Composer Reacts to Death - Crystal Mountain (REACTION & ANALYSIS)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 июл 2024
  • Bryan reacts to and talks about his thoughts on Crystal Mountain
    ORIGINAL VIDEO // • Crystal Mountain
    ALL LINKS // linktr.ee/criticalreactions
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 207

  • @Rose-From-the-Dead
    @Rose-From-the-Dead 3 года назад +217

    The drummer on this particular album is the legendary Gene Hoglan, considered by many to be one of, if not THE greatest metal drummer ever. He's been in other bands such as Testament, Strapping Young Lad, and I even saw him fill in for Opeth's drummer once.

    • @progperljungman8218
      @progperljungman8218 3 года назад +21

      Fear Factory, Forbidden etc etc. Still a member of Dark Angel 😊

    • @Markcello
      @Markcello 3 года назад +16

      @@progperljungman8218 Anthrax and Testament at the same night!

    • @GregDineen
      @GregDineen 3 года назад +12

      Sorry but the best metal drummer ever is Lars Ulrich lol

    • @progperljungman8218
      @progperljungman8218 3 года назад +9

      @@GregDineen Can actually "understand" why some people do think that - it's subjective, if you like the drumming the most it's the "best drumming". I do find it a strange oppinion though 😁

    • @mellowcorpsep6665
      @mellowcorpsep6665 2 года назад +8

      @@progperljungman8218 hes just joking lol

  • @voxstelarum
    @voxstelarum 3 года назад +56

    Chuck was ahead of its time by decades. Each Death album is a study on how to put new ideas into death metal

  • @angelz9841
    @angelz9841 3 года назад +95

    First half of Death's work is pretty standard death metal, but back then not many other bands were doing that. Second half is more progressive and has more melodic ideas mixed in. Also has some nice acoustic sections later on as well. I guess most people don't throw Death into the melodeath camp because most people associate melodeath with bands like Insomnium, Amon Amarth, Arch Enemy, At The Gates etc. Even when Death started to incorporate more melodic elements they still sound very different from those Swedish death metal bands. Just goes to show how experimental and unique Death really was! Their cover of Painkiller on their last album still blows my mind to this day. Chuck Schuldiner was hitting whistle fry notes before anyone even knew what the hell to call it.

    • @eetusuutari8354
      @eetusuutari8354 3 года назад +7

      Well yeah but Symbolic is pretty melodeath to me and a good starting point for getting into the genre

    • @johnmcdonald789
      @johnmcdonald789 7 месяцев назад +2

      We have human to thank for that chuck working with Paul Masdival abd Sean Reinert heavily improved his song writing ability that was already pretty good but human pushed it over the threshold

  • @mikelbentube
    @mikelbentube 3 года назад +158

    I think a lot of us started off hating screams, growls etc....but liked the music...then learnt to tolerate the vocals...then became indifferent...then kinda liked them....now love it!!

    • @CriticalReactions
      @CriticalReactions  3 года назад +38

      I could see that being the trend. Enjoying 90% of a song means we'll keep coming back and slowly acclimate to that 10%.

    • @isopropyltoxicity
      @isopropyltoxicity Год назад +5

      Exactly my same experience with death

    • @AgentNight1
      @AgentNight1 Год назад +1

      same here

    • @waltuh11121
      @waltuh11121 9 месяцев назад +2

      Yep. I started with Nirvana and here I am now, listening to Cryptopsy

    • @deaddycruel
      @deaddycruel 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@waltuh11121it's like moving from collecting shit to collecting gold :)

  • @pascalg16
    @pascalg16 3 года назад +36

    The thing is, there are many death metal bands with "melody" and harmony, but Melodic Death Metal is not just a characterisation, its an actual genre name.

  • @davidortega3968
    @davidortega3968 3 года назад +11

    Dude, Voice of the soul!

  • @ShadowFlame420
    @ShadowFlame420 3 года назад +32

    Yes! the 2nd half of Death's discography is fuckin great

    • @Bartman61911
      @Bartman61911 2 года назад +13

      So is the first half best straight Death metal you could find.

    • @zsjb_
      @zsjb_ 2 года назад +2

      Personally the mid era is my favourite, but all are amazing

  • @revocation3x
    @revocation3x 3 года назад +10

    Chuck was so beyond his time, such a legend

  • @Dave_Shredder
    @Dave_Shredder Год назад +8

    More DEATH please !! Anything from "Human" will do, it was such a game changer in death metal. Gene Hoglan drum style on "Symbolic" and "Individual Thought Patterns" was strongly inspired by the great Sean Reinert (R.I P.). It's basically a death metal album with a jazz drummer. I can't say enough good things about that album...

