Had a kid in middle school from Japan wear his Grandfather’s Japanese imperial army uniform to class when we discussed World War Two on Veterans Day. Needless to say the Chinese and Korean students weren’t thrilled...
I'm assuming since it's middle-school we're talking, he wore it more out of naivety for the reaction he'd get rather than in trying to make some kind of point about military history, nationalism, and remembrance.
@Jedem Das Seine Actually Turkey has very close realitionship with Romania and Hungary. All three protecting each other in international politics and they have a really good import, export rates so politicians always acts like they always have been good bodies.
@@ChristopherNFP Don't forget to also look for the _Hinomaru._ In my home country (the United States), the military flags are usually depicted in war films as national flags used during World War II, while the _real_ national flag's use at the time is ignored by the films. Those who don't know much about flags just assume the Rising Sun Flag (both of them) was a national flag during World War II (kind of like the German Nazi flag, but not a party flag), and not what it really is: a military flag used almost continuously by Japan since 1870, and still to this day. In short, look out for the national flag, for it does not usually make the war films.
@@SoooooWhatt I would assume that if I saw the Hinomaru in a movie set prior to August 1945 then it would be an historical error. Is that correct? I do not recall Hilbert contradicting that belief.
That is actually one of the hallmarks of good flag design. Is it easily recognized from a distance and can the children of your country recognize and recreate it
I would rather compare "Rising sun flag" to german Iron Cross (military symbol, often associated with WW2, but not strictly representing any ideology, used by military of these countries to this day) , not to NSDAP flag (made specifically to be symbol of ideology and implemented as the symbol of ideology, being in use ONLY when country was run by followers of that ideology).
that's a much better comparison. It still makes me chuckle when people get their dander up about seeing a German Leopard 2 MBT with the iron cross painted on the side.
@@kaiserofgermania5236 >Was used before WW2 You know, to East Asians, Japan was still a horrible nation before WW2. It really is a European/American perspective. To anyone in East Asia, or Australians who know their history, the Imperial Japanese were worse or at least on par with the WW2 Germans. So yeah, it's equal with the Swastika.
@UCAk61SHJsXG_h-BgiIDDJyw Aye, but the Japanese forces were also still committing atrocities before WWII in earnest so it's a specific example that's further complicated by not falling strictly within the confines of a single regime or conflict. It's comparatively easier to draw distinctions with - say - the Swastika and the Iron Cross. One represented this party/organization/regime - the other has a longer, more varied history. To play devil's advocate against my point, though - if there were any Herero around today they may even have an issue with the Iron Cross as a symbol, regardless of WWII. I suppose the inter-war period and WWII were such a hyper-charged climate in regard to national symbols and identity that it tends to make everything else more gray in comparison.
Don't think the Rising Sun Flag is okay to be used nowadays because it is older than the Japanese imperialists. In that logic, the Swastica has also existed for thousands of years, it was originally an Indo-European alphabet and the Nazi took it as their symbol to exert the "Aryan superiority." Yet the swastica is literally banned in most of the world. The Rising Sun Flag is the same. Although it may have existed since before the Japanese Empire, it still was used as the symbol of their imperialism and hundreds of millions of Asians suffered under that flag. Westerners are in no place to justify their use.
@Biracial Boy He's like a symbol for modern Japan, though. A living representation of the dangers of nuclear warfare and all that. If Godzillas were a real thing, I bet Japan would be using them the same way China uses pandas in regards to diplomacy. lol
There was never a change: the rising sun flag was not the official national flag of Japan even in those days - it was the country's military flag and was often popularly used with the regular national flag, but the national flag was the same as it is today.
@@Maple_Tachibana Except he's totally wrong. National flag changed slightly and rising sun flag always had two different versions depending on Army or Navy... that's what I understood....
The rising sun flag is actually still up on a helicopter carrier to and is actually still the Japanese war flag only it has some golden triangles on the top bottom and sides
@History With Hilbert I saw it on a random RUclips video once (no idea which one I'm afraid). It was an attempt to satisfy the two families that were merging. If you see the original two it's quite clever. Type in “mitsubishi symbol creation” into google and you’ll see it.
@@historywithhilbert I believe the Mitsubishi symbol you show is actually a stylized propeller - as in the Mitsubishi aircraft produced before and during the war. (much like Mercedes)
This flag has been in use since before the war. Many countries must have a history of war and colonization. It's like saying that the British flag should be abolished.
There is a wartime flag that was created during WW2, the Taisei Yokusankai flag. The flag is not well known to foreigners, but it was created during the WW2 war and is no longer used after the war.
yeah i agree with this. the difference between this flag and the Nazi one is that the Nazi flag was the flag of the Nazi party that took control of Germany and changed the German flag. it's inseparable from the Nazi party, but the Japanese navy flag was the flag before the war and before the terrible acts where committed its more of just a Japanese flag.
Just for general knowledge: “land of the rising sun” doesn’t mean the people are “of the rising sun” or named themselves after the rising sun, but it represents, from a Chinese geographical perspective, the location of japan to the East. I like to translate it more as “the perceived origin of the sun as seen from China” lol. Kinda like how the name of China is “middle country.” Its more of a description of location than a true name. But then that’s where most Japanese family names come from, locations in nature.
It's not only in Asia. There's a theory, regarding the etymology of "Europe" that says the name comes from Mesopotamian word "ereb" meaning "descent", so in that case Europe would be "the land of the setting sun".
@@yuki.s.3881 No they didn't. The name is written in both languages as 日本, which means "sun origin." Japan took the Chinese name when it adopted Chinese culture over a millennium ago (including the Chinese writing system to write the Japanese language). Not only that, but they also took the Sinitic-based pronunciation for the name: _ni_ is based on the old Chinese reading of 日 (read as _rì_ in modern Mandarin) and _pon_ is based on the old Chinese reading of 本 (read as _běn_ in modern Mandarin).
ZhangtheGreat you think i can't use internet?What I said is “they named themselves Nippon.”What you are saying? kanji?i know kanji were borrowed. So what?
Jennie .S. You are wrong as hell. My moms Japanese. Doesn’t matter that the Japanese might pronounce the characters in a different way. Yeah, the Japanese adopt many of their own readings for all the characters. The original meaning of the characters still stands.
For centuries Sony Clan and Nintendo Clan fight with each other over the control of Japan. Now gamers.. I mean mercenaries from around the world support them in this endless war
@@4.0.4 It is false! SONY has its HQs in japan, it is the SIE (Playstation-division) who moved their HQs to california for research and development purposes since most of their gaming equipement like processor, GPU etc come from america , also North America account for about 50% of Playstation renue so i isgoodforthem to have a foothold there so as to better service that market. Do not forget Playstation also have division in Japan and europe lol
@@ulrichleukam1068 Most of the development is done outside Japan with majority of foreigners. So it really doesn't matter where Sony's HQ is located if you are talking about technology
@@ulrichleukam1068 Yes but SIE is the one that matters if you're comparing it to Nintendo. They're also shifting away from being the electronics company we all knew, since insurance makes them more of a profit. They're also becoming more censorious with what they allow, and their next console could be just a decent x86 computer, if leaks are correct. Not the cool company it once was.
It's been used long before WWII and still used as a Japan Maritime Self Defense Force Flag. It's not that flag is from WWII as some people want to automatically associate with war. It's a flag used even by the ordinally civilians in many ways, even fishermen or commercial ships or festive events, to think it's only associate with war is because one not knowing the Japanese culture.
@@마바사가나다라-j2l Please do not make a mistake. The same flag as Haken Kreuz is the flag of the Imperial Rule Assistance Association. The Japanese are also against the flag of the Imperial Rule Assistance Association. I hope Koreans will work together to oppose the Imperial Rule Assistance Association flag instead of the Rising Sun Flag.
Honestly if the Rising Sun flag is taboo then most other old military and national flags should also be. Few people want to Union Jack taken down despite the horrors done in the name of British imperialism. The flag of the Third Reich was designed specifically by Nazis as a symbol of Nazism, which is incomparable to flag that was adopted long before the militarists seized power in Japan.
That’s the way I see the black-white-red flag of the German Empire. For some reason, here in Germany, it is associated with Nazism and racism. Personally, I see no issue with it. It is the flag that unified Germany after decades of consisting of bickering nation-states. It showed a rebirth of Germany as a whole, after the decline and fall of the incompetent and falling-apart Holy Roman Empire. It should be revered as the flag that unified Germany. Shame on those that misuse it, but can we really let such a small minority of racist neo-Nazis ruin our nation’s heritage and perception of the past? There is such a despicable shame-culture here in Germany; if anything isn’t 100% politically correct, you get shot down as if you were a Nazi. I hate it, I really do. It’s all in the name of freedom, but it’s more oppressive than any other regime in Germany. You can’t even show patriotism without being questioned on whether or not you’re a fucking neo-Nazi. That flag was practically replaced by the Swastika, and Hitler didn’t even like the German Empire or emperor. He barred people from going to Wilhelm II’s funeral. Yet, apparently this flag is “racist?” I would love to bring back this flag, to show my people that there is nothing inherently wrong with it. If it’s bad, then the Union Jack, Stars and Stripes, or you-name-it, are ten times worse. The idea of “history is written by the victors” is very debatable. But socially, I believe that it is very true, considering the victors fly their flags with no shame, but actually pride, whereas we must put down ours with shame.
@@Vaterlandstreuer While I can't see why the German Empire's flag is controversial, I think it isn't used officially because it was for the German Empire, not the German Republic.
Io I can understand that entirely. I simply believe that we shouldn’t distance ourselves from the past because of incorrect associations, and we should embrace our heritage. Does the flag say „This flag only usable for empire?“ No. Hell, the Japanese still use their flag. Including the „Rising-Sun Flag“ for their navy. They’re not ashamed of it. And that was infamously flown during the time of fascist Japan, which committed numerous war crimes, on the level of Nazi Germany. So why should we be ashamed of a flag that has practically nothing to do with war crimes or anything shameful, not that that would matter, since a flag has nothing inherently wrong with it?
@@Vaterlandstreuer the destruction of the heritage is a disgrace I've heard some people have so Mutch shame cast upon them that thay have themselves sterilized which in it's self is genocide. It has to stop
Chris Lates Yes, it’s absolutely terrible. The last surviving relatives of Hitler‘s bloodline (not even direct descendants of his, by the way) are determined to not have children because their great-brother-in-law was Hitler. What do they have to do with Hitler? Nothing. What do their would-be children have to with Hitler? Nothing. They could’ve changed their name, as if that was even necessary. Instead, they’re basically going to kill their own family because of their great-brother-in-law. It’s pathetic, completely illogical, and outright sad and shameful that they would do this. I harbor no shame for the actions of my ancestors. They did what they did. Doesn’t matter if they believed in the cause. Doesn’t matter if they didn’t. I am not associated with them. From what I know they did not support the anti-Semitic parts of the Third Reich, but rather supported a strong Germany. Does it matter either way? Nope. Because I am NOT them. I am someone else. With my own thoughts, my own feelings, ambitions, hopes, dreams, goals, beliefs, strengths, and so on. I will not shame myself for something I have nothing to do with. Sadly, many of my countrymen and -women do not think as I do. Instead, they help the „de-nazification“ process, which, at this point, is more of a de-Germanisation process. Patriotism is grounds for being called a neo-Nazi. Not being super-liberal, socialist, and globalist is seen as „Nazist.“ It’s sad that Germany carries the legacy of a terrible time that ended 75 years ago. We should free ourselves from these self-applied shackles and start thinking about what would actually be good for this country, instead of self-loathing.
If you want a Japanese equivalent of the German swastika, look up the symbol of “Taisei Yokusankai”. The purpose of the symbol actually comes from a political stance. The Japanese rising sun is more like the German iron cross, a cultural symbol thats rooted in their history.
well it not swastika but it more like old american flag or the Confederate flag... it had too strong of military design... not very useful for peace when they don't want to remember them... PTSD and shit...
@@campkira What PTSD, the vast majority of the people who can actually associate the flag with horror are dead or so far gone into senility it is practically the 1940s all over again.
@@kgbcommitteeforstatesecuri3315 No the Iron Cross it literally the official symbol of the Bundeswehr. i think you mean the balkenkreuz(beam cross) which isnt banned or so but not used idk why cause it actually looks better and more modern
Having lived in Japan for 25 years, and been preoccupied with other aspects of life in this amazing country I’ve never really had any opportunity to delve deeper into the questions surrounding Japan’s flags. This brief and informative documentary helped a lot. Of course, for all the time I’ve been living here I have been aware of the sensitivity surrounding Japan’s flags. Living here, you can’t help but notice its absence from daily life. Unlike in my native Australia, this country’s flag never gets used in TV commercials, billboards, or other forms of social education. In Japan, the Hinomaru is just simply missing from the public agenda. Yes, it hovers over city administration buildings and public schools. But its presence is part of that building’s design only, like a “wall” or “elevator” would be. The national flag rarely publicly reminds residents nor visitors which country they are in. The Hinomaru comes out on buses, trains, and urban street poles on public holidays only, and is quietly folded away the following day. On holidays perhaps one neighbor out of ten thousand might hang a Japanese flag up on their access to the street. People here seem to “be OK” with their flag, but the overall accepted Western version of historical events has obliged the individual Japanese not to “love it”. Those people who display the Hinomaru on days that are not public holidays are seen as extreme right-wing nationalists who are shunned by the majority. While there is much ongoing criticism internationally of Japan’s actions in history, one can’t help but feel sympathy for the confused typical young Japanese and their uneasy relationship with its flag. Sporting events are a rare opportunity for the individual Japanese to wave a flag that depicts the usual pride that peoples have towards a common identity, belongingness and success on the international stage, yet at international away sporting events though, particularly within Asia, Japanese supporters are warned by its government of the risks of flying any flag that symbolizes Japanese pride. All nations’ flags carry history. Few nations can be totally pride of its history. The Japanese certainly have issues of history it needs to deal with internally. Yet perhaps more than most people, the Japanese are aware of and struggle with the relationship between history and the flag that represents it, the present and the future.
