Trade Republic vs Scalable Capital: The Best Depot for Investing in Germany: Detailed Comparison 🇩🇪

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 дек 2024

Комментарии • 275

  • @ricardo.fontanelli
    @ricardo.fontanelli 3 года назад +6

    Definitely missing Vanguard ETFs on TR

    • @brandevise
      @brandevise  3 года назад +2

      Amen! I really missed that too specially with such low TER that Vanguard charges! It is hands down the cheapest way to invest in ETFs! In general you just have a lot more choice at Scalable Capital in comparison to Trade Republic.

    • @georgenistor2761
      @georgenistor2761 3 года назад

      @@brandevise If I use etoro in Germany and i have less then 801 euro devidents/year...do I need to declare when I make for
      annual tax?

    • @SMAonlineTrend
      @SMAonlineTrend 3 года назад

      Hallo pans In scale capital I pay fess approximately 1 euro if buy any share of ETF

  • @prisicabasil3933
    @prisicabasil3933 3 года назад +39

    WHOEVER THAT'S READING THIS , I PRAY THAT ONE DAY YOU WILL REACH YOUR DREAMS.
    ALWAYS KNOW THAT THE SECRET OF YOUR FUTURE IS HIDDEN IN YOUR DAILY ROUTINE. SUCCESSFUL PEOPLE DO DAILY WHAT THE UNSUCCESSFUL DO ONLY ON OCCASIONALLY. That's why the rich invest and the poor don't.

    • @benben3556
      @benben3556 3 года назад

      to be successful in life there must be some vitals game to play by following the link of the rich ones as your mentor and always try to be good with them as your mentor so that you can get to the successful point you are aiming.

    • @kevintim5488
      @kevintim5488 3 года назад

      Most times having knowledge or insight a particular activity can as well be a best exercise.

    • @kevintim5488
      @kevintim5488 3 года назад

      I can boldly say that forex is one of the pro-fitable money ex-change services that elevates investors and their financial status

    • @alipatrick5122
      @alipatrick5122 3 года назад

      @@kevintim5488 That’s true most people today have been having alot of failures in forex sector because of poor orientalists and bad experts

    • @jansophie6063
      @jansophie6063 3 года назад

      Most people remain poor only because friends and relatives di-scouraged and advised them against in-vesting and t-rading for-ex while the wise ones kept in-vesting and going higher finan-cially

  • @studious90
    @studious90 3 года назад +6

    A couple of questions here
    1) can we transfers stocks to this account ?
    2) let’s assume scalable capital is bankrupt or closed, is there a risk of losing holding stocks in future? Or somehow it’s protected by the any regulatory body?

  • @ZARADAMcom
    @ZARADAMcom 3 года назад +5

    The way that you explain things keep me watching all your videos! Really! Or I think I am in love with you!

  • @maryannqueen7356
    @maryannqueen7356 3 года назад +2

    Would u ADVICE i open Scalable and still keep TR?? Is it that i pay 2,99 a month if i buy or Not buy, if i sell or dont sell????

    • @badgerlife9541
      @badgerlife9541 3 года назад

      The subscription option is 2,99/ month. But you can also get the free account. Then you have no monthly fees! But you pay 0.99 euro per trade instead of 0 euro per trade.

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад

      @@badgerlife9541 hey,it doesn't work out like that

  • @mandaalexiou4927
    @mandaalexiou4927 2 года назад +1

    I Wonder if I can purchase indexfonds/ index fund which is managed by some online brokers in scalable ? Like I only put my money monthly in the account. Im really new to this if I use any wrong words that u can’t understand I’m sorry.
    And thank you for the video !

  • @ninehoursful
    @ninehoursful 3 года назад +3

    Can someone tell me what exactly is savings plan? What does it do?

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад +1

      mr MARCOS ANTONIO MADRIL is the best , recommending him to all beginners who wants to recover losses like I did

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад +2

      You can reach him directly on WhatsApp

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад +1

      He would explain better to you💪

  • @OlyaOppenheim
    @OlyaOppenheim 3 года назад +1

    Hey, I heard that back in October there was a data breach in scalable capital, do you know how they handled that and how safe my data is if I decide to join them now?

  • @vikranthg9486
    @vikranthg9486 3 года назад +2

    Hi Bharath, how do we register a business in Romania but live in Germany? Is this legal ? Or do you plan to shift to Romania so that you can save on taxes in business?

    • @brandevise
      @brandevise  3 года назад

      You can’t. That’s illegal.

