carbine has always been underrated imo i would say it deserves second place, great looking, well rounded, the fastest reload, it just lacks in ammo capacity. (my personal ranking) 4. Lichfield Repeater 3. Lancaster Repeater 2. Carbine Repeater 1. Evans Repeater
Ammo capacity is way more valuable than reload speed. Obviously all of the guns are capable of killing people pretty effectively (especially if you're good with headshots), so none of them suck. But compared to the rest of them, fourth place is where it belongs. With the lower damage and ammo capacity, it's not great with body/limb shots. And if you can land headshots well enough, you might as well just get a gun with more ammo capacity. I can't think of any good reason to use it over any other repeater.
@@Aaron_HD lancanster lacks in reload speed, evans lacks in damage, Litchfield lacks in range. While carbine doesn’t excel at anything it doesn’t lack in anything either, so well it’s not the best if you have a certain play style it’s easily the most well rounded and there’s no situation it’s not good in, all the other rifles have weaknesses but carbine can be good in any situation, if you have moderate skill then you can use the carbine repeater easily and kick ass with it in any situation with other rifles you can usually do even better but if you get into a bad situation with them you’re pretty much fucked and it’s for this reason i’ve always loved carbine.
@@TomatoMan90 That's fair. It is pretty well rounded. I always go with the Litchfield for short to medium range combat, and the bolt action rifle for longer range. Since you can carry two large weapons, I find it unnecessary to have a jack of all trades that excels at nothing in particular, when you could just have two guns that excel at what the other doesn't. It'd definitely rank higher if you could only carry one gun.
At least to me? Carbine is close to being first place because it is really good! The second most damaging, great stats overall and even if you can't hold a lot? The reload is so fast it literally doesn't have it matter that it reloads more often when it kills in good three, two or one shot cus of it's overall well balanced stats
Lancaster Repeater was my main short rifle personally, it’s incredibly reliable because it’s accuracy bonus made the hit to damage worth it compared to the other short rifles, if you’re a good aim and can consistently hit centre mass and headshots you don’t need to worry about the lower damage stat, and even then you can pump it with express rounds to give the damage stat that extra boost.
Lancaster all day for online, especially pvp. The Evens reticle bloom is much bigger. Sometimes, missing a shot altogether. The Evans sounds real beefy though. The Litchfield is well so so.
I love the Evan’s for the reload noise and the 26 bullets. I’ll also run sawed offs and a carcano. Sometimes I’ll swap the sawed offs for schofields or m1899s but if I do that I change out the carcano for a repeating shotgun
Nah the Lancaster is objectively the second best weapon in the game. Maybe in single player it’s good, but in online the thing has perfect accuracy and bloom compared to every other weapon.
Omgggg fr tho it's my immediate go to in gunfights if the ppl im fighting aren't lag switching it gets headshots like no other it's accuracy makes up for its lack of strength
@@Mr.MANN1234 it does less damage on body shots though. Lancaster two taps while the Evans three taps. The Lancaster is also a quarter more accurate by default and you can maximize the accuracy to 100 with improved iron sights which makes it the best for landing quick headshots with free aim. Evans to me is just not worth the extra 12 bullets considering the downsides. Plus, most firefights are over before you reach the fourteenth bullet of the Lancaster. You have ample time to reload in between tbh, and that’s without Dead Eye instantly reloading your weapons in single player.
@@Mr.MANN1234 And the Lancaster has 14, and ammo count is wholly irrelevant in this game when flicking on dead eye for a millisecond will fully reload anyways, plus if you need 26 shots in a fight you’re actually just horrible at shooting.
The drawbacks to the Litchfield are actually why ive hung with the Lancaster to this day: I much prefer to land all of my shots even if I have to spend a couple more of them to drop the target.
Lancaster is #1, the accuracy of the weapon is top notch, may lack stopping power on regular ammo, but you can get high velocity and express rounds. Evans repeater is at #2, mainly for storage capacity, holding 26 rounds. But that gives you a really long reload time. Pretty accurate but I rarely use it. The litchfield stats are strange to me. Supposedly they are better than the Lancaster, but I don’t see it. It’s really loud, sounds like I shotgun and it’s hard to hit any damn thing. I rather use the regular carbine repeater.
@@dukemeiser19 yeah it's why they were rejected by the U.S. military while the carbine repeater (based on the spencer carbine) was actually used in the civil war as a calvary rifle iirc. There was even a breech loaded version
@dukemeiser19 alright you forced my hand. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy.
