Climate justice can't happen without racial justice | David Lammy

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 окт 2020
  • Take action on climate change at countdown.ted.com.
    Why has there been so little mention of saving Black lives from the climate emergency? For too long, racial justice efforts have been distinguished from climate justice work, says David Lammy, Member of Parliament for Tottenham, England. In a stirring talk about building a new movement to care for the planet, Lammy calls for inclusion and support of Black and minority leadership on climate issues and a global recognition that we can't solve climate change without racial, social and intergenerational justice.
    This talk was part of the Countdown Global Launch on 10.10.2020. (Watch the full event here: • [Replay] Watch the Cou... .) Countdown is TED's global initiative to accelerate solutions to the climate crisis. The goal: to build a better future by cutting greenhouse gas emissions in half by 2030, in the race to a zero-carbon world. Get involved at countdown.ted.com/sign-up
    Follow Countdown on Twitter: / tedcountdown
    Follow Countdown on Instagram: / tedcountdown
    Subscribe to our channel: / ted
    TED's videos may be used for non-commercial purposes under a Creative Commons License, Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives (or the CC BY - NC - ND 4.0 International) and in accordance with our TED Talks Usage Policy (www.ted.com/about/our-organiz.... For more information on using TED for commercial purposes (e.g. employee learning, in a film or online course), please submit a Media Request at media-requests.ted.com

Комментарии • 970

  • @Miranox2
    @Miranox2 3 года назад +432

    Justice does not need a qualifier nor prefix. Stop trying to "fix" past injustice by adding more injustice.

    • @karolinad9567
      @karolinad9567 3 года назад

      Gggg

    • @karolinad9567
      @karolinad9567 3 года назад

      H

    • @karolinad9567
      @karolinad9567 3 года назад

      muhahaha u

    • @natashaferran
      @natashaferran 3 года назад +7

      muhahaha lets be honest it isn’t even well meaning. It was and still is lies in an attempt to gain power. Also if they really cared about their people they would go and sort their own homelands out that murders children claiming they are witches.

    • @thej.cosbyshow5590
      @thej.cosbyshow5590 3 года назад +3

      Absolutely ridiculous

  • @rjb9239
    @rjb9239 2 года назад +38

    It's disappointing how most people on the comment think that it's an attack on them. Climate change does disproportionately affect Black, indigenous and BIPOC people. It's something to think about and recognize.

  • @hadihassan372
    @hadihassan372 3 года назад +39

    By outsourcing manufacturing , pollution is outsourced.

    • @JeepCherokeeful
      @JeepCherokeeful 2 года назад

      Many people aren’t smart enough to realize this.

  • @AudioRedmusicunlimited
    @AudioRedmusicunlimited 3 года назад +77

    racial justice can’t happen without black fathers, taking a stand and rasing the children they helped created.

    • @ottowelt4378
      @ottowelt4378 3 года назад +13

      75% single motherhood Rate in the black Community wtf bro

    • @josiahcochran8290
      @josiahcochran8290 3 года назад +1

      @11STARFIRE yeah that is not true, get clued into that statistics or stop spreading misinformation

  • @chille-ql4ry
    @chille-ql4ry 3 года назад +269

    This world became a southpark episode

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад +2

      Lmao!

    • @Jaakuna-usagi
      @Jaakuna-usagi 3 года назад +3

      Always has been.

    • @khawajaans5714
      @khawajaans5714 3 года назад

      @@saucywench9122 ءط

    • @jameslong2618
      @jameslong2618 3 года назад

      It’s a faze like the hippie era or the gothic era or the witch craft era. It’s just something for us to laugh at in the future.

    • @slimfast67
      @slimfast67 3 года назад

      And maybe you are Randy Marsh...

  • @samuelsofa
    @samuelsofa 3 года назад +159

    Hey TED this Isn’t Comedy Central

    • @breadfan7433
      @breadfan7433 3 года назад +7

      Actually, it is, nowadays. It's just that some people can't get over that it once used to be really "Ideas worth spreading".
      Look, TED means "Technology, Entertainment, Design". I, at least, choose to see this type of video as belonging to the Entertainment section. If nothing else, the comments are hilarious.

    • @nousername8162
      @nousername8162 3 года назад

      Reminds me of onion talks lol

  • @abcam20
    @abcam20 3 года назад +134

    Oh boy the comment section is lit

    • @lovequeen7080
      @lovequeen7080 3 года назад +1

      Is Trump a racist? Mr. Truthbomb did a video explaining....made me cry!
      ruclips.net/video/TSDa9YUJ-aA/видео.html

    • @galaxyyfrog
      @galaxyyfrog 3 года назад +1

      @@lovequeen7080 damn how many drugs are you on

    • @lovequeen7080
      @lovequeen7080 3 года назад

      @@galaxyyfrog Why do ask that?

    • @galaxyyfrog
      @galaxyyfrog 3 года назад

      @@lovequeen7080 deep state? Really?

  • @one1charlie643
    @one1charlie643 3 года назад +50

    Lammy, haha haha. The guy that said that donating funds to the starving in Africa is racist. FFS TED.

  • @zeake13
    @zeake13 3 года назад +25

    bye, ted.

  • @INFPownage
    @INFPownage 3 года назад +111

    I love how united the comment section is over this. I have a tinge of hope.

  • @Puiutzu96
    @Puiutzu96 3 года назад +131

    TED talks used to be about cool, innovative, scientific visions. Now everything is political. Everything has to do with race, discrimination and oppression. TED is no longer what is used to be. I will kindly unsubscribe from TED until somebody sets it back on track.

    • @PresidentialWinner
      @PresidentialWinner 3 года назад +2

      I did then at some point i came back. These days i just open the videos, check out the dislike ratio and close the video if it has more than 15% dislikes coz i know it's bullshit. Other viewers can filter them for me.

    • @Puiutzu96
      @Puiutzu96 3 года назад

      @@PresidentialWinner I would literally wait the whole day to come home and watch 2 or 3 videos. Now I do exactly what you stated.
      Bullshit pretending to be scientific reports.
      Ted talks, maybe take feedback from your viewers and do something about it. Invite people that actually accomplished something and have deep understanding of a REAL mechanism. I swear we need a petition to depoliticize TED talks.