  • @progperljungman8218
    @progperljungman8218 3 года назад +19

    Death with band leader Chuck Schuldiner initiated death metal many years before. He also took the band into more melodic/progressive territories like this and the line-up here included the legendary drummer Gene "The atomic clock" Hoglan. Great stuff - glad you liked it!

    • @Cynips
      @Cynips 3 года назад +3

      Yeah, but even though Death were at the forefront of death metal, being truly progressive in many ways, this still isn't representative of original melo death (although influential in its own way). Would have been more appropriate to start the week off with At the Gates from -92, since they're considered to have started the so called Gothenburg Sound.

    • @progperljungman8218
      @progperljungman8218 3 года назад

      @@Cynips Do agree - a pity no one even suggested them for this theme's poll...

    • @thegrimner
      @thegrimner 3 года назад +1

      @@progperljungman8218 No ATG being suggested for melodeath? That is weird indeed.
      And I'd say Death are Melodeath adjacent, like Necroticism-Heartwork era Carcass, early Amorphis and Entombed and Dismember. They all added something to the genre, Death added the catchiness, Carcass the rock n' Roll, Amorphis the folksy leads and Dismember/Entombed the Boss Pedals on overdrive.
      My personal suggestions would be ATG- The Swarm, Dark Tranquility- Punish My Heaven, In Flames- Moonshield and Dissection- The Somberlain as the very oddball chioce that's more rooted in Black Metal aesthetics but still shares a fair bit of DNA.

    • @progperljungman8218
      @progperljungman8218 3 года назад

      @@thegrimner There was a good six suggestions of Swedish bands though (but neither ATG nor In Flames... Dark Tranquility, Soilwork and Amon Amarth being three prominent ones though.)

  • @MoiseDosSantos
    @MoiseDosSantos 3 года назад +37

    Glad you liked it ! I would say last 3-4 Death albums were more Prog Death than Melo Death but has elements of both ofc ... my fav is their last album sound of Perseverance... Death is one of those bands that has like no bad album/songs , their entire discography is flawless ! From the theashy death metal from their first albums to the progressive and melodic style in their last ones. So sad that Chuck passed away so early , he was a legend and an unbelievable musician and person! Looking forward for more Death in the future

    • @marcusrobertson5627
      @marcusrobertson5627 3 года назад +3

      I endorse everything in this comment, especially the first 2.5 lines

    • @Daedalus-ed5nd
      @Daedalus-ed5nd 2 года назад

      Also RIP Sean Reinert. Death (particularly Human) and Cynic were a very large part of my life between 16 and 25. Hell, still are.

  • @xcforce9067
    @xcforce9067 3 года назад +11

    Death is best defined as "technical death metal". Genre emerged in the early 90ies curtesy of bands like Death, Cynic and Atheist.
    I would recommend Charging the Void by Vektor as an example of more modern evolution of this genre. Compositionally its very interesting.

  • @tropiq
    @tropiq 3 года назад +9

    The genre name of death metal came from Possessed "Seven Churches" debut album that contained the "Death Metal" track, but Death the band helped solidify not only the name but also the style of the genre with their early work, later albums (like the one you listened here) expanded into what later became the basis for technical death and progressive metal, insanely influential band and even with many lineup changes always attracted mad talent
    when i first got into death the vocals didn't really fit with the music for me somehow, i only understood when i saw a live recording that the lead guitarist was also the vocalist and the lines fit into his guitar work, that's when it made sense timing wise, rest in peace Chuck

  • @GregsWhiskyGuide
    @GregsWhiskyGuide 3 года назад +25

    Ah, nice choice, Brian...but you have to listen to "Flattening of Emotions" or "Lack of Comprehension" from the Death "Human" (1991) album ! (probably their best, with for instance legendary bass player Steve Di Giorgio), I'm sure you'll be interested...Besides Death Metal genre started around 1985, often derived from Thrash Metal subgenre, while others came from Grindcore (but Death did "explode" success wise rather around 1990/1991, as often first albums of each were not necessarily the more representative of the genre yet & too raw) with main bands like Death (1987), Obituary (1989), Morbid Angel (1989), Possessed (1985), Bolt Thrower (1988), Carcass (1988), Immolation (1991), Suffocation (1991), Autopsy (1989), Nocturnus (1990), but also Sinister, Brutality, Benediction, Entombed, Deicide, Cannibal Corpse, Dismember, Massacre, Monstrosity, Malevolent Creation, Cancer, etc..."Melodeath" came later & often from Scandinavia, and Sweden in particular, with bands like At the Gates (though starting in 1992), Dark Tranquillity, In Flames, Dissection, Edge of Sanity, Omnium Gatherum, Insomnium, etc...