The perception of old symbols like this one strongly depends on where you live. For instance I live in Europe, so i don't perceive any negative connotations of the Rising Sun Flag. I even used to have a big decal of it on the roof my Honda because I liked the look of it, and nobody had a problem with it. Many fans of Japanese cars in Europe have some form of the Rising Sun Flag on their cars and it's perfectly fine. In the same way now I have a confederate flag on the roof of my Ford pickup truck and it's just a cool design feature (because of the Dukes of Hazzard) without any historical or ideological significance because in my country nobody cares about the american civil war. On the other hand I couldn't drive around with a Swastika on a Mercedes even if I wanted to, but in China I saw action figures of war criminals like Reinhard Heydrich in Nazi uniform, and nobody seemed to care. I presume that people in China perceive Nazi symbols just as some western exotic culture without any deeper meaning.
I live in Australia though which was attacked by the Japanese sure were weren't dominated by japan but POWs still were treated poor and personally I think they should able to fly what ever flag they want it's not symbolic of oppression people need to grow up. It has much more cultural significance to just be discarded after a few short years of dark history, if every country changed their flags after every wat the get into they run out of creative ideas.
@@profile1172 it was present in Indo-European cultures as well in ancient history. It has also been depicted slightly different depending what culture and era it was being used.
@@michael3088 you literally explained why your point is worthless, Australia didn't face the atrocities china and Korea faced that were committed by the Japanese so of course you don't find it offensive.
@DunklerJägerZach This also baffles me, but this what makes developing country (3rd world) remains the same or slow to develop is that most of the corrupt politicians are just plain selfish and don't care about their people, and likely incompetent as well which make things worse. Reality is that most government in the world will have some corruption in one form or another, different is how they still contribute back and actually make positive impact to the society, not just let it rot and make society struggling to make it work. Difference is one steal some, other one leaves little back to the people. Both are bad, but former one is lesser evil than the other. It's sad really.
@Roger Dodger it's almost like a nationalistic, right-wing government makes for a good country to live in, and a communist country is invariably a hellscape of misery. Strange, right?
It has like 5 or 6 who effectively run the country through a myriad of business interests so complex it would likely takes years to figure it out. Honestly they should just stop pretending and reinstate the Shogunate with the Emperor as its puppet again.
@Uncle Ho international？ where is that? It's only some peninsula. for US military and some allies, Japan was an enemy in the last war, however they have drills with Japanese SDF with this flag and I don't know their complaints.
I was in Yokosuka Japan in 1979-1980 as a U.S. sailor. There were several Japanese naval vessels moored at the naval station there and I was startled to see a Hinari flag at the stern of each vessel. I looked into the history of Japanese national flags at that point. Your post recounts much of what I discovered, and I thank you for letting the world know. One small addition. The reason the naval ensign used the hinari was because it was visible at great distances to approaching or passing vessels. The reason the sun-disk is offset is that it gives observers some indication of the ship's direction or course (I was told this by a signalman aboard my own ship). Again, many thanks, good post!
@@ヤマトウズメ-r1o yeahhhhh... history begs to differ... like, it really really begs to differ... (Japan created the monster that is communist China, and the US rebuilt Japan after WW2 and is basically Japan’s military. Also, the Japanese constitution is based off of America’s... sooooo yeah)
@@ヤマトウズメ-r1o The Japanese government is modeled after the American one (as is France for example, it’s not unique to any country), although in your defense, it was much more free than a lot of western monarchies. Modern Japan was founded 1947. Even before then it took much inspiration from the US.
@Paultry Paul it's a misconception, Japanese never saw themselves a superior race ,they marely wished the westerner saw them as their equal, as a matter of fact the Japanese propose in the league of nation that all race must be equal as the league's principle but this was brutally rejected by the British and the American, both of them twisted this logic by making the Japanese looks diregarding other race as propoganda
im chinese. I am not offended by the flag and i think they should keep it. I am against cancel culture. If they have to change a centuries year old cultural flag because of one war then british should have to change their flag for also invading others and so should americans.
There are a lot of flags with the Grain Britain flag onto them, I think its extremely terrible to "show" that you conquered the country and put your flag on top of anothers...
This might be off topic, but in my school in Singapore we were made to sing Kimigayo once or Japan's national anthem in our history lesson to simulate the wartime experience of students in Singapore during the Japanese Occupation.
Dangerous Sir Kiwi wait seriously? That’s...kinda cool i wish they did that in my history class,closest we did was our teacher locking us out of our class to simulate the French 3rd Estate being locked out of the Estates general. But singing a song that was an anthem of your occupying nation to simulate life during occupation sounds way cooler. Props to your history teacher
Actually it never changed. “Sun Beam version “ is still the official flag of Today’s powerful Navy, Japan Maritime Self Defense Force , and it is “ Official “. Simple version on the other hand has been the “National Flag”. No charges. Both are appropriate Flags as the Land of Rising Sun.
I will point out three things about the video including misunderstanding ・ The Rising Sun Flag is not in the same line as the Haken Kreuz. The Rising Sun Flag corresponds to the flag such as German Iron Cross and White Ensign. If the theory of eliminating the Rising Sun Flag holds, then the flags of the countries that also controlled the colonies (such as White Ensign, US Navy flag, and other europian countries' flag) must also be eliminated. ・ The Rising Sun symbol has been used as a sign of good luck since before the Edo period. The main meaning of the Rising Sun Flag and the symbol itself is "I wish you good luck." The military element was added later. ・ The official flag of Japan is the Rising Sun Flag at any time. The official national flag of Japan before and after the war is the "Hinomaru".
> If the theory of eliminating the Rising Sun Flag holds, then the flags of the countries that also controlled the colonies (such as White Ensign, US Navy flag, and other europian countries' flag) must also be eliminated. yes, you are correct by accident lol
@CockSlicet Its nonsense though since they used the hinomaru on campaign as well. The US doesn't care about the flag and they were the main adversaries of the IJN.
@CockSlicet They do use it, and will tell you to stuff it otherwise. It is not them with the problem, it's people like you with the problem. You can't hold today's Japan responsible for what it had done then. People in the West may like being bent over for their past - we've not went as far as the Romans yet, perhaps do what ISIS did, start removing Roman history - at the rate the West is going, they'll be doing that sooner or later.
@CockSlicet its not dumb actuly if my calculations are correct, that flag is the same as a union jack. Thats true. It is a symbol of royalty and the signature of a army. Nothing more nothing less. I belive japan should be allowed a army again and start stopping China. Do u know how much blood British have spilled? Lots of French and Spanish sunk. And lots of cities burned! But I don't care what British did then! I don't care what japan did then! I acknowledge it happened. But I don't care because japan is not the same as before, same that British ain't the same They still embody the traditions of yesturday, but they are evolved (both countries have) I don't care about ur petty racist Asian grudges you hold against Japanese (people protesting flag outside japan) If it wasn't for Japan being in way of China China would continue to sink civilian ships
The flag is still being used actively by the Japanese Navy. I see it all the time (20 year resident of Japan) in the Yokosuka Navy Base and Tokyo area.
It's war flag for sure. Not only korea many countries that got invaded by Japan feel the same way. Most of Americans feel the same way is well. No wonder that USA is the one nuked Japan.
“Rising the sun” flag which is called “Kyokujitsuki(旭日旗)” in Japan has ordinary 16 rays the reason why there are 16 rays on it is that Japanese imperial emblem, “Kikkagomon(菊花御紋)” which was designed based on flower of chrysantheum has 16 petals
Originally, it is a lucky charm that expresses "Rising Sun". Sometimes a national flag, sometimes a military flag, sometimes a fishing boat's big catch flag, and sometimes a soccer cheering flag. It has nothing to do with Haken Kreuz. It's a lie made by South Korea. In 2011, Ki Sung-yueng performed a racial discrimination performance in the soccer match between Japan and Korea. Ki Sung-yueng made an excuse that he went to the Rising Sun Flag. Despite the fact that the Rising Sun Flag was not raised on that day. It has nothing to do with the Empire of Japan. The Rising Sun is an auspicious symbol, not that of militarism. There has been no criticism of this flag since the end of the war. There was none at all. 'Cause this flag is a celebration flag. Because it's an auspicious flag. Criticism began suddenly in 2011. Forged hoaxes with no historical background spread from South Korea. He got Japanese traditional flag dirty. When I see this flag, it reminds me of Korean criticism. We are really sad. Since 2011, South Korea has sharply linked it to the war. There is no sin in this beautiful flag. It all started with an excuse for Ki Sung-yueng to hide racism. The Japanese are confused by the large number of Koreans who criticize Japan. Please do not pollute the beautiful flag in the lie of Ki Sung-yueng. Please know the truth.
This comment sections are seems awfully scripted Those Korean languages are copy pasted and poor translated and btw Even nazi symbol was originated from buddhism and It had meaning of lucky same as your sun rising flag but Look at it imagine german person wave Hakenkreuz in public or olympics that man would be beaten up to death you Japanese should learn from your old friend
@@shawnofdanaukota3843 ohhhh watch out! The Japanese Internet fascists might come in and try to justify their war crimes as “well China is worse” despite them being the ones who made modern China!
@@Pepe-dq2ib yes, the Chinese communist party only won the Chinese civil war and replaced the Republic of China because of Japanese invasions into China, Mao himself even said he couldn’t have taken control of China if the Japanese didn’t rape, murder, and enslave the Chinese at the time. So yes, the big scary monster that is the CCP, it’s Japan’s Frankenstein. Now the republic of China is nothing more but a husk on the island of Taiwan. The Japanese government barely touches upon the Second World War, and thus the Japanese people know very little of the events that led up to the creation of their modern rival. I think education on the subject and time period could go a long way in mending relations between the two nations.
Japan's rising sun flag, German Empire's flag, Nazi Germany's Wehrmacht Commander flag, and the US Confederated flag all look pretty cool. I'm not a Nazi or a white supremacist, I just think they look like pretty cool flags. I also think the Union Jack and the USSR flag looks pretty cool also.
@fjf sjdnx the teacher died with his/her principle. Life without purpose is nothing. The teacher decided his/her purpose is for Japanese Nationalism, now whether it was right or wrong is up to personal preference but I wouldnt definitely say it was a waste of human life.
When I was little I loved ninjas so I made a Rising Sun Kamikaze headband. I had no idea what it meant, just thought of ninjas. One day we went to see my great grandparents and we went to eat at a Chinese restaurant. I made it a point to wear my Kamikaze headband. Nobody there was fucking happy with me at ALL
The rising sun flag isn't like the swastika that was used by the Germans in WW2 but more like the iron cross that was used by the Germans during WW1, WW2 and it is still used today. The equivalent to the swastika would be the taisei yokusankai, which is a white bird with the red sun between it's wings
It's not swastik .....Swastik is a Sanskrit word and it's extremely sacred in Hinduism... Hitler never called it swastik ..he called it 'heukenkraus' or hooked cross
This is why the neighbors are just playing stupid about Japan not apologizing properly like Germany. The American occupation didn't dismantle the Japanese goverment like nazi German goverment. To replace it with a new goverment.
True. It upsets me everytime that people connect it with that. I think the logo of the Taisei Yokusankai is more like the asian nazi-swastika. It's just like with the imperial german flag. I can't openly show it because people connect it with nazism or right wing groups.
Haken Kreuz is a political party flag that shows the Aryans' superiority, but the Rising sun flag is a military flag, and its origin is the universal civilian sun belief. There is no problem. www.mofa.go.jp/files/000481576.pdf
even then, the swastika is also a religious symbol from South Asia that has been tarnished by the Nazi image, so there’s really a lot of nuance here when it comes to symbol comparison.
As someone from Korea, I personally don't see the rising flag as bad as swastika 'cause unlike swastika, the rising sun flag has previous history before the atrocities Japan had committed and also it's not a copycat of some other nation/religion's symbol. But I'm sure to tell you that many here do see the flag as one of the most evil flag. I think Japan can still use it just like Germany still use the iron cross to this day. But that *would* destroy Japan's diplomatic relationship with her neíghbors. Because here in East Asia, nationalism is as wipe spread and emotional (irrational) as Balkan. Even more so you might say.
Oh yeah definitely. As a chinese, can tell from experience that they’re also miffed af seeing it. Unlike in other nations however, China has rampant nationalism bc of their communist government’s brainwashing.
The Nissho flag(Hinomaru) was first adopted by the Shogunate as a ship flag on the high seas. The Rising Sun Flag has its roots in the military flag used in the Revolutionary War by the Revolutionary Army centered on the Satsuma Domain. As the new government, they adopted the Nissho flag(Hinomaru) as the national flag and the Rising Sun Flag as the military flag. Even now, the national flag is the Nissho flag(Hinomaru) , and the rising sun flag is used as the military flag.
Those who were educated after World War II were brainwashed by the brainwashing education program designed by the U.S. and Syngman Rhee at that time. Before the Japanese rule, Korea was ruled by the Yi Dynasty and a handful of yangban who exploited the people. The infrastructure and educational system were not developed, and the people were only allowed to wear white clothes. It was Japan that overthrew such a system that treated the people like slaves and laid the foundation for Korea to become a modern nation. Did you know that An Jung-geun was in favor of the annexation of Korea? The Japanese Prime Minister at the time, Hirobumi Ito, was assassinated for his opposition to the annexation of Korea.
@@u1v.s7 Honestly, I'm not bothered by the use of the rising sun flag nor the Swastica. I'm more bothered by the double standard of Swastica being bad but the Rising Sun flag is not. Both have a tradition of being used as a sign of fortune and good energy and such and used by the mustached dictator. But somehow only Swastica is bad because Hitler was the only bad guy in Europe and anyone else who opposed is a hero despite of all the bad works in it's colonies.
6:15 Stance? Maybe. Kinda condition of surrender. Most often we require that the nations deescalate their military capacity to only,being able to defend the nation and not have any forces able to go beyond that. Same with post-WW1 Germany when we effectively castrated their ability (in theory) to have a militsry.
The Rising Sun Flag of Japan is not a claim of militarism, but a flag that is displayed in front of the house when celebrating. In addition, the Rising Sun Flag of Japan has existed before 1900. Certain people are trying to give a bad impression to Japan's Rising Sun Flag, but the truth is this.
