I find it interesting that everyone is writing off this episode, but Din and Bo now have official relations with a planet that uses domed cities that are similar to what was on Mandalor. I can easily see this as laying the groundwork for the eventual rebuilding of their planet.
@@niehoe3048 hard to know if it is false until the season ends. I think it will be interesting to see where it goes over the final two episodes.. I have spoken ;-)
Thanks for saying it! I'm so tired of the complaints. For the first two seasons, people whined about not having enough exploration of Mandalorians, now that we are meeting and exploring Mandalorians and their factions, people are whining about not enough Din or Grogu. I'm sorry, they said this season would be about uniting the Mandalorians and reclaiming Mandalore... didn't they? Din NEVER WANTED THE DARKSABER...he isn't power hungry. BO SAW THE MYTHOSAUR FOR A REASON...and Bo earned respect from the CotW through those "filler" episodes. Geez. Can't make anyone happy, I guess.
I love Grogu and Mando, but honestly - we already got enough and they still have the same relationship. Now we are finally focusing on Mandalorians as a whole story of the title culture. Its finally what I wanted from the start for it to be - exploring titular mandalorian and his 'tribe'. Series 3 ending with their mission of retaking the home planet and uniting the clans couldnt be more fitting for a show with such title! Also SPOILER FOR EP 7 --- ... ---> empire general fascinated with Mandalorian culture and making his own imperial-mandalorian squad to fight them? P-E-R-F-E-C-T! I would also be fine with them making time jump during next season. Perhaps if they retake Mandalore, Grogu could grow up there a bit to the next level of speech at least? Take his relationship with his 'father' master to next level. We know he wont grow up much, as he is from the species that ages super slow, but we could take it at least this far with him as a youngling.
I agree. My gut check for 'Does this feel like Star Wars?' with all these series is: Would this thing (character/ship/planet) fit in an episode of The Clone Wars series? Personally I can see 100% of Plazier 15 coming right out of that setting. For me, it worked.
Count Dooku was a visionary! Imagine being a loyal separatist for 30 years at least. I was glad to see those battle droids and prequels-era references.
Im gonna give the rest of the season a chance but tbh to say say that Lizzo and Jack Black felt "normal" to me indicates a lack of imagination. I don't have a problem with either of them IRL but to me it broke immersion to have them in this. They could've easily brought in some unknowns wearing the exact same costumes and reading exact same lines and it would've worked better imo
@@ericlopez5218 The Star Wars Universe has no limits in the types of people and cultures it can possess. Just look at Earth with 8 billion people, and now imagine a galaxy with 500 trillion people. It would wholly unrealistic if there weren’t people like Jack Black, and Lizzo in that universe.
Ditto to pretty much everyone else. Love your takes on the validity of this episode. A couple favorite things for me were: 1. The call back to the Ugnaughts. That was so awesome. I loved that they tied that back in. 2. The droid perspective. Before this episode, I hadn’t considered that the imperial tech they were decommissioning included droids, because they’re so much more than just tech / machinery. It’s another way the New Republic is misstepping.
Your reactions to the guest appearances were everything I wanted and more! Loved this episode as the series continues to give us insight into the state of the galaxy overall. 👍
I love that you guys always seem to have the most fun with these cooky episodes that flesh out the world. Almost everyone else I've watched has complained about this episode vehemently. I'm in the same boat that I just wanna experience as much of this world as possible. Why wouldn't there be a post-Imperial Wall-E world that is totally utopian with a Separatist sympathizer. There's all kinds of crazy shit still going on in the universe at large. This is also huge development for Bo and Din. They have so much respect for one another now and Bo can finally bring everyone together. I expect 7 and 8 to be big potentially crossover episodes. This season has been so incredible. Have loved every second of it.
This is my favorite episode yet! I love cameos like this and I actually like stuff being more "goofy" than overly serious like Andor was. It keeps my attention way more personally.
@@keithredacted8154 I thought Preview'd had pretty similar reactions. They had a good time with this episode as well. I watch like 10 different channels, but I always watch Preview'd first, then Heroes Reforged if I can help it, then Reel Rejects and whoever else after that. The Rejects were a lot more critical of this episode in the grand scheme of things, but Jay and Adam over at Preview'd always have a good time with this cameo stuff and the more fun exploring the universe at large bits. :)
@@fuzzyotterpaws4395 I can do either/or, but like, Star Wars has always been campy and over the top. It's why I loved Book of Boba Fett so much. It told, imo, a good and fresh story about a beloved character, expanded the current universe a bit more, and didn't take itself too seriously. Danny Trejo training a Rancor for Boba Fett to ride wasn't on my bingo card, but I fuckin' loved it. 😂 I think episode 5 is still my favorite so far this season because seeing Din, Paz, and Bo all on the same page made me really emotional for some reason, like Din has finally earned the respect of his Covert.
If Din just had said "This is the Way" after her gave Bo back the Dark Saber would have given me more goosebumps along with the music would have been so cool!!!
Ad someone who loves this episode my heart was broke watching others reviews. Then Yall give me hope, thank you. I'll always be here will you guys on this beautiful ride.
Nerdy Nightly channel perfectly put to thought and explained everything about this episode and season. Shame more people don't see it too, too blinded by their own expectations -kinda like with a lot of SW projects too-
This is my favorite episode yet! I love cameos like this and I actually like stuff being more "goofy" than overly serious like Andor was. It keeps my attention way more personally.
I appreciate you guys SO MUCH. I saw the shenanigans on the internet after this episode and was like ew i need the HR guys and their enthusiastic commitment to have a great time watching Star Wars BECAUSE WATCHING STAR WARS IS A GREAT TIME! And you never disappoint. Thanks homies.
