawah at "a place where they feel comfortable" or start rapping the quran just becuse "they can relate to it" (even if 500 people would becom muslims). Salaam...
May Allah forgive us. It is unbelievable to hear such words from scholars. Why would you celebrate his birthday when in fact the prophet never asked of us to celebrate his birthday nor have the closes of people to him celebrated. In fact the prophet never liked to be praised highly. As we know this would lead people to worship him. If you love the prophet follow his message and send salutation as he asked of you.
Computer is bidah in dunya, meaning towfiq, not ibadah bidah meaning religion or worship, it is a means not an act, You don't understand basic Islam an act of worship is accepted when its in Quran, Sunnah and done sincerely for Allah alone, under those 2 conditions as reported, not your hidden crazy sufis who dream up stuff and contradict Quran, sunnah. One Bidah is tawfique which is fine, its from dunya, another is worship which is batil, wrong, saying religion is incomplete. Learn basic Islam
Disgusting to even try to make it seem like an acceptable thing. Did you forget the christmas tree, should we put light and decorations on a camel and make tawwaf around it, holding hands too? Sorry for my way of expressing myself put it's frustrating to see this, making people more and more comfortable with accepting more and more crazy things into the religion of mercy. Understand that this is not from islam. Lets keep rasulullah (saas) in or heart all year round and not for some special day!
yes it is totally bidah....why do we not find Sahabah telling us to celebrate Mawlood an nabi? this is all sufism . totally shirk... which will never be forgiven.. why dont we celebrate mawlid everyday??? we want to remember the Rasul, right??? audhobillah... it is Rasul's sunnah that we need to follow on daily basis.... the deen is complete and nothing was left out so how can we make these occasions up.... allaaho must'an
i dont think the sufi shaytan should speak for sunniyah, and you are right about one thing, you on't be sucessful as you hypocrites speak on jahanum contradicting the very hadiths books you quote while going against the Quran, if he SAhabas Radiyallahu Anhu didn't understand it as a birthday as birthdays aren't always on Mondays but as a day to fast then your ignorance of the Sahabas RAdiyallahu anhu is ignorance of the hadith. And your ignorance of the hadith is your bidah being xposed!
He makes so much sense.
Great to see the global acceptance and praise of the greatest person who ever lived (peace be upon him). Shows the universality of Islam.
Thanks to shaykh hamza yusuf and shaykh abdullah hakim murad, among other great shaykhs, in the UK and around the world, for your explanation as they make so much sense...
Allah knows best how many countless people are helped by this event over the centuries. How many people are awakened by this event non Muslims and Muslims.
Send salaam to our beloved prophet (saw)
How pathetic is it that on a video talking about the Prophet's birth pbuh, people come here arguing against each other. If you think it's bidah and we're going to burn for loving him on Mawlid, then leave us alone. Allah will decide.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x I suggest you acquaint yourself on the fiqh behind types of Bidah. There are "good" and "bad" bidahs as elaborated by the likes of Imam Shafi. Taraweeh is a bidah. Making the quran into an organized written manuscript is bidaah. Using an electronic microphone for azaan is bidaah.
@@AntiKaratekid
Exaaaactly, they just don't love Allah man.
If they loved Allah, they would celebrate his servent and messenger, Mohammed (habib Allah).
@@AntiKaratekid Living after the prophet is a bid3ah.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x i agree that you shouldn’t leave a muslim alone with sin, however in this instance there is ikhtilaf among the ulama about the mawlid.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5xok so if I make dhikr 500 times or 5000 then according to your understanding of the Hadith I’ve performed a bid3 that will be considered dolala
Love both of these scholars
What Sh. Hamza Yusuf is saying about Dr. Tim Winters being rarified is so true. One only needs to read his book the Eleventh Contentions. It is so beautifully written and covers so many topics from marriage to Palestine, all built on a sense of taqwa and sincerity.
