Love it how his son in law has already land where the new canal will be made... Corrupt politicians always do that, transfer money from foreign countries (e g . US paying them to get to Black sea) , into their own pockets.
I thought it was obvious. They'd rather blow up new buildings that have no attraction for tourists than blow up the buildings that tourists want to come and see. The people that live there are of no concern.
@@rovari524 nah bro ı am turkish and one one sayin istanbul to contantinapole its just to long and ıf you say consantinapole in street turkish peoples beat you up
Turkey argued it, my God the silent genocide we don't talk about a 100 years ago, political corruption but a factional democracy, oil hungry, a failed political coup backed by foreign powers. It's like I never even left.
@@Lawrance_of_Albania well, if america didn't invade the soviet union, then invade majority of the countries in Europe, invade majority of Germany despite soviets being the liberator, subject europe through Marshall plan propaganda to eventually remove the large opinion of the Soviets as the primary liberator in the second world war, if the US didn't suppress the communist movements in turkey, soviet union wouldn't be aggressive and turkey wouldn't have someone as stupid as Erdogan and a situation where their lira is inflating, and usually that ends in a coup for turkey, LOL
@@АндрейЕрмилов-х8п It isnt even that i dislike russia, i live in orthtodox nation and russia is greatest protector of orthodoxy. But such a stupid move is what i call "shoting yourself in a foot" That communist moron stalin pushed turkey in NATO, and thats faaar from his only mistake
we appreciate the informative video about the Istanbul canal project. However, we noticed a few mistakes that we would like to point out. Firstly, the Suez Canal is not actually 200km long but is still quite significant. Secondly, we want to clarify that Istanbul is not the capital of Turkey, it's actually Ankara. Lastly, it's important to consider the potential environmental risks that could come with such a large-scale excavation project. Despite these points, we are grateful for the opportunity to learn more about Istanbul's future development plans. Thank you RealLifeLore!
They didn't actually say that it's the capital of Turkey, they said that it was capital of 3 great empires, the romans, byzantium and the ottoman empire.
They said that Istanbul was the capital of 3 great empires as in empires that existed before Turkey, not that it is the capital of Turkey. They also explained a lot about the potential detrimental effects of such a large scale excavation
I did a double take on his Suez measurement because the graphic didn't add up, but it was 162 km during creation and now 193 km. I'm more interested in why the Bosporus Straight has such significant traffic problems, it's massive. The Suez is tiny. Fun: You can see several submarines underwater on Google Earth near the mouth of the straight to the Black Sea
@@dotmashrc The Byzantine Empire was literally the Eastern Roman Empire, not some ancient Greek remnant. 18th century academics didn’t like calling it the Roman Empire because it offended their enlightened sensibilities, so they made up the term Byzantine Empire. The people living there called themselves Roman and referred to the state as the Land of the Romans. Even long after the Ottomans conquered Constantinople, the area was referred to as the Rûm Millet or Roman Nation.
Calling eastern Roman empire as Byzantine empire is like calling France as Lutetian republic (France's capital Paris old name), and calling China as people republic of Fanyang (China's capital Beijing old name), thats sound ridiculous right ? just because some holy german confederation (HRE) claim themselves as romans when they really not, it doesnt erase the real history of eastern roman empire.
As a resident in İstanbul, none of my neighbors want this project. Everyone thinks that turkey should focus on other problems such as unemployment and high inflation rates. This project is just a way to launder Erdogan and his friends' dirty money.
If it'll make you feel better, most of turkish economy goes to corrupt government and citizens do not get profit from it. Rich people get richer while poor people get even more poor each day. Turkey itself is rich compared to most other countries, but turkish people are not.
@@tilkilit for instance, the SA president fired the defence minister last week. This week, that same person is formally nominated as Parliament Speaker, by the same party the president heads. There are little to no repercussions for politicians being incompetent or corrupt in SA, so it seems.
@@Siphamandla.Ngcobo Do you think South Africa will balkanize along ethnic lines in the future? As an outsider, it sadly seems like a very unstable country with alot of ethnic tension.
At 8:50, the line that shows the size of the suez canal is wrong because the canal is only the upper part which was dug through the land and not the whole passage. I think the 200 km is right though but I'm not sure about that
According to Wikipedia the Suez Canal is 193.3 km long. You are correct that the graphic incorrectly puts the Red Sea as part of the length of the Suez Canal. The Suez Canal is properly measured from its entrance at the northern tip of the Red Sea to its exit on the Mediterranean.
It doesn't make sense to mess with it. As an American, the only reason there should be American war ships in the Black Sea is if there's a war going on. If there's a war going on, does the treaty really matter?
@@Sheridantank I reckon there are no reasons for American war ships to be in the Black Sea even if there is a war there. It's halfway across the bloody world. But you know, how else are they supposed to provoke Russia?
@@milseq Honestly the Russians have a right to be angry if there are American war ships in the black sea. America likes to stick it's fingers in everyone else's pie.
The Istanbul earthquake will definitely happen one day, when it happens, Turkey will go back at least 5 years. Most of the Turkish politicians still do nothing about it, and they still think the most important and priority issue of Istanbul is the making the canal. Just consider, 15 million people live in Istanbul and most of the houses are very rotten. And we already know what happened in the Izmir earthquake.
Many of the houses in that part of the world are old and masonry doesn’t have any steel reinforcement like rebar. I was around that area in the 1970s and remember seeing building being built where they put straw in the concrete, what’s with that?
@@Chris_at_Home Even today, most of the houses built in Istanbul are still too weak for earthquakes around 6.1 - 8.2. And keep in mind this, although only 4.5 million people lived in the earthquake in Izmir, the poor infrastructure of the earthquake left many people homeless.
The canal isn't the point of this project. Making money for construction companies is the whole point of this project. I wouldn't be at all surprised if in ten years there are several bridges to nowhere but no canal.
@@Mr-Money01 It would be a plus, but not us. Not to regular citizens. This and all other "Build-operate-transfer " projects made under AKP government have been primarily about shoveling public money into few private companies (all Erdoğan's allies). No project made in this arrangement provides any profit to the public coffers, on the contrary, they get payments each and every month from the treasury. One example to this is the Avrasya Tunnel connecting two sides of İstanbul from the south. It's a good tunnel except it costs too much to use and costs way way more if we don't use it. Because the deal is there needs to be certain quota met each month and treasury covers the difference if that quota is not met. Since its opening in 2016, that quota of use was met only one month. That's it. And this is one of the better projects made under this arrangement, there are far worse ones out there.
@@Mr-Money01The idea is that it is the reason used to convince and gather majority support for the expensive project. The construction companies and real estate owners will likely be the first to benefit and made loads of money from whether or not it is actually completed.
@مالك القطيف Having $25.000 per capita was the dream for the Turks yet here we are, wasting money on useless projects instead of helping the 24 million people living in poverty in our country.
As a Turkish citizen, I always taught that Montreux needed to get renewed and modernized. It would have saved a lot of effort and cleaned up the problems of the strait. The canale idea itself is very cool but on paper has a lot more negatives than pozitives. Hopefully, the project will stop. And right now Istanbul and the Eagen coastlines are facing a sea pollution problem as well. Adding more waste to that won't be any smarter I reckon.
Ok both super powers were stupid in this case 😑. Both Broke turkeys s rules which was uncool. Nearly provoked a neutral nation which was uncool. And abused a potential Allies for Idiocracy
@@Borg231 I you listened well , they both did not broke any rules they subverted. As both did not sign UNCLOS for geographic reasons, self determination is a pretty word in diplomacy you see you can't force another to sign a largely voluntary treaty. As for the other Treaty it did not describe missile ships, I know both countries Turkey and US, you can include Russia as well if you want subscribe to a Roman law, of "what the law does not include it excludes".
Just to clarify: No big cargo ship is able to travel through the Danube. Only a "barge" can travel on the Danube. We call them "Binnenschiffe" in german.
Another correction is that the convention they talk about also affects the Dardanelles. So Turkey needs to build another canal there if it wants to bypass the Montreaux Convention.
@@PROUD-COUNTRY would be funny joke if you weren’t from Greece, a country that almost destroyed the Euro during the 2008 finanical crisis because of Greek government being too inpatient to actually do things legitimately to use the Euro
It was used to be the capital in the Golden Age of the Ottoman Empire, but never meant to be after that, especially in late 19th and early 20th centuries. As it was tactically useless since there was such little land protection left against European forces like Balkan countries. Original: It was used to, but never meant to be. As it was tactically useless.
@@44theshadow49 Given the whole sentence, I'm quite certain they meant "it used to be" (if this is the bit that threw you off). Not everyone on the Internet is a native English speaker.
@@Basauri48970 I'm more criticizing the assertion that Constantinople, one of the most historically significant cities in the past 2 millennia, lauded as "The City of the World's Desire," and was famously difficult to siege, is "tactically useless." Its so backwards I thought he was trolling, but the tone of the rest of his comment leads me to think he's serious.
As someone from Turkey that also lived in Istanbul for 15 years, I can say that basically no one supports this project anywhere in our country. Especially after the mucilage breakout in the Marmara Sea this year. I hope this problem gets more international recognition and can be canceled. We already have a lot of problems and many don't want to add ecological collapse of the Marmara Sea to that list.
