You want feedback.. ok.. Don't change your ways. Don't change your methods. Don't change your attitude. Don't change your level of service. Don't change your depth of service. And last, make more videos!
@@HVACRVIDEOS all above i agree with... also... don't lose your sense of humor either!... the intro to this video had me splitting my sides... had to rewatch it twice to allow the captions show what you said.
Well spoken for sure. Spot on just think if we reinvent the wheel we have a HIGHER CHANCE of mistakes to over come. And who wants more mistakes then what we all ready have. Chris spot on again young man you impress me everytime. Great video. And most of all thank you for your time,effort, and your knowledge of this trade. Love it.
I bet they forgot to add thread locking compound to those bolts. As soon as they begin to loosen, even slightly, the vibrations will increase, which will feed back into the bolts causing them to loosen even more, perpetuating and accelerating the problem. Consistent vibrations will almost always loosen nuts/bolts unless you use special metallurgy/glue/torques/etc. Once vibrations start then just about all other problems follow. Vibrating parts are rubbing, causing friction and heat, which will destroy the oil causing even more issues. Other bolts loosen, metal fatigues and cracks, and so on. Edit: Really like your videos. Enjoy seeing into the black hole of HVACR
My family is in the HVAC industry, but I teach architectural drafting. The default roof access for many designer is a 24”x24” roof hatch and a ladder. I’ve had to climb up through these, and can’t imagine doing every day and hauling tools and equipment through it. On a 1 storey building with a short parapet wall, that may be okay, since you can likely pull stuff up over the parapet rather than having to haul it inside and up through a hatch. On buildings 2-10 storeys I have my students use a ship ladder at the top of the staircase with a larger 36”x60” hatch that makes roof access easier. On taller buildings, we’d have a full staircase to the roof - sometimes even one elevator. It’s not all about designing buildings to look good, but also makes them easy to service so they can continue to operate for years. Love the videos and your dedication to your trade.
Thanks so much for watching, funny I took 4 years of Architectural drafting in high school. I thought I wanted to go to school for that and become an architect but I changed my mind after my senior year. anyways thanks so much for the nice words!!
@4:25 You can see torch smoke flowing out from that valve--forced by the purge gas. @10:54 to @15:10 if you want feedback: I might hit fast forward when you make six (!) perfect, identical brazing joints* in a row. As in: show the start of one, then speed it up a little. *I was VERY impressed with those.
17:58 I really like how you explained how the charging chart works. I don’t think I’ve seen that before in your other videos. It’s funny because I’m a volunteer fire fighter and so whenever I’m at the fire station I like to go up on the roof and look at the equipment just to see up close in person some of the stuff that you’re talking about. I don’t remember seeing those charts on our package units so I will have to look next time I’m on the roof. You’re so damn thorough I love it. I’m sure most people would not have installed the uni-strut to support the lines the way you did. It’s funny how you do things differently (properly) when running your own company. I’m the same way with my company. Super clean job, well done!
Just so you’re aware, those charts are only present on Carrier units I believe. So if you have a different brand of roof top units, there may not be a chart like that. I know some Lennox units have a chart as well inside of the electrical/compressor section. Enjoy looking at the units!
Don’t look too closely. I did the same thing following HVACR videos and yearning for more real life examples. Visited a few RTU’s in some of the exchange buildings I work in. found all sorts of dead units, error codes clogged condenser coils etc. Now I’m on a first name basis with our HVAC repair contractor lol. I only wish we had a tech as detailed oriented as Chris!
24:13 Drive adaptor bushing Failure, is what happened to it, The Bushing in the adapter failed, allowing the shaft to slightly rotate, More than it should have, allowing the compressor to vibrate, which Caused the screws to vibrate out, what cause it could be anything, Manufacture defect, bad oil, Reversing valve Surg, Contaminant, ect.
Years ago I had a bad reversing valve and when removing the line between the compressor and valve it had pressure trapped in it and blow apart when i put my torch on it and it put hot oil all over me, I was wearing my PPE and long sleeves but still received some burns on my face So now I always take my awl and punch a small hole in all four lines. Please all take note really enjoy your videos Stay safe
@@Davemte34108 The trapped pressure in the line was a fluke and only happened once, But with that said this is for the young up coming techs. I retired after 40+ years in the trade. Still involved with local apprentice programs. Stay safe
I’ve enjoyed the videos. I used to work in a factory assembling these Emerson Scroll Compressors. (Well more than ten years ago. ) The bushing on top should not be oblong that slides into the rotor shaft. All bolts are installed using computer controlled machines that check for proper torque and I think the bolts have thread locker pre applied. My guess (for what it’s worth) it just wasn’t perfectly balanced and started to vibrate causing the excess wear and eventually the two main failures you noted. Was fun to see the insides of one again!
