Should you switch to electronic shifting? The pros and cons of ditching the cables

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 88

  • @solitaryrefinement6787
    @solitaryrefinement6787 3 года назад +26

    I had a Dura-Ace 7800 groupset so dialed in that it did everything electronic shifting is supposed to do so wonderfully today (crisp, precise, flawless & smooth shifting), but without carbon bits, without needing batteries and without worrying about it getting mixed signals. All it required was regular lubing & cables as they wore out.

  • @nickw6175
    @nickw6175 3 года назад +14

    honestly after a good few years riding a few to many years i suppose I firmly believe that a well maintained 105 is as good as I need, will swop out my current ultegra for a 105 when it wears out. Spend the money on decent wheels !

    • @yonglingng5640
      @yonglingng5640 Год назад

      Somebody here has the right idea.

    • @I_am_NEVER_wrong
      @I_am_NEVER_wrong Год назад +1

      Spoken like a frugal club man! I didn't need Di2 but now I have it, man I would NEVER go back, as for wheels upgraded them to carbon hoops at the same time, with a titanium frame (more expense!) you get a lightweight comfortable bike for life that you can reconfigure every so often if you wish. So I guess it's just down to what you want to spend your money on. I don't go to the pub now, so spend my money making my life easier.

  • @andrewkiyko7413
    @andrewkiyko7413 2 года назад +16

    Mechanical shifting, given its simplicity, looks like an upgrade from electronic shifting...

  • @tomrachellesfirstdance7843
    @tomrachellesfirstdance7843 3 года назад +21

    Very definitely 1st world problem video 😂 I would have electronic if I could afford it but I cannot so I have good ol 105

  • @jonathanip6757
    @jonathanip6757 3 года назад +13

    Maintenance? I’d probably count charging batteries and pre-ride checking their charge as maintenance. Also replacing when they come to the end of their useful life. Not sure if it’s any less than cable systems to be honest

    • @quantumdecoherence1289
      @quantumdecoherence1289 Год назад

      lol, 2 seconds at best compared to faffing with cable replacements, shifter going out of spec, etc etc. No thanks

  • @tubehabit
    @tubehabit 2 года назад +4

    Seeing some of the comments about the superiority of electronic shifting makes me think that the writers have never had an optimally set up mechanical system. I have used Di2 and most of the major manufacturers mechanical systems and find there is little or no difference either in speed or precision of shifting. As for comments about the greater need for adjustment/maintenance of mechanical systems, I've never experienced this - a quick fine-tuning after installing a new cable and that's it for a mechanical system.

    • @andredegraaf1643
      @andredegraaf1643 Год назад

      Exactly. I've had cables on my 1989 Bianchi completely trouble free since I bought the bike. All this talk of cable stretching is complete nonsense after the first few rides. Fraying cables are a sign of other problems but not with the cable itself.

  • @andrew1976williams
    @andrew1976williams 3 года назад +2

    I bought my first bike with electronic gear shifting at the start of this year (a Cervelo Caledonia) and I absolutely love it. It is so much better than the mechanical systems that I had on previous bikes and I've had no problems with it at all to date. I've not yet needed to charge the battery as I still have a solid green light at the end of my right-hand handle bar. When I do have to, however, it will be a very simple task.

  • @gregvassilakos
    @gregvassilakos 2 года назад +2

    I checked with several bike shops in Athens for a new Shimano 105 (mechanical) road bike in my size. I have been using 105 in the United States for years. Due to supply chain issues, no 105 road bikes were available, but I was able to find a road bike with SRAM Rival eTap AXS. It was a revelation. Even after riding 105 for years, I sometimes push the wrong lever. The SRAM eTap system seems more intuitive. Also, 105 will produce chain rub when using the extreme cog and chain ring combinations. SRAM eTap is free of chain rub regardless of the gear combination. I have noticed with 105 that I need to adjust the shift cables due to seasonal weather changes to compensate for thermal expansion. I don't expect this to be a problem with SRAM eTap. I will get a SRAM eTap road bike in the United States as soon as my wife agrees I can buy a new bike.

