My uncle got 8 years for moving weed across states and this chick who murdered her brother over inheritance, gets 6 years (with good behavior, probably 4 years) The judicial system is so fucked.
Be even more effed if your skin tone was of a darker hue. The judicial system has never been unbiased. Being super rich helps, they love being bought off.
Control freak, greedy bully. They did get what they want. If I was the mother/grandmother I would leave it all to the son who's not around. But they are obviously willing to kill for that property/inheritance
@traybern the infallible. This is your contribution. Pointing out poor comprehension (of someone probably typing on their phone while pooping) with additional poor comprehension.
Life for a LIFE. Families-Friends & those who suffer from the loss of their loved one- AFTER proving w/out a doubt whomever took that life- Should be made available to the family-friends- TO DO AS THEY WISH!!!
Six years is insane to me. She literally took someone’s life and shown no remorse for it. She gonna get out early on good behavior and capitalize on her uncle’s tragic murder. She’ll probably write a book about it and paint herself as the victim and comment how the justice system is unjust. Yes it is unjust, for not giving you more jail time. Sickening!
6 years is insulting to that mans life .The mother is a greedy women who used her bad acting daughter to get what she wanted . Feel very sad there was no justice for this man.
Yelp I can see mom convincing her daughter that she wouldn’t get much time and when she gets out they will own the ranch ! The greedy will pay one day for sure ! God willing!
The obvious hatred for Shane (?) was so telling for me. I do believe the 2 of them plotted this for awhile. So I say it was premeditated murder. She only got 6 years..ridiculous.
Yeah and the dispute over the property and the fact that he was only murdered AFTER he had legally been awarded it and was trying to get them to sign papers that would show they recognize his ownership. They killed him over property.
Love how Tucker almost makes the smart decision of not talking further without a lawyer present, then proceeds to wave at the camera and...tell them everything. Probably the narcissism kicking in making her think "oh I'm smarter than these cops, I'm sure they will believe me."
@@lexijones8019That's not actually correct. The police do have to stop the interrogation. They did. They also can't initiate another interrogation. They didn't. She invited them to come and talk some more about the case. That constitutes a knowingly and intelligently waiving of her rights. Once that happens, they can begin interrogation again. She can then shut it down again, but she didn't. Anyways, if you want an authoritative source - Miranda v. Arizona 1966 "If the interrogation continues without the presence of an attorney and a statement is taken, a heavy burden rests on the government to demonstrate that the defendant knowingly and intelligently waived his privilege against self-incrimination and his right to retained or appointed counsel." "An express statement that the individual is willing to make a statement and does not want an attorney, followed closely by a statement, could constitute a waiver." Which is, *exactly* the situation that occurred here. Further supported by Edwards v. Arizona 1981 "In concluding that the fruits of the interrogation initiated by the police on January 20 could not be used against Edwards, we do not hold or imply that Edwards was powerless to countermand his election or that the authorities could in no event use any incriminating statements made by Edwards prior to his having access to counsel. Had Edwards initiated the meeting on January 20, nothing in the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments would prohibit the police from merely listening to his voluntary, volunteered statements and using them against him at the trial." In short, once you tell the police that you want to keep your mouth shut, you have to actually... You know... Keep your mouth shut.
@@lexijones8019 not necessarily true. Once she invokes her right to counsel, authorities may not question her any further. If they continue to question/interrogate after that, then yes, it is inadmissible. However, just as one can invoke their 5th Amendment rights, they can also retract them and choose to talk after all. I'd argue that is what happens here. Tucker initiated further dialogue with the investigators and gave her account of the events. Their questions were mostly clarifying the information she was freely giving. There is also another situation where one can invoke their rights yet still incriminate themselves, in where a suspect makes a spontaneous statement that was not prompted by interrogation. For example, while in custody a suspect says "they got what they deserved" or "I'd kill them again if I could" and the statement just came out of the blue (hence being considered spontaneous) and was not influenced at all by the questioning of Law Enforcement, the information can still be used against the suspect. With all that said, defense attorneys can always bring these situations to light in an attempt to suppress the evidence. This occurs in an official suppression hearing in front of a judge and they can decide whether or not the information will be admissible during the trial or not. Courts have ruled both ways regarding these situations, and the judge has complete autonomy over the decision. So, with all that said, you aren't wrong, there are just circumstances where things are different and the courts ultimately decide on how to proceed.
I'm not sure this can be considered a "he said/ she said" case since "he" is dead and can't speak for himself. She clearly murdered him, but sometimes those plea deals are not as risky as a new trial.
I feel like he meant that the notary, the other brother, and his GF were speaking for him. IMO. That could be me reading into it too much lol. I agree with what you are saying though in that sense.
I’ve heard in that video “This isn’t a will!” So I’m guessing the brother called the notary and told the sister it was o my for a will just to trick the grandmother to sign the property over to him. The daughter probably thought “Hey I only took out loans in the amount of maybe $30 grand or so, I still have another $10 grand left if this property is valued at $80 grand, and he’s trying to jip me out of my share and screw us over. He’s a dirty drug addict, a loser, a fall from grace and no one would ever miss him or worry about him…(not sure if he ever had kids of his own so she likely expected him to just “vanish” or not wake up cuz of the drugs.” For some author and her daughter, I’m willing to bet the mom already maxed out her share and the brother let it slide for as long as he could. If they dug deep enough, I’d be willing to guess that the property or the loans on the property started to creep into the brothers entitled amount and that’s when he decided to take action. The mother felt cheated even though she got her loans. She likely didn’t care to acknowledge that the loans she got, were lowering the property which reflected on the brother. It doesn’t matter if he blew it on drugs or not. You can take your money and do whatever with, he had no say, while he could do his. It would be sad to sell a family members home that they raised money to own for themselves only for a relative to blow it all on drugs. I get that. But also, some people you can tell them til your blue in the face that they are touching your inheritance and they just don’t care. They don’t like you feeling like a victim when they have to be it. It just perplexes them. They can’t function without being the victim. Money changes people. I’ve seen it with my mother. When my parents were separated, my mom would still go to family court and talk about my dads stupid things from old jobs he wasn’t working for anymore.. I think a 401k or something..I was young like 13.. she just kept going on and in about that money.. and eventually when they sold the house, they paid off the bank loans and went there separate ways, mom blew through all her money. Some people arnt good with money. We should have money management courses in school. Have you heard. Chase banking has credit cards for students under 18. Not typically credit but I mean debit cards adults parents can monitor transactions and transfer money into their accounts. It’s incredible. Parents can have their kids learn about managing money and expenses. It would be a useful hobby. I’m still horrible with balancing my checkbook. It’s basic math😅
On the video, the mom being all “she’s not signing a grant deed,” that’s pretty much proof they killed the uncle for the land. At least to me. What horrible women.
I’m surprised the prosecutor allowed a 6 year plea deal. Mom will get the property once Grandma dies, and Tucker will get out very soon. I’m not seeing justice here.
@@karenneill9109these losers won’t have any lasting benefit. They’ll blow the money and wind up with nothing before too much time passes. Sounds like they were treating the property like a bank account.
The interrogations of mother and daughter are painful to watch! It’s like watching bad acting school! May Shane RIP. What a senseless murder!! Tucker should’ve gotten more than 6 years and mom too!!
I definitely get this idea, but I also question how I would behave in a situation where I was in a police interrogation, tbh. I get terrible panic attacks when in high-stress situations. While I don't think she was telling the truth... Would people just dismiss me as a "bad actor" if I went nonverbal and curled up into a ball in an interrogation room? Panic attacks can LOOK "dramatic" because they're not neurotypical behavior. Hnn.
@21:35 the only person who reacts to the dramatic screaming is the mother, nobody else even flinches. She went to the Amber Terd school of acting where they teach the (sh!t) STAINivslaski method.
Yes, the mom for LYING to investigators, it is obstruction of justice, it's better to not say anything to them at all than to lie to them.The daughter was MORE of a threat TO her uncle, obviously. She and her mother were a signature or 2 away from losing the rights to any MORE of their parent's property after their deaths, and Mom had already taken out loans on THEIR property,for more than what her half of everything would've been worth..So those 2 would've not gotten any more money off the parents THAT is why she shot her uncle.. When you shoot someone & you have that much motive plus a video that proves the man was not threatening anyone's life at all, then a,15 year minimum sentence should've been her sentence if not more.
For the jury to have found her liable for defamation, that evidence must have been overwhelming, this means they proved actually malice, she must have sent him threatening messages or something
While we obviously dont know the details, if the defamation jury determined there was malice, then that means there was enough evidence to reasonably conclude that she knew she was lying and lied anyway with pure malicious intent.
She seems like a spoiled kid grew up and still thinks she's owed something. Annoyed when she doesn't get her way and expects everyone to believe her. And her mom seems like a "let me speak to the manager" kind of woman.
