Mid-Air Collision In Colorado! | How Did Metroliner and Cirrus Collide?!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 26 дек 2024

Комментарии • 490

  • @CuriousPilot90
    @CuriousPilot90  5 месяцев назад +59

    I hope you enjoyed this one!
    Just a point on the aircraft, the one shown is a SA-227, rather than a SA-226. The aircraft are massively similar with the main difference being a 3 bladed prop on the SA-226.

    • @emmyjj5612
      @emmyjj5612 5 месяцев назад +7

      Still a great video! Your numbers are climbing!

    • @NoPulseForRussians
      @NoPulseForRussians 5 месяцев назад +4

      Never say the word "and" when saying a date. You should know this, you are from the birthplace of the English Language lol.
      Instead of " Two Thousand And Twenty One" , just say, "Two Thousand Twenty One".
      the word And when used in a date is the bridge between two different dates. 😉

    • @timothyp3378
      @timothyp3378 5 месяцев назад +1

      My thoughts exactly

    • @emmyjj5612
      @emmyjj5612 5 месяцев назад +8

      @@NoPulseForRussiansit's also used to indicate that the numbers should be added together. 2000 + 21 is 2021. It's not incorrect, it's just not common in the US. When critiquing someone's grammar, make sure to use the standards set by the speaker's country of origin, not your own. Never say never unless you've done your research.

    • @rescue270
      @rescue270 5 месяцев назад +2

      The SA-227 also has wing extensions that are absent on the SA-226.

  • @ibgarrett
    @ibgarrett 4 месяца назад +17

    Fun fact - as of two weeks ago, the Metroliner is still parked on the ramp at APA. The fuselage is all wrapped up and just sitting there.

  • @mikeknowles8017
    @mikeknowles8017 5 месяцев назад +19

    The performance of the Metro and it's Pilot are impressive.

  • @ISL28587
    @ISL28587 5 месяцев назад +56

    I passed by that Key Lime plane on the way to one of my training flights. I don't know how you could ever land that in that state, that pilot is a miracle worker.

    • @novicereloader
      @novicereloader 5 месяцев назад +8

      That pilot initially didn't know he'd been struck by another aircraft. He did such a good job focusing on flying the plane that he thought there was a major problem with the rudder mechanism until he heard another pilot advise the tower that the cirrus was on parachute over the state park.

    • @MagicTurdd
      @MagicTurdd 4 месяца назад

      @@novicereloader he thought it was an engine failure....not a rudder issue

    • @ZachShannon
      @ZachShannon 4 месяца назад +3

      That pilot goes to my church - I guess I know someone famous 😂

    • @MagicTurdd
      @MagicTurdd 4 месяца назад +1

      @@ZachShannon yes....Shannon

  • @Fluffy-Fluffy
    @Fluffy-Fluffy 5 месяцев назад +191

    No casualties? That's insane!

    • @sarahmacintosh6449
      @sarahmacintosh6449 5 месяцев назад +5

      Amazing!

    • @Randomly_Browsing
      @Randomly_Browsing 5 месяцев назад +11

      The metroliner somehow managed to land despite losing the back chunk of it

    • @marcwolf60
      @marcwolf60 5 месяцев назад +1

      Are seat covers 'entities'

    • @A320_shrek
      @A320_shrek 5 месяцев назад +4

      Don’t spoiler 🥲 (no but I’m honestly glad they survived)

    • @greggpedder
      @greggpedder 5 месяцев назад +4

      Thats due to the inherently safe design of the Cirrus and the best safety feature available for GA Aircraft.

  • @Deadfoot-Dan
    @Deadfoot-Dan 5 месяцев назад +96

    Finally, one of these stories ends with no deaths. Those parachutes always intrigued me. Saved two lives.

    • @rescue270
      @rescue270 5 месяцев назад +6

      Cirruses need those parachutes. I consider them to be dangerous airplanes.

    • @tyler60k
      @tyler60k 5 месяцев назад +5

      @@rescue270 It's almost always pilot error, as in this case too.

    • @mahbriggs
      @mahbriggs 5 месяцев назад

      ​@rescue270
      all aircraft are dangerous machines! Especially with pilots aboad!

    • @bigd3046
      @bigd3046 5 месяцев назад +2

      @@rescue270 Why? I've been in one on several occasions and they seem like a good aircraft.

    • @rescue270
      @rescue270 5 месяцев назад

      @@bigd3046
      I've been in one, too. It was heavier than I thought it would be, loved fuel, and if it rained the windshield would leak water into that big display screen and short it out, and they are prone to flat spinning.
      Supposedly they've improved them, but, as I've been told, still not enough to keep them from easily flat spinning if they stall. That's why they have that parachute, and intentional stalls are prohibited in them. Their stall/spin characteristics were not going to be acceptable to the FAA, so they asked for a waiver from meeting those criteria if they incorporated a BRS parachute system into the Type Design. Somehow the FAA agreed to that.
      Not many airplanes have ever been able to recover from a flat spin. It's not an added safety feature. It's a necessary part of Type Design. It cannot be removed and maintain legal Airworthiness. The shroud lines of the chute are embedded into the composite fuselage skin. Deploying the chute totals the airplane.
      Seems like a lot of them have crashed, despite the chute. Furthermore, the chute has to be removed every ten years and repacked at considerable expense- I've heard $15,000-$20,000- in order to maintain Airworthiness. Can't call myself a fan of them. One guy I knew loved them. Another guy said he thought their Airworthiness Certificates should be revoked.

  • @mattskustomkreations
    @mattskustomkreations 5 месяцев назад +31

    Wow! What a testament to the build quality of the bigger craft, value of CAPS, skill of the pilots, and divine intervention!

    • @ttystikkrocks1042
      @ttystikkrocks1042 5 месяцев назад +6

      The skill of ONE pilot, sure. The Cirrus pilot, not so much.