This flag is the 1880's first written in Japanese navy. From the Navy, the Army and the Japanese Army began to use.The Japanese always say that the Rising Sun Flag means a good thing, but Hakenkreuz also means symbol of luck. And used in the Asuka period in japan you mentioned is clearly different from the shape of the Rising Sun Flag. In addition, Japan's Rising Sun Flag was clearly used militarily and politically. The Rising Sun Flag used in the Pacific War. Japan until now not to apologize properly while slaughtering a huge number of people, and always emphasizes that Japan seems to be a victim of a nuclear bomb rather than causing damage even though it caused World War II. Of course i don’t want to fight you, but I wanted to tell you exactly what Koreans and Chinese say
@@jadenlee7506 I think you love so much about the rising sun flag because you studied so hard about it. How much do you love that flag?😂 Are you 츤데레? P.S World War 2 was started and caused by Germany, not Japan. Learn history going back to elementary school 바보🤞🥺
@@jadenlee7506 You Korean always run away to using Korean language when it comes to getting at the core of the matter. To tell you the truth, you love so much about the rising sun flag while saying "the rising sun flag is Hakenkreuz!" alone. Be honest 츤데레.
@@dragonesryan282 Hahaga, you never told me the core of the matter. Is the core of your matter ‘츤데레’?If you want to get an answer from me, ask me a real question not bullshit
I personally don't have a problem with Japan's Rising Sun flag, but my grand father working in Darwin as a home guard and my grand uncle as a private infantry man fighting in New Guinea during the 1940's would have thought VERY differently about it.
@@williamwang3729 It was just war, nothing personal; we've fought lots of wars, even amongst our own peoples from time to time, if we held a grudge against every one we had ever fought we'd hate virtually every person who walks the earth. Hatred and animosity may be reasonable during times of war, but once the war is over, it's time to move on; it's a regular occurrence throughout history that today's enemy becomes tomorrow's ally and today's ally becomes tomorrow's enemy.
Costa Keith I got where you come from, but a lot of Chinese and Korean family lost their friends and families by the Japanese empirical army, and they should be held accountable (which they didn’t, U.S. let a lot war criminals lose in order to make Japan a U.S. ally that can counter Chinese and Russian influence.
Yeah I also don’t have personally problem with Nazi symbol. So I can use Nazi symbol in personal. But I didn’t use that symbol. Cuz I respect the soldiers that defending from Nazi in WW2. But many westerners don’t think about it the same way about rising sun flag. I think if you respect your grand father and your grand uncle, then you have to think the same way as them.
If you look into more of war images of Japan, you'll find that they only flew the rising sun flag when they won the battle. basically the rising sun flag was used for celebration. also the reason why Japanese imperial navy used the rising sun flag is simply because hinomaru just looked like a white flag from the distance on the sea when it's not waved. that's why japanese navy aka japanese maritime self defense force uses the rising sun flag still:)
@flyveto457it’s because Japan hasn’t apologized for all the atrocities they did, such as forcing women and girls into prostitution, and denies TO THIS DAY any wrong doing
@@ヤマトウズメ-r1o funny how you mention cruelty...... fooling no one , strangely pacifist since you were handed your arses following dishonourable acts during ww2....
It's not the problem of flag. It's only the way to look and how you think of it. I'never heard of the complain about the Stars and Stripes or Union Flag from Native Americans, Vietnamese, African,Chinese, Korean, of course Japanese. Why?
I'm Japanese. Some foreigners misunderstands that Japanese Rising sun flag was the national flag of Japan until the end of ww2. Actually, it was not. And it has never been a national flag of Japan. Japanese national flag has been Hinomaru which is same as today's. Rising sun flag had been a symbol flag of Japanese navy and it is being used by Japanese maritime self defense force too.
If South Korea insists that national symbols that Japan used to invade neighboring countries (in the past) should not be used at all, then South Korea should also send objections to the use of for example the British flag and the tricolor French flag (Drapeau français), because these were traditionally used by the European countries during European colonialism, the first wave of European colonization (1415 to 1830 CE) and New Imperialism (late 19th and early 20th centuries).
Not the same, it's hard to compare what Imperial Japan atrocities with the other Imperialists. And the timeline is more recent. It may require a few more generations to pass.
@@No_Anime_No_Life. what Timothy is referring to is Japan trying to cover it up in the history it try to teach their own people. The Japanese are being taught that world war 2 is an attempt for Japan to liberate all the people of western colony and forging closer economical ties
Hi, We are Japanese. That's a nice post. However We must insist about this subject.... The Japanese "Hinomaru flag" has been for hundreds of years. and the "Rising sun flag" also is it that would be displayed at the time of celebrations. The Rising sun flag was adopted for the war so that it would not be mistaken for a white flag when there was no wind. This is a very nervous problem for Japan as well. And you know only some fanatic Koreans are screaming that the Rising Sun Flag is a war criminal in Asia. Do you know any groups, for example in Thailand or Indonesia that are screaming so? Your ancestors have also invaded and slaughtered Africa, Asia and America, but what do you think if your country's flag is shouted "identical to the Nazis in war crimes"? Europeans, Americans are should to check directly with the parties, including Japan.
As a Korean, I want to talk to you. Koreans don't actually know what the Rising Sun Flag is like, but they are opposed in that it was used as a symbol of militarism. Obviously, it is true that the mesh or media acts stimulatingly in Korea, and it is true that there is an extreme Korean that you said because they hate Japan politically or blindly. However, it is true that problems have arisen since you colonized Korea in the first place. After occupying it by force, it committed things such as exploitation of human resources, slaughter, and national extinction, and after World War II, it was divided into the United States and the Soviet Union, and the Korean War broke out. Of course, you can't look good from a Korean perspective. Of course, it is also true that the Japanese government officially apologized like Konodamhwa. But Japanese military sexual slavery and laborers who people's issues and not seen as a sincere apology to Yasukuni Shrine to honor their war crimes. You said that the relationship between Korea and Japan is important. On the one hand, don't Koreans say they are fanatic and blame Korea unconditionally? When I talk to Japanese people about these issues, Everyone says it's in the past and everyone says it's anti-Japanese agitation.
Do you think we're acting noisy to you unlike other countries? What do you think it would be like if you guys were us? Is it right for you to forget about it and shut up quietly?
Rising Sun Flag ≠ Haken Kreuz. Haken Kreuz = Imperial Rule Assistance Association flag. Rising Sun Flag = Iron Cross. Although Hakenkreuz was abolished in Germany, the Iron Cross is still in use. The Imperial Rule Assistance Association flag has been abolished in Japan, but the Rising Sun Flag is still in use. I think that is the reason why the Rising Sun Flag is not abolished. I would like to exchange opinions once about what Koreans think and what Japanese people think. I would like to exchange opinions peacefully rather than in a quarrel.
@@heiwa_is_best Good idea. Nice to talk to you. It is certain that the Rising Sun Flag is not a good image in Korea. In fact, it is rare for Koreans to know what the Rising Sun Flag is like in Japan, but it is true that there is no way they would like the flag used by the former Japanese Empire in Korea. According to the opinions of people who hate the Rising Sun Flag, I heard that it should be banned because it was the main culprit of the Pacific War after the Japanese army took over the Japanese regime in a coup in the past. Good idea. Nice to talk to you. It is certain that the Rising Sun Flag is not a good image in Korea. In fact, it is rare for Koreans to know what the Rising Sun Flag is like in Japan, but it is true that there is no way they would like the flag used by the former Japanese Empire in Korea. According to the opinions of people who hate the Rising Sun Flag, I heard that it should be banned because it was the main culprit of the Pacific War after the Japanese army took over the Japanese regime in a coup in the past. Originally, I had the same idea as above, but from the Japanese side's point of view, I think Japan's position is well-founded, so I'm still thinking about it. If the Rising Sun Flag should be banned, Belgium, France, and Britain, the same colonial empires in the past, are also logic that flags should be banned, so it seems too complicated. Recently, I don't think Japan clearly expresses its position in Korea. I think Japan doesn't apologize like Germany. But because of that, I think there are cases where Korea treats Japan too emotionally.
@@김태원-p1c Japanese here and what I would like to say is that we *never* "colonized" Korea. Please learn your history and you will find out that your royals at the time left your people and Japan with no choice but to let Japan "adopt" you. Basically, what happened was we fought a war with Russia to *make Korea independent* from China (or the Great Qing Empire, because we didn't want their influence so close), and that didn't go well. After we won the war and made Korea an independent state, your royals didn't know what to do to keep the country running, and your government was a *total chaos with the most corrupted officers* on Earth. Gojong, or the Emperor Gwangmu, *refused to modernize* and ordered to kill people who held the idea. Your government at the time *failed in everyway* you could imagine: they were *corrupted* , secretly *allowed people to make fake money* by selling secret permits. They also betrayed Japan & UK & every other country who were actually trying to help your country to get on your feet. Gojong secretly asked Russia for help to get rid of Japan so he can restore power, and this made everyone furious. *Sarcastically, Russia actually turned against Gojong* after his got busted, because one random crazy korean guy *murdered our prime minister* Hirofumi Ito, and the Russians didn't want any problem on that shit. Japanese people *were sympathetic* to Korean people, however, we totally lost hope when we found out that your Emperor had just betrayed us, and what he did wasn't even for your own interest. Then, after all trials have failed and everyone lost all hope in your royals and your government, *Japan, UK and US talked to each other and decided* it's best for Japan to make the annexation. I know you may argue that no country will be "nice" enough to help a country out of total courtesy, well, of course we had our own interest. We had several concerns: 1. The fact your country did not have a functional government made it *hard for us to trade with you* . 2. The fact your government allowed people to make fake money caused a *financial disaster* . Your country literally had to adopt Japanese Yen just to have some working currency. 3. Your government was never one piece and was always fighting internally, which led to a ton of diplomatic betrayal. Several incidents almost *put us into the danger of war* for some total nonsense. For all the reasons and circumstances above, *WE HAD TO MAKE YOUR COUNTRY STABLE ONE WAY OR ANOTHER* . We tried to help you establish a new working government, and that failed, which just *left us no choice* . And there you have the annexation. The annexation was *well accepted* by the international community at the time.
Kyokujitsu-ki the rising sun flag goes back to 1603 during the edo period.It was used first by warlords then used by Nippon in 1870 as the flag for the armed forces....Take the video above with a grain of salt.
The rising sun flag is still flown (2021) from Japan's naval vessels. I have seen it flown from the stern in Port Melbourne on a rare occasion a Japanese navy ship visits.
I was going to say the same thing. This flag has been flown on Japan's Naval Ship docked in Australian ports in recent years. Its not Japan's national flag, it is Japan's "self defence" force flag.
The title of this video creates a lot of misunderstandings, because the Rising Sun Flag has never been used as a Flag of Japan, so it did not change after the war.
The Rising Sun Flag is also used as a flag to teach the land when fishermen have a big catch. It is also used for baby gifts. It's not the flag of war.
@@越の赤狸 The Rising Sun Flag is the flag of war of japan. But Japan nationalists who refute japan's WWII war crimes, have promoted its use after the war, to gain common acceptance.
Japanese flag is also a sign of "Non-Vegetarian" food on every packaged food in India. Edit : In India it is mandatory for companies to label every food item with Sign/Label. The "Red Dot' like Japanese flag is for Non-Vegetarian food, There's "Green Dot" for Vegetarian food and "Yellow Dot" for food that contains Eggs. In India Eggs are not considered vegetarian, Also there will be Vegan labelling on foods soon. I wish every country had this type of labelling it's quiet simple to know about food this way.
that's not the Japanese flag lol, it's actually supposed to be brown but some manufacturers also put red for some reason. it's a white square outlined by the line of same color as the circle inside the square. Green dot for vegetarian and Brown dot for non vegetarian.
@@joshzhang7041 I’m sure they’re just clueless what that means, I’ve seen some confederate flags too. They might’ve thought the thing just looks nice to add as decorations so why not.
@@mjolninja9358 .... They probably find them aesthetically cool but I don't think there are many other nations out there who would put the rising sun flag as a decor after the Japanese killed 1+ million of their grandparents and also massacred their capital. There's also the online stereotype/meme that Pinoys hate themselves.
The 'War Flag' with its sun rays radiating out from the centre disc was adopted in 1870, as part of Japan's modernisation. It was thought that modern, western countries such as Britain and the USA had national and military flags, so Japan must have them as well. In fact, the specific design of the Naval ensign with its offset sun disk and 16 red rays was formally adopted in 1889 - which was also the year that Japan became a constitutional monarchy with a democratically elected parliament, the Diet. The fact that the naval ensign was also used during the 1930s and 40s when Japan lapsed into militarism and dictatorship must be offset against the fact that the same flag was also used by democratic Japan in the preceding years - and it uses symbolism which has been associated with the country for over a millennium. This can be contrasted with flags such as Germany's swastika (Hakenkreuz) and the Soviet Union's hammer and sickle. They were the symbols of specific political movements, the Nazis and Communists, and were adopted as the national flag when those movements seized power in their respective countries. As such, when Nazism and Communism were overthrown, their flags were also abolished and banned. The Rising Sun flag, however, is not the symbol of an ideology but of a nation. In this context, the events after the Second World War should be considered. When the Americans occupied Japan in 1945, they banned all displays of nationalism. Any display of Japanese flags at all was prohibited without the permission of the occupation authorities, which was rarely given. These restrictions were partially lifted at a highly symbolic moment: in May 1947, when Japan adopted a new and fully democratic constitution, they were also permitted to fly their national flag over major public buildings such as the parliament building and supreme court. Over the next two years the ban on private citizens using the national flag was also lifted in two stages.
FizzyElf maybe to you, but to many other Asians who were occupied by japan it’s equivalent to the confederate or even the nazi flag for them. And no, I don’t gotta re-evaluate shit
8:05 Requesting a Naval Vessel to not fly its ensign upon entering one of your ports is actually quite a huge Diplomatic Affront no matter the circumstances.
They could fly their official national flag. Considering the history and atrocities committed under the rising sun flag in korea and china, the koreans are absolutely justified in their request that the japanese not fly it. I'm totally on their side. Like if they can't even swallow their pride and admit to their own history on a joint, supposedly peace keeping, practice in korea, then they can fuck right off... and i'm not even korean.