I really enjoy your videos. I don’t work in the industry, my dad did I his whole life. He passed in 1983. I used to go to work with him on the weekends and during the summer breaks from school. My first job was working for a family friend building air conditioning control panels. I really enjoyed that. I really enjoyed working with my dad and the other techs on weekends. He was a designer later in life, but the techs let me work with them and it was fun. Back then the hot control systems were made by Staefa. I ended up going into the telecommunications industry but I like watching these and being reminded of the old days. A lot has changed and it’s cool seeing the new tech. I’m still pretty good at controls and electrical on residential systems and I help out friends when I can with thermostat and capacitor swaps. Keep making them and I’ll keep watching! It’s always nice to get a notice when you have something new posted. Be safe!
Nice work as always. Like how you take the extra time to figure shit out & not just knock the job out. Great way of thinking, keeps call backs & repeated failures down. I'm 54 & been in the trade 26 years, & my back feels like it too. Keep working smart it pays off in the long run.
Along time ago when I had a summer job installing TV antennas the foreman told me something I have never forgotten. Whatever needs to be at the other end of a ladder should be set near the ladder. If you are going up or down, grab whatever is waiting, there will always be something waiting.
Wow, thanks! I am going live on RUclips this evening 10/12/20 @ 5:PM (pacific) to discuss my most recent upload and answer live questions from emails, RUclips comment and the live chat, come on over and check it out. ruclips.net/video/FNJac28OvjU/видео.html
You are the man I learn a lot of stuff every time I watch your videos. Keep up the good work I appreciate everything you teach me and the rest of the world
Good afternoon. I work with these refrigeration equipment and I have disassembled these Copeland Scroll compressors and it is not the first time that the lower rotor bushing is loosened by these two screws and causes damage to the equipment due to friction or overheating.
For the pulley system you might want to look at adding a Prusik loop. That would allow you to let go of the rope and not have everything fall down. They are easy to make in the field or you can buy them ready made.
My heart skipped a beat at 16:28. Thought for a moment you were about to take a very unpleasant tumble. Love the teardown. I wonder if perhaps the bearing had too much friction for some reason and it eventually loosened the bolts from starting and stopping. That or maybe they weren't torqued or loctited right from the factory. Weird failure indeed, Great video
Very interesting,you rarely get to see what killed a compressor because no one ever bothers to take them apart . The gantry was nice . They really should have some kind of lift on all those hatches . It is a smart innovation.
Love watching your videos. I am a Dual ticketed journeyman in gas and refrigeration. After 8 years in commercial refrigeration, I was laid off due to this pandemic. I found a job with a residential company so watching your videos keeps my knowledge up. Thanks for the content
20:53, Hannibal Lecter LOL. It’s totally cool being able to see all of the internals. It’s always smart to try to take things apart and find the point of failure. This is how we learn
This compressor was damaged by overheating...and then cooling.. The expansion and contraction was enough to pull those bolts out slowly...also the force of that stator vibrating will destroy anything eventually. Also could be from the manufacturers doing a shotty job building the compressor. But im going with the expansion theory tho
Don't forget that the screwholes are chewed out sideways. It could have been the rotor all along but expansion is part of it as you said. If you overheat it, it's possible that the bearings were pressed axially by the rotor, they held up, then the rotor bent a tiny bit, bowing to the side from the pressure, giving it a bit of excentricity and angle. Now you are twisting the bearings around in their socket. If the screws chewed the bearing holder even just a tiny bit, this became a self fueling circle where the excentricity got worse and the screws rattled more and more. This is just an idea but this is an issue I ran into when trying to make a bearing holder once and it acted just like this. non-parallel bearings are absolute monsters
I love watching your videos sir, seeing how you accurately and safely diagnose issues, and have all the proper equipment for every job makes me want to change company’s knowing how mediocre my refrigeration company can be.
@2:00, should have had the winch rack pushed to 1 side or the other, not in the middle, as then when the compressor was up, you could roll it to the post and have room for it to land. A brake or some other strap to also hold it would mean you don't need to keep pulling on the rope just to hold it in place... so it doesn't fall. Same at 16:30. Having your hoisting rig in the right spot makes it easier to raise/lower equipment.
Put in foam ear buds when it's loud. After a couple minutes you should be hearing almost normally and still hear vibrations or if something is rubbing.
I need to give that putty a try. Great video, as always. A tip. Rent a two man scissor lift or a boom lift to get all equipment to roof. Obviously it will add a cost to the job but the time saved in hauling everything to the roof more than makes up for it.
Gordon Freeman has a good point. I'd also like to suggest the possibility of a slightly off-balance motor. If that top part was weak from the factory and failed, that would cause the motor to flop around a bit, which would wrench on those lower bolts until their mountings failed. impressive that the bolts themselves held up so good, considering the damage to the mounting plate on the bearing.
Good job. I am in my mid 50's now and still try to rope up comoressors. I like your gantry crane and have been looking to build something like that for a while now. Thanks for posting!