    • @bellpolo08
      @bellpolo08 4 месяца назад +3

      Crazy how you don’t need CAPS if you don’t fly into other aircraft…

    • @moiraatkinson
      @moiraatkinson 3 месяца назад +1

      @@ttystikkrocks1042it’s a shame it can’t in some way be replicated by a good pilot in a plane without one. Like, it seems to stop spinning and go wings level with the greatest of ease. There’s a new model of Cirrus with a “wings level” button that really seems to work. I wonder what it’s actually doing to the aircraft that pilots could learn to copy?
      Great video and a fantastic outcome. Did either aircraft have a transponder on and would that need to be on the same frequency to see another plane? Sorry if some of this sounds a bit “beginner-ish”, but it would be interesting to know.
      2.9.24 JUST EDITED the first sentence as I missed out a word which made it sound nonsense.

    • @ttystikkrocks1042
      @ttystikkrocks1042 3 месяца назад +2

      ​@@moiraatkinsonthe transponders would likely have not made a difference since both planes were already in communication with the tower. The error on the ground was poor communication between controllers, the error in the air was the Cirrus pilot flying half again too fast in the pattern, overshooting his turn and infringing on the other plane's flight path. It is there that ultimate responsibility for the accident rests.

    • @moiraatkinson
      @moiraatkinson 3 месяца назад +1

      @@ttystikkrocks1042thank you - I assume transponders can “step on” each other like people do. The other thing I wondered about was why they didn’t get TCAS warnings, because the radio altimeter triggers those? Or why they had such a dumb system of traffic control in the first place? You could literally have 2 controllers lining up 2 planes to land on the same runway at the same time, with no communication between planes or people.

  • @SnowTCAS
    @SnowTCAS 4 месяца назад +5

    Finally! Someone’s talks about this incident. I found it like a year ago, it’s so interesting

  • @lachutequimarche8074
    @lachutequimarche8074 5 месяцев назад +16

    Beautifully-told and visually-spectacular. Thank you!

  • @rodterrell304
    @rodterrell304 5 месяцев назад +7

    Wow, I was very happy to hear that no one was hurt! Thank God and the folks that built that bigger plane.

  • @malcolmcarter1726
    @malcolmcarter1726 5 месяцев назад +5

    How refreshing. Nobody was hurt despite the severity of the impact.
    Ballistic parachutes are a terrific invention, and have saved many souls since their inception.

    • @ylekiote99999
      @ylekiote99999 3 месяца назад

      Those parachutes only work if the plane is travelling around 100 mph or less.

  • @Darkvirgo88xx
    @Darkvirgo88xx 5 месяцев назад +96

    My question is was the Cirrus pilot actually thinking he was going to land flying that dang fast in the pattern.

    • @sludge8506
      @sludge8506 5 месяцев назад +1

      That’s a great point!! Perhaps the final report has some information on that. 👍👍

    • @sludge8506
      @sludge8506 5 месяцев назад +4

      The final report has the speed and the recommended speed, but nothing else. 😧

    • @timtreeborgsonjen1533
      @timtreeborgsonjen1533 5 месяцев назад +2

      I was thinking he was flying faster because of the density altitude at 7000. Never flown a Cirrus so not sure. I would have to ask an instructor.

    • @timtreeborgsonjen1533
      @timtreeborgsonjen1533 5 месяцев назад +6

      Talked to instructor. He said 98 was a decent downwind speed. Pilot probably had to take a leak and was in a hurry to get down.

    • @johnsmith-po1uo
      @johnsmith-po1uo 5 месяцев назад +8

      @@timtreeborgsonjen1533, indicated airspeed is always the same regarding density altitude. GROUND speed is affected. If you are a pilot, I suggest you thoroughly educate yourself on this matter, as it is of some importance to piloting.

  • @wtywatoad
    @wtywatoad 5 месяцев назад +12

    Interestingly, there was another pilot on his first solo flight who witnessed the mid air collision. He radioed the tower and handed the situation perfectly, according to the tower.

  • @flymachine
    @flymachine 5 месяцев назад +4

    Several very lucky characteristics of both aircraft saved the crew’s lives, the Metro’s control cables rout through the floor and the floor is reinforced for cargo which is why it never came apart and remained controllable, the composite structure of the Cirrus prevented in flight break up post impact and of course the Capps system did what it is supposed to. This was a Swiss cheese model of positives for a change that came into play after a series of mistakes caused the initial incident.

    • @CuriousPilot90
      @CuriousPilot90  4 месяца назад +2

      Such a good point, an example of the swiss cheese model in both the positive and negative.

  • @dodoubleg2356
    @dodoubleg2356 5 месяцев назад +35

    As soon as you mentioned the speed of the Cirrus I immediately knew what the outcome would be.

    • @solefinder3708
      @solefinder3708 5 месяцев назад

      I don't even think airline transport jets come in that fast.

    • @michaelgranger7113
      @michaelgranger7113 5 месяцев назад

      ​@@solefinder3708it wasn't a jet

    • @justanotheraviator2357
      @justanotheraviator2357 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@solefinder3708 that's about 737 speeds.

    •  5 месяцев назад

      I'm not even a tower controller, but my first though was "hey, that's not right, that's way too fast". From what I know, a 737-800 has an approach speed of ~140 kt.

  • @UncleKennysPlace
    @UncleKennysPlace 5 месяцев назад +51

    The Cirrus thought he was flying a 737, with those approach speeds. It would have been a long float at landing.