More detailed analysis: 1. Lancaster have a *slightly* lower damage output than the carbine repeater and the most accurate. But it is overall a jack of all trades weapon that's preferred by many for it's generic appearance and reliability. (Is also easy to find due to it being obtainable FREE by completing a stranger mission in Rhode's gunsmith) 2. The Carbine repeater has the fastest reload out of all of the repeaters (which sorta makes up for it's 7 rounds capacity but it can be put to last by using deadeye which reloads anything instantly.) So it's more preferable to be used by some players in online since dead eye won't reload the repeater unlike in story mode. 3. Litchfield Repeater has the highest damage out of all the repeaters and often have the ability to one shot enemies with express ammo types. This comes at a cost of accuracy which is bad but more manageable than the carbine repeater. 4. Evans repeater has the highest ammo count out of all the guns in the game at 26 rounds. Has mediocre damage but predictably the slowest reload time out of every gun (excluding using dead eye) So in my opinion: Story mode: 1. Evans Repeater 2. Lancaster Repeater 3. Litchfield Repeater 4. Carbine Repeater Online mode: 1. Lancaster Repeater 2. Evans Repeater 3. Carbine Repeater 4. Litchfield Repeater
I personally think that the list goes like this: 1. Lancaster 2. Carbine 3. Evans 4. Litchfield The litchfield literally cannot hit anything, the evans feels solid but i think the reload is too slow, the carbine is soild too and has a really fast reload, and the lancaster just feels the best to use and is the most well rounded
The carbine repeater has the highest per shot damage out of all the repeaters but the lowest magazine capacity, however it is MUCH faster to reload which IMO makes it extremely underrated
Yeah, I dont know what the video is talking, claiming that Lancaster is more powerful than Carbine. Carbine has higher dmg and accuracy. Carbine would be the best overall, but magazine is too small. I rather use Vulcanic pistols, which are pretty much single hand Carbines you can dual wield. Also, when I use long arm with big punch, I rather just take Bolt Action then instead of Carbine, and some faster and large clip repeater like evans instead.
You are delusional if you think anything other than the Lancaster should be #1 😂 Litchfield is worst by far! Worst accuracy in the game. I hit more shots with a shotgun at 100 yards than that pathetic Litchfield. Unless you are using deadeye constantly the Litchfield is the worst gun in the game. Its decent in Online if you're using Paint it Black constantly because of its high damage output. Other than that its trash! Carbine gets the 3rd spot because it has a quick reload and decent damage tbh. Evans isnt bad but the reload takes forever due to its high ammo capacity and it has worse accuracy than the Lancaster. That reload will get you killed in Online. Lancaster has the best accuracy of all 4 and has the 2nd best damage behind the Litchfield. Lancaster is so good you dont even really need deadeye to get constant headshots. So given all these facts idk how in the hell you could rank the Evans and Litchfield above the Lanny? Whatever you're drinking I want some too so I can take a trip to la la land once in awhile as well 🤣
That’s just your aim fam. I don’t miss with the Litchfield and with Express it’s usually one shot one kill. Litchfield is also better for repeated shots from the hip. Lancaster is also ugly in my opinion.
@@pharoahlewis4668 the lancaster is the best looking one by far, its literally just the winchester 1897 (i think) and when it comes to aim the litchfield is just shit, its like a 1700s musket with a faster firing speed
I think you are not that skillful. Evan repeater is above them all, it will op when you are using scope it applies with other repeaters. So yes number 1 should be evan then lancaster
@@dukemeiser19 The Lancaster 2 taps to the body, Evans 3 taps, Lancaster is slightly more accurate by default, the only thing the Evans has on the Lancaster is 12 more shots. How is it better?
Lancaster is my second weapon choice after bolt action rifle. Accuracy is everything in this game and powerful weapons like the Litchfield won’t matter if you’re missing your shots because of poor accuracy.
They are all more then adeguate, I personally like the Carbine the most just because of it's distinctive cycling and reload animations. Looks really pretty with black iron frame and mahogany varnish. I prefer the Bolt Action for serious gunfights anyway
No matter what ranking it is, the Lancaster will always be my favorite repeater cause it's so iconic for a western game or movie, it's so powerful, looks good and you can get it pretty quickly at the start of the game❤
The Litchfield Repeater would be an amazing option, if it weren't for its terrible accuracy and slow time to stabilize aim. Aiming while moving is just as wide if not wider than the carbine repeater, and unlike both the carbine and lancaster repeaters, the litchfield repeater has the widest aim from consecutive shots. Especially while hipfiring. The carbine repeater is not a particularly bad repeater, but it isn't outright the best repeater. It has the lowest magazine in its class at 7 rounds, but its time to stabilize aim is decent enough to be usable in PVE applications. This is a little bit of lancaster and litchfield, as moving while aiming gives a wider cone, almost just like the litchfield, but accuracy in consecutive shots nearly match the lancaster repeater. Its hipfire is decent as well, and the reloads are the quickest in its class. The lancaster repeater is by far the best for quick use and ease of handling, and boasts the tightest accuracy cones in the game. Time to stabilize is quick, as the general cone is already small enough to hit medium-distance targets. Consecutive shots hardly broaden your aim, and moving while shooting doesn't kill much of your accuracy, unlike with the carbine and litchfield. Hipfire on this repeater is so good that you can hit targets with it from borderline close range. In terms of damage and damage alone, the litchfield is the best, lancaster is middle, and carbine is worst, but in red dead online, damage is absolutely not everything. Even the varmint rifle can kill an npc if you're hitting headshots as you should be, and because handling is more important than just raw damage, for quick headshots, the lancaster repeater is the best repeater to buy for PVE and even PVP applications.