This is sad . She’s a spoiled Rotten entitled Embarrassin to watch little girl . Her mom was totally behind this ( imo ) Disgusting the interview with the mom . Thank You Mike !! 💚💚
What's really sad is Shane had lived there 16 years while taking care of his ailing father. No mention of anyone else helping the father, just Shane. And suddenly, those 2 bytches want all the inheritance? I've been a caretaker for my ailing/dying parents. It's extremely hard work. More work than caring for small children. Shane deserved that inheritance, those women did not. What a shame! Even outrageous that she only got 6 years. Smdh.😢
Yes, and the history of violence seems to be just whatever those 2 reported. I haven't heard any evidence of it. The fact that he had his gf there and had called the police earlier seems that he was the one afraid. The other brother said he was the nicest one in the family. Which makes sense since he was the one who cared for his dying father. Als is no joke. It's just so sad. I hope those 2 lose the ranch.
Tbf, inheritance is not deserved through actions, it's simply the wishes of a person who dies for how to settle their affairs. Whether or not his sister helped out is not material to the will of inheritance. The fact that she accrued debt against the inheritance, then probably had her daughter murder her brother to steal his half is crazy. Not half as crazy as the fact that she got away with it. There's little justice here.
@@holyhex6520 I think it just goes to show Shane’s good character. There you have someone who paid no attention to her parents but still was getting 50% of the inheritance, and then you have Shane who was a very active part of his parents life and their well being and was essentially being set up to look like this violent monster and slaughtered so the evil lady and her daughter could get money. Absolute disgrace that Tucker only got 6 years. If you take into account time served, she probably would only have to have done about 1-2 years of that sentence
Caretakers receive rarely the credit for the grueling work they do. It’s not about getting paid it’s done by a family member (and nurses during self health care breaks) out of empathy and love. The only true payment for such a misunderstood sacrifice is the joy you receive by making your loved one comfortable. It’s the ultimate gift you can give to a vulnerable and sick human being. I wish there was more support for those of us that do it but there isn’t. Caretakers must remember to take time for themselves so they are not overwhelmed.
Amen. It’s hard work that gets harder and harder, unlike taking care of a healthy child. And it’s ugly and exhausting and emotionally draining. Our society doesn’t acknowledge or respect or compensate the people who do this work nearly as much as it should. And the story of relatives being completely absent during a sick/elderly person’s last years then suddenly materializing when they die and expecting a reward is a very very common one.
“I do not grieve for my brother, I am GLAD he’s dead!” In the mix of all this I have to say this one absolutely tore me apart. To think someone’s sister feels that way…ouch.
@@TS-rd7oy He/she didn't say anything about their story and only commented on the fact it's sad someone would like to see their family member dead. They didn't say one was in the right and the other was in the wrong. Don't be so reactionary.
@@Rugelacharugula the same way you do with any other crime you’d have to prove beyond the shadow of a doubt through evidence that they fabricated it. It’s a hard claim to prove with a high level of evidence required, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t. That means we should apply that same rigourous level of justice to all crimes. You seem to be suggesting that because it’s somewhat difficult and would take a little bit of investigating we should just not bother
@@Bonsoirmonamie sure. “Guess what, rape victim, if your rapist is acquitted (which 993 of 1000 are), it means YOU LIED! And we put *you* on trial! Still wanna *report?”* You should really be in law. Or rape crisis counseling.
My sister survived a couple of rapes and I always find it interesting that the people who are against getting proof for SA also fail to understand that when a guy gets investigated for rape or sexual assault, the cops look into him for other stuff too because it's just sitting there. If my sister had gone to the cops about her first rape, the second wouldn't have happened. But not just her own tapes. This guy has a history of raping women. How many other women got raped because she didn't take it to the cops? She was a junkie at the time, but now, she regrets this very much. People who get upset about requiring women to prove sexual assault invariably don't really care about the other victims. That is pretty sad. In reality, this "believe all women" Schtick is more about giving women the power to use the long arm of the law at their beck and call with impunity, not actually about protecting vulnerable women.
I really detest the way some people feel they're entitled to what their parents earned during their lifetime. Murdering that man over someone else's money is disgusting.
When my father was ill and didn't look like he was going to make it I overheard one of my sisters calling dibs on what furniture and stuff she wanted. He wasn't even dead yet. I made sure everyone knew that.
I have three half siblings, and my biological father (didnt grow up with him or them) inherited a million. two of the three are already vying for this money and hes not dead. They try to turn the family on me. sure I wouldnt mind some cash but I have no cares for this at all. Kinda sick to watch. Heck our dad is still alive anyway. Its nuts.
Funny enough even people with old age want money still for example my grandpa, I'm not even kidding back then he was a abusive, manipulate, greedy bastard. Still he acts like this to this day (he's not even walking any more for God's sake).
Sure they feared him, after taking care of things for years, watching his mom get manipulated by his sister and niece, and watching his inheritance treated like an atm, he was pissed. He was trying to save what was left by way of the grant deed, but they were so very much against that, you can hear the attitude in his sisters voice. She knew she could get more money from the whole deal the way things were. After all the loans ,lowering the value, mom passes away, Sister gets away with all the loan money and half of whats left of value. If he wasn't killed, my guess is that they would have constantly tried to get him out of the whole estate/ inheritance another way.
Based off the home video and the interviews, if she didn’t murder him then she or her mother or even both would’ve murdered him eventually; the moment realization hits that they would either lose the inheritance or their plan of making him miserable, making things miserable for him, wasn’t working they would’ve went straight to murder. Their interviews are creepy as hell; 6 years and they get to keep what he was murder over is a joke.
SIX YEARS? she shows zero accountability, I can't believe she got off this lightly. Imagine being reasonably successful and having so many promising prospects in the future but choose to murder a family member for a few bucks AND THEN still be so entitled that you play the victim to everyone around you. poor shane. even if he was difficult or whatever, he certainly did not deserve this
6 years, thats all?! My gosh, the Uncle didn't get much justice. She is out of jail now probably. It's actually terrifying knowing she and her mother are walking among us.
What you said about nominative determinism makes total sense. People named Dennis are more likely to become dentists. People named Murdaugh are more likely to become murdaughrers.
16:00 I love how the detectives didn’t fall for her “helpless baby bird” routine. She was putting her community theatre acting skills to work and they were just like 😒😐
So do I pal and I'm sure that the majority watching are glad that the detectives weren't fooled by "a woman crying?"(seriously that's all it takes sometimes with some stupid men?) However in lots of cases innocent men are in jail due to a woman perp' crying and simp idiot men cop's believing the act?; Disgraceful
When I watch these true crime stories, I am amazed at the wild swings in terms of sentencing for murder, 1 state the same charge is 20 years another state it’s 5 years. Incredible
6 years for murder?? Wow! So basically she killed him, served a little bit of time and gets to continue living her life like nothing happened?! Our justice system can be so disgusting sometimes!
It's difficult to get a jury to give a heavy sentence to a young (white) woman. We tend to empathize more with women, even when a violent crime has been committed. It's just a by-product of sexism, the assumption that women can't or won't be violent.
Wow ! This one is crazy. Poor Shane , may he rest in peace. The way Tucker’s mom behaved in her interview with detectives makes it easy to see how Tucker could be a bit unhinged! What a sad situation. Great work , Mike , as always. I love ya too !
How could he rest in peace? He was murdered by people who were extorting his mother, who were borrowing against his inheritance and killed him for his inheritance. And the person who came up with the whole plan, Aisling's mother escaped with no charges and Aisling got a slap on the wrist (she'll serve half that time before parole, at most) And she's going to get that inheritance. She will not only not be punished for murder, she will get rewarded with what she wanted from the murder.
She was acting like she's the one who's been wronged, when she was mortgaging the ranch that was supposed to belong to both of them. What a twisted mind.
I live in Medford, about 15 miles from where this happened. She is a piece of work. The whole family is creepy. Tucker was pretty much created in that family.
Tell us more interested in this family I don't know why but there intriguing to me please share any stories you know I love weird people antics and whatnot.
@@SATX_09 @carmendiego Just watch this episode four or five more times. I don't think there's much more to these characters we haven't already seen. ps. @konkubyne...sleep tight...
@@coldbringer9545 I find it hard to believe that we've unearthed all there is to know about these individuals. It's certainly naive to assert this as their closing chapter, presuming no further twists and turns in their tale. In my experience, particularly with such eccentric characters, there's always more beneath the surface. Not 'more' in the sense of positivity necessarily, but rather in terms of intrigue and entertainment.
Wow, I live in Oregon and have never heard this story. It's crazy what money and inheritances and who gets what can do to a family. I feel bad for the uncle he didn't deserve to die.
Thank you for mentioning the correct way to say Aisling, listening to people murder such a beautiful name was making me mad. I kept screaming at my screen, "If you were That Chapter, you’d get it bloody right! It’s Gaelic! You can’t just sound it out. RUclips make’s videos on how to pronounce names!!” There are people who named their daughters Aisling and Niamh who tried to tell me they’re pronounce Aceling and Nim. With total seriousness. I told them, to never go to Ireland and say their names out loud; as well as "YOU’RE DOING IT WRONG!”
Mike, please don't ever change! Not only are you are a top notch storyteller, your ability to punctuate the case with your snippets of humor (life insurance, fidget spinner, among others) genius! We love you Mike!
@@sirvilhelmofyonderlandthat does sound like a very professional action, I hope your knee is feeling better, I had to do the same to my knee yesterday, soon we won't be needing the drs that actually went to medical school 😂
He was so proud to say “hollyweird” lmfaoooo. I love that no matter how big his platform becomes, he stays himself through and through. Love you, Mike!