I could never thing or dream or whatever that i would be watching this kind of content. Im quite interested in tech and im keen on learning all sort of stuff and repair all devices in my house and friends houses beside graduating law school and working in that field for over 7 years now. Just wanted to say that you man have an amazing channel! Its a pleasure watching your vids and your approach to work. I dont like every word you say but thats maybe just my law side :) cheers and keep up!
I higly recommand to check the oil on a short notice. It is most likely very dirty due to mixing with the old oil. So an oil-change is required. Nice job.
I clearly need to get some of those special heat protection rags. There's some stuff I want to get, but I'm not ready yet, so I hope the arrangement with Tru Tech Tools goes on for a bit...
Idk if you get paid more through commercials or through premium members but as much as I hate supporting youtube I can never go back to a non premium member!! Love not seeing a bunch of ads. Some channels theres ad after ad after ad. I like seeing the video straight through.
Yeah I have premium too and I still get paid with premium, I will discuss this on my Livestream this evening 10/12/20 @ 5:PM (pacific) come on over and check it out. ruclips.net/video/FNJac28OvjU/видео.html
Good job Chris !! Loss of hearing and back problems, are part of the trade. your still young, and have many years ahead of yourself. the advantages today, compressor weights are much less today then years ago. the compressor you hauled up at 78 pounds, a compressor like that years ago would have weighted over 300 pounds. The damage looks to be caused by overheating and contracting, causing fatigue on those bolts, causing them to loosen. Overall Good job.
16:28 I thought you were going down that roof hatch for a minute, that scared me. I know it wasn’t even close and you know what you’re doing but it made me nervous!
Put light pressure on the line while I torch it. You might want to move your hand out of the flame. Actually the way the guy was pulling on the lines at first it was like his first day on the job. But a few solder joints later he was a pro. Maybe he just hadn't had his coffee yet.
Hi....I never dessoldering to remove any parts ... Because it can blow oil firer on my face I always cut the pipes.. You doing a good Job..from Portugal ...be safe ... take care!
You might have a point about about that very long line set. I’ve seen similar situations like that. Some of these design engineers are not aware that a lot of compressors/condensing units don’t lend themselves very well to massive or long piping configurations.
Doing the autopsy puts you on the road to mastery. More than just blindly swapping parts you’re gaining an understanding about what failed and potentially why. I’ve done similar in telecom electrical for years and the understanding I gain helps me in all other aspects of the job. You should send a failed compressor over to AvE, it would be entertaining to see a high detail explanation on the bearing failures featured on his channel!
When brazing/soldering and the filler metal suddenly decides to make the move into the connection, it is somehow very satisfying to me. Don't know why. Just sort of a "Got it!" moment. Looks like you make good, solid, well-filled and smooth joints.
I would not flare the drier either. On 1/2” a flare torque is roughly 40 foot lbs. and like you said other people could could unintentionally mess things up. Good work. I like the pulley set up to.
1:50 some places just need to have elevators for easy roof access. also 22:05 I wouldnt over think why those bolts fell out, who knows this could have been a manufacture rebuild when they put the bolts at the bottom they either weren't torqued right or they were never torqued to begin with so they started spinning and rotating around when the compressor kicked on.
Hang on, question: How does that reversible drier work? When refrigerant flow reverses, wouldn't that just send whatever the filter/drier potentially filtered out, back through the system again? Maybe not the moisture, but anything else it caught?
Good video, Chris. That's the first time I've seen anyone cut open a scroll. You're lucky you don't do residential installs like I did for 30 years. The knees and shoulders take a beating and I'm paying for it in my older years. Pulling compressors up on roofs by rope through scuttle holes and carrying them up ladders didn't help, either. Fortunately, I've got a skate job doing public school commercial kitchen work in the twilight of my career.
3:39 that’s what she said LOL, 4:59 that’s what she said LOL, 5:31 that’s what she said LOL, 5:48 that’s what she said LOL and finally the mother of all that’s what she saids, 8:43 that’s what she said LOL i’m just having fun man don’t block me. I love your videos! I find them very informative. I just like watching somebody run their own business as I have my own business as well.
that piece that you are not sure if it was supposed to be oblong easy way to find out. 1. if you get an identical compressor that is still good but pulled because you think it is bad but you decide to replace. 2. if you get a failing compressor that is pulling too much current and tripping breakers but is still running cut a still working compressor open to see if the piece is oblong.