In real life the Evans had some serious design issues, mostly around how the rifle reloads and holds it’s ammunition. The Lichfield is essentially a .44 Henry repeater, which was a rimfire cartridge. Rimfire is generally considered less reliable, and the Henry’s lack of forward grip meant the rifle got extremely hot to hold after successive rounds. The carbine is modeled after the Spencer’s repeater. Not a bad rifle by any stretch, but not considered the best. The Lancaster is modeled after the Winchester 1866. It’s widely considered to be one of the most iconic rifles ever produced and even reproductions are extremely coveted for their smooth action, accuracy and reliability. There for my list is as follows: 1. Lancaster 2. Carbine 3. Lichfield 4. Evans
The funny thing is the litchfield is older than the lancaster as i am pretty sure litch field is based on the 1860 henry rifle while lancaster is based on the 1866 whinchester rifle so yeah both are VERY classic western
#1 in my book is the Lancaster, but when you run those damage overhaul mods the litch field is my favorite go to since you can just pop of one round to the gut or leg and that’ll keep em down long enough to give you time to clear almost every other enemy. This game modded is almost a dream
I prefer the Carbine due to it’s reload speed, while other dudes in a Lever action rifle battle take forever to load theirs, it just takes one swift motion, a push, and hip fire, and the Carbine Repeater’ll come out victorious, while it does lack ammo capacity and power, it makes up for in speed, precision, and usefulness. The Carbine’s #1 in my op
Glad to see some Litchfield and Evans love. Litchfield is really good you just have to time your shot and it’s extremely powerful, evans is super accurate and quick with lots of ammo
The Lancaster is the best for me cause the sound is just ear candy, also idk why but on controller when u auto lock it’s just so easy to hit headshots with it
Remember. Every gun is good, it’s all about the user. If someone says this gun is bad then their just shit at using them. I killed a 4 pose of players online with a carbine while they used shotguns and Lancaster.
The Evans also has probably the most accurate iron sights. The Carbine is weird, the Lancaster is okay but sometimes gets blurry, the Litchfield has too small of a tiny of iron sights, but the Evans sight is clear enough to aim with and is easy to use.
I’m sick of all these Lancaster meatriders bro, it’s a mid ass gun the reload takes so long that by the time it’s reloaded the gang has already disbanded. Not to mention it’s shitty fucking damage
Which repeater is the worst? Comment down below 👇
Join the server:
discord.gg/VctH84hB
Litchfield
can u review all hatchet and knives and etc mele cus theirs alot of hatchet and knives
Carbine
@@SpanishGrandpai have check the playlist
The evans The 🐐
Land caster at 3 is wild
mmm middd
On my mama u glazing the evens repeater
@@FucSwampo980 facts
The Evan’s is super good and the Lancaster is shit
@@Yesyes35320proof
The best repeater is Arthur. He repeats 'yer a good girl' alot.
erm...
@@wellington66440he means the horse bro😭
“You sir, are a fish,”
Ok, catch you later then.
“It’s okay boy” my favorite getting on horse quote
First time I've heard someone else mention the goofy noise the Litchfield makes
it sounds like a wheezing cat
Bro I always thought I was trippin and it was the coughs of the npcs getting hit but nah it’s jus the rifle
😂
i searched on google why chicken sounds were playing when i shot😭
@@dukemeiser19 clean it, it’s not supposed to sound like a wheezing cat.
Lancaster >>>> Litchfield
Woah now the lanc sucks
@@Yesyes35320proof
@@Yesyes35320never cook again
@@UJHHYHG-jd3sk no I will
@@UJHHYHG-jd3sk fr lancaster is a classic and best of all can be got the second you get into ch2 for free
If you don’t stand by the lancast your an opp
I stand by the Lanc and want all the smoke.
@@Southernstereotype yeh
It with my 2 volcanic pistols are absolutely awesome
@@blitzboy2934 how much ammo they hold haven't bought them tho but thinking bout it
@@katherinemarks8067 haven’t played in a bit, but I think 8?
