@@henryjones8636 It's one of the randimonium episodes (obviously before this episode). Stephen got tribal homunculus and that dude was in the deck and it was just a meme how terrible that card was (making only 1 hom, but forcing you to sac 1 anyway).
Also when Stephen played Hour of Revelation, the Dictate of Erebos should have ended up in his graveyard and Razaketh should have come back at eot. And when Jeremy attacked with his face down commander, he should have dealt commander damage.
i might of said to do this in the past. i dont remember and i dont feel like digging through all the videos for it. but my play group does this sometimes. just glad you guys did it. and had fun with it.
Another fantastic episode! I know it's a bit long but it's nice to have some that are a bit long. Shows a different side of commander than a short one would.
Wouldn't rasaketh have come back at 1:06:20? Also, at 1:44:50, I think there should have been a butcher trigger. Not that any of this still matters now anyway, awesome to see you guys again.
A really cool idea, it was different. If a group is cool with it; it seems like you can have so much hilarity to ensue! Though I have to admit I'm just waiting for the Randomonium....ALL HAIL THE RANDIMONIUM, THE RANDHARMONICON, THE COLLOSSEUM OF RANDOMNESS, THE ARENA OF THE ARBRITRARY! *clears throat* good day sirs!
Justin, your best set of draws at the end would probably be something like Harmonize into Show and Tell, Omniscience and Enter the Infinite, then casting Laboratory Maniac into Brainstorm, but that sorta deck would probably fall outside the usual category of decks played at Commander versus :)
Pretty sure Jeremy shouldn't have gotten Crypt Ghast back, since it was Jon's, so it would have gone to Jon's graveyard then gotten shuffled away by Kozilek's death trigger.
Watching black’s mana production is always absolutely disgusting 😂😂. I’ve been patiently awaiting for this season and now it’s here. Keep up the epic work guys can’t wait to see dominaria cards 👍🏻
Jeremy I don’t think you need to tap your lands for black mana to double them with crypt ghast. For example, At 1:10:53 you could have cast goblin bombardment for just your command tower. Tap command tower for red, and because it is a swamp in addition to its other types and crypt ghast reads “whenever you tap a swamp for mana,” you would get the additional black, too. Am I wrong here?
I didn't realize that after the Tuck Rule change that your Commander can be put into the command zone from *anywhere*. I thought that if you put it in your graveyard and then someone Time Spirals or whatever that then it gets stuck back in your library. I love that you can move it to the CZ no matter what.
Yes, "blink" effects do work around the condition of Whip. Because it only applies if the card would be put "anywhere else." Blink effects exile, so it would not apply. :)
It feels like Jon and Jeremy are always Spike, Justin is Johnny, and Stephen is Timmy. I liked it when they each were assigned decks at random from the decks that were built.
Hey guys love the videos! My birthdays coming up on the 29th and I'd love it if Stephen Green played the new commander card Muldrotha, the Gravetide. I've been waiting for awhile for the next season to start and I enjoy watching the heated battles that will ensue so keep playing! Go team Green!
@Jeremy The crypt ghast reads, whenever you tap a swamp for mana, you add a black mana. When you casted marchesa for the third time? You shorted yourself mana :(
*looks at deck lists* Stephen, Why do you have a Gonti, Lord of Luxury deck without Panharnomicon? WHY do you have a flicker based deck with out it? You had the "ETB Exile target creature" creatures..you could have lived the ultimate Gonti dream of milling everyone out with infinite Gonti triggers.
My dream would be Omnath, Locus of Rage with blue. You get more draw, and moonfolk to bounce lands to play again, as well as Patron of the Moon to throw lands out at instant speed.
what a shame Steven #TEAMGREEN you had the best deck to abuse whip. If you flicker a creature returned with whip of erebos, the creature will return to the battlefield without the whip trigger hanging over it. This because the exile effect of whip is a replacement if it goes anywhere else (which doesn't happen). So the flicker effect will resolve normally. But awesome episode gentlemen! thanks for the fun :)
Grenzo+Blue is something I've talked about for a long time... a deck where you top-deck lands so you can scry creatures to the bottom. Oh the wonders...
Ermm... Why didn't stephen gain life when Razaketh attacked Ugin, but did gain life when zombies attacked nissa? Shouldn't he have an extra 8 life and be at 41 at around 1:38:53?