    • @yonglingng5640
      @yonglingng5640 Год назад +2

      SRAM is more lenient with cross-chaining due to the rear of the front derailleur cage being wider than the front and their Yaw Technology contributed by two parallelograms of different sizes (larger front, smaller rear) that allow the cage to yaw when switching between chainrings. These are things no other front derailleur have.

    • @richardcarr6493
      @richardcarr6493 Год назад

      wow that s $2450 CDN OUCH PRICEY just for the groupset . l can buy a good gravel bike with that kind money N+1

  • @stuartdryer1352
    @stuartdryer1352 2 года назад +1

    I've never regretted switching to Di2. You don't NEED it, but you will love it. As for batteries, I charge it at the beginning of each month.

  • @binauppal876
    @binauppal876 3 года назад +8

    id rather keep my 105 and upgrade my wheels,,that mite actually make a difference to my speed as to fancy electronic shifting which probly wont

  • @GC987
    @GC987 2 года назад +1

    What a great, balanced discussion of the key issues

  • @talonlan
    @talonlan 3 года назад +2

    I got first gen ultegra Di2 on a second hand bike I bought, recently had battery discharge issues and had to upgrade junction Box before I could even start diagnosis. Turned out being external battery holder so all in all set me back about £300 but all nice new intensity system now

  • @ErwinPfuhler
    @ErwinPfuhler 3 года назад +3

    Excellent video with some very useful insights as I am considering electronic shifting for my next bike

  • @richbob594
    @richbob594 3 года назад +2

    Sram Etap is great until the spring in the little battery connector in the front derailleur dies. Sram has no support for the first gen Etap. So you are left with searching for used. Which are currently selling for 150% over new.

  • @rasmuswi
    @rasmuswi 3 года назад +1

    I have two bikes with di2, and two with mechanical shifting, and I have to say I'm getting more and more tired of mechanical shifting and all it's fiddliness. Sometimes I even consider going back to friction shifting if I really want to keep using mechanical shifting.

  • @estrellacorrea4921
    @estrellacorrea4921 2 года назад +5

    I used di2 for 6 years and went back to DA mechanical 9100 now i enjoy cycling again di2 almost made me hate riding i think the price and inconvenience makes it logical to use mechanical

  • @thangarajmj5814
    @thangarajmj5814 2 года назад +5

    Only buy it if you can afford it, it is not necessary to have an Electronic groupset. Mechanical just works fine.

  • @rayF4rio
    @rayF4rio 3 года назад +17

    Mechanical shifting is such a pain in the a**. I can't believe how hard it is to actually press the shift levers, my hands get so tired when riding a couple of hours. And the noise...OMG!! So noisy and distracting. Not to mention, the carbon green house gas impact of mechanical shifting...oops, sorry that an electronic shifting thing.
    But seriously, mechanical shifting is less profitable for the bike industry. And as cyclists, we need to keep the bike industry going by always buying new stuff, whether we need it or not. And thankfully channels like this keep us feeling inferior for not upgrading to the latest tech which we really don't need. Long live bike industry marketing and their supporters!!!

    • @DNGR369
      @DNGR369 2 года назад +1

      It's quite an unbiased video IMO. It's their job to present any innovations for us to make an informed choice. If it's easier and more fun to use, why not talk about it or consider it

    • @richardcarr6493
      @richardcarr6493 Год назад

      LOL nah real cyclists don t need uber tech overpriced stuff we need stuff that just works and easy to fix ourselves without breaking the bank !! l like bang for buck its about mechanical simplicity/ efficiency not complexity /expensive . So how long does this oh so not green tech expected to last BTW??

  • @markzebr6463
    @markzebr6463 Год назад

    I have a 2022 SRAM FORCE DI2. I have all praise and no complaints except that SRAM Batteries can be very hard and long to initially charge. My solution was to buy generic batteries that are cheaper, faster to charge and seem to last just as long.

  • @gsmd770
    @gsmd770 3 года назад +3

    All 3 of my road bikes are Ultegra Di2. I love it!!!! I think that's why I don't ride my mountain bike anymore?

