SHOWDOWN! Badger VS Synthetic Brush

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 авг 2024
  • Greetings! I hope you are all staying safe and healthy!
    In today's episode, Geofatboy describes the differences between badger and synthetic shaving brushes and performs a "showdown" contest mixing lather with a Simpsons Chubby 2 brush vs a Simpsons Trafalgar T2 shaving brush. World famous Proraso-Green Tube shaving cream is lathered up in a Shave Nation ceramic shaving bowl. Watch to improve your shaving knowledge and see which brush emerges victorious! Click below to purchase these items. Visit ShaveNation.com for all your shaving supplies.
    Please Subscribe and comment.
    Shave Gear:
    All Simpsons Brushes: bit.ly/Simpsons...
    Trafalgar Synthetic Brushes: bit.ly/Trafalg...
    Proraso Shaving Cream: bit.ly/ProrasoM...
    Shave Nation Lather Bowl: bit.ly/ShaveNat...
    Marble Brush Soaking Cups: bit.ly/MarbleB...
    Shave Nation Microfiber Cloth: bit.ly/SNMicrof...
    Geofatboy's Attire:
    Under Armour Shirt: amzn.to/2taPE7V
    G Shock Watch: amzn.to/3lU6qzq
    Top 10 Videos:
    How To Shim a Razor: • Shim and Shave! Will Y...
    Safety Razor vs Cartridge Razor: • Safety vs Cartridge Ra...
    Shave Against The Grain: • How To Shave Against T...
    Top 10 Safety Razors: • Top 10 Safety Razors
    Eliminate Shaving Irritation: • How To Deal with Shavi...
    How To Shave With a Safety Razor: • Tutorial: Learn How To...
    How To Shave With a Straight Razor: • Quick Tutorial: Learn ...
    All About Shaving Bowls: • Ready? Lets Bowl! All ...
    All About Shaving Brushes: • Learn About Shaving Br...
    All About Double Edge Razor Blades: • Learn All About Double...
    Filming Equipment:
    Camera: amzn.to/2ukcw4e
    Memory Card: amzn.to/2uozfgf
    Tripod: amzn.to/2un6OPi
    Microphone: amzn.to/2ufiSCx
    Background Music: amzn.to/2sVSA40
    Social Media:
    RUclips: bit.ly/GeofatboyYT
    Facebook: bit.ly/FBGeofatboy
    Instagram: bit.ly/InstaGeo...
    Instagram: bit.ly/InstaSha...
    Twitter: bit.ly/TwitterG...
    Wonder How It All Started?
    The Story of Shave Nation: • The Story of Geofatboy...
    Have A Great Shave, Have A Great Day!
    Geo

Комментарии • 351

  • @Shaverboy516
    @Shaverboy516 3 года назад +43

    I think Geo had a lather party after this video😂 Even when I don’t shave, I still have a great day when Geo uploads a video:) and at 10:47 man down, with slo motion and sound effects!!!!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +12

      Thanks RK! It does my ❤️good to know that these little episodes brighten your (and other's) day.

    • @Shaverboy516
      @Shaverboy516 3 года назад +3

      @@geofatboy you’re the best Geo! and thank you:)

    • @kelseymj1975
      @kelseymj1975 10 месяцев назад

      You should do a shave with each and then compare results.

  • @penburger
    @penburger Год назад +19

    I only came to your videos as an introduction to wet shaving but I just keep watching them. I gotta admit your enthusiasm is infectious.

  • @WSF176
    @WSF176 3 года назад +64

    Synthetic for me. I have one badger I originally obtained many many moons ago and keep it for sentimental reasons. The synthetic is what I use 99% of the time.

    • @karunsabbarwal007
      @karunsabbarwal007 3 года назад +2

      Likewise. When I started wet shaving, everyone said buy a badger but with years of shaving I get excellent lather and shave with synthetic. With AliExpress selling reasonable synthetic brushes - they give badger a run for there money.

    • @BrettzGaming56
      @BrettzGaming56 3 года назад +3

      Samer here. I LOVE my WCS Honeycomb Synthetic.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +6

      Thanks for sharing your experience!

  • @JeroenvanKleef
    @JeroenvanKleef 3 года назад +19

    “No markings on the back, no markings on the bottom”. That almost sounds like the start of a magic trick ;)

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +7

      Nothin' up my sleeve-Presto!

  • @marvley361
    @marvley361 3 года назад +25

    I have badger, synthetic, and boar brushes and haven’t used my badger brushes for several years. The boar brushes are great for hard pucks and synthetic for everything else.

  • @rickwebermusic
    @rickwebermusic Год назад +8

    A good badger brush is hard to beat. That said, I love my $12 Stirling synthetic and use it exclusively now. The biggest pro for synthetics is that you don't have to "baby" them. No break-in ritual, shampooing, or soaking required. They're zero fuss, no maintenance brushes that always perform well.
    BTW, I started my wet shaving journey 10 years ago watching your videos; and here I am...still watching! Always great content, brother!