Forget it. No one has even heard of it until now. And frankly from the reactions here, hardly anyone cares whether it gets built. If you want more attention, go stage a huge protest and show the world when people gets arrested and killed. That’s how you get attention
@@TheZachary86 Erdoğan Controls The Media. The people that opposed Erdoğan's rule had made an march similar to salt March made in India with Ghandi, but even bigger, no one cared or heard about it. Even me living in Turkey didn't even hear it and learned about it years later after it happened. Edit: Sorry not weeks, YEARS.
@@raptorfromthe6ix833 We are already doing that. Nobody cares or even knows about it because Erdoğan Controls The Media, like the Bosporus University Events. Wich all the students were suddenly called "Terrorists" because the media under Erdoğan said so.
I think it could work since wait times are really important in shipping bussiness. If the cargo gets to late the loss could be expenontial sometimes so people decide to give toll money instead of waiting.Although this needs to be measured like how long the wait will be,how much the loss will be and to make a profit how much you need to put toll money. But again this is just a way Erdodan to get his pockets full. Neutrality is the most important thing in my opinion also transport over the bridges is just a nightmare for the citizens. So it comepletely expected to be both military and citizens oppose the idea.
I laughed out loud at the assertion that cargo ships from Shanghai ever transit the Rhine-Main-Danube Canal to go to Rotterdam. Besides the excruciatingly slow speed of the Canal versus the Mediterranean, the maximum beam possible in the Canal is only 38 feet versus the typical cargo ship which is more than 100 feet wide - usually much more.
@@kebabseverim3364 dont mind these people they probably support pkk or feto orgnanisation. sorry to say that but there are so many people inside Turkey that dont want Turkeys success
So, let's build a new canal to divert dangerous volatile cargo away from the heavily populated Istanbul center. Also let's heavily populate the new canal's banks! 👌
Yes, But! The Bosphorus is a natural waterway, you cant change its geography. With the new canal, you can take the necessary actions and preparations to avoid possible dangerous accidents as much as technologically possible. Not that I support but if this is the topic, the canal would be of course much safer. The Bosphorus is a difficult waterway to navigate with many big accidents in history. One recently, a ship crashing into a $25m historical mansion.
@@maythesciencebewithyou Thats for sure one of the ideas. But cost of the project is basically much higher compared to the investors. I think there are few goals here; - protecting bosphorus straight - finding new investment areas in Istanbul - global attraction - political stand against Montro - of course economical benefits - increase power against black sea countries
Romans and Byzantines were one and the same. They never called themselves the Byzantine Empire, historians called them that to differentiate between the ERE before and after the fall of the West.
@@maniaces not all byzantines were greek but they were greek speaking romans. They still considered their empire the roman empire. Only it was eastern and western
They mostly spoke greek but latin was a second language. The eastern roman empire had conquered most of the old western roman areas at one point just to regain lost roman land. They viewed themselves as romans with greek characteristics just like the egyptians viewed themselves as romans with a egyptian characteristics. The same could be said of The rest of the old roman empirical areas with their own identities.
@@maniaces The “Greeks” considered themselves Romans up until the Greek Independence Movement revived the terms “Hellene”, “Hellas”, “Hellenic”, etc. Actually, they considered themselves as Rhomanoi for about a generation thereafter, because the poorest areas were contacted last.
@@M3E92V8 South Korea didn't exist in 1915 and Euro became a currency in 1999/2002. The 1915 Çanakkale Bridge was built from 2017 to 2022. The 1915 in the name honours an Ottoman naval victory against the navies of the UK and France during WW I.
This sounds stupid. Instead of negotiating the terms of a UN treaty to find a solution everyone is happy with, turkey is needlessly wasting resources building a redundant canal
aside from the UN being useless. you have 5 countries that can veto any resolution the UN makes up. And if you have watched the video 3 off the ones that can veto have an interest in it.
It is. The reason they want to do this project is not because they care about the public. The reasons why the government wanted this project: 1- Being richer by building the canal and the city around it. That is corruption, 2-Vanity, 3-In addition, the man at the head of the government sees himself as the sultan. He probably has something like a god complex. Such a channel is completely meaningless when there is a natural strait next to it. The Suez Canal saves ships from circumnavigating the African continent, which is about 10 days less travel. Kanal Istanbul does not have such a function because there is a natural strait right next to it. They say that Kanal Istanbul will reduce the ship traffic in the Bosphorus, but the ship traffic in the Bosphorus has been decreasing since 2008. This is because larger ships are being built. Apart from that, they claim that with the construction of the canal, the danger in the strait will decrease. Because a ship had hit a mansion before. However, there is a problem here: They will build cities on both sides of Canal Istanbul. Moreover, the widest part of Kanal Istanbul is narrower than the narrowest part of the channel, the deepest part of Kanal Istanbul is shallower than the shallowest part of the Bosphorus, and Kanal Istanbul is longer than the Bosphorus. Other arguments are that Kanal Istanbul will increase revenue. They talk as if the ships passing through the strait don't pay. This is not true. Every ship that passes through the strait pays. If this money was to be raised, they would have to resort to international laws for this. However, they do not have the political power to do this, and that is not their main purpose. In short, the government knows that all this is not true. But like any dictator, they want to continue to rule. For this, they need to please interest groups (those who commit corruption and much more).
@@gareaap7806 VETO only work on Security Council, normal general assembly didn't have VETO and there are tons of agreement passed GA every year if they really want to. So It just about didn't want to do the paperwork.
Im Turkish, first of all thanks for spending time and creating this video , and if anyone wondering what is this canal about watch 15 seconds from 13:30 this tells the whole story . A selfish project that even lead Turkey to war
Economy is in crisis everywhere. Ever heard of Corona? At least Turkey is going its own way despite the sanctions and economic warfare of the west. Albayrak did a lot of good after his predecessor by actually tackling inflation which spiked shortly before he took office.
The main reason is provide a profit for upper class people who are close to current gov half of the lands already bought from peasants for cheaper price before the announcement.. coincidence??
It s not the paper, it s tens of armies of tens of nations. They re trying to outwit and bullshit each other. The paper is but a small but critical component of that.
They do this because corrupts close to the government bought territory from the cannal İstanbul area when it was cheaper with hopes of government building the cannal.
The Airport is already built and is operating, just not 100%. And in case of a disaster such as an explosion it is less dramatic if newly build residental and commercial areas get destroyed rather than the historical and more inhabited city center.
The land around the proposed canal belongs to Erdogan and his cronies. The canal isn't for transporting cargo, it's so that the future houses there have a canal that goes next to them, so they become worth more.
I don't understand why you're telling Danube River is a major asset for trade. The Danube is very big, but cargo container ships can't navigate on it... only few trade on the river with some small ships.
Agreed. I can see the canal connecting the Rhine and the Danube from my bedroom window. There are not a lot of big barges going up and down there. Maybe one medium-sized one every half hour. Not a lot in terms of global trade.
Lots of nonsense in this video. No major Russian ports (not even Murmansk) ever close due to ice, and most Russian oil exports by sea actually do go from the Baltic ports of Ust-Luga and Primorsk, not Novorossiysk.
Sooo... NATO warship can cross? Well, the day of it's opening, the first 20 Russian cargo ships starting to cross in a convoy. Suddenly they had a mysterious malfunction, and sunk. Russia blame the Turkish, sabotaging their cargo fleet. The ships found really problematic to remove, thanks to mysterious, and dangerous cargo.
@@A1509MDIX There is a munition ship that sunk during WWII in Thames estuary's shallow water which is still there because of the volatile cargo. If they try to move it the explosives might detonate so they had to cordon it off as navigation hazard and can't get rid of it to this day. so it's not an entirely impossible scenario that Russia pulling something like this if more sanction are imposed by NATO nations.
Basically Reason: To sell Arabs more land, coastsides. To make companies' ships trade faster in same amount of time, with that they gain more and there's a reason to pay to acces it. Also Turkey loves buildings, if that happens there would be several bridge thus consruction companies profit
@@unknownv1065 I checked and you are right. The foundation for the first bridge is set to start work in the last week of june. That is next week so it has not started as of today.
@@unknownv1065 we show the CHP how things are being done for the last 20 years. They only moan and complain until they themselves are using the facilities and projects like every bosporus bridge built until this day, the two big airports, the intercontinental subway marmaray and much more.
I love youtube premium and have been a loyal and happy customer for nearly 5 years now. being able to play youtube videos while my phone screen if off is invaluable and I cannot stand ads. The only time my sub has lapsed was when my card expired.
@@whosasking9655 by “Russian” I mean I was born in Russia and live in Russia rn. This country is garbage and I want to destroy it so much because of government, people, nation mentality and some much more.
As a Turk, on top of the comments made by my friends, Turkey has 3 bridges on the straits, not 4. In addition, Turkey has a bridge connecting Bursa and Gebze and a newly opened bridge in Çanakkale
Rhine-Main-Danube Canal flows through Nuremberg, where I live. Actually, it's approximately 5 minutes away from my home. I go there for a run multiple times a week, feels special every time.
@@roiq5263 no, Europe is still connected to Asia via Russia. Also a continent isn't an island, otherwise North and South America would be an island. And Australia isn't classed as an island because it's classed as a continent.
I'm turkish and i can say that this canal thing got politic. People are blindly supporting or going against this idea by their politic opinion. It sucks that politics and money make peoples desicions. Trees and fields in the way of the canal will be destroyed. It's not just the canal, they are going to build a city around it! So both İstanbul's population will boom and nature will be gone. I doubt the sanity of anyone who supports this.