    • @hannijazz3276
      @hannijazz3276 3 года назад +1

      So, to end discrimination is not an idea worth spreading? Are you suggesting that we should not try to end discrimination? If so, for what reason?

    • @PresidentialWinner
      @PresidentialWinner 3 года назад

      @@hannijazz3276 It's not like that. There are plenty of "ideas worth spreading" but when i watch TED, i want to see something incredible, interesting, amazing, innovative. Not some boring lecture about some random subject. If they want to focus on social issues 99% of the time (like they seem to be doing currently), ok, count me out.

    • @Puiutzu96
      @Puiutzu96 3 года назад

      @@hannijazz3276 how exactly has this video helped you stop discrimination? What if as a normal person I don't discriminate? I just want good content from a format that was providing it. Now it's political, and that's a problem. Instead of educating people with science, they spread biased opinions.

  • @aightbet164
    @aightbet164 3 года назад +20

    Stop

  • @DegreesOfThree
    @DegreesOfThree 3 года назад +123

    The Darfur conflict was about oil, not climate. Nice try though.

    • @iddrisparks1383
      @iddrisparks1383 3 года назад +4

      Bearly your an idiot

    • @canaryimpulse989
      @canaryimpulse989 3 года назад +8

      yeah its not like theres any connection between those things or nothing

    • @DegreesOfThree
      @DegreesOfThree 3 года назад +4

      @@iddrisparks1383 It's 'you're' not 'your' smart guy.

    • @DegreesOfThree
      @DegreesOfThree 3 года назад +5

      @@canaryimpulse989 The 2nd civil war in Sudan started in 1983. There was no such thing as climate change or even global warming then.

    • @unaa9380
      @unaa9380 3 года назад +7

      @@DegreesOfThree all those centuries of corruption and pillaging done largely through colonialism has contributed to the state of mind these nations are in now and global warming as a whole, it's like u watched the video but nothing got in

  • @freddobbs8558
    @freddobbs8558 3 года назад +194

    Oh my god. Get a freakin’ life TED talkers, producers and associates.

    • @bravojr
      @bravojr 3 года назад +7

      They will just disable the comments section soon.

    • @dkt6408
      @dkt6408 3 года назад +2

      @@bravojr they won't

  • @mojo3008
    @mojo3008 3 года назад +37

    You are not a victim. You seem to be doing pretty good to me.

    • @unaa9380
      @unaa9380 3 года назад +2

      So only victims can stand up for victims? Great mentality there

    • @mojo3008
      @mojo3008 3 года назад +1

      @@unaa9380 America is the least racist country on the planet. He is proof that in America it doesn't matter what your skin color is you can make it. All you have to do is finish high school, don't get any felonies, don't become a drug addict and don't have children until marriage. With that formula anyone can become middle class. There is no systemic racism in this country.

    • @josiahcochran8290
      @josiahcochran8290 3 года назад

      @@mojo3008 ok mike, while I think I get you point, and we probably are on the same side, lammy isn’t from America, he’s from the UK

  • @DoloresJNurss
    @DoloresJNurss 3 года назад +7

    I'd like to know where The University of Michigan claimed that only 12% of American environmental leaders aren't White, because if they did say that, they weren't looking very hard. Standing Rock was the most massive and long-lasting protest in environmental history, and it was entirely led by Native Americans, who also were the primary participants. And that was only the beginning. Standing Rock gave birth to environmental activist groups throughout the USA,Canada, and Mexico, all led by the indigenous people of this continent.
    I think this is an important example of what the speaker calls being "cropped out of the picture". Or perhaps their criteria for "environmental activist group" didn't include groups defined by some academic definition that ignores size, persistence, effectiveness, and a high degree of organization for some other peculiar standard. I'm frankly puzzled.

    • @jaapiegoedhart2904
      @jaapiegoedhart2904 2 года назад +1

      I think he meant what is picked up by the (western european) media, not what groups are very effective.
      If I talked to a random person on the street (in NL) and asked them what is the biggest climate activist movement, I guess it'd be Fridays For Future or Extinction Rebellion, not any of the much older (often indigenous) movements for protection and restoration of the Earth.

    • @DoloresJNurss
      @DoloresJNurss 2 года назад

      @YouStink LOL! You cared enough to comment. Most people who genuinely don't care don't bother announcing it unless somebody demands their opinion--it's not that important to them. In contrast, you went out of your way to volunteer the information that you supposedly don't care, to total strangers who didn't even know you existed till you spoke up. That's the action of someone who wants heard.
      So, now that you've gone out of your way to get my attention, do speak up and say what's really on your mind.

  • @kevinj9059
    @kevinj9059 3 года назад +67

    You've been putting out a lot of crap lately, but this takes the cake. You can talk about climate issues without bringing this CRT bullcrap into it. You've earned this unsubscribe.

    • @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism
      @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism 3 года назад +5

      We're all just in tears seeing you go.

    • @scallywag870
      @scallywag870 3 года назад +12

      @@Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism He's disappointed, kinda like many others who possess critical thinking skills. I'm happy to see him go because he made a wise decision.

    • @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism
      @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism 3 года назад

      @@scallywag870 Critical thinking skills. Wow, that must feel like such a privilege to have. I bet you must read a lot uh?

    • @scallywag870
      @scallywag870 3 года назад +1

      @@Warrior_Resisting_ColonialismYes I read the book of being a rational human being. Can you apologize for being indian please?

    • @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism
      @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism 3 года назад

      @@scallywag870 I figured you probably read that one. I don't apologize to colonizers for being me.

  • @JasonEyermann
    @JasonEyermann 3 года назад +41

    Omg this talk is so cringing.

  • @skiptrace4630
    @skiptrace4630 3 года назад +5

    Illogical.

  • @tjs8329
    @tjs8329 3 года назад +31

    In no way are these two issues correlated. I subscribed to hear and learn from intelegent people on smart subjects- not be lectured on a vague correlation between social justice issues.