From the book:
43. Use words in your preaching only if absolutely necessary.
44. Academic Islamic Studies is as foolish as it is because we are as foolish as we are.
Salaam
Thanks for this
- May Allah bless you
peace
Mawlid is blessed, Wahabi's are not. Najd was never ever blessed.
Ou ou ou, your mawlid is blessed? Says who?
I dont think so, because if it was blessed the first 3 generations would do it more than you.
And if someone is a wahhabi for you when hes working against bidaah than ALHAMDULILLAH that we are Wahhabis according to you...than we are on the right path
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x
So what the first 3 generations didn't do it?
That doesn't make it wrong or haram, use your logic and common sense.
This is an act of love, if you love your wife, you would celebrate her birth.
If you love your prophet, you would celebrate his birth......simple.
@@omarmansour6766 i know, youre ahlul bidaah. For you everything is out of love
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x ahlul bidah this ahlul bidah that. There’s bid3a even amongst those of the wahabiya brother and there’s bid3a amongst the sufiya. As long as one does not have the intellect of a retarded donkey they should be fine and able to veer away from it bi idhn Allah.
Milad nabwi was traditionally celebrated in every Muslim country.
These Shaykhs are wonderful Muslims who speak in beautiful English
Subhan'Allah! Very nice Video.
You are right we should remember Allah's greatest blessing to the World everyday, not just one day but the reality is, most of us don't. So at least this day is a good way of reminding those who don't remember the Prophet(pbuh) at all or very little.
There is no harm in it but goodness for those who know not the Messenger(pbuh) as the Sahaba knew him(pbuh). Which I believe is most of us nowadays, it seems as we are moving away from the Prophet (pbuh) because so much misinformation about the Blessed Messenger (pbuh) of Allah.
Our youth are fed lies about the Final Messenger(pbuh) so perhaps this can be a way of calling them back. Don’t worry about Milad worry about the real issues, fornication, haraam, fraud, drugs, illicit relationships outside of marriage and extremism.
Yup we have gone so far in time and far from the line of prophethood
Thank you for this
Well said brother, jazakAllah khair. x
For those people who confess to be muslims, remember one thing. If you fail to understand the true status of our noble Prophet (saw) then there is no way in this universe u'll ever become a 'muqarybeen' i.e. close to Allah. And if ur happy being a mere believer, then there is no way u'll ever get 2 taste the spiritual ecstacy of being close to Allah.The door way 2 Allah can only b entered if u give our beautiful prophet (saw) the respect which Allah accorded him that of 'Insaan-al-Kamil'.
@husainfahmy
Give me a Dalil saying you can use an Alarm clock for Fajr.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5xwhy don't u explain. Not just alarm. 3 or 4 Jumma prayers in a mosque, etc
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x the technology used to wake up for ibadah. How about creating the 3, 4 FRIDAY PRAYERS I SAME MOSQUE. EID PRAYERS WERE DONE ON GROUNDS NOW THEY ARE DONE I MOSQUES. NEW INNOVATION THE HAJJ WILL BE DONE IN A BUILDING INSTEAD OF TENTS. O TOP OF ONE ANOTHER. THERE IS A SERO S WHICH HUNAN KIND HAS MADE FOR EASE BUT THE ONLY BIDDAH THAT COMES TO PEOPLE'S MIND IS ASSOCIATED WITH LOVE AND RESPECT.
@@user-hw6cg9ji5x wow lol
those who say oh birthdays, prophet never did birthdays, right but he did hint towards his birth being a specially day by his own tongue and it is narrated :
Abu Qatada al-Ansari narrates in Sahih Muslim, Kitab as-siyam, that the Prophet was asked about the fast of Monday, and he answered: "That is the day that I was born and that is the day I received the prophecy."
its but obvious the prophet of Allah wasnt gonna cut a cake, but was only gonna do shukar, that being his style :)
salam
@SayfAlMujahid99
i will upload a video soon insha'Allah on extreme sufism, although tassawuf is fundemental in islam we should be careful as their are many ott sufi's out ther and this deen is a deen of balance.