Did anyone else notice the detective in the background trying as hard as he could not to laugh 😂😂😂 too funny! The mother is even funnier, it’s like she’s on stage shouting her script but really badly 😂
Sad that a man's life is only worth 6 years. If he was such a bad person, and wasn't supposed to be there, why didn't anyone go help her when she went to the door? When I had a restraining order against my ex I sure did not go to the front door if I did not have to. The few times I did go, I did not go alone!
Exactly, I pointed that out in commments earlier, cause I've been in situations where I WAS actually afraid of some people ( 1 person at a time but a few different situations) and NO you don't go close to the door when actually in fear for your life because you know bullets can go through wood and metal....and you certainly don't fling the door wide open and start screaming at the one you're afraid of IF you're REALLY afrid of someone who has truly been aggressive with you in the past....when you WERE perfectly safe inside a locked house and 2 rooms awy in the kitchen right before you saw the person (that you claim you were so afraid of) walking to the fron door ...in a non aggressive way with NO weapon in his hands....They lied so much .... Oh AND WHO is the moron who thought that recording would exonerate her? That lawyer should NEVER practice law ever again, right? Lol.
@@KathyHussey063 Naw the lawyer was good. The person who should never practice law again is the prosecutor who had motive, conspiracy and murder ALL ON TAPE and chose to give the murderer a sweetheart deal and the co-conspirator nothing at all. Lazy ass district attorneys and prosecutors who care more about getting a win on paper versus actually serving the spirit of the law.
I say, always believe the third sibling. He testified that Shane was peaceful and kind. I believe that Shane was infuriated, but he had a right to be! That horrendous Kelly was bleeding his inheritance dry with her greed. This was a set up, an ambush. Greedy Kelly manipulated her bizarre, unstable daughter into murdering the man standing in the way of her getting everything she wanted. Kelly should be in prison, instead, she got her blood money, just as she planned.
The youngest brother should sure his sister for culpable homicide. Sure the lawyers would end up with all the money from the estate, but least his bitch sister would get nothing.
@@courtney_neidtYeah, it's pretty gross. Honestly, I wish they took her to trial. There's some grey area here but a jury that sees that clip isn't gonna have much sympathy for her.
It's a two year old in an adult body and until you have seen it for yourself it's difficult to comprehend .. and it's very disturbing! Now they call it "narcissistic injury" but it's a child tantrum.
Thank you for pronouncing Aisling for me I have always wondered how it was really pronounced. Also, "they were descendants of the Mayflower, so they were made of wood," had me rolling.
Them women are nuts, but that mother played Tucker like a fiddle. She got her daughter to give her everything she wanted and now she's livin' a cloud nine.
That’s my feeling too. Can’t know for sure but to me it seems like the mom is probably the mastermind here... The vitriol in that interview was something else, and if the daughter was in a venerable position after her college experience I bet it wasn’t too difficult for her to spin some tales making the uncle a monster…
@@WhatAWonderfulNameItIs We can only wish. Doubt she learned half of this stuff though. If they went to a real trial she would've learned it all. As is, Kelly's probably gonna get everything she wanted.
The biscuit wheels are gonna come flying off that gravy train soon enough, though. The more she continues to borrow against the property, the less it'll be worth, and sooner or later, it's likely it'll end up with a lien or foreclosed outright
With all that high-level acting training you’d think she’d have learned how to cry properly. RIP Shane. You deserved better. Caring for aging parents, especially with such a devastating disease, is a selfless labor of love.
He was a crazy meth addict who SA women by giving them tainted drugs, bragged about getting away with murder, absolutely destroyed his mother's property, and attacked Tucker multiple times before his death. He can rot in whatever dark hole he's spending eternity in right now.
@@johns1625I feel like there's 2 kinds. Normal, quirky, maybe shy or introverted and theatre gets them out of their shell. Then there's the narcissists who want that captive audience.
Anyway you look at what she did. She murdered this man on purpose. She didn't hesitate when her mom said get the gun. She is a Stone Cold Killer. Her mother needs to be in prison too. These women are pure evil. Hopefully another prisoner in prison will get the deadman the justice that he really deserves.
@@fernfunk I think its much more harsh to murder your own family for a piece of property or to maintain your own privileged lifestyle "get a whooping" jfc, is it just women in your world that should only be punished with an ass-kicking for luring someone to their own murder site and then lying to everyone to try and get the murderer off and painting the victim as a vicious monster?
A controlling mother of adult children is one of the most destructive forces on earth. I’ve seen it up close in the mother of my daughters first husband.
It looked like she had planned to shoot him. The notary, Shane's girlfriend and brother, can't all be wrong about this one person. The grandmother should have been honest. R.I.P Shane.
He was a crazy meth addict who SA women by giving them tainted drugs, bragged about getting away with murder, absolutely destroyed his mother's property, assaulted his mother previously (breaking one of her teeth), and attacked Tucker multiple times before his death. He can rot in whatever dark hole he's spending eternity in right now.
This is my neck of the woods....been in Southern Oregon my whole life, 56 years. Its an absolutely beautiful place to live and I'm completely grateful for that! I just try to stay away from the "interesting" folks and not-so-smart criminals!😃
Well I just got a new quote. " You were born on 3rd base, but you think you hit a triple! " I definitely can apply this in today's age. Good stuff Mike!!
A person that calls 911 and asks protection from the police probably is not thinking about attacking anyone. They got rid of him like disposable garbage and for a 6 year sentence i can say they are probably really glad they did it.
Interesting that the detective was Tony Young. I’m pretty sure he is the Stepfather to Kyron Horman who disappeared from Portland OR in 2008ish. The stepmom is who everyone suspects.
Wow Mike thanks for your awesomeness in the way you give us all the details of your cases, you are a amazing story teller this case is horrific, Thanks again Mike!!!!❤❤❤❤❤
The mother clearly had her little part in this and should be doing time as well-however, the daughter only getting 6 years as the gunman is a joke. Greed at its core. That was her fricken uncle. Family means nothing to these sick people. The fact the mother stood over her brother as he lay dying and said “just die already”, is disgusting. Gross, talentless hacks who value money over blood.
Mike, you’re sounding so much better this week! I’ve been in the hospital for a few days after surgery, and I’ve been in a lot of pain. But your uploads always put smile on my face. Thanks for getting me through this, even if you don’t realize it.
Mike, I am impressed that you can pronounce Siskiyou correctly! And I apologize for the deplorable way we Americans pronounce Aisling, you are right to call us out for being so cavalier in our handling of Irish names.
I'm glad to see the way Melissa McCarthy ruled in this case. 👍 And the Oscar goes to.... not Tucker. More time should have been added on for the bad acting. Looking at the crazy mom, it's easy to see how she ended up this way. The timing of the murder speaks volumes. They were not going to allow him to have that property Poor Shane. What a tragedy. 💔
All those fake panic attacks and fake crying, I'm surprised she didn't write the detectives in to a script where they took sympathy on her, apologized and let her go on her merry way.
and his poor mother, torn between two greedy children who wanted her house ( and money borrowed against the house) before she was even dead! In the mean time who is looking after Her?? Just her greedy , money grabbing children. It was her Moms house, and she had the right to do whatever the hell she wanted to with it! My heart goes out to see her witness this destruction of her family over something she worked all her life to buy, and care for ; and thought after she was gone could help them. No good deed eh?
This is so similar to something that my family went through (minus the murder part 😅). My mother, brother, and I were caretakers for my grandmother after my grandfather died, but my uncle manipulated my grandmother (who I believe was in the beginning stages of Alzheimer’s) into signing over her power of attorney to him. We were all kicked out of her home and then my uncle put my grandmother into a rest home. My mother (the eldest and previously the executor of the will) got exactly zero dollars of her inheritance and lives in a slummy apartment while my uncle lives in my grandmother’s house. Crazy what people will do for money, even to their own family.
Been there....a boyfriend of my daughter now lives on a nice Texas ranch, and complains that my Mother is not alive anymore to pay for utilities, taxes, feed for her animals.....he lives for free
Ugh. So glad my sisters and I aren’t like that. My mothers sisters kids are like that. After she died, all three of her children, on separate occasions, tried to have my uncle sign everything over to them behind their siblings back. I still think my cousin that ended up with the lions share forged his signature. Their mother was like that too. My mom and her sister were night and day. My moms will has remained the same, only updated when my dad died. Everything is split evenly between my sisters and I and my brothers children get the share that would have gone to him. Sadly, he is no longer with us. Should I or one of my sisters pass before my mom, our share would go to our kids. Not like she has a huge estate or anything. I honestly have everything I want already. I’m a simple woman. She gave me the quilt her aunt made her already. That’s really all I wanted.
You can contest the outcome based on the mental capacity of your grandmother. They tried to do that to my Grampa but he was femmes legally of sound mind. If she is t, then changing the will while suffering from dementia should negate the will
And you feel entitled to the property? Your grandmother was sent to a slummy apartment? Yet, she has Alzheimer’s? Why doesn’t your family take care of her? Was that an assisted living apartment? This doesn’t add up. Your uncle is her son, he is entitled to the home he was living in. Sounds like he was taking care of your grandmother more than anyone else until she got to the point he couldn’t do it. It’s best for her to be with people who can care for her - she couldn’t have stayed in that house alone and tbh it sounds like your family just wants to take the property and sell it for themselves.