    • @ShadoFXPerino
      @ShadoFXPerino 3 года назад +1

      The video spells it out pretty clearly:
      1. People who are distracted by social justice issues don't care about climate change
      2. Climate can only be fixed if all of humanity works together to fix climate change
      Therefore:
      3. Climate cannot be fixed until people distracted by social justice issues no longer exist

    • @wholelottalight
      @wholelottalight 3 года назад +2

      @@ShadoFXPerino Thank you for attempting to spell it out clearly, but the logic is heavily flawed as it is based on false premises.
      1. The people who can actually do something about climate change are elected leaders of countries and billionaires. We would need actual programs put in place that actually sequester carbon or do something about other greenhouse gasses. Re-distributing money isn't actually a solution, especially when all it really does is turn those people producing 2.6 metric tons of CO2 into people producing 16 metric tons. Just think about it for a minute. I'm totally on board with hiring a bunch of people to plant trees as he suggested or to build things that will actually DO something. That isn't what they are doing, but I would be on board with that. All they ever do is meet and talk about it. Carbon credits are the STUPIDEST load of crap ever. That is the reason the right doesn't take this seriously. Oh and forest management needs to be a thing. Forests aren't particularly helpful when we have a situation like we are currently having in California.
      2. Nope. Even if everyone agreed that something needed to be done, what exactly are they supposed to do about it? While it isn't a bad idea to recruit people and to promote your cause so that there is enough public support to elect officials who can do something about it; ultimately the solution is going to involve people who re-design society. You just need a few people with a good idea who can get things rolling.
      3. Since this was based on the false premise of 1 and 2 it is also false. This is an absurd position to take if you think about it from more than one angle. I'm sure they are both good causes, but that is like me saying I can't even start to build a house until everyone tells me how amazing the house will be and that we all agree the house will look amazing. Of course I can start building it, and of course people can start trying to change the climate to whatever they want.
      4. Of course this brings up a real problem. Large scale efforts like planting trees will have a major impact in and of themselves on local climates. That is like trying to solve climate change by introducing climate change. Altering weather patterns might be great for some areas, but not so great for others. That is why this is ultimately such a political issue. Most solutions will involving hurting people in one way or another even though it may be a net benefit to the world.
      Here is a video that (unlike this supposed TED talk) actually talks about real solutions and is an idea worth spreading. ruclips.net/video/ecxCL84n26g/видео.html&ab_channel=RealEngineering

    • @ShadoFXPerino
      @ShadoFXPerino 3 года назад

      @@wholelottalight The rich and the politicians can only be brought to heel on the environmental issue by vote or revolution. Blacks need to have their needs addressed before they will vote in eco candidates, I guess? Then after that we can all vote in eco politicians to make eco laws.
      Overall I think the goal of this video is to get black activists more interested in eco activism, going as far as to put false promises into eco activists mouths to make eco activism more palatable to black activists.
      What he's basically done is tell people to vote for eco politicians because they will need to solve social problems first before they can truly fix eco problems, and presumably that is what will be done. And even if they ignore social problems and only focus on eco problems it's still a quality of life bonus to black communities.

    • @Sam-wb2mp
      @Sam-wb2mp 3 года назад +3

      @@ShadoFXPerino So you're saying humans need to work together. What's stopping us. Just creating excuses for not taking action and actually doing something. You make out as though all black people want to make a change and no white people do. A human is a human and both white people and black people probably want change in the environment equally. I don't see the point making this a problem about race when it's clearly just a problem about the laziness of humans. Black and white people work together everyday and it works perfectly so stop creating problems where there isn't one because it actually ends up making you the racist hypocrite

    • @ShadoFXPerino
      @ShadoFXPerino 3 года назад

      @@Sam-wb2mp that is essentially the speaker's entire point. He's not trying to accuse people of being racist. He's trying to get black activists and climate change activists to engage more closely.

  • @truthsayer
    @truthsayer 3 года назад +4

    if we are serious about climate justice, we will prioritize other species

    • @marvooutthamo
      @marvooutthamo 3 года назад

      priortize ourselves and the other species will naturally fall back in order

    • @truthsayer
      @truthsayer 2 года назад

      @YouStink the problem with being a jerk is that - everywhere you go, there you are

  • @BarnardClangdeggin
    @BarnardClangdeggin 3 года назад +43

    So the climate is racist now? TED has gotten so bad I’ve decided to UNSUBSCRIBE.

    • @liamwinter4512
      @liamwinter4512 3 года назад

      So is Covid

    • @BarnardClangdeggin
      @BarnardClangdeggin 3 года назад +1

      @ - clearly YOU haven’t watched the video, or you wouldn’t be saying that. The thumbs up/down ratio indicates most people agree with me.

    • @BarnardClangdeggin
      @BarnardClangdeggin 3 года назад +1

      @@liamwinter4512 - COVID is racist too? Well, it was only a matter of time until anything whatsoever is labeled as racist to avoid a meaningful, rational, fact based conversation. These skills are apparently not taught in institutions of higher learning any more. Stephen Pinker made this point perfectly in the video titled “Political Correctness is Redpilling America.” (look it up).

  • @Shazistic
    @Shazistic 3 года назад +24

    Random fact
    Armadillos are the only animal besides humans that can get leprosy.
    -The Shades

    • @biggus6633
      @biggus6633 3 года назад +3

      Wow! That is more interesting than this video. Thanks for sharing!

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад

      So we're related to armadillos. Good to know.

  • @suzannedoyle5100
    @suzannedoyle5100 3 года назад +13

    👎Using one divisive agenda to prop up another one is unconscionable. 🙄

  • @chetisrael9840
    @chetisrael9840 3 года назад +30

    How about we all unsubscribe guys?

  • @TripodJonas
    @TripodJonas 3 года назад +17

    Racial justice is racism. Justice can only be individual based, because any group contains more than one individuals deserve more than one judgement.

    • @aylbdrmadison1051
      @aylbdrmadison1051 3 года назад

      That's exactly like saying: _justice for a murder is murder. Just how thick is that skull of yours anyway?

