It must have been very gratifying for Det. Susan to openly testify against him after pulling off such a great undercover OP against that pernicious creep. Come on Florida, why is he still breathing air?
MrBallen had already covered this story in his channel but to hear it from the family members and officers who were directly involved in the case hits differently and much more deeper!!! RIP Peggy!!!
Wow, he was fully preparing to torture that detective. His repeated attempts to get her back to his house are even creepier after knowing that good. Thank goodness she turned him down!!
I loved the last bit where they said that he was still waiting on death row and his only complaint was that his inmate neighbours played their music too loud...what a hoot!
I heard about this case but I didn’t know it happened in Polk County. I don’t believe I would be committing a crime like this in Grady Judd county. He seems like the type to not to give up. Music. Music basically caused her neighbor to kill her. Complete evil. Wow.
The amazing thing is that it is routine practice to send sick patients home if the ER staff can't "figure it out". Happens every day. And it costs lives. I drove myself to the local ER with excruciating high abdominal pain. They ran a couple of tests, said my heart was fine and sent me home even though the pain was still there. Three days later I went back to the same ER on a gurney in the back of the local Rescue Squad. Different doctor ran a different test and discovered I need immediate gall bladder surgery. Worst pain in my life. Bottom line is, we the public have no idea what kind of expertise we're going to get at an ER. We might get some dude fresh out of medical school starting his or her internship. My suggestion would be to always seek a second opinion if this happens to you.....even if you have to go to a different ER in a different city. I came very close to death because my original ER doctor was an idiot.
Omg.. same!! I kept getting SEVERE pain, ended up in ER over and over for months.. and they couldn’t figure anything out 🤬😡 finally.. a Dr walking past me as I was laying on a hospital bed ( wasn’t even my Dr) picked up my chart, pressed a couple of areas on my body, and blatantly said out loud to everyone standing around ( Drs & nurses) “ it’s her gallbladder “! Sure enough, I was in surgery the following day! I can understand a little what the confusion was, because normally, gallstones happens mostly with “ fair, fat, & 50” scenario.. and I was skinny and 23. By the time I would end up in the ER.. they would give me pain relievers, and nothing would show up! Fast forward 7 yrs.. started having the same pain again, which was confusing, because I had no gallbladder at this point.. for a year ran tests.. and they FINALLY figured out I was still creating gall stones in my bile duct. They put a stint in so they could pass through in the future, and now, I do not go through the severe pain.. my point, lol, is I agree.. they just get confused after a few tests, and send you home without finding the root of the problem! I get that there are times it takes special drs to find things.. but lives would be saved if they just took a little more time, run special tests to eliminate possible issues, before sending people home after a few hours!!
It’s funny to see how much credit we gave to the idea of a “genius” killer back then. Not even attempting to bring him in for questioning because he would supposedly be too clever for that! I’m sure any experienced detective could have easily exploited his narcissism.
If they are really smart, they will lawyer up right away and that's that. Now you can't talk to them and their guard is wayyyy up. Fortunately, even smart people don't get a lawyer when they should.
An incredibly, diabolically evil human being. One just never truly know who is living next door to them. What an incredibly brave woman Detective Susan Goreck is.
@@dongvai937and also she should have taught her children to behave themselves around adult and have respect for them and not disrespect them or pick at them a child should stay in their places both should adults and children
100% point-blank. You do not trust anybody. If you don't know where something comes from just throw it away. I know that might seem paranoid but there are people out there that will kill you for no reason
Yea its called life. No point being paranoid your entire life. What a waste of energy. If someone wants to kill you, throwing away an unknown item isn't going to save you. Think about it lol.
@@chndlr18 it has actually saved so many different people's lives. Poisoning is something that happens more often than you think. And attempted poisonings happen a lot. Pay attention to what you are consuming. Nothing paranoid about that.
@@dolinaj1 No, wrong. It IS a deterrent. Unquestionably it prevents the further murder of prison guards and those by escapees, which happen every year. Even the Catholic Church doctrine supports capital punishment for 2,000 years, because it is retributive justice, not revenge. Get over being lame and weak, and, instead, recognize the rights of those innocent victims of these criminals who deserved to live.