    • @Williamb612
      @Williamb612 3 месяца назад

      The Cirrus pilot was in a mid life crisis and taking visgra

  • @chrisg9627
    @chrisg9627 5 месяцев назад +56

    Ja, one of my "almost died there" was caused by two aircraft being on different tower frequencies.
    A CH Sea stallion was cleared to depart with an underslung load after a bunch of V22 Ospreys had done a pretty formation turn off the runway and soaked the air with dust.
    Our airliner was cleared to takeoff by the civil controller only to find at V1 at the end of the dust cloud was a shipping container on a wire 50 feet above the runway.
    We had nowhere to go except to stay on the ground and roast the brakes.
    This was Djibouti in case anyone is interested.

    • @BobbyGeneric145
      @BobbyGeneric145 5 месяцев назад +2

      Jeezus!

    • @chrisg9627
      @chrisg9627 5 месяцев назад +14

      @@BobbyGeneric145 yeh, I didn't even manage to yell the word STOP !!! as we both saw this at the same instant.
      Fortunately training kicked in but the brakes took 30 minutes to return to the takeoff limiting temperature.

  • @jimburig7064
    @jimburig7064 4 месяца назад +2

    I heard about this mishap when it happened & have always been curious to learn more. Thank you for this information, Curious Pilot.

  • @sdaniels7114
    @sdaniels7114 5 месяцев назад +72

    The menace flying the Cirrus was so badly out of control that he was literally aligned with the wrong runway yet so many of you figure he would have flown a sensible pattern if everyone was on the same frequency? Those of you who are licensed should think back to your days as a student and recall how many times a flight instructor used the term "Good landings come from good approaches" in your presence.

    • @malcolmwhite6588
      @malcolmwhite6588 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@superkendall1003 I have spent too much of my life with my hand on my throttle!😂

    • @thomaswilson8634
      @thomaswilson8634 5 месяцев назад

      I did that before. To fast. Simple error. Im guilty as charged

    • @KjartanAndersen
      @KjartanAndersen 4 месяца назад +1

      The point with using the same frequency is to improve situational awareness for BOTH pilots. As it was this time, the only pilot who knew there was traffic on both runways was the one who flew like he needed a bathroom break immediately.

  • @rylanrussell9595
    @rylanrussell9595 5 месяцев назад +1

    I used to fly at Centennial airport all the time. It's crazy to see this, how miraculous it turned out. I did my first solo flight on 17R flying the same pattern the cirrus was in. Crazy.

  • @dareelamb1964
    @dareelamb1964 5 месяцев назад +4

    One of the major factors for the metro was
    That all of her control cables run through the floor. The metro is a well built and excellent aircraft. I know of 2
    Companies here that fly them as cargo and there is one out of Canada that actually fly them for passenger service.

  • @erichusmann5145
    @erichusmann5145 5 месяцев назад +9

    I remember hearing about this one. I also recall that the plane behind the Cirrus in the pattern was a student on his first solo, who helped spot the chute for ATC (and then landed normally, if maybe a bit shaken).

    • @machintelligence
      @machintelligence 5 месяцев назад

      But what a story he has to tell!

    • @solefinder3708
      @solefinder3708 5 месяцев назад

      I'm waiting for someone to post 'I was that student'...
      That would complete the story...yep.

    • @stejer211
      @stejer211 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@solefinder3708 I was that student.

  • @greenthing99100
    @greenthing99100 5 месяцев назад +8

    Excellent video, with good, clear explanations and graphics. I like the flight simulations, leading up towards the actual post-incident photos of both planes. I imagine that at least one of the occupants of the Cirrus had a fairly unforgettable visual memory from the instant of the actual collision, whereas the poor pilot of the Metroliner probably had little idea of what had happened and just how close the plane came to an inflight breakup which would have led to a very different outcome.

  • @patrickunderwood5662
    @patrickunderwood5662 5 месяцев назад +22

    Learned to fly at Centennial. Those runways are CLOSE. We were usually in that RH pattern for 17R and the instructors drilled into us that we absolutely must not overshoot base to final. BTW what a great airport, one of the busiest Class D airports in the US. I drove past the Key Lime place every day for training. The Texas Death Tube is really a beautiful machine. Also saw lots of warbirds and those amazing Piaggio Avanti canard commuters. That was a fun time. Glad everyone was okay here.

    • @RADIOACTIVEBUNY
      @RADIOACTIVEBUNY 5 месяцев назад +3

      Landed on 35L with a P40 off to my right once.

    • @Phil-y8c
      @Phil-y8c 5 месяцев назад

      "Texas Death Tube"; I thought they were called "Lawn Darts". 🤔

    • @patrickunderwood5662
      @patrickunderwood5662 5 месяцев назад

      @@Phil-y8c google “metroliner nicknames”, there’s a bunch of them and they’re all, er, not complimentary! 🤣

    • @andycraig7734
      @andycraig7734 5 месяцев назад +2

      The San Antonio Sewer Pipe

    • @tomspettel3646
      @tomspettel3646 5 месяцев назад +1

      I never had any problem with staying clear from 17l while doing t-n-g If i was doing 90 knt mid field for 17R i would be going way to fast! Then i hear about this guy entering the pattern at 148 knts i though what is this guy doing ?!?

  • @kevinb3812
    @kevinb3812 4 месяца назад +1

    Thanks for covering this one... it was a stunning story! A local jaw-dropper!!!

  • @evelynpaterson2823
    @evelynpaterson2823 2 месяца назад +1

    To realise that all survived, absolutely fantastic, skilled pilots.

    • @Musikur
      @Musikur 2 месяца назад

      Hmm, well one fantastic, skilled pilot...

  • @_KRose
    @_KRose 5 месяцев назад +12

    A deployable parachute for the entire aircraft? That's pretty cool. I didn't even know what was a thing.

    • @mahbriggs
      @mahbriggs 5 месяцев назад +3

      They have been around for a couple of decades, at least! They are only available for small planes. I believe they originated on ultra light craft and evolved to include single engine general aviation!