If youre playing outside of the rules of commander I think the thing you should do is Partner Commander, but you have to use two ego's of the same person (Both Marchesa seems sweet, but there are a couple of others that would be fun)
John plays the thing that gives him a lot of mana (doubling cube) untapped with a Blind Obedience in play, the proceeds to play Titan tapped. Stephen: “Thanks for showing some respect”. Yeah, right.
Jeremy Should have sacrificed the goblin bombbardment to the "all is dust" at around 1:44:00, also Jeremy should have put 5 counters on his Marchesa at 2:03:00 ish
Just for the recrods: If a creature returned to the battlefield with Whip of Erebos would leave the battlefield for any reason, it’s exiled instead. However, if that creature is already being exiled, then the replacement effect won’t apply. If the spell or ability that exiles it later returns it to the battlefield (as Chained to the Rocks might, for example), the creature card will return to the battlefield as a new object with no relation to its previous existence.
I would absolutely love it if you guys do at least one Brawl video. I understand Brad, Ross, and Steven have done 1v1, but I’d love to see it in a 4 way free for all as it is intended to be played. That being said, I just really want to see Justin play with Slimefoot. Be it in EDH or Brawl:
At some point you should play with uncommon Legends (from just Dominaria or any set), as if they had Partner. Maybe one of your two commanders must be one of the Commander 2016 commanders that actually have Partner.
One thing I'd really like to see would be everyone playing a mono colored deck but ALL the lands need to be nonbasic and have to relate to the color. For example, if someone was playing mono red, they couldn't use mountains but they could use spinerock knoll, hanwier battlements, dwarven hold, etc.
Honestly at the start of the video i was trying to guess the theme and i looked at all the commander names and all of them were formatted with name comma description and i thought it was such a weird concept.
When Steven Green activated whip of erebos and wasn't sure if he could flicker it to save it. He could, a replacement affect can't replace and action with the same action. So basically whip would go to see the grave titan leave the battlefield, see that it is being exiled, and then says "I'm fine with that"' not caring that the creature will be coming back.
mehmehxxx check out the rulings for whip of erebos on the gatherer page. Third ruling down will explain it. This is true for other effects like it (like the keyword unearth). There is no magic rules text for this that I am aware, at least not within the section of replacement effects.
Best commander content by far, I won't mention the names of some other commander channels but some of the other contenders are so corny they must be aimed at younger audiences and too hard to sit through without turning the volume off.
Just curiously, but why does the Kozilek player play black cards and lands? Colorless commander means colorless card identiy only, right? Edit: Nvm, didn't realize the 'Add a color' twist
You should play with the uncommon dominaria legendaries as commanders, maybe play with just commons and uncommos (this second part is a litle bit too far but it would be cool anyway), Brasil loves you guys!!
You guys should do 1 player can only play artifacts ( includes artifact creatures), 1 player can only play creatures, 1 player can only play enchantments ( includes enchantment creatures) and 1 player can only play instants and sorceries.
![Commander VS S12E1: Nicol Bolas vs Arcades vs Vaevictis Asmadi vs Chromium [EDH]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gtfErgL6f9U/mqdefault.jpg)
YESSSS!!!! I have been immortalized!!! Glad you liked it guys!
More like eternalized. You're a 4/4 now.
Nice work! That's a pity that the Puppet Conjurer is doomed to be behind Jeremy's head forever :c
Damn that's funny
What video can I watch to find the origin of the homunculus meme?
@@henryjones8636 It's one of the randimonium episodes (obviously before this episode). Stephen got tribal homunculus and that dude was in the deck and it was just a meme how terrible that card was (making only 1 hom, but forcing you to sac 1 anyway).
"It's our show and we do whatever we want" love it!
I suppose I will point out that John played an untapped doubling cube with a blind obedience on the field. Yup. Gonna be that guy
Ted McGlothern came to stand by you, sir. People crossed the table to turn a morph, but left 16 free Mana loose.
Also when Steven attacked Ugin with Razaketh, he missed the lifelink from the Whip of Erebos.
Also when Stephen played Hour of Revelation, the Dictate of Erebos should have ended up in his graveyard and Razaketh should have come back at eot. And when Jeremy attacked with his face down commander, he should have dealt commander damage.
i might of said to do this in the past. i dont remember and i dont feel like digging through all the videos for it. but my play group does this sometimes. just glad you guys did it. and had fun with it.
my buddy turned me on to this episode, and now we are going to start up a league with this idea.....Thank you guys for this!