  • @floriandurre4953
    @floriandurre4953 3 года назад +15

    You look like a little kid in a candy store while lathering. Very cool. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @Neo_Rain146
    @Neo_Rain146 3 года назад +14

    Geo has such a satisfied look on his face when whipping up that lather. Love it!

  • @williamcass68
    @williamcass68 3 года назад +30

    Great comparison! One can’t argue about the superior performance of badger but at least for me, synthetic is better as I don’t like the feeling of animal hair on my face (personal preference). Also the cost difference is pretty significant.

    • @drumrit
      @drumrit 2 года назад +4

      I know it sounds stupid but I didn’t think of that! I have a cat and that hair irritates me all the time lol

    • @whatever_it_takes6691
      @whatever_it_takes6691 Год назад +9

      1. The classic vegan joke
      Q: How do you know if someone is Vegan?
      A: Don’t worry, they’ll tell you within the first 2 minutes of meeting them.

  • @googlesu
    @googlesu 3 года назад +5

    I love how he says 'supplies' in the intro!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Nice! I'm gonna replay it myself and check. Thanks.

  • @EricMustardman
    @EricMustardman 3 года назад +9

    I bought a Simpson Trafalgar T2 1.5 years ago and it replaced all my other shaving brushes within less than a month. Great lather, super soft tips and still looks like it came out of the box just yesterday. For under $25, it was rather a steal than a purchase.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +1

      It is a great brush for the price point!

    • @righteousredneck777
      @righteousredneck777 7 месяцев назад

      The T2 is exactly what I'm thinking of getting. Glad I saw your comment

    • @EricMustardman
      @EricMustardman 4 месяца назад

      @@geofatboy I've meanwhile upgraded to a Simpson Duke 3 Synthetic and this thing shoots all my other brushes straight out of the water. It might be a very good (absolutely equal!) comparision letting a Duke 3 Synthetic compete against a Duke 3 Best Badger.

  • @rajansharmaadv
    @rajansharmaadv 3 года назад +11

    Hello, Geo, how are you, I like using synthetic hair shaving brush as I get allergy all over my face with the badger hair shaving brush and moreover synthetic hair brushes are cruelty free 🙏🙏🙏👍👍

  • @87licorice
    @87licorice 3 года назад +34

    The synthetic looks like it paints on thicker. Taking into account the ethical issues, price and softness it seems like synthetic is a bit better except for lather ability.

  • @mcflotty
    @mcflotty 3 года назад +6

    The call is going to come down to what someone prefers. Both clearly produced enough for multiple passes

  • @witeq1471
    @witeq1471 3 года назад +6

    Love my Trafalgar T2 Synthetic

    • @davesheppard8797
      @davesheppard8797 3 года назад +1

      Yeah, great brush! I prefer my T2 to my T3. The Chubby 2 synthetic though is really stunning but not a huge difference between the Chubby and the T2.
      Dave.

  • @davesheppard8797
    @davesheppard8797 3 года назад +3

    I have a Simpsons T3. Its a great brush. I have a few Taylors super badger a Trumpers super badger brush and two Kent Silvertip Bk8 & Bk4. I also have a Simpsons best badger X2L. I find the T3 needs a lot less care and dries a lot quicker when hung up to dry. I think my favourite is my Taylors HT2 super badger brush.
    Dave.

  • @agore1945
    @agore1945 3 года назад +4

    I rotate through multiple brushes, synthetic, badger,boar and horse. All perform well, but I personally like the stiffness of the natural brushes better.

  • @rsolsjo
    @rsolsjo 3 года назад +4

    I've tried both and I prefer synthetic. No smell (ugh, the smell), not as harsh for sensitive skin, easier to clean and they hold together better. And of course no animal was harmed or "farmed" if you will.

  • @azaz...
    @azaz... 3 года назад +7

    i love the detail you go into when making the videos, thanks geo.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +3

      Thank so much azaz!

    • @azaz...
      @azaz... 3 года назад +1

      @@geofatboy welcome, hey geo, any chance you can ask taylor of old bond street to make more CEDARWOOD products please , i know sandalwood is popular but cedarwood is pure heaven!!!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +1

      @@azaz... I will convey it, they may or may not abide... Thanks!

  • @BartBuzz
    @BartBuzz 3 года назад +5

    You always have great comparison videos. My first brush was a cheap boar. Then I discovered synthetics. Synthetic brushes cost much less than quality boar/badger brushes. I have 4 synthetic brushes, including the Simpsons T2. I even have a $10 synthetic that rivals my more expensive ones. But that doesn't surprise me since there's not a whole lot of difference in synthetic materials. They all pretty much look, feel, and perform the same in the short time I've used them.