  • @DavidKing-wk1ws
    @DavidKing-wk1ws 2 года назад

    I like my Bike O Matic. Mechanical shifting automagically :)

  • @jimsappington4603
    @jimsappington4603 Год назад

    I've had a Specialized Roubaix for 2 years with Shimano di2 Ultegra and it is fantastic but it's hard to explain

  • @BleakVision
    @BleakVision Год назад +2

    So now I need a torque wrench to adjust my seatpost, oily fluids and a syringe for my brakes, weird sticky milk for my tires plus a compressor and a special charger for my shifter.
    Cool, what else is new?

    • @EditioCastigata
      @EditioCastigata Год назад

      A mobile phone for managing your Di2, and a six-digit PIN to connect to your bike. (Not joking.)

    • @scottster8858
      @scottster8858 Месяц назад +1

      @@EditioCastigata That is until the apps become non compatible with your new phone.

  • @lines374
    @lines374 Год назад +1

    I ride a standert steal frame with ultegra, think about going to the new 105 di2, but the weight is a honest problem for me. Ultegra weight 2300 and 105di2 2900.what u think guys

  • @rudyelizondo1935
    @rudyelizondo1935 10 месяцев назад +1

    Good vid, mech every day, cheaper and easier to use, get on your bike and go!

  • @JayLato
    @JayLato 2 года назад +2

    2 words from the tech world. Proprietary Batteries. Cables will live on. I’d be on board with electronic only if they used the AA battery standard.

  • @LimYQS
    @LimYQS 3 года назад +2

    SRAM seems to be the bomb with etap esp the sequential shifts!

  • @mikaelljungberg1019
    @mikaelljungberg1019 6 месяцев назад

    Do you know abort and testa in real Coldplay temperaturen.

  • @povertyspec9651
    @povertyspec9651 Год назад

    Greatest group ever: Campagnolo Record 10 ErgoPower mechanical

  • @wasupwitdat1mofiki94
    @wasupwitdat1mofiki94 3 года назад +3

    I have Dura-Ace Di2 coming from SRAM Red eTap and I can without hesitation say Shimano is better and never has missed a shift. The SRAM would drop the chain either inside or outside the chainrings because it just would not dial in as you put it. I always had to be mindfull of front shifts every time. With Shimano I have become complacent because it works fantastic. I have Campagnolo mechanical on my cyclocross bike and I just can't shift it well anymore because with mechanical it comes down to feel and I lost that. I would never buy another mechanical group and I would never buy SRAM again either.

    • @feluacc
      @feluacc 3 года назад +1

      Really mechanical comes down to feel? Toptube shifters maybe but how can a modern mechanical shift movement be :)

  • @MrCyclist
    @MrCyclist 2 года назад

    Today, Oct 22, Shimano 105 has Di2

  • @laszlozoltan5021
    @laszlozoltan5021 3 года назад +2

    I ride a lot of long distance loops on hilly rural roads- bit of a grinder- I dont shift much- each hill is a test. I once had clipless pedal body pull off the spindle and had to ride back effectively one legged (my weak one) about 40 k- now do I want to try to troubleshoot problems out there, racing the dusk home with no lights ? while the premium price of that crap I could get something for my wife or kids instead ? All the so-called pros of electric is a con.

  • @jackbnimbleist
    @jackbnimbleist 2 года назад

    How can I order a new charger?

  • @danielsotelo3942
    @danielsotelo3942 Год назад

    I get to see this cable vs electronic situation play out everyday at my private pro shop. Yes, electronics are definitely GREAT in every-way possible, "especially if you are older". It comes down to Shimano Di2 or SRAM wireless as I favor SRAM because it gets rid of all cable/wire problems. Any SRAM wireless system allows older folks to save a ton of money as they can use their older bikes to be "easily" converted to electronic shifting. Where a Shimano Di2 presents a big and very costly wiring plumbing problem(s) unless you purchase an all new bike with Di2 installed. Hey if you have that kind of money yes go for it complete with disc brakes too.
    Why it's good for older riders is simple.... As you get older (ie 40 plus) hands don't work so great, especially on cold days so pushing a cabled lever is often a very painful proposition, vs a simple touch of the finger. Also shifting on a SRAM wireless system is extremely simple because you only have One button on each lever, vs two tiny buttons on each lever on a Di2 system.
    Sure initially its a bit expensive but Electronic offers great Long run money savings because there are no more gear wire problems/headaches thus avoiding costly visits to the bike shop. If you think about it, the number one reason having to go to a costly bike shop visit is because of a shifting problem. Electronic shifting virtually eliminates these costly visits.
    So yes, if you are older and you love to ride your bike, you'll thank me for giving you this advise, and you'll say to your self, "I should have done this long ago"... Enjoy. ( :

