Battles | 16th-Finals - Round 7 : Finnish vs Hungarian

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 27 окт 2024

Комментарии • 42

  • @Superibis.
    @Superibis. 2 года назад +12

    "Kinda makes me laugh how people say [insert language] voices all sound the same, while that's literally the case for any country"... YES! THANK YOU. I'm so tired of this bullcrap 🙄

  • @dubbingcollector
    @dubbingcollector 2 года назад +3

    Another great video! Finnish and Hungarian (especially Hungarian) are so beautiful.

  • @poisonivyYT
    @poisonivyYT 2 года назад +3

    Ooo cool :D This was really interesting to watch, definitely the highlight of my day being sick. I honestly had no inkling who'd win, but to be fair that didn't really matter to me because I just liked to compare the voices to one another and see your opinion. I think both languages have their big hits and big misses & we pretty much see eye to eye a lot here. I had completely forgotten about Fei Fei and this video reminded me of how cool the Finnish voice is. Also, so great that you have some songs of Finnish Elena saved, when my other channel was wiped out, I lost all Elena of Avalor songs in Finnish and I was a bit sad that there's no trace of them on RUclips.
    Great video!! It was a lot of fun to watch, and I really like the editing here, the ink drop effect is cool :D

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад

      Hey I’m glad you liked it :) hope you’re feeling okay though.
      Yeah Finnish Fei Fei is amazing!
      Yeah I think I have most videos of Elena in Finnish, do you want me to send them to you?

    • @poisonivyYT
      @poisonivyYT 2 года назад

      I’m okay, just a common flu, I’m already much better than yesterday :) I read the description, I hope everything is alright with you!
      If you could send what you have, that would be so great!! I honestly don’t even remember what she sounds like… if they ever add the dub to D+, it’ll either be with a completely new voice or they just ask Seera to sing them again; the rights to that dub belong to a TV channel company, idk how that works but when I asked Disney Suomi about the dub of Before Ever After not being on D+, they said that the rights belong to this TV channel which is why they can’t add it to D+… and it’s the same case with Elena.
      And with the launch of D+, every TV channel in Finland seemed to lose their streaming rights to Disney content, so that TV channel has removed the episodes and the Before Ever After movie from their streaming platform, and there’s no trace of the dubs anywhere. It’s so stupid 🥹

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад

      @@poisonivyYT Oh I didn't know Elena was a TV dubbing! It's so weird, like here, no matter where the dub is shown, it's a Disney dub and that's all, so it'll be the same on any TV channel, or DVD or VOD!
      Here's everything I had saved : we.tl/t-2pflMZMN2s

  • @chriskdisney
    @chriskdisney 2 года назад +2

    Oh gosh! 39 rounds.... ☠️☠️
    That must have been exhausting and there are still many rounds on the way. But the result is worth it, just amazing, and I also enjoy reading your comments. I didn't expect Hungarian to hit that high, I thought it was an easy outsider and, thought it lost, it did unexpectedly well!
    I'm not very fond on these 2 dubbing countries, but I loved what Hungary did with "Quest for Camelot" & "The Prince of Egypt"
    We only disagree on some hungarian voices I really love and those are the newer ones, like Elsa, Moana & Jasmine 2019.
    As I have already said to you before, these kind of series are my favourites on your channel and congrats on managing to make it, considering your situation. ❤️

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад +1

      Thanks a lot, I’m glad you liked it.
      And yeah I didn’t think Hungarian would hit that high, but they’ve made pretty great choices especially lately

  • @kithann99
    @kithann99 2 года назад +3

    Johanna Nurmimaa is quite interesting for me lately. I mean, I'm not a fan of her Ariel and it's easily her worst role, but her Snow White is not that bad imo and her songs for Aurora in the Finnish 1987 storybook is just SO awesome I keep wondering what if the movie was dubbed that year as a whole.
    On the other hand, I still don't know how to feel about Marika. Her singing is very weird and I have often seen people calling her Ariel "alien" but still there's something captivating in her performance. I guess she is my guilty pleasure (not to the extent of Kristi Stassinopoulou's Ariel tho, she will always be top #1 guilty pleasure Ariel :D)
    That's just me spitting out some of my opinions tho, that's a great video you've made, keep going!