Not only that, but since the immediate area is overdue for a major earthquake, dumping all that money on a political project instead of rebuilding of the old buildings within the city (there are many, some standing by a thin thread) is ignorance of millions at best. That money would be spend best to rebuild the city, but more importantly, improve Anatolian cities and generate quality jobs there. Nowadays people who live in Istanbul do so not because it's a good city to live, but because economic opportunities are better there.
@@elemparador Considering that the contest Is between them and the Russian Empire(yes, the russians claimed to be the third Roman Empire), It Is not an hard choice 😂
Casue of Turkey is staying between Russia and America on many subjects, Turkish news and politics are always interesting and so confusing. If you are living in Turkey many Turkish people will tell you to not follow politics in Turkey. Cause if you will, you'll go crazy.
Meanwhile Turkey: Hey Merchants bored of the heavy traffic and longer wait times in the Bosphorus upgrade to our premium Istanbul canal for better experience.
Did you really measure 200km for the Suez canal from the tip of the Sinai pininsula? Most of that is a natural part of the red sea, the actual canal is only a fraction of that length.
One more thing that I would have added to this video is that, Istanbul is located in a very geologically active location so in the event of a large earthquake (which experts say that will be above magnitude7), everybody who lives in European Istanbul would be stuck and they would not be able to escape the densely packed city. On top of that, this new canal will travel through kilometers of forest which would danger the lives of many native and endangered species. It also has the added risk of introducing invasive marine species to the inland sea of Marmara from the black sea or vice versa because the strong currents of the Bosporus straight blocks this naturally. Edit: New polls suggest that on the general elections in 2023, it looks highly likely that Erdogan might not get re-elected and I feel like the entire reason on why this insane project is going ahead is because he wants to leave a final mark, a permanent signature, before he is stripped away from all of his power.
merak etme deprem bundan çok önce olacak, İstanbul'da yaşıyorsan asıl o zaman ağlayacaksın, gidecek yerin olmayacak, şehir eski ve çarpık, yenisi gerekiyor? yüzde kaçı yıkılacak kim bilir ama çok yüksek bir oran olacağı belli.
If there is an earthquake, you won't be able to go that far either. Earthquake is not like volcano at all. Earthquake is short and sudden, any escape would be into a nearby open field like road instead of escaping the city.
@@xwtek3505 what im saying is not the time that earthquake happening, i mean the after, the only buildings that can stand that earthquake are the bridges or others, other than that city will become pile of rubble, and clearing all those rubble will take a long time, that will cause so many damages to economy and people, but imagine new city that has better buildings and new stuff to make money for country, at least for a while, thats what i was meaning to
@@mushi475 1. Replacing the city would be an even bigger investion than istanbul canal. 2. Such problem can be solved for cheaper than applying a strict building code to new building to gradually make the building stronger.
Tbf just because it is called the Roman Empire doesn't make it one either While in name it was the continuation of the Roman Empire itself in practice, it was led by Greeks and not latins and thus should be separated not as a distinctive empire entirely, but not the continuation of the original Rome too
@@ekn_38 we greeks, were the second strongest ethnicity of the roman empire, greek was the second languadge of rome and we for ever will be romoioi, NOBODY can take this from us.
@@yanniskarageorgiou3573 there was coup happened in cyprus greek military junta took over cyprus and turkey invaded cyprus to defend his citizens why you guys want cyprus back when it has peace right now
2:25 There is no way for ocean going cargo vessels to travel up the Danube or the Rhine into Rotterdam. This is absolutely impossible due to bridges, low waters, and the river's geography.
You forgot the ports can also unload cargo and load it onto smaller vessels. The other video says all you need for Danube-Rhine route is 4m depth and 26m width for the river size.
@@glacialimpala No business is going to do what you are suggesting. A ship leaving Shanghai headed for Rotterdam will go west in the Mediterranean, into the Atlantic at Gibraltar, and then north and east to Rotterdam.
in Turkey: People are dying of hunger, graduates can't find a job, innocent people are being arrested, Turkish Lira's worth sent to oblivion Politicians: *let's build an island*
@@swiggyhunter4682 did you watch the video? it could be, for the goverment, which doesnt mean much in turkey, could be a bad thing. it will cost a good amount of moeny, istanbul will loose a good amount of freshwater.
@@swiggyhunter4682 Its NOT good for Istanbul, After some years Istanbul will be hit by an eartquake wich is bigger than 7.We are crying our asses to tell Erdogan that he needs to cancel this because its makjing city weaker, ınstead of making it stronger he does THİS.Next Election he will definitly lose because Gen Z can vote and OOHHH BOY THEY HATE HİM.
I would like to point out a slight *Mistake* The Northwest Passage is claimed as internal Canadian Waters by Canada, while other countries in the EU/UN primarily the USA claim it's international so they can move cargo through it for free. Some years back though, USA tried bringing a cargo ship through the Northwest passage without the Canadian Navy's permission, and was forced to turn back. That caused a huge issue for a bit, before the States and Canada signed an agreement where the US have to ask Canada before sending a ship through the Northwest Passage. In a backwards manner, meaning theyre obligated to say that the N-W Passage is Canadian. Also if any ship is to sink or crash in the passage, Canada has to fix it without being paid internationally sooo.
There is another mistake in the video. 8:50 The Suez Canal is perhaps 200 km long, yes. But it stretches only from Port Said on the mediterranean coast to the city of Suez, which is just left of where you put the sign "Suez Canal". This sign is put on the northern parts of the Gulf of Suez. And the distance from Port Said to the southern tip of the Sinai Peninsula is around 450 km (not 200km as written in the graphics). The Gulf of Suez is a natural gulf of the Red Sea, like the Gulf of Aqaba on the other side of the Sinai Peninsula. The Suez Canal starts at the northern end of the Gulf of Suez. Nevertheless, a very interesting video about Istanbul. Have a nice day. :)
The Suez Canal was built by the French in order of the Ottoman empire. Egypt was then ruled by the Turks. The liberty statue in America was built for the Suez Canal but later they rejected the statue because it could lead to problems in the Egyptian muslims. because it was a woman. So they transformed it to France and it sit in the garage until French decided to gift it to America
@@kebabseverim3364 i bet you have no idea about what dictator is.i dont wanna start a political discussion but the fact that you can call him dictator means that he is not a dictator
@@kebabseverim3364 Sorry but it's Democracy. My idea Democracy is not working for all nations. So he's not actually a Dictator I mean you don't have to be bad to be a Dictator for example Ataturk was an Dictator
Soviet union: "Turkey thinks they are clever. Heh! There's a loophole." Turkey: "Guess i'll just join NATO then." Soviet union: "Wait that's not supposed to happen."
I feel bad for the ppl who don't have RUclips premium and have to watch agressively timed and placed ads that are very aggravating but RUclips doesn't lose any sleep over it.
This is a very wrong and harmful project for our planet. Why a ship is already wide: instead of passing free and faster through a canal whose narrowest point is between Rumeli Hisarı and Anadolu Hisarı, approximately 698 meters and the widest point 3 thousand 500 meters, "The Channel will pass through Küçükçekmece, Avcılar, Başakşehir and Arnavutköy districts. Would he want to pass through an artificial canal with 360 meters in the narrowest part, 775 meters in the widest part and a minimum width of 275 meters in Istanbul?
Companies will be very happy to use the new canal. Even now there are sometimes several day wait times to cross. Ship operators lose money sitting around. This new Canal will be very helpful for everyone.
Once the canal is completely built, an evergreen ship will be stuck on the bosphorus thus everyone would have to go through the new canal. Chaching
lol
You need at least 3 Evergiven class ships side by side to block it even in the narrowest point.
Dont temp them.
Guys, this is a joke 🤣
Guys, this is a joke 🤣
I am from Turkey and i am learning why we are transforming Istanbul into a island from a foreign RUclips channel
@sülüman yes we all are
Love it how his son in law has already land where the new canal will be made... Corrupt politicians always do that, transfer money from foreign countries (e g . US paying them to get to Black sea) , into their own pockets.
I’m am too
Much love to turkey
Same here
EA: To get the full Black Sea experience you have to buy the Istanbul canal DLC
:d
@@mckone9 and extra regime tax for that
Only 999.9$
lmao this made my day
😂😂😂😂
As a representative of Turkish people, we don't want canal. Dictator Erdogan is oppressing us
When you said that Suez is 200km long, you counted the Red sea, which isn't artificial. The Suez is at least 2 times smaller (but still quite big)
Its 193.3km long, I guess he just rounded
"Using Istanbul canal is like using RUclips premium"
Comparison of the year.
yeah and noone uses it
Its more like a project to arabify the İstanbul and launder money.
Wait,why're u commenting on a non-chess vid?I only see u in chess vids of gothamchess,etc..
Worth it.
@@herrleser6337 I'm watching this video on RUclips Premium! No commercials and unlimited music is worth it. 👍
Boats: Zzz this takes so long
Turkey: you want bosphorus premium subscription?
😂😂😂 best comment of the day
Skip add. 🤣
Lmaoooo
oh, you made ma day 🔥🙏 :D hehe
oh NO!!
Turkey: let's build a canal to avoid the city center.
also Turkey: Let's develop the area next to the canal to make a new city center.