«The pale Horse» by Agatha Christy. A coven of “pseudo” witches, who specialise in removing rich relatives. What gives the show away, is the hair loss. The first warning signs of thallium poisoning. To me, it is the creepiest of all Ms. Christies thrillers. But since it is the third of her plots which I find here, turned to reality, the question does obtrude itself: how much do such books give people ideas? Or do the murders give the ideas to the crime writers?
❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂 I love Sheriff Grady Judd !!! I am so glad that he was able to get all of the help he could to take down this man…The Lady Detective was surely the person that he built the room for ??? He was just too insistent on her taking “A grand tour” !!! He was sentenced to death, maybe, add a little Thalium to his meal every now and then ??? That should be the way it’s done, like for like ???
Should be made into a movie . Alert everybody to these kind of people out there . This way a lot sheep will not fall into traps of snakes in the grass .
The concept of Mensa is hilarious. Like you can’t possibly think of something more important to you? On the flip side seems like a great way to sucker some fools through membership and application fees
You didn’t get in I take it. It’s just a club for clever people, just like s football club is for footballers. Us nerds need our own organisations too.
@@teresatv9209 For sure fair to want to surround yourself with people with similar interests but surely you could choose an academic organization focused around something that interests you rather than just having a high horsepower brain. The premise and members who I've met just rubbed me the wrong way. Genuinely happy you get something out of it, I was just being facetious
I can understand their frustration with the Carr family. Pye was a quiet neighbor until he moves Peggy and her brood in. The kids were rude, noisy, destructive and just your typical low class neighbors from hell. But George being in his own little world thought he was smart enough to eliminate them. What was really stupid is he goes through all that trouble only to move anyway! High IQ doesn't mean smart! He was definitely an egg head from the 60s They didn't have a TV nor a radio. They loved their books. His actions were outlandish and completely heinous.
What is he doing in an orange grove, then? He belonged in NYC, probably where he came from. If he doesn't love children and "loving thy neighbor as thyself," then who needs him in this society? Good riddance. The d.p. should have been carried out in 48 hours on him.
does anyone remember the cold case files episode where a guy poisoned his wife with a cancer causing chemical he stole from the hospital where he worked
Intelligence that's not used to advance humanity and improve the human condition is a squandered gift. In what way does cooking and selling meth and poisoning neighbors you don't like make anything better for anyone? What does it prove?
All those orange groves are now wiped out. Empty rolling hills with 500,000 homes being built on the open parcels nowadays. Alturas looks unrecognizable.
George was sentenced to death like a medival times sorcerer. The modern wizard had met his match and the punishment was a playback of the ancient period.
@@chndlr18 In the past people were sentenced to death for witchcraft. Just because you are ignorant of that does not mean you have to be a cheeky swine.
If you are bing poisoned by your neighbor LOCK YOUR DOORS control your food in locked cabinets. Problem solved. I know… get a security camera. You could easily set him up and catch him in the act if you tried even a little.
Don't support ANY glamorization of drug dealers or murderers. Not ever. No exception. Not with dollars. Not with viewing time. NO and no. Never watched it. Not even once. I told a co-worker "I'll watch the episode in which they show him being hanged."
You missed it, they mentioned the doctors found he also had Thallium in his blood yet not to the amount others did, presumably he drank less of the Coke.
Nice channel real crime.. every month i"m go to gria cristall hangtuah sanur bali,, lero computer, rumah camera or house of camera denpasar bali. My name is I Gede wira adiputra, born thrusday16december1993, from penaRungan bangkiangsidem mengwi badungbali. Blood O. My friend in phone is christina desiyanti notaris in jimbaranbadung bali, lero computer denpasar & peter pool employed My father workin bali dinasty resort hotel, primw plaza sanur bali, tunggak bingin villa as pool
I really love liked this crime story. Iv seem it before but that was a long time ago. It gets you thinking if you never seen this episode? The George character is a ass!! Thought he was smarter than the police? Well he definitely underestimated the police!! Those detectives and officers are very smart and all with high IQ's. What bothers me is how come nobody realized that the 6 pack of coca cola wasn't bought by anyone in the house? I know I would question were it came from? My family was an still is Pepsi drinkers. Pye was there first suspect? Which I find odd cause he qas out hunting for a few days? Bottom line is the stupid George who thought he was so smarter than anyone else got caught by a highly bright individual woman. She played ger role perfectly. I mean when you have kids of course you'll have access noise. He never had the balls to confront Pye or his wife? He a straight up coward murderer!! I wonder if he has been executed yet? I hope so!! May the mom RIP 🙏❤️
We all need someone like detective Susan in our lives !