@SayfAlMujahid99
Yeh i read the deobandi position on this and i was very much inclined towards it and i agree with it mostly. But also i think there is nothing wrong with getting together on such a day to discuss or praise the messenger of Allah (saw) as long as people dont go over the top.
I myself have gone to deobandi mosque since childhood as its near my house...but recently i came to know of certain of its founders believes...its not as if the muslim who go there to pray adopt those corrupted believes...no one (normal muslims) actually knows about it...the problem is with certain elders among deobandi ulema who defend certain of the founders believes ....but now i am a bit shock and confused....but i am free from such belief....i will soon learn aqeedah at tahawiya
@@tazboy1934 Aqidah At tahawiyyah is the right Aqidah akhi. Stick to the Ulamaa Brother than you will be safe
Masha Allah ..Abdul hakim 😊 Allah has bestowed you with hikmah
door of misguidance. They said: "By Allah oh Abdur Rahman we intended only to do good". He (AbdurRahman) said: " And how many are those who intend to do good but do not achieve that goal!.."
Peace to all sincere seekers who puts the intellect before that of "humanistic, so called feelings". Oh muslims hold on to the guidance of the one who said: "There is nothing that brings you closer to Jannah exept that I have told you about it & there is nothing that brings you to Jahannam exept that i
Nice ethereal tones to the Mawlid and nice to listen to on occasion, but can you imagine an eternity of supplications
mashallah
@safi456 Bro, no one ever suggested to make this the only day. We do it everyday, with extra effort on sacred days such as Ramadan etc. Just because we try harder some days does not devalue the others. That being said ask yourself: On mawlid when people are out thanking Allah in masjids and gatherings for the Messenger (saw) and you're in your house, which of the two groups is Allah's favor really with?
The one thanking Allah and the one in the house also may get Allah favors depending on wat he is doing
Assalamu alaykum w rahmatullahi w baraktuh,
For all the brothers are celebrating the prophet's (SAW) please watch the following video by Salim bin Sa'd Al-Taweel who talks about the ways we should worship Allah like he wants to be worshipped. May Allah guide us all. Please make dua that may Allah guide me.
(2:43) - subhanAllah!
salam o alaikum wa rehmet allah
amazing.
Wow this is gold.Do you have the reference?
@DopePatriot i am not a wahabi, but what you must understand my honoured friend is that we acknowledge that they are there and we will just have to tolerate them, as sufism and islam teachers love and tolerance
Unfortunately most of you don't seem to know the passing date of our Beloved Master (s.a.w.s.); he passed away on Rabialawwal 12, just like he was born and finalized his hijrah exactly on the same date. SO: a vast majority of the sahaba (radiyallahu anhum) were not old enough to remember, and therefore, celebrate his birth! Maybe Abu Kuhafa, but there were only a handful of them. So, the sahaba didn't have anything to celebrate; R.awwal 12 was the worst day for them! Let's not miss this point.
The majority of ummah does it for centuries ...ummah will not unite on falsehood...
@ali12147: Mawlid is a very common practice in our part of the world: Senegambia and very spiritually fulfilling. It is only recently I heard people critizing it and considering it shirk on the claim that the Prophet (SAW) had never done it and as such an "innovation".
@peaceANDislam
You see the issue is that if i start bringing evidences (which their are many) to support such actions then i could but i wont because we aint scholars. U bring up the classical issue of innovation which is very real buthas to be understood properly. Use intellect, not emotion. The point is that stop flooding the page with comments that cause confusion and dont watch such people or videos if you disagree with them. Otherwise i'll just delete your comments.