  • @spartan9212
    @spartan9212 3 года назад +12

    The lather from the synthetic looked more thick and creamy where as the badger made a lot more which is unecessary unless you're shaving your whole body.

    • @bytebuster
      @bytebuster 3 года назад

      I have the same idea as yours. I”ve noticed this difference with my brushes too. I think that the badger hair holds more water than the synthetic hair and that is the reason why the lather of the badger brush is runny, compared to the lather of the synthetic brush.

    • @BerserkeR_031
      @BerserkeR_031 3 года назад

      You can fix that by putting less soap in the bowl and also using less water to get thicker foam ofc. So imo it's just about the bristles.

    • @spartan9212
      @spartan9212 3 года назад

      @@bytebuster or you can simply just use the synthetic.

    • @bytebuster
      @bytebuster 3 года назад +2

      @@BerserkeR_031 I don't know why, my experience and what I've heard from other people is that the lather of badger brush is different than the synthetic brush. Most of the people say that the lather of a shaving brush with synthetic hairs is more creamy and the badger hair runny. Conclusion is, as you say here, manage the amount of water. Now I go for synthetic haired brushes, because they are first animal friendly, last longer and they are cheaper.

    • @bytebuster
      @bytebuster 3 года назад +1

      @@spartan9212 I'm using synthetic brushes for a long time. I've noticed that they make better lather, they are animal friendly, cheaper and they last longer than badger brushes.

  • @Smootus
    @Smootus 3 года назад +3

    This is a video I didn’t know I wanted to see, and I am glad you did this! I have used badger brushes and I have a synthetic brush. I really like the “feel” of the badger and I like the “stiffness” and softness of the badger. The synthetic seems to me to lather better. The synthetic seems harder to lather some pucks, however. So, for me, it’s a badger. UNLESS I am traveling...... then I take a synthetic. It dries so much faster. Thanks for posting this video!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Hi Bryan-Thanks for sharing!

  • @sbatty65227
    @sbatty65227 3 года назад +8

    Have always used Silvertip badger as I've always found synthetic brushes to be fairly useless. However the Simpson's synthetic looks a fantastic brush and will be worth purchasing.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Thanks for your input Steven.

    • @nicetna2010
      @nicetna2010 3 года назад +4

      I also prefer badger to synthetic. Geo is spot on, the badger attracts and retains water like nobody's business. Exceptional lather everytime, and lots of it.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +3

      @@nicetna2010 Someone's got my back!

  • @thomaspowers6761
    @thomaspowers6761 3 года назад +4

    Geo, you looked in total bliss applying the lather, works better than meditation...

    • @brenthooton3412
      @brenthooton3412 3 года назад

      "The Zen moment of the shave right there."

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +1

      Like Brent said! Best part of the shave❤️

  • @Orochi_001
    @Orochi_001 3 года назад +25

    I’d say animal cruelty also comes into play for me. At this point, I can’t see a good argument for badger brushes. If one wants exfoliation and invigoration, go with boar. My favorite brushes are actually boar-bristle. Great vid, as always!

    • @JonBonesJones84
      @JonBonesJones84 3 года назад +5

      I think everyone should have that in the back of their mind. Does the hair from Simpsons' badger brushes come from China where they torture the badgers? We all know what China does to animals...And even if they do get the hair bristles from European badgers, how do we know that they weren't killed for their hair?

    • @EasyTarget82
      @EasyTarget82 3 года назад +7

      This is why I prefer synthetic since no animals are harmed over it.

    • @xvulture21gtav24
      @xvulture21gtav24 3 года назад +1

      Are synthetics also good at exfoliating?

    • @ripvanwinkle9072
      @ripvanwinkle9072 3 года назад +6

      You know, horse hair brushes are vegan, because cutting the hair of horses is part of their grooming.

    • @michaelhayward7572
      @michaelhayward7572 3 года назад +3

      @@JonBonesJones84 anti cruelty groups have investigated and done under cover videos which are on YT.
      Prepare to weep what mankind will do for a quick buck. Several outlets have since said once stock is depleted, they will not restock. If you like Badger brushes, stock up now.

  • @primaveraimages
    @primaveraimages 3 года назад +12

    When it comes to wet shaving, Americans are like with coffe: looooots of water 😁
    I prefer Espresso 😉😃
    Ciao @Geofatboy ! ❤️🇮🇹

  • @diganto1987
    @diganto1987 3 года назад +1

    every now and then I come to this channel and watch these vids. lol I do not even know why. Feel good factor may be,

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Thank you for your support-and the Tingles!