    • @harpandharley
      @harpandharley 5 месяцев назад +4

      Cirrus pioneered the general development and deployment of the ballistic parachute system for their line of aircraft. You can now find them in many types of ultralight, light sport and general aviation aircraft.

    • @stejer211
      @stejer211 5 месяцев назад +3

      They even strap people to them these days!

    • @mahbriggs
      @mahbriggs 5 месяцев назад +2

      @@stejer211 😁

    • @mike_oe
      @mike_oe 5 месяцев назад

      It's almost a trademark of Cirrus Aircraft. There are some interesting analysis on the how much safer if makes the aircraft.

  • @marcelb3645
    @marcelb3645 5 месяцев назад +49

    This one has been covered by many aviation channels, but your visuals beat them all. Still wonder how the Cirrus pilot thought he was going to land with that much energy. Unfortunately not spotting advised traffic got him first.

    • @kittytrail
      @kittytrail 5 месяцев назад +1

      he landed exactly how he was meant to, eventually, land. 🧐👆

    • @stejer211
      @stejer211 5 месяцев назад +3

      I'm hugely surprised the Cirrus pilot never saw the Metroliner...what's all that glass around you for?

    • @kittytrail
      @kittytrail 5 месяцев назад

      @@stejer211 it's not a _vision_ problem but a cognitive one. 🤡

    • @Musikur
      @Musikur 2 месяца назад

      @@stejer211 The Final Report is not very useful, however it says that the Cirrus had a TCAS system which sounded, but it's not clear how long before the collision it occurred. However, it also mentions that the flaps were extended only 4 seconds before the collision, so maybe his attention was taken away to configure the aircraft. All in all though, the report doesn't mention why he flew the approach 50kts faster than according to the POH, and doesn't state why we was configuring the aircraft for landing during the turn on to final when he clearly wasn't even going to make the turn, so it's a pretty bad report, and it's doubtful we will know all of the factors involved.

  • @BillDunne-n6y
    @BillDunne-n6y 5 месяцев назад +2

    Great information and graphics, well done,Bill

  • @benwillcox2246
    @benwillcox2246 5 месяцев назад +2

    Sure was crazy to show up to the hangar that day and see a Metro with the top fuselage peeled open!! One of the craziest things olive ever seen!

  • @darby5987
    @darby5987 5 месяцев назад +5

    I remember this accident. The local NBC affiliate immediately tried to do a hit piece on Key Lime Air because...well, because they could. They seemed to think it was cute to blame the airline because it is a mean ol' corporation. NBC is also a mean ol' corporation and May 12 is the mid-point of the April 25-May 22 Nielsen Ratings Period.

  • @theporschepilottpp910
    @theporschepilottpp910 5 месяцев назад +1

    I flew in that Cirrus as my discovery flight at KAPA, a few weeks later when I came back to the school for training, I found out that “DJ” was not available and was involved in a mid air. Scared me straight from the start of my flying career. Crazy how it all turned out

  • @CAROLUSPRIMA
    @CAROLUSPRIMA 5 месяцев назад +14

    Yay! So good to see an upload that isn’t about an incident that has been covered a hundred times.
    I think that channels that begin pivoting to interesting GA and charter incidents, rather than rehashing Tenerife, JAL 123, AA 191 etc will thrive.
    There’s a fatal GA accident almost every other day and others, such as this one, that are interesting despite having no casualties. Keep telling me about these and please spare me another deep dive into incidents that every single aviation channel covers.

    • @CuriousPilot90
      @CuriousPilot90  5 месяцев назад +3

      Thank you, it’s good to hear. You’ve been here long enough to see I cover a lot of GA incidents. Like you say, there is still so much to learn from them!

    • @CAROLUSPRIMA
      @CAROLUSPRIMA 5 месяцев назад

      @@CuriousPilot90 Yes I recall making a similar comment on this very channel. Keep up the good work.

  • @markbennett-ms1kv
    @markbennett-ms1kv 5 месяцев назад +21

    In my 40 year flying career I can honestly say the closest I’ve ever come to being wiped out in mid air was in a situation like this. The contributing factor in both my incidents (yes both) was a xwind from the right producing a tailwind on base for the aircraft on the parallel. In two seperate incidents only 3 days apart, the aircraft on the right parallel came sailing through my centre line as I was conducting a straight in on the left. I fortunately I saw both aircraft in time and was able to take evasive action. In the second incident a few days after the first, my evasive action was so extreme that I was forced to abandon the approach. I left for the airlines the next day! When asked by the ground controller to contact him by phone the pilot of the offending aircraft (grizzled old charter pilot, who frankly should have known better) pushed back and became even belligerent!

  • @poonkinlok
    @poonkinlok 5 месяцев назад +1

    Great video! I love you can tell where an aviator is from based on their phraseology like Q&H / Altimeter, Holding Point / Hold Short, Circuit / Traffic Patten.

    • @scoutty146
      @scoutty146 5 месяцев назад

      Or being a pilot at Centennial when i heard the parts about Salida and ATC and im like uncontrolled field... would have been a CTAF call and gun it

  • @ck2music712
    @ck2music712 5 месяцев назад +1

    Woah! Aviation has come a LONG way! I can't believe everyone lived! Those Cirrus Airframe Parachutes are a live saver! I just wish there was a way to make air travel TOTALLY safe- I'm sure EVENTUALLY that will be the case, especially when we get to antigravity technology where we won't NEED excessive speed... Hmm...

  • @stephencoogle2732
    @stephencoogle2732 5 месяцев назад +2

    Great job- thanks for the upload

  • @edrob2264
    @edrob2264 5 месяцев назад +5

    What simulation software do you use? The visuals are fantastic! Great work!

    • @CuriousPilot90
      @CuriousPilot90  5 месяцев назад +2

      Thank you, a slightly more difficult one to simulate this time. I used a mix of x plane 11 and 12.