Another fantastic episode! I know it's a bit long but it's nice to have some that are a bit long. Shows a different side of commander than a short one would.
I really like the idea of "Add a color." I got to try it with my playgroup this weekend
Welcome back gentleman, I've missed my weekly CMDRVS. Been watching you all since the beginning, love your content!
So happy to see your bright and shinning faces again:) haha great concept adding one color and grave titans.
I’ve never clicked on a video so fast, love your content been watching since the beginning!
Ryan Skolnick same been here since it was danny west vs david mcdarby. I hope i spelled david's name right.
Excellent video! Glad to have you guys back!
Great episode guys. Very jealous of Steven's deck.
-The guy with the Gonti deck at GP Hartford
So glad to see u back guys ! !
Awesome episode guys!!!
Wouldn't rasaketh have come back at 1:06:20?
Also, at 1:44:50, I think there should have been a butcher trigger.
Not that any of this still matters now anyway, awesome to see you guys again.
Talking about Razaketh, Stephen should also gained life for punching Ugin, as the Whip give his creatures lifelink.
Unique deck ideas, gameplay mistakes, and confident personalities are why I appreciate cmndr vs. 😁
This was cool. Looking forward to what Dominaria legends you guys use and for the rest of the season as always :D
A really cool idea, it was different. If a group is cool with it; it seems like you can have so much hilarity to ensue! Though I have to admit I'm just waiting for the Randomonium....ALL HAIL THE RANDIMONIUM, THE RANDHARMONICON, THE COLLOSSEUM OF RANDOMNESS, THE ARENA OF THE ARBRITRARY! *clears throat* good day sirs!
Justin, your best set of draws at the end would probably be something like Harmonize into Show and Tell, Omniscience and Enter the Infinite, then casting Laboratory Maniac into Brainstorm, but that sorta deck would probably fall outside the usual category of decks played at Commander versus :)
But at least there was a chance!
1:06:30 Really Stephen? Been singing all show, but you're not gonna jump on that Black Box classic there? Ride On Time is a great song, dude!
Great episode. If you're ever taking suggestions, giving Partner to the Uncommon Dominaria Mutlicolor Legends would be fun to see..
YES YES YES SO HAPPY YOU GUYS ARE BACK !
so... 4 Yargles next week?
Like 17 Badgers if we don't care about the rules then how about a deck with 62 Yargles and 38 swamps
woah woah, they already ignored the rules this game, they aren't Seto Kaiba, they can't just say "screw the rules" whenever they want.
Agreed.
this is the ONLY logical path
Even better 2HG one team on Yargles one on Gitrog for the battle of ultimate supremacy on best frog boi
You guys are the best!
Pretty sure Jeremy shouldn't have gotten Crypt Ghast back, since it was Jon's, so it would have gone to Jon's graveyard then gotten shuffled away by Kozilek's death trigger.
“If you guys are ready, and if YOU guys are ready...” (cuts to a commercial)
youtube red is OP
“Cause Stephen is always looking at packages”
“Steven…whats in your heart? Get the card thats in your heart.” Lol
I love how in the intro Marchesa is giving Jeremy the "oh honey" look
Welcome back to Grave Titan VS! Episode 1 Season 11: Gravetitan vs Gravetitan vs Gravetitan vs a whole lot of nothing
I THINK YOU FORGOT ABOUT THE TIME I PLAYED GRAVE TITAN
Wednesdays are good again lol. So good to have some fun commander to watch!
Thank Erebos, I've missed you guys so much
Watching black’s mana production is always absolutely disgusting 😂😂. I’ve been patiently awaiting for this season and now it’s here. Keep up the epic work guys can’t wait to see dominaria cards 👍🏻
Jeremy I don’t think you need to tap your lands for black mana to double them with crypt ghast. For example, At 1:10:53 you could have cast goblin bombardment for just your command tower. Tap command tower for red, and because it is a swamp in addition to its other types and crypt ghast reads “whenever you tap a swamp for mana,” you would get the additional black, too. Am I wrong here?
I didn't realize that after the Tuck Rule change that your Commander can be put into the command zone from *anywhere*. I thought that if you put it in your graveyard and then someone Time Spirals or whatever that then it gets stuck back in your library. I love that you can move it to the CZ no matter what.
At 1:02, doubling cube ahould have come into play tapped
To be fair to them, everyone forgets that Blind Obedience affects artifacts.