  • @masongates246
    @masongates246 3 года назад +4

    I wanted to personally thank you for uploading these videos. With help from your videos and a few others, I recently switched form a cartridge razor to a DE setup. I went with a Van Der Hagen kit from wal-mart. I noticed the factory blades that came with the kit were really "pulling" on my face when i shaved. I ordered a sample kit from amazon with some Astra superior platinum, Feather, Gillette platinum, Kai stainless, Personna platinums and wilkinson swords. I tried our the Astra's earlier tonight and WOW they were SOO much better then the Van der hagens. I can't wait to try the others.

    • @germanshepherd13
      @germanshepherd13 3 года назад +1

      decent starter razor you got. I would check out geo's shave nation website and upgrade to an even better razor. he has an excellent selection at competitive prices and great service.

    • @masongates246
      @masongates246 3 года назад

      @@germanshepherd13 Thanks for the advice. I recently purchased a Merkur 34c and I am loving it so far. I have also tried a 1955 Gillette Red Tip and it was far too aggressive for my skill level.

  • @robertgray9802
    @robertgray9802 3 года назад +2

    one of your better videos I enjoyed watching I think you can't go wrong with either brush I just prefer synthetic though because it doesn't fray as much and tends to last longer than a badger

  • @terrym1065
    @terrym1065 3 года назад +2

    Synthetic is so easy to maintain and less expensive, it's hard to not like them. Badger is more expensive with much more maintenance, kind of like a beautiful woman, it's hard not to like them😉 Both are great to use, I switch often. Just depends on whether I want easy or refined.. Nice demo Geo👍💈👍, thanks. Stay safe. Enjoy!

  • @AlikKra
    @AlikKra 3 года назад +10

    Спасибо, за отличное и интересное видео!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +9

      Спасибо за просмотр! Я рад, что тебе понравилось.

  • @shaverx3293
    @shaverx3293 10 месяцев назад +1

    I’ve used boar, horse, inexpensive badger, boar/badger mix, vintage nylon, and various synthetics. It’s synthetic for me. You don’t have to soak them, they dry more quickly (which makes them great for travel) and the super soft types feel fantastic! There’s nothing moralistic in it regarding my choice. Convenience, performance, comfort…..for me synthetics are best!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  9 месяцев назад

      Good stuff-Thanks for sharing!

  • @diamondback2085
    @diamondback2085 3 года назад +4

    This could not have been better timed! My 4 year old daughter just gave my brush a trim yesterday and it's now useless. Look for my order soon.

    • @LeFatalpotato
      @LeFatalpotato 3 года назад +2

      That's awesome! Kids will be kids lol. I hope you will like whichever brush you get.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Ouch! I hate when that happens! But it will be a fun tale to tell for years to come...

  • @isaiahperales8271
    @isaiahperales8271 3 года назад +2

    I’m extremely new but happy to have found this channel ive been trying to up my shave game!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +1

      Welcome Isaiah-Enjoy!

  • @waynejohnson3214
    @waynejohnson3214 2 года назад +3

    I prefer synthetic. It doesn't over aerate the lather like badger hair can. I get a better shave with a wet, dense lather vs a big fluffy lather.

  • @giorgosg8760
    @giorgosg8760 2 года назад +3

    We have to consider the animals as well. As the synthetic brushes give the same or almost the same result, I do not want to think about suffering animals each time I shave myself.

  • @zeefour
    @zeefour 3 года назад +1

    I use a Razorock Plissoft Hulk 34mm Brush. Its synthetic of course.
    I have no experience with any other brush hair material so my opinion aint much but I feel you dont have to soak the bristles on the synthetic as much as animal bristles.
    At least from watching videos and using a synthetic brush myself.
    The good thing about a synthetic also is you dont need to worry so much about getting it bone dry compared to animal brushes.
    Love the Plissoft knots made by Razorock. Great video 👍

  • @waynegotke5502
    @waynegotke5502 3 года назад +2

    Your videos are so much fun to watch!! They are both entertaining and so informative and your company has the highest quality and awesome products!!!!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Thanks Wayne! I appreciate that.

  • @Abe-fp7ip
    @Abe-fp7ip Год назад

    I got the synthetic T3.
    100% agree with your review! When it’s dry, very soft and works just as well as the badger brush it replaced. Thank you for your fantastic and honest review 🙏✌️

  • @genkoperezblair9268
    @genkoperezblair9268 3 года назад +1

    I have a Omega brush. It is 100% setola (i think horse hair). Synthetic brush is eco friendly. Nice video Geo.

  • @TWalsh2
    @TWalsh2 3 года назад +3

    3:03 I don't think it's water retention that flares the brush as those brushes are dry, I think it's the badger hair splitting over time that does this.

  • @dinalobanik2802
    @dinalobanik2802 3 года назад +3

    Badgers are not available in India locally. We have to import them in order to use one. So synthetic for me. I really like the wide array of topics you cover Mr. Geo. Hey, when are we getting a tour of the Shaving Laboratory?
    Ps I really like the fact that the knots of the badger brushes get bigger and fuller with use.