@@datnguyenthe8300The army used a different Rising Sun flag with the sun centered in the middle. The current one, which was previously used by IJN, is off to the side; it's a subtle difference but they're not the same flags and, to my knowledge, the IJN wasn't a large user of war crimes or abuse like the IJA was.
@@gerbearneronero9748 They even got some military planes from germany in World War 2. So its not that rare to see german equipment in the japanese military in the early 1940s.
When they were invited to come to South Korea for a fleet review the Korean government asked them to only put the national flag on their ships. However Japan refused to do so and said they would rather not participate then put the rising sun flag down. And really didn't come lol. Shame on them
山田 let me put it into perspective for you. Let’s say a foreign nation decides to take over your country, erase your culture, forces you to speak their language, makes your friends into sex slaves, forces your father to fight in their wars, kills entire villages for “fun”, turns your emperor’s palace into a zoo, digs up graves, constructs their administrative building in the front of a palace, kills countless people because of a peaceful protest, changes textbooks, spreads stories which cause your and your neighbor to hate each other, and much more. Do you think time will help you forget all of that? And y’know what? We want to forget it. But for us to forget it we just want Japan to admit their wrong doings, educate their children, and show how real people with dignity deal with their wrongs, so that we can stop hating Japan. Is that so much to ask?
I remember seeing the rising sun flag flown on Japanese ships when they pulled into Peal Harbor and went past the USS Arizona memorial. Of course no one I knew, nor I was offended by this but I found it interesting that 70+ years ago that flag represented a nation that attacked Pearl Harbor and now they fly that flag in Pearl Harbor as our friends.
@@jeayounhyun6786 When did Japan do to Koeans like the Jews? Germany slaughtered the Jews, but Japan treated Taiwanese and Koreans as Japanese citizens. The fact is that the Korean royal family was left intact and a Japanese princess married a Korean prince. In a 1936 survey, about 80% of Koreans said they were not dissatisfied with Japanese rule. Only about 10% of their advocated for Korean independence. Taiwanese, who were incorporated into Japan 16 years earlier than Korea, have not protested anything against Japan on historical issues until today. The reason why Korea protests against Japan is because Korea is divided into north and south, and moreover, the northern half is a communist state. The southern half is a democracy, but it is full of spies from North Korea. Since they are of the same ethnicity and speak the same language, it is difficult to detect that they are spies. North Korean spies are teaching false history in order to divide Japan and South Korea.
The Japanese changing their flag because "empire bad" would be like the British changing the Union Jack because empire bad, I mean comparing it to the nazi flag is so over the top dramatic, it's not the same, if you compared the German imperial flag to the Japanese imperial flag then that would be accurate.
Im indonesian, my country was in occupation of japan for 3.5 years and had very very terrible experiences from that even some says its more terrible than 350 years dutch occupation. We indonesians still remember it, but its the past, we cant change it and we make peace with our past. Im not okay if japan use that flag, but im okay with japanese. Its only ethical problem..
For me, because it was the Japanese army flag during World War II, and because it often appeared in the occupied areas or battlefields（or some inhumane place） of Japan, it was given a symbolic meaning (the occupied areas of Japan are generally managed by the army). And to a certain extent, it symbolizes the militarism and Nazi oriented Japan at that time. So on some special occasions, it may be natural for me to feel disgusted with this flag
We in the Phillipines have a lot of atrocities done to us by the Japanese Empire but , at least for me I dont give a fuck. I mean when I saw it back then, I just thought that. Owh, so thats the Japanese military flag
I'm Japanese, but when I went to the Philippines, I saw a sticker of the Japanese Kyokujituki flag on a motorcycle and my Filipino friends wore T-shirts with designs of the kyokujituki flag on them, and I laughed. When I asked him about it, he said he knew what it meant and wore it, so we became really good friends. I liked that mentality.
@@raihis1313 It is not only used by the military. It is used in every situation. It is also raised when the fisherman goes out to the sea. The Rising Sun Flag has existed long before the army was formed in Japan. Find out more about it yourself.
As a filipino the rising flag isnt really offensive to us (atleast to the people i know). Maybe because Japan just colonised the country for short time. And the flag is not really emphasized in our school, just the atrocities that japan committed.
You see, the Japanese flag represents the sun in the sky. The old Japanese sun represents the time period when it was a DEADLY LASER The new Japanese sun represents today, where it's not a deadly laser anymore, because it has a blanket.
"Rising Sun Flag" has been used in various happy events such as a birth-giving and big catch since the Edo period. Later in the Meiji period, because it is thought to be a symbol of happy events, it came to be used as the military flag praying for victory.
Had a kid in middle school from Japan wear his Grandfather’s Japanese imperial army uniform to class when we discussed World War Two on Veterans Day. Needless to say the Chinese and Korean students weren’t thrilled...
Now that's wack xD
So it was like having a hungarian a romanian and a turk at a bar and started a "civilized" discussion on their countries history?
I'm assuming since it's middle-school we're talking, he wore it more out of naivety for the reaction he'd get rather than in trying to make some kind of point about military history, nationalism, and remembrance.
@Jedem Das Seine Actually Turkey has very close realitionship with Romania and Hungary. All three protecting each other in international politics and they have a really good import, export rates so politicians always acts like they always have been good bodies.
@WoodberryLax40k Why? Did he perform a Banzai charge? xD
Hadnt realised the difference between the naval and army rising sun flags.
I didn't actually know either before I made the video!
It’s a subtle difference.
had only seen the Naval flag and noticed it was off centre.
Going to review movies like Bridge over the River Kwai and see if it uses the army flag.
@@ChristopherNFP Don't forget to also look for the _Hinomaru._ In my home country (the United States), the military flags are usually depicted in war films as national flags used during World War II, while the _real_ national flag's use at the time is ignored by the films. Those who don't know much about flags just assume the Rising Sun Flag (both of them) was a national flag during World War II (kind of like the German Nazi flag, but not a party flag), and not what it really is: a military flag used almost continuously by Japan since 1870, and still to this day.
In short, look out for the national flag, for it does not usually make the war films.
@@SoooooWhatt
I would assume that if I saw the Hinomaru in a movie set prior to August 1945 then it would be an historical error.
Is that correct?
I do not recall Hilbert contradicting that belief.
I was kinda hoping the answer was "it was too hard to draw"
That would be ironic
Dude have you seen how japan make anime
@@WhoCares869 yeah japan has some talented artist with an affinity for super roid style muscular men and thin women with ridiculous "proportions"
🤔........😆😆😆
It is hard to draw
well i mean drawing a perfect circle is hard
the best thing about simple flag is when in elementary school you're tasked to draw your country flag it won't cause a Headache
"How do I draw a circle?"
That is actually one of the hallmarks of good flag design. Is it easily recognized from a distance and can the children of your country recognize and recreate it
RIP welsh kids
@@fine5643 dude im lucky, just get a paper and make half of it red, though the french only need to do the first step
Until you realize that although each pupil brought a red marker there's really only one with the correct tone of red xD
I would rather compare "Rising sun flag" to german Iron Cross (military symbol, often associated with WW2, but not strictly representing any ideology, used by military of these countries to this day) , not to NSDAP flag (made specifically to be symbol of ideology and implemented as the symbol of ideology, being in use ONLY when country was run by followers of that ideology).
that's a much better comparison.
It still makes me chuckle when people get their dander up about seeing a German Leopard 2 MBT with the iron cross painted on the side.
I think he as making a comparison to the stigma that the flag has in the rest of Asia.
@@kaiserofgermania5236
>Was used before WW2
You know, to East Asians, Japan was still a horrible nation before WW2. It really is a European/American perspective.
To anyone in East Asia, or Australians who know their history, the Imperial Japanese were worse or at least on par with the WW2 Germans.
So yeah, it's equal with the Swastika.
@UCAk61SHJsXG_h-BgiIDDJyw Aye, but the Japanese forces were also still committing atrocities before WWII in earnest so it's a specific example that's further complicated by not falling strictly within the confines of a single regime or conflict. It's comparatively easier to draw distinctions with - say - the Swastika and the Iron Cross. One represented this party/organization/regime - the other has a longer, more varied history.
To play devil's advocate against my point, though - if there were any Herero around today they may even have an issue with the Iron Cross as a symbol, regardless of WWII. I suppose the inter-war period and WWII were such a hyper-charged climate in regard to national symbols and identity that it tends to make everything else more gray in comparison.
Don't think the Rising Sun Flag is okay to be used nowadays because it is older than the Japanese imperialists. In that logic, the Swastica has also existed for thousands of years, it was originally an Indo-European alphabet and the Nazi took it as their symbol to exert the "Aryan superiority." Yet the swastica is literally banned in most of the world. The Rising Sun Flag is the same. Although it may have existed since before the Japanese Empire, it still was used as the symbol of their imperialism and hundreds of millions of Asians suffered under that flag. Westerners are in no place to justify their use.
They should change it to just a picture of Godzilla
That's one idea xD
@Biracial Boy He's like a symbol for modern Japan, though. A living representation of the dangers of nuclear warfare and all that. If Godzillas were a real thing, I bet Japan would be using them the same way China uses pandas in regards to diplomacy. lol
If Wales gets to have a dragon then Japan should be able to have Godzilla :)
Fearsome Mumbler that’s exactly what came to mind when I thought this haha
Never. That would be an insult to the japanese people.
>School teacher committed suicide because of kids debating about the Hinomaru and the anthem
Maximum Nihonjin
This is so sad can we drink sake
she must have been a samurais decendant
ruclips.net/video/VKMw2it8dQY/видео.html
Pathetic
Tekiki tekiki
別に大日本帝国がキョクジツ旗って訳ではない
この動画嘘ばかりでまともなことが書かれてない。
一見まとめ方が上手くて動画も綺麗で質は高いように見えても言ってることは間違ってるの多いよね海外の動画...
そもそもサムネは海軍旗だからなにもchangeされてない
韓国系アメリカ人がロビー活動するし
欧米人も無知だし
これなんだよなあ…
There was never a change: the rising sun flag was not the official national flag of Japan even in those days - it was the country's military flag and was often popularly used with the regular national flag, but the national flag was the same as it is today.
There is a new leader who changed its flag
Nothing changed. The striped one is still the navy and army jack in Japan.
Its still used in jsdf. Nothing actually changed
This saved my 9 minutes. Well of I go to another documentary.
@@Maple_Tachibana Except he's totally wrong. National flag changed slightly and rising sun flag always had two different versions depending on Army or Navy... that's what I understood....
The Japanese Rising Sun Flag is still flown on Navy ships as is our first union jack.
Yep, it just floated into Pearl Harbor on a Japanese ship not to long ago.
Pity..
@@fbksfrank4 lmao it was an air raid not a naval bombardment
@@GageLeFox on his inflatable raft lmao
The rising sun flag is actually still up on a helicopter carrier to and is actually still the Japanese war flag only it has some golden triangles on the top bottom and sides
The Mitsubishi one was incorrect. That one was a merger of two symbols. One of 3 diamonds the the other (I think) was of a fern.
That's at least what I found but you may be right. Where did you come to learn about it?
@History With Hilbert I saw it on a random RUclips video once (no idea which one I'm afraid). It was an attempt to satisfy the two families that were merging. If you see the original two it's quite clever. Type in “mitsubishi symbol creation” into google and you’ll see it.
@@historywithhilbert I believe the Mitsubishi symbol you show is actually a stylized propeller - as in the Mitsubishi aircraft produced before and during the war. (much like Mercedes)
@@historywithhilbert looks like I'm wrong, and Tim Robinson is correct: thenewswheel.com/behind-badge-stunning-symbolism-mitsubishi-mark/
i think that it was gm and mitsubishi in the 1980's-2000's
This flag has been in use since before the war. Many countries must have a history of war and colonization. It's like saying that the British flag should be abolished.
There is a wartime flag that was created during WW2, the Taisei Yokusankai flag. The flag is not well known to foreigners, but it was created during the WW2 war and is no longer used after the war.
I agree with this.
その通りです。
For Vietnamese, the Taegeuk flag is a symbol of slaughter and rape.
yeah i agree with this. the difference between this flag and the Nazi one is that the Nazi flag was the flag of the Nazi party that took control of Germany and changed the German flag. it's inseparable from the Nazi party, but the Japanese navy flag was the flag before the war and before the terrible acts where committed its more of just a Japanese flag.
Keep up with the great work man, also Hilbert, I hope you're doing okay during this pandemic
Thank you Khaki that's really nice of you! I'm doing good - just staying busy but healthy thankfully. Hope you're well!
@@historywithhilbert Thanks for asking, I'm doing fine myself
Planned demic
Just for general knowledge: “land of the rising sun” doesn’t mean the people are “of the rising sun” or named themselves after the rising sun, but it represents, from a Chinese geographical perspective, the location of japan to the East. I like to translate it more as “the perceived origin of the sun as seen from China” lol. Kinda like how the name of China is “middle country.” Its more of a description of location than a true name. But then that’s where most Japanese family names come from, locations in nature.
Fun fact: A lot of sinicized country like to do this. Vietnam literally means the Viets/ Yue in the south lol
It's not only in Asia. There's a theory, regarding the etymology of "Europe" that says the name comes from Mesopotamian word "ereb" meaning "descent", so in that case Europe would be "the land of the setting sun".
@@yuki.s.3881 No they didn't. The name is written in both languages as 日本, which means "sun origin." Japan took the Chinese name when it adopted Chinese culture over a millennium ago (including the Chinese writing system to write the Japanese language). Not only that, but they also took the Sinitic-based pronunciation for the name: _ni_ is based on the old Chinese reading of 日 (read as _rì_ in modern Mandarin) and _pon_ is based on the old Chinese reading of 本 (read as _běn_ in modern Mandarin).
ZhangtheGreat you think i can't use internet?What I said is “they named themselves Nippon.”What you are saying? kanji?i know kanji were borrowed. So what?
Jennie .S. You are wrong as hell. My moms Japanese. Doesn’t matter that the Japanese might pronounce the characters in a different way. Yeah, the Japanese adopt many of their own readings for all the characters. The original meaning of the characters still stands.
For centuries Sony Clan and Nintendo Clan fight with each other over the control of Japan.
Now gamers.. I mean mercenaries from around the world support them in this endless war
Too bad Sony is more Californian than Japanese at this point. Their good years have ended.