😱 my god 6 years, that's taking the micky, she should serve longer, and so should her mother. May he rest in peace, 🙏 another outstanding video thanks Mike 🖤
Real interesting case. I think she got off lightly and definitely the mother had an overwhelming control/effect over her daughter to the extent I believe Tucker thought she could do anything and her mother would look after her..... oh dear, a hard way to grow up and learn about life and sad it ended in a death. RIP Dude.
If someone's scared and fearful of their life they wouldnt yell and act mad during the interview with the police! Why is her mother acting like that, 🤔 oh ya because she knows they murdered her own brother over $/greed SMH!!! They should feel embarrassed & low!!!
I had a much-beloved calico cat named Aisling (and her brother Dubh). I managed to get people to pronounce the name Aisling correctly, but they could not cope with Dubh to save their lives. My Aisling was much less murdery than the one in this video.
@@mischr13 Oh yea? Aren't they natural predators? I mean I've probably only had 20 or so but they all loved to go out a murderin at night. I remember once they climbed a tree and ate a whole nest of baby squirrels, dragging them down one at a time. Looking back, I'm starting to think maybe it's you who doesn't know very much about humans or cats.....
Been watching you 2 years probably more? Been watching you for soooooo long can’t remember how long for sure? But I know you do an amazing job on these stories, I appreciate your hard work, thank you
Thanks for posting this interesting case. Six years seems like a very light sentence for the crime under these circumstances, and I'm surprised the prosecution didn't try to negotiate a longer sentence or charge her with second degree murder. With credit for good behaviour, she should be out of prison in only a few more years, with enough time left in her acting career to make a sequel to "From the Dark".
Good one, Mike. Superb research and presentation. There is no one better in this genre than you are, Mike. Thank you for this and all that you do. Take care.
I try to watch other people do these videos and no one does them better than you Mike. You put your heart into these videos just for us! you're awesome love ya!
I love what you do and I cannot stress that enough but I want to say something that has nothing to do with this video. Extra huge “Thank You” for not covering that story from Alabama and giving that person any more attention. Absolutely ridiculous so many people covered it. Plus you do the best “real” crime stories.
I love the arm waving sequence as it reminds me of the" break away,no takeoff " and the aircraft carrier deck. I'd swear she'd worked on one,so calm and perfectly choreographed..
I mean someone said the uncle wanted to kill them. But idk. It seems like the mom convinced her daughter to kill her brother. That’s legit how I see it. Her mom clearly made her think her uncle was evil and needed to be killed. The mom needs to be looked at more.
@@mercster My whole life, my dad's side of the family were the most stoic Iowan Methodists you could ever know, like the American Gothic painting come to life, LOL. Until ....... my Grandma died of Covid in 2021. Then, they became the Kardashians. Money messes with people's minds.
@@audreymuzingo933 Yeah but these people were writing goofy novels and she was an actress and all that even before. I think they were overly emotional drama artists, and the money made it worse.
My uncle got 8 years for moving weed across states and this chick who murdered her brother over inheritance, gets 6 years (with good behavior, probably 4 years)
The judicial system is so fucked.
Yeh but the Goverment like to make more out of an example of people who cheat them out of potiental tax revenue than murdeers
One friend of mine did 8 years in Alabama for the same thing and another did 6 years in Texas for murder.
Be even more effed if your skin tone was of a darker hue.
The judicial system has never been unbiased.
Being super rich helps, they love being bought off.
And probably STILL got the inheritance 😳😳🙄🙄
It was a niece shooting her uncle... the mother (the deceased's sister) was not charged. But yeah, pretty messed up.
Mother is a control freak bully, daughter is drama queen, both as guilty as hell.
Your first sentence sounds like a line from a country song. Beautiful!
Control freak, greedy bully. They did get what they want. If I was the mother/grandmother I would leave it all to the son who's not around. But they are obviously willing to kill for that property/inheritance
Daughter is a narcissist.
@@vialogan It is all one sentence...
@@AnnaWessonEtters It's a special bully, called a crybully.
This is outrageous, not only does she get ONLY 6 years, but they got what they wanted, he was removed and they got their money. Absolutely despicable
@traybern the infallible. This is your contribution. Pointing out poor comprehension (of someone probably typing on their phone while pooping) with additional poor comprehension.
She still got prison time, that's what matters.
@passionsquietrage3617 So when someone hurts or ends someone in your family hopefully they only do a week in jail for it.
Saw your comment before I watched the video. Ruined it for me.
Life for a LIFE.
Families-Friends & those who suffer from the loss of their loved one- AFTER proving w/out a doubt whomever took that life- Should be made available to the family-friends- TO DO AS THEY WISH!!!
Six years is insane to me. She literally took someone’s life and shown no remorse for it. She gonna get out early on good behavior and capitalize on her uncle’s tragic murder. She’ll probably write a book about it and paint herself as the victim and comment how the justice system is unjust. Yes it is unjust, for not giving you more jail time. Sickening!
Hopefully no publisher would take her on
i can see this happening :(
Women aren’t capable of being held responsible haven’t you been told?
Her eyes don't look right scary my father said people don't change they let her out with those scary eyes God help society 🙏
6 years is insulting to that mans life .The mother is a greedy women who used her bad acting daughter to get what she wanted . Feel very sad there was no justice for this man.
They both should have got life without parole, both evil narcissists.
Yelp I can see mom convincing her daughter that she wouldn’t get much time and when she gets out they will own the ranch ! The greedy will pay one day for sure ! God willing!
The only two things that are tragic are the murder of Shane and the acting of Tucker. Six years in prison is a joke.
Best comment. Tucker’s acting was really… something.
Another case of no legal justice for evil people, how shocking
@@hastyhillfarmand4x480this world was built by psychopaths, for psychopaths.
@kaynucklehead1633
Yep…should’ve got DP.
Blond rich white female working in the media ? I would've expected far less tbh , it's like they made an example of her
The obvious hatred for Shane (?) was so telling for me. I do believe the 2 of them plotted this for awhile. So I say it was premeditated murder. She only got 6 years..ridiculous.
Yeah and the dispute over the property and the fact that he was only murdered AFTER he had legally been awarded it and was trying to get them to sign papers that would show they recognize his ownership.
They killed him over property.
I thought so too. Also, why didn't they go after the Mother for making a false statement.
@@revolution2009E-7 accessory to murder
The momma should have went to prison too’
As usual, women get a sickenly light sentence for premeditated murder. How predictable.
Love how Tucker almost makes the smart decision of not talking further without a lawyer present, then proceeds to wave at the camera and...tell them everything. Probably the narcissism kicking in making her think "oh I'm smarter than these cops, I'm sure they will believe me."
Once she asks for a lawyer nothing is admissible after that
@@lexijones8019That's not actually correct. The police do have to stop the interrogation. They did. They also can't initiate another interrogation. They didn't. She invited them to come and talk some more about the case. That constitutes a knowingly and intelligently waiving of her rights. Once that happens, they can begin interrogation again. She can then shut it down again, but she didn't.
Anyways, if you want an authoritative source -
Miranda v. Arizona 1966
"If the interrogation continues without the presence of an attorney and a statement is taken, a heavy burden rests on the government to demonstrate that the defendant knowingly and intelligently waived his privilege against self-incrimination and his right to retained or appointed counsel."
"An express statement that the individual is willing to make a statement and does not want an attorney, followed closely by a statement, could constitute a waiver."
Which is, *exactly* the situation that occurred here.
Further supported by Edwards v. Arizona 1981
"In concluding that the fruits of the interrogation initiated by the police on January 20 could not be used against Edwards, we do not hold or imply that Edwards was powerless to countermand his election or that the authorities could in no event use any incriminating statements made by Edwards prior to his having access to counsel. Had Edwards initiated the meeting on January 20, nothing in the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments would prohibit the police from merely listening to his voluntary, volunteered statements and using them against him at the trial."
In short, once you tell the police that you want to keep your mouth shut, you have to actually... You know... Keep your mouth shut.
@@lexijones8019 not necessarily true. Once she invokes her right to counsel, authorities may not question her any further. If they continue to question/interrogate after that, then yes, it is inadmissible. However, just as one can invoke their 5th Amendment rights, they can also retract them and choose to talk after all. I'd argue that is what happens here. Tucker initiated further dialogue with the investigators and gave her account of the events. Their questions were mostly clarifying the information she was freely giving. There is also another situation where one can invoke their rights yet still incriminate themselves, in where a suspect makes a spontaneous statement that was not prompted by interrogation. For example, while in custody a suspect says "they got what they deserved" or "I'd kill them again if I could" and the statement just came out of the blue (hence being considered spontaneous) and was not influenced at all by the questioning of Law Enforcement, the information can still be used against the suspect. With all that said, defense attorneys can always bring these situations to light in an attempt to suppress the evidence. This occurs in an official suppression hearing in front of a judge and they can decide whether or not the information will be admissible during the trial or not. Courts have ruled both ways regarding these situations, and the judge has complete autonomy over the decision. So, with all that said, you aren't wrong, there are just circumstances where things are different and the courts ultimately decide on how to proceed.