  • @harveyrousejr.2069
    @harveyrousejr.2069 3 года назад

    I purchased a Chubby 2 Badger and initially didn't like it and actually put it on Bay. Fortunate for me it didn't sell and now it's my favorite brush by far. Takes time to learn how to properly hold it, especially with large hands.

  • @icecold2042
    @icecold2042 3 года назад +3

    Everybody loves a showdown!
    🥊🥊🥊🥊🏆🏆🏆👍

  • @loquendocapoxd
    @loquendocapoxd 3 года назад +2

    Geo, my man; a little bit off-topic. I have read some people say that hot water, when “priming” the shaving brush, will actually over-time soften/dissolve the knot glue.
    What’s your opinion on the matter?
    Of course, you can only get water ever so hot from the tap, but anyways, I have changed my mannerisms and now use lukewarm water.
    Love your channel, wish you the best

  • @robertross8565
    @robertross8565 Год назад +3

    Will only use synthetic brushes. I like that they are cruelty free, softer, less expensive, don't require soaking, and are improving every day.

  • @ladywetshaver
    @ladywetshaver Год назад

    Just bought 2 Simpson’s synthetic brushes, a travel size classic and a T3. I just tested the T3 and while I can tell there are differences between synthetic and natural hair brushes, I think it performed really well. I watched this video before buying.

  • @merrillquintrell9303
    @merrillquintrell9303 3 года назад +1

    I honestly prefer my silvertip badger brushes, not only for their superior water retention properties, but also for their combination of smooth tips (once properly broken in), and their beard lifting and exfoliating properties provided by a firmer backbone. The downsides are obviously price, their susceptibility to damage if brutally splayed (like some RUclips channel wet shavers do. Not you Geo!) and the longer time they require between uses to properly dry. It is actually for this last reason that my travel shaving brush is synthetic.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Agreed Merrill-I prefer the staunchness of the badger which allows you to drive the lather into the beard.

  • @mikeh9701
    @mikeh9701 3 года назад +2

    Hi Geo- Great shaving brush comparison video; thank you! I have two badger brushes, but find I keep reaching for the synthetics. Looking forward to the pink brush video! I hope you have a great Saturday. Take good care and be safe and be well. Best regards, as always, Geo!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Thanks Mike-Take care.

  • @-Wreckanize-
    @-Wreckanize- 3 года назад

    Just purchased my first decent badger brush. Parker silver tip for 60 bucks. Cant wait for it to get here. My second shaving brush ever. Used a basic cheap tweezerman that lasted me 10 years, cost 15 bucks.

  • @bretleversha
    @bretleversha 3 года назад +1

    I found after time my badger hair was much nicer to apply the lathered foam to the face over the synthetic that always pricks me a little.

  • @starlodear2987
    @starlodear2987 3 года назад +1

    There are badgers that lather just as well as synthies. The Semogue 2 band silvertip is a lather monster with excellent lather flow. It applies the lather as evenly as any synthie. Generally I prefer badgers because they are slightly scratchier and I can actually feel the brush. Virtually all synthies are too soft, apart from the Muehle Silvertip Fibre which comes close to badgers.

    • @gickojerke1262
      @gickojerke1262 3 года назад

      I got both the Mühle silvertip fibre and their black Fibre, if you like to “feel the brush” you might enjoy the Mühle black fibre more than the silvertip (like me)

  • @leemehan
    @leemehan 8 месяцев назад +2

    Will always like Badger, Boar and real hair better than synthetic... No question!!

  • @pappapiccolino9572
    @pappapiccolino9572 3 года назад +7

    Thanks Geo. Nice video. To my untrained eye, I thought the initial application of lather on each cheek resulted in a win for synthetic. The lather was more opaque, whiter with less gaps. On the badger side, I felt like I could see through it a little more.

  • @LauraKnotek
    @LauraKnotek 3 года назад +2

    I prefer badger. My favourite brush is the Simpsons Chubby 2 Best Badger. It is a lather making monster.

  • @TheRobby1971
    @TheRobby1971 3 года назад +1

    Excellent video George. Thanks Pal.

  • @cosminguramba8438
    @cosminguramba8438 3 года назад +1

    Geo, test is well performed but, you have to pick up a cream which is not lathering easy in order to see the performance. Proraso makes tones of lather only with a pen :), kind of detergent. The badger makes bigger bubbles, that's the reason is a lot more, synthetic is more creamy, better cushion, easy to use. Vote synthetic.

  • @markdavid3076
    @markdavid3076 3 года назад +3

    Thanks for posting. I love my Omega S-Brush. Great synthetic. I'm beginning to pay more attention to synthetics off late.
    Have yet to try any Simpson brushes as yet. I'm sure they're awesome.
    Stay safe Geo.