I’ve just gotta say how refreshing it is to see you guys respond so enthusiastically to this episode, after seeing so many negative reactions to it. You guys are just here the ride, embracing the wacky guest stars, and generally rolling with it…checking impatience at the door. Like Hector said, enjoying the journey. 🙂
Some less noticeable guest stars - the alien couple at the start were the actress who played Jefferson's wife Lynn on "Black Lightning" and Tom Holland's brother.
Adam and Hector...I love Star Wars! I fell in love with it in 1977 at the age of 10. I am so appreciative that we continue having stories told to us to enjoy. As for this season of Mandalorian, I have loved it so far and expect an awesome 2 final episodes. 💕
People have no patience these days. When I was a little kid , I watched 22 episode tv shows and if there was a cliffhanger, god forbid...I had to wait ALL SUMMER to find out what happened in the Fall premiere. I for one, LOVE the environments, character builds and seeing how all the other people in this galaxy are doing cuz when the hardcore shit eventually comes down and our protagonists have to put the pedal to the metal, we will know what is at stake.
I left this episode with a warmth and joy that was hard to figure out. It really reminded me of the 80's and 90's Scifi zaniness that made me fall in love with the genre. It sucks that not everyone is enjoying the season but I like how this father and son we grew to love are having such a deep impact on the mandalorians as a whole.
Again, gotta love the positive attitude and optimism towards this episode! It definitely wasn’t my favorite, but watching it with you guys provides me with a different prospective I really appreciate
I feel like I'm the only one who got "I, Robot" vibes from this episode. The droid bar tender not saying, " We don't serve your kind here" was a missed opportunity though. And the music during the fight between Bo and Ax Wolves (badass name number two this season, the other being Ragnar Vizla) is sick.
Well they referenced it by having Din's line about how they don't get our kind here. I also think it would've been out of character for the bartender to have said that because it's fairly antagonistic, but the droids are really subservient and gentle and would probably not say something like that.
Hector, the difference between you and the other folks you’ve been visiting on the other channels is that you enjoy and respect the work. Both of you - all three of you - understand and honor the creative process and evolution. The critics (if you can call them critics) are cynical. They are egoistic… sorry for the insult to them. I LOVE YOUR CELEBRATORY TONE.
This is my comfort show. I love it so much. I despise fanbois and their entitlement. If they stopped to think for five minutes, the amount of amazing content we're getting. I mean, sometimes I can't believe I can watch something like this show in my TV or laptop. Come on! I'm so glad you guys are so great, I love how positive you are :)
Nobody is talking about how happy the darksaber sounds when Bo ignites it. It makes a much calmer sound when she wields it. It's supposed to be in her care.
I only watch reactors now who appreciate the world of star wars, you guys, blindwave and the reel rejects. No matter how you feel about the episode, this is all ground work for the world and I for one am loving it! The work that goes into this is amazing! The costums, make-up, worlds, relationships that are being created. It is great, you can see the love that is put into it. This all will be a set up for years to come, lets enjoy it❤
Grogu 's reaction to hearing lizzo's character saying her and her husband had fell in love was hilarious. 😂 I think Bo will be a great leader . Hope we see Boba or even another force wielding character? Can't wait to see .😊
I really enjoyed this episode. It was so much fun to watch. The guest stars were great - seeing Lizzo and Grogu interacting was precious. I liked the interplay between Bo-Katan and Din when conducting the investigation, and the scenes with the Ugnaughts and in the droid bar was wonderful. Some cool action throughout, especially the Mandalorian fight. And, the ending with Bo-Katan left me very excited for more. Everything I enjoy about Star Wars.
i appreciate the open takes u guys have almost everyone trashed the episode and didnt enjoy it for what it was. A fun episode with fun cameos u guys are the best keep it up
I love you fellassszzzzz! Totes agree on the annoying comments people have on a series that isn't even done yet. Just watch it and STFU.. if ya don't like it, well then don't watch it. it's really simple. 😁
I totally love this show, and this episode. I totally agree with you guys. I;m 58, and had to sit through 24 to 32 episodes of any show in the past. And not every episode was worth sitting through. Where this has been the best, and I wish we were getting more, and having trouble understanding why people aren't enjoying it.
I remember hearing Christopher Lloyd would appear, but I never expected to see Jack Black and Lizzo. And I definitely didn’t expect Din to say Kuill’s catchphrase “I have spoken.”
I loved this episode when I watched it and then found out that many were disappointed. I don't expect a major plot arc until the last one or two eps anyway, this had more major impact on the story than I even expected. And it was a bunch of fun! Felt like classic Clone Wars but IRL.
I feel like many don't really do expectations well. They seem to want to have the show go exactly the way they want and any other way is bad. I just want to enjoy what I get and some things might be more enjoyable but I don't try to have any expectations beforehand at all really. And I feel like often you understand the vision or the space the story or medium overall tries to go for and that makes more things enjoyable in life. I don't have to want to create the same art as others but I can still appreciate their vision and what they ended up with.
I'm happy to watch ANY Star Wars content, like you guys said: seeing new places, species, backgrounds, lore, EVERYTHING in any form, even if the "main quest" takes a bit of time, It's Star Wars, It's supposed to be fun and silly alongside all the darkness. BoBF included, Obi Wan Kenobi too. In TV you can immerse yourself more in the world. More Star Wars will always be entertaining to me, and I feel bad for people that It doesn't satisfy (even if It's their right of course).
Damn man, this is easily becoming my favorite channel. I really cant afford Patreon right now, but I'm about to work it into my budget just to support these guys.
First the Beskar Spear and now the Darksaber; Mando Now Really needs a new weapon. {Here's to hoping when he joined back up with the covert, the Armorer restocked him with new whistling birds}. Or at least a New Melee Weapon along with/besides his Vibro-knife.
@@Aquilarden Well I feel like he really needs a new melee weapon. I feel like it would just come in handy in certain situations; such as just like when he had to fight the Dark Troopers where all of his shooting arsenal were rendered useless; and same thing against the Scorpenek droids
Look, I am LOVING the world building they are doing this season!! I cant stand everyone trying to set everything up and resolve it in ONE season. We have so much more to look forward to, they just need to calm down and enjoy the ride!!