Exactly mainstream muslims are confused right now
Its more important to follow the Prophets sunnah, then to celebrate his birth. Not to disregard the fact it is fardh to send salawat onto Muhammad saw. I think its extremely important to remember Rasoolullah every day of my life whether its on his birthday or not! But to set a specific day aside and to celebrate his birth when our Prophet never prescribed us to do so and neither did the sahabah ever do such a thing, i feel like its going too far. Please correct me if I am wrong. jazakhallah.
i understand the intent behind Mawlid but is it any different then going to a lecture to learn abt the prophet (pbuh)?
@peaceANDislam
Nobody justifies going to bars or any of the other practices that u seem to be attributing to certain scholars. Also if u feel praising the messenger of Allah saw is an evil act then May Allah ta'ala guide you.
Maybe one would learn something with an attentive ear Inshallah
@MrGrandDragon
Well thats your personal opinion, but it isnt a matter of trying to hard. If an english person embraces islam they still have aspects of their culture and heritage embedded in them. So if they want to utilize these in a halal way then good for them. Im sure chinese or african muslims have their own nasheeds which i may dislike but thats what bring them closer to their Lord so be it.
subhanallah
mashallah
Ameen.
@ saminashaikhsyed shirk is to attribute or remove something to the worship of Allah, a birthday doesnt fall in that category and if we are questioning Abdul Hakim Murad and Sh Hamza Yusuf, well then we know someone who is a bigger scholar then them or we are convinced with, what comes from our passion :(
Loving the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, implies keeping his sunnah alive, adhering firmly to it, and avoiding words and deeds that go against it. Undoubtedly everything that goes against his sunnah is a reprehensible innovation (bid'ah) and a manifest act of disobedience. That includes celebrating his birthday and other kinds of bid'ah. A good intention does not mean that it is permissible to introduce innovations into the religion. Islam is based on two things, purity of intention and following [the Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him]. Allah says (interpretation of the meaning), "Yes, but whoever submits his face (himself) to Allah and he is a Muhsin (a doer of good) then his reward is with his Lord (Allah), on such shall be no fear, nor shall they grieve." [Al-Qur'an 2:112] Submitting one's face to Allah means being sincere towards Allah, and doing good means following the Messenger and implementing the sunnah.
Lets not mistake this to be a bid'ah because its not being treated as a day of specific worship like eid ul fitr or eid ul adha. Its just a day that we try to recognise to be significant and be thankful that the prophet was born and that we're from his Ummah. To be honest, just to have a reminder about his description on this day of the year is not an innovation, rather its just a tool that we could use. An innovation would be like having a khutba and an extra 2 rakaa during the day like we would in the prescribed days of eid. This is not the case. (sorry this was just a logical conjecture to think about, this is really the issue of the fuqaha. May allah forgive me if im wrong).
Completey disagreeing with that celeberating mawlid is bidah...thats wrong bcz he peace be upon him told us that he did fast on MONDAY bcz he was born on that day. SubhanAllah. Alhumdulillah
to show our love for the Prophet we dont celebrate his birthday, we follow his teachings and emulate his character. when my children obey my command or follow what i have taught them, for me that is the best form of love and shukr, not when they celebrate my birthday. our sahaba never celebrated rasulullah's birthday, yet they would have laid down their lives without hesitation for him. and if we wish to celebrate his greatness, why on a fixed day? why not any day of the year? why ritualise it?
Following inclinations is something to be weary about. There's mention of not distinguishing between any of the messengers alayhum salam. This brothers intentions are probably good but he is speaking about something that's not mentioned in Al Quran and there for it's not accepted as certainty.
And what would that reason be?
@abuBakr97 Wa alaikumu ssalaam. Sry but I did'nt get that at all!?
@safi456 on point brother, well said.
this is one of the best videos ive watched on youtube discussing Bid'ah and mawlid on part 2
watch?v=Ny7XRpWVwvE&NR=1
@SayfAlMujahid99 so is taraweeh prayers in ramadan brother...that doesnt mean u dont pray them. mawlid is proven quran and ahadith. please listen to both of these videos again.