Stephen even referenced a creature to come in tapped in the same turn lol
Yes, "blink" effects do work around the condition of Whip. Because it only applies if the card would be put "anywhere else." Blink effects exile, so it would not apply. :)
I would have played Talrand + green, so you can make drake tokens with populate and doubling season effects. :)
And good spell ramp.
It feels like Jon and Jeremy are always Spike, Justin is Johnny, and Stephen is Timmy. I liked it when they each were assigned decks at random from the decks that were built.
Welcome to Season 11 where Stephen Green makes a song reference every single episode LUL
Hey guys love the videos! My birthdays coming up on the 29th and I'd love it if Stephen Green played the new commander card Muldrotha, the Gravetide. I've been waiting for awhile for the next season to start and I enjoy watching the heated battles that will ensue so keep playing! Go team Green!
@Jeremy The crypt ghast reads, whenever you tap a swamp for mana, you add a black mana. When you casted marchesa for the third time? You shorted yourself mana :(
Justin: "Everyone start shutting up now." AP Bio reference +1
*looks at deck lists*
Stephen, Why do you have a Gonti, Lord of Luxury deck without Panharnomicon? WHY do you have a flicker based deck with out it? You had the "ETB Exile target creature" creatures..you could have lived the ultimate Gonti dream of milling everyone out with infinite Gonti triggers.
Seems reasonable
My dream would be Omnath, Locus of Rage with blue. You get more draw, and moonfolk to bounce lands to play again, as well as Patron of the Moon to throw lands out at instant speed.
Lucas Garrett And Tatyova. 😉
Feyamius fantastic suggestion
But then you have to play kamigawa cards and that's blasphemous on this show
Emerson L Stephen could do it! 🙂
You also get rite of replication so that you get 6 omnaths seeing 5 die for 30 triggers of 3 damage.
Woo glad to see planar gate : D
Can't wait to see that these guys do with all of the new dominaria legends
Thx for the pics at GP Hartford yall are great justin play esper curses
what a shame Steven #TEAMGREEN you had the best deck to abuse whip. If you flicker a creature returned with whip of erebos, the creature will return to the battlefield without the whip trigger hanging over it. This because the exile effect of whip is a replacement if it goes anywhere else (which doesn't happen). So the flicker effect will resolve normally. But awesome episode gentlemen! thanks for the fun :)
Grenzo+Blue is something I've talked about for a long time... a deck where you top-deck lands so you can scry creatures to the bottom. Oh the wonders...
Fantastic and funny episode
Yes! I've been waiting so long for this!
#TeamParnell #BluePlaymat #LustinForJustin #ThinkTwice #BlackManaMatters #WHYARENTYOUPLAYINGBLACKJUSTIN?
Ermm... Why didn't stephen gain life when Razaketh attacked Ugin, but did gain life when zombies attacked nissa? Shouldn't he have an extra 8 life and be at 41 at around 1:38:53?
Welcome back!!!
What card did the sin collector hit (48:50)?
Oh Exsanguinate
They are back!!!!!!
Make your own commanders like you did for the dog legend you created!
Jeremy playing my all time favorite commander!! :D
If youre playing outside of the rules of commander I think the thing you should do is Partner Commander, but you have to use two ego's of the same person (Both Marchesa seems sweet, but there are a couple of others that would be fun)
Good stuff lads
John plays the thing that gives him a lot of mana (doubling cube) untapped with a Blind Obedience in play, the proceeds to play Titan tapped. Stephen: “Thanks for showing some respect”. Yeah, right.
Amazing idea, please do more.
This was wonky but I loved it! Well done lads!
Jeremy Should have sacrificed the goblin bombbardment to the "all is dust" at around 1:44:00, also Jeremy should have put 5 counters on his Marchesa at 2:03:00 ish
on the Goblin Bombardment no it would not have been as it was in exile it returned as
Banishing Light was sacrificed
My bad didn’t catch the Banishing Light trigger 😅
Few minutes into it, poor Jeremy :( fate hates you, but we're cheering for ya! #teamnoell
What card does Stephen exile with Sin Collector? I can't tell from the art...
Exsanguinate
Just for the recrods: If a creature returned to the battlefield with Whip of Erebos would leave the battlefield for any reason, it’s exiled instead. However, if that creature is already being exiled, then the replacement effect won’t apply. If the spell or ability that exiles it later returns it to the battlefield (as Chained to the Rocks might, for example), the creature card will return to the battlefield as a new object with no relation to its previous existence.
