@@Guywithnolimbs padres are a playoff team and Merrill is a major contributor. I understand Skenes is incredible, it didn’t get him anywhere though. I know that doesn’t really matter for rookie of the year. I’m just saying.
@@kermit1And yet Meril provides value to his team on a daily basis, both offensively and defensively. Skenes only pitches on average every 5 days. So Skenes is only helping his team once a week.
I’m going full baseball Nerd here with advanced stats per baseball reference. Skeenes has. 6.0 war, Jackson. M has 4.3. Skeenes has an era+ of 213 and Jackson. M has an ops+ 128. Jackson is great but Skeenes has been otherworldly with his dominance as a pitcher.
The Skenes glazing is so out of control. Merrill is one of the major reasons the Padres are in contention. Let’s just say that overall Merrill is more valuable everyday as a player and has shown up and played well every game. Pitcher bias is a real thing.
This is part of the reason why I'm convinced the league hates the padres and padres fans between how much they glaze the dodgers and how much they glaze Skenes it's ridiculous
Would hurt if we just let it tie? I will say I think its much harder for a rookie to come in and pitch like Skenes has (especially with the Pirates offense and bullpen backing you up) then hitting like Merril.
Merrill will win. Skenes is great, but he isn’t the best rookie this season… He may be the best rookie pitcher, but he is not the best rookie as he has not provided the value that the everyday players have. I’m saying this as a pitcher myself, and I still believe Merrill has been the best rookie due to his impact.
A guy who plays everyday vs a guy who plays 6 innings every 5 days? One has to produce and get results every day, every game, every inning. The other has to produce for 6 innings every 5 days.. who plays more?
That’s not Skenes fault, but Skenes appearances have been more valuable, who would u rather have? A guy with a 1.99 ERA come out every 5 days and give you like 6 innings with 9 strikeouts or a guy with a .820 OPS everyday
Might as well not have any pitchers on the roster then, huh? I guess you're better off signing 1 position player instead of 5 pitchers because pitchers contributions pale in comparison 😅
They need separate categories for pitcher and position players--you know, like they have for EVERY other fucking year besides rookie. The rookie year is not magically exempt from needing two awards for two very different performances.
Paul Skenes 6.0 WAR, ERA+ 213, WHIP .962, K/9 11.5. Pitchers in baseball history with those numbers: Pedro Martinez 2000 Paul Skenes 2024 Jackson Merrill is having a good season. Paul Skenes is having a historic season and will win ROY easily.
@@MichealScarn-bw1lf Maybe for the Padres, but not in MLB history. The stat you are thinking of for Merrill is that he hit more home runs in the 9th inning or later to tie or take the lead for a player at his age, 21, not of all players in MLB history.
The crappiness of the Pirates is just another sign of how great Skenes has been. Their bullpen is horrid, and has been especially horrid when trying to hold a lead for him. He'd have at least 4 more wins if they had the Padres' bullpen. And if they had a competent offense to support him, he'd have another couple W's and 2 fewer L's. He could have easily had a 17-1 record at this point if not for his bad teammates playing poorly.
One thing to add, Jackson Merrill is not just having a productive season, he is doing it late in game when they need him most. Not sure what his BA is in the 7,8,9th inning but it is right up there.
Where he was last year has nothing to do with ROY. If you want to play that game, think about this: Merrill had never played centerfield before spring training. He had to learn a new position and he still leads all rookies in every major batting category.
For the AL i think Austin wells, he's second in AL rookie war by a little and is a catcher not a courner outfielder which in my mind at least makes him much more valuable
“unanimous” and there is fucking Jackson Merrill being one of the best hitters in the league, played SS and moved to CF and is one of the best defensive players, he skipped AAA, he was in AA. It should be close but not “obviously”
skenes definitely deserves it...6.0 pitching WAR, 2nd best in the NL, 3rd best in ML...merrill and chourio are so similar, nearly identifcal stats (both around 4-ish WAR), they will likely split some votes.