  • @steffanaarts-greven1352
    @steffanaarts-greven1352 2 года назад

    Sounds like almost all the downsides are more human error downsides than system downsides. From what I hear that it is mostly price and maintainability that are really system downsides.

  • @davidski9542
    @davidski9542 3 года назад +10

    I’ll take mechanical 12 speed Campag’ over anything else (particularly Shimano 😬) all day long thanks 🤩

    • @Ghostina1
      @Ghostina1 3 года назад +2

      Me too - I'll take Sram 12 Speed mechanical over the 12 AXS aswell!
      Also budget wise 👌

    • @yonglingng5640
      @yonglingng5640 3 года назад +1

      @@Ghostina1 SRAM doesn't manufacture 12-speed for mechanical road groupsets, they only go up to 11.

    • @Ghostina1
      @Ghostina1 3 года назад

      @@yonglingng5640 are you shure? Why do I have 12 clicks om my leever and 12 rings on my cassette then ?

    • @yonglingng5640
      @yonglingng5640 3 года назад

      @@Ghostina1 What SRAM components are you running? Are you sure none of them are from their MTB lineup?

    • @Ghostina1
      @Ghostina1 3 года назад

      @@yonglingng5640 yes I do run a mtb cassette on my dogma f12 but shifting is all mechanical Force 12 Speed
      Check out the guys from RatioTech... they provide a simple solution. And in germany you have even guys who give you up to 14 Speed ... like Stockys.

  • @scifi2688
    @scifi2688 10 месяцев назад

    A big no to electronic shifting for me. I ride my bike everyday, so battery life will a lot lower. If you look at the recharge rates, you only get approx 200 recharges to 100% before degradation starts to set in or capacity becomes lower over time. Recharging or battery replacement for me isn't an option. For example, my head and tail lights are now all Dynohub powered and I'm not going back to buying new batteries The cost over the year(s) for batteries or using any of the rechargable variants is too high to continue.
    Nothing wrong with mechanical/cable shifting. Can find replacement cable, derailleurs or shifters just about anywhere lbs and at a reasonable cost. Can't make the same statement with electronic shifting setups. To each their own preferences, peace out .

  • @crion88
    @crion88 3 года назад

    SRAM Force, built two bikes and my partner wanted electronic shifting as well...
    The market is not going back, high-end and mid-end will be electronic and wireless while low-end groupsets will keep the wire.

  • @dyzoly
    @dyzoly 3 года назад +2

    Until they make a solar version which you never have to charge I wouldn't use'em for free.

  • @GrotrianSeiler
    @GrotrianSeiler 2 года назад +1

    I don’t see the benefit myself. Far too many things to go wrong with electronic shifting. I guess I’m old school. Though I’d love to ride a bike with it, I wouldn’t want to own one. There are so many other things I would rather spend my money on

    • @yonglingng5640
      @yonglingng5640 Год назад

      I've been in the sport for almost 11 years now and I prefer mechanical for my own bikes.

  • @Brotherman7
    @Brotherman7 8 дней назад

    I just balanced everything on my mechanical system, and I don't have to pay $2000 USD to upgrade.

  • @Andy_ATB
    @Andy_ATB 3 года назад

    The question I always ask with cycling tech; is it VFM? And will it make me significantly faster?

  • @hankhill3126
    @hankhill3126 2 года назад +2

    Through my research, Mechanical to me seems more reliable..

  • @jongoff2815
    @jongoff2815 Год назад

    *Quality*

  • @richardcarr6493
    @richardcarr6493 Год назад

    WHEN IT STARTS COSTING MORE THAN A DECENT BIKE ITS NOT WORTH IT !! A proper set up mechanical works just AS GOOD AND IS LIGHTER easier to fix yourself and most importantly cheaper to replace broken parts !! l dare you to ask the pros which they would rather race with also their mechanics which they prefer to work on !! WE know the new race bikes are super heavy compared to bikes just yrs ago by 1-2 kg and that on the mountain stages makes a difference !!