Then Uncle Bill from Microsoft Corp. nuked them both back to the stone age.
@@4.0.4 It is false! SONY has its HQs in japan, it is the SIE (Playstation-division) who moved their HQs to california for research and development purposes since most of their gaming equipement like processor, GPU etc come from america , also North America account for about 50% of Playstation renue so i isgoodforthem to have a foothold there so as to better service that market. Do not forget Playstation also have division in Japan and europe lol
@@ulrichleukam1068 Most of the development is done outside Japan with majority of foreigners. So it really doesn't matter where Sony's HQ is located if you are talking about technology
@@ulrichleukam1068 Yes but SIE is the one that matters if you're comparing it to Nintendo. They're also shifting away from being the electronics company we all knew, since insurance makes them more of a profit. They're also becoming more censorious with what they allow, and their next console could be just a decent x86 computer, if leaks are correct. Not the cool company it once was.
It's been used long before WWII and still used as a Japan Maritime Self Defense Force Flag. It's not that flag is from WWII as some people want to automatically associate with war. It's a flag used even by the ordinally civilians in many ways, even fishermen or commercial ships or festive events, to think it's only associate with war is because one not knowing the Japanese culture.
Shame on you
@@마바사가나다라-j2l Please do not make a mistake. The same flag as Haken Kreuz is the flag of the Imperial Rule Assistance Association. The Japanese are also against the flag of the Imperial Rule Assistance Association.
I hope Koreans will work together to oppose the Imperial Rule Assistance Association flag instead of the Rising Sun Flag.
韓国の人たちは学校で日本に全ての責任があるかのような教育を受けさせられているのでこのようなことになるのも仕方のないことです。
@@クソリプ師-b4b 実際自分たちの王族がやらかしちゃって国をめちゃくちゃにした挙げ句日本に助けられたんだろ
それで日本が負けたあとに虎の威を借りて日本を叩くなんて最悪や
@@마바사가나다라-j2l 洗脳教育乙〜www
Honestly if the Rising Sun flag is taboo then most other old military and national flags should also be. Few people want to Union Jack taken down despite the horrors done in the name of British imperialism. The flag of the Third Reich was designed specifically by Nazis as a symbol of Nazism, which is incomparable to flag that was adopted long before the militarists seized power in Japan.
That’s the way I see the black-white-red flag of the German Empire. For some reason, here in Germany, it is associated with Nazism and racism. Personally, I see no issue with it. It is the flag that unified Germany after decades of consisting of bickering nation-states. It showed a rebirth of Germany as a whole, after the decline and fall of the incompetent and falling-apart Holy Roman Empire. It should be revered as the flag that unified Germany. Shame on those that misuse it, but can we really let such a small minority of racist neo-Nazis ruin our nation’s heritage and perception of the past? There is such a despicable shame-culture here in Germany; if anything isn’t 100% politically correct, you get shot down as if you were a Nazi. I hate it, I really do. It’s all in the name of freedom, but it’s more oppressive than any other regime in Germany. You can’t even show patriotism without being questioned on whether or not you’re a fucking neo-Nazi. That flag was practically replaced by the Swastika, and Hitler didn’t even like the German Empire or emperor. He barred people from going to Wilhelm II’s funeral. Yet, apparently this flag is “racist?” I would love to bring back this flag, to show my people that there is nothing inherently wrong with it. If it’s bad, then the Union Jack, Stars and Stripes, or you-name-it, are ten times worse. The idea of “history is written by the victors” is very debatable. But socially, I believe that it is very true, considering the victors fly their flags with no shame, but actually pride, whereas we must put down ours with shame.
@@Vaterlandstreuer While I can't see why the German Empire's flag is controversial, I think it isn't used officially because it was for the German Empire, not the German Republic.
Io I can understand that entirely. I simply believe that we shouldn’t distance ourselves from the past because of incorrect associations, and we should embrace our heritage. Does the flag say „This flag only usable for empire?“ No. Hell, the Japanese still use their flag. Including the „Rising-Sun Flag“ for their navy. They’re not ashamed of it. And that was infamously flown during the time of fascist Japan, which committed numerous war crimes, on the level of Nazi Germany. So why should we be ashamed of a flag that has practically nothing to do with war crimes or anything shameful, not that that would matter, since a flag has nothing inherently wrong with it?
@@Vaterlandstreuer the destruction of the heritage is a disgrace I've heard some people have so Mutch shame cast upon them that thay have themselves sterilized which in it's self is genocide. It has to stop
Chris Lates Yes, it’s absolutely terrible. The last surviving relatives of Hitler‘s bloodline (not even direct descendants of his, by the way) are determined to not have children because their great-brother-in-law was Hitler. What do they have to do with Hitler? Nothing. What do their would-be children have to with Hitler? Nothing. They could’ve changed their name, as if that was even necessary. Instead, they’re basically going to kill their own family because of their great-brother-in-law. It’s pathetic, completely illogical, and outright sad and shameful that they would do this. I harbor no shame for the actions of my ancestors. They did what they did. Doesn’t matter if they believed in the cause. Doesn’t matter if they didn’t. I am not associated with them. From what I know they did not support the anti-Semitic parts of the Third Reich, but rather supported a strong Germany. Does it matter either way? Nope. Because I am NOT them. I am someone else. With my own thoughts, my own feelings, ambitions, hopes, dreams, goals, beliefs, strengths, and so on. I will not shame myself for something I have nothing to do with. Sadly, many of my countrymen and -women do not think as I do. Instead, they help the „de-nazification“ process, which, at this point, is more of a de-Germanisation process. Patriotism is grounds for being called a neo-Nazi. Not being super-liberal, socialist, and globalist is seen as „Nazist.“ It’s sad that Germany carries the legacy of a terrible time that ended 75 years ago. We should free ourselves from these self-applied shackles and start thinking about what would actually be good for this country, instead of self-loathing.
If you want a Japanese equivalent of the German swastika, look up the symbol of “Taisei Yokusankai”. The purpose of the symbol actually comes from a political stance. The Japanese rising sun is more like the German iron cross, a cultural symbol thats rooted in their history.
well it not swastika but it more like old american flag or the Confederate flag... it had too strong of military design... not very useful for peace when they don't want to remember them... PTSD and shit...
@@campkira What PTSD, the vast majority of the people who can actually associate the flag with horror are dead or so far gone into senility it is practically the 1940s all over again.
Isnt the eisernes kreuz (iron cross) banned or at the least not used by the bundeswehr as an award anymore?
@@kgbcommitteeforstatesecuri3315 No the Iron Cross it literally the official symbol of the Bundeswehr. i think you mean the balkenkreuz(beam cross) which isnt banned or so but not used idk why cause it actually looks better and more modern
Fact
I have the rising sun flag on my wall
Having lived in Japan for 25 years, and been preoccupied with other aspects of life in this amazing country I’ve never really had any opportunity to delve deeper into the questions surrounding Japan’s flags. This brief and informative documentary helped a lot.
Of course, for all the time I’ve been living here I have been aware of the sensitivity surrounding Japan’s flags. Living here, you can’t help but notice its absence from daily life. Unlike in my native Australia, this country’s flag never gets used in TV commercials, billboards, or other forms of social education. In Japan, the Hinomaru is just simply missing from the public agenda.
Yes, it hovers over city administration buildings and public schools. But its presence is part of that building’s design only, like a “wall” or “elevator” would be. The national flag rarely publicly reminds residents nor visitors which country they are in.
The Hinomaru comes out on buses, trains, and urban street poles on public holidays only, and is quietly folded away the following day. On holidays perhaps one neighbor out of ten thousand might hang a Japanese flag up on their access to the street. People here seem to “be OK” with their flag, but the overall accepted Western version of historical events has obliged the individual Japanese not to “love it”. Those people who display the Hinomaru on days that are not public holidays are seen as extreme right-wing nationalists who are shunned by the majority.
While there is much ongoing criticism internationally of Japan’s actions in history, one can’t help but feel sympathy for the confused typical young Japanese and their uneasy relationship with its flag.
Sporting events are a rare opportunity for the individual Japanese to wave a flag that depicts the usual pride that peoples have towards a common identity, belongingness and success on the international stage, yet at international away sporting events though, particularly within Asia, Japanese supporters are warned by its government of the risks of flying any flag that symbolizes Japanese pride.
All nations’ flags carry history.
Few nations can be totally pride of its history.
The Japanese certainly have issues of history it needs to deal with internally.
Yet perhaps more than most people, the Japanese are aware of and struggle with the relationship between history and the flag that represents it, the present and the future.
とても感動するコメントありがとうございます。日本人はもう少し愛国心を取り戻してもいいと思います
あなたの意見は正しいです。
It’s true
Yes. Like the Aboriginal massacre in Australia
Very well written. Thank you.
The perception of old symbols like this one strongly depends on where you live. For instance I live in Europe, so i don't perceive any negative connotations of the Rising Sun Flag. I even used to have a big decal of it on the roof my Honda because I liked the look of it, and nobody had a problem with it. Many fans of Japanese cars in Europe have some form of the Rising Sun Flag on their cars and it's perfectly fine. In the same way now I have a confederate flag on the roof of my Ford pickup truck and it's just a cool design feature (because of the Dukes of Hazzard) without any historical or ideological significance because in my country nobody cares about the american civil war. On the other hand I couldn't drive around with a Swastika on a Mercedes even if I wanted to, but in China I saw action figures of war criminals like Reinhard Heydrich in Nazi uniform, and nobody seemed to care. I presume that people in China perceive Nazi symbols just as some western exotic culture without any deeper meaning.
I live in Australia though which was attacked by the Japanese sure were weren't dominated by japan but POWs still were treated poor and personally I think they should able to fly what ever flag they want it's not symbolic of oppression people need to grow up. It has much more cultural significance to just be discarded after a few short years of dark history, if every country changed their flags after every wat the get into they run out of creative ideas.
You do know the swastika comes from Buddhism, so thinking its a western symbol just shows its you who lives in a bubble.
@@profile1172 it was present in Indo-European cultures as well in ancient history. It has also been depicted slightly different depending what culture and era it was being used.
@@michael3088 you literally explained why your point is worthless, Australia didn't face the atrocities china and Korea faced that were committed by the Japanese so of course you don't find it offensive.
i saw a t-shirt of ronald mcdonald looking like adolf hitler with the stache and swastika in hong kong
Me who plays hoi4: The Expert
"I was there when it was written"
Communist Japan: *The time has come*
EU IV: Pathetic
Do not chant the ancient magic to me witch
I don’t get it 🤷♂️
“Japan has a lot of ruling families” 1:24 Mitsubishi
@DunklerJägerZach This also baffles me, but this what makes developing country (3rd world) remains the same or slow to develop is that most of the corrupt politicians are just plain selfish and don't care about their people, and likely incompetent as well which make things worse.
Reality is that most government in the world will have some corruption in one form or another, different is how they still contribute back and actually make positive impact to the society, not just let it rot and make society struggling to make it work.
Difference is one steal some, other one leaves little back to the people. Both are bad, but former one is lesser evil than the other. It's sad really.
@Roger Dodger it's almost like a nationalistic, right-wing government makes for a good country to live in, and a communist country is invariably a hellscape of misery. Strange, right?
Yup
Vroom vroom
It has like 5 or 6 who effectively run the country through a myriad of business interests so complex it would likely takes years to figure it out.
Honestly they should just stop pretending and reinstate the Shogunate with the Emperor as its puppet again.
(Rising Sun Flag)
Westerners: I think it's a nice design.
Until the Japanese Imperial Army starts rolling in!
you dont need to be a westerner to think its a nice design. It IS a nice design
멋있다
@@otre3947 but it's a very nasty regime.
Japan never changed the flag, Hinomaru is national flag, rising sun flag is used for a lot of usage and military organization.
@Uncle Ho international？
where is that? It's only some peninsula.
for US military and some allies, Japan was an enemy in the last war, however they have drills with Japanese SDF with this flag and I don't know their complaints.
I was in Yokosuka Japan in 1979-1980 as a U.S. sailor. There were several Japanese naval vessels moored at the naval station there and I was startled to see a Hinari flag at the stern of each vessel. I looked into the history of Japanese national flags at that point. Your post recounts much of what I discovered, and I thank you for letting the world know. One small addition. The reason the naval ensign used the hinari was because it was visible at great distances to approaching or passing vessels. The reason the sun-disk is offset is that it gives observers some indication of the ship's direction or course (I was told this by a signalman aboard my own ship). Again, many thanks, good post!
Less cruel than China
Less cruel than America
is for freedom
Fought
We Japan
Our justice
We Japan
@@ヤマトウズメ-r1o yeahhhhh... history begs to differ... like, it really really begs to differ... (Japan created the monster that is communist China, and the US rebuilt Japan after WW2 and is basically Japan’s military. Also, the Japanese constitution is based off of America’s... sooooo yeah)
@@officalkingkrab1912 Japan has been a democracy since the earliest times.
日出づる処の天子、書を日没する処の天子に致す
大業三年、其王多利思比孤遣使朝貢。使者曰：「聞海西菩薩天子重興佛法、故遣朝拜、兼沙門數十人來學佛法。」其國書曰「日出處天子致書日沒處天子無恙」云云。帝覽之不悅、謂鴻臚卿曰：「蠻夷書有無禮者、勿復以聞。」 大業三年（607年）、その王の多利思比孤が遣使を以て朝貢。 使者が曰く「海西の菩薩天子、重ねて仏法を興すと聞き、故に遣わして朝拝させ、兼ねて沙門数十人を仏法の修学に来させた」。 その国書に曰く「日出ずる處の天子、書を日沒する處の天子に致す。恙なきや」云々。帝はこれを見て悦ばず。鴻臚卿が曰く「蛮夷の書に無礼あり。再び聞くことなかれ」と。
・なで日本が日いづる国と呼ばれてるのか。
・中国は遥かに進んだ文明で、日本よりも2000年前から文字を使ってた。
・結果、中国から政治構造や建築などで多大な影響を受けた。
・中国人から見ると日本は日が昇る東にある。
・西暦57年、日本は"倭国"と呼ばれていた。語源については諸説ある。
・中国の記録によれば当時の日本では豪族が争っていたけど、5世紀頃に大和が日本と同義になる。
・中央政府が誕生したことで中国の体制を真似ていった。特に聖徳太子は中国から多くの影響を持ち込んだ。
・儒教による階級、中国の暦、仏教寺院とか。儒教や仏教を学ぶために学者を中国に送り込んだ。
・この聖徳太子は日の本（ニッポン）という言葉を作った。
・中国の皇帝に対して”日いづる国の天の子から、日沈む国の天の子へ”という手紙を書いて。
・日本の記録では、大化の改新で中央集権化が進むと、日本という言葉が公式文書に使われるようになる。
・中国の記録では、唐の本では日本の使節が”倭”の名前を気に入らなかったので変えたとされてる。
・また、中国の皇帝が日本に改名するよう使節に命じたというのもある。
・また、唐末期に、高句麗侵略のお祝いを言いに来た日本の使節が気に入らなくて変えたというのもある。
・いずれにせよ、8世紀末に日本に変えられたらしい。
@@ヤマトウズメ-r1o The Japanese government is modeled after the American one (as is France for example, it’s not unique to any country), although in your defense, it was much more free than a lot of western monarchies. Modern Japan was founded 1947. Even before then it took much inspiration from the US.