A small tip to make your lift a bit safer: you should install a safety that prevents the weight from going back down if you slip or can't hold it anymore. There are some easy ways to do it and it safes a lot of money if something happens
My first thought when i saw the system arrangement was,,,, what a long vertical suction line lift.This will lead to poor compressor cooling by suction gas and poor oil return... That cooling putty was very interested,, never seen that before, replacement for a wet rug ... Thank you for an interesting video,,,,, and we all get older and slow down.... ,,,
You should have cut open the old compressor first to check how much oil was in it instead of checking the receiver! You would have saved alot of work and time! Always remember this : work the job! Don't let the job work you! I agree with you about flare nuts you want as few as possible because I have found they are leaking points in the future because they loosen as the metal expands and contracts! Did not see you leak check you solder joints? There is no easy way to get the compressor onto the roof even getting a sign crane creates time and money issues! If we had stairs to the roof we would fasten a pipe to the compressor and 2 of us would carry it up to the roof and vice versa! It saves alot of time bringing up and setting up a lift device! Liked how you made a support for the drier! That was alot of work it was smart to have a helper there with you! On a big job it's easy to over work yourself and get hurt trying to do to much! Even at your young age remember that you are not getting any younger and when you get older what you do now will definitely determine your physical health as you get older! As so many young people do you can't just live for today you have to think about the future! It will be here sooner than you think! You want be able one day to retire and be able to walk away with out a cane or Walkerand be able to enjoy yourself in retirement! The answer to that starts with what you are doing right now! Thanks for another awesome video! I enjoyed it!
Im with you that take care of you since this job looks very demanding, but dont focus to o much on you the limitations you think you have. I have got some limitations myself as well, try to take care but not to think too much about it, you talk like at 37 you were an old guy. Nice video. Love the comp dissecting part. Compressors are like the "untold heros", how many hours, how many cycles until finally they give up ... like its relaibility standards are so high in comparison to many crappy things that are around us.
I Commend you for removing the old compressor instead of leaving it out of sight meaning on the roof out of sight of customer many techs would leave a compressor on the roof because they R 2 LAZY to clean up after themselves
I remember lifting Carlysle 06Ds in Liebert units,they were north of 325 lbs that was 15 years ago and every day I pay the price! I now own a hydraulic table and a modular engine hoist! You should do a talk on the things new guys should not do now to protect them layer on( like don't use your hands as a hammer)!
Solenoid valve? I believe Carrier requires one for long lines. It could be liquid flood back washing the oil off of the bearings caused the failure. Common problem in malls.
Check out the Warn 910500 pullzall. We have a similar hatch frame as you do. Its drill powered, so you don't have to worry about an electrical connection.
I noticed all that black insulation on the pipes is cracked and shrivled up. Did you consider having an assistant wrap it with aluminum tape? It's UV reflective and pretty cheep.
Love watching your videos Chris. I’m not criticizing, but shouldn’t you put the heat underneath the copper pipe and the solder on the top part of the pipe and let it flow? I am also wondering too on some of those connections if you could use crimp connectors? Have a good one keep cool.
I’m a realtor, do i have any use for these videos? No. Do i watch them the second they post? Yes.
You want feedback.. ok..
Don't change your ways.
Don't change your methods.
Don't change your attitude.
Don't change your level of service.
Don't change your depth of service.
And last, make more videos!
Thanks bud!
@@HVACRVIDEOS all above i agree with... also... don't lose your sense of humor either!... the intro to this video had me splitting my sides... had to rewatch it twice to allow the captions show what you said.
Well spoken for sure. Spot on just think if we reinvent the wheel we have a HIGHER CHANCE of mistakes to over come. And who wants more mistakes then what we all ready have. Chris spot on again young man you impress me everytime. Great video. And most of all thank you for your time,effort, and your knowledge of this trade. Love it.
I bet they forgot to add thread locking compound to those bolts. As soon as they begin to loosen, even slightly, the vibrations will increase, which will feed back into the bolts causing them to loosen even more, perpetuating and accelerating the problem. Consistent vibrations will almost always loosen nuts/bolts unless you use special metallurgy/glue/torques/etc. Once vibrations start then just about all other problems follow. Vibrating parts are rubbing, causing friction and heat, which will destroy the oil causing even more issues. Other bolts loosen, metal fatigues and cracks, and so on.
Edit: Really like your videos. Enjoy seeing into the black hole of HVACR
Really looks like somebody on the assembly line messed up the torque or did not put threadlocker on the threads
Yes u are rite
I agree - looks like a manufacturing defect to me. A third alternative would be that the bolts weren't properly hardened, which sometimes happens.
Gordan Freeman does HVAC? When did half-life have this in the storyline :O
@@FrostBlueFire Hey, someone has to keep Black Mesa cool... I can't be participating in world ending experiments every day...
30 years later, I'm still roping everything up and down. I think an electric winch would make me fat and happy, so I stick with the rope. lol!
My family is in the HVAC industry, but I teach architectural drafting. The default roof access for many designer is a 24”x24” roof hatch and a ladder. I’ve had to climb up through these, and can’t imagine doing every day and hauling tools and equipment through it. On a 1 storey building with a short parapet wall, that may be okay, since you can likely pull stuff up over the parapet rather than having to haul it inside and up through a hatch. On buildings 2-10 storeys I have my students use a ship ladder at the top of the staircase with a larger 36”x60” hatch that makes roof access easier. On taller buildings, we’d have a full staircase to the roof - sometimes even one elevator. It’s not all about designing buildings to look good, but also makes them easy to service so they can continue to operate for years. Love the videos and your dedication to your trade.