  • @JoshDutton-nz3rp
    @JoshDutton-nz3rp 5 месяцев назад +2

    I was in class at Spartan College, when I heard about it. I asked if it was Metro Airport, but I was told by a couple classmates and a teacher that it was at Centenial. I do remember that day with that green key lime air and the red cirrus that deployed its parachute. Very very lucky day for all on board. One of those little events I probably wont ever forget.

  • @JRG72
    @JRG72 5 месяцев назад +1

    Centennial is close to my home, and if you drive past the Key Lime Air hangar, this aircraft is outside with a cover over the hole.

  • @tristanregini2219
    @tristanregini2219 5 месяцев назад +2

    I land at centennial on runway 17R a lot for my training, and my main concern while landing is to make sure I turn early on base before final, to make sure I don’t cross over the centerline. This is exactly why. I didn’t know this happened, let alone at my airport on my runway. Crazy stuff

  • @andrewlast1535
    @andrewlast1535 5 месяцев назад +12

    I always wondered why they still fly those Metroliners. Now I know. They must be good aircraft.

    • @dazrmorrison9558
      @dazrmorrison9558 5 месяцев назад +3

      Very solidly built.

    • @Danger_mouse
      @Danger_mouse 5 месяцев назад

      Might be solid, and perhaps a good small freight plane, but I had to endure a lot of time in them as a passenger.
      They're one of a few planes that can't sustain level flight on a single engine...
      We refer to them as Death Pencils.

    • @andrewlast1535
      @andrewlast1535 5 месяцев назад

      @@Danger_mouse The Army was using these “death pencils” to shuttle brass around Afghanistan in 2017. I know because I used to fuel them. They were civilian flown under contract. So if they were so terrible, why still use them? I asked a lot of questions because I am an aviation nerd and was curious why they still used them? If your information is correct, why would you want them in areas of high density altitudes? I didn’t see any jato in the tail. Lol My guess is that was an issue for their airliner role? I also got the impression that they were used because of their hot and high capabilities? I have no idea if that is true, based on vague memory? They also don’t have single point fueling, which is annoying if you are fueling this bird between airliners. My profile pic with the silly F-16 model, is in my shared fuel truck. It is pointing right towards where they parked the C-26. Behind the CRJ.

    • @Danger_mouse
      @Danger_mouse 5 месяцев назад

      @@andrewlast1535
      Can't imagine 'Brass' being too excited at crawling down the aisle on their hand and knees and sitting with their heads bent over due to the shape of the fuselage.
      They must have really had nothing else 🙂👍

    • @andrewlast1535
      @andrewlast1535 4 месяца назад

      @@Danger_mouse I highly doubt they are configured like the airliner variant.

  • @chipsawdust5816
    @chipsawdust5816 5 месяцев назад +4

    Looks like the Metro in this video is an SA-227 Metro 3. The 226 had a three bladed prop and the landing gear doors would be open on the ramp. Both sported the Garrett TPE-331-10UA engine, although the 3 had a more powerful version IIRC.
    Still a beast of an airplane to fly, and worse to work on!
    That said, Metros were overbuilt to a large extent, partly because they also had a high differential pressure fuselage.

  • @eyre1720
    @eyre1720 5 месяцев назад +2

    Best graphics on RUclips❤

  • @TheLincolnshireFlyer
    @TheLincolnshireFlyer 5 месяцев назад +3

    Great video. I remember this happening. Thank you for posting 😊

  • @fallandbounce
    @fallandbounce 5 месяцев назад +2

    I love the stories where everyone lives.

  • @jamesgraham6122
    @jamesgraham6122 5 месяцев назад +8

    The Cirrus would have employed a steeper than normal bank-angle while attempting to limit the overshoot to finals for 17R.. this would have completely blanked out his vision of anything to his left side. I get the impression that the annual loss-rate/hours flown of the Cirrus exceeds any other light single.. At close to a million dollars I can't but suspect that many are owned/flown by people that consider dollars can offset their limited flying skills... just a thought.

    • @stejer211
      @stejer211 5 месяцев назад +1

      And they're right... sadly enough, and thanks to the ballistic parachute.

  • @branchandfoundry560
    @branchandfoundry560 5 месяцев назад +2

    If not for parachutes, Cirrus would be the next-gen Doctor Killer.

  • @serge470
    @serge470 5 месяцев назад +16

    When i hear there two close lines operated with two different towers, with different frequencies....i immediately know what's gonna to happen.

    • @sludge8506
      @sludge8506 5 месяцев назад +3

      ATC was required to notify the pilots of the other traffic.
      It wasn’t the different frequencies. It was the failure of one of the controllers to do his job.

    • @M1903a4
      @M1903a4 5 месяцев назад +3

      @@sludge8506 It was the idiot in the Cirrus not only flying too fast and through the extended centerline of his intended runway, but the fact that he flew through the extended centerline of the other runway as well. Not to mention flying through the center of the Metroliner while he was at it. And he was advised of traffic which should have been very easily visible from the Cirrus.

    • @richardhole8429
      @richardhole8429 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@serge470 tower 1 and tower 2 are workstations near to each other.

    • @sludge8506
      @sludge8506 4 месяца назад

      @@M1903a4 Champ, my statement is factually accurate. Deal with it. I wasn’t determining who was at fault for the accident.

  • @rlopofficial4301
    @rlopofficial4301 5 месяцев назад +2

    No one will believe this but I was in school during the collision and watched it happen. I was standing on the black top of campus middle school a few miles away from the collision. Look at it on Google maps I had a clear line of vision it was unbelievable.

    • @ttystikkrocks1042
      @ttystikkrocks1042 3 месяца назад

      I believe you! Got your money's worth from class that day, eh?