Like ending the Uranus joke by changing its name to Urectum.
I thought it was obvious. They'd rather blow up new buildings that have no attraction for tourists than blow up the buildings that tourists want to come and see. The people that live there are of no concern.
Yeah but man instanbul is actually closer to 18 million years
@@sammyttheg412 wtf?
@@northofnashira2575 common people are always NPCs for governments
THIS, is probably one of the most interesting channels I’ve EVER stumbled across!
I CAN’T go to SLEEP! 😂
Thank you.
Yes, Thank You for not making me sleep 😭😭😭
Just to clarify: Istanbul is not the Capital Of Turkey, it's actually Ankara.
none of that is true its constantinople
@@rovari524 nova roma*
@@rovari524 *miklagard
@@rovari524 in the dreams of greeks
@@rovari524 nah bro ı am turkish and one one sayin istanbul to contantinapole its just to long and ıf you say consantinapole in street turkish peoples beat you up
"Guns are not allowed, so we only have missiles"
this so American lol
PSYCH! The missiles carry guns!
Turkey argued it, my God the silent genocide we don't talk about a 100 years ago, political corruption but a factional democracy, oil hungry, a failed political coup backed by foreign powers. It's like I never even left.
'Murca fuck yeah!
I love my country enough to know politicians are raping her 😭
@@GabrielHellborne Murcia
Missiles are not technically guns has to be one of the greatest arguments ever used😂😂😂
well, if soviets havent be so damn agresive towards everyone, turkey woudnt have to argue such stupidity
Well Soviet’s rocking in the strait is another loophole they did lol
@@Lawrance_of_Albania well, if america didn't invade the soviet union, then invade majority of the countries in Europe, invade majority of Germany despite soviets being the liberator, subject europe through Marshall plan propaganda to eventually remove the large opinion of the Soviets as the primary liberator in the second world war, if the US didn't suppress the communist movements in turkey, soviet union wouldn't be aggressive and turkey wouldn't have someone as stupid as Erdogan and a situation where their lira is inflating, and usually that ends in a coup for turkey, LOL
@@Lawrance_of_Albania so we need to send our misles into mexico bay to stop damn american agression to everyone
@@АндрейЕрмилов-х8п It isnt even that i dislike russia, i live in orthtodox nation and russia is greatest protector of orthodoxy. But such a stupid move is what i call "shoting yourself in a foot"
That communist moron stalin pushed turkey in NATO, and thats faaar from his only mistake
we appreciate the informative video about the Istanbul canal project. However, we noticed a few mistakes that we would like to point out. Firstly, the Suez Canal is not actually 200km long but is still quite significant. Secondly, we want to clarify that Istanbul is not the capital of Turkey, it's actually Ankara. Lastly, it's important to consider the potential environmental risks that could come with such a large-scale excavation project. Despite these points, we are grateful for the opportunity to learn more about Istanbul's future development plans. Thank you RealLifeLore!
They didn't actually say that it's the capital of Turkey, they said that it was capital of 3 great empires, the romans, byzantium and the ottoman empire.
They said that Istanbul was the capital of 3 great empires as in empires that existed before Turkey, not that it is the capital of Turkey. They also explained a lot about the potential detrimental effects of such a large scale excavation
I did a double take on his Suez measurement because the graphic didn't add up, but it was 162 km during creation and now 193 km. I'm more interested in why the Bosporus Straight has such significant traffic problems, it's massive. The Suez is tiny. Fun: You can see several submarines underwater on Google Earth near the mouth of the straight to the Black Sea
"...was the capital of three great empires, the Romans, the Byzantines..."
*Two spidermen pointing at each other*
byzantine was a legacy of ancient greece. the romans were.... well, the romans.
@@dotmashrc The Byzantine Empire was literally the Eastern Roman Empire, not some ancient Greek remnant. 18th century academics didn’t like calling it the Roman Empire because it offended their enlightened sensibilities, so they made up the term Byzantine Empire. The people living there called themselves Roman and referred to the state as the Land of the Romans. Even long after the Ottomans conquered Constantinople, the area was referred to as the Rûm Millet or Roman Nation.
Not to mention they still had a Roman senate, the roman Ranks, institutions, education system etc
Calling eastern Roman empire as Byzantine empire is like calling France as Lutetian republic (France's capital Paris old name), and calling China as people republic of Fanyang (China's capital Beijing old name), thats sound ridiculous right ? just because some holy german confederation (HRE) claim themselves as romans when they really not, it doesnt erase the real history of eastern roman empire.
@@dotmashrc Romans were the legacy of Ancient Greece too.
As a resident in İstanbul, none of my neighbors want this project. Everyone thinks that turkey should focus on other problems such as unemployment and high inflation rates. This project is just a way to launder Erdogan and his friends' dirty money.
This should generate a lot of employment.
As a Turk all my friends and my familys frieds also disagree with it too.
@@leadharsh0616 No. That is a lie. They are building this to launder money. Also all the houses and properties near the canal are sold to Qataris.
Turk nationalist: BuT ThIS wIlL bOosT cOnStRuCtIoN sEctoR
Actually, with counter-cyclical fiscal policy, infrastructure projects are ideal for helping with unemployment
Hearing that Istanbul's economy alone is larger than that of my country's, South Africa, makes me wanna cry.
If it'll make you feel better, most of turkish economy goes to corrupt government and citizens do not get profit from it. Rich people get richer while poor people get even more poor each day.
Turkey itself is rich compared to most other countries, but turkish people are not.
@@tilkilit thanks for the attempt to console me, but the same thing happens here in SA too. Politicians chiefly enriching themselves.
@@Siphamandla.Ngcobo Yeah i've heard of that most african countries have corrupt governments. We both suffer from the same things i guess lol
@@tilkilit for instance, the SA president fired the defence minister last week. This week, that same person is formally nominated as Parliament Speaker, by the same party the president heads. There are little to no repercussions for politicians being incompetent or corrupt in SA, so it seems.
@@Siphamandla.Ngcobo Do you think South Africa will balkanize along ethnic lines in the future? As an outsider, it sadly seems like a very unstable country with alot of ethnic tension.
Very detailed well explained video thx. 1 addition, the damage of canal on the environment will be catastrophic too.
Environment, economy, culture, political agenda... this project has far too many risks if you ask me.
Looks like tons of tourists will go here because its an "island"
Lol
°ᶜᵃⁿ ⁱ ᵍᵉᵗ ¹ ˢᵘᵇ ᵇᵉᶠᵒʳᵉ ᵗᵒᵐᵒʳʳᵒʷ?😢[
@@GoinGreninja they're bot man
just report if you see any of these comment next time,i can guarantee you will find it a lot
And maybe future battlefield, again. I already see that travel companies ads:
Visit Istambul! Centre od culture and wars since Romans.
@@abiez4018 True. But the few times I've reported them, they didn't go away. Hopefully they go away after I report them now.
At 8:50, the line that shows the size of the suez canal is wrong because the canal is only the upper part which was dug through the land and not the whole passage. I think the 200 km is right though but I'm not sure about that
"WE DON'T CARE"
@@fhc3240 I do and I'm sure some poeple care about receiving correct info
According to Wikipedia the Suez Canal is 193.3 km long. You are correct that the graphic incorrectly puts the Red Sea as part of the length of the Suez Canal. The Suez Canal is properly measured from its entrance at the northern tip of the Red Sea to its exit on the Mediterranean.
And the video does the same thing with the Istanbul canal. The beginning point in the south is a natural inlet, just like the Suez.
@@fhc3240 looks like people do actually care
A 100-year-old treaty that sucks? Let's make an island.
if the americans are payin for it
It doesn't make sense to mess with it. As an American, the only reason there should be American war ships in the Black Sea is if there's a war going on. If there's a war going on, does the treaty really matter?
If Americans again Not interfere-
@@Sheridantank I reckon there are no reasons for American war ships to be in the Black Sea even if there is a war there. It's halfway across the bloody world. But you know, how else are they supposed to provoke Russia?
@@milseq Honestly the Russians have a right to be angry if there are American war ships in the black sea. America likes to stick it's fingers in everyone else's pie.
Congratulations...regards from Athens Greece..
The Istanbul earthquake will definitely happen one day, when it happens, Turkey will go back at least 5 years. Most of the Turkish politicians still do nothing about it, and they still think the most important and priority issue of Istanbul is the making the canal.
Just consider, 15 million people live in Istanbul and most of the houses are very rotten.
And we already know what happened in the Izmir earthquake.
had to look it up... yeah that could happen again there.. and would be NOT good.
5 years is a very modest number to be honest. More like 15.
Many of the houses in that part of the world are old and masonry doesn’t have any steel reinforcement like rebar. I was around that area in the 1970s and remember seeing building being built where they put straw in the concrete, what’s with that?
@@afinoxi I said 'at least'
@@Chris_at_Home Even today, most of the houses built in Istanbul are still too weak for earthquakes around 6.1 - 8.2.
And keep in mind this, although only 4.5 million people lived in the earthquake in Izmir, the poor infrastructure of the earthquake left many people homeless.
“The Romans and the Byzantines” the Romans would like to have a word with you
LOL.
*The Eastern Romans would like a word with you
Justinian: "What is this you are talking about?"
@@nhandinh7404 IKR
they still live In Istanbul it was there idea
The canal isn't the point of this project. Making money for construction companies is the whole point of this project. I wouldn't be at all surprised if in ten years there are several bridges to nowhere but no canal.