Saying skenes is the unanimous choice isn't disrespect, its flat out stupid. Merrill will walk away. With this thing. 6 innings a week vs. everyday major impact. C'mon give me a break
(Opinion) Italk normally your takes are good but this is one of the worst takes I have ever seen. Skene’s is good but over glazed. Jackson Merrill is the easy pick because he’s clutch, he play insane defense, and he hasn’t gotten injured yet. He’s a big part of this Padres team. Tell me would you rather have a person who lead a team to the playoffs and is one of the best hitters this year or a pitcher on a bad team with good stats. Personally I believe that Merrill should win it.
Paul Skenes plays 5-6 inning 4 times a month. Jackson Merrill plays every game. They are not comparable! Personally Pitchers and Hitters should have separate awards!
One of the only times I disagree with you, I believe Skenes has more hype and might be better in the future, but right now, Merrill is winning ROY I will be upset if he goes unanimous
Jackson Chourio stepped in for Christian Yelich (who was in MVP form), and helped the Brewers to prove everyone wrong and win the Central. He should at the very least finish second in voting.
Team success doesn’t factor into individual awards in baseball because unlike other sports one guy can’t take over a game in baseball, that’s why guys like Ohtani and Trout can win MVPs
Does anyone not remember the outcome of 2022 and Spencer Strider putting up ridiculous numbers only to be beaten by his teammate Michael Harris??? Strider's numbers aren't too far off from Skenes and they have both thrown the same number of innings so far... not sure if Skenes will start 1 more game or not. Merrill, by far, has put up better numbers than Harris (has also played way more games while keeping solid numbers)... Merrill deserves ROY playing an above average CF for pretty much the entire season. Skenes hasn't been in the majors for the entire season and hasn't nearly made the type of difference Merrill has made to the Padres, who will be a 90 plus winning team at season's end. This debate is ridiculous... if Skenes had been up sooner, then sure... but he's only pitched 131 innings... not even close
I can’t understand everyone saying Merrill should win. Merrill is having literally the most average rookie of the year season ever. Skenes has 1.99 ERA 213 ERA+ and 6 WAR. He has a higher WAR than Merrill despite missing the first two months.
Jackson Merrill is hitting just 28% better than the average pitcher while Skenes is pitching better than the probable cy young winner in Chris Sale. Merrill is having a good season, but it isn’t on the same level as Skenes’s season so far.
Sorry but Merrill has been more consistent. As much as I think Skenes deserves it, I think longevity factors in to the argument. He’s been up with the team the whole year. If Skenes was up the whole year and did this, then no question he should win it, but I just think that’s the biggest damage to his argument
@@sir.muffiniii7011 sure but despite having a down June, he is still hitting .292, 24 homeruns, 89 RBIs, 4.3 WAR, .830 OPS on the season as a 21 year old rookie, so you could argue he would be over .300 if it weren’t for that. If I could give the ROTY to 2 players, no question if we be these 2. The longevity argument still applies and it’s the same reason why Churio isn’t the favorite. This is a close race but I think Merrill wins by a tooth
Pitches an avg 5 innings only every 5th day, team is last in division, tied for 30th in strikeouts. I'm sorry but as a pitcher, you need to have a near CY Young quality season to deserve the award, of you ask me.
Bro like dude go no inning, and in the middle he went against good teams then fell off and went against bad teams I would hie loved to see him go against Merrill. But it’s going to be him because of the hype and the amount of love he gets. And the way Skenes is just nasty.
It's ok to have an opinion and just be wrong. 6 innings every 5 days doesn't equate to every single game. I'd be more in favor of Cy Young than rookie of the year and even then he's 7 starts short 🤷
this is a terrible take. Not to say that Skenes wont win it or doesnt deserve to win it, but to say that Merrill and even Chuorio wont get any votes is ABSURD and just blind to what both of those guys (much more so Merrill) have done for their teams day in and day out compared to every 5-6 days and missing the playoffs Paul Skenes
I will say this right now - I think it's incredibly close between Merrill and Skenes. I think Merrill is going to win it though for three simple reasons. One, Skenes hasn't played the entire season - that shouldn't be a knock on him but you can blame the Pirates on that. Two, Skenes numbers are Historic - but Merrill has done Historic things like what was mentioned in the video at Clutch Time and at one point literally carried the Padres. Numbers are nice, but what did those numbers do to get that Rookie's team to where they wanted to go? In that respect, Merrill's numbers mattered more then Skenes numbers have. But Three, the biggest reason, is that Skenes is now DONE for the year. His body of work is complete, thanks to how much the Pirates sunk - thanks to getting blasted (and SWEPT) in their Season Series with the Padres & Jackson Merrill who had a hand in a number of those games. Meanwhile, Merrill is not close to done with the Padres looking to chase down the Dodgers for the NL West Title and will likely appear in the Playoffs. If he hits more Game Winning Home Runs in the Post-Season, I just don't see how Skenes will top that at this point. Skenes will win, if Rookie of the Year is determined only with the Regular Season. But if the Post-Season is added in, and Merrill goes off -- the award is going to go to the Rookie that helped his team get into the Post-Season.