  • @AviationJeremy
    @AviationJeremy 5 месяцев назад +3

    Extending flaps at 20 knots over Vfe, 50-60 knots in excess of the recommended approach speed, and 140 knots in a relatively close traffic pattern is absolutely ridiculous.

  • @sludge8506
    @sludge8506 5 месяцев назад +2

    Great graphics!! ✈️✈️✈️🛩️

  • @nigelbond4056
    @nigelbond4056 5 месяцев назад +1

    Another superb video from Curious Pilot 👏👏👏

  • @axelschroeder6413
    @axelschroeder6413 5 месяцев назад +6

    every pilot should know his pattern and approach speeds. the flap 50 limitation on the cirrus sr22 is 119 kts and the flap 100 at 104 kts. no trained cirrus pilot would fly a pattern at 140 kts (way too fast) and then even set the flaps. you would be in immediate danger to structurally damage the airplane. that only shows an unexperienced and/or reckless cirrus pilot, that should not be flying this complex airplane. additionally, no pilot would overshoot a base turn on parallel runways to interfere with the centerline of the OTHER runway. we did not hear the real ATC in this video, but the controller would most certainly call the cirrus pilot to attention for this overshoot. ATC for sure knows, that the parallel runway is in use and would immediately intervene and call the cirrus. does anyone have the ATC recordings? did ATC call the pilot?

    • @skayt35
      @skayt35 5 месяцев назад +1

      It says in the video that the Cirrus was advised of the traffic.

  • @nikiandre6998
    @nikiandre6998 5 месяцев назад +8

    That one was crazy one. I remember, when it happened. Still no idea, howw the pilots of Metrojet were able to bring it down in one peace. And I also remember, that they had no clue, what happened, until they got out of cockpit and discovered, that they have big part of fuselage missing..... Really crazy story with good ending)))

    • @maurice7413
      @maurice7413 5 месяцев назад +3

      Pilot of Metrojet, there was only one person onboard, the pilot.

    • @audengrumet3985
      @audengrumet3985 5 месяцев назад +1

      Piece

  • @bigdogboos1
    @bigdogboos1 5 месяцев назад

    The one condition where the chutes are life savers ... loss of control input and messed up control surfaces. just so glad they all survived, man that's crazy

  • @travispower2683
    @travispower2683 5 месяцев назад +2

    I watched it happen. Crazy.

  • @kmacksb
    @kmacksb 5 месяцев назад +24

    Wow. I can't believe that Metroliner didn't just come apart. That's really impressive.
    Also, the separate tower frequency thing is weird. It's incredibly beneficial for pilots to hear the chatter from other aircraft in their vicinity, especially when you have mixed general and commercial traffic.

    • @sludge8506
      @sludge8506 5 месяцев назад +2

      BTW, ATC is required to inform both pilots of the nearby traffic.

    • @dareelamb1964
      @dareelamb1964 5 месяцев назад +4

      I spent about 6 years working on both the metro 226 & 227. They’re a pain in the ass to work but they’re built like tanks. All of the control cables (for the tail) run through the floor.

    • @platapus112
      @platapus112 4 месяца назад

      ​@@sludge8506they did

    • @platapus112
      @platapus112 4 месяца назад

      ​@@dareelamb1964as opposed through the ceiling? They all go through the floor

    • @dareelamb1964
      @dareelamb1964 4 месяца назад

      @@platapus112not all.

  • @ttystikkrocks1042
    @ttystikkrocks1042 5 месяцев назад +3

    A few knots over speed is not an issue. The pilot was FIFTY knots too fast, half again as fast as he should have been. The Cirrus is a pretty high performance light plane and it requires paying close attention to airspeed. Cirrus pilots are giving a good plane a bad reputation.

  • @AviationNut
    @AviationNut 5 месяцев назад +18

    It's crazy that the cirrus pilot was still over 140kt on down wind and 140kt on base leg. I can never understand why people do that, it's only gonna save you few seconds or maybe 1 minute but it puts other aircraft and people in those aircraft in danger. Pilots like that should have their PPL revoked.

    • @flexairz
      @flexairz 5 месяцев назад +1

      If you fly that fast and turn and bank correctly it can be done.. but most GA pilots are not that proficient, so they f.u. No reason to revoke the license.

    • @marcjacobson6096
      @marcjacobson6096 5 месяцев назад

      Don't ever lump in cirrus pilots with other GA pilots. Until someone can train a cirrus pilot to actually look out their windshield they should disable the parachute which will thin the hurd of their arrogance...

    • @johnbuchman4854
      @johnbuchman4854 5 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@flexairzBudy you are *WAY* off! This wasn't an airshow performance. Cirrus operator (can't call him a pilot) should have lost his license, for good!

  • @alexandersheppard1997
    @alexandersheppard1997 5 месяцев назад +10

    Most cirrus "pilots" have no business being at the controls.

  • @scottstocking6935
    @scottstocking6935 5 месяцев назад +1

    If I am not mistaken the Cirrus pilot was warned by ATC to keep his base and final turn tight as there was traffic landing on the parallel runway.

  • @gsp8489
    @gsp8489 5 месяцев назад +12

    The cirrus guy was flying almost double the appropriate approach speed and just kept right on truckin' through the centerline of his runway into the path of another aircraft that he was TOLD was there.....He is 100% responsible. If the Metroliner pilot had been killed, the cirrus pilot should've been charged with reckless homicide.

    • @markadams7328
      @markadams7328 5 месяцев назад +2

      I'm pretty much with you on this one! I would only add, that when you are cleared to 17R, you stay the Hell away form 17L!!!!

  • @raysutton2310
    @raysutton2310 5 месяцев назад

    I live approx 4 miles north east of Centennial and have taken trial lessons out of there. This video proved a good reminder of the event. As I recall VASAviation had Excellent coverage of the event at the time and I saw it on his channel before catching it local news.