Thanks for this review, guys! I really enjoyed it and can't understand all the online hate about this. Also, that Mon Cal prince at the beginning was mentioned in the very first Mando Episode--he was one of the bounties offered by Carga in the bar that is now a school, I am pretty sure.
15:54 I'm sorry but when Hector said he'll cosplay as Dr. Pershing, I just lost it! Yes, please, do it. That'll be amazing 😁 Love your reactions, Heroes Reforged!
Thanks, Adam! Thanks, Hector! 👑 How fabulous to see *Lizzo* as 'the Duchess', *Jack* *Black* as 'Captain Bombardier' and *Christopher* *Lloyd* as 'Commissioner Helgait'?! #HeroesReforged #StarWars #Lizzo #JackBlack #ChristopherLloyd #TheMandalorian
Such a joyous episode and such a fun analysis of an episode that has been criminally slammed. How the Cameo players inhabited their characters made me smile. It's been a minute since we've seen the foppish courtier let alone the "Fairy Princess" ie The Duchess rolling by like a 30's swashbuckler movie. Mr. Lloyd as the heavy (he would've gotten away with it too if it wasn't for those meddling Mandos) was a slice of Scooby Doo. The 'Droid bar brought up not only some good philosophical points but the reality that for them, The New Republic Sucks! Seems that Placia 15 is a great place for second chances all around. The Heroes Reforged are correct in thier assessment of letting the story run its course. Such a fun ride in fact and deed!
I love the youtubers I can count on not to just enjoy the thing & not shit on certain episodes/media for seemingly arbitrary reasons. Loved your excitement in this. I had a lot fun watching it as well.
The moon of Paraquat is either this lonely deserted place or it's like Rura Penthe in Star Trek. Calling it now, even if we never get to see it in Star Wars media.
I like that even in these fun, side-questy episodes there are sprinklings of information about the universe as a whole which enrich the whole experience, it's interesting to see that there are groups still believing in the separatist movement.... it's interesting to see that all the imperial combat drones were repurposed but that that reprogramming can be redone... it doesn't all have to be strict to the narrative of the arc, I just enjoy being in the world.
I'm so grateful for your channel. This whining tiktok attention span commentators are truly pissing me off. Can anyone explain the purpose of hate watching? Because it seems like a waste of life for me. Thank you for being reasonable and enthusiastic.
This is my favorite episode yet! I love cameos like this and I actually like stuff being more "goofy" than overly serious like Andor was. It keeps my attention way more personally.
anyone else feel Logan's Run being the heart of the plot? (Movie not book) Domed city, hyper loops, sandmen hunting down a droid appearing refusal to "renew" maybe i'm stretching... but i loved it.... and pumped if that movie ever gets a remake HOW BEAUTIFUL it will be
Thank you so much for your positive response and feedback. It is so refreshing and fun to watch! And you are right, this is part of world building. Honestly right after I watched it the first time I was left somewhat disappointed. But going back and rewatching it and watching all the reactors it has given me a different perspective and point of view. It's not my favorite but it was fun, funny, new and interesting. Regardless this show can do no wrong in my eyes. Can't wait for final two episodes! PS.. Major missed opportunity with Christopher Lloyd saying "Great Scott" 😂
You guys-thank you, than k you, THANK YOU!!! 🥰🥰🥰❣❣❣ This has to be one of the funnest, uplifting reaction vids of this episode-so many of us loved it! I always love how infectious your positivity, inclusion and love is for SW and this ep is a prime example of that! Keep doing what you do! ❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥
The hesitation for Axe Woves after Din asks if the Darksaber belongs to her makes me think he was just saying that because he wanted anyone by a Child of the Watch to have it.
One of the criticisms about The Force Awakens that stuck with me as an enjoyer of media on a spiritual level was "The movie delivered everything we expected, and absolutely nothing we didn't even know we wanted". The review itself is beside the point, my biggest takeaway is the expression "what I didn't even know I wanted": always be open to things that I didn't know I wanted to see. Definitely have expectations, but don't be watching with a judgmental stance about how the media matches with the expectation you had. No matter how good the version of the story in your head was going to be, that's not the only good outcome there could have been, not even necessarily the best. First point, that's going to ruin your own experience. Something goes off track from your expectations and already all you do as you watch is complain and think about what should have been and not looking into where the show actually is going. Which brings to the second point, your judgment is going to be horrible. You stopped paying attention to what's actually happening and why and how, how would you make a proper deep dive and analysis? That's how you end up with ridiculous takes. (Like for example this episode, I've seen comments that Disney is disrespecting Din as evident from the Duchess knighting Grogu after Din did the hard work and, like, are you serious?) It's really great to watch level-headed reactions like yours, enjoying the ride and able to understand and analyze. Forces of positivity are really what all of us could benefit from.
I don’t get the dislike for this episode. I enjoyed it very much. I’m currently watching clone wars for the first time and this legit felt like a live action episode of later season clone wars. I can’t wait to see how Plazir and its inhabitants fit in later down the line
Great reaction. Even better explanation on how you judge episodes, and the season as a whole (one that I share). For myself, this was a fun excursion, tied in with THREE all-star cameos, giving the feel of a live-action version of Clone Wars. Even with this side adventure, like with other episodes, you never know what might be important down the line...be it for the current season, future seasons, and/or even for another production(s). The episode didn't need to pivot back to the larger story arc. Yet, considering how it was done (and the time factored in), I'm happy with the execution. Now, we have two remaining episodes in a season that gives me a feel that it's building up to something much grander than itself (and emphasized in SWCE 2023).