For the randimonium or the arena of arbitrary or the randharminicon can you guys do the dual colored uncommon legends from dominaria
I would absolutely love it if you guys do at least one Brawl video. I understand Brad, Ross, and Steven have done 1v1, but I’d love to see it in a 4 way free for all as it is intended to be played. That being said, I just really want to see Justin play with Slimefoot. Be it in EDH or Brawl:
Congrats Kyle
Man i like that they forget blind obedience effect and then remembered for a different card in that same turn
At some point you should play with uncommon Legends (from just Dominaria or any set), as if they had Partner. Maybe one of your two commanders must be one of the Commander 2016 commanders that actually have Partner.
What is that blue box that kind of looks like Commander Anthology in the background doing. Is this some sneaky spoilers?
One thing I'd really like to see would be everyone playing a mono colored deck but ALL the lands need to be nonbasic and have to relate to the color. For example, if someone was playing mono red, they couldn't use mountains but they could use spinerock knoll, hanwier battlements, dwarven hold, etc.
I would like to see you guys do a no ban list, no color restriction, no deck size limit commander game.
justin, why not add blue or red to meren? either would be sooooo good and right up your alley
So... 2:02:00 why didn't Jeremy take back his Glen Elendra Archmage? :/
Honestly at the start of the video i was trying to guess the theme and i looked at all the commander names and all of them were formatted with name comma description and i thought it was such a weird concept.
"You killed my Bleb!!"- Justin Parnell 2018
When Steven Green activated whip of erebos and wasn't sure if he could flicker it to save it. He could, a replacement affect can't replace and action with the same action. So basically whip would go to see the grave titan leave the battlefield, see that it is being exiled, and then says "I'm fine with that"' not caring that the creature will be coming back.
Stuart Pratt I thought this too... rules text?
mehmehxxx check out the rulings for whip of erebos on the gatherer page. Third ruling down will explain it. This is true for other effects like it (like the keyword unearth). There is no magic rules text for this that I am aware, at least not within the section of replacement effects.
At 1:12:00 the crypt ghast should hit Johns graveyard and then get shuffled in due to Kozileks triggered ability of being put into the graveyard
I'm just waiting for SCG to sell a t-shirt with Stephen's face on it that says "I'ma cast this here land"
under your control, doesnt that refer to target, not were it goes after?
Best commander content by far, I won't mention the names of some other commander channels but some of the other contenders are so corny they must be aimed at younger audiences and too hard to sit through without turning the volume off.
Make Meren great again, let Justin play his waifu
Justin has Muldrotha now. Meren has left him one too many times but Muldrotha will be true.
Kestral287 shove them both together!
Meren probably goes in the 99 of Muldrotha (she's been solid in mine), but Muldrotha leads the way now.
Yeah, Meren doesn't let you use blue.
Don't worry Meren, I'LL stay faithful
What card was it that got exiled by Sin Collector at 48:44?
It was Exsanguinate.
5 minutes in and theres a pic of Al bundy, yall got some good taste :D
I don't think so Tim.
Polk High Forever.
1:48:55That can’t be good. I’m pretty sure Stephen removing an Enchantment was one of the biblical signs of the apocalypse
That was a great idea for a change!
Just curiously, but why does the Kozilek player play black cards and lands? Colorless commander means colorless card identiy only, right?
Edit: Nvm, didn't realize the 'Add a color' twist
Did ixidrons effect change? Because it says nontoken creatures. So jon's tokens shouldnt have been flipped face down
Why Jeremy kept the enchantment after the all is dust?
59:39
To this day, I don't think that I've seen Justin that mad
You should play with the uncommon dominaria legendaries as commanders, maybe play with just commons and uncommos (this second part is a litle bit too far but it would be cool anyway), Brasil loves you guys!!
You guys should do 1 player can only play artifacts ( includes artifact creatures), 1 player can only play creatures, 1 player can only play enchantments ( includes enchantment creatures) and 1 player can only play instants and sorceries.
1:46:00 Jeremy had gained 3 from Noxious Gearhulk.
It’s ALWAYS willbender!
That awkward moment when the doubling cube should have entered tapped
The braidsmate Johnathon is FINALLY THE BRIDE
You guys should play banned commanders. But they are the only banned cards allowed in the deck. there are actually a good variety to choose from
YAYYYYYY!!!! It’s back!!!