  • @dvddmlngrc
    @dvddmlngrc 2 года назад +1

    Wow, excellent edition, it was so smooth and elegant.
    Moving on to the battle, it was really tight, I have a soft spot for Finnish voices but Hungarian were amazing as well.
    Normally, I'd put my preferences, but I think I can't with so many rounds, also I don't have time for that haha.
    So, anyway, wonderful battle and excellent choices. The edition was incredible, hope to see new videos from you 🙃

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад

      Thanks a lot, really appreciated :)

  • @pedrovictordonascimentolem7317
    @pedrovictordonascimentolem7317 2 года назад +2

    Guillaume,my opinion:
    Snow White:Oroszlán Szonja (Hungarian,agree)
    Cinderella:Anna Kuoppamaki (Finnish,agree)
    Alice:Tunyogi Bernadett (Mervi sounds too fake for me,she is better as Belle)
    Wendy:Hanna Salakari (Finnish,agree)
    Aurora:Ingrid Kertesi (Paivi sounds too casual for me)
    Shanti:Pirjo Vayrynen (Finnish,agree)
    Ariel:Nina Tapio (I know she sounds annoying,but she is one of my favorite Ariels)
    Belle:Mervi Hiltunen (Defintely love her as Belle,this is the role for her!)
    Jasmine:Janza Kata (Ulla sounds too old for me)
    Nala:Annimaria Rinne (One of my favorite Nalas)
    Odette:Outi Jarvela (I know she sounds agressive,but she is one my favorite Odettes)
    Pocahontas:Anna Udvarias (Arja sounds too operistic for me)
    Esmeralda:Tiina Lymi (Finnish,agree)
    Megara:Nyári Szilvia (She sounded too bitchy for me,but now that's past!)
    Anastasia:Petra Karjalainen (Finnish,agree)
    Kayley:Nina Tapio (One of my favorite Kayleys)
    Mulan:Auth Csilla (Fight me,Heidi lovers!)
    Miriam:Auth Csilla (Too hard for me)
    Kiara:Auth Csilla (Tiina sounds too casual for me)
    Melody:Bógdanyi Titanilla (I know she sounds a bit alien like her mother,but she is a favorite!)
    Giselle:Bernadett Vagó (One of my favorite Giselles)
    Tiana:Bernadett Vagó (Here,she totally shines for me,better than her Anna)
    Rapunzel:Dorina Csifó (Hungarian,agree)
    Anna:Saara Aalto (Bernadett losts her magic she had as Tiana)
    Elsa:Katja Sirkia (Nikolett sounds too lady-like for me)
    Moana:Yasmine Yamajako (I know that some of you don't like Fanni,and I totally respect that)
    Belle (2017):Maaria Nuoranne (She sounds a lot like Mervi,in a younger shape)
    Jasmine (2019):Jenes Kitti (She sounds a lot like Bernadett,and it's way better than her Fei Fei)
    Nala (2019):Péter Szabó Szilvia (She sounds powerful!)
    Fei Fei:Sonja Pajunoja (Kitti losts her magic she had as Jasmine)
    Change'e:Gigi Radics (She sounds young and powerful,gosh,that last note,A5!!!!!!!)
    Mirabel:Esme Kaislakari (Petra sounds too casual for me)

  • @birdsextras8441
    @birdsextras8441 2 года назад +2

    I don't know wether Hungarian musical theatre actresses tend to sound so similar for some reason, or if people intentionally cast similar sounding Hungarian singers for animated movies, but honestly, being a native speaker, I probably wouldn't have noticed they sounded similar if so many people hadn't pointed it out.😅

  • @mulwerk8574
    @mulwerk8574 2 года назад +1

    So nice to see that the battle of languages are back again! It's so entertaining to see this kind of videos :D.
    I really like both Hungarian and Finnish dubs (but between those I tend to prefer Finnish). And even of they somehow are from the same language family, each dubbing sound really different from the other.
    As always, the coments are in point! I really focus reading them more than just checking the winner of each round. Oh and also I really respect you for comparing the voces 39 TIMES! I don't think I could hace the patience to do this x).
    And don't worry, the audio is totally ok. Hope you are doing bettter with your ear problem. Amazing video :D

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад +1

      Thank you, I’m glad you like the comments and enjoy watching the video :)
      Lol yeah those videos take quite some time because of that so I didn’t think I’ll have the time to finish another, but here it is for now

    • @victorialeon9082
      @victorialeon9082 2 года назад

      @@charguigou Why happened with the Kazakh dub of Shrek? Why didn't he put it with Trolls as well?