@TheMusikHouse Comparisson Alarm Clock Vs Mawlid. - Look deeper.
@peaceANDislam
Do you get bored on a monthly basis which makes you come and watch this video that you despise and then you write a comment expressing how much you despise it, lol. What is wrong with you man.
What number?
why not?
@ali12147
The deobandi opinion on mawlid isn't bidah actually.. lol
Why so?
Someone who follows in righteousness as he didn't do Mawlid as the verse states.
9:100 And the foremost to embrace Islam of the Muhajirun (those who migrated from Makkah to Al-Madinah) and the Ansar (the citizens of Al-Madinah who helped and gave aid to the Muhajirun ) and also those who followed them exactly (in Faith). Allah is ...
Spelling eras are all you can talk about and verses aren't gud enough, you in deep trouble in Allah's religion.
Surah 2 says have no doubt the Quran is guidance!
Remember ever soul is accountable for their action. And remember there is no such thing as good innovation in religion. Allah has completed this religion if you do an act of deed which was not prescribe and act on while thinking you will be reward will only throw one in hell.
not denying*
uhm at the end of the day it's still a bid'aah. if you want to show your love for th prophet send salawat upon him and do dawah. :)
RIGHT
5:3
This day, those who disbelieved have given up all hope of your religion; so fear them not, but fear Me. This day, I have perfected your religion for you, completed My Favour upon you, and have chosen for you Islam as your religion. But as for him who is forced by severe hunger, with no inclination to sin (such can eat these above mentioned meats), then surely, Allah is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
Islam is perfect stop imitating kufar's pagan ignorance in celebrating b-days!!!!
Who understands islam better than us if not the ahlul bayt and rightous scholars after first three generations....
@kamelz86 And surley these people seems to be very nice people. But for a persons actions to count on yawmil qiyaamah the have to be according to THE Sunnah and not the christian one. Why don't we all gather on every new years eve to sing a song of praise for the sahaabah and the messenger? Becuse it's not legislated in islam so it becomes bid'ah since it's a form of worship, (even though you maight #feel# it's nice it's still bid'ah and every bid'ah.....
Wat things done in mawlid are against sunnah?we recite durood,recite poem,recite quran and seerah and express joy and happiness cooking food...all are according to shariah ....yes i agree there are people who free mix thats another issue
@@user-hw6cg9ji5xyou sound silly now.
The term "sufism" didn't exist until the advent of Wahabism & the babies it gave birth to. It should be known that 'sufism' is a derogatory term used for the followers of Ahelul-Sunna-Wa-Jamah. If u examine the contemporary belief system of Ahlel Sunna & cross-referenced it witht the life style of the Sahaba (AJ) then they'd b classed as 'Sufis' too. Neo-salafis et al have made it their life time mission to deliberately misunderstand the true charachter of our magnificent master Muhammad (saw).
What the 😂 even the 4 madhab scholars talked about sufis and sufism...like never heared such a dumb statement
Then how come Allaah has given Mecca and Medina to "Wahabies" for safe keeping, and not the sufies?
Lol wat logic is this....the saudi forcefully took the two holy cities ...yes ofc by Allah will...but it does not mean that they are on truth....by your logic u can say the pagan of pre islamic were on truth thats why Allah gave the haram to them lol...
@@user-hw6cg9ji5xare you really that naive to think it’s so black and white? According to your logic the Othmani caliphates didn’t exist then 😂
???????
No authentic proof (Dalil) with regards to Mawlid by Mr Murad. Sounds like A Christian tradition.
Nope....expressing joy and contentment ,reciting poem,food and seerah are allow....even ahlul bayt agree on that....will u deny ahlul bayt
Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him had never celebrated his birthday even after the revelation neither his companions. Despite the good intentions behind the idea of Mawlid but it's still considered among the majority of scholars a bedaa.