  • @ereky2991
    @ereky2991 3 года назад +2

    Dinosaurs move aside, the electric era is here! Just got the new Sram Rival and it was cost effective and is way better than mechanical! #Electronicgroupsets

    • @laurapiovan
      @laurapiovan 3 года назад

      looking at buying Rival eTap axs as well... coming from mechanic group. How is battery life? do you need to recharge often? what about cleaning the bike? I tend to just wash my mechanical groups, and sometime take it in the shower when it's very muddy. Is it an issue (electronic components and water don't always go well together)? How do you wash a bike with electronic components? Is the battery life affected in cold weather / at low temperature?

    • @dam-wm8vb
      @dam-wm8vb 3 года назад +1

      …and it adds around a kg to the overall weight (Rival AXS vs Ultegra 8000), looks fuck ugly and cheap (also in the case of Rival/Force AXS) and just not worth the extra 💵. Give me mechanical Ultegra all day long….well, maybe 2022 Ultegra Di2 when the price is right😁

  • @charng
    @charng 3 года назад

    switching to electronic shifting? man i am in the process of switching to wireless shifting. shimano no more.

  • @simonorr594
    @simonorr594 3 года назад

    Here in the US, people go for SRAM - no cables and the batteries are easier to charge.

    • @yonglingng5640
      @yonglingng5640 Год назад

      Also, SRAM is basically one of your national products, so I won't be surprised if prices are the cheapest there and if it's more easily acquired.

  • @NavyChief1999
    @NavyChief1999 2 года назад +1

    I have three road bikes. Two of which have Shimano Di2 groupsets, one is a 10 spd ultegra the other is Dura-Ace 9200 12spd. I only ride the 10 spd. Dura-Ace mechanical shifting bike during the winter months for nostalgia reasons, because electronic shifting bikes are far in away more superior. I equate it to people who prefer six-speed manual transmission cars to feel more connected to driving, however, we all know dual-clutch transmission cars, performs, much better, particularly in high-end supercars ( BMW, Mercedes, Porsche, Ferrari, Lamborghini), etc, everyone knows you can't outperform a dual-clutch electronic transmission system. So let the old heads hold on to the past 👴 🧓 👨. Electronic shifting bikes rule!

  • @ldavid2
    @ldavid2 3 года назад +1

    losing your charger? running out of battery? I know a stupid person you can blame for those

  • @wildsurfer12
    @wildsurfer12 2 года назад

    105 Di2 anyone?

    • @yonglingng5640
      @yonglingng5640 Год назад

      Not me, I'm taking R7000. A workhorse groupset that's supposed to be more affordable doesn't need electronics.

  • @iRyan876
    @iRyan876 3 года назад +1

    Hate electronics. Yuck. I like any vehicle of mine to have as little as possible; if any at all.

  • @amyx231
    @amyx231 2 года назад +1

    Too much. This is too much. I don’t need anything fancy on my bike. Then again, I’m pretty new to this. Let my butt stop hurting first before you talk upgrades, lol.

  • @X_Marks-u7r
    @X_Marks-u7r 29 дней назад

    That lever will break.

  • @christophercondron5388
    @christophercondron5388 3 года назад +1

    The battery doesn't last several hundreds of miles about 10000 clicks would be more better if I was riding on straight road and didn't need to change gears then I would probably get 10000 miles

  • @steroberry
    @steroberry 2 месяца назад

    The points against the electronic shifting are so dull

  • @garypostell5268
    @garypostell5268 3 года назад +3

    Cost too much !

  • @marinusholland
    @marinusholland 3 года назад +1

    Not necessary

  • @ColoradoE470
    @ColoradoE470 7 месяцев назад

    4:15 youre wrong.

  • @blahqwe
    @blahqwe 3 года назад +11

    Utterly pointless invention for the average cyclist.

  • @jonitas66
    @jonitas66 3 года назад

    I don´t race, so i don´t need any electronic shifting!