Thanks so much for watching, funny I took 4 years of Architectural drafting in high school. I thought I wanted to go to school for that and become an architect but I changed my mind after my senior year. anyways thanks so much for the nice words!!
Good job, work smarter not harder. Stay safe 🙏
@4:25 You can see torch smoke flowing out from that valve--forced by the purge gas.
@10:54 to @15:10 if you want feedback: I might hit fast forward when you make six (!) perfect, identical brazing joints* in a row. As in: show the start of one, then speed it up a little.
*I was VERY impressed with those.
I appreciate you taking the time to cut the bad compressor apart.
17:58 I really like how you explained how the charging chart works. I don’t think I’ve seen that before in your other videos. It’s funny because I’m a volunteer fire fighter and so whenever I’m at the fire station I like to go up on the roof and look at the equipment just to see up close in person some of the stuff that you’re talking about. I don’t remember seeing those charts on our package units so I will have to look next time I’m on the roof. You’re so damn thorough I love it. I’m sure most people would not have installed the uni-strut to support the lines the way you did. It’s funny how you do things differently (properly) when running your own company. I’m the same way with my company. Super clean job, well done!
Just so you’re aware, those charts are only present on Carrier units I believe. So if you have a different brand of roof top units, there may not be a chart like that. I know some Lennox units have a chart as well inside of the electrical/compressor section. Enjoy looking at the units!
Don’t look too closely. I did the same thing following HVACR videos and yearning for more real life examples. Visited a few RTU’s in some of the exchange buildings I work in. found all sorts of dead units, error codes clogged condenser coils etc. Now I’m on a first name basis with our HVAC repair contractor lol. I only wish we had a tech as detailed oriented as Chris!
24:13 Drive adaptor bushing Failure, is what happened to it, The Bushing in the adapter failed, allowing the shaft to slightly rotate, More than it should have, allowing the compressor to vibrate, which Caused the screws to vibrate out, what cause it could be anything, Manufacture defect, bad oil, Reversing valve Surg, Contaminant, ect.
Years ago I had a bad reversing valve and when removing the line between the compressor and valve it had pressure trapped in it and blow apart when i put my torch on it and it put hot oil all over me, I was wearing my PPE and long sleeves but still received some burns on my face So now I always take my awl and punch a small hole in all four lines. Please all take note really enjoy your videos Stay safe
Trapped pressure/electricity/tension has caused a fair number of injuries. Looking at the big picture as Chris says is crucial.
@@Davemte34108 The trapped pressure in the line was a fluke and only happened once, But with that said this is for the young up coming techs. I retired after 40+ years in the trade. Still involved with local apprentice programs. Stay safe
I’ve enjoyed the videos. I used to work in a factory assembling these Emerson Scroll Compressors. (Well more than ten years ago. ) The bushing on top should not be oblong that slides into the rotor shaft. All bolts are installed using computer controlled machines that check for proper torque and I think the bolts have thread locker pre applied.
My guess (for what it’s worth) it just wasn’t perfectly balanced and started to vibrate causing the excess wear and eventually the two main failures you noted.
Was fun to see the insides of one again!
My first thought too, it wasn't balanced correctly.
I really enjoy your videos. I don’t work in the industry, my dad did I his whole life. He passed in 1983. I used to go to work with him on the weekends and during the summer breaks from school. My first job was working for a family friend building air conditioning control panels. I really enjoyed that. I really enjoyed working with my dad and the other techs on weekends. He was a designer later in life, but the techs let me work with them and it was fun. Back then the hot control systems were made by Staefa. I ended up going into the telecommunications industry but I like watching these and being reminded of the old days. A lot has changed and it’s cool seeing the new tech. I’m still pretty good at controls and electrical on residential systems and I help out friends when I can with thermostat and capacitor swaps. Keep making them and I’ll keep watching! It’s always nice to get a notice when you have something new posted. Be safe!
I work for a small country hvac company and enjoy learning things from y'all that we don't typically see
Nice work as always. Like how you take the extra time to figure shit out & not just knock the job out. Great way of thinking, keeps call backs & repeated failures down. I'm 54 & been in the trade 26 years, & my back feels like it too. Keep working smart it pays off in the long run.
“Half as decent” - words spoken by a true technician
I feel like the person you are with is still training. And handing him the torch. You are an excellent teacher
Along time ago when I had a summer job installing TV antennas the foreman told me something I have never forgotten. Whatever needs to be at the other end of a ladder should be set near the ladder. If you are going up or down, grab whatever is waiting, there will always be something waiting.
Another great one. You make what are by far my favorite "on the field" hvac videos. Keep it up.