    • @ambassadortourettes753
      @ambassadortourettes753 3 года назад +2

      Great job on subdivisions on the way you outlined the bands listed👌

  • @FrankyGotTheBill
    @FrankyGotTheBill 11 дней назад +1

    Oh yeah for your information the "Pitch pick slide" you said, that effect is called "flanger" but there is ways to make a flange sound without the pedal, like you said, pick sliding, but you can just pick randomly, and do random natural harmonics. But they used a flanger pedal effect, some Death songs always have a flanger solo, or that riff. Just like this one, Chuck used a flanger in this song for the solo, including the the part before the solo starts. Not many people who covered this song with the flanger pedal, probably they don't notice it. But glad to see you notice the flanger effect.

  • @ryansadauskis
    @ryansadauskis 3 года назад +30

    D E A T H
    Let's go!!
    Also a cool thing to note is that Cynic's Paul Masvidal and Sean Reinert were members of Death before they formed Cynic. However, the only album they appeared on was "Human."

    • @GregsWhiskyGuide
      @GregsWhiskyGuide 3 года назад +2

      Yep, must do songs for me are "Flattening of Emotions" or "Lack of Comprehension" from "Human" album ! I'm sure Brian would be interested by the songs structures & I'm not even talking of the flawless performing of all members, including the mighty Steve Di Giorgio !

    • @DSoverPSP
      @DSoverPSP 3 года назад +5

      Technically Cynic were already around at the time Paul and Sean joined Death, but they were still in their early years with Tony Choy on bass (who later joined the tech death band Atheist) and hadn't yet put out their hugely influential first album Focus. They quit Death after touring for Human so they could get back to focusing on Cynic. I recently went through Death's full discography and you can really hear how big of a shift Human was for Death's sound, I like to imagine the Cynic boiz helped kickstart that process.

    • @GregsWhiskyGuide
      @GregsWhiskyGuide 3 года назад

      @@DSoverPSP Sure, Cynic has to be in...I wonder if Brian hasn't covered it yet, not sure

    • @DSoverPSP
      @DSoverPSP 3 года назад

      @@GregsWhiskyGuide I think he did one or two from them before but I don't remember. More Cynic is always welcome though Brian! Lol

    • @shryggur
      @shryggur 3 года назад +1

      @@DSoverPSP Yeah, he did two tracks but both from Traced. He liked one (Evolution Sleeper, selected by me) and disliked the other (Space for This, I believe). Still is to hear some from Focus, though...

  • @raen19
    @raen19 3 года назад +6

    Bryan reacting to Death - what an amazing start to my day! And there were several moments there that I KNEW it got you too, those "oooooh" moments that were great to see. Loved this analysis very much, thanks for doing it.
    Death was definitely at the forefront of the creation of death metal. Chuck Schuldiner (RIP), the vocalist/lead guitarist/songwriter and founding member of the band is considered to be the godfather of death metal. In fact, he's influenced the future of death metal several times - first, at the beginning of the genre that he (arguably) created. Then later, with the album Human, he set the stage for what would become the tech-death sub-genre. And then, with the album Symbolic (which Crystal Mountain comes from) he swung into a more melodic (though he always wrote melodic material) and progressive direction. Despite the fact that his music always included very similar elements, it somehow always managed to sound different and inventive. Every Death album was groundbreaking for its time, and the list of bands that he influenced is beyond count.
    Those people who told you that Death isn't 'Melodeath' are correct. Death is definitely melodic death metal, but it's not really the same as Melodeath. Hopefully by the end of the week you'll understand that one a bit better, when you've heard the other bands for comparison. I also love the idea that the 90's were the 70's of metal - you're absolutely right! The popularity of metal began to wane with the rise of grunge, which turned out to be a great thing. Metal in the 80's was typically charged with aggression, but in the 90's metal musicians got more of a chance to include other influences and techniques that wouldn't have been as popular in the 80's, and allowed metal to evolve into the far more complex collection of sub-genre's that we get to enjoy today. Death was at the forefront of that evolution all the way up to Chuck's eventual passing in 2001, and his music remains highly influential to this day.