Even in story mode, I'd still have to go with a fully upgraded Lancaster Repeater. I get headshots all day with it, in story mode and online mode.
And it has 14 shots before a reload. That’s a ton!
@@Jive33 Damn right.
@@Jive33 the Evans has 26!!!
@@JRJ15less accurate, less damage
@@JRJ15 yeah but its so bad lol
Reload-Carbine
Accuracy-Lancaster
Power-Litchfield
Ammo capacity and fire rate-Evans
true
Yes sometimes I am a horrible shot so I depend on accuracy so it's either lancaster or evans for me.
All you need are headshots ez
If I need anything more powerful than the Lancaster, I just use the bolt action. The Litchfield’s inaccuracy just isn’t worth it.
Each repeater has its perks, carbine, although lacking in how many bullets fit in it, reloads all bullets at once rather than one at a time
I like the carbine because I like to think it’s lore accurate, as well as dual cattlemen just the way I like to play the game.
The only Repeater with (practically) a Magazine/Cartridge/Clip reload
@@I_want_White_Cheddar_Popcorn and holds half as many bullets as the lancaster
Bro AINT NO WAY BRO PUT the Lancaster at 3 that’s CRAZY
RIGHT!! Lancaster is for the pro's who always get those headshots.
@@LukeJT22 exactly why it's my always go-to
Yeah I literally only use the Lancaster even when I have access to every other repeater
Lancaster sucks
@@filipkul Blud is a bit unintelligent
Lancaster Repeater❌
Winchester Repeater✅
Wow... you know something...
Hell yeah🔥
which one is the Winchester? the carbine?
@@PardalsemCasathe lancaster was called the winchester repeater in rdr1
@@mothman125which is also the real life name
Not including the number one option just cheats the viewer who sat through the whole thing. You just got hidden from my recommendations so congrats
So instead of checking for part two you jump to conclusions, go ahead and hide my content
@@dukemeiser19 why would you make it two parts . _.
@@falcon2345 i could only fit so many into 60s
@@dukemeiser19 like its not a big deal
Hiding him for me too what a joke
carbine has always been underrated imo i would say it deserves second place, great looking, well rounded, the fastest reload, it just lacks in ammo capacity.
(my personal ranking)
4. Lichfield Repeater
3. Lancaster Repeater
2. Carbine Repeater
1. Evans Repeater
Ammo capacity is way more valuable than reload speed. Obviously all of the guns are capable of killing people pretty effectively (especially if you're good with headshots), so none of them suck. But compared to the rest of them, fourth place is where it belongs. With the lower damage and ammo capacity, it's not great with body/limb shots. And if you can land headshots well enough, you might as well just get a gun with more ammo capacity. I can't think of any good reason to use it over any other repeater.
@@Aaron_HD lancanster lacks in reload speed, evans lacks in damage, Litchfield lacks in range. While carbine doesn’t excel at anything it doesn’t lack in anything either, so well it’s not the best if you have a certain play style it’s easily the most well rounded and there’s no situation it’s not good in, all the other rifles have weaknesses but carbine can be good in any situation, if you have moderate skill then you can use the carbine repeater easily and kick ass with it in any situation with other rifles you can usually do even better but if you get into a bad situation with them you’re pretty much fucked and it’s for this reason i’ve always loved carbine.
@@TomatoMan90 That's fair. It is pretty well rounded. I always go with the Litchfield for short to medium range combat, and the bolt action rifle for longer range. Since you can carry two large weapons, I find it unnecessary to have a jack of all trades that excels at nothing in particular, when you could just have two guns that excel at what the other doesn't. It'd definitely rank higher if you could only carry one gun.
@@Aaron_HD that's valid
At least to me? Carbine is close to being first place because it is really good! The second most damaging, great stats overall and even if you can't hold a lot? The reload is so fast it literally doesn't have it matter that it reloads more often when it kills in good three, two or one shot cus of it's overall well balanced stats
Lancaster Repeater was my main short rifle personally, it’s incredibly reliable because it’s accuracy bonus made the hit to damage worth it compared to the other short rifles, if you’re a good aim and can consistently hit centre mass and headshots you don’t need to worry about the lower damage stat, and even then you can pump it with express rounds to give the damage stat that extra boost.
Lancaster for story, Evans for Online. That Evans Repeater is wild.
Evans is imbalanced in any place
evans is even better in story, as it has really high ammo capacity that you can instantly reload by using dead eye, and has good damage and accuracy
Lancaster all day for online, especially pvp. The Evens reticle bloom is much bigger. Sometimes, missing a shot altogether. The Evans sounds real beefy though. The Litchfield is well so so.