So having a canal is just a plus?
I do not know that much, but i heard that it is an old dream for the turks, and it is finally getting done 🤷♂️
@@Mr-Money01
It would be a plus, but not us. Not to regular citizens.
This and all other "Build-operate-transfer
" projects made under AKP government have been primarily about shoveling public money into few private companies (all Erdoğan's allies). No project made in this arrangement provides any profit to the public coffers, on the contrary, they get payments each and every month from the treasury.
One example to this is the Avrasya Tunnel connecting two sides of İstanbul from the south. It's a good tunnel except it costs too much to use and costs way way more if we don't use it. Because the deal is there needs to be certain quota met each month and treasury covers the difference if that quota is not met. Since its opening in 2016, that quota of use was met only one month. That's it. And this is one of the better projects made under this arrangement, there are far worse ones out there.
@@Mr-Money01The idea is that it is the reason used to convince and gather majority support for the expensive project. The construction companies and real estate owners will likely be the first to benefit and made loads of money from whether or not it is actually completed.
@مالك القطيف Having $25.000 per capita was the dream for the Turks yet here we are, wasting money on useless projects instead of helping the 24 million people living in poverty in our country.
Turkey: Guns are not allowed.
US: okay but we have only missiles?
Turkey: okay you can pass.
🤣🤣
As a Turkish citizen, I always taught that Montreux needed to get renewed and modernized. It would have saved a lot of effort and cleaned up the problems of the strait. The canale idea itself is very cool but on paper has a lot more negatives than pozitives. Hopefully, the project will stop. And right now Istanbul and the Eagen coastlines are facing a sea pollution problem as well. Adding more waste to that won't be any smarter I reckon.
Ok both super powers were stupid in this case 😑. Both Broke turkeys s rules which was uncool. Nearly provoked a neutral nation which was uncool. And abused a potential Allies for Idiocracy
Don't worry since when president erdogan religion mindset ruined Turkish economy
I think they should address those water pollution and shortage issues before they think any further.
@@Borg231 I you listened well , they both did not broke any rules they subverted. As both did not sign UNCLOS for geographic reasons, self determination is a pretty word in diplomacy you see you can't force another to sign a largely voluntary treaty. As for the other Treaty it did not describe missile ships, I know both countries Turkey and US, you can include Russia as well if you want subscribe to a Roman law, of "what the law does not include it excludes".
I don’t think Montreux needed renewing. There would have to be a new convention to renegotiate the terms
"Why Turkey is Transforming Istanbul Into an Island"
-So they can call it Islandbul
i hate this canal thing but if they do i will own 3 house in EU island.
🥁
that is so stupid but I fucking love it
that's Constantinople
@@suryamukherji4943 no it's islambul
Just to clarify: No big cargo ship is able to travel through the Danube. Only a "barge" can travel on the Danube. We call them "Binnenschiffe" in german.
Exactly
Another correction is that the convention they talk about also affects the Dardanelles. So Turkey needs to build another canal there if it wants to bypass the Montreaux Convention.
@@ardagurbuz6924 but dardanelles only prevent the war ships part of the montreaux to be bypassed right. Turkey still can charge for the new canal?
@@muratakburakma Probably, yeah.
There's always a word for something in German
I'm pretty sure the second after you mentioned why nobody gets youtube premium the immediately hit me with an ad lol. Thanks for the great content!
Turkey:
"In terms of money, we have no money."
They do but it's not enough in terms of their everything else
Turkish lira is only for 🚾 paper..
@@PROUD-COUNTRY would be funny joke if you weren’t from Greece, a country that almost destroyed the Euro during the 2008 finanical crisis because of Greek government being too inpatient to actually do things legitimately to use the Euro
@@stantorren4400 and h win of this ? Germany 👌
@@stantorren4400 His point still holds true
After all of this remember that Istanbul isn't even turkey's capital.
It was used to be the capital in the Golden Age of the Ottoman Empire, but never meant to be after that, especially in late 19th and early 20th centuries. As it was tactically useless since there was such little land protection left against European forces like Balkan countries.
Original: It was used to, but never meant to be. As it was tactically useless.
@@poyrazaliguner2554 what are you on about.
Tokyo belongs to France
@@44theshadow49 Given the whole sentence, I'm quite certain they meant "it used to be" (if this is the bit that threw you off). Not everyone on the Internet is a native English speaker.
@@Basauri48970 I'm more criticizing the assertion that Constantinople, one of the most historically significant cities in the past 2 millennia, lauded as "The City of the World's Desire," and was famously difficult to siege, is "tactically useless." Its so backwards I thought he was trolling, but the tone of the rest of his comment leads me to think he's serious.
As someone from Turkey that also lived in Istanbul for 15 years, I can say that basically no one supports this project anywhere in our country. Especially after the mucilage breakout in the Marmara Sea this year. I hope this problem gets more international recognition and can be canceled. We already have a lot of problems and many don't want to add ecological collapse of the Marmara Sea to that list.
Forget it. No one has even heard of it until now. And frankly from the reactions here, hardly anyone cares whether it gets built. If you want more attention, go stage a huge protest and show the world when people gets arrested and killed. That’s how you get attention
@@TheZachary86 You dont jack about turkey
@@TheZachary86 Erdoğan Controls The Media. The people that opposed Erdoğan's rule had made an march similar to salt March made in India with Ghandi, but even bigger, no one cared or heard about it. Even me living in Turkey didn't even hear it and learned about it years later after it happened.
Edit: Sorry not weeks, YEARS.
protest and make everyone aware
@@raptorfromthe6ix833 We are already doing that. Nobody cares or even knows about it because Erdoğan Controls The Media, like the Bosporus University Events. Wich all the students were suddenly called "Terrorists" because the media under Erdoğan said so.
I think it could work since wait times are really important in shipping bussiness. If the cargo gets to late the loss could be expenontial sometimes so people decide to give toll money instead of waiting.Although this needs to be measured like how long the wait will be,how much the loss will be and to make a profit how much you need to put toll money.
But again this is just a way Erdodan to get his pockets full. Neutrality is the most important thing in my opinion also transport over the bridges is just a nightmare for the citizens. So it comepletely expected to be both military and citizens oppose the idea.
9:17 - Dolphins abide by no conventions, they just swim wherever they feel like it!
Lol exactly
Good eye
maybe thats why in Red Alert 2 the Allies had military dolphins
Dolphin get freepass to any sea ...no patrol will stop them....
9:17 - dolphins oh yeah
Sometimes in life you've just got to transform a city into an island
Cool 😎
Maybe they could do that with California
What Saudi Arabia did with Qatar lol
@@mjbowman2004 meh probably would make itself a country of its own later on
@@crowjan not yet. They have only hinted at it.
13:38 Berat Albayrak is no longer minister of finance. He resigned at 9th november of 2020.
yeah he is missing
@@marlena7965 With all of the money he stole
@@trashposs3849 after all the help he did for his kayınpeder
Abi bu kanalı izleyen Türk buldum ya artık rahat ölebilirim
@@nitrogen_1881 İzleyen var kardeşim ama biz bayrak atmıyoruz her yere :)
I laughed out loud at the assertion that cargo ships from Shanghai ever transit the Rhine-Main-Danube Canal to go to Rotterdam. Besides the excruciatingly slow speed of the Canal versus the Mediterranean, the maximum beam possible in the Canal is only 38 feet versus the typical cargo ship which is more than 100 feet wide - usually much more.
Yeah that was rather ridiculous and one of the many errors in this video.
@@NeovanGoth Yeah American cant do geography
Haha, same here. Makes me wonder what else is off the mark.
RLL is a fun channel, but I wouldn't cite him in school papers let's just say.
Indeed. The waves produced would also massively erode the river banks. Major civil engineering would be required.
did anyone notice he dolphins swimming in front of the cruising cargo ship ? 9:18 So Beautiful
That is why we dont want Canal İstanbul. It can destroy the whole İstanbul's ecosystem
Pasha? Where do you govern?
@@dorukstar7377 sometimes, these dolphins, whales get hit and severely injured by large ships. Thats so sad.
@@dorukstar7377 so true
@@TuAFFalcon I'm from India
Turkey: “I don’t want to use this canal, I’m making my own”
China: I don’t want to use your canal, I’m making my own”
As a representative of Turkish people, we don't want canal. Dictator Erdogan is oppressing us
@@kebabseverim3364 lol to the west your a Turk , no one likes you !
Doesn’t matter if you pretend to be western or not.
@@mrwhitenoise376 ah yes keep living in your small world where everyone is Serbian Greek Romanian and Armenian
@@kebabseverim3364 dont mind these people they probably support pkk or feto orgnanisation. sorry to say that but there are so many people inside Turkey that dont want Turkeys success
@@mrwhitenoise376 I have good life and family. I don't need strangers like me lol n**i kid
9:17 “upon arriving, ships have to usually wait an average of 14 hours”
Ports on western coast of North America: “Hold my beer”
It's like an Ever Given jam every single day here at LA/Long Beach
NOPE! Dolphins are like "hold my beer" - you have to, they have only flippers
Fascinating. Thank you!
So, let's build a new canal to divert dangerous volatile cargo away from the heavily populated Istanbul center.
Also let's heavily populate the new canal's banks! 👌
Seems legit.