Awards are determined by how you perform in the regular season. There are other awards that would determine your performance in the playoffs (which don't count at the moment).
So, give him the Cy Young. For ROTY, it should be Jackson Merrill. Not only is he the most clutch but he's playing out of position (he's a natural shortstop who has never played center field until the beginning of this season). He also play almost everyday, unlike Skenes would only play once every 5 days.
Countless rookies have been consistently clutch in the highest-leverage situations, thereby flipping losses into wins? Countless rookies set records for the number of high-leverage home runs over the course of a 50 game period? While playing gold-glove caliber defense at a new position? While playing 155+ games?
It's Jackson Merrill who is Rookie of the Year. Come on man, I thought you were better than this. Paul Skenes is amazing but Jackson Merrill is on another level. There is no debate.
@@iTalkStudios he’s missed about 10 starts this year due to pitching every 6 days and missing all of April and a 1/3 of May. That alone gives Merrill the edge
No disrespect my guy but you just overbooking how historic Merrill has been is insane. You gave his numbers and said yeah but this pitcher is better. I completely disagree and so do many people. The unanimous Rookie of the year? I smell a very strong bias.
And, if not for the moronic manager who pulled him far too early in many games and blew his earned wins with terrible releivers and closers who could not close a closet door, he would have probably been 15 - 2 with a sub 2 ERA. Rock on Paul. We will love you until the singling cheap owners give you away when it is time for you first real contract.
Arguable but still laughable. This is what you dont realize as a viewer who never even played HS ball. Pitching is not EASY BUT ill take the guy who is smashing 100 mph balls then credit the guy who is throwing them. Merill wins mid diff.
That’s not how the award works, just bcz what he does it harder doesn’t mean he’s better, Skenes has been a better pitcher than Merrill has been a hitter and fielder
I’ve had my suspicions that this iTalk guy was a clown, but this confirms it. You obviously haven’t been paying attention if you think Skenes deserves it over Jackson Merrill.
It’s so obvious that nobody agree’s with you .. a pitcher that pitches every 5 days is not worth as much as an everyday player .. not alone an every day centerfield who’s been infront of a playoff push … those clutch hits matter & the Padres wouldn’t be in the playoffs without him.. Italk always fulll of shhhit
@@iTalkStudios Dude plays once a week. Jackson Merrill is out there every single game. Has a 5.1 WAR which is higher than Skenes and doesn’t need a famous girlfriend to get him more clout.
The Padres wouldn’t be where they are currently without Jackson Merrill. Seems like in every big situation the kid comes through.
they have tatis and machado skeene the only pitcher
@@MatthewVasquez-x9s And that's Merrill's problem the Padres have better talent?
@@johnpolese6575 and? Skenes is the better player
Misspelled Jackson Merrill in the title of this video.
nope. Skenes and it's not even close
Let's go White Sox
@@CapnJack1 pitchers don’t deserve ROTY. This is historically true.
na its skeenes jackson overrated
@@jamesgoatcher ??? It goes to the best player their position doesn’t matter Skenes is a top 5 pitcher rn hes the obvious choice
I think the Cardinal’s Mason Wynn has been incredibly underrated. Maybe not ROTY but has gone under the radar for sure
Been very good but this year's roty is so crazy shota imanaga would be a rookie of the year in a lot of years and maybe won't even finish top 3.