  • @diyhooligan
    @diyhooligan 3 года назад +3

    I’m sticking to my badger brushes. The scritch, heat retention and overall feeling isn’t the same with the synthetic brushes. I’ve also had the same issues that Geo had in this video, the way the fibres splay out @8:35 and when I have applied lather to my face I’ve also had big dollops of it wasted by just dropping off @10:44. I wouldn’t mind if it was a one off but when it happens every time you use a synthetic brush you know where the problem lies. The synthetic ones are only used for when I’m travelling now (thank God). I understand the cost will come into play for some people but you can still get a good quality best badger for the same price (and possibly cheaper) as some of the expensive synthetic ones I’ve seen. You can also buy some great boar brushes for a lot cheaper than both too.

  • @Samuel-ge7im
    @Samuel-ge7im 3 года назад +1

    Great shave Geo

  • @InternetOblivion
    @InternetOblivion 3 года назад +2

    Synthetic seems to do well enough and no animals were hurt. I think I'll go for it. Thanks for the comparison.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Sounds good! shavenation.com/search?q=synthetic+brush

  • @10floz30minutes
    @10floz30minutes 2 года назад

    I have used and paid attention to lather making for one synthetic brush and one badger brush, neither brush expensive. One difference I found is the badger brush being stiffer seems to mix the soap into a paste (and then with adding water) and to lather a little more quickly. Other than that I have found about the same as you did here.

  • @90RangerXLT
    @90RangerXLT 3 года назад +1

    Awesome video Geo! I think the Badger hair is a better brush. Synthetic is cheaper, but would not consider using.

  • @jeffdurheim9153
    @jeffdurheim9153 3 года назад +1

    Great video as usual Geo..Thk you

  • @Foxtrot-jr5qu
    @Foxtrot-jr5qu 3 года назад +2

    i have only one synthetic brush and it great. I had an Omega boar brush for over one year, but I never liked it. Compared to the synthetic, the boar was ''eating'' too much creams and soaps and the results were not great. I've tried all kinds of things including more water, less water and also put the brush into the fridge like 5 times for 3-4 days to break it up and although the results were a but better after a while it was still not as good as the synthetic. Recently I had enough and sold the Omega. The good thing about synthetic brushes is that they are almost maintenance free and 99% of the brushes cost below 20$, while badger brushes are a bit more expensive and you really have to take care of them. I'm not some crazy hippie that protects all animals and stuff, but I don't think God created the badgers hair so we can make a lather to shave our faces, but I still respect what people like.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Thanks for sharing your experience.

  • @gerr7207
    @gerr7207 2 года назад +1

    I suppose that badger hair is from killed animals. I don't think it is shaved from living ones. Therefore, at the end of its life, the synthetic brush leaves more plastic in the environment. So that are additional ethical aspects when comparing these brushes.

  • @michaelswanson437
    @michaelswanson437 3 года назад +1

    I have had great success with both. If I am at home, I choose the badger. When on the road, it is the synthetic. Then there is my boar brush, which I love!!

  • @RichardE62
    @RichardE62 2 месяца назад

    Hard to beat a Badger but I have synthetics that are close and even better at some things "Simpson". I like the scritch from the Badger best.

  • @SteveK1953
    @SteveK1953 8 месяцев назад

    Good review just purchased the synthetic, good information....
    Thanks much.

  • @joncurry153
    @joncurry153 3 года назад +1

    Great video, enjoyed it been waiting for something like this for a while. I’ve only ever used synthetic but was interested to see the comparison. What I’ve taken away from this is that performs is equal, but consider a wider diameter knot (say 2mm) when buying a synthetic vs badger knot. The most interesting bit for me was the final face feel which you said to be very similar if not equal.
    Would of been good to add a bit more detail into the video:
    - Diameter in mm of each knot
    - Loft in for each in my
    Have a great day 👍

  • @kcc1762
    @kcc1762 2 года назад +1

    Great video. You should do the same thing with a soap.

  • @molonlabe9602
    @molonlabe9602 Год назад +1

    Nice looking brushes but I'm quite happy with my $2 wood handled synthetic. I have many name brand brushes but
    I use the $2 brush everyday. It's light colored wood with a gold ring trim. Expensive brushes are overrated and over priced.

  • @RaymondMillbrae
    @RaymondMillbrae 3 года назад

    Badger brushes are a course application. Similar to a cheap paint brush.
    But the synthetics “paint” much better, and leave a much more consistent layer of lather.
    I have two high end Silvertip badger brushes, but I purchased them more for the feel of vintage originality. (One is a Shavemac Silvertip that cost me around $110 just for the knot).
    I prefer the synthetics, hands down.