Wow, thanks! I am going live on RUclips this evening 10/12/20 @ 5:PM (pacific) to discuss my most recent upload and answer live questions from emails, RUclips comment and the live chat, come on over and check it out. ruclips.net/video/FNJac28OvjU/видео.html
I really enjoyed you taking the trouble shooting to the next level with root cause investigation by taking the compressor apart 👍
You are the man I learn a lot of stuff every time I watch your videos. Keep up the good work I appreciate everything you teach me and the rest of the world
Good afternoon. I work with these refrigeration equipment and I have disassembled these Copeland Scroll compressors and it is not the first time that the lower rotor bushing is loosened by these two screws and causes damage to the equipment due to friction or overheating.
For the pulley system you might want to look at adding a Prusik loop. That would allow you to let go of the rope and not have everything fall down. They are easy to make in the field or you can buy them ready made.
My heart skipped a beat at 16:28. Thought for a moment you were about to take a very unpleasant tumble.
Love the teardown. I wonder if perhaps the bearing had too much friction for some reason and it eventually loosened the bolts from starting and stopping. That or maybe they weren't torqued or loctited right from the factory. Weird failure indeed, Great video
Very interesting,you rarely get to see what killed a compressor because no one ever bothers to take them apart . The gantry was nice . They really should have some kind of lift on all those hatches . It is a smart innovation.
Love watching your videos. I am a Dual ticketed journeyman in gas and refrigeration. After 8 years in commercial refrigeration, I was laid off due to this pandemic. I found a job with a residential company so watching your videos keeps my knowledge up. Thanks for the content
Check in to General Parts we are hiring everywhere before, during and after this pandemic
@@dmiestercommkitchentech3043 thanks but not in my area. I live in Canada
20:53, Hannibal Lecter LOL. It’s totally cool being able to see all of the internals. It’s always smart to try to take things apart and find the point of failure. This is how we learn
0:58 the compressors good it just needs some P.O.E oil lol good video Chris I love that lift you made with unistruts 👍👌
I really like the way you do things, you're a great example for someone like me who just started out in the Industry.
This compressor was damaged by overheating...and then cooling..
The expansion and contraction was enough to pull those bolts out slowly...also the force of that stator vibrating will destroy anything eventually.
Also could be from the manufacturers doing a shotty job building the compressor. But im going with the expansion theory tho
Was evaporator checked for airflow issues possibly causing excessive heat in heating and low superheat in cooling?
Don't forget that the screwholes are chewed out sideways. It could have been the rotor all along but expansion is part of it as you said. If you overheat it, it's possible that the bearings were pressed axially by the rotor, they held up, then the rotor bent a tiny bit, bowing to the side from the pressure, giving it a bit of excentricity and angle. Now you are twisting the bearings around in their socket. If the screws chewed the bearing holder even just a tiny bit, this became a self fueling circle where the excentricity got worse and the screws rattled more and more. This is just an idea but this is an issue I ran into when trying to make a bearing holder once and it acted just like this. non-parallel bearings are absolute monsters
I love watching your videos sir, seeing how you accurately and safely diagnose issues, and have all the proper equipment for every job makes me want to change company’s knowing how mediocre my refrigeration company can be.
Very instructional and informative. You always give gold to us. Please make stickers.
@2:00, should have had the winch rack pushed to 1 side or the other, not in the middle, as then when the compressor was up, you could roll it to the post and have room for it to land. A brake or some other strap to also hold it would mean you don't need to keep pulling on the rope just to hold it in place... so it doesn't fall.
Same at 16:30. Having your hoisting rig in the right spot makes it easier to raise/lower equipment.
Put in foam ear buds when it's loud.
After a couple minutes you should be hearing almost normally and still hear vibrations or if something is rubbing.
I need to give that putty a try. Great video, as always.
A tip.
Rent a two man scissor lift or a boom lift to get all equipment to roof.
Obviously it will add a cost to the job but the time saved in hauling everything to the roof more than makes up for it.
Great video, I've been getting my apprentices to watch your videos. It helps them see the big picture.
Did you remember to pick up the can of wet rag I saw @17:04. Its located in the lower left hand corner of the frame.
Nice compressor autopsy Quincy!!! Thank you! It was muuurrrddderrr Sam!
Nice videos cutting does compressor opening and detailing the problem just a mechanical problem looks like! 👍👍👍
Loving your videos keep up the good work. From a colleague hvac technician from Belgium
You are the man!! Great job love how u go in to details and show the guys a few tricks of the trade!!....
I was surprised you didn't catch fire when learning over to braze the joints at 13:20 ish lol
Gordon Freeman has a good point. I'd also like to suggest the possibility of a slightly off-balance motor. If that top part was weak from the factory and failed, that would cause the motor to flop around a bit, which would wrench on those lower bolts until their mountings failed. impressive that the bolts themselves held up so good, considering the damage to the mounting plate on the bearing.
Good job. I am in my mid 50's now and still try to rope up comoressors. I like your gantry crane and have been looking to build something like that for a while now. Thanks for posting!
Me too, but nothing over 5 ton any more, Mikey.