Man Mason Wynn got my respect as a Padre fan when we played him, I was like who’s this guy that keeps hitting everything
As a Dodgers fan, Merrill should win it, but Skenes glazing is too op
as a dodgers fan its skeenes
@@MatthewVasquez-x9s fair enough :D
@@LangyLang hes literaly a top 10 maybe even top 5 pitcher in the league rn tf u on
@@Guywithnolimbs padres are a playoff team and Merrill is a major contributor. I understand Skenes is incredible, it didn’t get him anywhere though. I know that doesn’t really matter for rookie of the year. I’m just saying.
Skenes is a top 3 player at his position.
Merrill is a very good centerfielder.
Thats a great point that ignores all the context and logic that goes into giving out the award
Merrill has been top 3 center fielder this year
This a stupid ass comment when Merrill has been a top 3 center fielder ALL SEASON. And he has never played that position
@@Jr619LiFTED pitchers are a premier position in baseball. Centerfielders are not.
@@kermit1And yet Meril provides value to his team on a daily basis, both offensively and defensively. Skenes only pitches on average every 5 days. So Skenes is only helping his team once a week.
I’m going full baseball Nerd here with advanced stats per baseball reference. Skeenes has. 6.0 war, Jackson. M has 4.3. Skeenes has an era+ of 213 and Jackson. M has an ops+ 128. Jackson is great but Skeenes has been otherworldly with his dominance as a pitcher.
The Skenes glazing is so out of control. Merrill is one of the major reasons the Padres are in contention. Let’s just say that overall Merrill is more valuable everyday as a player and has shown up and played well every game. Pitcher bias is a real thing.
One could argue Merrill glazing is out of control too bozo
Every single Skenes topic I see has a bitch like you crying and sucking Merrill off.
@@holmes11_86 chill my guy if you have an opinion express it freely but there is no need to be calling people bozos cause you don’t like their take.
This is part of the reason why I'm convinced the league hates the padres and padres fans between how much they glaze the dodgers and how much they glaze Skenes it's ridiculous
@@marcosclegane6421 His comment is what you take of it, if you cant handle bozo then you certainly cant handle defending your take.
I’m impressed that Livy Dunne wasn’t brought up one time during this video lmao
Would hurt if we just let it tie? I will say I think its much harder for a rookie to come in and pitch like Skenes has (especially with the Pirates offense and bullpen backing you up) then hitting like Merril.
Merrill will win. Skenes is great, but he isn’t the best rookie this season… He may be the best rookie pitcher, but he is not the best rookie as he has not provided the value that the everyday players have. I’m saying this as a pitcher myself, and I still believe Merrill has been the best rookie due to his impact.
Additionally, I think Skenes could probably get a Cy Young, but definitely not rookie of the year.
Jackson Merrill Got 0 Hype this year and made his name known.
@@Komo47 that doesnt mean anything, skenes is the better player which means it should go to him
The merrill glazing is incredible. Skenes is having a historic year.
Jackson Merrill is winning it, comeback to this comment and pin it.
Jackson Merrill really stepped up this year. Before the opening day of 2024, he was not even the Jackson brothers.
I agree
Cap
He shouldn't
Yep
A guy who plays everyday vs a guy who plays 6 innings every 5 days? One has to produce and get results every day, every game, every inning. The other has to produce for 6 innings every 5 days.. who plays more?
That’s not Skenes fault, but Skenes appearances have been more valuable, who would u rather have? A guy with a 1.99 ERA come out every 5 days and give you like 6 innings with 9 strikeouts or a guy with a .820 OPS everyday
Might as well not have any pitchers on the roster then, huh? I guess you're better off signing 1 position player instead of 5 pitchers because pitchers contributions pale in comparison 😅
bro jackson got machado and tatis skeene the only guy on that team that can pitch
@@sir.muffiniii7011more valuable that’s why pitt is 15-33 since july real value there bud.
@@ibelucrative9920 that’s not Skenes fault at all and you know that
Skenes is having a historic season.
They need separate categories for pitcher and position players--you know, like they have for EVERY other fucking year besides rookie. The rookie year is not magically exempt from needing two awards for two very different performances.