not unless you murdered someone lol
Okay. Get in touch then
Love that Sheriff! Grady Judd ♥️ Americas needs one of him in every county in this country!
Congratulations to Detective Susan, an amazingly brave woman. Sorry for the sufferance and loss of Peggy and her family.
Detective Gorick, what a woman. Hats off.
It must have been very gratifying for Det. Susan to openly testify against him after pulling off such a great undercover OP against that pernicious creep. Come on Florida, why is he still breathing air?
Susan, you are one gutsy lady. Wow.
MrBallen had already covered this story in his channel but to hear it from the family members and officers who were directly involved in the case hits differently and much more deeper!!! RIP Peggy!!!
it is actually covered by Forensic files and new detectives before MrBallen got his hands on this story
Actual documentaries are much better than someone just telling the story. You never know how much is fabricated/'exaggerated etc.
Mr Ballsack is rubbish.
Many crime channels had already made a doc. about this story way before mr.ballance's... ( 🤭 ) jas sayin
Wow, he was fully preparing to torture that detective. His repeated attempts to get her back to his house are even creepier after knowing that good. Thank goodness she turned him down!!
I loved the last bit where they said that he was still waiting on death row and his only complaint was that his inmate neighbours played their music too loud...what a hoot!
Karma? Certainly deserved, I hope they keep him up every night with it.
Hahahahahaha
I heard about this case but I didn’t know it happened in Polk County. I don’t believe I would be committing a crime like this in Grady Judd county. He seems like the type to not to give up.
Music. Music basically caused her neighbor to kill her. Complete evil. Wow.
Then what crime do you believe you would commit in Grady Judd County ..?
The amazing thing is that it is routine practice to send sick patients home if the ER staff can't "figure it out". Happens every day. And it costs lives. I drove myself to the local ER with excruciating high abdominal pain. They ran a couple of tests, said my heart was fine and sent me home even though the pain was still there. Three days later I went back to the same ER on a gurney in the back of the local Rescue Squad. Different doctor ran a different test and discovered I need immediate gall bladder surgery. Worst pain in my life. Bottom line is, we the public have no idea what kind of expertise we're going to get at an ER. We might get some dude fresh out of medical school starting his or her internship. My suggestion would be to always seek a second opinion if this happens to you.....even if you have to go to a different ER in a different city. I came very close to death because my original ER doctor was an idiot.
Omg.. same!! I kept getting SEVERE pain, ended up in ER over and over for months.. and they couldn’t figure anything out 🤬😡 finally.. a Dr walking past me as I was laying on a hospital bed ( wasn’t even my Dr) picked up my chart, pressed a couple of areas on my body, and blatantly said out loud to everyone standing around ( Drs & nurses) “ it’s her gallbladder “! Sure enough, I was in surgery the following day! I can understand a little what the confusion was, because normally, gallstones happens mostly with “ fair, fat, & 50” scenario.. and I was skinny and 23. By the time I would end up in the ER.. they would give me pain relievers, and nothing would show up! Fast forward 7 yrs.. started having the same pain again, which was confusing, because I had no gallbladder at this point.. for a year ran tests.. and they FINALLY figured out I was still creating gall stones in my bile duct. They put a stint in so they could pass through in the future, and now, I do not go through the severe pain.. my point, lol, is I agree.. they just get confused after a few tests, and send you home without finding the root of the problem! I get that there are times it takes special drs to find things.. but lives would be saved if they just took a little more time, run special tests to eliminate possible issues, before sending people home after a few hours!!