That was probably her life experience. She'd been. used to getting her way and not being challenged all her life.
She forgot about her encore
I'm not sure this can be considered a "he said/ she said" case since "he" is dead and can't speak for himself. She clearly murdered him, but sometimes those plea deals are not as risky as a new trial.
I feel like he meant that the notary, the other brother, and his GF were speaking for him. IMO. That could be me reading into it too much lol. I agree with what you are saying though in that sense.
Exactly
His 911 call
I’ve heard in that video “This isn’t a will!” So I’m guessing the brother called the notary and told the sister it was o my for a will just to trick the grandmother to sign the property over to him. The daughter probably thought “Hey I only took out loans in the amount of maybe $30 grand or so, I still have another $10 grand left if this property is valued at $80 grand, and he’s trying to jip me out of my share and screw us over. He’s a dirty drug addict, a loser, a fall from grace and no one would ever miss him or worry about him…(not sure if he ever had kids of his own so she likely expected him to just “vanish” or not wake up cuz of the drugs.”
For some author and her daughter, I’m willing to bet the mom already maxed out her share and the brother let it slide for as long as he could. If they dug deep enough, I’d be willing to guess that the property or the loans on the property started to creep into the brothers entitled amount and that’s when he decided to take action. The mother felt cheated even though she got her loans. She likely didn’t care to acknowledge that the loans she got, were lowering the property which reflected on the brother.
It doesn’t matter if he blew it on drugs or not. You can take your money and do whatever with, he had no say, while he could do his.
It would be sad to sell a family members home that they raised money to own for themselves only for a relative to blow it all on drugs. I get that. But also, some people you can tell them til your blue in the face that they are touching your inheritance and they just don’t care. They don’t like you feeling like a victim when they have to be it. It just perplexes them. They can’t function without being the victim.
Money changes people. I’ve seen it with my mother. When my parents were separated, my mom would still go to family court and talk about my dads stupid things from old jobs he wasn’t working for anymore.. I think a 401k or something..I was young like 13.. she just kept going on and in about that money.. and eventually when they sold the house, they paid off the bank loans and went there separate ways, mom blew through all her money. Some people arnt good with money. We should have money management courses in school. Have you heard. Chase banking has credit cards for students under 18. Not typically credit but I mean debit cards adults parents can monitor transactions and transfer money into their accounts. It’s incredible. Parents can have their kids learn about managing money and expenses. It would be a useful hobby. I’m still horrible with balancing my checkbook. It’s basic math😅
So what you’re saying is it’s a “she said, he dead” scenario
On the video, the mom being all “she’s not signing a grant deed,” that’s pretty much proof they killed the uncle for the land. At least to me. What horrible women.
Yup the motive is cleared as day.
1,000%
I’m surprised the prosecutor allowed a 6 year plea deal. Mom will get the property once Grandma dies, and Tucker will get out very soon. I’m not seeing justice here.
@@karenneill9109more often than not, prosecutors don't care about actual justice..they just care about closing cases
@@karenneill9109these losers won’t have any lasting benefit. They’ll blow the money and wind up with nothing before too much time passes. Sounds like they were treating the property like a bank account.
The interrogations of mother and daughter are painful to watch! It’s like watching bad acting school! May Shane RIP. What a senseless murder!! Tucker should’ve gotten more than 6 years and mom too!!
I definitely get this idea, but I also question how I would behave in a situation where I was in a police interrogation, tbh. I get terrible panic attacks when in high-stress situations. While I don't think she was telling the truth... Would people just dismiss me as a "bad actor" if I went nonverbal and curled up into a ball in an interrogation room? Panic attacks can LOOK "dramatic" because they're not neurotypical behavior. Hnn.
@21:35 the only person who reacts to the dramatic screaming is the mother, nobody else even flinches. She went to the Amber Terd school of acting where they teach the (sh!t) STAINivslaski method.
Yes, the mom for LYING to investigators, it is obstruction of justice, it's better to not say anything to them at all than to lie to them.The daughter was MORE of a threat TO her uncle, obviously. She and her mother were a signature or 2 away from losing the rights to any MORE of their parent's property after their deaths, and Mom had already taken out loans on THEIR property,for more than what her half of everything would've been worth..So those 2 would've not gotten any more money off the parents THAT is why she shot her uncle.. When you shoot someone & you have that much motive plus a video that proves the man was not threatening anyone's life at all, then a,15 year minimum sentence should've been her sentence if not more.
children (women) never do
Yea it's such terrible acting lol. It's actually comical when they are trying to convey sadness.
For the jury to have found her liable for defamation, that evidence must have been overwhelming, this means they proved actually malice, she must have sent him threatening messages or something
While we obviously dont know the details, if the defamation jury determined there was malice, then that means there was enough evidence to reasonably conclude that she knew she was lying and lied anyway with pure malicious intent.
She seems like a spoiled kid grew up and still thinks she's owed something. Annoyed when she doesn't get her way and expects everyone to believe her. And her mom seems like a "let me speak to the manager" kind of woman.
Affluent and cosmopolitan. It can be a deadly combination.
Yeah, total Karen 🤢
Karen and Karen jr
This is what happens when a narcissist raises a narcissist.
Agreed
This is sad . She’s a spoiled Rotten entitled
Embarrassin to watch little girl . Her mom was totally behind this ( imo )
Disgusting the interview with the mom .
Thank You Mike !! 💚💚
only 6 years?!!!! For premeditated murder? That's outrageous 😲😲
As always when the murderer is female the sentences are a joke; if ever even given.
its equality! :P
There is still speculation that it was manslaughter
Yes but she does present well 😊
She pled guilty and was sentenced for manslaughter, not premeditated murder
What's really sad is Shane had lived there 16 years while taking care of his ailing father. No mention of anyone else helping the father, just Shane. And suddenly, those 2 bytches want all the inheritance? I've been a caretaker for my ailing/dying parents. It's extremely hard work. More work than caring for small children. Shane deserved that inheritance, those women did not. What a shame! Even outrageous that she only got 6 years. Smdh.😢
Yes, and the history of violence seems to be just whatever those 2 reported. I haven't heard any evidence of it. The fact that he had his gf there and had called the police earlier seems that he was the one afraid. The other brother said he was the nicest one in the family. Which makes sense since he was the one who cared for his dying father. Als is no joke. It's just so sad. I hope those 2 lose the ranch.
Tbf, inheritance is not deserved through actions, it's simply the wishes of a person who dies for how to settle their affairs. Whether or not his sister helped out is not material to the will of inheritance. The fact that she accrued debt against the inheritance, then probably had her daughter murder her brother to steal his half is crazy. Not half as crazy as the fact that she got away with it. There's little justice here.
@@holyhex6520 I think it just goes to show Shane’s good character. There you have someone who paid no attention to her parents but still was getting 50% of the inheritance, and then you have Shane who was a very active part of his parents life and their well being and was essentially being set up to look like this violent monster and slaughtered so the evil lady and her daughter could get money. Absolute disgrace that Tucker only got 6 years. If you take into account time served, she probably would only have to have done about 1-2 years of that sentence
Caretakers receive rarely the credit for the grueling work they do. It’s not about getting paid it’s done by a family member (and nurses during self health care breaks) out of empathy and love. The only true payment for such a misunderstood sacrifice is the joy you receive by making your loved one comfortable. It’s the ultimate gift you can give to a vulnerable and sick human being. I wish there was more support for those of us that do it but there isn’t. Caretakers must remember to take time for themselves so they are not overwhelmed.
Amen. It’s hard work that gets harder and harder, unlike taking care of a healthy child. And it’s ugly and exhausting and emotionally draining. Our society doesn’t acknowledge or respect or compensate the people who do this work nearly as much as it should. And the story of relatives being completely absent during a sick/elderly person’s last years then suddenly materializing when they die and expecting a reward is a very very common one.
This is wild! I did musical theater with her and she was mental, just as mental as her mom. Crazy to see Mike doing an episode on someone I knew haha
Lucky she didn't randomly accuse you of sexual assault and try to ruin your life...or did she?
They both do seem bat shit crazy
*Vsauce music
For real!?!? Thats crazy! She definitely comes off as mental. Completely unhinged!!
Musical theater? I thought that hadn't been around since the early 70s ...😂😂
“I do not grieve for my brother, I am GLAD he’s dead!”
In the mix of all this I have to say this one absolutely tore me apart. To think someone’s sister feels that way…ouch.
My sister feels that way about me but she's a borderline egocentric biatch
You don't know their history. She probably has a good reason for saying that.
@@TS-rd7oy He/she didn't say anything about their story and only commented on the fact it's sad someone would like to see their family member dead. They didn't say one was in the right and the other was in the wrong. Don't be so reactionary.
@@zachu225
What a strange reaction by you? Wow...
@TS-rd7oy and she might also just be a horrible greedy person that wanted him dead for money when he was a fine person. You don't know their story
Only six years? I've known people get double that for drug charges or fraud. Judges that give such pitiful sentences should be fired!