Part of my take with this episode, which I actually liked better than last week which had to contend with a massively great end of the Bad Batch. Is that Jack Black's character was to show the Amnesty program is not all rotten to the core. That there are good people who want to do right by their new circumstance. He easily could have been the baddie and was meant to question whether he was due to the A on his chest. I think it shows us that not everything about the program is failing just as the New Republic is not working as hoped but not completely a disaster as well. At the end of the day I thought it was a CSI galaxy episode with a critical end. I think head canon is messing everyone up... Grogu must be a Mando-jedi, Din will be the Mand'alor, what if neither of those are correct. What if Grogu just wants to be a good him and his dad just wants that too. Also wanting to skip to the point, to me that ignores the fact that side stories can definitely contribute to amazing stories.
I also agree that I wont watch everything if it doesn't work to me. I am not a fan of Andor so I have not watched it. I am sure there are ideas that people love about it but for me I am very different in what I want from Star Wars.
I’ve been asking for weeks why the dark saber didn’t transfer to Bo after she defeated the one eyed alien that defeated din. I’m so glad they finally addressed it.
Naw I had fun with this episode. I was so stoked when I saw Jack Black and Christopher Lloyd. I didn’t know she was Lizzo until the credits though. It felt like when you play an RPG and get engrossed in one of the side quests, which has some character beats for 2 out of the 6 members of your party which only makes you appreciate the story even more.
I appreciate your reaction to this episode. This seems to be everyone's example of "Star Wars falling off" but I genuinely found it a fun episode. Jack Black and Lizzo didn't really take me out. The acting was a little off in places but people saying Season 1 and 2 are peak and S3 is mid is beyond me. It's like everyone forgot how many episodes in S1 and 2 had rough acting (i.e. the prison break episode)
I saw this episode and realized I wanted a decteive series set in the SW universe so bad! Really insightful stuff as always homies, on the Armour Wars thing producer Nate Moore said they pivoted from a TV series to a movie cause the story they have is have big and expanse it can only be done justice on the big screen.
You guys made an excellent point about season length. We use to have to wait 24 episodes for plot payoff, and sometimes we didn't and it extended to the finale of the following season. People are FAR too spoiled by the episode count of these mini-seasons when it comes to setup and payoff
I appreciate your conversations at the end so much. After seeing the criticisms for this episode some of them are fair but I don’t care because I had so much fun with this one.
15:30 “Never pounce on an advantage as soon as it appears. Wait til it stands to have maximum effect” Din knew that shit and deliberately waited for a moment like this. Otherwise, I don’t think they would have believed it had the hand off been done right away.
I think Din would prefer to continue being the lone cowboy rather than be the leader, and Bo being the leader is just awesome. Love you guys for constantly being excited and amazed with the stories we get.
Since we have been seeing multiple people in the Amnesty Program like Jack Black’s character, I wonder if most of these people will back to/join the New Order.
Hector hit the nail on the head. This episode is a fun sidequest in the best way. I didn't play a lot of Mass Effect, but this episode felt like a mission you could play in that game. People can complain all they want about the cameos, but the Star Wars universe is a weird place. Jack Black and Lizzo don't stand out in a universe with Samuel L. Jackson and Harrison Ford. Considering how the next episode went down, people were crapping all over a great episode before another one rolled around. Bryce Dallas Howard did an excellent job with this episode. She definitely should direct a movie soon based on this episode and her previous ones. Edit: I really hope that Heroes Reforged can do those cosplay ideas. That would be awesome.
I find it interesting that everyone is writing off this episode, but Din and Bo now have official relations with a planet that uses domed cities that are similar to what was on Mandalor. I can easily see this as laying the groundwork for the eventual rebuilding of their planet.
The Ugnauhts are going to help with IG-11, too.
Yeah it's like a lot of people are ignoring this. They're saying everything but the end was filler, which is just completely false
@@niehoe3048 hard to know if it is false until the season ends. I think it will be interesting to see where it goes over the final two episodes.. I have spoken ;-)
Especially since Bombardier was responsible for rebuilding Plaisir 15.
Especially since Bombardier was responsible for rebuilding Plaisir 15.
Thanks for saying it! I'm so tired of the complaints. For the first two seasons, people whined about not having enough exploration of Mandalorians, now that we are meeting and exploring Mandalorians and their factions, people are whining about not enough Din or Grogu. I'm sorry, they said this season would be about uniting the Mandalorians and reclaiming Mandalore... didn't they? Din NEVER WANTED THE DARKSABER...he isn't power hungry. BO SAW THE MYTHOSAUR FOR A REASON...and Bo earned respect from the CotW through those "filler" episodes. Geez. Can't make anyone happy, I guess.
Exactly, thank you!
+1 This. 👆🏼
I love Grogu and Mando, but honestly - we already got enough and they still have the same relationship. Now we are finally focusing on Mandalorians as a whole story of the title culture. Its finally what I wanted from the start for it to be - exploring titular mandalorian and his 'tribe'. Series 3 ending with their mission of retaking the home planet and uniting the clans couldnt be more fitting for a show with such title! Also SPOILER FOR EP 7 --- ... ---> empire general fascinated with Mandalorian culture and making his own imperial-mandalorian squad to fight them? P-E-R-F-E-C-T! I would also be fine with them making time jump during next season. Perhaps if they retake Mandalore, Grogu could grow up there a bit to the next level of speech at least? Take his relationship with his 'father' master to next level. We know he wont grow up much, as he is from the species that ages super slow, but we could take it at least this far with him as a youngling.
Jack Black and Lizzo actually looked perfectly normal for the surroundings of this episode. Christopher Lloyd killing it in his monologue
I agree. My gut check for 'Does this feel like Star Wars?' with all these series is: Would this thing (character/ship/planet) fit in an episode of The Clone Wars series? Personally I can see 100% of Plazier 15 coming right out of that setting. For me, it worked.
Count Dooku was a visionary! Imagine being a loyal separatist for 30 years at least. I was glad to see those battle droids and prequels-era references.