    • @CriticalReactions
      @CriticalReactions  3 года назад +3

      Really great info here. I look forward to exploring the genre proper and seeing if I can nail down what separates melodeath from melodic death.

  • @mrmagoo8956
    @mrmagoo8956 2 года назад +3

    DEATH has so much going on in every song.
    The percussion is mind boggling, the riffs are pure adrenaline and the vocals / lyrics really hit you when you listen

  • @REDSIN1000
    @REDSIN1000 3 года назад +29

    R.i.p. Chuck Schuldiner You are missed. For me Death is Death Metal not Melodic Death Metal sometimes they touch the progressive.

  • @WhatDayIsItTrumpDay
    @WhatDayIsItTrumpDay 2 года назад +2

    When I was just but a 16 year old Junior in High School, in 1990, DEATH released their 3rd album "Spiritual Healing" and a fellow metalhead buddy in my Spanish class had this album upon its release and let me listen to it on his Walkman, and I was instantly hooked on the crazy tempo changes and everything else in DEATH's music. While I was never a huge Death Metal fan, bands that introduced a lot of tempo changes and melodic parts I could tolerate and yet into more. Bands like DEATH, Dimmu Borgir, Amon Amarth, Children of Bodom, Dark Tranquillity, and Norther were some that I have collected over the years. I tried getting into the 90s Florida Death Metal scene with bands like Deicide, Morbid Angel, Obituary, and Cannibal Corpse, and honestly, they were just too blast beat-ish and guttural for me. Obituary wasn't bad, and I could listen to them regularly, but the others were just noise to me. But you can't beat Chuck and DEATH. Despite not putting out a new album since 1999 because Chuck died in 2001, their music still sounds great today, especially if you can get the most recent remasters. Even their raw 1987 debut, "Scream Bloody Gore" sounds pretty good.

  • @kellyrankin8844
    @kellyrankin8844 3 года назад +8

    If you are willing to do another one from them, check out: Death - Sound of Perseverance - Flesh and the Power it Holds ..I feel like not doing something from that album would be missing out on where they evolved to.

  • @dbo0729
    @dbo0729 3 года назад +4

    If you want Death with clean vocals check out control denied which was chucks other band. It's literally this with clean vocals.

  • @khamutz2311
    @khamutz2311 2 года назад +4

    Death probably have one of the most unique music throughout history.. to literally put your name in front of an entire music genre is no small feat.

  • @BlackRoseImmortal
    @BlackRoseImmortal Месяц назад +1

    Their album "Sound of Perseverance" is incredible as is the second band Chuck started "Control Denied". They only made one album before Chuck died, but that album is incredible. Chuck doesn't sing in Control Denied.

  • @jeffersonaraujo7591
    @jeffersonaraujo7591 3 года назад +2

    Finally!!! Btw, death would be great on 'old VS new' week haha. And one more thing, Control Denied the last project that Chuck was envolved and it is basically a death without harsh vocals, so i think you should check it out.

  • @medicineman79
    @medicineman79 3 года назад

    I still remember the day I heard this album for the first time, at my friends house back in -95. The intro to Symbolic stuck with me and I bought the CD the day after. I still listen to them regularly.

  • @chotsbots
    @chotsbots 3 года назад +4

    I highly recommend checking out TesseracT - Concealing Fate suite. It pretty much scratches that itch of having the heaviness mixed with clean/aggressive vocals.

  • @Bradlyeon
    @Bradlyeon 3 года назад +3

    RIP CHUCK

  • @Danny_Inflames
    @Danny_Inflames Год назад +1

    ESTA CANCION ES UNA OBRA MAESTRA!!!!!!!!!
    Greetings From Chile dude!!🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

  • @chiquita_dave
    @chiquita_dave 3 года назад +1

    Hey Bryan! I just finished binging a ton of your videos the last few days. This album was my introduction to Death! Crystal Mountain is by far one of my favorites by them. The part that really sticks out to me is the drum work in the more spacey passages on the verses. To me, it really evokes the imagery of a mountain encased in crystal. I wouldn't *super* consider this melodeath but it certainly is death metal with melodic elements. Usually melodeath isn't as progressive as later Death is.
    For other melodeath bands, I would love to see you react to Dark Tranquillity - The Gallery or Kalmah - Hades, which was my introduction to the genre. If you are interested in something more progressive but stays true to the ideas of melodeath, I'd recommend Iapetus - The Star of Collapse.

    • @CriticalReactions
      @CriticalReactions  3 года назад +2

      We got some Dark Tranquillity coming up later today!