  • @richardhole8429
    @richardhole8429 5 месяцев назад +3

    I assume the Cirrus pilot's license was revoked permanently. Approach speed was far too fast, and flap extension above maximum speed. It is a wonder the flaps did not rip off from the wings.

  • @philip1522
    @philip1522 5 месяцев назад +8

    That Metro was a tough old bird. Built in the 1970's you say. Must have had better quality control back then. Certain companies planes seem prone to start falling apart as they come off the production line these days. Strangely same company used to make planes that could take massive damage and still bring the boys back home - wonder what changed?

    • @ttystikkrocks1042
      @ttystikkrocks1042 3 месяца назад

      Not "better quality control" but rather higher built in margins of error because they weren't built using finite element modeling. THAT'S why older planes tend to be tougher but also slower and thirstier.

  • @petewilson2314
    @petewilson2314 5 месяцев назад +1

    How did that metro-liner not completely break in two? Amazing!

  • @sebastiangeorger5791
    @sebastiangeorger5791 5 месяцев назад +3

    I was in the air during this. Not a fun time, diverted to BJC

  • @lloydrobert6182
    @lloydrobert6182 5 месяцев назад

    Subbed and liked. Very well researched and presented! Thank you and thank goodness for the no-causalities outcome!

  • @platapus112
    @platapus112 4 месяца назад +1

    All I can say is it was a fun day at the airport that day

  • @mgclark46
    @mgclark46 3 месяца назад +1

    Total fatalities 0
    Total injuries 0
    Total survivors 3

  • @RonRedden-wx9on
    @RonRedden-wx9on 4 месяца назад

    I flew thousands of hours instructing at Centennial. I have flown that Cirrus, and if the information I received is correct, I trained the Metroliner's pilot through several of his ratings. One factor not brought up is the distance that the controllers are extending downwind. The further out you fly, the less ability a pilot has to determine the approach centerline. The runways are close, and a pilot can believe that they are on centerline when, in fact, they may be 100' off. Speed was a major factor.

  • @greygoregoose
    @greygoregoose 3 месяца назад

    I was in Boulder when this happened! Interesting to actually learn what happened

  • @donaldwilson5693
    @donaldwilson5693 5 месяцев назад

    That's a miracle everyone survived!

  • @MmmHuggles
    @MmmHuggles 5 месяцев назад +2

    I wonder how many lives would be saved if all small craft were required to have those parachute systems. Seems a lot of crashes involve small crafts so it could be a lot.

  • @hongpan2240
    @hongpan2240 5 месяцев назад

    The way that both planes landed safely is just insane. I mean, how could two plain survive a mid air collision

  • @CyberSystemOverload
    @CyberSystemOverload 5 месяцев назад

    Great video, glad no one was hurt. Also can I just say its nice to see someone using X-Plane! Is this 11 or 12? How did you get yours looking so good!

  • @Musikur
    @Musikur 2 месяца назад

    I seem to recall that when this incident first occurred, lots of people noted on the ATC transcripts that the Cirrus had arrived extremely quickly after making the inbound call, and we all assumed then that speed was a major factor. I have no idea why the pilot thought that it was a good idea to make that approach at nearly double the recommended approach speed. 140kts is the speed of an A320 approach, not a single engine private plane. Ridiculous. Lucky for him that everyone here walked away.

  • @Bigfoot2025
    @Bigfoot2025 5 месяцев назад +7

    Yikes, this basically happened a few miles south of my house!
    I was once almost a hood ornament on an C-5A that was on a very low altitude speed run over the Florida everglades heading north. At the time I was in contact with PBI approach flying my assigned altitude and heading for a landing on 9R. Not a peep from approach. Pays to have your head on a swivel!

  • @FasterLower
    @FasterLower 5 месяцев назад +2

    Great video, thanks

  • @sgtmattkind
    @sgtmattkind 4 месяца назад +1

    I'm sorry...planes have PARACHUTES now?!

  • @erwinschmidt7265
    @erwinschmidt7265 5 месяцев назад +2

    I drew slick sketch for Ike, Family Friend in '54. One look & he ordered Top Secret Security Card for me. Few days later kid's size drafting table showed up, w/note DOD Kelly Johnson was my Handler - signed Ike! He had been PO'd as designs from expected sources regurgitated WW2 designs, where as my design looked as if half-bird. '63 thought OK, but Kelly's super speedster spy plane the "71" to be canceled, as much slower than design & poor mileage. He had been workin' on it for years, but could not cure above problems, sent Dual Colonel Couriers out with all plane's poop. I redesigned defective Belly, coded it in into IBM-360, Dad ran if for me, all faults cured, & it had taken less than 3 hrs! Kelly happy, had Gift of F4 Phantom Acrobatic Demo Ride for me, w/world's smallest G-Suit. We sped up to Mich U.P. Bomber Base for refuel, then over Lk. Superior for Aerobatics, but @FL64 Test Pilot broke, actually coming down w/6 wk FLU!! He blew chunks until still, so took control wanting to live. Like in your video, it was pure terror for me just being 13, no ID'd us to Tower, & told Controller, "Pilot out, just pushed over, heading back to Base straight down on burners, need runway please." He asked if F4, so answered affirmative. Controller said would help w/speeds for pull-out, touch, chutes, & runway remaining. He advised to stay away from parking lots, buildings, & parked Bombers! He was amazing, estimated pull-out exact, got us down to 411MPH to touch, I slalomed 2mi runway, stopping w/5 feet to spare, & engines outta gas! He had Fire/Rescue/Medical right there, & Doc saved Test Pilot's life, even though both tires aflame & blew while he was on ladder! Anyways, that was my introduction to "Terror in the Skies", w/dive so fast it even welded all the plates on! Kelly was very unhappy with me, but after 3 days, I had no idea what was going on for 6 weeks, just like the Test Pilot! He couldn't get back in air until 8th week when could again pass Class 1 Flight Physical. If somebody says they got somethin' for ya...RUN THE OTHER WAY!!