Fun fact: Paradox used the Hiashi flag for the Fascist Japan flag in HOI4 which is weird considered that the Fascist Japanese flag was a Pre-1999 flag
Wait japan was fascist too??
@@brutal4341 in the game you can change their alignment
@@brutal4341 during ww2 yes
@@brutal4341 no, Italy was fascist.
@Paultry Paul it's a misconception, Japanese never saw themselves a superior race ,they marely wished the westerner saw them as their equal, as a matter of fact the Japanese propose in the league of nation that all race must be equal as the league's principle but this was brutally rejected by the British and the American, both of them twisted this logic by making the Japanese looks diregarding other race as propoganda
im chinese. I am not offended by the flag and i think they should keep it. I am against cancel culture. If they have to change a centuries year old cultural flag because of one war then british should have to change their flag for also invading others and so should americans.
Agreed. Also than you for not hating my country
@@モノクマ-d3g i'm chinese too. We don't hate your country -- we only can't forgive the atrocities your ancestors did to ours
@@MrDragonballzbin ありがとうございます、ごめんなさい私の先祖があなたにしたことに対して
There are a lot of flags with the Grain Britain flag onto them, I think its extremely terrible to "show" that you conquered the country and put your flag on top of anothers...
So yeah... Changing a flag isnt always the worst ideia
This might be off topic, but in my school in Singapore we were made to sing Kimigayo once or Japan's national anthem in our history lesson to simulate the wartime experience of students in Singapore during the Japanese Occupation.
I am a Singaporean and I find that offensive. What the f is wrong with moe
Dangerous Sir Kiwi wait seriously?
That’s...kinda cool i wish they did that in my history class,closest we did was our teacher locking us out of our class to simulate the French 3rd Estate being locked out of the Estates general. But singing a song that was an anthem of your occupying nation to simulate life during occupation sounds way cooler. Props to your history teacher
@@meklavier4664 No not really we weren't really forced to sing it though and the idea was from my history teacher
@@aperson7645 yep, seriously.
Actually it never changed. “Sun Beam version “ is still the official flag of Today’s powerful Navy, Japan Maritime Self Defense Force , and it is “ Official “. Simple version on the other hand has been the “National Flag”. No charges.
Both are appropriate Flags as the Land of Rising Sun.
I see even your profile picture is a rising sun
1:07
Me: hears “Amaterasu”
Also me: *thinks of Itachi immediately*
Glad I'm not the only one
Same
Me too
I was thinking of Okami
I remember Akatsuki, is that weird?
I will point out three things about the video including misunderstanding
・ The Rising Sun Flag is not in the same line as the Haken Kreuz. The Rising Sun Flag corresponds to the flag such as German Iron Cross and White Ensign.
If the theory of eliminating the Rising Sun Flag holds, then the flags of the countries that also controlled the colonies (such as White Ensign, US Navy flag, and other europian countries' flag) must also be eliminated.
・ The Rising Sun symbol has been used as a sign of good luck since before the Edo period. The main meaning of the Rising Sun Flag and the symbol itself is "I wish you good luck."
The military element was added later.
・ The official flag of Japan is the Rising Sun Flag at any time. The official national flag of Japan before and after the war is the "Hinomaru".
> If the theory of eliminating the Rising Sun Flag holds, then the flags of the countries that also controlled the colonies (such as White Ensign, US Navy flag, and other europian countries' flag) must also be eliminated.
yes, you are correct by accident lol
the old flag looks like it had a better graphic designer
@CockSlicet Its nonsense though since they used the hinomaru on campaign as well. The US doesn't care about the flag and they were the main adversaries of the IJN.
@CockSlicet They do use it, and will tell you to stuff it otherwise. It is not them with the problem, it's people like you with the problem. You can't hold today's Japan responsible for what it had done then. People in the West may like being bent over for their past - we've not went as far as the Romans yet, perhaps do what ISIS did, start removing Roman history - at the rate the West is going, they'll be doing that sooner or later.
@CockSlicet well, sorry I just wanted to give some explanation.
@CockSlicet who cares what they did.
It should be forever flown, China is a threat and japan should scare them off with war flags
@CockSlicet its not dumb actuly if my calculations are correct, that flag is the same as a union jack.
Thats true.
It is a symbol of royalty and the signature of a army. Nothing more nothing less.
I belive japan should be allowed a army again and start stopping China.
Do u know how much blood British have spilled? Lots of French and Spanish sunk. And lots of cities burned!
But I don't care what British did then!
I don't care what japan did then!
I acknowledge it happened. But I don't care because japan is not the same as before, same that British ain't the same
They still embody the traditions of yesturday, but they are evolved (both countries have)
I don't care about ur petty racist Asian grudges you hold against Japanese (people protesting flag outside japan)
If it wasn't for Japan being in way of China China would continue to sink civilian ships
That "rising sun" thing became even more appropriate after the international date line.
Rising Sun flag is beautiful
Koreans are offended by it
@@ceelee5850 Why ?
@@disoneleg Because that flag have had and still used as a Japanese army which is actually a illegal.
The flag is still being used actively by the Japanese Navy. I see it all the time (20 year resident of Japan) in the Yokosuka Navy Base and Tokyo area.
*Self Defense Force.
I wonder what USA see that flag. Some joint training was issued due to that flag
@@jay-fl4pv i think south korea was the one who was mad
It's war flag for sure. Not only korea many countries that got invaded by Japan feel the same way. Most of Americans feel the same way is well. No wonder that USA is the one nuked Japan.
Japan: I got my army back officially. US: You are welcome.
“Rising the sun” flag which is called “Kyokujitsuki(旭日旗)” in Japan has ordinary 16 rays
the reason why there are 16 rays on it is that Japanese imperial emblem, “Kikkagomon(菊花御紋)” which was designed based on flower of chrysantheum has 16 petals
そうだよ。
@@connoisseurofchinesecartoo288 こんなところにもホモは湧くのか…
@@sutenpeiertadokorov917 よく見たら顔が…
タドコロフ…
Originally, it is a lucky charm that expresses "Rising Sun".
Sometimes a national flag, sometimes a military flag, sometimes a fishing boat's big catch flag, and sometimes a soccer cheering flag.
It has nothing to do with Haken Kreuz. It's a lie made by South Korea.
In 2011, Ki Sung-yueng performed a racial discrimination performance in the soccer match between Japan and Korea. Ki Sung-yueng made an excuse that he went to the Rising Sun Flag. Despite the fact that the Rising Sun Flag was not raised on that day. It has nothing to do with the Empire of Japan. The Rising Sun is an auspicious symbol, not that of militarism.
There has been no criticism of this flag since the end of the war. There was none at all. 'Cause this flag is a celebration flag. Because it's an auspicious flag. Criticism began suddenly in 2011. Forged hoaxes with no historical background spread from South Korea.
He got Japanese traditional flag dirty. When I see this flag, it reminds me of Korean criticism. We are really sad.
Since 2011, South Korea has sharply linked it to the war. There is no sin in this beautiful flag. It all started with an excuse for Ki Sung-yueng to hide racism. The Japanese are confused by the large number of Koreans who criticize Japan. Please do not pollute the beautiful flag in the lie of Ki Sung-yueng. Please know the truth.
맞습니다.
죄송합니다 일본.
한국은 자신들의 잘못과 논리를 가져야만 일본에게 말할 자격이 있을 것이다.
@Sapnap 제 말이 잘못 번역된 듯합니다.
욱일기는 사용해도 됩니다.
일본에게 죄송하다는 말씀드리고 싶습니다.
한국은 역사 인식을 바로 잡고 일본과 대화와 논리로 대해야 합니다.
열심히 노력해서 한국과 일본이 사이좋게 지냈으면 좋겠습니다.
@@정의는이긴다-x3y I hope so. Some day, we can become a friend
This comment sections are seems awfully scripted Those Korean languages are copy pasted and poor translated and btw Even nazi symbol was originated from buddhism and It had meaning of lucky same as your sun rising flag but Look at it imagine german person wave Hakenkreuz in public or olympics that man would be beaten up to death you Japanese should learn from your old friend
Not even gonna lie Japan had probably the cleanest looking flag with that rising sun flag
When I looked at that flag, I don’t a flag hanging. I see is my great grandfather being slaughtered while the devils laugh around his corpse.
@@shawnofdanaukota3843 ohhhh watch out! The Japanese Internet fascists might come in and try to justify their war crimes as “well China is worse” despite them being the ones who made modern China!
@@officalkingkrab1912 wow japan made china?
@@Pepe-dq2ib yes, the Chinese communist party only won the Chinese civil war and replaced the Republic of China because of Japanese invasions into China, Mao himself even said he couldn’t have taken control of China if the Japanese didn’t rape, murder, and enslave the Chinese at the time. So yes, the big scary monster that is the CCP, it’s Japan’s Frankenstein. Now the republic of China is nothing more but a husk on the island of Taiwan. The Japanese government barely touches upon the Second World War, and thus the Japanese people know very little of the events that led up to the creation of their modern rival. I think education on the subject and time period could go a long way in mending relations between the two nations.
Japan's rising sun flag, German Empire's flag, Nazi Germany's Wehrmacht Commander flag, and the US Confederated flag all look pretty cool. I'm not a Nazi or a white supremacist, I just think they look like pretty cool flags. I also think the Union Jack and the USSR flag looks pretty cool also.
A teacher straight up just killed themselves for a flags potential use
1999 according to this very video
You can't get more Japanese thab that.
suicide over flag use..... tantrum maxima.
@fjf sjdnx the teacher died with his/her principle. Life without purpose is nothing.
The teacher decided his/her purpose is for Japanese Nationalism, now whether it was right or wrong is up to personal preference but I wouldnt definitely say it was a waste of human life.
@@mosesracal6758 dying for a flag is a waste of life
When I was little I loved ninjas so I made a Rising Sun Kamikaze headband. I had no idea what it meant, just thought of ninjas.
One day we went to see my great grandparents and we went to eat at a Chinese restaurant. I made it a point to wear my Kamikaze headband.
Nobody there was fucking happy with me at ALL
Draco Distortion , bet it looked hella cool tho
A Canadian fighter in the UFC (Georges St. Pierre) walked out to the cage wearing the same thing. At least you were a kid, lol
If you weren’t a kid they will definitely a fight breakout, for Chinese and Koreans it’s like wearing swstika on you
@K B 그냥 님이 무식한듯
@K B then you should be ashamed of your self, you know nothing about this unbelievably important part of your countries history,
The rising sun flag isn't like the swastika that was used by the Germans in WW2 but more like the iron cross that was used by the Germans during WW1, WW2 and it is still used today. The equivalent to the swastika would be the taisei yokusankai, which is a white bird with the red sun between it's wings
You are on Indian military watch list now
It's not swastik .....Swastik is a Sanskrit word and it's extremely sacred in Hinduism...
Hitler never called it swastik ..he called it 'heukenkraus' or hooked cross
Ya
This is why the neighbors are just playing stupid about Japan not apologizing properly like Germany. The American occupation didn't dismantle the Japanese goverment like nazi German goverment. To replace it with a new goverment.
I can say without a doubt that the person who invented Rising Sun is a genius among geniuses and an artist of the highest level.
Japan is my favourite country in the world🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇮🇳🇯🇵🇯🇵🇯🇵🇮🇳🇯🇵🇮🇳🇯🇵🇮🇳🇯🇵🇯🇵🇮🇳🇯🇵🇮🇳
The rising sun which has a history of over 400 years, if anything, is equivalent to the German Iron cross, not the swastika.
And the British Union Jack, French Tricolore, American Stars and Stripes technically had the same meaning.
True. It upsets me everytime that people connect it with that. I think the logo of the Taisei Yokusankai is more like the asian nazi-swastika. It's just like with the imperial german flag. I can't openly show it because people connect it with nazism or right wing groups.
Haken Kreuz is a political party flag that shows the Aryans' superiority, but the Rising sun flag is a military flag, and its origin is the universal civilian sun belief.
There is no problem.
www.mofa.go.jp/files/000481576.pdf
even then, the swastika is also a religious symbol from South Asia that has been tarnished by the Nazi image, so there’s really a lot of nuance here when it comes to symbol comparison.
As someone from Korea, I personally don't see the rising flag as bad as swastika 'cause unlike swastika, the rising sun flag has previous history before the atrocities Japan had committed and also it's not a copycat of some other nation/religion's symbol. But I'm sure to tell you that many here do see the flag as one of the most evil flag. I think Japan can still use it just like Germany still use the iron cross to this day. But that *would* destroy Japan's diplomatic relationship with her neíghbors. Because here in East Asia, nationalism is as wipe spread and emotional (irrational) as Balkan. Even more so you might say.
Oh yeah definitely. As a chinese, can tell from experience that they’re also miffed af seeing it. Unlike in other nations however, China has rampant nationalism bc of their communist government’s brainwashing.