Im gonna give the rest of the season a chance but tbh to say say that Lizzo and Jack Black felt "normal" to me indicates a lack of imagination. I don't have a problem with either of them IRL but to me it broke immersion to have them in this. They could've easily brought in some unknowns wearing the exact same costumes and reading exact same lines and it would've worked better imo
@@ericlopez5218 The Star Wars Universe has no limits in the types of people and cultures it can possess. Just look at Earth with 8 billion people, and now imagine a galaxy with 500 trillion people. It would wholly unrealistic if there weren’t people like Jack Black, and Lizzo in that universe.
That dress tho. Perfect. I want to cosplay that dress.
EASTER EGG ALERT: Seth Gabel (Fringe) is the voice of the Droid bartender, he is the husband of Bryce Dallas Howard who directed this episode.
Ditto to pretty much everyone else. Love your takes on the validity of this episode.
A couple favorite things for me were:
1. The call back to the Ugnaughts. That was so awesome. I loved that they tied that back in.
2. The droid perspective. Before this episode, I hadn’t considered that the imperial tech they were decommissioning included droids, because they’re so much more than just tech / machinery. It’s another way the New Republic is misstepping.
The sparkpad they found on the droid...it's a "matchbook". They found a bar matchbook on a body. Proper detectives. 😄
it was such a good "buddy cop" episode
Wait, wait...
Do droids use death sticks? 🤔
This season has been fantastic; these "side-quests" help expand the universe, and add character building moments.
Your reactions to the guest appearances were everything I wanted and more! Loved this episode as the series continues to give us insight into the state of the galaxy overall. 👍
I love that you guys always seem to have the most fun with these cooky episodes that flesh out the world. Almost everyone else I've watched has complained about this episode vehemently. I'm in the same boat that I just wanna experience as much of this world as possible. Why wouldn't there be a post-Imperial Wall-E world that is totally utopian with a Separatist sympathizer. There's all kinds of crazy shit still going on in the universe at large. This is also huge development for Bo and Din. They have so much respect for one another now and Bo can finally bring everyone together. I expect 7 and 8 to be big potentially crossover episodes. This season has been so incredible. Have loved every second of it.
This is my favorite episode yet! I love cameos like this and I actually like stuff being more "goofy" than overly serious like Andor was. It keeps my attention way more personally.
I love cozy episodes like these. Do you know any other reactors who reacted to this episode like them?
@@keithredacted8154 I thought Preview'd had pretty similar reactions. They had a good time with this episode as well. I watch like 10 different channels, but I always watch Preview'd first, then Heroes Reforged if I can help it, then Reel Rejects and whoever else after that. The Rejects were a lot more critical of this episode in the grand scheme of things, but Jay and Adam over at Preview'd always have a good time with this cameo stuff and the more fun exploring the universe at large bits. :)
@@fuzzyotterpaws4395 I can do either/or, but like, Star Wars has always been campy and over the top. It's why I loved Book of Boba Fett so much. It told, imo, a good and fresh story about a beloved character, expanded the current universe a bit more, and didn't take itself too seriously. Danny Trejo training a Rancor for Boba Fett to ride wasn't on my bingo card, but I fuckin' loved it. 😂 I think episode 5 is still my favorite so far this season because seeing Din, Paz, and Bo all on the same page made me really emotional for some reason, like Din has finally earned the respect of his Covert.
If Din just had said "This is the Way" after her gave Bo back the Dark Saber would have given me more goosebumps along with the music would have been so cool!!!
Ad someone who loves this episode my heart was broke watching others reviews. Then Yall give me hope, thank you. I'll always be here will you guys on this beautiful ride.
Is it a New Hope?
Nerdy Nightly channel perfectly put to thought and explained everything about this episode and season. Shame more people don't see it too, too blinded by their own expectations -kinda like with a lot of SW projects too-
I love that them and Blind Wave were so positive about this episode and had a good talk about it.. I loved it too.
@@Andjelka99 I came here to say this. Their review after the reaction was perfect.
@@stevemcgowen they didn't even go to celebration. 🤷 I don't think they rolled out the red carpet for blind Wave either. Lol
This episode is so much fun. One of my favorites so far.
This is my favorite episode yet! I love cameos like this and I actually like stuff being more "goofy" than overly serious like Andor was. It keeps my attention way more personally.
I appreciate you guys SO MUCH. I saw the shenanigans on the internet after this episode and was like ew i need the HR guys and their enthusiastic commitment to have a great time watching Star Wars BECAUSE WATCHING STAR WARS IS A GREAT TIME! And you never disappoint. Thanks homies.
Great comments Hermanos! I'm so happy that I'm not alone in how we are watching our favorite & loved shows! And giving shows a chance! 🤩👍
I’ve just gotta say how refreshing it is to see you guys respond so enthusiastically to this episode, after seeing so many negative reactions to it. You guys are just here the ride, embracing the wacky guest stars, and generally rolling with it…checking impatience at the door. Like Hector said, enjoying the journey. 🙂
Some less noticeable guest stars - the alien couple at the start were the actress who played Jefferson's wife Lynn on "Black Lightning" and Tom Holland's brother.
Adam and Hector...I love Star Wars! I fell in love with it in 1977 at the age of 10. I am so appreciative that we continue having stories told to us to enjoy. As for this season of Mandalorian, I have loved it so far and expect an awesome 2 final episodes. 💕
People have no patience these days. When I was a little kid , I watched 22 episode tv shows and if there was a cliffhanger, god forbid...I had to wait ALL SUMMER to find out what happened in the Fall premiere. I for one, LOVE the environments, character builds and seeing how all the other people in this galaxy are doing cuz when the hardcore shit eventually comes down and our protagonists have to put the pedal to the metal, we will know what is at stake.
I left this episode with a warmth and joy that was hard to figure out. It really reminded me of the 80's and 90's Scifi zaniness that made me fall in love with the genre.