  • @agustinlopez2078
    @agustinlopez2078 3 года назад +2

    (old) In Flames, Dark Tranquillity, At the Gates, Hypocrisy, Insomnium, Be'lakor.. Those are great MDM bands to check

    • @ryukan250
      @ryukan250 2 года назад

      Throw in some Carcass, Edge of Sanity, Soilwork and Amon Amarth too

  • @marcusrobertson5627
    @marcusrobertson5627 3 года назад +3

    For more Death songs like this, check out stuff from their last 2 albums. I recommend Flesh and the Power It Holds; Spirit Crusher (the chorus of which /might/ sell you on Chuck Schuldiner's harsh vox); Symbolic (lyrics

  • @toni.tapola
    @toni.tapola Месяц назад +1

    Chuck 🤘!

  • @vladkillgore8266
    @vladkillgore8266 3 года назад +3

    As soon as you said. "if this is what melo death---" I was like, Be'lakor, Be'lakor!!

  • @Miguel0473
    @Miguel0473 Месяц назад

    Chuck started Death in 1983 as Mantas changing it to Death in 1984. Scream Bloody Gore album came up in 1987.

  • @ProgPro96
    @ProgPro96 3 года назад +4

    Like I said on Patreon, this song is both melodic and death metal but not melodic death metal. This is way proggier than regular melodeath. I would say bands like (early) In Flames, At The Gates and Dark Tranquillity are the pioneers of melodeath, and bands like Omnium Gatherum, In Mourning and Be'lakor are good examples of modern melodeath. The genre has evolved a lot over the years. I also think you've heard a few melodeath bands on this channel... Children Of Bodom, Amon Amarth, Persefone and The Agonist are some that I remember.

  • @tomopeth
    @tomopeth 3 года назад +3

    I'd say this is more akin to progressive death metal, to find more straight death metal you'd have to go further back into Death's catalouge (like Spiritual Healing or Pull the plug, from their earlier albums). From this album Perennial quest is a must!

  • @Maya_Ruinz
    @Maya_Ruinz 2 года назад +1

    Death has always been a breed apart, I remember as a ten year hearing this album was like a revelation.

  • @Nick_Har
    @Nick_Har 2 года назад +1

    Another great song by them is "Voice of the soul". It's an instrumental and small in duration I think you would love it

  • @squashedeyeball
    @squashedeyeball 3 года назад

    Another classic under your belt :)

  • @znmckague
    @znmckague 2 года назад

    The first death metal album is Possessed's Seven Churches featuring Larry Lalonde

  • @sethwinkleman2349
    @sethwinkleman2349 3 года назад +1

    Chuck Schuldiner, the frontman of Death, also formed a band with clean vocals called Control Denied

  • @hectorescobar9450
    @hectorescobar9450 4 месяца назад

    Voice of the Soul!

  • @arson86
    @arson86 2 года назад

    My favourite Death song. For other "melodeath" that leans more towards the technical side, I would recommend the song Arsis - Diamond for Disease (especially if you liked the guitar sections here). That one is a bit different from their other songs, with an almost classical structure at times and some really strong recurring melodies and transitions. (At 12 minutes it's also their longest song)

  • @FrostyFeet2018
    @FrostyFeet2018 3 года назад

    Woohoo, love this record!

  • @kevinmadden3396
    @kevinmadden3396 3 года назад +1

    Similar music, but with a clean vocalist, is Control Denied. Chuck Schuldiner wrote the music and played on it, but hired TIm Aymar to sing. Same bassist as on this track (Steve DiGiorgio) plus later-era Death members Richard Christy (drums) and Shannon Hamm (guitar).

  • @joshuanassir6487
    @joshuanassir6487 2 года назад +2

    Control Denied. Chuck (songwriter/vocalist/guitarist) didn't like doing vocals towards the end of Death and created Control Denied. If you want the same songwriting but with clean, strong vocals, check out that band. The first track on the album 'Consumed' would be a good choice.
    They only made one album, but it's one of my favorites of all time.

  • @liliIiliIilil
    @liliIiliIilil 3 года назад

    The Touch Tunes jukebox in bars used to have this song, not sure if it still does, but I used to play it all the time and the patrons usually did not react well.
    Absolute legends. But not melo-death. At The Gates is one of the OGs of that sub-subgenre (microgenre?). Also, someone else mentioned Control Denied -- That is this band's composer but with power metal singing.