And cash
Yes, But! The Bosphorus is a natural waterway, you cant change its geography. With the new canal, you can take the necessary actions and preparations to avoid possible dangerous accidents as much as technologically possible. Not that I support but if this is the topic, the canal would be of course much safer. The Bosphorus is a difficult waterway to navigate with many big accidents in history. One recently, a ship crashing into a $25m historical mansion.
The actual goal was to make rich investors who bought land along the proposed canal richer.
@@maythesciencebewithyou Thats for sure one of the ideas. But cost of the project is basically much higher compared to the investors. I think there are few goals here;
- protecting bosphorus straight
- finding new investment areas in Istanbul
- global attraction
- political stand against Montro
- of course economical benefits
- increase power against black sea countries
9:12 Happy Dolphins playing and jumping in front of a massive cargo ship.
Those are top secret Russian Anti-Submarine sweep and destroyer agents and they are not having fun, they are protecting the motherland!
thanks i didn't see them!
Thanks! You have perfected even your attention to detail.
Are you offended?
@@sarlaz3407 ayo man nice catch there
Romans and Byzantines were one and the same. They never called themselves the Byzantine Empire, historians called them that to differentiate between the ERE before and after the fall of the West.
@@maniaces not all byzantines were greek but they were greek speaking romans. They still considered their empire the roman empire. Only it was eastern and western
They mostly spoke greek but latin was a second language. The eastern roman empire had conquered most of the old western roman areas at one point just to regain lost roman land. They viewed themselves as romans with greek characteristics just like the egyptians viewed themselves as romans with a egyptian characteristics. The same could be said of The rest of the old roman empirical areas with their own identities.
Byzance était un petit faubourg de Constantinople.
@@pmparda some kings were Latins but Byzantine is a Greek empire.
@@maniaces The “Greeks” considered themselves Romans up until the Greek Independence Movement revived the terms “Hellene”, “Hellas”, “Hellenic”, etc. Actually, they considered themselves as Rhomanoi for about a generation thereafter, because the poorest areas were contacted last.
The water bridge that literally separates Europe from Asia. This fact is mind boggling I live for this stuff. Who’s plan was it.
@@M3E92V8 South Korea didn't exist in 1915 and Euro became a currency in 1999/2002. The 1915 Çanakkale Bridge was built from 2017 to 2022. The 1915 in the name honours an Ottoman naval victory against the navies of the UK and France during WW I.
U S A
are you unaware of the ural mountains
russua also connects asia and europe
this canal has existed for like ever... back to before the byzantine empire
Turkey: Imma turn instanbul into an island.
Everyone: *you weren't supposed to do that.*
°ᶜᵃⁿ ⁱ ᵍᵉᵗ ¹ ˢᵘᵇ ᵇᵉᶠᵒʳᵉ ᵗᵒᵐᵒʳʳᵒʷ?😢=.,=
in turkey we are trying to say that to Erduvan but he is not look like listening
@@arhanuzun7867 I confirm
Turks: you weren’t supposed to do that.
@@arhanuzun7867 I confirm
This sounds stupid. Instead of negotiating the terms of a UN treaty to find a solution everyone is happy with, turkey is needlessly wasting resources building a redundant canal
We live with these bullshits every day, news or projects doesnt make sense
aside from the UN being useless. you have 5 countries that can veto any resolution the UN makes up. And if you have watched the video 3 off the ones that can veto have an interest in it.
You need the vote of the five security council I don't know about the other but Russia will never accept
It is. The reason they want to do this project is not because they care about the public.
The reasons why the government wanted this project:
1- Being richer by building the canal and the city around it. That is corruption,
2-Vanity,
3-In addition, the man at the head of the government sees himself as the sultan. He probably has something like a god complex.
Such a channel is completely meaningless when there is a natural strait next to it. The Suez Canal saves ships from circumnavigating the African continent, which is about 10 days less travel. Kanal Istanbul does not have such a function because there is a natural strait right next to it. They say that Kanal Istanbul will reduce the ship traffic in the Bosphorus, but the ship traffic in the Bosphorus has been decreasing since 2008. This is because larger ships are being built. Apart from that, they claim that with the construction of the canal, the danger in the strait will decrease. Because a ship had hit a mansion before. However, there is a problem here: They will build cities on both sides of Canal Istanbul. Moreover, the widest part of Kanal Istanbul is narrower than the narrowest part of the channel, the deepest part of Kanal Istanbul is shallower than the shallowest part of the Bosphorus, and Kanal Istanbul is longer than the Bosphorus. Other arguments are that Kanal Istanbul will increase revenue. They talk as if the ships passing through the strait don't pay. This is not true. Every ship that passes through the strait pays. If this money was to be raised, they would have to resort to international laws for this. However, they do not have the political power to do this, and that is not their main purpose.
In short, the government knows that all this is not true. But like any dictator, they want to continue to rule. For this, they need to please interest groups (those who commit corruption and much more).
@@gareaap7806 VETO only work on Security Council, normal general assembly didn't have VETO and there are tons of agreement passed GA every year if they really want to. So It just about didn't want to do the paperwork.
RUclipsrs: I want to monetize my channel!
Istanbul: I want to monetize my channel too!
🤣
google: just sign this agreement
UNCLOS: just sign this treaty
Nice
Im Turkish, first of all thanks for spending time and creating this video , and if anyone wondering what is this canal about watch 15 seconds from 13:30 this tells the whole story . A selfish project that even lead Turkey to war
Yup
"Minister of finance"
*Looks at the crumbling economy*
Economy is in crisis everywhere. Ever heard of Corona? At least Turkey is going its own way despite the sanctions and economic warfare of the west. Albayrak did a lot of good after his predecessor by actually tackling inflation which spiked shortly before he took office.
@@minzblatt are you erdogans secret agent
Reverse stonks
@@nicholasthuya7683 Probably one of his countless sheep
@@nicholasthuya7683 Erdoğan is turkey's second greatest leader after Atatürk
The main reason is provide a profit for upper class people who are close to current gov half of the lands already bought from peasants for cheaper price before the announcement.. coincidence??
Happens everywhere
May I ask why did u choose saddam hussein as your name?
Of course they’re going to use cheap land to build it. Why would you pay extra when you don’t need to?
@@uhohhotdog cheap land has been bought by individuals, not by the state (yet).
I'm almost starting to believe that's what they are trying to do in California. Make everyone leave and grab the land for cheaper later.
When a piece of paper is stronger then metric tons of rock and dirt xD
It s not the paper, it s tens of armies of tens of nations. They re trying to outwit and bullshit each other. The paper is but a small but critical component of that.
Rock, scissors, Montreux Convention
@Russ Makhauri I choose rock!
@@user-fi4wn3te8v ROCK IS SUPERIOR
@@Bikavin not to paper gentlemen
Great video, thank you.
“We’re gonna build a canal to handle dangerous cargo, and then building housing and the worlds largest airport around it”
Genius move guys
Yeah, but think about this... almost *everyone* in the government will financially benefit from the canal, so they don't care lol
They do this because corrupts close to the government bought territory from the cannal İstanbul area when it was cheaper with hopes of government building the cannal.
The Airport is already built and is operating, just not 100%. And in case of a disaster such as an explosion it is less dramatic if newly build residental and commercial areas get destroyed rather than the historical and more inhabited city center.
maybe that argument means nothing, it's there just for public support
The land around the proposed canal belongs to Erdogan and his cronies. The canal isn't for transporting cargo, it's so that the future houses there have a canal that goes next to them, so they become worth more.
Wow a dolphin is having good time in front of the ship. 9:16
It is a dolphin
I don't think that's good. Boats are dangerous, if they blow their horn it will likely cause permanent damage to... well everything.
@@setysssty1845 Yes
actually they use wave forces from the ship to swim and having kind of fun
@@T800-i6h PETA: Nooooooo that ship is trying to crush those dolphins! Someone save them!
Dolphins: Haha wake surfing go brrrrrrr
6:53 I like all the "stan" being salty and not signing an agreement about the sea, even Bolivia and Paraguay signed it.
Well Pakistan and Afghanistan signed it so that's a lot of cap
They don't want to divide the Caspian lol. That's their only way to world trade through Russia's canal.
@@isaa7010 ya cause they aren’t touching the sea but ya that’s it’s cap 🧢 that all the stans aren’t agreeing to it
I don't understand why you're telling Danube River is a major asset for trade.
The Danube is very big, but cargo container ships can't navigate on it... only few trade on the river with some small ships.
Barges move grain. Lot of wheat and sunflowers.
Agreed. I can see the canal connecting the Rhine and the Danube from my bedroom window. There are not a lot of big barges going up and down there. Maybe one medium-sized one every half hour. Not a lot in terms of global trade.
Lots of nonsense in this video. No major Russian ports (not even Murmansk) ever close due to ice, and most Russian oil exports by sea actually do go from the Baltic ports of Ust-Luga and Primorsk, not Novorossiysk.
RLL: talks about Turkey digging canals
me: aww that dolphin on 9:12
Aww the bullies of the sea that only reproduce through rape. Ever saw a dolphin teeth?