  • @elijahmartinobracia4741
    @elijahmartinobracia4741 2 года назад +1

    Finnish Elsa might not be my favorite, but I just love how authentic she sounds, and her screaming somehow made a very fierce Elsa. This is my only opinion that I just wanna share

  • @SpinelSun
    @SpinelSun 2 года назад +4

    Don't worry, the audio levels were absolutely perfect, and even if they weren't it is not something you should apologise about. You did your best given your circumstances and that's all that matters. Sending you tons of hugs and strength

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад +1

      Thank you very much for that, that was very kind.
      Yeah Fei Fei voices are all kinda the same, but Finnish is actually one of the few who stand out to me, you should give her another listen!
      Yeah for Snow White it has been hard, Kukka has been over Szonja for a time, but now at least I like Szonja more.
      I’m glad we agree and that at least I could make my view understandable through the comments!

    • @SpinelSun
      @SpinelSun 2 года назад +1

      @@charguigou Anytime 🧡
      Hahaha okay I trust you I'll give her another listen. Honestly I should give a listen to all of them, I feel like I wronged them so much although they are all good and it was just Netflix casting voice clones 😂

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад +1

      @@SpinelSun well technically the aim of dubbing is to find similar voices lol, so they succeeded in that ^^

    • @SpinelSun
      @SpinelSun 2 года назад +1

      @@charguigou Okay you're very right, I can't say anything against that haha But ugh the differences are such a joy! They succeeded boringly haha

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад +1

      @@SpinelSun totally agree with that haha, for us it’s far more interesting to have diverse voices, like Ariel or Elsa have

  • @LaneTaylor-tv8zu
    @LaneTaylor-tv8zu 2 года назад +1

    I really loved that design 😍

  • @peru4068
    @peru4068 2 года назад +1

    Snow White 1962/1982: 🇭🇺 Hungarian (I don't like both, but I prefer Házy)
    Snow White 1994/2001: 🇫🇮 Finnish (I love Kukka-Maaria)
    Cinderella: 🇫🇮 Finnish 1992
    Alice: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Wendy: 🇫🇮 Finnish 1992
    Aurora: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Shanti: 🇫🇮 Finnish 1994
    Ariel: 🇫🇮 Finnish 1998 (Nina!!)
    Belle: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Jasmine: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Thumbelina: 🇫🇮 Finnish (I don't like both, but I prefer Outi)
    Nala: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Odette: 🇫🇮 Finnish (Same than Thumbelina)
    Pocahontas: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Esmeralda: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Megara: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Anastasia: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Kayley: 🇭🇺 Hungarian 1998 (Sorry Nina, but I prefer Auth)
    Lady Juliana: 🇭🇺 Hungarian 1998
    Mulan: 🇭🇺 Hungarian (Auth!!)
    Miriam: 🇫🇮 Finnish (I love both, but I prefer Nina, Sorry Auth)
    Tzipporah: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Kiara: 🇭🇺 Hungarian (Auth!!)
    Melody: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Giselle: 🇭🇺 Hungarian (Vágo!!)
    Tiana: 🇭🇺 Hungarian (Vágo!!)
    Rapunzel: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Anna: 🇫🇮 Finnish (Sorry Vágo, but I prefer Saara)
    Elsa: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Elena: 🇫🇮 Finnish (TV Series)
    Moana: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Belle 2017: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Mary Poppins 2018: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    Jasmine 2019: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Nala 2019: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Queen Iduna: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Fei Fei: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Chang'e: 🇭🇺 Hungarian
    Mirabel: 🇫🇮 Finnish
    🇫🇮 Finnish: 20
    🇭🇺 Hungarian: 18
    🇫🇮 Finnish Wins