  • @ManuelKorrigan
    @ManuelKorrigan 2 года назад +1

    Hey there .. great video and channel! I have a question : which is the best combination depending the material of the brush (boar , types of badger, synthetic) and the type of application (hard soaps, mild soaps, creams). I ve heard ,for example.. hard soaps need boar brush

  • @philipposgekousidis5634
    @philipposgekousidis5634 3 года назад +2

    Καλησπερα φιλε. Πολυ ωραιο βιντεο!!

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Ευχαριστούμε που παρακολουθήσατε. Χαίρομαι που απολαύσατε το βίντεο.

  • @hepgeoff
    @hepgeoff 2 года назад +1

    Badger brushes do have some advantages, but I refer synthetic brushes now. They're softer, less expensive, and the bristles dry faster after your shave.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  2 года назад +2

      Still the water retention capabilities of badger wins out

  • @laurent5084
    @laurent5084 2 года назад

    A new subscriber from France. Congratulations for your interesting videos.

  • @brenthooton3412
    @brenthooton3412 3 года назад +1

    I was going to say the badger until I saw you try to apply the lather to your face. The badger brush swelled up so much with the lather that it almost looked awkward to use. I use an Omega boar bristle brush and it doesn't swell up anywhere near that. Maybe the answer is to go down one size.

  • @theoned200
    @theoned200 11 месяцев назад

    I find with a triple milled soap / really hard soaps. synthetic brushes lack backbone to get a good load. Of course they will do fine with a cream

  • @PatVMurphy
    @PatVMurphy Год назад +1

    Hi GeoFB,
    Will you be doing a video on how they source and make badger & boar hair brushes?
    That might help people to decide which brush to buy.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  Год назад +1

      Thank you for your suggestion

  • @clafou1771
    @clafou1771 2 года назад

    I have a muhle kosmo fine badger and I ordered a T3 to have 2 brushes.
    I would like use synthetic (soft) for 2 days beard and fine badger for 3or 4 days beard to prevent any irritation even if fine badger is soft may be is goo to have 2 different brushes

  • @confederatejeb
    @confederatejeb 3 года назад +2

    My question is, if properly cared for, which will last longer?

  • @nevillefilar5245
    @nevillefilar5245 3 года назад +12

    For me the type of brush you use is less about performance than price and morality. To make a badger knot badgers are killed in an impossibly cruel manner. I'm not a vegetarian and have no compunction about knowing animals are killed to provide food. Im a carnivore. But to make a brush by taking a sentients life when there are so many other options available sticks in the craw. And the way it's done is horrific.
    Prior to killing badgers are kept in confined spaces to their obvious distress. It's not nice to see.
    A Simpsons Chubby Silver tip costs over £200 at my last look years ago. There is a Chubby Synthetic which could have been used in this comparison. It is a superb brush and cost me £ 65 three or four years ago. My T3 synthetic cost £20.
    I got rid of all my badger brushes and only use synthetics. They are every bit as good as badgers at doing all that a brush needs to do. Getting a decent lather on your face. All the rest is noise. And cruelty

    • @sokp9751
      @sokp9751 2 года назад +1

      Exactly!

    • @TheEdudo
      @TheEdudo 2 года назад

      "sentients", there you go you have been mindfuck by the new left ideology

  • @RainbowRoadCrashTest
    @RainbowRoadCrashTest 5 месяцев назад

    The synthetic seems more creamier though (could be the lighting). While the badger definitely seems to lather the fastest. But yeah, the good thing with synthetics is that no animals were harmed in making this brush if given to the wrong hands, and also it seems to require less maintenance and care in ensuring the quality of the synthetic.

  • @armanilehmann6537
    @armanilehmann6537 3 года назад +1

    Hey Geo, can you please use the Muhle Silvertip Badger Brush with Chrome Handle in your next video? Im considering one for Christmas.

  • @davidrosset8930
    @davidrosset8930 3 года назад +2

    Badger appeared to have the edge. But a Simpson is way above my pay grade. I would like to see a show down between Boar and Synthetic.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      There are some reasonably priced Simpsons brushes: shavenation.com/collections/simpsons-brushes

  • @borbetomagus
    @borbetomagus 3 года назад +2

    The badger seemed to produce lather more efficiently, but if you compared the same badger knot with a larger synthetic knot (at a still lesser cost) the results might have been similar. I much prefer a 26mm (or larger) synthetic brush, as it can produce enough lather using just a pea-sized amount of most shaving soaps/creams (or 6-8 flakes of triple-milled soaps) spread through the bottom of a cheap IMUSA salsa bowl. One problem one might find is that lather usually gets imbedded inside a synthetic or badger brush and can't be used. You can lean the base of the brush against the bowl and extract the lather so it can be re-worked (adding small amounts of water, if needed). The hairs will then have more room to whip up a fuller lather. But it would be nice if many brands (like Simpson) offered more ergonomic handles, as one brush I have (with a similar handle) cramps my hand and is rarely used.