Disbarred permanently.
people who make provably false SA allegations like she did should really get jail time. and to think she only got 6 years for murder. ridiculous
And how would you prove that it was false before imprisoning women for claiming they were raped?
@@Rugelacharugula the same way you do with any other crime you’d have to prove beyond the shadow of a doubt through evidence that they fabricated it. It’s a hard claim to prove with a high level of evidence required, but that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t. That means we should apply that same rigourous level of justice to all crimes.
You seem to be suggesting that because it’s somewhat difficult and would take a little bit of investigating we should just not bother
@@Bonsoirmonamie sure. “Guess what, rape victim, if your rapist is acquitted (which 993 of 1000 are), it means YOU LIED! And we put *you* on trial! Still wanna *report?”* You should really be in law. Or rape crisis counseling.
My sister survived a couple of rapes and I always find it interesting that the people who are against getting proof for SA also fail to understand that when a guy gets investigated for rape or sexual assault, the cops look into him for other stuff too because it's just sitting there.
If my sister had gone to the cops about her first rape, the second wouldn't have happened. But not just her own tapes.
This guy has a history of raping women. How many other women got raped because she didn't take it to the cops?
She was a junkie at the time, but now, she regrets this very much.
People who get upset about requiring women to prove sexual assault invariably don't really care about the other victims.
That is pretty sad.
In reality, this "believe all women" Schtick is more about giving women the power to use the long arm of the law at their beck and call with impunity, not actually about protecting vulnerable women.
@@Rugelacharugula the same way you prove any other crime. you stupid bro?
Her crying in the fetal position on the floor is truly infuriating.
Great word 'infuriating'
I think it's kinda cute
Both mother and daughter are guilty of premeditated murder. So much for justice.
this was straight out murder. both kelly and tucker deserve at least 25 years.
Murdered hours before he was set to get his half of the ranch. And they got their way. They won.
He was violating an order of protection.
Female privilege.
@@NineteenEighty8 oh shut up
This.
Did her mom get punished for conspiring and lying? She was the aggressor and he was likely afraid for HIS life.
They weren't scared for their lives. They were scared for their lifestyle. They didn't want to share the ranch
Exactly!
Yup!
Excellent observation 💯
couldn't have said it better.
drama queens. they probably believed their own drama. but that’s not a defense to murder.
I really detest the way some people feel they're entitled to what their parents earned during their lifetime. Murdering that man over someone else's money is disgusting.
When my father was ill and didn't look like he was going to make it I overheard one of my sisters calling dibs on what furniture and stuff she wanted. He wasn't even dead yet.
I made sure everyone knew that.
I have three half siblings, and my biological father (didnt grow up with him or them) inherited a million. two of the three are already vying for this money and hes not dead. They try to turn the family on me. sure I wouldnt mind some cash but I have no cares for this at all. Kinda sick to watch. Heck our dad is still alive anyway. Its nuts.
Inheriting should be made illegal. Saves a lot of deaths and hate.
Funny enough even people with old age want money still for example my grandpa, I'm not even kidding back then he was a abusive, manipulate, greedy bastard. Still he acts like this to this day (he's not even walking any more for God's sake).
What do they care, they're dead and gone
“They were part wood…” 😂 I lost it, Mike. Kudos on the video and thank you for all you do!!
😂😂😂😂😂 I read your message before he said and I laughed even harder!! 😂😂😂😂 gotta love Mike 😂😂😂❤
Omg, I lmao so hard!
Made me audibly LOL 🎉🍻
Same! 😂😂😂😂😂
YES! That was absolute gold.
My brother was the director and was in the movie and on the Dateline episode…she was legit crazy
What a person and moment in time to have a connection with.
Sure they feared him, after taking care of things for years, watching his mom get manipulated by his sister and niece, and watching his inheritance treated like an atm, he was pissed. He was trying to save what was left by way of the grant deed, but they were so very much against that, you can hear the attitude in his sisters voice. She knew she could get more money from the whole deal the way things were. After all the loans ,lowering the value, mom passes away, Sister gets away with all the loan money and half of whats left of value. If he wasn't killed, my guess is that they would have constantly tried to get him out of the whole estate/ inheritance another way.
If he wasn't dead they will make his life miserable for sure. But I think they will try other ways....evil very
Based off the home video and the interviews, if she didn’t murder him then she or her mother or even both would’ve murdered him eventually; the moment realization hits that they would either lose the inheritance or their plan of making him miserable, making things miserable for him, wasn’t working they would’ve went straight to murder.
Their interviews are creepy as hell; 6 years and they get to keep what he was murder over is a joke.
SIX YEARS? she shows zero accountability, I can't believe she got off this lightly. Imagine being reasonably successful and having so many promising prospects in the future but choose to murder a family member for a few bucks AND THEN still be so entitled that you play the victim to everyone around you. poor shane. even if he was difficult or whatever, he certainly did not deserve this
I like how the mother stated she couldn't remember who shot her brother, and then admitted she wouldn't tell who did even if she knew. 😅
Both of them clearly only share the one wit and it just saunters between the two slow af.
6 years, thats all?! My gosh, the Uncle didn't get much justice. She is out of jail now probably. It's actually terrifying knowing she and her mother are walking among us.
What you said about nominative determinism makes total sense. People named Dennis are more likely to become dentists. People named Murdaugh are more likely to become murdaughrers.
This made me laugh harder than it had any business doing.
😆
😂@@positivelycat
😂😂😂😂
Good one!😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂
16:00 I love how the detectives didn’t fall for her “helpless baby bird” routine. She was putting her community theatre acting skills to work and they were just like 😒😐
😂😂😂 I know. The one guy puts his hands on hips and just looks down at her.
Community theatre acting skills 😂😂😂😂
So do I pal and I'm sure that the majority watching are glad that the detectives weren't fooled by "a woman crying?"(seriously that's all it takes sometimes with some stupid men?)
However in lots of cases innocent men are in jail due to a woman perp' crying and simp idiot men cop's believing the act?; Disgraceful
When I watch these true crime stories, I am amazed at the wild swings in terms of sentencing for murder, 1 state the same charge is 20 years another state it’s 5 years. Incredible
Six years for murder??? That’s unbelievable. Wow this is awful. His life was only worth 6 years 🤦🏻♂️
6 years for murder?? Wow! So basically she killed him, served a little bit of time and gets to continue living her life like nothing happened?! Our justice system can be so disgusting sometimes!
It's difficult to get a jury to give a heavy sentence to a young (white) woman. We tend to empathize more with women, even when a violent crime has been committed. It's just a by-product of sexism, the assumption that women can't or won't be violent.
Female privilege.
Hell is eternal.
sometimes? Money talks here. Period. If you have money, you get away with murder, both literally and figuratively.
Manslaughter, sounds like it was measure 11. Still not long enough for taking a life!
Wow ! This one is crazy. Poor Shane , may he rest in peace.
The way Tucker’s mom behaved in her interview with detectives makes it easy to see how Tucker could be a bit unhinged! What a sad situation.
Great work , Mike , as always. I love ya too !
How could he rest in peace?
He was murdered by people who were extorting his mother, who were borrowing against his inheritance and killed him for his inheritance.
And the person who came up with the whole plan, Aisling's mother escaped with no charges and Aisling got a slap on the wrist (she'll serve half that time before parole, at most)
And she's going to get that inheritance.
She will not only not be punished for murder, she will get rewarded with what she wanted from the murder.
@@TheLikenessOfNormal You're tripping balls. Everyone says RIP. It's not literally.
@@FarmerFpv Lol right? This is a rather accosting response towards a positive and benign comment.
only a bit?
She was acting like she's the one who's been wronged, when she was mortgaging the ranch that was supposed to belong to both of them. What a twisted mind.
Still baffles me that they had a notary AT THE HOUSE to sign stuff, but kept on the whole "he's not allowed to be there!" WHAT!? Make it make sense.
I live in Medford, about 15 miles from where this happened. She is a piece of work. The whole family is creepy. Tucker was pretty much created in that family.
Tell us more interested in this family I don't know why but there intriguing to me please share any stories you know I love weird people antics and whatnot.
Yes I would love to hear more about them too!
@@SATX_09 @carmendiego
Just watch this episode four or five more times.
I don't think there's much more to these characters we haven't already seen.
ps. @konkubyne...sleep tight...
@@coldbringer9545 I find it hard to believe that we've unearthed all there is to know about these individuals. It's certainly naive to assert this as their closing chapter, presuming no further twists and turns in their tale. In my experience, particularly with such eccentric characters, there's always more beneath the surface. Not 'more' in the sense of positivity necessarily, but rather in terms of intrigue and entertainment.
@@SATX_09agreed
Wow, I live in Oregon and have never heard this story. It's crazy what money and inheritances and who gets what can do to a family. I feel bad for the uncle he didn't deserve to die.
Same, oregon all my lifead never heard this story!
Oh man, my heart sank when you said she only got 6 years.
Yeh i was waiting to be disappointed with the sentence as always!!