You have a good point but I still think that the Japanese military should at least try to respect the locals if they very well aware of their history
sorry, changing flag can't solve your problem
The Nissho flag(Hinomaru) was first adopted by the Shogunate as a ship flag on the high seas. The Rising Sun Flag has its roots in the military flag used in the Revolutionary War by the Revolutionary Army centered on the Satsuma Domain. As the new government, they adopted the Nissho flag(Hinomaru) as the national flag and the Rising Sun Flag as the military flag. Even now, the national flag is the Nissho flag(Hinomaru) , and the rising sun flag is used as the military flag.
For Koreans, the rising sun flag feels like the Nazi symbol. It makes Koreans think of things like massacre and war
Those who were educated after World War II were brainwashed by the brainwashing education program designed by the U.S. and Syngman Rhee at that time. Before the Japanese rule, Korea was ruled by the Yi Dynasty and a handful of yangban who exploited the people. The infrastructure and educational system were not developed, and the people were only allowed to wear white clothes. It was Japan that overthrew such a system that treated the people like slaves and laid the foundation for Korea to become a modern nation. Did you know that An Jung-geun was in favor of the annexation of Korea? The Japanese Prime Minister at the time, Hirobumi Ito, was assassinated for his opposition to the annexation of Korea.
@@u1v.s7 Honestly, I'm not bothered by the use of the rising sun flag nor the Swastica. I'm more bothered by the double standard of Swastica being bad but the Rising Sun flag is not.
Both have a tradition of being used as a sign of fortune and good energy and such and used by the mustached dictator. But somehow only Swastica is bad because Hitler was the only bad guy in Europe and anyone else who opposed is a hero despite of all the bad works in it's colonies.
日章旗には何も言わず、旭日旗にだけ過剰反応するのは分らんな。
日章旗も旭日旗も元々のルーツは同義なのに
Normal Japanese flag
Ww2 vet: Good ol japan heheheh
Imperial Japanese flag
Ww2 vet: *TENNO HEIKA BANZAI FLASHBACK INTENSIFIES*
6:15 Stance? Maybe. Kinda condition of surrender. Most often we require that the nations deescalate their military capacity to only,being able to defend the nation and not have any forces able to go beyond that. Same with post-WW1 Germany when we effectively castrated their ability (in theory) to have a militsry.
Even the UK and US Flags are probably offensive to some countries due to the past.
Italy was part of the Axis and still uses the same flag, but nobody seems to care.
The Rising Sun Flag of Japan is not a claim of militarism, but a flag that is displayed in front of the house when celebrating. In addition, the Rising Sun Flag of Japan has existed before 1900. Certain people are trying to give a bad impression to Japan's Rising Sun Flag, but the truth is this.
This flag is the 1880's first written in Japanese navy. From the Navy, the Army and the Japanese Army began to use.The Japanese always say that the Rising Sun Flag means a good thing, but Hakenkreuz also means symbol of luck. And used in the Asuka period in japan you mentioned is clearly different from the shape of the Rising Sun Flag. In addition, Japan's Rising Sun Flag was clearly used militarily and politically. The Rising Sun Flag used in the Pacific War. Japan until now not to apologize properly while slaughtering a huge number of people, and always emphasizes that Japan seems to be a victim of a nuclear bomb rather than causing damage even though it caused World War II. Of course i don’t want to fight you, but I wanted to tell you exactly what Koreans and Chinese say
@@jadenlee7506 I think you love so much about the rising sun flag because you studied so hard
about it. How much do you love that flag?😂 Are you 츤데레?
P.S World War 2 was started and caused by Germany, not Japan. Learn history going back to elementary school 바보🤞🥺
@@dragonesryan282 남은 까고싶고 아는건없고 ㅋ 키보드 워리어 딱 너수준 그이하 개가 짖어봐라 누가 보나 ㅋ
@@jadenlee7506 You Korean always run away to using Korean language when it comes to getting at the core of the matter.
To tell you the truth, you love so much about the rising sun flag while saying "the rising sun flag is Hakenkreuz!" alone. Be honest 츤데레.
@@dragonesryan282 Hahaga, you never told me the core of the matter. Is the core of your matter ‘츤데레’?If you want to get an answer from me, ask me a real question not bullshit
I personally don't have a problem with Japan's Rising Sun flag, but my grand father working in Darwin as a home guard and my grand uncle as a private infantry man fighting in New Guinea during the 1940's would have thought VERY differently about it.
I don’t get how Australia get so close to Japan now, even when America force Korea to be friend with Japan they still hate each other
@@williamwang3729 It was just war, nothing personal; we've fought lots of wars, even amongst our own peoples from time to time, if we held a grudge against every one we had ever fought we'd hate virtually every person who walks the earth. Hatred and animosity may be reasonable during times of war, but once the war is over, it's time to move on; it's a regular occurrence throughout history that today's enemy becomes tomorrow's ally and today's ally becomes tomorrow's enemy.
Costa Keith I got where you come from, but a lot of Chinese and Korean family lost their friends and families by the Japanese empirical army, and they should be held accountable (which they didn’t, U.S. let a lot war criminals lose in order to make Japan a U.S. ally that can counter Chinese and Russian influence.
Which Unit Jason Cowley
Yeah I also don’t have personally problem with Nazi symbol. So I can use Nazi symbol in personal. But I didn’t use that symbol. Cuz I respect the soldiers that defending from Nazi in WW2. But many westerners don’t think about it the same way about rising sun flag. I think if you respect your grand father and your grand uncle, then you have to think the same way as them.
｢日の丸｣の正式名称は｢日章旗｣です。
またハーケンクロイツと同列にするなら大政翼賛会の旗で、
旭日旗ではありません。
あなたは見かけた最初の日本語のコメントです
本当ですな
Japanese sunrise flag has good design 👏🏻✨
If you look into more of war images of Japan, you'll find that they only flew the rising sun flag when they won the battle. basically the rising sun flag was used for celebration. also the reason why Japanese imperial navy used the rising sun flag is simply because hinomaru just looked like a white flag from the distance on the sea when it's not waved. that's why japanese navy aka japanese maritime self defense force uses the rising sun flag still:)
But I don't understand.. why would Japan still use the rising sun flag when other countries feel offended???
@@Name-uc3ck Who gives a shit about our enemies.
@flyveto457it’s because Japan hasn’t apologized for all the atrocities they did, such as forcing women and girls into prostitution, and denies TO THIS DAY any wrong doing
The "army" is the JGSDF stands for Japanese Ground Self Defense Force
Less cruel than China
Less cruel than America
is for freedom
Fought
We Japan
Our justice
We Japan
@@ヤマトウズメ-r1o Isn’t it monitored under the US though?
@@ヤマトウズメ-r1o funny how you mention cruelty...... fooling no one , strangely pacifist since you were handed your arses following dishonourable acts during ww2....
He nailed the Japanese “r” sound when he said Hinomaru
R sounds like d in Japanese right?
@@R0DBS2 It can sound like a D depending on the person and the dialect. I like to describe it as a D, L & R sound combined
@@mossy_6475 okay
@@mossy_6475 it almost sounds like du but the d is rolled and isn’t as harsh as an American D
I heard "flag de jour", like soup de jour.
took me a while to realise you intended to say "de jure national flag"
He said the Latin term in French pronunciation
What is a soup de jour.?.....i've only heard plat du jour, apéritif maison, bière de Noël.....
It's not the problem of flag. It's only the way to look and how you think of it. I'never heard of the complain about the Stars and Stripes or Union Flag from Native Americans, Vietnamese, African,Chinese, Korean, of course Japanese. Why?
I'm Japanese. Some foreigners misunderstands that Japanese Rising sun flag was the national flag of Japan until the end of ww2. Actually, it was not. And it has never been a national flag of Japan. Japanese national flag has been Hinomaru which is same as today's. Rising sun flag had been a symbol flag of Japanese navy and it is being used by Japanese maritime self defense force too.
If South Korea insists that national symbols that Japan used to invade neighboring countries (in the past) should not be used at all, then South Korea should also send objections to the use of for example the British flag and the tricolor French flag (Drapeau français), because these were traditionally used by the European countries during European colonialism, the first wave of European colonization (1415 to 1830 CE) and New Imperialism (late 19th and early 20th centuries).
Not the same, it's hard to compare what Imperial Japan atrocities with the other Imperialists. And the timeline is more recent. It may require a few more generations to pass.
8:44 That was a dark time in history
Yeah the artwork really captures it I always find!
=D
CEKROM and they are trying to cover it up!
@@holeshe If Japan wants to cover this picture, then there hasn't been an internet, but thanks for make me laugh hard
@@No_Anime_No_Life. what Timothy is referring to is Japan trying to cover it up in the history it try to teach their own people. The Japanese are being taught that world war 2 is an attempt for Japan to liberate all the people of western colony and forging closer economical ties
Hi, We are Japanese. That's a nice post. However We must insist about this subject....
The Japanese "Hinomaru flag" has been for hundreds of years.
and the "Rising sun flag" also is it that would be displayed at the time of celebrations.
The Rising sun flag was adopted for the war so that it would not be mistaken for a white flag when there was no wind.
This is a very nervous problem for Japan as well.
And you know only some fanatic Koreans are screaming that the Rising Sun Flag is a war criminal in Asia. Do you know any groups, for example in Thailand or Indonesia that are screaming so?
Your ancestors have also invaded and slaughtered Africa, Asia and America, but what do you think if your country's flag is shouted "identical to the Nazis in war crimes"?
Europeans, Americans are should to check directly with the parties, including Japan.
As a Korean, I want to talk to you. Koreans don't actually know what the Rising Sun Flag is like, but they are opposed in that it was used as a symbol of militarism. Obviously, it is true that the mesh or media acts stimulatingly in Korea, and it is true that there is an extreme Korean that you said because they hate Japan politically or blindly.
However, it is true that problems have arisen since you colonized Korea in the first place. After occupying it by force, it committed things such as exploitation of human resources, slaughter, and national extinction, and after World War II, it was divided into the United States and the Soviet Union, and the Korean War broke out. Of course, you can't look good from a Korean perspective.
Of course, it is also true that the Japanese government officially apologized like Konodamhwa.
But Japanese military sexual slavery and laborers who people's issues and not seen as a sincere apology to Yasukuni Shrine to honor their war crimes.
You said that the relationship between Korea and Japan is important.
On the one hand, don't Koreans say they are fanatic and blame Korea unconditionally?
When I talk to Japanese people about these issues,
Everyone says it's in the past and everyone says it's anti-Japanese agitation.
Do you think we're acting noisy to you unlike other countries?
What do you think it would be like if you guys were us?
Is it right for you to forget about it and shut up quietly?
Rising Sun Flag ≠ Haken Kreuz. Haken Kreuz = Imperial Rule Assistance Association flag. Rising Sun Flag = Iron Cross. Although Hakenkreuz was abolished in Germany, the Iron Cross is still in use. The Imperial Rule Assistance Association flag has been abolished in Japan, but the Rising Sun Flag is still in use. I think that is the reason why the Rising Sun Flag is not abolished. I would like to exchange opinions once about what Koreans think and what Japanese people think. I would like to exchange opinions peacefully rather than in a quarrel.
@@heiwa_is_best Good idea. Nice to talk to you.
It is certain that the Rising Sun Flag is not a good image in Korea. In fact, it is rare for Koreans to know what the Rising Sun Flag is like in Japan, but it is true that there is no way they would like the flag used by the former Japanese Empire in Korea.
According to the opinions of people who hate the Rising Sun Flag, I heard that it should be banned because it was the main culprit of the Pacific War after the Japanese army took over the Japanese regime in a coup in the past.
Good idea. Nice to talk to you.
It is certain that the Rising Sun Flag is not a good image in Korea. In fact, it is rare for Koreans to know what the Rising Sun Flag is like in Japan, but it is true that there is no way they would like the flag used by the former Japanese Empire in Korea.
According to the opinions of people who hate the Rising Sun Flag, I heard that it should be banned because it was the main culprit of the Pacific War after the Japanese army took over the Japanese regime in a coup in the past.
Originally, I had the same idea as above, but from the Japanese side's point of view, I think Japan's position is well-founded, so I'm still thinking about it. If the Rising Sun Flag should be banned, Belgium, France, and Britain, the same colonial empires in the past, are also logic that flags should be banned, so it seems too complicated.
Recently, I don't think Japan clearly expresses its position in Korea. I think Japan doesn't apologize like Germany. But because of that, I think there are cases where Korea treats Japan too emotionally.
@@김태원-p1c Japanese here and what I would like to say is that we *never* "colonized" Korea. Please learn your history and you will find out that your royals at the time left your people and Japan with no choice but to let Japan "adopt" you.
Basically, what happened was we fought a war with Russia to *make Korea independent* from China (or the Great Qing Empire, because we didn't want their influence so close), and that didn't go well. After we won the war and made Korea an independent state, your royals didn't know what to do to keep the country running, and your government was a *total chaos with the most corrupted officers* on Earth.
Gojong, or the Emperor Gwangmu, *refused to modernize* and ordered to kill people who held the idea. Your government at the time *failed in everyway* you could imagine: they were *corrupted* , secretly *allowed people to make fake money* by selling secret permits. They also betrayed Japan & UK & every other country who were actually trying to help your country to get on your feet. Gojong secretly asked Russia for help to get rid of Japan so he can restore power, and this made everyone furious. *Sarcastically, Russia actually turned against Gojong* after his got busted, because one random crazy korean guy *murdered our prime minister* Hirofumi Ito, and the Russians didn't want any problem on that shit. Japanese people *were sympathetic* to Korean people, however, we totally lost hope when we found out that your Emperor had just betrayed us, and what he did wasn't even for your own interest.
Then, after all trials have failed and everyone lost all hope in your royals and your government, *Japan, UK and US talked to each other and decided* it's best for Japan to make the annexation.
I know you may argue that no country will be "nice" enough to help a country out of total courtesy, well, of course we had our own interest. We had several concerns:
1. The fact your country did not have a functional government made it *hard for us to trade with you* .
2. The fact your government allowed people to make fake money caused a *financial disaster* . Your country literally had to adopt Japanese Yen just to have some working currency.
3. Your government was never one piece and was always fighting internally, which led to a ton of diplomatic betrayal. Several incidents almost *put us into the danger of war* for some total nonsense.