Paul Skenes 6.0 WAR, ERA+ 213, WHIP .962, K/9 11.5. Pitchers in baseball history with those numbers:
Pedro Martinez 2000
Paul Skenes 2024
Jackson Merrill is having a good season. Paul Skenes is having a historic season and will win ROY easily.
Jackson Merrill has the most home runs as a rookie in padres history and hit more game tying or walk off home runs in padres AND mlb history
@@MichealScarn-bw1lf Maybe for the Padres, but not in MLB history. The stat you are thinking of for Merrill is that he hit more home runs in the 9th inning or later to tie or take the lead for a player at his age, 21, not of all players in MLB history.
What’s more important in terms of being a rookie. A rookie performing for a potential playoff team, or a rookie performing for an under .500 team?
Exactly
@@LangyLang that has nothing to do with winning this award🤣🤦
@@holmes11_86 winning doesn’t matter. Got it
@@LangyLang For a ROTY, no it doesnt
The crappiness of the Pirates is just another sign of how great Skenes has been. Their bullpen is horrid, and has been especially horrid when trying to hold a lead for him. He'd have at least 4 more wins if they had the Padres' bullpen. And if they had a competent offense to support him, he'd have another couple W's and 2 fewer L's. He could have easily had a 17-1 record at this point if not for his bad teammates playing poorly.
One thing to add, Jackson Merrill is not just having a productive season, he is doing it late in game when they need him most. Not sure what his BA is in the 7,8,9th inning but it is right up there.
Where he was last year has nothing to do with ROY. If you want to play that game, think about this: Merrill had never played centerfield before spring training. He had to learn a new position and he still leads all rookies in every major batting category.
I waited till I watched the video. I enjoyed it. Subscribed.
Yes Jackson Merril is great, but the stuff Skenes is doing is insane, sub 2 era with all the k’s and yhe stuff is so nasty, Skenes got it
Hell naw
It's crazy how good Skenes is. Too bad the Pirates will never make a play off run with him.
Merrill and it is not even close
For the AL i think Austin wells, he's second in AL rookie war by a little and is a catcher not a courner outfielder which in my mind at least makes him much more valuable
“unanimous” and there is fucking Jackson Merrill being one of the best hitters in the league, played SS and moved to CF and is one of the best defensive players, he skipped AAA, he was in AA. It should be close but not “obviously”
I don't know about that. Best pitcher in Baseball versus, all star hitter
Half of that stuff doesn’t matter and he’s not one of the best hitters in the league
@@greenfinmusic5142 he is not below average defensively
skenes definitely deserves it...6.0 pitching WAR, 2nd best in the NL, 3rd best in ML...merrill and chourio are so similar, nearly identifcal stats (both around 4-ish WAR), they will likely split some votes.
Saying skenes is the unanimous choice isn't disrespect, its flat out stupid. Merrill will walk away. With this thing. 6 innings a week vs. everyday major impact. C'mon give me a break
Actually Roty goes to Ben Simmons
Jackson Merrill for ROTY ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ RAH
Judge will win MVP, but it’s far from unanimous. Bobby Witt Jr. is a phenomenal player and will definitely be in the conversation.
Merrill Merrill Merrill Merrill Madness
skenes buddy
(Opinion) Italk normally your takes are good but this is one of the worst takes I have ever seen. Skene’s is good but over glazed. Jackson Merrill is the easy pick because he’s clutch, he play insane defense, and he hasn’t gotten injured yet. He’s a big part of this Padres team. Tell me would you rather have a person who lead a team to the playoffs and is one of the best hitters this year or a pitcher on a bad team with good stats. Personally I believe that Merrill should win it.
theyre gonna make a livvy dunne award
Paul Skenes plays 5-6 inning 4 times a month. Jackson Merrill plays every game. They are not comparable! Personally Pitchers and Hitters should have separate awards!
@@greenfinmusic5142 1 number to rule them all! 🤡
One of the only times I disagree with you, I believe Skenes has more hype and might be better in the future, but right now, Merrill is winning ROY
I will be upset if he goes unanimous
Jackson Chourio stepped in for Christian Yelich (who was in MVP form), and helped the Brewers to prove everyone wrong and win the Central.
