The (tricky) legal instructions for the jury in NY v Trump
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 май 2024
- Harry talks to the Honorable Shira Scheindlin, who served as a federal judge in Manhattan for 22 years, about the legal instructions that Justice Merchan will shortly provide the jury in the Trump case. There are several vexing legal issues, starting with the core felony charge, which requires the jury to find Trump caused the falsification of records with the intent to commit another crime. What other crime might that be, and need the jury agree on it? What happens if the jury concludes that Trump acted both to keep information from the voting public and to shield Melania? Will the judge give a “missing witness” charge to the jury about Allen Weisselberg? And to what strategic decisions for the parties do these issues give rise?
-
TALKING FEDS PODCAST is a roundtable discussion that brings together prominent former government officials, journalists, and special guests for a dynamic and in-depth analysis of the most pressing questions in law and politics.
New episodes every week! Listen wherever you get your podcasts.
Apple Podcasts: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/57MG7Rv...
Make sure to SUBSCRIBE!
/ @talkingfeds
FOLLOW US
Website: www.talkingfeds.com/
Twitter: / talkingfedspod
Harry’s Twitter: / harrylitman
Instagram: / talkingfedspod
Facebook: / talkingfeds
TikTok: / talkingfedspod
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER: www.talkingfeds.com/contact
BECOME A PATREON MEMBER: / talkingfeds
CONTACT US
Contact forms: www.talkingfeds.com/contact
Email: talkingfedspodcast@gmail.com
I'm 71 years old and petrified that Trump might get back into the White House . He should not be allowed to even DRIVE PAST the White House.
With luck and justice, he'll be too old for a driver's license and too broke for an Uber.
He's already DONE!!!!
Lets hope so!@@karynajabrail5035
He never has driven! Except for driving us crazy! 😠💙💙💙✌🏻
We all need to remind EVERYONE to do a thorough research on Biden's policies and wins for the American people and CORRECT THAT PUBLIC RECORD! THEN..... Keep talking about it and get people fired up to vote & VOTE ALL 💙 ✔️
Thank you for this conversation and explanation. I’m 74 in good health and have longevity in my family. I look forward to the day that I don’t hear trump’s name in the news!!
DITTO!
This judge knows her stuff. Why do we have Alito and Thomas when we could have a real judge with real competence like her instead?
Agreed!!!!!
These conservative judges are all compromised from the get-go. They know EXACTLY what they are buying before they are nominated.
They need to be REMOVED!!!!!!!
Politics
She wouldn't do the corrupt bidding of the right. Biden appointed Judge Ketanji Jackson, she has proven to be worth her salt, during the short time she has held her seat. She'll become more influential with time. But she's made a difference already.
I love when you invite judges to speak on this show, Harry. Thank you and the judge for keeping us informed.
Yes, judges have a different perspective and knowlege base than mere attorneys. Scheindlin is excellent.
Yes. Totally agree!
Judge Scheindlin is excellent, as are Harry's questions. I also like their mutual respect.
A perfect pairing of respect & knowledge! Thank you!
@@jollyjime2560 yes. Well said. “A perfect pairing of respect and knowledge!”
It’s refreshing to see and hear from a real judge applying the law without fear or favour and not blowing bubbles up trump’s rear end.
I love that we get to learn from a wise, intelligent, older woman who is clearly staying sharp. It disturbs me how many people think Biden is mentally incapable. It's the opposite. His wisdom and the wisdom of people like this justice are essential at this time.
💙💙 Your conversation with the renown Honorable Shira Scheindlin is captivating. The content is very interesting. I always thoroughly enjoy your commentaries. Thank you for your commitment to fight to relay truth and honesty to the public. Ps… Ma’am you look amazing!
Totally agree!
Harry, we absolutely loved having this woman on the podcast. Please have her back as often as possible.
Wow! Thanks Judge Scheindlin. Very nicely done. 🇺🇸
Very impressed, Judge Sheindlin! Thank you so much!
Thank you Harry for bringing brilliant guests into the discussion and furthering our legal education.
Thank you Harry Litman and Honorable Shira Scheindlin, great analysis and dignifying decorum.
Yes! Wonderful!
I never thought I’d be vitally interested in jury instructions, but here I am! Thank you for the thousandth time, Mr. Litman!
My hope is that the jury stays safe. There are crazy trumpers out there that would do unspeakable acts for him.