It sucks that not everyone is enjoying the season but I like how this father and son we grew to love are having such a deep impact on the mandalorians as a whole.
This episode felt like a Scooby Doo mystery 😂 "it was old man Jenkins all along!"
Again, gotta love the positive attitude and optimism towards this episode! It definitely wasn’t my favorite, but watching it with you guys provides me with a different prospective I really appreciate
I feel like I'm the only one who got "I, Robot" vibes from this episode. The droid bar tender not saying, " We don't serve your kind here" was a missed opportunity though. And the music during the fight between Bo and Ax Wolves (badass name number two this season, the other being Ragnar Vizla) is sick.
“Hey, nice to meet you, I’m Steve.”
“A pleasure to meet you as well, I’m AX.”
“Like the weapon?”
“Like the weapon.”
They made it up with "Guess they don't get many of our kind in here".
Well they referenced it by having Din's line about how they don't get our kind here. I also think it would've been out of character for the bartender to have said that because it's fairly antagonistic, but the droids are really subservient and gentle and would probably not say something like that.
@@hugomendoza5665 exactly. It wouldn’t have fit the situation nor the characterization they were going for.
Hector, the difference between you and the other folks you’ve been visiting on the other channels is that you enjoy and respect the work. Both of you - all three of you - understand and honor the creative process and evolution. The critics (if you can call them critics) are cynical. They are egoistic… sorry for the insult to them. I LOVE YOUR CELEBRATORY TONE.
The bartender's voice was Seth Gabel. I loved him in Fringe and Big Sky.
This is my comfort show. I love it so much. I despise fanbois and their entitlement. If they stopped to think for five minutes, the amount of amazing content we're getting. I mean, sometimes I can't believe I can watch something like this show in my TV or laptop. Come on! I'm so glad you guys are so great, I love how positive you are :)
Nobody is talking about how happy the darksaber sounds when Bo ignites it. It makes a much calmer sound when she wields it. It's supposed to be in her care.
Good to hear Adam and Hector understand how story telling works. I have spoken.
I only watch reactors now who appreciate the world of star wars, you guys, blindwave and the reel rejects. No matter how you feel about the episode, this is all ground work for the world and I for one am loving it! The work that goes into this is amazing! The costums, make-up, worlds, relationships that are being created. It is great, you can see the love that is put into it.
This all will be a set up for years to come, lets enjoy it❤
Grogu 's reaction to hearing lizzo's character saying her and her husband had fell in love was hilarious. 😂
I think Bo will be a great leader .
Hope we see Boba or even another force wielding character?
Can't wait to see .😊
I really enjoyed this episode. It was so much fun to watch. The guest stars were great - seeing Lizzo and Grogu interacting was precious. I liked the interplay between Bo-Katan and Din when conducting the investigation, and the scenes with the Ugnaughts and in the droid bar was wonderful. Some cool action throughout, especially the Mandalorian fight. And, the ending with Bo-Katan left me very excited for more. Everything I enjoy about Star Wars.
was so excited for the last few days waiting for your guys reactions to all of the actors in this ep
i appreciate the open takes u guys have almost everyone trashed the episode and didnt enjoy it for what it was. A fun episode with fun cameos u guys are the best keep it up
I love you fellassszzzzz! Totes agree on the annoying comments people have on a series that isn't even done yet. Just watch it and STFU.. if ya don't like it, well then don't watch it. it's really simple. 😁
I totally love this show, and this episode. I totally agree with you guys. I;m 58, and had to sit through 24 to 32 episodes of any show in the past. And not every episode was worth sitting through. Where this has been the best, and I wish we were getting more, and having trouble understanding why people aren't enjoying it.
I remember hearing Christopher Lloyd would appear, but I never expected to see Jack Black and Lizzo. And I definitely didn’t expect Din to say Kuill’s catchphrase “I have spoken.”
I loved this episode when I watched it and then found out that many were disappointed. I don't expect a major plot arc until the last one or two eps anyway, this had more major impact on the story than I even expected. And it was a bunch of fun! Felt like classic Clone Wars but IRL.
I feel like many don't really do expectations well. They seem to want to have the show go exactly the way they want and any other way is bad. I just want to enjoy what I get and some things might be more enjoyable but I don't try to have any expectations beforehand at all really. And I feel like often you understand the vision or the space the story or medium overall tries to go for and that makes more things enjoyable in life. I don't have to want to create the same art as others but I can still appreciate their vision and what they ended up with.
I'm happy to watch ANY Star Wars content, like you guys said: seeing new places, species, backgrounds, lore, EVERYTHING in any form, even if the "main quest" takes a bit of time, It's Star Wars, It's supposed to be fun and silly alongside all the darkness. BoBF included, Obi Wan Kenobi too. In TV you can immerse yourself more in the world.
More Star Wars will always be entertaining to me, and I feel bad for people that It doesn't satisfy (even if It's their right of course).
Damn man, this is easily becoming my favorite channel. I really cant afford Patreon right now, but I'm about to work it into my budget just to support these guys.
I can't believe some people are talking shit about this episode. It was awesome!
First the Beskar Spear and now the Darksaber; Mando Now Really needs a new weapon. {Here's to hoping when he joined back up with the covert, the Armorer restocked him with new whistling birds}. Or at least a New Melee Weapon along with/besides his Vibro-knife.
He needs a new weapon in general, since he lost his rifle in The Tragedy.
@@Aquilarden Well I feel like he really needs a new melee weapon. I feel like it would just come in handy in certain situations; such as just like when he had to fight the Dark Troopers where all of his shooting arsenal were rendered useless; and same thing against the Scorpenek droids
FR he's out here with that dinky pistol as his only primary weapon
Don't forget about his disintegrating pulse rifle before that. Got destroyed when the Razor Crest was.
The mans a Gun Slinger not a Melee specialist
Look, I am LOVING the world building they are doing this season!! I cant stand everyone trying to set everything up and resolve it in ONE season. We have so much more to look forward to, they just need to calm down and enjoy the ride!!