He should at the very least finish second in voting.
Central is complete ass, i dont think Chourio made that much of a difference.
No way in hell he wins it over Merrill… Merrill has been a critical part of the padres success this year which factors in the ROTY without a doubt.
Team success doesn’t factor into individual awards in baseball because unlike other sports one guy can’t take over a game in baseball, that’s why guys like Ohtani and Trout can win MVPs
It factors in for sure. There are past examples I can reference to. You should look it up
@@michaelbuchheit1463 can u provide some?
Does anyone not remember the outcome of 2022 and Spencer Strider putting up ridiculous numbers only to be beaten by his teammate Michael Harris??? Strider's numbers aren't too far off from Skenes and they have both thrown the same number of innings so far... not sure if Skenes will start 1 more game or not. Merrill, by far, has put up better numbers than Harris (has also played way more games while keeping solid numbers)... Merrill deserves ROY playing an above average CF for pretty much the entire season. Skenes hasn't been in the majors for the entire season and hasn't nearly made the type of difference Merrill has made to the Padres, who will be a 90 plus winning team at season's end. This debate is ridiculous... if Skenes had been up sooner, then sure... but he's only pitched 131 innings... not even close
i think skenes must win, but i also think julio was more obvious
I can’t understand everyone saying Merrill should win. Merrill is having literally the most average rookie of the year season ever. Skenes has 1.99 ERA 213 ERA+ and 6 WAR. He has a higher WAR than Merrill despite missing the first two months.
you are smoking crack if you think hes having an "average" rookie year LMAO
@@PadresEnjoyer A 125-130 OPS+ and 4.5-5 WAR is a pretty average rookie of the year season.
Jackson Merrill is hitting just 28% better than the average pitcher while Skenes is pitching better than the probable cy young winner in Chris Sale. Merrill is having a good season, but it isn’t on the same level as Skenes’s season so far.
@@ToonTwist i for about a week thought Merrill was gonna win but now its not even close
Sorry but Merrill has been more consistent. As much as I think Skenes deserves it, I think longevity factors in to the argument. He’s been up with the team the whole year. If Skenes was up the whole year and did this, then no question he should win it, but I just think that’s the biggest damage to his argument
Merrill is having the most average rookie of the year season ever. Skenes has 213 ERA+ 🤔
If Skenes played the whole year he would win Cy Young, not just ROY
Merrill was pretty inconsistent for a bit around the all star break, whereas Skenes has consistently been elite
@@sir.muffiniii7011 sure but despite having a down June, he is still hitting .292, 24 homeruns, 89 RBIs, 4.3 WAR, .830 OPS on the season as a 21 year old rookie, so you could argue he would be over .300 if it weren’t for that. If I could give the ROTY to 2 players, no question if we be these 2. The longevity argument still applies and it’s the same reason why Churio isn’t the favorite. This is a close race but I think Merrill wins by a tooth
@@ToonTwist average isn’t the right word
Great assessment
Pitches an avg 5 innings only every 5th day, team is last in division, tied for 30th in strikeouts. I'm sorry but as a pitcher, you need to have a near CY Young quality season to deserve the award, of you ask me.
Jackson Merrill has played more games than innings pitched by Skenes. Jackson Merrill is the ROY
jackson got machado and tatis skeene the only pitcher on that teak
@@MatthewVasquez-x9s Skenes got no pressure with the Pirates. Merrill has to step up to the talent on his team and has ALL DAMN YEAR!
Bro like dude go no inning, and in the middle he went against good teams then fell off and went against bad teams I would hie loved to see him go against Merrill. But it’s going to be him because of the hype and the amount of love he gets. And the way Skenes is just nasty.
Skenes is having one of the greatest years by a rookie pitcher ever. He is already the best pitcher in baseball.
Best rookie pitcher I can agree but best in all of MLB? NO. Longevity, consistency and accomplishments matter before we call players as the best.
It's ok to have an opinion and just be wrong. 6 innings every 5 days doesn't equate to every single game.
I'd be more in favor of Cy Young than rookie of the year and even then he's 7 starts short 🤷
agreed don’t need to watch but i will
this is a terrible take.