U are just repeating the same sentence that the wahabi said....be careful whom u follow...stick with traditional ahlus sunnah wal jamaah and ahlul bayt and traditional scholars...
Majority?since wen salafi are majority lol
@@tazboy1934 It’s easy, take reality, ignore it, and boom, Mawlid is evil. That’s the Minhaj of these heretic Wahhabis.
if you like mawlid keep Islam out of it
Islam is following Quran and Sunnah, not bid'ah
6:89 They are those whom We gave the Book, Al-Hukm (understanding of the religious laws), and Prophethood. But if these disbelieve therein (the Book, Al-Hukm and Prophethood), then, indeed We have entrusted it to a people (such as the Companions of Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) who are not disbelievers therein.
Sahabas Radiyallahu ANhu were trusted with teh revelation of religion and didnt do mawlid!
First go learn biddah from the four imam
@machine9191 u are no different to some salafi's who call you deviated as you are doing the same.
My position is to quote Quran which isn't gud enough for you because you don't feel like it and do bid'ah, that is not a fatwa that is a fact, denying ayats and facts is what makes a fatwa even though thats not what i am doing, however you follow innovation like the x-tians and jews who celebrate b-days. Leave Islam out of it, as Islam is the Qu'ran, the speech of Allah, and Sunnah which has nothing to do with your mawlid fitnah bidah ignorance of x-ians.
Sad to see these evil practices beeing justified in this manner, very sad :(. But at the same time on yawmul Qiyaamah I will only have my self to worry about. Oh muslim brothers and sister stick to the practices of islam and you will be saved. We dont go do bars and chill with naked women and drunks listening to trance in order to make dawah at "a place where they feel comfortable" or start rapping the quran just becuse "they can relate to it" (even if 500 people would becom muslims). Salaam...
Majority of the ummah will not be misguided in belief or practice...
May Allah forgive us. It is unbelievable to hear such words from scholars. Why would you celebrate his birthday when in fact the prophet never asked of us to celebrate his birthday nor have the closes of people to him celebrated. In fact the prophet never liked to be praised highly. As we know this would lead people to worship him. If you love the prophet follow his message and send salutation as he asked of you.
Computer is bidah in dunya, meaning towfiq, not ibadah bidah meaning religion or worship, it is a means not an act,
You don't understand basic Islam an act of worship is accepted when its in Quran, Sunnah and done sincerely for Allah alone, under those 2 conditions as reported, not your hidden crazy sufis who dream up stuff and contradict Quran, sunnah.
One Bidah is tawfique which is fine, its from dunya, another is worship which is batil, wrong, saying religion is incomplete.
Learn basic Islam
Disgusting to even try to make it seem like an acceptable thing. Did you forget the christmas tree, should we put light and decorations on a camel and make tawwaf around it, holding hands too? Sorry for my way of expressing myself put it's frustrating to see this, making people more and more comfortable with accepting more and more crazy things into the religion of mercy. Understand that this is not from islam. Lets keep rasulullah (saas) in or heart all year round and not for some special day!
yes it is totally bidah....why do we not find Sahabah telling us to celebrate Mawlood an nabi? this is all sufism . totally shirk... which will never be forgiven.. why dont we celebrate mawlid everyday??? we want to remember the Rasul, right??? audhobillah... it is Rasul's sunnah that we need to follow on daily basis.... the deen is complete and nothing was left out so how can we make these occasions up.... allaaho must'an
i dont think the sufi shaytan should speak for sunniyah, and you are right about one thing, you on't be sucessful as you hypocrites speak on jahanum contradicting the very hadiths books you quote while going against the Quran, if he SAhabas Radiyallahu Anhu didn't understand it as a birthday as birthdays aren't always on Mondays but as a day to fast then your ignorance of the Sahabas RAdiyallahu anhu is ignorance of the hadith.
And your ignorance of the hadith is your bidah being xposed!