  • @watakoe
    @watakoe 3 года назад

    Would love to see more Death!

  • @samuelegalli4844
    @samuelegalli4844 2 месяца назад +1

    I think Death is the only band that always doing killer songs. All their album work. If you want to listen to clear voice just look out for Control Denied,the last project of Chuck before he die😢

  • @cornelius8617
    @cornelius8617 Год назад

    Well this is one of the best death metal songs ever written. 👍

  • @HateMich
    @HateMich 3 года назад

    More Death please, you would love their late albums.

  • @FrostyFeet2018
    @FrostyFeet2018 3 года назад

    I wish I could hear the intricacies of music like you do

    • @CriticalReactions
      @CriticalReactions  3 года назад +2

      So it's actually something that anyone can learn with some practice. I do something called orchestral listening which is just a big phrase that means I hone in on each instrument individually. It starts out a bit difficult but the more you do it the easier it gets. Then I start asking questions about what I heard. Did any instruments share ideas? Have I heard anything similar before in other works? What does this combination of sounds mean? Finding the right questions takes a lot of practice (I've been doing it for over a decade) but like with anything else you'll get better the more you do it, especially as you explore a variety of music and can start to see larger patterns.

  • @olfrud
    @olfrud 5 месяцев назад

    As far as I know Chuck Schuldiner gravitated more towards clean vocals himself later in his life. I think with Control Denied he did more like Power Metal Vocals...such a shame he died so young. I listen to Death since I'm 16....I'm almost 40 now, it never gets old.

  • @manuele.itriagom.728
    @manuele.itriagom.728 Год назад +3

    What I love of this track (and pretty much most tracks from them) is that the drums are not quantized. If you hear the double bass, you realize he's not a machine and goes off and on tempo, that what I love about these recordings. They're human

  • @ac130kz
    @ac130kz Год назад

    You MUST listen to Chuck's last creation Control Denied, it has clean vocals and, in my opinion, one of the strongest albums he ever wrote

  • @naturalianoss
    @naturalianoss 6 месяцев назад

    You should listen the whole album .you will be amazed and turned into a fan

  • @soakedbearrd
    @soakedbearrd 2 года назад +2

    Death and Opeth singlehandedly got me into growls when before I hated.

  • @somberlight
    @somberlight 3 года назад

    alright; i´ll bite: 6:26
    Death metal of The Gothenburg Variety: Dark Tranquillity, with their song Forward Momentum.
    It might not be the magnum opus or anything, but as a track, it is very friendly to the ears while keeping true to their OWN core sound. Good "opener" if you will.

  • @Mohamedmifxal
    @Mohamedmifxal 2 года назад

    Bands that gives both punches and melodies are Kalmah, Carcass and Hypocrisy, and there are the good old swedish brand, with band like Dark Tranquility, In Flames and At the Gates.

  • @shagstars
    @shagstars Год назад

    if you dig deeper you find out that chucks screams are still melodic/dynamic in a way. later on its more noticable on their 1998 record.

  • @jesseh9600
    @jesseh9600 3 года назад

    If you want some cleans mixed in with melodic death you need to check out some in flames, some songs from dark tranquillity, soilwork, trivium (not straight up melodic death, but many melo-death influences).

  • @TexasFriedCriminal
    @TexasFriedCriminal Год назад

    Late comment, but Death music with clean vocals is Control Denied, the final project and album recorded by Schuldiner. The album is called The Fragile Art of Existence.

  • @PuppyFromH3ll
    @PuppyFromH3ll 2 года назад

    There are some great clean vocal demos on The Sound of Perseverance deluxe edition. Check em out!

  • @andrewwilson803
    @andrewwilson803 2 года назад

    If you enjoy Death then id also suggest checking out his "project band" before he passed. "Control Denied" definitely way different, but great in its own way.

  • @TheGrav666
    @TheGrav666 2 года назад +1

    Perhaps someone already suggested it here in the comments, but Chuck (guitarist/vocalist/songwriter) of Death had a separate project called Control Denied. It is essentially all the progressive elements found in the track you reacted to here, with the difference being all clean vocals. They released one proper album, The Fragile Art Of Existence, before Chuck left this earth.
    ruclips.net/video/32m0zj4kaRk/видео.html

  • @landrec2
    @landrec2 3 года назад

    208 upvotes with 99 comments. Holy crap that ratio. This song/album is fantastic. The vocals grow on you.

  • @HectorRodriguez-mp6ee
    @HectorRodriguez-mp6ee 11 месяцев назад

    I think he balances out his growl with thoughful , and inspired lyrics.