I know someone here to say this, ues I know about it use quillfish as viagra or something, just, ha, they have to lead the ship
Aww, such a cute dolphin. 😊
the dolphin:
omg there's a giant ship following me help it's too fast i will get killed
@@Morningstar_37 they re racing with ship :)
Sooo... NATO warship can cross? Well, the day of it's opening, the first 20 Russian cargo ships starting to cross in a convoy. Suddenly they had a mysterious malfunction, and sunk. Russia blame the Turkish, sabotaging their cargo fleet. The ships found really problematic to remove, thanks to mysterious, and dangerous cargo.
lol
Damn it. You may be right about this.. Let's hope Russia doesn't read this comment
@@A1509MDIX There is a munition ship that sunk during WWII in Thames estuary's shallow water which is still there because of the volatile cargo.
If they try to move it the explosives might detonate so they had to cordon it off as navigation hazard and can't get rid of it to this day.
so it's not an entirely impossible scenario that Russia pulling something like this if more sanction are imposed by NATO nations.
@@nom_chompsky Oh, yes! the mighty Hungarian Navy. :D
Our biggest and infamous warship is underwater about a hundered year ago. :D
@@dantetre but Little does anyone know, that ship will rise out of the waters like the Flying Dutchman in times of war
Basically Reason: To sell Arabs more land, coastsides. To make companies' ships trade faster in same amount of time, with that they gain more and there's a reason to pay to acces it. Also Turkey loves buildings, if that happens there would be several bridge thus consruction companies profit
It's just to get more money. It won't even start i don't think.
@@unknownv1065 construction already started.
@@fightsports66 n o pee
@@unknownv1065 I checked and you are right. The foundation for the first bridge is set to start work in the last week of june. That is next week so it has not started as of today.
@@unknownv1065 we show the CHP how things are being done for the last 20 years. They only moan and complain until they themselves are using the facilities and projects like every bosporus bridge built until this day, the two big airports, the intercontinental subway marmaray and much more.
I love youtube premium and have been a loyal and happy customer for nearly 5 years now. being able to play youtube videos while my phone screen if off is invaluable and I cannot stand ads. The only time my sub has lapsed was when my card expired.
"Its like RUclips premium, but nobody buys it" so true
You can bet your sweet ass that the US would pay to put subs next to Putin's South Beach residence.
I do :(
I bought it
As soon as he said that I got an ad
@@riverrat777 damn...
Reallifelore: Doesn't have a sponsor that is dashlane, skillshare, squarespace or curiosity stream
Everyone: *Impossible*
my lord is that legal?
its POSSIBLE
OMG ITS CAN'T BE POSIBBEL
*skillshare*
@@hazelich9113 Oh yeah, I will correct it
"Did you receive a profit from the canal?"
"Yes"
"What did it cost?"
"Global conflict at our doorstep"
To be fair they Joined Nato but flit with Russia so neutrally is really no longer an option.
@@GreenBlueWalkthrough peace was never an option
@@GreenBlueWalkthrough I am Russian and I think Russia needs to be destroyed
@@Redaft then you're not Russian. No wise person set's fire to their home because they want to feel warm
@@whosasking9655 by “Russian” I mean I was born in Russia and live in Russia rn. This country is garbage and I want to destroy it so much because of government, people, nation mentality and some much more.
As a Turk, on top of the comments made by my friends, Turkey has 3 bridges on the straits, not 4. In addition, Turkey has a bridge connecting Bursa and Gebze and a newly opened bridge in Çanakkale
Çanakkale is a strait as well, so 4
@@alpers.2123 olm istanbul boğazında 3 köprü var yaw
@@keremimamoglu9552 olm adam ileri görüşlü 4.yapar bunlar diye demiştir
I thought that 4th one showed in the video is Eurasian tunnel (location wise seems correct)
@@erayyyilmaz 4. Kopruyu yab mak farz -fatih sultan mehmet
Correction: "Former" Minister of Finance.
Not that it is important, just fills me with joy :)
lol me too
Yes same
@Panzer Elite that is our dream
@Panzer Elite He only wants what is best for his people. You can not blame him for that.
@@Matthew-Anthony too easy to say that for you
Me, learning that Europe is cut in half by two connected rivers:
My world view: 🤯
They are not naturally connected, they are connected by a canal
So a half of Europe is an island?
Rhine-Main-Danube Canal flows through Nuremberg, where I live. Actually, it's approximately 5 minutes away from my home. I go there for a run multiple times a week, feels special every time.
@@roiq5263 no, Europe is still connected to Asia via Russia. Also a continent isn't an island, otherwise North and South America would be an island. And Australia isn't classed as an island because it's classed as a continent.
@@roiq5263 my thoughts exactly
A new moat for the Theodosian walls
9:17 cute how those dolphins are playing in front of that gargantuan ship. it really gives a sense of scale
I've been to Istanbul before back in 2009/2010. It was a beautiful city.
Now it's a shithole
@@METAN0L is still more attractive than moscow, madrid or lisbon.
What do you mean, its still good. I live in here.
@@xavierrealmadrid7420 Oh come on that's not true.
Yeah it was. Now it is concrete. Just concrete and corruption.
at 9:12 through 9:20 you can see a pod of dolphins playing in front of the container ship 🥰
RIP dolphins
Ah my fellow attention deficit disorder
“GUYS HELP ME PLEASE IM ABOUT TO DIE!”
“Hey John, look at that dolphin!”
@@robertstone9988 hahaha
@hooman Yes, very funny 😁😁😁😁
I'm turkish and i can say that this canal thing got politic. People are blindly supporting or going against this idea by their politic opinion. It sucks that politics and money make peoples desicions. Trees and fields in the way of the canal will be destroyed. It's not just the canal, they are going to build a city around it! So both İstanbul's population will boom and nature will be gone. I doubt the sanity of anyone who supports this.
So what do you think about silksong?
@@KaiserRatte56 ah yes, the natural response to this
@@KaiserRatte56 Well, I'm excited to play as hornet. I just hope the game comes out as soon as possible.
Not only that, but since the immediate area is overdue for a major earthquake, dumping all that money on a political project instead of rebuilding of the old buildings within the city (there are many, some standing by a thin thread) is ignorance of millions at best. That money would be spend best to rebuild the city, but more importantly, improve Anatolian cities and generate quality jobs there. Nowadays people who live in Istanbul do so not because it's a good city to live, but because economic opportunities are better there.
@@NuggetOG well, when you see a hornet pfp you just have to ask!
I be nerding out with these vids sometimes
0:32
Ah, yes:
Rome, Rome 2, and Ottoman Rome.
My favourite ancient Empires.
You mean Latin Rome, Greek Rome and Turkish Rome? :)
@@truegamer_007 that also works
First Rome - Pagan
2nd Rome - Christian
3rd Rome - Muslim
Yeah i totally agree, Ottoman is the Third Roma.
@@elemparador Considering that the contest Is between them and the Russian Empire(yes, the russians claimed to be the third Roman Empire), It Is not an hard choice 😂
1:21
Oh boy, that map is going to make a lot of people angry.
At least it's accurate;)
@@benmm01 map is wrong actually
Idk what's wrong. Is it because of Kosovo?
@@olexander13 I meant the Crimea part is accurate. I wasn't paying attention to the other parts)
Cyprus?
This is probably the most interesting video I've watched in months
That makes me sad for you bro
Casue of Turkey is staying between Russia and America on many subjects, Turkish news and politics are always interesting and so confusing. If you are living in Turkey many Turkish people will tell you to not follow politics in Turkey. Cause if you will, you'll go crazy.
@@humihawl are you turkish?
@@vidarodinson5246 yeah.
@@humihawl can I ask you something? what most turkish people choose US or Russia?
Meanwhile Turkey: Hey Merchants bored of the heavy traffic and longer wait times in the Bosphorus upgrade to our premium Istanbul canal for better experience.
8:50 Hey, that's not the length of Suez, but about half of it; you cannot count the Red Sea inlet like that!!
True, but I looked up the actual length and it is 193 km.
misinformation :/
the line was fake but the measurements were very close seeming to have rounded up.
Did you really measure 200km for the Suez canal from the tip of the Sinai pininsula? Most of that is a natural part of the red sea, the actual canal is only a fraction of that length.
9:16 Those dolphins having the time of their life!
Istanbul..a beautiful City...biblical and historial..the Bhosphorous River..so beautiful
I was there..in Ephesus...
One more thing that I would have added to this video is that, Istanbul is located in a very geologically active location so in the event of a large earthquake (which experts say that will be above magnitude7), everybody who lives in European Istanbul would be stuck and they would not be able to escape the densely packed city. On top of that, this new canal will travel through kilometers of forest which would danger the lives of many native and endangered species. It also has the added risk of introducing invasive marine species to the inland sea of Marmara from the black sea or vice versa because the strong currents of the Bosporus straight blocks this naturally.
Edit: New polls suggest that on the general elections in 2023, it looks highly likely that Erdogan might not get re-elected and I feel like the entire reason on why this insane project is going ahead is because he wants to leave a final mark, a permanent signature, before he is stripped away from all of his power.
merak etme deprem bundan çok önce olacak, İstanbul'da yaşıyorsan asıl o zaman ağlayacaksın, gidecek yerin olmayacak, şehir eski ve çarpık, yenisi gerekiyor? yüzde kaçı yıkılacak kim bilir ama çok yüksek bir oran olacağı belli.
If there is an earthquake, you won't be able to go that far either. Earthquake is not like volcano at all. Earthquake is short and sudden, any escape would be into a nearby open field like road instead of escaping the city.