    • @TripodJonas
      @TripodJonas 3 года назад

      Aylbdr Madison murder is an good example, you can’t just catch the murderer’s brother and call it they day just because he got gifted something after the act. You have to judge the individual

  • @RenickJ
    @RenickJ 3 года назад +59

    Who are your donors sir?

    • @smokinghollywoods
      @smokinghollywoods 3 года назад +11

      That's a really important question.

    • @iddrisparks1383
      @iddrisparks1383 3 года назад +1

      Ramon Leite not really

    • @youcanfindrace
      @youcanfindrace 3 года назад +1

      @@iddrisparks1383 you are black

    • @Irishtradchannel
      @Irishtradchannel 3 года назад

      @@iddrisparks1383 It actually is, Lammy and corporate funds are never far apart.

  • @TheMonteCarlo
    @TheMonteCarlo 3 года назад +7

    STOP

  • @p1ll
    @p1ll 3 года назад +7

    Down votes says it all

  • @qg95
    @qg95 3 года назад +23

    Every word of this speech is right, yet two-thirds of the reactions are negative. The refusal to acknowledge the problem is contributing to it.

    • @thejacal2704
      @thejacal2704 3 года назад

      Everything in your first clause is incorrect, and yours eco d clause should read 'three quarter's. The refusal to acknowledge that this isn't a problem is contributing to a special kind of racism.

  • @dkt6408
    @dkt6408 3 года назад +31

    if a minority is affected more by a problem than the majority,
    then solving the problem itself is a better solution than helping more the minority.
    all problems should be solved equally, indifferent of the minority or the majority, except if the problem is directly tied to minority majority conflicts.
    Solving climate change first will also solve the climate change affect inequality,
    solving just the climate change affect inequality wont do much.
    I'm all for equality, and equality problems should be solved equally
    Edit: while this video is not that good, please don't use it as a representation of people wanting equality and BLM.
    and remember to always treat the other side of an argument with respect.

    • @moonbyulswife3990
      @moonbyulswife3990 3 года назад +2

      You're right. I agree with every word

    • @MartinMuehl
      @MartinMuehl 3 года назад

      So you're all for equality as long as the solutions don't negatively effect you or make you lose any privileges? Got it.

    • @SmokeJam
      @SmokeJam 3 года назад +1

      @@MartinMuehl explain to me what privileges do I have? I can't change the fact where and as what I am born, so that doesn't make any sense. "White supremacy" or anything enforcing that is just another tool of trying to gain power and forcing others to be your victim.
      If you have to take away everything my ancestors worked for to achieve equality, you are working on the wrong end, because those are the "privileges" achieved by sweat, blood and death and should be honored, preserved and expanded on!

    • @dkt6408
      @dkt6408 3 года назад +3

      @@MartinMuehl no that's not at all what I said, maybe you should read the comment more carefully.
      What I meant was to solve bigger problems which also include the original problems under it.
      example: climate change affect inequality can be solved by just solving climate change in the first place.
      the solution to unequal privilege would be for everyone to get the same privileges, not for everyone to not have privileges.
      I hope you understand, I'm on your side.
      BTW: I don't agree with @SmokeJam

  • @MrAlexandru1986
    @MrAlexandru1986 3 года назад +6

    Everything is about race these days . . .
    What's the point of all the progress made for equality where now what they push is equity AKA take from white to give to black. Doesn't that just define racism?

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад +1

      Yup. That and communism. All I took away from this video is that oxygen is now racist.Oh, and that the speaker wants us to think that anyone whose black must be a victim.

    • @akwatching
      @akwatching 3 года назад

      @@saucywench9122 how dense can you be

    • @akwatching
      @akwatching 3 года назад +1

      What have they taken from white people and given to black? Answer quickly

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад

      @@akwatching well, I am 75% water.

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад

      @@akwatching didn't you watch the video? All the polluted air.

  • @think32
    @think32 3 года назад +5

    I'm a little surprised (but just a little) by the multitude of negative, emotional reactions in the comments. I've yet to see a single person complain about a single fact David Lammy spoke or explain why they disagree. People are projecting their own biases. This is deep truth. If it causes you cognitive dissonance, then take a few breaths, clear your negative energy, and re-watch. If you disagree with any statements, quote him and say why you disagree. A rational argument against something said here would be much more effective than pouting.
    Thanks TED. This is excellent.

  • @DegreesOfThree
    @DegreesOfThree 3 года назад +44

    We're supposed to feel sorry for people that are lucky enough to own beachfront property? I'd be happy to trade.

    • @aaronabunu2725
      @aaronabunu2725 3 года назад +1

      the issue is that in a few years it'll be beach under property. if you still want to trade then Ben Shapiro was right all along about selling underwater houses

    • @DegreesOfThree
      @DegreesOfThree 3 года назад +3

      @@aaronabunu2725 They'll say anything to take your money. NYC was supposed to be underwater 10 years ago. If only it were true.

    • @christianguzman4688
      @christianguzman4688 3 года назад +1

      Rapture anyone

    • @asderathoslchaim7093
      @asderathoslchaim7093 3 года назад

      Money can't buy happiness.

  • @MrAlexandru1986
    @MrAlexandru1986 3 года назад +41

    He forgot to mention the emissions coming out of China and India . . . .
    I wonder why that is? Oh right . . . . the narative would sharter, , , I get you mate

    • @billhicks8
      @billhicks8 3 года назад +5

      You guys think you're so clever that you can wipe away entire critical analyses with a single sentence. I'm not big on David Lammy, but people with "opinions" like yours are by far worse, because you speak completely thoughtlessly and think you are exposing agendas and destroying "narratives". It would be funny, but it's quite pathetic really.

    • @TheLastSamurai101
      @TheLastSamurai101 3 года назад +6

      India's per capita emissions are extremely low - it's only the 158th highest in the world. The US generates 10 times more CO2 per capita than India. India's emissions are literally the minimum required to support the huge population.