Not to say that Skenes wont win it or doesnt deserve to win it, but to say that Merrill and even Chuorio wont get any votes is ABSURD and just blind to what both of those guys (much more so Merrill) have done for their teams day in and day out compared to every 5-6 days and missing the playoffs Paul Skenes
The Jackson brothers 😆 Nice one !!
Why are all the merril fans acting like they don’t glaze him??
We don’t glaze him as much as much has skenes
One plays every day. The other every 5th. One plays 130+ games a year. The other maybe 20. One plays 9 innings a game. The other maybe 5 on average...
I will say this right now - I think it's incredibly close between Merrill and Skenes. I think Merrill is going to win it though for three simple reasons. One, Skenes hasn't played the entire season - that shouldn't be a knock on him but you can blame the Pirates on that. Two, Skenes numbers are Historic - but Merrill has done Historic things like what was mentioned in the video at Clutch Time and at one point literally carried the Padres. Numbers are nice, but what did those numbers do to get that Rookie's team to where they wanted to go? In that respect, Merrill's numbers mattered more then Skenes numbers have. But Three, the biggest reason, is that Skenes is now DONE for the year. His body of work is complete, thanks to how much the Pirates sunk - thanks to getting blasted (and SWEPT) in their Season Series with the Padres & Jackson Merrill who had a hand in a number of those games. Meanwhile, Merrill is not close to done with the Padres looking to chase down the Dodgers for the NL West Title and will likely appear in the Playoffs. If he hits more Game Winning Home Runs in the Post-Season, I just don't see how Skenes will top that at this point.
Skenes will win, if Rookie of the Year is determined only with the Regular Season. But if the Post-Season is added in, and Merrill goes off -- the award is going to go to the Rookie that helped his team get into the Post-Season.
Usually in baseball team narratives and records dont matter for individual awards, and ROY and all awards are based strictly on the regular season
Awards are determined by how you perform in the regular season. There are other awards that would determine your performance in the playoffs (which don't count at the moment).
2012 Mike Trout would like a word
This is like watching FlightReacts talk about Steph Curry 😂
One of the best rookie seasons ever/ greatest season in club history >>> an above average year for a position player who happens to be rookie.
Hahahah the worst take
@@michaelbuchheit1463 majority of teams would pick Skenes over the other two if they had the chance
I can totally see Skenes in Philly
he should come to dodgers
If skenes doesn’t win the award another pitcher should never win the award ever again then.
So, give him the Cy Young. For ROTY, it should be Jackson Merrill. Not only is he the most clutch but he's playing out of position (he's a natural shortstop who has never played center field until the beginning of this season). He also play almost everyday, unlike Skenes would only play once every 5 days.
What your saying: pitchers should never win a non Cy young ever again
@@commanderaxw not necessarily. They should have one for pitching and one proposition players… That would be the best way to do it.
@@stores17if their production was similar then maybe, but Skenes has had a historically good season
one has tatis and machado one has nobody and yet doing better its skenes
@@stores17 I wouldn’t be opposed to that
Kershaw and degrom has had better pitching season.
Jackson Merrill is an all star player. Paul Skenes has been the best pitcher in the baseball. Paul Skenes should be the obvious choice.
He's not even a top 5 in the nl are you high?
@@secretagentrandybeans364 what are you talking about?
Unanimously is crazy
Jackson Merrill no question asked
Paul Skenes needs to be snubbed.
I think he has a case for cy young
Merrill wins it if San Diego goes deep
If it isnt Merrill, mlb is doing more than just glazing like this content creator.
Yeah he’s really good but he’s not the same impact player Jackson Merrill is on his team
Bro hasn’t heard of Jackson Merrill
I know it's not the MVP award, but Jackson Merrill has been the most valuable rookie to his team.
I think Jackson churio has something to say about that
He is though. What Merrill has done has been done countless times before
Countless rookies have been consistently clutch in the highest-leverage situations, thereby flipping losses into wins? Countless rookies set records for the number of high-leverage home runs over the course of a 50 game period? While playing gold-glove caliber defense at a new position? While playing 155+ games?