@@michaelhunt6920 I tried evans repeater in story mode and it is extremely op.
Bro got every in reverse
Never rank again
did you need to comment this twice
@@dukemeiser19 your complete garbage takes require posting twice
@@dukemeiser19 yes
@@simonpataki3343 fair enough
Lmaooo.
Guys, he’s not ranking by ONLY opinion, he’s also using stats.
yes
Bro tried to cook soo hard, but overcooked it, quit 🔥🔥🔥
Rude
I tried to get used to the Litchfield and Evans but I just had to go back to the Lancaster because for my play style it is just perfect
Exactly this! I've tried all three and the Lancaster just fits me best. I love the ammo capacity of the Evans, but it's reload speed is crap!
@@GrandDaddyDoug just use dead eye it auto reloads your gun
Evans is second best to the Lancaster in my opinion
Arthur Morgan himself will rise out of the grave to give you a big Tommy special if you don’t change the lancaster’s placement
Let him go ahead and try
I love the Evan’s for the reload noise and the 26 bullets. I’ll also run sawed offs and a carcano. Sometimes I’ll swap the sawed offs for schofields or m1899s but if I do that I change out the carcano for a repeating shotgun
nice
yeah even if the evans is impractical in game and irl, i love my conveyor belt repeater
@@adorablecenturion8436honestly its not, if you're good at hitting headshots it becomes a mass genocide weapon
“change out”?
@@adamtzschwhat's confusing about that? Lol
Nah the Lancaster is objectively the second best weapon in the game. Maybe in single player it’s good, but in online the thing has perfect accuracy and bloom compared to every other weapon.
Omgggg fr tho it's my immediate go to in gunfights if the ppl im fighting aren't lag switching it gets headshots like no other it's accuracy makes up for its lack of strength
What would you consider the best then?
Try the evans its just as accurate and has 26 rounds
@@Mr.MANN1234 it does less damage on body shots though. Lancaster two taps while the Evans three taps. The Lancaster is also a quarter more accurate by default and you can maximize the accuracy to 100 with improved iron sights which makes it the best for landing quick headshots with free aim.
Evans to me is just not worth the extra 12 bullets considering the downsides. Plus, most firefights are over before you reach the fourteenth bullet of the Lancaster. You have ample time to reload in between tbh, and that’s without Dead Eye instantly reloading your weapons in single player.
@@Mr.MANN1234 And the Lancaster has 14, and ammo count is wholly irrelevant in this game when flicking on dead eye for a millisecond will fully reload anyways, plus if you need 26 shots in a fight you’re actually just horrible at shooting.
Lancaster>>>Litchfield
Litchfield literally has no accuracy. You miss every shot with it
Edit: nobody in the replies agrees with me💀
Maybe ur just a shitty shot
No, you're just impatient. Just wait for reticle to tighten
YOU miss every shot with it
@@riordankneale3573 why would I do that if with the Lancaster does it a lot faster
literally skill issue
first person i've seen that doesn't glaze the lancaster
In my opinion the Lancaster is the best.
The Lancaster has the fastest reticle closing time, as in the fastest accuracy after aiming
@@Wcduc exactly that's why it's the best. It's a fast boi
It's literally the best repeater
YEEEEEESSSSSS BROOOO
The drawbacks to the Litchfield are actually why ive hung with the Lancaster to this day: I much prefer to land all of my shots even if I have to spend a couple more of them to drop the target.
Lancaster is #1, the accuracy of the weapon is top notch, may lack stopping power on regular ammo, but you can get high velocity and express rounds.
Evans repeater is at #2, mainly for storage capacity, holding 26 rounds. But that gives you a really long reload time. Pretty accurate but I rarely use it.
The litchfield stats are strange to me. Supposedly they are better than the Lancaster, but I don’t see it. It’s really loud, sounds like I shotgun and it’s hard to hit any damn thing. I rather use the regular carbine repeater.
try my hardest to like the litchfield but it just is so inconsistent
The Litchfield's sound always reminds me of Sunset Riders
I love the carbine repeater. I often interchange it with the Lancaster
The evans is my favorite specifically for the sound they gave it
What do you have to be smoking to rank the Lancaster at 3, LET ALONE putting it behind the litchfield
Personally, i use the lancaster bcoz it has the fastest ads time and amazing accuracy which makes me feel like a proper outlaw coz quick draw
evans repeater is the number 1 for me. 20+ bullets in one magazine and just really satisfying to shoot. but every gun is satisfying to shoot in rdr2
Nahhhhh
The noise it makes, the amount of bullets and that it can one shot to the body at mid range makes it really good
@Cebeileo it's damage is complete trash though
@@EvanWhiteYeah I barely play online but it’s good in story since that’s what I meant
@@EvanWhiteYeahjust have good aim and hit headshots idfk
Fun fact. The real basis for the Litchfield was actually very terrible because rounds could explode in the tube
crazy
@@dukemeiser19 yeah it's why they were rejected by the U.S. military while the carbine repeater (based on the spencer carbine) was actually used in the civil war as a calvary rifle iirc. There was even a breech loaded version
@@TheLostGamerMan crazy
@dukemeiser19 alright you forced my hand.
Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy. Crazy? I was crazy once. They locked me in a room. A rubber room. A rubber room with rats. And rats make me crazy.
@@TheLostGamerMancrazy
Number one for me is always the Carbine because of the reload, oh that sweet sweet reload
isn't it the best statistically? ie) accuracy, damage, etc. at least in story mode.
@@dylanwatt7461 I honestly have no clue lol
@@user-sj3cd1je9e ill be hella pissed if i was wrong and the evans litchfield and even lancaster were better the whole game.
@@dylanwatt7461 Lancaster is better
@@JSamad why the game stats say carbine is best then? im not talking about mag capacity or looks
Evan’s my fav so it’s nice to see other creators like it too
@@THEBOYSARETHEGOAT a very nice weapon
Evans be basically spitting bullets yet still killa in 2 to 3 shots. Imagine getting head shots with this.
More detailed analysis:
1. Lancaster have a *slightly* lower damage output than the carbine repeater and the most accurate. But it is overall a jack of all trades weapon that's preferred by many for it's generic appearance and reliability. (Is also easy to find due to it being obtainable FREE by completing a stranger mission in Rhode's gunsmith)
2. The Carbine repeater has the fastest reload out of all of the repeaters (which sorta makes up for it's 7 rounds capacity but it can be put to last by using deadeye which reloads anything instantly.) So it's more preferable to be used by some players in online since dead eye won't reload the repeater unlike in story mode.
3. Litchfield Repeater has the highest damage out of all the repeaters and often have the ability to one shot enemies with express ammo types. This comes at a cost of accuracy which is bad but more manageable than the carbine repeater.
4. Evans repeater has the highest ammo count out of all the guns in the game at 26 rounds. Has mediocre damage but predictably the slowest reload time out of every gun (excluding using dead eye)
So in my opinion:
Story mode:
1. Evans Repeater
2. Lancaster Repeater
3. Litchfield Repeater
4. Carbine Repeater
Online mode:
1. Lancaster Repeater
2. Evans Repeater
3. Carbine Repeater
4. Litchfield Repeater
I personally think that the list goes like this:
1. Lancaster
2. Carbine
3. Evans
4. Litchfield
The litchfield literally cannot hit anything, the evans feels solid but i think the reload is too slow, the carbine is soild too and has a really fast reload, and the lancaster just feels the best to use and is the most well rounded
*YOU* cannot hit anything, not the litchfield
@@lordspider4376If they can hit with everything else then maybe it’s guns fault and not theirs
The Evans is such an amazing Repeater. Love it!
🍷🗿
Fishing for engagement with Lancaster at 3 😂
Ok
The carbine repeater has the highest per shot damage out of all the repeaters but the lowest magazine capacity, however it is MUCH faster to reload which IMO makes it extremely underrated
Yeah, I dont know what the video is talking, claiming that Lancaster is more powerful than Carbine. Carbine has higher dmg and accuracy. Carbine would be the best overall, but magazine is too small. I rather use Vulcanic pistols, which are pretty much single hand Carbines you can dual wield.
Also, when I use long arm with big punch, I rather just take Bolt Action then instead of Carbine, and some faster and large clip repeater like evans instead.
Lancaster deserves number 1.
Someone gets it
Na Lancaster Is Glazed asf
@@GreysonGabbleFake News
nope
Dude the lanc is pure shit
Evans at #1 is nasty work
You are delusional if you think anything other than the Lancaster should be #1 😂
Litchfield is worst by far! Worst accuracy in the game. I hit more shots with a shotgun at 100 yards than that pathetic Litchfield. Unless you are using deadeye constantly the Litchfield is the worst gun in the game. Its decent in Online if you're using Paint it Black constantly because of its high damage output. Other than that its trash! Carbine gets the 3rd spot because it has a quick reload and decent damage tbh. Evans isnt bad but the reload takes forever due to its high ammo capacity and it has worse accuracy than the Lancaster. That reload will get you killed in Online. Lancaster has the best accuracy of all 4 and has the 2nd best damage behind the Litchfield. Lancaster is so good you dont even really need deadeye to get constant headshots. So given all these facts idk how in the hell you could rank the Evans and Litchfield above the Lanny? Whatever you're drinking I want some too so I can take a trip to la la land once in awhile as well 🤣
That’s just your aim fam. I don’t miss with the Litchfield and with Express it’s usually one shot one kill. Litchfield is also better for repeated shots from the hip. Lancaster is also ugly in my opinion.