It’s funny to see how much credit we gave to the idea of a “genius” killer back then. Not even attempting to bring him in for questioning because he would supposedly be too clever for that! I’m sure any experienced detective could have easily exploited his narcissism.
Nope. None of that's easy. Go try it if you are so good at it.
@@davidb2206 I said experienced detective. I am not one of those
If they are really smart, they will lawyer up right away and that's that. Now you can't talk to them and their guard is wayyyy up. Fortunately, even smart people don't get a lawyer when they should.
There needs to be a movie about the brave detectives work. What an incredible woman 💯
The whole time, I was waiting for Pye to be the real killer.
That was Grady Judd, I thought so.
An exceptional man and a meticulous investigator.
So sorry for that family. Awful to have to go through that.
Wow!!! Brilliant detective.
Hell, this gets a thumb for Sheriff Grady Judd ALONE.
Sheriff Grady is a beast !
@@tylerbailey470 Sheriff Judd was my boss for almost 25 years. I worked for him as a school crossing guard.
An incredibly, diabolically evil human being. One just never truly know who is living next door to them. What an incredibly brave woman Detective Susan Goreck is.
Thaliium is best
@@dongvai937 what do you mean “ is best” ?
Mercury Is best
@@dongvai937and also she should have taught her children to behave themselves around adult and have respect for them and not disrespect them or pick at them a child should stay in their places both should adults and children
teach your children right from wrong
That's Sheriff Grady Judd !! One of the best officers ever. He's all over youtube. 😊
So sorry for her family and her. And the poor dogs too. His wife needs prison too for the cookies.
Sheriff Grady Judd is my hero! I wish he was in south Florida!
Detective Susan was brilliant!
Yes, agreed.
I lived in Central FL and if you are deathly ill with a mysterious illness, you do not want to be at Winter Haven hospital
100% point-blank. You do not trust anybody. If you don't know where something comes from just throw it away. I know that might seem paranoid but there are people out there that will kill you for no reason
Yea its called life. No point being paranoid your entire life. What a waste of energy. If someone wants to kill you, throwing away an unknown item isn't going to save you. Think about it lol.
@@chndlr18 it has actually saved so many different people's lives. Poisoning is something that happens more often than you think. And attempted poisonings happen a lot. Pay attention to what you are consuming. Nothing paranoid about that.
Trepal has been on death row for more than 30 years, and doesn't have an execution date. What type of justice is this? None, obviously.
Whole life sentence is sufficient. Capitol punishment is cruel and inhuman, exceeding reasonable justice.
@@dolinaj1 No, wrong. It IS a deterrent. Unquestionably it prevents the further murder of prison guards and those by escapees, which happen every year. Even the Catholic Church doctrine supports capital punishment for 2,000 years, because it is retributive justice, not revenge. Get over being lame and weak, and, instead, recognize the rights of those innocent victims of these criminals who deserved to live.
That shack was the murderer’s house?! And the wife a doctor?! What a hoot, but only if the creep were not a smug, viscous killer with a ghastly wife.
She is a monster too. I hope someone is keeping an eye on her.
What an amazing woman that detective is!!!
«The pale Horse» by Agatha Christy.
A coven of “pseudo” witches, who specialise in removing rich relatives.
What gives the show away, is the hair loss. The first warning signs of thallium poisoning.
To me, it is the creepiest of all Ms. Christies thrillers.
But since it is the third of her plots which I find here, turned to reality, the question does obtrude itself: how much do such books give people ideas? Or do the murders give the ideas to the crime writers?
The sheriff in this is everywhere!! 🙊All over RUclips. Sheriff Grady?? 🤭
First time seeing this, wondering if a movie had been created about this? I would really like to watch it, that creep was so, so, disturbed!!!
Breaking bad.
What a sick bastard he was the lady was one lucky Detective not to become a victim. Really like the series thank you for upload👍😉
Sheriff Grady Judd is still in the saddle giving his unique press conferences in Polk Country Florida.
❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂 I love Sheriff Grady Judd !!! I am so glad that he was able to get all of the help he could to take down this man…The Lady Detective was surely the person that he built the room for ??? He was just too insistent on her taking “A grand tour” !!! He was sentenced to death, maybe, add a little Thalium to his meal every now and then ??? That should be the way it’s done, like for like ???
There's one easy way to tell if someone is lying. If they are telling you that they can see if someone is lying... then they are lying.
Hahaaa, nice!
The hair loss was a telling clue for anyone who has ever read Agatha Christie's The Pale Horse.
Nice surprise to see Sheriff Judd after watching his eloquent press briefings.
He's obviously not THAT smart as he kept a ton of evidence...
This is so disturbing 😮how can a human being do such an apalling thing!? RIP Peggy, you raised very beautiful children🌹❤️🌏🌏🌕🙏🌸🇦🇺🐝🍀🦋🦉🏡🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
My favorite sheriff 👍🏽
He's a joy to watch on his briefs.
That man is whistling every word.
I've seen this before but it was a while back so I watched it again :)
Well done, ALL 👍👍👍👍👍
Should be made into a movie . Alert everybody to these kind of people out there . This way a lot sheep will not fall into traps of snakes in the grass .
I haven't finished the video I just started actually but Grady Judd is the best sheriff around!! Genuinely cares about the people he serves!
The concept of Mensa is hilarious. Like you can’t possibly think of something more important to you? On the flip side seems like a great way to sucker some fools through membership and application fees
Exactly.
You didn’t get in I take it. It’s just a club for clever people, just like s football club is for footballers. Us nerds need our own organisations too.
@@teresatv9209 For sure fair to want to surround yourself with people with similar interests but surely you could choose an academic organization focused around something that interests you rather than just having a high horsepower brain. The premise and members who I've met just rubbed me the wrong way. Genuinely happy you get something out of it, I was just being facetious
Its so funny to me that the genus group is called mensa, which means stupid in Spanish
Quite ironic isn’t it😂
Still wondering why the husband didn't want the wife to be take to the hospital the sons had to?.....
I can understand their frustration with the Carr family. Pye was a quiet neighbor until he moves Peggy and her brood in.
The kids were rude, noisy, destructive and just your typical low class neighbors from hell.
But George being in his own little world thought he was smart enough to eliminate them.
What was really stupid is he goes through all that trouble only to move anyway!
High IQ doesn't mean smart!
He was definitely an egg head from the 60s
They didn't have a TV nor a radio. They loved their books.
His actions were outlandish and completely heinous.
“Low class” says more about you, than the victim and her family.
Probably it isn't so much about “low class” but about the age of the kids and their educational level.
What is he doing in an orange grove, then? He belonged in NYC, probably where he came from. If he doesn't love children and "loving thy neighbor as thyself," then who needs him in this society? Good riddance. The d.p. should have been carried out in 48 hours on him.
And may the other inmates play their radios too loud for a very, very long time.
this program repeats things alottttt
The repeats would have been where an advert was inserted.
WOW!!! Sheriff Grady Judd!! He always gets his man (or woman). WTG Sheriff Judd!!
Back pre-internet when detectives had no back-up! This guy was a sick puppy. It’s a good thing she didn’t go to his new house.
It's immediately obvious that this was an unusual case and they should have looked at poison at the outset. Duh
Sheesh, Florida needs to get with the executions. What are they waiting on?
I knew about Thalium poisen. It is used in Agatha Christie tv series, in the episode "The Pale Horse"
She cleaned up good 💞💞💞💞💞
Congratulations maam
Next level …
This was a very risky mission as Susan could have been poisoned by George if he suspected her. It was a foolhardy task to get near the clever killer.
They did a great job on this investigation. Great job
does anyone remember the cold case files episode where a guy poisoned his wife with a cancer causing chemical he stole from the hospital where he worked
Love sherif Grady Judd hope he is still going strong
Every time the ret FBI guy said s... my ears cry!
Intelligence that's not used to advance humanity and improve the human condition is a squandered gift.
In what way does cooking and selling meth and poisoning neighbors you don't like make anything better for anyone? What does it prove?
Why does dude keep saying how smart and brilliant they are. They are murderers.