    • @unaa9380
      @unaa9380 3 года назад +1

      That's the whole point, they literally make things for Western countries hence why David said there needs to be a change in racial issues so that there can be an economic change so that the climate can be saved, it's all linked

  • @dhairyadave1806
    @dhairyadave1806 3 года назад +7

    how tf does racism help with climate crisis??

  • @Maramba01
    @Maramba01 3 года назад +9

    Well done David for raising this important narration of the impact of climate change on us people of colour!! Never be silenced by negativity !!! Keep talking!! You will always have my vote and support 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

  • @ronaldg6427
    @ronaldg6427 3 года назад +11

    Ted doesn't seem to listen to it's comment section

    • @RunikaMori
      @RunikaMori 3 года назад

      @Rebecca Leeman The video was too so it fits. A stupid comment section for a stupid video.

  • @wellhungindung
    @wellhungindung 3 года назад +7

    Is this the guy that called Brexit voters Nazis or no?

    • @marvinrascal3376
      @marvinrascal3376 3 года назад +1

      Yes. He also claimed that it was the EU that defeated the Nazis.

    • @wellhungindung
      @wellhungindung 3 года назад +1

      @@marvinrascal3376 And I think he is one of the MP's who claims most in expenses per annum even though he lives in London. If you live in the Shetland Isles I kind of get it but London...

    • @marvinrascal3376
      @marvinrascal3376 3 года назад +1

      @@wellhungindung whilst claiming to be oppressed...

  • @VarenRoth
    @VarenRoth 3 года назад +23

    You're taking a social issue, and chaining it with a climatology issue. By doing this, you're bringing down both sides of the point.
    Children suffering from asthma? That's about where you live, and you can be the whitest richest kid and still breathe the worst air.
    This video is going to have people who are ignorant on or opposing doing something about climate change and racial inequalities to bring hate to the *other point*. If your point was to try to gather support for one cause by pulling members from the other, you have failed miserably.
    Climate change, pollution, they are issues that involve the whole earth. The USA, Europe, China, India, and so forth.
    The "Black lives" issue is so deeply american, that the amount of issues you're talking about don't even remotely pass through the mind of most people in europe or china. And if you speak of Africa's poverty? That's where white people are prosecuted and killed.
    Stop trying to mix fights that have nothing to do with each other, and realise that you need to fight on different fronts using different messages and tools.
    If on the way to that you want to help specific communities, that doesn't make it a prerequisite for everyone else's success.
    On both issues? You're dividing, when you should be uniting.

    • @DiscipleOfHeavyMeta1
      @DiscipleOfHeavyMeta1 3 года назад +1

      The climate issue is fundamentally a social issue. Climate change is a consequence of industrial activity under the current economic system.

    • @9rh9
      @9rh9 3 года назад +4

      I do feel like he’s making one valid point: people that live in poorer areas (or the PC version of that) get more of the negative effects of climate change and poor areas contain more black people.
      A more logical solution would then be to help poor areas with education, awareness and fighting/preparing against the negative effects of climate change.
      I think you are making some good points though. Trying to view everything through the lens of blm makes no sense at all and will probably divide people even further. I also feel like blm problems usually equates to poor people problems. Not a very good precedent to set imo.

  • @VerenaSatriani
    @VerenaSatriani 3 года назад +13

    I have one simple question; can we live peacefully in this world? At least that's my dream. To all my friends here, happy Tuesday, stay safe and helathy.

    • @josiahcochran8290
      @josiahcochran8290 3 года назад

      Preach people like you who *want peace* but don’t do anything about it aren’t helping

  • @mpho1
    @mpho1 3 года назад +10

    Video title was definitely ridiculous and my first reaction was to roll my eyes, but he made some really valid points throughout the video. I doubt all these people mad in the comments watched the video.

    • @anaag2682
      @anaag2682 2 года назад +2

      or they are racist

  • @johnspace1876
    @johnspace1876 3 года назад +28

    Curious how he defines the term Justice.

  • @josiahcochran8290
    @josiahcochran8290 3 года назад +26

    Well, Ted talks are now politics talks

    • @gantmj
      @gantmj 3 года назад +1

      Welcome to 2014.

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад +1

      Always was.

    • @KiwiKrazyable
      @KiwiKrazyable 3 года назад +1

      People's lives aren't politics and neither is the climate crisis.

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад

      @@KiwiKrazyable correct and yet politicians are basing their platforms on them both.

  • @Ash-ku5ho
    @Ash-ku5ho 3 года назад +14

    That's 9 minutes and 32 seconds of my life I'll never get back.

    • @Anonymous-kh3eu
      @Anonymous-kh3eu 3 года назад +2

      Why would you watch it? As soon as I saw that headline I just jumped strait into the comments

  • @mick7sp
    @mick7sp 3 года назад +16

    Total BS, low for TED even.

  • @milana3302
    @milana3302 3 года назад +15

    At first I saw the title and listened to the beginning of the video and click on dislike because it was unbearable.
    Then I forced myself to listen to the video and then I take off dislike.
    Although this video does not deserve a like either.
    What's the matter?
    1) Climate justice and racial justice are different things. You CAN'T mix them up, you can't try to solve one problem with another. It's like blaming the bad taste of a oversalty cake on a bad oven.
    2) The video has good ideas. Like the fact that poor people suffer the most from pollution. But it's not just black peeople. White people suffer from this too, as much as Asians, Australoids and all others. Don't blame people for what they didn't do.
    How can you fix it? Change the headline, for example "How climate change affects black peeople" or "How climate change is related to racial injustice" or "Why climate change is more affecting disadvantaged groups" or smth like that. And, of course, there is no need to push one problem to another.
    TED is becoming more and more like a company trying to make money than a company trying to change the world and make it better. Please, spotlight the problem, don't try to make benefit from it.

  • @ammarakkash556
    @ammarakkash556 2 года назад +2

    inspiring and well-siad

  • @Dbanj598
    @Dbanj598 3 года назад +17

    I am black and this is a joke

  • @Jerome...
    @Jerome... 3 года назад +21

    For every Thomas Sowell there are too many clowns like this guy.