Missed Agustin for the Jack Black reveal, would’ve been great haha. happy late birthday to the homie tho
The technician you recognized is Jen Kober - she's from my hometown, so every few minutes I was pleasantly surprised by who was in this episode.
Thanks for this review, guys! I really enjoyed it and can't understand all the online hate about this. Also, that Mon Cal prince at the beginning was mentioned in the very first Mando Episode--he was one of the bounties offered by Carga in the bar that is now a school, I am pretty sure.
I agree with you too, Adam 25:47 . It’s fun, it’s about enjoying it together.
15:54 I'm sorry but when Hector said he'll cosplay as Dr. Pershing, I just lost it! Yes, please, do it. That'll be amazing 😁 Love your reactions, Heroes Reforged!
Thanks, Adam! Thanks, Hector! 👑 How fabulous to see *Lizzo* as 'the Duchess', *Jack* *Black* as 'Captain Bombardier' and *Christopher* *Lloyd* as 'Commissioner Helgait'?! #HeroesReforged #StarWars #Lizzo #JackBlack #ChristopherLloyd #TheMandalorian
Such a joyous episode and such a fun analysis of an episode that has been criminally slammed. How the Cameo players inhabited their characters made me smile. It's been a minute since we've seen the foppish courtier let alone the "Fairy Princess" ie The Duchess rolling by like a 30's swashbuckler movie. Mr. Lloyd as the heavy (he would've gotten away with it too if it wasn't for those meddling Mandos) was a slice of Scooby Doo. The 'Droid bar brought up not only some good philosophical points but the reality that for them, The New Republic Sucks! Seems that Placia 15 is a great place for second chances all around. The Heroes Reforged are correct in thier assessment of letting the story run its course. Such a fun ride in fact and deed!
I love the youtubers I can count on not to just enjoy the thing & not shit on certain episodes/media for seemingly arbitrary reasons.
Loved your excitement in this. I had a lot fun watching it as well.
The moon of Paraquat is either this lonely deserted place or it's like Rura Penthe in Star Trek. Calling it now, even if we never get to see it in Star Wars media.
Y’all are the best!
I like that even in these fun, side-questy episodes there are sprinklings of information about the universe as a whole which enrich the whole experience, it's interesting to see that there are groups still believing in the separatist movement.... it's interesting to see that all the imperial combat drones were repurposed but that that reprogramming can be redone... it doesn't all have to be strict to the narrative of the arc, I just enjoy being in the world.
Great Great Reaction! Thank yall for just enjoying the journey!
Love your energy reacting to this show. You are amazing!
I'm so grateful for your channel. This whining tiktok attention span commentators are truly pissing me off. Can anyone explain the purpose of hate watching? Because it seems like a waste of life for me. Thank you for being reasonable and enthusiastic.
It gets clicks which is $$ that's why.
@@raybernal6829 Depressing if anything
Hector, I love your bookshelf!
This is my favorite episode yet! I love cameos like this and I actually like stuff being more "goofy" than overly serious like Andor was. It keeps my attention way more personally.
anyone else feel Logan's Run being the heart of the plot? (Movie not book) Domed city, hyper loops, sandmen hunting down a droid appearing refusal to "renew" maybe i'm stretching... but i loved it.... and pumped if that movie ever gets a remake HOW BEAUTIFUL it will be
Your take on this episode and the impatient fans was such a refreshing take. You have gained a sub 😁
Welcome aboard!
Agree 100% with what you guys said about people who complain about the show this year. It’s not for everybody and that’s ok. Enjoy the ride
Captain Bombardier, Grand Admiral Thrawn, and Moff Gideon were the ones that spearheaded the First Order and brought back Palp.
I believe fun fact the actor who portrayed the runaway prince/lover boy was Tom Holland's brother.
Can't wait for your next cosplays, guys!!
I kinda figured that Bo Katan would end up with the Darksaber eventually, since Din was terrible using it and wasn't really getting any better.
Thank you so much for your positive response and feedback. It is so refreshing and fun to watch! And you are right, this is part of world building. Honestly right after I watched it the first time I was left somewhat disappointed. But going back and rewatching it and watching all the reactors it has given me a different perspective and point of view. It's not my favorite but it was fun, funny, new and interesting. Regardless this show can do no wrong in my eyes. Can't wait for final two episodes!
PS.. Major missed opportunity with Christopher Lloyd saying "Great Scott" 😂
I love the BDH cameo too
You guys-thank you, than k you, THANK YOU!!! 🥰🥰🥰❣❣❣ This has to be one of the funnest, uplifting reaction vids of this episode-so many of us loved it! I always love how infectious your positivity, inclusion and love is for SW and this ep is a prime example of that! Keep doing what you do! ❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥
Been waiting to see your reactions for all the cameos! Christopher Lloyd is still the coolest!
The hesitation for Axe Woves after Din asks if the Darksaber belongs to her makes me think he was just saying that because he wanted anyone by a Child of the Watch to have it.
One of the criticisms about The Force Awakens that stuck with me as an enjoyer of media on a spiritual level was "The movie delivered everything we expected, and absolutely nothing we didn't even know we wanted". The review itself is beside the point, my biggest takeaway is the expression "what I didn't even know I wanted": always be open to things that I didn't know I wanted to see. Definitely have expectations, but don't be watching with a judgmental stance about how the media matches with the expectation you had. No matter how good the version of the story in your head was going to be, that's not the only good outcome there could have been, not even necessarily the best. First point, that's going to ruin your own experience. Something goes off track from your expectations and already all you do as you watch is complain and think about what should have been and not looking into where the show actually is going. Which brings to the second point, your judgment is going to be horrible. You stopped paying attention to what's actually happening and why and how, how would you make a proper deep dive and analysis? That's how you end up with ridiculous takes. (Like for example this episode, I've seen comments that Disney is disrespecting Din as evident from the Duchess knighting Grogu after Din did the hard work and, like, are you serious?)