@@td4637the only argument for Merrill is clutch, he’s literally just been a better 2022 Michael Harris
@@sir.muffiniii7011 Michael Harris won ROY, right?
@@sir.muffiniii7011impact, slenes has been good but not as impactful
@@td4637 yes, but he also wasn’t going up against a guy with a 213 ERA+
Where the Austin Wells appreciation vid releasing?
Honestly, it’s close to roy and mvp….
I want Merril to win it so bad.
how the hell did you spelled Jackson Merrill??
Skenes is gonna win it
It's Jackson Merrill who is Rookie of the Year. Come on man, I thought you were better than this. Paul Skenes is amazing but Jackson Merrill is on another level. There is no debate.
the 130 innings isn't enough
For a rookie? Absolutely it is lol. I'm not saying he should win Cy Young even tho he should def get votes
@@iTalkStudios he’s missed about 10 starts this year due to pitching every 6 days and missing all of April and a 1/3 of May. That alone gives Merrill the edge
@@AgnusDeiGloriabozo take
Tommy John in the future 100%
No disrespect my guy but you just overbooking how historic Merrill has been is insane. You gave his numbers and said yeah but this pitcher is better. I completely disagree and so do many people. The unanimous Rookie of the year? I smell a very strong bias.
bout time someone said the truth
Merrill deserves it more, but MLB will make sure Olivia Dunne's boyfriend wins it
J. A. C. K. S. O. N. …..M. E. R. R. I. L. L. !!
I think Chewbacca should win Wookie of the Year, easily... Wait, what are we talking about again...?
that thumbnail made him look like 40 uears old rookie
And, if not for the moronic manager who pulled him far too early in many games and blew his earned wins with terrible releivers and closers who could not close a closet door, he would have probably been 15 - 2 with a sub 2 ERA. Rock on Paul. We will love you until the singling cheap owners give you away when it is time for you first real contract.
Makes playoffs
Played more games
Most clutch player in the league
Not in the remote conversations for ROY
Lmaoo talking about biased
Shohei is on the verge of a 60/60 season. MVP has to go to him this year! 🎉 🥇
sure, coz the MLB laced his balls for the last few weeks lol
Jackson Merrill!!!!!!!!!
Merrill is an everyday player.
not skeenes fault
Arguable but still laughable. This is what you dont realize as a viewer who never even played HS ball. Pitching is not EASY BUT ill take the guy who is smashing 100 mph balls then credit the guy who is throwing them. Merill wins mid diff.
That’s not how the award works, just bcz what he does it harder doesn’t mean he’s better, Skenes has been a better pitcher than Merrill has been a hitter and fielder
@@sir.muffiniii7011 We shall come back to this soon
@@gabegilbert1043 we will
Pretty sure the pirates aren’t in playoff contention
And?
not skenes fault padres got machado and tatis bud
@@MatthewVasquez-x9s not Merrill’s fault Pittsburghs owner doesn’t Wanna win
@@iTalkStudios most ROTY winners are decided by which rookie makes the playoffs
Merril must win
I’ve had my suspicions that this iTalk guy was a clown, but this confirms it. You obviously haven’t been paying attention if you think Skenes deserves it over Jackson Merrill.
It’s so obvious that nobody agree’s with you .. a pitcher that pitches every 5 days is not worth as much as an everyday player .. not alone an every day centerfield who’s been infront of a playoff push … those clutch hits matter & the Padres wouldn’t be in the playoffs without him.. Italk always fulll of shhhit
I agree. To say Merrill is not even in the conversation is insane
yea not so much that merrill is the roty but to say he isnt even in the conversation is the worst take ive seen thus far
Skenes wins it easy
Nice click bait brother. It’s obviously Merrill
-Padres1969
@@iTalkStudios Dude plays once a week. Jackson Merrill is out there every single game. Has a 5.1 WAR which is higher than Skenes and doesn’t need a famous girlfriend to get him more clout.
@@Padres1969W Skenes has a 6 WAR
@@iTalkStudioslmaoooo
@@iTalkStudioscook that fraud
Sorry you know merill is taking kt
Glorified relief pitcher
Merrill gonna win it