  • @Dan-xo9ly
    @Dan-xo9ly 5 месяцев назад

    Single pilot in a metro and landed it safely. Great job!

  • @доктор-вонючая-морковь
    @доктор-вонючая-морковь 5 месяцев назад +2

    Great vid as always .
    Feed the algorithm 😋

  • @rigilchrist
    @rigilchrist 4 месяца назад +1

    There is nothing that the pilot of the Metroliner could or should have done. He was on a stable approach. The person pretending to be a pilot in the Cirrus flew a downwind too close to the runway, was absurdly fast AND permitted his aircraft to cross the centreline of the parallel runway DESPITE being warned about landing traffic. I hope he lost his license over this as he is a menace to others.

  • @Dovietail
    @Dovietail 3 месяца назад

    I used to live in Salida, Colorado. Trust me, the weather is ALWAYS lovely! 🙂🌞🙂

    • @Dovietail
      @Dovietail 3 месяца назад

      A plane w/a parachute??? I love it!

  • @johnsmith5255
    @johnsmith5255 4 месяца назад +1

    Wow, a mid-air collision and BOTH planes managed to get to the ground without crashing? Chances are that this will be the only time in all of history that this will happen.

  • @pauljacobs8562
    @pauljacobs8562 4 месяца назад

    Is it not recommended that if you’re doing a downwind leg under VFR conditions that you do a quick look at the airspace around you? Are you supposed to keep your eyes inside the cockpit at all times? No radar on either bird?

  • @spacewolfjr
    @spacewolfjr 5 месяцев назад +88

    I believe the FAA report noted the "passenger" in the Cirrus was actually a llama (possibly alpaca) wearing a hat.

    • @MiaMichele9696
      @MiaMichele9696 5 месяцев назад +10

      @spacewolfjr...now that's something I would love to see 😂😂😂

    • @TUPELO_HUNNY
      @TUPELO_HUNNY 5 месяцев назад

      RUFS???

    • @Irini-k2f
      @Irini-k2f 5 месяцев назад +1

      Seriously?

    • @moiraatkinson
      @moiraatkinson 5 месяцев назад +6

      What?! The passenger was a lama wearing a hat?? ROFL that’s the craziest thing I’ve ever heard of! It must have been a shock for the emergency services to see that climbing out of the plane uninjured 😂

    • @PM-mm3pz
      @PM-mm3pz 5 месяцев назад +1

      I seriously LOLd

  • @anthonyxuereb792
    @anthonyxuereb792 5 месяцев назад

    I nearly chocked on my lunch when I heard that the Cirrus was approaching at 140 knots, I ain't no polit but even to my ears it sounded way too high. Was the pilot in desperate need of the wc?

  • @rocketman4438
    @rocketman4438 5 месяцев назад +2

    Don't know how common it is to have different tower frequencies for each runway, but I would rather hear other airplane communications with the tower also.
    It helps.

    • @sludge8506
      @sludge8506 5 месяцев назад +1

      ATC is required to notify the pilots of the other traffic.

    • @M1903a4
      @M1903a4 5 месяцев назад +3

      It's common at busy airports. Another commenter said this is the busiest Class D airport in the country.
      The recreation doesn't show or mention other aircraft, but apparently the pattern was quite busy at the time.

    • @jennifercarr6918
      @jennifercarr6918 4 месяца назад

      @@sludge8506, ATC did call traffic prior to this accident.

  • @haywoodjablowme2972
    @haywoodjablowme2972 5 месяцев назад

    good explanation captain

  • @JamesMerrill-wu5fv
    @JamesMerrill-wu5fv 5 месяцев назад +36

    Typical Cirrus driver.

    • @CirrusSR20Pilot
      @CirrusSR20Pilot 5 месяцев назад

      I have 300+ hours in Cirrus and did my primary training in an SR20. I can tell you this is not a typical Cirrus driver. Yes, there are morons that fly all types of aircraft and this pilot was clearly an idiot! He is lucky no one died! Many Cirrus pilots, like myself, and Cirrus CFI's are incredibly safety-oriented. It is pilots like this one that give us all a bad name!

    • @DMS20231
      @DMS20231 5 месяцев назад +7

      Yep. A doctor or lawyer with more money than good sense - and an invincibility complex.

  • @j.paulm.1575
    @j.paulm.1575 5 месяцев назад

    I recognize the metroliner in the video, a freeware mod for XPlane 11 designed by the user Starving Pilot. I've flown the Zibo and Levelup 737s which are in a league of their own, but setting those aside, that metroliner is a solid contender for the best freeware aircraft out there.

  • @user-de2zo1bw4d
    @user-de2zo1bw4d 5 месяцев назад

    Great video, would have liked the names of the Pilots involved and any ATC transcripts too.

  • @Arcalargo
    @Arcalargo 5 месяцев назад

    Why is the Key Lime pilot catching anything from the FAA in this?

  • @jameswikstrom4174
    @jameswikstrom4174 5 месяцев назад

    Great video of a horrific crash . If both aircraft had been advised that there was traffic landing on both runways , it is possible that the collision could have been averted if both aircraft were made aware of other landing traffic . Only speculation on my part .

  • @kakumee
    @kakumee 5 месяцев назад +1

    So they was both heading to centennial? So the other plain was going from Englewood? I think I need to go to bed. It's 3 am mountain time 😂.

  • @MrEagleeye58
    @MrEagleeye58 5 месяцев назад +1

    What about TCAS?

  • @zekeonstormpeak4186
    @zekeonstormpeak4186 5 месяцев назад

    Salider airport??