    • @vikranthg9486
      @vikranthg9486 3 года назад

      @@brandevise thank you for clarifying

  • @ivancb882
    @ivancb882 2 года назад

    So if I just want to have one Etf in my savings Plan with the Freebroker mode, and that Etf ist from Vanguard for example, that wouldn't cost extra, only if I want to have another Etf Fron the non Prime Partners, right?

  • @sharifahruh996
    @sharifahruh996 3 года назад

    I love your videos.i never miss any., Scalable Capital hasn't opened up my Depot yet. It's been now like week since I applied but I hope they finally do

  • @imr4nkhan
    @imr4nkhan 3 года назад

    Hi Bharat, great detailed video. Is US30 available on Scalable?

  • @massi_shahnezhad
    @massi_shahnezhad Год назад

    Hello Bharat, I moved to Germany last year and I don't have my permanent residence permit yet, I wanna know that could I register on Scalable Capital without that?

  • @John-fe9ii
    @John-fe9ii 2 года назад +29

    Mrs Clarissa is legit and her method works like magic I keep on earning every single week with her new strategy

    • @Bigdreams-jy2pv
      @Bigdreams-jy2pv 2 года назад

      Wow I' m just shock someone mentioned expert Mrs Clarissa thought I' m the only one trading with her

    • @Bigdreams-jy2pv
      @Bigdreams-jy2pv 2 года назад

      She helped me recover what I lost trying to trade my self

    • @Emily-tl7cj
      @Emily-tl7cj 2 года назад

      expert Mrs Clarissa she's really amazing with an amazing skills she changed my 0.3btc to 2.1btc

    • @lucaskurt8326
      @lucaskurt8326 2 года назад

      I think I'm blessed because if not I wouldn't have met someone who is as spectacular as expert Mrs Clarissa
      I think she is the best broker I ever seen

    • @Drawduckgg
      @Drawduckgg 2 года назад

      My first investment with Mrs Clarissa gave me profit of over $24,000 us dollars and ever since then she has never failed to deliver and I can even say she's the most sincere broker I have known

  • @kuzdogan
    @kuzdogan 3 года назад +2

    Looking forward to hearing about moving your business to another country and how you handle taxes

  • @bridgetteisla2614
    @bridgetteisla2614 3 года назад +1

    Hi, I want to ask if is it better to buy ETF one time in bulk or better make Sparplan.. What are the pros and cons of both side.

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад

      Buy in bulk

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад

      mr MARCOS ANTONIO MADRIL is the best , recommending him to all beginners who wants to recover losses like I did

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад

      You can reach him directly on WhatsApp

    • @peterziech1323
      @peterziech1323 3 года назад

      He would help you 💪

  • @bevik12
    @bevik12 3 года назад

    I'm just about to start this broker thing as a beginner so it is totally SC for the win?

  • @helixx6647
    @helixx6647 2 года назад

    Thanks for your comparison!

  • @GHMA-m5m
    @GHMA-m5m 2 года назад

    so know which one is butter Treade republic or scalable please _`?=

  • @Varunpachisia123
    @Varunpachisia123 3 года назад

    Hey Bharat, is scalable capital trading platform also in English?

  • @ehtishamishere4055
    @ehtishamishere4055 3 года назад +1

    Hey Bharat! Big Fan of you :)
    Thank you for making all these videos, Keep it up :D

  • @SkysurferMr
    @SkysurferMr 3 года назад

    Great video. Answers a lot of my questions

  • @evelez
    @evelez 3 года назад

    Hi , the fees for stock purchases on Scalable Capital like the 3,99 for buying a stock, do these get charged to the bank you have attached to the service?

    • @brandevise
      @brandevise  3 года назад

      It is 0,99€. It’s debited from your current account separatelyz

  • @vivekkumar-iz2bh
    @vivekkumar-iz2bh 2 года назад

    Can we trade Forex in Scalable Capital?

  • @philippevaillant2465
    @philippevaillant2465 Год назад

    Lequel propose un IFU pour les frnacais pour declarer aux impots ?

  • @constantadi
    @constantadi 3 года назад +3

    lots of useful info, thanks sir! I'm curious if SC will be eventually available in English as well (that's one of the main advantages for expats with TR)

  • @ytuser4362
    @ytuser4362 3 года назад

    Thanks for the video.
    After you explained scalabe Capital.
    I opened it and invested in Tesla.
    I am able to make good Profit 🥳🥳

  • @gauravsonwani750
    @gauravsonwani750 3 года назад

    Can we do Derivatives/Options in Scalable Capital?