  • @vichi2059
    @vichi2059 2 года назад

    If you liked the drums on this one you've got to check out ANY songs off the "Human" album. PARTICULARY the song "Vacant Planets" - ive never seen anyone react to that an in my opinion the song is a masterpiece.

  • @JonnyM-sg7qu
    @JonnyM-sg7qu Год назад

    Richard Christy did great work with Death as well.

  • @zeigbert1743
    @zeigbert1743 3 месяца назад +1

    Not prog but Fear Factory might be to your liking. The vocals are a mix of growling and singing.

  • @cyborgoftheyear
    @cyborgoftheyear Год назад

    Chuck Schuldiner, via Death, was the creator/godfather of death metal. Some try to say Possession was the first death metal band. I completely disagree. Also, on a side note, Chuck was originally wanting to do Sound of Perseverance (the album after Symbolic, and their last album) with clean basically power metal vocals, but it didn't end up happening. Instead he created a side project called Control Denied to go that route. Not Chuck's best work though.

  • @ronbent
    @ronbent 3 года назад

    yas

  • @chrisdepp7665
    @chrisdepp7665 3 года назад +5

    Nice reaction, Death is very cool... check out Atheist - unquestionable presence for some progressive death metal! That would be a perfect reaction for you! Amirite guys?

  • @prepasni
    @prepasni 2 года назад

    If you like music od Death but have 'problem' with vocal of Chuck Schuldinger then you need to check Control Denied, which is Death-side project with different vocal. You need to check them, you will be surprised

  • @TheGiiant
    @TheGiiant 2 года назад

    Chuck is missed! What a master of music!

  • @onewaydown
    @onewaydown 3 года назад

    Chuck was a visionary guitarist who was taken far too soon by that beast called cancer. He made sure to pick great musicians to be on the albums - Steve Di Giorgio, Gene Hoglan, as well as Paul Masvidal and Sean Reinert (Cynic). Symbolic and Human are timeless death metal albums that leaned more into some melodic/prog tendencies, which set them apart from the generic "death metal" scene.

  • @reeceheller6200
    @reeceheller6200 3 года назад

    How can I recommend tracks for you to react to? Do you react to full albums?

    • @mikebiggums1921
      @mikebiggums1921 3 года назад

      Check out the Patreon link in the description!

    • @CriticalReactions
      @CriticalReactions  3 года назад

      You could join Patreon and suggest songs for each week's theme or submit a Special Selection (I react to whatever song you want me to). Both can be found in the LinkTree link in the description.

  • @TheFinnar
    @TheFinnar Год назад

    You should try Control Denied

  • @18hot30
    @18hot30 2 года назад

    Gene Hoglan, the Atomic clock, but not just him the whole band rips

  • @hextatik_sound
    @hextatik_sound Год назад

    This is not what melodeath is. This is Death. It's completely own thing. Own genre. There can be only one Death.

  • @NoName-fr3gq
    @NoName-fr3gq 2 года назад

    Melodeath had me laughing my ass off never heard that in my life

  • @MrxXtHeEdDy15Xx
    @MrxXtHeEdDy15Xx 2 года назад

    Something from Dissection you would probably like

  • @Xankill3r
    @Xankill3r 3 года назад

    You should really really really check out the Painkiller cover that Death did!!! I think you'll dig it.

  • @raiden3295
    @raiden3295 9 месяцев назад +2

    Funny thing is, Chuck was self taught on the guitar and completely ignored music theory to compose.

  • @coryclark6167
    @coryclark6167 2 года назад

    Please react to A Bid Farewell by Killswitch Engage it’s one of my favorites.

  • @Viiniciws
    @Viiniciws 3 года назад

    Best Tech Death album ever.