@@pharoahlewis4668 the lancaster is the best looking one by far, its literally just the winchester 1897 (i think) and when it comes to aim the litchfield is just shit, its like a 1700s musket with a faster firing speed
I think you are not that skillful. Evan repeater is above them all, it will op when you are using scope it applies with other repeaters. So yes number 1 should be evan then lancaster
Im not reading allat
@@pharoahlewis4668 the gun sucks ass especially in PvP
I just wanna say I wish they added the buffalo rifle. That would've been THE gun to use with any pistol
what is wrong with you the Lancaster is not only the best repeater, but the best gun in the game 😂
evans
@@dukemeiser19 you are so unbelievably wrong it's not even funny
@@adamlauer1096 Ok
@@dukemeiser19
The Lancaster 2 taps to the body, Evans 3 taps, Lancaster is slightly more accurate by default, the only thing the Evans has on the Lancaster is 12 more shots.
How is it better?
@@Jono_93 evans
Lancaster is my second weapon choice after bolt action rifle. Accuracy is everything in this game and powerful weapons like the Litchfield won’t matter if you’re missing your shots because of poor accuracy.
They are all more then adeguate, I personally like the Carbine the most just because of it's distinctive cycling and reload animations. Looks really pretty with black iron frame and mahogany varnish.
I prefer the Bolt Action for serious gunfights anyway
true
No matter what ranking it is, the Lancaster will always be my favorite repeater cause it's so iconic for a western game or movie, it's so powerful, looks good and you can get it pretty quickly at the start of the game❤
Evans is CRIMINALLY underrated
they called me a mad man
@@dukemeiser19 I just wish you could get it earlier in the game because I also think it's the best repeater in the game
@@ArthurMorganboahh unfortunately
The Litchfield Repeater would be an amazing option, if it weren't for its terrible accuracy and slow time to stabilize aim. Aiming while moving is just as wide if not wider than the carbine repeater, and unlike both the carbine and lancaster repeaters, the litchfield repeater has the widest aim from consecutive shots. Especially while hipfiring.
The carbine repeater is not a particularly bad repeater, but it isn't outright the best repeater. It has the lowest magazine in its class at 7 rounds, but its time to stabilize aim is decent enough to be usable in PVE applications. This is a little bit of lancaster and litchfield, as moving while aiming gives a wider cone, almost just like the litchfield, but accuracy in consecutive shots nearly match the lancaster repeater. Its hipfire is decent as well, and the reloads are the quickest in its class.
The lancaster repeater is by far the best for quick use and ease of handling, and boasts the tightest accuracy cones in the game. Time to stabilize is quick, as the general cone is already small enough to hit medium-distance targets. Consecutive shots hardly broaden your aim, and moving while shooting doesn't kill much of your accuracy, unlike with the carbine and litchfield. Hipfire on this repeater is so good that you can hit targets with it from borderline close range.
In terms of damage and damage alone, the litchfield is the best, lancaster is middle, and carbine is worst, but in red dead online, damage is absolutely not everything. Even the varmint rifle can kill an npc if you're hitting headshots as you should be, and because handling is more important than just raw damage, for quick headshots, the lancaster repeater is the best repeater to buy for PVE and even PVP applications.
At first, I thought Lancaster was written “Lanchester” and I still calls it Lanchester to this day
I believe the rifling and maybe barrel length affect the weapon’s firing noise; at least that’s been my experience. Glad you mentioned it.
never let bro cook again
Too late
@@dukemeiser19 😭
In real life the Evans had some serious design issues, mostly around how the rifle reloads and holds it’s ammunition.
The Lichfield is essentially a .44 Henry repeater, which was a rimfire cartridge. Rimfire is generally considered less reliable, and the Henry’s lack of forward grip meant the rifle got extremely hot to hold after successive rounds.
The carbine is modeled after the Spencer’s repeater. Not a bad rifle by any stretch, but not considered the best.
The Lancaster is modeled after the Winchester 1866. It’s widely considered to be one of the most iconic rifles ever produced and even reproductions are extremely coveted for their smooth action, accuracy and reliability.
There for my list is as follows:
1. Lancaster
2. Carbine
3. Lichfield
4. Evans
My list would go:
1) Evans
2) Henry (Litchfield)
3) Spencer (Carbine)
4) Winchester (Lancaster)
The funny thing is the litchfield is older than the lancaster as i am pretty sure litch field is based on the 1860 henry rifle while lancaster is based on the 1866 whinchester rifle so yeah both are VERY classic western
Lancaster at 3?? 😭
Chamber of Reflection not being available to anybody really sucks. Would be great in a main channel video.