  • @robertjohnson976
    @robertjohnson976 3 года назад

    This pattern of thinking solves nothing you are only giving you're rivals power.

  • @kirakilstrom3417
    @kirakilstrom3417 Год назад

    thank you for your talk!

  • @andrewbishop869
    @andrewbishop869 3 года назад +25

    Everyone lives on planet, therefore everyone needs to step up and fix it. This is not a racial issue, please take race out of it. Also would question some stats in this talk. Additionally love lets solve rasicm by being racist.

    • @infinitivez
      @infinitivez 3 года назад +2

      It's as if when you see a demographic, you feel since you're not a part of it, you have to defend yourself against it.
      Nothing in this talk was about racism. It was about how climate change directly affects a low-income minority group more than its white counterparts.
      It's as if there are giant groups of people who aren't even using the same words we are.

    • @andrewbishop869
      @andrewbishop869 3 года назад +1

      maybe but I think you miss the point on this one, Lammy has tried hard to make this about race and if he really cared he would be calling for us all to come together. Not suggesting things or using information the way he has. David in my opinion has tried to blame one group for all the problems, thus there is racism contained within this talk.

  • @sebastiankobialka4071
    @sebastiankobialka4071 3 года назад +13

    lets be honest: 90% of the disslikes came from people, that havent watched the video but just saw the title...

    • @lisagorman216
      @lisagorman216 3 года назад +1

      Good point 👍

    • @Anonymous-kh3eu
      @Anonymous-kh3eu 3 года назад +8

      The title is all you need to see to know that this video is an absolute joke and disgrace
      Very disappointed in this channel

    • @TheDav135
      @TheDav135 3 года назад +6

      The title sums up David Lammy in a nutshell.. you don't need to see some cows to smell some bullshit

    • @Hosenanzugtasche
      @Hosenanzugtasche 3 года назад

      Let's be honest: some people can see patterns.

    • @saucywench9122
      @saucywench9122 3 года назад +5

      I honestly couldn't finish it. I think I got maybe five minutes in and quit because I thought he was trying to convince me oxygen was racist. It made no sense.

  • @rcair123
    @rcair123 3 года назад +14

    Remember when TED talks were good? Seems like it was only a few years ago, so sad.

  • @eugenenumberoneov
    @eugenenumberoneov 3 года назад +2

    Oh sure:)

  • @daniaflores8013
    @daniaflores8013 3 года назад +5

    I really hate how the POC who speak on Ted and that are really passionate about racial injustice just make everything a race problem. It’s not. Why are you doing this Ted? Why?

  • @thedjslipmatt
    @thedjslipmatt 3 года назад +1

    OMG

  • @bvec97
    @bvec97 3 года назад +6

    seeing all these whypeepo (I am white so don't even try it) complaining about how they don't want to subscribe to a channel about learning because it made their little snowflake hearts shatter, it clearly demonstrates that they were never interested in learning in the first place. If you were committed to education in any way, in any area, you would understand what he's saying and agree that we cannot tackle the climate crisis without addressing racial inequalities. To say it doesn't affect people in cities more, disproportionately people of color, is laughable. 97% of scientists don't agree on ANYTHING, but they agree on this. Stop being butthurt over someone telling you there's a systemic problem. Did he mention any of you by name? Why are you offended, then? Maybe it speaks to the deeper issue, that you are, in fact, biased when it comes to race. And when you don't do anything to fix that, let alone acknowledge it, in a country with systemic racism, you enable the system and that is a racist action. It isn't difficult to understand, you're just willfully ignorant. Thank you for hating on this Ted Talk.

  • @michaelmullan1086
    @michaelmullan1086 3 года назад +15

    He brings race into everything, sees racism where there’s none, very divisive!

  • @lilcoco501
    @lilcoco501 3 года назад +4

    The truth is, not the consumer causes the damage to the environment
    Or at least it isn't our fault, imagine if companies wouldn't advertise everythjng everywhere
    imagine if they would tell you the truth about the product
    imagine knowing the effort put into/the resources used for the production and shipping
    Sorry for any mistakes, English isn't my first language but I think you get the idea

    • @iampdv
      @iampdv 3 года назад +2

      Good point. Imagine banking apps would not stop support for android 8 apps as of this year forcing me to change a perfectly working device.

    • @iampdv
      @iampdv 3 года назад

      @still learning this is a question of who deserves to tell us how to behave. Not those responsible for such advertising and other practices leading to an increased consumption.

    • @lilcoco501
      @lilcoco501 3 года назад

      @still learning yes we are responsible but why should we say 'no' if it is so cheap and accessible to get anything you want?
      A very small amount of people knows about the impact these decisions have
      I am no good rolemodel myself, cheap is good for me and I dont know how bad it is ordering stuff from asia to europe, I think that's a problem and people should be more conciousn on these decisions
      The question is how to make that happen

    • @barta9342
      @barta9342 3 года назад

      Everybody consumes and is in that sense responsible to.

    • @iampdv
      @iampdv 3 года назад

      @@barta9342 This is what the rich and some politicians want you to believe to develop guilt in yourself. Blame those who benefit, they are responsible.

  • @Kill_a_Bear
    @Kill_a_Bear 3 года назад +5

    What has race got to do with climate change?

    • @sinskisin
      @sinskisin 3 года назад +2

      He just explained it

  • @unabruja624
    @unabruja624 3 года назад +9

    Wow, the amount of offended white people in this comment section 👀

    • @user-bv1gq8jj6b
      @user-bv1gq8jj6b 3 года назад +1

      I'm not white and i'm "offended" because they make their followers to believe such bullshit

    • @unabruja624
      @unabruja624 3 года назад

      ​@@user-bv1gq8jj6b they don't make anyone believe anything, people will believe what they believe, oreo.

    • @user-bv1gq8jj6b
      @user-bv1gq8jj6b 3 года назад

      @@unabruja624 well, you are right, but I still think they brainwash people in some way, well, at least they try to...