Pye is Mayhem from the Allstate commercials and Law & Order.
Unbelievable! I thought it was the ugly husband.
His wife should be behind bars too!!
Sheriff Judd is the best!!
All those orange groves are now wiped out. Empty rolling hills with 500,000 homes being built on the open parcels nowadays. Alturas looks unrecognizable.
The poor innocent dogs
I agree. So cruel and sad. 🙏🐕💙🐕
Best one on this case was on Forensic Files..
Impressive that detective woman is.
Why did know that was the sheriff Grady lol 😍
George was sentenced to death like a medival times sorcerer. The modern wizard had met his match and the punishment was a playback of the ancient period.
Time to take your meds hun.
@@chndlr18 In the past people were sentenced to death for witchcraft. Just because you are ignorant of that does not mean you have to be a cheeky swine.
👍🏼
I remember this too from mr ballen.
If you are bing poisoned by your neighbor LOCK YOUR DOORS control your food in locked cabinets. Problem solved. I know… get a security camera. You could easily set him up and catch him in the act if you tried even a little.
So the kids terrorized this guy with loud music, etc. I guess they share some blame here.
I wouldnt be surprised if this case inspired the breaking bad TV show.
Happened well before Breaking Bad
Don't support ANY glamorization of drug dealers or murderers. Not ever. No exception. Not with dollars. Not with viewing time. NO and no. Never watched it. Not even once. I told a co-worker "I'll watch the episode in which they show him being hanged."
This was on forensic files
And you want me to believe that the wife didn't know about his evil schemes??
Oh cool..this is the current Chief in Florida who says if you do something stupid in Polk County, Florid your ass will be shot. Love this guy!!
My man Graddy Judd
Sheriff Judd is cool as shit.
So my neighbors meth labs were most likely poisoning me? Explains a whole bunch of things.
Bro whole time I thought it was the husband damn some people just mad evil bro smh 🤦🏽♂️
Florida again 🤣
Kind of peculiar that Pye was the only one not poisoned. Maybe he didn't drink as much Coke as the others?
You missed it, they mentioned the doctors found he also had Thallium in his blood yet not to the amount others did, presumably he drank less of the Coke.
Every person in the house had drank some of the cola.
Also, he was away hunting the weekend the mom first got sick.
Susan great job . You are sharp hats off to you.
How did he put coke inside their house
Is a real life Heisenberg.
Who tf called their kid pie??? Wtf America its worse than mitt 😂😂😂
If you're going to get stupid in Floriduh don't do it in Polk County sheriff Grady don't play
Damn y’all got Gpaw shiiii
Was he really smart? Who tested him😅
People with high IQ are usually common sense dumb.
His first mistake was doing a crime in Florida
Cannot send comment in real crime & police channel since 2 day ago & 3 day ago maybe hacker 100%
Nice channel real crime.. every month i"m go to gria cristall hangtuah sanur bali,, lero computer, rumah camera or house of camera denpasar bali. My name is I Gede wira adiputra, born thrusday16december1993, from penaRungan bangkiangsidem mengwi badungbali. Blood O. My friend in phone is christina desiyanti notaris in jimbaranbadung bali, lero computer denpasar & peter pool employed
My father workin bali dinasty resort hotel, primw plaza sanur bali, tunggak bingin villa as pool
I really love liked this crime story. Iv seem it before but that was a long time ago. It gets you thinking if you never seen this episode? The George character is a ass!! Thought he was smarter than the police? Well he definitely underestimated the police!! Those detectives and officers are very smart and all with high IQ's. What bothers me is how come nobody realized that the 6 pack of coca cola wasn't bought by anyone in the house? I know I would question were it came from? My family was an still is Pepsi drinkers. Pye was there first suspect? Which I find odd cause he qas out hunting for a few days? Bottom line is the stupid George who thought he was so smarter than anyone else got caught by a highly bright individual woman. She played ger role perfectly. I mean when you have kids of course you'll have access noise. He never had the balls to confront Pye or his wife? He a straight up coward murderer!! I wonder if he has been executed yet? I hope so!! May the mom RIP 🙏❤️
D is for death!