Thank you, Harry! This judge is so intelligent & so bright - a pleasure to listen to her! And so beautiful! She is much to be admired! You two provided us with extensive information in a fascinating conversation!! Please have her again!
I just want Trump to be held accountable for his crimes. All of his whiny accusations of unfairness are not an excuse for his criminality. 📜🤔
Judge Scheindlin is super-smart.
Brilliance like this is just so awesome to observe.
Yes!
Feeling a lot less hopeful of a conviction after hearing this.
She is wonderful! She has wisdom.
the Judge was fantastic! Thank you for having her as a guest. 👍
What an excellent interview!
That really increased my appreciation for the complexity of the charges in this case.
This was great to see Harry dialogue with someone with equal or even greater legal expertise. The two of you need to create a weekly segment titled “The Judge and the Juror “
Loved this!
Thanks Harry for the discussion...calm and civilized.
In the hands of the jurors 🙏
Great interview, Harry! Judge Scheindlin did a great job and her interaction with you gave us real insight into what lies ahead... No easy answers! Let's hope justice prevails!
Great episode! I loved listening to Judge Scheindlin. What a beautiful mind she has!
Agreed! Not at all like the other Judge of the same last name!
This is an important discussion- thank you Mr. Litman and Honorable Judge .
We thank Judge Scheindlin for another fabulous visit!
Harry, Honorable Shira Scheindlin, thank you so much for taking the time to share this valuable information. This was a very interesting show.
Everybody, enjoy a great and wonderful day.
Such a great guest. Must have been a great judge in her time.
Thank you for a very insightful discussion.
Thank you to both Harry and Judge Scheindlin, what a helpful discussion. I look for the experts for discussion of these legal cases and Harry always provides them for us.
Wow! Thank you *so* much for this great discussion/interview with the Hon. Shira Scheindlin! What a brilliant woman! What a gift you both gave us with your wonderful legal analysis! Thanks again, Harry and thank you Your Honor! ⚖️
Wow, marvelous. Thank you so much, Harry, for inviting Judge Scheindlin to explain all this. And thank you Judge Scheindlin for participating and educating us!
Excellent discussion of a sticky, and crucially important, matter. Frankly, I'm wishing DA Bragg could have found a charge that was easier for the jury. Cross your fingers!
Me, too!
It only feels sticky as it hasn't been discussed/mulled over at all in the public sphere. This is a start. Every journalist/pundit should be discussing this so it's in the public mind.
I love the Judge. She was so generous with her time and sharing her expertise. Really enjoyed listening to the two of you try to piece out the complexities of this case. Thank you to you both. As always, great job, Harry!
She was a wonderful guest she made it simple enough that even I understood what was going on. You did a great job in stopping her and asking questions, I did have to back up and watch certain parts again. But, hey my brain wonders around sometimes. Thank you so much for having this I appreciate you explaining all this to us.
Fascinating discussion with the delightful Judge Scheindlin. I'm sure I'm not the only new subscriber this video earned. Well done, sir.
Excellent video, thank you. As always, your legal analysis is the finest!
Excellent podcast!
Great guest, Harry! Thanks so much for helping us understand the system.
Thank you Harry and Judge Scheindlin, I found this discussion challenging and shedding light on the process. I have an appreciation of the burden on legal representation. I pray they are true to the law. Then there’s the jury. Clear integrity for their decisions. I trust the judge.
Excellent interview very much appreciated.
Yes!
Thanks HL for bringing the judge to explain the procedures. Im more hopeful than ever.
REALLY GREAT BREAKDOWN! This Judge is amazing! Is she a politician now? She sure should be although you can tell that she's already been an important public advocate! WOW! ❤ I really loved this discussion! 🌹
Terrific to have this conversation with such an authority on these matters, and to really get into the details of how the charging process can work. That said... Harry kept interrupting the judge way too often! It's as if he wasn't reading her facial expression to see that she had more good points to make, on subject after subject. Fortunately, she was able to forcefully come back to those points at times.
Great episode. Thx you Harry and Judge Scheindlin. Just excellent.
Love her- a delight to hear Judge’s perspective !!!
What a wonderful seminar for us who know nothing about the law.
logical people.
Thank you for translating the legalese for us.
Those of us who have followed and listened to Harry, Glen Kirshner, Michael Popok, and Ben Meiselas understand quite a bit more than we otherwise would have. This conversation has explained so much more for me to figure. Thank you both! I am eighty-four and will have to listen to this again and again.