  • @honestreview9019
    @honestreview9019 3 года назад

    quick question. is the scalable capital also in English? I found TR interface in English

  • @wazilis
    @wazilis 3 года назад

    Great Video, but how about the spreads? I mean Scalable Capital does not charge per transaction but are their spreads higher than Trade Republic? Thanks!

    • @wazilis
      @wazilis 3 года назад

      WATCH OUT OF THE FAKE ACCOUNT WITH THE WHATSAPP NUMBER!!!!

  • @kalaivanimanibarathi5945
    @kalaivanimanibarathi5945 3 года назад +1

    Thank you for this comparison video!!

  • @funnydose3586
    @funnydose3586 2 года назад

    If I have a Romanian nationality and I living in Germany and work here where should I pay tax for my profits?

  • @natalieong7503
    @natalieong7503 2 года назад

    Thank you for getting straight to the point and being very detailed at the same time! Appreciated it!

  • @aleksandrabroskin
    @aleksandrabroskin 3 года назад

    Hi, could you please help me figure out how is this 801€ threshold calculated when you use both trade republic and scalable capital ?

  • @pawanbro
    @pawanbro 3 года назад

    Do you have any withdrawal issue in Scalable Capital . I couldn’t withdraw although there is some amount. Is there a limit time to withdraw after account opening . Glad if you could express your experience

  • @bridgetteisla2614
    @bridgetteisla2614 3 года назад

    I also cant find OGIG, ARKK, invesco QQQ.. Can you advice what etf to buy as a beginner and planing for long term investing. Thanks

    • @badgerlife9541
      @badgerlife9541 3 года назад

      Where did you look for these ETFs?
      As far as I know, all ARK funds are not licensed to trade in Europe! You can only invest in these via a US financial institution.

    • @brandevisebusinessandfinan9329
      @brandevisebusinessandfinan9329 3 года назад

      WhatsApp +1 3 8 5 3 5 0 0 6 8 7,,,,

  • @badgerlife9541
    @badgerlife9541 3 года назад

    This was very informative! Thanks! I like several Xtrackers and Vanguard ETFs, so I guess it will become Scalable Capital.

  • @alex2204veles
    @alex2204veles 3 года назад +1

    Great Video. There are a lot of useful informations for beginners here !!!

  • @siddharthdedhia11
    @siddharthdedhia11 3 года назад

    Hey Bharat ,
    Whats your opinion on this:
    I send back money to my home country India. The equity mutual fund returns are 10-12% much higher than the ETFs offered in Germany (7-10 %) and I even save on the tax that is being cut just to have ETF in my account.
    Is this a good option? What are the pros and cons in terms of passive long term investment?

  • @silviaretana2075
    @silviaretana2075 3 года назад

    Hi! Thanks for the good information. Could you make a video explaining what is the advantage of using a broker like SC vs using the direct depot from your bank (in my case ING DiBa)?

  • @milanm6538
    @milanm6538 3 года назад +3

    Thanks for the content, it is very useful!
    If we invest in stocks in Germany for 10 years, then we move to another country to live and work. How can we "move" shares with us, do we have to pay taxes for the transfer, and if we sell shares in our new country, do we have to pay taxes in Germany?

  • @akv8317
    @akv8317 3 года назад

    Hey Bharat! Thank you for creating this channel. Apart from Comdirect which other depot accepts Indian Passport?

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      Make a note to my trusted trader miss Lisa don't forget to tell her I referred you

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      +1 5 6 2 3 7 8 0 5 9 5

  • @prabesh-khadka
    @prabesh-khadka 3 года назад

    Can a student in Germany open an account in Scalable capital? would there be a problem with the auslaenderbehoerde/ finanzamt as a foreign student from India buying shares?

  • @amirabbasi4066
    @amirabbasi4066 3 года назад

    Thank you, I'm alao a beginner but, as I checked none of them supports options trading! There is only warrants on TR! Do you know anything else which supports options in germany?

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      Make a note to my trusted trader miss Lisa so she can make a good trade for you

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      +1 5 6 2 3 7 8 0 5 9 5

  • @HoaNguyen-jj6nr
    @HoaNguyen-jj6nr 3 года назад

    Is trailing stop lost available in scalable?

  • @anwarmalik6633
    @anwarmalik6633 2 года назад

    Strange, I was able to open an account in Trade Republic from my Pakistan passport last week. Probably they have added more countries recently.