  • @aww.katiie6857
    @aww.katiie6857 2 года назад

    My opinion:
    Snow White 1: Hungarian
    Snow White 2: Very complicated..., but let´s go with Hungarian
    Cinderella: Finnish
    Alice: Hungarian
    Wendy: Finnish
    Aurora: Hungarian
    Shanti: Finnish
    Ariel: Finnish
    Belle: Finnish
    Jasmine: Hungarian
    Thumbelina: Finnish
    Nala: Finnish
    Odette: Finnish
    Pocahontas: Hungarian
    Esmeralda: Finnish
    Mergara: Hungarian (but i love finnish too)
    Anastasia: Finnish
    Kayley: Hungarian (but i love finnish too)
    Juliana: Hungarian
    Mulan: Finnish
    Miriam: Finnish
    Tzipporah: Hungarian
    Kiara: Finnish
    Melody: Finnish
    Giselle: Hungarian
    Tiana: Hungarian
    Rapunzel: Hungarian
    Anna: Hungarian
    Elsa: Finnish
    Elena: Finnish
    Vaiana: Finnish
    Belle 2017: Hungarian
    Mary Poppins 2018: Finnish
    Jasmine 2019: Hungarian
    Nala 2019: Hungarian
    Iduna: Hungarian
    Fei Fei: Hungarian
    Chang´e: Hungarian
    Mirabel: Finnish
    Hungarian: 20
    Finnish: 19
    Hungarian wins!

  • @raneemacintosh6842
    @raneemacintosh6842 2 года назад +1

    Somehow I feel like we will have opposite feelings on almost everything in this video lol. Tho out the gate I like Erzsebet. Oh what do you know, the name of a Cinderella has changed once again. I agree so much about your Ingrid comment...she's my fave Aurora other than the original English and I can't really put my finger on why. She's just good. I haven't thought of Outi Järvela in yeeears I was just reminded of how much I love her weird voice. Finnish and Hungarian are both Top 5 on Kayley. Also for Kiara, Finnish is my #1 and Hungarian is like, maybe 2nd or 3rd. I don't listen to the Juliana song so that Hungarian version really hit for me in that brief line there. I think with Rapunzel both these languages started a trend: Finnish voices were always nasal and energetic and Hungarian were just older or younger sounding versions of Bernadett Vago. The 2019 Nalas were hard to hear cause they are not as good as Anni and Anna to me.... WTF Fei Fei was Jasmine in Finnish? She's seriously one of my favorite Fei Fei.
    I'm so glad you're putting out these videos even if you are mostly stepping away from this; it's bringing me BACK to the old days when I loved listening to these dubs.

  • @s.a8714
    @s.a8714 Год назад

    SnowWhite(1962/1982): Hungarian🇭🇺 Snow White(1994/2001): Hungarian🇭🇺 Cinderella:Finnish🇫🇮 Alice:Hungarian🇭🇺 Wendy:Finnish🇫🇮 Aurora:Hungarian🇭🇺 Shanti:Finnish🇫🇮 Ariel:Finnish🇫🇮 Belle:Finnish🇫🇮 Jasmine:Hungarian🇭🇺 Thumbelina:Finnish🇫🇮 Nala:Hungarian🇭🇺 Odette:Hungarian🇭🇺 Pocahontas:Hungarian🇭🇺 Esmeralda:Finnish🇫🇮 Megara:Hungarian🇭🇺 Anastasia:Finnish🇫🇮 Kayley:Finnish🇫🇮 Juliana:Hungarian🇭🇺 Mulan:Finnish🇫🇮 Miriam:Finnish🇫🇮 Tzipporah:Hungarian🇭🇺 Kiara:Hungarian🇭🇺 Melody:Finnish🇫🇮 Guselle:Hungarian🇭🇺 Tiana:Hungarian🇭🇺 Rapunzel:Hungarian🇭🇺 Elsa:Hungarian🇭🇺 Anna:Hungarian🇭🇺 Elena:Finnish🇫🇮 Moana:Hungarian🇭🇺 Belle 2017:Hungarian🇭🇺 Mary Poppins:Finnish🇫🇮 Jasmine 2019:Hungarian🇭🇺 Nala 2019:Hungarian🇭🇺 Iduna:Finnish🇫🇮 Fei Fei:Hungarian🇭🇺 Chang'e:Hungarian🇭🇺 Mirabel:I don't like both Finnish:🇫🇮15 Hungarian🇭🇺:23 Hungarian wins

  • @hangaborbely8897
    @hangaborbely8897 8 месяцев назад

    My list:
    Finnish Hungarian
    Snow White 1
    Snow White 2 Cinderella
    Alice
    Wendy
    Aurora
    Shanti
    Ariel
    Belle
    Jasmine
    Thumbelina
    Nala
    Odette
    Pocahontas
    Esmeralda
    Megara
    Anastasia
    Kayley
    Juliana
    Mulan
    Miriam
    Tzipporah
    Kiara
    Melody
    Giselle
    Tiana
    Rapunzel
    Anna
    Elsa
    Elena
    Moana
    Belle 2017
    Mary Poppins
    Jasmine 2019
    Nala 2019
    Iduna
    Fei Fei
    Chang'e
    Mirabel