@@xwtek3505 what im saying is not the time that earthquake happening, i mean the after, the only buildings that can stand that earthquake are the bridges or others, other than that city will become pile of rubble, and clearing all those rubble will take a long time, that will cause so many damages to economy and people, but imagine new city that has better buildings and new stuff to make money for country, at least for a while, thats what i was meaning to
@@mushi475 1. Replacing the city would be an even bigger investion than istanbul canal.
2. Such problem can be solved for cheaper than applying a strict building code to new building to gradually make the building stronger.
@@xwtek3505 well you dont know how istanbul is, i live here and its too late to do anything
When you consider the Byzantines to be a separate empire from the Romans
[angry historian noises]
more like angry byzantineboo noises
after heraclius it wasn't really a roman empire yk
Tbf just because it is called the Roman Empire doesn't make it one either
While in name it was the continuation of the Roman Empire itself in practice, it was led by Greeks and not latins and thus should be separated not as a distinctive empire entirely, but not the continuation of the original Rome too
@@ekn_38 we greeks, were the second strongest ethnicity of the roman empire, greek was the second languadge of rome and we for ever will be romoioi, NOBODY can take this from us.
@@maciekGTR bruh
@@ekn_38 but it wasn’t led by the Greeks until the 7th Century. The likes of Constantine and Justinian for example were Latins through and through.
"Greece claims Istanbul under its EEZ"
"Turkish officials bamboozled"
Highly possible
nice idea lol, wait till i tell this to lord kulis
Honestly that ,Eastern Thrace and the rest of Cyprus are all we want back.
@@yanniskarageorgiou3573 lmao eastern thrace and istanbul combined have more than 2 times greek population, and a bigger economy
@@yanniskarageorgiou3573 there was coup happened in cyprus
greek military junta took over cyprus and turkey invaded cyprus to defend his citizens
why you guys want cyprus back when it has peace right now
totally educational! bravo!
2:25 There is no way for ocean going cargo vessels to travel up the Danube or the Rhine into Rotterdam. This is absolutely impossible due to bridges, low waters, and the river's geography.
This Istanbul canal itself is 15billion dollar project. I can't imagine what would be the cost for that one...
You forgot the ports can also unload cargo and load it onto smaller vessels. The other video says all you need for Danube-Rhine route is 4m depth and 26m width for the river size.
@@glacialimpala Sure, but the video implies that the ships travel directly from Shanghai to Rotterdam via the Danube.
@@glacialimpala No business is going to do what you are suggesting. A ship leaving Shanghai headed for Rotterdam will go west in the Mediterranean, into the Atlantic at Gibraltar, and then north and east to Rotterdam.
@@ShadySheev You are correct. This video is full of mistakes.
Imagine aliens looking at Istanbul, going: "Why are they building a canal? There already is a straight!"
Let's be honest, it is insane.
@@steven_003 and we dont want... erdogan and qatar want
*strait
Lol
As a representative of Turkish people, we don't want canal. Dictator Erdogan is oppressing us
in Turkey: People are dying of hunger, graduates can't find a job, innocent people are being arrested, Turkish Lira's worth sent to oblivion
Politicians: *let's build an island*
Smells like authoritarian fascist government. They all do megalomaniac projects when they feel it's close to the end.
Sorry, I'm ignorant to Turkish struggles...but isn't this canal a good thing?
No one ever dies from hunger in Turkey. The rest are true but people dying from hunger is an exaggeration.
@@swiggyhunter4682 did you watch the video? it could be, for the goverment, which doesnt mean much in turkey, could be a bad thing. it will cost a good amount of moeny, istanbul will loose a good amount of freshwater.
@@swiggyhunter4682 Its NOT good for Istanbul, After some years Istanbul will be hit by an eartquake wich is bigger than 7.We are crying our asses to tell Erdogan that he needs to cancel this because its makjing city weaker, ınstead of making it stronger he does THİS.Next Election he will definitly lose because Gen Z can vote and OOHHH BOY THEY HATE HİM.
They’re making a giant transmutation circle. Where’s Ed and Al when you need them!
Getting interested about things I didn´t even knew about
same
Same.
my mood with this channel
Where are you from?
I'm hearing it everyday
I would like to point out a slight *Mistake*
The Northwest Passage is claimed as internal Canadian Waters by Canada, while other countries in the EU/UN primarily the USA claim it's international so they can move cargo through it for free.
Some years back though, USA tried bringing a cargo ship through the Northwest passage without the Canadian Navy's permission, and was forced to turn back. That caused a huge issue for a bit, before the States and Canada signed an agreement where the US have to ask Canada before sending a ship through the Northwest Passage. In a backwards manner, meaning theyre obligated to say that the N-W Passage is Canadian.
Also if any ship is to sink or crash in the passage, Canada has to fix it without being paid internationally sooo.
Continue... I'm too dumb to draw a conclusion out of this.
@@yomajo soooo, the waters should rightfully belong to Canada if they're responsible for the actions that happen inside them.
Thanks for sharing this.
There is another mistake in the video.
8:50 The Suez Canal is perhaps 200 km long, yes.
But it stretches only from Port Said on the mediterranean coast to the city of Suez, which is just left of where you put the sign "Suez Canal".
This sign is put on the northern parts of the Gulf of Suez.
And the distance from Port Said to the southern tip of the Sinai Peninsula is around 450 km (not 200km as written in the graphics).
The Gulf of Suez is a natural gulf of the Red Sea, like the Gulf of Aqaba on the other side of the Sinai Peninsula.
The Suez Canal starts at the northern end of the Gulf of Suez.
Nevertheless, a very interesting video about Istanbul.
Have a nice day. :)
now imagine Rome becoming an Island like Istanbul.
I saw that.
Thank you for the scholarship. I've always wanted to go to Istanbul. Now more than ever. 31122
I thought that looked weird, thanks for explaining.
The Suez Canal was built by the French in order of the Ottoman empire. Egypt was then ruled by the Turks. The liberty statue in America was built for the Suez Canal but later they rejected the statue because it could lead to problems in the Egyptian muslims. because it was a woman. So they transformed it to France and it sit in the garage until French decided to gift it to America
13:11 “It’s sort of like how people feel about using RUclips Premium.” Your well placed bon mot just killed me!
Guys! Stop building canals! You’ll eventually turn Earth into a massive ocean!
As a representative of Turkish people, we don't want canal. Dictator Erdogan is oppressing us
@Mihai Pîrvu thanks for your beautiful thoughts, I hope we can be free in future
@@kebabseverim3364 i bet you have no idea about what dictator is.i dont wanna start a political discussion but the fact that you can call him dictator means that he is not a dictator
he... got the most votes...? how is he a dictator when the majority of turkish citizens vote for him?
@@kebabseverim3364 Sorry but it's Democracy. My idea Democracy is not working for all nations.
So he's not actually a Dictator
I mean you don't have to be bad to be a Dictator for example Ataturk was an Dictator
You could literally make this entire story up and everyone would believe you without question
WDYM
@@iamannocent2913 cuz that’s how deep the conflict is between those two national groups.
@@S_Warden no i was asking if i watched misinformation
@@iamannocent2913 oh gotcha
Well, I’m an resident in Istanbul and i can assure you that everything he is explaining is 100% true.
Soviet union: "Turkey thinks they are clever. Heh! There's a loophole."
Turkey: "Guess i'll just join NATO then."
Soviet union: "Wait that's not supposed to happen."
You can basically place Ukraine nowadays for Turkey and you see where it all is heading. Only idiots sits in Kreml who doesn't see this coming
I feel bad for the ppl who don't have RUclips premium and have to watch agressively timed and placed ads that are very aggravating but RUclips doesn't lose any sleep over it.
I love the effort you put to seamlessly insert your ads at the end.
RealLifeLore 2021: Why turkey is turning Istanbul into an island
RealLifeLore 2050: Why Turkey is turning Europe into an island.
I know what you mean, but Europe is a peninsula, not an island.
@@Matthew-Anthony Well, peninsula literally means "almost island" you just gotta make it whole
@@iwannaseehowlongyoucanmakethis What makes you say that?
@@Matthew-Anthony peninsula is Latin. It LITERALLY means "almost island".
@@Matthew-Anthony It's a compound word from "paene" (almost, close to) and "insula" (island) => paeninsula (which in anglicisation became peninsula)
I had no idea any of this was happening. The details and presentation and sheer amount of information was great. Well done RealLifeLore!
yes but this is not the plan of turkey this is the plan of erdoğan and so many people disagree
@@dominictoretto6234 It will be intriguing to see how it all plays out.
This is a very wrong and harmful project for our planet. Why a ship is already wide: instead of passing free and faster through a canal whose narrowest point is between Rumeli Hisarı and Anadolu Hisarı, approximately 698 meters and the widest point 3 thousand 500 meters, "The Channel will pass through Küçükçekmece, Avcılar, Başakşehir and Arnavutköy districts. Would he want to pass through an artificial canal with 360 meters in the narrowest part, 775 meters in the widest part and a minimum width of 275 meters in Istanbul?
@@kurkmantoluahmethoca9600 i totally agree
@@kurkmantoluahmethoca9600 Go create your own comment thread instead of spamming the same comment all over the place.
Companies will be very happy to use the new canal. Even now there are sometimes several day wait times to cross. Ship operators lose money sitting around. This new Canal will be very helpful for everyone.