Never let bro cook again
Wild, its almost like the guns are just more or less direct upgrades. Who would've guessed
Who let bro cook 😭🙏💀
accuracy is honestly to me the most important with capacity right after
#1 in my book is the Lancaster, but when you run those damage overhaul mods the litch field is my favorite go to since you can just pop of one round to the gut or leg and that’ll keep em down long enough to give you time to clear almost every other enemy. This game modded is almost a dream
Evans repeater>overy other repeater
facts
Hell nah
First content creator that doesn't glaze the Lancaster like a donut
lancaster ain’t allat
Litchfield should be 1, that repeater with express ammunition is fire
Only in online using PIB constantly lol
For Arthur the Lanny is the GOAT its not even a close contest...
Lancaster Gang here, I’d much rather hit my target consistently than hit a bit harder but miss more
Dude you are a genius, I absolutely love this list, I hate it when people are like “ Lancaster Carrys !!!”
yes yes
It does in fact carry
@@rexosaurus3610Evans carrys
Evans my boahh
@@rexosaurus3610 Evan’s Carry’s
I prefer the Carbine due to it’s reload speed, while other dudes in a Lever action rifle battle take forever to load theirs, it just takes one swift motion, a push, and hip fire, and the Carbine Repeater’ll come out victorious, while it does lack ammo capacity and power, it makes up for in speed, precision, and usefulness. The Carbine’s #1 in my op
Pretty much Evans
I think accuracy is the most important thing in red dead and the Lancaster just feels the most accurate
No way bro put lancaster in 3
My lancaster is the most damage dealing repeater
Glad to see some Litchfield and Evans love. Litchfield is really good you just have to time your shot and it’s extremely powerful, evans is super accurate and quick with lots of ammo
people act like the lancaster is the only gun to ever exist
Carbine Repeater was literally my favorite weapon in the game. Criminally underrated for being the best Repeater.
Agreed. It can be one of the best weapons in the game if you know how to properly utilize its strengths, of which it has many.
Have 600 kills (450 headshots) with it. My setup was:
Sawed-off Shotgun/Volcanic Pistol
Carbine Repeater
Carcano Rifle/Bow
The Lancaster carried me throughout my first 2 play throughs
Me the firts time playing rdr2: ¿and where is the winchester repeater?
it’s only in rdr1 unfortunately
@@dukemeiser19 😔
Whenever i go on a "crusade", evan and Schofield are my go-to
@@gokith1119 nice
Evens is the best in my opinion
My favourite is litchfield. The sound and a bit worse accuracy makes gameplay more immersive.
Spencer repetaer is the best for me
The Landcaster carried me throughout the entire game, it is a disservice to put in 3
You just straight up wrong on this one
fair enough
Lichfeild: What could possibly be the difference between you and me!?
Lancaster: “the difference is I’m not mid 🤠”
@@DodgedodgesProblems lancaster is the upgrade, the litchfield is a cheap knock off
i prefer both the Lancaster and the Evans
The Lancaster is the best for me cause the sound is just ear candy, also idk why but on controller when u auto lock it’s just so easy to hit headshots with it
Finally some more red dead again.
Remember. Every gun is good, it’s all about the user. If someone says this gun is bad then their just shit at using them. I killed a 4 pose of players online with a carbine while they used shotguns and Lancaster.
this has gotta be a troll video with the amount of misinformation ☠️☠️☠️
yea itnis
so lancaster is best right?😭
the carbine repeater is basic but its my favorite for its rapid reload via tube magazine and once you upgrade it, it packs a good enough punch aswell
carbine repeater reloads the fastest, why is that not the best
That barely means anything, with the Evans you probably will barely need to reload
I like the Litchfield repeater, the sound is so good
Breaking down dukemeiser19's illegal border crossing
Lancaster at three is crazy accuracy is everything
I like the Litchfield the most and Lancaster last
The Evans also has probably the most accurate iron sights. The Carbine is weird, the Lancaster is okay but sometimes gets blurry, the Litchfield has too small of a tiny of iron sights, but the Evans sight is clear enough to aim with and is easy to use.
it’s aight
this is literaly just the order of aquirement, same as rdr 1's carbine, winchester, henry and evans repeaters
which makes sense cause they get better the more you get into the game
Repeaters ❌
Rifles ❌
Carcano Without Scope ✅
valid
I’m sick of all these Lancaster meatriders bro, it’s a mid ass gun the reload takes so long that by the time it’s reloaded the gang has already disbanded. Not to mention it’s shitty fucking damage
On pvp if you're not worried about headshots the lancaster basically becomes a machine gun