It's really great to watch level-headed reactions like yours, enjoying the ride and able to understand and analyze. Forces of positivity are really what all of us could benefit from.
This episode reminds me of the early Marvel and LA Times comics. The ones published between ANH and TESB. The Jaxxon years, if you will. Love it!
I loved the nods to other TV shows and movies. Alice in Wonderland, Romeo & Juliet, I, Robot, Logan's Run, and CSI. Such much fun.
Reminded me a lot of the scene in IRobot, when will is trying to figure out which robot is sentient
I don’t get the dislike for this episode. I enjoyed it very much. I’m currently watching clone wars for the first time and this legit felt like a live action episode of later season clone wars.
I can’t wait to see how Plazir and its inhabitants fit in later down the line
Great reaction. Even better explanation on how you judge episodes, and the season as a whole (one that I share).
For myself, this was a fun excursion, tied in with THREE all-star cameos, giving the feel of a live-action version of Clone Wars. Even with this side adventure, like with other episodes, you never know what might be important down the line...be it for the current season, future seasons, and/or even for another production(s). The episode didn't need to pivot back to the larger story arc. Yet, considering how it was done (and the time factored in), I'm happy with the execution. Now, we have two remaining episodes in a season that gives me a feel that it's building up to something much grander than itself (and emphasized in SWCE 2023).
Loved this
IMO People need to chill and just enjoy.
Really wanted Mando and JB to have a rock off
I need that tshirt. Where can I get it
me watching Lady Katee fighting droids, "there are 12 models."
That’s the ship they jacked from Gideon at the end of season 2
Part of my take with this episode, which I actually liked better than last week which had to contend with a massively great end of the Bad Batch. Is that Jack Black's character was to show the Amnesty program is not all rotten to the core. That there are good people who want to do right by their new circumstance. He easily could have been the baddie and was meant to question whether he was due to the A on his chest.
I think it shows us that not everything about the program is failing just as the New Republic is not working as hoped but not completely a disaster as well. At the end of the day I thought it was a CSI galaxy episode with a critical end. I think head canon is messing everyone up... Grogu must be a Mando-jedi, Din will be the Mand'alor, what if neither of those are correct.
What if Grogu just wants to be a good him and his dad just wants that too.
Also wanting to skip to the point, to me that ignores the fact that side stories can definitely contribute to amazing stories.
I also agree that I wont watch everything if it doesn't work to me. I am not a fan of Andor so I have not watched it. I am sure there are ideas that people love about it but for me I am very different in what I want from Star Wars.
I’ve been asking for weeks why the dark saber didn’t transfer to Bo after she defeated the one eyed alien that defeated din. I’m so glad they finally addressed it.
Naw I had fun with this episode. I was so stoked when I saw Jack Black and Christopher Lloyd. I didn’t know she was Lizzo until the credits though.
It felt like when you play an RPG and get engrossed in one of the side quests, which has some character beats for 2 out of the 6 members of your party which only makes you appreciate the story even more.
I appreciate your reaction to this episode. This seems to be everyone's example of "Star Wars falling off" but I genuinely found it a fun episode. Jack Black and Lizzo didn't really take me out. The acting was a little off in places but people saying Season 1 and 2 are peak and S3 is mid is beyond me. It's like everyone forgot how many episodes in S1 and 2 had rough acting (i.e. the prison break episode)
I saw this episode and realized I wanted a decteive series set in the SW universe so bad! Really insightful stuff as always homies, on the Armour Wars thing producer Nate Moore said they pivoted from a TV series to a movie cause the story they have is have big and expanse it can only be done justice on the big screen.
I love your reactions. 👑 you, kyle katarn & struggle nation are my favourite reactors. #BePeace ✌🏽☯️
You guys made an excellent point about season length. We use to have to wait 24 episodes for plot payoff, and sometimes we didn't and it extended to the finale of the following season. People are FAR too spoiled by the episode count of these mini-seasons when it comes to setup and payoff
I appreciate your conversations at the end so much. After seeing the criticisms for this episode some of them are fair but I don’t care because I had so much fun with this one.
This episode reminds me of I-ROBOT in a weird way but a good way
Happy birthday, Augustin! Hope you're having a blast, bro! See you soon!
I didn't recognize Christopher Lloyd at all until the credits since I haven't seen him in much and he has less hair but the voice seemed familiar.
I love those Cosplay ideas Hector suggested.
15:30
“Never pounce on an advantage as soon as it appears. Wait til it stands to have maximum effect”
Din knew that shit and deliberately waited for a moment like this. Otherwise, I don’t think they would have believed it had the hand off been done right away.
Wasn't paraquat the chemical the police used to use tokill marijuana plants?
I think Din would prefer to continue being the lone cowboy rather than be the leader, and Bo being the leader is just awesome. Love you guys for constantly being excited and amazed with the stories we get.
Since we have been seeing multiple people in the Amnesty Program like Jack Black’s character, I wonder if most of these people will back to/join the New Order.
Awesome reaction 👍🏽👍🏽. Love the episode. 👌🏽
Hector hit the nail on the head. This episode is a fun sidequest in the best way. I didn't play a lot of Mass Effect, but this episode felt like a mission you could play in that game. People can complain all they want about the cameos, but the Star Wars universe is a weird place. Jack Black and Lizzo don't stand out in a universe with Samuel L. Jackson and Harrison Ford. Considering how the next episode went down, people were crapping all over a great episode before another one rolled around. Bryce Dallas Howard did an excellent job with this episode. She definitely should direct a movie soon based on this episode and her previous ones.
Edit: I really hope that Heroes Reforged can do those cosplay ideas. That would be awesome.
Grogu: Knight in the New Republic.
I absolutely agree, Hector. 22:39