  • @brigtsd7179
    @brigtsd7179 3 года назад

    The lather looked more dense and better with the synthetic brush. Very foamy with Mr Chubby. But I think it has more to do with the amount water you add than which brush you use. I would add less water than that since I prefer really dense and slick lather. I normally find the synthetic brushes way to soft but maybe the Trafalgar line has enough backbone. I need to check it out. Cheers!

  • @djkazuma
    @djkazuma 10 месяцев назад +1

    Yes badger holds more water but the hairs absorb the water as well and is unable to release the water that is absorbed in the hairs, synthetics hold about the same amount of water but it can be shaked out to almost completely dry. for me synthetic wins you don't have to pre soak the brush, its amazing for traveling as it can be dried in 10 minutes with shaking and a towel wipe, it feels beter for me, and the big one Price i paid 330 euros for my chubby 3 and i believe my 27 euro RazoRock 400 Noir is beter in every way. upkeep is also way easyer on synthetics no need to shampoo the brush and there is no smell at all.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  9 месяцев назад +1

      Thanks for sharing. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. The ongoing battle between badger and synthetic will forever be... ongoing. I like to hear both sides pros and cons.

  • @thejokergotham384
    @thejokergotham384 Год назад

    Synthetic took the esge on this test, wish i could see which one holds the heat longer as well. But very good test. Just seems the stnthetic had a thicker lather wherher it was due to less hydration is hard to say

  • @sadiqahmed3937
    @sadiqahmed3937 3 года назад +1

    Nice video brother

  • @moreshwarpanchal2861
    @moreshwarpanchal2861 2 года назад +1

    What is the difference between:
    Sovereign grade synthetic fibre
    and
    Platinum Grade synthetic bristle?
    Both are made by Simpsons…

  • @Phessington
    @Phessington 3 года назад +3

    The proraso boars hair brush is very good, once it’s been conditioned for about two to three weeks. Also because of the size , you don’t get lather over your fingers. I didn’t really like the Simpson brushes. Too short and may be it was my luck, lots of the hair was falling out of the brush.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +1

      Soaking the Proraso brush in water overnight will help soften it up quicker.

    • @Phessington
      @Phessington 3 года назад +2

      geofatboy That’s a good idea. I shampooed and conditioned the brush for over two weeks. I initially was put off of the brush, because the hairs were so scratchy, but I remembered someone mentioned on your comments or it could of been you, to shampoo and condition the brush. It’s my favourite brush now.

  • @lecco666
    @lecco666 2 года назад +1

    Why do people say they use badger at home and synthetic when they travel?

  • @Mr2Badboybrown
    @Mr2Badboybrown 3 года назад +2

    can you do a synthetic vs boar brush?

  • @dexterne
    @dexterne 3 года назад

    I don't have a Simpson's of any description. I have a Parker best badger, a Maggard synth, and an Omega boar. My go to is the synthetic, it's easier to clean, sheds less and dries quicker. Zero break in, and performs just as well 2 years in as it did on day one. Also the cheapest of the bunch.

    • @dexterne
      @dexterne 3 года назад

      My fave italian soap is hands down Cella btw. I have Proraso too, but something about that almond scent...

  • @deadcell4837
    @deadcell4837 3 года назад +1

    Have you ever used a vielong horse hair brush? Theyre worth a go

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад +1

      I have one, but still prefer the other types.

    • @deadcell4837
      @deadcell4837 3 года назад

      @@geofatboy i see, thanks for the reply 👍🏿

  • @DJViking775
    @DJViking775 3 года назад +1

    You should have compared the Synthetic against Silvertip Badger. Some of the newer synthetic are as good as Silvertip Badger. Synthetic is said to be much better than the lower quality badger, Pure, Best, Super. Like the Alpha Outlaw shaving brush that has a Gen4 synthetic fibres or the Muhle Silvertip Synthetic.
    What razor did you use when shaving this time?

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      More to come! I was test driving some new Shave Nation branded razors

  • @grandpad4197
    @grandpad4197 3 года назад +1

    What I see is you are preparing the Synthetic the same way as the badger......wonder if you use a different technique would if have a different effect? More pressure, less pressure or move faster with one.

  • @wackyp
    @wackyp 3 года назад +1

    While I never tried a Simpsons badger, I tried many others but synthetics won me over and I no longer use any natural hair brushes. In the beginning of the hobby one seems to experiment more and eventually you just use the gear that works day in, day out with no fuss. Synthetics fit this bill.

    • @geofatboy
      @geofatboy  3 года назад

      Exactly-Try out a few things and see what works best for you then stick with that.