I could never thing or dream or whatever that i would be watching this kind of content. Im quite interested in tech and im keen on learning all sort of stuff and repair all devices in my house and friends houses beside graduating law school and working in that field for over 7 years now. Just wanted to say that you man have an amazing channel! Its a pleasure watching your vids and your approach to work. I dont like every word you say but thats maybe just my law side :) cheers and keep up!
I higly recommand to check the oil on a short notice. It is most likely very dirty due to mixing with the old oil. So an oil-change is required.
Nice job.
I clearly need to get some of those special heat protection rags.
There's some stuff I want to get, but I'm not ready yet, so I hope the arrangement with Tru Tech Tools goes on for a bit...
Idk if you get paid more through commercials or through premium members but as much as I hate supporting youtube I can never go back to a non premium member!! Love not seeing a bunch of ads. Some channels theres ad after ad after ad. I like seeing the video straight through.
Yeah I have premium too and I still get paid with premium, I will discuss this on my Livestream this evening 10/12/20 @ 5:PM (pacific) come on over and check it out. ruclips.net/video/FNJac28OvjU/видео.html
Another fascinating tear-down of normally invisible machinery. Thanks, Chris!
"Invisible machinery" sounds like a good TV show name. :p
Good job Chris !! Loss of hearing and back problems, are part of the trade. your still young, and have many years ahead of yourself. the advantages today, compressor weights are much less today then years ago. the compressor you hauled up at 78 pounds, a compressor like that years ago would have weighted over 300 pounds. The damage looks to be caused by overheating and contracting, causing fatigue on those bolts, causing them to loosen. Overall Good job.
16:28 I thought you were going down that roof hatch for a minute, that scared me. I know it wasn’t even close and you know what you’re doing but it made me nervous!
Put light pressure on the line while I torch it. You might want to move your hand out of the flame.
Actually the way the guy was pulling on the lines at first it was like his first day on the job.
But a few solder joints later he was a pro. Maybe he just hadn't had his coffee yet.
Hi....I never dessoldering to remove any parts ... Because it can blow oil firer on my face I always cut the pipes..
You doing a good Job..from Portugal ...be safe ... take care!
I will discuss this on my Livestream this evening 10/12/20 @ 5:PM (pacific) come on over and check it out. ruclips.net/video/FNJac28OvjU/видео.html
Hey Chris, thank you so much for your videos.
Yes another one on the Sunday morning, thanx chris👍👍👍👍
I love the backpacks for these kind of job's. So convenient.
I just had my brazing final in class, what a coincidence you braze a whole bunch in this video 😂 glad to know it’s used a lot
Stay safe and healthy! Nice video as always!
You might have a point about about that very long line set. I’ve seen similar situations like that. Some of these design engineers are not aware that a lot of compressors/condensing units don’t lend themselves very well to massive or long piping configurations.
Doing the autopsy puts you on the road to mastery. More than just blindly swapping parts you’re gaining an understanding about what failed and potentially why. I’ve done similar in telecom electrical for years and the understanding I gain helps me in all other aspects of the job.
You should send a failed compressor over to AvE, it would be entertaining to see a high detail explanation on the bearing failures featured on his channel!
When brazing/soldering and the filler metal suddenly decides to make the move into the connection, it is somehow very satisfying to me. Don't know why. Just sort of a "Got it!" moment.
Looks like you make good, solid, well-filled and smooth joints.
Nice job. Great knowledge and installation experience
I would not flare the drier either. On 1/2” a flare torque is roughly 40 foot lbs. and like you said other people could could unintentionally mess things up. Good work. I like the pulley set up to.
1:50 some places just need to have elevators for easy roof access.
also 22:05
I wouldnt over think why those bolts fell out, who knows this could have been a manufacture rebuild when they put the bolts at the bottom they either weren't torqued right or they were never torqued to begin with so they started spinning and rotating around when the compressor kicked on.
"This is not supported well"
*Proceeds to shake violently*
Hang on, question: How does that reversible drier work? When refrigerant flow reverses, wouldn't that just send whatever the filter/drier potentially filtered out, back through the system again? Maybe not the moisture, but anything else it caught?
Good video, Chris. That's the first time I've seen anyone cut open a scroll. You're lucky you don't do residential installs like I did for 30 years. The knees and shoulders take a beating and I'm paying for it in my older years. Pulling compressors up on roofs by rope through scuttle holes and carrying them up ladders didn't help, either. Fortunately, I've got a skate job doing public school commercial kitchen work in the twilight of my career.
3:39 that’s what she said LOL, 4:59 that’s what she said LOL, 5:31 that’s what she said LOL, 5:48 that’s what she said LOL and finally the mother of all that’s what she saids, 8:43 that’s what she said LOL i’m just having fun man don’t block me. I love your videos! I find them very informative. I just like watching somebody run their own business as I have my own business as well.
Excellent work and thanks for the awesome content stay safe and take care
that piece that you are not sure if it was supposed to be oblong easy way to find out.
1. if you get an identical compressor that is still good but pulled because you think it is bad but you decide to replace.