  • @jonathanhenderson9422
    @jonathanhenderson9422 3 года назад +2

    I don't know how Death made it into melodeath week. They're not melodeath. However, they were arguably the most important/influential OG death metal band. Here's what I wrote about them on my Top 100 Artists (where I ranked them #18): "It's rare enough that a band invents/innovates a single genre, but Death essentially did so with two. Their early work helped to define the death metal genre and are still among the genre's finest; but from Human in '91 they equally helped pioneer the burgeoning prog metal genre along with Atheist, Cynic, and Dream Theater. Though opinions differ, IMO Death is a band that got better over time with their last album being their ultimate masterpiece and one of the genre's pinnacles. Of course mastermind Chuck Schuldiner deserves all the praise he gets for his songwriting, guitar playing, and vision for the genre, but equally laudable is the cadre of outstanding musicians he played with, most of whom have become fixtures in death metal, but rarely with the same level of influence and import as here."
    This track was from Symbolic, their penultimate album. I have both it and their final album (The Sound of Perseverance) as among my 5/5's. I think they're both masterpieces. Crystal Mountain is a fine song to represent their later, more prog-death work, but it's actually not even one of my personal favorites. Really though, pretty much every track from their last four albums are gold though. You should also check out a track from their first 2 albums (Pull the Plug would be a good pick) just to hear how far they came from OG death metal to this. Chuck's untimely death may be the biggest tragedy in metal history. Who knows where he could've taken the band/genre after this.
    RE difference between melodeath vs death metal that's melodic: melodeath is an actual genre that started in Gothenburg, Sweden by Dark Tranquility, At the Gates, and In Flames. These bands would go on to have a huge influence on metalcore (metalcore is basically melodeath with hardcore vocals and breakdowns).

    • @HateMich
      @HateMich 3 года назад +1

      It's not wrong to consider this melodic death. To me, both Symbolic and those swedish bands are melodic death, just as Morbid Angel and Entombed are both death metal. They are just different interpretations of the same concept.

    • @person1227
      @person1227 3 года назад +3

      @@HateMich It's not wrong to consider Symbolic "melodic death" but there is a clear similarity in style between Gothenburg death metal bands like those listed in the comment above that sound nothing like anything Death ever wrote. And as was pointed out in the comment, that particular style went on to influence the metalcore sound which also bears little resemblance to Death. Arguably, calling the Swedish sound "melodic death metal" was a bad choice to begin with but it seems more confusing to me to now lump in death metal bands utilizing melody into "melodic death metal" when they sound nothing like the Swedish bands that created the genre.

    • @Fidelio116
      @Fidelio116 2 года назад

      Death is also melodeath.

    • @Fidelio116
      @Fidelio116 2 года назад

      @@HateMich exactly.

    • @Fidelio116
      @Fidelio116 2 года назад

      @@person1227 “sound nothing like” my ass. Death metal is not that varied. Of course they have lots of characteristics in common.

  • @18hot30
    @18hot30 2 года назад

    Crystal Mountain is a reference to the twin towers that are no more, or as Chuck would say , this one is about a mountain built on greed, the Crystal mountain

  • @ClandestineMerkaba
    @ClandestineMerkaba 3 года назад

    Melo-death week? Perfect time to do some more Arch Enemy! I recommend the song "Carry the Cross," or "My Apocalypse."

  • @emeth111
    @emeth111 2 года назад

    This is the progressive death metal!

  • @nothaber8130
    @nothaber8130 2 года назад

    Can I recommend. In the maze of kadath-Catacombs

  • @oatmeal710
    @oatmeal710 Год назад

    death doesn't have a bad song, you could throw a dart at their discography and have something interesting to dissect

  • @krazycrismore
    @krazycrismore Год назад

    The 80s was the decade of evolution for metal, not the 90s. In the 70s you mostly had Sabbath and some Priest. Turn of the Decade you have NWOBHM with Maiden and Motorhead. Early 80s had Thrash leading into Death and Black Metal in the mid to late 80s. The 80s also saw the birth and death of Hair and Glam Metal. Power, Progressive, and Doom Metal also came to be in the 80s.

  • @blindcynic
    @blindcynic 2 года назад

    Nevermore - Next in Line

  • @jonkwape3097
    @jonkwape3097 2 года назад

    Oh man, Death, whether Chuck is the godfather of Death Metal or not, it's a great band on it's own. Look at the musicians that were a part of it! Cynic, or Gordian Knot (which is an awesome prog metal project btw). If Schuldiner didn't die, I bet we'd get a lot of prog metal from him by now. Such a shame, RIP.

  • @5H3R1F
    @5H3R1F 3 года назад +1

    React to tomorrow belongs to nobody by Carcass

  • @thenomad4123
    @thenomad4123 2 года назад

    I hated Chuck's depressive voice for a lot of time, but eventually got used to it and now I find it fits great with this band's philosophical themes.

  • @biglarry9759
    @biglarry9759 2 года назад

    The closest melodic type of music like this is probably Control Denied, Chuck’s other band which was much more melodic (not death metal but really good nonetheless). Maybe you should check it out. Great video, btw!

  • @NitroModelsAndComics
    @NitroModelsAndComics Год назад

    This song is above your pay grade.