For all the reasons and circumstances above, *WE HAD TO MAKE YOUR COUNTRY STABLE ONE WAY OR ANOTHER* . We tried to help you establish a new working government, and that failed, which just *left us no choice* . And there you have the annexation. The annexation was *well accepted* by the international community at the time.
Kyokujitsu-ki the rising sun flag goes back to 1603 during the edo period.It was used first by warlords then used by Nippon in 1870 as the flag for the armed forces....Take the video above with a grain of salt.
No one ever complained about the flag until the 2002 soccer World Cup.
No one realized they were still using it I guess. TBH i think we should nuke them one more time I think they forgot we beat them out of that flag.
The rising sun flag is still flown (2021) from Japan's naval vessels. I have seen it flown from the stern in Port Melbourne on a rare occasion a Japanese navy ship visits.
Video?
I was going to say the same thing. This flag has been flown on Japan's Naval Ship docked in Australian ports in recent years. Its not Japan's national flag, it is Japan's "self defence" force flag.
Our navy flag has been the same since 19th century. But the Army regimental flags use 8 stripes.
It didn't change, the rising sun flag was the flag of the military, it was never the official flag of the country.
The title of this video creates a lot of misunderstandings, because the Rising Sun Flag has never been used as a Flag of Japan,
so it did not change after the war.
damn
Ahhh
Oh--
The Rising Sun Flag is also used as a flag to teach the land when fishermen have a big catch.
It is also used for baby gifts.
It's not the flag of war.
@@越の赤狸 The Rising Sun Flag is the flag of war of japan. But Japan nationalists who refute japan's WWII war crimes, have promoted its use after the war, to gain common acceptance.
Japanese flag is also a sign of "Non-Vegetarian" food on every packaged food in India.
Edit : In India it is mandatory for companies to label every food item with Sign/Label. The "Red Dot' like Japanese flag is for Non-Vegetarian food, There's "Green Dot" for Vegetarian food and "Yellow Dot" for food that contains Eggs. In India Eggs are not considered vegetarian, Also there will be Vegan labelling on foods soon.
I wish every country had this type of labelling it's quiet simple to know about food this way.
Lol
That’s actually really handy. We should do that in the US
@@TheSlipperyNUwUdle Wait that Americans don't label products which contains meat
@@Rahul_G.G. nah, we do. But like, just words that say “no meat” and so on. The color symbol system seems more fun!
that's not the Japanese flag lol, it's actually supposed to be brown but some manufacturers also put red for some reason. it's a white square outlined by the line of same color as the circle inside the square. Green dot for vegetarian and Brown dot for non vegetarian.
You can still see the imperial flags here in the Philippines, they’re usually on passenger jeepneys or as stickers on Oners (jeep like vehicle)
typical Pinoy self hate
@@joshzhang7041 I’m sure they’re just clueless what that means, I’ve seen some confederate flags too. They might’ve thought the thing just looks nice to add as decorations so why not.
@@mjolninja9358 .... They probably find them aesthetically cool but I don't think there are many other nations out there who would put the rising sun flag as a decor after the Japanese killed 1+ million of their grandparents and also massacred their capital. There's also the online stereotype/meme that Pinoys hate themselves.
The 'War Flag' with its sun rays radiating out from the centre disc was adopted in 1870, as part of Japan's modernisation. It was thought that modern, western countries such as Britain and the USA had national and military flags, so Japan must have them as well.
In fact, the specific design of the Naval ensign with its offset sun disk and 16 red rays was formally adopted in 1889 - which was also the year that Japan became a constitutional monarchy with a democratically elected parliament, the Diet. The fact that the naval ensign was also used during the 1930s and 40s when Japan lapsed into militarism and dictatorship must be offset against the fact that the same flag was also used by democratic Japan in the preceding years - and it uses symbolism which has been associated with the country for over a millennium.
This can be contrasted with flags such as Germany's swastika (Hakenkreuz) and the Soviet Union's hammer and sickle. They were the symbols of specific political movements, the Nazis and Communists, and were adopted as the national flag when those movements seized power in their respective countries. As such, when Nazism and Communism were overthrown, their flags were also abolished and banned. The Rising Sun flag, however, is not the symbol of an ideology but of a nation.
In this context, the events after the Second World War should be considered.
When the Americans occupied Japan in 1945, they banned all displays of nationalism. Any display of Japanese flags at all was prohibited without the permission of the occupation authorities, which was rarely given. These restrictions were partially lifted at a highly symbolic moment: in May 1947, when Japan adopted a new and fully democratic constitution, they were also permitted to fly their national flag over major public buildings such as the parliament building and supreme court. Over the next two years the ban on private citizens using the national flag was also lifted in two stages.
I would say it went the way of Germany's WW2 Flag.
nope. the rising sun fly is still in use with the japanese navy just modified.
Its not same
FizzyElf still hella problematic
@@jy5819 actually its closer related to the prussian flag. also its a god damn flag if thats causing problems you need to reevaluate your life
FizzyElf maybe to you, but to many other Asians who were occupied by japan it’s equivalent to the confederate or even the nazi flag for them. And no, I don’t gotta re-evaluate shit
8:05 Requesting a Naval Vessel to not fly its ensign upon entering one of your ports is actually quite a huge Diplomatic Affront no matter the circumstances.
Agreed , it's called striking colors. And is a sign of surrender.
They could fly their official national flag. Considering the history and atrocities committed under the rising sun flag in korea and china, the koreans are absolutely justified in their request that the japanese not fly it. I'm totally on their side.
Like if they can't even swallow their pride and admit to their own history on a joint, supposedly peace keeping, practice in korea, then they can fuck right off... and i'm not even korean.
@@datnguyenthe8300The army used a different Rising Sun flag with the sun centered in the middle. The current one, which was previously used by IJN, is off to the side; it's a subtle difference but they're not the same flags and, to my knowledge, the IJN wasn't a large user of war crimes or abuse like the IJA was.
@@datnguyenthe8300 UK still use the damn Union Jack flag to this day and no one able to force them to take it down nor the Britts want it down.
5:00 One question. Why is Japanese soldier holding a german MP40?
Sean Keste Bernales a lot of German weapons were made in Japan
Possibly a lent weapon since the weapons the japanese were using at the time were getting outdated
Japan was allies together with Nazi germany in the ww2
@@qwerty-lb9qn they werent actual allies, they just had a peace treaty
@@gerbearneronero9748 They even got some military planes from germany in World War 2. So its not that rare to see german equipment in the japanese military in the early 1940s.
We also cannot forget, Clan Hojo was also the Hylian Royal Family.
*Civ6 gamers who play Japan joined the game*
When you realized you learn so much in youtube than at school
It's really funny JSDF were allowed to fly the rising sun flag as their naval flag during visting Chinese harbor for PLA navy's 70th anniversary.
When they were invited to come to South Korea for a fleet review the Korean government asked them to only put the national flag on their ships. However Japan refused to do so and said they would rather not participate then put the rising sun flag down. And really didn't come lol. Shame on them
@@BdischarY short stack is right
Short Stack it won’t be crazy if that symbol is related with the numerous atrocities entire nations had to go through
@@sunny11097ify
Or maybe Korea can stop being over sensitive of past and accept the flag.
山田 let me put it into perspective for you. Let’s say a foreign nation decides to take over your country, erase your culture, forces you to speak their language, makes your friends into sex slaves, forces your father to fight in their wars, kills entire villages for “fun”, turns your emperor’s palace into a zoo, digs up graves, constructs their administrative building in the front of a palace, kills countless people because of a peaceful protest, changes textbooks, spreads stories which cause your and your neighbor to hate each other, and much more. Do you think time will help you forget all of that? And y’know what? We want to forget it. But for us to forget it we just want Japan to admit their wrong doings, educate their children, and show how real people with dignity deal with their wrongs, so that we can stop hating Japan. Is that so much to ask?
I remember seeing the rising sun flag flown on Japanese ships when they pulled into Peal Harbor and went past the USS Arizona memorial.
Of course no one I knew, nor I was offended by this but I found it interesting that 70+ years ago that flag represented a nation that attacked Pearl Harbor and now they fly that flag in Pearl Harbor as our friends.
What a beautiful Irony
It's the same thing as Vietnam respecting the French flag or the American flag.
Only Koreans do not have this heart.
@@ebi2ch r u gonna say that to Jewish people also?
@@jeayounhyun6786 When did Japan do to Koeans like the Jews?
Germany slaughtered the Jews, but Japan treated Taiwanese and Koreans as Japanese citizens.
The fact is that the Korean royal family was left intact and a Japanese princess married a Korean prince.
In a 1936 survey, about 80% of Koreans said they were not dissatisfied with Japanese rule.
Only about 10% of their advocated for Korean independence.
Taiwanese, who were incorporated into Japan 16 years earlier than Korea, have not protested anything against Japan on historical issues until today.
The reason why Korea protests against Japan is because Korea is divided into north and south, and moreover, the northern half is a communist state.
The southern half is a democracy, but it is full of spies from North Korea. Since they are of the same ethnicity and speak the same language, it is difficult to detect that they are spies.
North Korean spies are teaching false history in order to divide Japan and South Korea.
@@ebi2ch bruh, Koreans(Especially Woman) were Literally enslaved by the Japanese
The Japanese changing their flag because "empire bad" would be like the British changing the Union Jack because empire bad, I mean comparing it to the nazi flag is so over the top dramatic, it's not the same, if you compared the German imperial flag to the Japanese imperial flag then that would be accurate.
1:34 The crane one is used as the logo of JAL
Yeah
It is kind of like the Dutch Prinsen Vlag, isn't it? We should use that one again.
Im indonesian, my country was in occupation of japan for 3.5 years and had very very terrible experiences from that even some says its more terrible than 350 years dutch occupation. We indonesians still remember it, but its the past, we cant change it and we make peace with our past. Im not okay if japan use that flag, but im okay with japanese. Its only ethical problem..
Arif Hendriyana Rising sun flag should be banned.... And banning that flag is not a meterial of anti-Japanese.
I feel you....
For me, because it was the Japanese army flag during World War II, and because it often appeared in the occupied areas or battlefields（or some inhumane place） of Japan, it was given a symbolic meaning (the occupied areas of Japan are generally managed by the army). And to a certain extent, it symbolizes the militarism and Nazi oriented Japan at that time. So on some special occasions, it may be natural for me to feel disgusted with this flag
We in the Phillipines have a lot of atrocities done to us by the Japanese Empire but , at least for me I dont give a fuck. I mean when I saw it back then, I just thought that. Owh, so thats the Japanese military flag
As a korean i feel great hatred for the rising sun flag. Actually doesn't it give you a little chill when you first see it?
Excellent video. You always learn something.
This video is full of mistakes.
From Japan
SLIGHTLY MORE WASHED OUT SHADE OF RED: EVIL
SLIGHTLY BRIGHTER MORE VIBRANT SHADE OF RED: GOOD
haha, love it
Personally i think the washed out variant looked better.
clearly the message intended is that you shouldn't use bleach when washing a flag
Not flying the Naval flag actually violates the international law..
They can change it...
because the first naval flag's design was set in stone by international law and they can’t change it... or could they?
@@WeAreSMC96 International law doesn't set flag designs in stone. That would be bs.
rising sun flag is actually really cool
Yass... True that..
I'm Japanese, but when I went to the Philippines, I saw a sticker of the Japanese Kyokujituki flag on a motorcycle and my Filipino friends wore T-shirts with designs of the kyokujituki flag on them, and I laughed. When I asked him about it, he said he knew what it meant and wore it, so we became really good friends.
I liked that mentality.
My brain is actually quite dead after reading the arguments in the comment section
Japanese, Koreans, and Chinese have a tendency of fighting each other in every comments section
@@bulbobaggins Yes
At least you can cut down on the costs of buying marijuana
Fr lol
Flag Lives Matter.
The rising sun flag is a symbol of Japanese folk beliefs.
The Japanese flag has always been the "Hinomaru".
I don't know what f*k shit faith it is, but if someone is carrying it in China, I will punch him.
Says a person who has never been to China and will never be...
@@leogogo7041 Have it your way!
@@mousammallik7526 ???
@@raihis1313 It is not only used by the military. It is used in every situation. It is also raised when the fisherman goes out to the sea.
The Rising Sun Flag has existed long before the army was formed in Japan. Find out more about it yourself.
The Japanese still uses the sun flag with rays on their ship's.
@@lol-ih1tl Fuck if they think it's offensive. They are wrong if they think it's offensive.
@@naturalthing1 …what
No,there are differences, the old fashioned one has an off center sun located in the left position,the current sun in the flag is in the center
@@naturalthing1 are you a militarist fanatic ¿
@@jeffreylee252 I love my country, don't you love yours?
As a filipino the rising flag isnt really offensive to us (atleast to the people i know). Maybe because Japan just colonised the country for short time. And the flag is not really emphasized in our school, just the atrocities that japan committed.
In Korea, the rising sun flag feels as the Nazi symbol is for Europeans.
@@u1v.s7in China too
0:58 *How about sunrise land*
Me: What different about Japan Flag?
My Japanese Friend: **JAPAN IS JAPAN**
It’s Japanese friend
@@r0xleg116 **yes**
Come on and slam, welcome to Japan!
No its welcome to anime world
@@kaito1213
Where's all the subtitles?
You see, the Japanese flag represents the sun in the sky.
The old Japanese sun represents the time period when it was a DEADLY LASER
The new Japanese sun represents today, where it's not a deadly laser anymore, because it has a blanket.
Nice Bill Wurtz refference
You can make a religion out of this
@@ViktorVonfuling Please don't.
Ah I see, you're a man of culture as well
you deserve more
"Rising Sun Flag" has been used in various happy events such as a birth-giving and big catch since the Edo period.
Later in the Meiji period, because it is thought to be a symbol of happy events, it came to be used as the military flag praying for victory.
へーーそーなんや
The Rising Sun flag has been used during fishing for a long time.Not only the war.
Also Japan's flag is The Rising sun flag not once.
rising flag is used in not only military but also private
8:48 Why don't you use Taisei Yokusan Kai 大政翼賛会
Love Japan From Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇯🇵
the offset ray flag is actually quite nice from a design standpoint. i can see why they wouldn’t want it, but it’s still a nice design.