Now she's out on good behavior
Thank you for mentioning the correct way to say Aisling, listening to people murder such a beautiful name was making me mad. I kept screaming at my screen, "If you were That Chapter, you’d get it bloody right! It’s Gaelic! You can’t just sound it out. RUclips make’s videos on how to pronounce names!!” There are people who named their daughters Aisling and Niamh who tried to tell me they’re pronounce Aceling and Nim. With total seriousness. I told them, to never go to Ireland and say their names out loud; as well as "YOU’RE DOING IT WRONG!”
Mike, please don't ever change! Not only are you are a top notch storyteller, your ability to punctuate the case with your snippets of humor (life insurance, fidget spinner, among others) genius! We love you Mike!
It seems ole Mike has recently become aquainted with Mr coca leaf
Agreed!
Aw c'mon. Lay off.@@breakmylegs7294
She clearly took the fact that she was an actor a bit too literally
I have to watch the movie to know whether or not she's a good actor but from what I've seen. Not so good.
C grade actor😅😅
Calling her an actor is like calling me a doctor because I put a bandaid on my knee.
@@sirvilhelmofyonderlandthat does sound like a very professional action, I hope your knee is feeling better, I had to do the same to my knee yesterday, soon we won't be needing the drs that actually went to medical school 😂
Actress…
actors have 🌭
She did SOOOOO good asking for a lawyer and the she screwed it all up by wanting to talk more. Totes unreal
Tucker waving her arms at the camera like she did was so overdone and annoying. I would have let her do that for an hour or so.
@@sarahwagner2739 😆😂🤣 Missed opportunity -Mike could have made a hilarious little 'remix' of it like she was dancing to music.
Self snitching 🤷
Even the way she asked for a lawyer was annoying... in that fake-timid way. I had a feeling right there that she might not stick with it.
6 years?!!!!!!! That’s IT for this murderer?!!! If this isn’t an example that the justice system is horrific, I don’t know what it is.
He was so proud to say “hollyweird” lmfaoooo. I love that no matter how big his platform becomes, he stays himself through and through. Love you, Mike!
Did anyone else notice the detective in the background trying as hard as he could not to laugh 😂😂😂 too funny! The mother is even funnier, it’s like she’s on stage shouting her script but really badly 😂
Sad that a man's life is only worth 6 years. If he was such a bad person, and wasn't supposed to be there, why didn't anyone go help her when she went to the door? When I had a restraining order against my ex I sure did not go to the front door if I did not have to. The few times I did go, I did not go alone!
Exactly, I pointed that out in commments earlier, cause I've been in situations where I WAS actually afraid of some people ( 1 person at a time but a few different situations) and NO you don't go close to the door when actually in fear for your life because you know bullets can go through wood and metal....and you certainly don't fling the door wide open and start screaming at the one you're afraid of IF you're REALLY afrid of someone who has truly been aggressive with you in the past....when you WERE perfectly safe inside a locked house and 2 rooms awy in the kitchen right before you saw the person (that you claim you were so afraid of) walking to the fron door ...in a non aggressive way with NO weapon in his hands....They lied so much ....
Oh AND WHO is the moron who thought that recording would exonerate her? That lawyer should NEVER practice law ever again, right? Lol.
@@KathyHussey063 Naw the lawyer was good.
The person who should never practice law again is the prosecutor who had motive, conspiracy and murder ALL ON TAPE and chose to give the murderer a sweetheart deal and the co-conspirator nothing at all.
Lazy ass district attorneys and prosecutors who care more about getting a win on paper versus actually serving the spirit of the law.
I live in southern Oregon and hadn't heard of this case. Thanks Mike!
This will forever be my favorite True Crime and Irish Pronunciation channel on YT.
What sicko says to a dying man, "Aren't you dead yet?!". These were the last words he heard. Mom should get years to that act alone!
I say, always believe the third sibling. He testified that Shane was peaceful and kind. I believe that Shane was infuriated, but he had a right to be! That horrendous Kelly was bleeding his inheritance dry with her greed. This was a set up, an ambush. Greedy Kelly manipulated her bizarre, unstable daughter into murdering the man standing in the way of her getting everything she wanted. Kelly should be in prison, instead, she got her blood money, just as she planned.
Imagine yelling at another human “aren’t you dead yet” - even thinking that! Let alone someone in your family 😞
The youngest brother should sure his sister for culpable homicide. Sure the lawyers would end up with all the money from the estate, but least his bitch sister would get nothing.
That ol broad gunna be broke in 5 year's. She'll live a long an bitter life as a constant victim in her own mind.
I think you’ve got that spot on.
@@courtney_neidtYeah, it's pretty gross. Honestly, I wish they took her to trial. There's some grey area here but a jury that sees that clip isn't gonna have much sympathy for her.
It's a two year old in an adult body and until you have seen it for yourself it's difficult to comprehend .. and it's very disturbing! Now they call it "narcissistic injury" but it's a child tantrum.
Thank you for pronouncing Aisling for me I have always wondered how it was really pronounced.
Also, "they were descendants of the Mayflower, so they were made of wood," had me rolling.
But he didn't get it right; it is Asshole, in this particular case. And now she has her ass in a sling, so to speak,
Hahahahhaa I missed that joke. That’s amazing
It is amazing how the law and courts work to protect certain people, clearly this was murder.
There will be eternal justice. Life is fleeting and goes by fast. Eternity is for ever. Isaiah 5:20.
Amen
Yup bingo. What if her uncle killed her
@inkfan4life I wouldn't say rich.
But Oregon like Washington has a laughable law enforcement and justice system.
@@myunknownland9272 - that is forever true
Them women are nuts, but that mother played Tucker like a fiddle. She got her daughter to give her everything she wanted and now she's livin' a cloud nine.
Yep, mental illness gets passed down from generation to generation.
That’s my feeling too. Can’t know for sure but to me it seems like the mom is probably the mastermind here... The vitriol in that interview was something else, and if the daughter was in a venerable position after her college experience I bet it wasn’t too difficult for her to spin some tales making the uncle a monster…
What would be wonderful is if Kelly’s mom took Kelly out of her will altogether. And, stopped loaning Kelly money.
@@WhatAWonderfulNameItIs We can only wish.
Doubt she learned half of this stuff though. If they went to a real trial she would've learned it all.
As is, Kelly's probably gonna get everything she wanted.
The biscuit wheels are gonna come flying off that gravy train soon enough, though. The more she continues to borrow against the property, the less it'll be worth, and sooner or later, it's likely it'll end up with a lien or foreclosed outright
With all that high-level acting training you’d think she’d have learned how to cry properly.
RIP Shane. You deserved better. Caring for aging parents, especially with such a devastating disease, is a selfless labor of love.
He was a crazy meth addict who SA women by giving them tainted drugs, bragged about getting away with murder, absolutely destroyed his mother's property, and attacked Tucker multiple times before his death.
He can rot in whatever dark hole he's spending eternity in right now.
😳 A toxic mother , daughter combo. It was all about them. Totally nasty. Sad they got away with it and profited by their crime.
The mother...geez, why did the daughter turn out to be an overdramatic, lying murderer? Eek, the DNA in those 2 didn't mix right.
I feel the same way. I can only imagine what the mother is like in private if she's so extra in front of officers.
Theater kids. Never trust theater kids. I say this as a reformed theater kid, whos grandfather owns a historic theater full of weirdos just like this.
@@johns1625I feel like there's 2 kinds. Normal, quirky, maybe shy or introverted and theatre gets them out of their shell. Then there's the narcissists who want that captive audience.
That ho said "mice memories" 😅. 13:20 mark lmao.
The old saying about the apple never falling far from the the tree kinda fits here in this scenario.
Anyway you look at what she did. She murdered this man on purpose. She didn't hesitate when her mom said get the gun. She is a Stone Cold Killer. Her mother needs to be in prison too. These women are pure evil. Hopefully another prisoner in prison will get the deadman the justice that he really deserves.
that's a bit harsh. i hope the mom gets a whooping by a neighbor or smth. but 6 years in prison isn't gonna be good anyway.
@@fernfunk😂😂😂😂. Harsh is being shot in the chest and bleeding all. Thats real suffering. 6 years is an absolute joke. She deserves a minimum of 20.
*bleeding out
@@fernfunk harsh?? The man is dead. They should get life.
@@fernfunk I think its much more harsh to murder your own family for a piece of property or to maintain your own privileged lifestyle
"get a whooping" jfc, is it just women in your world that should only be punished with an ass-kicking for luring someone to their own murder site and then lying to everyone to try and get the murderer off and painting the victim as a vicious monster?
A controlling mother of adult children is one of the most destructive forces on earth. I’ve seen it up close in the mother of my daughters first husband.
It looked like she had planned to shoot him. The notary, Shane's girlfriend and brother, can't all be wrong about this one person. The grandmother should have been honest. R.I.P Shane.
He was a crazy meth addict who SA women by giving them tainted drugs, bragged about getting away with murder, absolutely destroyed his mother's property, assaulted his mother previously (breaking one of her teeth), and attacked Tucker multiple times before his death.
He can rot in whatever dark hole he's spending eternity in right now.
This is my neck of the woods....been in Southern Oregon my whole life, 56 years.
Its an absolutely beautiful place to live and I'm completely grateful for that! I just try to stay away from the "interesting" folks and not-so-smart criminals!😃
I really like the lighting in your last few videos. The art is gently highlighted, and you look good. Thanks for all your hard work!