    • @unabruja624
      @unabruja624 3 года назад

      @@user-bv1gq8jj6b brain wash? Lol, if I said to someone, hey, trees are blue, I'm not brainwashing anyone, I'm just saying something. Brainwashing is way worse than stating something

    • @user-bv1gq8jj6b
      @user-bv1gq8jj6b 3 года назад

      @@unabruja624 ok ok i don't wanna fight anymore, please

  • @SkyeDoesRJ
    @SkyeDoesRJ 3 года назад +6

    That's very cool, but what does BLM have to do with climate change?

    • @TubeOfTheYou1000
      @TubeOfTheYou1000 3 года назад

      did you want the video he justt explained it smhh

  • @gianniclaud
    @gianniclaud 3 года назад +16

    TED has lost its way

  • @BeeMusic2024
    @BeeMusic2024 3 года назад +2

    No

  • @tb8813
    @tb8813 3 года назад +1

    What?

  • @pnuthead13
    @pnuthead13 3 года назад +6

    This post and the comments are an excellent example of what is ahead for any company/organization that publicly puts in the effort to combat racial inequality. I’m super aware that TED, while excellent, featured so many white speakers.
    You can see all the ‘remember when’ comments in this thread.
    TED - this is going to continue to trigger a chunk of your fan base but keep going. Add more content that continues to push for equality and - thank you!

    • @Mucving
      @Mucving 3 года назад +1

      Companies and organizations should push for meritocracy. Your melatonine levels or contents of your pants are irrelevant.

    • @pnuthead13
      @pnuthead13 3 года назад +1

      @@Mucving While I basically agree with your first sentence your second sentence seems to be something only a person insecure about either would worry about.

  • @ericthelemming
    @ericthelemming 3 года назад +11

    🌍💚 thanks for speaking on this issue. we need laws against ecocide!

  • @georgeanthony4834
    @georgeanthony4834 2 года назад +1

    I did'nt know he grew up black!

  • @thejacal2704
    @thejacal2704 3 года назад +2

    How the duck was Darfur a climate change conflict?

  • @karenness5588
    @karenness5588 3 года назад +4

    The word justice has been so distorted, it has lost its meaning in common parlance and is used, like the Queen in Alice's wonderland, to mean just what the speaker wants it to mean.
    That word, which used to mean enforcing the Law, the pillars of any society and culture, you know, trust, reciprocity, cooperation, freely acquired rights and obligations, a space safe from the coercion and deceit that reigns in the jungle, and equitable compensation from harm. That is and always means justice, the protection of those foundations, no matter how any authoritarian queen may besmirch that noble, yes, noble word.

    • @user-bv1gq8jj6b
      @user-bv1gq8jj6b 3 года назад +2

      Absolutely agree with you, wish there were more people with some braincells as well...

  • @grahammewburn
    @grahammewburn 3 года назад +3

    Years ago I watched a doco on RUclips of a black man who escaped from racial prejudice by moving to another country. If only the global problem of polluting our planet could be as easily fixed.
    Cheers Gray
    Australia

    • @joestetz8325
      @joestetz8325 3 года назад

      Shouldn't u be more worried about being raided and arrested for Facebook posts. By the new Australian authoritarian rulers

    • @grahammewburn
      @grahammewburn 3 года назад

      @@joestetz8325 I'm locked out of FB. I can't remember my old login code. Nor can I remember constant requests to have a new one

  • @davisluong2060
    @davisluong2060 2 года назад

    Davis Lammy should not even be on in TED considering his comments that are a direct reflection of what kind of person he is and not a good one.

  • @ShadaOfAllThings
    @ShadaOfAllThings 3 года назад

    I mean if you don't care about the people getting hurt first how are we supposed to address any problems? FFS its just a basic observation that when Society decides to offload its problems onto minorities as scapegoats we ignore the problems that are burning it down. If you can't see that you got a bias or you haven't been looking.

  • @aabeen1
    @aabeen1 3 года назад +10

    Without climate change and BLM this guy would be selling cars.

  • @ExiledAndBanished
    @ExiledAndBanished 3 года назад +8

    disgusting. stuff like this is why people are voting for trump out of spite

  • @budphillips5968
    @budphillips5968 3 года назад +14

    The whole premise of the topic is bs

  • @riorompero1314
    @riorompero1314 3 года назад +2

    Pls remove this fake ted talk

  • @chrisose
    @chrisose 3 года назад +13

    Next we will hear about how racist the sun is.

    • @iampdv
      @iampdv 3 года назад +1

      It is pretty racist in disproportionately hurting whites when they get too much of it. Let's cancel it. Let's also cancel clouds, as they disproportionately deprive blacks of vitamin D.

    • @vu4y3fo846y
      @vu4y3fo846y 3 года назад +1

      Stars racist too. Why isn't my black Jamal in the zodiac!? Until then, constellations are CANCELLED (/s)

    • @unaa9380
      @unaa9380 3 года назад

      People that totally missed the point, part of the problem smh

    • @finesse1125
      @finesse1125 3 года назад +1

      Ever notice minorities have darker skin than white people? That's bc sunlight doesn't make it through the walls of White Privilege surrounding them but cuts through minorities like they're made of toilet paper #cancelthesun

    • @finesse1125
      @finesse1125 3 года назад

      @@unaa9380 explain then. Because I watched the video and I'm still not convinced.

  • @FakeJeep
    @FakeJeep 3 года назад +15

    Oh look... my cue to unsubscribe. Thanks TED.

    • @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism
      @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism 3 года назад +2

      They'll really miss you, I'm sure.

    • @FakeJeep
      @FakeJeep 3 года назад +7

      @@Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism I came here years ago for the science talks and technology that could change everyone's lives for the better. As of lately they've become nothing more than a political platform and it's grating. The dislike ratio on this video says that much.

  • @vthilton
    @vthilton 3 года назад

    Unity in Diversity

  • @jabocamoranesi9270
    @jabocamoranesi9270 3 года назад +1

    Join the Rebellion!

  • @JohnQPublic11
    @JohnQPublic11 3 года назад +26

    He's a loon.