Excellent guest. Thank you.
Thank you Harry. This discussion was very informative.
Great job Harry and thx Judge for helping to unpack the complexities of the charges - really helpful!
Harry, I watched this episode two times, back to back to try to absorb all that was discussed. You both have helped me a great deal to understand the elliments in this case. I agree that there is no question about the intent to defraud the voters. It should have been available to the public but it wasn't. This discussion is amazing. I am in awe of Judge Scheindlin! She is the perfect example of what the people should expect justices and judges to be like in these judicial positions. Bring her back again Harry. Very powerful discussion!
Shira Shcheindlin...LEGEND
This was SO helpful! 😊
A delightful and obviously knowledgeable judge. An informative interview. I hope to see her again.
We can count on you, Harry, for these thoughtful and complex discussions-geek on, Harry!!
Fascinating 😊
Wonderful interview. Many thanks to you both. I learned so much without inflammatory rhetoric. I love it ❤
Me, too! Excellent, clear conversation.
I love Harry’s co host. Her reading voice is perfect. Encore!
It is my understanding that the lesser charge is not an option, precluded by statute of limitations, so it's felony or nothing.
Excellent analysis! It is clear that both discussants really love the Law.
Absolutely! Why can’t we have these two in charge?
Kudos, Harry🎉 thank you so much for having an experienced Manhattan Judge in conversation w/you. Thanks for all you do for us.❤ 0:53
She is engaging. Love her sensibility, experinced professionalism and ability to clarify.
non maga type.
Excellent discussion. Thank you both!
What a great guest!! Loved judge Scheindlin! So clearly knowledgeable and well spoken.
Good job
Thank you Harry and your Honor. During a trial where I served as a juror, the judge did give us a summary of charges. This helped tremendously.
Karen Friedman Agnifolo says the statute of limitations has run out on the misdemeanor alone. This is all so wildly complicated and such a great window on the inside of the law. Great guest and conversation, Harry!
Well , if the predicate can’t be charged , how could Trump be found guilty of the felony charge then ?
👍 SHIRA SCHEINDLIN 👍
👍 HARRY LITMAN 👍
What a wonderful, smart and thoughtful judge. Manhattan was so lucky to have her.
only in NY baby!😊
Great guest and conversation. Thank you both
(Harry gulps his stadium cup of brewski while reporting the ballgame)😅
This conversation with Judge Ms Scheindlin
Was interesting, .Good
Questions.
Hi Harry!😊
What a great analysis of law and fact to this case.😊
Wow! This was fantastic
Harry breaks the questions down beautifully.
Wow! Interesting conversation between knowledgeable professionals. Thank you.
Yes. Totally!
💯Excellent informative discourse!
Excellent. This interview gave me a better sense of the step by step process of the jury considerations, judge’s charge and attorney input & debate. As Harry said the successive level of complexity, intent to commit another crime, unlawful means…Wow. I have such respect for the minds of attorneys, judges and the careful consideration of the law to come to as close as possible a correct decision. Thank u
Thank you so much, your Honor.
Thanks Judge Scheindlin, it was fascinating to hear you explain all the intricacies involved. And Thanks Harry.
What a fabulous guest! She is an excellent educator and I thank her!
Thank you for this interesting and informative session.
NOT above the LAW!
you explained this very well... Thank you Ex- Judge Scheindlin and Harry for helping us to understand this.
Thank you both for this outstanding and informative discussion. I have learned so much.
Now my head is spinning!
Thanks. Excellent discussion with clear explanations despite head spinning.😵💫
Regards from France
Thank you !!!!!
Thanks for bringing us such a brilliant serious minded lawyer/judge. Much appreciated!
Mr. Litman this is an excellent choice of the Honorable Shira Scheindlin, your guest here. This interview was very helpful in understanding how jury instructions are compiled and how important the instructions are in determining the guilt or innocence of Defendant Trump.
This is the most informative video I have seen regarding this hush money trial. Her Honor is excellent at explaining for the non legal minds out here. Thank you Judge and Harry.
I agree.
If I ever go to court I want her as my Judge!
Great information.. Very impressive judge. Thank you Harry.
I liked this judge
Excellent explanations! Much appreciated. Harry is dependable for that. Guest was very clear. *️⃣*️⃣*️⃣*️⃣*️⃣