  • @Youssef-le8ft
    @Youssef-le8ft 3 года назад +1

    Awesome video 👌
    Can you please make a video about the first steps to take to start investing in crypto (like bitwala for example) =)

  • @jackleporteur1432
    @jackleporteur1432 3 года назад

    Is the trading done in EURO and not on USD when you buy the stocks there ? is there any exchanges fees or spreads

    • @brandevise
      @brandevise  3 года назад +1

      Trading is in EUR. Spreads are actually much better than what you find on L&S (Trade Republic)

    • @jackleporteur1432
      @jackleporteur1432 3 года назад

      @@brandevise Thanks because I believe the stocks are only available in USD in the New York Stock exchange or NASDAG ... So probably the spreads will include the exchanges fees etc

  • @straighttalk6239
    @straighttalk6239 3 года назад

    so Scalable is ur choice. What u think about Coinbase .As u cant buy Bitcoin on scalable if Im not mistaken.

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      Make a note to my trusted trader miss Lisa don't forget to tell her I referred you

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад +1

      +1 5 6 2 3 7 8 0 5 9 5

  • @133wavi
    @133wavi 3 года назад

    Thank you for the wonderful video. I am more interested in shares with dividend. It would be great if you can make a video that which broker has more options for buying shares with dividend.

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      Make a note to my trusted trader miss Lisa so she can make a good trade for you

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      +1 5 6 2 3 7 8 0 5 9 5

  • @benhar2159
    @benhar2159 3 года назад

    How about language is Scalable cap is english language interface ?

  • @cenk82
    @cenk82 3 года назад +1

    Have a question to you Sir: Don't you think put all your money in one Start-up Fintech, I mean SC, may be a dangerous move.
    Don't you think, here, we should also separate eggs into two different baskets? :-) Think on this please.

  • @VishalBalaji
    @VishalBalaji 3 года назад

    Wish this video had come out a couple of weeks back when i was researching which broker to use. Nevertheless, a spot on comparison between TR and SC. It really sucks that TR doesn't accept Indian Passports.

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      Make a note to my trusted trader miss Lisa so she can make a good trade for you

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      +1 5 6 2 3 7 8 0 5 9 5

    • @anees9877
      @anees9877 2 года назад

      Yes i too got same response from TR
      What about Scalable Capital? Do they accept Indian passport?

  • @nikhildiwate7538
    @nikhildiwate7538 3 года назад

    can we trade forex on both of this ?

  • @SalimAnsari-nx3iu
    @SalimAnsari-nx3iu 3 года назад

    I tried all three methods to do identification but it didn't work with Indian passport. I have informed scalable capital about it. Let's hope there is a quick and easy solution.

  • @hectormanuel8944
    @hectormanuel8944 3 года назад

    Hey Bharat, do you mind to explain me why the dividends payment of US stocks in Scalable Capital are 30%. I'm receiving 15 percent of US repeated in my documents of the dividends payment

    • @brandevise
      @brandevise  3 года назад

      Hey Hector, this shouldn’t be the case. Can you show me the screenshots on Instagram?

    • @hectormanuel8944
      @hectormanuel8944 3 года назад

      @@brandevise thank you very much, I'm sending you the screenshot now

    • @albertolopez5546
      @albertolopez5546 2 года назад +1

      @@hectormanuel8944 hola hector, estuve leyendo la apertura de cuenta y en principio EUA tiene acuerdo con españa por doble imposición, en su web dice que si eres extrangero y vives en españa usando la plataforma tendrias que rellenar el W8 DEn creo que se llama para evitarlo

  • @straighttalk6239
    @straighttalk6239 3 года назад

    great vifeo fella . very cool . thanks.R

  • @Yazd98
    @Yazd98 3 года назад

    Can you also please give aninsight for Trading212 and etoro?

    • @brandevisebusinessandfinan4250
      @brandevisebusinessandfinan4250 3 года назад

      WhatsApp +1 8 1 0 2 1 4 0 5 3 9,

    • @EdViaja
      @EdViaja 3 года назад

      Same question, but I would suggest Trading212 instead of etoro. For my experience. Revolut is also nice, but it's not free and after Brexit some problems appeared, at least this year.

  • @aneeshprasobhan
    @aneeshprasobhan 3 года назад

    you know, you're supposed to state in the video (or description) if it is sponsored by a company or not.

  • @walewax8806
    @walewax8806 3 года назад

    Hello greetings to you, I have been having trouble signing up for with scalable capital, it's said I most deposit a minimum of 250 euro. Is there any other way around that?

  • @EdViaja
    @EdViaja 3 года назад

    Nice video. Your channel is really interesting... Please, Could you do one with Trading212 and Revolut and how declare taxes in Germany? I sold more than 801 euros but I'm really lost on how to declare taxes using this kind of foreign brokers. I am almost to pay to a professional to make this accounts, normal webpages that help with this are nice but I don't know how to fill the information there from my profits.