  • @dasnet6846
    @dasnet6846 Год назад

    My opinion
    Snow White: Hungarian
    Snow White 2: Hungarian
    Cinderella: Finnish
    Alice: Hungarian
    Wendy: Finnish
    Aurora: Hungarian
    Shanthi: Finnish
    Ariel: Finnish
    Belle: Finnish
    Jasmine: Hungarian
    Thumbelina: Finnish
    Nala: Hungarian
    Odette: Finnish
    Pocahontas: Hungarian
    Esmeralda: Hungarian
    Megara: Hungarian
    Anastasia: Finnish
    Kayley: Finnish
    Juliana: Finnish
    Mulan: Finnish
    Miriam: Finnish
    Tzipporah: Hungarian
    Kiara: Hungarian
    Melody: Finnish
    Giselle: Hungarian
    Tiana: Hungarian
    Rapunzel: Hungarian
    Anna: Hungarian
    Elsa: Hungarian
    Elena: Hungarian
    Vaiana: Hungarian
    Belle 2017: Hungarian
    Marry Poppins 2018: Hungarian
    Jasmine 2019: Finnish
    Nala 2019: Finnish
    Iduna: Hungarian
    Fei Fei: Finnish
    Chang'e: Hungarian
    Mirabel: Finnish
    Hungarian: 22 Points
    Finnish: 17 Points
    Hungarian wins!

    • @PopRock-gl5ey
      @PopRock-gl5ey Месяц назад

      Snow White(1962/1982): Hungarian🇭🇺 Snow White(1994/2001): Hungarian🇭🇺 Cinderella:Finnish🇫🇮 Alice:Hungarian🇭🇺 Aurora:Hungarian🇭🇺 Shanti:Finnish🇫🇮 Ariel:Finnish🇫🇮 Belle:Finnish🇫🇮 Jasmine:Finnish🇫🇮 Thumbelina:Finnish🇫🇮 Nala:Finnish🇫🇮 Odette:Hungarian🇭🇺 Pocahontas:Hungarian🇭🇺 Esmeralda:Finnish🇫🇮 Megara:Hungarian🇭🇺 Anastasia:Finnish🇫🇮 Kayley:Hungarian🇭🇺 Mulan:Finnish🇫🇮 Miriam:Hungarian🇭🇺 Tzipporah:Hungarian🇭🇺 Kiara:Hungarian🇭🇺 Melody:Finnish🇫🇮 Giselle:Hungarian🇭🇺 Tiana:Hungarian🇭🇺 Rapunzel:Hungarian🇭🇺 Anna:Hungarian🇭🇺 Elsa:Hungarian🇭🇺 Elena:Finnish🇫🇮 Vaiana:Hungarian🇭🇺 Belle 2017:Hungarian🇭🇺 Jasmine 2019:Hungarian🇭🇺 Nala 2019:Hungarian🇭🇺 Fei Fei:Hungarian🇭🇺 Chang"e:Hungarian🇭🇺 Mirabel:Finnish🇫🇮 Finnish:13 Hungarian:22 Hungarian Wins!

  • @jakoblarsson1926
    @jakoblarsson1926 Год назад +1

    How about swedish vs norwegian?

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  Год назад +1

      It is planned, but I don’t have much time these days

  • @PedroVictor-nn9fq
    @PedroVictor-nn9fq 2 года назад

    Finnish Fei Fei is amazing,Guillaume!! Sonja made a perfect Fei Fei!

  • @thekoreandisneyprincess5958
    @thekoreandisneyprincess5958 2 года назад

    What is the truth about Cinderella's Hungarian dubbing? Pap Éva as both speaking and singing voice or Tiboldy Mária sang only "So This Is Love" and Éva sang other songs?

    • @charguigou
      @charguigou  2 года назад

      Apparently Éva is only the singing voice, and Mária is the singing

    • @whowantmuffin
      @whowantmuffin 2 года назад +1

      Pap Éva is her talking voice and Tiboldi Mária is her singing voice

  • @PixieDust18
    @PixieDust18 Год назад

    J'attends un français vs anglais... 🔥

  • @vanesszakiss8378
    @vanesszakiss8378 2 года назад

    HUNGARIAN ❤️