I'm from Oregon and this is what my family is like exactly it's a sick place with no mental health care
Hands up who's being waiting all day for Mike to drop a new episode?
✋
Well I just got a new quote. " You were born on 3rd base, but you think you hit a triple! " I definitely can apply this in today's age. Good stuff Mike!!
A person that calls 911 and asks protection from the police probably is not thinking about attacking anyone. They got rid of him like disposable garbage and for a 6 year sentence i can say they are probably really glad they did it.
Interesting that the detective was Tony Young. I’m pretty sure he is the Stepfather to Kyron Horman who disappeared from Portland OR in 2008ish. The stepmom is who everyone suspects.
Tucker and her mother wanted the property all to themselves! Those malignant narcissists got away with murder! 😡🤬💩😡🤬
Totally.
Wow Mike thanks for your awesomeness in the way you give us all the details of your cases, you are a amazing story teller this case is horrific, Thanks again Mike!!!!❤❤❤❤❤
Appreciate that!
Is the next one gunna be about the long island killer? I thought he'd never be caught
The mother clearly had her little part in this and should be doing time as well-however, the daughter only getting 6 years as the gunman is a joke. Greed at its core. That was her fricken uncle. Family means nothing to these sick people. The fact the mother stood over her brother as he lay dying and said “just die already”, is disgusting. Gross, talentless hacks who value money over blood.
What’s Bigfoot done to you, Mike? 😂😂😂 Thanks for another great video!
Love that she looked directly at the camera, then did her cry-acting. Tucker probably set him up and she isn't a very good actor.
Mike, you’re sounding so much better this week! I’ve been in the hospital for a few days after surgery, and I’ve been in a lot of pain. But your uploads always put smile on my face. Thanks for getting me through this, even if you don’t realize it.
Wishing you a speedy recovery.
Get better soon!
She cold blooded murdered him because she hated him. Thank you for the video. I look forward to these weekly.
Mike, I am impressed that you can pronounce Siskiyou correctly! And I apologize for the deplorable way we Americans pronounce Aisling, you are right to call us out for being so cavalier in our handling of Irish names.
I'm glad to see the way Melissa McCarthy ruled in this case. 👍
And the Oscar goes to.... not Tucker. More time should have been added on for the bad acting. Looking at the crazy mom, it's easy to see how she ended up this way. The timing of the murder speaks volumes. They were not going to allow him to have that property
Poor Shane. What a tragedy. 💔
I thought the same thing when I saw the judge! 😂
Terrible actress wasn't she! 😅
@@susanrobinson910 Circa Bridesmaids.
All those fake panic attacks and fake crying, I'm surprised she didn't write the detectives in to a script where they took sympathy on her, apologized and let her go on her merry way.
and his poor mother, torn between two greedy children who wanted her house ( and money borrowed against the house) before she was even dead! In the mean time who is looking after Her?? Just her greedy , money grabbing children. It was her Moms house, and she had the right to do whatever the hell she wanted to with it! My heart goes out to see her witness this destruction of her family over something she worked all her life to buy, and care for ; and thought after she was gone could help them. No good deed eh?
"So she was just pulling the trigger for fun like a fidget spinner" LMAO
This is so similar to something that my family went through (minus the murder part
😅). My mother, brother, and I were caretakers for my grandmother after my grandfather died, but my uncle manipulated my grandmother (who I believe was in the beginning stages of Alzheimer’s) into signing over her power of attorney to him. We were all kicked out of her home and then my uncle put my grandmother into a rest home. My mother (the eldest and previously the executor of the will) got exactly zero dollars of her inheritance and lives in a slummy apartment while my uncle lives in my grandmother’s house. Crazy what people will do for money, even to their own family.
Been there....a boyfriend of my daughter now lives on a nice Texas ranch, and complains that my Mother is not alive anymore to pay for utilities, taxes, feed for her animals.....he lives for free
Ugh. So glad my sisters and I aren’t like that. My mothers sisters kids are like that. After she died, all three of her children, on separate occasions, tried to have my uncle sign everything over to them behind their siblings back. I still think my cousin that ended up with the lions share forged his signature. Their mother was like that too. My mom and her sister were night and day. My moms will has remained the same, only updated when my dad died. Everything is split evenly between my sisters and I and my brothers children get the share that would have gone to him. Sadly, he is no longer with us. Should I or one of my sisters pass before my mom, our share would go to our kids. Not like she has a huge estate or anything. I honestly have everything I want already. I’m a simple woman. She gave me the quilt her aunt made her already. That’s really all I wanted.
You can contest the outcome based on the mental capacity of your grandmother. They tried to do that to my Grampa but he was femmes legally of sound mind. If she is t, then changing the will while suffering from dementia should negate the will
And you feel entitled to the property? Your grandmother was sent to a slummy apartment? Yet, she has Alzheimer’s? Why doesn’t your family take care of her? Was that an assisted living apartment? This doesn’t add up. Your uncle is her son, he is entitled to the home he was living in. Sounds like he was taking care of your grandmother more than anyone else until she got to the point he couldn’t do it. It’s best for her to be with people who can care for her - she couldn’t have stayed in that house alone and tbh it sounds like your family just wants to take the property and sell it for themselves.
My sister did something very similar. Disgusting.
Thank you SO MUCH for covering this case! Hardly anyone knows about it.
😱 my god 6 years, that's taking the micky, she should serve longer, and so should her mother. May he rest in peace, 🙏 another outstanding video thanks Mike 🖤
Wow haven’t heard this one before. Always appreciate the effort you put into your videos, thanks for covering this story, Mike!
Real interesting case. I think she got off lightly and definitely the mother had an overwhelming control/effect over her daughter to the extent I believe Tucker thought she could do anything and her mother would look after her..... oh dear, a hard way to grow up and learn about life and sad it ended in a death. RIP Dude.
If someone's scared and fearful of their life they wouldnt yell and act mad during the interview with the police! Why is her mother acting like that, 🤔 oh ya because she knows they murdered her own brother over $/greed SMH!!! They should feel embarrassed & low!!!
"So they were part wood" that was hilarious!
The fact that tucker asked for a lawyer at first and then still chose to run her mouth blows my mind....
She’s a narcissist like her crazy mother. It’s what they do!
I had a much-beloved calico cat named Aisling (and her brother Dubh). I managed to get people to pronounce the name Aisling correctly, but they could not cope with Dubh to save their lives. My Aisling was much less murdery than the one in this video.
I don't think I have ever met a cat less murdery than any person.
@@mazystarr😂
@@mazystarr then you don't know much about humans...or cats
How do you pronounce Dubh?
@@mischr13 Oh yea? Aren't they natural predators? I mean I've probably only had 20 or so but they all loved to go out a murderin at night. I remember once they climbed a tree and ate a whole nest of baby squirrels, dragging them down one at a time. Looking back, I'm starting to think maybe it's you who doesn't know very much about humans or cats.....
Mike is my favorite Podcaster for his deadpan and humourous delivery of the stories!! So funny even given the grim content..
Been watching you 2 years probably more? Been watching you for soooooo long can’t remember how long for sure? But I know you do an amazing job on these stories, I appreciate your hard work, thank you
Thank you so much!
Same here 😊
Same here, from County Cork, really enjoy your content, well..... not the reality, ya know what I mean 😂
Thanks for posting this interesting case. Six years seems like a very light sentence for the crime under these circumstances, and I'm surprised the prosecution didn't try to negotiate a longer sentence or charge her with second degree murder. With credit for good behaviour, she should be out of prison in only a few more years, with enough time left in her acting career to make a sequel to "From the Dark".
Nothing better than finishing work, coming home and cosying up to watch a Mikey ❤
Good one, Mike. Superb research and presentation. There is no one better in this genre than you are, Mike. Thank you for this and all that you do. Take care.
I try to watch other people do these videos and no one does them better than you Mike. You put your heart into these videos just for us! you're awesome love ya!
I love what you do and I cannot stress that enough but I want to say something that has nothing to do with this video. Extra huge “Thank You” for not covering that story from Alabama and giving that person any more attention. Absolutely ridiculous so many people covered it. Plus you do the best “real” crime stories.
I love the arm waving sequence as it reminds me of the" break away,no takeoff " and the aircraft carrier deck. I'd swear she'd worked on one,so calm and perfectly choreographed..
“Descendants of the Mayflower- so they were part wood” 😂
😂😂😂I was looking for this comment! Mike had me cracking up with that line and his serious face pairing it! 😂😂😂 thank you
I mean someone said the uncle wanted to kill them. But idk. It seems like the mom convinced her daughter to kill her brother. That’s legit how I see it. Her mom clearly made her think her uncle was evil and needed to be killed. The mom needs to be looked at more.
Overly dramatic family.
@@mercster My whole life, my dad's side of the family were the most stoic Iowan Methodists you could ever know, like the American Gothic painting come to life, LOL. Until ....... my Grandma died of Covid in 2021. Then, they became the Kardashians. Money messes with people's minds.
@@audreymuzingo933 Yeah but these people were writing goofy novels and she was an actress and all that even before. I think they were overly emotional drama artists, and the money made it worse.
@@mercster Yes, definitely.