    • @EdViaja
      @EdViaja 3 года назад

      German code 1810

  • @peterziech1323
    @peterziech1323 3 года назад +15

    mr MARCOS ANTONIO MADRIL is the best , recommending him to all beginners who wants to recover losses like I did

    • @waynejames8499
      @waynejames8499 3 года назад

      Knowing the right source guarantees winning and profit, Mr Antonio has been my money making machine

    • @annjane117
      @annjane117 3 года назад +3

      How can one reach an expert in trading , cos I have lost alot of money trading with a wrong trader .

    • @cematthew3841
      @cematthew3841 3 года назад

      @@annjane117 you can reach him directly on WhatsApp

    • @janelinda5148
      @janelinda5148 3 года назад +4

      Bitcoin has generally proven to be profitable to numerous individuals around the world but personally you will never understand how profitable Bitcoin is until you start investing in the market

    • @hallsandra2398
      @hallsandra2398 3 года назад +3

      He is really amazing with an amazing skills,he changed my 0.3btc-2.1 btc

  • @YouMTF202
    @YouMTF202 3 года назад

    can someone help me with how to recharge my account case am new here

  • @MrPabsify
    @MrPabsify 3 года назад +1

    I've been waiting a month to get the depot open in SC.
    Anyways, in their broker page I can see Ark Invest Arkk and Arkg funds, can you please confirm we can buy those in SC? I've been wanting them for a looong time.

  • @MCProvok
    @MCProvok 3 года назад

    Hi Bharat! just came across your channel, which imo would have been great if it wasn't for a few major inconsistencies... Expats + English-speaking channel don't mix up well with SC (german only desktop, german only client support -if you manage to reach anybody there-) ... are you paid by them to promote their platform? you do not seem to point out these OBVIOUS issues with them at all in your analysis given the audience you seem to target...

  • @MannedSoldier
    @MannedSoldier 3 года назад

    Can't wait for this video about moving to a tax friendlier country and see what to look for. I'll be employed in Germany and I'm not much of an entrepreneur so it looks like I will be stuck there for some time, my plan is to invest and build up a portfolio that will allow me to reach financial independence and early retirement. I would then try to move to a different country that charges less tax on dividends and capital gains. Real estate is also something I might consider in the future. In short, I hate high taxes.

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      Make a note to my trusted trader miss Lisa so she can make a good trade for you

    • @martinvincent8984
      @martinvincent8984 3 года назад

      +1 5 6 2 3 7 8 0 5 9 5

  • @ytuser4362
    @ytuser4362 3 года назад +1

    Please do more videos on Cryptocurrency 🙏🙏🙏☺️

  • @Andarwin
    @Andarwin 3 года назад

    I really learn alot from you brotherly. Will follow up on Instagram:)

  • @ytuser4362
    @ytuser4362 3 года назад

    Is bitcoin trading and bitcoin mining legal in germany. I am reading some articles regarding bitcoin.
    Some lawyers are saying that it's illegal in some kind of way.
    Can you please make a detailed video regarding cryptocurrency trading, mining,etc....??
    Thank you 🙏🙏☺️☺️

    • @cenk82
      @cenk82 3 года назад

      It is totally legal. All my friends doing it without any problem. Also, one benefit is its tax-free as long as you hold the bitcoins more than 365 days. Tax free investment is a huge deal in Germany.

    • @ytuser4362
      @ytuser4362 3 года назад

      @@cenk82thanks for the reply.
      Is bitcoin mining also legal in Germany or only trading??

    • @cenk82
      @cenk82 3 года назад +1

      @@ytuser4362 mining, I have no idea. Trading is done by the bitcoin markets online where you purchase and sell. Google "bitcoin börse vergleich" and see the different exchange markets of bitcoins operating in germany. Cheers!

    • @michealrezeal989
      @michealrezeal989 3 года назад

      Ubisoft i ask you again do you want to trade?

  • @rene1485
    @rene1485 3 года назад

    You wanna live in a country like Germany but don't wanna pay taxes...

    • @brandevise
      @brandevise  3 года назад +1

      Not the point. Taxes can also be fairer so that people are encouraged to start businesses too.

  • @jonasturmburger9156
    @jonasturmburger9156 2 года назад

    Go for TR. SC has really poor customer service and is incredibly laggy!

  • @davidsbaidya3595
    @davidsbaidya3595 3 года назад

    I shall grow bigger beard than you so that my musk stays loose and can breathe better ....mit freundliche gruss moin moin