  • @54nd5p1d3r
    @54nd5p1d3r 3 года назад +9

    well you lot can start by not burning everything to the ground just a thought

  • @josephstalin188
    @josephstalin188 3 года назад +1

    You've lost me

  • @thejacal2704
    @thejacal2704 3 года назад +24

    What's that noise?
    Oh, its the bottom of a barrel being scraped.

  • @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism
    @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism 3 года назад +4

    Native Americans are unquestionably victims of environmental racism. The Commission for Racial Justice found that about 50 percent of all American Indians live in communities with uncontrolled hazardous waste sites (Asian Pacific Environmental Network 2002). There’s no question that, worldwide, indigenous populations are suffering from similar fates.
    For Native American tribes, the issues can be complicated-and their solutions hard to attain-because of the complicated governmental issues arising from a history of institutionalized disenfranchisement. Unlike other racial minorities in the United States, Native American tribes are sovereign nations. However, much of their land is held in “trust,” meaning that “the federal government holds title to the land in trust on behalf of the tribe” (Bureau of Indian Affairs 2012). Some instances of environmental damage arise from this crossover, where the U.S. government’s title has meant it acts without approval of the tribal government. Other significant contributors to environmental racism as experienced by tribes are forcible removal and burdensome red tape to receive the same reparation benefits afforded to non-Indians.
    To better understand how this happens, let’s consider a few example cases. The home of the Skull Valley Band of Goshute Indians was targeted as the site for a high-level nuclear waste dumping ground, amid allegations of a payoff of as high as $200 million (Kamps 2001). Keith Lewis, an indigenous advocate for Indian rights, commented on this buyout, after his people endured decades of uranium contamination, saying that “there is nothing moral about tempting a starving man with money” (Kamps 2001). In another example, the Western Shoshone’s Yucca Mountain area has been pursued by mining companies for its rich uranium stores, a threat that adds to the existing radiation exposure this area suffers from U.S. and British nuclear bomb testing (Environmental Justice Case Studies 2004). In the “four corners” area where Colorado, Utah, Arizona, and New Mexico meet, a group of Hopi and Navajo families have been forcibly removed from their homes so the land could be mined by the Peabody Mining Company for coal valued at $10 billion (American Indian Cultural Support 2006). Years of uranium mining on the lands of the Navajo of New Mexico have led to serious health consequences, and reparations have been difficult to secure; in addition to the loss of life, people’s homes and other facilities have been contaminated (Frosch 2009). In yet another case, members of the Chippewa near White Pine, Michigan, were unable to stop the transport of hazardous sulfuric acid across reservation lands, but their activism helped bring an end to the mining project that used the acid (Environmental Justice Case Studies 2004).
    These examples are only a few of the hundreds of incidents that American Indian tribes have faced and continue to battle against. Sadly, the mistreatment of the land’s original inhabitants continues via this institution of environmental racism. How might the work of sociologists help draw attention to-and eventually mitigate-this social problem?

    • @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism
      @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism 3 года назад +1

      courses.lumenlearning.com/alamo-sociology/chapter/reading-environmental-racism/

    • @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism
      @Warrior_Resisting_Colonialism 3 года назад

      @11STARFIRE Not only can we. We absolutely agree. Raising my voice didn't take away from the conversation. It added to it. Far too often (almost always), Indians are excluded from the conversation.

  • @edhuber3557
    @edhuber3557 3 года назад +13

    Pap. Amazing this fellow can say this with a straight face.

  • @kennyhilaire1607
    @kennyhilaire1607 3 года назад +2

    wow... so many comments from people not living in the countries or areas described in the video claiming it to be fake

  • @WhiskeySpruce
    @WhiskeySpruce 3 года назад +13

    Every issue is a race issue, even when it isn’t.

  • @justinchrisloriega7235
    @justinchrisloriega7235 3 года назад +8

    The speaker has confidence and clearly knows what he is talking about. His voice is clear and understandable even with an accent. His nonverbal gestures are helpful and enhances the message he wants to send. He didn't tell any technical jargons and is understandable of all ages.
    #PrinciplesOfCommunication

  • @oOTiCkTaCkOo
    @oOTiCkTaCkOo 3 года назад +9

    Bye Ted, i am willing to come and resub once you go back on education track.

  • @Konradical007
    @Konradical007 3 года назад +6

    Agenda Presentation! Wow 😳

  • @HH-je3sh
    @HH-je3sh 3 года назад +11

    Professional victim

  • @williamh.gatesiii8183
    @williamh.gatesiii8183 3 года назад +9

    I'm a black, college educated engineer and I hate this nonsense.

    • @Finkelfunk
      @Finkelfunk 3 года назад +3

      Your race doesn't matter in this context and I hate that modern liberals have already pushed reasonable adults to include this in their statement because they fear not being given credit otherwise.
      You are a rational human being and you hate this nonsense. Your skin color doesn't matter.

  • @charlietube7165
    @charlietube7165 3 года назад +3

    I don't know why you don't talk about this 30 years ago, now it's not gonna help with the global issues at all...

  • @chidionoh
    @chidionoh 3 года назад +3

    He’s RIGHT in the sense that these issues are systemic and interconnected. Those who are exasperated with their “victimhood” are refusing to connect the dots. I’m not implying that the US should police the world’s pollution, but if we truly cared about poor and/or non-white peoples, it’d be clear to see how they are disproportionately affected by climate change and pollution.

  • @andrevanderlinden8722
    @andrevanderlinden8722 3 года назад

    TED is going to fck up like Genius did...

  • @JustSayin993
    @JustSayin993 3 года назад +18

    What you need to do mate is get yourself out of the ideoological plantation. To help you do so, read the book ‘Blackout’ by Candace Owens. It is essential reading for all of us.

    • @MartinMuehl
      @MartinMuehl 3 года назад +4

      Nothing that Candace Owens ever wrote is essential reading for anybody on anything ever.

    • @laurensahanna5826
      @laurensahanna5826 3 года назад +3

      Candace Owen hahahaha

    • @JustSayin993
      @JustSayin993 3 года назад

      @@namelessblob781 ... exactly. Read the book.