2. if you get a failing compressor that is pulling too much current and tripping breakers but is still running
cut a still working compressor open to see if the piece is oblong.
Great set up, and info. Chris. Great job.
A small tip to make your lift a bit safer: you should install a safety that prevents the weight from going back down if you slip or can't hold it anymore. There are some easy ways to do it and it safes a lot of money if something happens
My first thought when i saw the system arrangement was,,,, what a long vertical suction line lift.This will lead to poor compressor cooling by suction gas and poor oil return... That cooling putty was very interested,, never seen that before, replacement for a wet rug ... Thank you for an interesting video,,,,, and we all get older and slow down....
,,,
I always used a chain hoist. Safest way to move anything.
You should have cut open the old compressor first to check how much oil was in it instead of checking the receiver! You would have saved alot of work and time! Always remember this : work the job! Don't let the job work you! I agree with you about flare nuts you want as few as possible because I have found they are leaking points in the future because they loosen as the metal expands and contracts! Did not see you leak check you solder joints? There is no easy way to get the compressor onto the roof even getting a sign crane creates time and money issues! If we had stairs to the roof we would fasten a pipe to the compressor and 2 of us would carry it up to the roof and vice versa! It saves alot of time bringing up and setting up a lift device! Liked how you made a support for the drier! That was alot of work it was smart to have a helper there with you! On a big job it's easy to over work yourself and get hurt trying to do to much! Even at your young age remember that you are not getting any younger and when you get older what you do now will definitely determine your physical health as you get older! As so many young people do you can't just live for today you have to think about the future! It will be here sooner than you think! You want be able one day to retire and be able to walk away with out a cane or Walkerand be able to enjoy yourself in retirement! The answer to that starts with what you are doing right now! Thanks for another awesome video! I enjoyed it!
I will discuss this on my Livestream this evening 10/12/20 @ 5:PM (pacific) come on over and check it out. ruclips.net/video/FNJac28OvjU/видео.html
When your out in the field it’s hard to get everything right. But you got the job done.
Awesome videos Chris keep them rolling!
What is the reason for the special flare precautions with R-410a? Is it due to the blend becoming imbalanced if a leak developed?
Great video. I'm just the opposite in that I watch mostly residential. I'm learning more of the commercial side now and it's interesting.
You should do a behind the scenes video of your job site videos - how you set up the shots, outtakes etc. it’s really an art form how you do it.
I like your sporlan catch all filter drier too even when i am in philippines i used that kind of filter drier for a long time
Im with you that take care of you since this job looks very demanding, but dont focus to o much on you the limitations you think you have. I have got some limitations myself as well, try to take care but not to think too much about it, you talk like at 37 you were an old guy. Nice video. Love the comp dissecting part. Compressors are like the "untold heros", how many hours, how many cycles until finally they give up ... like its relaibility standards are so high in comparison to many crappy things that are around us.
I Commend you for removing the old compressor instead of leaving it out of sight meaning on the roof out of sight of customer many techs would leave a compressor on the roof because they R 2 LAZY to clean up after themselves
Couple of times where you needed a roach clip for your solder. Haha. Great video Chris.
I remember lifting Carlysle 06Ds in Liebert units,they were north of 325 lbs that was 15 years ago and every day I pay the price! I now own a hydraulic table and a modular engine hoist! You should do a talk on the things new guys should not do now to protect them layer on( like don't use your hands as a hammer)!
I will discuss this on my Livestream this evening 10/12/20 @ 5:PM (pacific) come on over and check it out. ruclips.net/video/FNJac28OvjU/видео.html
For some reason, I find watching brazing very satisfying... It's like soldering electronics, which I do enjoy, but even nicer.
Solenoid valve? I believe Carrier requires one for long lines. It could be liquid flood back washing the oil off of the bearings caused the failure. Common problem in malls.
Enjoying the window view of outside.
Definitely would be interested in some stickers and a shirt re design 👍🏻
Awesome video thank you so much for this.
another video and still wondering why I continue to watch this type of video, I am learning on something I will never use. Awesome video. keep it up.
Some red locktight may have saved the compressor....great videos.Thank you.
What filling material are you using as it did flow very well
Man! You do a great job.Love watching your videos.keep them coming
Check out the Warn 910500 pullzall. We have a similar hatch frame as you do. Its drill powered, so you don't have to worry about an electrical connection.
I noticed all that black insulation on the pipes is cracked and shrivled up. Did you consider having an assistant wrap it with aluminum tape? It's UV reflective and pretty cheep.
Love watching your videos Chris. I’m not criticizing, but shouldn’t you put the heat underneath the copper pipe and the solder on the top part of the pipe and let it flow? I am also wondering too on some of those connections if you could use crimp connectors? Have a good one keep cool.
Thank u for the video it was awesome!!👍🏼🙏🏼
Thanks buddy 👍🙏🙏🙏🙏
ohh, compressor autopsy, my favorite. lol I like to see how things failed and try to determine what caused it.